Latest / No Way Out / The Transcendent OODA Loop: Jordan Hall on AI, Strategy & What Makes Us Human
Transcript
- 0:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm here with Jordan Hall.
- 0:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I've been trying to get him on the podcast for a while now, uh, mainly because of his work with Jim Rutt, Plan B, uh, some conversations on consciousness, AI.
- 0:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh he's actually been on a podcast where he he explained the Ootaloop to um Michael Levin, which I think is fantastic.
- 0:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And Michael Levin has some fascinating work that he's doing with Carl Friston and something in the what they call the platonic space.
- 0:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's pretty fascinating.
- 0:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But welcome to the show, Jordan.
- 0:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How are you doing today, man?
- 0:48Jordan Hall: I'm good.
- 0:49Jordan Hall: Uh we were just out for several weeks in uh California and Texas with families, uh kind of resettling here at the house.
- 0:56Jordan Hall: We're probably we're 48 hours in, so I'm a little bit a little bit uh you know rattled, but we'll settle in.
- 1:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's all good.
- 1:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I think the one of the last podcasts uh I heard you do was back in March.
- 1:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then of course the one you did with Jim Jim Rutt.
- 1:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, and since that time, Jim Jim has gone on, has graduated.
- 1:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you wanted to say that, he's he's moved along.
- 1:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and the connection to Santa Fe Institute is is fascinating to me as well.
- 1:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh what I'd like to do is just kind of do some sense making for folks, uh give a little bit of not not your background, but what it is you're seeing in the world of AI, consciousness, the connection to religion.
- 1:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I know that's a big ask right now, but uh let's just kind of start there.
- 1:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's what's you know after you recovered with your family, what what's top of mind today?
- 1:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's a very, very big ask.
- 1:42Jordan Hall: Um big one.
- 1:43Jordan Hall: Yeah.
- 1:44Jordan Hall: I mean what I'll do is kind of like remember that game, I think it was called pickup sticks.
- 1:48Jordan Hall: You kind of just took a bunch of sticks and threw them down on the ground and kind of started pulling them out.
- 1:52Jordan Hall: Maybe we'll play pickup sticks.
- 1:53Jordan Hall: I'll throw some sticks on the ground and we'll see where the the interest.
- 1:56Jordan Hall: So we have God, there's so many different dimensions.
- 2:00Jordan Hall: So let me see if I can identify three just to start with.
- 2:04Jordan Hall: One is a recognition, a forced recognition, let's say by necessity of the individual and the social level of the uh inadequacy of the model of identity and consciousness that has been assembled in the darnity.
- 2:16Jordan Hall: So the past 500 years or so.
- 2:19Jordan Hall: Okay.
- 2:19Jordan Hall: Um, that's one.
- 2:20Jordan Hall: The second is the consequences of let's just call it LLM flavor artificial intelligence.
- 2:26Jordan Hall: So I don't necessarily need to go the far beyond where we currently are for the form of sociotechnical structure that we currently live in.
- 2:36Jordan Hall: So we could call it late modernity if you'd like, kind of a late-stage liberal capital system, or whatever language you'd like to use to describe it is the thing that we live in.
- 2:44Jordan Hall: But I'm specifically talking about the socio-technical framework.
- 2:47Jordan Hall: So the things like how we make decisions together, how we coordinate resource allocation, that kind of stuff.
- 2:52Jordan Hall: And then the third is maybe the most most relevant, but it's the hardest.
- 2:58Jordan Hall: And that has to do with something like let's see if I can throw how to say it cleanly.
- 3:01Jordan Hall: When you're some some context, when you're when you're dealing with accelerating change, this is a uh kind of a Wayne Gretzky metaphor, except now the puck can accelerate.
- 3:10Jordan Hall: I say you schedule where the puck is going, but if the puck can accelerate, that changes things a little bit.
- 3:14Jordan Hall: You have to start thinking about ways of thinking about the trajectory that you're on that will be true regardless of a lot of uncertainty, uh kind of fog of war in the shape of the landscape of the war, not even the characteristic of the movement on the landscape.
- 3:28Jordan Hall: Does that make sense what I'm saying?
- 3:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It does.
- 3:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm hearing some Stuart Kaufman in there, adjacent possibles, that type of thing.
- 3:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's certainly some of that.
- 3:35Jordan Hall: Uh and also just straight military theory.
- 3:38Jordan Hall: If you're if you're if you're planning on a war and you don't know whether you're going to be in the desert or the jungle, you have to think about a very different notion of what does it mean to be properly prepared.
- 3:46Jordan Hall: This is very bored, right?
- 3:47Jordan Hall: You just go up one entire level and say, okay, well, strategy is not desert strategy or jungle strategy.
- 3:53Jordan Hall: It's strategy that is invariant across contexts.
- 3:56Jordan Hall: Are there invariants in strategy that is no longer bound to a get given context that I can rely on no matter what the underlying context happens to be?
- 4:05Jordan Hall: And this is the kind of thing you have to do when you're dealing with accelerated change because you can't guess what's going on the world's going to look like in a year and what the secondary and tertiary consequences of this change happen to be.
- 4:15Jordan Hall: And I should point out, by the way, that the that the result, for me at least, was extremely good news.
- 4:20Jordan Hall: Like I actually moved from being, let's say, relatively pessimistic about the consequences of AI for humanity to meaningfully optimistic as a consequence of that work.
- 4:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 4:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you're going to meaningful, optimistic in the age of I I'm with you on that.
- 4:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The abundance that I believe is that it may emerge from what's happening all around us is not necessarily a bad thing.
- 4:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I think what I'm hearing from you is we have to rethink how we these socio-technical systems operate, from living in a land of scarcity to living in a land of abundance.
- 4:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What does that mean in in this landscape?
- 4:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think some of the things you're written in the past about a networked approach towards capitalism, if I can say it that way, where we're moving away from centralized control of government to uh network approaches, I I see that happening more and more.
- 5:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that is that what you're talking about?
- 5:10Jordan Hall: Yeah.
- 5:11Jordan Hall: Yeah, that's definitely what I'm talking about.
- 5:12Jordan Hall: So this just kind of decompose that.
- 5:14Jordan Hall: When the marginal cost of information and computation drops towards zero, most of the premises of modernity, which is let's say a book-based or literacy-based communications fabric, are no longer relevant.
- 5:29Jordan Hall: So one consequence is that the structures that we've inherited, and in many ways have kind of optimized or at least cobbled together functional versions of over the past 500 years, will be undergoing really quite significant transformation in much the same way that the Middle Ages, which had been around for a thousand years, fell apart rapidly in just a century or so after the introduction of the printing books, maybe two centuries if you want to be big aligned.
- 5:52Jordan Hall: And this, of course, is because the underlying premises of where being a race, not the that which sits on top of the underlying premises.
- 5:59Jordan Hall: So it's a very different regime of change.
- 6:01Jordan Hall: That part is it will be challenging.
- 6:02Jordan Hall: There's no question.
- 6:03Jordan Hall: There'll be a lot of challenges around that.
- 6:05Jordan Hall: So then taking it up one level, the next level is some you pointed to exactly, which is, and even more fundamentally, we have been operating under a basic assumption and a cultural logic of scarcity for as long as we've been around.
- 6:17Jordan Hall: And so moving to a cultural logic of abundance is qualitatively distinct, and as you can point out, it's premised on the qualitative, not the quantitative, and novel.
- 6:27Jordan Hall: We have some good hints on how to do it, but we don't really know how to do that.
- 6:30Jordan Hall: And so we're entering into a very novel environment.
- 6:32Jordan Hall: And I think it's important that a lot of people, almost everybody for a very good reason, tends to operate on the basis of analogy to the past.
- 6:40Jordan Hall: So you say, hey, in the past, technological disruption has always resulted in X, Y, Z.
- 6:44Jordan Hall: Okay, neat.
- 6:45Jordan Hall: Or fill in a blank.
- 6:47Jordan Hall: And the point is, yeah, but novelty is novel by nature.
- 6:49Jordan Hall: The part, the question is how novel is the context we're entering into.
- 6:52Jordan Hall: If it is truly novel and significant, then the past tells us very little about it.
- 6:57Jordan Hall: To the degree to which it's a pattern that has recognized is a pattern that is repeating from the past, the past tells us a lot, right?
- 7:02Jordan Hall: But we need to be clear on the distinction so we can understand how to actually navigate thoughtfully.
- 7:07Jordan Hall: And then the last piece, and this is almost like just this just drawing a pyramid, has to do with well, the language, uh uh, the psychological.
- 7:15Jordan Hall: So moving from the sociological or socio-technical questions of abundance and scarcity.
- 7:20Jordan Hall: The top of the pyramid and the or the most irrelevant part is actually the psychological.
- 7:24Jordan Hall: We might even say the spiritual, um, which is that how do human beings deal with abundance?
- 7:29Jordan Hall: And the answer is generally speaking quite poorly.
- 7:31Jordan Hall: So it's not just how do our institutional structures, the ways that we coordinate together, deal with abundance.
- 7:36Jordan Hall: That's a whole issue.
- 7:37Jordan Hall: That's layer two.
- 7:38Jordan Hall: The most important part is how do we as individuals deal with abundance?
- 7:42Jordan Hall: And that's actually some of the largest risks.
- 7:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So any examples from the past that you can pull from that that or nothing that we've seen.
- 7:49Jordan Hall: Yeah, I'll give you like a very simple example, one that's kind of relatively uh straightforward.
- 7:55Jordan Hall: We, in at least in the in the West and mostly in the United States, moved from a realm of caloric scarcity, which dominated human existence up until the 1950s or so, to caloric abundance by the time we got to the mid to late 1970s.
- 8:08Jordan Hall: And the result is out of control of obesity.
- 8:11Jordan Hall: What happened was is that the the governing structures of literally the hominid arc from anthropological time up, it was governed by the fact that getting access to adequate calories was the primary problem.
- 8:25Jordan Hall: We uncorked that, we flipped it and said, actually, no, now you can get access to many calories as you want, but we didn't actually build anything in place that enable people to navigate that new landscape properly.
- 8:36Jordan Hall: And the net result was a very large portion of the population flipped into obesity.
- 8:41Jordan Hall: Um that's a that's an example of both an absent sociotechnical environment and an absence spiritual environment that can navigate the shift from scarcity to abundance.
- 8:50Jordan Hall: You could do the same thing, by the way, if you even wanted to, more catastrophically in the context of reproduction and sex.
- 8:57Jordan Hall: Up until the pill, uh male-female sexual activity was driven by scarcity, grounded in scarcity.
- 9:03Jordan Hall: If it produces children, then and that that shaped all societies up until the 1970s and 1980s.
- 9:10Jordan Hall: When the pill became ubiquitous and the underlying premise was no longer available, we've now navigated into an environment somewhat paradoxically, but not radically paradoxically, where fertility rates are collapsing globally.
- 9:22Jordan Hall: And we may actually extinguish ourselves in two generations because we no longer have the capacity to produce and raise children that raise children.
- 9:29Jordan Hall: So that's another example of where scarcity moving to abundance lacked a and this image, and you can't really see it, but then this image of inversion, because it it actually very much is one of flipping things upside down and moving out of one regime into a completely different regime.
- 9:43Jordan Hall: And almost all of our inertial, inherited, unconscious, in many cases, evolutionary, biological, and then traditional structures weren't designed for abundance and therefore aren't properly able to govern a realm where the choices are now abundance.
- 10:00Jordan Hall: And this leads to a number of negative consequences.
- 10:02Jordan Hall: So those are examples.
- 10:03Jordan Hall: I can give you the minute you'd like.
- 10:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the the means to get there to this large access to higher to just abundance and food, the way we did it is not necessarily a naturalistic approach to to feeding the world.
- 10:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's more of an engineering approach.
- 10:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can we say that?
- 10:39Jordan Hall: Well, let me let me let me just I'll add more words.
