Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 190:18-27. Niddah: Kesem, Stains: Location and Assumptions

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 190:18-27. Niddah: Kesem, Stains: Location and Assumptions · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  OK, good morning. We are continuing some Simon kuf
• 0:03
  Saadi we are on. We're at Sif Yudkat OK to do
• 0:09
  Talia to right. We're gonna discuss with
• 0:12
  Khatamim here. Let's read Kevansh Khatamim
• 0:15
  Durabana. Now we already learned the whole
• 0:18
  din of khatam, right? You find the spot without any
• 0:22
  Hargasha. So it's all Durabana Mekeelin
• 0:25
  Bahim. So then we're more Makil than
• 0:29
  not. In other words, vitola bakkola
• 0:32
  var shiokhola lead lot. So anytime we see bleeding, even
• 0:37
  if it's on a white baggage, even if it's more than a grease, we
• 0:41
  say she's going to be Tahara. If there's any way to be told to
• 0:45
  assume it came from something else other than from Dom, from
• 0:50
  the McCord, that would make her that that that Mamaco would make
• 0:54
  her Tamaya. So we're going to assume
• 0:55
  whenever possible that's from somewhere else.
• 0:58
  Has to be reasonable. OK, how reasonable.
• 1:01
  It's OK, let's go on, Kate said. Now just remember, caveat, the
• 1:09
  next many CE theme are partially Lamisa, partially not anymore,
• 1:17
  right? Are are our behavior is a little
• 1:20
  bit different, not to mention we wear tight undergarments.
• 1:24
  So it changes the entire playing field for the Salaha, which we
• 1:27
  mentioned and let's read it inside Keitza shakhta behave
• 1:32
  makaya of. So she shakhta either any kind
• 1:37
  of a animal or a bird only to ask a biktamim or she dealt with
• 1:44
  something that gives stains, whether it's pain or blood or
• 1:48
  whatever. Oh, she yash right.
• 1:51
  Or she took care of a child who was bleeding.
• 1:53
  That can happen whatever it is. Oh yashwa betzad Hamid asking
• 1:58
  baham or she sat next to somebody who was dealing with
• 2:02
  such a situation. Oh, she Avra Bashuk Shalta Bahim
• 2:07
  or she went to a slaughterhouse or the the open market where
• 2:11
  there are well, they have they slaughter animals and we don't
• 2:16
  usually see this, but venin Saddam a big idea Tolebahen.
• 2:21
  So then if she sees actual blood, right, more than a
• 2:25
  grease, she says it's probably from one of these other things,
• 2:29
  right. It's not during her period, it's
• 2:31
  not during the vested. It's not when she expects it
• 2:34
  anyways. But bottom line, regular den of
• 2:36
  Ketta, anytime she has what to be tole on, we say she is an
• 2:42
  Utah hora afilo veshe shloka lokim zeh al zeb and imsafilo
• 2:48
  bittakhton tahora. So then even if she has, I don't
• 2:52
  know, we'll just call it 3 skirts or dresses, one on top of
• 2:55
  another and it's on the inner one.
• 2:57
  It can come from the floor and it can even even reach the inner
• 3:02
  skirts or slit, whatever you want to call it.
• 3:05
  And she's wearing a coat and a dress.
• 3:07
  We can say it can get it can come from there.
• 3:11
  OK, how's Evan Imsa feel a bit right.
• 3:14
  Even if she has no under underwear, we can still assume
• 3:17
  it came from the floor or from underneath.
• 3:19
  And she's tahara avala Ian Imsa al bisara anatola.
• 3:26
  But if that's if she finds the Ketchum on her on her on the
• 3:30
  clothing, if she finds it kept them on her skin.
• 3:34
  So we're that's a little different.
• 3:36
  We're more strict. We're not so likely to be told
• 3:39
  on something else. Ella imesh la maka begufa,
• 3:44
  unless she has some kind of a wound, she has a cut, she has
• 3:48
  something where that's also from her skin and it can and it's
• 3:52
  right. It's attached to her body.
• 3:53
  And so that's more likely to be from there.
• 3:56
  Then we assume it's more likely to be from a maka than it is
• 3:58
  from the makor. I was told about Philo al bisara
• 4:01
  inhuba Malcolm EF shar ladame la natef Michel.
