Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E040: Contrarian Thinking with Allen Farrington
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29in Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company. On Ramp's multi institution
- 0:35custody is a segregated institutional grade vault
- 0:38requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:41time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been met
- 0:45at on RAMP We understand that your Bitcoin journey is a multi
- 0:48generational pursuit catalyzed by the ideals of perseverance,
- 0:52aspiration and legacy. That's why we're proud to
- 0:55introduce on RAMP Heritage, a suite of private client services
- 0:59dedicated to ensuring your Bitcoin legacy is preserved and
- 1:02passed on, embodying the true essence of wealth that goes
- 1:06beyond mere numbers. If you would like to learn more,
- 1:08please schedule a consultation. As we prepare for the Bitcoin
- 1:11having and the next wave of global adoption of this nascent
- 1:15and growing asset class, we are halving all annual maintenance
- 1:18fees for clients that secure their wealth before the next
- 1:21Bitcoin epoch. What you're telling me is that
- 1:25music is about to stop and we're going to be left holding the
- 1:28biggest bag of odorous extra ever assembled in the history of
- 1:34doctors 1974198792972000 and whatever we want to call this.
- 1:42It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:44We can't help ourselves. I say.
- 1:47When we sell, I say. When we sell.
- 1:56To the Irish exit is an American phrase.
- 2:01You've never heard this in in your neck of the woods.
- 2:03Out. I I've literally never heard
- 2:06that before, no. It's my move in college.
- 2:12The Irish exit. You're out.
- 2:13I I can completely imagine where it even comes from, though, that
- 2:16it's like, I wouldn't say a slur exactly, but it's sort of an
- 2:21amicable slur between between, you know, ethnic groups in, in
- 2:29the US where they all say they're, oh, I'm Italian, I'm
- 2:32Irish, I'm German. And it's actually like their
- 2:34great, great, great grandpa. And you need that environment to
- 2:38like have a reason to make fun of Irish people.
- 2:40Where is actually where everyone's Irish is just like,
- 2:42not the thing. But I I've made a lot of, I
- 2:45don't know if that's. I completely believe that that's
- 2:47where it probably came from. Yeah, there's there's Irish lads
- 2:51at the pub having a good time and then they go home Irish.
- 2:53Goodbye. It's an endearing term.
- 2:56It's a it's a very Maybe it's not as polite as people would
- 3:01say, but it's it's just like, OK, I.
- 3:05Swear. I'm I'm an individual.
- 3:08I'm going to make my own decision.
- 3:09I don't need to say goodbye to everybody.
- 3:11I'm leaving. Just walk out the door.
- 3:14Yeah, I agree. I think it plays on both sides.
- 3:16I think a lot of people don't feel like I got to say bye to
- 3:18the like multiple times. You're kind of like benefiting
- 3:21both sides of the the part, the transaction.
- 3:24Oh, I totally get the action. I'm not saying that the action
- 3:27is is like needs to be insulted or anything.
- 3:30I'm just imagining where that phrase for it came from, that
- 3:34this was something that people who again, are like claimed they
- 3:37were Irish, but they're not really because they're American,
- 3:40you know, they they disproportionately did this.
- 3:42And then you know, they're also not really Polish and Italian
- 3:47friends were like fucking Irish. Exit.
- 3:49Sorry, real. I just swear on this.
- 3:51Like. Maybe not.
- 3:52You're going to bleed that out and post.
- 3:54We can do anything we want on the Internet here.
- 3:57Do you guys know what the opposite of an Irish exit is?
- 4:01No. Announcing a retirement 10
- 4:04months in advance, which is what the CEO of Vanguard did.
- 4:10Yeah, that's not not coincidental timing at all.
- 4:19So let's go over this Bitcoin ETFs.
- 4:22I think they surpassed even our wildest expectations so far.
- 4:26I think it's pretty safe to say. I think I said by the rumor, by
- 4:31the news, by Bitcoin, when we were talking about this, there
- 4:36was only one way. It's.
- 4:37I think the ETS remind me of just the Bitcoin trade or
- 4:40havings. Like all this stuff is so
- 4:42simple, it's so straightforward and so like, why wouldn't it be
- 4:46insane for opening up liquidity Like that was always the take.
- 4:50I think there were some individuals that might have been
- 4:51a little less bullish on it and you know, not naming names
- 4:55either here or and the Twittersphere, but it's just
- 4:58like common sense. Oh, I agree.
- 5:01But with that being said, ETS launched a month and a half ago
- 5:06now at this point, a lot. I mean, objectively they're a
- 5:11bunch of large money managers that have a 90 day waiting
- 5:13period before they can get in. So a lot of the activity up
- 5:17until this point has been predominantly retail driven and
- 5:20driven by wealth managers that don't have those restrictions.
- 5:23So the floodgates haven't even been fully open.
- 5:25And what are the net accumulation is 371,000 I
- 5:31believe Bitcoin. Yeah, close to over 300,000, I
- 5:35think. Yeah, so it's pretty insane.
- 5:39I'm convinced it's not even retail.
- 5:41Like I know they that Eric, like these guys talk about it, but
- 5:44like us as a group, how many people do you know buying
- 5:46Bitcoin like net new people. I don't know the ETFI know a lot
- 5:53of new people are buying Bitcoin that have texted me.
- 5:57And but I think like just this notion of people like
- 6:00anecdotally reaching out and people stepping into the market,
- 6:04I think is a different kind of bid, at least right now.
- 6:06Like I think these pools open to Raas and getting it on the
- 6:09platform and having the discussions and having to show
- 6:11all the the disclaimers around it.
- 6:14Like I don't think it turned on and then people just started
- 6:16buying out of the gate. I think there's different buying
- 6:18pressure right now that's completely unrelated to like the
- 6:20channels that I think people talk about from like a
- 6:24registered investment advisor or financial advisor just saying,
- 6:26oh, now I can smash by and do infidelity ETF.
- 6:31Yeah, I imagine I'm using exactly that language morning
- 6:36off all their clients. Like you can smash by now if you
- 6:38want. What are What are your thoughts
- 6:42on the ETF launch so far? Are you passing expectations?
- 6:45But like, I just honestly don't care at all.
- 6:48It's it's nice, it's nice for the price, obviously.
- 6:52I I I wouldn't say by by that I don't at all mean I'm bearish on
- 6:56it. Like clearly it's gonna juice
- 6:58the price to the moon and that's that's good.
- 7:02I just mean more it's not it's not really of of interest to me
- 7:09beyond that and and even that I think is like I struggle to see
- 7:13it as being a good thing as opposed to just an inevitable
- 7:15thing that that that's kind of my that's why I've been a bit
- 7:19confused by how excited it seems like most of Bitcoin Twitter is
- 7:24other than just the price because it it like obviously
- 7:27it's going to be amazing for the price but also obviously
- 7:30eventually there was going to be an ETF.
- 7:32So just to me it's kind of a nothing burger.
- 7:36If anything I can I can turn it around on you guys like why
- 7:39aren't you more mad about it? Surely every ETF buyer should be
- 7:44an on RAMP customer but isn't yet Because they, I don't know,
- 7:47they they're not stated enough. They haven't listened to TFTC
- 7:50enough. That's that's the exact thing.
- 7:53I went full circle and I kind of fell in your camp for a very
- 7:55long time. And then I realized an ETF
- 7:57similar to like the same mechanism somebody bought on
- 7:59Cash app is the same deal as somebody buying via Fidelity.
- 8:02It's like you buy it because it's the easiest way and then
- 8:05you go get educated because it's money.
- 8:06And that's the thing people forget.
- 8:08Like when it's an app or it's just like Amazon, you're just
- 8:10like, sure, I buy it, don't go that deep on it, I trade it
- 8:13around. But inevitably when the position
- 8:15goes from 1% to 3% to 10% because of price appreciation or
- 8:18doubling down, there's this inherent requirement to start to
- 8:22understand it. And then that's when people are
- 8:24like, holy crap. And we experienced this in 2021
- 8:27with GBTC when people realize that to get spot exposure they
- 8:32had to get out of the market. And generally those were tax
- 8:34advantage accounts. So it wasn't so much as a
- 8:36taxable event, which obviously happens with an ETF.
- 8:39It was more of when the price is railing and you step out of the
- 8:42market, generally people are like, holy crap, I have two
- 8:44weeks where I'm in dollars. And so this whole notion of
- 8:48like, oh shit, like, I can't take delivery of this, I'm
- 8:50worried about now that Coinbase has a trillion dollars in
- 8:53Bitcoin, whatever the number is. Like all those things will never
- 8:55really happen. And in our opinion, or at least
- 8:57my opinion, the only way that could have happened is with the
- 8:59ETF. So that's why I think it's
- 9:00ultimately bullish is because the education game for everybody
- 9:03started whenever this thing launched.
- 9:05Yeah. OK.
- 9:06That's a that's a good way of putting it, right.
- 9:07It's it's clearly bullish on the price.
- 9:09It was always going to be bullish for the price.
- 9:11I don't think it's really bullish honestly at all for
- 9:15anything related to, I don't know if you want to think of it
- 9:19as like technical development or or frankly even adoption.
- 9:24I think the the best way you can view it is as an educational
- 9:28stepping stone. I think you need to you need to
- 9:31expect this massive influx of capital into the ETFs and then
- 9:35just sit around waiting for a massive outflux of capital into
- 9:39real Bitcoin. Well it's it's massive into the
- 9:42ecosystem like and the margins people are going to allocate to
- 9:45infrastructure because the ETF is there.
- 9:47Which translates to technological development.
- 9:51Yeah. True.
- 9:51But I mean I see that as being part of the stepping stone
- 9:53right. That's that's education in a in
- 9:56a snapshot. I think I this is I don't want
- 9:58to get too like bogged down in the semantics of this.
- 10:00I just, I like being a party pooper on this.
- 10:02I just. I just really don't care.
- 10:03I'm sorry. Yeah.
- 10:05But, but, but I think it is very like even if this ends up just
- 10:09being a dead end for this capital, like people go in and
- 10:12and they remain cash redeems and nobody ever takes their capital
- 10:16out. It does flip a whole lot of
- 10:20people from being anti Bitcoin to now rooting for Bitcoin and
- 10:26wanting the price to go up and wanting more of it and wanting
- 10:29to accumulate actual Bitcoin. So like I think the psych
- 10:32psychological impact of it is a is a massive boon for pre
- 10:38adoption of real Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 10:41And I think, like, there's a big thing that we forget how long
- 10:44we've looked at this space that we joked when this thing was
- 10:47about to happen six months ago. And like what is going on in the
- 10:49normie brain, that BlackRock and Fidelity are stepping in to like
- 10:53magic Internet beans? And to Jesse's point, it's like,
- 10:55it's like the mask off moment of like you don't put the genie
- 10:58back in the bottle and it's out now.
- 11:00Everybody has to have a position, a good advisor that
- 11:03was framing overseas, his synagogues like Capital Treasury
- 11:07and he was like, look, you know, the meeting to bring it up.
