Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / SB 37, AI Advertising & Attorney Accountability: A Practical Compliance Framework for California Law Firms
Transcript
- 0:02My name is Mike Douglas, and I'm the chair of
- 0:07the BHBA's ethics and legal malpractice law section.
- 0:11Thank you for joining us in what I am sure will
- 0:15be a really, really enlightening CLE session
- 0:20on an emerging area of the law right now. I'm
- 0:25delighted to introduce our speakers, Yossi Yahudai.
- 0:30Monica Washington Rothbaum and Jonathan Sanchez.
- 0:37Yossi is the co -founder and managing partner
- 0:40of JNY Law Firm, a personal injury firm with
- 0:4421 offices throughout California. His practice
- 0:48focuses primarily on automobile and motorcycle
- 0:52accident cases involving catastrophic and life
- 0:56-altering injuries, as well as premises liability,
- 1:00product defect, elder abuse, and wrongful death
- 1:03cases. Yossi has received numerous awards and
- 1:08recognitions, including Rising Stars by Super
- 1:12Lawyers Magazine, the National Trial Lawyers
- 1:15Top 100 and Top 40 Under 40, a Martindale Hubbell
- 1:20AV Preeminent Rating, and Lifetime Membership
- 1:24in the Million Dollar and Multi -Million Dollar
- 1:27Advocates Forums. During law school, Yossi served
- 1:31as a judicial extern to the Honorable Alexander
- 1:34Williams III and as a certified law clerk for
- 1:38the Civil Liability Division of the City Attorney's
- 1:42Office. Monica Washington Rothbaum is the COO
- 1:48and a senior attorney at J &Y Law Firm. An attorney
- 1:53with over two decades of experience in corporate
- 1:56governance, legal operations, and strategic business
- 2:00planning, Monica is licensed to practice in Maryland,
- 2:03Florida, Washington, D .C., and New York. Before
- 2:07she joins JNY Law, she served as the chief operating
- 2:12officer at Bogan Muns and Muns, a full -service
- 2:16law firm with a significant personal injury practice,
- 2:19and as a managing director and deputy general
- 2:24counsel at the American Automobile Association.
- 2:28Monica also clerked for Justice David Souter
- 2:31at the U .S. Supreme Court and for Chief Judge
- 2:36Harry Edwards at the U .S. Court of Appeals for
- 2:39the D .C. Circuit. Jonathan Sanchez is the Marketing
- 2:44Director at J &Y Law Firm, where he leads branch
- 2:48strategy and growth initiatives. With over 17
- 2:52years of experience in marketing across the legal,
- 2:55technology, manufacturing, e -commerce, and advertising
- 2:59sectors, Jonathan brings a combination of creative
- 3:03strategy and analytical expertise in the firm's
- 3:08marketing efforts. His experience spans both
- 3:12business to business and business to consumer
- 3:15campaigns with a focus on digital and traditional
- 3:18marketing. creative direction and strategic partnerships.
- 3:23So with that having been said, please join me
- 3:27in welcoming our really experienced panel and
- 3:30I will now turn it over to you Monica to get
- 3:33us started. Great. Thank you, Michael, for the
- 3:36introduction. Good morning, everyone. And thank
- 3:40you to the Beverly Hills Bar Association for
- 3:43hosting this program. As Michael said, my name
- 3:45is Monica. I'm the COO. And I'm really pleased
- 3:49to be joined here today by Yossi and Jonathan.
- 3:56We're J and Y Law. One of the great things about
- 3:59our law firm, particularly in the past couple
- 4:02of years, is the tremendous growth we've experienced.
- 4:05And I could define growth in a lot of different
- 4:07ways, but for purposes of this presentation,
- 4:11I want to talk about signups. So we have a strong
- 4:16in -house marketing lead generation department
- 4:20that's led by Jonathan Sanchez, our marketing
- 4:23director. And then Yossi is really responsible
- 4:26for external lead gen. And the two of them are
- 4:30this powerhouse of lead generation. And month
- 4:34over month, we're increasing signups. So of course,
- 4:39when SB 37 came down the track, we were concerned.
- 4:45And we took our time and we dug into the law,
- 4:51and then we also built a compliance framework.
- 4:54So what we're doing today is sharing some of
- 4:57that with you so that you don't feel as overwhelmed.
- 5:03by all the intricacies of the legislation. So
- 5:06Jonathan, can you start the PowerPoint for us,
- 5:10please? Absolutely. One second here. And while
- 5:26he's doing that, I can get into sort of our learning
- 5:28objectives, right? So we've got three objectives.
- 5:31We want to understand what SB37 changed in California,
- 5:37legal advertising. We want to identify the risk
- 5:40areas in AI, lead generation, and intake systems.
- 5:44We want to apply a practical supervision framework
- 5:48for compliance, and then build a defensible review
- 5:51and monitoring workflow. So you can skip ahead,
- 5:55Jonathan, and then one more, and then one more.
- 6:00Great. Okay. Good stuff. All right. So you know
- 6:05that I clerked, and whenever you are trying to
- 6:10understand a law or regulation, you really want
- 6:13to go back to the history. So let me take a step
- 6:16back, and then we'll take a step forward. So
- 6:20SB 37 isn't just a statutory amendment. It's
- 6:23a structural shift in how California regulates
- 6:26the legal marketplace. Yes, it's about advertising,
- 6:29but more fundamentally, it's about authenticity,
- 6:33attribution, accountability, and public trust.
- 6:38Okay, so let's talk about the legislative timeline
- 6:40and some of the legislative history. It was introduced
- 6:43in December, well, December 3rd, 2024 by Senator
- 6:48Thomas Unberg. It passed the legislature, both
- 6:53houses in 2025, and it was signed by Governor
- 6:57Newsom on October 11th, 2025, and it went into
- 7:02effect on January 1st, 2026. So it amended and
- 7:07expanded several sections of the business and
- 7:10professions code. I'm not gonna give you those,
- 7:12you'll just forget them. But know that the vote
- 7:15margins were overwhelming and this was really,
- 7:17didn't appear to be controversial in Sacramento,
- 7:20right? Why is that? Because it was framed as
- 7:23consumer protection. So to understand SB 37,
- 7:26you have to understand what was happening in
- 7:28the marketplace. So over the last decade, legal
- 7:31advertising has changed dramatically. Algorithmic
- 7:36targeting has replaced billboards. Yeah, we see
- 7:38a lot of billboards, but it's a lot more digital
- 7:41advertising. Lead aggregators replace direct
- 7:45intake. Call centers are replacing an office
- 7:48consultation. Influencers are replacing testimonials.