• 4:06
  So as long as it's a reasonable scenario that the blood went, it
• 4:11
  could be, it could drip, it can. Whatever it is has to be in the
• 4:15
  same line of fire per SE, but it can even, you know, anyways, as
• 4:18
  long as it can get reasonable from the maca to the to the area
• 4:24
  on the skin where she found it. But we don't say that.
• 4:27
  Oh, maybe her hand touched it like it was on the back of her
• 4:31
  neck. We don't say their hand touched
• 4:33
  it. And then her hand afterwards
• 4:37
  took enough blood from there that she put it somewhere else
• 4:40
  and that it moved to there. That's that's the one thing we
• 4:42
  don't do. But if you need to repet, even
• 4:45
  if it starts to heal, even if Sharul al ET Galea, if it's
• 4:49
  possible that it's if it has like it has a little bit of a
• 4:53
  scab on it already, it's possible for it to open up and
• 4:58
  bleed from there. Lahotsi dam, I'd right you rub
• 5:01
  it hard enough or scrape it and then that scab can open up.
• 5:05
  We all know that's often possible until it's almost
• 5:08
  finished healing until the end stages.
• 5:11
  So then Toleba, you can assume that the bleeding came from
• 5:16
  there, the awful Pisha Akshav Allah Allah krum, even though
• 5:19
  now there's a scab over it, the inamit taftafit and we see it
• 5:24
  doesn't bleed from there. If it's possible to have that it
• 5:27
  opened and the blood from there Lithia ayan.
• 5:29
  But it's possible that it's, it got opened up, it bled and then
• 5:34
  it's sealed and you know, you can touch it with your finger,
• 5:37
  but it's not easy. You know, after a few minutes or
• 5:39
  an hour or whatever it is or a couple hours, it doesn't just
• 5:42
  lift up anymore. So anyway, anyways, that's the
• 5:45
  that's the principle and just a couple other modern day things
• 5:49
  that may I mentioned that I saw mentioned in the Piscay Tahara,
• 5:53
  but you can see others for him. Other examples where you can
• 5:56
  sometimes be tola eh Akula and say she's Tahara is if a woman
• 6:02
  shaves in the in the makoma Erva.
• 6:05
  So sometimes with the with the razor that can cause a maka.
• 6:08
  So that could be another thing to be tola on.
• 6:10
  She just shaved. If there's red urine she sees
• 6:15
  sometimes after eating beets or whatever it is, that can cause
• 6:19
  red colors. I don't know, some kind of
• 6:22
  stomach, intestinal illness or hemorrhoids, anything that
• 6:25
  causes bleeding. If that's the situation, one has
• 6:29
  to just realize, you know, before you, you jump to say, oh,
• 6:31
  it's ketem, it's usser, perhaps it's from there.
• 6:35
  That's if just has to be the same type that's normal for her.
• 6:40
  Sometimes there's bleeding with another color discharge,
• 6:42
  sometimes there's not. This has to be what's logical.
• 6:47
  Sometimes not so common. I guess it depends on the
• 6:49
  quality, but you can have a patterned or a colored clothing,
• 6:53
  some white and some other red color.
• 6:55
  The dye can run. Anyways, whatever is it could be
• 6:58
  tolean. It could be tolean.
• 7:00
  OK let's go to your Tet shame Chitoleva kaktola bivnau ubala.
• 7:07
  Just like she can be tolla on herself dealing with blood
• 7:11
  issues, then you can tolla also she hangs around with her son or
• 7:17
  husband. Even Nitasku be telling if her
• 7:20
  son or husband we're dealing with any of these blood stains
• 7:24
  or whatever it is. Oh imesh baham maka or if they
• 7:27
  have a maka wound on their skin, lafisha darkum ligaba.
• 7:32
  Since it's normal for a wife or a mother to touch their spouse
• 7:38
  or their their child. So therefore we we could be even
• 7:43
  not only if she has a mock or has been with the blood, even if
• 7:45
  her if they were or whoever she's dealing with, right?
• 7:49
  However, she's dealing with people that she touches all the
• 7:52
  time or doesn't touch all the time.
• 7:53
  Usually not, but depends on the case of Emiya Suki and Badam
• 7:57
  right? So obviously a nurse, especially
• 8:00
  anyway, I am hayu Asukhi and Badam if they were dealing with
• 8:04
  blood, but LO nimza bahim dam ina tolabahim.
