Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️102 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 28nd Sep Water Day 1 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments, and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. There were a few moments of light relief today before we disappeared completely down the water balance rabbit hole, early on, mr. Beatty brought us the unfortunate news that Dalradians ecologist was confined to bed with a throat infection. The timing was perhaps unfortunate, coming
- 1:13after some fairly difficult ecological evidence for the applicant. It did, however, add a new word to the unofficial dictionary of this public inquiry. Apparently, there's now a word for that ecological consultant who ventures over to the corporate dark side, and can always discover the biological
- 1:32argument where one is required. A biostitute, definitely not a scientific classification, and not a description I'm applying to anybody in particular. And apologies, of course, to the many perfectly respectable ecological consultants earning an honest living. Indeed, apologies also to the ladies of
- 1:54the night who may feel their very own professional standards have been unfairly impugned by the comparison. So apologies all around. There was also a small environmental incident inside the inquiry room itself. For the second time during the course of the inquiry, the commissioner pointed out the litter left
- 2:12behind on the Dalharian side of the room and asked that people take it with them. I don't want to read too much into a few abandoned coffee cups and plastic water bottles, although the symbolism of use it, finish with it, and leave somebody else to clean it up, perhaps a little unfortunate. A public inquiry
- 2:33into a gold mine. I'm absolutely sure there's no wider metaphor in there. Moving swiftly on, and there the day developed into something of a documentary treasure hunt again. At one point, mr. Beatty appeared to suggest that the drying of the tailings wasn't really part of the evidence under discussion,
- 2:53only for the commissioner to remind him that his own expert, mr. Spears, had raised it, and back we went to the water balance report, that set the tone. It's in Appendix C4. No, try Annex A, page 28. Actually, have a look at TR22. Hang on, your own expert mentioned it. Back to C4. You get the drift.
- 3:16At another point, the commissioner asked whether wind speed had been taken into account in calculating the water needed for dust suppression. An explanation began. The commissioner stopped it. Not the question I asked. I would like a simple yes or no. And those may be the most optimistic 12 words
- 3:35spoken at this inquiry so far, because yes and no have proved remarkably elusive creatures in The Sperrins. For all the paperwork, the commissioner's questions were often pretty basic today, which was refreshing. What figures did you use? Where does it say that? What exactly did you include?
- 3:55What hasn't been assessed? And occasionally, can you just answer the question. So for all the paperwork, the commissioner's questions were often pretty basic, and the first one was about wind. We'd been talking about the amount of water that would be needed for dust suppression on the dry
- 4:13stack facility. Basically, keeping this enormous area of mine waste damp enough that the dust doesn't start blowing around on the countryside. The commissioner wanted to know: Had wind speed actually been taken into account? Doctor Michael Stewart began explaining the dust suppression figures, and
- 4:33that was when she stopped them. Not the question I asked. I would like a simple yes or no, and then she asked it again: Was wind speed taken into account for the dry stack facility? Now, eventually, we got into the figures: litres per square metre, effectiveness rates, standard U.S. guidance, and so
- 4:53on. But the interesting thing was that when the documents were located, the evidence. Itself apparently didn't contain information on wind speeds.
- 5:04The calculation we were told was based on standard approaches and field testing, and I suppose that was the first indication of how the day was going to go. Because the next question was even simpler: How much gold ore are you actually going to process every day? This is important because the amount of
- 5:26water the mine needs is related to the amount of material being processed. Gold mining uses an awful lot of water. Dalradian submission referred to its water requirements being based on the proposed production rate. So the commissioner asked, "But what is the proposed production rate? Can anybody answer that? There
- 5:50was a brief search for the appropriate expert. Eventually, we got the answer: 1500 tonnes per day. Fine, except the commissioner wasn't finished. She wanted to know where that figure appeared in the information before the inquiry. We went to the surface water balance report, Appendix C4,
- 6:10Table 19, Page 63 of the PDF, and the commissioner asked, "Where does Table 19 say 1,500 tonnes a day? It didn't. mr. Belene explained that the figure had been provided by the process engineers, and that the tonnage itself wasn't the key input to his water model. His assessment was dealing with the water
- 6:33balance and was based on the highest production rate, and that may be perfectly legitimate modelling explanation, but you could see what the commissioner was trying to establish. If you're telling her that the water requirement is based upon a production rate of 1500 tonnes per day, she wants to be able to
- 6:54open the document and point to the 1500 tonnes per day, but alas, she couldn't. And then we got onto the dry stack facility itself. This is where the filtered mine tailings are going to be placed, and they don't arrive bone dry. They contain water. So the commissioner asked Doctor Stewart another fairly
- 7:18straightforward question: Has allowances been made for the water in those tailings while they're drying naturally, and can you show me where we were then directed to another part of the water balance work, where Dr. Stewart said the filtration and run-off rates from the dry stack facility had been modelled
- 7:39and fed into the overall water balance, and then came a question which I think we're going to hear quite a bit more about this week: evaporation. Where has allowances been made for evaporation, and where can I find it? Doctor Stewart directed the commission to the precipitation and evaporation
- 8:00sections of the model. mr. Beatty also pointed out that they had carried out a sensitivity test which increased evaporation rates fivefold, but the commissioner kept going. What about continuous days of rainfall? What happens to the target moisture content then? And could conditions go beyond
- 8:22what had been allowed for in that sensitivity test, and then she came right back around to think she actually wanted to know, what percentage of water have you included in your calculations for the evaporation, and there wasn't a single percentage. Doctor Stewart explained that
- 8:40evaporation varies with conditions, is part of a time series linked to precipitation and is an input to the model, so he couldn't give one simple number. So the commissioner tried again from another direction. Is the evaporation just evaporation from the ponds, or does it include the water
- 9:02that goes in the dry stack facility as well? The answer was that this too was taken into account through the soil water accounting model. Now I'm not going to go any further with this this evening because we will return to it later on the week, when there will be an interview with Doctor Emmerman,
- 9:26speaking exactly about this topic. But remember that exchange. What we're looking at now is how much water is actually lost from the system, and therefore how much has to be replaced. And ultimately, if that replacement water comes from the local water system, the obvious question for everybody
- 9:47living downstream is, how much water is left in the burns? And then we broke for lunch. After lunch, the commissioners started looking at the burns themselves, and. She had a map on the screen showing the application site the commission had been looking at, and she had counted 11 burns, 11 streams of burns within the red
- 10:11line area.
