Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Community Restoration: A Journey Through Mangroves with Dr. Claudia Teutli
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, Illuminated in the
- 0:07Human Side. In this podcast, we unveil the human
- 0:11side of laboratories and science. Scientists
- 0:14share personal experiences and will discuss their
- 0:16meanings from different perspectives and fields
- 0:19of research. Welcome to another exciting episode
- 0:25of Science Behind the Glass, Illuminated in the
- 0:27Human Side. Today, we have the privilege of speaking
- 0:30with an extraordinary woman. whose passion is
- 0:34transforming Mexico's coastal ecosystems. We
- 0:37are talking about Dr. Claudia Teutli Hernández,
- 0:39a biologist with a doctorate in environmental
- 0:42sciences and technology, recognized for her pioneer
- 0:46work in mangrove restoration. That's right. Dr.
- 0:50Teutli is not only a brilliant scientist, but
- 0:53also an advocate for community participation
- 0:55in ecological restoration. Her innovative approach
- 0:59revitalizes mangroves and empowers local communities.
- 1:03Claudia is a beacon of hope in the fight against
- 1:06climate change and the destruction of coastal
- 1:08ecosystems. Claudia, thank you very much for
- 1:11accepting this invitation. To begin with, could
- 1:14you explain what restoration means in the environmental
- 1:17context and ecosystem restoration? First, thank
- 1:21you for the invitation. And, well, delving into
- 1:24the topic of restoration, climate change, and
- 1:28anthropic development is very complicated. That's
- 1:31why today we talk about ecosystem restoration,
- 1:34like helping an ecosystem that has been destroyed
- 1:38or damaged to recover its ecosystem services.
- 1:41We no longer talk about returning the ecosystem
- 1:43to how it was before. It is not realistic, and
- 1:47this is not an achievable goal. So that's why
- 1:51we're already talking specifically about recovering.
- 1:55that ecosystem service that the community perceives.
- 2:00And that's important because many people think
- 2:02it's like returning the ecosystem to how it was
- 2:06before. Pristine, perfect, but that doesn't happen.
- 2:10Also, that thing about how it was before is subjective,
- 2:14right? Before, it could be 20 years ago, 100
- 2:17years ago, or up to 500 years ago. And your work
- 2:21focuses on mangrove restoration. Tell us a little
- 2:24bit about the ecosystem and why its restoration
- 2:28is important. What are mangroves? What are mangroves?
- 2:32Let's see. I always define mangrove ecosystems
- 2:35as those rare and essential trees. Important
- 2:39because there is an analogy that says that mangroves
- 2:42are like the skin, the skin of coastal countries
- 2:45that have this ecosystem. The skin is one of
- 2:48the most important organs at the physiological
- 2:50level. If we didn't have skin... we would have
- 2:53various health problems. And with mangroves,
- 2:56it is the same, although in percentage, it is
- 2:59a very small area compared to other tropical
- 3:02forests. Being in that ecotone zone between the
- 3:05sea and the land, they cushion, for example,
- 3:08extreme weather events. We are entering the rainy
- 3:11season, at least where we are. In the Yucatan
- 3:14Peninsula, we are having the ravages of LUDS.
- 3:20and strong winds. On the other hand, they provide
- 3:23economic sustenance for all coastal areas, either
- 3:27directly or indirectly. For example, Cancun's
- 3:30excellent tourist development and economic support
- 3:33are due to its geographical location in the Caribbean.
- 3:38Thanks to the mangrove, the dune, and the pastures,
- 3:42there is an economic benefit from all that scenic
- 3:45beauty. Some people live directly from this.
- 3:48from artisanal fishing to obtaining wood, and
- 3:51even these ecotourism issues that are now booming.
- 3:54Some people come from abroad, where they pay
- 3:57to spend a night in the mangrove because it is
- 3:59an experience to be like in the jungle, they
- 4:03say, and they pay well. Although there are other
- 4:05ecosystem services, such as mitigating climate
- 4:08change, which are already speaking of more tangible
- 4:11things, they have this economic relevance, either
- 4:14directly or indirectly. That is the importance
- 4:17of recovering mangroves. And how fast do mangroves
- 4:20grow? To be able to restore any ecosystem, not
- 4:24just mangrove ecosystems, you must have extensive
- 4:26knowledge of the ecology of the ecosystem you
- 4:29want to work on. Although today it is thought
- 4:32that everything is known about mangroves, that
- 4:35is not true. There's also a lack of basic ecology
- 4:39information, which now, due to the needs, the
- 4:42research parts are focusing on other issues.