- 10:43Jordan Hall: So we've got we have the ability to decompose an inherited complex event.
- 10:49Jordan Hall: So an apple has, as a complex event, has let's say three major constraints.
- 10:59Jordan Hall: One constraint is it's seasonal.
- 11:01Jordan Hall: There are sometimes aren't apples.
- 11:03Jordan Hall: Another major constraint is they're on a tree, so you have to actually harvest them in some fashion that requires a but certain activity.
- 11:09Jordan Hall: And the third constraint is that an apple is itself a complex object.
- 11:12Jordan Hall: It contains things like fiber and multiple different nutrients.
- 11:16Jordan Hall: Okay.
- 11:17Jordan Hall: So what we are able to do is we're able to decontextualize and extract out a apple-flavored apple jazz, which no longer has seasonality.
- 11:27Jordan Hall: It no longer has any of the context of a tree, and in fact, has none of the bound context of an apple.
- 11:33Jordan Hall: But it has sugar or sweetness, it has the sweetness of apple, it has the flavor of apple.
- 11:38Jordan Hall: And so what it does is it becomes a super what's called supernormal stimulus.
- 11:42Jordan Hall: It hit the portion of our evolved system that says apple flavored sweet is good and give us 50 times that.
- 11:50Jordan Hall: But by virtue of decontextualizing it for the remainder of the environment, it produces a, and this, by the way, is a classic problem with madurity in general.
- 11:58Jordan Hall: It unconsciously, usually, removes all the elements of that context that were actually critical.
- 12:03Jordan Hall: Sorry.
- 12:03Jordan Hall: Chesterton's apple feedlot.
- 12:06Jordan Hall: There's something about the fact of appleness, and maybe even the fact of apple treeness that is is actually critical and load-bearing in our nutritional, maybe even by the way, our social law, social psychological being, that when we decontextualize it and optimize for something narrow, we get a problem.
- 12:23Jordan Hall: So if you if that's what you mean by engineering approach, yeah.
- 12:26Jordan Hall: Decontextualize, optimize, and upregulate a narrow target, then yes, that's exactly the problem.
- 12:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 12:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if I'm hearing you correctly, if we take a more naturalistic approach, understand anthropology, understand natural sciences, and and this goes back to a lot of your work you've done in the past and things you've said in the past, that's probably the optimal approach.
- 12:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's that's going back to the you know, the work with complex systems and systems thinking, right?
- 12:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You mean the we think.
- 12:52Jordan Hall: Well, well, what I would say is that the the most critical element is the degree to which abundance rests upon individual collective discipline.
- 13:00Jordan Hall: Meaning that we move the criticality of our choices from highly bound by received context into deliberately selected.
- 13:10Jordan Hall: So this is the the easy example is if you just imagine, man, I cannot get this out of my throat.
- 13:16Jordan Hall: If you imagine the anthropological, naturalistic landscape, where again, my ability to access ten apples is very limited on the degree to which there are ten apples to get, and that I'm ready, willing, and able to put out the work to get them.
- 13:28Jordan Hall: And migrate that.
- 13:30Jordan Hall: This addresses that problem.
- 13:31Jordan Hall: Uh no, it's all good, man.
- 13:33Jordan Hall: So you were talking about uh migrate uh apple.
- 13:35Jordan Hall: Right.
- 13:36Jordan Hall: So now you find yourself in our plentiful American grocery stores.
- 13:39Jordan Hall: I could 10,000 apples at my ability to say, cheese, just make it Costco.
- 13:43Jordan Hall: I can hardly avoid it.
- 13:44Jordan Hall: Now what happens is instead of having my choice on how many apples to consume be almost entirely received by the constrained context of my natural environment, the choice of how many apples to consume has to come from somewhere else entirely.
- 13:57Jordan Hall: In this case, it had to come from my own normative, almost ethical and aesthetic, let's say, uh discipline of what is proper nutrition.
- 14:06Jordan Hall: Now that requires a lot, not j not just, it does require something like a science of nutrition, or at least a, yeah, science is good.
- 14:12Jordan Hall: I don't necessarily, when I say science, I don't necessarily mean I definitely don't mean a scientism, but a well-understood model of what nutrition is on the basis of a variety of different inputs.
- 14:21Jordan Hall: So I need a science of nutrition, but I also need something like ethical discipline.
- 14:25Jordan Hall: And you probably well know that it's not uh trivial.
- 14:28Jordan Hall: Easy to know that you should go to the gym.
- 14:30Jordan Hall: It's not easy to go to the gym and not skipping leg day is a non-trivial event.
- 14:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 14:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh I d I I know you have some experience in like neutropics and maybe even the uh psychedelic assistant therapy space and consciousness.
- 14:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if I'm hearing you correctly, we're what what I'm what I feel you're saying is we're what needs to happen is we need to get back to the basics of being human in this in this age of AI, you know, and this as things accelerate.
- 14:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a weird mirror image.
- 14:59Jordan Hall: So it will look very much like the basics of being human.
- 15:02Jordan Hall: Uh okay.
- 15:03Jordan Hall: But it will have to be done on this entirely different basis.
- 15:07Jordan Hall: That's the key.
- 15:07Jordan Hall: So if you recognize that the basics of being human already imply the anthropological context, just use our apple tree.
- 15:15Jordan Hall: It implies the fact that there's only 10 apples.
- 15:17Jordan Hall: Um, this this is key.
- 15:18Jordan Hall: So the basics of being human sit on top of a contextual substrate of our received evolutionary history.
- 15:25Jordan Hall: When you get rid of that, the basics of being human need something else, which is completely different in nature.
- 15:30Jordan Hall: But that something else will actually begin to reorient towards something that looks an awful lot like an indigenous Homo sapiens.
- 15:38Jordan Hall: It'll look a lot like that.
- 15:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 15:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's where you think we're heading?
- 15:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is is is that what I'm going to do?
- 15:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 15:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 15:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 15:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so now can you tie in consciousness again?
- 15:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I know we kind of started off with that.
- 15:51Jordan Hall: Yeah, and let me let me just kind of hit that point.
- 15:53Jordan Hall: So if you imagine AI or accelerating change or the singularity narratives, most of those narratives tend to look like transhumanism.
- 16:03Jordan Hall: They tend to look like disembodied minds or robot bodies or something that uh David Egan would have written about.
- 16:10Jordan Hall: I'm actually arguing that the the reverse, that the only futures that are stable, futures that are actually it's called viable timelines, look an awful lot like a archaifuturism, that human beings look and behave much more like we did in pre-civilized environments, pre-agriculture, than we look like space robots, for example.
- 16:30Jordan Hall: And that's why you're optimistic.
- 16:33Jordan Hall: No, that's actually not why I'm optimistic.
- 16:35Jordan Hall: Although I that does make me optimistic.
- 16:37Jordan Hall: That fact is does make me optimistic, but the the reason I'm optimistic has to do with the fundamental nature of eDIOS.
- 16:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What generative sides of that or learning, adapting, adapting?
- 16:47Jordan Hall: What do you think?
- 16:47Jordan Hall: Oh, it's if you take the idea of saying I can think about a way of I can formulate a theory of strategy that is generalizable across domains.
- 16:57Jordan Hall: Again, I don't have jungle or desert.
- 16:59Jordan Hall: I can use the Outinek and think about a meta-strategic approach.
- 17:02Jordan Hall: What I can do in the context of AI is I can say, well, is are there, is there sort of like a stable attractor in strategy space?
- 17:09Jordan Hall: What is in fact the most strategic strategy, the most powerful strategic position available in principle in all possible landscapes?
- 17:17Jordan Hall: And the answer I think is yes.
- 17:19Jordan Hall: And that answer turns out to produce an attractor in the form of what AI must look like.
- 17:26Jordan Hall: In other words, an AI that isn't in that location will be strategically suboptimal compared to an AI that is in that location, and therefore will lose.
- 18:33Jordan Hall: That's what it means to be strategically suboptimal in a conflict.
- 18:36Jordan Hall: And so the natural trajectory of the evolution of the AI landscape was towards that location.
- 18:41Jordan Hall: It turns out that that location looks pretty good for us humans.
- 18:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 18:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now I I don't think everybody shares this your point of view on this.
- 18:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and maybe nobody, in fact.
- 18:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, may uh no I I mean, uh I look at it as you know, as as we get this hockey stick acceleration, the snowmobiles as adjacent possible.
- 19:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And your your analogy of hockey puck that can actually accelerate.
- 19:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's the space we're in right now, right?
- 19:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I don't think most people can wrap their heads around that.
- 19:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I think a lot of folks are you know fighting the last war, using that type of metaphor, that type of analogy to how we they apply this thinking.
- 19:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And going to your point about strategy, when you think about strategy, I heard you on a podcast talking about what we learned from the Manhattan Project, and it was a process, right?
- 19:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the the innovation process is more important than the actual weapon that was created out of it.
- 19:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's more important here, too.
- 19:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you got to take the well, we'll call it the process for now, take the process out and understand how a strategy is applied and start thinking like that.
- 19:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when we talk about strategy from a Boyd uh you know, a Boydian view, a mental tapestry, right?
- 19:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have to understand the landscape.
- 19:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We need some type of optical flow.
- 19:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We need to create some type of map, and we know that all maps are generally wrong.
- 19:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So and you're talking about attractors, and a lot of people don't know what attractors are.
- 19:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, in a fitness landscape, we we talk about that in the brain, we talk about that in in actually in the markets as well and in music, uh, but most people just don't can't can't grok this at the moment.
- 20:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're starting to see the sports world pick up on attractors too, because they're starting to see how you can train people using in perception action loop and things like that.
- 20:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So everything's kind of converging on the language you're using in here, but this language is kind of unknown to folks.
- 20:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I think when they start learning this, they can start developing better strategies or a better strategy, understanding the landscape.
- 20:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then going back to sense making, I'm gonna throw something at you to see if it resonates.
- 20:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When when I learned about sense making, I learned at it from a view of situational awareness, third-level situational awareness, which is anticipatory thinking.
- 20:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, what happened, what's happening, and what could happen in the future.
- 20:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Most people can't figure out what the hell happened yesterday, right?
- 20:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're arguing about that.
- 20:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't know what the hell's happening today, and they certainly don't know what the hell is going to happen in the future.
- 20:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't think anybody does.
- 20:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But that's what I'm hearing from you.
- 20:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what, you know, when I read your work and I see what you're doing on podcasts, it's very aligned to this type of thinking.
- 20:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's not to say that it's right or wrong.
- 20:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's just that uh if you take a naturalistic approach to decision making, sense making, how we perceive reality, that that's what I'm hearing from you is you're taking that approach to project forward in the near future what's what could happen to us as humans.
- 21:10Jordan Hall: Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 21:11Jordan Hall: Um just to kind of make you think of s simple examples.
- 21:14Jordan Hall: So first the a premise, even an invitation.
- 21:17Jordan Hall: Because you made the example of sports, that's beautiful.
- 21:19Jordan Hall: More people in different domains that begin to grasp the utility of these ideas, the more they notice that these ideas in fact have real utility and deploy them.
- 21:28Jordan Hall: And then they become the ones who are successful, and that then begins to bring the ideas into the domain.
- 21:34Jordan Hall: Other people are like, well, how'd that guy get successful?
- 21:37Jordan Hall: Well, he started thinking in this way and acting in this way.
- 21:39Jordan Hall: Well, shoot, I need to do that too.
- 21:41Jordan Hall: And of course, we see that that's the history of everything.
- 21:43Jordan Hall: If if you can, anulated.
- 21:45Jordan Hall: Sometimes you can't, sometimes you are constrained by other opponents.
- 21:49Jordan Hall: So if I get an example, let's try one of those.
- 21:51Jordan Hall: Let's say I had a team of 11, 11-year-old soccer players, and then I had the Spanish national team who just won the World Cup, and I had them play soccer.
- 21:59Jordan Hall: Yeah.
