Latest / Deep Thoughts About Stupid Sh*t: A Pop-Culture Comedy Podcast / Disney’s Beauty & The Beast: Deep Thoughts About Classism, Stockholm Syndrome, and Yoga-Pants Feminism (Reprise Ep 6)
Transcript
- 0:00Tracie: When we decided we were going to do a series of favorite episodes, this one was at the top of my list.
- 0:06Tracie: When I try to explain to people about this podcast and this project, Beauty and the Beast is the one I almost always use.
- 0:16Tracie: A lot of ink and pixels have been spilt about the Stockholm syndrome at the center of the Beauty and the Beast narrative.
- 0:25Tracie: But I think a lot fewer people talk about the class consciousness and the classism and the essentialism of class that is baked into the Beauty and the Beast story, or the not like other girls' feminism that was so indicative of the 90s.
- 0:44Tracie: Both of these things are features of our analysis.
- 0:49Tracie: So I wanted to revisit it.
- 0:51Tracie: It's also kind of fun to listen to us still figuring out how to do this show.
- 0:57Tracie: We hadn't yet routinized the structure.
- 1:01Tracie: Have a listen.
- 1:03Tracie: I think you'll enjoy it.
- 1:05Tracie: Have you ever had something you love dismissed because it's just pop culture?
- 1:11Tracie: What others might deem stupid shit, you know matters.
- 1:15Tracie: You know it's worth talking and thinking about.
- 1:17Tracie: And so do we.
- 1:19Tracie: So come overthink with us as we delve into our deep thoughts about stupid shit.
- 1:24Emily: I'm Emily Guy Birkin, and you're listening to Deep Thoughts About Stupid Shit.
- 1:28Emily: Because pop culture is still culture.
- 1:30Emily: And shouldn't you know what's in your head?
- 1:32Emily: Today I'll be sharing my deep thoughts about the 1991 animated film Beauty and the Beast with my sister, Tracy Guy Decker.
- 1:39Emily: And with you.
- 1:41Emily: Let's dive in.
- 1:42Emily: So, Tracy, tell me what you know or what you remember about Beauty and the Beast.
- 1:47Tracie: Yeah, Beauty and the Beast, man.
- 1:50Tracie: Yeah, I loved it.
- 1:51Tracie: I remember, I remember loving it.
- 1:53Tracie: The some of the pieces of it have become like like memes in in my brain, you know, like the Mrs.
- 2:03Tracie: Potts and the teapot and her kids, and like, where do they sleep?
- 2:09Tracie: And what is that chip out of Chip's head?
- 2:12Tracie: Like some of those weird sort of qu like questions when you like when you overthink it.
- 2:16Tracie: The thing that immediately comes to mind when I think about the Disney Beauty and the Beast too is like I saw me within the past three or four years that was like, I thought that I was gonna be like Belle, but it turns out I'm like this lady.
- 2:30Tracie: And it was the woman from the the small provincial town song going, I need six eggs.
- 2:38Emily: And she's juggling a baby or these two babies.
- 2:42Tracie: Exactly.
- 2:45Tracie: Yeah, so that that comes to mind first.
- 2:47Tracie: And then like I I loved Beauty and the Bee so much, and I'm I'm sure we are gonna get into this, but when I look back on it, I think that sort of sense that like he transforms, that the beloved transforms into a civilized, like human being because of her love kind of messed me up when it comes to my romantic partnerships uh throughout my life.
- 3:10Tracie: Um or that that sort of idea.
- 3:13Tracie: This certainly isn't the only place we got.
- 3:15Emily: Oh, yeah.
- 3:16Emily: I mean, from John Bender to Mr.
- 3:18Emily: Rochester, it is over and over and over again theme throughout.
- 3:22Emily: Yes.
- 3:23Tracie: But it's a it it's literal.
- 3:25Tracie: It's literal in this in this one.
- 3:28Tracie: So um so I'm sure we're gonna get into that.
- 3:31Tracie: But those are like my like initial like beauty and the beast, like you know, stream of consciousness things that come up for me.
- 3:37Tracie: So why are we talking about it?
- 3:39Tracie: What's what's what's at stake here?
- 3:41Emily: Um I recently made the joke, and it's not exactly a joke, that Yvette from Clue is 40% of the reason why I majored in French in college.
- 3:51Emily: Um Beauty and the Beast is probably at least 50% of the reason.
- 3:57Tracie: Wow.
- 3:58Tracie: Um I did not know that.
- 3:59Tracie: I did not know that.
- 4:01Emily: So um now, some of it is I have always been a bit of a francophile.
- 4:06Emily: Like it's I can in the same way that I can remember being really interested in cats before we ever had a cat, I could remember being really interested in the French language and kind of um French art and things like that long before I ever took a single French lesson.
- 4:24Emily: So some of it is just, I think something in me is like, yes, that feels like right.
- 4:29Emily: But some of it is also um uh there is something very French about La Belle et la Bête.
- 4:36Emily: Um, this is one of the fairy tales that does not come from the Grimm brothers, um, that is is Disnified.
- 4:44Emily: So like it's um Grimm's fairy tales gave us Cinderella and Snow White and Sleeping Beauty and all of those, like kind of the original um uh fairy talkers.
- 4:55Tracie: While Disney was still alive.
- 4:57Emily: Yes.
- 4:57Emily: Um like Pinocchio is like the only one that's that's not from uh the Grimm brothers.
- 5:03Emily: This fairy tale was written in the 17th century.
- 5:06Emily: Um, it was a female writer uh whose name I have I looked up and have forgotten that quickly because it's like four names.
- 5:14Emily: Not that I should complain, I have three, but uh there was a duh and a la in there in the middle.
- 5:20Emily: Um and that's part of the reason why there's uh the heroine is so much more active and proactive than the princesses in previous Disney films.
- 5:29Emily: I did a little bit of reading, and apparently the Grimm brothers really did not like active heroines, and so they culled in their stories until they got to the ones who just sat and looked pretty and waited to be kissed, or literally or literally slept through it or looked like they were dead.
