Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Should Buckeye Fans Be Concerned About Ohio State Injury Trends?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Kurdman
- 0:05here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Oh, Tony.
- 0:11We've gotten some very nice reviews recently on our podcast platforms, the various
- 0:17podcast platforms for the Buckeye Weekly Podcast, and today we get to pay one
- 0:23of those listeners back. I'd leave us left us a very nice five star
- 0:27review, thank you, Glimidal. Glimidal one of those and asked us a
- 0:33question in the five star review, and we thought, all right, we
- 0:37can we can work with this. We can we can answer this question.
- 0:40And it's kind of an interesting question and it's probably going to take up a
- 0:44whole show. But if you want to leave us a five star review and
- 0:48the nice rating, we will. You want to have a question you want
- 0:52us to answer, well, we might just we might just do that for
- 0:54you as well. And what was the question? The question was, I'm
- 1:00very concerned that a number of the number of injuries on this team has been
- 1:03excessive. Is that true relative to other teams? Do we need to take
- 1:06a very hard look at the quality of the Buckeyes training program. Does it
- 1:10need to be revamped? Is it dated? And not taking advantage of current
- 1:12knowledge. And what we've done is gone back and looked at some numbers.
- 1:19But it's without like a team of people. It's kind of impossible to look
- 1:23at other programs specifically, For one, you don't necessarily know the team's well
- 1:29enough to know who has even been missing and things like that. But what
- 1:32we have done has gone back and looked at previous years for the Buckeyes and
- 1:38seeing how things have gone, and based on the findings and the facts,
- 1:47like last year was I'd say the most injury riddled year for Ohio State since
- 1:55at least twenty fourteen, because I went back to the last time they installed
- 1:59new turf because I willed to see, hey, the last time they installed
- 2:01new turf was twenty fourteen. Were there a bunch of injuries there as the
- 2:06turf gets broken in and things like that? And there weren't. But we'll
- 2:09get to that in a bit. But so last year and what I did
- 2:14is I just roughly, not roughly, like, how many starters missed games
- 2:19and how many starter games were missed And last year they're around roughly thirty three
- 2:24games missed by starters. Fourteen different starters missed games which is quite a lot.
- 2:32You know. Obviously Jackson Smith and Jigbo was ten of those. But
- 2:38Trevion Henderson missed five May and Williams missed two, Julian Fleming missed two,
- 2:42and you had five guys missed a game. You had Denzel Burke and Josh
- 2:46Procter also missed a couple of games, and Can Brown was in there.
- 2:50So yeah, there were a bunch of missed games for starters. But Tom,
- 2:54it's not just the starters. You get throw Evan Pryor's entire season,
- 2:58Mitchell Melton's entire seas, and so you could probably maybe even double the thirty
- 3:04three games lost when you include some guys that would have played, and then
- 3:08maybe have that and increase it because of all the guy the guys that were
- 3:14playing injured like Mine, Williams and Trevion Henderson. So last year, I
- 3:16think, by every metric, was just the most injury riddled season based on
- 3:25the numbers that I found, but also based on my recollection. Yeah,
- 3:29I mean it was a year when it felt like they constantly had a ton
- 3:32of guys hurt, and I think part of that was probably that a lot
- 3:37of that was clustered in the cornerback room and in the running back room,
- 3:40where it wasn't oh, you lost one guy on the offensive line and one
- 3:44guy in the defensive line and one of the linebackers and one of the corners.
- 3:47It was you're playing your true freshman probably number four or five on the
- 3:53depth chart cornerback as a starter against Wisconsin a weekend because or a month in
- 3:59because everyone's hurt, and you ended up with five different guys or four different
- 4:02guys having meaningful numbers of carries as running backs, and another one who missed
- 4:10the whole season. So I think some of that was it felt like more
- 4:13just for that reason, but numerically it was more. Now, I think
- 4:17the much more that that, I think is the first interesting question you had
- 4:21to answer, was this really a you know, an abnormal number of injuries?