- 4:45However... there is still a need for more research
- 4:47on issues from basic ecology, basic eco -physiology,
- 4:52and description of how this part of structure,
- 4:55productivity, and processes that occur that are
- 4:58key to being able to restore an ecosystem continues.
- 5:02And it responds quickly, yes, only if you have
- 5:06a good diagnosis, what we call forensic ecology,
- 5:10that is, doing it CSI style. Identify the cause
- 5:13of death of the mangrove. And if you identify
- 5:16which are those variables or components that
- 5:19are not working and why, the activity you do
- 5:21can have results in less than a year. Could you
- 5:25share with us what inspired you to dedicate yourself
- 5:28to ecosystem restoration, and in particular,
- 5:31in mangroves? It's interesting because I think,
- 5:34like everyone else, I don't know if it happened
- 5:36to you. I wanted to study marine biology, especially
- 5:40orcas, and I loved orcas. And I'm from Puebla,
- 5:43but, well, I always liked this marine part. At
- 5:46that time, there was no money to study abroad
- 5:48and study marine biology, which at that time
- 5:50was only in Baja California. Well, there were
- 5:54no resources, so I studied biology in the city
- 5:56of Puebla, and I did a stay at a research center
- 5:59at the Universidad Veracruzana, and there, with
- 6:02the professor -researcher with whom I did the
- 6:04stay, he spoke to me for the first time about
- 6:06restoration. In fact, he lent me a book, and
- 6:09I said, Oh, look, this is interesting, because
- 6:12many years ago, They had the intention of restoring
- 6:14the Laguna de Alvarado because it did have many
- 6:17problems with invasive species, fish shortages.
- 6:20There was destruction of the mangrove habitat
- 6:22that they had there. The dune, too. The truth
- 6:25is, Veracruz is one of the states that has lost
- 6:28the most dunes. And so, that's how I began to
- 6:31read a little more. It caught my attention. I
- 6:35did some studies in the lagoon. I helped to do
- 6:37some study or survey of some variables in Laguna
- 6:42de Alvarado. And then I looked for where to do
- 6:44my thesis. So I started to find out and so on.
- 6:48And I ended up at the Center for Research and
- 6:51Advanced Studies, where they gave me the opportunity
- 6:54to venture into this topic. Well, at that time,
- 6:58I'm talking about a long time ago, 25 or 30 years
- 7:03ago, when nobody took restoration into account.
- 7:07They told you that doesn't exist. And if you
- 7:10went to research centers, they would tell you
- 7:12no. That's optional. And so, well, I started
- 7:15there in mangroves because that's where the opportunity
- 7:18to do this restoration thing came in. I had not
- 7:21worked in mangroves. So when I started to learn
- 7:23a little more, because I wanted marine biology
- 7:26from the beginning, I came here to Sinvestav
- 7:29to do my bachelor's thesis. And I stayed for
- 7:33my master's degree. It was all circumstantial.
- 7:35Could you tell us what the main threats to mangroves
- 7:39are in Mexico and the world? Let's see that the
- 7:42impacts of all ecosystems worldwide are a function
- 7:46of the economic development of each country.