- 5:47Emily: So um, so that that I find pretty interesting.
- 5:52Emily: So that that was part of what drew me to it, is that it is it does feel very French, even though it isn't a very American Disney fied version of it.
- 6:00Emily: Um there is a little bit of the uh as a bit of a francophile, and when I was 12 when it came out, I had just started taking French class um in middle school.
- 6:10Emily: Uh, so I liked knowing the zootelor, and there's a sign that says Dargon, because it's the silversmith, and you know, things like that, boulangerie.
- 6:21Emily: I like I liked that.
- 6:22Emily: But then I think I also really identified with Belle in a way that I am now a little embarrassed by.
- 6:31Emily: Um, but that identification with Belle kind of further cemented my interest in French because Belle was French.
- 6:39Emily: Um and so, and I'd really like to dig into what it is you and I both loved about this film and why it makes me embarrassed now, because it is something that I feel like is um indicative of very much uh middle class to upper middle class white feminism.
- 7:02Emily: And um it's uh a little worrisome to look at now in 2023 with the hindsight.
- 7:13Emily: Um, and that's before you even get into the uh the this being the Disney version of Stockholm Syndrome.
- 7:19Tracie: Stockholm Syndrome.
- 7:20Tracie: Yeah.
- 7:21Tracie: I I actually have not allowed my daughter to watch uh as much as I loved it when I was a little older than she is now, uh, for exactly that reason, because of the straight up Stockholm syndrome uh that that is Belle's love for the beast.
- 7:38Tracie: Interesting.
- 7:39Tracie: Okay, all right.
- 7:40Tracie: So where do you want to start with this?
- 7:42Emily: So I'd like to start with um what it is that drew me to it and why that is repels me a little bit now.
- 7:51Emily: So we meet Belle, and uh it's you know, there's David Ogden Steers does that like gorgeous um narration, and which ends with, Who could ever learn to love a beast?
- 8:07Emily: And immediately we start with Belle singing, Little Town, such a quiet village, every day like the one before, little town full of little people waking up to say, Bonjour.
- 8:18Emily: Um, there goes the baker, this Trey, like always, so on and so forth.
- 8:21Emily: I'm not gonna do the whole thing, though I could.
- 8:23Emily: And what we have is the immediate not like other girls.
- 8:30Emily: And so we have Belle is not like other girls, and we get that like, I'm better than other women feminism, that I feel like is very indicative of the era in which you and I grew up.
- 8:50Emily: We got a lot of the not like other girls kind of feminism where like, oh, well, you know, I like to read.
- 8:58Emily: I'm not I'm not bubble headed.
- 9:00Emily: Oh, I am not interested in the handsome guy because I'm not, you know, I'm not a bimbo.
- 9:07Emily: So that is really uncomfortable.
- 9:09Emily: And it reminds me of when I was in college, it felt like every third young woman at my college was named Emily.
- 9:16Emily: I actually once told someone, like, they're like, oh, I met someone from your college.
- 9:19Emily: I'm like, well, if they're named Emily Meredith, Sarah or Erica, I'm not gonna know who they are.
- 9:24Emily: And they're like, oh, it was a Sarah.
- 9:26Emily: And so I was in college and I was like, I've I don't like the feeling like I'm one of a mass of people.
- 9:32Emily: And so I ended up going and getting a belly button um piercing, a navel piercing, which a few years later I was just like, so I got the most common type of hot girl piercing to say, I'm not like other girls.
- 9:50Emily: And that's kind of what this feels like.
- 9:52Emily: It is um pandering to the sense of, oh, you have this straw woman, straw cheerleader of uh of who you think girls are, and you set yourself as better than those other girls.
- 10:09Emily: You're not like those other girls, and uh the way that you do it is in the most vanilla way possible.
- 10:16Emily: You like reading.
- 10:18Emily: Um so now that's a lot to put on a 90-minute Disney movie.
- 10:24Tracie: Yeah, it's interesting too, because the the movie did does give us that.
- 10:29Tracie: I mean, we see we do see other women in that song, even like Monsieur Gazon, oh, he's so dreamy, you know, and they're like swooning over him, and then we immediately see him just like dripping with toxic masculinity.
- 10:44Tracie: Like, why are you bothering with that learning stuff?
- 10:48Tracie: Um the straw cheerleaders, for you to coin a phrase, they're there in animated splendor.
- 10:57Tracie: They're there for us to disdain.
- 11:00Tracie: So I I mean, so yes, that is a lot to put on it, but um, I I don't think you're making something up that's not there.
- 11:07Emily: Yeah.
- 11:08Emily: So the other part of it that I noticed this time, I I rewatched it um the other night uh in preparation for this, was the fact that it's not just that she's uh like not like other girls because she's smart and bookish and you know doesn't quite fit in as a little awkward.
- 11:28Emily: She's adorable.
- 11:30Emily: Um it's also she sets herself up in a different way in terms of class consciousness because it's this poor provincial town.
- 11:41Emily: And then when she gets to the castle, the all of the uh in the BR guest song, life is uh so unnerving for servant who's not serving.
- 11:51Emily: We're not whole without a soul to wait upon.
- 11:54Emily: And so there is a similar class distinction, um, which is part of the reason why I see this as like very indicative of uh middle to upper middle class white feminism from the 80s and 90s.
- 12:09Emily: And and I mean to this day, it still continues, but I think people are a little more conscious of it than uh uh now than they were then.
- 12:18Emily: And and in fact, I have not seen the 2017 um live action remake with I'm gonna call her Hermione Granger, uh Emma Watson.
- 12:27Emily: Watson.
- 12:28Emily: Um, I have not seen it, but I have heard that there have been a couple of, they made a couple of changes to the story, including a couple of changes that are indicative of their understanding of uh class consciousness somewhat.
- 12:40Emily: Um I haven't seen it, so I don't know for sure.
- 12:43Tracie: You know what occurs to me as we're talking?
