Latest / Deep Dive / Why Groups Fight to Be the Victim
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine a prize that is just so incredibly valuable, so
- 0:05incredibly laden with power, that entire societies will
- 0:09literally go to war just to win it.
- 0:11Right, but we are not talking about a piece of land here.
- 0:14Exactly. Yeah, It's not a natural
- 0:16resource like oil, and it's definitely not gold.
- 0:19The prize is an identity. It's a social standing, really.
- 0:23Yeah, it's the ability to prove to the entire world that you
- 0:27have, like, suffered more than anyone.
- 0:30Which is wild, because, I mean, it completely upends our
- 0:33standard understanding of human nature.
- 0:35Totally. Like our default psychological
- 0:37response to seeing someone suffer is just, well,
- 0:39compassion, right? Yeah, it's automatic.
- 0:41Right If you see someone slip on an icy sidewalk, or you know you
- 0:45read about a community devastated by a hurricane, your
- 0:47brain recognizes a state of helplessness.
- 0:49You recognize a victim. Exactly.
- 0:51And a social contract kicks in. You you want to help restore
- 0:56justice for someone who has been wrong through no fault of their
- 0:59own. Right.
- 1:00I mean, in our everyday lives, being a victim is something we
- 1:03generally want to avoid. It's a state of vulnerability.
- 1:05But when you zoom out and, you know, step onto the world stage,
- 1:09into the murky, devastating arena of historical and
- 1:12geopolitical conflicts, that clean, straightforward dynamic
- 1:16just completely shattered. It evaporates.
- 1:19Yeah, instead of being a status associated with helplessness,
- 1:22victimhood transforms into this fiercely coveted race war it.
- 1:26Really becomes a crown. It does, and welcome to this
- 1:29deep dive. Today, we are bringing you along
- 1:31on a mission to unpack one of the most counterintuitive, yet
- 1:35fundamentally important psychological phenomena shaping
- 1:39our world. Because it really is everywhere
- 1:41once you know what to look for. Yeah, we are unpacking why
- 1:45groups locked in violent conflicts actively compete to
- 1:48claim the title of the biggest victim, and honestly, more
- 1:52importantly, why understanding this bizarre psychological
- 1:54competition is essentially a cheat code for making sense of
- 1:58human behavior and global conflict.
- 2:01Right. What's fascinating here is that
- 2:02once you see the underlying cognitive architecture, you
- 2:05realize that groups aren't just arguing over history.
- 2:08No, they're doing so much more. Yeah, they are expending massive
- 2:11amounts of psychological and political energy to prove that
- 2:14their suffering is the ultimate exclusive suffering.
- 2:17I mean, they are fighting for survival on a cognitive level.
- 2:20And to help you, we see this architecture we are pulling from
- 2:22a really incredible stack of research today.
- 2:25The foundational stuff. Yeah, the main text for our
- 2:28journey today is a really comprehensive psychological
- 2:32review paper from 2012. It was published in the
- 2:35Personality and Social Psychology Review.
- 2:38By Noor, Schnabel, Haleby and Nadler.
- 2:41That's the one. It's titled When Suffering
- 2:43Begets Suffering, and we're also weaving in some crucial insights
- 2:48from a massive 2017 study out of Belgium.
- 2:51Which is a great addition because it looks at demographic
- 2:53samples. Right.
- 2:54It confirms that the mental gymnastics we're going to talk
- 2:56about aren't just isolated to one culture like they hold true
- 3:00across entirely different linguistic and cultural lines.
- 3:03But before we take another step, though, we really need to
- 3:06establish a very clear boundary for you, the listener.
- 3:09Yeah, this is super important. Because the source material we
- 3:12are unpacking explores the cognitive mechanics behind some
- 3:16of the most sensitive, politically charged, and
- 3:18historically tragic conflicts in human history.
- 3:21For talking heavy stuff. Very heavy.
- 3:23The data draws on the Israeli Palestinian conflict, the
- 3:27Rwandan genocide, the Troubles in Northern Ireland and Pinochet
- 3:30regime in Chile, among others. And I just want to look you in
- 3:33the eye, so to speak, and be crystal clear about this.
- 3:36Neither of us are here to take sides, Not at all.
- 3:39We are not endorsing any specific political viewpoints,
- 3:42and we are absolutely not passing moral judgement on the
- 3:46historical realities, the validity of the claims, or, you
- 3:49know, the profound tragedies of these events, right?
- 3:51The sole purpose of this deep dive is to impartially report on
- 3:56the psychological framework presented in the scientific
- 3:58source material. We are putting human cognition
- 4:01under a microscope. Exactly.
- 4:02We want to help you understand the psychology of why these
- 4:04cycles perpetuate strictly through the lens of the data.
- 4:07Right. We are looking at the wiring of
- 4:09the human brain rather than litigating the political or
- 4:13historical validity of specific geopolitical claims.
- 4:16It's about understanding the engine, not judging the
- 4:18destination. I love that.
- 4:20So with that mission firmly in mind, let's start with the
- 4:23foundation. The term the researchers use is
- 4:26competitive victimhood. Yeah.
- 4:28What exactly is that and how does it actually work in
- 4:30practice? So at its core, intergroup
- 4:33competitive victimhood is a group's underlying motivation
- 4:37and their subsequent active efforts to establish that they
- 4:40have suffered more than their adversaries.
- 4:42So it's an active competition. Oh, very active.
- 4:44It is this profound drive to be recognized as the true or even
- 4:49the exclusive victim of a conflict.
- 4:52And what's critical to understand is the environment
- 4:55where this thrives. Like it doesn't just sprout up
- 4:58out of nowhere. Right.
- 4:58The sources outlined that it happens in two main types of
- 5:01conflict environments, right? Like direct violence and
- 5:03structural violence. Yeah, and there are very
- 5:05different environments that trigger the exact same
- 5:07psychological response. Which is wild.
- 5:09It really is so Direct violence is what we traditionally picture
- 5:13War, bombings, mass harm, physical casualties.
- 5:18Lab stuff. Exactly.
- 5:20Structural violence, on the other hand, is systemic.
- 5:23It's institutional discrimination, severe
- 5:26inequality, the deliberate denial of access to housing,
- 5:30voting rights or education. The quieter but still
- 5:33devastating stuff. Right.
- 5:34But in both of those environments, whether a group is
- 5:38facing a military offensive or decades of systemic oppression,
- 5:42you see the emergence of this intense striving to prove their
- 5:45victimization is paramount. OK, let's unpack this, because
- 5:49it creates what the authors describe as a tragic stalemate.
- 5:52A total gridlock. Yeah, because if my group is
- 5:55entirely convinced that we are the ultimate exclusive victim,
- 5:58and your group is entirely convinced that the exact same
- 6:00thing about yourselves, yeah, we hit a brick.
- 6:02Wall right, Nobody moves. Because both sides believe it is
- 6:06100% the other party's responsibility to initiate
- 6:08peace. The logic is just incredibly
- 6:11destructive. It is.
- 6:12It's like we are the true victims.
- 6:14You hurt us the most, therefore you must be the ones to
- 6:16compromise, apologize and lay down your weapons.
- 6:19And if the other side operates on the exact same logic, nobody
- 6:22takes a single step forward. The stalemate becomes the engine
- 6:26of intractability. It just, you know, freezes the
- 6:29conflict in amber. It really does.
- 6:30The way it reads in the research, competitive victimhood
- 6:34operates almost like a bizarre arms race.
- 6:36That's a good way to put it. Right.
- 6:38But instead of stock piling nuclear weapons or fighter jets,
- 6:41these groups are basically stockpiling grievances.
- 6:44Yes, they are taking their profound grief and forging it
- 6:48into a shield and a sword, because holding that victim
- 6:51crown somehow grants immense social and political power.