- 22:00Jordan Hall: Who's going to win?
- 22:02Jordan Hall: More likely the Spanish team.
- 22:04Jordan Hall: Yeah, with very high likelihood.
- 22:06Jordan Hall: Like you, it's not absolutely certain, nothing is.
- 22:08Jordan Hall: But we could put a very you could put a pretty big bet on that and be pretty confident.
- 22:11Jordan Hall: And the point, of course, is the reason why you're able to say that is you have an internal model of how things like sports works, how gradients and quality of performance software, things like that.
- 22:20Jordan Hall: And you can do that across the board.
- 22:22Jordan Hall: Now, the point is that you can make a model of how a particular domain operates and use that model to that give you predictive power over how that a scenario would play out.
- 22:31Jordan Hall: This is an extremely trivial thing that I'm saying, but the point is we start at the most trivial, then we begin to work step by step.
- 22:36Jordan Hall: Now, let's say I take a uh a Spitfire and a uh an F-18.
- 22:42Jordan Hall: When?
- 22:43Jordan Hall: Unless the guy who's flying the F-18 isn't is or the plane or the man are dysfunctional in some way, it's gonna be the F-18.
- 22:51Jordan Hall: In fact, most likes the Spitfire doesn't even know he got blown up until he until he's uh looking at down from heaven saying, hey, what the heck happened?
- 22:57Jordan Hall: Um again, same idea, right?
- 22:58Jordan Hall: You can do the models, you can understand things.
- 23:00Jordan Hall: Now, as you begin to narrow the gap, obviously this is where a lot of board's work came in, but we can start saying things like that which has the ability to observe its environment, orient on what is the relevant set of choices to make in that context, make decisions that are actionable within the most effective deployment of Of energy and then deploy those decisions in the most effective and efficient way.
- 23:23Jordan Hall: Um A and B, right?
- 23:25Jordan Hall: One that is good at that, well, I'll compete one that is bad at that almost all the time, which is the most basic premise.
- 23:32Jordan Hall: Then we can start asking questions about what is that which optimizes against all the characteristics of Boodo's.
- 23:39Jordan Hall: Now we start getting interesting.
- 23:40Jordan Hall: So you can say, well, what would it look like to have something that has higher reaction time?
- 23:44Jordan Hall: Okay, that's neat, because that's going to be able to move from decision to action in a particular fashion.
- 23:48Jordan Hall: Nice.
- 23:49Jordan Hall: What does it look like to have problems with perception to observation or orientation?
- 23:54Jordan Hall: Okay, I've got a bunch of sensors, but I can't process the information.
- 23:56Jordan Hall: I've got a bottleneck.
- 23:57Jordan Hall: Okay, that's interesting.
- 23:58Jordan Hall: You can then actually run a process of looking at every single aspect of this kind of a loop and think about what does it look like to produce something that has as its basic nature, it is the optimal OODA loop and is an always optimizing loop.
- 24:12Jordan Hall: In other words, it isn't just statically good, it is also maintains evolvability at the highest level.
- 24:17Jordan Hall: And so if you can state the question in that fashion, then you're actually saying something which is which is this works for me.
- 24:23Jordan Hall: What I'm about to say works for me.
- 24:25Jordan Hall: It may not work for most people, but it's like saying how many angles are in a triangle.
- 24:28Jordan Hall: I'm sorry, how many degrees are in the angles of a triangle?
- 24:30Jordan Hall: And you go, well, 180.
- 24:32Jordan Hall: I go, yes, exactly.
- 24:33Jordan Hall: Or we can say that, say that with real precision.
- 24:35Jordan Hall: I call that a geometric statement, meaning circle has 360 degrees.
- 24:39Jordan Hall: Yes, no.
- 24:40Jordan Hall: Yes, cool.
- 24:40Jordan Hall: Um the beautiful thing about a geometric statement is that it speaks about phenomena or events that are transcendent in major.
- 24:46Jordan Hall: It doesn't matter which circle I'm talking about, circle in essence has a circle of characteristics.
- 24:51Jordan Hall: Once I know those characteristics, I can use them in a particular way.
- 24:54Jordan Hall: What we're trying to do is make a similar kind of argument about strategy, a similar kind of argument about oodaloops and say, is there a way to talk about the transcendent oodaloop, that oodaloop, which is the optimal and most evolvable?
- 25:06Jordan Hall: In other words, it maintains the highest level of in a given context and maintains that over arbitrarily large number of uh contexts.
- 25:13Jordan Hall: Such an object, such an event, will under most circumstances outcompete anything that is below it.
- 25:18Jordan Hall: That's the attractor.
- 25:19Jordan Hall: So this to give to give you a language, the attractor is there's a location in strategy space, which is this object is optimizing a volveability in Oodaloop, which anything that is trying to compete in strategy will move towards that.
- 25:32Jordan Hall: So the phalanx will become the Legion.
- 25:34Jordan Hall: Why?
- 25:35Jordan Hall: If you select against the Oodaloop space, Legion has closer to this transcendent peak in Oodaloop space than Phalanx is.
- 25:43Jordan Hall: Well, that's interesting.
- 25:44Jordan Hall: Napoleonic maneuver warfare outcompetes, you know, Frederick the Great, mass uh focused.
- 25:50Jordan Hall: Okay, why?
- 25:50Jordan Hall: Well, because it actually has a higher location on this landscape.
- 25:54Jordan Hall: Oh, neat.
- 25:55Jordan Hall: Well, if I can just grade things by their vertical or or their proximity to the to the peak, then I can say, well, if I can begin looking at what kind of moves move me closer to the peak, what kind of moves move me closer to the peak faster?
- 26:07Jordan Hall: That's the attraction.
- 26:08Jordan Hall: So that's that's the try I was trying to recapitulate the idea of not just your attractor in general, but the specific attractor that we're speaking about so that maybe more people could understand it.
- 26:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's great.
- 26:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's a great, great uh way to look at it.
- 26:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh hey, so you're you're very versed on the Oodaloop.
- 26:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, where did you come across it, just out of curiosity?
- 26:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When did you when in your career or your background did you find it?
- 26:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: About 25 years ago.
- 26:30Jordan Hall: I can't honestly can't remember the specific context.
- 26:33Jordan Hall: It's really odd that I can't, but I do know that I read and went through, somehow got access to the primary work, like the slides, the slide decks that Boyd put together, and then got, I was like, that's genius.
- 26:44Jordan Hall: I'm I'm a big fan of genius.
- 26:45Jordan Hall: So when I find genius, I had time to dive in and then said, All right, now I'm gonna go broaden out.
- 26:49Jordan Hall: I read like three commentaries, very comprehensive commentary, took it all the way to the end of Boyd's life, which was interesting to me because it's a number of post-structuralist thinkers that one would not ordinarily imagine would be part of his his uh his milieu, who I was familiar with separately.
- 27:03Jordan Hall: I'm like, oh, this is interesting.
- 27:04Jordan Hall: You know, I've got this guy who I'm reading through the lens of fighter pilot and then you know, strategic theorist.
- 27:10Jordan Hall: Like, wait, he's actually dealing with, I can't remember who it was, maybe Foucault or a Derrida or something like that.
- 27:15Jordan Hall: And he's doing something in a way which is he understands what they're talking about, and what he's saying is very interesting.
- 27:19Jordan Hall: So that reinforced my uh thought, thinking that this was a good thing to spend time on.
- 27:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, it is.
- 27:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and you know, we have access to the archives now, his handwritten notes.
- 27:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's they're making that more available.
- 27:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think you'll we'll see an announcement here from the uh Marine Corps um history division in the next few months.
- 27:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and I think a lot of people look at the OODA loop as a linear four-step process.
- 27:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, when I started to really pay attention to it, it was a connection between Eric Reese and Stephen Blank when they wrote the customer develop model after John Boyd's observer to side act loop.
- 27:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And of course, you get into fast transients with the lean startup and concepts like that.
- 27:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: However, a lot of their view of the OODA loop was a linear approach.
- 27:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then you get into the agile movement and the software development.
- 27:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm sure you're familiar with all that.
- 28:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's they're they're still applying the linear thinking of the OODA loop.
- 28:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, this this that's not the way I learned it in the military.
- 28:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and then you dive a little bit deeper and you see the connections of neuroscience, of philosophy, anthropology, biology.
- 28:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you're like, wait a minute, this is not a force-depth fighter pilot decision-making process.
- 28:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I I see that when, you know, we have Carl Fristenon saying that his active inference or the idea of active inference is isomorphic with Boyd's Oodaloop, uh, then I'm like, wait a minute, this this is more powerful than we think.
- 28:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's just, you know, it's it's about the lightest sketch of how a living thing operates with a changing environment.
- 28:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's what, you know, one of the reasons I want to talk to you is because you're already talking about these things and using the oodle loop.
- 28:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, and I think by helping those business leaders that that know about it from the the cocktail party they went to last night or the event where they heard a former Top Gun talk about the four-step process of Oodaloop, I think that's an opportunity, right?
- 28:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, wait a minute, we we need to dive into this and say that thing you're hearing actually has a lot of value.
- 29:01Jordan Hall: And it has a, as you say, a lot of richness that you may not be tapping into.
- 29:06Jordan Hall: Like you say, it's yeah, it's not, in fact, a linear four-step process.
- 29:09Jordan Hall: Each of the four components is is valid as a component, but that's you you you can be much more affected if you think about it more and more appropriately as to what it was actually talked about.
- 29:19Jordan Hall: Let's say and the active inference, uh, how to say orthogonal connection adds even more richness.
- 29:23Jordan Hall: Because now what that means is you can actually expand out and look at all the stuff that's going to happen in the active inference world and use that to bolster whatever it is that you're locally doing.
- 29:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so on that note, when we look at you brought up large language models earlier, we may not want to spend a lot of time on them, but there's there's a ceiling to them, right?
- 29:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're not actively engaging with the external environment, if I could put it that way.
- 29:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's a shift here with like reinforcement learning and using world models.
- 29:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit about that and what that looks like in the world of physical AI?
- 29:51Jordan Hall: Not a lot.
- 29:52Jordan Hall: I mean, what I can I can tell you maybe three things.
- 29:54Jordan Hall: One is, interestingly enough, I'd say, because it's not obvious that we're going to make breakthroughs in certain domains.
- 30:00Jordan Hall: So we know that world models matter.
- 30:03Jordan Hall: We were having trouble building world models that were actually performing effectively.
- 30:07Jordan Hall: And then there was a breakthrough in uh Lacun's team around world models not long ago, less than a year, maybe six months.
- 30:13Jordan Hall: I can't remember exactly now.
- 30:15Jordan Hall: And suddenly we're now in an environment where that's likely going to be on some kind of accelerating performance curve because it begins to add a whole, again, orthogonal dimension to what LLMs can do and fully compatible.
- 30:26Jordan Hall: There's like the the well, it's like the uh right side of the brain, the left side of the brain, more or less, like the uh language and kinesthetics are highly synergistic.
- 30:37Jordan Hall: So and then we should add things like you just think of a better way of thinking about it.
- 30:41Jordan Hall: This is actually a better way of thinking about it.
- 30:43Jordan Hall: The competitive frontier is extremely intense, and meaning that there's a a number of players, although not an arbitrarily large one, but someone maybe 12, I don't know how many there are specifically.
- 30:54Jordan Hall: The Chinese kind of throw some interesting monkey wrenches into how competitive landscape looks like recently, which could expand the name of competitors.
- 31:02Jordan Hall: But you know, open AI, Anthropa, now is in there, Google's got the play.
- 31:08Jordan Hall: China writ large, let's just cat make that a whole giant China Inc.
- 31:11Jordan Hall: kind of a big.
- 31:12Jordan Hall: So that's five.
- 31:12Jordan Hall: Maybe there's seven, something like that, but not many.
- 31:15Jordan Hall: But for the most part, these guys are all in.
- 31:17Jordan Hall: For the most part, they're saying this is a winner-take-all, zero-sum, full domain kind of a gig.