- 4:27And it feels like the answers yes. And then the far more interesting
- 4:30question, and really the makeup of this whole show is okay, why and
- 4:36some of those injuries you know, I mean, there was there was the
- 4:41the new turf theory. There is you know, hey, they focused too
- 4:45much on strength and not enough on flexibility theory. In terms of the conditioning
- 4:48program, there's all that kind of stuff, and you also kind of have
- 4:54to remember it. Yes, sometimes these are just kind of weird injuries like
- 4:57the Jackson spent the Jigba injury for example, gets hit from behind, ends
- 5:01up with a hamstring injury that costs him the whole season. And you know,
- 5:08was was that that they tried to bring him back too soon? Was
- 5:12that a function in how many games he missed? I mean, there's just
- 5:14there's a lot of different factors that goes into all this, and you know,
- 5:16we can we can do our best to dive into into a bunch of
- 5:20those as we kind of move forward here. Yeah, and even looking back
- 5:24at some of these, like some of the injuries occur on the road.
- 5:27But then you can argue, well, it's the build up from all of
- 5:29the practice on the new turf. And the reason the turf itself became an
- 5:33issue is Buen Ohio State installed their new turf last year. They went with
- 5:40what is called a slit film artificial turf, as opposed to what other programs
- 5:46and other teams like in the NFL that just have monofilament fiber monofilament tom mono
- 5:54meaning one filament meaning rail mono meaning one filament meaning filament, So yes,
- 6:02it was it is a one film. It's I went into look because I
- 6:06had read this whole thing, the whole idea from the NFLPA on why this
- 6:12you know, this was an issue and this new type of turf with causing
- 6:15more injuries. And one of the things that you sort of struggle with here
- 6:19is it's not like it looks like a civil war battlefield out there with just
- 6:25bodies lying all over the place on the field. The difference in terms of
- 6:29according to the NFLPA, in terms of the monofilament split film versus split film
- 6:35versus natural turf, is like two to three injuries per stadium per year.
- 6:41So that's in in the NFL that might be one for the home team and
- 6:46one for the road team over the course of the year. And that kind
- 6:48of feels like noise almost in the numbers. Where is that a statistically meaningful
- 6:55amount? There were only six NFL stadiums I believe last year that had the
- 7:00split film turf, so you're not talking about huge numbers. But if the
- 7:04numbers are higher, okay, how real is that and why is that an
- 7:08issue? And the answer on the why is kind of interesting. It's because
- 7:12of how those how that turf is actually made. The big difference is monofilms
- 7:16is basically there is it looks like grass. There is a piece of turf
- 7:21just sort of sticking up and it's a one piece of turf, and it
- 7:27just looks like a blade of grass, and there's just a whole bunch of
- 7:30them. Obviously, the split film turf is each one of those is kind
- 7:35of basically like one of those, but the blade is split. It's kind
- 7:40of like cut, so it looks kind of like a little bit of a
- 7:45mesh or if you're sort of braiding something together almost where it's instead of just
- 7:50being one solid piece of little plastic fake grass, it's cut into a couple
- 7:55of different pieces. And the thing that they you know, if they are
- 7:59trying you sell you monofilament turf, but there's a slit film turf, they
- 8:03will tell you the slip film turf holds the field. The rubber, the
- 8:05little chopped up tires or whatever, the kind of rubber infill is holds that
- 8:09down better. The tips of the grass will split more with use than a
- 8:13monofilament was, which will lead to a softer surface long term. So that's
- 8:18the pro. Now here's the con. The NFL says that the because there's
- 8:24all those little tiny slits in there, it makes it more likely that you're
- 8:26going to catch something. You're gonna you know, your cleats catch in that
- 8:30material and that little slit in the grass, and it just creates a little
- 8:33more just a little bit more resistance and maybe your foot sticks a little bit
- 8:37more. And that's where you see the video of the guy's knee bending sideways.
- 8:41Now, if you have a two hundred and fifty three hundred pound person
- 8:45running at you and crashing into you at ten miles an hour, you know
- 8:48there is a whole bunch of force involved in that. That is not the
- 8:52cleat catching in the grass, but it is a little more resistance. It's
- 8:56a little and you know, is just the straw that breaks the camels back
- 9:01in some of these cases. That's that's kind of the question. And you
- 9:05you're not getting ant, you know, a definitive answer from everyone on this,
- 9:13No what there is not like a consensus here. The NFLPA feels pretty
- 9:16strongly that this is the issue or an issue anyway. But you've got teams
- 9:22who are saying like, yeah, it's not you know, is this really
- 9:24that big of an issue? Maybe? Maybe not. Do you know how
- 9:28much of that is they don't want to pay five million dollars or whatever it
- 9:31is to replace their field that they just put in a year or two ago.
