Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration: Spotlight on ICDR Rules
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration Spotlight
- 0:05on ICDR Roles. I'm Belinda McCauley, executive
- 0:08director and CEO of the Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 0:11and I'm delighted to be here today to introduce
- 0:13our speakers, Fernanda Flores and Yasmine Malou.
- 0:16Fernanda Flores is the Director of ADR Services
- 0:19North America and Energy at the International
- 0:21Center for Dispute Resolution, which is part
- 0:24of the American Arbitration Association. She
- 0:26holds an LLM in alternative dispute resolution
- 0:28from the USC Gold School of Law and has extensive
- 0:31experience in mediation, arbitration, and regulatory
- 0:34legal work across public and private sectors.
- 0:37Based here in LA, she's recognized for her leadership
- 0:40in advancing innovative approaches to international
- 0:42and energy -related dispute resolution. Yasmin
- 0:46Lalu is a partner at Chafus Lindsay LLP with
- 0:49more than 25 years of experience in international
- 0:51arbitration and litigation. Fluent in English,
- 0:54French, and Italian, she's represented clients
- 0:56across a wide range of sectors, including energy,
- 0:59construction, engineering, and finance, in proceedings
- 1:02under the ICC, ICDR, LCIA, UNCTRL, and ad hoc
- 1:07rules. Trained in Paris and admitted in New York,
- 1:10Yasmin has arbitrated numerous cases and regularly
- 1:13advises sovereigns, corporations, and state -owned
- 1:15entities on complex cross -border disputes. And
- 1:19now let's get started. Hello. It's a pleasure
- 1:22to be here with the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 1:26And our goal today is very practical. We want
- 1:29to dismissify international arbitration and show
- 1:33you how it operates, not as an abstract international
- 1:38concept, but as a real lawyer -driven dispute
- 1:42resolution tool. that you may already be encountering
- 1:48or soon will in our practice and through contract,
- 1:55cross -border transactions or foreign counterparts
- 1:58as we live in a very interconnected world. We
- 2:03love international arbitration, but we brought
- 2:06this agenda with the goal to bring the main tools
- 2:12for help understand better how works international
- 2:18arbitration. We're gonna talk a little bit how
- 2:22and why parties choose international arbitration
- 2:26instead litigation. Also, we'll bring you a brief
- 2:31overview of the ICDR, who we are, how we feed
- 2:36within the AAA, and what distinguishes us from
- 2:40other arbitral institutions. Also, we will spotlight
- 2:45key features of the ICDR rules, focusing on provisions
- 2:49that matter most to practitioners, practitioner
- 2:53attorneys. And after that, we'll turn to the
- 2:57importance of a well -drafted arbitration clause.
- 3:02And this is where many disputes are won or lost.
- 3:10before they ever begin and will highlight essential
- 3:14drafting considerations and common pitfalls.
- 3:19We will explain the Arbitral Award and how and
- 3:23why ICDR awards are enforceable across borders.
- 3:30And of course we will look ahead the future of
- 3:32ADR including how the AAA ICDR is integrated
- 3:37innovation and AI driven tools to enhance efficiency
- 3:42while preserving due process and party autonomy.
- 3:47So let's start. Why international arbitration?
- 3:54Yasmin, what do you think? Why we should choose
- 3:58international arbitration? Hi Fernando. Hi, everyone.
- 4:03I'm very pleased to speak to you, even though
- 4:06not live. You want to go to the next slide, Fernanda?
- 4:09Sure. So there's several reasons that international
- 4:16or US businesses opt for international immigration
- 4:20rather than litigation. The primary one is enforceability
- 4:25of the award, nearly universal enforceability
- 4:29of the award. The reason being that in 1958,
- 4:37the United Nations promoted the adoption of the
- 4:40so -called New York Convention on the recognition
- 4:43and enforcement of our ritual awards, which now
- 4:47has 170 signatories. And in 75, The Inter -American
- 4:54States Organization adopted also the Panama Convention,
- 4:58which mirrors the New York Convention, but for
- 5:01Latin America. And what happens is that under
- 5:04the New York Convention, if you have an award,
- 5:06it's nearly a universal currency, which is almost
- 5:10certain to be enforced wherever the award debtor
- 5:13is found because the convention provides for
- 5:16extremely limited grounds to deny enforcement
- 5:19and recognition. and imposes the burden on the
- 5:24award debtor to establish the existence of those
- 5:26grounds. We can discuss them further later. And
- 5:30the thing is, there is no comparable international
- 5:34treaty involving the United States for court
- 5:38judgments. In 2009, the United States joined
- 5:42the so -called Hague Convention on Choice of
- 5:44Court Agreements, which allows for the enforcement
- 5:48of judgments. But unfortunately, it has limited
- 5:52traction, and the United States has, in any event,
- 5:55not ratified that convention. So if you want
- 5:58something enforceable worldwide, you have to
- 6:01opt for international arbitration. Other key
- 6:07features is the expertise. Most arbitrators are
- 6:14lawyers, but they all have different focuses,
- 6:17and they know certain industries customs and
- 6:20practices and will have a quick understanding
- 6:23of certain features, certain contracts, joint
- 6:25operating agreements for Los Angeles, the customs
- 6:30in the entertainment industry, oil and gas and
- 6:33things like that. And that is because you can
- 6:37choose the arbitrator or you can tell the institution
- 6:41that when they offer names, they should be looking
- 6:43for certain individuals with specific skills.
