Latest / Murder Junction / Episode 99 - A special episode recorded live at Malice Domestic, USA debating: Which is better? American or British Crime Writing?
Transcript
- 0:13Welcome to the Red Hot Chili Writers Podcast. Where are your hosts, Vassin
- 0:16Khan and Abe Mukuji, two crime authors ready to expose themselves on air for
- 0:20your titillation, edification and amusement. We'll be talking life, pop culture,
- 0:25and the pursuit of the creative arts, all seasoned with just a dash of
- 0:29gen massala the best laid plans of mice and men. Dear listeners, the
- 0:43episode you are about to hear was recorded live last week at the thirty fifth
- 0:46Malice Domestic Crime Convention in Maryland, USA. My co host and I were
- 0:50invited to the festival as international guests of honor. Last due to circumstances beyond
- 0:56our control or more likely, someone realizing they'd made a horrible mistake, Abbet
- 1:00was forced to pull out of the trip at the last moment, and so
- 1:03once again it was left to yours truly to hold the fort. Abbet,
- 1:07however, did manage to zoom in on the last date to record our planned
- 1:11podcast. Technical difficulties made a tricky endeavor, but we nevertheless hope you enjoy
- 1:15the recording. Now, before you dive into that session, I have a
- 1:21request. My last book, The Lost Man of Bombay, the third in
- 1:23the Malabar House series, is currently long listed for one of the world's biggest
- 1:26crime fiction awards, the Thiegston Old Peculiar Crime Novel of the Year. The
- 1:32shortlist is decided by public vote. Absolutely anyone can vote, and voting takes
- 1:38about ten seconds. So may I request that you go onto the voting website
- 1:42and vote for me, or for any of the other brilliant books on the
- 1:45long list if they take your fancy. Instead, to vote, simply go
- 1:49to the Harrogut Thixton Crime Award website. Thiexton is spelled t h e a
- 1:55K S t o N and the website is ww dot Harrogut Thiegston Crime Award
- 2:00dot com. Select the book that you want to vote for from the dropdown
- 2:02box, then submit simple and if the website is temporarily down, as sometimes
- 2:07happens, do come back to it. The deadline is fast approaching, so
- 2:10if you would like to vote, please do so quickly, and thank you
- 2:14in advance to those who do vote for me. You're clearly the best and
- 2:16the sanest ones listening and now, without further ado, let's head off to
- 2:21the good old us of a Ladies and gentlemen, Welcome to Malice de Mesti
- 2:35and to a very very special episode of the Red Hot Chili Writers Podcasts,
- 2:40coming to you live from Bethesda, Maryland and the good old us of A
- 2:46and also the Siem's Basement in London. My name is Abia Kugee and you
- 2:54already know who I am vast can't And tonight in the slive recording of our
- 3:00podcast, we shall be hosting three very wonderful and very confused authors. You
- 3:07can't call them confused. There are guests. I'm only saying that because in
- 3:15the emails that we've exchanged with them, they have been telling us that American
- 3:20crime writing is superior to British crime writing. So clearly they must be confused,
- 3:27or, as I believe they say, in this neck of the woods,
- 3:30as crazy as cross eyed cowboys. Well, tonight the cowboys are going
- 3:35to meet the Indians. More on this and on. For those of you
- 3:39who don't know who we are, we are the Red Hot Chili Writers.
- 3:44We co hosted podcast myself and my learned colleague here he wrote these notes,
- 3:49by the way, and he spelled colleague wrong. I had to fix it.
- 3:52Where have I got to? Yes? And it's one of the most
- 3:53well known crime fiction podcasts in the UK, and indeed a few other players.
- 4:00We have interrogated many of the world's most famous criminals David Baldacci, Ian
- 4:06Rankin, Val McDavid Lee Child, Deem Kuntz and Please Essay Cosby, Ruth
- 4:12Ware, Jane Harper, Lisa Jeweled. The list is positively endless. I
- 4:16think it's time for you to introduce our lovely guests. Okay, let's start
- 4:20with Jeff Cohen sometimes no, so be aware that they provided these infos to
- 4:30us. So sometimes known as drug sometimes known as e J. Kopperman,
- 4:36which does make things confusing. Whichever one is here today, writes the Jersey
- 4:41Go Legal mystery series, and in the past wrote the Haunted Guesthouse, Agent
- 4:45to the Pause, Mysterious Detective and Asperger's Mystery series. In two days he
- 4:49will launch the fran and ken Stein mystery series about two sibling detectives who are
- 4:55let's say, about two percent less than completely human, with the of all
- 5:00Ukulele of Death, which should be available in his book room right now.
- 5:04Jeff Or E. J. Writes in New Jersey, which is convenient because
- 5:06he lives there now. I bear you you have a very strong connection to
- 5:12the ukulele. Do you know well I do. My son plays the ukulele
- 5:15very badly. Condolences and but I'm going to tell you about our next guesses.
- 5:23Katrina McPherson was born in Scotland. You can tell look at those look
- 5:27at those rosy cheeks. You can see that that bonny face. Hey,
- 5:30and she immigrates, immigrated to the US in two thousand and ten. Why
- 5:34did you do that boy trouble? And so boy trouble or tax trouble or
- 5:44FBI trouble, whichever it was. Live in patwin Land in north northern California.
