Latest / Humanise The Numbers - for ambitious accountants in practice / Richard Sergeant, Managing Director at Principle Point Ltd
Transcript
- 0:05Paul Shrimpling: Welcome to the Humanize the Numbers podcast series.
- 0:08Paul Shrimpling: Leaders, managers, and owners of ambitious accounting firms sharing insights, successes, and issues that will challenge you and connect you and your firm to the ways and means of transforming your firm's results.
- 0:21Richard Sergeant: Actually, although I make a quite a big personal deal of saying I've got nothing to say to accountants, actually, I believe what the situation they're facing is really hard and really challenging.
- 0:32Richard Sergeant: And I actually do want to say a couple of things to people.
- 0:36Richard Sergeant: I do want to say a couple of things like, I understand this is hard and this is challenging, and I don't think vendors take it on board enough.
- 0:42Richard Sergeant: I don't think they appreciate the cost.
- 0:45Richard Sergeant: I don't think they appreciate fully how hard it is to get value out of their solutions.
- 0:50Richard Sergeant: I don't think they fully appreciate how frustrating this stuff can be and how it doesn't work and all fit together.
- 0:57Richard Sergeant: And because they've got financial targets that hit often that's not an excuse for ignoring those people who are your customers and your clients, and often they are pushing you to their clients, and that's a huge risk, you know.
- 1:14Richard Sergeant: And I don't think people, I don't think vendors fully appreciate that.
- 1:18Richard Sergeant: So I really would I'm gonna increasingly start banging the drum for that recognition, and also for them to start to feel even more confident in being sure what it is that they want out of the stuff that they buy.
- 1:32Richard Sergeant: And I think that's important for everybody.
- 1:35Paul Shrimpling: What do you do to transform the relationship you have with all of your clients through the skills of your client managers?
- 1:42Paul Shrimpling: And what do you do to transform the financial performance of your business to use technology better?
- 1:48Paul Shrimpling: Well, on this podcast with Richard Sargent, Richard unpacks both of those questions based on his decades of insight and knowledge of working within the profession.
- 1:58Paul Shrimpling: Let's go to that podcast with Richard now.
- 2:00Richard Sergeant: Hi, I'm Richard Sargent.
- 2:02Richard Sergeant: I'm uh I have a little consultancy business called Principal Points, and I've been knocking about the world of accountants for 26 years, first as a vendor, doing stuff for accountants, and then latterly kind of working almost exclusively with the software vendors, helping them to understand, communicate, and build better products for accountants and bookkeepers and finance professionals.
- 2:22Richard Sergeant: I love music, I live here in Bristol, we're surrounded by it, and my life is not as busy as some people kind of make out sometimes, I think.
- 2:31Richard Sergeant: So I'd either put it kind of goods or I need some more work, I'm not quite sure.
- 2:36Richard Sergeant: There you
- 2:37Paul Shrimpling: go.
- 2:37Paul Shrimpling: Well, who knows what might come out of this?
- 2:40Paul Shrimpling: Um really appreciate you joining us on the uh on the pod, uh Richard.
- 2:44Paul Shrimpling: So um, given all the experiences uh uh a vendor and working with other vendors across the profession for a number of years, what does the phrase humanize the numbers mean to you?
- 2:57Paul Shrimpling: Where where does it make your brain go in terms of the profession?
- 3:01Paul Shrimpling: Humanize the numbers, what does it mean to you?
- 3:03Richard Sergeant: Well, I kind of thought that was what I was here to find out and work out, to be really honest.
- 3:08Richard Sergeant: I've got quite an open mind, so perhaps it will reveal itself more to me when I get towards towards the end of this podcast.
- 3:15Richard Sergeant: You can ask me again.
- 3:17Paul Shrimpling: Okay, that's an interesting position.
- 3:18Paul Shrimpling: Okay.
- 3:19Paul Shrimpling: So what where's where's where do where are your questi where do your questions lie, therefore, in and around that phrase?
- 3:25Richard Sergeant: I guess it er I I honestly haven't thought about it particularly deeply.
- 3:30Richard Sergeant: And when I look at accountants and I look at the diversity of the profession and I look at the and I think about the diversity of their clients, I've got just as much respect for people who kind of churn out the numbers in quite a mechanical way because compliance is an important part of what they do as I have for people who really deeply, not even deeply, kind of oh who form really strong, really important relationships with their clients.
- 3:58Richard Sergeant: And I think there's room in the world for for for both approaches, it just depends on what the needs are of the end user client.
- 4:05Richard Sergeant: So I'm actually in awe of the profession, have been for years.
- 4:09Richard Sergeant: I have a deep respect for and deep love for the people in it, and I've got to know some incredible people along the way, and what I've always noticed is that they always do it their own way, you know, and it and and I like that.
- 4:21Richard Sergeant: I think we need choice, I think we need different viewpoints and different perspectives.
- 4:25Richard Sergeant: So yeah.
- 4:28Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, no, I like that.
- 4:29Paul Shrimpling: The um what maybe there's more than one way to skin a cat, is there's more than one way to run an accounting practice, there's more than one way to lead a team, and there's more than one way to work with a client.
