Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 280: How to Disagree Without Falling Out With Harvard’s Julia Minson
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the show. To be honest, even the smartest of us struggled with constructive
- 0:04conversations when opinions clash and I'm the stranger to this whether it's at home
- 0:09and the office or when it comes to talking to friends and family about politics, right?
- 0:14So I wanted to find out how we can disagree better without hurting the relationships because
- 0:18my relationships are the most important thing in my life and I'm sure your relationships
- 0:22are very important to you too. So I'm glad that today we are joined by Harvard's
- 0:26Julia Minson. She's going to help us uncover the secrets to navigating these tough conversations
- 0:33and building a culture of open dialogue in the business. And that means we can transform
- 0:37these nasty disagreements, nasty but necessary, maybe, into opportunities. Enjoy. Julia,
- 0:44I want to come to speak like a CEO. Thank you so much. It's great to be here. Likewise,
- 0:48so I wonder why do smart successful people still struggle to have productive disagreements?
- 0:54So I think most of the reason we struggle to have productive disagreements is because we're
- 1:02trying to win something, right? So people don't think hard about why are they in a conversation
- 1:08and what is the likelihood of accomplishing their goals? And if your goal by default is to win,
- 1:15you know, and that's both people's goal, then like you're not going to win because the other
- 1:19person is also trying to win. That's right. I mean, it feels like there's more disagreement in
- 1:22the world right now, but maybe that's just my subjective feeling. Is there do you have any data on this
- 1:28from a scientific perspective? So I think, you know, we certainly have lots of data on
- 1:35disagreement on political and social and sort of ideological issues having gotten worse.
- 1:41And I think in professional context, people have become much more expectant that they can
- 1:47bring their ideologies and identities into the workplace, right? There used to be sort of certain
- 1:51things you didn't talk about at work, but now there's this expectation of authenticity, right?
- 1:57And now that like we're all working from home, you can sort of see the background you have,
- 2:02you can see kind of your different cues of your beliefs and identities in your home office,
- 2:10for example. And so those political and social disagreements I think have come up into the workplace
- 2:16much more than they used to exist there. Is that a good thing or is that a bad thing? I just
- 2:21wanted to because I mean, disagreement on the face of it are not great, of course, but on the
- 2:25other hand, they could also help move things forward in the right direction that could help,
- 2:30for instance, us being more authentic. Whatever that means, we could talk about that. But just
- 2:34one, is it double as sort or is it good or bad? So I definitely think that disagreement is a good
- 2:41thing, right? I think that when like the whole reason we work with other people is because we want
- 2:46them to bring something new to the table. We want them to have different opinions, we want them to
- 2:50have different perspectives to like no different things than we do. So disagreement in and of
- 2:56itself is an asset. The problem is we're sort of all uniformly terrible and handling disagreement.
- 3:03And so often when you're bad and handling disagreement, disagreement becomes conflict,
- 3:08right? And so then you have sort of all these negative emotions and you have all this drama and
- 3:13that's where it becomes bad. What's the biggest mistake people in business make when it comes to
- 3:19navigating tough conversations? I think the biggest mistake is that you think you know what the
- 3:28other person has to say, right? So you aren't actually sort of inquiring and trying to understand
- 3:35because you know, and either you know that their reasons are stupid or you know that their
- 3:40reasons are selfish or sort of kind of self-interested. And so you don't try to really like
- 3:50consider why this person believes what they believe because you've already reached your own conclusion.
- 3:55And that of course is very unhelpful. Right, because that person does have some reasoning,
- 4:01right? They you know most people form opinions based on evidence, right? And that evidence might be
- 4:08you know sort of what we think of as scientific evidence or evidence from their lives,
- 4:12but they have some reason for believing it. And it's usually not like you know I'm just
- 4:18believing this because it's good for me. People consider their beliefs very seriously.