- 7:52And AI is generating ads, avatars, scripted intake.
- 7:57the legislature recognized this widening gap
- 8:00between who appears to be communicating with
- 8:03the consumers and who is actually responsible
- 8:06for the communication. So some purposes that
- 8:12come out when you look at the legislative history,
- 8:16it's an attempt to modernize attorney advertising
- 8:19law. Because existing statutory laws are written
- 8:23long before the digital marketing area, it expands
- 8:26this definition of advertisement to cover all
- 8:30written, recorded, electronic, or online communications
- 8:33intended to promote legal services. So you're
- 8:36including websites, paid digital ads, landing
- 8:39pages, and also lead generation content. It's
- 8:43intended to protect consumers from misleading
- 8:45practices because the legislators concluded that
- 8:48many legal advertisements were creating unrealistic
- 8:51expectations about outcomes, lawyer identity,
- 8:54or experience. And so it tightens prohibitions
- 8:57on false or misleading advertising claims. Third,
- 9:02it addresses unlawful solicitation and referrals.
- 9:05So the bill strengthens California's longstanding
- 9:08outlaws of Runners or cappers, right? People
- 9:11pay to solicit client and ambiguous third party
- 9:15referral services by extending these enforcement
- 9:17tools, including a private right of action that
- 9:21allows individuals to sue over unlawful or misleading
- 9:25advertisements. And then fourth, as I just already
- 9:29alluded, it authorizes civil actions with statutory
- 9:32damages, injunctive relief, attorney's fees,
- 9:35and other remedies. And it's explicitly designed
- 9:38to empower consumers and other affected parties.
- 9:42All right. So to dig into the details of SB 37,
- 9:46I'm going to pass it now on to Yossi Yahuday.
- 9:49Thanks, Monica. And thank you, everyone, for
- 9:51having me. It's a pleasure to be here. So let's
- 9:55look at what SP37 actually does. It expands the
- 10:00scope of advertisement. In terms of how it's
- 10:04defined, SP37 defines advertisement broadly as
- 10:08any written, recorded or electronic communication,
- 10:12public or limited audience that encourages someone
- 10:14to hire a lawyer or law firm. So practically,
- 10:17it's not just TV and radio. We're talking everything
- 10:20here. Websites, landing pages. paid search, social,
- 10:24drip campaigns, and co -branded microsites. So
- 10:28it's everything that we do. So let's go into
- 10:30the content prohibition. I wanna walk through
- 10:33like a red zone list of things we can't do anymore.
- 10:36We can't make any guarantees or warranties of
- 10:39success. So we used to see ads saying like, oh,
- 10:4198 % success rate, 99 % success rate, it's not
- 10:45allowed anymore. We used to see a lot of quick
- 10:48cash or immediate settlement type claims on ads.
- 10:52Those are no longer allowed, so be careful with
- 10:55those types of claims. There's no more impersonations
- 10:59or deep fake -style use of name or voice, photo,
- 11:02image, implying a lawyer or a client or a dramatization
- 11:06without any disclosure. Any ads with spokespersons,
- 11:12they are not allowed unless there's a disclosure
- 11:14of title. So things can be done. in terms of
- 11:20impersonations, deepfake style methods, but there
- 11:25needs to be specific disclosures. Without those,
- 11:27you'll be in violation. Again, if you're going
- 11:30to be talking about your skills, your experience,
- 11:33your record, nothing can be misleading, deceptive,
- 11:37or false. So if you're going to make a claim
- 11:39about those things, you have to make sure that
- 11:41if it comes up, you'll be able to objectively
- 11:43prove it and actually have evidence that shows,
- 11:47yeah, this is... our experience, this is our
- 11:50record, so there is no gray area. And then a
- 11:54big one are the awards. A lot of people have
- 11:58these what they're called pay to play awards,
- 12:00where as long as you pay a membership fee, they
- 12:03give you an award. So those are no longer allowed.
- 12:06Awards are still allowed to be displayed, but
- 12:08they must be for organizations that are bonafide
- 12:11organizations where you're genuinely voted in.
- 12:15There is an objective voting process and it's
- 12:17just not just purely pay for play. So be careful
- 12:20with those. There's also mandatory disclosures
- 12:24for all our ads. Every ad needs to name at least
- 12:27one California licensed lawyer or law firm or
- 12:30certified referral service. You must disclose
- 12:35your city, town and county of a bonafide office
- 12:38location, or you can use the state bar address
- 12:41of record, but I don't recommend that. Of course,
- 12:43much better to use your own address. And then
- 12:46for any character limited platforms where there's
- 12:48not going to be enough space to have a full disclosure,
- 12:51like a Google PPC ad, you have to have a compliant
- 12:54link to a landing page with a full disclosure
- 12:57that satisfies all the requirements. Now onto
- 13:02enforcement. You know, this is the scary part,
- 13:06I guess. If one was to make a complaint, they
- 13:09would file a complaint with the state bar. personal
- 13:12service is required on the attorney, and the
- 13:15advertiser must provide a copy to the state bar.
- 13:18The nice thing is that there is a cure period
- 13:20with all these complaints, meaning if a complaint
- 13:25is made against you and it deals with a digital
- 13:27ad, you have 72 hours to take it down. And if
- 13:31it's a non -digital ad, you must take it down
- 13:33as soon as possible, but no later than 30 days
- 13:35from notice. So that is a huge plus for us attorneys
- 13:41advertising. And now for practical risks and
- 13:54lead gen and intake, I'm going to pass it on
- 13:55to back to Monica. Monica, it looks like you're
- 14:03muted. Thanks, sorry about that. So yeah, we,
- 14:10many of us use lead generators. They help augment
- 14:15some of our in -house marketing efforts. And
- 14:20so, you know, we wanted to highlight some of
- 14:23the risks of using these lead generation sources.