- 4:40Paul Shrimpling: There's more that so it's um that's interesting.
- 4:43Paul Shrimpling: So the human bit is actually settle into who you are, do it the way it suits you best.
- 4:50Paul Shrimpling: Is that where you go with that?
- 4:52Richard Sergeant: I mean, I don't I I mean I don't really know.
- 4:54Richard Sergeant: I'm just kind of shooting a breeze now, so I haven't thought about this particularly deeply.
- 4:56Richard Sergeant: But I'm I think what I'd recognise is something that my old boss and mentor, Mark Lloyd Bottom, used to say, which is basically all accountants are exactly the same, but they're all completely different.
- 5:08Richard Sergeant: And I extended that
- 5:09Paul Shrimpling: and
- 5:10Richard Sergeant: unextended it and said, well, to be honest, all clients are exactly the same, but they're all completely different, and actually all services are exactly the same, but they're all completely different.
- 5:19Richard Sergeant: And it's the way that you deploy that service and expertise around the needs of the client that
- 5:26Paul Shrimpling: is
- 5:26Richard Sergeant: the important part.
- 5:27Richard Sergeant: So you can't run payroll the same way for every client, not least because some people are monthly, some people weekly, some people are both, and you can't, you know, year-end accounts.
- 5:38Richard Sergeant: We know the difficulties and issues around standardizing things like working papers.
- 5:43Richard Sergeant: You know, you can't just take what you did for somebody else and just replicate it somewhere else.
- 5:48Richard Sergeant: So that diversity is a challenge.
- 5:53Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, no, no, you're challenging me now, which I I love.
- 5:56Paul Shrimpling: Um, you know, coming off the back of you know a number of meetings over the last fortnight with a number of different different unique firms, all with their own different tongues, different people, different client makes, in in some cases, different service levels, which therefore points to the fact that there's clearly a huge opportunity, lots and lots of opportunity out there, depending on the nature of the firm you want to run.
- 6:21Richard Sergeant: Yeah.
- 6:22Paul Shrimpling: Uh, whether, you know, I mean, could you get any wider?
- 6:25Paul Shrimpling: I've got you know, uh a firm that started two years ago, grown it to about 700k.
- 6:30Paul Shrimpling: Uh following day in in deep conversation with a firm that's turning over a 150 million with you know 19 offices.
- 6:37Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, it's like you know, you couldn't, yeah, I mean you couldn't create too stark a polar operation.
- 6:42Paul Shrimpling: That's this week, weirdly enough.
- 6:44Paul Shrimpling: Um and so there is a different perspective, and I love this.
- 6:51Paul Shrimpling: Oh, maybe we should be uh just relaxing into who we are as a human and the way we want the firm to run.
- 7:00Paul Shrimpling: Uh I'm just wondering where to go with this, Richard, because uh the the deep conversation yesterday was partly about why are you in business?
- 7:10Paul Shrimpling: What's what's the meaning behind what you're doing?
- 7:14Paul Shrimpling: Was the question I challenged the lead two leaders of the small firm yesterday?
- 7:18Paul Shrimpling: Um, and it's a hard question to um to answer uh on the hoof, you know, having never been asked anything, you know, it's like uh someone say, Well, it's just that we're in Simon Sinek, you know, start with Y territory.
- 7:31Paul Shrimpling: Well, yeah, we are, but actually it's turning into something that truly reflects who you are and what your firm stands for.
- 7:37Richard Sergeant: I just
- 7:38Paul Shrimpling: wondered who who have you seen, whether be vendor or a currency firm, that's maybe done that really well.
- 7:46Richard Sergeant: Who's done it really well?
- 7:49Paul Shrimpling: Or who's done it really badly?
- 7:51Richard Sergeant: Well, I know.
- 7:52Paul Shrimpling: I
- 7:52Richard Sergeant: guess I just need a little bit of clarification.
- 7:54Richard Sergeant: Done what well?
- 7:57Paul Shrimpling: Uh worked out and clearly communicated why they exist, the meaning behind their firm.
- 8:05Richard Sergeant: Right.
- 8:06Paul Shrimpling: So that the all the team in that firm have got a real sense.
- 8:11Paul Shrimpling: There's we're not just doing a job, we're doing it for really good reasons.
- 8:16Richard Sergeant: Yeah.
- 8:17Richard Sergeant: I think that's quite hard for me to answer.
- 8:20Richard Sergeant: I mean, I've known lots of accountants along the way.
- 8:23Richard Sergeant: I mean, some of the people who stand out for me these days are more in the vendor community, right?
- 8:28Richard Sergeant: Because that's more my bread and butter.
- 8:30Richard Sergeant: So less kind of I guess the people who automatically stand out for that at the moment are people like All in Place, Richard Burton's crew, who they really passionately believe that they come from a place of real experience and dealing with the business owner rather than the business itself, primarily.
- 8:52Richard Sergeant: And yeah,
- 8:53Paul Shrimpling: other
- 8:53Richard Sergeant: chartered accountants you know is very much in the financial services world.
