Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 12 - Silo Thinking - The Business Killer Nobody Owns
Transcript
- Dan Culverhouse: Hello everybody and welcome to Under the Palette Wrap. This week we are asking is silo thinking actually the root of the problem for general business misalignment or is specialization doing exactly what it should? And is the real failure that nobody really owns the handoffs between the silos? Or is it just bad management? And Keith, can we get you? Give us your headline, what do you think? Keith: going to go straight in there two-footed and say I think it's a result of bad management and I say that as a specialist myself. I have gone to so many businesses as a consultant, worked at so many businesses and the silo effect is so prominent to me when the leaders have lost control sometimes they're not as aware as maybe they should be that there is a silo thing going on and they're not doing anything about it. So that's my take. I think it is down to the leader to manage it. What about you? Dan Culverhouse: I can't say I disagree with that entirely, but I don't think you can abdicate and just say, it's my boss's fault. I think it's everybody has a responsibility to act in a manner that is for the good of the business and not just for the good of themselves. And I just don't think you can just say, well, you you don't pay me enough to be worried about that. That's my job is I analyze this data. I do the forecasting, so I've done the forecasting. It's not my fault if you don't read it or don't see it. know, that's people above my station have got that issue. And I'm sorry, I just don't buy that. think everybody has a responsibility to ensure that what they do, they do for the betterment of the business, not just for the betterment of themselves or hitting their own target. You know, so, yeah, I can't say that I can align with you and say, yeah, yeah, it's just, it's a leadership problem. It is a leadership problem, but it's not just Keith: is simply the leader. Dan Culverhouse: a leadership problem in my mind. Keith: It's a good challenge and of course we all ask for autonomy don't we? mean most of us, not everybody, some people really enjoy the security and the framework of being told you know this is your job and that's what's expected of you but a lot of us want a bit of autonomy so how can we expect autonomy if we're not trusted but where does the line blur from being trusted to going entirely off on your own direction and slowing down the progress of the business. Where do you think that that fork in the road occurs if it isn't down to the manager? Dan Culverhouse: Well, I don't think having autonomy eliminates your ability to share what you find. Right. So I don't think it's about everything you do. You have to do it with everybody. I mean, that's just madness right now because you need specialists to be able to get in and understand the cause of the problems or you need specialists to be able to manage a chain. And you can give people the autonomy to drive that, but they need to tell people what they're doing. You know, can't just go in and do it. And then when someone comes in and they say, this is all different. Oh, yeah, yeah, we implemented the change. It's much better. You know, that's just, that's just stupid. So for me, you can be autonomous. You can have autonomy. You can be trusted to get on with stuff. But when you've reached a conclusion before you go running off and do it, maybe talk to a few people. You know, there's a ripple effect in everything that you do in a business, it affects others and everybody should have that in their head. Keith: The shit. Why don't they? Dan Culverhouse: It's a good question. and it does come from leadership for sure. one of the things I always think is is a naivety around objective setting. If you set an objective for one team to drive demand as hard as they can, no matter what, right, they just say drive demand and you say to another team, the ops team, I want the cheapest operation you can possibly create. I want you know, it to be as cost effective as possible. Well, there are polar different opposite mindsets that are going to cause each other problems. So if you have a operation that's focused on being cheap and doing it as for as little as possible, every time there's a rush in demand, you're going to have a problem. And if you have a team that's only focused on how do I drive more and more demand, they're going to completely overwhelm the operation on a regular basis. you know, There's a core part of this as they're making sure that you build aligned objectives. You build a culture where sharing is the right thing to do and you recruit people in that way. You don't recruit arrogant, selfish people that are just wanting to get on for themselves. You need to build team players and team players will always want to share and want to give what they've learned and what they've done. You know, I just don't know that you can allow everybody in the business. Well, you know, you're a specialist. Just do that. Don't worry. I'll tell everybody about it later. Keith: yes, well, leader as messenger. I heard your point about don't employ elegant people. I'm going to be asked a rhetorical question here. We're very geared up to a certain idea of success sometimes. And we always look for those big wins. I've done had these big wins in my past career. I'm going to make the same happen here. Isn't that what the leaders are looking for? People who are driven, successful, uncompromising, Dan Culverhouse: Well, it might be. Keith: deliver results. Dan Culverhouse: I don't necessarily think it's the right way to drive a lasting, sustainably successful business. I mean, you might have some success with it, but if you're just standing on the shoulders of others and not recognizing their input, sooner or later, those people are not going to help you and