- 12:45Tracie: I have seen this movie many times, but just in case some of our listeners maybe haven't seen it or haven't seen it in a while, perhaps um you can do like a quick nutshell of because the from that beginning, that first song that we both now have referenced to um the Be Our Guest song where we're in the castle.
- 13:02Tracie: Can you give us like the the sort of rough outline of the plot that gets us from the poor provincial town to the castle?
- 13:09Emily: So um uh we have the introduction where we meet the beast and his curse.
- 13:14Emily: Uh, we then immediately meet Belle with the introductory song.
- 13:18Emily: Her father goes off to the fair to share his uh his invention.
- 13:24Emily: Um while he is gone, uh Gaston surprises her with an immediate marriage proposal.
- 13:30Emily: Like he's brought everyone there for the wedding and then goes to propose to her.
- 13:34Emily: Uh she turns him down flat.
- 13:36Emily: Meanwhile, her father gets lost, the horse runs away, and he ends up in the beast's castle.
- 13:42Emily: The beast um uh imprisons him.
- 13:44Emily: The horse comes back and Belle rides it to find the castle, finds her father, and um negotiates with the beast to switch places with her father.
- 13:55Emily: Her father ends up um back at the village.
- 13:58Emily: Uh, he's taken there by one of the enchanted objects in the castle.
- 14:02Emily: It's an enchanted carriage that takes him there, so he doesn't need Philippe, the horse, and he tries to get help to go uh rescue Belle, which gives Geston the idea to threaten to put him in an insane asylum unless Belle agrees to marry him.
- 14:17Emily: Meanwhile, Belle is discovering that the hot castle is enchanted.
- 14:21Emily: There, all the servants are objects.
- 14:23Emily: There's Lumiere the candlestick, there's Cogsworth the uh the clock, there's Mrs.
- 14:27Emily: Potts, the uh teapot with her son Chip that has a chip in it, which is always the one she uses to stir up to guests, which you'd think you wouldn't give the chipped cup to the guests.
- 14:37Emily: Anyway.
- 14:38Emily: So uh Belle and the Beast end up um uh well, he saves her from the wolves when she tries to run away.
- 14:46Emily: They end up kind of falling for each other.
- 14:48Emily: She wishes she could see her father again, and so he uses a magic mirror to let her see her father who is sick and dying.
- 14:54Emily: So Gaston is there to with the villagers to try to convince her to marry him, or else her father will go to the insane asylum.
- 15:04Emily: She uses the magic mirror to prove that she's telling the truth, and that causes Gaston to whip up the townsfolk into a frenzy of paranoia and fear that the beast is going to hurt them.
- 15:15Emily: So they go lay siege to the castle.
- 15:17Emily: The objects uh all fight back, but Gaston and the beast end up fighting on top of the roof.
- 15:24Emily: Gaston proves himself to be a monster, uh, even though the beast has has uh uh let him go after besting him and stabs him and then falls to his own death.
- 15:34Emily: The beast dies in Belle's arms just as she tells him that she loves him, and then he transforms back into the prince and happy, happy ending with dancing and stuff.
- 15:45Emily: Thanks for that.
- 15:47Tracie: Catching us up.
- 15:48Tracie: I think you know, the class consciousness is a really interesting point here is when we meet these servants who don't have a soul when they're not serving or feel as though they don't have a purpose when they're not serving, they are animated, inanimate objects.
- 16:05Tracie: And there's something really powerful and dangerous about that, right?
- 16:11Tracie: If you are a human who has a certain job, you could get a different job.
- 16:16Tracie: If you are a candlestick, you're a candlestick.
- 16:20Tracie: Like you can't then like become an architect because you're a frigging candlestick, right?
- 16:27Tracie: Like there's something like really um essentialist about the classism when you make the inanimate object into the servant.
- 16:36Tracie: Um, so that it's it's like you'd have to change species, but it's not even species because they're not animals.
- 16:42Tracie: Um, which is really that's a really interesting, like sort of Marxist kind of lens on that particular piece of the classism and and class consciousness that comes up.
- 16:55Tracie: I had never, I just had never examined before.
- 16:59Emily: Well, the the moment when Maurice Bell's father uh wanders into the castle and discovers Lumiere and Cogsworth, and he's fascinated, he's he's a scientist, he's an inventor.
- 17:08Emily: And so he picks Cogsworth up and is like um like examining his feet, which tickles him, and and and it's played for laughs and it is very funny.
- 17:16Emily: But what got me me thinking this time was like the lack of consent.
- 17:21Emily: Uh, because we have talked about consent quite a bit uh in this show, and the fact that he felt perfectly comfortable picking up an object and touching it, uh, and like opening up the cabinet that had the clockwork.
- 17:35Emily: So the pendulum to, and it's when Cogsworth like shuts the cabinet on Maurice's finger that he finally stops.
- 17:43Emily: And if you're looking at it again through this kind of Marxist lens of Maurice, though they don't have a whole lot of money, does consider himself to be above.
- 17:55Emily: Now it's a clock.
- 17:57Emily: So yes, but it's like the actual embodiment of these class differences, like what you're talking about.
- 18:06Emily: Like Cogsworth cannot be anything other than a clock.
- 18:10Emily: Even though were Cogsworth still human, he could, you know, he could be a butler at someone else's house, or he could, you know, go do something else or uh become a sailor.
- 18:19Emily: He could get a different job.
- 18:21Tracie: It's a job, it's not an identity.
- 18:24Emily: Yeah.
- 18:24Emily: So um so that's that made me a little uncomfortable watching it this time.
- 18:30Emily: Um, where you know, instead of being like, oh, this is funny and it tickles that he's and it is funny, but it's also, you know, if you spend any kind of time thinking about the deeper meaning of it, it's it gets kind of ugly.
- 18:43Emily: And it feels like the thing that is interesting in looking at it from that lens and the and the idea of you know, not like other girls kind of feminism.
- 18:55Emily: Belle doesn't have any friends in the in the provincial town.
- 19:00Emily: Gaston is interested in her, but only because of her looks.
