Latest / The STA Clinician Podcast / STA208 'Statutory Regulation For Sports Therapists?' Matt Phillips, Gary Benson, Anna Maria Mazzieri
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the Sports Therapy Association podcast, putting evidence
- 0:04back into soft tissue therapy.
- 0:07Music.
- 0:17How are you doing? Welcome to the Sports Therapy Association podcast, episode 208.
- 0:25My name is matt phillips creator of runchatlive.com and
- 0:28as always this episode is being recorded live on the sports
- 0:30therapy association youtube channel and facebook page so if you are listening
- 0:35to the podcast and you're thinking oh i'd like a little bit of that i'd like
- 0:37to go and hang out with like-minded soft tissue therapists maybe ask questions
- 0:41directly to our guests then all you need to do is go along to one of those places
- 0:45normally on a tuesday at eight o'clock but for For full details,
- 0:48just follow UK underscore STA on any social media you so choose and you will be updated.
- 0:54Or best thing, subscribe to our YouTube channel and then you'll get notifications
- 0:57every time we're about to go live.
- 0:59If you do join us live, then thank you very much. It means we really hope a
- 1:02few of you do join live tonight because it is a great opportunity to add your
- 1:06concerns and reflections.
- 1:07As we start this episode entitled Statutory Regulation for Sports Therapists,
- 1:13joining me will be gary benson founder
- 1:16of the sports therapy association and anna maria
- 1:19mattieri director of the st school and together
- 1:22we'll be discussing the topic of statue statutory regulation for
- 1:25sports therapists what are the pros and the cons is it something we
- 1:28should be striving for is it a pipe dream that could never really
- 1:31be achieved even if we wanted it so if any of
- 1:34you out there have questions more so than ever i really want
- 1:36you to chime in in fact if you are are joining live what
- 1:39i'd love you to do to give us an idea is in the comments just
- 1:42write what your profession is are you a sports therapist are
- 1:45you a sport massage therapist are you a sports rehabilitation specialist or
- 1:49are you hopefully you've got some allied health professionals out there i'd
- 1:52love to know that if you're a physio chiro diatrist chiropodist or anything
- 1:58else that you might be because we'd love to hear your experience of being regulated
- 2:02because that's the that's a very important part as well i'm just joining us
- 2:06in the live lounge now just to say hi Hi, when you do join us live,
- 2:08then I can bring your comment and question and your logo up.
- 2:11For example, Imi Tester, listening on my drive home from work. Good.
- 2:14Eyes on the road, Imi. I know how addicted to getting involved in this you are,
- 2:19but concentrate first. Safety first.
- 2:20Sir Glenn Murphy, MBE. That's where the level is with this podcast.
- 2:24We get all the hierarchy coming in here. So Sir Glenn Murphy,
- 2:27MBE is here as well, saying good evening all.
- 2:29Stevie Barr, that shows the other end of the spectrum. Yeah.
- 2:33Sorry steve i couldn't resist that i'm just saying diversity inclusion is massive
- 2:39on this podcast because we've got stevie saying i'll do good people in a scottish
- 2:43accent which i can't do i'm sorry steve you can hit me at therapy expo for that
- 2:46cecily hislock good evening good people.
- 2:49Stevie oh good people are putting in there we got sports therapists we got sports
- 2:53massage therapists sports massage
- 2:54therapists i'm hoping some allied health professionals turn up as well,
- 2:58and because i did put what you mean to stevie sorry stevie anyway right so yes
- 3:02do use the comments tonight people would love to hear anything is on your mind
- 3:06with this very interesting topic,
- 3:08just to let you know after this episode there
- 3:11is going to be a summer hiatus of two weeks with no podcast i
- 3:15know but we're giving you that time to reflect to pause because what we really
- 3:21want to do is do a follow-up to this episode with hopefully some representatives
- 3:25from the other professional associations for sports therapists and we'll all
- 3:29get around kind of a virtual table and hopefully have a chat about what can we do? Is it a reality?
- 3:33Can we work together to help statutory regulation actually become a thing?
- 3:40So I'll send that invitation out to you now.
- 3:43And we'll talk about other associations and bodies and that as the show goes on.
- 3:47But first, let's do it. Without any further ado, I will now bring up my guests,
- 3:51Gary Benson, founder of the Sports Therapy Association, and Anna Maria Mazzieri,
- 3:56director of the ST School.
- 3:59Music.
- 4:10Hi gary hi anna good evening good evening thank you so much as always for giving
- 4:15up your valuable time i'm sure you haven't even had dinner yet i imagine so thank you for joining us.
- 4:22For those i mean people who are regular listeners to the podcast and and people
- 4:26who may not listen to the podcast will be aware probably of both of you the
- 4:30great work you do in our industry for people who don't know you which i always
- 4:33hope there are people who don't know you gary maybe Maybe, first of all,
- 4:36could you give us an idea of who you are and what you represent?
- 4:40And yeah, that would be great.
- 4:42Yeah, I founded the STA over a decade ago now,
- 4:46really to plug a gap in the representation for people with foundation degrees,
- 4:52diplomas, advanced diplomas, when the then largest professional body in the
- 4:59industry limited access to their membership to graduates only.
- 5:05And there were people who trained with the likes of the Rayworth School Active
- 5:10Health Group, the International Institute of Sports Therapy,
- 5:13who were left without representation.
- 5:15I'd already been working in the industry for quite some time and felt that I
- 5:20could offer the support necessary for those people to thrive in their business.
- 5:25Fantastic. Thank you very much. And Anna Maria Mazzieri. I'm a clinician.
- 5:30I have a background in massage therapy, soft tissue therapy,
- 5:35and graduated sports therapies.
- 5:37But I always say I like to address myself as a soft tissue therapist because
- 5:44it's way more representative of what we do, what I do.
- 5:49And I also run the SD School, which has been established since 2008.
- 5:55And I've been teaching for even before that, since 2006.
- 5:59And for my scenes, I've been around long enough and I've been involved at different
- 6:04levels within professional associations and in,
- 6:09me and Gary know each other from the industry quite a bit and this issue of
- 6:17regulation has been coming in and out for many years and so it's great to be
- 6:24invited to discuss this one.
- 6:26Fantastic, thank you very much. And for listeners who aren't aware of my background,
- 6:30just in case, i'm matt phillips i started i
- 6:34started off in swedish massage back in the
- 6:37early 2000s coming
- 6:41from a strength and conditioning background and my family my
- 6:44brother in fact basically i would kind of
- 6:47bend them in the gym upstairs and he'd mend them downstairs in the clinic so
- 6:50it was a wonderful relationship we had but then i was interested in working
- 6:53with the hands-on as well as the exercise prescription so
- 6:56i got into that in the early 2000s like i say and that's
- 6:59how eventually as i moved up and did cbd and stuff i ended up gary
- 7:02was actually one of my tutors as you mentioned in the active health
- 7:05group when i did my level five there later on so i was interested to see what's
- 7:08level five all about and and then hence after meeting the gary benson i had
- 7:14no choice but to join him when he invited me to be a member of the sta and because
- 7:19you have very common themes in mind when it came to yeah being a professional Association.
- 7:24One of the few out there who we will mention, who just want to provide support for clinicians.
- 7:29And indeed, this podcast came out of that, particularly in the COVID pandemic,
- 7:33because more and more clinicians needed support.
- 7:36Suddenly, they were reaching out rather than keeping all in,
- 7:38which was great. Probably helped a lot of clinicians maintain their business.
- 7:41And here we are today, 208 episodes, two weeks, weeks later on, episodes later.
- 7:48So that's where I'm coming from. So great.
- 7:50Here we go then. It's a massive topic. We're going to try I'll try and do it
- 7:53now, but like I say, there will be a follow-up.
- 7:55I've got a kind of a structure down here, which I'm going to take it through.
- 7:58But like I say, if there's any questions out there, people who are listening
- 8:00live and do jump in, because this really is a case where your questions,
- 8:03you're on the shop floor, you're working therapists.
- 8:06And we want to know how you sit in your personal situation.
- 8:09So I think maybe to start off and maybe I'll turn to you, Gary,
- 8:13first of all, I think a good place to start is maybe talk about one of the best
- 8:18known statutory regulators out there for health and care professions,
- 8:21especially when we talk about physios, for example, and that's the HCPC.
- 8:25So maybe, I don't know whether you could do it in brief, but what is the HCPC,
- 8:29Gary, and what do they do?
- 8:31Well, the HCPC is formerly the Health Professionals Council,
- 8:36the HPC, oversees the 14 regulated professions in England,
- 8:4212 in Scotland and 13 in Wales.
- 8:47They answer to the Professional Standards Authority, who are the overarching regulator.