- 5:50What's patwin Land. It's the land that's the ancestral lands of the Patwin
- 5:56people. I'm just an incomer, oh I see, I see. She
- 6:00writes preposterous nineteen thirties detective stories set in the Old Country and modern comedies set
- 6:05in the New Country, as well as domestic noir standalons where the relationships are
- 6:11as bad as the weather. Katrina is a serial awards botherer, lifetime member
- 6:19and former National president of Sisters in Crime. Welcome to Last, but by
- 6:29no means least is art Taylor, who is an Agatha and Edgar Award winning
- 6:33short story writer whose most recent collection came out earlier this year, The Adventure
- 6:39of the Castle Thief and Other Expeditions and Indiscretions. He's a professor of English
- 6:43and Creative Writing at George Mason University in Virginia, and art has been called
- 6:47the present day Edgar Allan Poe. Now, I don't think they mean that
- 6:51he wonders about drinking too much, absent and looking boulish. Frankly, he's
- 6:56the only one of us here who has any real credibility, So we are
- 6:59just going to call him professor. We are scooled. We've got a real
- 7:03professor on our either is that he is? Yeah, some days I think
- 7:10before we start, let me see that, let me see the audience again.
- 7:13If left, we normally stipulate we locked the doors, but you guys
- 7:21unaware of that. So let's let's get some ground rules sorted. I know
- 7:25that debating is a national pasttime in America, particularly amongst the young and energetic,
- 7:33but unfortunately, nobody on the panel is either young or energetic, so
- 7:39hopefully we'll still be able to live up to it. But there are some
- 7:42rules today that you, the audience, will decide who wins today's contest.
- 7:47Okay, so you can't go to sleep, any of you, the ones
- 7:51of you that aren't already asleep, of course, please pay attention because at
- 7:55the end of the day you are going to decide whether British or American crime
- 8:00writing is superior. And we're quite confident that at the end of the day
- 8:03you will see the light and agree with from a good friend for Seamen and
- 8:07I that British fiction is far superior. But as we say, this is
- 8:11open. So that's let's get going. Let's get we should say Katrina is
- 8:16the wild card. Right, so we've got two Americans, two Brits and
- 8:18I'm not really sure. Let's start with some scenes, steady. So Britain
- 8:22is clearly the place where crime writing has consistently made leaps and bounds, from
- 8:28Kundole Sherlock Holmes to Agatha Christie's porow, from Golden Age to police procedures.
- 8:31Britain has set the gold standard in crime writing. And yeah, then there's
- 8:39you and me, and yet that's there are some people no names mentioned,
- 8:46who would like us to believe that all truly daring sexy stuff has come out
- 8:52of America, from Dashiell Hammet's The Multese Falcon to Raymond Chandler's The Big Sleep,
- 8:58from Gillian Flynn's Gone Girl, The Leech House, Jack Reacher, Gon
- 9:01hang On, Lee Childs is British? Was Lee Child for a star?
- 9:07There are two of them now, aren't there? So maybe it is children
- 9:15the child In a minute, let's start with a couple of questions. That's
- 9:24it's your question. Can you know with your own name? You got an
- 9:26old version? Okay, let's start with this one. So start with the
- 9:31who? All right? Who invented? They? Will? I'll do it?
- 9:35Okay, because obviously the seam hasn't seen the latest version, which he
- 9:37made me update in the middle of the night, rented Prime fiction. The
- 9:43Americans or the British, Edgar allen Pool or Arthur Conan Doyle panel, esteemed
- 9:50panel? Who'd like to start on this one? I'll start? And it
- 9:54was Anna Catherine Green? Right, did you lose? For the audience?
- 10:00For people who don't know, sorry, lucidate, tell a little bit more.
- 10:03Oh, everyone in the audience knows who are a Catherinian? But for
- 10:07basing year she wrote the first female detective in what we would we Brits would
- 10:15call him American Times, Victorian Times. And she wrote a detective story before
- 10:20Cronan Doyle was started writing. I mean it was seventeen fifty three. I'm
- 10:24making that up, but it was before, so she was groundbreaking. She
- 10:30wrote Miss Markle before miss Marcle. I can't remember what our detective was called,
- 10:35but you know Amelia Butterworth. Amelia Butterworth, thank you, Professor Art.
- 10:39And I have no idea why she's forgotten. Hint sexism. There,
- 10:45that's my Tappansworth. Okay, that is a strong opening page. Okay,
- 10:50and for the Americans, Jeff for Professor Art, um, I was I
- 10:54was gonna good. I mean, obviously you mentioned Edgar Allen Howe and I
- 10:58was going to go back there. I think Captain Green is a terrific person
- 11:01to point too. Sorry, sorry, I just can old of you make
- 11:03sure you're talking to your mike's because we're recording this for actual release. On
- 11:07the basically, I should not look at Katrina while I talk, because this
- 11:09is what it is, because it's a don't touch the mics, hello,
- 11:13okay, don't cross the beans. Don't look at Katrina don't touch the mic.