they're going to do their damnedest to make you fall. It might be a short term gain, but I don't think it's an approach or a culture that has longevity or not long term success anyway. You know, I think to some degree it comes from the leadership. leadership sets the culture, but I think if you can create that culture or you can develop and train people with to have an understanding of that kind of a culture, it then. very much sits with the responsibility of everybody in the business to be considering how what you might do may have a positive or negative effect on another team. And how do you find that out? You talk to people, you you share what you're doing. And it's, you know, I think the days of, you know, someone creating something and it just being taken by a boss and everybody went. It's a little bit of a kind of an antiquated, you it's very easy to see who created documents and who did what. Keith: I agree it's antiquated if we suggest that everything comes from the boss. I don't think that's what leadership is about. It's still about empowering your team and getting them in the right mindset. But it's about unifying those in your team to the same mission and unblocking their path. That's the job as the leader and I think a good leader is well aware of their stakeholders needs. You're not always going to agree but you're also aligned with the mission of the business. I think the most successful businesses I've experienced have had a shared vision and the strongest leaders are just very good at showing their teams that vision and allowing them to achieve it. But based on your points around building a culture, I've been very lucky at Netapurite to work somewhere where there was amazing culture. Not siloed at all. There are probably small silos here, there and everywhere, especially as it grew. You can't maintain the equilibrium forever. It's a living entity, isn't it? we had company vision, what we call bless, our values. Bless, we were all aligned to that. We all knew what that meant, be the best, lead, follow. And we all aspired to it. obviously with lots of mergers and lots of acquisitions it sort of became diluted and Dan Culverhouse: you Keith: it became a thing of the past but certainly there was an era where we all very much aligned with that culture but there were very very strong leaders who made those values very clear to us and an investment in training and that's what I wanted to come back to you your vision of the autonomous successful organisation you mentioned training, alignment, culture. Do you think then that there should be a big investment in HR, learning and development and the rest of it that comes with that? What do you think the right balance is there? Dan Culverhouse: I would definitely say all businesses, matter how big or small you are, should invest in people. HR as a function, I have mixed feelings about how that has developed and grown over the years. In many companies it's simply the policy police and they create more problems than they solve, but that's a different topic. So yes, I do think that all businesses should invest in people. and it's not just investing in people's training and development, it's also investing time into listening to them because you know what? Just because you're the founder or just because you're the CEO doesn't mean you know it all. There are people in your business, probably in relatively small junior, lower paid roles that have a lot of value to share if you'd only listen to them. this is where you come back to culture and values again. Something you said just kind of resonated with me. And I think it's a very common thing that a CEO and a leadership team that creates a culture and a set of values. To me, that's completely wrong. Values should be created by everybody. You know, it should be a listening exercise that ends up at the top where they finalize the wording and based on what they've heard and the feedback from the company, the people in the company. that creates, because then if people feel like they've been involved in that process, in that decision making, in that creation of values, you've built a company of advocates. Whereas if the top six people sit in a room in some nice country estate, you know, with a nice dinner and they come up with some great values, I'm sure they'd be lovely worded and they sound very good. But nobody else in the business is invested in it. And then it's a real hard slog to try. to impose that on everybody or convince everybody it's the right way to do it. So I think absolutely invest in people, but invest in people beyond training and development. Invest in listening and giving them time and recognizing the value that they can add. There you go. Keith: I agree with that point sometimes at the very beginning the business is only the six people. How long have they got to come up with these values when they're a bigger business? I think it's quite utopian to suggest that everyone's invested in creating these Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, you can't listen to it. Keith: values. It's a lovely way to look at it and I mean we maintain those values. at Net-a-Pour-Tay for many many years. Our social committee, the things we did for charity, the way we brought the teams together. Eventually the business became a bit too big to manage that in the way that we were accustomed to. you know we had to split the Christmas parties in two. Ops versus Westfield and that started to become a little bit more difficult to to manage those values at that Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, Keith: point. it was a good time for me being in the blessed committee because we had all these great ideas that we put to the team and we decided that we'd do something nice for the team once a month in the operation. We'd have an ice cream van, we'd have something for valentines, we'd have something for