- 8:52Regulator they have a mixture of hdpt type
- 8:56general osteopathic council and more
- 9:00recently the accredited registers so that's the
- 9:03hierarchy it's the professional standards authority healthcare professionals
- 9:06council fantastic and we should mention that there's loads of titles in there
- 9:11very varied i mean i had to look some of them up but that's just my my my lack
- 9:15of information but yeah we've got loads of people physios are both well known
- 9:19for being part of them but they also So regulate podiatrists, chiropodists.
- 9:23We've also got in there arts. Would you know what an art therapist is?
- 9:30Have you heard that before?
- 9:32I mean, I think if we look at regulation, Matt, regulation has always been touted
- 9:37as a way to protect the public.
- 9:40So my perception of wanting to protect the public means that the therapy being
- 9:46provided, the intervention being provided is dangerous.
- 9:49Now, I don't want, in inverted commas, my industry, you know,
- 9:54the remedial, the sports therapy industry, to be labelled as dangerous.
- 9:57And that's one of the reasons that I don't think that statutory regulation is appropriate.
- 10:02I can go on to the other reasons later on.
- 10:06Oh, right. Just to put it into perspective of how much...
- 10:13Money changes hands here, okay? If you look at the HCPC and just take one of
- 10:18their professions, which is the Chartered Society of Physiotherapists,
- 10:23if you just look at the CSP fees, 65,000 physios each paying £442 per year.
- 10:32Extrapolate the figures, £28.75 million.
- 10:36And that's from one profession, and that doesn't take
- 10:40account out that some people don't pay the full amount because there might be student
- 10:43members or affiliate members but that's the
- 10:46type of money we're talking about in 2010 the
- 10:49estimate to regulate a further profession was between three and
- 10:52five million pounds in what was called machinery of government that's the time
- 10:57taken in the houses of commons and lords to actually go through the process
- 11:02to legislate for it to be statutorily regulated and that's undoubtedly gone
- 11:07up and And if anybody listened to the Treasurer's,
- 11:11the Chancellor's speech yesterday,
- 11:13they're trying to save £22 billion.
- 11:16I don't see us anytime soon having
- 11:19the machinery of government required to regulate further professions.
- 11:22And that's reinforced by three government white papers since 2010,
- 11:26enabling excellence and reforming regulation.
- 11:29OK, so one of the obstacles is the money, which in fact was one of the things
- 11:35which we'll mention later on. and somebody did bring that up,
- 11:38is some people don't realise the cost of it. But I don't want to get too negative straight away.
- 11:41I was going to kind of hope that you guys were going to save your personal opinions
- 11:44until a bit later on, but you've made it quite clear now that you are totally against the idea.
- 11:48But I'm interested still in the idea of the HCPC, because this is what a lot
- 11:54of people are attracted to the idea of it.
- 11:56Is that by having a regulator, then they do have kind of key functions of maintaining
- 12:01standards of efficiency and conduct.
- 12:04And this is a really important one, I think, and affects our industry,
- 12:07approving education and training programmes, which health and care professionals
- 12:11must complete before they can register.
- 12:13And then also the other one, which I think attracts people to this,
- 12:16is maintaining and publishing a register of health and care providers.
- 12:20So you've got three determined professional requirements and standards of practice.
- 12:23So I know Anna's jumping to get in here yes i'm
- 12:26dying paper that for me i'm going
- 12:29to play devil's advocate here for me that sounds like exactly what our
- 12:31industry needs and the public need oh yeah absolutely sorry
- 12:35i didn't talk about absolutely that you know we don't have
- 12:38you know most of it i agree with you
- 12:41here we're talking about statutory regulation that
- 12:45is it's you do not you're talking
- 12:48about standardization and we're talking about statutory regulation you
- 12:51do not need to be start to regulate it
- 12:54to have standardization of training
- 12:59of quality and on
- 13:02abilities of providing and some of the nhs services and i'll give you some examples
- 13:08after so what is our needs in the industry i'm sure that here we all agree that
- 13:15we want standardization of quality go and talk to
- 13:20osteopaths, chiropractors and physiotherapists that they are structurally regulated
- 13:25and ask them if their training is standardised as we think it might be.
- 13:32So being structurally regulated is to protect the public for those interventions
- 13:40that they have a risk ratio where the public needs to be protected.
- 13:49The only thing I would say that.
- 13:53The i agree with gary that we do
- 13:56not have as a we do not think we have as a
- 13:58higher risk ratios and maybe other professions i would argue though that that's
- 14:04the only part that i that i would argue for a statutory regulation that what
- 14:11is harm it's not just physical harm so we can be by the the lack of standardization.
- 14:19We can certainly harm clients with no civic language and old narrative and lack of training and so on.
- 14:27But in general, I think we are discussing two different things.
- 14:31The need of standardization and the need to have a centralized register that
- 14:39helps us keep the accountability in our industry and start a re-regulation.
- 14:44The two, they don't have to go, they don't have to be.
- 14:49And I would say, being following HCPC and for those ones, HCPC has been criticised
- 14:56quite extensively for not being fit for purpose.
- 15:00So, you know, it's not all roads is what is out there.
- 15:07At the last and the promised and I'll let Gary go, it's quality,
- 15:13sorry, being staturally regulated does not necessarily mean quality.
- 15:19There are other ways that we can demonstrate and we can raise our profile in the public domain.
- 15:28Of quality that does not have to be estate registered
- 15:32okay great points let me just
- 15:35break that down a little bit so yeah i it's interesting
- 15:37i think that's a really important point that listeners need to take on board that
- 15:41statutory regulation is not the only way to get standardization of quality and
- 15:46training there's other ways without that might not incur the fees which gary
- 15:50picked up on because it's important to remember that and people already kind
- 15:54of saying steve steve and bar has already stood in the comments hey where the
- 15:57hell does that money go What's it used for?
- 15:59And that is a really important question and one that often is not answered a lot.
- 16:03It's a lot of money. Where does it go and what cars are they driving?
- 16:07So it's it's an important question.
- 16:09The other interesting thing I wanted to pick up on was the health thing for me personally.
- 16:15And again, I'm playing devil's advocate a little bit. it i worry
- 16:18that there is a danger in what
- 16:21you said anna maria of manual therapists
- 16:24soft tissue therapists with the best intentions in the world getting
- 16:28their cups out giving that 100 sorry an
- 16:31hour of acupuncture whatever it is some mode i'm not dissing any
- 16:34particular mode or application but doing this oh please do a repeated client
- 16:38for like eight sessions with all the best intention in
- 16:41the world they might not even be charging that much so probably not but missing
- 16:44red flags bags miss not looking at that case because they've been trained in
- 16:49such a way that that's that's the only tool they've got it's the old thing if
- 16:53you've only got a nail what you're going to do you're going to hammer it so
- 16:55you can protect i think there is a danger you're adding to.
- 17:01Undiagnosis or misdiagnosis by not asking the right questions and not knowing
- 17:05when to send people on so that would be my only comment of where i think statutory regulation,
- 17:09or definitely some standardization is needed because people with the best intention
- 17:13in the world are delaying proper necessary treatment.
- 17:16I am pretty sure that all, everybody here, Gary, I'm not sure about you,
- 17:20but I'm pretty sure that we all here agree that we need standardization of quality.
- 17:25At least the base, you know, at least the, so standardization of quality is not under scrutiny.
- 17:33Okay. All right. I'm interested then. Don't forget, people, if you've got questions
- 17:37in there, then do kind of leave them in the comments so we can get to them.
- 17:42Um if we're talking about standardization yeah
- 17:45and and i'm just going to make up locations a
- 17:49sports therapy degree we're
- 17:52talking about sports therapists there's no
- 17:55minimum standard of education you know we
- 17:58we've got members who've come from the ex-military who
- 18:01might be an exercise remedial instructor they might
- 18:04be coming from a sports coaching background you know
- 18:07a strength the conditioning background and transitioning and adding
- 18:11skills and therefore meeting the national
- 18:14occupational competency standards as a sports therapist but if
- 18:17you went to Wales as an example and enrolled on
- 18:20a degree that degree might be called a sports exercise and massage therapy degree
- 18:26and it might be heavily weighted towards manual therapy if you go to the northeast
- 18:33you you might do an honours degree and it might be heavily weighted towards
- 18:38strength and conditioning.
- 18:39If you go to Scotland, just as another example, and do a degree,
- 18:42it might be heavily weighted towards sports trauma.
- 18:45And if you go down to the Southeast, it might be heavily weighted towards.
- 18:51Pitchside first aid so there's no standardization
- 18:54and a degree is a degree and and
- 18:58what happened in 2013 and one
- 19:01of the reasons that the sta was born was because there was a discriminatory
- 19:07policy against people who've done a foundation degree at level five achieved
- 19:12a certain benchmark and then did a top-up but those people who took that route
- 19:17came out with a sports therapy honors degree Now,
- 19:21how can we differentiate between a sports therapy honours degree and a sports
- 19:24therapy honours degree?
- 19:25And that's my point is that there isn't standardisation. It'd be very difficult to standardise it.
- 19:31And the number of universities seeking accreditation has dropped immeasurably.