- 19:03Emily: He doesn't actually care about her.
- 19:05Emily: Not in the least.
- 19:07Emily: Um and so the only person she has to talk to is her father.
- 19:11Emily: When she ends up at the castle, she uh befriends the the servants, but they are definitely not her equals.
- 19:22Emily: Right.
- 19:23Emily: And so the beast is the only person who is in any way her equal that we meet.
- 19:31Emily: Um and the reason why the author who originally wrote this fairy tale was in part for well-born girls and young women who were going to be in arranged marriages was to help them understand that if they were kind and accommodating, these strangers who felt like beasts could turn into lovable men who would be their husbands.
- 19:59Emily: I just a chill.
- 20:02unknown: Yeah.
- 20:02Emily: Not in a good way.
- 20:03Emily: Yeah.
- 20:04Emily: Um, and so I mean, that's a comprehensible story and and and moral for 300 years ago, and it was intended to give comfort to these young women.
- 20:20Emily: And instruction.
- 20:21Tracie: And comfort, but instruction, yeah.
- 20:24Emily: Um, but even so in the original, like Disney didn't make up the idea that the servants were were objects.
- 20:30Emily: Now, in the original, they they're not objects, they're just never seen.
- 20:34Emily: They're un, they're like basically invisible servants.
- 20:36Emily: So, like all the different elements of the story are in the original, it's just they became disnified.
- 20:42Emily: But it mirrors what it would be like for these poor young women.
- 20:47Tracie: Yeah, I think your point about the you know, that the beast is the only real peer, even possible peer, is really interesting.
- 20:56Tracie: And it's clearly like a foundational assumption, both to the original and to the Disney version, that in and of itself is an assumption that I think we can and should question.
- 21:09Tracie: Right?
- 21:10Tracie: Like Belle has no peers because they've all like Belle and the other people have decided that that this hierarchy must be maintained.
- 21:18Tracie: There's not there's no actual reason for her to not have peers.
- 21:23Tracie: Whether the girls in the provincial town who were mooning over Gaston, I mean, he is handsome if you if he doesn't talk.
- 21:33Emily: I I I gotta tell you, when he's dressed up for the wedding, like I always really liked that part.
- 21:38Emily: Even though he's awful, I'm just like he does cut a nice figure.
- 21:43Emily: I mean, he's a handsome dude, right?
- 21:44Emily: He's handsome.
- 21:45Emily: Yeah.
- 21:46Emily: And every last inch of him is covered with hair.
- 21:49Emily: I don't remember where I was going with that.
- 21:53Emily: Um the hierarchy people take it as getting.
- 21:56Tracie: Oh well, the so those girls, those girls back, like that's the Reason that we are given to not care for those girls as the audience is because they moon over Gaston and he's a jerk.
- 22:05Tracie: But he is handsome and like that's what teenage girls do.
- 22:08Tracie: Yeah, yeah.
- 22:09Tracie: There's actually there actually is no real reason why Belle and those girls couldn't be friends.
- 22:14Emily: Well, and there's the scene where she she goes to the bookshop, which first of all, just as a small business owner, how does he maintain a bookshop in this in this tiny town?
- 22:26Emily: Um when he lends out the only reader and then gives the books.
- 22:33Emily: But, you know, like why is she not staying and talking his ear off about like his favorite books?
- 22:39Emily: You know, why are they not friends?
- 22:40Emily: Which, and obviously it's because he's an old man and she's a young woman and that's that's not how it's supposed to be.
- 22:45Emily: It's like you're kindly and that's it.
- 22:47Emily: But that comes from a similar assumption.
- 22:49Emily: The assumption is that you are friends with people who are similar to you in age in certain things, rather than like you are friends with people who have similarities to you, you know, that you have something coming uh in common with.
- 23:02Emily: So, like, you know, theoretically, she would have spent 45 minutes or an hour there just talking to him, like, you don't have anything new, but what's your favorite book that you read recently?
- 23:11Emily: What's your favorite book in the store?
- 23:12Emily: Like, now, granted, that would have brought the entire movie to a halt, but it's it's a it's a part of these similar kinds of assumptions that like she is different from the rest of us, and so she is alone.
- 23:25Emily: Similarly, the um I want so much more than they've got planned, because she's she has that song after she runs Geston off after he tries to propose to her, and she's like, she wants adventure in the Great Wide somewhere.
- 23:39Emily: Uh, I want it more than I can say, and it would be grand if someone could understand that I want something more than they've got planned.
- 23:45Emily: And I loved that when I was a kid because I felt there was a similar sort of like, this is what girls do.
- 23:56Emily: Like, you get married, you have kids, you do this, you do this, you do this.
- 23:59Emily: Um, and she's like, I don't want uh what's planned.
- 24:03Emily: I want my own thing, I want adventure.
- 24:05Emily: And like the plot of the movie makes it clear she's right.
- 24:10Emily: They do have something planned for her that is not what she wants.
- 24:13Emily: But looking at it now with hindsight, it's it's like she doesn't have a specific want.
- 24:21Emily: There's not a specific thing that she's uh yearning for.
- 24:25Emily: She says adventure in the great wide somewhere, but she doesn't get that, and yet she's supposed to be happy at the end, married to the the beast now prince.
- 24:33Emily: That would have been so much more moving if like there was a specific thing that she wanted rather than just this generalized, I want adventure and I like to read.
- 24:44Emily: Now, some of that is like by doing that, that means like so many little girls are like, Oh, that's me.
- 24:51Emily: You know, by being non-specific, you can you anyone can self-insert, but it really does lower the stakes because what is she fighting for?
- 25:00Emily: Now, her devotion to her dad is completely comprehensible, and like you know, her her willingness to to go after him and and switch with him is very brave and all of that.
- 25:11Emily: And there's a reason why they call this the first feminist Disney princess, but that's a low bar.
- 25:18Tracie: Yeah, okay, so the first feminist Disney princess, but but a low bar.