- 7:49For example, in Asia, there was a high exploitation
- 7:52of mangrove resources, one for wood and the other
- 7:56for tannins because they used them to tan leather
- 7:58and shrimp farms. In Mexico, for example, obviously,
- 8:02depending on the state, the change in land use,
- 8:05weather due to tourism development, urban development,
- 8:08poor road... construction or the opening of sheltered
- 8:12ports needs to be adequately regulated. So, well,
- 8:17yes, it is a function of the economic development
- 8:20of each country. For example, in Panama, the
- 8:23urban development that they have on top of them,
- 8:25the part of Ecuador and the effect of the shrimp
- 8:30farms are impressive. The trends that are coming
- 8:32are that coastal cities will have a population
- 8:35increase of more than 200 percent. which is a
- 8:39lot. The construction in the entire coastal zone
- 8:42is impressive, and it is a problem in America
- 8:44in general. Yes, here in Australia, there is
- 8:48also huge problems with mangroves. They have
- 8:51transformed quite a bit here. In the area where
- 8:55I live, there are a large number of mangroves,
- 8:57but that has been transformed because the city
- 8:59is located in that area. But also, they have
- 9:02restored quite a lot. Could you explain why restoration
- 9:06techniques are not simply reforestation? Let's
- 9:10see. Yes. Here, reforestation is one of the restoration
- 9:15activities, right? Because there are many restoration
- 9:18activities. However, reforestation is the most
- 9:22common activity worldwide. Why? Because mangroves
- 9:26have always been treated like pine forests. Obviously,
- 9:28plantations are used to recover forests in these
- 9:30forest areas. Here, the mangrove ecosystem doesn't
- 9:34work because mangroves are wetlands. They need
- 9:36water. So, yes, the main action is reforestation
- 9:39worldwide, and what they are also doing is like
- 9:43monospecific forests, because they always do
- 9:46it with a single species, the easiest one, which
- 9:49is the red mangrove. After all, they have their
- 9:52little seeds like pencils, so they collect them
- 9:55and plant them. Now, the success of these reforestations
- 9:59worldwide has a 5 % success rate. That is very
- 10:02little. Many times, all these reforestations
- 10:06or plantations worldwide were done by trial and
- 10:10error. Before, there was no talk of making a
- 10:13diagnosis identifying the cause of death because
- 10:15you have to understand that something that was
- 10:18missing is that when the mangrove dies, there
- 10:22are some changes. There is also a process of
- 10:25succession in the degraded areas. where all the
- 10:28physicochemical parameters change, both in the
- 10:31sediment and in the water, and also the levels
- 10:35of flooding. They change, or they remain flooded
- 10:38for a long time, or it does not flood. Usually
- 10:40those are the extremes. Furthermore, since they
- 10:43want to return to the ecosystem as it was, with
- 10:47the species that were there, if what they do
- 10:50is plant a single species, That is why it is
- 10:53necessary to identify the action correctly and
- 10:56also to be able to select the species. There
- 10:59is also a need for more knowledge in the eco
- 11:03-physiological part of mangrove species to be
- 11:06able to know which one is adequate after you
- 11:09recover the conditions of the site and allow
- 11:11the succession process. Your restoration work
- 11:14has involved local communities that live and
- 11:17benefit from the mangrove. How has that experience
- 11:20been? in the development of your restoration
- 11:23project? And how did you involve these communities?
- 11:27In order to do restoration and be considered
- 11:30a successful restoration project, it has to be
- 11:32socially acceptable and ecologically functional.
- 11:35That is, all the restoration activities that
- 11:38you do have this ability to resist events and
- 11:41begin to recover on their own, and it has to
- 11:44be economically viable. Therefore, you have to
- 11:48form a working group. And a fundamental base
- 11:50is the communities. First are the people who
- 11:53live there. Second, restoration also has to help
- 11:58communities by generating jobs, which is what
- 12:01is now being talked about as green jobs. You
- 12:04have to pay them a wage. Yes, it is not their
- 12:07primary source of income, but it does help them.
- 12:10We must remember that most of the communities
- 12:12that live in mangrove areas engage in some fishing
- 12:15activity, whether they are directly engaged in
- 12:18fishing, collecting shells, shrimp, etc. The
- 12:21restoration activity is also enjoyable. When
- 12:24they start working with mangroves in this context,
- 12:27they do not see it as an important ecosystem,
- 12:29as if that reality is not yet so tangible. As
- 12:33they work on restoration projects, their perception
- 12:36changes as they see that restoration works. In
- 12:39fact, they even change the terms. Because before
- 12:42you would say to them, where are you going? Oh
- 12:45well, I'm going to the mud. I'm going to get
- 12:48some dirt. And then, now you ask them, where
- 12:51are you going? Oh, I'm going to restore it because
- 12:54we have to recover. That is, the changes in perception
- 12:57are also quite interesting. So that's how we
- 13:00involve communities from the beginning, in the
- 13:03execution, in the monitoring of restoration actions.