- 11:09It hasn't had, it hasn't come up, you know, they're bearish,
- 11:12whatever. And the framing, which is like a
- 11:14really good framing, it's like, OK, that's fine if we're not
- 11:16allocating, but we have to have a very strong reason why we're
- 11:18not at this point because of everything happening, which is
- 11:21just a foundational difference in having to like advocate for
- 11:25it. I talked with somebody this week
- 11:27who's mulling over there, an investment consultancy group,
- 11:30and they're mulling over going to their clients.
- 11:33They're sold on Bitcoin internally and they're pitching
- 11:36it to their clients. And they're mulling over like
- 11:39having a document that they want their clients to sign,
- 11:42acknowledging that they turned down their advice to buy Bitcoin
- 11:45for like for like legal. Coverage.
- 11:49On the back end of the bullet bull market, when it runs, it's
- 11:52like you can't say that we didn't tell you to buy Bitcoin.
- 11:56Yeah, and then turn it into an inscription.
- 12:02I had AI had a Stanford MBA classmate text me yesterday who
- 12:07I've been trying to get in and he he works for, he works for a
- 12:13family office basically, and I've been trying to get him in
- 12:19for six years, four years, heavily.
- 12:23I presented to his his team four years ago, you know, a
- 12:26PowerPoint presentation. I went down to the office and
- 12:29did it, and they were interested and curious and didn't didn't
- 12:33buy any. And he texted me yesterday, You
- 12:37are a genius on Bitcoin, kind of like first of all, no.
- 12:42But where is this coming from? And he's like the price.
- 12:45So it's all it's the only thing that really moves the needle in
- 12:49terms of people wanting in is FOMO, Yeah.
- 12:54That, well, I mean, that's another thing you can throw in,
- 12:56in terms of no, it seems like you guys don't really want to
- 13:00want to do this, but I do quite enjoy just being pointlessly
- 13:02contrarian in this and and trying to poop the party, right?
- 13:05And do you not worry that we're all going to get outrageously
- 13:09large egos as a result of this? Like if people keep calling us
- 13:12geniuses when we like, nothing has changed.
- 13:15Not disturbed at all, yes. That's definitely fair and it's.
- 13:19Getting increasingly difficult to stay humble.
- 13:21We all, we all need a little Alexander the Great follow boy.
- 13:24It just tells you you're only man.
- 13:27That's Alan. You're you're spot on that.
- 13:30I mean that's real alpha is like you know we talked about EC and
- 13:32slack and everybody's like the price and like I don't get like
- 13:34that's the alpha is like you can have the focus of what we've
- 13:36always been doing whether it's 20K or 100K, but the price helps
- 13:40and that's why you know somewhat pushed back on the bearishness
- 13:43simply because you've made your mark and in a good mark and
- 13:46being contrarian, I think the contrarian nature for this exact
- 13:48moment is literally the opposite.
- 13:50Like this changes everything. It blows everybody out of the
- 13:52water in the sense of like, because it's so obvious of like
- 13:55what it did, yeah. I mean, yeah, you're probably
- 13:57right. None.
- 14:01All right. Thanks for coming on, Allen.
- 14:03It's for I. Mean yes, everybody and.
- 14:09We already have an example like again, going back to the
- 14:12Vanguard situation, CEO, forget his name, announced that he'll
- 14:16be retiring at the back end of this year.
- 14:18They made a very hard stance at the launch of the ETF that they
- 14:22were not gonna give their clients exposure to these
- 14:25products because they believed it was speculative in nature and
- 14:28too risky. And since the ETFs have
- 14:31launched, Vanguard clients have missed out on a more than 50%
- 14:37appreciation opportunity in terms of exposure to Bitcoin.
- 14:41And so people are speculating. Bitcoiners are speculating,
- 14:45certainly, that he has announced his retirement because the
- 14:50internal clamoring of fumbling the ball so bad with the big
- 14:54Well. Marty, come on.
- 14:55We're not. We're not speculating.
- 14:57We're actively spreading misinformation.
- 15:01Guys, I never know it's real or. Not you have to bend the need to
- 15:04Bitcoin. You have to bend the need to
- 15:05Bitcoin. Did he actually have the quote
- 15:07that never while he's CEO will they do it?
- 15:09Because I've seen that like I think it was.
- 15:11Or is that not true? I think that's a meme.
- 15:14It's possible. I mean, I've heard it.
- 15:16I I heard it right now. So I'm.
- 15:19Going to say it. Yeah, I mean, hey, I I'm, I'm
- 15:23spreading information. I don't know if it's
- 15:25misinformation or if it's more information.
- 15:27Yeah. I mean, 33 years as CEO,
- 15:30inconveniently the year that the ETF launches and it's the best,
- 15:35you know, performing from all measures, he has to step down.
- 15:37I think there's only one one answer there.
- 15:41Yeah, it it does feel, it feels very notable.
- 15:44It feels like hey, hey buddy. You know the the board of
- 15:48directors is probably thinking you know this isn't panning out
- 15:52the way that our guy in charge said it would.
- 15:56We're seeing massive outflows of capital from our platform to
- 16:00platforms that do offer the ETF, the Bitcoin ETF and maybe he's,
- 16:05you know past his prime. Maybe this is a different time,
- 16:09a different era, and he's attuned to a prior era of
- 16:14investing. I could see that conversation
- 16:16happening in a boardroom. And it's probably also like,
- 16:21he's like, I don't need this, I'm, I'm ready to retire anyway.
- 16:24I've been doing this for 34 years.
- 16:26Like, I want to enjoy my family and so maybe it was like just
- 16:29time to pass the baton. But it is very notable timing
- 16:34here. And we just started in hot.
- 16:37Ellen, how are you doing? Good to see you.
- 16:39Nice seeing you in Dubai. It's the best way to start.
- 16:43Start. Just think about this right
- 16:45before we jumped on. Actually I as much as I would
- 16:48like to say, you know I'm doing great, usually that's what I
- 16:51would say, start of start of podcast.
- 16:53I'm actually kind of grumpy because all my friends are in
- 16:56Madeira and I suck here moving houses.
- 16:59It doesn't look like any of you are in Madeira.
- 17:02Either I was watching the live stream this morning, a lot of
- 17:05high signal content coming out of my Madeira right now.
- 17:07No, don't tell me that, Marky. Come on.
- 17:09I'm trying to. I'm staying off of Twitter.
- 17:12Alan, how come you aren't? There, join the real world.
- 17:15Did you, Alan, did you not pull up the weather in Madeira versus
- 17:19the weather in Scotland and just make a, you know, an obvious
- 17:22decision? I I don't need to pull anything
- 17:25up to know the answer to that. It actually looks quite cold.
- 17:30Everybody was wearing jackets. Oh, that's surprising.
- 17:33Yeah. The no, yeah, I mean, Madeira,
- 17:37the, the content there is strong, I mean bull run market
- 17:41or excuse me bull market vibes at conferences.
- 17:45There's nothing better if you're at a conference when the price
- 17:47is bumping. It's one of the most
- 17:51invigorating energies that you can be a part of.
- 17:53I think I disagree with that and I maybe don't have a big enough
- 17:58sample to really draw any meaningful conclusions.
- 18:00But like, for example, Miami 21 was ridiculous and Miami 22 was
- 18:09like, oh, OK, there's like real conversations happening here.
- 18:11Now I I'm pretty sure this won't apply to Madeira because it it,
- 18:14it almost feels like throughout that cycle people learned a lot
- 18:19of these lessons. I mean in particular people who
- 18:22are planning conferences and like what kind of things they
- 18:23should be seen to be supporting. But I mean my my experience so
- 18:29far is that the bear market conferences are sadder I guess
- 18:34but but better quite quite clearly.
- 18:36I'm I'm honestly, I'm nervous for this.
- 18:39You know next conference season like Nashville will be absurd.
- 18:45I guarantee it. There's nothing better than
- 18:47Nashville and the middle of July.
- 18:50It's going to be absurd to many levels.
- 18:52It's going to be a hot market, literal hot days, and a ton of
- 18:57people in a relatively small city.
- 18:59Marty, you might You might need to get some fresh air up on a
- 19:02rooftop and do a broadcast. Oh, that's right.
- 19:05Yeah. And get people to stack at the
- 19:07top. Yeah, that's what I was
- 19:09referencing. Bitcoin Conference 2019, the
- 19:11first one they ever threw, that Bitcoin magazine ever threw San
- 19:15Francisco on a rooftop. That Adele had no facial hair.
- 19:20We were we were pumped. It was like the the mini bull
- 19:23fake out in the middle of that cycle.
- 19:26Up to 14,000. Yeah.
- 19:28And we were drinking whiskey telling people to smash by
- 19:31partying. Like like the Super cycle was
- 19:33upon us. But it was not.
- 19:35It was not. That was five years ago.
- 19:37Are you? Are you like?
- 19:40Allen, what you said about the price and being like I was
- 19:42thinking about this the other day, it's like nothing's
- 19:44foundationally changed, especially this return because
- 19:47we just did this sharp run to 16/8 or whatever and back up to
- 19:5060. When you really think about it
- 19:51looks almost like a Max, like a large bar when it's just like
- 19:54everybody got shaken out and nothing actually really changed
- 19:57other than maybe we wiped CZ and you know, some players off and
- 20:00an ETF launched into the realities like nothing.
- 20:02The fuck the the thesis hasn't changed.
- 20:03What we're all building, I think, is the exact same thing.
- 20:06And so that lens is always helpful to have in it because
- 20:09we're not any smarter than we were back then or where we're
- 20:11going. And I think that's just like a a
- 20:13very healthy way to look at this market and how we like allocate.
- 20:16Person, I think. Honestly, I mean, I'm obviously
- 20:18kind of joking about it and I'm, I'm being a bit facetious just
- 20:21because it's amusing. But.
- 20:23But my kind of pseudo contrarianism, I think.
- 20:27I think where it's coming from is like a frustration with what
- 20:30feels like, I don't know if you guys know this expression, the
- 20:33eternal September like we've now, it feels like we've now
- 20:35very much entered the eternal September with Bitcoin.
- 20:38And so, yeah, again, obviously ETFs are great for price, but it
- 20:43it seems to have created such a, it's almost like a vacuum of
- 20:49what want what people want to talk about and in particular
- 20:52what the newbies want to talk about.
- 20:54When, as you say, Michael, as far as I'm concerned, nothing
- 20:57worth talking about has actually changed.
- 20:59So why are these people all texting me, You know what I
- 21:02mean? What I'm sure has happened to
- 21:03you as well. Yeah.
- 21:07Yeah, well. But.
- 21:09Let's not, let's not focus. We don't have to focus on the
- 21:12eternal September, like what would be a different a a big
- 21:16shift in the Bitcoin market particularly, particularly the
- 21:19market structure. Michael, you mentioned Dubai.
- 21:24Alan, I watched you give an incredible speech presentation
- 21:28at Riga. What was that two years ago on
- 21:31Bitcoin being Sharia compliant money?
