Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: The geopolitics episode
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome to Energy VOICE Out Loud, the first
- 0:05recording of ENERGY Voice Out Loud in 2026.
- 0:09Happy New Year to our precious, really important listeners.
- 0:15I'm Erica Askeland. I'm the news editor of Energy
- 0:19Voice. And in this week's episode, we
- 0:23will be talking to Ed Reed, editor of E Forward, who's going
- 0:29to be telling us a little bit about what is going on with the
- 0:33dark tankers from Venezuela in the North Atlantic.
- 0:36Then Michael Baer, our renewables reporter, will be
- 0:40telling us about how the offshore wind sector is going
- 0:45now that Dogger 3 might be delayed.
- 0:48And then we're going to be going down to the Humber with our
- 0:52Northern correspondent, Floyd March to discuss what the latest
- 0:57is going on with the Lindsay refinery.
- 0:59So stay tuned. Hello and welcome, everyone.
- 1:02Happy New Year. Can we still say that?
- 1:04I think, I think carry on saying Happy New Year until you've
- 1:07until you've seen the last person you've you've seen for
- 1:10the year. So I'm, I'm happy to take it
- 1:12through to October, November. I mean, keep on flying that
- 1:15flag. You know, I mean, in Scotland,
- 1:17Hogmanay, you're supposed to. It's a sign of good luck if
- 1:22someone told Dark and Handsome comes in with some coal, you
- 1:26know, at Hogmany and you know what I mean?
- 1:29My trouble is is sometimes I have to wait years for that sort
- 1:32of stuff to happen. There should be some sort of
- 1:35service, shouldn't there? Just, you know, get the, get,
- 1:38get the, get the cold man to deliver.
- 1:40Absolutely. And taller than me.
- 1:41That's not. That's not.
- 1:42Hard. That's not hard.
- 1:43Absolutely. So all good.
- 1:45So Ed, you have been tracking dark tankers from Venezuela
- 1:52being rebranded in the middle of the night and now being taken
- 1:56control of by US in the North Atlantic.
- 1:58Is this World War three? What's going on?
- 2:00Yes, it's all, it's all going a bit crazy, isn't it?
- 2:04It really is. So I, I suppose, I suppose, you
- 2:06know, hard to know where to sort of really start with with, with
- 2:09how things were done about so. But this week we have seen a
- 2:13tanker which was in its most recent iteration called
- 2:17Marinara, stormed by US commando Special forces chaps who look
- 2:24very serious, I imagine, jumping out of helicopters onto a tanker
- 2:29just in the sort of the South of Iceland's exclusive economic
- 2:33zone. It was.
- 2:36They were supported by the RAF and the UK armed Forces.
- 2:41Various European militaries were also keeping tabs on this
- 2:44tanker. The Irish, the French, everyone
- 2:47was kind of watching it move. Interestingly enough, it had no
- 2:51cargo on it, that is. Interesting because you know
- 2:56what people US has been kind of like jumping onto Venezuela
- 2:59tankers and taking the oil and selling it, right?
- 3:01Right. That is very much the vibe that
- 3:03they've been giving since since snaffling Nicolas Maduro last
- 3:08weekend. It's a technical term, snaffling
- 3:11just. What do you do?
- 3:12An ex dictator from Venezuela. Well, indeed, indeed so so this,
- 3:18this tank of the marinara had left Venezuela in December.
- 3:24The US Coast Guard had tried to board it at about December the
- 3:2721st. I think the, the people on the,
- 3:31on the, on the ship had said, no, thank you, we're not up for
- 3:34that today and set off. They just hightailed it across
- 3:37the Atlantic. Halfway across.
- 3:39They changed their flags and essentially who, who can, you
- 3:42know what, what state they're responsible to from Guyana to
- 3:47Russia. They painted a flag on the side,
- 3:49a Russian flag on the side. They presumably started speaking
- 3:54a lot more Russian accents, although I gather that the crew
- 3:56was, had a significant number of Russians on it already.
- 4:01Um, and apparently the Russian Navy started shadowing the this
- 4:06tanker as well. There were reports that a, a
- 4:09submarine was in the vicinity and a warship from I think the
- 4:13Baltic fleet had been dispatched to also kind of escort it from
- 4:17the Atlantic into moments that of course didn't happen.
- 4:20The, the, the Americans grabbed the ship in, in, in sort of
- 4:24southern Iceland. And So what happens next is
- 4:27obviously very much up to question.
- 4:29Drama, right? Right, right.
- 4:32This is you. You'd have thought this is the
- 4:34sort of thing which could go quite badly wrong.
