Latest / Rhythm of Life / AMBIOLOGY Ep. 1 - Why It's Getting Harder To Understand Each Other
Transcript
- 0:00[SPEAKER_01]: Hi everyone, it's Steve Ordauer here, and if you've been following rhythm of life, you know we're always exploring how to see things more clearly.
- 0:07[SPEAKER_01]: What you're about to hear is the first episode of a new podcast called the Ambiology, I'm co-producing with the dear friend of mine, Blake Minerly.
- 0:16[SPEAKER_01]: It challenges something most of us take for granted that politics is simply a battle between left and right.
- 0:22[SPEAKER_01]: We're not asking you to pick the middle or change what you believe, quite the contrary.
- 0:27[SPEAKER_01]: we're asking a very different question.
- 0:30[SPEAKER_01]: What if the framework itself is the problem?
- 0:34[SPEAKER_01]: The goal is simple to reconnect with what you truly believe without the labels, the noise, or the narrative shaping it.
- 0:42[SPEAKER_01]: If that resonates with you at all, this conversation is for you.
- 0:46[SPEAKER_01]: Enjoy.
- 0:47[SPEAKER_01]: Am I crazy?
- 0:48[SPEAKER_01]: Is there something wrong with me?
- 0:51[SPEAKER_02]: Are you seeing this?
- 0:53[SPEAKER_02]: Is anybody else seeing what I'm seeing?
- 0:55[SPEAKER_02]: This doesn't make any sense.
- 0:57[SPEAKER_02]: None of it makes any sense.
- 0:59[SPEAKER_02]: Has the world gone mad?
- 1:32[SPEAKER_05]: Thank you very much.
- 1:51[SPEAKER_05]: and a young white men to fight.
- 1:54[SPEAKER_05]: You can't win from the shot of gravity.
- 1:58[SPEAKER_05]: If when they come back home, they can't pause and live on the same block.
- 2:02[SPEAKER_05]: The white liver differs from the white conservative only in one way.
- 2:07[SPEAKER_05]: The white liver will be able to use the Negro as a pawn or weapon.
- 2:12[SPEAKER_05]: In this political football game.
- 2:40[SPEAKER_00]: They share their personal journeys, question the stories you've been told, and explore how history, incentives, and media shake the way we see each other.
- 2:48[SPEAKER_00]: Rather than arguing for compromise or centrism, this conversation invites curiosity and humility, as they begin to build a framework for understanding our political system, beyond tribal labels.
- 3:01[SPEAKER_00]: If you've ever felt politically homeless, or wondered why nothing seems to make sense anymore,
- 3:13[SPEAKER_02]: Welcome everybody to ambiology episode one.
- 3:18[SPEAKER_02]: I'm Blake Minnerly and with me is my intrepid cohost and partner in crime and producer of the show Steve Orgauer.
- 3:27[SPEAKER_02]: Hey Steve.
- 3:28[SPEAKER_02]: Hello.
- 3:29[SPEAKER_02]: Hello.
- 3:29[SPEAKER_02]: Nice to see you Blake.
- 3:31[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, good to see you too.
- 3:33[SPEAKER_02]: I'm excited about this conversation.
- 3:34[SPEAKER_02]: This has been a project which to put it mildly has been a long time in the making, right?
- 3:41[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, absolutely.
- 3:42[SPEAKER_02]: I don't know when we started talking about this, but it was probably maybe seven months ago, eight months ago.
- 3:53[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and when I say this, of course, the whole point of this episode is that we're going to try and describe this idea that we have developed, this sort of burgeoning philosophy, this journey that we are on to sort of produce a deeper understanding of our political system and of ourselves, how we interact with each other, how we communicate with each other as people as in culture.
- 4:23[SPEAKER_02]: And how the various forces historically have led us to where we are today in the kind of political situation that we are seeing ourselves in.
- 4:34[SPEAKER_02]: And so, and it's the idea that we are trying to develop ambiology, which is a short term, an attempt to escape the left-right spectrum entirely as a construct.
- 4:49[SPEAKER_02]: Not an attempt to seek compromise or to be centrist, but to simply release the construct entirely as unnecessary and in fact mythological.
- 5:04[SPEAKER_02]: It's very difficult to describe to people, and it's going to take us...
- 5:09[SPEAKER_02]: probably more than one episode and a part of that is because it's a complex idea and novel to the two of us but also because both of us really are engaged in this journey of developing this as we go.
- 5:22[SPEAKER_02]: So everybody is really going to be watching us develop this idea in real time.
- 5:28[SPEAKER_02]: We have kind of like a rough starting point, right?
- 5:31[SPEAKER_02]: We have some understandings of what it is
- 5:35[SPEAKER_02]: Both some current events and a lot of historical events in order to try and develop this idea.
- 5:44[SPEAKER_02]: But everybody is really going to be seeing us trying to figure out in real time what the hell it is that we actually mean really by ambiology, right?
- 5:55[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, we're processing it.
- 5:57[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and processing the experience that we have each personally gone through and going through and trying to understand where do we belong if there is in fact such a thing as where we belong.
- 6:14[SPEAKER_02]: politically, vis-à-vis, the country, our peers, our family, you know, and now our wonderful listeners, in fact, are any, we'll see, right?
- 6:30[SPEAKER_02]: So, you know, we wanted to sort of start off the conversation, I guess, by talking about just kind of who we are a little bit and where we're coming from and why this idea seems so necessary to us.
- 6:48[SPEAKER_02]: And we're trying to get to what we're hoping to achieve through all of this, and maybe give people kind of a window into what they can expect in future episodes as well.
- 7:01[SPEAKER_02]: Great.
- 7:03[SPEAKER_02]: So I guess starting with with the personal journey, I think there's kind of a due diligence.
- 7:11[SPEAKER_02]: that is required that we talk about where we're coming from politically, even though both of us, I would say, I don't want to speak for you, but both of us would probably say that we've really moved away from where we were politically, not to the other side of this spectrum, but off this spectrum.
- 7:34[SPEAKER_02]: Which is an important distinction, very important.
- 7:37[SPEAKER_02]: very important because I guess I would say really be ideals that both of us have as I understand that we've known each other a long time we should start with that we've we've been friends for 30 years and you know it so we have a very good sense of who each other is if that's the
- 8:06[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, very funny how I mean I've had these conversations with people and it's like, you know, the ideals that I had growing up seem to have been confirmed over time, although now we're in a
- 8:30[SPEAKER_01]: in order for us to maintain a strong relationship with our ideals.
- 8:36[SPEAKER_01]: There was a crossroads that we came to, and we had to make a move, and now we reconnected within the last year, and we noticed we were experiencing some similar things in a similar way.
- 8:52[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, I think it would be fair to say that a realization that we've had is that a lot of the people around us have seemed relatively comfortable with major adjustments to not necessarily their values, but.
- 9:11[SPEAKER_02]: the way that those values are reflected in their positions on policies and historical events.
- 9:18[SPEAKER_02]: And there's a kind of a messaging that is coming from the dominant political factions that we have in the country.
- 9:28[SPEAKER_02]: And there's a lot of people who seem quite comfortable shifting according to those messages and shifting.
- 9:34[SPEAKER_02]: And we've had a lot more difficulty than other people perhaps in getting on work with those changes.
- 9:42[SPEAKER_02]: And there was a growing sense of sort of cognitive dissonance between what we have believed.
- 9:52[SPEAKER_02]: And what we have believed was the sort of central, were the central tenets of the political tribe that we belong to.
- 9:59[SPEAKER_02]: And yeah, what we were seeing that political tribe advocate, they've seen very much in conflict.
- 10:06[SPEAKER_02]: That seemed not to bother a lot of people.
- 10:08[SPEAKER_02]: And I want to be clear, it's not a judgment.
- 10:13[SPEAKER_02]: It's not even a little bit that I think that either one of us is somehow better.
- 10:19[SPEAKER_02]: that were for whatever, there's a sort of almost random personality traits, and one that we both share, that we have more difficulty making those kind of...
- 10:32[SPEAKER_01]: epistemological shifts without being like what you know and getting that kind of like Scooby-doo or sort of face like totally but it's not yeah it is not like we were totally not susceptible to it I mean we're all susceptible to this to some degree and so what absolutely you know what I keep what keeps coming up in our conversations over time is
- 10:58[SPEAKER_01]: is sense of humility that is so critical to allow us to transcend these perspectives that have limited our understanding of things.
- 11:10[SPEAKER_01]: And once we have been able to do this in a conscious way, I know that my, and I would probably speak for both of us, our understanding of issues that are
- 11:26[SPEAKER_01]: For sure.
- 11:26[SPEAKER_02]: And because the the dissonance that we felt has really forced us to take a lot of deep dives into a lot of different issues, a lot of different historical things, a lot of different aspects of how our system really functions if you start to unpack the sort of service level stories about what's going on and try and look at a more sort of systemic institutional level,
- 11:55[SPEAKER_02]: They seem different.
- 11:56[SPEAKER_02]: And I think the reasons that we're able to be in this position are really mostly accidental.
- 12:02[SPEAKER_02]: It has nothing to do with like any superior intellect or anything else that we have.
- 12:07[SPEAKER_02]: It's a happenstance of the course of our lives and a happenstance of where the world is at right now.
- 12:17[SPEAKER_02]: So, you know, I
- 12:19[SPEAKER_02]: And that desire to belong, that desire to be part of the tribe, to be on the same page with the people who are important to you, with your community, your peers, a super, like understandable, and maybe even essential human function.
- 12:40[SPEAKER_02]: Like it's completely clear why it happens.
- 12:45[SPEAKER_02]: There's even really good things about that.
- 12:49[SPEAKER_02]: There's reasons that you don't just want to be oppositional to everyone around us all the time, right, that we're just really irritating and not productive, right?
- 13:01[SPEAKER_02]: Personally, I certainly don't want to just be a contrarian.
- 13:05[SPEAKER_02]: I don't want to simply be the person who is standing up and being, I'm not like the rest of you.
- 13:13[SPEAKER_02]: This has been a very reluctant
- 13:16[SPEAKER_02]: voyage for the two of us, I'd say, and sometimes a very painful one, right?
- 13:21[SPEAKER_02]: Because you've been really, sometimes a lot of loneliness, and until that we started to sort of understand the position, a lot of like, am I crazy?
- 13:31[SPEAKER_02]: Is there something wrong with me?
- 13:34[SPEAKER_02]: And Mark Conversations, and conversations that we've had with other people have really brought us to a point where it's like, okay, no, we're perceiving something that is worth pursuing here.
- 13:46[SPEAKER_01]: yeah for sure and it's uh it's it's interesting how it's been playing out and um yeah and when we reconnected it was uh well specifically between you and me I could speak for myself that would oh hello my dog is going to be barking during this podcast by the way that's being tested what's your dog's name?
- 14:09[SPEAKER_01]: Percy yeah Percy okay well hello Percy thanks for
- 14:16[SPEAKER_01]: But, yeah, for when you and I connected specifically, it was very, very helpful for me to just not feel so alone in terms of, are you seeing this, is anybody else seeing what I'm seeing?
- 14:34[SPEAKER_01]: That was very, very helpful.
- 14:37[SPEAKER_01]: For me to stay grounded in who I am and what I'm perceiving that that it wasn't I wasn't just making this up in my head
- 14:48[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and also there was a sense to me that there was an increasing sense of like, has the world gone mad, right?
- 14:58[SPEAKER_02]: You know, like it not this doesn't make any sense.
- 15:01[SPEAKER_02]: None of it makes any sense.
- 15:03[SPEAKER_02]: And when we began to let go of that surface level, what we claim as a hypothesis is really a mythology.
- 15:13[SPEAKER_02]: our political system.
- 15:16[SPEAKER_02]: Everything made a lot more sense.
- 15:18[SPEAKER_02]: It seems crazy anymore.
- 15:20[SPEAKER_02]: It seemed like a system behaving the way you would expect it to behave according to the incentive structure and the institutional structure.
- 15:30[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, it is guiding the system.
- 15:32[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 15:32[SPEAKER_01]: And the incentive structures are so critical to understanding this.
