Latest / The Confessional Booth / The Masks We Wear
Transcript
- Marie Wagner: Welcome to the Confessional Booth. I'm your host, Marie Wagner. I am a certified sex, love and relationship coach, as well as a hands-on dearmoring practitioner. The Confessional Booth is a safe space where we bring voice to what has been hidden, where we explore the things that shape us beneath the surface. And it's a place where shame and other internal blockages begin to lose their grip. As a result, we can start to experience more freedom, energy, joy, pleasure, and to ultimately feel more fully ourselves. Let's begin. There are so many different ways we learn to perform in relationships. We learn to be the strong one, the independent one, the successful one, the sexy one, the easygoing one, the one who never needs anything, the one who always knows what to do, the good partner, the good lover, the provider, the caretaker. The emotionally stable one, the one who doesn't cause problems. Maybe you can relate to some of these roles. And sometimes we become so good at playing these roles that we forget there is a person underneath them. And that is what I want to talk about today. First, let's explore this question: Why is it that we perform in relationships? Why can it feel easier to play a role than to actually let someone see us? And what happens in the body when we are constantly monitoring ourselves, managing someone else's experience, or trying to become the version of ourselves we think will be most desirable? Keep in mind that performance isn't only something that happens on a stage. It happens at the dinner table, it happens in the bedroom, it happens on dates, it happens during arguments, it happens when someone asks if Are you okay? And you automatically say, I'm fine. Most of us learn pretty early in childhood that certain behaviors get rewarded. Maybe as a child you learned that doing well in school got you approval. Maybe being agreeable and easy-going kept the peace. Maybe being funny made people like you, or being attractive brought you attention, or being sexually available made you feel wanted and desirable. Maybe being independent meant you didn't have to rely on anyone. Or being strong meant nobody worried about you. And over time, these behaviors can become part of our identity. Psychoanalyst Carl Jung called one aspect of this the persona, the social face we develop to move through the world. The persona is not inherently unhealthy. We need different roles to interact in the world. You probably behave differently with your boss than you do with your best friend. Or you probably show up differently as a parent, a partner, a friend, or a professional. The problem begins when the role becomes so rigid that we don't know who we are without it. You may be able to see why it's so important to look at our persona within our relationships. Because intimacy asks us to loosen our roles. After all, if someone is going to know you deeply, eventually they are going to see the places where the performance doesn't hold. They're gonna see you when you're insecure, when you're tired, when you're jealous, when you're afraid, when you don't know what to do, when you need reassurance, when you're sexually uncertain, when you're angry or resentful. or grieving, or when you simply don't have the answer. And for someone who has built their identity around competence or control, that can feel incredibly vulnerable. Therapist and sexologist Esther Perrell has spent a great deal of time exploring the tension between security and desire in long-term relationships. We want to feel safe, known, accepted, and secure with our partner, but at the same time, desire often needs some sense of freedom, mystery, separateness, and aliveness. That tension becomes even more complicated. When we think about performance. Because if I am constantly trying to be the perfect partner, I can become very safe and very predictable while becoming increasingly disconnected from my own desire. I'm monitoring. Am I doing enough? Am I attractive enough? Am I giving my partner what they need? Are they happy? Are they still attracted to me? Do they think I'm good in bed? And suddenly I'm no longer experiencing the relationship. I'm monitoring it and managing it. This can happen sexually as well. You can be having sex while mentally standing outside yourself, watching yourself have sex. How do I look? Am I moving correctly? Is my partner enjoying this? Am I taking too long? Am I going to orgasm? Can I maintain my erection? Should I be more dominant? Should I be more passionate? Should I be more relaxed? And the more we're monitoring ourselves, the harder it can become to actually experience ourselves. Stephen Porgis, famous for his polyvagal theory and his work on neurosception, describes how our nervous system is Continually evaluating cues of safety and threat, often outside of conscious awareness. Your body is taking in facial expressions, voice tone, movement, proximity, context, and countless other signals. And when the nervous system perceives threat, even subtle social threat, your physiology can shift, your heart rate can increase, your breathing becomes more shallow. Your muscles become more tense, your attention narrows, you become more vigilant, scanning for danger or threat. And this can happen in relationships, even when there is no obvious danger. You might be sitting across from someone you love, thinking, are they upset with me? Did I say something wrong? Do they still want me? Why haven't they touched me today? What does that look mean? Your body is gathering information. And when you're already carrying a lot of relational anxiety, neutral things can start to feel significant. A change in tone, a delayed text, a different facial expression, a partner turning away in bed. The nervous system doesn't always wait for conscious reasoning. It responds to what it perceives. And this is one reason self-awareness matters so much in