- 9:35Maybe some of that. After the last NFL season, they replaced the
- 9:39turf, the slit film turf in Detroit for the Lions play, replaced with
- 9:43monofilm that they also replaced the one in East Brotherford, New Jersey, where
- 9:46the Giants and Jets play. So instead of six NFL state aids with this
- 9:50slit film turf, next year, there's going to be four. So you
- 9:54know, people are taking this seriously enough that they're doing something about it,
- 9:58but they're not taking it so seriously that they've passed a rule and banned the
- 10:01stuff. So this is it's kind of one of those things where, yeah,
- 10:05there could be something here, but I don't think it's so definitive that
- 10:11you can definitely point to it and say, yes, this is the issue
- 10:15period full stop. Well, and I remember when this was the hubbub back
- 10:18in the fall, reading different stories about the slip film and the numbers and
- 10:26the studies. What I remember reading is that there are more non contact injuries
- 10:33with the slit film, minor quote unquote minor injuries, more severe injuries on
- 10:39monofilament or other types of turf like an acl or things like that. And
- 10:45the slip film decreases your odds of a season ending injury, but maybe increases
- 10:52your odds of a season lasting injury. And both of those are bad,
- 10:56but again the numbers still are pretty low. What I think people may have
- 11:01forgotten is how much everybody hated the field in twenty twenty one and how everybody
- 11:07was excited for a new turf because everybody was slipping in twenty twenty one.
- 11:11Players were complaining. And then so the turf goes in prior to springball last
- 11:18year, right prior to spring ball or after springball? I can't I think
- 11:24it was after. I'm currently madly scrolling through my photo mayor June. Yeah,
- 11:31I think it was after. I believe it was after, and then
- 11:35because then, yeah, it was after, because we're talking to the players
- 11:37in fall camp Jackson Smith and Jigbo back in August said it looks good and
- 11:43it feels good, so we're ready to bounce. Around on it being out
- 11:46there. I'm just more confident in my cuts. For really, we were
- 11:50kind of slipping a little bit last year. So there's just more confidence in
- 11:52the surface. It's good to always have that. Of course, he missed
- 11:56ten games, Trevi and Henderson who missed five games and was injured, and
- 12:01others. He said of the turf, it's way better, way better.
- 12:03I'm glad they finally got that done. It was slippery. Sometimes I would
- 12:09roll my ankle out of nowhere, and he's talking about the old turf,
- 12:11and now that doesn't happen, and they've been practicing on a new turf and
- 12:15it feels great. It's softer. A lot of the turf last year is
- 12:16very hard. It's a safety thing, and we're able to cut better and
- 12:22stuff. And so anytime you're able to cut better, you're also able to
- 12:26get stuck better worse if you will. I still go back to being a
- 12:31bearrass fan. Wendell Davis was a receiver in the late eighties who went up
- 12:37for a catch and came down and is both of his cleats caught in the
- 12:41turf and he blew out both acls on one plan that was that was it
- 12:45for his career basically, And yeah, it's great to be able to cut,
- 12:50but it's also great for there to be some give and that's why,
- 12:54you know, grass fields are safer and the dirt will give, and the
- 13:01slip film is made to give less. Did I mean you're even talking about
- 13:05it's made to keep the uber pellets down better and the Reber pellets there are
- 13:09there for you to be able to grip better, and so it's designed to
- 13:13be stickier. But also with that stickiness, there's some danger, but not
- 13:18so much that it's it's dangerous. You know, yes, it's more dangerous,
- 13:24but it's not dangerous per se. And I think it's worth noting.
- 13:28It did go in after spring ball last year. That was last June.
- 13:31I was taking pictures of the stadium with the new turf going in so last
- 13:35year when Mitchell Melton blew out his knee on the turf and Ohio Stadium that
- 13:39was on the old monofilament, you know, sort of worn out slick turf
- 13:45that everyone was complaining didn't grip grip well enough and then he had a non
- 13:50contact knee injury on that. So I think there's this is one of those
- 13:56things where you look at the turf and it's like, well, well,
- 14:00how does this turf perform? And it's like, well, okay, the
- 14:01turf performs one way when it's brand new, and a year or two later
- 14:05it will perform a little bit differently because some of those those filaments will be
- 14:09split up. It will be it'll be a softer field that you know,
- 14:13maybe will will it be as sticky or allow you to plant as much?