- 19:36Plus, the amount of universities delivering
- 19:38these programmes has dropped exponentially over the past two years.
- 19:42You know my local college and university they are
- 19:45not running their their foundation degree and degree
- 19:48in sports therapy that one of them still maintaining a master's so
- 19:52there's lots of things going on but you know if you could put up that you know
- 19:58the reason that we're having this chat matt we've got that screenshot haven't
- 20:01we of the post that was put out recently which stimulated lots of of our members
- 20:07to get in touch and then i felt incumbent to issue a response to that.
- 20:12Okay, hold on, whoa, whoa, whoa, you're jumping the gun. I'm going to bring
- 20:14that out, go on. There's one other question just to pick up some things.
- 20:18I love the idea and I want to talk more eventually about this idea of standardization
- 20:22without statutory regulation.
- 20:24What about the protection of protected titles?
- 20:27Because that's the other thing that comes with statutory regulation is you're
- 20:30not allowed to call yourself a physio unless you have got everything which is
- 20:35being processed and handed over.
- 20:37And so we know there's a standard there as well.
- 20:40Can you have a protected title without statutory regulation or is that something
- 20:44which should only be achieved if you have got statutory regulation?
- 20:46Because it would be very useful if all universities offering sports therapy
- 20:49had the same syllabus and the same kind of regulated thing where you're all
- 20:52getting the same product because it would help patients to know what they're getting.
- 20:56Employers, there wouldn't be this, I'm paying one person to do the job and they're
- 21:01terrible, this other person could be great.
- 21:03So how does that until until we until
- 21:06everybody every stakeholder sits around the same table and
- 21:09comes up with some cohesive forward plan
- 21:12that can't occur because at the moment there's
- 21:15no minimum standard of education my granny could
- 21:18call herself a sports therapist with no training whatsoever and
- 21:21nobody can stop her okay the protected
- 21:24title it's you know
- 21:28i don't know what people want from that protection of title you know
- 21:31if people ask me what my title is i always say i'm a
- 21:34facilitator i'm here to facilitate outcomes that you desire i never use i'm
- 21:38a you know a teacher i'm a you know a graduate sports therapist i'm a diploma
- 21:42sports i never i never say that i'm just here to facilitate your your goals
- 21:48your outcomes so it's it's really difficult to achieve that and And even with a protected title,
- 21:54like physiotherapy and physiotherapist,
- 21:58there's lots of people on social media calling themselves physio.
- 22:03And as much as HCPC, you know, get in touch with them and say for every proven
- 22:09case, it's up to £1,000 fine.
- 22:12Physio is not a protected title, neither is sports physio. so
- 22:16it's not it's not the therapy has become
- 22:19a verb for what we do to people rather than
- 22:22a title yes it implies something
- 22:25on on a on a weekly basis
- 22:28i'm i'm contacted by members who are saying yeah
- 22:31but you know i'm in the phone as gary the physio
- 22:34because that's what people put us
- 22:37down as i've got dave the plaster and shane the electrician in
- 22:40my phone somebody might have gary the
- 22:43physio and doesn't matter how many times i
- 22:46tell them i'm not a physio oh yeah but that's
- 22:49what i think of you as so it's all about public awareness you
- 22:53know there's lots going on in the background and you
- 22:55know i've had to support quite a few of our members with in in discussions with
- 23:01hcpc around that if you remember a couple of years ago we there was the whole
- 23:05thing about hashtags if you use a hashtag physiotherapy in your social media
- 23:09posts are you inferring you're a physio or are you trying to engage with that community?
- 23:15Yeah, yeah. I'm just thinking, would you be worried if you had a mate calling
- 23:18himself Gary the dentist or Jane the GP?
- 23:21Well, that's what it's got outside. They wouldn't do it, would they?
- 23:24Because they wouldn't have the balls to do it. There are cases,
- 23:27you know, if you go back five, ten years when tooth whitening was all the rage
- 23:34and you had clinics setting up for tooth whitening.
- 23:38That had to be regulated because it was a part of dentistry.
- 23:42At the moment, we've got really invasive treatments that are not regulated.
- 23:49We've got the CSP have come out and said because of the exponential rise in
- 23:53pneumothoraces from thoracic needling, well, acupuncture is not regulated.
- 24:00Aesthetics, you can go to your local physician, somebody pump fillers into your
- 24:06lips and your eyelids. with no regulation and no checking at all.
- 24:10And this is where, for me, the term protected title,
- 24:16and there is this discussion quite often in another forum of physiotherapists,
- 24:20and you hear them getting quite upset by the local sports therapist or sports
- 24:25massage therapist calling themselves a physio.
- 24:28Most of the time they do so without the awareness of the protected title.
- 24:33And my comment is always, why is he bothering you?
- 24:40So the protected title was something that was for physiotherapists,
- 24:44was something that was born when there was the need.
- 24:48That need has changed. The workforce has changed. Should we protect the title
- 24:53or should we protect the occupational competencies?
- 24:56Disease so because now that we're
- 24:59going towards a more inter interdisciplinary
- 25:03multidisciplinary the cross-pollination between osteopaths
- 25:08physiotherapists chiropractors is the name that we should protect or should
- 25:13we protect the ability to work with occupational competencies i.e the abilities
- 25:19in my set in my case in our case the ability to work with people with pain in an injury.
- 25:24That should be protected. So people that do not have at least a certain minimum
- 25:28of those learning outcomes and therefore those qualifications,
- 25:33then they cannot work with people.
- 25:37Not, you know, a title about, I could not care less if somebody calls themselves a sports therapist.
- 25:46So I always say to our students, for respect
- 25:49to the sports therapists that they have it in their
- 25:52diploma but a lot of
- 25:55occupational competencies are very
- 25:59similar across the board even with
- 26:02physios so shall we rethink the whole
- 26:05title protection of title within msk care well it has been thought you know
- 26:12if you look at the government white paper enabling excellence from 2010 that
- 26:16was a consultation over 18 months to two years discussing a more modern approach to regulation.
- 26:25There was then reforming regulation, I think, in 2017, 2019.
- 26:30And what came out of those is that the government, white paper stated things
- 26:37like the professional associations involved in the industries need to take more responsibility,
- 26:43embrace codes of conduct and ethics, have a disciplinary procedure,
- 26:49which in an unregulated industry, if one of my members did anything untoward,
- 26:54My only power is to revoke their membership.
- 26:57I can't stop them practicing. So that's the limitation.
- 27:01But, you know, look at the HCPC disciplinary procedure. We all know one person
- 27:05who's been going through it for over four years. Five years.
- 27:08It's not fit for purpose. And that's why the government are moving away from
- 27:13statutory regulation, unless it can be clearly demonstrated that that profession
- 27:18presents a grave danger to the public.
- 27:21And and the other thing is i'm sorry
- 27:24i know i'm sending you messages in private just oh i'm so
- 27:27sorry can you resist the temptation to sit forwards because your volume goes
- 27:29up about to a 10 out of 10 sit back am i
- 27:33okay am i that's lovely back there i'm just just you've got to take away
- 27:35that italian lurching forward a little bit
- 27:38just yeah sorry it's just i'm thinking of the
- 27:41podcast continue i'm sorry to interrupt madam now completely
- 27:45gone with my again straight away i said
- 27:47idiot and you that's it so that's it that's it
- 27:50so oh god
- 27:53that is no what i meant that out of
- 27:56that i think it was the 2010 or 2011 the
- 28:00professional associations they they sorry the government asked for a voluntary
- 28:07regulation in fact that was from the 2000 initial consultation from the king's
- 28:13fund that we needed to be looking for voluntary regulation.
- 28:18That's why the CNHC.
- 28:21To be laughed at, sorry, I'm not allowed to say that, but I'll say it.
- 28:26You know, that organization to be laughed at, that was born to be the voluntary
- 28:34register to help maintain the
- 28:37standards of the complementary health industry. Look what they've done.
- 28:44They got the funding from the government. they were not fit
- 28:47for purpose from the first place because the people let's say
- 28:51they did not understand the industry
- 28:54and then once they lost the funding they had to get
- 28:57any team that team d canary or tom d canary it's great yeah yes you know and
- 29:03then you you know you are you are in the same broad with crystal healers not
- 29:07no offense to crystal healers but what what happened anna maria When CNHC and
- 29:14the voluntary regulatory route was recommended,
- 29:16I was a profession-specific board advisor for three years to the CNHC for sports therapy.
- 29:23And when they launched their sports therapy register, certain criteria weren't met.
- 29:30154 people were accepted onto the register. I flagged that up and they said,
- 29:35well, what we'll do, we'll put them through a program of training to meet the
- 29:38occupational competencies which were missing.