- 8:57Richard Sergeant: I'm kind of understanding that behind every business and the business planning that we might do is the direct correlation towards the family, the business owner, and the and their families.
- 9:08Richard Sergeant: And while we accountants may focus on the tax side, there's a lot more to the context of that family, what it needs that drives what would be need to be generated from the business, and making that connection between the two is an evident passion for the whole organization.
- 9:26Richard Sergeant: I know they've kind of brought in people like Richard Bruin and Will Farnell into that, and yeah,
- 9:31Paul Shrimpling: yeah, I think
- 9:33Richard Sergeant: you know, quite a tight sense of of um and clear sense of which direction they want to kind of kind of go in, and I and I and I like that.
- 9:43Richard Sergeant: I like that.
- 9:44Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, and and I mean they're lovely people, uh, they've been on the podcast as well.
- 9:48Richard Sergeant: Oh, have they
- 9:50Paul Shrimpling: no
- 9:50Richard Sergeant: more?
- 9:51Paul Shrimpling: We'll we'll anchor their podcast in the uh yeah, brilliantly done.
- 9:54Paul Shrimpling: Uh in the uh in the show notes.
- 9:55Paul Shrimpling: So if anyone wants to dive into understanding better where they're coming from and how that works.
- 9:59Paul Shrimpling: Um they've also got
- 10:01Richard Sergeant: a bigger point, just on on that point though, more generally, why I struggle a little bit with that is because I I know that businesses start with often passion and a desire, but they often get moved as the kind of business grows and evolves, the day-to-day can take over too much.
- 10:21Richard Sergeant: And you just have to do whatever's on your plate, and that's all sometimes not in line with maybe how you how you kind of started out.
- 10:30Richard Sergeant: And I've seen it lots with the
- 10:31Paul Shrimpling: community
- 10:31Richard Sergeant: firms over the years that I have had the privilege to know is that they don't often grow with intent, they grow by accident, and that's a clear sign of not that you've lost touch of why you started in business, it's just the fact that your business kind of sometimes overtakes you.
- 10:46Richard Sergeant: And I see that a lot within the vendor communities, you're starting with people who often the founders have a very clear sense of objective and why they're doing it, but as that team by necessity grows, it's very hard to instill that sense of passion and purpose and commitment when you need people to get in and kind of do a job, and I think that's a real challenge, and that's kind of one of the reasons why my my role exists in the world a little bit because some of it's just quite simple and fundamental understanding the profession, for example.
- 11:20Richard Sergeant: For example, you're great great salespeople, great developers, great product people, but no one's born with an innate knowledge of the accounting profession.
- 11:28Richard Sergeant: So, how do you get to know it, you know, and how is that fed down in an undiluted and quite strong way from the founders of the of those businesses through the rest of their team?
- 11:41Richard Sergeant: It's incredibly hard to do, I think.
- 11:45Paul Shrimpling: So I'm now curious, what what what distinguishes the people, whether in the vendor space or the accounting space, that manage to grow with intent rather than grow by accident, so that as they grow their firm, they maintain, if not even enhance this sense of what passion, you know, meaning, whatever label we want to give, you know, the it's like the I just I'm a big fan of the Juracell bunny on the ground because some everyone around me says I twitch too much, so there must be too many batteries in there somewhere.
- 12:18Paul Shrimpling: But but it's that, you know, what is it that there's that drive, isn't there, behind what they're doing.
- 12:22Paul Shrimpling: So what what distinguishes and I'm looking, I I think, Richard, I'm looking for the processes or skills that mean we're growing with intent rather than growing by accident, drifting towards lots of people doing jobs for jobs' sake rather than doing jobs for real meaning, intent connected to the passion of the founder or the leadership team because you know, as businesses enhance,
- 12:48Richard Sergeant: um,
- 12:48Paul Shrimpling: it becomes less founder-driven.
- 12:50Paul Shrimpling: Um what distinguishes the two?
- 12:52Paul Shrimpling: And I am hunting for skills or processes that you see.
- 12:57Richard Sergeant: My my honest answer to that is I think it's it's being brave enough to take honest feedback from your clients.
- 13:04Richard Sergeant: Because I think the adjustments we need to make is we might start out with a central founding idea and principle, but ultimately we never know whether or not it's going
- 13:15unknown: to
- 13:15Richard Sergeant: be currently viable until people start paying us for it.
- 13:17Richard Sergeant: And as soon as we start having clients and customers, then we need to be very conscious of what their needs actually are, which might be slightly different to what we anticipated them to be.
- 13:29Richard Sergeant: And I don't think there's enough honesty with ourselves about what we are, how often, how frequently, and how openly we're asking for not just feedback but real engagement from our clients.
- 13:42Richard Sergeant: And that's and I and I mean that as a separate thing to uh how well are we doing the job.
- 13:50Richard Sergeant: It's not about service delivery per se.
- 13:53Richard Sergeant: It's not about you know testing the water, giving us a ranking out of five.
- 13:57Richard Sergeant: How do how was your experience of our support team or something like that?
- 14:01Richard Sergeant: Or
- 14:01Paul Shrimpling: yeah, yeah, yeah, NetFotoscore PISA, or yeah.