- 6:49If you opt for arbitration, then you enjoy broad
- 6:53latitude in organizing the proceedings. It's
- 6:59flexible and allows the party to opt for a pretty
- 7:04efficient process if they want to. Of course,
- 7:08some parties may try to counter that, but that's
- 7:13when the role of a powerful backboneed tribunal
- 7:17comes in to streamline the process to the extent
- 7:20necessary. And one related feature is that this
- 7:25can become more cost efficient if you have less
- 7:28discovery and less sort of motion briefing than
- 7:34litigation. I don't think that businesses opt
- 7:39for international migration for cost reasons,
- 7:41but there has been an immense focus by the institutions
- 7:44over the past years to create mechanisms to reduce
- 7:50costs and time in international arbitration.
- 7:55On discovery, you can take a look at Article
- 7:5924 -4 of the ICDR rules, which clearly sets forth
- 8:05a standard for limited discovery, where you really
- 8:09have to identify the documents you want and why
- 8:13you need them. and also 2410 of the ICDR rules,
- 8:18which says, and I quote, depositions, interrogatories
- 8:22and requests to admit as developed for using
- 8:24US court procedures generally are not appropriate
- 8:28procedures for obtaining information in an arbitration
- 8:31under these rules. So these are clearly the exception
- 8:35and the burden would be on the body seeking those
- 8:38to demonstrate why they are necessary. And I
- 8:41can tell you this nearly never happens. Because
- 8:48arbitration is also a commercial business involving
- 8:51a large amount of institutions, they have an
- 8:54incentive to be innovative and offer new tools
- 8:59to the users to attract users and for them to
- 9:03opt for an institution over another. And Pananda
- 9:07will tell you a little bit about that later in
- 9:11the presentation about sort of technological
- 9:14innovations that enhance the efficiency. Finally,
- 9:19it's two more points. International creation
- 9:23has evolved to adopt some of the features of
- 9:30litigation that are the most attractive. It started
- 9:33a few decades ago with more and more institutions
- 9:38and national laws recognizing that arbitrators
- 9:42can issue interim measures, then there was the
- 9:48institution of the emergency arbitrator that
- 9:50can step in on an emergency basis before the
- 9:53time it takes to have a full tribunal, and you
- 9:58have other mechanisms such as summary disposition
- 10:01mechanism when someone submits a manifestly unmeritorious
- 10:06claim. And finally, you have sort of the neutrality
- 10:11of the arbitrator since you are not in anyone's
- 10:15domestic court. But obviously when you're looking
- 10:19for an arbitrator, sometimes you will appoint
- 10:21one that has familiarity with your legal culture
- 10:26or is a national of the same country. There is
- 10:30the issue of whether the presiding arbitrator
- 10:32or the sole arbitrator should be of a nationality
- 10:35that is different from that of the parties. Yes
- 10:39and no. Some institutions expressly require that
- 10:44the arbitrator be of a different nationality
- 10:46than either side. The ICDR don't say that. But
- 10:50you can ask at the time that you ask the institution
- 10:54to give you a list of candidates that you would
- 10:57prefer that they be neutral. Next slide. Yasmin,
- 11:06can I just jump a little bit and bring some data
- 11:09regarding the cost saving and efficiency? And
- 11:13this is another thing that you know, makes parties
- 11:18to go to international arbitration and not to
- 11:21litigation. So we have our infographics with
- 11:25the data from 2024, as we don't have our infographics
- 11:29from 2025 yet. So in claims below $1 million,
- 11:36the median average time for the award was 10
- 11:41months. So you can see how is faster international
- 11:47arbitration if we compare with US litigation.
- 11:51And if our claims above $1 million US dollars,
- 11:57the median average time is 21 months. So there's
- 12:02a data to consider when you're thinking where
- 12:05you want to take your case. Here we go. A few
- 12:11more points. One important feature of international
- 12:15arbitration in general is that you can be involved
- 12:18in the selection of the arbitrator either by
- 12:21identifying them directly or providing qualifications
- 12:30profiles to the institutions that will seek to
- 12:33identify the proper arbitrator, the proper candidate
- 12:36that parties then can discuss and select. Arbitration
- 12:41is a private mechanism. This is not open to the
- 12:43public. And it can also be confidential. But
- 12:47by default, arbitration is not confidential under
- 12:51the ICDR rules. The ICDR rules require that the
- 12:54institution and the tribunal maintain the confidentiality
- 12:57of the proceedings and not disclose anything
- 12:59about the proceedings. But the same obligation
- 13:01does not apply to the parties except with respect
- 13:04to documents produced in the arbitration. So
- 13:08if the parties want the arbitration to be confidential,
- 13:11they should say so either in their arbitration
- 13:14agreement or more likely when they negotiate
- 13:19the procedural order with the arbitrator. As
- 13:24we were saying, you usually get a faster resolution
- 13:27because of your dispute since your tribunal is
- 13:31really focused on your dispute and in theory
- 13:34does not have a huge docket. This is not necessarily
- 13:37true because most companies, most operators look
- 13:41for experienced arbitrators and they have a heavy
- 13:43docket. But in any event, under the ICDR rules,
- 13:49once the arbitrator closes the hearing, closes
- 13:53the possibility of introducing new evidence,
- 13:56then they have 60 days to issue their award.
- 14:01And finally, for disputes below $500 ,000, you
- 14:07can opt for so -called expedited proceedings,
- 14:12and there will be a much faster timeline, and
- 14:16the time limit for the award will be 30 days
- 14:18from closing those proceedings. And these expedited
- 14:21proceedings apply for disputes, mandatory apply
- 14:25for disputes below $500 ,000, or the parties
- 14:28can opt in for larger disputes. To you, Fernanda.