- 29:40That never happened I chose to
- 29:43resign my tenure there now I
- 29:46just had a look yesterday and on the CNHC register
- 29:50which has been around for around about
- 29:5314 years give or take there are 90
- 29:56sports therapists and there
- 29:59are 54 sports massage therapists that's
- 30:03on one voluntary register another voluntary register is held
- 30:06by the FHT and this may be just the
- 30:09way that they are their website performs the
- 30:12functionality but there are 50 sports therapists and there
- 30:16are 50 sports massage therapists but when you look through the the these the
- 30:21skills that they have they may not have say sports therapy or sports massage
- 30:24so the industry as a whole has decided that voluntary regulation is not their
- 30:31desired route because it's it's not working because more people would have joined.
- 30:36And of those people who did join, lots of people don't renew.
- 30:42Hey there matt phillips here sorry to interrupt the
- 30:44podcast just 60 seconds to remind you that
- 30:47if you're looking for beard grooming products there is
- 30:50a sports therapy association discount code that will
- 30:53get you 15 off at the brighton
- 30:57beard company website the brighton beard company
- 31:00dot code at uk yes i am biased what
- 31:02with brighton being my hometown but the brighton beard
- 31:05company really do offer an absolutely amazing selection
- 31:08of luxurious beard balms and impeccably scented
- 31:12oils all handmade in small batches
- 31:15with 100% natural ingredients their current spring collection for example contains
- 31:20bergamot coriander thyme and lavender giving you a fresh and energizing essence
- 31:25with both citrusy and peppery notes making it the perfect gift for you a family
- 31:30member or any friend with facial hair.
- 31:32Go to thebrightonbeardcompany.co.uk and get 15% off now by entering the discount code STA15.
- 31:42Doesn't include already discounted bundles.
- 31:47So we started throwing some different letters in there, which is one of my,
- 31:51it just makes my brain kind of fry when I hear all these.
- 31:54So this is something I wanted to go on to just to clear up what we have got
- 31:57because we've got very similar letters so and acronyms so while
- 32:01at the moment the state of sports therapy is we
- 32:05haven't we're not regulated so instead there's a
- 32:08number of professional associations and correct me if i'm wrong here because
- 32:11if i may well be but there's their voluntary
- 32:14professional associations you can be a sports therapist and not belong
- 32:17to any of these and there's no legal need for
- 32:19you to do so but there are professional associations who
- 32:22offer for their services to provide advice and support like and
- 32:26as far as sports therapy goes i think we've got the sports therapy association which
- 32:29is us the sta you've also got the
- 32:32society of sports therapists we're going to mention as you mentioned earlier
- 32:35on gary probably stimulated this discussion by a recent post they did in relating
- 32:39to the new government and also we've got the sports therapy organization which
- 32:43is where i met you originally gary many many many moons ago as far as sports
- 32:47what therapy goes? Is that the three? Is there another left out?
- 32:50Well, I mean, they are the three who, in theory, develop resources which are industry-specific.
- 32:59You could argue that.
- 33:02The CNHC is not a membership body, that's a registration body,
- 33:06they don't offer any membership benefits whatsoever.
- 33:08But you could, as I've already mentioned, join the FHT or the CTHA as a soft
- 33:15tissue therapist, a sports massage therapist, or a sports therapist.
- 33:18But they tend to be more general on the complementary therapists,
- 33:22none of which I'm willing to diss in the same way as Anna Maria did.
- 33:26It because you might want to get into the table but
- 33:29that's interesting so because this is one of the other thing i want to lead
- 33:32on from here as far as sports massage goes and
- 33:35like you said we've got people there like the isrm sma
- 33:39fht i'm not going to start saying what they stand for because it's
- 33:42about sports therapy tonight and the ctha and but
- 33:45in theory because there's no regulation they could
- 33:48advertise themselves as sports therapists and there
- 33:51would be no problem at all but my other follow-up
- 33:55question is we're talking about regulation for statutory
- 33:58regulation or even standardization for sports therapists should
- 34:02people who are sports massage therapists and belong to these
- 34:04other associations and organizations are what is what we're talking about tonight
- 34:08relevant for them as well could they benefit from some kind of standardization
- 34:11would it come under the same umbrella as sports therapists would that need to
- 34:14be kind of separate well matt if we look at the the whole regulatory process
- 34:19that there was a precedent set called grandparenting.
- 34:24Now, let's just hypothesize that today the government have announced that sports
- 34:30therapy is going to be regulated on its anniversary next year.
- 34:35So the 30th of July 2025, sports therapists will become regulated.
- 34:42Now, between now and then, anybody who's a member of one of the stakeholders...
- 34:50We as the SCA we would fight your
- 34:53case for you to be accepted onto the register if
- 34:56you're not a member of the of any of
- 34:59the of the bodies specific to our industry you still
- 35:03have the right to apply to go
- 35:06onto the register and it's not beyond the
- 35:09realms of possibility that soft tissue therapists who have
- 35:13met the occupational competencies for sports massage
- 35:16of which there are two general ones there are
- 35:18some subsections within those if they've met
- 35:21the additional 12 competencies for sports
- 35:25therapy then in theory they could apply as
- 35:28well to be allowed onto the register the
- 35:31question is who judges that who
- 35:35is going to be responsible for making the decisions because the
- 35:38physios have the chartered society but this
- 35:42time next year we would have to have a representative council
- 35:46made up of people from the
- 35:49sto people from the sta and people from
- 35:52the sst one of us wouldn't say well you know we're taking this on board because
- 35:57that's not democratic we would all have to be involved in that which is why
- 36:02we're kind of inviting members well i said at the beginning representatives
- 36:05from the other two main organizations am i missing someone out here I've already
- 36:09upset Stephen Barr once.
- 36:11Can I just say, Stephen Barr mentioned SMTO. What's SMTO? The Scottish Massage.
- 36:17Oh, no, it's not Scottish Massage anymore.
- 36:20It's Scottish Manual Therapy Organisation.
- 36:23I'm sorry, Stevie. Yeah, we should mention that. My apologies for missing them
- 36:26out as well. And we could have a representative from regions like that as well. That'd be great as well.
- 36:30Yeah, and Basrad as well, which for people who aren't aware,
- 36:33British Association of Sports Rehabilitators. I just want to say one thing,
- 36:36and I'm not having a go, But I think there's.
- 36:39I don't think it's done on purpose, but people get confused.
- 36:42And I know there's been emails from STMMs and things, but like you go to, this is just an example.
- 36:46I went to Basra just to check, you know, what it's being advertised as.
- 36:49And there it says the British Association of Sport Rehabilitators,
- 36:52the UK regulator and professional association for sports rehabilitators.
- 36:56Now, to me, that sounds like, oh, well, sports rehabilitators have already got
- 36:59a UK regulator. Why can't we have that?
- 37:01But that's not the case, is it? That would be my interpretation.
- 37:04That's what it looks like it implies like. Matt, that doesn't just apply to BASRAP.
- 37:10And with respect to BASRAP, they've done some really good work on their international
- 37:15recognition program. Yeah, thumbs up to Olly Carbond, yes.
- 37:17For going through the voluntary accredited route through the Professional Standards
- 37:23Authority, and they maintain their register. That's their business model.
- 37:27I personally don't believe that accredited registers are solving anything.
- 37:32Thing they're just perhaps adding another layer of bureaucracy
- 37:35to the process but we've got it in our industry and i'm going to read if i may
- 37:39from one of the stakeholders websites just to just to highlight the confusion
- 37:44that is out there for for yeah i was gonna say about the psa let's mention about
- 37:49the psa so the psa the professional standard authorization is there at the regulator
- 37:54of all those councils.
- 37:57So PSA regulates HCPC, regulates Basrat.
- 38:03So HCPC is actually accountable to PSA.
- 38:10And that's what I mentioned earlier, the PSA are the overarching regulator.
- 38:14You know, if I wanted to start an accredited register today,
- 38:18it would cost me in excess of 25,000 pounds,
- 38:24of hoop jumping and fee paying to
- 38:27get an accredited register additionally there's an
- 38:31annual fee of twenty something thousand pounds
- 38:34plus a pound or two per member so
- 38:37you could hypothesize that Basra are paying thirty thousand pounds a year for
- 38:41the privilege of holding the accredited register and Gary the other thing is
- 38:45for the for the for those people that they do not know us for those the audience
- 38:50that do not know us we you listen to us in podcast but we work.
- 38:57Extensively so those are all options that have
- 39:00been explored oh you
- 39:04know let's have a look what it is so you do that your calculation you
- 39:07think what can that bring so if i
- 39:10have to pay minimum of 25 000 pounds for my
- 39:14members what i will bring to my
- 39:16members in terms of benefit that i will have
- 39:19to raise their annual fee so
- 39:23much more and you think of you know so those
- 39:26things have been already explored especially from people like us that we've
- 39:30been around for a little bit long enough to to have had the opportunity to explore
- 39:35if i could go on matt going on from yes definitely So we're going to have some
- 39:39examples of the confusion that's easily seen from different stakeholders.