- 15:36[SPEAKER_02]: absolutely, absolutely.
- 15:38[SPEAKER_02]: And much more important than understanding the supposed moral authority of any of the individuals who are supposedly representative of these systems of thought.
- 15:55[SPEAKER_02]: So, I guess kind of getting back to where we came from, I think due diligence kind of demands
- 16:03[SPEAKER_02]: Where we were politically initially, you know, I, both of us, I think sort of grew up very much on the left, right, correct.
- 16:15[SPEAKER_02]: We both grew up on the south side of Chicago in a very strongly democratic.
- 16:22[SPEAKER_02]: community that was very tied to the civil rights movement that was very tied at least to some extent to the anti-war movement.
- 16:32[SPEAKER_02]: Both of us had parents that in different ways really championed those issues, your father and my father in particular.
- 16:41[SPEAKER_02]: I know we're very influential on each of us respectively in that regard for sure.
- 16:48[SPEAKER_02]: So we had these kind of classic 60s and 70s democratic left ideology, at least so we thought of it at the time.
- 17:04[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I just want to just add a little bit to that from my own experience.
- 17:08[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, my
- 17:10[SPEAKER_01]: You know, my father was even kind of beyond that to some degree.
- 17:15[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, he was kind of a freedom fighter.
- 17:18[SPEAKER_01]: At least in my interview, I'm working on a documentary about him and the show he produced, the Scott's music, television, short, jubilee showcase.
- 17:27[SPEAKER_01]: So when I interviewed Reverend Jesse Jackson about him,
- 17:30[SPEAKER_01]: That's what he said.
- 17:31[SPEAKER_01]: He's like, Oh, Sid was a freedom fighter, which, you know, it's like these ideals were firmly implanted in me, not forcefully at all.
- 17:42[SPEAKER_01]: It was through lots of, um,
- 17:46[SPEAKER_01]: uh, vibrant debate, which was very stimulating on a lot of levels, um, intellectually, it was wonderful to have conversations with my father and I, I miss him dearly and I wish that I could have these conversations with him now to make sense of what's going on, because he was
- 18:08[SPEAKER_01]: of the United States.
- 18:10[SPEAKER_01]: And I would be very interested to hear what both of our fathers would be saying about what we're doing right now.
- 18:17[SPEAKER_01]: I think they would probably be heavily in favor of it to be honest with you and like what's going on here with this political divide.
- 18:25[SPEAKER_01]: And then when you mentioned this conversations with Coleman interview with Hyramin Verlan Lewis about the book that
- 18:37[SPEAKER_01]: This is it.
- 18:37[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, this is what I've been processing and you just kind of help bring it home for me.
- 18:43[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, I definitely has always been thinking about these type of things from a, you know, from a ideal standpoint, but in terms of the political party affiliation, it just seemed like that was.
- 19:00[SPEAKER_01]: The Democratic Party was the one to that lined up with the most, but you know, when I met and I know this is a bit of an aside, if I may, but when I met my wife Christina, we couldn't be, I mean, our backgrounds are very different.
- 19:16[SPEAKER_01]: I grew up in Hyde Park as you mentioned in the south side of Chicago and.
- 19:20[SPEAKER_01]: a very integrated mixed environment rather and there were a variety of opinions for sure and perspectives and cultures and she was from a pretty homogeneous community or what have you
- 19:37[SPEAKER_01]: You know, fairly conservative for lack of a better phrase, I know we're trying to get a right way from those labels, but um, I get identified as conservative.
- 19:47[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, exactly.
- 19:48[SPEAKER_01]: And and so what was interesting when we started getting a little bit more into our relationship, and we started to talk about politics a little bit more.
- 19:56[SPEAKER_01]: I say, look,
- 19:58[SPEAKER_01]: The key to voting in my mind, if I may, is just find, like, you have your values and find political representatives that are running for office, that are in line with your values and work backwards.
- 20:17[SPEAKER_01]: And I still hold, hold, hold,
- 20:21[SPEAKER_01]: I still hold that to be true, however with what you're saying is, yeah, the memo came out and things are shifting and we're just supposed to get in line on and we're both like, no, no, we're not doing that because we actually do have a pretty strong sense of
- 20:42[SPEAKER_01]: our ideals, and so like you're saying, to be clear, this show is not about getting away from what you think is right or wrong or your perspectives on things and your ideals.
- 20:54[SPEAKER_01]: It's actually an avenue to keep them with you and to embrace them even that much more closely and be clear about what actually is influencing you to get away from those ideals that are really important to you.
- 21:11[SPEAKER_02]: Absolutely.
- 21:12[SPEAKER_02]: And analogy that I sometimes think of is a little bit like joining a fraternity, which was always something not to knock anybody who's an fraternity.
- 21:23[SPEAKER_02]: I'm sure it's like there's lots of good things about fraternities and they for sure.
- 21:28[SPEAKER_02]: They get a bad rap and maybe that's to serve, maybe it's not, that's not really my point.
- 21:32[SPEAKER_02]: But right, right.
- 21:34[SPEAKER_02]: You know, sort of the ideas you could go to a college and just be like, I like these kinds of people and I like having these kinds of conversations and sharing these ideas and so here's somebody and here's somebody and there's somebody or you could sort of outsource that.
- 21:52[SPEAKER_02]: And say, well, there's these different fraternities and they have kind of like different personalities and if it's like, you know, fight alpha, alpha, I don't know what the, I don't know what you've, I don't know what you've, I don't know what you've, I don't know what you've, I don't know what you've, I don't know, right?
- 22:09[SPEAKER_02]: I was never in a frat.
- 22:11[SPEAKER_02]: So, but the idea is, I'm sorry, go ahead.
- 22:18[SPEAKER_02]: Go ahead.
- 22:18[SPEAKER_02]: That was pretty funny.
- 22:19[SPEAKER_02]: I'll fall for.
- 22:19[SPEAKER_02]: That's me.
- 22:20[SPEAKER_02]: Hey, hey, yeah, I'm a little rascals fan.
- 22:24[SPEAKER_02]: So the idea is that these different frats have like different personalities, right?
- 22:28[SPEAKER_02]: People really strongly believe that.
- 22:30[SPEAKER_02]: So this frat is, you know, these kinds of people and that frat is more those kinds of people.
- 22:35[SPEAKER_02]: So the assumption is if I join this frat, then I'm going to be hanging out with the kind of people that I like, right?
- 22:41[SPEAKER_02]: So you're letting this sort of institutional middle man come in and be like, hey, we're going to handle your political values for you.
- 22:50[SPEAKER_02]: If you have these kinds of values, hey, you want to be over here in this political threat.
- 22:55[SPEAKER_02]: That's where those kinds of people are.
- 22:57[SPEAKER_02]: And the fact is, you just don't have to join a threat.
- 23:01[SPEAKER_02]: You can just like the people that you like, you can just have the political values that you have without needing to associate them, without needing to place them somewhere on a spectrum.
- 23:14[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.
- 23:16[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.
- 23:16[SPEAKER_02]: We would claim is actually mythological, right?
- 23:20[SPEAKER_02]: That's going to be the whole basis of the show is that this best one is, and I want to make this point right here because when we say mythological, I can hear some people reacting like, what do you mean mythological?
- 23:30[SPEAKER_02]: Like it doesn't matter if trump wins or Biden wins, it's not at all what we're saying, right?
- 23:35[SPEAKER_02]: Right, right, right, right.
- 23:36[SPEAKER_02]: Myths myths can have profound impacts on what actually occurs in real life.
- 23:44[SPEAKER_02]: as a biological entity race is a myth, right?
- 23:50[SPEAKER_02]: It doesn't really have a biological essence, right?
- 23:56[SPEAKER_02]: And that's a whole other discussion, but because we believe in that myth,
- 24:07[SPEAKER_02]: It's real.
- 24:09[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 24:09[SPEAKER_02]: It's that's our everyday life profoundly, right?
- 24:12[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.
- 24:12[SPEAKER_02]: So saying that something is a myth is not to say that it's not real.
- 24:19[SPEAKER_02]: It's a real myth, right?
- 24:22[SPEAKER_02]: And in the same way, like any myth that you believe, like if you believe that, you know, all Leo's are brave and all Scorpios are intense.
- 24:33[SPEAKER_02]: Then that's that might be nonsense if you don't believe in astrology, but it's still going to affect how you interact with other humans if you believe right, so it becomes real right that that's what they mean by the left right spectrum is a myth it's a story that we tell ourselves that then has very profound effects on how we see reality how we see each other yeah we interact with each other.
- 24:59[SPEAKER_02]: Totally.
- 25:01[SPEAKER_02]: Totally.
- 25:01[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 25:02[SPEAKER_02]: Absolutely.
- 25:02[SPEAKER_02]: So not and we're also not saying that the positions that get represented in any given current moment by the left or the right are mythological, right?
- 25:14[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 25:14[SPEAKER_01]: So totally.
- 25:15[SPEAKER_02]: Totally.
- 25:17[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, a given party at any given moment might be associated with something that you genuinely think is terrible, and it's no way are we trying to dissuade anybody from that belief.
- 25:30[SPEAKER_01]: Because, you know, a lot of people, yeah, for sure, and I just want to say a lot of times people will say things like, well, you know, they're all cropped in.
- 25:41[SPEAKER_01]: There's really no difference between the Democrats and the Republicans, and I just think,
- 25:46[SPEAKER_01]: It's kind of lazy to be honest, it's lazy to respect it because there's a huge difference between them, there's a vast difference between them.
- 25:56[SPEAKER_01]: That's not what we acknowledge that we acknowledge that and we are still saying that it would be a good idea, perhaps, to break free from this, so that we can have a deeper understanding of what's going on, because oftentimes what we'll talk about in a variety of different ways over the life span of this project of this podcast show.
- 26:23[SPEAKER_01]: and biology, which is, you know, oftentimes from the scholarship of the Lewis Brothers with their book, they noted that nowadays you can be part of a tribe agreeing with one or two policy positions and then
- 26:41[SPEAKER_01]: Generally, people are in for the rest, which is not really conducive to understanding these policy initiatives on a deeper level.
- 26:52[SPEAKER_01]: And so what I think is the best way to go about understanding this landscape is to just
- 27:08[SPEAKER_01]: this bucket of issues.
- 27:10[SPEAKER_01]: And then you say, okay, I'm my stance on abortion is this and this other thing and and one other thing and then all of a sudden year for all the stuff in this this bucket, it seems rather absurd and unlimited.
- 27:28[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and I think that reproductive rights is a great example, right?
- 27:32[SPEAKER_02]: Because someone might, for example, feel very strongly about reproductive rights.
- 27:40[SPEAKER_02]: Myself included, I'm very strongly in favor of reproductive rights as a
- 27:50[SPEAKER_02]: But if you do, then you're going to look at the two parties.
- 27:53[SPEAKER_02]: And of course, you're going to align yourself in the current moment more with the Democratic party than with the Republican party.
- 28:01[SPEAKER_02]: If you believe that, okay, and in no way would we suggest that that's.
- 28:05[SPEAKER_02]: insane or wrong or anything else, it's completely understandable, but you're associating with a group of people who are part of a larger institution that has kind of a shopping cart full of the positions which don't necessarily have any coherent link to each other and just to get along with the other people.
- 28:30[SPEAKER_02]: that share your belief in reproductive rights, everyone has to take on these other ideas also.
- 28:38[SPEAKER_02]: So that's a part of it.
- 28:39[SPEAKER_02]: It doesn't make any sense.
- 28:40[SPEAKER_02]: But another thing that I think we want to get to is it's not simply a matter of the fact that we think
- 28:47[SPEAKER_02]: that this sort of like frat system, these two shopping cards of issues that we can pick that are actually constantly shifting, right?
- 28:56[SPEAKER_01]: What's going to, you know, way more than we, you realize actually when we see our examining it.
- 29:02[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 29:02[SPEAKER_02]: way more.
- 29:03[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and it actually goes back to our early appointment when we were saying like, well, the left used to be like this, it's not like we're harkening back to the good old days.
- 29:11[SPEAKER_02]: So one of the realizations that we've had is that that shift is continuous.