- 14:18You know, a year or two from now. I guess we'll all find
- 14:20out together. But you know, if you're if your complaint on the old
- 14:26turf was it's slippery, then yes, this is absolutely going to be performing
- 14:28better than the old one. Did it Just it feels like we're talking,
- 14:33you know, when we're talking about that. The models, the NFL model
- 14:37said quote models suggest there are two to three more non contact lower extremity injuries
- 14:41per season per stadium on slit film surfaces than other types of synthetic turf field.
- 14:46Again, this is two to three more injuries over the course of a
- 14:50year, which it just it's a lot if you're one of those guys,
- 14:54boy, it's a lot. But it's also there are so few of these
- 14:58and I don't know that this has been studied at the college level. It
- 15:01doesn't. I'm not aware of any studies at the college level. So you're
- 15:03just doing six six stadiums two to three more. That could be statistical noise
- 15:11or there really could be something there. It's just you're dealing with such small
- 15:15sample sizes that it feels like there's something there. But I would not be
- 15:20so confident that I would definitely point to this and say this is absolutely the
- 15:24issue. But it could be now. Will it still be the issue a
- 15:28year or two from now if they keep playing on this field and the stuff
- 15:33breaks down a little bit more and then maybe it doesn't catch as much.
- 15:35Well, maybe we don't know. And yeah, I go back to when
- 15:39Ohio State was playing in the Fiesta Bowl against clums And a few years ago.
- 15:45That was on a grass field, and it's that field was terrible.
- 15:48People were sliding all over the place. They were taking up huge chunks of
- 15:52grass. Think about Ohio Stadium for the Michigan game in two thousand and six,
- 15:56when it's the game of the century one versus and the field isn't horrendous
- 16:02shape. They couldn't they couldn't get the grass to grow wet, right,
- 16:04And you know, now you're at the point where you're, you know,
- 16:07potentially going to be playing college football playoff games into December, and you're so
- 16:12can they Can they even make a grass field work in Ohio Stadium right now?
- 16:18Maybe? But you know, you're you're probably it feels like you've got
- 16:22you know, enough pros and cons to each of these different kinds of surfaces
- 16:26that I don't I don't know that I could definitively point to one and say
- 16:30this is absolutely what they should do moving forward. It's just it's just such
- 16:34a weird and difficult situation, and without actually being able to do a real
- 16:38real study on it, or or having someone else do a real real study
- 16:41on it, I don't know how confident I could be that there's a definitive
- 16:45answer here. And you know, I didn't do a real real study on
- 16:49it, but I read some stuff on the internet, and from my experience,
- 16:53they're basically the same. But what I was reading about this this champion,
- 16:59this greatest turf ever, and it was a monofilament, and basically it
- 17:04was judged so good because they ran a few, you know, like forty
- 17:07thousand tests and it never showed anywhere and tear, whereas like the slip film
- 17:12stuff is kind of designed to wear and tear in some sense. So it's
- 17:17it's interesting just the different theories on what is the best kind of turf and
- 17:21what works, you know, in terms of the blades of grass, and
- 17:25just to have an idea and like in your minds, I have what the
- 17:26slip film turf looks like. You can just take a regular plade of grass
- 17:30and kind a couple of slits in each one, and you know, just
- 17:33maneuver and bend it and you'll see, like you know, the holes pop
- 17:36out and it's it's there's some kind of lattice work type of thing going on
- 17:40there. Um. But it will be interesting to see what this year looks
- 17:45like because it was last year just a blip, and you look the year
- 17:52before. You know now that you're playing on different services and you're practicing on
- 17:57different services. If the numbers stay the same and they don't start to drop,
- 18:03then then you've got an issue. And Mickey Marati, we talked to
- 18:07him back at the end of May with the rest of the Ohio State Assistant
- 18:11coaches, and they said they look at injuries every year, they do their
- 18:15studies, they do their analysis, and I guess at this point you're just
- 18:21chalking up to it. It was just a not a fluke. But it's
- 18:25just one of those years. I think it's the best way to put it.
