Latest / Bourbon Bytes Podcast / $12,500 Eagle Rare, New Booker’s Batch, But Is Knob Creek Blender’s Edition the Best Buy?
Transcript
- 0:00Today on the Bourbon Bytes Podcast, Buffalo Trace just dropped an Eagle Rare worth over $12,000,
- 0:06Elijah Craig has yet another PGA Bourbon, and Booker's is back with its first batch of 2026.
- 0:12Then I have a 'Byte-Sized Review' of the new Knob Creek Blender's Edition.
- 0:29Hello everyone and welcome to the Bourbon Bytes podcast. I'm your host Clifton,
- 0:34and this is the week of Thursday, April 23rd, 2026. I hope you all are having a fantastic week,
- 0:41and it seems to be a fantastic week in the world of bourbon news because we have a lot to talk
- 0:47about today. The first of which you most likely have probably already heard of, but Buffalo Trace
- 0:52has just announced a new 30-year-old edition of Eagle Rare. And before you get too excited,
- 0:59this bottle is retailing for over $12,000. This is the type of whiskey that makes non-whiskey
- 1:06people think we've lost our minds. So this new edition of Eagle Rare is actually the oldest
- 1:11age-stated bourbon that Buffalo Trace has ever released. Back in 2023, they released a 25-year-old
- 1:18version of Eagle Rare, so this is the continuation of their exploration of extended maturation. Now
- 1:24like Eagle Rare 25, this was also aged in their mysterious Warehouse P, which has been their home
- 1:31for experimentation across the brand's lineup. So what's interesting about that is this series is
- 1:37designed to explore whether extended aging can enhance American whiskey in the same way that it
- 1:42does in more temperate climates such as Japan, Scotland, and Ireland. So I imagine they're doing
- 1:48a lot of things with temperature control here in this warehouse to make sure that this 30-year-old
- 1:52bourbon is hopefully not over-oaked. But let's be honest, if you're paying $12,500 for a bourbon,
- 2:00do you really care how it tastes? I don't know. This ultra-premium world of whiskey is something
- 2:04that I've never really understood. Even before I was into whiskey, I would see, you know,
- 2:08Macallan bottles going for tens of thousands of dollars. And to me, that just doesn't scream
- 2:14someone that loves to drink whiskey. That screams someone with a lot of money and maybe a lot of
- 2:20power and influence. I don't know, maybe I'm just being influenced by the media, but I can't imagine
- 2:25a bourbon being worth $12,500. It is a beautiful bottle, as with all these ultra-premium bourbons.
- 2:34But to me, it seems a little bit like an excessive way to flaunt your wealth. They do say that Eagle
- 2:40Rare 30 is not simply about time, it's about what time can reveal. They say aging whiskey in Kentucky
- 2:45comes with inherent challenges such as evaporation and barrel influence intensity, but they say that
- 2:51the environment within Warehouse P allows them to manage those effects, softening the extraction and
- 2:56preserving the nuanced flavor that defined ultra-age bourbon. So it is good to hear that they're not
- 3:02just throwing whiskey in a barrel for 30 years and just hoping it comes out good. It seems like
- 3:07this is a very intentional release where they are experimenting with those elements that are very
- 3:12non-Kentucky. You know, the reason that Kentucky bourbon is so intense and so flavorful, even at a
- 3:17young age, is because of those crazy climate changes that happen throughout the year from
- 3:22winter to summer. The extraction of the barrel is what's causing all that. So when you have a
- 3:27temperature-controlled warehouse like their experimental one, you can technically age whiskey
- 3:31for as long as you want. Of course, there's probably some caveats there as well, with it
- 3:35being new charred oak barrels versus reused cast like we see in Scotland and Ireland. But it is an
- 3:41interesting experiment. I just don't necessarily see it for the general consumer who would actually
- 3:46be curious about that. So if you are wondering the best way to get your hands on this new Eagle Rare
- 3:5130, you can look no further than Bonhams, which is one of the world's most respected auction houses.