- 29:16[SPEAKER_02]: It's constantly changing.
- 29:18[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 29:18[SPEAKER_02]: What what constitutes the left and what constitutes the right is really very unstable over the actual store in scale.
- 29:26[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 29:27[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 29:28[SPEAKER_01]: But that's
- 29:30[SPEAKER_01]: That's scholarship by the Lewis Brothers is so important.
- 29:33[SPEAKER_01]: So go ahead.
- 29:33[SPEAKER_02]: I'm so important.
- 29:35[SPEAKER_02]: And we'll spend some more time talking about them and specifically at the end of the show too.
- 29:39[SPEAKER_02]: Um, you know, we've referenced them a lot because they've been extremely and they've been formed.
- 29:46[SPEAKER_02]: probably more than any one academic source, they've informed a lot of our thinking about this position.
- 29:54[SPEAKER_02]: So we'll definitely more into them.
- 29:56[SPEAKER_02]: But it's not just that the left and right, the left-right spectrum is unrealistic or unnecessary.
- 30:05[SPEAKER_02]: It's that we have come to the very strong opinion that it is dysfunctional, destructive, reduces the compassion that we have for each other.
- 30:17[SPEAKER_02]: Increases fear, anxiety, blind hatred of other people that we don't even know that in fact we might have a very warm regard for an large amounts of common ground with even if we disagree in this place and
- 30:35[SPEAKER_02]: And that spectrum serves a social function of power, right?
- 30:41[SPEAKER_02]: It is useful in power, right?
- 30:45[SPEAKER_02]: And so that is the other idea that there's, there's these differences.
- 30:50[SPEAKER_02]: Mm-hmm.
- 30:51[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.
- 30:52[SPEAKER_02]: And there's these differences that are legitimate reproductive rights over here, and that's over here.
- 30:57[SPEAKER_02]: First of all, there's all this other stuff kind of above those wedge issues.
- 31:05[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, really?
- 31:06[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and that's totally.
- 31:10[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, there's so many really, really important issues like the environment.
- 31:17[SPEAKER_01]: You know, campaign finance reform, how we are interaction with other countries on a global scale, how are we managing the economy, taxes, fiscal responsibility or lack thereof, etc.
- 31:34[SPEAKER_01]: It goes on and on and on and I'm sure you and I both have seen many examples of
- 31:42[SPEAKER_01]: people that are really used to hear about in the political landscape, the one issue voter.
- 31:52[SPEAKER_01]: That's just kind of boggles my mind to me.
- 31:55[SPEAKER_01]: You know, like one issue is more important than any other.
- 31:58[SPEAKER_01]: Well, maybe that's fine.
- 32:00[SPEAKER_01]: And I don't, I don't want to stand in judgment of anybody, but there's so many issues that are important, particularly, you know, you could say that about anything time in history.
- 32:11[SPEAKER_01]: I was going to say particularly right now, you know, with the environment.
- 32:15[SPEAKER_01]: and the variety of opinions and perspectives about that.
- 32:19[SPEAKER_01]: And why should that have anything to do with your stance on reproductive rights?
- 32:24[SPEAKER_02]: Like, yeah, the assumption that she was trying to crazy.
- 32:27[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, if you, if you believe in reproductive rights, then bodily autonomy.
- 32:34[SPEAKER_02]: that therefore let's say you are also a very in favor of continued funding for arming Ukraine or you are in favor of higher taxes on the 1% fiscal policy or foreign policy or any of you know that's the part that's really
- 33:00[SPEAKER_02]: mythological that there is one sort of liberal or conservative principle that is cleaving every political issue in half according to that singular principle and sorting them into two bins according to that that one sort of
- 33:28[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and that's a minute.
- 33:30[SPEAKER_02]: It's quite obvious that there's more than one issue in politics, right?
- 33:33[SPEAKER_02]: It should be.
- 33:34[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 33:35[SPEAKER_01]: Well, that's what I think with the interview that will be rolling out next episode with Verlan Lewis, which is incredible.
- 33:46[SPEAKER_01]: I can't wait to share this with the audience, but, you know, he was basically saying there's more than one issue in politics, and I'm like, what?
- 33:53[SPEAKER_01]: of course there is.
- 33:54[SPEAKER_01]: But then he broke it down in terms of what we're talking about right now.
- 33:59[SPEAKER_01]: Of course there is.
- 34:00[SPEAKER_01]: Why should you just be in line with one issue and then get in line with the rest because you part of a tribe and it's part of your identity.
- 34:08[SPEAKER_01]: I used to talk to, I mean, I used to think about this as a kid and it's it's just those thoughts have just been confirmed
- 34:20[SPEAKER_01]: One's identity is very, very powerful and how that is shaped and how one relates to their themselves in that way if you identify in a certain way and align yourself with a political tribe and then you throw in a little religion to amplify that.
- 34:39[SPEAKER_01]: that that relationship in terms of how you move through the world.
- 34:44[SPEAKER_01]: It's a very powerful mix and that's why, you know, you mix, you know, like the Republican Party years ago made a relationship with evangelicals.
- 34:57[SPEAKER_01]: And next thing, you know, they wanted to increase that power base.
- 35:02[SPEAKER_01]: And they brought in this, this, this,
- 35:07[SPEAKER_01]: This policy about abortion rights or rather they were against abortion and they increased their power based dramatically, but it's not like
- 35:20[SPEAKER_01]: the Republican Party really cared about that before this moment in time where they made an alliance with the Evangelicals.
- 35:27[SPEAKER_01]: So if you just start looking at it from an unattached lens and you put a motion to the side, things start to get clear pretty quickly.
- 35:38[SPEAKER_01]: It's actually quite refreshing and liberating and actually empowering, but the initial stages to be quite frank can be a little daunting.
- 35:49[SPEAKER_02]: Absolutely.
- 35:50[SPEAKER_02]: It's a very unsettling thing to vary, to abandon a worldview, a framework.
- 35:58[SPEAKER_02]: Like we are so used to viewing all political interactions as a struggle between an epic battle between two sides, one of which is good and one of which is bad, right?
- 36:09[SPEAKER_02]: We're so conditioned to that.
- 36:10[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 36:10[SPEAKER_02]: When you first start to like put that down,
- 36:14[SPEAKER_02]: It's like taking off a pair of glasses that you've been doing for years.
- 36:18[SPEAKER_02]: Every time it's distorted and fuzzy and you're like, where am I and you're falling over and bumping into things?
- 36:24[SPEAKER_02]: People are getting mad at you, you know, it's a, you know, and it's, it's very daunting.
- 36:30[SPEAKER_02]: And the, the one other thing that I would add is that the other really powerful, perhaps the most powerful aspect of this, in terms of this show,
- 36:40[SPEAKER_02]: And where we really want to go in future episodes is that if, in fact, the nature of our institutional structure, the nature of our political struggles is not actually a battle between the left and the right.
- 36:55[SPEAKER_02]: That's kind of a storytelling veneer that we put over the top of things.
- 37:01[SPEAKER_02]: That means that there is some other
- 37:04[SPEAKER_02]: actual reality underneath that, or maybe it's just layers of an onion and you're just constantly going down, but at any rate by putting away that distorting lens, you can look more nakedly at the reality of our structure, at the nature of our history, at the nature of what we call modern U.S. democracy,
- 37:27[SPEAKER_02]: at what the functions of our institutions are.
- 37:31[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 37:32[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 37:33[SPEAKER_02]: Another realization that I think that both of us have come to is that at a certain high level.
- 37:40[SPEAKER_02]: above the level of party.
- 37:43[SPEAKER_02]: There's a lot of very, very powerful people who simply they're not engaging in that mythology.
- 37:50[SPEAKER_02]: They're like, left, right, whatever you need.
- 37:53[SPEAKER_02]: Right, pro-abortion, anti-abortion.
- 37:56[SPEAKER_02]: I don't know what of the focus groups say, right?
- 37:58[SPEAKER_02]: How are we going to make more profit as a corporation?
- 38:01[SPEAKER_02]: What's more effective as a public relations
- 38:04[SPEAKER_02]: when narrative is going to be more useful to us in this particular shifting political moment.
- 38:10[SPEAKER_02]: So by putting our hope is that by putting this structure away and just leaving it alone, we can deepen our understanding of how our institutions actually function.
- 38:24[SPEAKER_01]: So that's what I'm hoping this show can become.
- 38:33[SPEAKER_01]: podcast, I host rhythm of life, and you said that, and in this particular paradigm, inhibits real and thoughtful institutional analysis.
- 38:47[SPEAKER_01]: And that just hit me like a ton of bricks.
- 38:49[SPEAKER_01]: It couldn't be more true in my mind.
- 38:54[SPEAKER_01]: And it really does.
- 38:55[SPEAKER_01]: And that's why we're so, I think, inspired to bring this show to the public.
- 39:01[SPEAKER_01]: So that,
- 39:02[SPEAKER_01]: It can help people with this process of letting that those rose colored glasses go and taking them off so to speak because I don't think we're alone I don't think we're alone at all I think a lot of people.
- 39:19[SPEAKER_01]: are experiencing something like this but they can't quite maybe articulate it or can't put their finger on it but they feel something's going on and something's really strange and just a handful of folks in my circle that I shared my interview with you with.
- 39:39[SPEAKER_01]: They were very grateful and thankful that We're doing something like this.
- 39:45[SPEAKER_01]: It really hit them in a very profound way So I think actually there's a much larger audience than we might think I mean, it does feel at first.
- 39:57[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you're all alone, but
- 39:59[SPEAKER_01]: You know, part of this is really cathartic for us as we process this because we're going through it right now as we're developing this show we're going through the transformation so you guys can, you know, our audience can experience this with us.
- 40:26[SPEAKER_02]: It's not, we're never gonna be saying, this is the way things are.
- 40:32[SPEAKER_02]: Maybe we're gonna be saying, this is the way things aren't.
- 40:35[SPEAKER_02]: You know, like this mythology, this story does not really seem to add up with reality.
- 40:41[SPEAKER_02]: But then it's one of the things, each of us, once we put that distorting lens, it's not to each of us to decide for ourselves what's actually going on and my idea or your ideas really not any more valuable than any, but we're not claiming any expertise, right?
- 41:00[SPEAKER_02]: I'm not, we're not political scientists, totally people on, you know, the only things I'm expert at are Newtonian
- 41:10[SPEAKER_02]: So nice, you know, with these things.
- 41:14[SPEAKER_02]: Well, I'm even that, you know, I'm going to like put expert with a little asterisk on it.
- 41:18[SPEAKER_02]: I'm not a big believer in expertise anyway to be honest, but so we have more questions than answers.
- 41:29[SPEAKER_02]: We are trying to unpack the distorting lenses and then the actual reality, that's for everybody to have at and decide for themselves, hopefully what they think is really going on.
- 41:43[SPEAKER_02]: some different texts from the past, some different moments that we think are illustrative of the process that we're talking about, totally, but it's really both of us trying to figure this out in real time, just what you said.
- 42:02[SPEAKER_02]: Absolutely.
- 42:02[SPEAKER_02]: And this might be a great time to move on a little bit to
- 42:08[SPEAKER_02]: some of the the polling data that we looked out about like you know are we alone where are where are where is the American public in terms of these ideas of left and right and and maybe that polling data also starts to reveal a little bit of the mythology that we've been talking about.
- 42:25[SPEAKER_01]: Can I just say what and one quick thing before we move on, which is what's really amazing about this process is I can hear and I believe that you're experiencing this as well as I can hear politicians.
- 42:41[SPEAKER_01]: from the other side in a much more substantive way, I can actually hear what they're saying and consider it for myself rather than immediately looking at them and already subconsciously thinking their full of crap, they're from the bad side, they're the enemy, they're from the other friend.
- 43:01[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly, and they're not good or what have you.
- 43:05[SPEAKER_01]: So I can listen to somebody like Rand Paul and just listen to the words coming out of his mouth and the ideas coming out of his mouth and make a much more thoughtful consideration of what he's actually saying.
- 43:22[SPEAKER_01]: as opposed to what I think he's saying, and really, or maybe I'm reading somebody's interpretation of what they're saying.