Easter, Easter eggs as an example. We've won a lovely Easter egg. And then we decided we'd have pumpkin carving at Halloween. And then we sent a survey out in December because we wanted people's feedback. Filling the anonymous survey, send it back to see how successful our social committee was. Some of the answers were hilarious. mean, someone actually wrote on their forum, less pumpkins. I just remember thinking, you can't please them all can you? Dan Culverhouse: No, well, you definitely can't. And I think I get your point about it's a very utopian perspective to say you need to. And I don't mean ask everybody, but I think you need to take people from across the business and all levels of the business Keith: Look, presenters. Dan Culverhouse: and bring them together, because Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: then they become advocates and they can talk amongst their team, say, I'm going to this meeting, you know, tell me what you think. I'll you know, it's it's I just think that they're for really to make a culture, a vision and a set of values to work, it has to come from the business. And you're right that the initial ones may well be those top six, because you know what? When they did them, they were the only people in business and it were their values. And that makes a lot of sense. But as they then become 50 people, you should review them, you know, get people's opinions. You know, think, surveys are fabulous things to do to get, you know, but the important thing is, but you know, The important thing about those staff surveys is don't do one if you're not prepared to listen and do something about it, because otherwise all you do is create even more frustration, right? Because Keith: I agree that's where the leader comes in. Dan Culverhouse: you ask us and now you don't even listen, you know, so it's better when you didn't ask. Keith: This is where we go back to the responsibility of the leader and making sure they're steering their team to be involved and to participate in that sort of thing. I've conducted numerous staff surveys. I've also been responsible for submitting them. I've fought for my team When I've had to fill them in from a more detached perspective. I've just looked at it and thought, what's the point? This is a tick box exercise. it definitely comes down to leadership. It's hard to draw the line as to where that begins and ends sometimes. But I think the best way to put this is, I once worked with a managerless company. I thought it was a brilliant idea because I've never been particularly hierarchical. We'll touch on hierarchies shortly. It was managerless and they were quite small at the time. Not a tiny company. and they had a managerless framework and I thought that was amazing. It fascinated me. I thought how can I bring this into my own team almost? Dan Culverhouse: Sounds like tails. Keith: Yeah, it worked very well for them from my experience. I thought they delivered this project in a very collaborative way. They had the right specialists on the project and we continue to work very well with them. I'd love to know how that, whether they're still doing it now Dan Culverhouse: So, Keith: if they're still operating in that way. I hope they are, but they're the only business I ever experienced that had that true approach. Dan Culverhouse: And did that mean that nobody worked for each other? So you had no responsibilities for other people. You only had responsibility for tax. Keith: Yeah, yeah, you came up with your own title. So Dan Culverhouse: You Keith: it was your title. Now, I wish I could go into the details of how they delegated, but I think they just between them decided he was the best person for each project. They were very open about their capacity, their strengths and weaknesses, what they were interested in, where they thrived. And they went with it and... Dan Culverhouse: Did everybody get paid to see? Keith: From my experience it worked but... Dan Culverhouse: Did everybody get paid the same amount? Keith: I don't Dan Culverhouse: it's not that. Keith: know. Perhaps. They did seminars on it. I wish I'd gone to one of the seminars because it was something that very much interested me at the time. It was something that sort of inspired my own beliefs at the time. I've always Dan Culverhouse: Mm-mm. Keith: been a bit egalitarian in that respect. Like, obviously Dan Culverhouse: or communistic. Keith: I don't necessarily think that people, you know... pay structure should be equal but I have my own controversial views on that for sure. Another episode. it's always fascinated me but I've always felt you needed a to Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: drive the vision. Like a visible leader Dan Culverhouse: I want to hold you to a hint. Keith: for the business but I'm always open to challenge. So I thought well how does this challenge my own approach? How am I too hierarchical? How am I too traditional? So it did inform me but I've always been of the belief that a leader has a very important role and it's not to be the most important or necessarily the best paid although you're paid for your expertise obviously it's Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: more to do with having the responsibility the accountability and the guts to face the difficult moments for your team and guide them through and teach them and prepare them and that's why you're paid for it in many respects but I've always felt that to leave people to own devices can sometimes turn into chaos. Now I know it worked for them but I haven't necessarily seen it happen elsewhere. Have you seen it firsthand? Dan Culverhouse: I guess it makes your recruitment really critically important. You have to recruit the right type of person because there are certain people that you can just give responsibility to and you know it will just get done and they'll do it in the right