- 4:37You know, sort of grand powers sort of squaring off in the
- 4:41Atlantic. It feels like we're sort of back
- 4:43in the sort of the 80s or possibly the 70s.
- 4:47But I suppose it's. 50s even, you know, pigs.
- 4:50Oh my goodness. Yeah, right.
- 4:51Haha. Maybe even the 50s, who knows.
- 4:52Pick pick pick your decade of of of paranoia.
- 4:56But I mean, you, we were having discussion the other day and it
- 4:59was very interesting because I'm like going this is so Maduro.
- 5:04I mean, is anyone really, you know, kind of weeping big tears
- 5:08for, you know, what was kind of maybe the leader of essentially
- 5:12A narco state? And he's been imprisoned in the
- 5:16US and he's up on charges now. It kind of seems to me like
- 5:20Trump is not a very complex strategist.
- 5:23Umm, it kind of looks like he wants his hands on Venezuela
- 5:25oil. In fact, he said as much.
- 5:27But you think that there's maybe a little bit more of a complex
- 5:29thing going on. Tell us a bit about that.
- 5:31I do, I mean, I possibly at the risk of, of of overcome, they're
- 5:35getting a simple story, right. I feel like this is one of those
- 5:37things where you're like, oh, there is lots of lots of factors
- 5:39to play. I'm sure that the oil, you know,
- 5:41that is one of those things that they're keen on.
- 5:43And obviously look, Venezuela's got a lot of oil right.
- 5:45So like 300 billion barrels apparently recoverable.
- 5:48And yes, of course, I mean, that's like a 30% figure of the
- 5:50sort of the 1.2 trillion or whatever that is supposed to be
- 5:54in the sort of the Orinoco. But The thing is, right, this
- 5:57oil is super sludgy. It's I think extra heavy.
- 5:59It's 8 to 10° API. So to actually get it out of the
- 6:04ground, to get it to flow, to put it on a tanker like the
- 6:07Marinara or any other tanker, you're going to need to do quite
- 6:09a lot of work for it. I think so you see various
- 6:13numbers coming out of it. I think, you know, one number I
- 6:15saw for the, for the break even was $80 per barrel.
- 6:19So, and, and obviously oil barrel oil prices at the moment,
- 6:22$60.00 and maybe frankly going down, right?
- 6:25I mean, I think, you know, everyone's talking about like,
- 6:27oh, there's too much oil. OPEC keeps on increasing
- 6:30production. Chinese tanks are filling up
- 6:34because obviously they've seen the, the, the, the opportunity
- 6:36of, of, of low prices. So I think there's a sense that
- 6:40if you were in the pocket of big oil, which is the sort of this
- 6:44this sort of conspiracy around Mister Trump, is that actually,
- 6:48would you try and find new sources of oil?
- 6:51Or would you say, actually, it would be better to give, you
- 6:54know, these guys a higher oil price?
- 6:57So I feel if Trump was in the pocket of big oil, he'd be
- 6:59saying, look, I want to choke off supply.
- 7:01I want to tell OPEC not to produce so much, and I would
- 7:04want to increase sanctions on Venezuela.
- 7:07I feel like this is the opposite, right?
- 7:08He's saying, like, look, we are going to actively go in there
- 7:12and start producing oil. We are going to use it for the
- 7:14benefit of the Venezuelans and the United States, rather
- 7:18interestingly. And we're going to use this oil
- 7:20to to fund the reconstruction. Right.
- 7:21Of course. I mean, you know, as, as we
- 7:24know, you know kind of and I think this is again something
- 7:27you also touched on. So, you know, the vast majority
- 7:30of oil exports from Venezuela, which have declined
- 7:35dramatically, you know, since Hugo Havez, you know, kind of
- 7:39kicked out the foreign investors like Chevron and Exxon in, you
- 7:45know, kind of, I don't know, the 2006 or something like that.
- 7:492007, the decline has been quite dramatic.
- 7:53So it's only a billion barrels of oil a year, but most of that
- 7:57is being sold to China. But now it won't.
- 7:59Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. So it's, it's fallen to
- 8:02something like I just say 900,000 barrels per day or so.
- 8:05And obviously there's this plan like, oh, we could get it back
- 8:07to sort of 3,000,000 barrels per day.
- 8:09How long would that take? I mean, I think rice, I'd say
- 8:10it's something like 15 years, maybe a. 187 billion.
- 8:15Dollars $200 billion between friends, I feel like to know
- 8:19what's. Got that hand?
- 8:20This is real sort of kind of Galaxy brain stuff.
- 8:23Look, I feel like look, obviously all is one of the
- 8:26other factors. I think there are things about
- 8:27critical minerals. There's, there's the Iran,
- 8:31Russia, Chinese, Cuban influence in Venezuela.