- 6:55Weaponizing wounds is a very accurate way to frame it, and
- 6:58honestly, it brings us to the fundamental paradox at the heart
- 7:01of this entire phenomenon, which is well, objectively speaking,
- 7:04intractable conflicts almost always involve mutual
- 7:08victimization, right? Even in highly asymmetrical
- 7:10situations where you know one side has undeniably suffered
- 7:14vastly more casualties or endured far greater structural
- 7:17oppression, the objective reality remains that the other
- 7:20side has also experienced some level of pain or loss.
- 7:23Because it's a conflict. Harm goes both ways.
- 7:25Exactly. Harm in some form has traveled
- 7:28in both directions. Yet the psychological state of
- 7:31competitive victimhood provides groups with the cognitive tools
- 7:35to entirely dismiss, minimize, or outright deny the other sides
- 7:39pain. It turns reality into a strict 0
- 7:43sum game. Meaning like, if my group
- 7:46possesses the status of victim, your group cannot possibly
- 7:50possess it, right? So any acknowledgement that your
- 7:53people have suffered somehow mathematically subtracts from
- 7:56the validity of my people's suffering.
- 7:57It creates a reality where two contradictory things cannot be
- 8:00true at once. And this denial, it operates on
- 8:032 tracks simultaneously. OK, walk me through the tracks.
- 8:06So you have the collective level, which is the macro view.
- 8:08This is driven by political leaders shaping discourse, mass
- 8:11media framing the news, and the education system constructing a
- 8:15national historical narrative. Like the top down stuff?
- 8:19But that macro level only works because it is feeding the
- 8:22individual level. This is how everyday regular
- 8:25group members internalize that rigid victim identity into their
- 8:28own personal, daily sense of self.
- 8:30And the sources provide a pretty harrowing illustration of how
- 8:33deeply this mutual exclusivity penetrates.
- 8:36Right, by looking at the Wanda genocide, Yeah.
- 8:39Rwanda is a stark, complex case study in how entrenched this
- 8:44mindset gets, even in the face of overwhelming objective
- 8:47reality. Yeah, it's intense.
- 8:49During and after the 1994 genocide, where Hutu extremists
- 8:53systematically murdered hundreds of thousands of Tutsis,
- 8:56researchers observed elements of the Hutu population actively
- 8:59competing for the victim. Role which sounds completely
- 9:02contradictory to what the world saw.
- 9:04It does. They would point to historical
- 9:06oppression under colonial rule or subsequent retaliatory,
- 9:10basically to maintain a victim narrative despite having just
- 9:13committed a globally recognized genocide.
- 9:15But the sources also know the dynamic on the other side as
- 9:18well, right? Yes, they do.
- 9:20The Tutsis dealing with the profound, unimaginable, and
- 9:22entirely justified trauma of a genocide committed against them
- 9:26would often cognitively dismiss or minimize their own historical
- 9:29role in oppressing the Hutu majority in the decades and
- 9:32centuries prior. So the mindset of competitive
- 9:34victimhood literally demands absolute purity.
- 9:37It cannot tolerate nuance. It cannot tolerate shared blame.
- 9:42One side must be the pure, unblemished victim and the other
- 9:46must be the pure, irredeemable perpetrator.
- 9:49OK, but I keep getting stuck on this one point.
- 9:51What's that? If this mindset fundamentally
- 9:54defies objective reality? I mean, if it requires a normal,
- 9:58rational person to look at the visible suffering of another
- 10:01human being and feel absolutely nothing or even deny it's
- 10:05happening, how does the brain actually pull that off?
- 10:07It's a great question. Like what is happening inside
- 10:10the skull of an individual to make them so blind to their
- 10:13adversary's pain? To answer that, we really have
- 10:15to open up the hood and look at the engine.
- 10:17Let's do it. We have to examine the specific
- 10:19cognitive biases that every single human being possesses,
- 10:23which, when triggered by conflict, create this massive
- 10:26blind spot. And the first mechanism the
- 10:28researchers highlight is a psychological concept called
- 10:31moral typecasting. Oh man, I want to spend some
- 10:34time on this because when I read about moral typecasting it
- 10:37genuinely broke my brain a little bit.
- 10:39It's a foundational quirk of human cognition.
- 10:42The human brain is constantly bombarded with incredibly
- 10:45complex social information. Right, it's too much data.
- 10:48Way too much so to survive without being overwhelmed, the
- 10:51brain relies on shortcuts or heuristics to categorize the
- 10:56world. OK, one of the ways it
- 10:58simplifies the social world is by classifying people into
- 11:01mutually exclusive moral roles. Specifically, the brain likes to
- 11:05categorize individuals as either moral agents or moral patients.
- 11:10Breakdown the difference between an agent and a patient for us.
- 11:12Sure, a moral agent is the actor.
- 11:15It's someone who has the capacity, the agency, to do
- 11:19right or wrong. They do things.
- 11:20Exactly. A moral patient is the passive
- 11:23target of those actions. They are the recipients of right
- 11:26or wrong. They're the ones to whom things
- 11:28happen. OK, that makes sense.
- 11:29But here is the deeply fascinating and somewhat
- 11:31disturbing discovery. Our brains struggle immensely to
- 11:35view someone as both an agent and a patient at the exact same
- 11:39time. OK, let's talk about the study
- 11:40by Gray and Wegner on this, because the methodology they use
- 11:43to prove this is just wild. It really is.
- 11:46The Gray and Wegner study on pain sensitivity is a perfect
- 11:50illustration of how rigid our cognitive categories are.
- 11:53Yeah. So they set up an experiment
- 11:56where they manipulated how participants perceived a target
- 11:59individual sensitivity to physical.
- 12:01Pain. OK.
- 12:03In one condition, they described an individual as being highly
- 12:06sensitive to pain, essentially framing them in the participants
- 12:10mind as vulnerable, as a moral patient, a potential victim.
- 12:14OK, so like if I read a profile about a guy, let's call him
- 12:17John, and I'm told John has a very low pain tolerance.
- 12:21Like he feels physical and emotional pain.
- 12:23Very deeply correct. Then the researchers asked the
- 12:26participants to judge how responsible John would be if he
- 12:29committed a bad act, like stealing a car.
- 12:31And what happened? The participants, who had been
- 12:33told John was highly sensitive to pain, consistently judged him
- 12:37as being less responsible for the crime.
- 12:38Wait, just because my brain perceives John as someone who
- 12:42can feel pain deeply, my brain automatically assumes he is less
- 12:46capable of committing a crime? Yes, it just revokes his agency.
- 12:49It literally limits your brains ability to view him as a
- 12:53perpetrator. But the experiment goes further
- 12:56because it actually works in reverse too.
- 12:58Oh, wow. In another condition, the
- 13:01researchers introduced an individual and explicitly told
- 13:04the participants that this person had done something bad,
- 13:07that they had behaved in a blameworthy, aggressive manner.
- 13:11So they established the person as a moral agent.
- 13:13Exactly. Then they asked the participants
- 13:17to rate how much physical pain they thought this person was
- 13:20capable of feeling. And the participants rated them
- 13:22lower. Significantly lower.
- 13:24The participants literally perceived the bad individual as
- 13:29being less capable of feeling physical pain.
- 13:31That is staggering. Like if you do something bad, my
- 13:34brain decides your nervous system doesn't work the same way
- 13:36mine does. Essentially, yes.
- 13:38My brain just decides you cannot feel pain.
- 13:40When you increase the perception of someone's moral agency, their
- 13:43capacity to do bad things, things, you automatically
- 13:46decrease the perception of their moral patients, their capacity
- 13:50to be a victim. They act like ends of a seesaw.
- 13:53So apply that to a massive geopolitical conflict.
- 13:57If my group's entire identity is built on being the ultimate
- 14:00victims, if we are the ultimate moral patients who have endured
- 14:03all this historical pain, then by the strict biological rules
- 14:07of moral typecasting, we are cognitively incapable of being
- 14:11the bad guys, right? Our brains literally won't allow
- 14:14us to see ourselves as aggressive moral agents.
- 14:17Because if we are the victims, we cannot be the perpetrators.