way. I mean, it's a very specific recruitment challenge to make sure that the people you bring in can truly live that. Keith: Do you need therefore the strongest recruitment team in the business to operate that way or is it luck or? Dan Culverhouse: they certainly need to understand what you're doing very well and know how to, you I think you need to understand what is it in people that makes that work? It's easy for you to scoff and go, come on. But, you know, there are examples of it where it's working. Not many, but there are. And Keith: There we go. Dan Culverhouse: it will be so important to understand what are the personality traits that you need to find in people? that to be successful because your recruitment has got to be pretty challenging. You've got to, it's not only finding people with the right skills, technical skills, but their behaviours are truly, truly... Keith: What would you say they are? Accountability, surely got to be there. A sense of responsibility. Dan Culverhouse: And I think a sense of community, you know, kind of a great collaborator, know, there's no selfishness. There's no ego. It's a very non-ego centric structure, If you're not going Keith: very much. We've all got an E-Guy day don't we? Dan Culverhouse: to have a team of people that you're responsible for, you know, it takes a very... specific type of person which is definitely not an ego driven person, selfless, know, an engager, a collaborator. So yeah, I've not experienced it myself. It would be an interesting thing to have a go at. But you can see all sorts of challenges. Keith: When does someone step in? Dan Culverhouse: You certainly wouldn't have any silo thinking, right? Because you'd have no silo. Because everybody is a silo. Keith: Well does it in effect turn into silo thinking because everyone is actually... not accountable for anyone else and therefore might veer into personal preference and if Dan Culverhouse: I guess it depends how the outcome is measured. If it's just measured on what you did, then you're to get silo thinking. If it's measured on what you did, but also how the overall business performs, what you do affects other people. Keith: Yeah and the end result is what drives the machine We've all done performance reviews in our time, the moderating that became very popular for the time. Dan Culverhouse: Mm. Keith: You have to rate people, high performers, and can do better. You have to organize your HR would always tell us you can't have too many in the same buckets. You need an equal mix. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: And of course from my own perspective I've always thought well you can't employ loads of people like yourself. You need people who are complete opposites who are going to challenge you. And we've all got our own egos and our own ways. I've always thought we need people to knock us off our perch and challenge our ideas and teach us because I'm a firm believer. I don't know a fraction of what there is still left to learn. So I need to learn from experts. I need people to challenge me. I need to be able to challenge them. And I think When we're talking about having very specific people, that I think can create a bit of an agreement culture, perhaps. Obviously not if it's right, but I think Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: that's where we're veering off into the role as leader. What's the role as leader? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, so and I think Keith: do we not need people who are skilled at leading those that don't fit workhorses they turn up every day but they go home and do a good job not everyone's the Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: same but they still add a lot of value Dan Culverhouse: Right, so what I'm hearing from what we've just talked about for the last 10, 15 minutes is that actually, I don't think it's the structure that matters. I think we've made an argument that actually a managerless hierarchy could work. It depends on the culture of the individual as a culture of the company. And I think that's also true in a manager hierarchical culture. So I don't think siloed thinking. is about hierarchy. I really don't. I think it's about the leadership mentality for sure. It's about what they portray because that no doubt has an impact on the overall business. It has to do with how you instill a culture, the values for sure. know, whether it's managerless or a standard hierarchy. But I also think there's a lot in there about processes. controls, checkpoints that ensure that certain things have happened. I mean, I'm sure you must have a good example of some siloed thinking that has caused a real problem in a company. And if you kind of take a look into it, what was behind it, where do you land on what caused that? Keith: It's my bread and butter, it's what I do for a living. And you too. I mean, it's where the benefits of fractional management comes in because a business has grown quickly. Maybe in the early days, the marketing person has taken on shipping. They don't know what they don't know, but they're under pressure to deliver and they just get their head down, they do their job, but they don't see the edge cases. They're missing the obvious because they're too within the trees. And I think... Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, they don't see the ripples from what they do. Keith: Yeah, I think that I noticed silo thinking as some of the biggest obstacles growing business faces. When maybe the founder or the CEO has lost track of their own role or their own expertise or where the expertise of everyone else sits and they just get on with it because the driver is growth and just getting over the line. Yeah, things like missing processes, communication structure. cadence all that sort of stuff tends to come from siloed thinking individuals trying to get by in their own way and yeah I sometimes you notice the band-aids like do Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: you meet as a team yeah we have a 10-minute stand-up every morning okay so you join the stand-up and you think what are you really talking about in the scheme of things but to everybody yeah we catch up we catch up but They don't really, not about the things that are really getting in the way of the business. it's never really done on purpose. It always generally happens when business is growing with a smallish team. Everyone's building their own individual case. Because I've heard contradictions from people before who say, look, I want my team to be autonomous and to get on with it. But then they say just do what you think is best. But they're talking to individuals about different priorities. So they're doing what they think is best about that particular priority and they're not joined up. And that's the leadership thing. It comes back to my original point. You can't tell a leader to go and make something happen but tell another leader that their priority is something completely different and then complain Dan Culverhouse: Absolutely, I agree with you. Keith: that you're siloed. Well, you can complain but you need someone like me or you to... Tell them the truth. Dan Culverhouse: I want to give you an example. As you know, I've done a lot of project work development in my time and I was leading a distribution center development years back. Really, really big one. You know, so it's Greenfield site. We've put in a whole load of automation in it. We'd spent a year going through all of the data, understanding how the business was working and therefore designing a solution that fitted the business. And this is a very established business. You know, it's not it wasn't a fast growing, very big established business. Alongside that project was another project that was looking at ordering systems and the how how orders were created. So this was a, you know, a big retail business over supplying stores. And they were so alongside my DC development, we had a an ordering system where it was looking at, you know, basically stores were ordering once a day. and they get that delivery the next day. And all the data we were working on was based on that. But while we were busy over here, you know, and all talking, you know, amongst the in the business about what we were doing, this other project thought up this fantastic idea of the same rather than just do one order a day. Why don't we in the evening do what we think is 70 percent of the demand that we want for the following days? They call that the fill up. So the main get the main stuff in. But then that was done sort of in the afternoon. managed at the evening and delivered first thing in the morning. But then at the end of the day, so first thing in the morning, they also were able to do what they call a top up order. So based on what actually happened by the end of the day, they could order a bit more and sort of be a smaller order. Now, if we hadn't realized that at the right time, we were about to say go on a 60 million pound development, which There was a portion of it was driven by the fact that it was one order a day and it drove high volume in a certain number of lines. And we had this very specific fast pick area that was going to pick these top 100 lines super fast. But when you took 30 percent of that volume out and made it into a secondary order, it killed about 50 percent of those picks because actually you will have to pick them twice. And therefore, actually, the volume wasn't really big enough to justify doing that. And We were happy working away in our silos. if I hadn't known that person personally, it could have completely gone the wrong way. We could have developed the solution and then had a whole portion. And this was a frozen warehouse, right? So you really can't afford to have a whole portion of the warehouse not being used because it's very, very expensive real estate. And we had to pivot our design because this solution was being implemented. It was going to offer all sorts of benefits. So was definitely a great thing to do. But we worked in the same project team, the program team. We were part of the supply chain development team in this company. We sat close together. We kind of knew what each other were doing, but we never really sat down and talked about it until it, I can't even remember how it occurred. You know, that so that was a silo even within a team that was potentially going to cost multi millions if we had not had the discussion at the time. You know, that gives some of the kind of impact. of, you know, and I've never forgotten it. And now whenever I'm managing developments or managing teams that have got things, I always insist on regular sit downs where each project manager will talk about their project. And yes, everybody else has to be in there. And after you get this, you know, I have to listen to this for two hours and a lot of it's got nothing to do with me. But it might. You might hear something that is a real issue and then we need to make sure we'll cross. changing those things. And it's so close to spending millions of pounds on something we wouldn't have been able to make use of. It's a frightening. Keith: Well it's an opportunity of course to go back to the original objective. How close are we to it? Is there anything we haven't thought about? Actually saying these things aloud, force people to think. And you know there's ways and means of holding these catch-ups to ensure you know we've all had those meetings where 70 people dial in on Zoom and you know. Most of them have got their camera off, Dan Culverhouse: I feel grossed. Keith: but there's ways to make people engage and that is to involve them, inform them, Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: to engage them throughout and I think it's definitely the