- 13:07That also helps, and they are trained with workshops
- 13:10so that they have tools. They can defend their
- 13:13territory, appropriate those territories, and
- 13:16not be easily fooled if someone comes along with
- 13:19the construction of a 5 ,000 -room hotel. They
- 13:22have to throw mangroves. They already know that
- 13:25no, as the structure of the mangrove is recovering,
- 13:28there are communities that have seen that they
- 13:30flood less. For example, they can already take
- 13:34people to do ecotourism activities, and there
- 13:37will be birds, which is very common now. You
- 13:40are telling us how important all... This change
- 13:43is at all levels, cultural and economic, even
- 13:47for the local communities that live and benefit
- 13:50from the mangroves. And in long term, what can
- 13:52the impact be on these communities? But behind
- 13:56the money from the daily labor and the fact that
- 14:01they are already aware of the mangroves, how
- 14:02do you see this change in perception affecting
- 14:05these communities in the future? The change for
- 14:08long -term help is the conservation and recovery
- 14:10of these ecosystems in the face of the events
- 14:13they are experiencing because, for example, in
- 14:16this season that we went through droughts, these
- 14:18record temperatures that we are breaking, it
- 14:21is terrible. Yeah. Here we have flood in December.
- 14:25It completely flooded where we are. It was catastrophic
- 14:29and the temperatures were terrible. Also, members
- 14:32of these coastal communities saw it when we went
- 14:35to show with the students. Something that surprised
- 14:37me is that the surface water, usually the temperature
- 14:41is at 30, 35. This time it was at 45 degrees
- 14:45with salinities of 60. The little fish floating,
- 14:48some dead, so the repercussions are already being
- 14:51felt. When they see that it is recovering and
- 14:54this dampens, for example, the temperature, they
- 14:57realize that if we protect them, they will keep
- 15:00us. Also, not having a patch of vegetation requires
- 15:03that you have air conditioning or a fan. There
- 15:06is an economic cost for electricity, and you
- 15:09have to pay the bill. So the truth is that having
- 15:13trees dampens this incidence of temperature.
- 15:18Later, sometimes the community don't know it,
- 15:20but they have a lot of power and a lot of influence
- 15:24in decision -making at the political level. They
- 15:27can stop many things, more than one of what I
- 15:29can say or publish or in the newspaper. They
- 15:33are the ones who have this power in their hands.
- 15:35which sometimes they do not know, it is good
- 15:38to give them the tools to fight for it. And what
- 15:40do you think are the conditions that are needed
- 15:43for restoration processes to maintain their benefits
- 15:46in the long term? There has to be a group formed,
- 15:49as I said, with the community, with specialists,
- 15:52with government representatives, and with NGOs,
- 15:56but ethics must prevail. Ethics, because many
- 16:01groups have appeared worldwide, is not something
- 16:03local. to a country where some feel they are
- 16:07specialists and need to transmit the correct
- 16:09information to the communities. For example,
- 16:13we are in the decade of restoration. We are in
- 16:162024. And we are still determining how many hectares
- 16:20have actually been restored. But why? When we
- 16:23talk about the success of restoration and you
- 16:26go to the communities, if they were paid and
- 16:29if they were given money, they will tell you
- 16:31that they are successful. People... with deficient
- 16:35purchasing power so if someone comes along and
- 16:39gives them 20 000 pesos obviously they are going
- 16:43to tell anyone you know what it worked even if
- 16:46ecologically it didn't work so in order to move
- 16:49forward that ethical part is in all environments
- 16:54academic social and political because you have
- 16:57to be consistent with what you say and what you
- 16:59do After all, although there is a global interest
- 17:02in restoring and maintaining mangroves through
- 17:05conservation, there is also an inconsistency
- 17:08because on the one hand, you are protecting,
- 17:11but on the other, you are giving permits to build
- 17:14these large urban areas. The other thing, which
- 17:17is also within the academic part, is to be honest,
- 17:20generate knowledge and accept where we fail.
- 17:23Because if you talk to any researcher dedicated
- 17:25to this, they tell you everything has been very
- 17:28successful. And why didn't anything grow? Oh,
- 17:31who knows? So that's what I'm advocating. Why
- 17:34not say where we failed so that we don't make
- 17:36the same mistake? That's very difficult because
- 17:39even if you see that everything is dead in the
- 17:43area, you say it didn't work and they don't accept
- 17:46it. So I think that's why I'm coming now with
- 17:49ethics at all levels, because there are also
- 17:52communities where, although communities are essential,
- 17:55we shouldn't romanticize them. There are also
- 17:58people who have no interest in conservation.