intimacy. Because if you don't recognize what is happening inside you, you may assume the feeling is entirely about the other person. Peter Levine's work on trauma and the nervous system gives another useful lens here. Levine describes defensive responses as biological survival responses that can become stuck or incomplete when the nervous system doesn't get an opportunity to fully process what happened. I'm simplifying a much larger body of work here, but the basic idea is useful when we think about relational patterns. Sometimes a behavior that looks like perfectionism, control, withdrawal, people pleasing, or hyper-independence developed because it once helped us navigate something difficult. You may have learned to read the room because you grew up around unpredictable emotions. Maybe you became exceptionally competent because needing help wasn't safe. Or you became sexually pleasing because being desired gave you a sense of security. You might have learned to suppress anger because expressing it caused consequences, or perhaps you became the person who never asks for anything because asking once resulted in rejection. These strategies can become automatic, and years later, the relationship may be perfectly safe while your body is still responding according to an older map. And that is important because sometimes we judge ourselves for behaviors that originally developed as protection. Dr. Gabor Mate often talks about the tension between authenticity and attachment, particularly in childhood. The basic human dilemma is incredibly powerful. We need connection, we need belonging, And when expressing some part of ourselves threatens connection, we may learn to suppress that part. Maybe you learned that anger made you difficult, so you stopped expressing anger, you repressed it. Maybe you learned that meeting people made you weak, so you became hyperindependent. Maybe you learned that sexuality was shameful, so you disconnected from desire. Maybe you learned that your emotions were too much, so you became very easy to be around suppressing your emotions. And eventually you become incredibly skilled at maintaining relationships while having less and less access to yourself. that is one of the costs of chronic adaptation. You can be loved for the version of yourself that you learn to present while still wondering whether anyone would love the parts you have hidden. Bessel Vanderkock, author of The Body Keeps a Score, has also been influential in bringing attention to the way overwhelming experiences can continue to shape the body, attention, emotion, and behavior long after the original event has passed. Experiences don't simply disappear because we intellectually understand them. You can know logically that your partner is safe. You can know they love you. You can know They don't have to be perfect and still feel your chest tighten when they become disappointed. You can know that you are attractive and still panic when someone doesn't initiate sex. You can know that you're allowed to have needs and still feel guilty when you ask for something. The body can carry patterns that the conscious mind has already outgrown. And this is why intimacy intelligence has to include the body. you can't always think your way into feeling safe. Sometimes you have to notice what your body is doing while you're trying to connect. One of the most common relationship performances is probably the simplest. I'm fine. You're not fine. You're disappointed. You're hurt. Misunderstood. You're lonely. You wanted affection. You wanted sex. You wanted reassurance. you wanted your partner to notice something without having to ask. But instead you say, I'm fine. And maybe you're trying to avoid conflict. Maybe you don't want to be needy, or you don't want to burden them, or you're afraid they'll reject what you need, or criticize you, or get hurt. So you perform being okay. And then Something interesting happens. Your partner responds to the version of you that you presented. They think you're fine. So nothing changes. And now you're even more resentful because they didn't respond to a need they were never actually given the opportunity to see. This is where performance can quietly erode intimacy. The other person can't respond to information they don't have. And now let's bring this directly into sexuality. There is an enormous cultural script around what sexual confidence is supposed to look like. You should know exactly what you're doing. You should always want sex. You should be able to get aroused on command. You should be able to maintain an erection. You should know how to make your partner orgasm. You should be adventurous. You should be dominant. You should be sexy 24/7. Or perhaps you should be completely relaxed and Effortlessly sensual. There are scripts for everyone. And when you believe you need to perform confidence, your attention can become focused on whether you're successfully demonstrating confidence. That is very different from actually feeling confidence. Real confidence can include uncertainty. For example, it can sound like I don't know if this is going to work, but let's see. Tell me what you like. Can we slow down? I want to try something. I'm nervous. I really want you. Can you touch me here? That doesn't feel good. Can we stop? Those statements require a tremendous amount of presence, and they require enough internal safety to tolerate being honest. And now consider this: what happens when the role you've been performing for years becomes part of your identity? If you're always a strong one, receiving help can feel very uncomfortable. If you're always a successful one, failure can feel devastating. If you're always the independent one, dependence can feel dangerous. If you're always a sexual one, having a low desire period can feel like losing yourself. If you're always the good partner, having an unpopular need can feel like becoming a bad person. If you're always the calm one, Anger can