- 25:23Tracie: And um, and I think it's very it's really interesting that you name it as sort of middle class white feminism of the late 20th century.
- 25:31Tracie: I think that's a really it's very specific, but I do think accurate.
- 25:34Tracie: And we haven't talked about the Stockholm syndrome yet.
- 25:37Tracie: Are we gonna talk about that?
- 25:39Emily: Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 25:40Emily: So here's the thing that's really interesting on this rewatch.
- 25:44Emily: Is it Gaston and the Beast are not that different?
- 25:48Emily: It's just that the Beast is successful.
- 25:51Emily: Um, because Gaston is similarly trying to trap her, whereas the beast literally does.
- 25:59Emily: She is his prisoner.
- 26:01Emily: And the reason she starts to uh feel something for him is because he saves her life.
- 26:09Emily: And uh it's really hard for me to examine this uh rationally because this is my catnip.
- 26:20Emily: Like I still to this day love uh like enemies to lovers as a romance trope.
- 26:27Emily: I love uh like the bickering, but underneath they're really they really like each other.
- 26:33Emily: Um I love the like love of a good woman will transform a beastly man.
- 26:38Emily: Um I'm not proud of that, but it really, really hits me somewhere deep whenever I see it or read it.
- 26:47Emily: I don't know what of that is programming because I've gotten so much of it, and what of it is is, you know, actual inclinations on my part.
- 26:58Emily: But I don't think that it's a coincidence that, you know, my early crushes in terms of media, like John Bender, Mr.
- 27:08Emily: Rochester, the Beast, John Bender from The Breakfast Club, Mr.
- 27:11Emily: Rochester from Jane Eyre, um, Beast and from Beauty and the Beast, were like my idea of what romance is.
- 27:19Emily: And I dated a lot of people who were mean to me.
- 27:24Emily: And that really dovetails, like the this sense that the love of a good woman will turn around a beastly man, is something we are very much spoon-fed.
- 27:38Tracie: Yeah, we've definitely been conditioned by that one.
- 27:40Tracie: One of the ways that this movie conditioned us in that in in this the distinctions that it that it tries to make for us between Gaston and the Beast is that we see the beast vulnerable uh in ways that we do we do not see Gaston ever vulnerable.
- 27:56Tracie: We are shown that his meanness is actually because of his insecurity, or because he's been hurt, or because of his trauma.
- 28:04Tracie: Like we're we are we're we're spoon-fed the the breadcrumbs to the fact that it's a trauma response, or that like there was something.
- 28:11Tracie: I don't I don't remember.
- 28:12Tracie: It's I haven't seen it as recently as you have, but I remember like she had to tend a wound or something after the wolves.
- 28:16Tracie: Yes, and so we see and he like pulls away because it hurts.
- 28:20Tracie: So there's like a direct kind of like the meanness is because he's been hurt that we're given about the beast that we're not given about Gaston, he's just a jerk, and we're not given any reason for his jerkiness, yeah.
- 28:35Emily: But I I think that still like helps contribute to the conditioning, like well, and then the sense that there's something special about her because she can see past his beastliness, and so like, oh, I'm special because I can see the wounded little boy inside this violent man.
- 28:55Tracie: Yeah, yeah.
- 28:56Tracie: You don't see him how I see him.
- 28:58Tracie: I mean, that's like every bad teenage romance that we have been conditioned to swoon over.
- 29:04Emily: And when you just logistically within the story, when you have this child, because I mean she's what supposed to be 17, 18, maybe maybe as old as 20, but a child, um, who has no peers, no relationships with anyone other than her father, who is then isolated in a uh castle with no other humans, and then she sees the vulnerability from her captor, yeah, she's gonna start to feel for him, particularly since we've already established that she is a compassionate person.
- 29:40Emily: So it's wow.
- 29:42Emily: I mean, it's it's a I sometimes think about the media that we consume and how it will look in 500 years, presuming that humanity has progressed.
- 29:53Emily: Which survived, you mean that's a that's a that those are those are a couple of big assumptions on my part.
- 30:01Emily: But that because that's going to be like, wow, I can't believe they let little girls watch this.
- 30:05Emily: I can't believe they let little children watch this, and they thought thought this was you know good family entertainments and you know their highest awards is this is the only Disney film that was nominated for like the best film of the year Disney Award or Oscar Award.
- 30:21Emily: Not not just animated, not just animated, the regular category.
- 30:25Emily: And the thing is, it's it's an amazing film.
- 30:27Emily: Like it this is hand-drawn with the exception of the ballroom scene, which I remember yeah, um, I remember being in um uh my friend Jen's basement watching TV when an ad came on for it and they showed the sweeping ballroom scene.
- 30:44Emily: I was like, I gotta see that because of the CGI.
- 30:47Emily: And now looking back, it's the hand-drawn animation that I'm actually like, holy cow, it's amazing.
- 30:53Tracie: Yeah.
- 30:53Emily: So it is incredible entertainment, but yowza.
- 30:57Emily: I can remember you saying long, long time ago, it's also uncomfortable if you think about it, about this story, that Belle, let's say that this is genuine.
- 31:10Emily: She genuinely fell in love with the beast, and then she's got this milked toast white guy with blonde hair.
- 31:17Tracie: I remember that, right?
- 31:19Tracie: Like because if she genuinely fell in love with the beast, yeah, like who is this, who is this human being that she's now gonna marry?
- 31:27Emily: Yeah, and there is like I honestly, there is something to that because I I have been thinking about like the whole point of this is that she can see past appearances, right?
- 31:37Emily: But it's not just seeing past it, she fell in love with this hulking creature that didn't even know how to use a spoon anymore.
- 31:45Emily: Right.
- 31:46Emily: You know, like that's part of how it is.
- 31:49Tracie: I actually think that the that Hollywood kind of got that memo because in Shrek, right?
- 31:55Tracie: When True Love's Kiss is supposed to give her like her final form, and Fiona like is like excited to be a human again, and then like the magic happens and she's the ogress forever.
- 32:08Tracie: Like that actually was kind of great.
