Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Synthetic Share Repurchases
Transcript
- Lucas: So we talk a lot on this show about what companies do after they go public — buybacks, dilution management, insider trading windows. But there's a quieter, more structural move that some of the bigger post ipo names are starting to use, and it's not a standard open-market buyback. It's called a synthetic share repurchase. Luna: Synthetic — meaning they're not actually buying shares on the exchange, right? Lucas: Exactly. Instead of going into the open market and buying stock, the company enters a total return swap with a bank. Under that swap, the company pays the bank a fee — typically a floating interest rate like SOFR plus a spread — and in return, the bank pays the company the total return on a notional amount of its own stock. That includes any dividends and any price appreciation. Luna: So economically, the company gets the same benefit as owning the stock — they capture the upside — but without actually owning the shares. Lucas: Right. And that's the key. Because under accounting rules, total return swaps are treated as derivative instruments, not equity. So the company doesn't report them as a reduction in shares outstanding right away. But economically, they can achieve a similar effect: the bank often hedges its exposure by buying the stock in the open market, which supports the share price. And when the swap matures, the company can settle in cash or take delivery of the shares, effectively retiring them. Luna: That feels like a cheat code for companies that are in a blackout period or still under lockup restrictions. They can't buy stock directly, but the bank can do it for them under the swap. Lucas: That's exactly when it's most useful. Think about a company like Palantir — ticker P-L-T-R — which went public in 2020 but has had a volatile post ipo life. It's up about 14 and a half percent in the last five days alone, as of this morning. But throughout 2025 and 2026, they've had periods where insider selling windows are closed, or they're navigating lockup expirations. A synthetic buyback lets them be active in managing their capital structure even when they can't touch the open market directly. Luna: And it's not just Palantir. I've seen this used by a few other post ipo tech names. The obvious advantage is flexibility — you can start and stop a swap program without the same disclosure requirements as a formal buyback plan. Lucas: That's a big one. Under SEC Rule 10b-18, companies doing open-market buybacks have to follow strict volume limits, timing restrictions, and disclosure rules. A synthetic program through a swap doesn't trigger those same disclosure obligations in real time. The company reports it in its quarterly filings, but by then the activity is done. Luna: So it's less transparent. That's a double-edged sword — it gives the company more operational freedom, but it also means investors might not know the company is effectively supporting its own stock. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the SEC has started paying more attention. In 2025, the agency issued some guidance reminding companies that synthetic repurchases can't be used to evade insider trading rules or manipulate the stock. But it's still a grey area — many companies argue these swaps are legitimate hedging and capital management tools. Luna: I want to zoom in on the mechanics for a second. How does the bank hedge its risk? If the bank pays the company the total return on the stock, the bank is short the stock — they lose money if the stock goes up. So they need to offset that. Lucas: They buy the stock. That's the standard hedge. The bank goes into the open market and buys the notional amount of shares, so they're flat — they own the stock, they pay the total return to the company, and they collect the fee. The net effect is that the bank is holding the shares on its balance sheet, but the company is bearing the economic risk and reward. Luna: And because the bank is buying, that creates buying pressure in the market, which can prop up or even lift the stock price. So the company gets the benefit without having to announce anything. Lucas: Right. And there's another layer: when the swap matures, the company can choose to settle in cash or take delivery of the shares. If they take delivery, they effectively retire the shares, reducing their share count. That boosts earnings per share, just like a traditional buyback. But because it was done via swap, the timing and scale were opaque. Luna: So it's a way to manage dilution from employee stock options or restricted stock units without the market reacting to a big buyback announcement. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a huge concern for post ipo companies. When you go public, you typically have a lot of equity compensation outstanding. Every quarter, new shares hit the market as options are exercised or RSUs vest. That dilutes existing shareholders. A synthetic buyback can offset that dilution in a stealthier way. Luna: But it's not free. The company pays the bank a fee, which is usually based on a floating rate like SOFR plus a spread. In the current rate environment — SOFR is still above 4 percent — that's not cheap. And if the stock drops, the company might have to post collateral to the bank. Lucas: That's a real risk. If the stock falls significantly, the bank will ask for more collateral, which can strain the company's liquidity. We saw some companies get into trouble during the 2022 downturn when their stocks dropped 50, 60 percent and their swap collateral calls came due. It's not a risk-free tool. Luna: So who is actually using this today? Do we have any recent examples beyond Palantir? Lucas: A few of the larger post ipo names have disclosed swap programs in their filings. Coinbase — ticker c o i n, up 11 percent in the last five days — has used total return swaps as part of its capital return strategy. Shopify too. It's more common among companies with large cash balances and volatile stock prices, because the swaps give them flexibility to act quickly. Luna: And it's not just tech. I've seen this in biotech and even some SPACs that went public and then wanted to manage their stock price. Lucas: Right. Any company that has a lot of equity compensation and wants to manage dilution without the market fanfare. The trade-off is always between transparency and flexibility. Luna: And that's the part that gives regulators pause. Because if a company is effectively buying its own stock but not reporting it in real time, that changes the information environment for investors. Lucas: It does. And I think we'll see more scrutiny as these programs become more common. But for now, synthetic buybacks are a legitimate, if opaque, part of the post ipo toolkit. Luna: It really comes down to how companies choose to communicate their capital allocation priorities. If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, listener support is what keeps the show ad-free. You can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small gesture that goes a long way in helping us keep the episodes focused and without sponsors pushing a narrative. So, back to the tools — one thing I find fascinating is how synthetic buybacks interact with the lockup expiration calendar. Luna: Tell me more. Lucas: When a lockup expires, a flood of insider shares can hit the market, depressing the stock. A company that has a swap in place can have the bank absorb some of that selling pressure — the bank might buy shares as the insiders sell, effectively stabilising the price. It's a way to manage the lockup cliff without the company itself being the buyer of record. Luna: So it's like a backstop. And since the swap terms are private, the market doesn't know the company is there catching the falling knife. Lucas: Exactly. And that can be smart if the company believes its stock is undervalued. They can get the benefit of a buyback at a lower average price without tipping off the market. But it also means that if the stock drops further, the company is on the hook for collateral. Luna: So it's a bet on the stock's recovery, essentially. Lucas: In a way, yes. But it's a bet backed by the company's own cash and credit line. And if the bet pays off, shareholders benefit from reduced dilution and higher EPS. Luna: I want to circle back to the regulatory angle. Do you think the SEC will eventually require more disclosure for these swaps? Lucas: I think it's likely. The SEC has been vocal about wanting more transparency around all forms of stock buybacks. In 2024, they introduced new rules requiring daily disclosure of buyback activity for open-market programs. Synthetic swaps are the next frontier. But any rule change would face pushback from companies that value the flexibility. Luna: So for now, it's a tool that's available but carries both opportunity and risk. Lucas: Exactly. And for investors, it's worth checking the footnotes in quarterly filings. If you see 'total return swap' or 'equity swap' in the derivatives footnote, you know the company is using this strategy — and that can tell you a lot about how they're managing their capital structure behind the scenes. Luna: Good point. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. That wraps up episode 94.