- 31:22Jordan Hall: What I mean by that is if you look at Facebook, this is a classic example.
- 31:27Jordan Hall: They discovered, oh wow, it turns out there's only one.
- 31:30Jordan Hall: Well, once Facebook achieved dominance, they owned this giant thing.
- 31:34Jordan Hall: There weren't like 15 competitors in Facebook land.
- 31:37Jordan Hall: There's one Amazon.
- 31:39Speaker 1: Amazon.
- 31:40Jordan Hall: That's the whole space.
- 31:41Jordan Hall: It's a kind of network effect.
- 31:42Jordan Hall: And the basic premise is that uh AI looks something like that.
- 31:47Jordan Hall: There might be an AD to Intel.
- 31:50Jordan Hall: There might be a Twitter to Facebook thing, require those niches.
- 31:54Jordan Hall: The world is not a sing a smooth, untextured topology.
- 31:59Jordan Hall: But the basic premise that's driving basically everybody who's plugged in the AI space is that uh whoever wins wins very, very big, 85% and more.
- 32:08Jordan Hall: The size of winning is enormous because you're talking about an abstraction layer that is above money.
- 32:13Jordan Hall: It's larger than winning the money game, winning the coordination and intelligence game.
- 32:17Jordan Hall: You maybe winning the deal with boom.
- 32:19Jordan Hall: Um and therefore, all chips are in.
- 32:21Jordan Hall: And so the the consequence is that the uh the frontier of what can be done to achieve local strategic advantage is extremely explorable.
- 32:30Jordan Hall: I think about uh World War II.
- 32:33Jordan Hall: All the players were like, this is a big, this this very intense conflict, existential.
- 32:37Jordan Hall: You know, whoever loses, loses completely.
- 32:38Jordan Hall: Whoever wins, wins becomes global global hedging on for some meaningful people to die.
- 32:42Jordan Hall: Leave no stern unturned.
- 32:44Jordan Hall: So the classic you know, Nazis were looking to see if Odin's spear can be found.
- 32:48Jordan Hall: Did they believe Odin's spear was real?
- 32:50Jordan Hall: Hard to say.
- 32:51Jordan Hall: Doesn't matter.
- 32:51Jordan Hall: They don't care.
- 32:52Jordan Hall: Like, look, if Odin's spear is real, we want it.
- 32:55Jordan Hall: And if it isn't, it doesn't hurt.
- 32:57Jordan Hall: Like, well, we're gonna we're gonna investigate it.
- 32:58Jordan Hall: And the point of that is that the notion of world models is a highly likely advantage for everyone knocked it out.
- 33:04Jordan Hall: And people like Elon are looking at it going, hmm, what are my strategic advantages?
- 33:08Jordan Hall: Tesla.
- 33:09Jordan Hall: Interesting.
- 33:10Jordan Hall: I have the strategic advantage that I have by by very large far the most real-world information sitting in things that are AI at the edge.
- 33:18Jordan Hall: And I'm actually actively teaching AI how to navigate it.
- 33:20Jordan Hall: That's neat.
- 33:21Jordan Hall: All right, let's lean into that.
- 33:22Jordan Hall: For a little while, Facebook had the advantage of the QM's research.
- 33:26Jordan Hall: They don't need more.
- 33:27Jordan Hall: And so that's kind of becoming more of an academic open source thing.
- 33:30Jordan Hall: But the point being that you you wherever advantage can be found, it will be explored with significant intensity.
- 33:35Jordan Hall: And so at a high level, we can say where are advantages likely to be found, and world models is extremely likely because it's so orthogonal.
- 33:43Jordan Hall: You know, we look at the gaps that LLMs have.
- 33:46Jordan Hall: One gap is they is that they don't live in the world.
- 33:48Jordan Hall: And the second gap is that they are not grounded, meaning that they don't have a comprehensive closure on where they are.
- 33:54Jordan Hall: Entirely received consequence of humans doing language.
- 33:57Jordan Hall: If humans didn't do language, LLMs couldn't produce anything but neurons.
- 34:01Jordan Hall: That's why their training data, the reason why the LLM structure or the math produces something that is actually interesting in the world, is that language is grounded in reality.
- 34:10Jordan Hall: And that grounding in reality is because humans are grounded in reality and we have produced the corpus of language.
- 34:15Jordan Hall: So because those are two caps, the exploration of what does it look like to make the uh stronger, actually, there's a third cap, is that because they're not in reality, they don't have agency.
- 34:25Jordan Hall: So we've had add agency, and that agency frontier has now been a big part of the last what year, year and a half?
- 34:31Jordan Hall: And will continue to expand really quite dramatically.
- 34:34Jordan Hall: I should just sort of plan to be surprised by the expansion of what's happening on the AI agency frontier for the foreseeable future.
- 34:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm curious if you can bring up the open AI controversy.
- 34:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh okay, if if you we do have these AIs that are that have a world model, they're lower energy, um, and we all have access to it.
- 34:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I would say that's a that's a good thing.
- 34:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If they're protected, if one company has universal access and and dominates, that's probably not a good thing.
- 35:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh can you comment on that and and correct me where uh you know what what would help help our listeners understand what does this networked world look like in the age of world models and AI?
- 35:16Jordan Hall: Well, let me just sort of state the the basic problem.
- 35:19Jordan Hall: Asymmetry, the word word asymmetry is good.
- 35:21Jordan Hall: We actually have even used the Spanish national team versus our 11-year-old soccer players.
- 35:26Jordan Hall: There's an asymmetry there.
- 35:28Jordan Hall: That's kind of the defining factor why you can say the Spanish will win.
- 35:31Jordan Hall: Asymmetry and a number of different objectives.
- 35:34Jordan Hall: Well, what AI does is it produces an asymmetry across a very large front of important characteristics, fill in the blood.
- 35:42Jordan Hall: Asymmetry and medical research, asymmetry in mathematical research.
- 35:46Jordan Hall: What week, month, we've now seen AI cracking stuff that has never been cracked before in a surprisingly blase fashion.
- 36:01Jordan Hall: That's an asymmetry.
- 36:03Jordan Hall: And asymmetry is power asymmetry.
- 36:05Jordan Hall: If somebody has a power asymmetry over you, then that somebody can make you do things that they want to do and you don't want to do.
- 36:11Jordan Hall: Simple as that.
- 36:12Jordan Hall: Um and because AI produces a potentially very large asymmetry, and I should maybe also tease that apart.
- 36:19Jordan Hall: Right now, if I have access to Claude Fable, I and you have no AI at all, I am significantly more capable than you are in a very large number of domains, and the breadth of domains matters a lot.
- 36:32Jordan Hall: Like if you're an elite software engineer and I'm a mediocre software engineer and I have Claude Fable, I might be maybe roughly equivalent to you, maybe not as good, actually, because verticality matters.
- 36:43Jordan Hall: If you're elite and I'm elite and I have fable, I'm probably 10 to 50 times, five, zero times more capable than you, just in terms of productivity.
- 36:50Jordan Hall: But here's the thing I'm also a pretty darn good physicist.
- 36:54Jordan Hall: I'm also a pretty darn good real estate agent, and I'm also a pretty darn good neuroscientist because AI is has that has breadth.
- 37:02Jordan Hall: And so you, as an elite software engineer, may know nothing about any of those other domains.
- 37:07Jordan Hall: That's the very nature of becoming elite, is that you have to have focused in that narrowing.
- 37:11Jordan Hall: I may not be able to compete with you in software engineering, although I might get close, but I can do something which is a thousand times, ten thousand times more than you in all these other domains, because the AI is part in that direction.
- 37:25Jordan Hall: So that's the that's the the the multiplier effect or the uh asymmetry in one way.
- 37:30Jordan Hall: And the other asymmetry, and this is the one that everybody talks about, and we're already seeing them, is uh the feedback loop.
- 37:35Jordan Hall: So if I use my AI to make the next generation AI, and you're just having to code by hand, then I get the advantage of I get basically compound interest.
- 37:45Jordan Hall: You're sort of uh lit linear accumulation of stuff, and I'm getting compound interest.
- 37:51Jordan Hall: So next year you've got 10 sheaves of wheat and I've got a thousand off.
- 37:55Jordan Hall: And then, you know, it just the curve is a geometric curve as opposed to a linear.
- 37:59Jordan Hall: And that is the problem.
- 38:00Jordan Hall: Like that's the capital T A G problem, is that if there is a compounding effect of intelligence on intelligence, which there is to some extent, we don't know if it's capped.
- 38:08Jordan Hall: We certainly are seeing the real effects of it in terms of the competition between AI companies, then he who has access to the most intelligence doesn't just have a particular advantage, he has an accelerating advantage over time.
- 38:21Jordan Hall: And so therefore, you you might find yourself in a circumstance that's kind of like the British showing up to the Polynesians, and well largely, meaning so much power of symmetry that whoever happens to have the high end of the stick can really dictate turns to sort of everybody else.
- 38:36Jordan Hall: And I shouldn't even expand on that.
- 38:38Jordan Hall: I'm not just talking about the ability to do software engineering, I'm talking about the ability to do material science, I'm talking about the ability to do physical aerospace, all domains that require intelligence to drive innovation, which is literally every domain.
- 38:51Jordan Hall: I have an asymmetric advantage, perhaps a remarkably large asymmetric advantage, which means that my power advantage multiplies over time.
- 38:57Jordan Hall: That is the biggest risk.
- 38:59Jordan Hall: That's the thing that most people are worried about.
- 39:01Jordan Hall: And most people who are worried about things, that's what they're worried about.
- 39:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So did I hear you say that maybe generalists in this age are more important than specialists?
- 39:10Jordan Hall: Yes, you did.
- 39:11Jordan Hall: Yeah, I I implied it.
- 39:12Jordan Hall: I didn't say it, but that's definitely the case.
- 39:13Jordan Hall: And I need to hear something like a coherent generalist or a polymath, not somebody who is a just sort of dabbler in many things, but somebody who's actually able to achieve a kind of a B plus or higher level of grounded quality in a number of different domains, suddenly is going to have already is having substantial improvement in performance.
- 39:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Boyd was, you know, he talked about cross-referencing domains all the time that you you got to look across, not not in the vertical aspect of things.
- 39:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I think what he wrote about years ago, and I think what what's being shown today is that's true.
- 39:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and then going back to software, you you know, your days in software, my days coaching software development in the Agile space, you know, 80, 100 people coding software has been replaced by a few.
- 39:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that correct?
- 39:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, absolutely.
- 39:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 39:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I remember, you know, 15, 10 years ago that you had coding camps where everybody was saying, you need to go to a coding camp, you need to do this thing because these jobs are not going to go away.
- 40:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that was less than, I'd say, seven, eight years ago, right?
- 40:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and now we're starting to see the decline in software developers, a requirement for them.
- 40:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then guys that were Marines that played with crayons can develop things.
- 40:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I I'm saying that in a nice way because my friends who are Marines, they can actually use cloud and things to create software, right?
- 40:23Jordan Hall: Yeah.
- 40:23Jordan Hall: Well, and you got you got two different things that are going on there.
- 40:26Jordan Hall: One is to the degree to which the amount of work that is being done by an organization is limiting, it's bottlenecked in some way.
- 40:34Jordan Hall: Then you're going to see a significant decrease in the number of people who need to do that work because the you know, the two or three best can actually do all the work and and frankly do better.
- 40:43Jordan Hall: Now, now, of course, that to the degree which is a is an assumption.
- 40:46Jordan Hall: It may be that the the the the uh organization will simply expand the amount of work that it's doing.
- 40:51Jordan Hall: This then goes into category B, which is the the competitive landscape explode.
- 40:55Jordan Hall: Very large number of groups that were previously unable to produce software, for example, suddenly can.
- 41:00Jordan Hall: They can either produce it for themselves or produce it in the marketplace.