- 14:27You know, be careful of these co -branded landing
- 14:30pages with aggressive claims about what you're
- 14:35going to win. or millions and millions won and
- 14:44things like that. Be careful of SEO vendors that
- 14:48are drafting unreviewed content. Now that AI
- 14:52is available to pretty much everyone, they can
- 14:54just generate these AI blogs and things like
- 15:00that that can have content that is simply not
- 15:03true. Be careful of AI chatbots answering legal
- 15:08questions, and then also shared referral funnels
- 15:13that obscure responsibility or even impersonate
- 15:17different types of helpful resources. Sort of
- 15:24coalitions that are, well, they're lead generation
- 15:28companies, but they're they're fronting themselves
- 15:31as coalitions or helpful resources. So be careful
- 15:35of all that. And know that when you use these
- 15:39lead generation companies, it's your state part
- 15:42number that's going to go on the complaint, right?
- 15:45And that's because this is all tied to your ethical
- 15:50responsibilities. Rule 7 .1, which is against
- 15:54false and misleading communications. 5 .3, which
- 15:59is your responsibility for non -lawyer assistance,
- 16:02and even rule 1 .1 regarding your competence.
- 16:06So let's go to the next slide. We put together
- 16:11just a quick heat map. So you can know where
- 16:16to focus your attention with respect to landing
- 16:19pages, chat bots, and intake scripts. Those are
- 16:23high risk, high volume, but also a lot of high
- 16:27risk. Awards and specialization claims are also.
- 16:34high risk but lower volume. That would be specialist
- 16:40or expert or even using influencers or celebrity
- 16:44spokesperson that are making exaggerated claims.
- 16:48Lower risk but also high volume is educational
- 16:51content if you review it, right? If it's a blog
- 16:55and it's reviewed, it's a little lower risk.
- 16:58Community announcements still need disclosures
- 17:02if they're an ad. And even lower risk, didn't
- 17:06make it on this heat map, would be the brand
- 17:08level PR that doesn't have the direct call to
- 17:12action. All right, Jonathan, you're up. All right,
- 17:17thank you very much. So we're very happy to share
- 17:20with you all this information because we've been
- 17:22developing this in -house here at JNY Law as
- 17:25part of our marketing efforts. What we've put
- 17:27together is actually what we call the five -step
- 17:30compliance loop. Thinking in terms of the good,
- 17:33the bad, and the ugly of SV37, right? We've covered
- 17:36the bad and the ugly. Now let's talk about the
- 17:38good and how we can implement this into your
- 17:40workflow. So the first thing we do is we want
- 17:43to make sure that we inventory all of our advertising
- 17:45channels. As both of my colleagues were mentioning,
- 17:48this can include websites, landing pages, any
- 17:51ad copy that is out there, either published by
- 17:54your team or vendors that you're working with,
- 17:57or even third parties that are doing it on your
- 17:59behalf. So making sure that you have inventory
- 18:01of all of that. What we do here at JNY Law is
- 18:04that we actually go through every single ad that
- 18:07is published. We inventory that. We create an
- 18:10archive of screenshots. We have Excel sheets.
- 18:13So we just make sure that we're keeping a log
- 18:15of everything that is being published so that
- 18:18in the event that you know obviously we're preventing
- 18:21it but if it were to happen that somebody were
- 18:23to file a claim we have a log of everything that
- 18:26was published time stamped and also with the
- 18:29url so that we can prove that we have been complying
- 18:34we're wondering also if there may be some bad
- 18:37players or bad actors out there that may create
- 18:41fraudulent claims and so in that case you can
- 18:43also safeguard yourself by having this archive
- 18:46of all of your advertising as part of your protocol.
- 18:50The second step is to assign an attorney to oversee
- 18:53the approval process. So we've heard often times
- 18:57lead gen companies will focus on results. They
- 19:00will connect with attorneys to discuss overall
- 19:03how many cases are you interested in acquiring?
- 19:05What is your budget look like? What is it that
- 19:07you're trying to achieve? You could take a certain
- 19:10number of cases out of the market share. So they're
- 19:12very pushy when it comes to their sales pitch.
- 19:15However, they don't necessarily share the framework
- 19:17with you. So they don't offer you insights into
- 19:20how they're putting together the ad copy. They
- 19:22don't share the images that they're either creating
- 19:25via AI or that they're getting from different
- 19:29stock publishers and so on. So now we encourage
- 19:32everyone to actually have an attorney overseeing
- 19:35that. As much as you may have a marketing department
- 19:38or a trusted resource, it is important that you
- 19:40have an attorney involved because it is your
- 19:42license that is on the line. So that is obviously
- 19:45step two. Step three is to again go over that
- 19:48approval process. So we encourage you to create
- 19:51some sort of internal system where you can say,
- 19:53for example, we are interested in running a new
- 19:55campaign. At that point, you work with your marketing
- 19:58team. You put together the app copy, all of the
- 20:01different assets that are involved. And then
- 20:03at that point, you go through an approval process.
- 20:05And obviously, this is something that a lot of
- 20:06people are accustomed to doing, especially when
- 20:08it comes to presenting information or even sharing
- 20:12documentation. And obviously, in your... legal
- 20:15expertise as well. And so we think that it's
- 20:18very good to have an approval process so that
- 20:20you can approve everything before it goes live.
- 20:22The fourth thing also ties into the first point,
- 20:24which is to archive everything that you have.