• 8:07
  But if they're not dealing with blood and there's no and they
• 8:10
  don't find any blood on them. So then you now, generally we
• 8:14
  say if there's even if it's a maka, though, you don't have to
• 8:17
  actually see blood as long as you know that they have a maka
• 8:19
  that could be opened up anyways, Ala Inka Nayu Asukhi and Badal
• 8:23
  version Darko Lintas or she they were dealing with something that
• 8:28
  can squirt blood to go on shrita.
• 8:30
  Right when you cut the even if you know they don't have any
• 8:34
  blood on them, but they were they did a shrita.
• 8:36
  That's normal for the blood to squirt.
• 8:37
  So then that can also be a reason Coyote say BA in any of
• 8:42
  these cases that you could think of, it's reasonable.
• 8:44
  We could be told of who I didn't IM shakba bemito nashim
• 8:48
  sheshalamakod begufan. Also, she sleeps on a bed with
• 8:52
  other women and they have a mock on their body.
• 8:57
  I'm totally behind Kamal bivna ubibala.
• 8:59
  Same thing. It's it's right.
• 9:00
  It's not a din me you had to the son and the husband.
• 9:02
  It's just that's what's more common.
• 9:06
  The other woman is a needa. Yeah.
• 9:10
  Then you could be told on that too.
• 9:12
  Sure. OK.
• 9:13
  Cough. OK.
• 9:16
  MI shiraguya latsate MI menu dam Derek P ha AMA.
• 9:21
  So if a man it's normal for him to see blood from his from his
• 9:26
  Xavier, so then it's so that's not normal, obviously, but it's
• 9:32
  right. It's not normal.
• 9:33
  But for him again, whatever that this is just the case, whatever
• 9:36
  is normal for him. We're not even we're talking not
• 9:39
  about you, not when he goes, you know, to urinates.
• 9:41
  It's just it's because he's not going to urinate inside his wife
• 9:45
  while they are together. Ubisha Tashmish.
• 9:48
  So now they're together. So it's normal for him to have
• 9:50
  bleeding and he's in his right during Tashmish Nimsa, but Eid
• 9:56
  hai ishadam and then she finds, when she does ebidika, she finds
• 10:01
  blood right then. So then tola bibala, she could
• 10:04
  even be tola Anabala as the beer gras quotes the rashbhaba en la
• 10:09
  hamaka gedola mizzo leitlod BA. We know you can be tola anamaka.
• 10:14
  So too you. We know the husband bleeds, so
• 10:16
  we could be tola. It's from the the husband,
• 10:20
  right? And again, just it could even as
• 10:23
  a piece of Cuba points out, not that these cases are common, but
• 10:27
  it could even happen in this case where a couple days later,
• 10:30
  if it's normal for her to have Shikhwat whatever for things to
• 10:33
  come out a couple days later is whatever is normal.
• 10:36
  You can still be tole on the husband for Dom, it's a couple
• 10:41
  days later, whatever is normal for this for this woman,
• 10:45
  whatever is reasonable. OK, then we could be tole if OK,
• 10:49
  let's go to kafala. Hey ika the ashka khatam bishi
• 10:53
  puleo mehreya umaka ICA mikame Talia BA the ashka de yatva hak
• 11:00
  de batra atela kame venatva miyahimaka.
• 11:04
  So a woman she has a a khatam. She finds it on the back of her
• 11:09
  clothing, but the maca is on the front of the clothing.
• 11:13
  So then we still say we could be toler because when she's it's it
• 11:19
  all depends on the matsias. If it's possible that when she
• 11:23
  sits down at the outskill, when she sits down, so then the the
• 11:30
  clothing and that's in on her back moves around to the front
• 11:34
  and it can reach it. And it all depends on the type
• 11:37
  of clothing that the person has. If it's possible for the
• 11:40
  clothing to move around and reach it or bend and listen,
• 11:44
  twist, whatever is possible. Even if they bend over and sit,
• 11:48
  we discussed, then we can be totally on that If it's
• 11:51
  impossible. So then we just say that's not
• 11:54
  reasonable. Yeah, he's quoting us.
• 11:56
  OK. The rival Rd. isn't probably in
• 11:58
  RMA. I don't know.
• 11:58
  I don't know. Cuff base.
• 12:00
  Sorry. Safik in avra Beshukh Sholta
• 12:03
  Bakhim. So now she's not sure if she
• 12:07
  passed the Shukh Sholta Bakhim, right?
• 12:09
  The marketplace where they have slaughters, Oh IM Yashva now
• 12:13
  it's loved off because slaughter is if you go to a marketplace
• 12:16
  and the meat or the fish is all is bloody.