- 14:04Richard Sergeant: Yeah, I mean MPS has got covers a lot of papers over a lot of cracks, for example, I think.
- 14:10Paul Shrimpling: As
- 14:11Richard Sergeant: well as kind of developing corporate values, which is another big bugbearer of mine, but we can talk about another time.
- 14:15Richard Sergeant: But there's there's there's a sense of I think going deeper with clients.
- 14:20Richard Sergeant: It's kind of stuff which I always say, you know, is one of my drivers is that I like looking at things which are easy to know but hard to find out.
- 14:27Richard Sergeant: You know, it's it's easy to know that we're doing a good job, but it's actually really hard to substantiate.
- 14:34Richard Sergeant: It's really hard to substantiate that.
- 14:37Richard Sergeant: Why are we doing a good job?
- 14:38Richard Sergeant: What does that mean for this client?
- 14:40Richard Sergeant: What does it mean for our direction?
- 14:41Richard Sergeant: What does it mean what we need to do next?
- 14:43Richard Sergeant: How does that control our priorities?
- 14:45Richard Sergeant: Are we growing in the right way?
- 14:47Richard Sergeant: Where is it highlighting?
- 14:48Richard Sergeant: Are they saying we're doing a great job in the wrong place?
- 14:51Richard Sergeant: Yeah, or is it obviously where we want to go?
- 14:54Richard Sergeant: And I think this is where, from a vendor perspective, they start developing things that that accountants don't need, so we get a lot of feature bloats, they start not fixing problems that have been there for a long time, which creates frustrations and workarounds.
- 15:09Richard Sergeant: It means that it just can seem things can seem like quite empty promises, or you can seem at odds with your customers at some certain points.
- 15:19Richard Sergeant: And I think the same true is true with accountants.
- 15:21Richard Sergeant: I used to a long time ago, when I was more engaged with accountants, we used to run these exercises of speaking to the partners and members of the team about what they thought their clients would say about them, and then we go and ask their clients, and the difference is often quite stark and sometimes quite upsetting as well for certain
- 15:40Paul Shrimpling: people.
- 15:40Richard Sergeant: And but actually, this is the this is the meaning it's like it's easy to know, but it's hard to find out, and then that's hard to reconcile sometimes, or those two things
- 16:49Paul Shrimpling: really making me think today, Richard.
- 16:51Paul Shrimpling: Thank you.
- 16:52Paul Shrimpling: Um all sorts in there.
- 16:58Paul Shrimpling: Uh what clients need and what clients want are sometimes different.
- 17:02Paul Shrimpling: Um I just wonder if you know, as a profession, as an individual accounting firm, as an individual leader or manager in a firm, are we obligated to deliver what the client needs or what the client wants, or is it a blend?
- 17:17Paul Shrimpling: I don't know what where does that take you?
- 17:19Richard Sergeant: Oh, glime, okay.
- 17:20Richard Sergeant: Um we obligated to give what they need.
- 17:24Richard Sergeant: Well, yes, but well, by by the very fact of being a profession, we're there to give what clients need, right?
- 17:30Richard Sergeant: Fundamentally, the and if you don't mind me saying so, the two central pillars for all accountancy firms out there is keeping people compliant and helping them to manage their tax bill.
- 17:39Richard Sergeant: Rest is kind of built around the the data, uh, the conversations, the relationships, and the kind of evolving progress that a client makes and and and and stumbles up needs that stumble across as they go through their own challenges and you know way through this life.
- 17:55Richard Sergeant: So the fundamentalist basically need do clients know what they want is an is another interesting kind of question.
- 18:02Richard Sergeant: Um I'm gonna go refer back to my boss and mentor Mark Lowbottom who debate a lot around the horrible nebulous term of advisory, and I don't want to debate the term, but I do want to kind of point, I think, point to something which I believe strongly is that most additional kind of the value-driving services are often questions emanating from the client, not emanating from the accountant.
- 18:28Richard Sergeant: So the client discovers a situation, a perspective, something that needs to be looked at, or as an itch that needs to be scratched, or they're facing something they don't quite understand.
- 18:38Richard Sergeant: So they're they're the ones who are generating the the question, the query, the inquiry.
- 18:45Richard Sergeant: We don't often have the accountants going to clients and trying to uncover those things on a more regular basis.
- 18:51Richard Sergeant: I think that's more that's harder to do, which is gotta go back to all in place and some of the stuff that they're trying to do there by getting tools.
- 18:58Richard Sergeant: I still think the
- 19:01Paul Shrimpling: majority of
- 19:02Richard Sergeant: what we do is reactive as accountants rather than by necessity, I think, reactive because we can't get to know all our clients all well potentially.
- 19:14Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, just if if we if uh uh any any firm sits um I'm loading this up uh in terms of making it edge, uh maybe edgy, maybe not, uh but they sit back on their laurels and wait for the questions from the clients and respond well.
- 19:34Paul Shrimpling: That's one way of um uh running the firm, you know.
- 19:39Paul Shrimpling: Um that we do that brilliantly, but if the client doesn't know what they don't know, they ain't gonna ask the questions that might have a profound impact on their business.