right thing to do. I mean I have my own story that... You you mentioned big cost here. There's a story that I have that also had a huge cost but it had an implication in my life too that I posted about this. I was blowing up balloons for my daughter's birthday when I received a call saying, like editorial shoot was on the verge of being cancelled in Canada because the stock hadn't arrived. They're going to make an absolute fool of themselves and all of this and cost of business and money because they have to pay everyone there. So of course I got on the phone, I worked out where everything was and you know. It was solvable. I managed to get it delivered. It was a simple issue in the end to do with customs clearance into Canada. what puzzled me was how it had come to that to actually disturb me around 10 at night when I was off to solve a problem. What had driven everything to that moment to be so late in the day? And as for a lot of things that I got involved in, no one asked me to. I just decided to solve it because it bothered me a lot. I decided to take every communication, every email relating to this event and analyse it. Put it on a spreadsheet and I tried to work out how many of these emails actually took this forward. It was really big indicator of how siloed all the teams were because they were too busy or ill-informed and so many questions ended up being backwards steps because they didn't have the information they needed. They were choosing not to understand. Like computer says, no, you haven't got the requirements. You haven't done this, you haven't done that. But rather than inform the team beforehand, everything in one go, was all done in a very bitty way and it was full of no, full of this, full of that. I actually worked out instead of 250 emails, seven would have done the job. Dan Culverhouse: Hmm Keith: therefore there were only seven steps in the entire process to get everything you need to deliver any stock for an event on time. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: So I went about realigning the whole process. We never had this issue again as far as I was aware because... I stopped and I looked at it as a leader and I said, what is the problem? And the leaders within this chain had to be accountable. What did you need and why? Okay, so you can chuck away all the other staff like this team doesn't provide this, that or the other. Do they even know? Do they know what they're supposed to provide you with? Have you ever made it clear? No. I compared it to a chef's table. You only need the ingredients you need. They have to be in the right place and you have to clean as you go. You have to revisit the plan all the time. Go back to square one. We revolutionized the whole process. we talk about cost. But what are costs in people's time and effort and energy? And nearly in a cancelled event. You're employing Dan Culverhouse: Bye. Keith: people to effectively waste time. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I learned a very powerful tool during my time at Tesco. We used to live by this management process called RACI. I'm sure you know it, which is Keith: Now, cuss. Dan Culverhouse: Responsible, Accountable, Consult and Inform. And yeah, whenever you're working in an operation, we used to detail who's accountable. Who is responsible? So accountable is where the buck stopped. Who's responsible? Who's actually doing this task? Who do they need to consult with to be able to complete that task? Who do they need to ask questions to? Keith: The experts. Dan Culverhouse: And who do they just need to tell, by the way, I've just done this, this is the output. And it's a fantastic tool, right? And it's so simplistic, but it is hugely powerful. And I get, you know, I can imagine people going, yeah, that's great, you know, but you know, can't always just keep going back and referring to it. And they're right. But I think when you get in that mindset, well, ever you do, race is running through your head. OK, who do I need to consult about this before I instigate this change or this? Maybe it's a promotion. Who do I need to consult with before I do this price crash? Maybe I should consult the warehouse. Because if they don't know and I drive a 20 % increase in volume and they are all going to fail to deliver, Keith: Exactly. Dan Culverhouse: my thing is going to fail. But I also need to inform the shops that this is going to be happening. So they put it on the right. And once you get it, there's one thing about writing all these down. You can write all Keith: customer service that you're making a change yeah Dan Culverhouse: these down and it's very organized and great, but it's a mindset. if whatever you're doing in your job, Keith: It's a discipline. It's a discipline. Dan Culverhouse: You kind of think, OK, who do I need to consult with this? Who do I need to inform? It can eliminate silos immediately. mean, that is the anti-silo way of thinking. it's such a simplistic thing. And, you know, that was when I was in my early 30s and I'm now in my mid 50s. My wife would tell you it's my late 50s and I still use it every day. And it's like one of those things that I've just carried with me. you know, Keith: Yeah, I mean, it's Dan Culverhouse: Great. Keith: in part part of every SIP I develop. We talked earlier, you asked me what is often the biggest issue in companies I experience, this level of discipline. And when I've mentioned discipline before, they're like, what you mean we should tell people off? No, no, I mean, rigour, discipline Dan Culverhouse: some time. Keith: and methodology. include in any project, a project charter with the race seed diagram in it. All of your stakeholders, even down to what do you need from each of them? Because your initial meetings will include every stakeholder and they all know what's in for them. Now things can change a bit but if they're informed on