- 20:27So if at one point you were running ads, make
- 20:29sure that you archive those and you have. a timestamp
- 20:32for them, and then maintain records of any edits
- 20:34or anything that was being done to that ad so
- 20:38that, again, you have a history of how you're
- 20:40running your marketing. And then the last thing
- 20:42is to make sure that you're constantly monitoring
- 20:44this activity. Oftentimes, we know that agencies
- 20:48will launch pilot campaigns that are typically
- 20:50around a 90 -day campaign, if not longer. we
- 20:54would encourage you to do it quarterly, but obviously
- 20:56if you have the bandwidth and the resources to
- 20:59do it, do it as often as you can because this
- 21:01will allow you to remedy any situation quickly
- 21:03and avoid obviously any sort of pitfall from
- 21:07that. Now when it comes to an actual checklist,
- 21:11so something that we're using here at JNY Law
- 21:13is that we're checking through all of our ad
- 21:16copy and all of our marketing and making sure
- 21:19that it complies with these four questions. So
- 21:21number one, are the required disclosures included
- 21:23in the ad? As Yossi had mentioned earlier, there
- 21:27are often times where we have character limits.
- 21:29So for example, on Google Ads, a headline can
- 21:32only have 30 characters. Unfortunately, you can't
- 21:34fit a disclaimer within 30 characters. So you
- 21:37do have to include that disclaimer on the landing
- 21:39page. And some get away with just linking to
- 21:42it. Others include it in small font toward the
- 21:44bottom. but it is important that you include
- 21:46that or at least have an option where somebody
- 21:48can access that. Number two is, are the claims
- 21:51that are being mentioned, are they substantiated
- 21:53and are they non misleading? So again, kind of
- 21:55what Monica and Yossi had been mentioning earlier.
- 21:58There are a lot of organizations out there that
- 22:00are pay for play. They will give you an award
- 22:04or they'll name you as number one in a certain
- 22:07area or in a certain region. But is that a neutral
- 22:10party? Is that an organization that is reputable,
- 22:14that is not just for lead gen purposes? The reason
- 22:17being, if it's mentioned as an advertisement,
- 22:21then that does implicate you. And so it's important
- 22:23to make sure that these are substantiated and
- 22:26that they're non misleading because we can't
- 22:28mislead the public. That's really the heart of
- 22:30SB 37 is offering that type of transparency.
- 22:33Number three is, are dramatizations properly
- 22:36disclosed? Everyone is using AI and I think I
- 22:39can speak for most companies. A lot of us are
- 22:41taking advantage of that. Unfortunately, it's
- 22:44still not a highly regulated industry. And so
- 22:47oftentimes images will be created that look very
- 22:50real or can portray a situation that obviously
- 22:54through prompt engineering, you can make it look
- 22:57almost identical to a situation. However, if
- 23:00somebody were to run across that or let's say,
- 23:02for example, you're creating a situation that
- 23:04was a client's story. And it's not the actual
- 23:08client. It's a dramatization, or it's AI. We
- 23:11have to make sure that we include that in there.
- 23:13Otherwise, it could implicate some consequences
- 23:16here. So you want to make sure that you incorporate
- 23:18that. We sometimes include it as a little funny
- 23:22byline saying, just so you know, this is AI.
- 23:25And we'll try to make it humorous. But in terms
- 23:28of including that, it is important. And then
- 23:30the last thing is, are the vendor scripts and
- 23:32chat bot responses reviewed? I'm sure many of
- 23:34you here have received cold calls or emails where
- 23:38a vendor will pitch their AI chatbot or their
- 23:42services to you. And so you just got to make
- 23:44sure that you have oversight over that script.
- 23:47As my colleagues had mentioned earlier, we can't
- 23:49allow for these chatbots to offer any legal advice
- 23:52or to even portray themselves as the actual law
- 23:56firm without a disclosure and making sure that
- 23:59you imply that this is an AI chatbot or that
- 24:01this is an AI response. Anything that has to
- 24:04do with get a quick evaluation on your case or
- 24:09do I have a case, yes or no? Those are the types
- 24:12of things that you wanna make sure that you're
- 24:13reviewing with your vendors because unfortunately,
- 24:15those are now being highly scrutinized. And with
- 24:20that, I will actually... I'm sorry, actually
- 24:23before I step into that. So as far as vendor
- 24:25contract safeguards, so this is now, again, obviously
- 24:28a lot of you that are perhaps maybe a sole practitioner
- 24:32or don't have a marketing team on hand and work
- 24:35with vendors. This is something that you want
- 24:37to make sure that you spend a little more time
- 24:39on, especially as you're vetting them. So some
- 24:41of the vendor contract safeguards that you can
- 24:44incorporate into your vetting process is compliance
- 24:46warranties. So make sure that you have approval
- 24:49rights, like we mentioned before publication.
- 24:51So you want to make sure that you incorporate
- 24:53that into your contract, that you have the final
- 24:55say in every single piece of content that is
- 24:58published on your behalf. And demonification
- 25:00provisions, so making sure that that is included
- 25:03in your contract as well. Rapid take down obligations.
- 25:06So as we've described here, there is a timeline
- 25:10that is assigned as soon as a claim is processed.
- 25:13So you want to make sure that you have some sort
- 25:15of procedure for if an ad is flagged, how quickly
- 25:20can you take it down? How quickly can you identify
- 25:22where it's been dispersed? Because it's likely
- 25:25that the ad is probably not just running on Google,
- 25:27especially if you're using a vendor. It's likely
- 25:30running on social media or on an email campaign
- 25:33and so on. So how quickly can all of that come
- 25:36down? And then last thing is the audit rights
- 25:38for scripts and recordings. So again, making
- 25:40sure that you have that authority over what it
- 25:43is that these tools are saying on your behalf.
- 25:48And with that, I will hand it over to Monica,
- 25:50or I'm sorry, Yozi. Yeah, thanks, Jonathan. So
- 25:55SB37 also affects referrals, joint advertising.
- 26:00So a lot of attorneys, you know, use lead gen
- 26:03companies to generate cases. And we're still
- 26:06allowed to, but SB 37 has definitely tied in
- 26:09the expectations around joint advertising. So
- 26:12if you're going to be in a joint advertising
- 26:14relationship with another company, it must, it
- 26:19requires the law firm and the company to join
- 26:23a, to enter into a joint advertising agreement
- 26:26where each law firm attorney takes liability
- 26:30for the ad content. So what that means is if
- 26:34they violate SP37, you're on the hook. It wasn't
- 26:40like that before. If they generated cases and
- 26:44they got you cases, that was great, but not anymore.