- 41:03Jordan Hall: And the groups that did produce software are now producing more of it.
- 41:06Jordan Hall: And the question is whether or not the need, the overall demand expands at all in relationship with the overall supply.
- 41:13Jordan Hall: That's uh sometimes this is very important, by the way.
- 41:17Jordan Hall: There's there is no law of nature that an expansion of supply will produce an expansion of demand.
- 41:22Jordan Hall: Some things, we've seen that.
- 41:24Jordan Hall: We have seen it, for example, that we improve the efficiency and the produ and the uh availability of energy, that beats paradox.
- 41:31Jordan Hall: However, an increase in the supply of beanie babies did not increase the demand of beanie babies.
- 41:36Jordan Hall: There are things that have fixed demand, and supply does not drive increased demand.
- 41:40Jordan Hall: So we have to be thoughtful about what exactly are we talking about.
- 41:43Jordan Hall: Now, you know, this goes back to that notion of abstraction.
- 41:45Jordan Hall: It may be that there is, in fact, fixed demand for the kinds of things that can be done in software, but the demand for the kinds of things that can be done by intelligence is less fixed, flows after.
- 41:54Jordan Hall: Um, and that means we may be entering into opening up domains that we haven't actually even thought about recently, or maybe ever.
- 42:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Mm-hmm.
- 42:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm kind of curious, the type of jobs, like if you want to help our listeners, the individual listeners build resilience capacity in this environment, what are the things you would recommend for them to do?
- 42:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're talking about job seekers and things like that.
- 42:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then the same thing for organizations.
- 42:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If they want to re you know, survive and thrive in their own on their own terms uh going forward in this age, what do they need to do?
- 42:22Jordan Hall: Well, this all depends.
- 42:24Jordan Hall: Uh you you definitely should be very aware of the impact of AI in your industry.
- 42:27Jordan Hall: That is that that would be that's clean and simple for sure.
- 42:30Jordan Hall: This is not a trivial thing that you should ignore.
- 42:32Jordan Hall: This is substantially more important than the entire internet, for example.
- 42:35Jordan Hall: I would say it's substantially more important than computation thus far.
- 42:38Jordan Hall: If you imagine yourself sitting in 1958 and somebody came along and said, you should probably pay attention to computers, the answer is yes, you should probably pay attention to AI.
- 42:48Jordan Hall: So what does that mean?
- 42:49Jordan Hall: Um, let me give you an example.
- 42:51Jordan Hall: If you're if what you do, if your industry or what your activity is is is very much in the ground, let's say you build uh this is so hard, you you do wire wire harnesses for drones, then you're gonna want to do at least two distinct things.
- 43:05Jordan Hall: One is you're gonna want to leverage AI to tighten your processes and your operations so that you're able to get more effective, efficient inputs and outputs, communication from customers, designs and specifications, procurement, um, logistics, like tighten everything up.
- 43:20Jordan Hall: Just like this is what we did with the information economy in the first place, right?
- 43:23Jordan Hall: We actually wanted supply chain management.
- 43:25Jordan Hall: Just think about something equivalent to that.
- 43:27Jordan Hall: The other side, of course, is the innovation frontier.
- 43:30Jordan Hall: Going to have to have some kind of loop that is monitoring your environment to look at competitors, potentially emergent competitors, who are pushing the frontier outside of your capability of actually meeting the current standard of your market, because your market's going to be evolving faster.
- 43:46Jordan Hall: So what if your product meets the market's needs now, it may in fact not meet the market's needs in a year or two years.
- 43:51Jordan Hall: That that might be true in terms of functionality, it might be true in terms of price.
- 43:54Jordan Hall: Like I think I actually saw some guys who pushed out a new, as well, I mentioned wire harness, a new way of producing wire harnesses that's like twice as efficient.
- 44:02Jordan Hall: Well, shit.
- 44:03Jordan Hall: I mean, everybody else is effectively obsolete unless they can accelerate and catch up.
- 44:07Jordan Hall: Now notice this is I characterize it as a new loop thing.
- 44:10Jordan Hall: You're going to be using the LLMs to be monitoring your operating environment, right?
- 44:13Jordan Hall: You actually need to be doing sense making at a vastly higher level because the known players may not even be the relevant players on the maybe an adjacent movement, somebody who'sn't even in your industry, or by some startup out of who knows where.
- 44:25Jordan Hall: So you have to be able to scan your environment, upregulate events that are of meaning to you, which is a whole different kind of heuristic observe.
- 44:32Jordan Hall: Oh, yeah.
- 44:33Jordan Hall: Then you have to be able to decide how you're going to act on the basis of this new information.
- 44:37Jordan Hall: And then you have to be able to build a flexible enough organization that you can pivot, pivot, pivot.
- 44:41Jordan Hall: Um, and so a lot of the stuff that we talked about, say, for example, in Agile, starts to become intrinsically required for all kinds of organizations because uh the environment we're operating in is getting hotter.
- 44:53Jordan Hall: So you use that as a simple metaphor.
- 44:55Jordan Hall: As you heat things up, you have simultaneously more fluidity.
- 44:58Jordan Hall: So as ice melts, things become able to move in directions they were no longer they were previously unable to move, and you have more energy.
- 45:05Jordan Hall: They tend to be moving with more intensity in certain directions, more than water.
- 45:09Jordan Hall: There's a metaphor.
- 45:10Jordan Hall: So the entire economy is heating up.
- 45:13Jordan Hall: So if you're in something that you have that has been for the let's say real estate or uh construction.
- 45:18Jordan Hall: Construction has largely been untouched by technology.
- 45:21Jordan Hall: I mean, nail guns or technology, but untouched by the information technology revolution.
- 45:25Jordan Hall: And therefore, it's relatively slow, relatively inefficient, relatively slow.
- 45:30Jordan Hall: By hypothesis, everything's going to heat up.
- 45:32Jordan Hall: Therefore, your industry is going to heat up.
- 45:34Jordan Hall: And your industry is not used to being hot.
- 45:36Jordan Hall: It's used to being cold.
- 45:37Jordan Hall: And so you have to learn how to operate in a more nimble fashion.
- 45:41Jordan Hall: So you might want to bring in somebody who understands, let's say agile, and say, what would it look like to apply deploy agile as a fundamental way of thinking about how to build an organization in the domain of construction?
- 45:51Jordan Hall: So that's that's kind of the industry side.
- 45:53Jordan Hall: I give three or four points aside.
- 45:55Jordan Hall: I would look at it in terms of harvest, horizon, and fundamental.
- 46:00Jordan Hall: So this is a gigantic economic dislocation, and there will be trillions and trillions of dollars invested in it.
- 46:06Jordan Hall: You can harvest that.
- 46:07Jordan Hall: If you happen to be an electrician, I would recommend that you learn how to build electrical wire systems and hyperscalers.
- 46:13Jordan Hall: They're going to be needing a lot of electricity.
- 46:14Jordan Hall: And there is a radical scarcity in people who can actually deploy the electrical capability and/or hardware that they're going to need.
- 46:21Jordan Hall: Literally, trillions of dollars will be invested in that sector.
- 46:24Jordan Hall: And if you can move into that environment, you will simply be on the receiving end of a large wave.
- 46:28Jordan Hall: And it doesn't really matter how many water rules are built for that wave, a large wave returns a lot of water risk.
- 46:33Jordan Hall: Water rail here is a metaphor of how you can wave energy into your energy.
- 46:37Jordan Hall: So that's an example.
- 46:38Jordan Hall: You could simply navigate towards if you happen to be somebody who can figure out how to allow hyperscalers the ability to build in your region because you can navigate the real estate and regulatory and political environment, you will be making a lot of money.
- 46:51Jordan Hall: It's as simple as that.
- 46:52Jordan Hall: So that's one.
- 46:53Jordan Hall: That's a car list.
- 46:54Jordan Hall: You just notice where this enormous pouring of money is going to be.
- 46:58Jordan Hall: The point is it's enormous.
- 46:59Jordan Hall: And then figure out, happen to be able to move yourself towards that enormous pour in some fashion that hold out your cup and let it pour into your cup.
- 47:06Jordan Hall: The second category has to do with the example that I have, because I lived through it, was when the internet began to emerge, there was a whole wave of companies that popped up that helped legacy industries begin to migrate into the internet.
- 47:20Jordan Hall: They built websites, for example, you know, did the back end.
- 47:23Jordan Hall: What was that called?
- 47:23Jordan Hall: SAS?
- 47:24Jordan Hall: No, no, SAP.
- 47:25Jordan Hall: Remember those guys?
- 47:26Jordan Hall: Pubblestogles.
- 47:27Jordan Hall: Um, they existed to help migrate legacy economies into the information age.
- 47:32Jordan Hall: Well, something like that is going to exist ad nauseum at all levels in the AI age.
- 47:37Jordan Hall: So if you happen to be somebody who could master how to use large language models, and I'll give you an example in a moment of how weirdly trivial this can be, then you can bring that out to small businesses, medium businesses, or large businesses, depending on how good you are.
- 47:50Jordan Hall: And if you're interested in scaling, you can hire other people and train them and build a larger business.
- 47:54Jordan Hall: So the migration of every single piece of the economy across that threshold is an opportunity of enormous size.
- 48:02Jordan Hall: And kind of anybody can do it if you choose to put your mind to it now.
- 48:06Jordan Hall: That will not be the case in years, like three, four, five years.
- 48:09Jordan Hall: We will become more and more specialized and more and more professionalized.
- 48:12Jordan Hall: But right now there is no professional LLM jockey class.
- 48:16Jordan Hall: And so if you decide to learn how to do it, you'll be the one in your neighborhood who can.
- 48:20Jordan Hall: And then that gives you an opportunity.
- 48:21Jordan Hall: And the reason why I was going to give you an example is that this was uh how old are you?
- 48:24Jordan Hall: 53.
- 48:25Jordan Hall: Okay, so we're roughly the same age.
- 48:27Jordan Hall: I'm like, you're older than you.
- 48:28Jordan Hall: So Gen X discovered, not everybody in Gen X, but many people in Gen X discovered it.
- 48:33Jordan Hall: Our willingness to learn how to do HTML coding, for example, or to become a sysadmin was meant that somebody who had no training whatsoever could suddenly become the expert in this thing called the internet in their company and suddenly became a the guy.
- 48:47Jordan Hall: Fill the blank.
- 48:48Jordan Hall: You know, you could become the guy at the newspaper.
- 48:50Jordan Hall: You know, the boss of the newspaper comes in and says, You, you're 19, go figure out the frickin' internet and do it for us.
- 48:56Jordan Hall: Okay, go.
- 48:57Jordan Hall: And you could do it because the amount of information needed to become more capable than anybody else in your environment is actually relatively limited.
- 49:04Jordan Hall: And if you're willing to learn it, then you can.
- 49:06Jordan Hall: And the leverage is high.
- 49:07Jordan Hall: So that the point is the frontier for kind of like Gen Z, older Gen Z, youngest millennials, but mostly Gen Z is wide open.
- 49:15Jordan Hall: Just become the become very, very skilled.
- 49:17Jordan Hall: And for the next three to five years, you will in fact have an asymmetric capability that can be deployed more or less anywhere.
- 49:23Jordan Hall: Okay, so that would be sort of an example.
- 49:24Jordan Hall: Number two, you can do the other work, which is say, okay, there's what what industries will be disrupted in what way?
- 49:30Jordan Hall: So if you happen to be a junior software engineer, it might be a little tough.
- 49:35Jordan Hall: You might have to say, am I good enough to actually start competing in what's going to become a substantially more competitive environment?
- 49:40Jordan Hall: Or should I pivot to becoming an AI migration specialist, for example?
- 49:45Jordan Hall: Uh certainly if you're a copywriter of mediocre marketing copy, you should look for something else.
- 49:51Jordan Hall: Just not going to exist.
- 49:52Jordan Hall: It's a thing anymore.