- 11:18Is it very very still, everybody in the audience a beer. I
- 11:24already mentioned Edgar Allen Poe. I was going to go back there. Of
- 11:26course, we think about the murders in the room work as the first modern
- 11:31detective story, published April eighteen forty one in Graham's magazine. It is a
- 11:35key point in the development of the modern detective story. We got a locked
- 11:39room mystery. We've got a genius detective. We got our Watson figure,
- 11:43and I say Watson figure pre Watson Watson figure. We've got the clues,
- 11:48the witnesses, the investigation of the crime scene. All that is right there.
- 11:54And the idea is is it anything that we've seen since then? Sort
- 11:56of builds from that in one way or another. And I know you mentioned
- 12:01Conan Doyle when you first made your pitch about I'm sitting very still, first
- 12:05made your pitch about British prime fiction. But even Conan Doyle said that everything
- 12:09I do is just following in the footsteps of a master. So I'm gonna
- 12:13trust Conan Doyle on this. That the Americans inventage it. This is not
- 12:20fair. This is this is like a basketball game where everybody has just just
- 12:26come out from their homes, has never played basketball. And then you've got
- 12:28Shaquille O'Neill and Lebron Lebron James and Madison Bumgardner. You're not allowed to see
- 12:35Gardner online the scene the scene. Let's let's say from you. Oh no,
- 12:41let's done. I feel like I'm on the wrong panel. Um.
- 12:50So one thing, I'm not an American. Um, I'm from New Jersey.
- 12:56For the Brits, who I'm going to be listening to this, You're
- 12:58gonna have to explain that. I will. I will very much. We're
- 13:01right on the east coast and immediately to our west, it's a state that
- 13:05they like to call Pennsylvania. And at the border there's a sign that says
- 13:13Pennsylvania, America begins here. So I can only assume that I'm not an
- 13:22American, and I'm certainly not an authority on who wrote the first crime story.
- 13:33I wasn't there. I'm lucky if I can tell you who wrote the
- 13:37crime story like last week. Okay, So I My impression has always been
- 13:46that the Edgar Award is named after Poe because he got there first. Now
- 13:52it's also possible that he had the best publicist. So I'm willing to.
- 13:58I can go either way on this. That's like the Jewel Biden of answers.
- 14:01There cousin Joe, his cousin Joanah after his Guinness drinking is America.
- 14:11What do you class yourselves as then, Jeff Um, we hate everybody so
- 14:16you're Scottish very much though, but we know not to try to do the
- 14:22accent. Can you tell Katrina? I can listen to Katrina talk all day
- 14:28long, just don't look at her. No, it's God. No,
- 14:33I've got to I've got to say out beer. They put some very strong
- 14:35arguments forward. Here have you got I would like? I'm gonna I'm gonna
- 14:37let you answer the case for Britain here I've got nothing. The only the
- 14:43only thing I can I can say on behalf of mister Conan Doyle, or
- 14:48two things. Firstly, he was involved in setting up one of the oldest
- 14:50cricket teams in in Britain which I play for, called the Authors eleven.
- 14:54You've played for them since the beginning I've had I've had a charmed life as
- 15:00you can see. And the only other lovely fact I know about Conan Doyle
- 15:03is that when Christie went missing nineteen twenty six twenty seven for eleven days.
- 15:09Conan Doyle was one of the people who most ardently pursued the police and the
- 15:15investigation to try and find One of the things that he did was higher a
- 15:18medium conductor seance or whatever it was that, or gave her a handkerchief as
- 15:24if she was a sniffer dog or something. I'm not sure it really worked.
- 15:28I think Conan Doyle believed that you could find someone with a magic handkerchief.
- 15:33Case closed, No, not quite. Tapping your brain, there's none
- 15:39in there now. This is this one is from Katrina. Who would you
- 15:43back in a bar fight? America's terrific terrific old Broad or Britain's most splendid,
- 15:50splendid old trout. I don't know what Beca's most terrific terrifical broad right
- 16:00broad. So clearly this is confused, caused confusion, trainer, it's your
- 16:03accent. I have absolutely no idea what she's talking about other than the second
- 16:11reference, obviously, So who is America's terrific old Who is America's most terrific
- 16:18terrific old Broad? In crime fiction, Amelia Peabody, Maybe Jessica Fletcher.
- 16:25Who else is a contender? Amelia Peabody, Emerson, Britain's most splendid,
- 16:30splendid old trout fictional missus mar Paul. But I met Britain's real life most
- 16:41splendid, splendid old trout. It's got to be a toss up between Agatha
- 16:47Christie, Va seman A Beer obviously Agatha Christie, Dorothy Sayers or most recently
- 16:53mc beaten. I mean, would you mess or mc hammers. She was
- 16:59known and she was on tour. Yeah, right, I want to hear
- 17:02from professor on this. I was still trying to figure out the slang on
- 17:07trout. So it's affectionate, is it? Yeah? Yeah, yeah,
- 17:11try it on your mother's affection Yeah. I'll give her a call later.