- 26:46It's got to be in compliance with SP37. So what
- 26:49that means is you really have to review all ads
- 26:52before they go live. You have to have final say.
- 26:55You have to have veto power. violates part of
- 26:58this provision, you need to prevent that from
- 27:01going live. Because if it does, you will be held
- 27:05liable. So make sure you do that. If you work
- 27:08with a company that refuses to share their ads
- 27:11with you, that's a huge red flag. I would definitely
- 27:13not work with them. There's something there.
- 27:17So as long as, you know, they share with you,
- 27:19you approve everything ahead and everything's
- 27:21compliant, you know, and you have this agreement
- 27:23with them, you should be okay. And then with
- 27:26referrals, you know, if you are getting referrals
- 27:29from a law firm that enters into joint advertising
- 27:32agreement, you want to make sure that that law
- 27:34firm also is in compliance with SB 37. You don't
- 27:39want any issues with that. And this is a particular
- 27:42area of importance to us because we're a heavy
- 27:46referral type law firm, both in referring out
- 27:49cases and accepting referrals. And for referral
- 27:52relationships, you want to remember you're not
- 27:54just evaluating the legal skill of the firm,
- 27:56they're evaluating their infrastructure, their
- 27:58intake, their advertising, their disclosures,
- 28:01and their scripts. And with that, I'm going to
- 28:05send it back to Monica. Okay, so, you know, I'll
- 28:10just wrap it up. Look, we, for those of us who
- 28:13are in have more volume practice, we're always
- 28:17looking for ways to innovate. We're always looking
- 28:20for ways to differentiate. We're always looking
- 28:23for new tools and, and, you know, avenues for
- 28:30attracting business. You know, this isn't To
- 28:32limit innovation, but it does mean that we have
- 28:36to be more deliberate and creating supervisory
- 28:40systems that, you know, protect our innovation.
- 28:44Alrighty, so it does look like we have a question
- 28:48from Megan. Polly regarding some clarification
- 28:51for. Let's see the language requires disclosure
- 28:58of the city town or country. Yeah, I can take
- 29:03that one. Yeah, the bill does use the disjunctive
- 29:06uses or, you know, you know, if you wanted to
- 29:11just put the city or town or county, it looks
- 29:13like it's, you can do that. Again, the, I would
- 29:17go back to the purpose, you know, again, that
- 29:19you always start with the purpose of the bill,
- 29:22it's consumer protection. And, you know, you
- 29:26could, you could put one if you wanted, you could
- 29:28put, you know, 2, if you want to just remember
- 29:30it's the intent of the, of the bill that you
- 29:33want to go for. Right, thank you. And also, we
- 29:41did receive another question online. Um, how,
- 29:44um. How does ask 37 to find a, I generated or
- 29:51synthetic content and practice and where is the
- 29:54line between minor editing and full on, uh, authorship.
- 29:58It says electronic, so I don't know that it gets
- 30:03into the weeds there. Okay. So it's defined more
- 30:09broadly than that. I had a quick question for
- 30:18the panel. This is Mike Douglas here. Have you
- 30:22guys had any conversations with the lead generators
- 30:25at this point? to sort of prime the pump on these
- 30:29discussions. Seems like you guys are pretty heavily
- 30:32involved in marketing efforts. So this would
- 30:35be a pretty big ship to turn. Have you had those
- 30:42conversations with your partners in the advertising
- 30:44space? Yes, of course. How's that been going?
- 30:49Overall, well, they understand. It's very stressful
- 30:51for them. It adds a lot of work to them. It really
- 30:55changes everything. But if they want to continue
- 31:01being in the legal space, they have no choice.
- 31:03But it has made it a lot more difficult on them,
- 31:05for sure. I think we've had, you know, we've
- 31:10we've gone a couple of rounds on the contracts.
- 31:14Sometimes with the lead generation companies,
- 31:16they want to present something that's almost
- 31:19like a shrink wrap. Contract, right? You can
- 31:22sign this or not work with us, but we are lawyers,
- 31:25right? We know that we can always change contract
- 31:28language and we dig in our heels on what we consider
- 31:34to be non -negotiable and we have walked away
- 31:38from lead generation companies that will not
- 31:44protect our non -negotiables. We have. We did
- 31:48walk away from one. Jonathan, here's a question
- 31:56for you. What's your recommendation for reviewing
- 31:59past content that was posted in a large volume?
- 32:04We've got two different people ask that same
- 32:08question. Yeah, as far as our team here at January
- 32:12Law, what we've told ourselves is when in doubt,
- 32:14throw it out. just archive it. If you feel like
- 32:17it didn't fully comply at any point in time,
- 32:19you want to make sure that you just take it down
- 32:21if you can. So like for example, on our social
- 32:24media channels, we went through and scrubbed
- 32:27all of the content. It was a major project for
- 32:30us. Thankfully, we had the resources, thanks
- 32:32to our leaders as well for giving us the time
- 32:34to do that. But it was a matter of just going
- 32:36through and scrubbing everything that was done
- 32:39prior to implementing this new process that we've
- 32:42developed and then looking ahead. So how do we
- 32:45prevent this from happening again, if it were
- 32:47to happen? And that's where we came up with that
- 32:50compliance plan as well as creating really just
- 32:53a log of all the assets that we have out there
- 32:55so that we know exactly what it is that is being
- 32:58portrayed on our behalf. So going through, unfortunately,
- 33:02it will be time consuming. I won't shy around
- 33:06that, but it is worth it, especially considering
- 33:10the fact that anyone can file a suit at this
- 33:14point. It's really just... Open to anyone so
- 33:16it could be a competitor it could be a client
- 33:20that possibly you turn their case away and they
- 33:22got riled up and decided to go through your instagram
- 33:25and maybe this is somebody that spends a lot
- 33:27of time reading about the law or understanding
- 33:30compliance regulations and so they may go and
- 33:32flag your your ad and so it's really important
- 33:35that you invest the time and the energy and and
- 33:38scrubbing all of your content when it comes to
- 33:41your website it may be a little easier depending
- 33:43on um, what you're using. So if you're on, for
- 33:46example, on WordPress or some of these other
- 33:48tools, they sometimes have some sort of like
- 33:52search and replace. And I know I'm diminishing
- 33:54the actual process for it, but it's a matter
- 33:55of using these tools and taking advantage of
- 33:58some of the plugins that they incorporate. So
- 34:00like, for example, you can have website publishers
- 34:02go through and find things that are probably
- 34:05against compliance. So for example, as my colleagues
- 34:09had mentioned, things that talk about any guarantees,
- 34:12any amounts, any quick cash, anything that has
- 34:15to do with some sort of hook that a lot of agencies
- 34:19or writers have incorporated in the past. So
- 34:22you can quickly just use these tools to search.