- 49:53Jordan Hall: By contrast, as I mentioned, electrician, good job for sure, for the next five years, maybe seven.
- 49:58Jordan Hall: Now, here's the problem: supply and demand.
- 50:00Jordan Hall: Lots of people are going to get that, and lots of people are going to move into that.
- 50:03Jordan Hall: And as this hyperscaler wave comes and goes, there'll be an oversupply.
- 50:07Jordan Hall: So that's could be problematical.
- 50:09Jordan Hall: You gotta be thinking about that.
- 50:11Jordan Hall: This is gonna be a real challenge of how do you ride these waves?
- 50:13Jordan Hall: And this goes back to that notion of agile.
- 50:15Jordan Hall: So then we'll get to the kind of the fundamental.
- 50:17Jordan Hall: The fundamental is everybody's willing to have to become more disciplined and more agile.
- 50:21Jordan Hall: That's all there is to it.
- 50:22Jordan Hall: Um, there is no, let me see if I can I'll put this in historical context.
- 50:25Jordan Hall: Once upon a time, they were large companies, and you'd go work for them when you were young, and you would work at them their your entire career, and you would retire and they'd give you a watch, and that was that.
- 50:35Jordan Hall: And and a pension, by the way.
- 50:37Jordan Hall: They had a thing called a pench.
- 50:37Jordan Hall: You used to get getting paid money by the company, and then you didn't work there anymore.
- 50:41Jordan Hall: Um obviously, by the 1980s, that began to break down, and as far as I know, now it doesn't exist at all.
- 50:46Jordan Hall: And if it does, it exists almost entirely in its uh kind of mutant character caricature form.
- 50:52Jordan Hall: The point is this that basic notion of small, small groups, become very fluid and very capable on your own, and also become very good at assembling into groups of three, five, eight, think about it at that kind of like squad level, and spontaneously jumping into a squad, identifying a problem domain, rapidly building an appropriate approach, solving the problem, and then being able to dissolve back into individual groups, right?
- 51:16Jordan Hall: Become more like the special forces than like the 1950s army, is a simple way to put it.
- 51:21Jordan Hall: And that's just what it is.
- 51:23Jordan Hall: Like that's just again, the environment is getting hotter.
- 51:25Jordan Hall: Hotter environments mean smaller, more fluid, more able to bond in different ways, organisms.
- 51:31Jordan Hall: And this bonding matters.
- 51:32Jordan Hall: A metaphor I used with Jim, right, I'm not sure publicly, was the notion of carbon bonds.
- 51:38Jordan Hall: In other words, become the kind of person who people are loyal to because you are loyal, because you are trustworthy.
- 51:44Jordan Hall: People trust you because you are trustworthy.
- 51:47Jordan Hall: You are reliable.
- 51:48Jordan Hall: Why?
- 51:48Jordan Hall: Well, because in an environment where large organizations don't exist anymore, your ability to attach to something and just ride that positively or paratically goes away.
- 51:58Jordan Hall: Meaning your ability to thrive becomes your ability to become, to, to be choicefully bonded over and over again.
- 52:05Jordan Hall: Three days I'm working with this team, and then for three days I'm working with this team, and then three days I'm working with this team.
- 52:09Jordan Hall: Well, what does selecting mean to these teams?
- 52:11Jordan Hall: Ultimately, it's because you are the kind of person other people want to work with.
- 52:14Jordan Hall: And that kind of information, by the way, in a world where the marginal cost of information plummets to zero, becomes highly available.
- 52:21Jordan Hall: Literally, just is this is what it'll look like in the future.
- 52:24Jordan Hall: I will have my own personalized LLM agent that is an agent that knows me very, very well.
- 52:30Jordan Hall: And I'll wake up in the morning and I'll say, Samuel, I feel like the following three things.
- 52:35Jordan Hall: And Samuel come back and say, Of those three things, these two are extremely ripe right now.
- 52:39Jordan Hall: Would you like me to negotiate a project for you?
- 52:41Jordan Hall: Well, yes, I would.
- 52:42Jordan Hall: Samuel then reach out to, you know, into the into the web of environments, would come back and say, We have the following three invitations on the basis of our reputation.
- 52:51Jordan Hall: Would you like to join one of these projects?
- 52:53Jordan Hall: Click.
- 52:54Jordan Hall: Yes.
- 52:55Jordan Hall: That all that all on the back end, that's a lot of information, a vast amount of information.
- 52:59Jordan Hall: There's going to be actual, think about like the way that engineers get hired in the post-open source world.
- 53:03Jordan Hall: You'd say, hey, well, show me the project you've worked on.
- 53:05Jordan Hall: Well, show me the data stream of everything that you've done and everybody who's interacting with you.
- 53:10Jordan Hall: And it'll be processed instantaneously.
- 53:12Jordan Hall: And so you are going to be a walking a ledger of your actual relational quality, your ability to perform again, things like reliability, trustworthiness, effectiveness, efficiency, ingenuity, all the sort of virtues of collaboration.
- 53:27Jordan Hall: And weirdly enough, oddly enough, that is what it's selected for now.
- 53:31Jordan Hall: So all the various sort of vices of collaboration that have been able to be selected for, things like good at pretending to be effective for virtue signaling, these start to get selected against.
- 53:40Jordan Hall: It's just because the environment is able to be sensitive to small numbers of people constantly renegotiating their relationship and has the ability to perceive them.
- 53:50Jordan Hall: And so therefore they'll be selected against.
- 53:51Jordan Hall: And so the weird truism is become express the actual virtues of collaboration at a very high level.
- 53:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to read back to you what I think I heard, or the way I would put this, and that is in the military and in fighter aviation, uh, we have crew resource management, which is the foundation of team science.
- 54:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So think about uh commercial aviation.
- 54:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh the pilots that fly together generally don't know each other.
- 54:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They just do exactly what you described.
- 54:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The way they do that is through the crew concept, the ritualized form of a team.
- 54:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They have the teaming skills, the non-technical skills.
- 54:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If I'm hearing you, when you talk about the three, five, eight small teams or squads out there, that is gonna be more important now more than ever.
- 54:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The the non-technical skills you bring to the uh environment to collaboration are important.
- 54:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think there's another element in here.
- 54:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When you start bringing agents in here or robots, robotics in, or uh trying to think of another name, not not I guess not gonna say NHIs, but human machine teaming becomes a thing, right?
- 54:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so you brought in Samuel, who's your physical AI or whatever you want to call it, you're working together with a machine, we'll call it that.
- 54:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're using a crude concept, which I believe you define quite well.
- 54:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um the collaboration skills are more important in this environment.
- 55:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're you're still coming to the fight with technical skills, but those technical skills are evolving because they have to.
- 55:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 55:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But the nice thing is if you don't come to the fight, and I'm calling the fight the this new landscape.
- 55:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you have to have the non-technical skills.
- 55:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what and and there's a reason I'm saying this, because that's the space I'm in.
- 55:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, we we try to coach that, and most people push back on it and go, ah, I already know how to do this.
- 55:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, you better hope you do, right?
- 55:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 55:29Jordan Hall: Because this is what's coming.
- 55:31Jordan Hall: In the in the past, this is two two dimensions.
- 55:34Jordan Hall: One was technical skills could get away with actually being relatively dysfunctional at the teamwork level, just because technical skills were relatively precious.
- 55:42Jordan Hall: And even worse, various forms of parasitic organization, organi organization parasitic skills, like being an effective middle manager who nobody quite knew what he did, but was good at playing the game, uh, could get away with it.
- 55:55Jordan Hall: And and we, you know, anybody who's been in an organization knows that once an organization gets past a relatively small number, more and more and more of the weight is actually dead weight.
- 56:03Jordan Hall: And that's all just all there is to it.
- 56:05Jordan Hall: Well, what happens is that large organizations are all going to go away.
- 56:08Jordan Hall: There won't be large organizations.
- 56:09Jordan Hall: So there is no more niche for that skill set.
- 56:12Jordan Hall: So then you get two cuts.
- 56:13Jordan Hall: One cut is technical skills become less precious and parasite capabilities become vastly less capable.
- 56:20Jordan Hall: And that the what's remaining then is as a primary capability, and and I like your point, your uh addition, and I won't expand on it, of teaming with the machine.
- 56:30Jordan Hall: So teaming with other humans and teaming with the machines.
- 56:33Jordan Hall: Now, teaming with the machines is a highly non-trivial skill.
- 56:37Jordan Hall: Uh, the the anecdote I have here is these things are world-class bullshitters, the best bullshitters ever, the best bullshit that you've ever even imagined.
- 56:45Jordan Hall: And if you're not capable of calling bullshit, they are more than happy to leave you, lead you down a path of days, weeks, months of bullshit that looks amazing until it actually touches reality.
- 56:56Jordan Hall: And then you discover to your chagrin that it was all complete nonsense.
- 56:59Jordan Hall: Um, and that all that worked is just best off being thrown away.
- 57:02Jordan Hall: Now, on the other hand, if you do have the ability to call bullshit, if you have the ability to ground what's being done and be able to distinguish what is what is, say, true or grounded real from what is bullshit, then you can take advantage of them and they become a massive lever.
- 57:17Jordan Hall: This is the difference between, say, a junior engineer who steps into this harness and thinks they suddenly became a superhero, and a senior engineer who, in fact, actually is becoming superpower.
- 57:28Jordan Hall: And that difference is gigantic.
- 57:29Jordan Hall: This is very important.
- 57:30Jordan Hall: I've noticed a lot of people who are, um, how do you say it right, greedy and naive, who think that they can say, hey, I'll just start working with this LLM and I'll you know radically improve the quality of my business and I can fire all these other people.
- 57:43Jordan Hall: Quite often they're wrong, completely.
- 57:45Jordan Hall: Quite often they will be hundreds of thousands, millions of dollars into a business plan that was actually complete nonsense from the get-go, but they just built more and they began to be more and more and more in a world of their own creation because the LLM just is a world-class bullshitter, and they couldn't ground it themselves.
- 58:01Jordan Hall: That's the key thing.
- 58:02Jordan Hall: And psychologically, it's very easy to sort of say, it seems really bad.
- 58:05Jordan Hall: I would, I would hate for it to not be true, what this LM is saying.
- 58:08Jordan Hall: And I every time I ask it, it gives me really good answers that seem really brilliant.
- 58:12Jordan Hall: You know what?
- 58:13Jordan Hall: I'm just going to accept it and just go to the next step because you feel you get that dopamine hit if I feel like I'm moving forward.
- 58:17Jordan Hall: And of course, it's created, giving you a string of dopamine hits for spinning a large amount of your yarn.
- 58:22Jordan Hall: And this is not just my experience, this is an experience I've talked to hundreds of people about.
- 58:27Jordan Hall: So it's an interesting bifurcation.
- 58:28Jordan Hall: If you are able to really ground it and you're able to call bullshit, and you're able to know where it's delivering real results and law, then you're superpowered.
- 58:38Jordan Hall: If you're not, then you're superpowered in the opposite direction.
- 58:41Jordan Hall: You know, you're going to be subject to tremendous bullshit.
- 58:44Jordan Hall: So teaming with the AI looks like that.
- 58:47Jordan Hall: And by the way, if you aren't already grounded, like I knew basically nothing about high-level mathematics two months ago.
- 58:53Jordan Hall: And I started working on something.
- 58:54Jordan Hall: And for the first month, I kept running into this problem of bullshit.
- 58:57Jordan Hall: But of course, what happened was is I started learning how to ground properly and started learning enough pieces adequately all the way up and down that I could actually start scaffolding.
- 59:06Jordan Hall: And then the AI started filling in the gaps.
- 59:08Jordan Hall: And now I'm actually doing decent work.
- 59:10Jordan Hall: Not yet great work, you can't hold that yet, but decent work.
- 59:12Jordan Hall: And over time, if I keep focusing on it, I'll get more capability and be able to do good work.
- 59:16Jordan Hall: And then maybe maybe great work.