- 17:18Um, yeah, you know, if we got Jessica Fletcher, I like
- 17:21Jessica Fletcher. Um, you know my my wife. And now we've been
- 17:25watching a lot say something. Sorry, sorry again? Did I turn my
- 17:29head? So no, I still can't hear you. I got sorry,
- 17:32carry on his back you hear me? Now? Yeah? Yeah? Can
- 17:37I just tell you the answer to the last question before we continued? Yes,
- 17:41in America, audience, who do you think invented crankfit Britain. Claque
- 17:47for Britain, no class flat for America. They're all wrong. Crime fiction
- 17:56was invented in India. Choice I didn't say it was fair. Great fiction
- 18:08was invented fifteen hundred BC in the Hindu scriptures, the Vedas, and the
- 18:17first detective was it was a dog called Sarahma. So she wasn't a goddess,
- 18:22she was a dog. Es it was a female dog, sarah Mar
- 18:30the dog. The writer was the writer female. The writer apparently was God.
- 18:37Yes, you're not gonna win this argument. May not. You're not
- 18:45going to win this. So the dog Sarah was forced to investigate when the
- 18:49heavenly heard of cows was stolen um and the god Indra initially sent a bird
- 18:56to do the job, but the bird ended up not finding these cows,
- 19:00and so Sarama was sent to investigate, and she discovered that the herd had
- 19:06been stolen by a bunch of bad people called the Pannies. So there you
- 19:10are. Crime fiction firstly was invented in India, But you're all wrong.
- 19:15The second piece of crime fiction, as we all know, was Kane and
- 19:19Abel, which was Jeffrey Archer. So that's so the British win by default.
- 19:26There you go right now, to get back to working out whatever it
- 19:33was that Katrina Usked still has been most scared of taking their earrings off and
- 19:38turning their rings. Yeah. I was going to say Jessica Fletcher and as
- 19:44started to say that that we watch a lot of murder. She wrote a
- 19:48lot of murder, she wrote, we know how smart she is at solving
- 19:51things. But many of you probably know about the T shirt as well,
- 19:53with that nice picture of Jessica Fletcher that says I killed them all. So
- 20:00she gets points for double duty killing and solving Jessica Fletcher who played her exactly
- 20:07who played Jessica Fletcher. Man has a point, and he's got a point.
- 20:14He's got a point. You know, if he's rigging the game from
- 20:17his end, we could just mute him, right, I mean here,
- 20:21No, we don't have to. It just goes out on its own.
- 20:23Ye. I think the gods are on our site. For an American,
- 20:29I gotta go with Norah Charles. Well, I think you know is Nick
- 20:33and Nora? Oh yeah right, um, because she's she's the brains of
- 20:38the operation. But she will take you out with right cross if she has
- 20:44to it. So that's my American. Did you want to expand because there's
- 20:48lots of people in Britain who will not know who that is? Ah,
- 20:51never heard of the Thin Man? Good lord, it's frightening. So the
- 20:55education is better here too. Who it was this podcast? Why do you
- 21:06think? I used to do you know, author appearances at like not assisted
- 21:15living, but you know kind of uh, active adult communities. And I
- 21:19would say who's seen the movie The Thin Man? And you would get a
- 21:25lot of hands the glennup and I say, okay, who remembers who the
- 21:29killer was? And the Thin Man? And it would be like you know,
- 21:30a good night. There would be like one guy and I would say
- 21:33who remembers Nick and Nora Charles and all the hands came back up. It's
- 21:37about character. So for my American, I have Nora Charles. For the
- 21:44British, I'm gonna go with Jessica Fletcher because I'm afraid of her. Dashel
- 21:56Hammond, it was Dashall Hamnett. I think you'll find the Brits on this
- 22:03panel don't know very much at all. Well, what's your response to this?
- 22:14My response is, how did you get us into this. I'm gonna
- 22:18say, I'm going to go back to the old lady. I'm going to
- 22:22go back to Anatha Christie, and I'm going to say the woman faked her
- 22:26own death, right, her own death, and it ended up weaving the
- 22:32south of England and going to the north, which is dangerous at the best
- 22:34at time. All right, she went to Harrogate, which is quite genteel.
- 22:40But the woman, you know, she she left her car on the
- 22:44edge of a cliff, right, and then she she disappeared for ten days,
- 22:48took the name of her husband's lover. That's pretty bad as I And
- 22:55this is what the twenties or thirties of the scene were around at the time.
- 23:00Do you know what the best part of that story is though? What
- 23:06she um when he when she was eventually tracked down, I mean most of
- 23:08you will know this and her husband turned up, she acted as if nothing
- 23:14had happened. I mean, can you imagine to brazen it out and pretend
- 23:18as if absolutely nothing had happened for eleven dation she'd gone missing? What else
- 23:23would you do? It's the British way, yes, But we were talking
- 23:26about this yesterday, right, um, when I ended up in a queue
- 23:30at a Mexican grill um and there was no grill. I mean it says
- 23:34Mexican grill and it was just a counter where people slop stuff. But because
- 23:40I joined a queue, I felt too embarrassed to leave. Right, what's
- 23:45what's next on your listen? Yes? My next question? We have to
- 23:49vote. Oh that's that's reaching, that's preaching. Yeah, but it's our
- 24:06podcast, right, vote clap? So who's the baddest of them all?
- 24:15But just remember if you vote America on this one, you're voting a gangst
- 24:18Agatha Christie and you do host the Christie Awards. Right, fast, get
- 24:27to vote? Who votes for whose first? I can't remember? There's Nick
- 24:30and Nora first, wasn't it? No? Who's first? Last? Landsbury?
- 24:34Who's voting for Angela Landsbury? Nobody? Are you gonna clap? They
- 24:41can't hear you raise your hands? Okay, So who's who's voting for?