- 14:21The identity as dichotomous. And because every human has a
- 14:24fundamental drive to maintain a positive view of their own
- 14:27group, which is the core of social identity theory, we
- 14:30naturally subconsciously passed our in Group as the pure moral
- 14:33patient and the out group as the pure moral agent.
- 14:36Literally strip the enemy of their capacity to feel pain so
- 14:39that we don't have to feel bad about hurting them.
- 14:41It is a profound cognitive distortion and it leads right
- 14:44into the second individual bias the paper mentions, which is
- 14:46social comparison now. I have to stop you here, because
- 14:49when I read about social comparison in the context of
- 14:51competitive victimhood, I was really confused.
- 14:55Usually when I think of social comparison, I think of
- 14:57benchmarking myself against a neighbor or a coworker.
- 15:00Like, if they get a new car, I feel a twinge of jealousy and
- 15:03want a new car, sure. If they get a promotion, I feel
- 15:06inadequate. We compare wealth or success or
- 15:10attractiveness. So my assumption is that if I am
- 15:13comparing myself to my enemy, I want them to be miserable.
- 15:16I want them to be poor, weak, and suffering naturally.
- 15:20Why on earth would a group feel threatened by finding out their
- 15:23enemy suffered more than them? Like in a normal context,
- 15:26wouldn't finding out your enemy is suffering be a cause for
- 15:29celebration? That is a brilliant pushback
- 15:31because it highlights exactly how the physics of reality warp
- 15:34when you enter a conflict zone. OK, you are entirely correct
- 15:38about everyday social comparison.
- 15:40Usually, finding out someone else did worse than you on a
- 15:43test or lost their job makes you feel relatively better about
- 15:46your own standing. Psychologists call that a
- 15:48downward comparison, and it boosts yourself esteem.
- 15:51Right, but in the context of an intractable violent conflict,
- 15:54the metric of value completely flips.
- 15:57Because the currency isn't money or test scores anymore.
- 15:59Exactly. The currency is morality in a
- 16:02violent conflict. Your group's collective self
- 16:05esteem, your very right to exist and fight, is entirely tied to
- 16:10your moral image. Be the good guys.
- 16:12You have to believe you were fighting a just war.
- 16:14So if you are presented with data showing that your adversary
- 16:18has actually suffered more than you, if they have significantly
- 16:21more civilian casualties or greater generational
- 16:24devastation, that realization implies a horrifying truth.
- 16:29It implies that your group is the evil perpetrator inflicting
- 16:33that suffering. I get it now because if they are
- 16:36suffering more, I am the one causing it.
- 16:39Finding out your enemy suffered more is an upward comparison in
- 16:42the twisted logic of conflict. It means they have outperformed
- 16:46you on the dimension of victimhood.
- 16:48And because vistem hood equals morality, their greater
- 16:51suffering directly threatens your group's positive social
- 16:54identity. It's strips you of your moral
- 16:56high ground. So to protect our own self
- 16:59esteem, to protect our identity as the righteous good guys, we
- 17:02literally have to minimize their suffering and inflate our own.
- 17:06Yes, because if we don't win the suffering contest, we are the
- 17:09villains. And that exactly.
- 17:12But if we interview you, the victim, your perception is
- 17:15entirely different. You felt the jolt.
- 17:17You lost your sense of safety. I'm mad.
- 17:19You are thinking about the whiplash, the hassle of
- 17:22insurance, the sheer illegitimacy of someone texting
- 17:25while driving. You will hyper fixate on the
- 17:28loss of agency. You will view the event as
- 17:30significantly more severe, more intentional, and more damaging.
- 17:34So the researchers point out that even when you statistically
- 17:38control for the objective severity of an event, victims
- 17:41naturally overestimate the damage and illegitimacy, while
- 17:44perpetrators naturally underestimate it.
- 17:46Now multiply that car crash by millions of people, add
- 17:49historical trauma, and swap out a Fender Bender for centuries of
- 17:53violence. The magnitude gap becomes a
- 17:55Canyon. It's just unbridgeable.
- 17:57The perpetrator group thinks the victims are wildly exaggerating
- 18:00ancient history, and the victim group thinks the perpetrators
- 18:02are maliciously denying their current agony.
- 18:05And to make sure that Canyon stays wide open, the brain
- 18:08deploys the 4th mechanism, biased memory.
- 18:12Right. We often think of human memory
- 18:14like a video recording stored on a hard drive.
- 18:16But it's really not. Memory is an active, ongoing
- 18:20construction project and the construction manager is highly
- 18:23vulnerable to our current goals, motives, and biases.
- 18:26So it's subjective. Highly individual memories of
- 18:29past transgressions are inherently self-serving.
- 18:32The paper actually notes that individuals will actively
- 18:35highlight their own group's innocence in their memories,
- 18:37while simultaneously forgetting or downplaying instances where
- 18:41their own group was aggressive. The brain has a highly selective
- 18:45auto delete function. It filters the memory to fit the
- 18:48required narrative. Wow.
- 18:50Studies actually show that group members will frequently
- 18:52completely forget instances where the out group has actually
- 18:55offered a formal apology for past wrongs.
- 18:58Just erase it entirely. They don't just ignore it.
- 19:00The memory literally degrades because it conflicts with the
- 19:03established narrative that the enemy is purely evil.
- 19:06That is nuts. So you take these four
- 19:08individual biases. Yeah, you have moral
- 19:11typecasting, forcing us to see the enemy as incapable of
- 19:15feeling pain. You have social comparison,
- 19:18forcing us to view their suffering as a threat to our
- 19:21goodness, right. You have the magnitude gap
- 19:23making us feel every slight against us as an existential
- 19:26threat and bias memory actively deleting any evidence to the
- 19:30contrary. Yeah, every single person in a
- 19:33conflict zone is operating with a brain that is fundamentally
- 19:36biologically wired to skew reality.
- 19:38But the individual mechanisms, they just lay the foundation
- 19:42because one person with a bias memory doesn't cause a century
- 19:45long war. Fairpoint.
- 19:46The real danger is what happens when you take millions of these
- 19:49individual biases and scale them up into a societal structure.
- 19:53That is when competitive victimhood becomes
- 19:55institutionalized across generations.
- 19:57And the transition from the individual brain to the societal
- 20:00echo chamber is really fascinating because the most
- 20:02powerful tool in that societal echo chamber is what the
- 20:05researchers call the creation of chosen traumas.
- 20:07Yes, a chosen trauma, which is a concept heavily explored by
- 20:11Vemic Vulcan, is a specific historical wound that a group
- 20:16collectively decides to mythologize.
- 20:18OK, what does that look like? It's an event of profound
- 20:21victimization, a battle lost, an exile, A genocide that becomes
- 20:26embedded into the very core of the guru's identity.
- 20:30So it's not just history. No, it's no longer just a tragic
- 20:32thing that happened in the past. It becomes the defining lens
- 20:36through which the group views the present in the future.
- 20:39I was trying to think of a way to visualize this.
- 20:41It's almost like a society passing down a corrupted
- 20:45operating system to the next generation.
- 20:47I like that. Right, like every child born
- 20:49into the society downloads this operating system.
- 20:52It contains the files of the chosen trauma, and the code
- 20:55actively runs in the background, filtering every new piece of
- 20:58information. Exactly.
- 20:59If a new event occurs that contradicts the victim
- 21:01narrative, the operating system flags it as malware and deletes
- 21:05it. It transmits feelings of
- 21:06humiliation and helplessness across generations, even to
- 21:09people who weren't alive when the original trauma occurred.
- 21:12That is a very precise analogy. The operating system ensures the
- 21:16trauma remains active, and when a group operates under the
- 21:20shadow of a chosen trauma, they often act in line with a concept
- 21:23psychologist John Mack termed the egoism of victimization.
- 21:27The egoism of victimization. So the suffering makes us
- 21:31selfish. It severely limits emotional
- 21:33bandwidth. The deep historic suffering
- 21:36increases a group's sense of entitlement, perhaps to disputed
- 21:39territory or to extreme security measures, and simultaneously
- 21:44decreases their capacity to feel empathy for their current
- 21:46adversary. Wow.