- 19:46Paul Shrimpling: I'm just this is coming from a really personal position, Richard.
- 19:49Paul Shrimpling: I ran a business with my dad for 12 years,
- 19:53Richard Sergeant: yeah.
- 19:53Paul Shrimpling: And you know, you know, green behind the gills, I didn't know any, you know, I was you know, it was from 19 onwards.
- 19:59Paul Shrimpling: Um uh I didn't know what to ask, I didn't I didn't know where my problems were.
- 20:06Paul Shrimpling: And uh I I after that 12-year window, when I ended up working in the profession, I look back at that and go, Goodness me, if I'd have had a different accountant who posed questions that challenged my thinking, I'd have made different decisions, and if I'd have made different decisions, maybe I'd have had a better business and I wouldn't have blown it 12 years later, which is what I did.
- 20:28Paul Shrimpling: Uh so there's that do we sit on our laurels and wait to react to the questions our clients ask?
- 20:34Paul Shrimpling: Or do we take seriously the and like you know, the all-in-place model is go and ask some questions about them and their lives as business owners, not just about the business.
- 20:44Paul Shrimpling: So the skill of asking questions then becomes, and that you know, you and I, I'm sure we could have a brilliant debate around advisory because it's an overused word and and and really weakly implemented in most meetings with most clients in most firms,
- 20:58Richard Sergeant: yeah,
- 20:59Paul Shrimpling: and yet the opportunity there is massive in terms of building a deeper trusted relationship.
- 21:04Richard Sergeant: Yes.
- 21:05Paul Shrimpling: Um I'm showboating a little bit here, just trying to stimulate some thought.
- 21:10Paul Shrimpling: Is that is it is it hard to ask a question?
- 21:14Paul Shrimpling: So
- 21:15Richard Sergeant: not hard to ask.
- 21:16Richard Sergeant: Are
- 21:16Paul Shrimpling: you where you want it to be?
- 21:17Richard Sergeant: No, I don't think it's hard to ask a question, but there's a discipline around that which is quite hard to instill when you're doing the day job.
- 21:23Richard Sergeant: And I think to a certain extent there's an embarrassment as well, a little bit.
- 21:26Richard Sergeant: Reluctant to ask.
- 21:27Richard Sergeant: Well, reluctant to ask maybe some personal questions when asking for permission to ask some things is probably not gonna ruffle any feathers at all.
- 21:37Richard Sergeant: Um covering some of the covering some of the starting a conversation based on the business is always so safe territory, but that quickly then kind of then can lead into con, should, could potentially quickly lead into conversations about how that impacts how much you're extracting and what you want to do with it, and then talking more broadly about family situation and what your aims and ambitions are and putting some of that in place, asking the question if they've ever had the opportunity to sit down and think about it.
- 22:04Richard Sergeant: So I agree with you that it's it doesn't sound particularly difficult.
- 22:09Richard Sergeant: I also kind of like worked with enough businesses to the practices to know that they are constantly running at a really high pace, you know, and the intensity in working in practice when you're you know your dates and deadlines align, and you know, and all the complexities are actually being in practice, the compliance burden on firms, let alone the compliance burden on their clients, has increased enormously over the years.
- 22:34Richard Sergeant: And although technology is my you know more where I s where I sit, I don't see a lot of that technology actually helping.
- 22:42Richard Sergeant: And and so kind of building up systems and processes that don't seem to ease the burden, we just kind of use them because we understand that they're there to.
- 22:53Richard Sergeant: The cope were increasingly enforced on people to use.
- 22:57Richard Sergeant: And so I don't take for granted how tricky it is asking the additional when you're already trying to do the job.
- 23:07Paul Shrimpling: Too much.
- 23:08Richard Sergeant: Yeah.
- 23:10Paul Shrimpling: Does that excuse it
- 23:10Richard Sergeant: though, Paul?
- 23:11Richard Sergeant: And I would say it doesn't.
- 23:13Paul Shrimpling: I
- 23:13Richard Sergeant: don't think, and I don't think it does excuse the fact, but I think there are ways in which you can do that.
- 23:18Richard Sergeant: Just like there are times when it's right to change technology tools.
- 23:23Richard Sergeant: I mean you can fit it around the cadence of your year and your clients year.
- 23:27Richard Sergeant: There are opportunities for you to sit with your clients and just push in different directions quite gently to begin with, if you're not sure, not so sure.
- 23:36Richard Sergeant: But
- 23:37Paul Shrimpling: yeah.
- 23:38Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I I yeah, I we could debate the word push as opposed to pull.
- 23:42Paul Shrimpling: I think asking a question is a bit of a pull thing as opposed to a push thing, but perhaps we need to push ourselves to pose one or two of those questions.
- 23:50Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 23:50Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, that's exactly
- 23:51Richard Sergeant: what push ourselves to just push out the conversation a little bit more.
- 23:56Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 23:57Paul Shrimpling: No, I've just I've just written down, you know, asking about the business is safe, asking about the person is sensitive and therefore less safe, they're less comfortable.
- 24:07Richard Sergeant: Paradoxically, can I just pick on some though?