- 18:26It's just one of those years. But if you keep having one of
- 18:32those years, I mean, you can't let it become an a It's just
- 18:34one of those decades, because there's no such thing. Because in a moment,
- 18:37we're gonna talk about some of the past years where it was crazy the
- 18:45number of injuries that there weren't compared to the number of injuries that there are
- 18:48now. And I'll just even mentioned like twenty twenty one. So in twenty
- 18:55twenty two there were around thirty three games lost for starters. Twenty twenty one
- 19:00they're around twenty eight. So like that's two different fields, and the numbers
- 19:04aren't far off, but just the number of different injuries and then other non
- 19:11starters missing injuries last year, it makes it a larger number overall. But
- 19:17if the numbers stay in the high twenties, low thirties, like what's the
- 19:22next step, And I think it involves a heavy analysis into the strength and
- 19:27conditioning. Right, Yeah, Well if you if you start having historically anomalous
- 19:33numbers, historically as anomalously high numbers every year, then at some point it
- 19:38stops being a coincidence. And is that the turf Is that something you are
- 19:44doing or not doing in your strength and conditioning program. I mean, it's
- 19:47something. At some point it stops being you know, a coincidence. You
- 19:52don't If you flip a coin ten times and it comes up heads, six,
- 19:56seven, eight, nine times in a row, at some point,
- 20:00you know, at some point that becomes meaningful. If you flip a coin
- 20:03twice and it comes up heads twice, Okay, it came up heads twice.
- 20:07If you flip a coin five, six, seven times and it comes
- 20:10up heads and heads and heads and heads, okay, at some point there's
- 20:11something weird with this coin. If it with the foot, with the injuries.
- 20:17If you have one weird season, maybe it had one weird season.
- 20:21If you have another historically and anomalously high season here, okay, then there
- 20:25probably is something you got to look at. And I think you're you are
- 20:29looking at the turf again, and you got to look at also what kinds
- 20:33of injuries are you having because, for example, Mind Williams had an injury
- 20:37at Penn State where his hand got caught or his finger got caught in the
- 20:41first down chain. That's not because of the slip film turf. That's not
- 20:47because of strength and conditioning. Like, that's just one of those things where
- 20:51you start to look at stuff and you know, is it a conditioning thing
- 20:55or something to do with the strength and conditioning program or potentially with the turf.
- 20:59Is do you have a bunch of soft tissue issues? Is it constant
- 21:03growing injuries? Is it constant hamstring injuries? That kind of stuff where it
- 21:07might be, Hey, you need to put more focus on flexibility. Back
- 21:11at the Peach Bowl, Kirby Smart, the second time we got to go
- 21:15watch Georgia practice, they opened up the last fifteen minutes of practice and it
- 21:19was Georgia and the other football players doing yoga, and you know, at
- 21:25the time, I know my reaction was, you know, number one,
- 21:27this is completely hilarious because this is Kirby Smart just trolling because he doesn't like
- 21:32the media and he doesn't want to show us any kind of actual football.
- 21:34But it was also, Hey, that's really interesting. I wonder how much
- 21:38yoga stuff, flexibility stuff, Ohio State does because if you're having soft tissue,
- 21:45muscle poll kind of injuries constantly, then maybe you do need to look
- 21:49at that. That's something that you know as always. There's a negative Mets
- 21:55example here. The Mets about eight to ten years ago brought in Mike Barwiss,
- 22:03the former Michigan strength and conditioning guru, who was going to completely revolutionaries
- 22:07Michigan football and they were basically going to turn into the Incredible Hulk when Rich
- 22:11Rodd brought him in. How did that turn out? Well, we're out
- 22:14of time, we don't have time to talk about that. But the Mets
- 22:17brought in this guy and he ended up doing basically football style strength training for
- 22:22baseball players and that was okay, and guys did started hitting the baseball further.
- 22:26But also they had started having a bunch of like lat issues and you
- 22:32know, muscle strains and poles in areas where they didn't necessarily usually have them
- 22:37because you're you're maybe a little more stiff, you're not as flexible as you
- 22:41might have been, and so that ends up creating more issues down the line.