- 21:48The trauma takes up so much processing power in that
- 21:50operating system that there is simply no memory left to care
- 21:53about the pain they might be inflicting on someone else
- 21:55today. So reminders of past collective
- 21:58victimhood have been shown to actually decrease a group's
- 22:02acceptance of collective responsibility for hurting an
- 22:04out group in a contemporary conflict.
- 22:06Because the origin story says we are the victims forever, right?
- 22:10And if we connect this to the bigger picture, the source
- 22:12material points out something truly chilling about how these
- 22:15chosen traumas map onto the present day.
- 22:17What's that? The mental representation of the
- 22:19current adversary often becomes contaminated with the image of
- 22:23the historical enemy from the chosen trauma.
- 22:25The paper actually used the example of Jewish Israelis and
- 22:28how they perceive contemporary geopolitical threats.
- 22:31Yes, for many Jewish Israelis, the profound, unutterable chosen
- 22:36trauma of the Holocaust fundamentally alters the
- 22:39perception of present day adversaries.
- 22:42Consequently, contemporary leaders who express hostility,
- 22:45such as Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the former president of Iran, are
- 22:49not just viewed objectively as geopolitical rivals with
- 22:52competing national interests. They are perceived through the
- 22:55psychological lens of a modern day Hitler.
- 22:58So the past trauma completely overwrites the present reality.
- 23:01The threat level isn't just we might lose a border skirmish.
- 23:04The threat level is automatically dialed to maximum
- 23:07to existential annihilation and when a.
- 23:09Society lives in a state of perpetual existential threat.
- 23:12They develop what researchers call an ethos of conflict.
- 23:16In intractable conflicts, ones that are protracted 0 sum and
- 23:19seem unsolvable, societies build an entire psychological
- 23:23infrastructure to cope with the stress.
- 23:25And what does that ethos do? This ethos demands that the
- 23:28society view the world strictly through a victim perspective.
- 23:31And how does a society enforce that ethos?
- 23:34The researchers mention cultural violence.
- 23:36Cultural violence is any aspect of a culture, religion,
- 23:41ideology, language, even art and literature that is used to
- 23:46legitimize direct physical violence.
- 23:49A prime example is the doctrine of the Just War.
- 23:52Right. The idea that under our
- 23:53specific, unique conditions, our violence is morally justified.
- 23:58God or history is on our side. But the crucial caveat of the
- 24:02just war doctrine is that groups almost never accept it as a
- 24:05valid excuse for their adversaries.
- 24:07Violence. Yeah, our violence is a tragic
- 24:09but necessary defense of our existence.
- 24:11Their violence is unprovoked, intentional terrorism.
- 24:14And to make sure everyone in the society stays on message, you
- 24:16have the role of the media war promoting journalism.
- 24:19The media acts as the amplifier for the corrupted operating
- 24:23system. War promoting journalism is
- 24:25characterized by an absolute US versus them narrative.
- 24:29It prioritizes reporting the physical, gruesome impact of the
- 24:32conflict, the blood, the rubble, over exploring the complex
- 24:36psychological or historical root causes.
- 24:38It's sensationalized. Very It focuses heavily on
- 24:41differences rather than similarities.
- 24:43It highlights stalemates, broken promises and failures rather
- 24:46than previous agreements or moments of peace.
- 24:49It relies on emotional propaganda rather than
- 24:52objective, nuanced truth. So it's journalism that only
- 24:55gives a voice to us, frames them entirely as the cause of the
- 24:59problem, and focuses exclusively on our suffering and their
- 25:03violence. That when you combine chosen
- 25:05traumas, the egoism of victimization, the doctrine of
- 25:07the just war and war promoting journalism, you have a society
- 25:11utterly locked into a collect reality where they are the sole
- 25:14exclusive victims of history. OK, so a society is firmly
- 25:18locked into this echo chamber. They believe they're the
- 25:20ultimate victims, but how exactly do they prove that to
- 25:23the world and to themselves? Well, they have to work for it.
- 25:25Right. You can't just walk into the
- 25:26United Nations and say we feel worse than they do, so give us
- 25:30what we want. They have to litigate this, they
- 25:32have to prove it. And the researchers identify the
- 25:35groups keep score across 5 distinct battlegrounds, or
- 25:38dimensions of suffering. Yes, to win the victim crown,
- 25:43groups will strategically deploy arguments across different types
- 25:47of pain. It is an evolving strategy
- 25:49board. OK, breakdown the board.
- 25:51If they are losing on one dimension, they will retreat and
- 25:54advance on another. The 1st and most easily
- 25:57identifiable is the physical dimension.
- 26:00This is the quantifiable suffering.
- 26:02Like body counts. Body counts, injuries,
- 26:04incidences of torture or destroyed infrastructure.
- 26:07Groups will try to prove they have endure a larger share of
- 26:10the overall physical violence. But it's not just about raw
- 26:13numbers. What else is it?
- 26:14Insidiously, they will attempt to devalue the physical
- 26:17suffering of the other side. Oh, right, the differential
- 26:20valuation of human life based on ethnocentrism.
- 26:23Yeah, this part of the research was incredibly dark.
- 26:25It reveals a lot about in Group bias.
- 26:28The paper sites studies showing that US participants, under
- 26:32conditions of national competition or threat,
- 26:35inherently valued American lives more than Iraqi or Afghan lives.
- 26:39Which is awful, yeah, But the crucial, devastating part of
- 26:42that finding is this. The bias held true even when
- 26:47participants were explicitly asked to compare the value of
- 26:50American combatants, soldiers actively engaged in warfare to
- 26:55the lives of Iraqi or Afghan civilians, including children.
- 26:58Think about that. Let that sink in.
- 27:00Yeah, our soldiers lives are perceived as intrinsically more
- 27:03valuable, more worthy of mourning than their innocent
- 27:06civilians lives simply because of group identity.
- 27:09It shows how the physical dimension isn't just about
- 27:11objective spreadsheets of casualties, it's about the
- 27:13perceived moral weight of those casualties.
- 27:15Right, but if a group can't win on the physical dimension, they
- 27:18move to the second battleground, which is the material dimension.
- 27:21This goes back to structural violence.
- 27:23Yes, this is competition over relative deprivation.
- 27:27It's arguing over systemic discrimination.
- 27:29Who has been denied housing? Who has been shut out of the
- 27:32economy? Who lacks access to clean water
- 27:35or education? You do not need an active hot
- 27:38war to compete on the material dimension.
- 27:41The researchers actually used the conflict in Northern Ireland
- 27:44as a prime example here, where the tension was heavily rooted
- 27:47in the systemic discrimination experienced by the Catholic
- 27:50community in housing and voting prior to the Troubles breaking
- 27:53out. But importantly, it's not just
- 27:55historically disadvantaged or minority groups that claim
- 27:57material victimhood. The political right in Chile,
- 28:00for example, heavily emphasized their material victimhood
- 28:03stemming from the radical land reforms and wealth
- 28:06redistributions enacted by the leftist Allende government prior
- 28:10to the Pinochet regime taking power.
- 28:12Which moves us to the third battleground.
- 28:13Yeah, the cultural dimension. Now this one feels a bit more
- 28:16abstract, but the mechanics behind it are incredibly potent.
- 28:21It is extremely potent. Cultural victimhood is the
- 28:24perceived threat to a group's way of life, their language,
- 28:27their religion, or their overarching worldview.
- 28:29The paper references Tony Blair citing the 9/11 attacks not just
- 28:34as a horrific physical tragedy, but as a direct existential
- 28:37threat to the Western way of life, which he used to justify
- 28:41engaging the UK in the Iraq war, or French Canadians in Quebec
- 28:45experiencing what the researchers call collective
- 28:47angst over the threat of English Canada erasing their distinct
- 28:51culture and language. To understand why a threat to
- 28:53culture is so enraging, the researchers apply terror
- 28:56management theory. This biological fears.