- 4:25Yeah. So what's a better way to go about disagreements? So I think of every conversation
- 4:32in sort of a very basic way which is there's a part where you're listening and there's a part
- 4:37where you're talking, right? It's just like that's the only two things that are happening.
- 4:42And I think it's useful to start with the listening part because that's you know that's the
- 4:47piece that I think we don't do enough. You know and it's not just it's not enough to just listen,
- 4:55right? Because listening is something that's kind of happening between your ears and your counterpart
- 4:59can't even tell if you're listening or not. And it's very easy to sort of space out or think about
- 5:05other things or you know spend your listening time coming up with your own counter arguments. So
- 5:10what you should be doing is trying actively to understand where the other person is coming from,
- 5:16right? And so a good way to do that is by signaling verbally, I'm interested in understanding
- 5:23where you're coming from, right? Like please help me understand. And so you know people often
- 5:28talk about question asking. Question asking is one tool but often people ask very snarky questions.
- 5:35What's question asking? It's shiny like a map. Sure. So if you you know if you talk to a lot of
- 5:43folks who give communication advice, they say you should ask more questions. You should ask
- 5:49better questions. And both of those things are true. But I think it's often sort of not sufficiently
- 5:58precise advice. What you should be doing is showing your counterpart that you want to learn
- 6:05about their point of view, right? And so that could be in the form of a question, right? But often it's
- 6:12in the form of a statement. Please tell me where you're coming from. Right. So not a question but
- 6:19a statement. Please tell me where you're coming from. That makes a lot of sense. That makes a lot
- 6:22of sense. And I guess that that is true. And the family in the workplace, any human interaction
- 6:28really, right? Absolutely. Right. Anytime you have two humans, you are more likely than not to have
- 6:35some kind of disagreement, some kind of misunderstanding. And so saying, hey, I want to understand
- 6:41where you're coming from is a really good first step. And then you have to actually listen to what
- 6:48they say. And that's kind of the listening part. And then there's the talking part. And the
- 6:55talking part is where you get to say, like, well, I understand where you're coming from. But I
- 7:01disagree for XYZ reasons. And that's okay. You're allowed to disagree. But then the question becomes
- 7:09how do you disagree in a way that still shows sort of engagement and consideration of the stuff
- 7:18that other person just told you, right? And so that's where we often talk about how do you
- 7:26verbally signal that you really listened to the other person while they were talking earlier
- 7:33in response to your good questions. Yeah. And your research introduced the concept of here. So
- 7:39you develop this acronym. Could you break that down for us, please? Yes, absolutely. So
- 7:45in our research, we developed a communication style that we call conversational receptiveness.
- 7:52So the idea is when you're expressing your point of view, how do you show your counterpart
- 7:58that you're still engaged with their point of view? And the way we did this is we went through
- 8:04thousands of transcripts of people disagreeing with each other. And then we use machine learning
- 8:11to basically pick out the words and phrases that make people feel hurt, right? And so the machine
- 8:19learning algorithm comes up with like 36 different categories of words and phrases, which is way too
- 8:25much. And so we boiled it down to this framework we call here, which is an acronym H-E-A-R
- 8:35that helps you memorize like the most important features that the algorithm produced.
- 8:41So the most important features, H stands for hedging. So it's phrases like I think it's possible
- 8:49that or it may be the case. The idea is that you're kind of softening your claim a little bit.
- 8:57The E stands for emphasizing agreement. So in any disagreement, no matter how like dramatic,
- 9:05you probably agree on some things, right? So this could be an overarching value or
- 9:11sort of an important common goal. So it's phrases like we both want to or I am also concerned with
- 9:20or I agree with some of what you're saying, right? You're not compromising but you're reaching for
- 9:26some like higher level broader agreement. The A in here stands for acknowledgement. So most of the
- 9:35time when people are in an argument, as soon as the other person stops talking, you jump in and
- 9:41you talk over them. And the idea behind acknowledgement is you take just a few seconds to restate what
- 9:49the other person said. So you're demonstrating with your behavior that you actually heard them when
- 9:57they were talking. So it's phrases like I understand that XYZ is really important to you or you
- 10:05are saying that you're very concerned with ABC, right? And so then you have to get ABC correctly
- 10:13to show that you're really listening. You can't just sort of like make up your own thing.