- 21:35And that's one of the themes that I'm placing my bet on this
- 21:40year is that we see somebody in the Middle East, an Islamic
- 21:43country, either define Bitcoin as Sharia compliant money.
- 21:47I believe one has already in some layer of their court
- 21:50system, and not only that, but tape into Bitcoin in a big way
- 21:54and make a public statement about that.
- 21:56You were all in Dubai, or two of you were, yeah, that sentiment
- 21:59at all. Ellen, I'm pretty open book, so
- 22:01I'm gonna throw it to you and you can share as much of our
- 22:03conversation that we had host Dubai on this call about like
- 22:06our stance there and we'll use that as a jumping off point.
- 22:11Oh, sure, yeah. I mean, there's loads of that.
- 22:13We can do the entire podcast on this if you want to go down
- 22:15every every rabbit hole. Just back to Marty's point
- 22:18specifically, I think there's a distinction worth making that on
- 22:23the nation state, you know, adoption or however you want to
- 22:27describe it, that's almost certainly happened already.
- 22:29It's just a question of when they're going to be public about
- 22:32it. So I agree with you.
- 22:33It feels like probably this year decent odds that there will be
- 22:37news around that. The the point about it, I forget
- 22:42exactly how you phrase it. There's something to the effect
- 22:44of becoming legally enshrined. I think that's a bit trickier
- 22:48and I I wouldn't, I wouldn't hold out any particular hope for
- 22:51that just because, I mean, this isn't now immediately a massive
- 22:55rabbit hole, but because of the way that legal process works.
- 23:03It's nowhere near as simple as a parliament passing a law or
- 23:08something like that. It's it's far more of almost a
- 23:11theological process around which there's no consensus, actually
- 23:16kind of an amusing term to bring up here.
- 23:19It's it's very it's very sort of decentralized and and unofficial
- 23:24and slow as a result. You could actually I I'm not I
- 23:28don't want to strain this too hard and end up insulting people
- 23:32on both sides. But it's not completely
- 23:35dissimilar, let's say, to something.
- 23:38Like core development? Where you know you, you have
- 23:41many, many, no, no official central body per SE, many
- 23:48unofficial contributors, and for completely different reasons.
- 23:52Admittedly, people having a very strongly conservative bias and
- 23:59kind of a fear of changing anything too quickly.
- 24:02So that's probably far enough down that particular rabbit
- 24:05hole, but I I strongly doubt that will happen soon.
- 24:08But I actually think that whenever it does, I think it
- 24:10will happen eventually. I think when it does happen, the
- 24:13first point having happened first, will have been really
- 24:16important to it because there will it.
- 24:17It won't just be theory at that point, There'll be actual
- 24:19applications in terms of how people are using this new money
- 24:23that that can be pointed to as part of the justification for
- 24:27it. Yeah.
- 24:29One of the things we talked about Marty, that I think you'll
- 24:32appreciate is just the whole mining and energy component and
- 24:35just there's fundamental reality tied to that area of the world
- 24:38of of their goods and services or their their goods, their
- 24:41energy tied to like GDP. That just like roots you in
- 24:45foundation of what is value, that there's like a
- 24:47predisposition there than like in a lot of places like San
- 24:50Francisco. And not only that and the
- 24:52culmination of events for that particular region, events or
- 24:56themes, I mean it, it's the Saudi government, Aramco,
- 25:02Aramco, the company Saudi Aramco.
- 25:04They've made it explicitly clear that they want to begin
- 25:06diversifying their assets away from being so heavily
- 25:10concentrated with oil and gas. Adding Bitcoin to the mix makes
- 25:14a lot of sense, and they can leverage their oil and gas
- 25:17assets to make that that possible.
- 25:19On top of that, obviously timing Bitcoin has the institutional
- 25:23stamp of approval of BlackRock, Fidelity and others getting into
- 25:27the space and then timing again and leaning specifically into
- 25:33mining. You finally have industrial
- 25:36scale production of hydro facilities that'll make it much
- 25:41easier to mine in these climates.
- 25:45And so you have like those 3 culmination of events where they
- 25:49want to diversify away the narrative for Bitcoin is
- 25:53extremely strong and the hardware to actually materialize
- 25:58a Bitcoin strategy in terms of mining is where it needs to be
- 26:01for them to actually ape in. Yeah.
- 26:05There's another point on top of all of that too, which is I'd
- 26:08say even more intriguing I guess from like a geopolitical
- 26:13perspective, which is that they want to end their reliance on
- 26:16Swift as well. They've seen what has happened
- 26:19to Russia. And I mean to some extent it's
- 26:22it's been, it's been obvious that something like that could
- 26:24happen for a very long time. In terms of the, I don't want to
- 26:29get too conspiratorial about it, but effectively the US State
- 26:31Department weaponizing the the Petro dollar for for purely
- 26:38political purposes. Now, you know that that had been
- 26:42talked about in kind of conspiratorial tones for a very
- 26:44long time but now the writing is very much on the wall given
- 26:47what's actually happened to Russia.
- 26:48And so there's this is the reason I say it's even more
- 26:52intriguing is that I don't think you're ever going to see or
- 26:54certainly not for a very long time will you see any public
- 26:56announcements about this. You might even see the Isles in
- 27:00the face of the the kind of the obvious reality of it playing
- 27:04out. But I think that's yet another
- 27:06reason for them to to favour integrating various flavours of
- 27:10Bitcoin infrastructure to give them a payment alternative so
- 27:14that they can't just be shot out of global trade.
- 27:17Yeah. And one of the things that
- 27:18doesn't get talked about is the competitive nature in the GCC as
- 27:22a whole where they like operate. You hear it in the sense of like
- 27:25they run countries like their companies.
- 27:27But then if that that is true, but if it's to be true, then the
- 27:30different countries running as companies are competing with one
- 27:33another to one up each other. And the closest example not even
- 27:36close is like Texas and Wyoming. I feel like there's like a
- 27:40natural healthy like cooperation slash competition with you know
- 27:44being more forward thinking and all the things associated with
- 27:47Bitcoin mining, you know potentially stable coins or or
- 27:50things like that. And that's like on steroids over
- 27:52there specifically. And you hear this a lot between
- 27:54UAE and Saudi because Saudi sees what the UAE has done and for
- 27:58this multiple times, I'm sure you have as well Ellen that they
- 28:00want to basically 100X whatever happened in Dubai and they have
- 28:03the money to do it which everybody understands that part.
- 28:06So now that's like Riyadh is this like area that a lot of
- 28:09people are basically buying real estate and starting to like move
- 28:12to because they understand that kind of they can do it at an
- 28:14accelerated pace whatever happened in Dubai, the Marty's
- 28:20moving to Riyadh. I don't think so anytime soon,
- 28:24but I would like to visit, see what's going on.
- 28:28It is I mean intuitively to me whether it's the Middle East or
- 28:35some other or country in the Middle East or some other
- 28:37country in some other part of the world, a more developed
- 28:39country that's the next domino to fall.
- 28:43So we have the institution stamp of approval.
- 28:46I think nation States and Michael and Allen both make very
- 28:51good points where they'll probably deny it and they won't
- 28:53admit it, but I think they're going to get in in a big way.
- 28:57That's like the next wave of big adoption as nation states,
- 29:02sovereign wealth funds aping into Bitcoin.
- 29:05Allen do you feel like the the you know Zoltan Pozar or however
- 29:11he pronounces his name from Credit Suisse put out that that
- 29:17that very well written piece right when the Russia cut off
- 29:23from Swift and the foreign exchange reserve sees occurred
- 29:26that you know this is the beginning of Bretton Woods 3.
- 29:29The end of Bretton Woods 2. And we're entering an era now
- 29:32where where countries are going to be searching for outside
- 29:37money rather than inside money. Meaning that inside money mean
- 29:42meaning that it's part of the system.
- 29:44It's, it's inside it's, it's controlled by the powers that be
- 29:48in outside money is not. And I think he largely meant
- 29:53like oil and gold, but he also noted at the end of it that
- 29:59despite not being a Bitcoin bowl himself in general, that Bitcoin
- 30:03could be the big winner out of all of this.
- 30:05Do you feel like, you know, Fast forward three years, That was
- 30:10probably two years ago, Two years now.
- 30:11Do you feel like that's playing out?
- 30:20To be honest, I don't, I don't want to comment too much on that
- 30:23because I would very quickly get out of my depth.
- 30:28And the the one thing I would say though just in terms of
- 30:30tying together his comments, it's very enticing, it's very
- 30:36encouraging that he would do this.
- 30:38But I think just in general it's very enticing to start thinking
- 30:41of Bitcoin in the same category as something like gold or oil or
- 30:45oil, sorry. And on the basis of a something
- 30:49that's completely obvious to us, but I think isn't at all to
- 30:52normies and is now becoming so that it is completely tangible
- 30:57value, right. It's not it's not credit based
- 31:01like the system that seems to be unwinding.
- 31:04So and and I mean you've heard this kind of thing for a for a
- 31:07really long time and again still still out my depth more just
- 31:10kind of as a a curious observer and you know having read various
- 31:16historical accounts of this kind of thing that that it's always
- 31:19in the back of or not not eternally let's say, but since
- 31:23since Bretton Woods it's been the back in the back of a lot of
- 31:25people's minds that it is just inherently unstable.
- 31:29It's inherently reliant on politics.
- 31:31It would be better if gold oil, I think is a little bit
- 31:35trickier, but certainly gold just because of its history
- 31:37could have more of a role in this if it, if it could be more
- 31:41grounded in reality, right? Like even maybe back to to
- 31:44Michael's point about why, you know Texas and Wyoming and then
- 31:48Heidi and UAE seem to get this more because they're this is
- 31:53more sorry what we were talking about before we came on.
- 31:55But our theory, I think is that it appeals to them far more in
- 32:00the first place because their own economic experience is far
- 32:05more tethered to reality than, you know, to make a maybe a bit
- 32:09of a a characterizing gross characterization, you know, New
- 32:13York being tied to Fiat finance or San Francisco being tied to
- 32:17to software or something like that.
- 32:19So, so yeah, I mean this this kind of thing is obviously been
- 32:22talked about for a long time. We can all very clearly
- 32:25articulate why Bitcoin would be far better than gold in that
- 32:29kind of role. I think what's super exciting
- 32:31is, yeah, that that other people are the people who are in fact
- 32:35qualified to to opine on these issues are starting to include
- 32:39Bitcoin in the conversation. Yeah, there isn't an irony there
- 32:44that when you grow up in in a part of the world that enjoys
- 32:49the exorbitant privilege of being able to print the global
- 32:53reserve currency out of thin hair, you are no longer in tune
- 32:59with monetary reality and you can't see when reality is
- 33:05knocking on the door. Well, it's it's interesting too
- 33:10for from the American perspective because yes, for the
- 33:14world of hyper finance in New York and the world of Hypertech
- 33:18in San Francisco and Silicon Valley.