- 3:58They actually have 15 different curated lots, including one that is the complete collection
- 4:03of the Eagle Rare portfolio. That includes Eagle Rare 10, 12, 17, Double Eagle Very Rare, 25, and 30.
- 4:11It's also paired with a luxury experience at Stagg Lodge, which is the distiller's private
- 4:16invite-only lodge overlooking the campus. And that auction is going to go live this Friday at 7 a.m.
- 4:22EST. So if you are going to be bidding on that, that's probably the best chance to do it if you
- 4:28have that kind of money and are, you know, wanting the VIP experience. I mean, I feel like if you're
- 4:33going to pay that much, you might as well go all out, right? And if you're looking for a guest to
- 4:38join you on that experience, well, I might clear my calendar just for you. Now, a little bit more
- 4:43relevant news coming to us from Buffalo Trace Distillery is the grand opening of their John G.
- 4:49Carlisle Cafe. It's going to be the distillery's first permanent dining destination. Now, this
- 4:54place is primarily focused on lunchtime service. It has a 4,900 square foot cafe and can seat up to
- 5:0170 guests with additional seating on the patio. It says they have food like made-to-order sandwiches,
- 5:07salads, and desserts as well. And of course, classics like the Kentucky Hot Brown. Now, like other
- 5:12distillery site eateries, they are infusing the world of bourbon into their menu. They're having
- 5:18a bourbon bacon, a barrel-aged coffee, a bourbon-infused fudge topping and whipped cream,
- 5:24and more. They also have select cocktails featuring Buffalo Trace spirits available for purchase,
- 5:30including an old-fashioned, a Wheatley Vodka Peach Mule, and a Traveler Whiskey Lucky Penny. I love
- 5:36to see this. You know, I don't make it out to Kentucky that often, but visiting distilleries
- 5:39has become more than just doing the tour or visiting the gift shop and leave. It's about
- 5:43just spending time with people and just getting to understand the land and the culture behind it.
- 5:48I've heard some great stories about different cafes on site at all the main Kentucky distilleries,
- 5:54so it's nice to see Buffalo Trace get in on the action. Now, they're going to have a three-week
- 5:58lineup of daily specials throughout the month of May, so if you are local, definitely check out
- 6:02the press release for this. You should be able to find it just searching John G. Carlisle Cafe.
- 6:07They're doing things like Free Meal Mondays, From the Archives Open House Event on Tuesdays,
- 6:13and fun things like Whiskey Wednesdays with complimentary samples of new, soon-to-be releases
- 6:19all day, and much, much more. They basically have things going on every single day in May after they
- 6:25open. By the way, opening date is May 11th of this year. They're going to be open from Monday
- 6:30through Sunday from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m., so definitely seems cool. I would love to visit.
- 6:36All right, well, we have yet another new release from Elijah Craig,
- 6:39continuing their tradition of releasing special PGA Championship bottles. Now, some of these have
- 6:44been great, others have been just kind of okay, but this is a celebration of the tournament's 108th
- 6:50year by releasing a 108-proof bourbon. So, last year's release was bottled at 94 proof, so this
- 6:56is a pretty big jump up in proof. Now, as with some of these other releases, it's pulled from
- 7:00specific rickhouses in the distillery, so this one particularly is from N and S, and that's a tribute to
- 7:07the historic Newtown Square, Pennsylvania, which I assume is where the PGA is taking place this year.
- 7:14I've actually really liked these in the past, especially the higher proof ones.