- 8:35I think we've seen the Americans talking about this of the, you
- 8:37know, back to the Monroe Doctrine saying we control the
- 8:40Western Hemisphere. No one, you know, is, is, is
- 8:43kind of in charge of the no one, no one sells oil here without
- 8:47our say. So I feel like these are all the
- 8:50things that that are all, you know, kind of driving this,
- 8:52this, this, this interest in, in Venezuela.
- 8:54And it's less about actually kind of getting in there and
- 8:56stealing Venezuelan oil. It's more about geostrategic
- 9:00control of of of this landmass and exerting American power in
- 9:06sort of, you know, essentially throughout the Americas.
- 9:10To me, that feels like more of a sort of a convincing narrative
- 9:13than like, oh, you know, this isn't like this isn't the
- 9:15invasion of Iraq, right? Where, you know, there was that
- 9:18sort of sense like, oh, maybe we do need this oil.
- 9:20Maybe that case could be made a bit more convincingly for
- 9:23Venezuela. I feel like the world has
- 9:24changed. The, you know, we've moved on.
- 9:28I'm sure there will be opportunities.
- 9:29These big companies can, you know, take these kind of, you
- 9:31know, multi year kind of investment plans, but they're
- 9:34going to need a lot more convincing to make those to take
- 9:37those steps, right. Exxon has obviously been
- 9:39famously burned in the past in Venezuela.
- 9:41They might go back to Venezuela, but they're going to need
- 9:43investment certainty. They're going to need real
- 9:45political change. They're going to need that so
- 9:48long term certainty to be able to invest, you know, those, as
- 9:52you say, $188 billion to make it worthwhile.
- 9:56And that may happen. But I, I feel like it's not,
- 9:59it's not a kind of a, a 2026 story, Is it a 2029 story?
- 10:04What does political change mean? Right.
- 10:06I feel like it's it's, it's, it's not oil for me.
- 10:09There is political change and you mentioned Monroe Doctrine
- 10:12and of course, being Canadian, my thoughts are going to
- 10:16Canada's neighbor Greenland, which of course, you know,
- 10:19doesn't have, isn't a member of OPEC like Venezuela is or Iran
- 10:24is, which of course Trump was rattling Sabres at not too long
- 10:28ago. But of course, Greenland
- 10:30actually is a mineral rich country like Venezuela and
- 10:36Canada. You know, it has a, a kind of
- 10:38indigenous, you know, use of kind of like leaking oil nearby,
- 10:46which suggests a, a very complex and deep hydrocarbon system
- 10:49which no one's been able to get at because of icebergs.
- 10:52You know, it's a bit dangerous to drill oil when you've got a
- 10:55big chunk of ice floating at you.
- 10:57Just look at the Titanic. I'm so.
- 10:59But the things are changing now and, you know, the North and the
- 11:02Arctic is going to be a huge one.
- 11:05And if, if the US extends its influence over Denmark, I mean,
- 11:10you know, who knows what's going to go on.
- 11:12So interesting times for everyone.
- 11:14Well, thank you very much and for your deep penetrating
- 11:18insight. Always a pleasure.
- 11:19Thank you so much. We will then be take a quick
- 11:24break and then we will come back to hear Michael Baer report on
- 11:29what the heck is going on with Dogger 3 and the upcoming AR 7.
- 11:35Stay tuned. International upheaval and
- 11:39uncertainty make one thing clear.
- 11:41Energy security starts at home. So what can Scotland do to
- 11:45leverage its advantages? What are the resources we should
- 11:48be thinking about industry and people to deliver security,
- 11:51affordability and tackle emissions?
- 11:53E Ford will be hosting a special event with Anna Sawa, leader of
- 11:57the Scottish Labour Party in Holy Rood on the 22nd of
- 11:59January. We'll have an on the stage
- 12:01interview with him and then panels drilling into what
- 12:03industry needs and how politicians can deliver.
- 12:06Sign up now for the event on the 22nd of January.
- 12:13Welcome back to ENERGY Voice Out Loud.
- 12:15Michael Baer, you've been reporting what's been going on
- 12:20with Dogger Bank 3, so why is it being delayed?
- 12:25I think that is the big question.
- 12:26We've saw there was a spate of and by a spate I mean two other
- 12:31projects that were delayed late last year we had a Morecambe and
- 12:36Outer dousing. Each time when they were
- 12:38delayed, it was this sort of relatively vague justification
- 12:42that was to ask For more information.
- 12:44This is the the same with Dogger Bank 3.