- 33:20But I think due to the misunderstanding of Bitcoin in
- 33:25the early years, where people really saw it as this tech play
- 33:29haven't really grokked the monetary aspects or took people
- 33:33really to hone in on the monetary aspects of what it was
- 33:36it it looked like a tech play to a lot of people here in the
- 33:39United States and afforded American citizens to accumulate
- 33:44a large portion of the Bitcoin supply to date.
- 33:52Which is? Which Could be an explanation
- 33:54for why there's been altcoining for the last decade, you know?
- 33:57But that energy has been diverted into what else can we
- 34:01create with technology and cryptocurrency?
- 34:04Yeah. Yeah, I've, I've said this kind
- 34:07of thing before actually that not not exactly wrapped up in
- 34:11like oh, it's America's fault, but but that is kind of a funny
- 34:14framing for this, right, that you could, you could very easily
- 34:17think of of crypto in its various flavors.
- 34:20I mean certainly still today I'd say more so.
- 34:23I think we'll probably look back on the peak as being 2122, but
- 34:27it's basically the starting point obviously is Bitcoin, but
- 34:31it's then specifically misunderstood through the lens
- 34:34of both SF tech and New York finance.
- 34:39It's like how how can you misunderstand both the
- 34:42technology and the monetary components of this?
- 34:45And then you dial that up to 11 and then what you get is crypto.
- 34:50I think there is a, there's a poetic version of that of like
- 34:53who what the individuals, whether it's in China or the US
- 34:56and in between who gets it, like who's holding Bitcoin today
- 35:01versus who holding crypto in the future.
- 35:03And like that lens, I think it affords itself for the right
- 35:06people are holding it and we'll kind of like work through
- 35:08whatever transition or whatever it looks like and the things
- 35:11that are built. It's fascinating to see the past
- 35:1415 years and who are their adopters and then who got in
- 35:16early, but it basically gone crazy and lost all their
- 35:18Bitcoin. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 35:20Well, then it also provides, I mean for what we do, Allen, in
- 35:23the context of 10/31 for me and Axiom for you, it provides us an
- 35:27incredible opportunity where all these people are raising
- 35:30billions of dollars, absolutely miss allocating it to nauseating
- 35:34levels, overlooking Bitcoin in the industry being built on top
- 35:39of it. And there's not a lot of Bitcoin
- 35:43only funds out there. I think the two of ours are two
- 35:47of less than maybe two dozen if if that many.
- 35:51And it just provides an incredible opportunity for us to
- 35:55to go support the companies, you know what it actually get the
- 35:57signal. I I wonder if you've ever
- 35:59thought about this before, actually.
- 36:00And I'm not meaning to shit on well, certainly on myself, not
- 36:04really anyone else either. But I actually think it's kind
- 36:06of sad that there even needs to be such a thing as a Bitcoin
- 36:08only fund like that. It exists in the 1st place
- 36:13because of the misinformation. Non not saying that ironically,
- 36:20but like literal misinformation spewed by crypto, that's the
- 36:22only reason Bitcoin only funds exist.
- 36:24It should just be something that competent tech generalists
- 36:28understand. But it isn't.
- 36:30At least not yet. David King's a good example of
- 36:34this. If you guys follow him, he's a
- 36:35good buddy with Max Webster. He like, actually, he
- 36:38understands Bitcoin so deeply, he doesn't even like talking
- 36:40about it because he knows like the whole kind of connotation
- 36:43around. He's still like scarred from,
- 36:45you know, whatever happens on Twitter.
- 36:47And you know, obviously we're we're past that.
- 36:49Like he doesn't like to be labeled from individuals that
- 36:52are building. He's thinking a bit more of like
- 36:54his background in technology, former Google guy, that's like
- 36:59just where does Bitcoin insert into the traditional world that
- 37:01provides it more utility. And so to your point, I think
- 37:04that's what like you sure kind of looks like is less of like
- 37:07individuals chasing a small amount of Bitcoin companies
- 37:09versus just like every company ends up looking like that in
- 37:12some respect that incorporates Bitcoin or builds.
- 37:15Yeah. I mean, we we.
- 37:16Say this, we say this all the time.
- 37:17I think it comes up on both sides.
- 37:19On the one hand, we're typically very attracted to investment
- 37:22opportunities where in some or other form the Bitcoin component
- 37:26is just obfuscated away. So.
- 37:29So the company is just, I can say this in entirely general
- 37:33almost vague terms, right. The company is providing some
- 37:36good or service that is dramatically improved or only
- 37:40possible in the 1st place because they're utilizing
- 37:43Bitcoin as technology. We find that a lot more exciting
- 37:46that obviously not name any games and like show on anybody
- 37:48but find that a lot more exciting than you know yeah
- 37:51another wallet or whatever or or just just again maybe suitably
- 37:55general level something that we've talked about this before
- 37:58Michael as well, something that would absolutely make sense if
- 38:02we'd already hyper bitcoinized. But you know we haven't.
- 38:05So the time is like you and your friends essentially and aside
- 38:10from anything else that's you know obviously there's an
- 38:11investment rationale there. But I I think you can, you can
- 38:16and we do our best to rationalize it on the basis that
- 38:21actually that's what's going to grow adoption in the 1st place.
- 38:24Like I I can think of all kinds of almost use cases if you like,
- 38:27maybe even Martin's example of you know, sovereign states, in
- 38:32particular Middle Eastern states getting in through energy is a
- 38:35good example of this. It's not exactly the kind of
- 38:37thing that you know we are likely to be in a position to
- 38:40make an investment case around. But I think, I think the logic
- 38:43perfectly applies of you know you're you're doing it in their
- 38:47case for energy. In our case it could be
- 38:48anything, could be like fintech or telephones or whatever.
- 38:52You you get involved because it is superior technology for
- 38:56precisely the thing you need That then encourages you to
- 39:00learn more about you know Bitcoin in a in a wider sense.
- 39:04And then it's kind of inevitable at some point after that you end
- 39:07up orange building and you you start thinking about it more
- 39:09generally. But, but everybody has
- 39:12something, you know every, every business in particular will will
- 39:16have some area they're involved in that they deeply appreciate
- 39:20and that it's it's frankly just a far easier way of orange
- 39:24Pilling as well or at least a first step right.
- 39:26It's not you know you don't need to tell them about the the evil
- 39:30conspiracy of how the Federal Reserve was formed.
- 39:33You just say you know if you use this your costs will go down
- 39:37something like that. So yeah so that's that's on the
- 39:40on the company side but then just in terms of US trying to
- 39:43trying to fundraise as well and and maybe not even fundraising
- 39:46just thinking about what we want the business to look like.
- 39:48You know we we do we do say quite often that we think it
- 39:54it's only going to be so long from now that it's even going to
- 39:58make sense calling ourselves Bitcoin investors.
- 40:00And it this is sort of an obvious comparison to the point
- 40:03of kind of being a cliche at this point but nobody calls
- 40:06themselves an an Internet investor right there there there
- 40:09was a time when that. Meant something when it was
- 40:13helpful to say that because it was, it was helpfully, you know,
- 40:16communicating the more limited area at some point, extremely
- 40:19limited area in which you were looking to deploy.
- 40:22But I assume everyone and you know everyone on this podcast
- 40:28and probably everybody listening to this podcast as well, thinks
- 40:31that Bitcoin will end up having a a similar effect.
- 40:33Don't know over what time horizon exactly, but certainly
- 40:36as it becomes more and more normalized, it'll just become
- 40:40less and less relevant to to specify that that's what you're
- 40:43investing in. Yeah, I mean, the concept of
- 40:46bitcoiners will fall to the wayside at some point.
- 40:48Yeah, yeah, it's like. Yeah, Alan you you reminded me
- 40:54of some venture capitalist came and spoke at at B school about
- 41:00you know to to a class and they they were asked like what's the
- 41:03number one thing you look for in A in a start up and without
- 41:08hesitation they said shrinking markets which is to say like I
- 41:13want to find something that through technology provides a
- 41:16service that incumbents provide at a higher cost.
- 41:21You know, so really the the manifestation of of deflationary
- 41:26technology like that's what that's what wins and that's what
- 41:29really has an edge in the market and that's what they look for.
- 41:32But also which the Fiat mind cannot compute, right?
- 41:38Yes. And so you're you're talking
- 41:40about, you're you're talking about like you know, riding,
- 41:43leveraging the Bitcoin infrastructure, the rails, which
- 41:47touches everything in order to tap into that kind of that kind
- 41:51of investing philosophy of like what does, how do you, how do
- 41:57you invest in companies that do something better by using
- 42:00Bitcoin than income can do? Yeah.
- 42:03And I did just to tie it back to Marty's question as well, that I
- 42:07feel like not just me but again almost every every Bitcoin focus
- 42:13VC has such a ridiculously disproportionate advantage in
- 42:18not only finding just because of the community but evaluating and
- 42:22and hopefully successfully investing in companies like
- 42:24that. For for again, I think a really
- 42:27sad reason it's it's not even that we are brilliant or you
- 42:31know, we. I don't know.
- 42:34I don't even see it. I I I don't.
- 42:35I don't think complementing ourselves is the appropriate way
- 42:38of addressing that. It's that the generalists should
- 42:42see it, but they don't because on the one hand, they just don't
- 42:47understand Bitcoin basically. But I think it's even worse than
- 42:49that. It's that they deeply
- 42:52misunderstand Bitcoin. They believe a lot of things by
- 42:54Bitcoin that are are completely false.
- 42:56And so they'll dismiss it rather than take it seriously.
- 42:59And then that's only dramatically compounded from
- 43:02there by all of the, again, misinformation coming from
- 43:07crypto that that just exacerbates the entire
- 43:09situation. But yeah, I mean, I, I, I, I, I
- 43:13think of a lot of what we do is just so incredibly
- 43:16straightforward that I'm just, I'm like amazed that others
- 43:21don't see it. Hopefully they will one day and
- 43:23then hopefully all these investments will be amazing.
- 43:26Well, it's like going back to Michael's point from earlier,
- 43:27it's like we've been in this so long that we've seen it and
- 43:30we've understood it and internalized it, and it's crazy
- 43:33to us and others have not gotten to this point yet.
- 43:36But you have to remember, it takes years, maybe shorter now
- 43:41with all the information out there, but it takes quite a
- 43:43while to come to fully grok it. Start with the monetary
- 43:46properties, the distributed network and then dive in deeper,
- 43:49understanding how the protocol level interacts with the
- 43:52Lightning network, how protocol level interacts with things like
- 43:56Fetty Mints or single member federations.
- 43:59Like that's a very steep learning curve.
- 44:03And going back to your point earlier that the journalist
- 44:06should get this and you should be incorporating Bitcoin into
- 44:10businesses that aren't even Bitcoin first businesses.