- 34:24You could also even export a lot of these files
- 34:28from For example, Google Ads allows you to export
- 34:31everything onto Excel. So you can do a quick
- 34:33search and figure out which ad and which ad ID
- 34:37incorporates this. So you can go back into Google
- 34:39or use a mass upload tool and re -upload all
- 34:42of your ad copy. So it is a matter of just going
- 34:46through using the tools to the best of your ability
- 34:49and then possibly even counting on outside resources
- 34:51to help you do that. There's a question. Uh,
- 34:58about whether hashtags count for naming the city,
- 35:02you know, I wouldn't, you know, I got to opine
- 35:04on that. But if you go back to the statute, it's,
- 35:07you know, would that be false deceptive or misleading?
- 35:11Right? Could if you had your, you know, you had
- 35:14a, you know, a hashtag a city, but then you also
- 35:18had hashtag other cities. Um. So I think you
- 35:22really, you know, you want to, again, keep going
- 35:24back to the purpose of the statute, keep going
- 35:26back to the language, and then, you know, ask
- 35:28yourself, could a consumer or would the state
- 35:32bar consider that particular practice to be false,
- 35:36deceptive, or misleading? Yeah, as far as hash
- 35:43sets go, I don't know that that would be explicitly
- 35:47mentioning the city. Good one. I do see here
- 35:54a question regarding best of competitions. I'm
- 35:57familiar with these. I've seen some especially
- 36:00like magazines and even some directories. They
- 36:04almost treat them as business directories to
- 36:06highlight businesses in the city. That is a voting
- 36:09process. So if you're not paying to be included
- 36:14or named I believe, and this is just my personal
- 36:18opinion, that it is safe to use that. I have
- 36:21seen some cities, for example, like in Playa
- 36:23Vista or in Southern California, there are a
- 36:27lot of them where they'll mention like best of
- 36:29torrents or best of Manhattan Beach and so on.
- 36:32So my assumption is that those are safe. But
- 36:35if it's an organization that will send you an
- 36:37email and say, we will be recognizing you as
- 36:40a lawyer of X, Y and Z. here is the fee to be
- 36:44included, then that is a pay for play situation.
- 36:59Alrighty, so it looks like we received another
- 37:00email. For small firms without in -house counsel,
- 37:05what's a realistic supervision structure like?
- 37:13really depends on your volume, right? And how
- 37:18conservative you are in your calls to action
- 37:22and what you're saying about your firm. But if
- 37:25I were a solo or two or three person firm, I'd
- 37:31definitely make sure that we have attorney oversight
- 37:34and that you're cataloging everything that you're
- 37:39putting out there. Well, Jonathan, what would
- 37:45you add? If we didn't have you, what would we
- 37:47do? Yeah. Well, that compliance checklist that
- 37:51we had shared with you all today, I feel would
- 37:53be effective because at least it organizes your
- 37:57thoughts on this. So it'll help you design a
- 38:00framework for yourself. And perhaps maybe you
- 38:02don't have the bandwidth to fully do this in
- 38:04-house and you'll have to outsource it. But it'll
- 38:07at least create a checklist. Like Monica was
- 38:10mentioning, create an inventory of all of your
- 38:12ads, or at least those that you have access to.
- 38:13Ask your vendors to do the same. They should
- 38:15be able to share that with you. If they're not,
- 38:18obviously, like Yossi had mentioned earlier,
- 38:20that's a big red flag. If they're not willing
- 38:22to share that with you. And then a lot of the
- 38:25tools themselves, if you have access to Meta,
- 38:26if you have access to Google, if you have access
- 38:28to some of these other... media companies, you
- 38:31should be able to access your content on the
- 38:33back end if you are truly the owner of that advertising
- 38:36account. Some of these lead gen companies or
- 38:39marketing agencies will oftentimes create profiles
- 38:41for you and you are not the owner. In that case,
- 38:45you should actually reach out to them and say,
- 38:47may I have access to this profile so that you
- 38:49can do your auditing in the event that they're
- 38:50not doing that for you. So hopefully that framework
- 38:53does help. I know that you all received it, but
- 38:55you know, in any event, it's something that we
- 38:57recommend, but obviously you can get really granular.