- 12:47To be honest, we haven't actually been able to find out
- 12:50what additional information. Yeah.
- 12:52What do they need to know? Is it like about birds?
- 12:54Is it about marine life or is it about, you know, wind, you know,
- 12:57getting, you know, kind of stolen by the other ones like
- 13:01Dogger Bank 1 and 2? Yeah.
- 13:02And at this point, it's sort of almost the question of right,
- 13:05who who's at fault here? Is it a case that the developers
- 13:10that they haven't provided enough information that or is it
- 13:13a case that the government's application process is maybe
- 13:18lacking? I remember there was a case that
- 13:21I looked at, it was in Denmark and this was a bit of a furrow
- 13:23there that after years stuck in development process, one project
- 13:29got approved and then a change in the law meant that it had to
- 13:34go back into the process because the way the the application was
- 13:39done had now changed, which was obviously a case of, right, This
- 13:43is why we don't have offshore wind farms stuck in the approval
- 13:46process for all this time. But I think it also it's, you
- 13:50know, I think the sort of the context around this is always
- 13:53the fact that under the current timeline we should be finding
- 13:56out the offshore wind AR results for AR 7 next week.
- 14:00And next week is AR 7 day. I mean, I'll, I'll take, I'll
- 14:05take your, your opinion on this. I would go so far as to say that
- 14:09people are not optimistic about the AR 7 results.
- 14:13Now, you've been doing a lot of research into AR 7 in our
- 14:18special edition of Energy Voice Out Loud.
- 14:20That was out in your Energy Voice in print.
- 14:24Sorry that it was published in January.
- 14:27You did a, a kind of like runners and riders, you know, a
- 14:29history of the, you know, CFD process.
- 14:35Now is, is, is Dockerbank 3 in the running for AR-7 or is that
- 14:40going to be a little bit later on?
- 14:41And if that's the case, I mean, what is this?
- 14:44I mean, is Ed Miliband going to get his, you know, offshore wind
- 14:48revolution that he's hoping, you know, will decarbonize the
- 14:51energy system? I mean if.
- 14:52Projects keep getting pushed back, then it's only a few
- 14:58months. It was supposed to be half of
- 15:00the His original deadline was the 10th of January.
- 15:03It's been pushed back to the 30th of April, but the fact is
- 15:06that we've just gone into 2026 and that means that the little
- 15:10counter for Clean Power 2030 has moved that little bit closer.
- 15:14We're now not five years out, We're four years out, Tick.
- 15:18And that is? Tick and that's.
- 15:20Coming, that is not a long time in terms of offshore wind farm
- 15:24development. We are really getting to the
- 15:26point that every little counts and Dogger Bank 3 is by no means
- 15:32on every little. It's 3 gigawatts, that is a
- 15:34substantial chunk to to the the clean power.
- 15:38Can I ask a question? Go ahead.
- 15:40So Dogger Bank was supposed to start up by 2030.
- 15:43That is a good question. Let's have a quick Google.
- 15:46Well, because there's several phases of Dogger Bank and
- 15:49there's also different investors.
- 15:51So Dogger Bank 3 is RWE and interestingly Masdar is, you
- 15:56know, doing this, whereas previously other ones have been
- 16:00largely led by Ecuador and SSE. Is that the case, Michael?
- 16:03And altogether, Docker Bank is going to be the biggest ever for
- 16:11wind farm in the world when it eventually gets done.
- 16:15Although you know when when it gets done now is You know how
- 16:18long is a piece of string or how long is it cable connecting
- 16:23Dogger bank to the grid? How long is?
- 16:25That very good, very good. I love a bit of offshore
- 16:28transmission. Mark, what do you reckon?
- 16:30So it would have so you're right, it is these different
- 16:33phases of southeast and southwest.
- 16:37So let's have a look. So SE was due to come on, is due
- 16:43to come online in do do do do. Do do do.
- 16:48It would have been expected around 2026.
- 16:51So it theoretically, yeah, it would contribute to to 2030.
- 16:57So I'm not going to go so far as to say that 3, three extra
- 17:02months is going to be catastrophic to it contributing,
- 17:05but it is now starting to look like a bit of a trend.
- 17:08What is the, the saying that, you know, once this happens,
- 17:12stands twice as is coincidence, 3 times as enemy action?
- 17:16Well, we're now in the, we're now in the point where we can
- 17:19see, OK, Is this starting to look like a bit of a trend?
- 17:22What is the reason behind these, these approval delays?
- 17:26Are they something that's going to get fixed for coming wind
- 17:30farms or are we going to see more delays?
- 17:33Because also if we don't know the, the reasons for it, we
- 17:36don't know if it's going to get pushed back again.