- 14:33Thank you. Thank you, Esmin. So now I'm going
- 14:36to talk a little bit about International Center
- 14:38for Dispute Resolution, ICDR. So AAA, the American
- 14:45Amortization Association, was founded in 1926,
- 14:48and this year will celebrate 100 years. And with
- 14:53time, they realized that they needed they will
- 14:59start having like international disputes and
- 15:01they're like, okay, maybe we need to create a
- 15:03division. So in 1996, ICDR was founded and right
- 15:10now we manage all cases that present international
- 15:15component. The primary office of ICDR is New
- 15:21York City, but nowadays this AAA has 26 office.
- 15:27in the US and in Singapore. But the ICDR staff
- 15:33is in Houston, Chicago, Miami, Los Angeles, and
- 15:37Singapore. We have a very global and multilingual
- 15:41team with attorneys from Brazil, India, Mexico,
- 15:48Russia, Singapore, Spain, Kenya, and of course,
- 15:52the US. And I think we have one from Romania
- 15:55as well. And these attorneys, they are training
- 15:59in civil law and they have also common law backgrounds.
- 16:05And another thing that I wanna highlight that
- 16:08make us different from other organizations is
- 16:12that we are a non -for -profit institution. And
- 16:16in a very simple language, that means basically,
- 16:20after we pay all staff and everything, we put
- 16:25our earnings in a foundation. And this foundation
- 16:30has a very beautiful initiative to help other
- 16:36organizations, institutions, also nonprofits,
- 16:39that share the same ADR principles. and creates
- 16:44an impact in society. So far, we have granted
- 16:49in donating around $8 million in projects like
- 16:53that. So this is very, very interesting. And
- 16:59why ICDR when you're thinking about your international
- 17:03arbitration dispute, right? So we have been...
- 17:07a pioneer in the design introduction and implementation
- 17:11of innovative mechanisms in arbitration and mediation.
- 17:17For example, we were the first institution to
- 17:19introduce emergency measures of protection. We
- 17:24realized that some cases, they had urgent matters.
- 17:31So we created this as an equivalent that we have
- 17:36in the civil court. And this is very effective
- 17:42for protecting the right of the parties. We also,
- 17:47in 2010, we created an online platform to file
- 17:51and manage cases. So we don't need to send mails
- 17:55anymore. And the case can be completely managed
- 18:00through a website. that is very user -friendly.
- 18:06And I think this advances a lot, especially when
- 18:09you're talking about international parties. Also,
- 18:14we implemented AI and Hanson tools to support
- 18:18case management and the parties and the arbitrators.
- 18:23Also, ICDR administers cases under its own...
- 18:27ICDR rules, as well other AAA rules adapted to
- 18:32each industry for cases with international component.
- 18:36So for me, I have international ICDR cases that
- 18:42we administered under the construction rules,
- 18:47under commercial rules, under health care rules,
- 18:50under energy rules. Actually, UNRG doesn't have
- 18:54specific rules yet. Maybe I'm telling something
- 18:59for the future. I'm disclosing something for
- 19:02the future. And we also manage cases under the
- 19:05UNCTRL rules. The ICDI rules reflect the best
- 19:08practice in international arbitration, as Yasmine
- 19:11was saying before, the limitation of discovery.
- 19:16This is one of the things that we understand
- 19:18for international arbitration. the most appropriate
- 19:22practice. So this is one of the best practices
- 19:25that we adopt. And we are a trusted institutional
- 19:30administration because we provide experienced
- 19:35neutral case management to ensure the procedural
- 19:38integrity and fairness. So the parties and their
- 19:42betrayals will count with a dual background licensed
- 19:50attorney to help them and to make sure that the
- 19:53case doesn't have anything, any arbitrary from
- 19:58the arbitrator or in the parties that they don't
- 20:02need to deal with some administrative cases because
- 20:05they will have the case administrator to deal
- 20:08with that. Yasmin, do you have anything to add
- 20:13within your experience with ICDR? I mean, going
- 20:19back to the point you raised on discovery, the
- 20:23rules reflect best practices. And the best practices
- 20:27are really a compromise between civil law and
- 20:30common law countries. Civil law countries do
- 20:33not have historically discovery in their process.
- 20:38So there was a compromise, but there is some
- 20:40discovery, but not the tools that you find under
- 20:43US litigation. And you don't have sort of the
- 20:47extensive document discovery that you would see
- 20:52in the US, but instead you have to identify a
- 20:54specific category or specific documents that
- 20:57you're after. But of course, that goes back to
- 21:01the procedural flexibility we were talking about.
- 21:03If the parties want extensive discovery, they
- 21:05can agree to it. They can put it in their agreement.
- 21:08I understand this is very much the case in the
- 21:10entertainment industry on the West Coast, where
- 21:15parties do not necessarily look for that less
- 21:18discovery, but what they're really looking for
- 21:21is a private forum where they can have a quasi
- 21:27US litigation, but before a private tribunal.
- 21:30Yeah. And you're talking about this, remember,
- 21:33like some IP disputes as well, that they want
- 21:38confidentiality, right? They don't want to disclose
- 21:40to the world what has happened with the RIP.
- 21:43Okay, thank you. So right now I'm going to talk
- 21:47a little bit about ICDI rules and I'm bringing
- 21:51some spotlights. So here is like a roadmap how
- 21:59an arbitration case, international arbitration
- 22:01case works. And again, Some people, they say
- 22:06the case starts with the clause and agreement,
- 22:09right? So here, but this is not completely true
- 22:13because the parties can agree after. So it's
- 22:18not mandatory that to go to arbitration that
- 22:24the parties need to have a clause before it happens,
- 22:28right? So the parties can agree after that. So
- 22:31here's a very easy roadmap that starts with the
- 22:35clause agreement. Then when there is a breach,
- 22:39then the party files the request for arbitration.