- 10:18And then the final piece of here is the R and R stands for reframing to the positive.
- 10:25And so here what we're doing is we're dropping a bunch of negative and contradictory words that
- 10:30we often use in disagreement. So no can't won't don't. And instead we're trying to replace them with
- 10:38more positively valanced words. So instead of saying I hated when people try to rush me through
- 10:46stressful decisions, I could say I really appreciate it when people give me the opportunity to
- 10:53consider both sides of an important decision. Right. So same sentiment. The sentiment is like
- 10:58slow down and let me think but phrased in a very different way. So that's the here framework.
- 11:05Nice. That's excellent. And I wonder if sometimes emotions get the better of us, right? And it
- 11:12seems to me that that disagreements often have their origin in potentially something that happened
- 11:19before, not even in that conversation, right? There's a track record. There's a there's a backstory
- 11:23to any conversation. And often it, you know, maybe we get triggered by something and then it gets
- 11:28very emotional. So I can see us being very rational about certain work topics and going through the
- 11:33framework. But what do we do if emotions, yeah, get the better for us? Right. So you're you're
- 11:39totally right. Emotions are a big piece of this. And emotions, the reason that emotions are
- 11:47connected to history, right? Is because the emotion is usually frustration or anger, right? So
- 11:53we've had this conversation before, we've had it 17 times. Why are you still not changing your
- 12:00mind? Or I've asked you to take out the trash. And now like I'm asking you for the fifth time,
- 12:07why is it my job to keep reminding you to do the thing that you're obviously supposed to do every
- 12:12week, right? So in those cases, that's where the here framework is particularly useful, right?
- 12:20Because if you are very calm and collected, let's say you are actually advising a friend,
- 12:26you could come up with many of these techniques on your own, right? Like sort of none of this is
- 12:32rocket science. But when you were the one in the hot emotional state, it's hard to come up with
- 12:38the right words, right? Because all the words that you want to say are words that will actually
- 12:43escalate the conflict. And so having like a little cheat sheet that gives you the right words
- 12:51in the moment when you can't come up with them on your own is really what, you know, what really
- 12:56is helpful about here. It's a shortcut. Yeah, it's a shortcut. So it applies to emotional conversations
- 13:03as well. And even more so. And let's take it from the personal level to the organization level.
- 13:08And as a leader, I may think, okay, how can we have, what can we foster culture of constructive
- 13:14disagreement? Because that moves us forward. The best ideas may win. We become more innovative. We,
- 13:20you know, we're not, you know, we're not, we're not hiding things that should be out in the open.
- 13:25So it seems that a lot of good reasons to be constructive and positive about disagreement.
- 13:31But how do I do this? So I'm really glad you asked that question because I think people often
- 13:38think about becoming better disagreement as an individual task. But that's not the most
- 13:46effective way to go about it. I would say for, you know, considering it from an organizational
- 13:52level, there are two very important ideas. One idea is that we have shown in our research that if
- 13:59you are good at conversational and receptiveness, other people mimic it. So if one person is highly
- 14:07trained, their counterpart will naturally do the same thing. So that implies that you should be
- 14:15teaching people in teams, right? Instead of sort of just randomly grabbing a bunch of people who
- 14:20sign up for the training, you should be training in tech teams because that really switches the
- 14:27culture as kind of mimicry begins to take hold. And it's, you know, that's sort of a wonderful
- 14:33thing, right? Because it really speeds up the change process. But the other piece that I think
- 14:42is also very important is most of the time when we train people in disagreement, we tell them how
- 14:50to think differently and we tell them how to feel differently, right? So try to control your emotions,
- 14:56try to take the other person's perspective, try to, you know, exercise intellectual humility,
- 15:01try to come from a place of respect. Those are all internal mental processes that are very,
- 15:07very hard to evaluate if you are a leader or a manager, right? Like if I tell you to sort of have
- 15:13more respect for me, like how do I know that you have more respect for me? What we're really trying
- 15:19to shift this to is giving people observable behaviors that leaders can train, right? Like the
- 15:30hear framework is a great example. I can teach you how to do it. And then as a learner, you know
- 15:36what they're you're doing it or not because you can literally, you know, count your words and see
- 15:40how many times you use hedging and how many times you have it. That also enables evaluation,
- 15:48right? So every time we do an annual performance review, we ask people to evaluate their soft skills.