- 22:45So you look at the injuries that they had last year, some of
- 22:49them are you know, you had guys with hamstring issues last year, but
- 22:55it wasn't all the same kinds of issues. So how much do you want
- 22:59to walk up to you know, they're not doing enough flexibility stuff versus they're
- 23:03not doing enough speed stuff versus not doing enough strength stuff whatever. I mean
- 23:08that it's really like a case by case basis, And with as weird and
- 23:14secretive as Ohio State is about injuries, I don't know that I feel like
- 23:17I have enough information about the very specifics of all of the injuries to be
- 23:21able to say, yes, there's a definitive trend here or no, there's
- 23:26nothing to do it no, And then that's absolutely right. Every every instance
- 23:30is specific to itself and different. It's information we don't have. So you
- 23:33see these nine guys, you know they're they're injured, and it's like,
- 23:37well, clearly Strength and Conditioning needs to be doing something about this, or
- 23:41maybe they're doing something in correcting, and it's like, well, one injury
- 23:44might have been a back poll you know that we had nothing to do with
- 23:48anything else, and one might be chronic knee issue that he came to Ohio
- 23:52State with. And so like there are ways to I'm sure that you could
- 23:57explain away and the bulk of this as to why it doesn't pertain to this
- 24:04blame or that blame. Again, if it happens, you know, you'll
- 24:10definitely yet you look at the TURR, if you look at the methods that
- 24:12they're using. I also think Tom, some players are just injury prone.
- 24:17And and also when you lose a guy for a season that Jack's the number
- 24:22up because we've already said like thirty three games roughly last year missed. That's
- 24:29one guy missing a season, and that was Jackson Smith and Jigbo basically,
- 24:33and it doesn't it doesn't take much for one guy to miss a season and
- 24:40then really raise those numbers like Josh Proctor missed eleven games in twenty twenty one.
- 24:45COVID was twenty twenty. But you know Jonathan Cooper missing nine games in
- 24:49twenty nineteen, Nick Bosa eleven games in twenty eighteen, Brandon Bowen eight games
- 24:56in twenty seventeen, twenty sixteen, you lose both Tracy Sprinkling Dante Booker early
- 25:00on. So right there, that's you know, twenty games for those guys.
- 25:04Of course, in twenty sixteen, those were the only two starters that
- 25:07ended up missing games, which is incredible, and those guys get replaced.
- 25:11Tracy Sprinkle gets replaced by Draymont Jones, Dante Booker gets replaced by Jerome Baker.
- 25:17Like, not bad. But when you look at this and we go
- 25:22back to Joe, want to go back to twenty fourteen, which is the
- 25:25first year of the new turf. They lost about four games for starters that
- 25:30year and two of those three of those were JT. Barrett and the same
- 25:36five starting offensive lineman started all year long. Every defensive starter played all fifteen
- 25:42games. And so go back to that turf, man, I get that
- 25:48turf again, because we've talked in the year's past, like how amazing it
- 25:52would be, how amazing it was when every starter on the offensive line played
- 25:56every game, and it's happened a couple of times. Hasn't happened lately,
- 26:00but I don't think it has. But like, for a while there,
- 26:03it was customary that those guys played every game. In just twenty fourteen,
- 26:07a season that was known for a specific injury should be known for having almost
- 26:17no injuries outside of that one. Yeah, it was you know, four
- 26:21games lost for starters except for the fact that the starting quarterback missed the whole
- 26:23season with a shoulder injury. And then there you go, yeah, yeah,
- 26:27I mean, and it's like, how do you want to calculate this?
- 26:30This is and you know that was a shoulder injury, so that very
- 26:33clearly was not turf related. But you know that that's a you know,
- 26:37and then JT. Barrett breaks his ankle and is that because his foot stuck
- 26:41in the turf on the new turf at Ohio Stadium. You know, I
- 26:45don't know, It's just it's and I think the other the other piece of
- 26:48this that makes making a real definitive declaration that this has gotten much worse.
- 26:55The general trend has been based on the way it's calculated here, it has
- 27:00been it has gotten worse. Four games in twenty fourteen, three games in
- 27:03twenty fifteen, twenty one, and twenty sixteen than that was basically two guys,
- 27:07but it was the whole season more or less with two guys. Twenty
- 27:11seventeen, there were twenty two, twenty eighteen, there were twenty six.