- 24:45Agatha Christie? Yes? You see my cunning plan there, because they host
- 24:49the Agatha Awards. Right. So, so after two questions, the scores
- 24:53are Britain one, India one. Okay, you know what I'm I'm gonna
- 25:00pull one of your jobs where you're gonna go back and then rig the vote.
- 25:03I'm gonna come back to Anna Katherine Green. Can I do that?
- 25:06I'm sorry I turned to Katrina. You couldn't hear me. So Anna Katherine
- 25:10Green created Miss Marple before there was a Miss Marple, and that was Amelia
- 25:15Butterworth, as you said, And she created Violet Strange, who was a
- 25:18precursor to Nancy Drew, and there is no other character. I would think
- 25:22that has a bigger influence on writers today than Nancy Drew in terms of what
- 25:27we read, what we learned from what we write. So I'm gonna pull,
- 25:33I'm gonna out that is a mighty well, well just raised their hands.
- 25:41You're cracting, But we haven't heard the qualification to that rather bold statement.
- 25:48So we're all influenced by Nancy Drew. You say, I think in
- 25:52terms of yes, in many ways. Yes, that's what I was saying.
- 25:56There was no qualm learned, colleague. She had told you it's a
- 26:00mistake to have a professor. I told you, fine, he'll be drunk,
- 26:06it will be fine, and no, it's sober, and he's beating
- 26:08the shit out of us. Another question, anyway, I'm going to move
- 26:15on to the next question. I love the fact that American brought up the
- 26:19subject of vote rigging, like we would know anything about that. Next question,
- 26:25which American author do you think would be most likely to be voted president?
- 26:30And which British author do you think would be most likely to be voted
- 26:36Prime minister? And why? And then I suppose who would win in a
- 26:40fight between them? Jd Vance Sorry, no, is he a crimewriter?
- 26:47That's just a crime ye that silence suggests no, Jack great, no author.
- 26:56I think we've got to because we've got to keep it realistic here.
- 26:59We can't. It's very realistic so far. I think I'm Cleaves would make
- 27:03an excellent prime minister. Yes, he could beat the Crapper and most people
- 27:11as well. First, yeah, I'm gonna since we're at Malison again,
- 27:18you mentioned Ann Cleaves, who of course was honored last night. I'm gonna
- 27:21shout out a couple of other people on the president side. I got two.
- 27:25One is Donna Andrews, who is here. M Donna is the head,
- 27:30the executive vice president of Mister Writers of America. I have seen behind
- 27:34the scenes how good she is at diplomacy, at thinking through all sides of
- 27:40an issue and at delivering compromises and things to people. So that's my first
- 27:45book. You know you're not on the campaign trail. Yeah, I know
- 27:48who's at. Robert Kennedy Junior is who he's hat in the ring yesterday,
- 27:53very small hat. The other is uh, Hank Philippi. Ryan Tank has
- 28:03poise and posture and as articulate. I mean, she belongs behind a podium
- 28:08there. But I've also read her works. I know how twisty she can
- 28:14be, and the behind the scenes machinations and strategies and secrets, so which
- 28:18I'm not saying that's needed in politics, but I guess I am Jeff as
- 28:26for president UM, I will not seek the nomination of my party, nor
- 28:33if called, will I run, although that would be absolutely hilitious. That's
- 28:41what we used to think everyone. Uh. I think Julius Spencer Fleming would
- 28:49make a good president. She's she's very compassionate, she speaks really well,
- 28:56and you don't want to cross her. So I think that would be good.
- 29:00That's for Prime minister. I don't understand how you people come up with
- 29:03the steps. I feel that I should be generous enough to note that men
- 29:07are allowed to be presidents and prime ministers too, because so far we've got
- 29:11Donna, Hank Julian Ann. Can I can I suggest someone from the prime
- 29:19minister. I don't know if you've heard of him over there? Have you
- 29:22heard of Wildean? Yeah? Wildein is a phenomenal writer, but from a
- 29:29political point of view, he is also the handsomest man on the planets.
- 29:34A dog cause for an argument would let you down at me? No,
- 29:38you just wanted. I mean the man lives in a forest in Sweden and
- 29:41he looks like Jesus. If you have a baby, you want Wildeine to
- 29:48kiss your baby? Right? Any other candidates for prime minister, We're a
- 29:52bit threadbig given our recent recent history of prime ministers. I might go for
- 29:57a first Minister of school Hotland and I would have to say Val McDermott absolutely
- 30:06none of that nonsense of big bowls in charge. I'm telling you, bloody,
- 30:11Probably that's the greatest thing. She probably will end up being first minister
- 30:17if her name's probably coming to the top as we run through them. Yeah,
- 30:22right, sure, we have a vote on this one. I'm conscious
- 30:25of the time. Can I just say Kathy's could run wheels, right,
- 30:30yeah, absolutely, yeah, So I think I think there has to be
- 30:34a bit of you know, I mean, you know, you can't just
- 30:37have women running everything. It seems a bit unfair. I'm sure it does.