- 38:59with it or just use it more high level when you're
- 39:02connecting with your vendors or any other resources
- 39:05that you don't have in -house. Another question
- 39:18within the Q &A, Agatha Riley is asking, if we
- 39:22use stock footage in our creatives, what disclosure
- 39:24language is required? Where must it appear? That
- 39:30is a good question. On some of the research that
- 39:33I did regarding stock footage, I believe if you're
- 39:36paying a license and it's not depicting an accident,
- 39:40so if it's more of just like somebody sitting
- 39:42at a desk, that should be fine. But if it's depicting
- 39:45a scenario or a situation that you're using for
- 39:48advertising purposes, like, for example, a car
- 39:50accident scene, if you're replicating a scene
- 39:53that One of your clients endured during their
- 39:56accident. We know that there's television commercials
- 39:58that use a lot of dramatizations. You need to
- 40:01include that in the disclaimer. So making sure
- 40:03that it's a dramatization or that it's it's not
- 40:07the actual scene, but it's either actors being
- 40:10actors portraying, sorry, the client or something
- 40:12to that effect. We don't have the exact terminology
- 40:15that must be included, but I'm sure all of your
- 40:18attorneys, you can come up with some sort of
- 40:20legal jargon for it, but it. it should be implied
- 40:22that it is either not your actual content, but
- 40:27in fact something that you are purchasing or
- 40:29using for dramatic effect. prohibits impersonating,
- 40:40you know, impersonations, that would be false
- 40:42misleading or deceptive. So if you are taking
- 40:46stock, as Jonathan said, if it's just stock footage
- 40:49of the city, you know, LA, that's one thing,
- 40:54but if you're dramatizing certain events, then
- 40:59you need to disclose that this is an impersonation,
- 41:03impersonation or a dramatization. And it looks
- 41:15like Megan has another question for videos that
- 41:19feature attorneys. Does their role have to be
- 41:21featured on screen in the video or only in the
- 41:24caption? I'm not quite sure what she means by
- 41:31that. What the question is getting at. Does the
- 41:35role of the attorney you mean, whether or not
- 41:37they're. Lead or what do you mean? Okay, I guess
- 41:48perhaps we can, ah, all right. So it says the
- 41:53role, okay, so for social media videos, the role
- 41:57of the person speaking, you know, parentheses
- 42:00attorney. Okay. There was a question about is
- 42:09the law retroactive? It is. So if you have anything
- 42:11on live on a website, Either take it down or
- 42:16make it compliant. Yeah. I have another question
- 42:29here is AI marketing tools accelerate content
- 42:31production. How confirm scale review without
- 42:34paralyzing growth. Yeah, that's a great that's
- 42:42a great question. you have to have your review
- 42:49system in place. And with any AI tool that you're
- 42:53using, you have to come, well, you should combine
- 42:57it with human judgment. So you'll need to get
- 43:01good at scaling this review process. I think
- 43:08it's a good thing, right? I think it's a good
- 43:10thing that people can't just generate things
- 43:14willy -nilly with AI. You could generate hundreds
- 43:17of articles a day and then just put them out
- 43:20there. I think it's a good thing that now we
- 43:23are required to review each and every article
- 43:27and that we have to put our name on it. Great.
- 43:33Thank you. Do you anticipate foreseeability and
- 43:38reliance doctrines expanding firm liability for
- 43:40AI -generated misinformation? Yeah, when you
- 43:46have these, when it gets to the courts, yeah,
- 43:49I mean, I think courts are gonna start looking
- 43:51at foreseeability, but, you know, that's with
- 43:56any, I mean, with any law, any sort of civil,
- 44:04you know, action when that's approved. I mean,
- 44:07you're gonna end up having to deal with foreseeability
- 44:09at some point in time. All right, so I actually
- 44:16see a question here regarding risk and enforcement.
- 44:22It's kind of a 2 for are we likely to see enforcement
- 44:26driven primarily by competitor complaints and
- 44:29what level of statutory damages exposure should
- 44:32firms realistically be preparing for. Yeah, do
- 44:38we think that they're going to be a competitor
- 44:41firms. posing themselves as consumers for purposes
- 44:46of the statute to bring action. That's possible.
- 44:50And SB 37 authorizes damages between five and
- 44:54$100 ,000. I can see people asking for the max.
- 45:03Yeah. And I can add to that. I think even now
- 45:06our industry is already experiencing that with
- 45:11competitors that use unethical practices to be
- 45:16in position one or two both on Google and on
- 45:20Meta and all these other companies. I do have
- 45:24a feeling that there will be bad players that
- 45:26come in and start just acting as the, you know,
- 45:29they're going to start policing. Sure. Which
- 45:33honestly, I think Maybe maybe a good thing. It'll
- 45:36keep us all honest. It'll create a greater responsibility
- 45:40for both the publisher and the the one that's
- 45:45writing the content. But I, again, I'm probably
- 45:49just using an assumption here. But based on my
- 45:53experience, I've seen competitors flag each other's
- 45:55Google business profiles as fake or post fake
- 45:59reviews. just so that they can bring down their
- 46:01star ratings. Unfortunately, this industry is
- 46:03highly competitive. So the idea of that being
- 46:07true, I think is likely rather than not. Thank
- 46:17you. And then it also looks like Agatha Riley
- 46:21is asking a question as well in our Q &A. When
- 46:25designing graphics that reference past case results,
- 46:28even if we include a disclaimer such as past
- 46:30results do not guarantee future outcomes, could
- 46:33that be considered misleading under SB 37? Is
- 46:36this considered a gray area? I actually believe
- 46:42you'll be safe with that because that's something
- 46:43that I've seen more often, especially with those
- 46:45firms that have really advanced in their compliance.
- 46:50You're including a disclaimer as long as you
- 46:53have the case to back it up. Some of these cases
- 46:57I know follow non -disclosure agreements, so
- 47:01if you're not even able to share the amount,
- 47:03you likely probably shouldn't be using it in
- 47:05your marketing material. But if you have that
- 47:07case, if it's available to be found both in public
- 47:10record or private, whatever it is, obviously
- 47:14you can display the amount, but you do have to
- 47:17make sure that that disclaimer is included so
- 47:19that it doesn't allude to that being what every
- 47:22single accident will generate for that client.
- 47:31All right, I guess, I guess there's also following
- 47:33up regarding his content featuring written client
- 47:37reviews, including reviews posted on third party
- 47:39platforms such as Google, Yelp. Are they safe
- 47:42to share under SB 37? My answer to that would
- 47:49be yes, and the reason is because it is publicly
- 47:51available So if the client published a review
- 47:54on Google and you're screenshotting that and
- 47:56using that in your marketing It is actually displayed
- 48:00on a public forum. It isn't misleading in the
- 48:03and the way that SV37 is written. You're not
- 48:05making any claims or any guarantees. All you're
- 48:08doing is you're sharing content that somebody
- 48:10shared with you on a public forum, which could
- 48:13be considered neutral in my case. However, anything
- 48:17that we publish that has to do with results.