- 44:13I think as venture venture funds in this space, that's going to
- 44:18be one of our biggest advantages moving forward is you're going
- 44:21to have all these companies, they're like, oh shit, we need a
- 44:24Bitcoin strategy. We need to figure out how to
- 44:27incorporate Bitcoin into our business model and into our
- 44:30application stack. And they're going to go to us
- 44:33and be like, all right, you guys know Bitcoin, you have capital.
- 44:36Get on the cap table and help advise me as I do this.
- 44:39There's two sides of that because the other side is like,
- 44:41there's two missing parts of like, the thing that operators
- 44:44or generalists have generally if they're doing it right is they
- 44:47have operational experience in the traditional world, which is
- 44:50like a prerequisite from building.
- 44:53So you have to like tie both together.
- 44:55But I think what Allen said, that's really like you were
- 44:58saying that they're deeply misunderstand Bitcoin And if we
- 45:01take it a step further, it's the foundational layer that Bitcoin
- 45:05allows us to see the world through.
- 45:06That I think you're alluding to of like they're like whether
- 45:09it's chasing a dollar return or just thinking about how do you
- 45:11build a business because you have this like unit that just
- 45:14fundamentally warps your your brain and how do you think about
- 45:17growth and all of these things is that like fundamental layer
- 45:21And then everything else starts to build on top of it And that's
- 45:23where you see this like insanity whether it's we work or all
- 45:25these different different things that M from it.
- 45:29And so it's almost like if AVC like in like whatever top tier
- 45:32just understood Bitcoin. And there's actually ones like
- 45:35that. The guys like the Palantir Co
- 45:38founders, Joe Lonziel and Drew Oding, which I would think is
- 45:42like top five VC sitting in Austin.
- 45:45Like they actually foundationally believe that
- 45:47crypto is all BS, Bitcoin is the thing.
- 45:49And you can actually that thesis, if you go look at their
- 45:51site, what they do, they have an incubator, they do like really
- 45:54incredible stuff. But I think that's like the
- 45:56prerequisite to be a top tier in the market because you got to
- 45:59understand like Bitcoin. But that's not enough because
- 46:02you have to know the current market landscape, operational
- 46:04excellence, who operates at the highest level and how do you
- 46:06infuse those together to like actually build the next
- 46:10generation of companies. Yeah, there's a couple others
- 46:12like Valor Craft. They seem to get it as well.
- 46:16Yeah. David Sachs is an interesting
- 46:18person that, like, seems to grok like foundational kind of.
- 46:21You can't make things out of thin air, yeah.
- 46:25Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 46:27exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 46:30about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 46:33allocation, get in touch with our team at onrampbitcoin.com.
- 46:37We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 46:40And so this is how Bitcoin is affecting venture capital.
- 46:46I know we wanted to talk about bitcoin's overall effect on
- 46:49asset management as well. Like what hard lessons is the
- 46:55asset management world going to learn over the next decade
- 46:58because Bitcoin is gaining an adoption and proliferating
- 47:02throughout the global economy? Could could I could I make it
- 47:07like 50 years rather than 10? Because then yes, I get to be a
- 47:10bit more obnoxious to my answer. I I I'm pretty sure we've spoken
- 47:14about this before, Mark. Yeah, I've definitely written
- 47:16about it, although potentially in a similar tone to my my chat
- 47:20earlier about the ETF. It might have been so facetious
- 47:22that people didn't take it seriously, but I I honestly
- 47:25believe without intending this is as a joke or or a dunk on,
- 47:31you know Vanguard or whoever. Actually, no, sorry.
- 47:34I do very much intend it. As a dunk on Vanguard, no, as a
- 47:36dunk on people buying ETS. Global Asset Management in the
- 47:41very, very long run is going to go to Max 10% of what it is now.
- 47:46Maybe even smaller, basically because the vast, vast majority
- 47:53of the purpose it serves is legitimate now, but only because
- 48:00of the perverse incentives of Fiat.
- 48:02So I I I'm phrasing that very carefully because I'm I'm not
- 48:06saying, oh, it's all a scam. If anything it's it's kind of a
- 48:10coping mechanism for the the far more widespread, more insidious
- 48:15scam. It's it's it allows a lot of
- 48:18people a way to maybe not escape the scam entirely, but at least
- 48:25you know, not feel its effects to the fullest that they might
- 48:29otherwise. But as that gradually gets
- 48:33replaced by Bitcoin, so will the entire purpose of most of asset
- 48:39management I think which which by the way was quite a quite a
- 48:45daunting well, to the extent is true was quite a daunting
- 48:49realization. When I worked in asset
- 48:51management, well, I still do work in asset management but now
- 48:53at least it's now. Now it's explicitly Bitcoin
- 48:56focus. When I worked in generalist
- 48:58asset management, I remember realizing this and being like,
- 49:00oh this is this is bad. Well, I mean I guess it's good
- 49:03for civilization, it's good for my career.
- 49:05It was bad. And so, so I guess the the
- 49:08implication there Alan is that the Cantalon effect and debt
- 49:13based monetary system creates inefficiencies or opportunities
- 49:17that necessitate or or allow for not necessitate allow for value
- 49:24accretion on a much larger scale than you can have in the
- 49:29financial system if you do not have a Cantalon effect and a
- 49:32debt based monetary system in action.
- 49:35Yeah, I think that's. Part of it, that's that's not
- 49:37exactly what I was getting at, although that is also that's
- 49:40yeah, another reason to believe this.
- 49:42What what I meant was more like the fact that you simply can't
- 49:49save with with money, right. Money is purely or almost
- 49:54entirely useful transactionally, but not really as a savings
- 50:00instrument, which is why I think it's so useful to just, you
- 50:03know, this touches on a whole bunch of things we've talked
- 50:04about so far to to to call Bitcoin savings technology.
- 50:09That's by far the most accurate way of describing what it does.
- 50:12And also not not just in terms of being accurate, but kind of
- 50:15downplaying a lot of stupid hype around what it doesn't do that
- 50:19actually lends itself better to to crypto.
- 50:22So with that in mind, given basically given you can't save
- 50:26with Fiat on an appropriately long time horizon you'd say for
- 50:29a couple of years, but you certainly can't save for your
- 50:31retirement say. It creates this absolutely
- 50:36gigantic need for not only a savings instrument but
- 50:41channelled via investment vehicles that have no business
- 50:47at a very time monetary premium that they now have.
- 50:52But I think frankly in a lot of cases they have no business even
- 50:55existing because they they exist at all to fulfil this, you know
- 51:01our SAT savings role. And so that's what I mean.
- 51:04Eventually, all that'll just go away because because you can
- 51:06save it. So savings technology shrinks
- 51:09the market of needing to. Yeah.
- 51:14I mean, the level of the level of fuckery is absolutely like
- 51:17insane. Like I can't even wrap my head
- 51:19around. It's why I appreciate like what
- 51:20we're trying to build and just figuring out the custody because
- 51:22then you can start to build up. But to Allen's point, I think
- 51:24about like zombie companies that go to the capital markets, like
- 51:27I cannot understand. I think about not to throw them
- 51:30under the bus, but IBM is probably a great example.
- 51:32I think it's understood that they're like a zombie, you know,
- 51:35effectively. But to be able to go and raise
- 51:37debt and do all these things to continue their life, like the
- 51:40amount of ways that transpires, whether it's economically
- 51:43through an investment bank and managing that and who's getting
- 51:46the fat check And then the people that are still working
- 51:49going and building things that like again I think Chamath got
- 51:52crap for this. But it was like there was
- 51:54directional to it a few weeks ago when he made that tweet
- 51:57about like I'm starting to fund to go just invest in companies
- 52:00that will rebuild like Fortune 5 hundreds are publicly traded.
- 52:03But at 110th the amount of like just 110th the efficiency or the
- 52:07OR 110th the the cost at 100th or whatever of the efficiency
- 52:11basically being like all these companies just foundationally
- 52:13aren't built correctly. And that's just one micro
- 52:16example of what you're alluding to from a more macro finance
- 52:19financial architecture, how everything has been built if
- 52:22there's just so much fat everywhere.
- 52:24I mean, I don't. I don't know.
- 52:25I don't know the details of Chamath's proposal, so I don't,
- 52:28I don't mean to. I'm not really arguing against
- 52:31it per SE. But from what you outlined just
- 52:33there, it seems like it's nonetheless missing the critical
- 52:36component of Bitcoin or or more like missing the the critical
- 52:41lack of a component of Fiat. Given that yeah you can you can
- 52:45go after IBM if you want you know the Boeing came to mind as
- 52:50as as you were giving that example too.
- 52:53I mean there's the point though is that there's endless examples
- 52:55that you you could get. You know you can go after them
- 52:58as a start up, but you can't compete with their completely
- 53:03artificial access to gargantuan amounts of capital that keeps
- 53:08them alive even though they shouldn't be alive on the one
- 53:11hand and this capital shouldn't really even exist on the other.
- 53:16So good luck to him I guess. But I think he he's not.
- 53:20The the problem is far deeper. He should just buy Bitcoin.
- 53:24And the beauty of that is like we will get there with like the
- 53:27the core theme is the opportunity cost should be
- 53:29Bitcoin because once it's Bitcoin then you don't end up
- 53:31with all that because that's like where we end up the end
- 53:33state. Yeah, it's interesting you
- 53:35you've actually, I've realized just in the past couple of
- 53:37minutes in the past few questions you've taken a
- 53:40slightly different perspective on this which again I also
- 53:42approval but it's it's not exactly what I meant.
- 53:44So it's correct me if I'm wrong, I don't need to put words in
- 53:46your right, but it seems like you're more interested in
- 53:49describing the opportunity cost of all the capital misallocation
- 53:53that follows from this which is also true.
- 53:56Very happy to talk about that too.
- 53:57My original concern though was that to some extent this is a
- 54:01misallocation of capital, but I see it as more honestly, like a
- 54:05like an injustice more than more than the the directly, you know,
- 54:09economic implications is why does this industry even exist?
- 54:13Like there's there's a huge amount of middle men and, you
- 54:18know, intermediation of various sorts.
- 54:21That again, is why is a rhetorical question, because I
- 54:24know why it exists. It exists to provide a a means
- 54:27of saving that otherwise just wouldn't.
- 54:30But now we have a means of saving that doesn't require any
- 54:34intermediation, which actually, we've come full circle, right?
- 54:36This is why the ETFs are bullshit.
- 54:38Why are you paying these? Well, just save.
- 54:42Just use savings technology. And to like, go like a layer
- 54:46deeper into the bullshit. Like, it's gotten to such a
- 54:49point from a passive investment standpoint that a lot of the
- 54:53relationships that are built between companies and the
- 54:56investment managers that are running the four O 1K plans,
- 54:58whatever, they're just literally people taking each other out,
- 55:03getting them drunk, becoming friends, being like, hey, you
- 55:05should just come into our fund, pay our fees because you like me
- 55:10and everybody's doing the same thing essentially.
- 55:12And there is actual value, Alan. To your point this came up
- 55:16yesterday with a guy that's we may know Circle.
- 55:19They manage like $80 billion from an investment perspective.