- 43:32[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I think it's very, very important to listen to people directly, and I think, you know, one of the aims of this show is to have people do more of that.
- 43:42[SPEAKER_01]: then look through these lenses that we've spoken about before.
- 43:47[SPEAKER_01]: So anyway, I just wanted to throw that in there.
- 43:49[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, for sure.
- 43:50[SPEAKER_02]: In order to critique an idea effectively, even if someone you disagree with strongly, you have to understand.
- 43:57[SPEAKER_02]: First, be willing to present the best version of it.
- 44:00[SPEAKER_02]: What is this person actually saying?
- 44:03[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.
- 44:04[SPEAKER_02]: And if you're just like, this is an expression of somebody from the bad frat.
- 44:08[SPEAKER_02]: So therefore, I'm not going to even engage with the idea itself.
- 44:11[SPEAKER_02]: You're not even critiquing the idea.
- 44:13[SPEAKER_02]: You're not even effectively disagreeing with the idea, right?
- 44:17[SPEAKER_02]: So let's take a look at that at that data.
- 44:20[SPEAKER_02]: I think this is kind of fascinating.
- 44:21[SPEAKER_02]: So we'll bring this up in post and put these issues up on the screen.
- 44:25[SPEAKER_02]: But we're going to be making it some polling data from, I believe it was 2016.
- 44:31[SPEAKER_02]: This is Pew Research Group and they looked at, they did a survey of, I want to say,
- 44:41[SPEAKER_02]: self-identified likely Democrat and Republican voters.
- 44:46[SPEAKER_02]: And the polling data was all about their perception of each other.
- 44:56[SPEAKER_02]: the degree of polarization that is being revealed by people's political positions over time.
- 45:06[SPEAKER_02]: OK, all right.
- 45:07[SPEAKER_02]: OK.
- 45:08[SPEAKER_02]: So looking at the first graphic here, beyond dislike viewing the other parties to threat to the nation's well-being, we have three graphics here from 1919, your intervals, 1994, 2004,
- 45:19[SPEAKER_02]: 2014, this is already kind of out of date, obviously, we're 10 years down the road and I would guess that if we looked at the 2024 data, these trends would be continuing maybe even exponentially.
- 45:33[SPEAKER_02]: I don't really know.
- 45:34[SPEAKER_02]: But we've already seen that more than a quarter of Republicans and Democrats are now basically viewing each other as existential threats.
- 45:45[SPEAKER_02]: right where it was a much smaller percentage in in 1994 right then we all know that this is no surprise to anybody right of course of course.
- 45:59[SPEAKER_02]: You know, they start to kind of like unpack why.
- 46:02[SPEAKER_02]: And they sort of look at some other data.
- 46:05[SPEAKER_02]: Here's another one.
- 46:06[SPEAKER_02]: Republicans are shifting to the right.
- 46:08[SPEAKER_02]: Democrats are shifting to the left.
- 46:10[SPEAKER_02]: And here's where we start to really see this mythology and action in my mind.
- 46:16[SPEAKER_02]: So there's one point, which is just that we can see that according to this poll, a larger and larger percentage
- 46:26[SPEAKER_02]: Democrats are becoming, quote, more democratic, right, more liberal, and Republicans are becoming more conservative.
- 46:37[SPEAKER_02]: And I think it's just worth pointing out here that conservative and liberal are already just being sort of defined, axiomatically, right, just without proof.
- 46:48[SPEAKER_02]: Right,
- 46:51[SPEAKER_02]: I think with the parties right being more democratic is being more liberal being more conservative is being more being more Republican is being more conservative right right and the same thing here Democrats are more ideologically divided in the past so that Democrats are more consistently liberal now and rub Republicans are more consistently conservative right
- 47:18[SPEAKER_02]: The assumption here that is being given without discussion is that there is such a thing as a measurable conservative belief system that you can pin down and say, here it is, this is what conservatives believe, here is what liberals believe, this is a stable, philosophical, political entity that we can measure and we're just observing reality, exactly.
- 47:48[SPEAKER_02]: The devil is going to detail what does this mean to say that people are consistently conservative, right?
- 47:56[SPEAKER_02]: What is being consistently conservative?
- 47:58[SPEAKER_02]: Well, you can see on this issue that they say this is according to a distribution of Democrats and Republicans on a 10 items scale of political values.
- 48:08[SPEAKER_02]: Okay, so that's the way of measuring it, right?
- 48:10[SPEAKER_02]: They come up with 10 ideas that are bifurcated that are split.
- 48:17[SPEAKER_02]: into a conservative view in a liberal view.
- 48:20[SPEAKER_02]: And you have to go to the appendix and dig a little bit to find this scale and what they actually look at, which I do.
- 48:28[SPEAKER_02]: And here it is, okay.
- 48:33[SPEAKER_02]: This is where it really gets interesting to me.
- 48:36[SPEAKER_02]: Like, let's take a look at the first one, right?
- 48:39[SPEAKER_02]: The conservative position is government is always wasteful and inefficient, right?
- 48:46[SPEAKER_02]: Mm-hmm.
- 48:47[SPEAKER_02]: And the liberal position, government often does a better job than people give it credit for.
- 48:54[SPEAKER_02]: And make it almost see a lot of people nodding their heads.
- 48:58[SPEAKER_02]: Like, well, that seems right.
- 49:00[SPEAKER_02]: My claim is that this is really no different than any other set of preconceptions and stereotypes about any groups of people.
- 49:11[SPEAKER_02]: Men like machines, women like people, lios are brave, Pisces are fickle.
- 49:21[SPEAKER_02]: I don't even know, I don't really follow astrology very much, but you get the idea.
- 49:25[SPEAKER_02]: These are...
- 49:26[SPEAKER_02]: These are sort of unsubstantiated claims that could be true or false, depending on whether you want them to be true or false.
- 49:34[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.
- 49:35[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.
- 49:35[SPEAKER_02]: Serve the position.
- 49:36[SPEAKER_02]: Government is always wasteful and inefficient.
- 49:40[SPEAKER_02]: Well, right now I would say a lot of conservatives probably think that ICE is not wasteful and is very efficient.
- 49:53[SPEAKER_02]: right so they're in favor of the set of that section of the government right and you know maybe some others but there's obviously portions of the government that the current republican party is in favor of and therefore thinks is good right and the same with the liberal position right so um government does a better job than people credit give it credit for well they're not going to
- 50:23[SPEAKER_02]: There's portions of the government that liberals are going to think are terrible, so called liberals, right, the identity of liberal.
- 50:34[SPEAKER_02]: So this really just boils down to which part of the government you happen to be in favor of it a given point in time.
- 50:41[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.
- 50:42[SPEAKER_02]: As a generic statement, it doesn't make any sense.
- 50:45[SPEAKER_02]: Same with regulation of the next one, regulation of business, right?
- 50:49[SPEAKER_02]: The conservative position is the government regulation of business usually does more harm than good, the liberal position, government regulation of business is necessary to protect the public interest, right?
- 51:02[SPEAKER_02]: Well, it really depends on what's being regulated.
- 51:07[SPEAKER_02]: Right, you could say that right now, we are regulating immigration to a much higher degree.
- 51:13[SPEAKER_02]: And so it's the same thing, right?
- 51:18[SPEAKER_02]: It's like, what, what business sector are you talking about that needs to be regulated?
- 51:23[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, exactly.
- 51:26[SPEAKER_01]: And I think a lot of conservative-minded people, again, feel like we're a better phrase, think that we should have clean drinking water.
- 51:35[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you know what?
- 51:36[SPEAKER_01]: That takes regulation.
- 51:37[SPEAKER_01]: So, I mean, it's all about how to equalify this.
- 51:40[SPEAKER_01]: It's just, I mean, these are just ridiculous generalizations on their face.
- 51:46[SPEAKER_01]: You know, you're looking at this, you're like, oh, this is how they're coming up with these,
- 51:51[SPEAKER_01]: this statistical analysis.
- 51:53[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, we're moving farther away from each other.
- 51:56[SPEAKER_01]: Conservatives are becoming more conservative and liberal up more liberal.
- 52:00[SPEAKER_01]: It's like, well, how are you defining that?
- 52:03[SPEAKER_01]: And how did you get to that conclusion?
- 52:05[SPEAKER_01]: Well, now we're seeing and the more we're looking at it, the more ridiculous it is.
- 52:10[SPEAKER_01]: So anyway.
- 52:12[SPEAKER_02]: Absolutely.
- 52:12[SPEAKER_02]: Or this one is one of my favorites.
- 52:16[SPEAKER_02]: The best way to ensure peace is through a military strength.
- 52:19[SPEAKER_02]: That's the conservative position.
- 52:20[SPEAKER_02]: Good diplomacy is the best way to ensure peace.
- 52:23[SPEAKER_02]: That's a liberal position.
- 52:25[SPEAKER_02]: Well, not as regards NATO and Ukraine right now.
- 52:29[SPEAKER_02]: Right, right now it would be more of a liberal position that we need to be interventionists that we need to arm you crane that we need to aid them in their work and pressure and of course we are not weighing in on these issues we are talking about how we talk about these issues.
- 52:49[SPEAKER_02]: There's valid reasons for people to believe what they believe about these things.
- 52:54[SPEAKER_02]: We're not trying to say that anybody should or shouldn't believe these things.
- 52:58[SPEAKER_02]: We're saying that the attempt to categorize them as left or right doesn't make any sense.
- 53:05[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.
- 53:05[SPEAKER_02]: Especially on a historical scale.
- 53:07[SPEAKER_02]: Look at this last one.
- 53:08[SPEAKER_02]: Homosexuality should be discouraged by society as opposed to the liberal position.
- 53:13[SPEAKER_02]: Homosexuality should be accepted by society.
- 53:17[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 53:18[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 53:18[SPEAKER_02]: I'm a majority of Republicans voted for gay marriage, right?
- 53:25[SPEAKER_02]: And, or at least a large number of Republicans, I don't actually know that it's a majority, so I need to be cautious about that.
- 53:33[SPEAKER_02]: But there was relatively broad support amongst Republicans for gay marriage.
- 53:41[SPEAKER_02]: On the other hand, historically, if we look back,
- 53:44[SPEAKER_02]: Let's take probably the icon, historic icon of modern liberalism, FDR, FDR started his role as a prosecutor by prosecuting and jailing homosexuals for the crime of being gay.
- 54:04[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 54:05[SPEAKER_02]: Now, it's not that the Republicans were pro homosexuality at the time, but it's sort of silly to say that the liberal position is that homosexuality should be accepted by society in this moment, that's true, but in relatively recent history, it was not, right?
- 54:22[SPEAKER_02]: And a time period that's still remembered by a lot of living people, right?
- 54:26[SPEAKER_02]: That was not crazy.
- 54:28[SPEAKER_02]: yeah total and it may not be the case 20 30 years from now it's shifting all the time right so this reminds me more than anything else of like these kinds of categorization schemes of like what kind of beetle are you are you John or Paul or Ringo or George or you know are you a summer spring winter or fall personality like we loved
- 54:53[SPEAKER_02]: making up these categorization schemes that really don't have any basis in reality and trying to figure out where we fit in them.
- 55:02[SPEAKER_02]: And there's nothing wrong with that, but we have to realize that we're the ones making it all up.
- 55:08[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, totally, totally.
- 55:09[SPEAKER_01]: And sometimes, you know, in certain regards, it gives people comfort, I guess, but
- 55:15[SPEAKER_01]: You know, we're viewing it, I guess, from, you know, our point of view is that oftentimes it gets in the way of really understanding what's around us and also interacting with each other.
- 55:31[SPEAKER_01]: And that's so critical and you know, we keep so many people would probably agree and out of concern that our country is becoming increasingly polarized and you know, I would venture to guess that that has become exacerbated through social media is kind of ridiculous and very, very disturbing on many levels.
- 55:54[SPEAKER_01]: And so this is an attempt to allow us to perceive people from different walks of life and different factions and different tribes, more as people and listen to them and try to understand as opposed to try to win an argument.