• 12:18
  So that's the same. It's it all depends what's
• 12:21
  reasonable. Oh IM Yashva Bitsad Hamid
• 12:24
  asking, Hey, but if it's everything is OK anyway and if
• 12:27
  she sits next to these those right.
• 12:31
  So the case over here is it's a Suffolk in that situation, or
• 12:35
  she's right with people who deal with Tamim with any kind of red
• 12:38
  stains, Ina told Ibrahim she cannot be.
• 12:43
  Since it's a Suffolk, she cannot assume it's from there.
• 12:46
  Bah medvari memoriam by Irsha TA Bahim Amit Azimuth, Tam Yoshima,
• 12:51
  Malcolm Edua. That's if they have their
• 12:54
  stationary store, they have their place.
• 12:57
  Nowadays that's usually how it is.
• 12:59
  They have their place. So there was no way for them to
• 13:02
  come to her. She would have to pass by and be
• 13:05
  next to them. So in order to be tole, she
• 13:09
  would have to know that at least she went there.
• 13:12
  So at least then there's a chance about Imdarko MIT Asik
• 13:15
  convicon. But if they move around, you
• 13:18
  know, they they have a little their store is a little wagon
• 13:22
  and they go from street corner to street corner or one day
• 13:26
  here, one day there, whatever it is, whatever is reasonable about
• 13:29
  Imdarko MIT Asik convicon Tolin. Then you could she could we
• 13:34
  could assume it's from them. Even though she didn't go there.
• 13:37
  She doesn't remember going next to them because they can.
• 13:39
  They could have come to her by feeling me Suffolk, even if it's
• 13:42
  a Suffolk Shamma need to ask about Malcolm.
• 13:45
  She Avra villa here Gisha and maybe there she they were next
• 13:49
  to her and she didn't quite realize.
• 13:51
  OK, Puff Gilman need to ask Abedavar Edom.
• 13:55
  She was dealing with Adam, right?
• 14:00
  Adam, of course. So she was dealing with red, the
• 14:03
  Nimza Alea Ketem Shahor. So we kept saying, well, she was
• 14:07
  need to ask Bakhtani if she was dealing with whatever.
• 14:11
  So, so it depends. It has to be the same color.
• 14:14
  Let's say we're going to assume two different colors and they're
• 14:17
  both a mare of Tamaya. We're going to assume two colors
• 14:21
  generally black and red, but we assume our Dom, but they're two
• 14:28
  different colors. So the point is blood change can
• 14:31
  change a little bit and become more black.
• 14:33
  But if we act if but as far as being told on dealing with, you
• 14:39
  want to be told that it wasn't her Dom, it was let's say an
• 14:43
  animal or paint red paint red paint's not going to change.
• 14:46
  But anyways, for this concept of being Tola Lahacquel, so we say
• 14:51
  it has to be the similar, relatively similar color, right?
• 14:55
  But if one is red and one is black, that's too that's too
• 14:58
  much. That's then we say it's not
• 15:00
  reasonable. Oh, ibka, the opposite, right?
• 15:03
  Black and red the opposite ain't tolling both.
• 15:06
  Then we cannot be told the meddwar memoriam.
• 15:09
  When do we say that Adom Bashar, Bashar be adom.
• 15:12
  That's with red and black adom whatever aval adom BA adom.
• 15:18
  But if it's red and a red, but it's still a little bit
• 15:20
  different red, the shakur, the shakur black and black a little
• 15:24
  bit a little bit different. I feel in Eno Nikar Mama shadow
• 15:27
  mellow, even though it doesn't quite look the same.
• 15:31
  All right, you can't tell that it's coming from the same.
• 15:34
  You can still be told about you could be because could go on.
• 15:37
  She can ask Abimei Tilton, Abimei Bassar Bikilor Adom Kzat
• 15:43
  or any kind of red, whether it's and whatever the red's coming
• 15:47
  from. But it's a little bit, it's a
• 15:49
  little bit different or it's also like watered down a little
• 15:52
  bit, a little bit. Anyways, tola Bo ha Adam, you
• 15:55
  can just say, well, it's close enough.
• 15:58
  It's the same family of colors. And we know she dealt with it.
• 16:02
  She was touching with it, she walked by it.
• 16:04
  And therefore we could be tola lahaka OK kaftala NIT ascar
• 16:11
  paternagola tola Bo adom V shahor V kharkomi lafish Adam
• 16:15
  shrita Adam vidam ivera shahor vidam vinaya kharkomi.