- 29:03TMT is based on the idea that human beings are uniquely
- 29:07burdened by the conscious awareness of our own inevitable
- 29:09death Cheerful, right? We know we're going to die, and
- 29:12that knowledge creates an underlying paralyzing terror,
- 29:16what psychologists call mortality salience, the buffer
- 29:19against this terror. Humans created culture, our
- 29:22cultural worldview, our religion, our national identity,
- 29:24our lasting traditions gives us a sense of permanence.
- 29:27It tells us that even though our physical bodies will die, we are
- 29:31part of something immortal. We belong to a culture that will
- 29:33endure. So culture is literally our
- 29:36psychological armor against the fear of death.
- 29:39Exactly. So if an adversary threatens
- 29:41your culture, if they mock your religion or try to ban your
- 29:45language, they aren't just insulting you psychologically,
- 29:48they are ripping away your armor against the void.
- 29:51They are exposing you to the raw terror of death.
- 29:54That makes so much sense. Like that explains why threats
- 29:58to culture trigger such extreme defensiveness, prejudice and
- 30:01aggression. When the cultural worldview is
- 30:04threatened, the existential dread rushes in and the group
- 30:08lashes out violently to protect their psychological immune
- 30:10system. Precisely, the 4th battleground
- 30:13is the psychological dimension. This focuses on emotional pain,
- 30:17the distress from constant threat, and transgenerational
- 30:19trauma. A group might highlight the
- 30:22pervasive invisible psychological damage of living
- 30:25under constant surveillance, like citizens in East Germany
- 30:28under the Stasi, or the lingering trauma of historical
- 30:31famines like the the Irish potato famine shaping the Irish
- 30:34soul. OK, I see.
- 30:35Groups engage in competitive victimhood here by focusing
- 30:39exclusively on their own psychosocial suffering, their
- 30:42own collective PTSD, while completely minimizing the mental
- 30:47toll the conflict takes on the out group.
- 30:49And finally, the 5th battleground, which might be the
- 30:52most insidious of all the legitimacy dimension.
- 30:56This is arguing over who's suffering is more unjust.
- 30:59Right. A group might acknowledge that
- 31:01the other side has suffered. They might even concede that the
- 31:04other side has suffered more physically, with higher body
- 31:06counts, right? But they will pivot and claim
- 31:09that their own suffering is decidedly more illegitimate,
- 31:12more cruel, or more immoral. Here's where it gets really
- 31:15interesting. I was looking at these 5
- 31:17dimensions, physical, material, cultural, psychological
- 31:21legitimacy and I started wondering how a group decides
- 31:23which one to use. Is it purely based on their
- 31:26relative power level? It is highly strategic, and it
- 31:29is absolutely tied to power dynamics.
- 31:31Less powerful groups, groups that are structurally
- 31:33marginalized or militarily weaker, will almost always
- 31:36highlight the objective dimensions.
- 31:38The tangible stuff. Right.
- 31:39They will point to the physical or material battlegrounds.
- 31:43They will say look at the body count, look at the poverty line,
- 31:46look at the infant mortality rate, objective.
- 31:48Actively, mathematically, we are suffering more.
- 31:50Because they have the raw, undeniable data to prove.
- 31:53It exactly. But a more powerful group, a
- 31:56group with a vast military or economic advantage that might
- 32:00objectively inflict far more physical harm, cannot win on the
- 32:04physical dimension. If they try to compare body
- 32:07counts, they lose the victimhood competition.
- 32:10So they will strategically pivot.
- 32:12They will compete fiercely on the legitimacy dimension or the
- 32:15psychological dimension. The paper actually uses the
- 32:18dynamic between Israel and Hamas to illustrate this pivot, right?
- 32:22Yes, in that asymmetrical conflict, Palestinians can point
- 32:26to significantly higher objective physical casualties
- 32:29and widespread material devastation.
- 32:31Right. To counter that in the
- 32:32victimhood competition and maintain their own moral high
- 32:35ground, the Israeli discourse often shifts to the legitimacy
- 32:39dimension. How does that sound in practice?
- 32:41Well, the argument is framed around intent.
- 32:43The assertion is that Israeli military strikes are aimed at
- 32:46military targets, making civilian casualties a tragic,
- 32:50unintended by product, a means to an end, whereas Hamas attacks
- 32:54are aimed directly at civilians, making those deaths the
- 32:58intentional goal, an end in itself.
- 33:00So they reframe the metric. Right.
- 33:02Therefore, even if the objective physical harm suffered by
- 33:05Israelis is lower, their suffering is framed as more
- 33:08unjust, more illegitimate, and therefore morally superior in
- 33:12the victimhood hierarchy. Man, it is exhausting just
- 33:15thinking about the mental gymnastics required for an
- 33:17entire society to constantly litigate these 5 dimensions
- 33:21across generations. It's a full time job for a
- 33:23society. It really is, yeah.
- 33:24Which brings us to the most pragmatic question of this whole
- 33:27deep dive. Why do we do it right?
- 33:29If being a victim is normally associated with stigma, weakness
- 33:32and helplessness, why do powerful groups hold on to this
- 33:35label with a death grip? What is the utility of it?
- 33:38Because winning the victimhood competition provides massive
- 33:41tangible and psychological benefits.
- 33:44It isn't just about feeling sorry for oneself.
- 33:46It is a highly effective survival strategy.
- 33:49OK. The researchers outlined 4
- 33:51specific functions that competitive victimhood serves
- 33:53for a group in a conflict. Let's explore these hidden
- 33:57benefits function #1 increasing in Group cohesiveness.
- 34:02In a protracted conflict, leaders face a constant
- 34:04challenge. They need loyal, unified
- 34:07followers who are willing to sacrifice for the cause.
- 34:10And nothing binds a group of people together faster and
- 34:13tighter than a shared sense of profound existential injustice.
- 34:17Nothing unites like a common enemy.
- 34:19Exactly. A narrative of historical
- 34:21suffering passed down from trusted elders to the younger
- 34:24generation induces what we call vicarious victimhood.
- 34:27So even if I personally haven't been harmed, I adopt the trauma
- 34:31of my ancestors as my own. Yes, it satisfies the deep human
- 34:34desire for acceptance, belonging and ideological consensus.
- 34:38Yes, circles the wagons. If we are all victims together,
- 34:41anyone who dissents from the group narrative isn't just
- 34:44disagreeing, they are betraying the memory of the victims.
- 34:47Wow function #2 Justifying in Group violence.
- 34:52If this victim identity pulls a group incredibly close together,
- 34:55what happens when that tight knit group looks outward at
- 34:58their enemy? Does the sheer pain make them
- 35:00more empathetic or more dangerous?
- 35:03Historically, it makes them far more dangerous.
- 35:06Victimhood acts as the ultimate moral justification for
- 35:09aggression. OK, if you believe you're the
- 35:11pure innocent victim facing an imminent existential threat, you
- 35:16are morally cleared to take preemptive or wildly
- 35:18disproportionate retaliatory violent action.
- 35:21Because it's framed as survival, not aggression.
- 35:23Exactly. Victimhood fuels action oriented
- 35:25emotions like rage, moral outrage, and collective angst.
- 35:29These emotions push groups toward confrontational,
- 35:32aggressive responses rather than negotiation or compromise.
- 35:35We saw this vividly in the build up to the violence in the former
- 35:38Yugoslavia in the 1990s. Politicians deliberately
- 35:42weaponized historical grievances, dusting off memories
- 35:45of atrocities dating back centuries to the Ottoman Empire
- 35:48to trigger fresh anger and justify modern day ethnic
- 35:51cleansing and massacres. They activated the chosen trauma
- 35:54to justify present day violence. Function #3 is perhaps the most
- 35:58insidious cognitive trick, denying responsibility and
- 36:01avoiding negative emotions. Well, accepting responsibility
- 36:05for hurting someone else triggers collective guilt.