- 30:44We get back to us in fifteen hundred years of year. Okay,
- 30:51so let's let's do let's have who's going to run who's going to run America
- 30:55and who's gonna run Britain? Or put it another way, so we can
- 30:59have a on this. If you think America would be better run by a
- 31:03crime writer than Britain would be better run by a crime writer, clap the
- 31:08other way around. Oh from the one person in the audience who is a
- 31:15Irish half Irish. Okay, so you can have your crime writer and we'll
- 31:21stay with our clothes, is what you're saying, right, Okay, So
- 31:26I think I think that point goes to America. Then, so it's what
- 31:30as one point to America, one to Britain, and one to India.
- 31:33Right now, fast, next question for our esteemed panel. What have we
- 31:38got what have we got on on this person? Oh wait, wait,
- 31:41wait wait, I've got a special round here, right, this is the
- 31:45round you've all been waiting for. This is the self plugging round. Tell
- 31:49us why your novels best represent represented what is best in American fiction or British
- 31:56fiction. As I meant, I am not an American. I'm from New
- 32:01Jersey, and so all my books speak the native language of New Jersey sarcasm.
- 32:09We're fluent. You guys may think you know it. Look it up
- 32:15on duo lingo. You do a couple of weeks, but you're not going
- 32:19to get the accent right. Okay, So we represent what is best about
- 32:25America, which is that you can say whatever you damn well please, and
- 32:31you should be funny doing it, because if you're not, why did you
- 32:36bother compelling argument? Is that reflected in your books? Yeah, although I
- 32:45have to say, Joe Biden doesn't really strike me. It's very funny.
- 32:49Joe Biden's not from New Jersey. So this is a very specific argument you
- 32:54have. Oh yeah, because because the question was best about your entire country,
- 32:58not that is my entire Can you top that? No? I don't
- 33:06think that's the best about our country's writings. Is that book? It Pits
- 33:14of Mice America. I came late on this email chain. I don't remember
- 33:20this question being on there and this is not one of your classes. Aren't
- 33:25we allowed to ask questions not on the syllables supposed to do lesson plans for
- 33:29this That's what I was working on, you know, Katrina, Why is
- 33:37my fiction the best thing about Scotland and the books that are set in California
- 33:40the best fiction that comes out of California. That's the question. You've already
- 33:45lost the audience because in the books that I write about California, if I
- 33:52get anything wrong, I can just say, oh, that's that's how we
- 33:54do it in Scotland. And in the books that I write about Scotland,
- 33:58if there's any plot points, a gaping hole, I can say, oh,
- 34:01well you see Robert the Bruce and back then you know before mel Gibson
- 34:07and I can so I can get away with anything. I've got such a
- 34:09lot of cover because I can just lapse into scott so nobody can understand me
- 34:13anyway. And I'm quite big, so nobody's going to argue. So well,
- 34:21I thought i'd give a plan. It's a chance to talk about their
- 34:22work, and they've fluffed it completely. Told that she's too scary for very
- 34:29much a challenger that's because Americans find it unseemly to blow our splash their own
- 34:34trumpets, not like these brash Brits. Yeah, you do so much self
- 34:39promotion, my dear. How awful you think last night? Yeah, I'm
- 34:47just wondering if Katrine has ever heard of a person called Boris Johnson. We've
- 34:55just had our breakfast. You have liked to have had it with Boris because
- 35:00he's available. I'm trying to see I should have brushed my hair a bit
- 35:04more than we'll have words least say he's available. He's available at the at
- 35:08the bargain rate of about five hundred thousand dollars on the speak circuit. And
- 35:13it's also he's also the reason we have the phrase that's a pile of that's
- 35:17a total pile of Boris. It's a steaming pile of Johnson, as we
- 35:23see on this safe But yeah, I know, I'm sorry, but as
- 35:27the only woman on the panic, I just can't help it. He's just
- 35:30so dreamy. Well, Dan a side, Borises. I'm looking at the
- 35:38audience Thereah, I think there might be a few American women looking forth for
- 35:43that charm and that bluster and the British, the British accent would Yes,
- 35:50it'll Actouald be the next question. There's your answer. That's what you've won,
- 35:58Katrina. It was in a small print but particular round. I think
- 36:08Katrina wins. Yea he who said anything coherent? Sorry, Jeff, I
- 36:15know yours was. We didn't understand it. It's mutual. We never got
- 36:23to art at all. Yeah, it's just why. It's this how you
- 36:30are in clones pretty much. Yeah. So I write short stories, I
- 36:35mean, and give and give short answers, yeah, and short answers yes,
- 36:42Efficiency, economy, those are good good hallmarks. All right. So
- 36:46I think if I've counted that correctly, that makes one for America, one
- 36:52for Britain, one for India, and one for Katrina. What's next on
- 36:57this list? Do you know? I think we should tackle the most important
- 37:00question of all, the one that everybody has mentally been asking themselves. Who
- 37:04would get Lee child in the divorce? This is a complicated one, right,
- 37:10He's a break but he sold one hundred and one hundred and fifty million
- 37:14books featuring an American and he loved Tom Cruise in the films He lives there.
- 37:22Yes, yes, Jeff, what Jeff of New Jersey. Yes,
- 37:31who gets Lee child in the divorce? Missus child gets Lee child in the
- 37:38divorce. Well, let's look at it this way. How long has Lee
- 37:43lived in America and how long before that did he live in the UK.