- 17:37What is this information that seems to be hampering so many
- 17:42projects right now? Is this sorry?
- 17:44Go ahead. Sorry.
- 17:45Just I know I just had another question.
- 17:48Sorry. I realized he wasn't jumping in.
- 17:50But like I you say, you know, optimism is low about AR 7.
- 17:55What is I mean, obviously like there will be some amounts if
- 17:58where it feels like there should be some amounts of offshore wind
- 18:00awarded. Hopefully this won't be AR5
- 18:02again, but what will be like a good result and what would be a
- 18:05bad result? I mean, I feel like is it, do we
- 18:08need to it's a good result enough to deliver sort of CP2030
- 18:13or is it, or is there some other sort of magic number that you
- 18:16feel is a good or a bad result? We've had a few predictions of
- 18:21how much we might expect to come through.
- 18:24For example, I think floating wind, there's five eligible
- 18:26projects and it's likely that at most we'd get 2, for example.
- 18:31But I think there is still that little bit of hope because under
- 18:34the new AR rules there is an opportunity to expand the budget
- 18:39a little bit. We've had a lot of calls for for
- 18:41that to basically for the Secretary of State Ed Miliband
- 18:44to come in and just be like put in as much money as possible.
- 18:48Under the new rules, he is able to review some of the bids.
- 18:51So there is an opportunity that assuming there's enough bids and
- 18:55they're coming in at a good price, we might see more money
- 18:58coming in under the current budget.
- 19:01I can't remember the exact numbers, but it is pretty low.
- 19:05And given that we've basically had to ramp up the amount of
- 19:10capacity that's been brought in compared to a lot of the the
- 19:13previous ARS and after Orsted cancelled it's I want to say
- 19:18Hornsea. Yeah, I think it's Hornsea,
- 19:21isn't it? Yeah.
- 19:22Yeah, it's Hornsea project. Obviously that put back AR 6's
- 19:27performance quite a bit. So there is a need to catch up.
- 19:30And at this point is almost a case of every MW counts.
- 19:34And from what I've seen under the current projections, the the
- 19:38budget that's been laid out right at the start isn't going
- 19:40to be enough to. I think at absolute best, the
- 19:44absolute best case scenario is it brings in the minimum amount
- 19:48that it would have to to bring in.
- 19:49Well, so AR 7 next week is going to be telling, isn't it?
- 19:58I mean, you know, we've been kind of hearing rumours.
- 20:01You know, is there going to be anything coming through, you
- 20:04know, from Scotland, you know, from AR-7 allocation round
- 20:09seven, you know, kind of being, you know, thought to be
- 20:12increasingly critical ahead of Clean Power 20-30, you know,
- 20:17that big, you know, requirement in the sky.
- 20:23But you know, maybe, I guess, you know, the question is, and
- 20:26this is the what keeps on, you know, kind of troubling me is we
- 20:30know that offshore wind is difficult and floating offshore
- 20:33wind is even more difficult and it's not proven.
- 20:36And yet all of a sudden Ed Miliband and GB Energy nuclear
- 20:42and GB Energy seems to be rather focusing on nuclear power
- 20:48generation instead, which is clean, but of course, you know,
- 20:51has that awful problem of residual toxic nuclear waste.
- 20:56Speaking of sludge, and you know, you thought, you know,
- 20:59Orinoco was bad. You know, I mean, try Sizewell
- 21:033, Sizewell C, you know, like what that's going to be
- 21:06producing. So, I mean, are we kind of
- 21:10feeling that, you know, the targets and expansion for
- 21:16offshore wind and maybe floating offshore wind that we've got for
- 21:192035 and 2050? You know, may not if they don't
- 21:23quite reach, you know, the great heights that of gigawatts that
- 21:28were predicted, you know, going to maybe even as far back as
- 21:33Boris Johnson's regimen regimen, You know, if it doesn't make it,
- 21:39will it matter? And do you think anyone's going
- 21:41to care? Michael, I'm going to put the
- 21:43pressure on you this. Was actually a question that I
- 21:45asked at one of the previous event was look, why don't we
- 21:49just put push back twin clean Power 2030.
- 21:53It's starting to look less and less likely and the consensus
- 21:56was no, we're better off keeping it.
- 21:58Even if we don't hit Clean Power 2030, having that as a goal
- 22:04gives, gives the industry that ambition to to just bring in as
- 22:08much capacity as possible. And essentially, I think, you
- 22:12know, outside of Roy economics, there is the environmental case
- 22:16for offshore wind and renewables to the point that the more we
- 22:19have, it's generally seen as the better.