- 36:08And nobody, no individual and certainly no nation, wants to
- 36:12feel collective guilt. It's an incredibly aversive,
- 36:15heavy emotion. So portraying oneself as the
- 36:17ultimate victim deflects that guilt entirely.
- 36:20The narrative becomes we didn't want to be violent, We are
- 36:23peaceful people, but we were backed into a corner and left
- 36:26with no other choice by the evil out group.
- 36:28Our violence was entirely reactive.
- 36:31The researchers talk about a specific cognitive mechanism
- 36:33here called defensive temporal distancing.
- 36:36Can you explain the timeline stretching trick the brain does
- 36:39here? This is a brilliant, subtle
- 36:41manipulation of perception. The brain literally plays a
- 36:44trick with time to protect the group's ego.
- 36:47When a group is reminded of terrible atrocities they
- 36:49committed, they will subjectively push that event
- 36:51further back in time. How did they actually prove
- 36:54that? Through comparative studies,
- 36:56researchers asked German participants and Canadian
- 36:59participants to read about German and perpetrated
- 37:01atrocities during the Holocaust. Even though both groups knew the
- 37:05objective historical dates, the German participants judged the
- 37:09Holocaust to feel subjectively further in the past than the
- 37:12Canadian participants did. So the German brain was actively
- 37:15stretching the timeline. He was saying that was a long,
- 37:18long, long time ago. Those were different people and
- 37:20has nothing to do with us today. Exactly.
- 37:23The brain creates distance to dilute the guilt, and that
- 37:27greater subjective distance directly predicted a lower
- 37:31willingness among the German participants to fuel collective
- 37:34guilt or to support making modern day amends.
- 37:37Which perfectly transitions to the 4th and final function.
- 37:40Yeah, seeking compensation and 3rd party support.
- 37:43Basically a GoFundMe page. Pretty much.
- 37:46In a globalized world, very few conflicts are fought in
- 37:48isolation. Material and moral support from
- 37:51the international community, the United Nations, powerful allied
- 37:54nations, global NGOs is vital for survival.
- 37:57In victory. You need their money, their
- 37:59weapons and their sanctions against your enemy.
- 38:01But third parties are highly conditional.
- 38:04They only help groups they believe are truly innocent.
- 38:07But why are third parties so picky?
- 38:09Why do they care about absolute innocence?
- 38:11The researchers linked this back to a classic psychological
- 38:15concept, Melvin Lerner's Just World hypothesis.
- 38:19Oh, the idea that bystanders desperately want to believe the
- 38:23world is fundamentally fair. Right.
- 38:25We all want to believe that good things happen to good people and
- 38:29bad things happen to bad people. When a bystander sees someone
- 38:32suffering immensely, it causes them deep psychological
- 38:35discomfort because it implies the world is unjust, chaotic,
- 38:39and random, right? It implies that terrible things
- 38:42could happen to the bystander too, for no reason.
- 38:45So how does the cure that discomfort?
- 38:48To relieve the anxiety, bystanders have a strong
- 38:51subconscious psychological urge to blame the victim.
- 38:54They search frantically for a reason why the victim brought
- 38:57the suffering upon themselves so the world makes sense again.
- 39:00Like they shouldn't have been walking in that neighborhood at
- 39:03night, or they shouldn't have elected that radical government,
- 39:05or they shouldn't have provoked the superpower.
- 39:08Precisely therefore, conflicting groups know intuitively that
- 39:13they are fighting an uphill battle against the bystanders
- 39:16natural instinct to blame them. They have to work extra hard to
- 39:20prove their absolute, pure, unblemished innocence to the
- 39:23international community. So they have to double down.
- 39:25They have to engage fiercely in competitive victimhood to
- 39:28overcome the just world bias. Otherwise, they won't get the
- 39:31foreign aid, the military alliances or the UN resolutions.
- 39:35OK, so those four functions, cohesion, justifying violence,
- 39:39denying guilt, and getting foreign aid, explain the
- 39:41tactical, practical utility of competitive victimhood.
- 39:45That's the strategy, yes, but strategy is driven by underlying
- 39:48emotions. What is the deep underlying
- 39:51psychological starvation that these groups are desperately
- 39:53trying to feed like? What is the root cause?
- 39:55To understand the emotional core of this entire phenomenon, the
- 39:59researchers apply something called the Needs Based Model.
- 40:02This model posits that experiencing conflict threatens
- 40:05fundamentally different dimensions of identity for
- 40:08victims and perpetrators. Because their identities are
- 40:11threatened in different ways, it creates highly divergent
- 40:14psychological motivations. Let's breakdown those divergent
- 40:17needs. Let's start with the victims.
- 40:19When a group experiences severe victimization, they experience a
- 40:22profound traumatic loss of power, autonomy, and control.
- 40:27Their agency has been stripped away by an external force.
- 40:30They were rendered helpless. Therefore, moving forward, their
- 40:33primary overriding psychological motivation is to restore a sense
- 40:38of power. They need empowerment.
- 40:40They need to know they control their own destiny again.
- 40:42Yes. Now look at the perpetrators or
- 40:44the group that holds the structural power.
- 40:47When a group commits violence or enforces systemic oppression,
- 40:51they experience a massive threat to their moral image.
- 40:54Because the world is watching. They face global condemnation.
- 40:57They fear being permanently excluded from the global moral
- 41:00community. Therefore, their primary
- 41:02psychological motivation is to restore their moral image and
- 41:05regain social acceptance. OK, so victims are starving for
- 41:09power and agency. Perpetrators are starving for
- 41:12moral acceptance and empathy. How does the competition for
- 41:15victimhood tie into this? Because the acknowledgement of
- 41:18suffering is the only thing that fulfills both of these distinct
- 41:21needs simultaneously. That is why both sides fight for
- 41:25it so viciously and why they refuse to give it to the other.
- 41:28Think of it like two people suffering in extreme life
- 41:31threatening conditions, right? One person is suffocating.
- 41:34They desperately need oxygen. That's the victims need for
- 41:37power. The other person is freezing to
- 41:39death. They desperately need heat.
- 41:41That's the perpetrators need for acceptance.
- 41:43Oh I like this. Right, acknowledgement of their
- 41:46suffering by the other side is the only machine that provides
- 41:49both oxygen and heat. So they arrive at the machine
- 41:53and instead of sharing it, they fight to the death over it
- 41:56because they are both dying for what it provides.
- 41:58That captures the desperation perfectly.
- 42:00For the victim, receiving an explicit acknowledgement of
- 42:04their suffering, especially a formal apology from the
- 42:06perpetrator, is a massive infusion of oxygen.
- 42:09It breathes life into them. It is a profound form of
- 42:12empowerment. It forces the perpetrator to
- 42:15admit a moral debt, which shifts the power dynamic.
- 42:19It restores the victim's control because now the victim holds the
- 42:22power to decide whether to grant forgiveness or demand
- 42:25reparations. For example, the paper notes
- 42:28that acknowledging the Holocaust empowers Israeli Jews by
- 42:31validating their historical narrative, their trauma, and
- 42:34their ultimate right to self determination and security.
- 42:38When adversaries deny the Holocaust, it is a deeply
- 42:41disempowering act. It attempts to strip away their
- 42:43oxygen. Conversely, for the perpetrator,
- 42:45having their own suffering recognized by the victim or the
- 42:48world provides the heat they need to survive the moral
- 42:51freeze, right? It opens the door for empathy.
- 42:53It allows the world to understand the difficult
- 42:55circumstances, the historical fears or the existential threats
- 42:59that compelled them to act violently in the 1st place.
- 43:02It rehumanizes them. It mitigates their moral
- 43:04inferiority and restores their social acceptance.
- 43:08This actually helps explain a question I had earlier.
- 43:10This raises an important question, right?
- 43:12How does a group that holds all the structural, economic and
- 43:15military power still feel the intense need to act like a
- 43:19victim? That is the crux of asymmetrical
- 43:22power relationships. Even a vastly superior military
- 43:26power can be intensely motivated to stress its own suffering.