- 7:18I know that in some past years they've done some additional finishing on these releases,
- 7:21and those have really been the highlights to me, but I do love seeing a higher proof offering. I
- 7:25think it's kind of a nice way to try Elijah Craig at higher proof, but not quite barrel strength. So,
- 7:31I'll definitely be seeking out a bottle. Retail on this is only going to be $36.99,
- 7:35so I think it's a very fair price for a special commemorative bottle. It has a really nice cork,
- 7:41it has a special label. As someone that doesn't necessarily care about the PGA,
- 7:45it's still a really good bourbon. I'm just an Elijah Craig fan, so getting a chance to try it
- 7:49at 108 proof sounds like a good time. So, I'll be keeping an eye out for that. You'll probably get a
- 7:54review of it here soon on the podcast once I do. Another one that you may or may not get a review
- 7:59of on the podcast is the first release of Booker's Bourbon for 2026. This was announced back in
- 8:06March, but I'm just now starting to see it show up around the country. This is called the Big Easy
- 8:12Batch and is a tribute to one of Booker Knows' favorite cities, New Orleans. And I love New
- 8:17Orleans, so that kind of caught my eye as well. This limited release is the 2026-01 batch. It's
- 8:22going to be aged 7 years, 2 months, and 15 days, and bottled at 129.1 proof with a suggested retail
- 8:29price of $100. So yeah, still pricey, still typical Booker's age and proof. I will say I
- 8:37revisited my 2025 Booker's probably a couple weeks ago, and it was better than I remembered.
- 8:43I just think once they're up there in that price, I'm not going to seek out every single batch.
- 8:48But with this being a tribute to New Orleans as, again, one of my favorite cities, I might pick
- 8:52this up for the novelty of that. I love the stories with these Booker's batches. You know,
- 8:56you're buying it for not just the whiskey inside, but the story behind it. At least I am,
- 9:01because Booker's is always kind of meant to be a collectible piece, right? It comes in this special
- 9:05box, and the little card inside tells you about why they picked the name and the story behind it.
- 9:11So I think they're really fun, especially when they have a specific meaning that's important to
- 9:15you. I just am not at the point where I'm buying every single batch of Booker's like I used to,
- 9:20unfortunately. But I might pick this one up. If I do, I'll let you guys know. Or if you
- 9:25particularly think this is an amazing batch, let me know. Or if I should skip it, also let me know.
- 9:30Just basically, if there's ever an exciting batch of Booker's that you think is above the norm,
- 9:37reach out to me on Discord or shoot me an email, contact@bourbonbytes.com,
- 9:42and I'll pick it up and review it. I just am not buying every batch. So if there's an exceptional
- 9:47one, I'm happy to pick it up. But until then, I'll stick to the ones that speak to me, like the Big
- 9:52Easy batch. All right, well, before we get into our Byte-Sized review, I do have a couple of TTB
- 9:57labels to talk about. Of course, these are featured from @ComingWhiskey on Instagram.
- 10:02Check him out and make sure to follow for the latest and greatest TTB filings, one of which
- 10:07is the new release of the Old Forester 117 Series. Now, this one's kind of interesting
- 10:14because it is really just Warehouse L barrels. They say that this is the newest addition to the
- 10:20Brown-Forman Distillery, and they say its unique character stems from the barrel-rick configuration
- 10:25with only four separate floors, but the ricks extend to six high. They say that this design
- 10:31results in distinct micro-environments that influence the maturation process. I don't
- 10:36think people are too excited about this. I mean, unless you know what that flavor profile is from
- 10:40Warehouse L, it's a little, um, it's a little vague. They say this is going to come out in
- 10:46December of 2026. Proof is going to be 95 proof, and it's batch number one. I'm curious
- 10:52if they're going to do other batches because they mentioned this is going to be a micro-environment
- 10:55within that warehouse. I'm curious to see if they're going to maybe release this whiskey
- 10:59at the different micro-environments. I don't know. I'll keep an eye out. But the more interesting
- 11:04label I saw is a new Heaven Hill Bottled in Bond. Now, this is basically the exact same label as the
- 11:11Blue Label Bottled in Bond bourbon that they have available, but this is a red label, and it says
- 11:16a Double Mash. It says a masterful union of wheated and traditional Kentucky straight bourbon
- 11:22whiskey. So it sounds like they're combining their bourbon mash bill with the high rye with
- 11:27their wheated bourbon mash bill and doing a double mash at nine years old. Of course, this is going
- 11:33to be 100 proof, so same proof as all Bottled in Bond bourbons. They say tasty notes of toasted oak
- 11:39and honey with gentle spice and bright citrus and a finish of rich caramel and baking spices.