- 39:43So from one of the major stakeholders in this industry, the sports therapy organization,
- 39:48this is taken from a screenshot of their website today.
- 39:50And if anybody wants to verify these facts or to challenge this information,
- 39:56I urge you to write to them.
- 39:59If you are a member of the STO and you are led to believe what this statement
- 40:03is correct that I'm going to read out, challenge them. Make them accountable for their actions.
- 40:09When I read out from the SST website, challenge them.
- 40:14Don't come to me. All I'm doing is presenting publicly available information. So I'll read.
- 40:21And I quote, we, the STO, are an organisational member of the GCMT,
- 40:27the General Council for Soft Tissue Therapies, are a sports therapy regulator
- 40:33and a PSA accredited register.
- 40:38We are also an organisational member of the Federation, the International Federation of Sports Medicine.
- 40:44That is factually incorrect. They are not a sports therapy regulator.
- 40:49They are not a professional standards authority
- 40:52accredited register that's one example the
- 40:56second example the gmct did
- 40:59that last year and i i got quite attacked because
- 41:02i replied to the comment this i don't remember what it
- 41:05was but they said something about we got together and created these new policies
- 41:11which therapists must follow no you're not the regulator this is a this is a
- 41:19direct quote from the Society of Sports Therapists website today.
- 41:25A sports therapist who is a member of the Society of Sports Therapists is an
- 41:32allied health professional who has the knowledge, skills, and ability to,
- 41:37and then they list five competencies.
- 41:40So I went on to the allied health professionals websites for England,
- 41:45which is 14 professions sessions and sports therapy is not listed.
- 41:49For Scotland, there are 12.
- 41:51It's not listed. And for Wales, there are 13. It's not listed.
- 41:54So if you are a member of the SST and you believe you are an allied health professional,
- 42:01please write to them, make them accountable for that statement.
- 42:07So there we go. This is why we need to have a conversation around the table,
- 42:10because I mean, just to make sure it could be outdated information.
- 42:12It could be a website that hasn't been updated.
- 42:14We're just saying what this we check today where they carry on the website.
- 42:18So this is currently what's being displayed and it you can't go away from it.
- 42:22It is confusing for therapists.
- 42:24It's dangerous. And yeah. So this is the sort of thing we want to talk about.
- 42:29So when people are interested in going down the route of statutory regulation,
- 42:33we've all got to get together in case of the fee.
- 42:35People are making choices of their university degrees out of those texts because
- 42:41they think they're going to be stately regulated because they think they're
- 42:46not going to be just, into bracket,
- 42:49massage therapists because they all look down at us massage therapists.
- 42:54They're making those decisions to go university because they think they can have NHS jobs.
- 43:01It's tricky. So this is the importance of being very, very clear at those stages.
- 43:09Matt, can I just say something? I want to address some of the concerns that
- 43:15have been sent to me this week and some of the messaging that's in here.
- 43:19Why can't we have one body that covers sports therapy, one body that covers sports massage?
- 43:26And I think that's an issue for commercialism.
- 43:31Okay. Now, I admit that I add to the problem.
- 43:40By creating the STA, I added to the problem, and I did it for the right reasons.
- 43:48I was involved. I was invited to be the chair of one of the other organizations
- 43:52we've mentioned previously.
- 43:54And I resigned probably about nine or ten months later for a mixture of personal
- 44:00and professional reasons.
- 44:01And I decided to set up the STA. And I did that because I'd made promises to
- 44:07people in the industry, in my job as an assessment strategist,
- 44:11a lecturer and an instructor, that I could represent them.
- 44:15I'd been a member of the GCMT Council. council i'd been a member of the sport
- 44:20remedial therapies council when it put together the curricula for for sports
- 44:24and remedial therapies in the in the late noughties and and i represented,
- 44:30you know i'd been a sports therapy advisor to other associations and
- 44:34other other people so i thought i've got the skills i've
- 44:37got the contacts i've got the knowledge i've got the experience and i
- 44:40don't want to feel anybody leaving isolated feeling isolated so
- 44:44i add to that political climate by doing this
- 44:47but i i say you know and on judgment day i'll
- 44:50stand at the pearly gates and i will be able to say with
- 44:53confidence that i have told the truth about this
- 44:56industry i have not done this for commercial
- 44:59gain because we're a not-for-profit association if
- 45:03anybody wants to check out the companies that
- 45:06we're mentioning now all you've got to do is go into company's house.
- 45:09Website website do a search for the
- 45:12company do a search for the people of significant control and
- 45:16you will see who who is running these and who who in
- 45:19theory is taking the money somebody mentioned where
- 45:22does all the money go where does all the money go great points
- 45:27yeah look right so look where are we 2047 yeah
- 45:30so we're just again we're not our objective
- 45:34here is not to is it vilify vilinify
- 45:37vilinify i can't remember the word is no we're not picking on
- 45:40anything particular just showing that the a lot of people
- 45:42say yeah we know it would be great to have fantastic standards
- 45:46of practice and education training but in the case of sports therapy because
- 45:49the history of it and the way there are different associations with different
- 45:53ways of running things it's not that easy which is why we all want to get around
- 45:56the table and kind of talk about it which which brings us on to what you mentioned
- 46:00early on gary and why we decided to have this podcast it was a post that
- 46:05was shared and and we got a lot of email you got a lot of calls didn't you gary
- 46:08i'll bring it up on the screen and i'll talk you through it people who are listening to the podcast,
- 46:12because this is why basically we made this episode let me just bring this up
- 46:16a moment so this was a post to share across social media and it was from the
- 46:22society sports therapists who are one of the three main professional associations
- 46:28for sports therapists just Just remember,
- 46:30hopefully we've made it clear that there is no one rule.
- 46:37Official association or regulator that represents
- 46:41all sports therapists out there okay it's
- 46:44just not it just doesn't happen so it's interesting to remember that as as we
- 46:48read this because it's important so matt if i may anna maria touched on the
- 46:54point earlier it's a it's a really valid point people are making decisions based
- 46:59on information that they are given at university at college etc
- 47:02and what they see on social media it's very
- 47:05true it's the power of social media good and bad they can't
- 47:09make an informed choice until they've
- 47:12got all of the information and all of this information is
- 47:15publicly available you can go to the hcpc website
- 47:18you can look at all of the minutes and and just on this
- 47:21you know on this post that was put up despite our
- 47:24continued continued effort since 1998 right the
- 47:29society of sports therapists was incorporated according to the company's house
- 47:33in 2002 okay so there's a disparity there the first hcpc meeting where there
- 47:41was a discussion of an application happened on the 1st of march 20 2006 and
- 47:46in my response to this i did list.
- 47:49And go through provide links to
- 47:52all of this information but if i may i'll read let me
- 47:55just read for people listen to the podcast who can't see the screen image
- 47:58i'll just read out what was on the post because then it will make sense yeah and so
- 48:01it's important to update on statutory regulation for sports
- 48:04therapists yeah an update from one
- 48:07of the professional associations so despite our continuous efforts and we're
- 48:10quoting here since 1998 which gary referred to
- 48:13the journey to regulate sports therapists has faced many
- 48:15political hurdles the hcpc's recommendation for regulation
- 48:18was made during the previous labour government but changes
- 48:22in government stored progress progress this recommendation still
- 48:25stands strong and has received unanimous recommend accommodation from
- 48:28a health select committee with a new
- 48:31government this might finally push through this vital regulation
- 48:34want to help let us know if you'd like a draft email to send to your local mp
- 48:39there we go we've got some context now so gary you've already kind of mentioned
- 48:42the dates don't really stand up but yeah yeah and then the second thing that
- 48:46concerns me it says the hcpc's recommendation for regulating was made during
- 48:51the previous government,
- 48:53the HPC, the Health Professionals Council, was the body at the time.
- 48:57And I appreciate it's the same thing. It's changed its name.
- 48:59But for clarity and for, you know, for detail, it has to be correct.
- 49:05At the meeting, this is the feedback.
- 49:08And I've just chosen three of the minutes, minute 8.4 from the meeting on the.
- 49:16The 1st of March 2006, the council noted that
- 49:19further clarification regarding the distinct scope of practice of this profession
- 49:24was necessary as there appeared to be substantive overlap between the work undertaken
- 49:30by sports therapists and the work undertaken by professions regulated by the HPC.
- 49:37It went on to say at 8.5 the council noted that clarification was required as to
- 49:44whether the possibility of a joint application with other professional bodies
- 49:48such as the British sports rehabilitators and trainer Basrat has been considered.
- 49:558.6 said the council noted it was unclear how many practitioners were using
- 50:02the title of sports therapist.
- 50:03The council noted that consideration needed to be given to the question of how
- 50:08the HPC would communicate with the
- 50:12individuals who were not on the voluntary register regarding grandparenting
- 50:17for the use of protected titles.
- 50:20So that was the first meeting.
- 50:23That's quite clear. There was, you know, HPC said there should be a consultation
- 50:28with BASRAP. To my knowledge, that never took place.