- 43:29Why not? Because they need to restore
- 43:31physical power. They already have the tanks, the
- 43:33drones, and the economy. They engage in competitive
- 43:36victimhood to gain the world world understanding.
- 43:39They want the international community to say we understand
- 43:42the fear and the trauma that forced you to use those Dinks.
- 43:45That understanding is the heat that restores their moral image.
- 43:48The researchers use the Rwandan context again here to show how
- 43:51powerful this need for acceptance is.
- 43:54Yes, studies on post genocide interventions in Rwanda found
- 43:58something remarkable, interventions that taught Hutus
- 44:01about the deep historical roots and systemic pressures that
- 44:04preceded the 1994 genocide. Importantly, not to excuse the
- 44:08genocide, but to understand its psychological and historical
- 44:11context, actually helped them feel rehumanized.
- 44:14It eased their crushing burden of collective shame, which
- 44:18paradoxically made them less defensive and facilitated a
- 44:20better path toward reconciliation.
- 44:23They needed that baseline acceptance to move forward.
- 44:26But the tragedy of the needs based model is that because both
- 44:29sides are utterly starved for their respective needs, oxygen
- 44:32or heat, their competitive mindset completely blocks them
- 44:36from giving the other side what they need.
- 44:38It's a closed loop of denial. A total deadlock.
- 44:41Which brings us to the ultimate tragic cost of competitive
- 44:45victimhood. It acts as an impenetrable
- 44:48biological barrier to forgiveness.
- 44:50The research on this is bleak, but it is necessary to confront.
- 44:54In intractable conflicts, group identity often morphs.
- 44:57It doesn't just become about who you are, it becomes based
- 44:59entirely on the negation of the other groups narrative.
- 45:02Yes, your identity isn't just we are group X and we have a rich
- 45:05history. It becomes we are group X and
- 45:07group YS entire story is a fabricated lie.
- 45:10And when you challenge a group's narrative in that state, the
- 45:13reaction isn't just a polite political disagreement.
- 45:16The physical biological reaction is intense.
- 45:19Very intense. The paper site studies showing
- 45:21that when people in these conflicts are confronted with
- 45:23narratives that negate their victimhood, they experience
- 45:26measurable psychological distress.
- 45:29They even show a temporary drop in IQ.
- 45:31A drop in IQ. It's called ego depletion.
- 45:34Their cognitive resources are so overwhelmed by the existential
- 45:38threat to their core identity that their brain literally has
- 45:42less bandwidth to process complex thoughts.
- 45:45That's. Crazy.
- 45:46They become temporarily less intelligent.
- 45:48It proves that this is a physiological threat response,
- 45:51and because of this, competitive victimhood is identified across
- 45:54multiple studies as a unique, powerful negative predictor of
- 45:58intergroup forgiveness. You fundamentally cannot let go
- 46:02of the past if your current identity, your self esteem, and
- 46:05your political leverage rely entirely on winning the
- 46:07victimhood contest today. Let's bring this down to a
- 46:09granular level. So what does this all mean for
- 46:12you? The research points out that
- 46:13this inability to forgive isn't distributed equally across a
- 46:16population. It is governed by a crucial
- 46:18psychological moderator. The strength of in Group
- 46:22identification, meaning how deeply you wrap your personal
- 46:26identity into your political, national or social group,
- 46:30dictates how blind you become. Let's talk about the experiment
- 46:34in Chile, because it isolates this variable perfectly.
- 46:37What do they do in Chile? Researchers conducted an
- 46:39experiment focusing on the political left in Chile who
- 46:43suffered the greatest, most objective human rights abuses
- 46:46under the Pinochet military regime.
- 46:48OK, they took participants who identified with the political
- 46:51the left and had them read a fake manipulated survey.
- 46:55The fake survey claimed that new data showed the political right
- 46:58actually suffered more overall during the conflict years.
- 47:02That is the ultimate competitive victimhood provocation.
- 47:05It is a direct, data-driven challenge to their victim crown.
- 47:09What was it like for them to read a survey that essentially
- 47:11destroys their worldview? The results were completely
- 47:14dependent on how strongly the participant identified with the
- 47:17political left. For participants who were only
- 47:20weakly identified with the left, meaning they leaned left
- 47:23politically but it wasn't the core of their personal identity,
- 47:26reading the fake survey didn't really affect them.
- 47:28It bounced right off their willingness to forgive the right
- 47:32remain relatively stable. But what about the true
- 47:34believers? For those who strongly
- 47:36identified with the left, whose personal identity, social
- 47:39circles, and sense of self were deeply intertwined with the
- 47:42group's history of suffering, reading that fake survey caused
- 47:46a massive, statistically significant drop in their
- 47:49willingness to forgive. They dug their heels in.
- 47:52The threat to their group's victim status triggered extreme
- 47:55psychological defensiveness. High identifiers will even shift
- 47:58their own internal standards of justice to excuse their own
- 48:01side's violence just to maintain the purity of the victim
- 48:04narrative. The paper also mentions a study
- 48:07on the Hindu Sikh conflict in India showing the exact same
- 48:10dynamic. Highly religious identifiers
- 48:13recalled far fewer incidents of their own groups past violence
- 48:16compared to low identifiers, and they were much less likely to
- 48:20remember out group apologies. Their brains just deleted the
- 48:23inconvenient data to protect the identity.
- 48:26And to under score how universal this cognitive trap is, we look
- 48:29at the 2017 Belgian study. Now the authors of that study
- 48:33were thorough in noting their own limitations.
- 48:35Their sample overrepresented French speaking Belgians, for
- 48:38example. Right.
- 48:39But Despite that demographic limitation, the massive sample
- 48:42size confirmed the underlying architecture.
- 48:44It confirmed that these specific psychological links between high
- 48:48in Group identification, collective victimhood and
- 48:51negative behavioral tendencies like a refusal to forgive hold
- 48:55true across completely different linguistic and cultural lines.
- 48:58This. Is not a localized issue.
- 48:59No. Whether you are in Chile, the
- 49:01Middle East, Northern Ireland, India or Belgium, human brains
- 49:05fall into the exact same trap. OK, the picture you've painted
- 49:08over the last hour is incredibly dark.
- 49:11We are cognitively wired to categorize people and to need
- 49:14boxes of agents and patients. We are wired to remember only
- 49:17our own pain. We are driven by a desperate
- 49:20need for power and acceptance to compete for victimhood, and
- 49:23doing so literally destroys our cognitive capacity for peace.
- 49:28It's a bleak reality. It feels like an evolutionary
- 49:30dead end. So how on earth do we hack the
- 49:33system? How do we break this cycle
- 49:35before it destroys us? The researchers do not offer a
- 49:38magic wand, but they propose 2 main psychological routes to
- 49:41overcome competitive victimhood and foster reconciliation.
- 49:45However, both routes face massive, terrifying real world
- 49:49obstacles. OK, what's route one?
- 49:51Route one is based directly on the needs based model.
- 49:53We discussed removing identity threats through reciprocal
- 49:56exchange. OK, how does a reciprocal
- 49:59exchange work in practice? It requires A carefully
- 50:02orchestrated, highly vulnerable exchange where both sides give
- 50:05the other what they psychologically crave.
- 50:07The more powerful or perpetrating group must provide
- 50:11the oxygen of empowerment. How do they do that?
- 50:13They do this by actively admitting injustice, taking
- 50:17responsibility, and offering a sincere apology.
- 50:20In return, the weaker or victimized group must provide
- 50:24the heat of acceptance. They do this by expressing
- 50:27empathy for the historical fears or circumstances that compelled
- 50:30the perpetrators behavior and ultimately offering forgiveness.
- 50:34It's. Trading the oxygen for the heat.
- 50:36Exactly when groups reciprocally exchange these messages, the
- 50:40motivation to compete for victimhood decreases because the
- 50:43underlying psychological threats have been neutralized.