- 27:14Twenty nineteen, there's twenty two. Twenty twenty was the weird COVID years we'll
- 27:18leave that out. Twenty twenty one is twenty eight games, twenty twenty two
- 27:21is thirty three games. Now, how much of that is there being a
- 27:25little more cautious with people? How many times have we seen Julian Fleming is
- 27:29a game time decision and well it rained at Indiana, so they're not going
- 27:33to play Julian Fleming in Indiana? Is that? You know? Are they
- 27:34being more cautious with head injuries? Is you know the change of the concussion
- 27:38protocol that's come over the last ten years or so. How much does that
- 27:42potentially play into this? There's this is this is I think something where it
- 27:49feels like there is something to the data here. I think the most interesting
- 27:53thing we've discussed so far of anything is, boy, there does seem to
- 27:57be a trend towards more more injuries. Generally the curve is kind of going
- 28:02up. However, we're talking about how are we defining this? You know,
- 28:07Braxton Miller doesn't count for twenty fourteen, but uh, you know,
- 28:11but because the Tracy Sprinkle and Dante Booker were in there in twenty sixteen,
- 28:17they do count. I mean, it's you run into all sorts of how
- 28:21are we defining terms kind of issues here, which makes drawing a real firm
- 28:26conclusion difficult to impossible, but it does. It feels like there's probably something
- 28:33to the increasing number of injuries, just the fact that that curve does seem
- 28:37to kind of be going up as you as you go, and it would
- 28:41be pretty shocking if it went back down to like at And that's completely I
- 28:45mean, I never once thought about Braxton Miller as I was putting that,
- 28:49because I don't I don't incorporate him with the twenty fourteen team. It's it's
- 28:55just, well, how did he get hurt? Was he was hurt at
- 28:59the end of didn't he get wasn't he hurt in the Orange Bowl the year
- 29:03before that? And then he was kind of recovering, So you know,
- 29:07he got hurt in the Orange Bowl. Okay, that was on a natural
- 29:11grass turf. I don't remember if that was like he got driven into the
- 29:15ground or did he get driven into the ground. Okay, so you know
- 29:18that's not that that's like one of those things that happened sometimes and so you
- 29:26can't really hold you know, that's that's not a conditioning issue, that's not
- 29:27a turf issue. That's a one of those things. But you know,
- 29:32and then you go back and unless you want to dive deep into exactly when
- 29:37and where these guys got hurt last year, you go through and you know,
- 29:42what was the play where this guy got hurt or was it you know,
- 29:47Jordan Hancock got hurt during fall camp. He was hurt you know before
- 29:51anything started. Now we did I don't know that we've ever gotten an answer
- 29:53on you know, what was he doing that he you know it was a
- 29:56hamstring thing, but what was he doing at the time that the hamstring Was
- 30:00he just kind of jogging running? Was he posting, turning? Was he
- 30:03covering someone in practice? I don't know that we've actually gotten the answer on
- 30:06that. So, you know, there's just there's so much you got to
- 30:08dive into here that if you're looking for something to make you think that there's
- 30:15not a clear systemic issue Ohio State Ryan Day, that they are incentivized if
- 30:22there is a systemic issue that is causing these problems, these injuries, they
- 30:26are incentivized to fix it. They there is not there's nothing that is in
- 30:30Ryan Day's interest to hide you know, hey, oh well, actually actually
- 30:37there is a very clear problem and it's this, but we don't want to
- 30:38you know, we don't don't don't tell anyone. We're going to keep this
- 30:42a secret. They're incentivized to solve the issue. So that to me,
- 30:47you know, I'm not the biggest defer to authority person in the history of
- 30:52the world. But this is just like, let's understand the motives here.
- 30:53The motive is their their best interest is to solve this issue. If there
- 30:59is a clear issue. I am sure they have done study on this.
- 31:03They do study on all this kind of stuff. They will never release the
- 31:07results of that study. That's just you know, that's how that goes.
- 31:10But if they found something that was a pretty clear through line to a lot
- 31:15of these injuries, well I think they would probably be doing something to address
- 31:18it. And I don't think we've heard anything definitive on them doing something to
- 31:22address anything. And I think, again, a good percentage of this number
- 31:30may just be players who are prone to injury, who have been injured repeatedly
- 31:33in a number of seasons, like a Cam Brown who has missed games throughout
- 31:37his career. They're just some guys that have that kind of luck bad luck
- 31:42you mentioned where some of these injuries happened, like in twenty eighteen, Austin
- 31:47mac missed the final six games of the season Bait because of an injury at
- 31:49Perdue. Nick Bosa injured at Jerry World, you know, So it's not
- 31:55just stuff that happens. And of course that was a much safer turfed Ohio
- 31:59stadium at the time. Anyway, we know that. But that's a little
- 32:01bit of a joke. But so this is where things are now. If
- 32:07things go wonky again, like Ryan Day is gonna have to answer some questions
- 32:12and he's going to be, as you said, looking for those answers.