- 10:13But the hydrological assessment being discussed appeared to have been applied specifically to five burns, so she asked NIEA, have you assessed whether the mine workings or the exploration workings could lead to these streams being de-watered? And more particularly, have all these streams actually been
- 10:38assessed in the modelling? NIEA's mr. McLeary said that the hydrological assessment had been applied to five burns, and that might include some of the others, but that this would have to be clarified. The commissioner came back to it. There are 11 streams within the red line, and at that point, NIE
- 11:00said it would need to clarify the position yet again, and for anyone listening who's become completely waterlogged by the terminology, that is the bit to remember. There's 11 burns on the map, five specifically identified in the assessment being discussed, and a question from the commissioner about the
- 11:20other six, we don't yet have the complete answer to that. Then the commissioner moved from surface water to groundwater, and again she spotted something on the map. NIEA had produced a map around the mine portal in relation to groundwater abstraction, so she asked, "Is that actually the only place
- 11:44where groundwater is going to be abstracted? And this is an important point because groundwater isn't necessarily being drawn from one neat little point underneath the portal. The mine workings extend far underground. The commissioner started asking whether, if you moved that assessment area
- 12:10further east, or measured from the red line boundary rather than one particular point, you could potentially bring the black bog into the area being considered. In other words, if you're drawing a five-kilometer circle, where do you stick the pin in the middle? And that really matters. In IES,
- 12:34Stephanie Miller acknowledged that the portal location wasn't actually where all the abstraction Would occur later. The applicant's groundwater evidence stressed that the numerical model considers the mine as it develops, and that groundwater effects are much more complicated than a single
- 12:54point on a map. So there's clearly more to come on that. Then, towards the end of the afternoon, we arrived at the Pallen Row Burn, and the commissioner asked Elrod in another wonderfully uncomplicated question. Can you please tell me how you're going to stop the Pallinro Burn and
- 13:12avert it? mr. Beatty said he'd been hoping mr. Loosely from the Peat team would answer that. He then offered to try to select the right answer himself, which did make it momentarily sound less like a public inquiry and more like who wants to be a millionaire. But the substantive answer is going to have to wait
- 13:33for the appropriate evidence, and then, just when everybody was probably begin to think we might escape for the evening, the commissioner asked, "Why have you proposed zero discharge parameters? Miss Smith from the NIEA explained, and I'll try to translate this into ordinary English. They start with the
- 13:56quality of the water in the burn. They look at the flow and the concentration of the particular substance they're concerned about. They then work backwards from the water quality standard that has to be achieved to calculate what level of discharge could be permitted. Then the commissioner listened
- 14:14to all of that and then reduced it to one sentence. So I understand you. The limits are so high there's no acceptable amount of discharge, and Miss Smith replied correct. Now we need to understand what this means. NIEA was not saying that absolutely nothing ever can be discharged from the mine. What
- 14:36they were explaining was that for some of the parameters being assessed when they apply their approach and the relevant water quality or conservation standards to these small burns, the calculated acceptable discharge is zero, and that's important because Dalreadian and NIEA disagree about this. They
- 14:57disagree about the amount of. Discharge. They disagree about where that discharge should be assessed. They disagree about the appropriate water quality standard to apply, and I think that's probably where I leave today's water story. Because after hours of really complicated evidence, we ended
- 15:21up back where we'd started, with the basic questions: How much water do you need? What assumptions did you use? Where are those assumptions written down? What happens to the water that evaporates? Have all 11 burns been assessed? Where exactly are you measuring the groundwater from, and how do you
- 15:42stop and divert the pollen row burn?
- 15:45And finally, how much of some substances can NIEA's assessment allow to be discharged into those little burns? And for some of them today, their answer was zero. There are yet another three days of water evidence to come. So after the day, I suspect the most useful thing we can do is keep listening for the
- 16:10answers to the commission's questions, because increasingly she seems to be asking exactly the questions that need answering. We'll see if anyone has the answers. We'll see you all tomorrow. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for
- 16:30joining us today. All the links you need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares
- 16:49about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people
- 17:09who protect them.