- 59:18Jordan Hall: We'll have to see.
- 59:18Jordan Hall: So those are that that's the invariant.
- 59:20Jordan Hall: The invariant is teaming skills in the human, which is time and memorable.
- 59:24Jordan Hall: You can just read basic virtue or military textbooks on what good squad looks like.
- 59:30Jordan Hall: And then teaming skills with the machine, which is completely novel.
- 59:32Jordan Hall: But the metaphor that I've used is it's kind of like a samurai sword that's a chainsaw.
- 59:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 59:40Jordan Hall: It's very, very powerful, but you really do need to learn how to wield it properly.
- 59:44Jordan Hall: Well, you will cut off your own.
- 59:46unknown: Yeah.
- 59:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh what if we could switch gears for a little bit and skip you for a few more minutes?
- 59:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I'll look at uh go back to consciousness and actually ground that in the uh emerging ideas that are coming out.
- 59:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We brought up earlier Michael Levin's uh platonic space.
- 59:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, there's some things coming out in from Donald Hoffman and Andrew Gallimore on the DMT side about others of or traces of others, things like that.
- 1:00:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know if you've seen any of that yet.
- 1:00:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But uh, can we talk a little bit more about the we'll call it the woo side of things, which I don't think is woo.
- 1:00:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's actually uh fascinating, the connection to religion, spirituality, uh, what we're learning about consciousness and and what we're learning from this acceleration of technology and how that applies to understanding who we actually are as humans.
- 1:00:24Jordan Hall: Uh-huh.
- 1:00:24Jordan Hall: Nice.
- 1:00:24Jordan Hall: So yeah, what I would say is maybe two things, first order.
- 1:00:28Jordan Hall: One is consciousness is, which I've always found that a bit amusing because sometimes you'll get people who are materialists that will say, well, no, consciousness isn't.
- 1:00:36Jordan Hall: There is nothing more so self-evident than the fact that consciousness is.
- 1:00:40Jordan Hall: Uh, you are the experimental apparatus.
- 1:00:43Jordan Hall: If you're currently conscious, you know it.
- 1:00:45Jordan Hall: You are self-conscious.
- 1:00:46Jordan Hall: And if you're not currently conscious, while you do not know it, the fact that you were not conscious is something you were aware of the moment you're conscious again.
- 1:00:52Jordan Hall: So consciousness is a very strong premise.
- 1:00:54Jordan Hall: What it is exactly, you know, is it is somehow deeply bound to material in a certain fashion.
- 1:00:59Jordan Hall: Okay, fine, we're gonna start having a conversation.
- 1:01:01Jordan Hall: But they're just premise.
- 1:01:03Jordan Hall: Consciousness is.
- 1:01:04Jordan Hall: Second, I'm very, very confident, though not certain, that the LLMs are not conscious.
- 1:01:10Jordan Hall: Okay, so that's the second.
- 1:01:11Jordan Hall: That one's again very confident but not certain.
- 1:01:13Jordan Hall: Some people I know who are more focused on that have come to similar people who I think are quite cake have come to similar conclusions now, not just my own assessment, okay, but also other people's assessments.
- 1:01:24Jordan Hall: So I will not be speaking about the fun kind of fantasy science fiction novels about conscious AIs.
- 1:01:30Jordan Hall: What I will be talking about is the model of identity, the model of human intelligence, the model of human identity that is being shattered by the fact of what LLMs are.
- 1:01:42Jordan Hall: So one way of thinking about it is that a big piece of modernity is that it has taught us to think that being a mediocre machine, mediocre is emphasis, machine, is what it means to be a human.
- 1:01:55Jordan Hall: And the kinds of things that machines do is what intelligence is.
- 1:01:59Jordan Hall: Okay.
- 1:01:59Jordan Hall: So if you would kind of walk around a early 2000s atheist coffee meeting, they would probably nod their head as something that they wouldn't say it that way, but you'd give a bunch of examples of what intelligence is and what humans are, and they would more or less agree, which is to say that there was a weird consensus that being able to do things like remember information and process information and articulate information in novel ways is a is both intelligence and what human beings are.
- 1:02:25Jordan Hall: Now, you you mentioned 11.
- 1:02:27Jordan Hall: Uh, those who are beginning to really delve into the nature of intelligence are showing profoundly that that never was even a vaguely adequate definition, both horizontally and vertically.
- 1:02:37Jordan Hall: In other words, it didn't cover the scope of what we're going to be able to identify and it was not grounded in what what's actually happening.
- 1:02:43Jordan Hall: And LLMs push that to the limit because LLMs are not mediocre machines.
- 1:02:47Jordan Hall: LLMs are extremely good at being machines.
- 1:02:50Jordan Hall: And so, in just the same way that if I would have said in 1960, uh human beings are just things that add numbers together arithmetically, and then you gave me a calculator, you'd go, well, shit, we're screwed, because those things are much better adding numbers together arithmetically.
- 1:03:04Jordan Hall: So I guess we're out of out of business as beings.
- 1:03:07Jordan Hall: Same thing.
- 1:03:08Jordan Hall: I say, hey, everything that an LLM can do is precise as the sort of thing that is actually not the essence of being human.
- 1:03:14Jordan Hall: That's the key key point.
- 1:03:16Jordan Hall: Nothing that an LLM can do is essential to being a human.
- 1:03:19Jordan Hall: Now, there are things that LLMs do that humans do.
- 1:03:22Jordan Hall: LLMs do produce rather coherent long text and write software.
- 1:03:27Jordan Hall: Humans do that too.
- 1:03:28Jordan Hall: And historically, only humans did that.
- 1:03:30Jordan Hall: So it makes sense that we would have identified that as being something that is essentially human.
- 1:03:34Jordan Hall: But the argument I'm making is that it's not essentially human.
- 1:03:36Jordan Hall: It is a function that has never been essentially human.
- 1:03:39Jordan Hall: And to the degree to which we accidentally identified that as being essentially human, we were already making a category error, much to the detriment of ourselves.
- 1:03:47Jordan Hall: Because LLMs are coming along and are forcibly taking that territory from us, we will go through a trough and then a recovery.
- 1:03:55Jordan Hall: The trough will be the demoralization of, oh my gosh, I had thought that I was a human because I could do acts, I could write software, or I could do math, or I could speak English fluently, at least quasi-fluently.
- 1:04:06Jordan Hall: And no longer am I the only one that can do that.
- 1:04:09Jordan Hall: In fact, I'm out competing.
- 1:04:10Jordan Hall: I've actually lost my job as an English speaking, fluent English speaker to an LLM.
- 1:04:15Jordan Hall: Therefore, I no longer have an identity as a human.
- 1:04:17Jordan Hall: That's kind of the trough.
- 1:04:18Jordan Hall: The trough of disillusionment.
- 1:04:20Jordan Hall: Um and by the way, it seems absurd, but the reality is that will actually happen to a lot of people because most people have identified they are the value as a being, is what they do.
- 1:04:28Jordan Hall: And what they do is largely stuff the mediocre machines do, because never already needed mediocre machines into have got good ones.
- 1:04:34Jordan Hall: Okay, so that's the trough.
- 1:04:35Jordan Hall: But on the other side of the trough is the reawakening of the reality that none of that was ever essential, and that a human is a qualitatively different kind of being.
- 1:04:44Jordan Hall: And maybe a way of putting it is that they're the fluid, fluent intelligence that LMs seem to demonstrate effectively.
- 1:04:51Jordan Hall: And there is something like the soul, or if you'd like a more fancy Greek word, the noose that humans have, and the LMs categorically do not.
- 1:04:59Jordan Hall: And that difference is going to be a wonderful difference because the restoration of humans into their proper role and place of being human means, and going all the way back to the beginning of our conversation, a restoration to a more indigenous way of being human.
- 1:05:14Jordan Hall: We will actually re-thrive because we will remember who and what we actually are, because the illusion that we've been living in for the past 500 years is just going to be forcibly removed by good machines.
- 1:05:26Jordan Hall: Quick interruption here.
- 1:05:27Jordan Hall: Noose, N-O-U-S.
- 1:05:31Jordan Hall: And a simple way of understanding that, if you understand Khan's distinction between the phenomenal and the numeral.
- 1:05:36Jordan Hall: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:05:37Jordan Hall: The noose is an ambient, intrinsic human faculty for being directly in relationship with the numeral.
- 1:05:45Jordan Hall: That's not precise, but it's a good way of thinking about it.
- 1:05:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Not familiar with that.
- 1:05:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the reason I thought I brought it up, I thought it related to the the Is it Newest Fear by Big Shardan?
- 1:05:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, no, it's not.
- 1:05:57Jordan Hall: Okay.
- 1:05:57Jordan Hall: My wife asked the same question three weeks ago.
- 1:06:01Jordan Hall: No.
- 1:06:01Jordan Hall: So you're familiar with that though, right?
- 1:06:03Jordan Hall: I am, yeah.
- 1:06:03Jordan Hall: Yeah.
- 1:06:04Jordan Hall: So newest fear is N-O-O.
- 1:06:05Jordan Hall: And this is N U.
- 1:06:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 1:06:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sorry for that interruption.
- 1:06:09Jordan Hall: Just curious.
- 1:06:09Jordan Hall: No, I was done.
- 1:06:11Jordan Hall: So the the point there is that um this is actually a very nice.
- 1:06:14Jordan Hall: I'd like here's a conjunction called a crossover.
- 1:06:17Jordan Hall: So a crossover that I would promote heavily is the crossover of Marshall McLuhan and Boyd.
- 1:06:22Jordan Hall: Yeah.
- 1:06:22Jordan Hall: And so McLuhan has said, or perhaps his son said, I can't remember which one, digital retrieves the medieval.
- 1:06:30Jordan Hall: So modernity is very much a consequence of the printing press, the literate, which moved us away from the medieval, uh, the uh C.S.
- 1:06:38Jordan Hall: Lewis's discarded image, right?
- 1:06:39Jordan Hall: So the image in the medieval world, the medieval mind, a bunch of very interesting stuff that this had went away in the context of literacy.
- 1:06:46Jordan Hall: And digital retrieves it, meaning we'll be noticing a very substantial restoration of medieval sensibilities, let's say, and the consequence of the digital, in fact, already are.
- 1:06:55Jordan Hall: And a big part of that is wonderful because a big part of that actually restores the intrinsic value of what is human in essence, and which the machine can never compete with potato because it is not qualitatively capable of.
- 1:07:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we do have a lot of conversations about the connection between McLuhan and Boyd.
- 1:07:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And in effect, yeah, we there's a lot of overlap there.
- 1:07:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then the deshred ant's work on the The phenomenon of man.
- 1:07:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Most people don't know that Boyd actually read that.
- 1:07:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And he read a lot of uh books on mysticism and and of course the Tau of Physics and things like that.
- 1:07:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So um I you've read that.
- 1:07:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It sounds like you're you're familiar with it.
- 1:07:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 1:07:31Jordan Hall: A long time ago, like twenty.
- 1:07:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I saw recently that even folks that are studying in psychedelic assisted therapies and how psychedelics work are starting to get into that as well as as they are looking at complex adaptive systems thinking.
- 1:07:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so uh the neuroscientists involved, and and I'm I know you're tracking that as well, is they're looking at, hey, this complex adapted system approach to understanding how this thing works is is fits well with what they're looking at now.
- 1:07:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's where you get attractors, right?
- 1:07:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's where we get it to I'm not gonna say affordances come from the same place, but uh attractors, affordances, the landscape, the fitness landscape, and things like that.
- 1:08:04Jordan Hall: Yeah, that language.
- 1:08:04Jordan Hall: And just FYI, just I just remember.
- 1:08:06Jordan Hall: So for for those who don't have it, the idea of an attractor is kind of simple.
- 1:08:09Jordan Hall: Let's take a uh a funnel and let's take a small ball bearing, and I I drop the ball bearing into the funnel.