- 55:22And I was telling him about some like very large institutional
- 55:25investors that are we're onboarding and he's like well
- 55:27why wouldn't they just go smash buy Bitcoin.
- 55:29And again I was telling him I was like this tell you told me
- 55:32exactly what do you know how far you're down the rabbit hole
- 55:34because it doesn't make sense to us.
- 55:36But if you take a step back and this is part of like where you
- 55:38know we say an asset management firm built on multi institution
- 55:41because at the end of the day there is value in somebody
- 55:45whether it was BlackRock, I don't think it's BlackRock
- 55:47because I don't think they understand what's happening
- 55:48here. But educating the buyer of what
- 55:51they're getting into and the price cuts in half to double
- 55:53down And when it appreciates not to sell and all the things
- 55:56associated with the asset because there's so much inherent
- 56:00understanding or innate understanding from this group,
- 56:02but that isn't there and they don't necessarily know what
- 56:04they're buying. It's the same example is like
- 56:06financial advisors, which I think in today's terms are
- 56:09almost like this is going to, you know, a lot of financial
- 56:12advisors piss them off but they're almost in my mind like
- 56:15travel agents in the future they won't really exist unless
- 56:18they're very niche. I think what will exist and it
- 56:21reminds me of what a lot of folks that like an unchanged or
- 56:23here do. And what we did was thinking
- 56:25about what is financial advice around the asset.
- 56:27How do you think about it from an inheritance perspective?
- 56:30How do you think about it? If you do need to access to
- 56:32capital markets to get dollars because you have to buy a home
- 56:35and you don't want to sell because of a tax gain or a
- 56:38capital gains, all of those things will be foundational and
- 56:41are needed because of the understanding of us looking at
- 56:44this for so long. They just take a different form
- 56:46and they should be paid for like it's a good value being
- 56:48delivered. It's just not an ETF where
- 56:51somebody smash buys it sits on Coinbase where they like go to 0
- 56:54or whatever happened the past week.
- 56:56They they like, you know, incompetent in multiple levels
- 56:58and they're hoping that they're going to give them the Bitcoin
- 57:00when they want it because we know how that ends.
- 57:02Yeah, yeah. And then there's a lot of pick
- 57:04up on there too, Just that I I was very deliberate in how I
- 57:07said I didn't say or certainly didn't mean to say or imply that
- 57:11asset management just goes away. Like Bitcoin just
- 57:13disintermediates finance or whatever.
- 57:16Which interestingly, there's maybe even a good tangent there
- 57:17about why I hate Defy as a meme because it just doesn't, doesn't
- 57:20make any sense. Even even if you believe all of
- 57:24this, it still doesn't make any sense.
- 57:25I I picked 10% just because it seems like a nice ride number.
- 57:28I don't know, it could be 5 percent, 1%, who knows.
- 57:29But I think there's there's a huge number of functions of
- 57:35financial and financial intermediation that are
- 57:38extremely valuable and will will absolutely still be needed on on
- 57:42a Bitcoin standard. I don't know how interesting it
- 57:44is to like go through what I think some of these will be.
- 57:47And my my point is more about the quantum of capital that is
- 57:54forced through this system. That's what I think goes away,
- 57:58right Or or or mostly goes away and because currently the, the
- 58:02and I think actually even to your point about you know what
- 58:05somebody like BlackRock thinks or or does or doesn't understand
- 58:10about what's what's really happening here.
- 58:14And I almost feel like the I forgot where I was going to go
- 58:19with that. I was going to make fun of
- 58:21BlackRock, but I forget why. There's too many reasons.
- 58:26Yeah. The the thing that I was
- 58:28anchoring and I think where we're both saying the same thing
- 58:31and I I just try to pull back where you're given a wider
- 58:34aperture and I think to like zoom in for individuals that are
- 58:37again as deep is I think of fintech.
- 58:41Like I think Bitcoin is the real fintech and this idea of like
- 58:44think about how much capital has this.
- 58:46Financial technology. Yeah, but then you know how much
- 58:48capital from, like all the way from the fat of formation that
- 58:51you're talking about, investment banks and VCs and pensions
- 58:54putting money like to the tunes of probably trillions of
- 58:56dollars. It's not hundreds of billions of
- 58:57dollars into fintech. And what we're describing here
- 59:00is Bitcoin is financial technology and there'll be
- 59:02capital invested into it. It's just we at one one
- 59:05thousandth or whatever of the amount.
- 59:07And that takes out a lot of needs for all the different
- 59:09people right now playing within that capital stack.
- 59:12Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I mean, I'm.
- 59:16Just like I'm gonna remember how I was gonna make fun of
- 59:18BlackRock. But I remember what it was.
- 59:21Yeah, no, it it ties perfectly to exactly your point.
- 59:23Just there, Michael, too. And it's that they I think the
- 59:28this is, this is almost like a truism in a sense.
- 59:30But appreciating exactly why it's the case I think is is
- 59:33interesting that they're they're acting with a very they're
- 59:38acting what seems rationally on a very short term time horizon.
- 59:43And the problem is that they've never really thought about why
- 59:50the circumstances they're used to even exist in the 1st place.
- 59:53So you can kind of see why they'd be, if not, like, super
- 59:58strongly resistant to Bitcoin, at least highly highly skeptical
- 1:00:01even in the context of like, oh, we can make shit load of money
- 1:00:03off an ETF, right? We can skim the flows of this,
- 1:00:06even if we don't really believe in the stock.
- 1:00:10Their entire, their entire business model.
- 1:00:14I guess that's probably the best way of putting it.
- 1:00:15Their entire business model is is predicated on a need that
- 1:00:19this undermines. I mean that's that's yet another
- 1:00:21reason I I like to be. Kind of jokingly contrarian
- 1:00:25about the ETF that I think they I think I like in all honesty,
- 1:00:29there's maybe not that much of a joke.
- 1:00:31It's maybe just more on what perspective are you willing to
- 1:00:34adopt that you you can't really be bullish on Bitcoin if you own
- 1:00:41an ETF. It it doesn't, it's
- 1:00:43philosophically incoherent. You can have a bullish thesis on
- 1:00:47Bitcoin that involves ETFs making sense.
- 1:00:51So that's another. I mean, obviously no one, no one
- 1:00:53cares. No one smashed by an ETF.
- 1:00:55Scares by this, but I think in like 50 years they will.
- 1:00:58That's kind of my point. Yeah.
- 1:01:01No, I I love that because I think it's resonates with like I
- 1:01:05just joked that it's a different they're different planets.
- 1:01:08The gravity's different. Like, we're just talking about
- 1:01:10different things, right. And like when you try to like
- 1:01:12understand this, you're like, wait, you're breathing a
- 1:01:13different type of like oxygen than when I'm at we're talking
- 1:01:16about a different level playing field and that's what you're
- 1:01:18describing. And so you can.
- 1:01:20Yeah. I think, I think it happens
- 1:01:22sooner than 50 years because we've discussed this.
- 1:01:25I think in the summer, last summer, Michael, like the ETF,
- 1:01:29when when the ETFs first started getting filed, they were
- 1:01:32becoming a big conversation and we were telling people don't buy
- 1:01:35the ETF, you're going to want an actual Bitcoin.
- 1:01:37They can call in kind at some point.
- 1:01:39Because what we're seeing is that it is turning into actual
- 1:01:42money that you can spend many different ways.
- 1:01:45And I think at some point sooner than 50 years from now, it's
- 1:01:50gonna be abundantly clear that you're gonna be able to transact
- 1:01:53with Bitcoin and use Bitcoin in unique ways.
- 1:01:55It's collateral or use its properties to do specific escrow
- 1:02:00agreements that you're gonna need the actual underlying UTXOS
- 1:02:03or access to Bitcoin on the Lightning Network or within via
- 1:02:09E cash tokens within a mint like.
- 1:02:11And I think the pure utility that using actual Bitcoin
- 1:02:17provides today and will provide in the future, it's just gonna
- 1:02:20force people out of the ETFs because they're like, I actually
- 1:02:22need to use this thing. I can't just, yeah, have it sit
- 1:02:25in this fund. And look well so, so that's
- 1:02:27interesting. I I I think obviously completely
- 1:02:30agree with the, the points about the utility.
- 1:02:33I do think to some extent though the the bull case for the ETFs
- 1:02:40kind of necessitates a bit of a bear case on the timeline of all
- 1:02:44of this. I'll explain what I mean by
- 1:02:46that. So I think the I I don't really
- 1:02:49know the details, this is pure speculation, but I I would
- 1:02:52imagine that the vast majority of ETF demand not just now but
- 1:02:58probably ever is coming from Best way of describing I guess
- 1:03:04would be something like pools of capital with no other legal
- 1:03:08option. So it's it's people who actually
- 1:03:11can't just go buy Bitcoin and and hold it.
- 1:03:14I mean actually Michael probably disagrees with this because I'm
- 1:03:16sure you have a whole on ramp presentation explaining why this
- 1:03:19is like misunderstood. But but I I would even in light
- 1:03:23of that actually Michael you should comment on this in just a
- 1:03:25second. But I I would imagine that the
- 1:03:27extent to which that's true is largely the case just at the
- 1:03:30margin and for for the still for the majority if not that not all
- 1:03:35but you know some pretty solid majority of EDF buyers.
- 1:03:38It's because like they also couldn't just have dollars,
- 1:03:41right. It's like it's trapped in this
- 1:03:42environment and this is like a nice release valve almost.
- 1:03:47But it's again it's not you know it's not real Bitcoin.
- 1:03:49It's not like going all the way. And so in terms of linking that
- 1:03:52to the timeline though, the way I see this unraveling and the
- 1:03:55and the reason I just picked 50 years, again it's just it's like
- 1:03:58a round Number, but it's suitably long that it's
- 1:04:02difficult to think about it is that I see this unwinding by
- 1:04:05people not contributing to pension plans in the 1st place.
- 1:04:10So it it really takes an entire it.
- 1:04:13This won't be the only reason obviously, but I think this will
- 1:04:15be the most important reason on a sufficiently long time horizon
- 1:04:19that because we have this savings technology now which is
- 1:04:22we've just never had in any of our lifetimes, people will
- 1:04:26choose to actually save. And one way you can actually
- 1:04:31interpret this, I guess is that they'll in doing so, they will
- 1:04:33be starving the beast, right? The capital that would otherwise
- 1:04:37have just naturally flowed into whatever ETFs, mutual funds, all
- 1:04:42all kinds of active passive management, trillions of dollars
- 1:04:46of most of which is useless intermediation.
- 1:04:49Now actually just goes into money instead.
- 1:04:51But I think that takes, I don't know, 50 years is exactly the
- 1:04:55right number to pick. But you know it it takes a a
- 1:05:00life cycle of workers opting for a different way to save.
- 1:05:08I think that's that's like the cleanest way of understanding
- 1:05:10it. So that's why I'm kind of
- 1:05:11bearish on the on the timeline, yeah, there's a.