- 50:31I did have sight of an email around that time.
- 50:35I can't find it, so I'm not going to tell you what it said, but there was a
- 50:40decision made not to consult with Basrat.
- 50:42They now won't be interested because they've got the accredited route.
- 50:46The follow-up to this meeting where the answers were expected,
- 50:51and this was a meeting on the 11th of May 2006,
- 50:55the council noted that the society was experiencing difficulty in ascertaining
- 51:00a figure of how many practitioners were calling themselves sports therapist.
- 51:05The Society of Sports Therapists was a voluntary body and practitioners are
- 51:10not obliged to have membership of the society or the STO or the STA or any of
- 51:17the other bodies that the stakeholders involved in order to use the title sports therapist.
- 51:24The council noted that the entry qualification for the
- 51:27part of the profession covered by the society of sports
- 51:30therapists was at degree level that's not
- 51:33correct because at the time you could join the
- 51:36society on the back of a 20-day diploma from active
- 51:39health group or a 10-day diploma from sportstherapyeducation.com which was a
- 51:45company which was run by this person's insignificant control until 2020 were
- 51:51with the chairman of the society and his i i assume it's his partner his his
- 51:56wife because they have the same address in Glasgow.
- 52:00Those who had completed a degree represented only a small but growing percentage
- 52:05of those who call themselves sports therapists.
- 52:08It is likely that only a small percentage of those using the title would be
- 52:14eligible for grandparenting onto the proposed register.
- 52:18Okay, so what's the solution, Gary?
- 52:22I mean, it's the first thing is we need to all get together and talk this out
- 52:25because we're saying what these people have done in the past and it'd be really nice to have
- 52:29representative from the sto and representative from the
- 52:32sst to sit down and go and clarify some of
- 52:35the things there might be totally instant explanation or whatever but until we
- 52:38sit down and talk about these things in a public environment to let other people
- 52:41hear it then it's a little bit difficult to move forwards and talk about standardization
- 52:45it's it's very hard not to be political okay but if you look at the you know
- 52:53the support for statutory regulation and you look at
- 52:56the major stakeholders you know the SGA don't
- 52:59run any training and and and I can
- 53:02quite honestly say that if tomorrow the government
- 53:05announced that we were going to be regulated I would fight tooth and nail to
- 53:09have a position on the council or the board of the authority deemed necessary
- 53:16to take that forward okay but I would be quite happy that I'd done my job for
- 53:22our sports therapy members.
- 53:24That I could then hand over then that
- 53:27you know those people to the to the council if you
- 53:30like I would be upset because you know
- 53:32we've got a reputation for extremely efficient communication for comprehensive
- 53:40support and we don't just represent graduate sports therapists we've got graduate
- 53:45sports rehabilitators we've got soft tissue therapists we've got sports massage
- 53:48therapists And I would still want to fight the corner for them.
- 53:53So we've all got to get around the table. But if you look...
- 53:59What we called aspirant professions. They were people who wanted to be regulated.
- 54:04In 2012, when I was promised that we'd be regulated in time for the Olympics,
- 54:11in 2012, the HCPC removed sports therapists from the aspirant professions list.
- 54:18So we're no longer on there. The government have issued
- 54:21two white papers saying they only see
- 54:24statutory regulation being used in emergency
- 54:28situations in the future so we're
- 54:31talking about a minute point it's not going to
- 54:34happen we've got to get over that yes we could all
- 54:37sit around the table yes we could all join forces and be a really strong force
- 54:41for the voice of sports therapist but that won't happen when people who have
- 54:45got 1700 members paying 100 pound each have got an income of 170 000 pounds
- 54:51a year they might I have 2,000 students paying the equivalent of £75,000 a year.
- 54:57Go on Companies House, look how much money is involved in this industry.
- 55:02I'm independently audited. My accounts are online. Go and search them.
- 55:06Challenge me on them. Make me accountable, but make the others accountable too.
- 55:10There is also.
- 55:13For me, another point to that.
- 55:16Often, you have, in fact, even in this context here, I've seen some of the comments
- 55:22saying, can we have one body for sports therapies, one for sports rehabilitation?
- 55:29Actually, I like to have different professional associations because we're all
- 55:37a tiny little bit different.
- 55:38Or every professional you know i'm a member of several of
- 55:41them because i get out of each of them each
- 55:44of them they have a little bit their own little niche so having different professional
- 55:49association i think is very healthy and again it reflects i keep saying that
- 55:53but it reflects the the depth of
- 55:56the variety that we have in our beautiful industry the fact that we need,
- 56:03standardization of quality at least a minimal level that
- 56:07is something different would we
- 56:09need that would we need to sit around a round table to
- 56:12achieve that standardization i agree would we need
- 56:15that yeah with these people we're talking about we still have to have the conversation
- 56:18but it's not for statutory regulation it's for how do you get standardization
- 56:22of training can i say matt i i've been researching a little bit for my next
- 56:27projects and i do like what the foot health practitioners at DAN.
- 56:33So a foot health practitioner, for those of you that are not aware,
- 56:37a foot health practitioner is somebody that works, is support,
- 56:43in fact they're called support workers for chiropodists.
- 56:48They have level three and level four qualifications and the Royal College of
- 56:54Podiatry They started in 2021,
- 56:58so they started training, like individual training, private training, like it would be for us.
- 57:05All of it is vocational, so there is no BSc on it.
- 57:09But what they do, they can now apply for registration as foot health practitioners,
- 57:17support workers of the podiatrists under this Royal College of Podiatry.
- 57:25And actually, it works very well because it maintains the standards.
- 57:30So the Royal College of Podiatry looks after the standards.
- 57:35There is the application, competence has been mapped over,
- 57:40the quality, so they maintain the standards, they protect the public,
- 57:46but it's overseen by one.
- 57:50Plus you have all the other associations that look after the foot health practitioners.
- 57:55So it's a very similar profession than ours because they're a little bit autonomous,
- 58:00but not enough to be able to work with, like, for example, you know,
- 58:05a diabetes foot at a certain level.
- 58:08So that's why they have to then to refer to chiropi. But the way they're working
- 58:11towards it, I think, is something that we ought to look at.
- 58:16That's also repeated in the CSP now that they have physio assistants.
- 58:21Correct. They come from soft tissue, they might come from sports therapy,
- 58:25might come from sports rehab, but they're working in the NHS as exercise prescribers
- 58:30or, you know, physio assistants, essentially.
- 58:33And this is why I do think that having all this one to look after all might not be the best option.
- 58:40The other thing that often they say, I see, we don't get recognised,
- 58:45we don't have recognition as healthcare professionals. Right.
- 58:50Again, I say that the industry has changed.
- 58:54We need to push for different, to look at a different model of,
- 59:03we're talking about register, not even regulation, because I think some people,
- 59:08I think we're talking about regulation without really understanding the impact
- 59:12that regulation can have on a profession like ours.
- 59:17Can you remember during Covid there
- 59:21was uproar from the physios because they weren't even
- 59:24included in the descriptors for who
- 59:27could and couldn't work you know we were lumped in initially with parlours and
- 59:33then because of some of the good work from the people involved in some of the
- 59:37associations and I'm not going to name them but they did some really good work
- 59:41EIS to get sports massage sports remedial massage made possible
- 59:47its own category so you know the industry
- 59:50has got sway but whilst there is
- 59:53whilst there are you know people involved who are not willing to talk we haven't
- 59:59got a joint you know a big voice we're speaking independently and and if you
- 1:00:04look at the whole regulatory route one of the stakeholders that we've mentioned
- 1:00:08tonight is a supporter of the accredited register route i've I've just read from their website.
- 1:00:13Now, if you look, the person who founded that body also runs a training provider,
- 1:00:21which runs an advanced diploma in sports therapy.
- 1:00:23It's not likely for commercial reasons they're going to support statutory regulation
- 1:00:27because that would then mean that all of their training is unsellable.
- 1:00:33So so i think sometimes when i think all of the time if a professional association.
- 1:00:40Is linked with a training provider there's a
- 1:00:43conflict of interest unless it's mitigated unless
- 1:00:46the conflict of interest is mitigated by by external
- 1:00:49audit yeah there's got to be external validation to
- 1:00:53it but if if a person in significant control control of
- 1:00:56one of these stakeholders stakeholders runs a training provider i
- 1:00:59think it's a direct conflict of interest we are writing cpd policies
- 1:01:03for our members we're designing codes of conduct
- 1:01:06of codes of ethics and then we're so we're selling
- 1:01:09courses to them that's definitely a conflict of
- 1:01:12interests it's very true right listen
- 1:01:15people we're gonna have to start wrapping stuff up i just want to i think with
- 1:01:17i mean we've covered a whole load of information in this and and
- 1:01:20in an hour that's incredible there were some points which i'm pretty sure we've covered
- 1:01:23from people who kindly left comments on our posts
- 1:01:26in the the lead up to this i just want to i'm sure we've covered them but
- 1:01:29um stewart sahan i hope that's the
- 1:01:31pronunciation uh sports and exercise therapist and owner of sports therapy
- 1:01:34one raised the point i mean they left a comment actually
- 1:01:37on the sst's linkedin page in response to their
- 1:01:40important uptake on statutory regulation where they
- 1:01:43just mentioned that the money they mentioned that to my knowledge a physio registered
- 1:01:46as a chartered member of csps an annual fee of 442 pounds 20 mandatory registration
- 1:01:51with hcpc is around 232 72 biannually along with relevant insurance costs So
- 1:01:56Stuart was kind of pointing out this is something we need to consider before we start,
- 1:02:00you know, thinking about where we should guide the future of our profession.