- 32:10Tracie: Because Shrek was in, you know, like I don't know, it it still is it's still is not perfect.
- 32:16Tracie: There's yeah, we maybe we'll do Shrek in another episode.
- 32:20Tracie: Oh, absolutely.
- 32:21Tracie: Yeah because I think there but I think there's there will be some when we do, I think there will be some interesting conversations between uh Shrek and Beauty and the Beast in terms of this question in particular about like what is the reward, right?
- 32:34Tracie: So the reward for Belle falling in love with a beast is to get a handsome prince.
- 32:40Tracie: But she's in love with that beast, yeah.
- 32:44Emily: And they, I mean, they they try to do it where she's like like weird around him, right?
- 32:49Emily: Right when she's taken aback and maybe and she's taken aback and she sees his eyes, like, oh, it is you.
- 32:53Emily: But who is he?
- 32:54Emily: This gets to something that I think might be too much for a Disney film to have to carry, but we are our bodies, and so who are we if we transform like that?
- 33:08Emily: And that's not to say that like a physical transformation changes who you are, you know.
- 33:12Emily: If if you know I were to become a paraplegic, that wouldn't change who I am.
- 33:16Emily: But that is different from me turning into a candlestick or a giant haul looking beast, you know?
- 33:22Emily: Yeah, it gets into some some really interesting stuff.
- 33:25Emily: We get at the end, Chip asks Mrs.
- 33:28Emily: Potts, like, are they gonna live happily ever after?
- 33:30Emily: Of course they are.
- 33:31Emily: Like, why?
- 33:32Emily: How?
- 33:33Emily: What do they have in common?
- 33:36Emily: What do I do on Saturday nights?
- 33:38Emily: You know?
- 33:38Emily: Yeah.
- 33:39Emily: It also is weird.
- 33:42Emily: I in I have headcanon that is different from from what the movie is.
- 33:46Emily: So we know that it's been 10 years since he was cursed, and the the rose is supposed to bloom until he turns 21, and then it will uh wilt.
- 33:54Emily: And once the last petal falls, if he hasn't found someone to love who loves him in return, he'll be a beast forever.
- 34:00Emily: Disney has made it clear he's 21, so he was 11 when uh when he was cursed.
- 34:05Tracie: When he was cursed.
- 34:06Emily: In my head, I have always I was like, okay, so he's 16 when he was cursed, and so like you know, they don't say that it was gonna um wilt quickly.
- 34:15Emily: It took five years.
- 34:17Emily: That's in my head.
- 34:19Tracie: Yeah, because as the mother of an 11-year-old, like do not judge an 11-year-old and curse them.
- 34:26Tracie: No, well, they're it is not the pinnacle of our species development in that age.
- 34:33Emily: And like, it's also like, why if he's 11 then he has never when when he's cursed, he he's never been a man.
- 34:43Emily: Yeah.
- 34:44Tracie: It's also like I think about at least in the story that's in my head, so I'm assuming it's from the Disney movie, like he's cursed because he is less than kind to an ugly old lady.
- 34:55Tracie: Like, I in my head, she was specifically ugly.
- 34:57Tracie: Yep, yeah, they made it that clear.
- 34:59Tracie: Who comes to the door and asks for hospitality or something, or and he's and he's unkind to her.
- 35:06Tracie: And like, that's not okay.
- 35:08Tracie: I'm not condoning that behavior, and also like stranger danger, how does this punishment fit the crime?
- 35:16Tracie: Yeah, how does this teach the I mean, like, there is no teachable moment in this curse, is what I'm getting at.
- 35:24Tracie: Like, if they if this consequence for unkindness, how is that actually leading to kindness?
- 35:34Tracie: Clearly, kindness isn't not, in fact, even hospitality is not in fact the goal.
- 35:42Emily: Well, it's I mean, they they try to make it that not to judge people by appearances, but then Belle is the most beautiful girl in the town.
- 35:52Emily: You know, like if it were a plain girl who'd who'd wandered in.
- 35:58Emily: The other aspect of this is what the hell did his servants do to deserve being transformed?
- 36:04Tracie: Yeah, they just had a job.
- 36:06Tracie: Yeah, yeah, they just worked for this Braddy King or Prince.
- 36:09Tracie: I I think back to when we talked about Ghostbusters and Winston is like, come on, man, I wasn't even there.
- 36:16Tracie: I just work here.
- 36:18Emily: Like, yes.
- 36:20Emily: So, and then the fact that the other thing that I it really hit me, and again, looking at it from like the Marxist perspective, when Belle is like, I have to go to my father, and he says, Okay, I'll let you go.
- 36:33Emily: You're no longer my prisoner, um, and is you know, just heartbroken because he loves her.
- 36:39Emily: What is his concern for his servants?
- 36:42Emily: Now, like it's one of those where like you can't force love, and his letting her go is proof of his love for her and and and all of that.
- 36:52Emily: I get that.
- 36:53Emily: But at the same time, it's also like, why is there no moment where he's like, Oh gosh, I want to let you go because I care about you, but I need you to be here because there's only you know a few petals left, and my my poor servants, they've been stuck like this for 10 years.
- 37:09Emily: And it's there's no sense of that.
- 37:11Emily: Is it entirely about him?
- 37:14Tracie: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 37:15Tracie: No, that but that comes back to the class consciousness that we talked about that you brought in in the very beginning.
- 37:20Tracie: Those these folks are, I mean, sonar peers, they're literally objects.
- 37:26Tracie: I mean, of course, like of course, like I don't think about how my actions are gonna affect my clock.
- 37:33Tracie: I I don't.
- 37:36Tracie: Yeah, it's a clock.
- 37:38Tracie: These people, these people who have who are employed by him have been so reduced of their humanity.
- 37:47Tracie: They're literally objects.
- 37:49Tracie: Of course, he doesn't think about how it affects them.
- 37:52Tracie: Yeah, they are possessions, they are literally possessions, yeah.
- 37:57Tracie: That's really messed up.