- 1:08:15Jordan Hall: I can say two things about it.
- 1:08:16Jordan Hall: One is well, three, it's going to have a trajectory, in other words, it'll hit the funnel, it'll roll around in some fashion.
- 1:08:22Jordan Hall: Second, it's very, very difficult to predict what that trajectory will look like in its particular high or low.
- 1:08:28Jordan Hall: Will it go around six times or seven times hard enough?
- 1:08:30Jordan Hall: But the third is that I can say with almost certainty that it will drop down the bottom of the funnel.
- 1:08:34Jordan Hall: The bottom of the funnel is known as the attractor.
- 1:08:37Jordan Hall: I could drop in 10,000 ball bearings, and while they will have a very large number of different trajectories, they will all collapse to a single point.
- 1:08:47Jordan Hall: The attractor of the trajectories is the bottom of the funnel.
- 1:08:50Jordan Hall: So that's a very clean visual physical metaphor that I think most of you will have within an attractor.
- 1:08:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I actually I used a similar I use a bowl to explain that basics, and I said, hey, look, your uh your brain is not a bowl, it's more like a ski resort inside a snow globe, right?
- 1:09:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you shake it up, and you know, that that changes the landscape quite a bit.
- 1:09:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you want to have you know, if you're going down in a sled or down skis, you're gonna create these um grooves uh over time, and then you're gonna start going to the same basin, the same valley, whatever it may be, right?
- 1:09:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's an analogy I got from uh Robin Carhart Harris, and and the attractor landscape stuff is is a fantastic way to talk about this success.
- 1:09:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Most people don't know what they are.
- 1:09:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I we argue that they are uh if you start looking at Michael Levin's work again and Carl Frist and we asked him about this, we believe that there are in the market, there are attractors because they're harmonics.
- 1:09:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if the market is one global conscious, if we're all communicating with each other, then it's being reflected back to us in price and time.
- 1:09:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And more we can't prove it yet, but if everybody uses some type of stochastic approach to understanding the market or a process that uses volatility and and price and all that, they're using some type of math, which is a subset of the geometry that's inside the market, the the attractor set.
- 1:10:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the same thing is true when in strategy, I believe.
- 1:10:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we talked about that earlier.
- 1:10:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you're building a strategy, you've got to understand the landscape, and you have to build out what you believe the attractor landscape is based off constraints and energy, whatever it may be.
- 1:10:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But most organizations don't know to do this.
- 1:10:20Jordan Hall: They they just go, well, we're a really good example is classic, right?
- 1:10:24Jordan Hall: Is the high ground.
- 1:10:25Jordan Hall: The high ground is a metaphor that we often can now use across a variety of different domains.
- 1:10:29Jordan Hall: The high ground is an attractor, strategy space, meaning most trajectories that have the high ground win.
- 1:10:35Jordan Hall: Okay, we're done.
- 1:10:36Jordan Hall: Not always, but most.
- 1:10:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, we know I'm sure you're familiar with uh Dave Snowden's work, and he talks about that quite often where we use heuristics.
- 1:10:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if you look at the Marine Corps, they use you know, take the high ground, stay in contact, keep maneuvering, right?
- 1:10:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's a simple way to understand how to maneuver in a complex space.
- 1:10:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's what organizations need too is one could be take the high take the high ground, maintain your customer base.
- 1:11:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know, I'm just throwing things out there, but the same type of approach needs to be understood that heuristics matter.
- 1:11:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you're starting to see this in sports too, with them with basketball and and you know, they're using we know that uh through Bernstein that uh we don't have muscle memory.
- 1:11:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we have this habits of mind and and and you know the way we maneuver in space changes all the time.
- 1:11:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um so therefore, what we need to do instead of talking about the perfect delivery of a of a kick or a shot or anything like that, we need to talk about the heuristics of uh the back of the rim and down, right?
- 1:11:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what you want to be thinking about.
- 1:11:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Did did that go to the back of the rim and down?
- 1:11:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and we can guide people through that.
- 1:11:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're starting to see the emergence of this type of thinking in different places, but it's it's it's kind of clouded in different language.
- 1:11:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um but to me, when when you look at it, it's all the same.
- 1:11:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a fractal nature of the universe that if we understand how these things work, and going back to Boyd, going back to the things you talk about, if you start to understand it, you can start to see how these scale in different domains.
- 1:11:52Jordan Hall: Nice.
- 1:11:52Jordan Hall: Yeah.
- 1:11:53Jordan Hall: So just to kind of reinforce Snowden Dave, his work, uh, very fundamental work in complexity.
- 1:11:58Jordan Hall: And specifically, a distinguishing the complicated from the complex, which is helpful.
- 1:12:03Jordan Hall: And then second, where I think the prior his primary lead is how do we operate properly in the complex.
- 1:12:08Jordan Hall: So in the complicated, that's where you rules and regulations, right?
- 1:12:11Jordan Hall: Buy the book.
- 1:12:12Jordan Hall: Buy the book can work because it's a finite set of problems and you can actually find a place to look.
- 1:12:17Jordan Hall: The complex by the book is impossible in principle.
- 1:12:19Jordan Hall: So you have heuristics.
- 1:12:21Jordan Hall: And the key is to hone effective heuristics.
- 1:12:24Jordan Hall: And then by the way, you hone a meta heuristics that allows you to be able to select the proper heuristic rapidly, whole different kind of thing.
- 1:12:30Jordan Hall: Then you're going to be navigating complexity as well as you can.
- 1:12:33Jordan Hall: And by the way, it's complex.
- 1:12:35Jordan Hall: So you'll never be doing it perfectly.
- 1:12:36Jordan Hall: But if you can do it better than anybody else, you'll do it better than everybody else.
- 1:12:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll tell you what, this has been fascinating.
- 1:12:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I really appreciate your time.
- 1:12:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh I I know we can go on for a couple more hours.
- 1:12:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's so many more things we want to cover.
- 1:12:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh anything you want to share?
- 1:12:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What are you working on these days?
- 1:12:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What do you what do you what is your you're retired now?
- 1:12:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What is your life like?
- 1:12:53Jordan Hall: I've been retired since 2007.
- 1:12:54Jordan Hall: So I've been almost 20 years.
- 1:12:57Jordan Hall: Well, I've been absolutely neck deep in AI.
- 1:12:59Jordan Hall: So I've got you know $1,000 a month on the different AI systems.
- 1:13:03Jordan Hall: So I have using them all and using them.
- 1:13:05Jordan Hall: I'm becoming quite skilled at understanding what the characteristic difference is, like when does this question go to and COD?
- 1:13:11Jordan Hall: When does this question go to uh Google, for example, not often, but sometimes, maybe next first guy.
- 1:13:16Jordan Hall: And then figuring out how to deploy it.
- 1:13:18Jordan Hall: So how do I actually not just learn how to use it as an instrument, but then how do I use it to produce something useful?
- 1:13:24Jordan Hall: So as I mentioned over the past few months, I've been actually doing an extremely radically deep dive in what's called architectonics, mathematics, and physics.
- 1:13:32Jordan Hall: So I'm becoming somewhat skilled as a mathematical physicist.
- 1:13:37Jordan Hall: More importantly, I've been rather skilled in using AI in the domain of mathematical physics.
- 1:13:43Jordan Hall: Very weak in mathematical physics, but I'm quite skilled in using AI in that domain.
- 1:13:46Jordan Hall: So I'm trying to grow those two.
- 1:13:48Jordan Hall: That's just an interesting domain.
- 1:13:49Jordan Hall: Like if it has the advantage that useful interesting results can actually be grounded, you can find out.
- 1:13:54Jordan Hall: And there's not a lot of people who are competing for that territory.
- 1:13:56Jordan Hall: For a while, I actually started running into pure software development because I was like, wow, I no longer have to hire software engineers.
- 1:14:03Jordan Hall: I can write it.
- 1:14:03Jordan Hall: And that's true.
- 1:14:04Jordan Hall: But so can a lot of other people.
- 1:14:06Jordan Hall: And uh, so I looked at it and said, geez, while I am building good stuff, the velocity of stuff that's coming out is so much faster than even my current ability to build it, but I'm constantly having to go meta instead of building things.
- 1:14:18Jordan Hall: I'm actually building things to see who else has built something in this domain already.
- 1:14:21Jordan Hall: Well, wow, I'm actually building things that are learning how to seek between those who are building things to see other things.
- 1:14:28Jordan Hall: But like I was writing up the stack so rapidly, I was like, that's not gonna work.
- 1:14:32Jordan Hall: I'm gonna have to go down instead of up.
- 1:14:34Jordan Hall: So I went down into mathematics and physics, which have the characteristic of being invariant, and that otherwise, I mean.
- 1:14:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't have a math background, you know, enough to be dangerous, uh, some engineering background.
- 1:14:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you get into this uh work with uh again, going back to Friston and the active inference free energy principle, you get into the stuff that's coming out of game theory, connection to um consciousness.
- 1:14:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um I mean, it's it's pretty fascinating that it's all coming back down to math.
- 1:15:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And math is an invariant, right?
- 1:15:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's in the universe, it's it's it's there.
- 1:15:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and that's fascinating too.
- 1:15:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and some of the weirder aspects are looking at like the pyramids and understanding the geometry and the harmonics that are are there and seeing that in other places.
- 1:15:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, it's cool.
- 1:15:15Jordan Hall: I can see that you're a you're a rabbit holer.
- 1:15:17Jordan Hall: You've you've you've named like 16 things that are all of the rabbit hole characteristic, including uh a half moony.
- 1:15:22Jordan Hall: So let me give a last tip.
- 1:15:24Jordan Hall: This is actually a nice, useful, helpful tip.
- 1:15:26Jordan Hall: So to anybody at all, learn some math.
- 1:15:29Jordan Hall: Use AI to learn some math.
- 1:15:30Jordan Hall: Work with your LLM, pick something that you at one point you were frustrated because you didn't learn it, or were maybe can imagine being intrigued to learn it, and then learn it.
- 1:15:38Jordan Hall: Because here's the thing you say, okay, give me an example, give me differential equations.
- 1:15:43Jordan Hall: And the first time it gives it to you, you're like, I don't understand that at all.
- 1:15:46Jordan Hall: So write down this, right?
- 1:15:47Jordan Hall: Sorry, I didn't understand that at all.
- 1:15:49Jordan Hall: Let's go through a series of loops where you dumb it down until I do get it and you verify that I do, and then we'll build back up.
- 1:15:55Jordan Hall: And like literally, you'll the thing that you'll have is you'll have three good things out of it.
- 1:15:59Jordan Hall: One, you'll learn that math.
- 1:16:00Jordan Hall: You really will.
- 1:16:01Jordan Hall: Like, it's shocking how easy it is.
- 1:16:03Jordan Hall: It's not hard.
- 1:16:03Jordan Hall: It's kind of hard, but not really.
- 1:16:05Jordan Hall: Two, even really hard math is not really that hard.
- 1:16:07Jordan Hall: The hard part is understand.
- 1:16:08Jordan Hall: Once you get it, once you kind of get it, then you can start building out the capacity or capability.
- 1:16:13Jordan Hall: The second is you'll learn how to work with AI in learning new things, right?
- 1:16:17Jordan Hall: So that's that meta thing.
- 1:16:18Jordan Hall: And the third is you will get a feeling of being capable.
- 1:16:22Jordan Hall: You're like, wow, that was a win.
- 1:16:24Jordan Hall: I actually tried something with AI and it worked measurably, demonstrably.
- 1:16:28Jordan Hall: And you get a sense of what it means to be grounding in real truth, which again, mathematics is helpful because it can be proven, which then helps distinguish between bullshit and real truth with AI.
- 1:16:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I think that's a great I re I really appreciate it.
- 1:16:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll wrap it up right there.
- 1:16:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll keep you on for a few moments.
- 1:16:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks again.
- 1:16:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right, see ya.
- 1:16:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Bye bye.