feel frightening. And this is where Jungian psychoanalyst James Hollis explores the question of whether we are living from conscious choice or from inherited expectations and adaptations. At some point, we have to ask ourselves: is this actually who I am? Or is this who I learned I needed to be? That question can change a relationship Because once you can recognize the role, you have more choice about whether you want to keep playing it. This can feel surprisingly vulnerable. Imagine saying to your partner, I actually don't know what I need right now. I want more affection. I feel jealous. I'm scared you're losing interest in me. I want to try something sexually, but I'm embarrassed to ask. Or even I've been pretending I'm okay and I'm really not. Your nervous system will probably react. your heart might start racing, you may feel heat in your face, your stomach might tighten into a knot, and you might suddenly want to take it back. You may laugh or want to change the subject or think, why the fuck did I say that? That doesn't necessarily mean you've made a mistake. The work is learning that you can experience activation without immediately escaping it. This is where somatic awareness becomes so important. Noticing the breath, the jaw, the chest, the stomach, whether you're leaning toward the person or pulling away. Notice the urge to explain yourself or the urge to make a joke or to say, never mind. You don't have to immediately fix. The feeling. You can become curious about it. And this brings us to something we've already started exploring in this series: presence. And I'll keep coming back to presence time and time again because it is essential for so many reasons. Presence means you're actually in the room with the person. You're aware of what you're experiencing and you're aware of what they're experiencing. You're able to respond. rather than simply follow an old script. In sex, presence might mean noticing sensation rather than evaluating your performance. In conflict, it might mean staying connected to your body while listening to something difficult. In emotional intimacy, it might mean saying, I don't know what to say, but I'm here. In desire, it might mean noticing what you actually want before deciding whether it is acceptable. And in a relationship, presence might simply mean allowing yourself to be a person rather than constantly trying to be a particular kind of partner. That is a very different way of relating. Most of us perform to some degree. We all have roles. We all have social conditioning. We all have ways we've learned to protect ourselves. The question is whether the performance is flexible. Can you take the armor off sometimes? Can you admit you don't know? Can you ask for something? Can you say no? Can you receive? Can you disappoint someone and remain connected? Can you let someone see you when you're struggling? Can you be sexually honest or emotionally honest? Can you stay connected to yourself when someone else has a different experience than you do? That is where intimacy intelligence begins to become practical. It's not simply knowing what intimacy means, it's recognizing what you do when intimacy becomes uncomfortable. Do you perform? Do you withdraw? Do you pursue? Do you fix? Do you become sexually seductive? Do you become overly independent? Do you shut down? Do you become the person you think the other person needs? And once you can recognize the pattern, you have something incredibly valuable. You have choice. You can pause, you can breathe, you can feel, you can communicate, you can decide whether the old strategy is still serving you. And that is a big part of what I mean when I talk about intimacy intelligence. It's the ability to understand what is happening inside you and between you and another person well enough that you can participate consciously in the relationship. And sexual intelligence takes that into the sexual realm: your body, your desire, your arousal, your boundaries, your patterns, your communication, your pleasure, Your ability to stay present. Because ultimately the goal is not to become better at performing intimacy. It's to develop enough awareness and enough safety so that you don't have to perform quite so much. So, a few things to take with you from this episode. We all develop roles in relationships, and those roles can begin as a way of finding belonging, safety, approval, or protection. Over time, they can become so familiar that we mistake them for our identity. The nervous system is involved in this process, constantly responding to cues of safety, threat, connection, and rejection. And sometimes our bodies continue to respond to old relational patterns, even when our present circumstances are different. Performance can show up as perfectionism, people pleasing, emotional control, hyper-independence, sexual performance, or simply saying, I'm fine when you're not. The invitation is to become curious about the role you're playing. What are you trying to protect? What are you afraid would happen if you stopped performing? And who might you become if you had a little more freedom to be yourself? Because intimacy requires presence. And presence requires the willingness to actually be there for your own experience while allowing another person to experience you. That is where we start moving from performance toward connection. This is the Confessional Booth. If you like this episode, please rate it and subscribe and refer it to anyone you know who may benefit. To find out more about what I offer, head over to my website mariewagner.ca on Facebook, YouTube, and LinkedIn at MarieWagner, and on Instagram at the MarieWagner Coach. Subscribe to my weekly email love letters for all things sex, love, and relationship. The link is in my IG bio. And try my free, exclusive, guided, gentle breathwork session. Have sex with your breath. The link is in my Instagram bio or website. Thanks for being here. See you in the next episode.