- 15:55We ask them, are you a good leader? Are you a good team player? Are you a good communicator?
- 16:01The question of, are you good at managing disagreement? Should be there in 100% of these performance
- 16:10reviews, right? I can't imagine a skill, an interpersonal skill that is more important to running
- 16:17organizations than being able to engage with opposing perspectives. And right now we don't measure
- 16:23it, right? Part of the reason we don't measure it is because we are relying on these like
- 16:28internal mental states that we can't measure, right? So we start teaching things to people that are
- 16:35observable, then they become measurable. And then we can try to increase them.
- 16:40I'm still not, it sounds like a great idea. I'm still not clear about how we can measure it. How
- 16:44can we measure good disagreement in an organization? So you can think about a variety of approaches,
- 16:52right? So the way we measure, are you a good team player? Is we ask in your, you know, 360 performance
- 17:02feedback? We ask everybody you work with is this person a good team player, right? So you could
- 17:07imagine doing the same thing and saying is all over good at engaging with disagreement, right? And
- 17:14then you take the ratings of the five people you work with and average them and you say, okay,
- 17:19here's how Oliver was rated. Another way to do it that, you know, could be, while there's
- 17:26several other ways to do it that are it's even more precise where we ask you to do a task where
- 17:32you have to engage with a disagreement, right? Sort of the way consulting firms use the case
- 17:38centering method when they do recruiting. And in this case, the task is, you know, here is a
- 17:44disagreement. How would you go about it? What would you say to the person? What are the questions
- 17:48you would ask, right? So you could literally create sort of a test around it.
- 17:55You could look at people's communication and measure their receptiveness in text in like a very
- 18:03precise algorithmic way. A lot of organizations might find that too invasive. But again, if we're
- 18:09talking about behavior, then it's definitely measurable is just a question of how much do we want
- 18:15to invest in measuring it? Yeah, super fascinating. And I haven't seen any organizations that do this
- 18:21well, but it seems like something that should we should all pay more attention to. I just want to
- 18:26having worked in big organizations as well for many years. You have different appetite for
- 18:32disagreement, right? And I mean, you're the harvest psychologist, but as far as I know, the big five
- 18:38agreeableness is one of the big personality traits. And some people are more than people pleasing,
- 18:44avoiding conflict, avoiding disagreement and of the spectrum. Others are they have an appetite for
- 18:49it. They like the back and forth and they find it interesting and creative. How do we how do we make
- 18:57how do we foster a creative culture of disagreement between these different poles of people
- 19:04opposite end of the spectrum? Yeah. So, you know, what's interesting is that nobody likes conflict.
- 19:14The big five trade of agreeableness ranges between people who really, really care about making other
- 19:23folks sort of comfortable and happy. And people who kind of don't care and are just sort of, you know,
- 19:30okay, with whatever, but there isn't there isn't an end of the spectrum where people are just like
- 19:35looking for a fight. Interesting. Yeah, that's like a stream. Yeah, most people may be in a dive bar,
- 19:41not a not an organization is setting. Right. Well, you know, like even people and dive bars who
- 19:47are constantly in fights, it's not that they were looking for a fight. It's that they don't
- 19:52recognize it when it's coming. They sort of end up in that situation from lack of foresight.