- 56:16[SPEAKER_01]: And so much of our public discourse seems to be
- 56:19[SPEAKER_01]: about the warring factions and trying to win an argument.
- 56:22[SPEAKER_01]: You look on social media and you see headlines such as, so-and-so destroyed, so-and-so, in the Senate hearing, are they made so-and-so look foolish?
- 56:33[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not interested.
- 56:35[SPEAKER_01]: I'm so tired of that.
- 56:36[SPEAKER_01]: I want to, was there something that allowed us to understand the issue?
- 56:42[SPEAKER_02]: In a better way, idea to unpack there is there is there's there's some data is there's some some evidence is there is there's some deeper understanding of the world that we're achieving.
- 56:55[SPEAKER_02]: Obviously no, it's just it's just ideological battle with the assumption that if we battle the bad people and we.
- 57:04[SPEAKER_02]: marginalize them and get them out, everything will get better and then don't do that.
- 57:10[SPEAKER_02]: The bad people are going to take charge and everything will get worse.
- 57:13[SPEAKER_02]: And so this is another thing that I think sometimes we don't when we get into this mode.
- 57:20[SPEAKER_02]: We don't realize what we are no longer able to talk about.
- 57:24[SPEAKER_02]: I entering that mode.
- 57:26[SPEAKER_01]: Totally.
- 57:27[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 57:28[SPEAKER_01]: A lot of subjects are taboo.
- 57:30[SPEAKER_01]: You can't even bring it up.
- 57:33[SPEAKER_01]: You can't even bring something up with folks before they're labeling you as evil and a member of the opposing side.
- 57:42[SPEAKER_01]: And then they'll assume that you have views on a array of other issues that they know nothing about your perspective zone.
- 57:50[SPEAKER_01]: And it's just ridiculous, completely unproductive, and I would put forth very, very destructive on a lot of levels.
- 57:58[SPEAKER_01]: And I think you would probably agree the way in which we're interacting.
- 58:02[SPEAKER_01]: with each other is just silly.
- 58:04[SPEAKER_02]: Very much so.
- 58:05[SPEAKER_02]: And it's also, um,
- 58:10[SPEAKER_02]: You know, look, we all know that there is a group of people with a lot of power in this country.
- 58:18[SPEAKER_02]: Billionaires, corporations, large donors, large powerful institutions, media institutions, powerful foundations and nonprofits and so forth.
- 58:34[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, intelligence agencies, branches of government,
- 58:38[SPEAKER_02]: All of them are constantly trying to shape a narrative in their favor in order to increase the power and their resources because that's what they do, right?
- 58:49[SPEAKER_02]: So if you give them a tool by which you can make something undiscussable because to even discuss it,
- 59:01[SPEAKER_02]: identifies you as on the bad side, and therefore certain to be ideologically battled.
- 59:10[SPEAKER_02]: That's a very powerful tool to give those individuals with which to manipulate us.
- 59:19[SPEAKER_02]: from having discussions that they do not want us to have.
- 59:22[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly, great man.
- 59:24[SPEAKER_02]: Wait a second.
- 59:25[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.
- 59:26[SPEAKER_02]: You hit the nail right out of the head and go ahead.
- 59:30[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, I was just going to say, and just to dispel the image that might be coming to some people's minds,
- 59:35[SPEAKER_02]: None of that requires a group of people smoking cigars in the back room, you know, like plotting.
- 59:42[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 59:43[SPEAKER_02]: That happens.
- 59:45[SPEAKER_02]: I think sometimes.
- 59:46[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 59:46[SPEAKER_02]: But this is the normal behavior of systems that have certain incentive structures and the incentive structure is to build narratives.
- 59:57[SPEAKER_02]: that uh uh uh because we do live in a democracy which means that you can't just power people over the head when they say the wrong thing with a stick, right?
- 1:00:08[SPEAKER_02]: You have to figure out some way to prevent them from even thinking the wrong thing that you don't want them to think.
- 1:00:15[SPEAKER_02]: Totally.
- 1:00:15[SPEAKER_02]: That structure of good side, bad side, hey, have at it.
- 1:00:20[SPEAKER_02]: That's a very powerful tool for those who want to control those narratives.
- 1:00:24[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, and you mentioned incentive structures.
- 1:00:27[SPEAKER_01]: And that's what I wanted to just comment on quickly.
- 1:00:31[SPEAKER_01]: There's a lot of incentives for the powers that be to keep this paradigm alive and thriving because it does exactly what you are articulating.
- 1:00:42[SPEAKER_01]: It gets people to not have these conversations that they don't want people to have.
- 1:00:47[SPEAKER_01]: And also, there's a lot of incentive structure to gym up the controversy in the media landscape.
- 1:00:52[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, that's how my lot of money is made.
- 1:00:54[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, these captivating thumbnails or headlines on YouTube, for instance, and a lot of news is being consumed over social media and YouTube.
- 1:01:06[SPEAKER_01]: And that's what gets clicks and eyeballs and we're in an attention driven surveillance economy.
- 1:01:15[SPEAKER_01]: And so the incentive structures are antithetical to fostering substantive understanding of issues.
- 1:01:23[SPEAKER_01]: And that's why podcasts,
- 1:01:25[SPEAKER_01]: are one of the structures that actually works against that, that stream that's becoming like a river and becoming extremely powerful in our society because it allows for a more nuanced and thoughtful conversation.
- 1:01:44[SPEAKER_02]: Totally agree.
- 1:01:45[SPEAKER_02]: And I think
- 1:01:48[SPEAKER_02]: that sort of also brings up the there's a there's a kind of attention that happens like let's say you are you know the DNC or you are the RNC right so there's this automatic tension that happens that you have kind of two constituents that you have to be dealing with and both are important but one is kind of more important than the other so there's the funders the people
- 1:02:16[SPEAKER_02]: And that's the critical part because you can't keep the lights on.
- 1:02:20[SPEAKER_02]: You can't keep the doors open.
- 1:02:21[SPEAKER_02]: You can't pay the staff.
- 1:02:23[SPEAKER_02]: You can't personally get paid.
- 1:02:25[SPEAKER_02]: You got kids and going to college.
- 1:02:27[SPEAKER_02]: You got a mortgage to pay.
- 1:02:28[SPEAKER_02]: You got that money has to keep flowing.
- 1:02:32[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 1:02:33[SPEAKER_02]: So the donor class has to be appeased.
- 1:02:35[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 1:02:36[SPEAKER_02]: At the same time, you also have a base, a voter base.
- 1:02:40[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 1:02:41[SPEAKER_02]: And
- 1:02:42[SPEAKER_02]: They want populist ideas, right?
- 1:02:46[SPEAKER_02]: What does our voter base, in general, what do people want collectively, most people who identify, you know, left, right, whatever, most people are in favor of, for example, having some kind of single-payer health system in this country, right?
- 1:03:05[SPEAKER_02]: Most people are in favor of raising the minimum wage, right?
- 1:03:09[SPEAKER_02]: There's lots of things like this,
- 1:03:10[SPEAKER_02]: that people want but the donor class has really different goals and it's not necessarily an interest to the donor class.
- 1:03:20[SPEAKER_02]: So then you get this thing where the party is having to promise things that may be completely antithetical to what the donor class actually wants, right?
- 1:03:29[SPEAKER_02]: That's right.
- 1:03:29[SPEAKER_02]: How do you resolve that problem, right?
- 1:03:32[SPEAKER_02]: How do you please both of those?
- 1:03:34[SPEAKER_02]: If you can convince the populace base,
- 1:03:40[SPEAKER_02]: But that other side is going to destroy everything you care about, right?
- 1:03:48[SPEAKER_02]: That other side is pure evil.
- 1:03:50[SPEAKER_02]: And your only job is to support us to get them out, right?
- 1:03:56[SPEAKER_02]: The capitalist communists are going to destroy everything, right?
- 1:04:00[SPEAKER_02]: These racist fascists are going to destroy everything.
- 1:04:05[SPEAKER_02]: which is not to say that there are Godless Communists and racist fascists, you know, in reality, on right sides in some cases, right?
- 1:04:13[SPEAKER_02]: But the point is, when you can make your main political rationale preventing the other side that's super bad and evil from taking over, you no longer have to justify what you are actually going to do for your voter base.
- 1:04:31[SPEAKER_02]: You just have to protect those guys from getting in.
- 1:04:33[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 1:04:34[SPEAKER_01]: I mean like what you just said and I saw some research I wish I had access to right now with regard to the policy positions Americans had across the board on a variety of really important issues such as healthcare and single payer specifically I believe was on there and a majority of Americans upwards of 60 maybe even 70% thought that that was a good idea.
- 1:05:00[SPEAKER_01]: But yet, with all of these important issues, the American people that were pulled, and hopefully they were done with polls were taken with some decent accuracy.
- 1:05:15[SPEAKER_01]: I know that's not easy to do sometimes, but some of these polling companies actually do understand how to take a variety of opinions into account.
- 1:05:31[SPEAKER_01]: uh, you know, oftentimes these, these policy positions that most Americans want in our four, the United States Congress didn't enact, but yeah, but the policy positions, policy positions of the donor class were enacted.
- 1:05:53[SPEAKER_01]: So what I'm saying is we really don't have
- 1:05:57[SPEAKER_01]: That's strong of a representative government as we think Congress doesn't vote in line with what the people want They vote in line with what the donors want and what the donors want and what the donors do is they generally control Congress and they shifts
- 1:06:16[SPEAKER_01]: their opinions on issues according to what they want, not according to what the people want.
- 1:06:23[SPEAKER_01]: So the idea of representative democracy tends to go by the waste side.
- 1:06:30[SPEAKER_01]: When I saw that, I mean, it didn't surprise him because I'd heard about more a majority of people wanting certain things like you were saying single pair, healthcare and how
- 1:06:44[SPEAKER_01]: You know, be a really great way to go about administering real health care for people because, you know,
- 1:06:52[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think I'm alone in this is that our healthcare system is rather upside down and absurd in so many ways that's like a whole other podcast actually, but anyway, we'll do a few episodes on the evolution of our healthcare system historically.
- 1:07:16[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, for sure.
- 1:07:17[SPEAKER_01]: And it's just so great to look at this and then you realize, oh, that's why these policy initiatives are being put forth the way they are because when you peel back the onion as we were mentioning before, you start to realize not just the incentive structures, but also the power structures in this country.
- 1:07:38[SPEAKER_02]: 100% and one of the ways that really gets revealed exactly what you're talking about is when there's some issue that the dominant party supposedly wants that they supposedly ran a like whatever party is is in power it like uh uh
- 1:07:58[SPEAKER_02]: I'm trying to think, I probably shouldn't even pick a specific example because it doesn't really matter what that issue is.
- 1:08:05[SPEAKER_02]: But let's say one of the parties has control of Congress, right?
- 1:08:11[SPEAKER_02]: And so in theory they should be able to get through whatever they're sort of most favored populist.
- 1:08:18[SPEAKER_02]: policy plank is, and yet inexplicably what happens, time and time again, is that there's like three or four defectors from that party who inexplicably vote against their own party.
- 1:08:35[SPEAKER_02]: And then everybody gets very, very mad at them, how dare they, you know, abandon the, they ruined what, you know, we could have had this thing, except for these three traders who betrayed the party by not voting that way, right?
- 1:08:50[SPEAKER_02]: And you kind of think like, oh, okay, well, those three traders that are going to get primary and like they're not going to get kicked out of the party.
- 1:09:05[SPEAKER_02]: the defectors, the so-called traitors, are people who are not going to be in danger of being voted out.
- 1:09:15[SPEAKER_02]: They're either running on a post or they have their district locked up in whatever way, and the party not only
- 1:09:27[SPEAKER_02]: doesn't financially try and primary them or give money to someone else that would negatively affect them.
- 1:09:38[SPEAKER_02]: It seems that those people almost get rewarded and a lot of people are like, you know, scratching their head, what's going on here?
- 1:09:46[SPEAKER_02]: Why is the party behaving this way?