- 22:22So for the most part, it does seem that OK, we there's maybe
- 22:28optimism is, is waning, but there is still a case for for
- 22:34Clean Power 2013. I get you.
- 22:35I mean, but if 2025 was completely and you know, put
- 22:40your bleep, you know, kind of a warning on the on the radio
- 22:45here, if 2025 was a shit year for offshore wind, is 2026
- 22:50looking any better? I am going to make one of my
- 22:54famous predictions as someone who would not does not expect to
- 22:57be held the case. For.
- 22:59It I am, I'm expecting 2026 to have more headwinds.
- 23:04I do not think we're going to get past the the 2025.
- 23:08But you know what? I'm here to be proven wrong.
- 23:11You heard it here first, folks. Thank you, Michael, once again.
- 23:15You know, the answer may be blowing in the wind, but for as
- 23:19far as energy voice out loud, we were going to be holding, you
- 23:24know, our faces, you know, in the face of the storm and
- 23:27telling you all about what's going on with offshore wind in
- 23:31the rest as months progress. So thanks ever so much for that.
- 23:35We will take yet another break and then we will be going down
- 23:39to the Immingham, the refinery fight that seems to have broken
- 23:45out on the banks of the Humber. Stay tuned.
- 23:51Hello, I'm Edreid, the editor of E Ford.
- 23:53E Forward is a membership community that brings together
- 23:56the entire UK energy supply chain, every hub, every sector,
- 24:00every stage. Our aim is to deliver growth to
- 24:03the energy sector, working with industry and policy makers to
- 24:06unlock the UK's opportunities and advantages.
- 24:09This is the movement to secure increased investment, improve
- 24:13policy making and better collaboration by providing our
- 24:16members with visibility, influence and access.
- 24:19Joining Forward today. And we're back for the third and
- 24:25final leg of this week's installment of Energy Voice Out
- 24:29Loud. Of course, all of our
- 24:31discussions and that we've had so far, you can go onto Energy
- 24:35Voice and read all about it. For example, you can read all
- 24:39about what Floyd has been writing about the Lindsay
- 24:42Refinery and the whole Prax saga.
- 24:46Like if we thought offshore wind was a dramatic in 2025, you
- 24:50know, like what's been going on with Prax and Lindsay has been
- 24:53absolutely crazy. But we maybe have come to an
- 24:57interesting point in the future of Lindsay, which is it might
- 25:02just be shut down in mothballed because Phillips 66 has taken it
- 25:06over and they don't they've got a Humber refinery.
- 25:08Thank you very much. Is that the case?
- 25:10Oh, well, yeah, it just seemed that way.
- 25:11And if the conspiracy theorists from before saying that Philips
- 25:1566 have got it and no one else has got a look in that turned
- 25:18out to be true, if we keep listening to them, then then,
- 25:22yeah, a mothball is is in place. You know, Philips 66 aren't
- 25:27really denying that that that that would be the case.
- 25:30They've already openly come out and said evaluations have shown
- 25:33the refinery is not viable in its current form.
- 25:36Current form obviously doing a lot of heavy lifting to like
- 25:40say, well, it could be in some form, but we just don't know
- 25:43yet. So well, it makes sense, right?
- 25:46Philips 6600 refineries made steady profit recently.
- 25:50You know, would would spending so much money getting another
- 25:55refinery next door to get up to scratch makes sense or would
- 25:59just using it as storage make more economic sense?
- 26:03I mean, for the workers, they must be feeling like they don't
- 26:09know where to look really, because 1 moment jobs are safe
- 26:13till March for the remaining 250 workers, then there's a sale is
- 26:18going to happen. Everyone's thinking, oh, maybe
- 26:20I'm going to keep my job. And then Phillips 66 are like on
- 26:23the fence about what, what direction the refinery is going
- 26:25to go in. And yeah, so all these workers
- 26:28are safe till March, but until then, like, who knows really.
- 26:32Yeah, not great for the workers, but I mean great for me because
- 26:37I can keep writing these articles, I feel like.
- 26:41Well, yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, wasn't it the case
- 26:43though, you know, because of course there were a number of
- 26:48interested parties in the refinery asset.
- 26:52But you know what, there was a lot of discussion that, you
- 26:56know, you know, the, the, the language was very interesting.
- 26:59They didn't say that the buyers weren't credible, but just that
- 27:01the offers weren't credible, which I think probably gets you
- 27:04out of a lot of hot water. Although you know what?
- 27:07Actually, when it comes right down to it, you were speaking to
- 27:09someone who maybe doesn't think it's a done deal, which you know
- 27:14what I mean? Like, I'd like to see them like,
- 27:17you know, come back from that one.