- 19:58Interesting. And that's what happens in organizations too. Like people who are constant arguments,
- 20:04it's not because they're looking for an argument. It's because they say things that they don't
- 20:09realize will offend other people, right? It's like pluralism. But, you know, that being said,
- 20:16the question you're asking is, you know, if we assume disagreement is good, how do we make people
- 20:23across the spectrum with sort of different personalities more comfortable with it? And I think
- 20:29that it's unrealistic to say, hey, we decided as a company that disagreement is good. And now we're
- 20:39all going to disagree for like the good of the shareholders, right? Because people care about
- 20:45their own relationships and their own teams and their own reputations far more than they care
- 20:51about kind of like the latest company fat about what we're all going to do. So what we need to do
- 20:59is enable people to disagree in a way that doesn't cost them personally, right? And this is back
- 21:08to where conversational receptiveness and the here framework come in. Because if you can disagree
- 21:14in a way that does not create conflict, you're more likely to do it, right? If something is
- 21:20interpersonal costly, you're going to avoid it. But if you can have sort of an interesting
- 21:26productive conversation and have some level of confidence that it won't turn into a fight,
- 21:32then you're far more likely to engage in that conversation. Yeah. Makes sense. You already
- 21:38mentioned and your reviews, you know, the feedback sessions that lead us off to give to their
- 21:42team members and often can be disagreement about pay rises, about performance. To me, in my experience,
- 21:49that that can be a source of disagreement. What's a what's a good way for a leader to handle
- 21:55these tricky conversations? So, you know, I think reviews and feedback are a really
- 22:03interesting space because that's that's something that again, we all do, right? In every organization
- 22:10that is a repeated process that happens to every single employee. And so we should be much better at
- 22:17it than we are. It's a space where when disagreement occurs, usually the manager assumes
- 22:29that they know why the employee is disagree, right? And, you know, this is sort of
- 22:36back to the beginning of our conversation about sort of like, what's the biggest mistake people
- 22:42make? And I said the biggest mistake people make is assuming what the other person has to say.
- 22:48This is a great example of it because if I say, you know, you underperformed in this area and you
- 22:56say, well, no, here's, you know, all the reasons why that happened and it actually was at my fault
- 23:02and I was understaffed and I was under resourced and, you know, et cetera, et cetera. My assumption
- 23:08as a manager is often, well, this person is just being defensive, right? So my employees
- 23:15trying to teach me something important about why this project failed, but I'm not listening because
- 23:21I've already made the assumption, right? And similarly, if I say, you know, here is your
- 23:29raise for the year and you say, I want more, my assumption is, well, everybody always wants more.
- 23:36Yes. Right. And I'm not going to again sort of like take this seriously. No budget for this.
- 23:41Right. Right. Right. Right. And next thing you know, you have a valuable employee that's going out
- 23:45the door because they did get more somewhere else. And that's what they were trying to tell you.
- 23:50Right. So it's back to that, it's back to that initial advice of when somebody's trying to tell
- 24:00us something, can we let go of the assumption that we know better than they do? Right. And actually
- 24:07try to understand what they're trying to say. I think that's really good advice. And I also
- 24:12wanted to have the remote hybrid environment in which most of us work now has an impact on how to
- 24:18disagree in the right way. Yes. So it's harder to build rapport and build relationships
- 24:29in a remote work situation. Right. I, you know, I'm not sort of personally a fan of everybody being in
- 24:40the office five days a week. I think that might be sort of overkill. But we do need to see each other
- 24:46occasionally to build informal relationships, right? To go out for lunch together to, you know,
- 24:52go grab a coffee, you know, chat about our families. I think that happens much more organically
- 24:59when people are in the office. And then when you are having these more sort of challenging
- 25:05conversations, there is research that shows that people build rapport better in person than they
- 25:12do over Zoom. So if you're working remotely, you know, three days a week and working in person,
- 25:17two days a week, you want to schedule those difficult conversations for the days when you're in
- 25:22person. That makes a lot of sense to me. I think it's, it's easy to misread something on a Zoom call.