- 18:00And, well, you also put yourself in their shoes,
- 18:04right? Also, land tenure in the mangrove is a
- 18:07problem. There is community property, and there
- 18:10is private property. So sometimes they are not
- 18:13making any money from that land. And if someone
- 18:15says, hey, I'll give you a million pesos for
- 18:19your land, and these are people who have no money,
- 18:22well, they think about it. And very older people
- 18:25we have touched, they say, Look, I'm going to
- 18:28die. Let them do what they want. But I'm going
- 18:31with my million. You can't judge them either.
- 18:34Recognizing where we have failed would make many
- 18:36of the restoration projects more successful,
- 18:39and not only in mangroves, but also in whatever
- 18:42ecosystem they are. Yes, that's very interesting,
- 18:45because behind all these actions that lack ethics,
- 18:49there are usually economic pressures. There is
- 18:51someone who needs to say one thing in order to
- 18:54sell a piece of land. or to be able to change
- 18:57the land use of some place. There is always an
- 19:00economic pressure behind it. So there would have
- 19:03to be a change of model to avoid the pressure
- 19:06that those factors play against restoration.
- 19:10Generate alternatives because also when you want
- 19:14to do things correctly, I mean the 2001 permits
- 19:16that also that I'm not against. There has to
- 19:19be legislation, but there also has to be a willingness.
- 19:23on the part of the government to be able to do
- 19:25the activities because it is easier to build
- 19:28a hotel or a golf course than to do a productive
- 19:30project. I don't know to what extent the government
- 19:32can buy land from people to protect that part.
- 19:36That's what they've been talking about. But here,
- 19:38the issue is getting to the price, right? Some
- 19:41people do it by buying land to allocate it for
- 19:44conservation, but it is a pretty solid political
- 19:48role. Finally, would you like to tell us any
- 19:51interesting anecdote that has marked you or that
- 19:54you remember, such as any particularity during
- 19:59your mangrove restoration work, either in the
- 20:01field or sharing with the communities? Let's
- 20:04see. Well, there's been everything here. From
- 20:08when you arrive and want to do the restoration
- 20:10and they don't believe you, to being left in
- 20:12the middle of the lagoon with the boat engine
- 20:14broken down, and there to see who... rescues
- 20:18me because I don't know how to drive a boat.
- 20:20Even to be chased by the crocodile, I have to
- 20:23admit that I am from the city, and they always
- 20:26tell you, the nests, the crocodile nests, be
- 20:28careful, I imagined them on the Discovery Channel,
- 20:31with frogs and all, and it has nothing to do
- 20:35with it. It's a mound of sand, and I just stopped
- 20:38there, and nothing more when they told me, Claudia,
- 20:41when I tell you to run, but I didn't know it
- 20:44was a nest. So, When a little boy tells me, Claudia,
- 20:49run, and I run out. Well, it's because the mother
- 20:52was already coming. It was the nest of a mother
- 20:55crocodile, and since I'm small, I thought she
- 20:58would take me in one bite. That's right. I passed.
- 21:02Everyone. At that time, they were Ana Gabriela
- 21:04Guevara, the athletics champion. I think I beat
- 21:07her, but yes, those are the anecdotes. Also,
- 21:10I have learned a lot from the communities. I
- 21:13really respect local knowledge. which teaches
- 21:16you to value and teaches you about ecology. In
- 21:19the academic part, you learn from both good and
- 21:22bad experiences. At least you recognize what
- 21:25you don't like or what you are not going to do
- 21:27and mark your line. Wonderful. Very brave with
- 21:30mosquitoes and all. Oh, well, that's the other
- 21:33one. The first time I got into the mangrove,
- 21:36I came out like these candies in Mexico, the
- 21:38garrapiñados, with first -degree burns and dehydration.
- 21:42And look! I stayed for more than 20 years. Thank
- 21:45you very much for your time and for sharing all
- 21:47this knowledge and all your experiences with
- 21:50us and with the public. No, on the contrary.
- 21:53Thank you very much. Linda and Dani. Great interview.
