Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Endowment Effect Makes You Overvalue Your Work
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot on this show about cognitive biases that affect how other people perceive you—like the halo effect, the spotlight effect. But today I want to talk about a bias that affects how you perceive your own work. It's called the endowment effect. Luna: The endowment effect. I've heard that term in behavioral economics. It's the idea that we value things more just because we own them, right? Lucas: Exactly. And it was famously demonstrated by Richard Thaler—the Nobel laureate in economics—in the 1980s. He gave half a class of Cornell students a coffee mug, and then offered to let them trade it for a chocolate bar. The students who had the mug valued it at nearly double what students who didn't have the mug valued it. Luna: That's wild. A mug they just got handed, and they already couldn't part with it. Lucas: Right. And the effect is real and consistent. In a 2012 meta-analysis covering over 80 studies, researchers found that the endowment effect is robust across different goods and contexts. And it's not just about mugs—it's about ideas, projects, processes, even our own job roles. Luna: So how does this play out in office politics? I can imagine a few ways, but I'd love to hear your take. Lucas: Let's start with a concrete scenario: you're in a salary negotiation. You've been working on a particular project for six months—you've put in late nights, you own it. And you're convinced that project is worth way more to the company than it probably is. So when your manager offers a raise, you feel slighted because you're anchoring on your own inflated valuation. Luna: Yeah, and I've seen that happen. A friend of mine spent a year building out a new reporting process—she was so attached to it. When her boss suggested they streamline it, she took it as a personal attack. Lucas: That's classic endowment effect. She 'owned' that process, so giving up even a small part of it felt like a loss. And loss aversion is a cousin of the endowment effect—losses hurt about twice as much as equivalent gains feel good. Luna: So you're fighting to keep something that might actually be inefficient, just because it's yours. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a political liability. If you're known as the person who defends their turf no matter what, you become hard to collaborate with. People stop suggesting improvements because they don't want a fight. Meanwhile, someone else who's more flexible might take that idea and run with it. Luna: So what's the antidote? How do we check ourselves before we get too attached? Lucas: One tactic is to mentally 'un-own' the thing. Ask yourself: if I didn't already own this project, would I fight to acquire it? If a new hire proposed exactly the same process, would I think it's brilliant, or would I have reservations? That reframing can help you see the actual value. Luna: That's like a reverse endowment effect—pretend you don't own it. Lucas: Right. Another tactic is to get market data. In salary negotiations, for example, you can benchmark your role against industry surveys. That external reference point is a powerful anchor that overrides your internal bias. Instead of 'I deserve X because I've been here and I own this project,' it becomes 'The market says this role is worth Y.' Luna: And managers can play this too. If you're leading a team and you see someone getting overly attached to their work, you can introduce a pre-mortem. Like, 'Assume six months from now, this project has failed. What went wrong?' That distance can help people let go. Lucas: That's a great technique. A pre-mortem forces you to detach from ownership and think critically. And it's not just about projects—it's about ideas. In meetings, people often defend their pet ideas long past the point where the data says otherwise. That's the endowment effect on ideas. Luna: Speaking of ideas, I remember a study where researchers asked people to generate ideas for a new product, and then later asked them to evaluate their own ideas vs. others'. People consistently rated their own ideas higher, even when objectively they were no better. Lucas: That's a perfect example. And it creates real friction in brainstorming sessions. Someone's idea gets shot down, and they take it personally. But if you can frame feedback as 'we're trying to make the idea better, not kill it,' you reduce the defensive reaction. It's a small linguistic shift but it matters. Luna: So the endowment effect is always there, but we can design our processes—and our conversations—to counteract it. Lucas: Exactly. And if you've found these kinds of frameworks helpful in your own career—thinking through moves, negotiations, or just navigating office dynamics—consider supporting the show. We keep it ad-free thanks to listeners like you. You can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, but it helps us keep going. Luna: Yeah, we really appreciate it. And it makes a difference. Okay, back to the endowment effect—another area where this bias shows up is in performance reviews. Lucas: Right. When you've owned a project for months, your perception of your contribution is inflated. You might think you did 80% of the work, while your teammate thinks they did 60%. Those don't add up, and it creates resentment. Luna: So you go into a review feeling underappreciated because you're overvaluing your own contribution. Lucas: Exactly. And the manager is looking at the same project with a different set of reference points—they're comparing it to other projects, other teams, market standards. So there's a built-in conflict driven by the endowment effect on both sides. Luna: What's the fix there? Besides the pre-mortem? Lucas: One thing is to keep a 'brag file'—a running document of your achievements with concrete metrics. But don't just save it for review time; share progress updates regularly with your manager. That way, when review comes, the data is already out there. The endowment effect is about ownership, but if you make your work visible to others, their perception can serve as a check on yours. Luna: So it's not just about managing your own bias, but also about influencing how others see your work—without the bias. Lucas: Right. And that's a political skill in itself. The most effective people I've seen don't hoard credit or overclaim; they make their work transparent and let the results speak. That builds trust, and it also makes it harder for the endowment effect to distort their own self-assessment. Luna: Let's also touch on how the endowment effect plays into organizational change. When a company restructures, people cling to their old roles, their old processes, their old teams. Lucas: That's a massive version of it. And it's one reason why change management is so hard. You're asking people to give up something they own—their current job, their current desk, their current status—for an uncertain future. The loss aversion is twice as strong as the potential gain. Luna: So how do leaders navigate that? Just acknowledge the loss? Lucas: Partly. Good change leaders explicitly validate what people are losing—'I know you've built this process, and it's been valuable. But here's why we need a new one.' That recognition can reduce the defensive reaction. And they often give people a sense of ownership over the new thing—let them help design it. That transfers the endowment effect to the new, desired behavior. Luna: So you're leveraging the bias instead of fighting it. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a recurring theme in office politics: understand the biases at play, and use that understanding to navigate more effectively. The endowment effect is just one of many, but it's a powerful one because it's so automatic. Luna: One last thought: I've noticed that the endowment effect is stronger for things we put effort into. The IKEA effect—we value furniture we built ourselves more. That's like a subset of endowment. Lucas: Great connection. In fact, we did an episode on the IKEA effect a few episodes ago. They're related but distinct. The endowment effect is about ownership per se; the IKEA effect adds the effort component. Both can distort how we value our work. Luna: So if you've spent months on a project, you're doubly biased. Lucas: Right. So the most practical takeaway today: the next time you feel strongly attached to a work output—a report, a process, an idea—pause and ask, 'If I didn't own this, would I still think it's this good?' That one question can save you from a lot of political missteps. Luna: And save you from some awkward performance review conversations. Lucas: Indeed. Thanks for listening, and we'll see you in the next episode.