- 11:45That sounds really good. I do like Heaven Hill's wheated mash bill. I like their rye bourbon mash
- 11:51bill, and I think this is a fun combination. I think maybe it'll taste somewhere between like
- 11:57an Elijah Craig or even a Larceny or Henry McKenna. I'm not really sure exactly what this
- 12:02flavor profile is going to be, but I will definitely keep an eye out for that. Again,
- 12:06no official announcement. This is just a TTB label filing. I will follow up as soon as I know more
- 12:11about that whiskey, but it's definitely going to be one of the most exciting releases of the year
- 12:15for me because I love that blue label Bottled in Bond. All right. Well, that does it for this
- 12:20week's whiskey news. Now it's time to get into our 'Byte-Sized Review'. All right. Well, I actually
- 12:34first talked about this week's whiskey a couple of weeks back on my April 9th episode. I talked
- 12:40about what Knob Creek Blender's Edition was all about, but I'll summarize it for you here. This
- 12:46new permanent addition to the Knob Creek lineup where they're exploring different flavor profiles
- 12:51through blending. The one I'm reviewing today is Edition 01, and it's labeled a sweet bourbon
- 12:57blend. So this blend is specifically targeting those sweeter flavor profiles. And for a Knob
- 13:03Creek, that's pretty interesting because Knob Creek, I usually think of as rich and dark,
- 13:07and maybe that's why they chose that for this release. They say on the side of the bottle,
- 13:11compared to the caramel and char of our classic nine-year bourbon, this experimental expression
- 13:16has confectionery notes from specially selected barrels. Enjoy vanilla and warm oak. So it doesn't
- 13:23sound like they're deviating too far from their flavor profile. It's just meant to focus mainly on
- 13:29those sweeter vanilla notes. And there's a little chart on the side of the bottle that shows you
- 13:33where the flavor is different from their standard releases. And it's definitely spiking more in the
- 13:39of sweet and vanilla, whereas the traditional looks like it usually spikes closer to the caramel,
- 13:44char, and even spice. Now it is coming in with a specific age statement. This one says
- 13:50aged 10 years. However, that doesn't seem to be the main indication on this bottle. I could maybe
- 13:56anticipate that age statement going away because it's in very small font just below Kentucky
- 14:00straight bourbon whiskey. But the good news is it is higher proof than regular Knob Creek. It is 106
- 14:05proof. So like I talked about when I announced this, there have kind of been some mixed things
- 14:09online about this whiskey. I knew I had to try it for myself as someone that just loves Knob Creek
- 14:14as a brand who has really tried almost every expression I've been able to get my hands on
- 14:19from Knob Creek. So I'm excited to see a new one, especially a permanent addition to the lineup.
- 14:24I had to give it a try and share my thoughts. So I'm very glad that I finally found a bottle.
- 14:29I've been enjoying it quite a bit, mostly in cocktails, which I'll talk about in just a little
- 14:34bit before we get into my final thoughts and score and everything. But today we're going to
- 14:38be trying it neat for the purposes of this Byte-Sized Review. Let's go ahead and give it a nose.
- 14:45Well, lucky for us off the bat, this is smelling pretty similar to regular Knob Creek. I will say
- 14:51it's far less oaky. And maybe I'm just thinking of more of the older single barrels of Knob Creek
- 14:57or not even the older ones, just the cast strength releases. Those to me are kind of oak bombs. This
- 15:02has some of that there. It's not completely gone, but it is a lot more sweet up front.