- 24:09Richard Sergeant: Because we're not a lot of training with deliver a lot of training to vendors.
- 24:13Richard Sergeant: And one of the things which we do in some of the training courses, we look at these different things called businesses, business entities.
- 24:20Richard Sergeant: So, what's the difference between these business entity types?
- 24:23Richard Sergeant: Which is like you know, business one-on-one type stuff, really.
- 24:26Richard Sergeant: But that only gives you part of the story, and what a big part of the training delivery is going, okay, you understand that to service a limited company, there are certain actions and certain requirements that they might have that you can do.
- 24:37Richard Sergeant: But actually, you also then need to know exactly what that business does in order to be able to serve it.
- 24:42Richard Sergeant: Now, to me, vendors to go and talk to accountants about them and their business and their ambitions and their desires for the future and how they want their practice to run is incredibly hard to get answers from.
- 24:55Paul Shrimpling: It's
- 24:56Richard Sergeant: really difficult because it's a big question, and then all you can see is log jams.
- 25:00Richard Sergeant: You know, that's
- 25:03Paul Shrimpling: a lot where the problems lie.
- 25:06Richard Sergeant: Where do you want to even want to how do I unpick this?
- 25:08Richard Sergeant: In like the small time we're gonna have together.
- 25:10Richard Sergeant: So I always say, well,
- 25:11Paul Shrimpling: yeah,
- 25:12Richard Sergeant: you know, you're gonna bash on the door a lot if you just focus on that.
- 25:16Richard Sergeant: What you often get better luck from is that position of psychological safety, which is talking about their clients.
- 25:23Richard Sergeant: So tell me, give me an example of your kind of clients that you deal with.
- 25:28Richard Sergeant: Tell me about so and so.
- 25:30Richard Sergeant: Tell me about and and and and it's the clients, the client, they're really happy to talk about their clients.
- 25:36Richard Sergeant: The problems, the challenges, the good ones, the exciting ones, the old duffers, whoever it is, and all of it.
- 25:41Richard Sergeant: And to start the conversation and to explore that gives vendors huge amounts of information about how
- 25:48Paul Shrimpling: that
- 25:49Richard Sergeant: practice works and operates, and importantly, the challenges of servicing and dealing with those clients.
- 25:55Richard Sergeant: And also, it starts a different point of the relationship that you then can start talking to your accounting partner or prospect in a way that says, actually, I understand your business now, I understand more about your business, and we can use that as a way of starting to unpick maybe some of the challenges that you've got I can help you with.
- 26:16Paul Shrimpling: Brilliant.
- 26:17Paul Shrimpling: Actually, it elevates the relationship, and so therefore, you've probably end up with a more loyal client who's likely to buy more, pay more, recommend you, etc.
- 26:32Paul Shrimpling: etc.
- 26:32Paul Shrimpling: in in simple terms.
- 26:34Paul Shrimpling: Um, there's two things in that Richard that are really in terms of uh simple skills that we can just signpost.
- 26:43Paul Shrimpling: One is you you you mentioned the maybe you're in a business conversation with a business owner, just having a transition question, uh, and you call you know, ask permission.
- 26:54Paul Shrimpling: Would it be alright if I just asked you one or two questions of uh that of less business business of more about you and your what's going on for you in the business?
- 27:04Paul Shrimpling: And you know, if someone says no, but still, you know, we don't know, you know, that's the worst thing that can happen.
- 27:09Paul Shrimpling: But the best thing that happens is say yes, and then you're gonna ask a what or a how or a
- 27:13Richard Sergeant: uh
- 27:14Paul Shrimpling: you know when question that then dives into that personal space.
- 27:18Paul Shrimpling: But you could make that even easier by going, uh, can I ask permission?
- 27:21Paul Shrimpling: I just wanted to would it be okay if I ask a few questions about your clients,
- 27:25Richard Sergeant: yeah, and
- 27:25Paul Shrimpling: then all of that's almost an easy way into and you know changing into a different conversation, a more elevated conversation, and ultimately their customers pay their wages and their teams' wages, and the future revolves around them doing a good job with them, so you're in a really good place.
- 27:42Paul Shrimpling: I like that a lot, Richard.
- 27:43Richard Sergeant: Yeah, I mean I I I I I don't know how it'd work for accountants, it'd be interesting to try for sure.
- 27:48Richard Sergeant: I think like I said, elevating the conversation because you understand not just how the numbers are working, but the kind of what's motivating their customers, their clients to buy from them.
- 28:01Richard Sergeant: I mean, that's actually kind of really kind of interesting.
- 28:04Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, of course it is.
- 28:05Paul Shrimpling: I mean it may you know, I'm just thinking of you know port as five forces here, you know, in terms of where what what's um just if you're wondering what I'm talking about, just Google it, you know.
- 28:16Paul Shrimpling: But but there's the um one of the forces is your customers.
- 28:21Paul Shrimpling: You know, who's got the power in the relationship?
- 28:24Paul Shrimpling: Is it the customer or is it the accountant?