- 1:09:49[SPEAKER_02]: It makes perfect sense if you think of it from this standpoint of
- 1:09:54[SPEAKER_02]: the party has a problem, and the problem is that the populist legislation that they ran on cannot actually be delivered without offending the donor class.
- 1:10:07[SPEAKER_02]: If they are in power, they need to have some way of preventing that legislation from coming through.
- 1:10:15[SPEAKER_02]: If they really wanted
- 1:10:22[SPEAKER_02]: It's one of many things that made so much more sense once I kind of understood.
- 1:10:25[SPEAKER_02]: Like, okay, this is not really like a war between two sides, you know.
- 1:10:33[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you know, like you were saying, if we could just get rid of those people or what have you, when you start looking at it from a broader perspective, you just understand what's actually going on to a large, much larger degree and, you know, yeah, you should be following the money.
- 1:10:49[SPEAKER_01]: That's always part of the conversation.
- 1:10:51[SPEAKER_01]: It's not always.
- 1:10:53[SPEAKER_01]: uh, always the thing to just focus on there's a variety of other variables, but if you ignore that, you will, there's no way you can really understand what's happening.
- 1:11:04[SPEAKER_01]: It's like trying to study political science or international relations without, um, you know, studying economics on the world stage.
- 1:11:14[SPEAKER_01]: There's no way you can understand about it, because they're deeply intertwined.
- 1:11:18[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, I mean, in a lot of ways, I would say follow the power and power and money are very, very deeply connected, occasionally they might not be exactly in line, but
- 1:11:31[SPEAKER_02]: general money is going to give you more power.
- 1:11:35[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, so it's, and I think power in the end is what is desired, right?
- 1:11:41[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, and you know, you just, I also saw some statistics about the likelihood that a political candidate in most races across the country will win.
- 1:11:52[SPEAKER_01]: Well, it's usually the person with more money, and that's just so sad.
- 1:11:59[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I didn't have something like 98% of racism, one by the person that's going to turn up, but it wouldn't surprise me and it's very sad because, you know, it comes out to media and influence and, you know, one of the things that we're going to talk about on this show, which is the power of PR or propaganda for, you know, if you want to turn it in another way and it's super powerful messaging is incredibly powerful.
- 1:12:27[SPEAKER_02]: It really is.
- 1:12:28[SPEAKER_02]: Starting with the name public relations.
- 1:12:30[SPEAKER_02]: Public relations is itself a public relations term.
- 1:12:35[SPEAKER_02]: Because we're gonna look, we're gonna look back on this.
- 1:12:39[SPEAKER_02]: But in the sort of birth of the modern PR public relations movement,
- 1:12:45[SPEAKER_02]: That was a time period at which that behavior, that endeavor was still called propaganda.
- 1:12:52[SPEAKER_02]: But it had such a negative connotation after World War I and the Committee for Public Information, which we'll also talk about in quite a bit on the show.
- 1:13:03[SPEAKER_02]: The first act.
- 1:13:05[SPEAKER_02]: was to come up with a new name that didn't have the negative connotation, which was public relations.
- 1:13:11[SPEAKER_02]: Right?
- 1:13:12[SPEAKER_02]: Uh-huh.
- 1:13:12[SPEAKER_01]: I like that.
- 1:13:13[SPEAKER_01]: That sounds so innocuous.
- 1:13:15[SPEAKER_01]: And we're just relating to the public.
- 1:13:19[SPEAKER_02]: I think this might be a good time to talk about some of the things that people are going to hear on future episodes, what we're going to be talking about.
- 1:13:31[SPEAKER_02]: The first episode that we're going to hear at the second episode, the first episode after this one episode too, is going to be the interview that you've referred to quite a bit already, which is the interview with Dr. Furalin Lewis, he and his brother wrote the book, The Myth of Left and Right, which is,
- 1:13:56[SPEAKER_02]: very strongly recommended reading for anybody who is interested in flushing out this context, they do an amazing job of laying out the history of what was called the Left and the Right in the United States, a remarkably recent history.
- 1:14:14[SPEAKER_02]: A lot of people sort of assume
- 1:14:17[SPEAKER_02]: that there was a revolution and then some founding fathers and the next thing you knew there was the left and right and they just are battling each other and here we are.
- 1:14:26[SPEAKER_02]: But it's really quite a modern invention that only came into sort of widely used
- 1:14:42[SPEAKER_02]: prior to that, really, the terms were used but very infrequently and without most of the connotations that they currently have.
- 1:14:53[SPEAKER_02]: We have not historically been a country framed within the
- 1:15:06[SPEAKER_02]: very much a product, again, of the public relations industry, the technologies of radio and television and mass print media, without which I don't think the left and right could actually exist without these technological changes and how we communicate with each other and how we form narratives, how we tell stories to each other with people.
- 1:15:31[SPEAKER_02]: And they do an amazing job of breaking down why that spectrum is really mythological if you start to tease it apart.
- 1:15:40[SPEAKER_02]: To the point that we don't really probably, we shouldn't even really go into it that much in this episode.
- 1:15:45[SPEAKER_02]: We've already given a lot of the flavor of it.
- 1:15:48[SPEAKER_02]: But our next episode is really going to be making the case via that interview with them in their book.
- 1:15:56[SPEAKER_02]: for why we are starting with the assumption that the left-right spectrum is, in fact, mythological.
- 1:16:04[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and it was incredible.
- 1:16:07[SPEAKER_01]: And the moment that, well, the thing that actually allowed me to
- 1:16:17[SPEAKER_01]: learn about this book was you were telling me about their an interview with the brothers Hiroman Verlin Lewis on conversations with Coleman and I remember I remember listening to that interview And just blown away on so many levels so grateful that you shared that with me
- 1:16:42[SPEAKER_01]: and it really just struck so many cords for me and it propelled us forward in the inspiration to make the show for sure.
- 1:16:53[SPEAKER_02]: Absolutely.
- 1:16:54[SPEAKER_02]: I don't think that we could be making this show, at least not with the framework that is clearly delineated as I hope it will be without without their work.
- 1:17:07[SPEAKER_02]: We really owe a great
- 1:17:09[SPEAKER_02]: Deal a great debt to them and for sure can't can't recommend their book enough To anyone is relatively short and relatively easy.
- 1:17:20[SPEAKER_02]: They are academics.
- 1:17:21[SPEAKER_02]: They're they're both professors of Political science and history and as academic books go very readable
- 1:17:31[SPEAKER_02]: a very common language, but very rich, very dense, very well-sourced, very well-foot-noticed.
- 1:17:37[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, yes, yes.
- 1:17:39[SPEAKER_01]: That's a really good research and scholarship done.
- 1:17:43[SPEAKER_01]: And that's what's really beautiful about it.
- 1:17:45[SPEAKER_01]: And they kind of, you know, you can tell when they were talking about it, how,
- 1:17:50[SPEAKER_01]: It was very revelatory for them, you know, they, they're, they're going through the same type of process we are and they wrote this book that really was really instrumental in us having the idea for the show.
- 1:18:04[SPEAKER_02]: Absolutely, and we'll put the link to they have a web page and to their book we'll put that link in the show notes and a little more information about them.
- 1:18:19[SPEAKER_02]: But so that's going to be the first episode is really just kind of setting that case so that hopefully then we can move on with like hey we've really kind of established.
- 1:18:30[SPEAKER_02]: Uh, we've made the case for the fact that the left right spectrum is mythological now what right so now now episode three right and this is where I guess I would say that we are going to embark on a historical journey right we're going to go back in time.
- 1:18:50[SPEAKER_02]: and with this reframing or unframing, I suppose is a better word than reframing with this unframing of our political history.
- 1:19:02[SPEAKER_02]: We're going to re-examine the evolution of our political
- 1:19:10[SPEAKER_02]: free to that framework.
- 1:19:11[SPEAKER_02]: And the first destination in the time machine, which is obviously somewhat arbitrary because history does not have the starting point, but we have to start somewhere.
- 1:19:25[SPEAKER_02]: And right right in our kind of deep dives down a bunch of different rabbit holes.
- 1:19:31[SPEAKER_02]: The consensus was, we want to go back to a post-bellum, post-Civil War, industrial revolution, the 1860s, 70s, 80s, that time period, where America really is undergoing a profound technological
- 1:19:54[SPEAKER_02]: and cultural revolution in industrial revolution.
- 1:19:59[SPEAKER_02]: Obviously, that started many years earlier but we had the development of trains, steel, coal, the bathing system,
- 1:20:10[SPEAKER_02]: and one of my, and oil, right?
- 1:20:17[SPEAKER_02]: So, the partnership of all of those and the way that they kind of reworked how we interact with each other.
- 1:20:26[SPEAKER_02]: We went from an agrarian society to an industrial society.
- 1:20:31[SPEAKER_02]: People relocated in mass to urban areas.
- 1:20:34[SPEAKER_02]: It was mass immigration.
- 1:20:37[SPEAKER_02]: in the south, mass migration of the freed slaves, north, yeah, gradually over time, of course, stir-fran.
- 1:20:50[SPEAKER_02]: This is where we really start to see some powerful changes in
- 1:20:56[SPEAKER_02]: the narratives that Americans are told about themselves and their own political system and what constitutes good citizenship.
- 1:21:09[SPEAKER_02]: And there is one particular document that I found to be extremely telling as a kind of
- 1:21:18[SPEAKER_02]: an origin story of this new reimagined America, and that is a text called The Gospel of Wealth by Andrew Carnegie, and none of our names.
- 1:21:36[SPEAKER_02]: very, very appropriate because it really is a gospel.
- 1:21:43[SPEAKER_02]: It is a religiously inspired text.
- 1:21:48[SPEAKER_02]: that gives the moral justification for modern, capitalistic greed as an inherent moral good.
- 1:22:01[SPEAKER_02]: Yep, and a justification for the growing inequality that you see during this time period, right?
- 1:22:09[SPEAKER_02]: The guilty age, of course, the time when a small number of individuals were getting fabulously wealthy,
- 1:22:16[SPEAKER_02]: and a huge number of other individuals were living in absolute squalor, right, in horrendous working conditions, child labor, no unions, indentured servitude, the Jim Crow, all of these kind
- 1:22:42[SPEAKER_02]: And the gospel of wealth is really fascinating, especially because if you go search the gospel of wealth, you will find dozens and dozens of law-to-tory champions expressing how this text is still wonderful representation of how we should behave economically to this day.
- 1:23:10[SPEAKER_02]: But if you unpack it, it's sort of a recipe for a very small group of very, very wealthy men and white men, of course.
- 1:23:23[SPEAKER_02]: Usually, usually, you know, doesn't necessarily have to be, but certainly was historically.
- 1:23:38[SPEAKER_02]: The Rockefeller Foundation and non-profits and this sort of confluence of all those institutions coming together to reshape the structure of society.
- 1:23:56[SPEAKER_02]: And I think it's a great, a great point to start on our journey.
- 1:24:01[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, oh for sure, and the, you know, the next topic that we're going to talk about
- 1:24:08[SPEAKER_01]: Um, which is the committee for public information, it allowed them to justify this to the public.
- 1:24:15[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it's just like, hey, let's, let's roll out the advertising.
- 1:24:21[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, so in line with what we're doing.
- 1:24:24[SPEAKER_02]: talking about the committee for public information, and looking at this, I'm still wondering if we want to do an episode.
- 1:24:32[SPEAKER_02]: This is an ongoing, this is a living document, folks.
- 1:24:36[SPEAKER_02]: So, you don't hold this 100% to this.
- 1:24:39[SPEAKER_02]: There is kind of a gap of a
- 1:24:42[SPEAKER_02]: filler in there that I think needs to be addressed, which is the birth of the modern corporation, as a verbal person with the legal protections of an actual citizen, particularly the 14th Amendment.
- 1:24:58[SPEAKER_02]: that happened in 1886 with the Supreme Court decision that gave corporations those rights.
- 1:25:07[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, and it's very important for people to recognize the date that you've just, the year 1886, right?
- 1:25:15[SPEAKER_01]: We're not talking about citizens united.
- 1:25:18[SPEAKER_01]: No, okay.
- 1:25:19[SPEAKER_01]: No, just pat on on it anyway way way before that.