- 15:08And I'm thinking like vanilla is a pretty spot on note. It's not those darker, richer
- 15:13caramel bakery notes that I sometimes get on a Jim Beam product. Instead, it's bright. It's a
- 15:19little, I don't want to say floral, but it's definitely more of like a vanilla scented candle
- 15:23on the nose. There's also a lot of corn sweetness there. It kind of has a little bit of a creamed
- 15:28corn kind of thing going on that I think actually compliments the vanilla. It's not like they're
- 15:32competing necessarily. It rounds it out a little bit more and makes it a little bit more of a
- 15:36natural smell versus like an artificial vanilla you might get on, like I said, a candle.
- 15:41But like I said, it's not devoid of that oak and char. It's still there. It's just kind of a little
- 15:45bit on the back burner compared to what I'm used to. There is a little bit of a fruitiness coming
- 15:50on the nose here, but it's really bright fruit. I'm actually thinking more of like a cranberry
- 15:55or even like a sugar coated cranberry. And I think that's a thing. I think I've had that in a
- 16:00Christmas themed cocktail before, but very, very bright,
- 16:04leaning towards that vanilla sweetness. So let's go in and give it a taste. Cheers.
- 16:10Oh yeah. Well, first of all, I like that it's high proof, you know, something like this,
- 16:15I would almost be worried they would kind of pull the Basil Hayden's path of being lower proof and
- 16:20just a brighter, sweeter flavor profile. But they are keeping this targeted for what I think is a
- 16:25core Knob Creek audience. Those who like 100 plus proof whiskeys. And believe it or not, they
- 16:30were right. It is sweet. It's not as sweet as I was worried about. I think it's just more of a
- 16:35slight nuance compared to regular Knob Creek. It definitely leans less oaky, a little more bright.
- 16:41It honestly, you know what it kind of reminds me of? It reminds me of some of those special
- 16:45Jim Beam bottlings that aren't available anymore. One of my favorites was the Distiller's Cut,
- 16:50which is a hundred proof expression. I think it used to have an age statement on it too.
- 16:53And then of course the Repeal Batch that a lot of people had as their favorite.
- 16:57This kind of leans a little bit in that territory, but with the character of a Knob Creek,
- 17:02I don't want to say this tastes like a Jim Beam product, like a core label product.
- 17:06This definitely has elements that make me think this is a Knob Creek product, which I think of
- 17:10as the more premium line. If we ignore the Smoked Maple Knob Creek release that doesn't belong in it
- 17:15whatsoever. That's a conversation for a different day. This definitely feels like a Knob Creek
- 17:20product and I'm pretty impressed with it. It is up front with that bold vanilla flavor.
- 17:26That's hard to miss, but there's a little bit of a nuttiness that I kind of think is kind
- 17:30of what's reminded me of those Jim Beam releases. Now, do I think this is a very complex nuanced
- 17:34bourbon? No, not really. I think it, you know, is probably a little more elevated than standard
- 17:40Knob Creek nine year, just the hundred proofer, but I'm not usually buying that one. I'm usually
- 17:44buying, like I said, the single barrel releases or some of their other one-off releases.
- 17:49Not that there's anything wrong with the regular Knob Creek nine. It's just, I usually go for some
- 17:54of their, you know, higher proof or more limited releases, which brings up the question of price.
- 17:59So this Blender's Edition, I got for about $45, which is about $15 more than the standard Knob
- 18:06Creek and also about $15 to $25 less than some of the Knob Creek Single Barrel Reserve picks.