- 28:25Paul Shrimpling: Now, if we just like step out of the accounting space into the businesses space, they've got customers that might have a lot of power over them.
- 28:32Paul Shrimpling: They might have two key suppliers who have a lot of power over in influencing their business, and so being really curious about their customers or their suppliers or their team, just asking about the humans in the business,
- 28:48Richard Sergeant: yeah,
- 28:48Paul Shrimpling: changes the conversation out of just I mean, I nearly said just the numbers.
- 28:53Paul Shrimpling: I'm like you, Richard.
- 28:55Paul Shrimpling: It you can't use just in a sentence with numbers in it because the numbers are jugular to knowing whether a business is working well and it's going to progress well.
- 29:03Richard Sergeant: Yeah.
- 29:03Richard Sergeant: So
- 29:04Paul Shrimpling: yes, unbelievable, unbelievable.
- 29:07Paul Shrimpling: Um, and so asking permission to talk about suppliers, team members, uh customers, clients, or new entrants into their uh into their space, the competition, you know, they are com, you know, there's two or three or four conversations, but you I your point, well made, and it's never come up on any podcast before, is just ask permission to just can I just ask a bit a little bit about your customers?
- 29:33Paul Shrimpling: Can I just ask a little bit about your suppliers?
- 29:35Paul Shrimpling: Can I just ask a little bit about what's going on with your team?
- 29:38Paul Shrimpling: And all of a sudden they're just gonna go and vomit all over you
- 29:41Richard Sergeant: in
- 29:42Paul Shrimpling: a really good way, maybe.
- 29:43Richard Sergeant: Well, okay.
- 29:44Richard Sergeant: And actually, you know what, what do we like doing?
- 29:46Richard Sergeant: We like we like talking about ourselves, but actually talking about ourselves sometimes isn't easy, and and so what we do know, and what we're often quite happy to talk about, is what we do rather than about ourselves.
- 30:01Richard Sergeant: So actually shifting the competition to our jobs, our clients, our things, because we're the experts, aren't we?
- 30:08Richard Sergeant: The accountant isn't intended to be the expert, but they can be curious.
- 30:15Paul Shrimpling: I think that you know the the curiosity about the business, great, curious about the customers of the business, curious about the suppliers, curious about the team, any other humans that are you know, key advisors, I don't you know, don't know, um, is a a gateway to an elevated, different conversation that delivers greater value, um, drops into the all-in-one place space when it's about them, but that's at the real sensitive end, talking about their customers and the suppliers is not so sensitive, but we can you know build towards the more sensitive stuff as the conversation unfolds, and maybe that's for meeting two or meeting three later in the uh calendar with our client.
- 30:55Paul Shrimpling: Please forgive this brief interruption.
- 30:57Paul Shrimpling: Richard and I have been talking about curiosity, asking questions of clients in a slightly different way, and we'll unpack a little bit more of that on the podcast.
- 31:06Paul Shrimpling: But if you want to dive deeper into how you ask better questions, check out the business breakthrough report in the show notes called Ask Better Questions.
- 31:16Paul Shrimpling: Now let's get back to Richard.
- 31:18Richard Sergeant: It's also as well, isn't it?
- 31:19Richard Sergeant: There was a well one of my one of my favourite old uh accountants from old, an old, very old customer of mine.
- 31:25Richard Sergeant: It's not that he's an old man, an old customer of mine, Stevie Knowles from Knowles Work.
- 31:29Richard Sergeant: You feel it out there, Steve?
- 31:30Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I've met Steve, yeah, a long time ago.
- 31:32Paul Shrimpling: Right.
- 31:32Paul Shrimpling: So I had some
- 31:33Richard Sergeant: interesting experiences with Steve, and I keep telling him about this that he's probably said something to me 23, 24 years ago that stuck with me a lot.
- 31:40Richard Sergeant: The first is we made a monumental cock-up serving him as our client, and uh, I went all the way to Manchester.
- 31:47Richard Sergeant: Oh, we went to Sheffield to go and see him, effectively to apologize.
- 31:50Richard Sergeant: And his graciousness was was unbound, and I really remired that.
- 31:55Richard Sergeant: And he and he was very, very honest and frank with me about stuff, and but never an un never an unkind word, it was entirely constructive and brilliant.
- 32:03Richard Sergeant: I've always appreciated that as an approach.
- 32:04Richard Sergeant: But the other thing he said to me during the same meeting was we totally overestimate the financial literacy of business owners,
- 32:12Paul Shrimpling: yeah.
- 32:12Richard Sergeant: And I really that really struck with me because it goes to your point, Paul, about the things you would have known while you're in business.
- 32:19Richard Sergeant: Actually, it's we don't as business owners, we don't often know exactly what the question is we need to ask, but we know that there's some kind of spider sense kind of tingling, and I've experienced my own business where I think this is what's wrong.
- 32:34Richard Sergeant: But actually, once it's nothing that's wrong, but it's a signal of the fact that I don't understand how this stuff works, and I've
- 32:42Paul Shrimpling: had
- 32:42Richard Sergeant: to go and find out with my accountable how this how this stuff or how does this what what does that mean?