the race seed diagram they know this because they've received the information. They know what's happening. They can challenge it. but it's part of every project charter I ever develop and it's part of every SOP I ever produce for any of my clients because simple tools are the best. I'm a firm believer of that discipline. Dan Culverhouse: And I would challenge everyone to say I have a talent. Yeah. Keith: Do the simple things. Five S's is another, isn't it? It's just discipline every day. Look at the workspace. Clean as you go, there's so many things, shadow words, there's so many ways of instilling a level of discipline as well as DMAIC, define, measure, analyze, improve and control don't start making improvements on things that don't inform the mission. know, it's very easy to disappear into different tangents on a project, isn't it? Trying to achieve the same goal. one of the questions we would land on here, have you changed your way of thinking at all as part of discussion? I think I have. I mean, it's very much, yes, a leader's job to implement the tools. But if you do have the right tools and the right mindset, you should, as a good leader, a good operative, be able to... be autonomous and work within that culture without being micromanaged. But I don't think my point was micromanagement in the first place. It's Dan Culverhouse: I don't think. Keith: just down to the leader to build that organisation. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, and I still firmly believe that responsibility sits with everybody. But I also do recognise, and I think you put this very well, that leaders have a responsibility to instil that culture. And if you don't instil that culture and if they don't follow that way of being, then you can't really expect anybody else to. So I'm fair to blame the staff if the leaders don't behave that way. Yeah, I absolutely think it's everybody's responsibility. And if anyone takes anything away, think racy think of the ripple effect in the decisions and actions that you take, even if they seem small, just spend a moment thinking about who might be impacted by this, you know, and I think you'll find what you're trying to do will work better. will land better. The business will perform better. Keith: Your stakeholder may have opposition to what you're trying to do, but in speaking to them, you overcome these barriers and you learn so much about their issues, their problems and the obstacles they face and you work together to achieve the mission together. It might sound a bit utopian, but I don't agree. I think it's a small level utopia that we can all achieve. And as I say, we both go back to it. Some of the biggest chaos begins with a lack of... focused on this sort of stuff and trying to do 500 projects at once. No priority, no communication and an element of surprise when it keeps happening time and time and time again. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I was looking at a few kind of statistics around this stuff earlier today and I found a couple of I thought were quite interesting. So I thought I would share some interesting stats. So the Harvest Business Review did a little bit of work with Salesforce actually. They came back saying that 70 % customer facing leaders, placed silo mentality as the biggest obstacle to achieving customer service excellence. 70 % believe that just a lack of good communication between teams was the major reason for failing customers' expectations. That's a lot, right? And then there's another one I thought was interesting that McKinsey did a study and they found between 30 and 40 % of supply chain improvement opportunities come from simply talking to other departments, cross-functional improvements and alignment. mean, nearly half of the improvement that you can make is just by talking to people. I mean, that's just insane. Keith: Honestly, I would agree with them. That's my own feeling. A lot of the time, the solution is a lot simpler than people think it is. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: But what isn't simple is getting people to see clarity. And I think that's where, you know, that's a big opportunity. If you're in this position, get someone in. It's a mantra of ours. Get someone in, now take a look at it. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, we say it before fresh pair of eyes. You see what you can't You can do it every Keith: Yeah fresh pair of eyes. Have a look. Sun! Dan Culverhouse: day. You're not going to see the same things as someone walks in and will just go, why do you do it that way? You know, but someone just asking that question is quite often enough for someone to look at it and go. Yeah, I don't know. It doesn't make a lot of sense, but it's easy when you head down and it's all going on around you every day. it becomes the norm, even when it's a crazy process, it becomes the norm and people can't see how inefficient or unproductive or difficult it is because it's just become normal and it can be fixed Keith: Indeed. Dan Culverhouse: quite easily. So. Keith: It's one of the simplest and least expensive investments she could ever make to be honest. It's my view. But Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. So interesting conversation. Keith: that brings us to the end of another episode. If you've got any questions, any suggestions, send them our way. We really want to hear them. We want to hear your opinions. Have you ever seen a successful silo based operation? I'm curious. Please tell me. Disagree with everything we say. If you've seen one, share it and come on the podcast and we'll talk about it. Likewise, if you're in a managerless organization, so curious, tell us. We wanna know. So subscribe, Dan Culverhouse: I'm sorry. Keith: like, follow, enjoy, and we'll see you next week. Dan Culverhouse: We certainly will. Another interesting debate. See you next Thursday.