- 37:50Whichever one's hired, that's who gets I would I would claim that as I
- 37:53can do. I would say that living a year in Britain is much tougher
- 37:58than living a year in America. Once again, that's because you haven't been
- 38:02in New Jersey. I would say we don't want him because he used to
- 38:10live on He used to live right opposite the Flat Iron Building in New York.
- 38:14He's lived in the middle of Manhattan. He's lived in the wide open
- 38:16spaces of Wyoming where it doesn't rain for seven months of the year. Just
- 38:21imagine what a bad mood he'd be in he had to move back to like
- 38:25Coventry. I say we don't want him. I was. I was surprised
- 38:30to hear it was British at all. So you know, says professor,
- 38:37Well, we expect more from you. Come on, tell us short story,
- 38:42short answers. That's I think we get him. He's established more over
- 38:46here, so he's he you know, it was it was happening joke.
- 38:50But I think I think if you were to a lot of us who know
- 38:52Lee and have talked to Lee, we hear a little bit of an accent.
- 38:57But I think if you were to get the average person on this eat
- 39:00and ask him is he British or is he American? Most people think he's
- 39:01American. So that's what, that's what. And also sorry, yes,
- 39:10but also he cooked admirably with Tom Thump, Tom Thumb, Tom admirably Tom
- 39:22Cruise creacher, but Tom Cruise is all perfect with the teeth and the hair
- 39:28and everything. If he had to be surrounded by little wizzened rickety knuckle dragon
- 39:36people, he'd be so unhappy. You can't say that baby, well you're
- 39:43here because that's your job, or yeah, okay, so yeah, I
- 39:47just want to follow the argument you're saying that I'm saying, divorce is hard
- 39:51on everyone, but Lee shouldn't suffer. We should let him stay in Wyoming
- 39:59fair enough, Do we feel that his books accurately represent America from the audience,
- 40:12I hope not. In defense? Does does he get a vote?
- 40:16I mean you would think that it would be like where do you want to
- 40:19go? And he would tell you. No, he's like a child,
- 40:22right, He's a child clues in the name. Oh yeah, with his
- 40:28little bag shuttling between the different homes. You get him. We could have
- 40:32him Tuesday for his bally lesson and every other weekend and like trade off on
- 40:37Thanksgiving and Christmas. How about you take Lee and we take his bank account,
- 40:43you know, and then and then everybody's happy. Yeah, okay,
- 40:49can you make a case for the good old, for good old United off
- 40:52Kingdom. No, look, it's still on his birth certificate. He was
- 40:59born in Britain, Right, That's all I've got. Well, well,
- 41:00here's the question. Here's the question then, And I think I'm making the
- 41:04point for the Americans here. How many American writers have become hugely famous and
- 41:09moved to Coventree? Sorry, no, I don't know, all right,
- 41:27Okay, yeah, but I mean but there are limits, right, Well,
- 41:30um, what's what's the coldest, most miserable, dullest, most boring
- 41:35place in America? Oh? Well, North Dakota is a bit of a
- 41:44challenge. Yeah, I've been to North Dakota. It's it's cold, it
- 41:51gets colder, look out. But that sort of leads on to another question.
- 41:54That's what coffee table books are for. Wait, I mean did we
- 41:58did we settle that one? So Lee Childs is British? Yes, let's
- 42:01let's put it to the audience. Then let's put it to the audience.
- 42:04Clap if you think Lee Charles should should be considered an American crime writer.
- 42:14If you think he is, clap. Clap for the truth, not the
- 42:20alternative facts. Right, So one clap for truth? I think No,
- 42:27I think I think that carries more weight truth. We're in DC. Let
- 42:32just say I think Katrina deserves a bonus point for saying tom thumb as well,
- 42:40high judgs. Really, so the scores I think are written one India
- 42:47one America two Katrina two. Good. You know you've got a good stance
- 42:57of winning this right, and she should we ask the audience for a question.
- 43:02I'm just gonna warn you this woman is Canadian. Anything could happen.
- 43:10I'm sorry I didn't understand the next Senta, because you're you're above this conversation.
- 43:21Because Canada is the Scotland of America, France is the Mexico of England.
- 43:30Alaska is the northern ireland of the States. I'll never get the whole.
- 43:36I can't find my way home now, I'm completely Can we have another
- 43:42question from the audience, not related to Canada, preferably in American or a
- 43:47brit this time, because you know we can't get other countries involved, it's
- 43:53too dangerous. That's him, as are Coventry. I can, I can,
- 44:07I haven't got this question. I think this is an unfair question,
- 44:09right for starters. You guys are heavily armed, right knocked on the wrong
- 44:15door and you get shot. Whereas I think, because we don't have access
- 44:22to weapons of mass destruction on it's not a consumer level, we have to
- 44:25be a lot more creative with how we hurt people. Well, I'm going
- 44:30to say Britain because we you know, we don't have the firepower. We're
- 44:34going at it with bottles and with bricks. The comments or I mean,
- 44:39if you if you've been a carving your initials in someone else's forehead, I
- 44:44think is far more artistically relevant than you know, firing off on eight A
- 44:51sixty four or whatever it is into them. So I'm going to say Britain
- 44:53as specifically Glasgow, which is where I'm from. I used to be a
- 44:59lot more hands them before, before I had all the violence done to me.