- 1:05:17A few things there. One is so Marty's wife listens
- 1:05:20and you know she he's promised 8 to 10 years because she's tired
- 1:05:24of him hanging out with his Internet magic Internet friends.
- 1:05:28They want to Marty has a small Latin American country.
- 1:05:30He's going to to buy with his his his Bitcoin on the price.
- 1:05:37But another eight years. Yeah.
- 1:05:39The the funny part you referenced, Alan, is there's a
- 1:05:42lot of like like corollaries to like past, you know biblical and
- 1:05:47like not even yet like in that side of.
- 1:05:49But there's this like notion of you got to be out, you got to
- 1:05:51like wait for almost like what you described as a a group to
- 1:05:55pass before the next people will understand it or like adopt it
- 1:06:00or fully embrace it. But then the the ETF thing is
- 1:06:04really interesting because I I've found like when you build
- 1:06:10in this space like the closer you tie to like Bitcoin or the
- 1:06:12the protocol or the the history and experiences that Unchained
- 1:06:16where you start to really like tie into like a lot of the
- 1:06:19Saints or like the the notion of I guess it's a Sunzu quote but
- 1:06:22wait for the long enough by the wait long enough by the river
- 1:06:25for the body of your enemies to float by And it's like you think
- 1:06:28about exchanges and all the things happening.
- 1:06:30And another one I think of is like the Bitcoin ETF for
- 1:06:34specifically you reference on ramp or or any like buddy
- 1:06:37building custody is it's almost good.
- 1:06:41Unchained is a great example as well.
- 1:06:42It's good if they don't release if they don't let you have this
- 1:06:46escape valve like you can take delivery and it's it's good if
- 1:06:50they let you and it's good if they don't and for obvious
- 1:06:53reasons if they don't then people are going to learn and go
- 1:06:55other places. And if they do the beauty is
- 1:06:57like people or at least my thesis is like they're going to
- 1:07:01need help and they're not going to go to Coinbase like they
- 1:07:03would just leave it with the ETF.
- 1:07:04So then they're going to go search out solutions.
- 1:07:06And then we talked about this with KPMG last week.
- 1:07:09It's like I see a, a future world where like again, let's
- 1:07:12say Michael Saylor, somebody like him is holding a large
- 1:07:14position like $10 billion into Bitwise or, you know, whatever.
- 1:07:17ETF might as well be the same right there at Coinbase.
- 1:07:20And then they wake up and they say, well, why don't I
- 1:07:23participate in this governance effectively and why don't you
- 1:07:26know in a three O 5, four or five, whatever the number is.
- 1:07:28Why does an our organization sign the first transaction
- 1:07:31between 10 controllers, whatever that looks like And then some
- 1:07:35they if they come to that, they're going to need somebody
- 1:07:37to support them with that process.
- 1:07:40And so I just see that would be the the valve regardless of if
- 1:07:43they let it come out because Blackrock's not going to do
- 1:07:45that. Like, no, I mean, there's very
- 1:07:46few people are going to do that because that's just now they're
- 1:07:49built, they want to centralized and hold the assets.
- 1:07:51So I don't know if that helps in like the framing of like how I
- 1:07:53think about this playing out. But either way, they're gonna
- 1:07:55get educated and they're gonna be like, holy crap, BlackRock
- 1:07:57holds a trillion dollars. This is not good for my position
- 1:07:59because if something happens, that's a zero on my book.
- 1:08:02And that's why I like very bullish on everything we're
- 1:08:04building. Because we've seen this happen
- 1:08:05with Block 5 and nobody thought it would go to zero and then it
- 1:08:08goes, it goes to 0. Yeah, yeah, I think the market's
- 1:08:10gonna force this. I mean, just look at what
- 1:08:12happened. Was it 2 days ago now at this
- 1:08:14point? Like Queen Base could not handle
- 1:08:17the the trading volume, they their systems went down.
- 1:08:19You couldn't buy, you couldn't sell.
- 1:08:21You're seeing $0.00 asset balance in the application, like
- 1:08:25if you're an ETF. I didn't know that.
- 1:08:27That's quite funny. If you're an ETF custody with
- 1:08:29this company or if you're a buyer of the ETF that is
- 1:08:32custodying with this company, you're like, what is going on
- 1:08:35here? We need, we need to make sure
- 1:08:37not that all this risk is not concentrated within this one
- 1:08:41company. So I think to your point,
- 1:08:42Michael, the participants will begin to force this like, hey,
- 1:08:46if you want, yeah, my business, you're going to have to play in
- 1:08:49this model. Yeah.
- 1:08:50To to be fair though so so this is an interesting point to again
- 1:08:54be a bit bearish but for a more serious reason rather than just
- 1:08:57pseudo contrarianism. Right.
- 1:08:58And I I do Michael, will, I guarantee you Michael knows what
- 1:09:02I'm about to say significantly more detail than I do.
- 1:09:04So I encourage you to push back on this, but I I do wonder if
- 1:09:08there's the, the kind of the glass half empty view is you
- 1:09:12know, OK, yes, all these somewhat inevitable failures
- 1:09:17will encourage people to think it through more thoroughly than
- 1:09:20if anything I think that goes to what we talked about right at
- 1:09:22the start in terms of them being an educational stepping stone.
- 1:09:24But how much will not be able to escape, like how much will go in
- 1:09:31and will never come out regardless of how educated
- 1:09:35everybody gets. I don't know.
- 1:09:36Do do you have a, do you have a comeback for that, Michael?
- 1:09:39I have a very strong one and it's kind of, it's scary.
- 1:09:42I don't even want to say it, but I will because I don't care is I
- 1:09:45think that there's a real world. There's a non zero chance
- 1:09:47whatever goes in never comes out.
- 1:09:50Yeah. And and what happened?
- 1:09:53What you're agreeing with. Me even more never comes out and
- 1:09:56never comes out in Bitcoin and dollars or just Bitcoin.
- 1:09:59The Bitcoin gets out there. Are you saying that it's getting
- 1:10:01confiscated? Is that what you're trying?
- 1:10:02I've been in chat with you. I've told I've told you that
- 1:10:05that I think that there's a non zero chance whatever the ETFs
- 1:10:07are we like it's basically forget about the ETFs that
- 1:10:10whatever 21 million obviously we all know it's arbitrary number
- 1:10:13and we think in our heads it's 17,000,000 we end up with our 16
- 1:10:16it could be maybe 12 or 11 or 10 and this could be a real reason
- 1:10:20why I think there's non zero chance.
- 1:10:23Like I think it's that like I fall in your camp, Allen, like
- 1:10:26in my heart and my, you know ahead of like where you're
- 1:10:29coming as staunch like this is not good.
- 1:10:31But at the same point I really have to build a business in the
- 1:10:33real world and like from this perspective and you know the the
- 1:10:36products and services and the reality is when you meet people
- 1:10:40where they're at, they don't want to hear that.
- 1:10:42So you got to explain that. Yeah, of course.
- 1:10:44And all of it. But there's just, it's true,
- 1:10:46like I would tell anybody that it's like you go in and it
- 1:10:48happened like the the beauty of all the things we're saying.
- 1:10:51We're not pontificating for the sake of it.
- 1:10:53It's like we saw this. We told people this at previous
- 1:10:55firms whether it was Genesis, which I guess maybe they're
- 1:10:57making people whole, but in some respects not not every respect.
- 1:11:02Three AC, Celsius, FTX, we can continue to go and it's going to
- 1:11:06happen again. It's basically the basis of what
- 1:11:08we build this for is because we believe orders of magnitude of
- 1:11:10carnage are going to happen in you know two or three years when
- 1:11:13the market the, the fun part about this are not fun but I've
- 1:11:16been having this conversation is you know, it'd be like well why
- 1:11:19would you think it's going to happen?
- 1:11:21And the easiest answer is the same people that were running
- 1:11:25Block Fire FTX or running these exact same products.
- 1:11:29Yeah, yeah. I thought you were going to say
- 1:11:30something even snarkier than that.
- 1:11:31I thought you were going to say why don't you think it's going
- 1:11:35to happen? Yeah, there you go.
- 1:11:39I I think that's I'm so bold for Alan on that that.
- 1:11:42Pushes them to again actually start going deeper and like
- 1:11:46force them out of the, you know the I wouldn't.
- 1:11:48I don't need to be insulting but non Bitcoin.
- 1:11:51I was going to say the Fiat attitude, but it's just you know
- 1:11:54the the pre Bitcoin legacy financial system attitude of you
- 1:11:59know, it's slightly different to the point I was making before
- 1:12:02about all these intermediaries. Now it's more like custodians,
- 1:12:05right? Like these assets don't really
- 1:12:07exist in any meaningful sense without the custodian's
- 1:12:10involvement, but now they do. So like why are you putting it
- 1:12:14back in the box? No.
- 1:12:15And it's, I mean, we've seen this, I've seen this person, I
- 1:12:19saw it this week. I told the story on Rabbit Hole
- 1:12:21Recap yesterday. But it is important to us
- 1:12:25because this stuff will happen. We've seen it many times.
- 1:12:28We've predicted it many times. We talked for years about Block
- 1:12:31Fi and the fact that their lending practices were extremely
- 1:12:34risky and likely to blow up. Celsius was a well known scam
- 1:12:38behind the scenes. And then FDX was just obviously
- 1:12:43a corrupt institution. SPF had no idea what he's
- 1:12:46talking about, if you actually have listened to him during his
- 1:12:48interviews. And so you have examples there.
- 1:12:50And as we're talking here like it seems like there's a similar
- 1:12:54trend taking place right now, even though there may be an
- 1:12:57institutional stamp of approval on these things.
- 1:13:00Like I would not rule out the likelihood that the Bitcoin is
- 1:13:05mismanaged in one way or another, whether that's taking
- 1:13:09it and lending it out for DGN traders to do something with it,
- 1:13:13whether the government confiscates it.
- 1:13:16But you have this ability via multi sig setups like the ones
- 1:13:22that on ramp provides to actually take control of your
- 1:13:26Bitcoin and reduce this risk and eliminate this risk.
- 1:13:29And I had a buddy who called me on Monday, he got SIM swapped on
- 1:13:36Sunday and he thanked me because two years ago I convinced him to
- 1:13:40move his Bitcoin off of the exchange he was using and into a
- 1:13:44multi sig Volt It Unchained. And the reason I told him is
- 1:13:48he's a public figure and he's talked about owning Bitcoin and
- 1:13:50I'm like dude, you're a target. You've talked about Bitcoin
- 1:13:54publicly, you're pretty well known like you are going to get
- 1:13:57attacked in the future and that is exactly what happened.
- 1:14:01And he texted me to thank me for telling him to get it into a
- 1:14:06secure a secure custody set up with Unchained.