- 37:58Emily: It's it's grim.
- 38:00Emily: It's pretty grim.
- 38:01Emily: I kind of wish I could put all that back in a box because I do I did love this movie so much.
- 38:06Emily: Um, and it was still very enjoyable watching it the other night.
- 38:10Emily: And I have been singing.
- 38:12Emily: So when I think I was that December, I got um the the soundtrack.
- 38:20Tracie: Um, I remember I can I can see the CV in my head, yeah, with the rose and the beats.
- 38:25Emily: Yeah, yeah.
- 38:26Emily: Yeah.
- 38:26Emily: Um, and I I listened to it and listened to it over and over and over and over again.
- 38:32Emily: So like I like Howard Ashman and Alan Mencken were amazing.
- 38:37Emily: Like they were amazing lyricists.
- 38:40Emily: And the fact that Howard Ashman was a gay man has helped me to in some ways rearrange the furniture in my head in how I look at some of some of the movies that he he helped score.
- 38:53Emily: Particularly when I found out that The Little Mermaid is beloved by uh members of the trans community because it is a uh metaphor for being trans, um, helped me forgive the movie somewhat because it feels so anti-feminist because she literally gives up her voice for Oh, I'm with you.
- 39:10Emily: But when I could see it as a trans allegory, I can like, okay, okay, I can, I can, I can be a little more okay with it.
- 39:18Emily: And similarly, um the sense of feeling like a monster and the ways that like there's there's a line, and I cannot remember his name, Robbie White, I think, who did the voice for Beast, where he says, uh, and when we touched, she didn't shut her up, my paw, and like it's like he goes tenor all of a sudden.
- 39:37Emily: Uh-huh.
- 39:37Emily: And it's it's lovely.
- 39:39Emily: And I always loved that moment because yeah, that line is like in my head right now, actually.
- 39:43Tracie: Like even before you said it, I had that line in my head.
- 39:45Emily: Yeah.
- 39:46Emily: Um, and and so this sense of like feeling like a beast, and but being accepted for who you are and looking at it through an LGBTQ lens is something that makes it easier for me to accept the movie and its flaws and its worths.
- 40:04Emily: Even though they're there.
- 40:06Tracie: Um yeah, no, I I I actually think that that is actually is very powerful.
- 40:10Tracie: Sort of the self-hatred and navigating through self-hatred, where if we were to view this as like maybe she doesn't see the beast at all.
- 40:21Tracie: That's the way he thinks of himself, you know, and then then then the transformation because he is loved uh actually feels it does, it feels less uh less like conditioning if if I can go into that allegorical space of mental health and just just self-acceptance and self-love, or the opposite, self-loathing.
- 40:42Emily: Yeah.
- 40:43Emily: But there's, I mean, honestly, the other podcast that you and I have, Lightbringers, where we're discussing uh the TV show Lucifer.
- 40:50Emily: I believe that a big part of our love for that show is the same thing where it is a monster who is loved by a human woman and who does not see his monstrousness, but sees his humanity.
- 41:03Emily: She sees his humanity, yeah.
- 41:06Tracie: Yeah.
- 41:06Tracie: In and in that same show, there's also a great deal of self-loathing.
- 41:10Emily: Yes.
- 41:11Tracie: On the part of the the monster.
- 41:13Emily: The male.
- 41:14Emily: Yeah.
- 41:15Emily: Uh, and why, I mean, we've talked about this before.
- 41:19Emily: My favorite version of Lucifer in that show is uh devastated Lucifer.
- 41:24Tracie: Yeah.
- 41:25Emily: Just as in Beauty and the Beast, my favorite moments with the beast are when he is vulnerable and when Belle is standing up to him.
- 41:34Emily: There, there's something very powerful in that that again, I don't know is how much is conditioning and how much is just human.
- 41:42Tracie: Whew.
- 41:43Tracie: This one's got a lot.
- 41:44Tracie: I feel like we could keep talking about it for a while, but we've we've been talking.
- 41:48Tracie: So I'm gonna maybe try and see if we can do a little, if I can repeat back and do a little synthesis of what we talked about.
- 41:55Tracie: So you started with naming this as Disney's first feminist princess, but she's a very specific middle class, middle to upper class white feminist from the late 20th century.
- 42:09Emily: Yoga pants feminist.
- 42:10Emily: I should trademark that.
- 42:15Tracie: So, and I and I think that played out specifically in the the ways that other women, minimal as they are, are um not peers of Belle.
- 42:26Tracie: She is a better than.
- 42:27Tracie: Um, we talked about the Stockholm syndrome that Gaston tries to trap Belle and she hates him for it.
- 42:37Tracie: Beast literally traps her, does trap her, and she falls in love with him, which is pretty yucky.
- 42:45Tracie: Um I think your class analysis was really, really interesting when we sort of back and forth on the fact that the people who are employed by the by the beast have been transformed into the beast's possessions and are treated as such.
- 43:02Tracie: And um, what am I missing?
- 43:05Tracie: I feel like I'm missing something.
- 43:07Emily: So the the the self-loathing component of of it and how that could be an allegory for uh both mental health issues and also what it would feel like to have to be in the closet as uh a member of an LGBTQ community.
- 43:23Tracie: I think actually, so the research that you brought to to me today about the original story actually is among the most telling that really kind of is gonna underscore for me a lot of my understanding of this film moving forward, that it was written for girls of a certain social and class status to give them comfort and instruction for the arranged marriages in which they were likely to find themselves with men who they thought of as beasts.
- 43:54Emily: Wow.
- 43:55Emily: Well, and they they would likely be like much older than them.
- 43:59Emily: Yeah.
- 44:00Emily: Have nothing in common common.
- 44:02Tracie: I'm going to be carrying that around with me for a while.
- 44:06Tracie: That it's there's something really do you ever think about like I saw this, I guess it was a meme on social, but it was talking about the fact that like our train tracks, our roads are all the size that they are because that's the roughly the size of like a horse's ass.