- 1:02:04So we talked about that. The cost is a huge thing. Maybe some people aren't taking into account.
- 1:02:09We also had Patrick Criss, who's covered the point. Patrick Criss in the sports
- 1:02:12massage therapist community said you run the risk of overregulation,
- 1:02:15which turns into a money making scheme.
- 1:02:17There is this problem, isn't there, of money making and money, money, money, money.
- 1:02:21Money yes as the song says it's just a real problem
- 1:02:24sometimes that's something which as you say gary needs to be kept separate you
- 1:02:27know if we're if we're looking after therapists looking after the public we
- 1:02:31can't expect it to be a profitable lucrative kind of thing and so that's something
- 1:02:36which else uh vernon fong of the vernon of the venard clinics all right so there's
- 1:02:39comments that statutory regulation is the internal carrot that gets dangled.
- 1:02:44And says that when it comes
- 1:02:47to cpd it has to be kept up to date you can get randomly
- 1:02:50selected for audit when it comes to renewal time there'll be
- 1:02:53two people auditing one from your profession one from a different hcpc profession
- 1:02:56there has to be indication of progress as well you can't just
- 1:02:59be redoing courses or skills you already have to tick one box if you
- 1:03:02don't meet the criteria in the audit there's a chance you can lose your registration it
- 1:03:06happens i've seen this happen that's something thing i've seen the msk hub you
- 1:03:09know with sponsored by physio matters
- 1:03:12and joe turner it's very stressful
- 1:03:16me have coke it's a very stressful time and if you're
- 1:03:19there around audit time you can see exactly how physios respond
- 1:03:22to good working hard professionals who really care for their patients
- 1:03:25it's it's as venard points out can be a horrible time
- 1:03:28for them and even cause some people just leave the profession and
- 1:03:32john yeah sorry matt for full clarity venard
- 1:03:35comes from a previously regulated
- 1:03:38industry he chose to leave and we've
- 1:03:42got a number of members who chose to leave their regulating they are
- 1:03:44out there it's true yeah yeah it's true what was before then
- 1:03:48but you don't want to say it was something to do with eyes i can't pronounce
- 1:03:50it i'm not even going to try yeah john richardson hey hi john thanks for leaving
- 1:03:55the comment of jr sports massage and also barefoot physio yeah yes it's training
- 1:04:00to be a physio actually oh fantastic he said i think the argument needs to move
- 1:04:03away from the perks of professionals Professionals, recognition,
- 1:04:06comparison of other modalities, professions, towards what value,
- 1:04:08consistency and trust it could bring to the public.
- 1:04:10The political back and forth at professional government level seems to stall any progression.
- 1:04:14If statutory regulations set a pathway for more insurance or funded coverage
- 1:04:18for those who can't afford private treatment, would that not be a plus for the public?
- 1:04:21We didn't kind of mention that. No, but it goes back to the same thing, Matt.
- 1:04:27For being able to be provided through the NHS, Chess. Mm-hmm.
- 1:04:34You don't necessarily need, you can bring forward a kind of a lobby to actually
- 1:04:43be part. Look what Basrat did.
- 1:04:45What Basrat did. What Basrat did. So state of regulation does not necessarily
- 1:04:50mean that you can get work from the NHS if you want work from the NHS,
- 1:04:54because you realize that it's not necessarily everything that it seems to be.
- 1:04:58But this is not the only way to do it. And I personally, like with Gary,
- 1:05:05not because I do not think it will ever happen.
- 1:05:08I don't want my public money that I work really hard, you know,
- 1:05:14the money I spend for my taxi, that they are spent to regulate in a profession
- 1:05:18that does not need to regulate it.
- 1:05:20I would prefer it for the money to be invested in health care and in other, not to regulate it.
- 1:05:29Do we need to have a centralised system that we are accountable to,
- 1:05:36that is fit for purpose for our industry?
- 1:05:40I think that that would be very beneficial. That sets the minimum standards.
- 1:05:45And I would say that should be a training cross-pollination between all the professions.
- 1:05:52Professions so kairos osteopaths sports
- 1:05:55therapy sports anybody that works with people
- 1:05:58with pain and injury there should be a training cross
- 1:06:02parliamentary cross what would you call it you know cross professional that
- 1:06:08we put down the basic muscles the basic care that everybody has to follow in
- 1:06:14order to be able to work with people i think there's too much elitism you know for that to happen,
- 1:06:21you know, with, with doctors of chiropractic and, and, and, you know,
- 1:06:26people in our industry create, I know it's changing, but it's changing very, very, very slowly.
- 1:06:30I think we can't even, Anna-Marie, we can't even sort out our own sector.
- 1:06:36Oh yeah before we start you know doing cross-sector
- 1:06:39stuff but when you wrap up matt
- 1:06:42i just want to finish with a quote that i've.
- 1:06:45Got from hcpc so have you
- 1:06:48got anything to add before before i do that no i just wanted to
- 1:06:51kind of conclude that it seems to me from what i've heard tonight like
- 1:06:54i say we do want to do a follow-up which i mentioned at the end we need
- 1:06:57to have a conversation about maybe how to achieve and
- 1:07:01promote standardization of education and training
- 1:07:04that should be the a bigger topic because that would be something that
- 1:07:07would still have its barriers and still going to have lots of conversations but
- 1:07:10it's something we should be moving towards because it
- 1:07:13sounds like thanks to you guys kind of sharing your
- 1:07:16experience that that would satisfy a lot of the
- 1:07:18criteria which people are after which they
- 1:07:21think the only way of getting that is through statutory regulation and it
- 1:07:24would avoid a lot of the problems like financial considerations that
- 1:07:28come with statutory regulation wouldn't necessarily come with
- 1:07:32just simply standardization of education and training so is
- 1:07:35that a fair summary is that what the next debate needs to be how can we move
- 1:07:37forward and do that it's probably got as many challenges as ever but
- 1:07:40it's something we need to talk about and then maybe that could
- 1:07:43be the topic well like i say
- 1:07:46no you go first guy i'm going to finish up with again my call out
- 1:07:49to people to do a follow-up to this but we're going to say okay what's the quote well
- 1:07:52i think for that to happen matt you know i'm
- 1:07:55going to be absolutely honest here those initial conversations can't happen
- 1:08:01in the public domain main on the podcast though those need to happen you know
- 1:08:06behind closed doors so that we can have an agenda for for forward movement.
- 1:08:13I think that I'm called a charlatan by members of this industry.
- 1:08:19I've been told that people have been told to avoid the STA stand at therapy
- 1:08:24because I'm a charlatan.
- 1:08:25I may not be a doctor or professor, but what I am is an honest individual who
- 1:08:31commits to my members that I will support them come what may.
- 1:08:35I will tell them the truth about the industry. and
- 1:08:38for that I'm shot down because I'm ruining the
- 1:08:41commercialism of other business models but
- 1:08:45the final point I want to read out Matt and and I
- 1:08:48email HCPC and PSA Professional Standards Authority every year the late the
- 1:08:54last response I got was just before Covid and that's on my website at the bottom
- 1:08:58during on the pdf links but when I email HCPC I always get a link to this minute of this meeting.
- 1:09:07This meeting took place on the 10th of February 2011 at minute 8.2.
- 1:09:15The review of regulation of
- 1:09:18public health professionals had recommended
- 1:09:22the regulation of public health professionals by the HCP and a subsequent press
- 1:09:29release issued after a white paper stated that the government would only ever
- 1:09:37consider statutory regulation for further professions as a last resort.
- 1:09:43But was that the Conservatives? Is it significant there's been a government
- 1:09:46change now or do you think it would be the same as one?