- 1:14:11And this is going to happen time and time again in many different
- 1:14:16ways. The thing I'd be careful in that
- 1:14:19one is it was good for now. But like I think we all agree
- 1:14:23we're in a like bear market for whether it's statism or the just
- 1:14:27like you know what I'm sorry, bull market for statism and
- 1:14:31overreach. And also in the same way of like
- 1:14:33degradation of, you know, just we all walk around cities and we
- 1:14:36see kind of, I don't know if it's famine is the right word,
- 1:14:40but like despair and and you see that on the Internet, it
- 1:14:43manifests in the Internet form and that's why you want to
- 1:14:45protect the asset. What concerns me is being loud
- 1:14:48about us holding our keys. And and it's not to say not to
- 1:14:51do it or whatever. It's more of like I talked to
- 1:14:54somebody the other day in South Africa.
- 1:14:55His brother was tortured for his Bitcoin because he knew, they
- 1:14:59knew the process. They knew how to like it was
- 1:15:00just a whole OTC transaction went wrong.
- 1:15:03But it's this whole notion of like where that will not not
- 1:15:06happen as the price goes into orders of thousands of dollars.
- 1:15:09And so this idea of like because we have our keys and now they're
- 1:15:12split apart like our families are not, it's not something we
- 1:15:15want to be loud about even though it's a good like thing to
- 1:15:18say off the exchange. It's like we're still so early
- 1:15:20that what's good at 40K won't be the same AT400K or 4 million.
- 1:15:25So anyway that that's just a a notable thing.
- 1:15:28And then Alan, I really like your position on there.
- 1:15:30It's like tell me why this wouldn't happen.
- 1:15:32It goes back to what we said earlier in the calls, like tell
- 1:15:34me what your position is on why this, why we shouldn't have a an
- 1:15:37allocation. In the same way tell me like why
- 1:15:40the ETF or any centralization will work out well and Brian
- 1:15:44Cabela's from our team said it really nicely.
- 1:15:45It's like we have the most decentralized asset we've ever
- 1:15:47seen and we put it on a centralized custodian.
- 1:15:50Like it doesn't even make any sense.
- 1:15:54Yeah, I mean I agree even further than that right.
- 1:15:55It's it's obviously agree with that framing of it.
- 1:15:57But and and Marty mentioned this before in terms of you know
- 1:16:00various utilities let's say of of actually owning it that it's
- 1:16:06also natively digital. It's it's arguably the first and
- 1:16:10only the kind of the only natively digital asset, and
- 1:16:13you're you're also just forcing it back into an analogue wrapper
- 1:16:18like. Why?
- 1:16:19Yeah, I I joke around. I say the only difference
- 1:16:21between Bitcoin and gold is multi sig.
- 1:16:26Yeah, that was a good idea. I've said, I've said a similar
- 1:16:28version of that several times that that you can't multi say
- 1:16:32gold. Yeah, again, usually in just
- 1:16:34kind of a snarky way to, like, make people think rather than
- 1:16:37making an actual point. You probably could.
- 1:16:40You could have a vault with three keys, 3 individuals.
- 1:16:44Yeah, it was a golden. Turn it in one place.
- 1:16:47Like it's true. Yeah.
- 1:16:48Yeah. No, it's no, no.
- 1:16:53It is hard like timelines and thinking how quickly all this
- 1:16:56will evolve, whether it's on the capital formation side and the
- 1:17:00price of Bitcoin or the utility side and what you can do with
- 1:17:04Bitcoin. It's fun to think about because
- 1:17:06I mean on the utility side, I see it every day.
- 1:17:09There's new apps coming out that you can interact with very
- 1:17:12easily. That again, we're in a bubble.
- 1:17:15We've been in this for a while. We see it clear than most people
- 1:17:18on the planet. It's like, holy shit, this is a
- 1:17:21step function improvement on the way I was interacting with apps
- 1:17:25that exist in the incumbent tech space.
- 1:17:29Just because you add some Bitcoin to it, maybe add noster
- 1:17:32or something else, and it seems like things are happening
- 1:17:35quicker. And then you also have the
- 1:17:36tailwind of the maybe, I mean, societal degradation is one way
- 1:17:41to see it, but another one way to say it, another way to say it
- 1:17:45is just the complete collapse of confidence in institutions.
- 1:17:49And I think that introduces A catalyst where people will be
- 1:17:52more receptive to looking into Bitcoin and using Bitcoin.
- 1:17:58Yeah. No I I.
- 1:17:59New ways to do things. That's huge.
- 1:18:01I I think my only I don't know what's the best way to put this.
- 1:18:05I was gonna say my only issue with it, but I I don't disagree
- 1:18:07with you at all. It's more like my concern about
- 1:18:11it even being true in the 1st place is that I've always found
- 1:18:14that is a terrible way to advertise it, right?
- 1:18:18Like, nobody, nobody wants to hear that everything is going to
- 1:18:23shit. Like if or if they are willing
- 1:18:26to hear that, they're certainly not willing to hear, you know,
- 1:18:29they just sit through the lecture on how everything's
- 1:18:31going to shit. Then you're, you know, you're
- 1:18:33going to fix it with your magic Internet beans.
- 1:18:35Like that's that. That just pushes them over the
- 1:18:37edge. So yeah, I mean, I completely
- 1:18:40agree with the the facts of the case, if you like.
- 1:18:44I just have no idea how to make that argument.
- 1:18:46I I I kind of feel like it almost came across in the way
- 1:18:48you said it there, Marky, that probably the best way that works
- 1:18:52is people just making the argument for themselves, like
- 1:18:55all coming to a similar conclusion about that.
- 1:18:59Yeah, I mean, that's what's happened to the up until this
- 1:19:03point is individuals coming to their own conclusions.
- 1:19:05Like, hey, all of us at one point looked at what was
- 1:19:09happening. We looked at Bitcoin.
- 1:19:11We're like, all right, I'm going and playing over here.
- 1:19:13That'll happen, I think, at an accelerated pace.
- 1:19:16And it's hard because you can't completely disconnect the state
- 1:19:20of the world from the value prop of Bitcoin.
- 1:19:24But I agree, messaging's important narratives are
- 1:19:27important. And that's why I'm excited to
- 1:19:30see all these new applications and use cases for Bitcoin coming
- 1:19:34to market. Because it provides the
- 1:19:35opportunity to pitch Bitcoin and optimistic like like look at
- 1:19:39what you can do with Bitcoin that you can.
- 1:19:41Well and to and to Michael's point.
- 1:19:43Right. To reach people where they are.
- 1:19:44Right. If you can.
- 1:19:46This is this is I mentioned this in a completely different
- 1:19:48context before in terms of like what we like to invest in.
- 1:19:52And if you can I'm trying to think how even how sneaky you
- 1:19:58can be about it. If you can actually get somebody
- 1:20:00to use something or to start using something fairly
- 1:20:02continuously on the basis that it just works right or is just
- 1:20:07is cheaper or whatever. And then at some point you know
- 1:20:10pull back the curtain is like it was Bitcoin all along.
- 1:20:13Like that's that's great. That's way better than what was
- 1:20:16I said before. You know, whining about the the
- 1:20:18conspiracy of the set up of the Federal Reserve, or, as you
- 1:20:21know, as you brought up now, like pointing to how
- 1:20:23everything's going to shit like that's.
- 1:20:26There's very few people you can meet there.
- 1:20:29There's a lot more people you can meet by it just being
- 1:20:31useful. Yes, yeah.
- 1:20:33Yeah. Yeah, I think the people coming
- 1:20:36in as an exciting component because price is the forcing
- 1:20:39function for awareness and a lot of these discussions in people
- 1:20:42and companies will be exciting at the next wave.
- 1:20:44And I'm actually, I would say this after the thing, but I'll
- 1:20:48say it now. I'm pretty bullish on Allen
- 1:20:50being on the the last trade. You know you're going to have to
- 1:20:52do do this again. It's a nice like different take
- 1:20:55than to help it. What's that?
- 1:20:59It's much more laid back since we all know each other.
- 1:21:01It's much more laid back conversation and.
- 1:21:02Well, laid back, but there's like a healthy like pushback and
- 1:21:05contrarian take of like let's let's think about it in a
- 1:21:08different way that I think, I think listeners are going to
- 1:21:11like. I think this was a good that's a
- 1:21:13good Rep. You you got to take that with a
- 1:21:14pinch of salt though, because keep in mind my proclivity to do
- 1:21:18that very much comes from Twitter rather than like real
- 1:21:22life or it being useful or anything.
- 1:21:26I just well, that's why. I just want.
- 1:21:27To kick the hornet's nest a bit. No, that's why.
- 1:21:30That's why it makes good because instead of just taking it, we're
- 1:21:32like, wait, let's let's really dissect.
- 1:21:34Are you saying this just to say it's ruffles and feathers or
- 1:21:36there's the validity and and I think that's what we've done
- 1:21:38kind of on this, the set episode?
- 1:21:42Yeah, And for anybody who has not read the incredible research
- 1:21:46pieces that Axiom puts out, make sure you go read those.
- 1:21:50One of my favorites is the one that Theo Mojane wrote on.
- 1:21:57Oh yeah, yeah. That's recreating money market
- 1:21:59funds. There's there's three of them
- 1:22:00and I think they're all good, but.
- 1:22:01Yes, Eric Yanks and then your piece, right and my one was?
- 1:22:06The first one. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:22:09Go read it all. It's Orange is the New Green, I
- 1:22:13think was my favorite. We'll all have to get together
- 1:22:17soon. I think me and Alan might be
- 1:22:18looking at the UAE little part time go go visit and then Marty
- 1:22:22wants to go out there, so. Are you getting a place in the
- 1:22:24UAE too? I don't.
- 1:22:26Think he would get a? Place he's flagged, isn't it
- 1:22:30Right, You got to get places everywhere.
- 1:22:32I'm not a so do. You know society is collapsing,
- 1:22:35Martin. I'm.
- 1:22:37I'm not going anywhere. America will be the best scene
- 1:22:41of freedom. I will die on that hill are.
- 1:22:45You going to be in Texas or you'll?
- 1:22:46Probably will literally die on. That.
- 1:22:51Yeah. Oh man.
- 1:22:53Get stabbed by some some on the street with.
- 1:22:56The machete shabbed. By some shit coiner.
- 1:23:00I should have went to Dubai. Well, Alan, thank you Michael.
- 1:23:05We have anything else we want to.
- 1:23:07No. Thank you guys.
- 1:23:09No, it was awesome. I'm.
- 1:23:10I'm looking forward to doing this again.
- 1:23:12Yeah. Yeah, definitely.
- 1:23:14Good luck with the rest of your move.
- 1:23:15I know it's literally the worst activity in the world is is to
- 1:23:19move. So thank you.
- 1:23:20I don't envy your position at all and hopefully you get some
- 1:23:24time to to enjoy part of your weekend this weekend.
- 1:23:27I will do my best. Yes, I will.
- 1:23:29I will stay off Twitter. I will temper my FOMO.
- 1:23:33I'll maybe go outside. I'll enjoy the real world.
- 1:23:36That's nice. Get some fresh air.
- 1:23:38We'll be back next week. See you guys.