- 44:18Tracie: So like Roman like carts and chariots that made the ruts, that made the roads that then we kept using, and now like cars and trains are the size they are because thousands of years ago our ancestors or predecessors made vehicles that fit or you know with the horse, the size of a single horse.
- 44:43Tracie: Um, and I this this feels like that where there's like a thing that we are doing as a species, psychologically, sociologically, that was sort of of necessity, maybe I don't know, I don't know.
- 44:58Tracie: We could argue about that.
- 44:59Tracie: Well, but it was was a reaction to a reality uh three or four hundred years ago.
- 45:05Tracie: And like, I mean, it's relatively neutral how wide a road is or the with the railroad tracks.
- 45:13Tracie: This is not neutral, and we're still doing it, and we're still like conditioning ourselves to not just find meaning, but actual find satisfaction and like seek out these these circumstances and these relationships that cause harm and not just to the women in them.
- 45:33Tracie: I mean, it the this this vision of masculinity that like be a beast until uh a woman like manages civilize you can pass it and civilize you, like that's not healthy for dudes either.
- 45:47Tracie: And I mean, forget about like the fact that there's just those two choices.
- 45:52Tracie: Yeah, so and that's that's gonna be with me for for a while.
- 45:57Tracie: Uh that's gonna be sitting with me for a while.
- 45:59Tracie: So thank you.
- 46:00Emily: It's uh I just went to see the Barbie movie yesterday, so I'm not sure when this is gonna air, but uh you know, just after it uh the Barbie movie came out, my kids were not interested in going.
- 46:11Emily: They are boys who are at at the time of this taping, nine, twelve years old.
- 46:15Emily: And the movie is all about the idea that patriarchy is an idea, and yet we keep perpetuating this idea that is so harmful.
- 46:25Emily: And this is part of what you're talking about.
- 46:28Emily: And even the people who are trying to subvert it in a way, so I know I personally am doing what I can within my life to try to subvert this.
- 46:39Emily: I would like to believe that Howard Ashman wanted to subvert the things that harmed him because patriarchy certainly harmed him, but we keep getting back into those horse-sized ruts because that's what we know, and that's the that's where we find meaning and um intrigue and and it seems natural, even.
- 47:04Tracie: Yeah, and we didn't even talk about speaking of LGBTQ stuff, we didn't even talk about the um what's the little guy's name?
- 47:11Tracie: Le Fou.
- 47:11Tracie: LeFu.
- 47:12Tracie: That means the fool.
- 47:14Tracie: Does that mean the fool?
- 47:15Tracie: It does, yeah.
- 47:15Tracie: So we didn't even talk about Le Fou and like what clearly to me, even then, when I was what 15 is uh like a homoerotic attraction between LeFou and Gaston in that direction.
- 47:29Tracie: I don't know that Gaston reciprocates, yeah.
- 47:31Tracie: Um, we didn't even talk about that.
- 47:33Tracie: We don't have time for that now.
- 47:34Tracie: But just throwing that out there as like a little cookie, yeah, cookie at the end.
- 47:39Emily: Yeah.
- 47:39Emily: Um, yeah, there's so much within this.
- 47:44Emily: I mean, it's not even a 90-minute movie to unpack that nobody saw.
- 47:50Emily: I mean, if they did, they were like, oh come on, it's just a movie, or you know.
- 47:54Tracie: Well, we're right, exactly.
- 47:55Tracie: That's why we're doing this show.
- 47:57Emily: But even um, I went back, uh, I have a great deal of respect and affection for Roger Ebert, and I went back to see what he said um about it.
- 48:04Emily: I remembered that he loved it, he gave it four stars, which that's that's the maximum.
- 48:10Emily: And he he did not give those out lightly.
- 48:13Emily: And he said he felt like a kid again watching it.
- 48:16Emily: And there were things that he had some blinders on.
- 48:19Emily: Um, I'm not gonna say Ebert was was any kind of perfect reviewer or critic or anything like that, but he was someone who saw the deeper meanings, even when they are not clear to the majority of audiences.
- 48:30Emily: And uh, this is gliding along on something that is uh so common and so expected in our culture that someone I respect as one of the deepest thinkers about film didn't see it.
- 48:46Tracie: Didn't see it, didn't or didn't see it as worthy of note.
- 48:50Emily: Yes, yeah, yeah.
- 48:51Emily: And that that to me is uh that's telling.
- 48:54Emily: That that that's telling.
- 48:55Emily: Now, I mean, some of it's you know, he was a commercial film critic, so he's writing for the general audience.
- 49:01Emily: And and you know, if he started talking about like class consciousness and you know, like second and third wave feminism, and I like would have turned off his readers of the Chicago Sun-Times.
- 49:11Emily: I get that.
- 49:12Emily: But it also like he didn't shy away from bringing up stuff that he found uncomfortable in films that no one else saw.
- 49:21Emily: So it's it's just interesting that this is it's it's so deeply embedded in our cultural consciousness that we don't even think to you know get some shovels and go digging.
- 49:32unknown: Whew.
- 49:33Tracie: Thank you.
- 49:34Emily: Still a fantastic soundtrack, though.
- 49:36Emily: Music is good.
- 49:38Emily: It is so good.
- 49:41Tracie: Yeah.
- 49:41Tracie: All right, well, I'll see you soon.
- 49:43Tracie: See you soon.
- 49:45Tracie: This show is a labor of love, but that doesn't make it free to produce.
- 49:49Tracie: If you enjoy it even half as much as we do, please consider helping to keep us overthinking.
- 49:55Tracie: You can support us at our Patreon.
- 49:57Tracie: There's a link in the show notes, or leave a positive review so others can find us.
- 50:02Tracie: And of course, share the show with your people.
- 50:05Tracie: Our theme music is Professor Umlaut by Kevin McLeod from Incompitech.com.
- 50:11Tracie: Find full music credits in the show notes.
- 50:14Tracie: Until next time, remember pop culture is still culture.
- 50:18Tracie: And shouldn't you know what's in your head?