- 22:45Then the case will assign to one case administrator.
- 22:51And then we're going to have the initiative conference
- 22:54call, the arbitrator selection, the procedural
- 22:59hearing. Brightness submissions are the briefing
- 23:03phase, information exchange, if they share a
- 23:08hearing, and then the award. And the spotlight
- 23:14I want to bring. It's here, the administrative
- 23:17conference call. This is a very important tool
- 23:21under my view. I want to hear Yasmin's opinions
- 23:25after, because sometimes the parties draft arbitration
- 23:28clause like a long time ago. And the administrative
- 23:32conference call is a very important meeting.
- 23:35The parties will meet with the case administrator
- 23:39to confirm. what is what is they have in the
- 23:44agreement or if some things still make sense
- 23:48right and I'm going to give an example one of
- 23:50my cases so the clause was draft and they want
- 23:55the the place of the arbitration to be I don't
- 23:59know California let's say but then the parties
- 24:03change change the the main local the main place
- 24:10And now they are in Texas. So they changed the
- 24:13locale with the administrative conference call.
- 24:16And that was very important for them in terms
- 24:20of costs and efficiency. And then the arbitration
- 24:23selection, absent agreement, the list method
- 24:26with rank and strike. So we wanted the party
- 24:32autonomy. And we want to avoid administratively
- 24:37appointing appointing the natural decision maker
- 24:40because we believe this is the party process
- 24:43so they determine not to be in court right so
- 24:48they want to be in the arbitration and um so
- 24:56we're gonna the case administrator will build
- 24:59a list according to the expertise and requirements
- 25:03that the party disclosed to us in the administrative
- 25:07conference call. With that information, the case
- 25:10administrator will create a list with the most
- 25:15suitable arbitrators, and then the parties will
- 25:20be able to rank and strike. After that, when
- 25:25we receive the list from the parties after the
- 25:29review, we're going to insert, we're going to
- 25:34fill up in our system and the system will come
- 25:36up with the most suitable arbitrator. So I think
- 25:41this is very interesting and fair because we're
- 25:44not privileged any party. the parties will kind
- 25:47of decide that together with a rank strike, very
- 25:52not arbitrary system. And if you have any question,
- 25:55I can explain a little bit more after. Our arbitrators
- 25:59are compensated and basically on hourly rates.
- 26:05So when we create the list, and send to the parties,
- 26:08the parties will have the arbitrator resume.
- 26:11And there, they will see the arbitrator's experience,
- 26:15how is their rates. So these give the parties
- 26:22the discretion to decide how much they want to
- 26:25pay for the arbitrator regarding their qualification.
- 26:32We also encourage concurrent mediation and arbitration.
- 26:36And this is a very interesting tool and I see
- 26:39great results with that because sometimes the
- 26:45parties are not ready to do a mediation before
- 26:50the arbitration. But when arbitration starts
- 26:53and they start exchanging documents and exchanging
- 26:58other points and see where they are at, sometimes
- 27:04they they want to try mediation before that.
- 27:08Or the opposite is also true. Sometimes the parties
- 27:11try mediation. And in the mediation process,
- 27:16the exchange and the argument prepare them for
- 27:20where they are at in arbitration. And the arbitration
- 27:23runs smoothly. So this is a very interesting
- 27:26mechanism that we provide in our rules for the
- 27:30parties. We also, one of our principles is transparency
- 27:34and the fees that we have reflects that. So the
- 27:39parties will have previous access to the fees.
- 27:42We have a fee schedule in our rules and they're
- 27:46going to be aware of how much they will expand
- 27:49in arbitration. We also have the ICDR administrative
- 27:55review council and this is a very interesting
- 27:59tool that we provide to the parties to internally
- 28:04solve some disputes, not disputes, but like disagreements
- 28:09between the parties within the arbitration process.
- 28:15So this council, it meets once per week. So,
- 28:22and we have very experienced and seniors vice
- 28:29presidents, they are with the council and they
- 28:33help decide as like, not appellate court, but
- 28:38it's kind of like that. If we're going to compare
- 28:41with the court system here in the US, they help
- 28:45to decide how is the best way to proceed with
- 28:50the arbitration. And again, the positions and
- 28:54interrogatories as developed for used in the
- 28:57US usually are not appropriate for international
- 29:02arbitration under our rules. But again, as has
- 29:05been mentioned, the parties can agree with an
- 29:08extensive discovery process. And the review of
- 29:14the award, I think this is another thing that
- 29:17makes ICDR a very international and neutral institution.
- 29:25because we want to keep the quality of the award.
- 29:29So it's not going to be only the arbitrator who
- 29:31will reveal the award. The award is going to
- 29:35go through the case administrator and then some
- 29:41senior case managers and vice presidents to make
- 29:46sure that all the requirements and the awards
- 29:49in a good shape to go out. to the parties. Another
- 29:57ICDR spotline is regarding the tribunal authority
- 30:02and case management. So the arbitral tribunal
- 30:07has - Fernanda, if I may step in, if we can go
- 30:10back to the prior slide, just to give a little
- 30:15bit of a flesh to the administrative review council.
- 30:23they don't engage in the substance of the dispute.