- 1:09:49Well no if you look at the Chancellor's statement yesterday they've got a 22
- 1:09:53billion pound black hole and that's multiple
- 1:09:56departments across government multiple quangos the
- 1:10:00hcpc is not going to get extra any extra funding
- 1:10:03to sort this problem out we've got bigger fish to fry
- 1:10:06we're still paying for covid we're still paying for the hs2 we're
- 1:10:09still paying for lots of things lots of services are
- 1:10:12being cut this is not a priority for government right okay
- 1:10:16theory into practice i think we probably we've may
- 1:10:20have given people more questions than answers which wasn't
- 1:10:23necessarily our intention but that is the reality at the
- 1:10:26moment sometimes in life you look for quick answers but there's not it is
- 1:10:28a confused area and that's why the original question statutory regulation
- 1:10:32for sports therapists is not a simple answer if you're
- 1:10:35saying yes definitely or you're saying no there's there's
- 1:10:38a middle ground of confusion where most people should really lie when they've
- 1:10:41got all the information at hand so but to try and
- 1:10:43put some theory into practice imagine that our listeners have listened to this
- 1:10:46and they've taken on board what you've said but what
- 1:10:50could therapists themselves sports therapists themselves be doing to help our
- 1:10:55industry with regards to standardization with regards to sorting out this conflict
- 1:10:59of interest and stuff if we go back to that that post matt that came out on
- 1:11:05social media we shouldn't be sending draft emails to our mp.
- 1:11:10What we should be doing is making our professional associations accountable
- 1:11:14for what they're telling us.
- 1:11:17And if I ever tell anybody that they must be a member of the STA going forward
- 1:11:24if regulations happen, please shoot me.
- 1:11:26You have my full permission in public to shoot me because it's not right.
- 1:11:31You have no obligation to be a member of an association.
- 1:11:34Speak to them all. Find out how they're going to represent you.
- 1:11:38Find out how they're going to support you. you find out how much they're going
- 1:11:40to charge you is it value for money have you done your due diligence about the
- 1:11:45company that you're paying the people that you're paying and if you have make
- 1:11:49an informed choice that's all i ask make an informed choice do your due diligence,
- 1:11:55great stuff and anna i add to that literally what what gary said but what i
- 1:12:00add and we might I want to put those links here.
- 1:12:03Go and read what statutory regulation is.
- 1:12:08Go and look at the, do it like a little review, a pro and a con.
- 1:12:13And that's you make an informed choice.
- 1:12:17If you think that the way our profession, the broader, is actually would be
- 1:12:24best suited to statutory regulation.
- 1:12:28So because often I hear this idea of statutory regulation, but actually there
- 1:12:32is not that you know it might not actually be what people think it is but standardizations
- 1:12:39yes push you know make your professional association accountable,
- 1:12:45so putting theory into practices have a
- 1:12:48conversation with your professional association and maybe send
- 1:12:51them links to this podcast see what they think about it i'm sure there's going
- 1:12:53to be a lot with that and also ask them why you're not collaborating with others
- 1:12:57instead of putting in something like that on the social media like it's been
- 1:13:01put wouldn't not been better to contact all the other sports therapy association
- 1:13:09and say we might have the option the government has changed,
- 1:13:13what do we think do we think do we have a common ground here and then if there
- 1:13:19was no common ground they could have taken they think they can take the things
- 1:13:22by themselves but to put it up there They are not contacting the industry.
- 1:13:27Those are people that we rely on.
- 1:13:30And if they're the first one not wanting to collaborate, what chance have we got?
- 1:13:34Yeah and just to add if you have listened
- 1:13:37to this and it's been some of the things we've talked
- 1:13:40about been a bit of a shock you may have
- 1:13:43felt that we are insulting somebody who
- 1:13:46you have a high kind of respect for then
- 1:13:49we understand your first reaction is probably anger it's
- 1:13:53going to be pushed away these people don't know what they're talking about that's normal
- 1:13:55totally human i would have the same thing if somebody started slagging somebody
- 1:13:59i respected off but once you
- 1:14:02get through that then maybe just check things
- 1:14:05out talk communicate with your professional association tell
- 1:14:08them a nice calm way oh i heard this was mentioned the other day and they
- 1:14:11might come back with a with a suitable answer if it's just oh those guys are
- 1:14:15charlatans and that's not really a very sensible productive kind of debate but
- 1:14:18if it's explained in another different way cohesive way then then fine that's
- 1:14:22marvelous and we'd love to have you along on the show commenting on that but
- 1:14:25just communicate if you are paying money to be part of a professional association association,
- 1:14:30we, and I'm sure the idea of fresh association is we're supporting you.
- 1:14:35We're answering your questions.
- 1:14:36It's the same as a therapist and a client or patient. We're here to facilitate.
- 1:14:41We're not making you, not guiding you to do this or to buy this, whatever.
- 1:14:44We're here to listen to you, the same as we listen to a patient and help support
- 1:14:49you for whatever queries you have.
- 1:14:50So do that. That would be my theory into practice.
- 1:14:54Communicate and make sure that you are
- 1:14:57in a position where you are being supported and looked after and yeah
- 1:14:59have that conversation and if you haven't been affected by
- 1:15:02it then do feel free to email us as well we're not saying oh just turn around
- 1:15:05and join us that's not our goal at all believe us not at all at
- 1:15:08all is it gary we don't expect everyone to turn around and join our association we
- 1:15:11might not be the best association at all no but i'm more than
- 1:15:13willing to have a chat with anybody who would like to join and
- 1:15:16see how i can support their journey and the team can support their
- 1:15:19journey and we've got lots of things planned and we've
- 1:15:22got lots of information that we would have liked to got out out today that
- 1:15:25we haven't but what i would say is that i will
- 1:15:28never disrespect anybody who has spent
- 1:15:32and dedicated their life to supporting an
- 1:15:35industry yeah i will never disrespect anybody
- 1:15:38at the cnhc the gcmt the sst the sto because we may have differences of opinion
- 1:15:48but there should always be professional respect and it's the differences of
- 1:15:53opinion that we discuss around that table,
- 1:15:58So I haven't meant to offend anybody today, but, you know, being offended is a choice.
- 1:16:04You know, I've just put publicly available information out into the public domain
- 1:16:08again, where it already is. You know, don't shoot me for that.
- 1:16:12Great point. And I've just realised my phone might be out of action for the next two weeks.
- 1:16:17I know. That's great. Hey, we're talking. We always talk about communication.
- 1:16:21That's what we're doing here. we're opening up debate and hopefully there will be some
- 1:16:24some useful criticism because none
- 1:16:27of us are claiming to be perfect and some of the information and there might not
- 1:16:30be as factual as we believe it is so we hope this starts the debate like we
- 1:16:33say if we can have a follow-up or a second episode where people can come along
- 1:16:37and write things in the comments that's always an option we'd love to do that
- 1:16:39if you do have any feedback in particular to save gary's phone because he's
- 1:16:43got a lot of members to look after and help them then let me be the conduit for your
- 1:16:47feedback and anger i've got broad shoulders not as big as our gary here but.
- 1:16:51Email me matt at the sta.co.uk any
- 1:16:54concerns you've got i'll accept shouty emails don't worry i'm
- 1:16:57too old and wise now to get offended by anything you say you can talk about
- 1:17:01as a person it's fine i would prefer you to do that and just not talk to us
- 1:17:04at all because that doesn't help at all so matt at the sta.co.uk and i will
- 1:17:08engage and and reply that said and done we've got two weeks off now for you hopefully to relax.
- 1:17:16I'm sure a lot of you are still working and not everyone naturally can go on
- 1:17:20summer holidays, but hopefully with the better weather, if it stays where you
- 1:17:22are, that you get a chance to smell the roses and look after yourself.
- 1:17:26With that in mind, I would again, just stress you check out mehabjoe, mehab.co.uk.
- 1:17:31It's one of the things that's resonating in our mind. We're in an industry where
- 1:17:35we're doing this to look after others.
- 1:17:37And in that, by definition, it
- 1:17:40means often we don't look after ourselves our goal
- 1:17:43is to look after as many people as possible and it's so easy for you
- 1:17:45not to look after yourself so check out mehab.co.uk even
- 1:17:49join the mehab.co.uk facebook group because joe does some
- 1:17:52lovely videos where it's just i mean she's so amazing to
- 1:17:54listen to but just some things to reflect and pause like six
- 1:17:57or seven minutes and it's enough to make you go you know
- 1:18:00what that's that's that's something i should be thinking about and
- 1:18:03literally i listened to one today and it just listened to it while i was just
- 1:18:06relaxing thing and it's just so valuable to do that there's my
- 1:18:09practice theory into practice check out me have.co.uk just
- 1:18:12to chill yourselves out especially after today's heated discussion that's it
- 1:18:15thanks gary benson family thank you yeah thank you maria
- 1:18:18thank you score really appreciate your time guys if
- 1:18:22you listen to the podcast and you've enjoyed it actually if
- 1:18:24this episode yeah no one leave any ratings or reviews please just
- 1:18:27let's just get about that this episode don't need to forget it don't touch the
- 1:18:31button but we would like to however angry or happy you are we'd look would like
- 1:18:35you to follow us on social media and have your voice in three weeks time when
- 1:18:39we do the next sda podcast so you can so we can talk that's it bye people enjoy
- 1:18:44life and hopefully we'll speak to you soon take care.
- 1:18:48Music.