• 16:20
  So if she was dealing with chickens.
• 16:23
  So just like a chicken has different colors, different
• 16:28
  shades of blood. So therefore, as long as any one
• 16:33
  of them can match, then it it works.
• 16:35
  So then we can be told so the OK cough.
• 16:39
  Hey, stay in Ashim. You have two women shenid asko.
• 16:45
  This is an interesting case. Two women shenid asko.
• 16:48
  But Sipore Echad, they are both dealing with one chicken, right?
• 16:52
  We're trying to use one bird. We're trying to use this bird or
• 16:56
  chicken, whatever it is to be tolle, right?
• 16:59
  Chickens are bigger. So we're using a small bird for
• 17:01
  this case. And we're using the blood of
• 17:04
  this bird to say, well, the blood that's on her clothing,
• 17:08
  Mistama is from the bird and not from her, not from the Domicor.
• 17:13
  So the problem is there's two women who dealt with one.
• 17:17
  They're trying to use the same 1 bird that they dealt with to be
• 17:20
  Tolla, but there's Shane Bodum, Ella Casella.
• 17:25
  But there's only enough blood that can come out of this bird.
• 17:28
  The amount of acella, whatever that is, it's the size of a
• 17:34
  coin. I think you're saying it was.
• 17:35
  It's thick. It's thick enough to be for two.
• 17:37
  I don't think we do that. I don't be Mccalla can say Bain
• 17:41
  la cula, Bain la kerma. We don't look at 1 area and say
• 17:44
  well, you know, if you could slice it thin enough, we can
• 17:47
  replicate it. If a ketam is smaller than a
• 17:50
  grease, we don't say, well, it's thick enough, maybe in every
• 17:54
  direction. I've I haven't heard of anyone
• 17:56
  doing that. I think it means the the area.
• 17:59
  Anyways, let's read the example. Shain Bodam, Ella Casella.
• 18:03
  There's only enough area for one cella, right?
• 18:06
  And it's obviously we're talking about more than a grease venimza
• 18:10
  alcohat casella. But each woman has a sela of
• 18:16
  blood on her. The full amount that's on the
• 18:19
  essentially the point is we have a case.
• 18:22
  We want to be tola on one bird, but it's not possible that both
• 18:27
  women came from this one bird. And we have no other birds or
• 18:31
  any other shook or any other situation to be tola.
• 18:34
  So what do we do? We have no choice but to say
• 18:36
  well, like every other Kasich had done, my stomach came from
• 18:40
  her since it's more than degrees and there's not enough here to
• 18:43
  be told and tooth. So what's the halacha Shitehan
• 18:46
  tamayo? Do we say both of them are
• 18:49
  tamaya now this happens to be an interesting discussion.
• 18:53
  Mokhokastaz and Shah, the Shah and the Bach both hold the case.
• 18:58
  We say they're both tamay only if they ask at the same time
• 19:03
  because there's no way to turn. We know for sure 1:00 we we know
• 19:07
  there is there. We all see them.
• 19:09
  It's the situation. And we can't just discard and
• 19:12
  say everyone's taller because there's only one to use and you
• 19:15
  can't pick. So you have to end up by saying
• 19:18
  both are to males. The taz holds if one comes after
• 19:24
  another. So when the first lady comes and
• 19:27
  asks the rabbi, he could say she's he.
• 19:30
  We say she is Tahara and then when the second lady comes and
• 19:34
  the rabbi goes oh, oh, Oh my gosh.
• 19:37
  And then he has to call the other lady and tell them both
• 19:40
  that they're to male. That's the that's how the tazler
• 19:44
  and said Kochikane. If they come at the same time,
• 19:46
  anyway, they're Michael Lucas had to deal with Tosos had to
• 19:48
  deal with these issues. And we have this interesting
• 19:51
  issue come up a few times. We had it with Paso Bukhalo and
• 19:53
  every case is a little bit different, but had to deal with
• 19:57
  it. OK, let's go on to Kaf Vav.
• 20:04
  You'd ask of Badam she E after she a man with Khatam.
• 20:08
  I like a Greece. So there's no way you're dealing
• 20:11
  with a situation and she it can't be that this Khatam one
• 20:18
  second. How do you read this?
• 20:20
  She dealt with it and there's only enough for one grease and
• 20:24
  she has two greasing on her her raise it tola.