- 48:21we always make sure to include a disclaimer just
- 48:23to safeguard ourselves because if the review
- 48:26itself mentions the results that were obtained
- 48:29or if it makes any sort of claim for example
- 48:32some reviews mention these are the best personal
- 48:35injury attorneys in California that sounds great
- 48:38and looks great and is obviously a wonderful
- 48:40accolade to to attain but We like to include
- 48:44a disclaimer just to safeguard ourselves, and
- 48:47it's typically a short one. As we had mentioned
- 48:49earlier, past results do not guarantee future
- 48:51outcomes and things like that. So I just say
- 48:54err on the side of caution. If you're wondering
- 48:56if something doesn't follow the protocol, just
- 48:59include a disclaimer or even link to one at least
- 49:03just so that you are completely confident that
- 49:05it's something that does comply with SB37. Great.
- 49:11Thank you. And it looks like we have another
- 49:13question from Jack Russo. He's asking how will
- 49:17BNP 17200 play into litigation? Well, I suppose
- 49:26you could bring a case under 17200, but then
- 49:31also 6158. 17200, as I understand it, is it prohibits
- 49:37unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business acts.
- 49:40And then this one is obviously oriented towards
- 49:43misleading, um, um, false deceptive and misleading
- 49:48practices. So, um, you could, you could bring
- 49:54an action under, under, under both, I would,
- 49:56I would imagine. Great. And it looks like I have,
- 50:02um, in there. Two questions now, mainly regarding
- 50:07vendor management. How should firms handle vendors
- 50:12who are resistant to pre -publication approval
- 50:17agreements? Don't work with them. There's a reason.
- 50:21Why wouldn't they be transparent? They're doing
- 50:24nothing wrong. They should understand the gravity
- 50:27of the situation. That's a huge red flag. You're
- 50:30walking into a danger zone. Just don't even...
- 50:33Don't even think about it. Just walk away. It's
- 50:38not worth your license. All right, thank you.
- 50:42And then the next one being, what documentation
- 50:44would you want in your file to demonstrate reasonable
- 50:47supervision during a state bar inquiry? I would
- 50:54say document everything. Scots, URLs, timestamps,
- 50:59email exchanges, anything that can be possibly
- 51:04used against you, make sure that you're on top
- 51:06of it. And I put the framework, your review framework
- 51:11as well to show that you have, in good faith,
- 51:18attempted to comply. For sure. All right. Let's
- 51:25see, one last one just came in. Let's see here.
- 51:46What common mistakes would you say that firms
- 51:49are making with required disclosures under SB
- 51:5137? Maybe being more reactive than then proactive
- 52:03Right. We've been talking about, you know, how
- 52:07do you lean forward? How do you create a compliance
- 52:10framework? How do you instill discipline? among
- 52:16the members of your team, whether you have a
- 52:18marketing team or whether they're just attorneys.
- 52:23I think that, you know, maybe kind of thinking,
- 52:26you know, there's so much, you know, there's
- 52:28so many other people out there not complying
- 52:31with the, you know, with SB 37 that I'm not,
- 52:34it doesn't really matter to me. I mean, we can
- 52:38drive down the road every day and there's still
- 52:40billboards saying, you know, Millions one and
- 52:44we're the best and things like that. We may not
- 52:46see the little small print down there. So we
- 52:49think that you know, look there Those guys and
- 52:52gals are going to get it before I do and I think
- 52:56that that would be That would be unwise Great.
- 53:09Thank you, Monica And in the Q &A, we have a
- 53:13question from Aaron Stiegerwald. Do you have
- 53:17to disclose the year of each award in non -pay
- 53:21-to -play awards? I believe that actually is
- 53:26based on the compliance regulations for each
- 53:30of those awards. So I know, for example, you
- 53:32can't tout yourself as a super lawyer unless
- 53:35you include the year and also the trademark.
- 53:37The same goes with best lawyers. even like top
- 53:40verdicts and so on, those are all assigned per
- 53:43year. So you're not allowed to use any of their
- 53:45trademarks unless you're complying with those
- 53:49policies. And so typically, if it is based on
- 53:52a year and it's not an evergreen award, you should
- 53:56incorporate the year. Otherwise, you may end
- 53:58up forfeiting that award if that publisher were
- 54:01to find you not following their guidelines. Thank
- 54:06you, Jonathan. And it does look like Megan did
- 54:10reach out with some clarification regarding her
- 54:12question area about captioning. What she had
- 54:16meant originally was that when an ad features
- 54:18a video with an attorney speaking, does the attorney's
- 54:20title have to be featured on screen in the video
- 54:22portion? Not only in the written caption. SB37
- 54:30just says that the name has to be conspicuously
- 54:34displayed. or intelligible if it's audible. So
- 54:39I would use that as my guide. And even just marketing
- 54:48best practices. I mean, understanding that a
- 54:51lot of people watch videos on social media with
- 54:53the audio off. So having your attorney's name
- 54:57on the video, I think is a good idea. And it's
- 55:01also because Why not? You know, I would hate
- 55:04to think that a video circulates and goes viral
- 55:06and doesn't include Yosio Monica's name on it.
- 55:09I would much rather, as a marketing person, make
- 55:11sure that we're getting their name out there.
- 55:13So my recommendation would be to always include
- 55:15it if you can. But obviously, to Monica's point,
- 55:18as long as it's somewhere displayed, I think
- 55:20you should be fine. Great. Thank you both. So
- 55:25it looks like that's it for the questions that
- 55:27I have here. Do any of you have any, you know,
- 55:30Extra closing remarks or review that you'd like
- 55:32to provide to our audience? I just think do great
- 55:38marketing. Keep your clients in mind. Always
- 55:41consider yourself their advocate, both when it
- 55:44comes to filing claims on their behalf, but also
- 55:47keeping your audience safe. And I'd just like
- 55:51to say thank you. Thank you for joining us today.
- 55:54And thanks so much for your questions. Love questions.
- 56:00Please reach out in the future. You can email
- 56:02us, Monica, Jonathan, myself, all three of us
- 56:05with questions that come up. I'm sure they will,
- 56:08because we're all navigating this for the first
- 56:09time. Don't hesitate to reach out via email call,
- 56:14and we'll be happy to try to help out. Great,
- 56:18fantastic. Thank you. So this concludes today's
- 56:21presentation. Thank you so much for an excellent
- 56:23program, and thank you so much to our audience
- 56:25for joining us today. Have a great day, everybody.
- 56:28Thanks for having us. Thanks. Goodbye.