- 1:25:23[SPEAKER_01]: And most people don't have any idea.
- 1:25:25[SPEAKER_01]: The power of that decision many, many years ago.
- 1:25:30[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, looking at this from a historical perspective is absolutely critical just understanding what the hell is going on today.
- 1:25:40[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and that decision, I think, one of the things that was fascinating about it was, you know, the 14th amendment, which established due process for all citizens, was really written in order to give rights to freed slaves.
- 1:26:05[SPEAKER_02]: That was really a supposed rationale.
- 1:26:08[SPEAKER_02]: After that decision, within a few years, the vast majority, something like out of 240 cases, something like 230 years, something like that, the vast majority of appeals based on the 14th Amendment were by corporations.
- 1:26:25[SPEAKER_02]: not my free place.
- 1:26:29[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 1:26:30[SPEAKER_02]: So they were the ones who quickly take advantage of that.
- 1:26:34[SPEAKER_02]: And really from that point on, corporations have been more and more legally codified as legal people, right?
- 1:26:42[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 1:26:42[SPEAKER_02]: Virtual people that have the same rights as actual people, but not the accountability and liability.
- 1:26:55[SPEAKER_01]: you have the rights of a person, but you don't have the accountability because when the corporations do something really egregious or nefarious, oftentimes nobody's going to jail, where you think, oh my god, that's criminal activity, crimes against the environment and contaminating drinking water, whatever the case may be, or, or
- 1:27:24[SPEAKER_01]: this pushing I see cotton on a lot of different communities across the country and paying doctors to do so.
- 1:27:31[SPEAKER_01]: I don't see any of them in jail.
- 1:27:34[SPEAKER_01]: What's up with that?
- 1:27:35[SPEAKER_01]: They're just legalized drug pushers but yet somehow they're shielded from this liability through the corporate structure so we're going to address that.
- 1:27:44[SPEAKER_02]: And it's really necessary because the individuals that we're talking about, the so-called rubber bearings or captains of industry depending on who you're asking, they're still this sort of debate, where they great, where they terrible, one thing that's certainly not endowed is that they were incredibly unpopular.
- 1:28:05[SPEAKER_02]: to the point of armed revolt, to the point where they are having to hire their own private armies to compel the violence their workforce to continue working for them.
- 1:28:18[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, deeply deeply unpopular.
- 1:28:20[SPEAKER_02]: And this was really one of the key elements of the gospel of wealth.
- 1:28:26[SPEAKER_02]: It's these individuals saying essentially Carnegie was saying hey, we actually have to do, we have to perform philanthropy.
- 1:28:35[SPEAKER_02]: We have to use our money to make society better because otherwise people are going to hate us, which certainly they did.
- 1:28:45[SPEAKER_02]: And yeah, that kind of brings us up to the committee for public information, because at this point, we have these charitable foundations, these philanthropic foundations like the Rockefeller foundation, the Carnegie Mellon foundation,
- 1:29:10[SPEAKER_02]: essentially created their own foundation, and those foundations then had sweeping powerful effects on the shape of society and the shape of politics, and you see some of that, and the narratives that we, the stories that we tell ourselves about how our political system works, and maybe nothing is more exemplary of that than the committee for public information.
- 1:29:40[SPEAKER_02]: So, and just what that was for those who are not familiar, Woodrow Wilson was elected, I want to say that was 1913.
- 1:29:51[SPEAKER_02]: My nephew double-checked me on that, but he was elected on running on a policy of keeping us out of World War I.
- 1:30:01[SPEAKER_02]: World War I was deeply, deeply unpopular.
- 1:30:05[SPEAKER_02]: And once he was elected,
- 1:30:09[SPEAKER_02]: There's debate about whether he changed his mind or about whether he never actually meant the promises that he made in the first place, but we do know that almost as soon as he was elected, he shifted his position.
- 1:30:23[SPEAKER_02]: He decided that the war was inevitable that we had to get involved.
- 1:30:29[SPEAKER_02]: That we could not afford to be isolationist.
- 1:30:32[SPEAKER_02]: You know, we had to join the world stage.
- 1:30:35[SPEAKER_02]: And there was then this problem of how do we convince the vast majority of Americans who do not want to be in this war, that in fact we should be in this war.
- 1:30:46[SPEAKER_02]: And they created the first public private governmentally run massive propaganda movement in American history.
- 1:30:58[SPEAKER_02]: directed from the federal government top down involving tens of thousands of people, including thousands and thousands of average citizens who were hired or convinced as volunteers to be influencers, who were given scripts written by the committee to deliver as if they were organic expressions of those individuals,
- 1:31:25[SPEAKER_02]: They were simply the so-called four-minute men because they would give these four-minute speeches in intermissions during movies all around the country, passionately advocating for involvement in the war, and it was incredibly successful and within one year the public had completely shifted its opinion and that was in favor of battling the evil hunts as they were called.
- 1:31:55[SPEAKER_02]: totally.
- 1:31:56[SPEAKER_02]: So it it sort of set the precedent that it was possible through a coordinated effort in cooperation between the government, the media, very prominent journalists were involved, like George Creel, propagandists, PR people like Edward Bernays and lots of politicians,
- 1:32:25[SPEAKER_02]: all coming together to say, like, hey, we need the American people to believe this.
- 1:32:33[SPEAKER_02]: And so we are going to manufacture that consent to you in terms of Edward Bernays.
- 1:32:41[SPEAKER_01]: And also the book, I was in a book entitled with the same phrase by Nome Chomsky, Manufacturer.
- 1:32:48[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, he said.
- 1:32:50[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 1:32:50[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 1:32:52[SPEAKER_01]: Who does it?
- 1:32:52[SPEAKER_01]: That's really what that's what's that?
- 1:32:55[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, just a chance to be, of course, gives a great analysis of all of that.
- 1:33:02[SPEAKER_01]: And that's essentially what we're talking about.
- 1:33:04[SPEAKER_01]: We're talking about the manufacturing of consent.
- 1:33:08[SPEAKER_01]: But it's called public information or public, sorry, public really sins.
- 1:33:14[SPEAKER_01]: And to put a nice spin on it.
- 1:33:18[SPEAKER_01]: And I love the idea are the terms spin.
- 1:33:23[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, we're gonna put our spin on this topic.
- 1:33:26[SPEAKER_01]: Oftentimes, your spin is just a euphemism for it.
- 1:33:30[SPEAKER_01]: No, we're going to lie about it.
- 1:33:32[SPEAKER_01]: But we're going to put it in a way that seems palatable and believable.
- 1:33:36[SPEAKER_01]: It's like unbelievable.
- 1:33:39[SPEAKER_01]: This system that we live in.
- 1:33:40[SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, the Committee for Public Information is absolutely critical.
- 1:33:44[SPEAKER_01]: And figures like Edward Bernays, who is the nephew of Sigmund Freud, who was
- 1:33:50[SPEAKER_01]: Intimately familiar in how to manipulate the subconscious mind and so you know a lot of this does happen in the subconscious Which a lot of people don't realize and a lot of our visceral reactions us included and we've Learned how to tamp those down over time just by having these conversations and making these distinctions.
- 1:34:14[SPEAKER_01]: I mean I can
- 1:34:15[SPEAKER_01]: I probably speak for both of us that were a lot less triggered, which is very wonderful.
- 1:34:20[SPEAKER_01]: And I can listen and discern with a lot more peace around controversial issues now.
- 1:34:29[SPEAKER_01]: And it's very, the manipulation of the subconscious mind happens in a very insidious way.
- 1:34:39[SPEAKER_01]: People don't realize this is happening.
- 1:34:44[SPEAKER_01]: that does this, and they're experts at it.
- 1:34:48[SPEAKER_01]: They're extremely effective in while trained, and Edward Benese was one of the people who really set this emotion that we'll talk about, even the precursor to him.
- 1:35:01[SPEAKER_01]: This guy named Ivy Lee, and his nickname was Lead Belly, which is weird.
- 1:35:06[SPEAKER_01]: Ivy, Lead Belly Lee.
- 1:35:08[SPEAKER_01]: like LeBally, the lose artists I believe is, but they're two different people, but yeah, these people are very, very influential in this, in this whole industry taking shape in this country, and you know, fast forward to today, it has a profound effect on our society right now.
- 1:35:33[SPEAKER_02]: For sure.
- 1:35:34[SPEAKER_02]: And Edward Bernace is going to get he deserves his own episode.
- 1:35:39[SPEAKER_02]: I would say so he would be next in line Edward Bernace was involved in the committee for public information not at a super high level he was a very young man.
- 1:35:50[SPEAKER_02]: But he was successful in his, as you mentioned, Edward Bernace was Freud's nephew.
- 1:35:59[SPEAKER_02]: He grew up as a child in Vienna.
- 1:36:02[SPEAKER_02]: He was his double nephew, which is kind of a crazy thing.
- 1:36:06[SPEAKER_02]: Freud's, how does that work?
- 1:36:09[SPEAKER_02]: Freud's sister was married to his wife's brother.
- 1:36:15[SPEAKER_02]: Okay, so so he was a double nephew if that makes sense He was a nephew of both sides of the family and now he grew up listening to these discussion Every all of these people were heavily involved in the psycho and a community of Vienna
- 1:36:33[SPEAKER_02]: in the late 1800s during the same time period that corporations are beginning to form and propaganda is beginning to be sort of a science.
- 1:36:50[SPEAKER_02]: Edward Bernays essentially used the theory of the unconscious, Freud's theories of the unconscious that people were driven not by rational understanding of information, but by deep, raw, powerful emotions, and that therefore the way to affect their opinions, the way to affect their behavior, was not by convincing them with good information, but by appealing to emotional hot buttons.
- 1:37:20[SPEAKER_02]: And, uh, totaler, which of course we understand now that that advertising is entirely based on manipulating our emotions, you know, if you drive this car, you're going to be successful and have high status and date the person you're going to date, you're going to be amazing.
- 1:37:39[SPEAKER_02]: And, you know, these, these tropes of belonging and attraction and status and all these things that we care a lot about.
- 1:37:47[SPEAKER_02]: And that he was the one who, if the introduction of the show, you've career Edward Bernays as the first quote, he says that after he came back from his foreign posting, he was actually overseas trying to influence the publications in other countries in order to
- 1:38:09[SPEAKER_02]: increased popularity about our involvement in World War I.
- 1:38:14[SPEAKER_02]: His famous quote was, I found that ideas were more powerful than bullets.
- 1:38:21[SPEAKER_02]: And if propaganda could be used for war, it could be also used for peace.
- 1:38:28[SPEAKER_02]: And of course what he means by peace is we can manipulate
- 1:38:35[SPEAKER_02]: at the behest of wealthy clients.
- 1:38:38[SPEAKER_02]: That's what he actually means.
- 1:38:40[SPEAKER_02]: So Edward Bernage has some fascinating clients and jobs that he performs for people.
- 1:38:48[SPEAKER_02]: One of the most fascinating to me is his work in getting more women to smoke.
- 1:38:57[SPEAKER_02]: This is in the early 20s, very few women were smoking tobacco, it was almost exclusively men, and the American tobacco company hired Edward Bernese to try and get more women to smoke.
- 1:39:12[SPEAKER_02]: And he was very successful at it.
- 1:39:14[SPEAKER_02]: He was very liberal man by today's definition of that, he was very heavily involved in the suffragette movement.
- 1:39:24[SPEAKER_02]: and advocated for the women to get the vote.
- 1:39:29[SPEAKER_02]: And he designed an event in which a number of suffragettes who are parading in New York for some action and favor of the women getting the vote, with light of cigarettes all at the same time.
- 1:39:47[SPEAKER_02]: And he hired photographers to capture this and get images and all the newspapers in the country and he called them the cigarettes torches of freedom.
- 1:39:59[SPEAKER_02]: So that's a really good idea, right?
- 1:40:02[SPEAKER_02]: Brilliant.
- 1:40:03[SPEAKER_02]: The guys brilliant.
- 1:40:04[SPEAKER_02]: And so he instantly transformed the cigarette into an image of female power of a women being able to do everything a man could do.