• 20:28
  KE Greece badam shint ask about UK Greece BEMA Colette inside
• 20:35
  Quetta mutera missione Greece in Timaea.
• 20:39
  So then the halacha was like this.
• 20:41
  Basically you you didn't have more than it's right, because
• 20:44
  the sheer is Greece of ode to drop more than a Greece.
• 20:47
  If it's actually an exact Greece or less so, then she's Tahara
• 20:52
  that's with Keta. So here she dealt with it.
• 20:56
  So if there's any way to be told that one came from what she was
• 21:01
  dealing with, it's only the maximum amount that can come
• 21:04
  from what she was dealing with was one Greece, but there's
• 21:07
  still one more Greece. But we could be told that since
• 21:10
  that's in total, you can you can still say that one came one
• 21:15
  amount. One Greece came from a Maholet
• 21:18
  from the the lice. So Akina.
• 21:20
  So it's so, yeah. So you ended up you can add on
• 21:25
  to 1 what she was dealing with and Akina, which gives you an
• 21:29
  extra grease. So you have you can get a bigger
• 21:32
  shear than a grease and still end up Sahara, but you can only
• 21:37
  be. But since you can only be in
• 21:39
  your specific case, there was a maximum of how much she was
• 21:42
  dealing with that you can rely on.
• 21:45
  And the maximum of Akina is a grease.
• 21:47
  Exactly if it's any bigger than that.
• 21:50
  So then she ends up being Tamaya.
• 21:52
  I hope that was clear enough. The Asia Mahmirian Umatami
• 21:56
  Mccoset and the the Hamas says no.
• 21:59
  Once you're dealing in this case, some are Mahmar Mikomakom
• 22:03
  near the Asia Makhala Mikilian, the Katami Mahaka.
• 22:07
  But the Hamas says no, no, we stick with the Shah Khanaras the
• 22:09
  way we just explained, because even though it's a Mahokat,
• 22:11
  Katami and General are Dera Bannan and we are a Miko,
• 22:17
  Suffolk Duraban and the cool cops sign you Tasco Apache make
• 22:22
  a Greece, the name Saliac, a Greece, the ode.
• 22:24
  So she was dealing with less than a Greece.
• 22:26
  And then she finds on herself a Greece, the ode.
• 22:30
  She's still Tahara Shani, Omar Ketenzema, Esakatami, Mulkovar,
• 22:34
  Hayasham dhamaakhola perusha Dhama Kina, right?
• 22:37
  Mahola. Thinkina's the same thing.
• 22:39
  So she was dealing with let's say half a Greece and now she
• 22:43
  has a grease of oath on her. So we say half of it comes from
• 22:47
  what she was dealing with, half of it comes from the kina.
• 22:50
  She needs staref, a love that gets added to it.
• 22:54
  Very similar to the case of Kafag al Shahazar, Leo,
• 22:57
  Teramika, Greece until it's too big.
• 22:59
  Once it's bigger than a Greece. So then it becomes a problem.
• 23:05
  Even on the no. Usually if it's on the bizarre,
• 23:11
  it depends on the case. But usually when it's on
• 23:14
  bizarre, we're not so quick to be told on something.
• 23:16
  She was dealing with the maca. Yeah, but something else, unless
• 23:21
  it's on her and. And the skin and the clothing
• 23:24
  also. That's go back to what you read
• 23:28
  yesterday, I think. OK, fine.
• 23:33
  Yeah, I think so. I'll just the next line.
• 23:39
  Basically everyone deletes the Shah, the the the gras because
• 23:43
  it doesn't make sense to us. He writes Vaheni Niskala pako
• 23:47
  niska Grizin in Salya Kishne Grizin and the shokanura that I
• 23:52
  have says Tahora and that they had everyone says it should be
• 23:55
  Timaya. It's must be a tautsa Sofir
• 23:59
  because it's it's double. It's bigger than what it than
• 24:02
  than Akina. Whenever there is an unexplained
• 24:08
  right and you play time, it's more than an unexplained Greece.
• 24:11
  OK, right, Malcolm Ibn Taska badam veni odad bakama zina
• 24:18
  Nakula, right summer Malcolm. But again, we generally go
• 24:21
  Lakula for not sure if Anrina and Shahaya Badam Kishi or
• 24:25
  Hakata. And if we're not sure if it's
• 24:28
  more than a Greece or not. So we just go again Lakula and
• 24:31
  final stuff.