- 30:26Sometimes it happened that a request for arbitration
- 30:30is based on a pathological arbitration clause
- 30:32that has some ambiguities whether the party is
- 30:36intended to decide to opt for the international
- 30:38rules or the AAA in the first place and the respondent
- 30:43objects to the administration of the case by
- 30:46the ICDR. That will go to the Administrative
- 30:50Review Council to decide whether they will accept
- 30:53the case and administer it or whether they will
- 30:56invite the claimant to go to court and seek an
- 31:00order. They will also decide issues if you challenge
- 31:03an arbitrator. They will review the body submission
- 31:07and decide or not whether or not an arbitrator
- 31:10should be challenged based on lack of competence
- 31:13or more commonly lack of independence impartiality
- 31:16or incomplete disclosures. And the little point
- 31:20on the final bullet point here, the review of
- 31:23the award, it's not a substantive review. It's
- 31:26purely a formal review to make sure, assume that
- 31:31the arguments of the parties are properly explained,
- 31:35that there are no new arguments that are analyzed
- 31:39by the tribunal that parties did not submit.
- 31:42We're talking about procedural and formal review,
- 31:44but the institution cannot a second guess or
- 31:49question the substantive findings of the arbitrator.
- 31:53No, thank you. Yeah, maybe it means my, my example
- 31:56is not good, right? Comparative. Thank you. Thank
- 32:04you for bringing the examples. And regarding,
- 32:08we have the Article 22, the tribunal authority
- 32:13and case management. So the tribunal has broad
- 32:16discretion to conduct arbitration in a manner
- 32:19it's considered appropriate, ensuring fairness,
- 32:22efficiency, and economy. So the tribunal may
- 32:27address preliminary issues at an early stage.
- 32:31The tribunal can also bifurcate proceedings,
- 32:35direct the order of proof exclude cumulative
- 32:38or irrelevant testimonial evidence, and require
- 32:43the parties to focus in submissions or issues,
- 32:46both resolutions may dispose all or part of the
- 32:50case. And another article that I want to bring
- 32:55here is the early disposition. So the RCDR rules
- 32:58expressively authorize early dispositions of
- 33:01claims or defenses that are manifestly without
- 33:05merit or outside the tribunal jurisdiction. It
- 33:09provides a powerful tool to streamline proceeding,
- 33:11reduce costs, and avoid the necessary evidentiary
- 33:14phases. Yeah, and this is interesting because
- 33:21I recently had a default judgment in one of my
- 33:28arbitration cases. So this I think this is a
- 33:34tool that parties should know that exists in
- 33:37arbitration as well. Do you want to add something,
- 33:41Esmin, in this slide? I think if you read article
- 33:4722, you will see that the ICDI rules are quite
- 33:52unique in their explicit endorsement of the extensive
- 33:56authority of the tribunal to organize the proceedings
- 33:59efficiently and effectively. And if the parties
- 34:03agree on something, the arbitrator is unlikely
- 34:07to do something against the party's agreement
- 34:12because then there's a risk of vacature. But
- 34:16also, when there is a procedural disagreement,
- 34:19this provision, Article 22, justifies the tribunal's
- 34:26use of its power to conduct the proceedings efficiently.
- 34:30It avoids what's so -called due process paranoia,
- 34:33where the arbitrator will allow a body to present
- 34:37all the arguments, to seek an additional hearing,
- 34:41et cetera, where it's really not necessary, where
- 34:43each side has actually had the opportunity to
- 34:45present their evidence. And there is no need
- 34:48for more evidence. There is no need for hearing,
- 34:51for example, because there are no witnesses.
- 34:54And this is the basis, Article 22, for the arbitrators.
- 35:00authority to conduct the proceedings as they
- 35:03see fit and under that provision the courts look
- 35:11at that provision when parties seek to challenge
- 35:13an award because the arbitrator rejected their
- 35:17request for a 20 second hearing and that says
- 35:22that you the parties agreed to gave that sort
- 35:24of authority to the tribunal and it cannot now
- 35:27second guess it. And it looks like you have in
- 35:29any event had the opportunity to present all
- 35:31your arguments and evidence. And so there is
- 35:34no basis to challenge the award. That's all.
- 35:39Thank you. I think it's me now. Yes. So. As.
- 35:49Fernanda said it all starts with a properly drafted
- 35:55arbitration clause. There is a saying that arbitration
- 36:01is a matter of consent, and that consent is found
- 36:05in the arbitration clause. You can, of course,
- 36:08also agree post -dispute to arbitration, but
- 36:11it's very rare that parties agree to anything
- 36:16after the dispute has arisen. So on this slide,
- 36:21we have really identified the must -haves in
- 36:27your arbitration agreement and the can -haves
- 36:32in your arbitration agreement. One is you clearly
- 36:36express that the dispute shall be arbitrated.
- 36:44And that says two things. One, that you are opting
- 36:47for arbitration. and you are doing so to the
- 36:50exclusion of another dispute resolution method
- 36:54such as litigation. You also have to say what
- 36:59is the scope of the arbitration agreement and
- 37:03the wider, the broader the scope, the less likely
- 37:06you are to have then disputes about whether or
- 37:09not the arbitral tribunal has authority to address
- 37:13tort claims or fraud claims that are not technically
- 37:19contractual but are related to the contract.
- 37:24That, as I said, the arbitration agreement must
- 37:27show that to opting for arbitration to the exclusion
- 37:30of other mechanisms, you should identify the
- 37:35institution in the arbitration or it will make
- 37:38it very hard otherwise to have an institutional
- 37:42arbitration and ad hoc arbitration can be complicated
- 37:46and that can be a discussion for another day.