- 1:40:17[SPEAKER_02]: And within the year of that campaign, the number of women smoking increased by something
- 1:40:28[SPEAKER_02]: really traumatic.
- 1:40:29[SPEAKER_02]: And there's dozens of those examples.
- 1:40:32[SPEAKER_02]: It's either a good breakfast at where Bernace was responsible for that campaign.
- 1:40:38[SPEAKER_02]: Breakfast is the most important meal of the day which she performed on the heast of a meat packing company that made bacon and sausage.
- 1:40:51[SPEAKER_02]: there's a bunch and we'll go into all of that.
- 1:40:54[SPEAKER_02]: So that's that's our next episode.
- 1:40:56[SPEAKER_02]: The last episode that I think we're going to highlight here today is the individual that you refer to a little while ago.
- 1:41:04[SPEAKER_02]: Ivy led better Lee and the Rockefeller Foundation.
- 1:41:07[SPEAKER_02]: Ivy Lee.
- 1:41:08[SPEAKER_02]: Oh yeah.
- 1:41:10[SPEAKER_02]: Another
- 1:41:14[SPEAKER_02]: who famous partner with John D. Rockefeller, who again had this real problem with his reputation.
- 1:41:21[SPEAKER_02]: He was very deeply unpopular, widely hated, widely mocked and reviled in the press.
- 1:41:30[SPEAKER_02]: And he convinced him to form a charitable foundation, the Rockefeller Foundation, and publicized these good works.
- 1:41:39[SPEAKER_02]: And the Rockefeller Foundation, principally, began to shape our modern medical system.
- 1:41:49[SPEAKER_02]: via something called the Flexner Report, which can radically change our system of medical education, the better in some ways, I would argue, and for the worse and many others.
- 1:42:04[SPEAKER_02]: And we can really see some of the debates and issues we are having today with our health care system.
- 1:42:12[SPEAKER_02]: traceable directly to that action that movement by Ivy Lee and the Rockefeller Foundation in the early teens and 20s, the 20th century.
- 1:42:26[SPEAKER_02]: Yep, for sure.
- 1:42:27[SPEAKER_02]: So I think that gives people kind of an idea for what they're going to be listening to and we're going to kind of continue that historical march.
- 1:42:39[SPEAKER_02]: through the new deal, and FDR, and the post-World War II political environment, where we really see the left and the right start to develop.
- 1:42:54[SPEAKER_02]: It really takes off after World War II, right, and it becomes completely the dominant mode of our discussion about politics in the late
- 1:43:08[SPEAKER_02]: We're kind of we've kind of arrived and the rest of it almost seems like kind of window dressing what kind of technological changes we've made and the ways that we communicate the power of the internet, social media, that they're very influential obviously.
- 1:43:26[SPEAKER_02]: So I think that gives people a pretty good idea of the kinds of things that they're going to be hearing.
- 1:43:34[SPEAKER_02]: Absolutely.
- 1:43:36[SPEAKER_02]: So here we are.
- 1:43:37[SPEAKER_02]: This is the beginning of this journey and I want to make it clear that, you know, we don't know exactly what we're going to find as we continue the story.
- 1:43:48[SPEAKER_02]: We've done enough of a dive to know that these are pivotal moments that we want to look at.
- 1:43:54[SPEAKER_02]: We are going to be interviewing academics and other individuals who have studied these topics.
- 1:44:02[SPEAKER_02]: We're not just going to be ruminating in our own, but we're going to try and reach out to find the people who have really spent the time to provide an academic underpinning for some of these historical movements, we'll be talking to each other continuously as we continue
- 1:44:23[SPEAKER_02]: And I hope people join us and can put up with our long-winded music.
- 1:44:34[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, this is definitely a journey.
- 1:44:36[SPEAKER_01]: And we're pretty naked in our approach.
- 1:44:41[SPEAKER_01]: We're just, we're going through this right along alongside our audience in a, as transparent and honest way as possible, so that other people can experience this and take some comfort that perhaps they're not alone if they're starting to experience some of these things.
- 1:45:02[SPEAKER_01]: So we're very excited and move forward.
- 1:45:04[SPEAKER_02]: very much and i'm excited to make this a two way street to i know we're going to get things wrong right we're going to get things wrong first sure right so i'm really counting on informed listeners who can say like hey
- 1:45:19[SPEAKER_02]: You know, this part of it maybe you kind of missed and that's going to be part of our learning process because we have a lot to learn, right?
- 1:45:26[SPEAKER_02]: We have a lot to understand.
- 1:45:27[SPEAKER_02]: A lot to have a pack here and it's you're not going to arrive at an answer.
- 1:45:32[SPEAKER_02]: You're going to for every question that we answer, there's going to be 10 more.
- 1:45:37[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 1:45:39[SPEAKER_02]: So I'm really good.
- 1:45:42[SPEAKER_02]: It's incredible thinking back to when we were just having these conversations as I was driving across country.
- 1:45:49[SPEAKER_02]: You know, I think the first time that we talked it was something like a four-hour conversation, you know, it just like we were just like, oh my god, someone else who is having the same pathway.
- 1:46:03[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, very relevant story.
- 1:46:05[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, very relevant story.
- 1:46:07[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, I'm so grateful for being able to have these conversations with you.
- 1:46:12[SPEAKER_02]: And likewise, for, you know, for your, for your expertise and getting this podcast together and helping get introduced.
- 1:46:21[SPEAKER_02]: And I think it's going to be very fruitful.
- 1:46:25[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and the aim is to provide something that is beneficial to not just our listeners but society at large and to be a contribution.
- 1:46:38[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that's a really beautiful thing to do to be of service.
- 1:46:42[SPEAKER_01]: And this is our time to do that.
- 1:46:44[SPEAKER_01]: So we'll see how it unfolds.
- 1:46:46[SPEAKER_02]: I hope so.
- 1:46:47[SPEAKER_02]: I hope that we can help each other have a little more compassion for each other.
- 1:46:50[SPEAKER_02]: Tamped down the hatred of people we don't even know.
- 1:46:54[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.
- 1:46:56[SPEAKER_02]: In power of people to validate their own beliefs without needing to get messages from the outside.
- 1:47:05[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.
- 1:47:06[SPEAKER_02]: To free us a little bit from the.
- 1:47:09[SPEAKER_02]: the high-temperature emotionality of our discourse and get a little bit back into compassion for each other empathy for each other and rationalist ideas as opposed to feelings and heroes.
- 1:47:23[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean, you know, this came up in the the most recent election cycle when I was talking to a friend of mine and they were saying oh so and so is your guy.
- 1:47:36[SPEAKER_01]: I said nobody's my guy or gal or whatever.
- 1:47:41[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not married to a person.
- 1:47:43[SPEAKER_01]: I'm married to ideas and I'm married to.
- 1:47:46[SPEAKER_01]: What I feel is good for society versus bad, and if that person's in line with that, great, and you know, everybody, I mean human beings are frail, and everybody has their shortcomings, and we prop these politicians up like they can do it all wrong.
- 1:48:05[SPEAKER_01]: Of course they're going to do wrong at some point.
- 1:48:07[SPEAKER_01]: They're human beings, you know, anybody who's perfect.
- 1:48:09[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.
- 1:48:10[SPEAKER_01]: But the thing is, you know, there's the key is to not look at these politicians as these God like figures at all, but that aside, the key is to just look at issues.
- 1:48:23[SPEAKER_01]: And so this is an our attempt to foster that type of thinking as opposed to looking at people and putting all of our belief in them, you know, in, in, in, like, you know, in some sort
- 1:48:38[SPEAKER_01]: which is ridiculous and just unsustainable standard that doesn't serve us.
- 1:48:44[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, no heroes, no villains, no simple binaries of good and evil.
- 1:48:50[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.
- 1:48:51[SPEAKER_02]: We all know that those are silly distortions of reality.
- 1:48:56[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 1:48:56[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 1:48:57[SPEAKER_01]: An antithetical to us understanding what the hell is going on.
- 1:49:00[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 1:49:00[SPEAKER_02]: And please do join us for episode two with Berlin Lewis and the myth of left and right.
- 1:49:06[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you so much for joining us.
- 1:49:09[SPEAKER_01]: If you've been listening to this and feeling a little disoriented, well, that is to be expected.
- 1:49:14[SPEAKER_01]: Because what we're really doing here is taking off a set of lenses that most of us have been wearing our entire lives.
- 1:49:21[SPEAKER_01]: Lenses that tell us the world is divided into two sides, left and right, good and bad, us and them.
- 1:49:27[SPEAKER_01]: And what we're asking is a much more uncomfortable question.
- 1:49:30[SPEAKER_01]: What if that framework itself isn't real, or at least not real in the way we've been taught to believe?
- 1:49:37[SPEAKER_01]: The first episode is just the beginning of that process.
- 1:49:40[SPEAKER_01]: As you heard, we're not claiming to have all the answers.
- 1:49:43[SPEAKER_01]: We're working through this in real time, questioning, testing, and sometimes even struggling with what it means to step outside of that system.
- 1:49:51[SPEAKER_01]: But it's not easy.
- 1:49:52[SPEAKER_01]: There's a real cost to letting go of a framework that once gave you clarity, identity, and even belonging.
- 1:49:58[SPEAKER_01]: But there's also something on the other side of that, a deeper understanding, a little more humility, and maybe a little bit more compassion for people we've been taught to see as the quote-unquote other.
- 1:50:10[SPEAKER_01]: And if there's one idea to carry forward from this episode, it's this.
- 1:50:14[SPEAKER_01]: You don't have to outsource your thinking.
- 1:50:17[SPEAKER_01]: You don't have to accept the prepackage set of beliefs just to belong.
- 1:50:21[SPEAKER_01]: You can hold your values and still question the system that tries to organize them for you.
- 1:50:26[SPEAKER_01]: In our next episode, we take this conversation a step further.
- 1:50:30[SPEAKER_01]: We sit down with political scientists, Dr. Verlin Lewis, co-author of The Myth of Left and Right, a book that helped spark much of what we've been exploring here, and is the catalyst for the creation of this podcast.
- 1:50:42[SPEAKER_01]: And at the core of his argument is something deceptively simple.
- 1:50:45[SPEAKER_01]: There's more than one issue in politics, which raises a powerful question.
- 1:50:50[SPEAKER_01]: If that's true, why are we using a single spectrum to understand everything?
- 1:50:56[SPEAKER_01]: We dive into why the left-right spectrum doesn't actually hold up under scrutiny.
- 1:51:01[SPEAKER_01]: how political tribes shape what we believe often more than logical principle.
- 1:51:06[SPEAKER_01]: And why breaking free from that framework doesn't weaken your values, it actually clarifies them.
- 1:51:12[SPEAKER_01]: This is not about abandoning your beliefs, quite the contrary.
- 1:51:16[SPEAKER_01]: It's about understanding them more clearly without the distortion of a system that may be shaping more than we realize.
- 1:51:24[SPEAKER_01]: This is Ambiology, and if you're willing to question the story, we'll keep following it together.
- 1:51:30[SPEAKER_01]: And if this conversation resonated with you, if it made you pause, question something, or see things just a little differently, please take a moment to follow or subscribe to the show.
- 1:51:41[SPEAKER_01]: It really helps us grow and continue having these kind of conversations.
- 1:51:45[SPEAKER_01]: and if someone came to mind while you were listening someone who's been thinking about these same questions share this episode with them because ultimately this isn't just something to listen to it's something to talk about you can also find us on social media where we will be sharing clips ideas and continuing the conversation beyond the podcast.
- 1:52:07[SPEAKER_01]: So give us a follow, join in, and let us know what you're thinking.
- 1:52:11[SPEAKER_01]: We're building this in real time, and we'd love to have you be a part of it.
- 1:52:15[SPEAKER_01]: This show is produced by me, Steve Ordauer, and Blake Minnerly.
- 1:52:19[SPEAKER_01]: The editor, graphic artist, and social media manager is Carrie Tanner.
- 1:52:24[SPEAKER_01]: Thanks for listening, I'm Steve Ordauer.
- 1:52:27[SPEAKER_04]: This has been a rhythm and light production.