- 21:57Making a diagnosis and identifying what variables
- 21:59are affecting the ecosystem, in this case, the
- 22:02mangrove ecosystem, is essential to developing
- 22:04studies that allow us to understand the dynamics
- 22:08of these ecosystems. and where an intervention
- 22:11is necessary and when it is at risk. It's also
- 22:17necessary to have realistic objectives. Yes,
- 22:20doing that precisely, in restoration ecology,
- 22:22we learn that ecosystems are very complex systems,
- 22:25and there are some properties called emerging
- 22:27properties that come from the interactions of
- 22:30their complexities, actually. For example, I
- 22:32also work in mangrove ecosystems like Dr. Claudia,
- 22:35and we only focus on a tiny delimited part. which
- 22:38is the part of microorganisms that inhabit the
- 22:41mangrove sediments. Knowing these microorganisms
- 22:44help us to understand other processes that help
- 22:47restoration or are linked to restoration processes.
- 22:50Something else that is interesting is what Dr.
- 22:53Claudio mentioned, that restoration is not about
- 22:56returning the ecosystem to its initial state.
- 22:59I think that needs to be emphasized because for
- 23:02many people it is about returning it to its pristine
- 23:05state. And it really is about making the ecosystem
- 23:10ecologically viable and resilient. But it doesn't
- 23:14mean that it's going to return to its initial
- 23:17state. That's right. We were talking about it
- 23:20in the interview. We don't know exactly what
- 23:24we can refer to as initial state. Initial state
- 23:28may be 50 years ago, 100 years ago. So really
- 23:32what is sucked in these restoration works is...
- 23:35As our guest explained to us, to resume or recover
- 23:39ecosystem functions that are important for the
- 23:41environment and for the people who use the ecosystem.
- 23:44Something that is also indispensable is to involve
- 23:47the communities. They allow for better protection
- 23:50and recovery of ecosystems. Successful conservation
- 23:54and restoration projects involve the community
- 23:56and they cannot be left out. Explaining and telling
- 23:59them what is going to be done, that does not
- 24:02involve the community. Involving them means respecting
- 24:05their point of view and making them participants
- 24:08so that there is a chance of perception. They
- 24:11have knowledge that no one does not have, and
- 24:15with all their humility and willingness to listen
- 24:18to everything. I have an example of a project
- 24:21in which the Colombian government invested a
- 24:23lot of money in microorganisms that help to decompose
- 24:27organic matter. You may have heard of it, Dani.
- 24:30It's called End Microorganisms. And this came
- 24:33from Japan. So the project was to teach communities
- 24:36in different regions of the country how to manage
- 24:39organic waste. But what happened when I visited
- 24:43one of the most remote regions where it was implemented
- 24:46is that the containers that the government gave
- 24:49them to manage this organic waste was unused.
- 24:52And I saw that the packages of microorganisms
- 24:55were already expired. So when I asked them what
- 24:58had happened, they told me, well... They came,
- 25:01they gave us these things and they left them
- 25:04there. It is a shame because in reality the management
- 25:08and composing for people from farming families,
- 25:11well, it could have been beneficial. Yeah, and
- 25:14you can think that simply by arriving in a few
- 25:17days or during the development of a short -term
- 25:20project, you're going to be able to implement
- 25:23measures in communities that have to make a technical
- 25:27development or maybe implement things. that they
- 25:30have never learned in their lives. Contrary to
- 25:33your example, as we saw with Dr. Claudia, these
- 25:36collaborations with communities in these mangroves
- 25:39ecosystems have been going on for more than a
- 25:42decade. So communities are becoming more aware.
- 25:45They already know a little more about the technical
- 25:48issues, the concepts that are required when restoring
- 25:51an ecosystem as complex as the mangroves. Yes,
- 25:55I totally agree. Well... We learned a lot, and
- 25:58I hope everyone enjoyed this episode. The article,
- 26:01Community Benefits are Crucial for Landscape
- 26:04Restoration, inspired this episode. We have included
- 26:07the references in the episode description. Remember
- 26:10that this podcast is self -funded and self -edited
- 26:13by its presenters. You can support us by listening
- 26:16to this episode on YouTube, Spotify, and subscribing
- 26:20and giving a like, and visiting our website.
- 26:23Follow us on our social media like Facebook and
- 26:27Instagram. Original music by our colleague and
- 26:29friend Bernardo Aguila. And technical advice
- 26:32of our friend Rafael Giordano.