- 37:49You can also specify if you want one or three
- 37:53arbitrators. You don't have to do that because
- 37:58most institutional arbitration rules deal with
- 38:02that issue if the parties have not said anything
- 38:05on the topic. You can also mention the language
- 38:08of the arbitration even though usually The tribunal
- 38:14or the institution in the first instance will
- 38:17go with the language of the contract under the
- 38:20assumption that this is what was used between
- 38:22the parties. And finally, an important component
- 38:25is the seat. It's a legal, it's a juridical anchor
- 38:33point for the arbitration. And you're saying
- 38:35the arbitration. will be under the arbitration
- 38:39law of a specific state and state as sovereign
- 38:44and if you opt for the seat in the United States
- 38:48you will be under the federal arbitration act
- 38:51and all the standards to vacate an award will
- 38:54be those found in section 10 of the FA and so
- 38:58on and so forth. That doesn't mean that you will
- 39:00have to have hearing at the seat but this is
- 39:03the legal standards that will apply to the arbitration.
- 39:08Additional consideration is if you want to have
- 39:14pre -arbitration steps, if you're on the parties
- 39:19to have a negotiation or mediation before, be
- 39:24careful with drafting those clauses and making
- 39:29them as mandatory because then you can end up
- 39:32being in a deadlock in satisfying those because
- 39:36a court or tribunal can decide that these are
- 39:40conditions precedent and if the other side doesn't
- 39:42play ball you may have some disputes. As we discussed
- 39:45earlier you can decide whether or not you want
- 39:47to have the arbitration to be confidential. Also
- 39:51if it's a complex transaction where there are
- 39:54multiple parties and multiple contracts and you
- 39:57may want to have you want to be able to have
- 40:00the same tribunal decide a chain of contracts,
- 40:03be it the main contract and perhaps the one with
- 40:05the subcontractor, because really this is what
- 40:09happened with the subcontractor that is causing
- 40:11the liability of the contractors. Whether or
- 40:14not you want interim measures, if you want litigation
- 40:17carve -outs, for example, if you want IP issues
- 40:20to be litigated rather than arbitrated, again,
- 40:23be careful in drafting these carve -outs because
- 40:25the less clear the carve -out is, the less likely
- 40:29you will go to litigation. And most of the litigation
- 40:32we see on pathological arbitration clauses are
- 40:35about unclear carve -outs. If you want more or
- 40:40less disclosure, you can spell it out in your
- 40:45clause. If you want to opt for a fast -track
- 40:48procedure, an expedited procedure, you can mention
- 40:50that. You can exclude remedies. Very often, parties
- 40:53say that the arbitrator cannot award punitive
- 41:02damages. Here, actually, the ICDR rules explicitly
- 41:04say that arbitrators cannot award punitive damages
- 41:09unless the parties agree otherwise. But some
- 41:13of the remedies is that you can say that the
- 41:17tribunal will not have the authority to enjoin
- 41:21a party from exercising its business and things
- 41:24like that. And finally, you can have something
- 41:26to address the costs, attorney's fees. Under
- 41:29the ICDR rules, the tribunal has very broad authority
- 41:32to award those things. And usually, in international
- 41:36arbitration, the practice is that costs follow
- 41:39the event that the party who has prevailed will
- 41:41recover some or all of their costs and attorney's
- 41:44fees. But the parties can agree to exclude that
- 41:47part. I think in the next clause, we have sort
- 41:51of a few things. comments, be careful about the
- 41:59sort of requirements that you're including about
- 42:01the arbitrator in your arbitration clauses, because
- 42:03you may end up dramatically reducing the pool
- 42:08of available candidates. And you can leave that
- 42:12to the moment when you will select the arbitrator
- 42:15and to have a more narrow, well -defined qualification.
- 42:22When you decide on the number of arbitrators,
- 42:26you have to think about the likely size of the
- 42:28dispute, the likely complexity of the dispute,
- 42:31but you have to know that for smaller disputes,
- 42:36you really prefer one arbitrator because it's
- 42:40less costly. It's a third of the price. And also
- 42:43because when you have to schedule or reschedule
- 42:46hearings, it's much easier to reschedule based
- 42:50on one. arbitrator schedule than three. And very
- 42:54quickly, on the fees of the tribunal, on what
- 42:58Fernanda was saying earlier, each arbitrator
- 43:02set their own fees, but the fees of the entire
- 43:06tribunal are paid in half by the parties. If
- 43:11you appoint an arbitrator and he charges more
- 43:13than the other, it doesn't mean that you pay
- 43:15only that arbitrator's fees. Each side pays 50
- 43:19% of the entire tribunal's fees, and the tribunal
- 43:25does not get involved in those issues. The ICDR
- 43:28handles that. If a party resists pay, usually
- 43:31the tribunal doesn't know which party resists,
- 43:34to avoid sort of tainting the view of the tribunal
- 43:37based on that. If the parties have not agreed
- 43:42at the start of the arbitration on what arbitrator
- 43:44they want, they don't want to do that, then you
- 43:48go through the process that Fernanda described
- 43:51earlier into sort of a list method and the list
- 43:56consisting of arbitrators that the ICDR will
- 44:00have prepared based on the features of the dispute
- 44:03and what the parties discussed during the administrative
- 44:05conference. In the slides a few minutes ago where
- 44:10Fernanda was talking about why choose the ICDR,
- 44:16who will both administer international cases
- 44:19under the ICDR rules, but also international
- 44:21cases under other rules, is that, in my view,
- 44:26the roster of the ICDR is better vetted than
- 44:31other AAA rules' rosters. So that's also a reason
- 44:38why the ICDR is more attractive as an administrator
- 44:41of your case. You want to go to the next slide?
- 44:46So we'll just leave you with this very simple
- 44:52clause that you can find on the ICDR website.