- 27:18But hey, you know what? What's your insight into?
- 27:20Well, who who doesn't love an underdog story, right?
- 27:23May maybe someone that has got experience in Swiss luxury goods
- 27:26may be able to pull out something out of the bag in the
- 27:29final hour A. Luxury bag, obviously.
- 27:32Yeah, yeah, of course, of course I'm an.
- 27:35Expert at that. But but yeah, so yeah, I did, I
- 27:39did try to speak to the kind of the guy behind the due diligence
- 27:43for Mark Cameron's potential bid.
- 27:45Anyone that's listened to this podcast has probably heard me
- 27:48berate this guy and kind of cyber bullying him for the last
- 27:50couple months. But but yeah, he was like the
- 27:54the deal's not done yet basically when I was just trying
- 27:57to speak to him about it and how he feels.
- 27:59But you know, I think we've we're all long enough in the
- 28:01tooth to see when this kind of like thing happens, the sale
- 28:05will likely go through. So, yeah, and and like you
- 28:09mentioned the credible word, credible like did a lot of heavy
- 28:14lifting again, because obviously TPMC, which is Turpal pitching
- 28:17mining company, which is too hard to say and Mark Cameron's
- 28:22secret consortium, they both did want to have the refinery
- 28:27running, you know, as a refinery.
- 28:30But obviously the official receiver mustn't have seen that
- 28:34as a credible option as well as Philips 66 or whether they just
- 28:39trusted Philips 66 because they've got a, a better track
- 28:42record. You know, who knows really to
- 28:45the answer to that question, but Philips 66 kind of makes sense
- 28:48if they've got a a refinery which is just 4 remaining in the
- 28:51UK and that's running a profit. You know, if they put an offer
- 28:56in, you're probably going to go with it, if I'm being honest.
- 28:59Are there any, are there any other bits of Prax outstanding
- 29:02because I know that the North Sea assets got sold or?
- 29:05Ceracas picked those up in the North Sea there, So there's like
- 29:10an oil and gas field West of Shetland and then, you know,
- 29:15kind of some of the pipelines and the gas plant on Shetland
- 29:20and some. And then of course, they also
- 29:22did the deal with total energies, which is now
- 29:26completely exited, uh, or will be exiting, uh, the North Sea,
- 29:32uh, production, uh, as a result, Um, and of course, remember, uh,
- 29:36total energies owned the refinery at Lindsay, uh, before
- 29:41they sold it to Prax, which seemed like it was a bad idea.
- 29:46And seems like, you know, maybe, maybe they weren't the best
- 29:48caretakers at all. Fell of 66 kind of seemed to
- 29:51blame them, you know, for how you know much of A shambles the
- 29:55refinery is now because they say it's like hunk of junk
- 29:58basically. Isn't it, I mean, it's, it's
- 30:00presumably quite a good way for for total to extricate itself,
- 30:03isn't it? I feel like the Lindsay plant
- 30:05had obviously been sort of struggling.
- 30:07The economics were clearly challenging, which is why they
- 30:09sold it. But then rather than, you know,
- 30:11sort of just shut it down and, and, and, and be blamed for
- 30:15those, what sort of 500 job losses, selling it to Prax and
- 30:18then letting Prax go sideways feels like.
- 30:22Have we just, yeah, have we discovered who where the
- 30:26decommissioning liability lies? Is that now with Phillips 66,
- 30:29Floyd, we were talking about, you know, how much it's going to
- 30:32cost to, you know, just flatten that place.
- 30:34Yeah, I think, I think the decommission was in like the
- 30:37hundreds of millions, like touching billions.
- 30:39But I'm not sure who would be responsible for that, if I'm
- 30:41being honest. But I assume Phillips 66 are
- 30:45either OK with that or it's not going to be their
- 30:48responsibility. So that's why they're happy
- 30:50enough to to to buy the refinery.
- 30:53So yeah, I'm not too sure if I'm being perfectly on this where,
- 30:56where that liability lies. Is there a Is there a chance
- 31:00that it is US noble taxpayers? Well, yeah, I would have thought
- 31:05so. If the if the official receiving
- 31:07the government couldn't find a buyer for such a long time and
- 31:10then someone comes in, you know, quite late in the day, then
- 31:14maybe that was part of the deal. So yeah, maybe Energy Voice will
- 31:18uncover that in the future. Again, stay tuned for that.
- 31:20So, but now we're down to four UK refineries.
- 31:24Is that the case? Yeah, yeah, that's right.