- 50:46The paper sites truth and reconciliation commissions like
- 50:49the famous one in post apartheid South Africa as macro level
- 50:53institutionalized attempts at this reciprocal exchange.
- 50:56But the obstacle here is huge. It requires baseline trust, and
- 51:00taking the first step to apologize is an enormous,
- 51:03terrifying risk. It is a massive political and
- 51:06psychological risk. If a powerful group apologizes
- 51:09and the weaker group weaponizes that apology to demand punitive
- 51:13reparations instead of offering acceptance, the powerful group
- 51:15looks weak and humiliated, right?
- 51:17If the weaker group offers forgiveness and the powerful
- 51:20group uses it to just absolve themselves and change nothing
- 51:23structurally, the weaker group is revit victimized.
- 51:26Without a baseline of trust, neither side wants to jump
- 51:29first. OK, what is Route 2?
- 51:31Route 2 is fostering a common victimhood identity.
- 51:34This relies on a psychological concept called the common in
- 51:37Group Identity Model or CR AM OK.
- 51:41The goal here is re categorization.
- 51:43You try to get the conflicting groups to maintain their unique
- 51:46sub identity, their specific historical pain, but
- 51:50simultaneously adopt A larger superordinate identity of shared
- 51:54suffering. I have to push back hard on
- 51:55this. Doesn't saying we are all
- 51:57victims here, we all suffered risk completely invalidating the
- 52:01very real objectively asymmetrical suffering of the
- 52:04structurally oppressed group? Yeah.
- 52:06If one side lost 1000 people and the other lost 10, saying we are
- 52:09all victims sounds like a cruel erasure of the weaker groups
- 52:12reality. That is the exact correct
- 52:14pushback, and it highlights a major danger in conflict
- 52:18resolution. If you just blanket everything
- 52:21as shared suffering, the group that suffered the most severe
- 52:24objective harm will feel erased, enraged, and will reject the
- 52:29process entirely. This is why the researchers
- 52:32emphasized that dual identity is absolutely crucial for Route 2
- 52:36to work. Explain dual identity.
- 52:38You cannot and must not erase the subgroups unique pain.
- 52:42You must explicitly, continually recognize it.
- 52:45But while recognizing the unique pain, you attempt to separate
- 52:48the responsibility for the conflict from the shared
- 52:50universal negative impacts of the conflict.
- 52:53Like focusing on the fact that the war has ruined the economy
- 52:55for everyone, or that nobody feels secure in their homes, or
- 52:58that mothers on both sides are burying their children.
- 53:00Exactly. A powerful real world example of
- 53:03this in action is the Palestinian Israeli Bereaved
- 53:05Families for Peace. I've heard of them.
- 53:08This is an organization of individuals who have lost
- 53:10immediate family members to the conflict.
- 53:12When these individuals interact, they realize that the adversary
- 53:15has suffered the exact same agonizing universal human grief.
- 53:19They don't negate their own political realities or their
- 53:22asymmetrical structural conditions, but they create a
- 53:25super ordinate identity based on that shared profound loss of a
- 53:29child. The paper also mentions Emil
- 53:32Shufani as an example of an individual blending these routes
- 53:35together. Yes, Emil Shufani is an Arab
- 53:37Israeli clergyman who led a joint Jewish Arab pilgrimage to
- 53:41the Auschwitz concentration camp.
- 53:43Which is an incredible, profound gesture.
- 53:46It was a monumental act of empathy designed to demonstrate
- 53:49a deep understanding of historical Jewish wounds, the
- 53:52ultimate chosen trauma, without in any way denying or erasing
- 53:56the Palestinian experience of the Nakba.
- 53:58It was a proactive move to transcend The Who suffered more
- 54:01competition by validating the most raw existential pain of the
- 54:05adversary. But Route 2 has its own massive
- 54:08cognitive obstacles, specifically something the
- 54:10researchers call the in Group Projection Model.
- 54:13This is a very tricky cognitive hurdle regarding that
- 54:15superordinate identity when you try to create a new overarching
- 54:19identity. Let's say we are all going to
- 54:21identify as Northern Irish now instead of strictly Protestant
- 54:25or Catholic. The majority or more powerful
- 54:27group tends to just subconsciously project their own
- 54:30values and characteristics on to that new super ordinate
- 54:33identity. So they assume Northern Irish
- 54:35just means Protestant. Exactly.
- 54:37The researchers found that in Northern Ireland, asking groups
- 54:40to identify as Northern Irish only increased forgiveness and
- 54:43positive attitudes among the Catholics, who are the
- 54:45historically minority group. The Protestants viewed the
- 54:48Northern Irish identity as practically identical to their
- 54:51own Protestant identity, so adopting it didn't change their
- 54:54out group bias at all. And hanging over all of these
- 54:58solutions, casting a long shadow, is the ultimate
- 55:01obstacle. Deep, entrenched dehumanization.
- 55:05If you don't view the other side as human, if moral typecasting
- 55:08has convinced you they literally cannot feel pain, you cannot
- 55:11empathize with their grief. You cannot offer them oxygen or
- 55:14heat, which is why the researchers say we desperately
- 55:16need massive macro level changes, particularly in how we
- 55:20consume information. We need a shift toward peace
- 55:23promoting journalism, journalism that actively deescalates by
- 55:26focusing on the complex root causes, exploring nonviolent
- 55:29alternatives, and steadfastly avoiding the dehumanization of
- 55:31either side. This macro level shift has to be
- 55:34combined with micro level face to face intergroup contact to
- 55:37slowly, painfully rehumanize the adversary over time.
- 55:40It is a monumental generational task.
- 55:44So to summarize this incredible journey we've been on today, we
- 55:48are fundamentally driven by a psychological need for power and
- 55:51acceptance which leads us to fight for the victim crown.
- 55:54We utilize deeply ingrained cognitive biases, moral
- 55:58typecasting, memory gaps, social comparisons to justify our own
- 56:02actions and completely blind ourselves to our adversaries
- 56:05pain. We institutionalized this
- 56:07blindness through chosen traumas and war.
- 56:09Promoting media and this very competition, this desperate need
- 56:13to be the only victim, is the exact biological and societal
- 56:16mechanism that ensures the conflict will never, ever end.
- 56:20It is the ultimate vicious cycle.
- 56:22The psychological cure these groups are seeking.
- 56:23The status of exclusive victimhood is the very poison
- 56:26keeping them sick. I want to thank you, the
- 56:28listener, for staying with us and coming on this intensive
- 56:31intellectual journey today. It is heavy, complex material,
- 56:33but understanding the mechanics of how our brains fail us is the
- 56:36only way to start fixing the problem.
- 56:38And I want to leave you with a final provocative thought.
- 56:40Go for it, the source material briefly notes.
- 56:43The competitive victimhood isn't just a phenomenon reserved for
- 56:45global wars, geopolitical intractability, or history
- 56:48books. The exact same cognitive
- 56:51mechanics happen in interpersonal transgressions,
- 56:53too. It happens in our own lives
- 56:56every single day. I want you to think about your
- 56:58last massive argument. Think about a fight with a
- 57:02romantic partner, a deep conflict with a family member,
- 57:05or a bitter dispute with a Co worker.
- 57:08Think about the mechanics of that fight.
- 57:10Were you secretly competing to be the true victim in order to
- 57:13protect your own self esteem? Were you tallying up your
- 57:17grievances, utilizing bias memory to delete their apologies
- 57:21just to prove they hurt you worse than you hurt them?
- 57:24Were you wielding your hurt feelings as a moral shield to
- 57:27avoid taking responsibility for your own bad behavior?
- 57:30It's a tough question to ask yourself.
- 57:32It is, but if we could start to recognize the mechanics of
- 57:34competitive victimhood in our own living rooms, in our own
- 57:37relationships, maybe we have a slightly better shot at
- 57:40understanding how to dismantle it on the global stage.
- 57:43Keep exploring, keep questioning your own biases, and we'll see
- 57:46you on the next deep dive.