- 18:13So it falls right there in the middle of the pricing of those two releases. And I think that's
- 18:18actually where it needs to be. I'm glad to see this. Isn't like some crazy expensive,
- 18:23you know, 80 to a hundred dollar release of Knob Creek. You know, I don't want it to put
- 18:27itself into the Booker's territory where I won't be buying them, but at $45. Yeah,
- 18:31I'm excited to pick this up. I'm excited for future releases. Hopefully there are some that
- 18:36go a little bit different in direction. You know, I do like those darker, oakier, toastier notes on
- 18:41a Knob Creek. So I'd love to see if maybe the next one is, you know, one of these other flavor
- 18:45profiles they highlight on their back sticker because the label shows oak, char, smoke, caramel,
- 18:51vanilla, sweet, spice, fruit, and floral as the categories. So it sounds like it can lean any of
- 18:57those directions with these blenders editions. But like I said, before I get into the score,
- 19:02here's the kicker. I've been enjoying the heck out of this bottle in cocktails, whether it's an
- 19:08Old Fashioned or a Manhattan, I've used up almost half the bottle exclusively drinking it that way.
- 19:13So while this review is based on my neat, you know, neat poor impression, I'm going to consider
- 19:19the fact that this does amazing in a cocktail when I figure out my score because I think that plays
- 19:24a factor into it. You know, I'm not always drinking whiskey neat. I am most of the time,
- 19:29but I'm always looking for that go-to spirit forward cocktail bourbon and this checks a lot
- 19:35of those boxes. So that being said, I keep my score simple here based on everything from price,
- 19:40availability, nose, palate, finish. Oh, I forgot to mention finish. Finish is medium. It's not
- 19:45anything crazy short or crazy long. It just hits right where it needs to be. It does bring up some
- 19:50of those darker notes that aren't at the forefront of the palate on the finish. So you do get a
- 19:54little bit of that oak and that char on the back end. So I appreciate those show up back there.
- 19:59But anyways, in terms of score, I think this is a hit from Knob Creek. I think it's a great
- 20:05addition to the lineup. It gives me something to fill that void of not picking up every Booker's
- 20:10batch, but trying different blends at a very reasonable price. So with that being said,
- 20:15I'm going to give this an 8 out of 10. You know, it's not something that I'm going to reach for
- 20:19regularly as a neat pour, but there's nothing wrong with it as a neat pour. It's definitely
- 20:24a step above the Knob Creek 100. Not quite as good as some of those single barrel selects,
- 20:28but pricing, it makes total sense where it's at. But I will be buying multiple bottles of this as
- 20:34a cocktail whiskey because I love a spirit forward cocktail. And so far, this Blender's
- 20:39Edition has stood up to every single cocktail I've put it in. So for me, 8 out of 10 is a
- 20:44shelf recommendation. Definitely buy it once. If you love it, buy multiple bottles of it.
- 20:49Definitely give this a try if you see it on the shelf because you're not really taking big risk.
- 20:53You know, if you like Knob Creek 100, this is $15 more and higher proof and a cool story. So
- 20:58definitely give it a try. Let me know what you think. I'd be curious to hear what you all think
- 21:03of it. But that does it for this week's episode. Thank you all so much for listening. I also want
- 21:07to give a shout out to our newest Byte Club member, which is your way to support the channel
- 21:11for as little as $2 a month. Huge shout out to Wayne, who is our newest Bourbon Bit, which is the
- 21:16$2 tier. At that tier, you get access to our full membership page where you get early access to
- 21:21podcast episodes when I can do them in time, chances to vote on upcoming episodes and whiskeys
- 21:27I drink during those episodes and polls just like I did last week on YouTube. And just an inside
- 21:32look into the behind the scenes of the channel. So if you want to support the channel like Wayne,
- 21:37you can go to bourbonbytes.com or patreon.com/bourbonbytes wherever you feel the most
- 21:41comfortable supporting and look into those tiers because there are some really great rewards for
- 21:47our incredible Byte Club members. So thank you, Wayne. Thank you to the Byte Club. Thank you to
- 21:51my Bourbon Daddy, Donnie Webb. And until next time, this has been the Bourbon Bytes Podcast,
- 21:56a whiskey podcast with a gaming twist. Cheers, and I'll talk to you guys next episode.