- 32:15Because you go out and recruit all of this talent and you have everything the
- 32:20way you want it now, your defensive coordinators here for a second year,
- 32:23you're running the same defense. Everything is ready to go. You've got everything
- 32:29set and it just gets derailed because of injuries. You need to figure out
- 32:36why. And if it's the turf doesn't matter, like Ryan Debut, take
- 32:39it out of my checkbook for that six million dollars to replace it, I'm
- 32:43not doing this anymore. Or if it's strength and conditioning, you know,
- 32:46that's that's you're gonna have to deal with that, or if it's just injury
- 32:50prone players, we have to move on from them and you've got to fix
- 32:54it. And if it's just one thing after another every single year you're dealing
- 32:59with this, that's no way to live. And the injuries happen, it's
- 33:04football. I think that that should be the beginning and the end of the
- 33:07show. Injuries happen, it's football. But if there are things you can
- 33:10do to prevent the stuff that isn't necessarily happening to everybody else, then you
- 33:16need to figure that out. Yeah, and just you know, he continue
- 33:22to monitor this stuff. This is I always go back to Jim Pressel when
- 33:24he got to Ohio State doing a study of Ohio Stadium and the winds in
- 33:29Ohio Stadium at various times of day and various times of year, to just
- 33:34in terms of taking that into account when he's talking about punting and that kind
- 33:37of stuff. I assure you they have done rigorous study on this to try
- 33:42to identify some of the issues. And the fact that we haven't heard anything
- 33:45like real, definitive, like major changes coming to the program makes me think
- 33:50that they have not found anything that is a you know, very clear and
- 33:53decisive answer on this, but you keep an eye on it moving forward,
- 33:58and if there's another year they're losing a bunch of guys and and you potentially
- 34:02lose a game because you have a bunch of guys hurt and you know you're
- 34:07you're running out your you know, there's no Mining Williams, there's no Trey
- 34:09Via and Henderson for the Michigan game again this year. Well, you know,
- 34:14if you if you have another year like that and you potentially have it
- 34:17something that costs you a game where it's in you know, just injury costing
- 34:21you a game. That's something that they you know, no one don't have
- 34:24a state likes to lose. That is true of fans, that is true
- 34:28of players and coaches, that is true of administrators. That is true of
- 34:30everyone. So if there's something that is causing them to lose or causing them
- 34:34to not perform at the level that they want to perform at, they will
- 34:37find a way to find a way to address it. So just kind of
- 34:42watch this space, I guess, and we'll you know, well we'll see
- 34:45if this is a an injury free year. You won't hear the you won't
- 34:49hear slit film turf coming out of anyone's mouth at any point this fall,
- 34:53and the first time someone rolls an ankle or blows out a knee, you
- 34:55will undoubtedly hear about it again. And yeah, I mean it depends on
- 35:00how many how many times does that happen? You're gonna have you it's football,
- 35:05as you said, you're gonna have injuries. Just is it a you
- 35:07know, a real anomaly in terms of a number of injuries or is it
- 35:10just kind of Yeah, sometimes bad stuff happens, That's how football goes.
- 35:15I do wonder, and we'll wrap up, but I do wonder if we
- 35:19are far enough removed from COVID that you can't blame the two biggest number of
- 35:24injuries star games missed by starters twenty two. If we don't are no longer
- 35:31aren't going to blame that on COVID. COVID has impacted so much. You
- 35:36talk to the coaches and then strength coaches, like they still will tell you
- 35:39that the damage that it has had on the program. I wonder if they
- 35:45might point at the injuries the last two years as something And the way you
- 35:51look, you're just looking for answers. Is it grasping at straws maybe,
- 35:55but it will be interesting to see what the numbers look like this season,
- 35:59hopefully for everybody on the field, much lower than what the trend has been
- 36:02going. So that will do it for this episode. Wanna thank you all
- 36:07for joining us as I always find us at bucket huddle dot com. Become
- 36:10a member, find us there as well on the message board. Check out
- 36:15all the premium content, recruiting updates, things of that nature from the entire
- 36:21team here at Buckeye Huddle. Also find us at YouTube dot com slash bucket
- 36:24Huddle and Facebook dot com slash bucket Huddle. Thank you for joining us and
- 36:29we'll talk to you guys later.