- 25:28And because we're just lacking some of the cues, right? There's less context. We were lacking
- 25:33the non-verbal side of things to some degree. So it makes a lot of sense to me to, to, to
- 25:39save these tricky conversations for when we meet each other in person. But if it can't be helped,
- 25:43what do we do if we really have to have that disagreement now on Zoom?
- 25:48So there is a colleague, I have a colleague at Berkeley, a researcher named Juliana Schroeder,
- 25:57who does a lot of work on different communication modalities and how the modality affects
- 26:06disagreement outcomes. And her work actually offers good news, which is that a lot of the benefit
- 26:15that we get from being in person is actually the benefit of hearing somebody's voice. So in other
- 26:23words, like the very big gap is between written communication and spoken communication. But whether
- 26:29it's spoken on the phone or on Zoom or face-to-face seems to make less difference. So if you can
- 26:37pick up the phone or, you know, dial in to like a team's meeting, that's much better than having
- 26:44the difficult conversation by email. But email, maybe, maybe the emojis will say first and that,
- 26:49and that is. If I can sum up just for myself, I mean, I think in our team we have a pretty good
- 26:57culture of disagreeing about ideas. And I think it works because we tend to have these,
- 27:03when we actually in the office together, not via Slack, it also works, I think, because we don't
- 27:08take it personally. It's all just about which ideas better or, you know, how can we develop an idea
- 27:13together? So feedback is welcome. And it's not an attack on our identity or our self-worth or any
- 27:19of that kind of thing. So I think sometimes these things get mixed up. And that's where it gets tricky
- 27:24that a criticism or a different opinion is an attack on my identity, which of course it's
- 27:29probably not. But sometimes it's perceived that way. So I think it chimes what you've, so kindly
- 27:36outlined in the last half hour. So I think we're on a good track. But if you could say there's one
- 27:40thing we should all take away from this conversation to become better at disagreeing, what would that be?
- 27:46I think the number one thing people should take away is the recognition that their counterparts
- 27:57can't tell if they're listening well or not. They can't really tell if they're considering their
- 28:05perspective or not. And so you have to show them. You have to show them sort of over and over again
- 28:12with your language and your behavior that you are thinking about their point of view and you're
- 28:18taking it seriously. And that doesn't have to be done in the course of a particular disagreement.
- 28:26That can be done sort of continuously to like, you know, put credit into the account, right?
- 28:33If I am frequently and consistently showing you that I value your input and I value your ideas
- 28:41and I'm paying attention to your contributions, then when we happen to disagree, you're less likely
- 28:48to take that disagreement as a personal attack because I've shown to you over and over again that
- 28:54I value your thinking, right? And so then in the context of the disagreement, you can use the
- 29:00hear framework to continue showing to me that, you know, you're engaging and you are sort of keeping
- 29:07my thoughts in mind. And so that behavioral signal of engagement that's consistent and repeated,
- 29:15I think is what creates that culture of good disagreement. That's wonderful advice. So deep
- 29:21human connections, they give us the basis for having the occasional disagreement. Exactly,
- 29:28exactly. You're putting money into the bank so you can use it later. Beautiful.
- 29:32Thank you so much, but can people find out more about you?
- 29:35So my website is julia-minson.com and you can also measure your own level of
- 29:42receptiveness by going to receptiveness.net. Perfect. And we will of course link to those
- 29:48in the show notes. Thank you, Julia. Really, really much appreciate it. I learned a lot. I think
- 29:52this is such an important topic question we all face over and over every day, but more so
- 29:58potentially than ever because there is a lot of disagreement in the world and hopefully with
- 30:02the hear framework and your advice, we can make it a little better. Thanks so much.