- 44:55To me, small is beautiful, and everything that
- 45:03is not addressed here can be and will be addressed
- 45:07either by the institution or by the arbitral
- 45:09tribunal. But the building blocks... going back
- 45:13to what we were saying earlier, is really that
- 45:15you really have to be as broad as possible and
- 45:19you see the controversy arising out of or relating
- 45:24to. Courts in the U .S. consider this to grant
- 45:28the broader authority to the arbitral tribunal
- 45:30to decide disputes that are even incidentally
- 45:35related to the contract. The shall be determined
- 45:39is the expression that the arbitration is mandatory
- 45:42and to the exclusion of other discrete resolution
- 45:46methods, and then you identify the institution
- 45:49and the rules. You don't need to identify the
- 45:52seat. You don't need to identify the language.
- 45:55So long as if you have those building blocks,
- 45:56then the ICDI, when they see a contract with
- 46:00that clause, they will accept to administer it
- 46:02without any question. as I said, unless you have
- 46:10counsel to walk you through a complex arbitration
- 46:14clause or you are able to use a tool that Fernanda
- 46:17will describe to you in a few minutes, go with
- 46:20a simple clause. The final phase of the arbitration
- 46:31is when the issuance of the award and really
- 46:36Going back to what we were saying earlier in
- 46:38this presentation, an arbitral award presents
- 46:42the attractiveness of finality and enforceability.
- 46:47An award is the final determination of a dispute
- 46:49and it is binding on the parties. Unless you
- 46:57use the option of appellate arbitration, which
- 47:00is very, very rarely opted for and is not available
- 47:05under all institutional rules, there is no appeal
- 47:09on the substance of the arbitral award. And what
- 47:13the arbitrator decided is the final decision.
- 47:19The grounds to challenge the validity of an award
- 47:23are extremely limited. they can never touch the
- 47:26substance of the decision, but only issues of
- 47:30due process, issues of whether the arbitration
- 47:34was within the scope of the arbitration clause
- 47:37or not, whether a party was actually a signatory
- 47:41or a party to the arbitration clause, because
- 47:43a lot of arbitrations involve non -signatories,
- 47:48and things of the sort. So it's very, very narrow.
- 47:54And in an international context, I think there
- 47:59was a recent survey. And in New York, only two
- 48:05awards were vacated in the past five years. That
- 48:09is extremely exceptional. And to ensure the validity
- 48:16of your award, it's essential that the arbitrator
- 48:20meet due process standards. Next. In addition,
- 48:28you're able, going back to what we were saying
- 48:30earlier, to have your award enforced in over
- 48:34170 jurisdictions. Under the New York Convention,
- 48:38the grounds to refuse enforcement of the award
- 48:42are extremely limited. Again, lack of due process,
- 48:47validity or outside the scope of the arbitration
- 48:49agreement, public policy. which are generally
- 48:54extremely interpreted in a very narrow sense.
- 48:59Also, if the dispute is addressing a matter that
- 49:02is non -arbitrable under the law of the state
- 49:04of enforcement. In the US, everything is arbitrable,
- 49:10except usually domestic relations, for example,
- 49:13but antitrust, employment disputes are arbitrable.
- 49:19This is not the case in all states. And that
- 49:23can be a limitation to the enforceability of
- 49:26your work. And usually when you opt for a well
- 49:32-recognized institution such as the ICDR, you
- 49:38have at least the comfort that it was administered
- 49:44in a transparent, neutral fashion. and that the
- 49:47rules are globally recognized by of course around
- 49:53the world to provide a repair. A quick point
- 50:01also on that is that there's a very important
- 50:05provision in the rules, it's the waiver. And
- 50:13it says that if there's a violation of the rules,
- 50:15that happens during the arbitration and you have
- 50:17not objected to it at the time, you are considered
- 50:21to have waived it. This principle reflects a
- 50:25principle in the unsuitable model law and also
- 50:28under the U .S. Federal Arbitration Act as interpreted
- 50:32by the court and it's really if you have a complaint
- 50:35to be made about something that happened in the
- 50:37arbitration, if you did not raise it at the time,
- 50:40you are considered to have waived it. This is
- 50:43an important signal. to object if you've considered
- 50:50that you have a serious ground to question the
- 50:54conduct of arbitration. Next. It's to you, Fernanda.
- 51:01Yeah, thank you, Yasmin. Even that we are 100
- 51:05years organization, we are very committed and
- 51:09worried about the future. So within the TripOA
- 51:14ACDR, we have an AI lab. It's like a TripOAI
- 51:19innovation lab. And we are working with some
- 51:25innovation initiative and technology to enhance
- 51:29the arbitration process and system. So I'm going
- 51:33to bring some highlights that I believe is very
- 51:36important for the parties to know they are available.
- 51:43the online case management system that we have.
- 51:47We have a mobile app so the parties can have
- 51:50access to the e -center and web file for case
- 51:55data access. So they need to check the case,
- 51:58they have access through that. We also have the
- 52:05Clouds Builder, the tool that Yasmino has mentioned
- 52:08that can help the parties to to draft a very
- 52:13good clause. So this tool is a power tool that
- 52:19leveraged advanced artificial intelligence to
- 52:22streamline the creation of arbitration and mediation
- 52:26clauses. So this is a free tool that we have
- 52:29in our website. And I will provide with the materials
- 52:35here so you can try and see how it looks so you
- 52:40can As Yasmina is saying, we provide a very simple
- 52:45clause that if you insert the clause in the clause
- 52:52builder, and you can start adding, okay, I want
- 52:56to one arbitrator, this is the seed that I want,
- 52:59I want to discover it or not. So you can tailor
- 53:01the clause according to your needs. We also have
- 53:08chatbots that help the parties, external, internal,
- 53:13and that help the parties and help the case management
- 53:18team to get some doubts and questions solved.
- 53:29We also have the clear brief. This is AI -powered
- 53:34writing platform to streamline document summarization,
- 53:41drafting, fact checking process. Right now, these
- 53:45two is only available for our arbitrators, but
- 53:50we are working to get these two available to
- 53:54the parties, to the attorneys in the future.