- 45:06You imagine how bad he looked before. Well we've here from Jeff about
- 45:10New Jersey on this one though, so that kind of depends on where you
- 45:15go. You know, it's Saddle oh man. Yeah, you don't want
- 45:22to go to Saddle River without a switch blade in your hand, particularly upper
- 45:28Saddle River. Yeah. Uh, New Jersey. You want to stay out
- 45:34of Camden and Patterson. Um, but everywhere else the people are lovely,
- 45:39really lovely, or you think they're lovely, Well how would I know?
- 45:46Um, but you know, the sarcasm thing always works. Go there.
- 45:52Uh, but which streets are are meaner? Britain definitely has the mean streets
- 46:00and it's all cobblestone. You can fall anywhere. Um. You know.
- 46:05I'm reminded of when we visited London and the bus driver in London the bicycles
- 46:13on the London streets the buses were like inches behind the bicycles. So so
- 46:16I'm gonna say miner streets in the UK, I'm going to vote for that.
- 46:22I'm getting wrecks and bottles as the bus drivers at are a problem?
- 46:24Would I would agree with Glasgow being the worst place in the entire world.
- 46:31I'm telling value said that, I will say for Edinburgh. You know,
- 46:36we don't. We won't carve our initials on your forehead with a broken bottle.
- 46:40We'll just be so frosty and standoffish and snobby and awful. But you
- 46:47won't realize at first, but you'll go home and your soul will start to
- 46:52die. And once you've been in Edinburgh for five years, you just don't
- 46:57want to live anymore, and you don't know why. Last there is only
- 47:00a fourteen minute train ride and you get there and you get hugged by a
- 47:02drunk who vomits down your back. And again, I'm generally the drunk on
- 47:09Tuesdays. Yes, he's vom died down my back many times. I think
- 47:16that brings us to a close. Now we need to we need to get
- 47:19a final vote on this. Okay, let's ask. Let's ask the audience.
- 47:22Turn me to the audience again. Come on, I can't see the
- 47:23audience right. Audience. If you believe that America is the home of the
- 47:31best crime fiction in the world, clap now. Oh. If you believe
- 47:39that Britain is the home of the finest crime fiction in the world, clap
- 47:45now and oh it's pretty close, fast, pretty close. It's not really
- 47:51that close because for the purposes of no, no, it's not close,
- 47:53mate, because for the purpose I'll tell you. I'll tell you why.
- 47:57I'll tell you why, because for the purposes of the recording, I muted
- 48:00it when the Americans were clack okay. Final question. If you believe that
- 48:07Katrina McPherson is the finest explorent of crime fiction on either side of the Atlantic,
- 48:12please clap now it's pretty unanimous. You got my glasses on it.
- 48:22See him says no taking names and kicking ass. I believe they say you
- 48:31go, Um, thanks, please thank her. No, I was just
- 48:37gonna say we should thank our other panelists, right, yeah, absolutely,
- 48:42um, Professor Art and Jeff, who now has me very very worried because
- 48:47on Tuesday I'm due to go to New Jersey to meet a new friend who's
- 48:51going to drive me around the state. Thank you so much everybody for joining
- 48:58us for this. I mean, it's it's been the journey over the last
- 49:00three years. We started this podcast in Abby's mum's house where she made us
- 49:05samosas and pacorus and it was really nice and she was the only listener that
- 49:08we had still the only listener, so to now have listeners around the world
- 49:16and to be invited to do things like this, I think I speak for
- 49:20both of us to say how delighted we are at how welcoming you've all been
- 49:23for us. Thank you very much, because I locked the doors now I
- 49:29locked the doors arena. As a question, no, I don't have a
- 49:31question. It's going to say something very very sad. She's lying. I
- 49:39know that the scene represented you stellarly than I had a gun to my head.
- 49:47Stop it he ate enough for two people, Is that what you're saying.
- 49:53I was forced to say nice things about you, and we really enjoy
- 49:58having enjoyed it even more if you could have been here with him, And
- 50:01that's why we wanted you here with us on Zoom today. And I appreciate
- 50:06you taking the time. No, no, no, thank you. I'm
- 50:08really sorry. I couldn't buy. My wife had COVID. She still does,
- 50:13but she's been sarcastic again, so she's obviously on the mend. Thank
- 50:19you so much. And I can only apologize for sending the scene on his
- 50:22own take it reasonably with and I'm not broken totally. And we're glad to
- 50:34hear that your wife is on the men. So thank you everyone, Thank
- 50:38you very much. Right, I've seen you soon, mate, I think
- 50:42thanks a lot for coming buddy. Well, I hope you enjoyed that episode.
- 50:52Ladies and gents, don't forget to leave a review and to tune in
- 50:57for future episodes. And may I say from a personal point of thank you
- 51:00to all of the friends that I made over in the States. Thank you
- 51:04for looking after me, for your warmth, your generosity, your friendship,
- 51:07and for making sure that I did not get lost. Now, don't forget
- 51:12to vote for the Lost Man of Bombay in the thinkstans Old Peculiar Crime Novel
- 51:15of the Year. The deadline is fast approaching, so do get onto your
- 51:19phones and computers and complete that vote. I wish you the best until the
- 51:23next episode.