Latest / Ego and Other Things / Is The Self Something That You Discover or Construct?
Transcript
- William: Is the self something that you discover or that you construct? I believe that the self is something that you discover. Ideally, this is something, a process that happens in childhood. Ideally, the parents allow the child to explore who they are and give them the resources necessary to do so. Because the self is not something. That you are born with in a solid sense. It's not as though, as you first come to consciousness, the self is just there, ready to go. Rather, what you have is what I've called an authentic instinct. And the authentic instinct is the instinct of exploration. It's this instinct that tries to experiment and act in the world. And see whether or not a certain action or certain outcome actually makes you happy, right? So you're a little kid, you want to try out for karate, right? And karate just seems cool. There's something in you telling telling you that you would like to go try out for karate. So you ask your parents, hey, can I go to this karate class? They say yes. You go and do it, and you enjoy yourself, right? want to do more of it. Or on the other hand, you recognize, actually I don't really like this karate thing all that much. And that would be an example of of this experimentation. And as a child, this happens more or less naturally, though it's really the responsibility of the parents to encourage this sort of authentic instinct. And again help the child to discover it for themselves. Help the s the child discover who they are. what they really value, what they really want to do, what they really like. That's part of what that is really principally the the the parents main job there. So it isn't solid at the beginning, but through this investigation, through this repeated experimentation, that identity, that self, becomes more and more solid over time. as more and more of what gets tested survives. Survives. So this what we call self-experimentation, the authentic instinct, which helps you to become more and more aware of who you really are. Much like how scientific investigation over time helps us to understand the nature of the world around us. And this is a process that sort of just constantly gets repeated and updated. Problem is, of course, that this process rarely goes smoothly in childhood because of the fear of death and the needs of survival. The parents and the society around them often believe that what the parent's job is to do is to prepare the child for the society. And so, at least in the modern day, things have softened up a little bit to where now they call it socialization, where they say job of the parent is to socialize the child. Get the child to conform nicely to the world around them, the people around them, so that they can get along in the world, so that they can get a job, get married, have children of their own, whatnot. In the past things were a little bit more brutal because we depended so much more directly on the people around us for our survival. So the socialization process was at an extreme pitch because if the child failed to get along with his tribe, they were often just ostracized and kicked out, left to to starve and rot in a forest somewhere. In fact, if the ch if the child came out ugly, that wasn't a very good sign. and the child was often gotten rid of. Children were were beat and they used as labor and they were used essentially as objects for the survival of the tribe around them. Today children have rights thanks to people like Ianis Korchuk, who actually, you know, gave some dignity and respect to the child and treated them like a person. And that's a that's a modern concept. Child as a person is a very new concept that people forget. But even today, we treat the child as an object that needs to be socialized, right? As a child who needs to conform to what we think is right and good and wonderful for our own satisfaction rather than helping the child discover who they actually are. And so typically what happens is the child becomes not who they really are through this open exploration of their authentic instinct. They become what they have to be in order to survive, either conforming to their parents' expectations and their their peers' expectations, because of of course the child is entirely dependent on their parents in particular for what they need in order to survive. the parents have very conditional kind of love that says, you know, we will give you what you need and treat you well if you conform to whatever arbitrary rules that we've made up for you to follow. So the child becomes what the child needs to be for the sake of the parents. Whatever the parents have threatened the child into becoming either explicitly or implicitly, subtly or overtly, this is what the child becomes. And this is what the child identifies with when they become an adult. And the child now adult feels as though their identity they have a solid identity. The only problem is the solid identity isn't built around what they actually value, but what they needed to be in order to survive. And inevitably that kind of identity leaves one unhappy and unfulfilled, feeling meaningless, purposeless, aimless, alienated from the world around you. Causes all kinds of problems because it's an identity that was built in the past and not actually in the present, in the past situation of survival dependence, not the present situation of actual freedom. But all of this has been sublimated, all of this has been pushed into the unconscious, all of this has is been put at an instinct level. And if they're lucky, a crisis point happens. And there is a moment where the truth gets to come out about their past, about their relationship with their parents, and if they take advantage of that moment, typically this happens most effectively within therapy, but if they take advantage of that moment and they can confront the truth, then they'll get back to that meshy sort of fluid identity that the child originally has. And they get to start that exploration of the their true authentic self through their authentic instinct again as an adult. and so essentially what should have taken place as a child now gets pushed off into adulthood if the person is lucky. But of course what usually happens is that this this false identity gets repeatedly broken in crisis and then either the consequences of that crisis or the the fear of the fluidity the lacking of identity breaks out into some kind of destructive behavior pattern and then the person retreats back into an either a new false self or the same false self. And that gets that pattern of crisis gets repeated again and again. And typically comes out at inflection points. So you're talking about transitions away from from college, the the midlife crisis, having a child yourself, getting married, the big life events, that tends to be where you get these crish crisis inflection points to one degree or another. But they could really happen any time. So the the self is not really constructed in a sense that it's made up. In the sense that that one could just decide who they are, or in the sense that society determines for you who you are. Rather, you have a nascent self, you have an authentic instinct that seeks to be objectified in the world. And the way that you come to know yourself and who you really are is by experimenting with that authentic instinct in the world, experimenting and objectifying. that that instinct as far as you can and seeing what's successful. I mean seeing what actually gives you meaning and purpose and happiness and joy and fulfillment and all the good things of life. And if the objectification does that, then that is evidence that that is part of who you are. And that evidence builds up over time and again what sticks sticks and what doesn't falls away. And so ideally over time, especially if you can do this consciously, you become more and more aware of who you are. Now you never get to the the total knowledge of the self, because that's impossible because you can't know everything about yourself. But you do get enough of what actually matters if you are actually free to explore yourself and if you actually take the risk to do so, because of course there's certain risks and costs with doing that, especially especially socially. But most people never get the chance. And the reason people go most most people don't get the chance is because Their parents socialize them. Their authenticity is not who they are. Their authenticity is some corner in their soul that sometimes gets to come out in play or else breaks out in crisis because one feels a complete lack of purpose, meaning, joy, happiness, etc. And the unfortunate truth is that most people never really get in contact with who they really are. They never get in contact with their authenticity. They just continue to build on a false identity that comes out of fear, that comes out of the need of survival, that comes out of the need to get along with people, that comes out comes out of the need to conform, that comes out of the need to you know reinforce the identity that you've already projected to people so that they don't think you're crazy for you know, this sort of sudden personality of change that often comes out of. a real authentic drive. So it isn't constructed, it's it becomes known through experimentation and solidified through that kind of experimentation. But But yeah, you you guys will have to let me know what you think in the comments. And as always, thank you guys for listening.