- 53:58And it's very interesting the work it does and
- 54:01how it saves time. And it's very important this
- 54:06because this is a grounded AI tool in the sense
- 54:12that keeps the confidentiality regarding to the
- 54:18documents that the arbitrator is uploading to
- 54:22the case. So we are not training the AI here,
- 54:27and this is not an open AI model. This is a closed
- 54:31and grounded model. We launched in November last
- 54:35year the AI Arbitrator that delivers fast, cost
- 54:39-effective, and trusted dispute resolution. This
- 54:44tool is already available, but right now it's
- 54:46only for expedited cases, for construction, and
- 54:52only documents. This is a very, very interesting
- 54:57tool that we have right now. Because this tool,
- 55:02we trained the AI to do that. It's so interesting
- 55:07how it should award. For first, we trained the
- 55:16AI arbitrator with all already awarded cases.
- 55:22The award the arbitrator issued was almost exactly
- 55:26the same as the arbitrator at that case at the
- 55:29time issued the award. Now, we are receiving
- 55:37new cases that were not awarded. But for now,
- 55:42we also have arbitrator We also have the human
- 55:49factor that reveals the whole process, just to
- 55:52ensure that it's correct. But yeah, but it's
- 55:58very impressive how it works. So yeah, I think
- 56:04AI is something that we cannot run from it right
- 56:08now. Is it a tool that does not involve an individual
- 56:15arbitrator, but you're really feeding the machine
- 56:18with the briefs and the documents and you get
- 56:21a decision? Yes. So the arbitrator, so we have
- 56:24this group, Yasmine, and thank you for your question.
- 56:27So we have this group of arbitrators, construction
- 56:31arbitrators. They just review the award to ensure
- 56:35that, you know, there was any chance of a hallucination
- 56:41of the AI. But that's it. He just reviewed the
- 56:45award. So, I mean, I can see the reason why we're
- 56:50using that word, but I don't think it will be.
- 56:53I'm not sure it will qualify as an arbitral award.
- 56:58I don't know where it's been tested, the issue,
- 57:01but in some jurisdictions, if it's not a human
- 57:03being. uh, that issued the award. It's not an
- 57:06arbitrary award. So you don't have the old, all
- 57:08the regime on the enforceability, et cetera,
- 57:10et cetera. It will be interesting to see what
- 57:12happens. Uh, and, and, and very, and very possibly
- 57:16the arbitration clauses of the future, uh, will
- 57:20agree to consider that as an award or something
- 57:22of the like, but, um, we need to, to be cautious.
- 57:26Not, it's not necessarily an arbitration. No,
- 57:29definitely. And that's why Yasmin is just here
- 57:32for right now. It's just released here in the
- 57:35US. It's not international. It's not an international
- 57:39tool. Even if they are planning to do so. And
- 57:43another point that you're talking. So for use
- 57:47this tool, both parties need to agree with. So
- 57:50it's not something that just one party filed
- 57:52arbitration with the AI arbitrator. Both parties
- 57:55need to agree to use this. So, yeah. So, yeah.
- 58:00Let's see how it goes, right? Let's see what
- 58:03the future has for us. And then we also have
- 58:08the Arbitrator search tool that is a complementary
- 58:12tool that we developed to help the case manager,
- 58:18the case administrator to build the list of the
- 58:21arbitrators that are going to be sending to the
- 58:23parties. We have our internal system that we
- 58:27create the list, but this AI tool, it looks for
- 58:33concepts. And I'm going to give an example. So
- 58:36here they was consumer issues can be arbitrator,
- 58:44right? So right now we have like mass arbitration
- 58:49cases. When the case administrator is building
- 58:54the list, it doesn't need to search for mass
- 58:59arbitration experience. Their case manager can
- 59:04write concepts or just search consumer and will
- 59:09look for similar concepts. It's just a tool that
- 59:15helps us to bring more qualified arbitrators
- 59:20to the list of, to the parties. And one of the
- 59:24last news that we have is the Integra. It's a
- 59:28partnership with Integra. This is a blockchain
- 59:32document certification. And this is something
- 59:37to not use the blue ink anymore. So this is very
- 59:43interesting. to have the award in blockchain
- 59:48certificated. And then now I'm going to, because
- 59:52we were talking about the clause, how drafting
- 59:55a clause, I'm going to bring the Clause Builder,
- 59:58an example of how it works. So here's the demonstration,
- 1:00:04what type of AAA dispute resolution, and then
- 1:00:09the Clause Builder AI will provide you with a
- 1:00:12template. And then after that, you can add arbitration
- 1:00:16clause options to that, like arbitrator qualifications,
- 1:00:22governing law discovery, e -discovery, remedies.
- 1:00:27So this is a tool available in our website. And
- 1:00:33again, this tool was the internal people from
- 1:00:39Triple ACDR that developed. Sometimes with partnership
- 1:00:43with trusted companies, but this one was trained
- 1:00:47by our case managers. So I think you're going
- 1:00:51to have interesting templates. Maybe, Yasmin,
- 1:00:54you can take a look after and then tell me if
- 1:00:57you would use that for your cases. Okay, so this
- 1:01:04is a recording session, but Yasmin and I. I'm
- 1:01:07going to be very, very happy to answer any questions
- 1:01:11that you have. Here are our emails and phone
- 1:01:17numbers. So please don't hesitate to reach out.
- 1:01:22And I hope this was helpful. Thanks, Fernanda.
- 1:01:28Thanks to Beverly Hills Bar Association. And
- 1:01:30thanks, everyone, for your time and attention.