- 31:27Obviously Philips 66 having one of those next door, which is
- 31:31quite helpful. Yeah, the the unions obviously
- 31:35unite not very happy with with the the sound of it being
- 31:39mothballed. They want to protect as many
- 31:41jobs as possible and they kind of went on the attack on the
- 31:44government as well. Just saying about how much the
- 31:48Labour government needs to get into gear.
- 31:51They're saying that the net 0 policies are are hurting
- 31:54workers. So the unions seem to think that
- 31:57the government are to blame for refineries closing down or or
- 32:00maybe the, you know, lack of urgency in finding a buyer and
- 32:05getting refineries up and running again.
- 32:07You know, would Ed Miliband be pretty happy with the fact that
- 32:10a refinery that he doesn't really want to have operating
- 32:14shuts down? Like, is he going to be that
- 32:16bothered about Philips 66 saying, OK, we'll buy it, but we
- 32:19use that as a storage tank. You know, there's a case to be
- 32:23made for that. But at the at the heart of it is
- 32:26always just the workers, right? 250 people are going to work
- 32:29each daylight not knowing what's happening in the future, which
- 32:31can't be nice. Although I'm not sure you can
- 32:33really blame net 0 policies for that, right?
- 32:35Like, I feel like, you know, we've seen the problem with
- 32:38Lindsay kind of growing over the years.
- 32:39Like the, as you know, mentioned, like the economics
- 32:41were, were were tough. I mean, obviously it's, it's
- 32:43nice to have someone to kind of point the, the finger at and
- 32:45say, oh, you know, Ed Miliband strikes again.
- 32:48But I feel like this isn't really like an Ed Miliband
- 32:51problem. This is like, God, you know
- 32:53what? It's hard to run a refinery in
- 32:55Europe. You know, we've got
- 32:56environmental regulations, all of these things and frankly
- 32:59economies of scale, right, like running a small refinery, it's a
- 33:02brutal business. Like, you know, they're getting
- 33:05refineries getting bigger and bigger.
- 33:06Obviously demand here is questionable.
- 33:09Moving to EVs. That's the kind of longer term
- 33:11question. There's, you know, there's kind
- 33:12of like an emissions question, but I feel like just in general,
- 33:16it's, it's a tough business and, and, and probably these things
- 33:20are going to go to the wall, right?
- 33:21So I think really the focus should be less on being like,
- 33:24oh, how can we stop those guys from losing their job at a
- 33:27refinery and more how can we get those guys into jobs elsewhere.
- 33:31Yeah, for sure. And it's not like Ed Miliband's
- 33:33come out and just, like, tax the hell out of refineries, like out
- 33:36of nowhere. Like you know, pracs have not
- 33:39got a good track record anywhere in the UK now.
- 33:42Although there are a lot of people who are very, you know,
- 33:45concerned about, umm, you know, the cost of energy for
- 33:49industrial users, uh, like refineries, which of course, you
- 33:52know, kind of like refine a lot of umm, oil and gas and you
- 33:57know, make all sorts of useful, uh, products.
- 34:00Umm, But umm, you know, the economics and you know, the, uh,
- 34:05green charges, umm, which are we're using, of course, to kind
- 34:09of build, umm, you know, kind of our, our, our future, or should
- 34:13be anyway, is making, you know, kind of an extra barrier and
- 34:18maybe hastening, you know, that decline, I guess, you know,
- 34:21faster than, you know, the just decline of North Sea production
- 34:24that would have been greasing the wheels at refineries in the
- 34:27UK, you know, just dropping off. But yeah, well, I'm sure we'll
- 34:31be covering this refinery, you know, the sales not done.
- 34:34Hopefully Mark Cameron can come in the final hour and give us
- 34:37another twist in the tale of the Lindsay or refinery.
- 34:41Well, get. Him get him on the podcast,
- 34:43right? He can, he can, he can send out
- 34:45his next. Step.
- 34:46Yeah, well, therefore need the bleep button if the emails and
- 34:48the phone calls anything to go by, but yeah, but yeah, sounds
- 34:51good. Bleep button coming more.
- 34:53There we go. That's another prediction we can
- 34:55make here on Energy Voice Out Loud for 2026.
- 34:58Floyd, thank you ever so much for giving us a tour of what's
- 35:02going on in the Humber. And you've been listening to
- 35:07Energy Voice Out Loud, and hopefully you enjoyed it as much
- 35:12as we did. And hopefully you will continue
- 35:14coming back every week. And then, of course, coming to
- 35:19us through your podcast selector of choice.
- 35:24You can also read us on Energy Voice.
- 35:27We've got exciting stuff always coming up here.
- 35:30I've been Erica Ascolan, news editor for Energy Voice, and
- 35:33thanks again for listening. Bye bye.