- 32:48Richard Sergeant: How does that mean that and
- 32:50Paul Shrimpling: how
- 32:50Richard Sergeant: does it impact the changes that I needed to work to make in my business?
- 32:53Richard Sergeant: Understanding that I have seasonality in my business when I thought I was just a year-round business, and the reality is I don't.
- 32:59Richard Sergeant: I've got the numbers to back it up going over 10 years, and that kind of stuff is really important, I think.
- 33:07Richard Sergeant: Understanding that clients do need support, they're not experts in the numbers.
- 33:13Richard Sergeant: Sometimes we need to ask, listen to the what they might be signalling to us, might be something which needs exploring because it's it's not that that they're after, it's something else.
- 33:26Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 33:29Paul Shrimpling: And there's a skill in that, isn't there, in terms of looking for those um those signals.
- 33:35Paul Shrimpling: Um, but your point, I think, very well made, is that you know you as an accountant accountancy professional have got the curse of knowledge, you know, you know you know how to interpret it, and sometimes it makes it harder to therefore explain because you know so much, you explain it from a position of knowing as opposed to explaining it from a position of um I don't know what you're talking about.
- 34:02Richard Sergeant: Yeah,
- 34:02Paul Shrimpling: um, but it's you've a danger of patronizing in there, isn't there, as well, which you need to avoid, I guess.
- 34:10Paul Shrimpling: Um
- 34:11Richard Sergeant: yeah, like again, I I I stand on the shoulders of giants again.
- 34:15Richard Sergeant: But um Jonathan Gore of FD works here, you know,
- 34:19Paul Shrimpling: yeah, yeah.
- 34:20Richard Sergeant: I mean he's
- 34:21Paul Shrimpling: he's been on the podcast as well.
- 34:22Paul Shrimpling: I'll get his in we'll get we'll get that link in the show next as well.
- 34:27Richard Sergeant: Yeah, sorry I'm interested.
- 34:28Richard Sergeant: Really slipstreaming here.
- 34:29Richard Sergeant: Um but I really like what I've always enjoyed talking to Jonathan is the fact that he's seamer qualified, and management accountants kind of have a very uh slightly different perspective, much more kind of commercially minded, looking from the perspective of working within a business and bringing a slightly different kind of perspective to some of those kind of conversations, they're looking for things.
- 34:54Richard Sergeant: And I like the some of the things Jonathan always used to used to say to me, which is like, you know, we're not the experts in the business, the business owner can walk into a place and know that that machine's not running right, or something instinctively that we know needs to be looked at.
- 35:11Richard Sergeant: But our job is to help kind of uncover that and substantiate what that might be, or to point in the direction where they might like to look and make some changes and adjustments.
- 35:22Richard Sergeant: And I like that kind of collaborative sense around that.
- 35:24Richard Sergeant: You don't even have to be the expert in the business, but you can be the detective, you know, responding to the client, concern, query, whatever it is,
- 35:34Paul Shrimpling: yeah,
- 35:34Richard Sergeant: and offer enormous amounts of value by you know not letting it lie and wanting to discover.
- 35:41Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 35:42Paul Shrimpling: And if you're in that sort of yes, collaborative is a uh I think it's an important word because it positions you with the expert in the business.
- 35:52Paul Shrimpling: You're the uh you're the expert at numbers.
- 35:56Paul Shrimpling: Um the two together collaborating is a very powerful force.
- 36:00Paul Shrimpling: Um, if together we can be detectives and using your word, you know, be curious about the other humans in the business, them as and their lives, you know, where the issues lie with their suppliers, with their customers, uh, within what the business is delivering you and your family over the next five to ten years, or it there's that curiosity piece.
- 36:21Paul Shrimpling: Um, but it's looking for signals that's bugging me now because I think that's a really important insight.
- 36:28Paul Shrimpling: Um, and then what do you do when you spot a signal?
- 36:31Paul Shrimpling: What do you do?
- 36:32Paul Shrimpling: So, what how do you think those signals manifest themselves, Richard?
- 36:37Richard Sergeant: Well, in business owners.
- 36:39Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, well, business owners, or I think ultimately you go into an accountanty firm, that's a business.
- 36:44Paul Shrimpling: So if you as a you know from a the vendor perspective are spotting signals, there won't be much dissimilar to the signals that an accountant, when they drop into a different business,
- 36:53Richard Sergeant: yeah,
- 36:53Paul Shrimpling: is seeing or hearing or experiencing.
- 36:56Richard Sergeant: Yeah.
- 36:57Richard Sergeant: It's really interesting, actually, and I think there's kind of slightly involved.
- 37:00Richard Sergeant: My position on this is kind of evolving a little bit at the moment, I think.
- 37:04Richard Sergeant: And I think it's because the vendor space has evolved so much in the last 20 years as well.
- 37:12Richard Sergeant: And what we tended to have is if you go back to like 2000s, I'm not I don't want to turn into the history lecture of the technology world, but if you go back like 20 years or so, or the early 2000s, solutions were there really to kind of just improve on what was already there.
- 37:29Richard Sergeant: You know, so we had an incumbent in the bookkeeping space, his sage, you know, and they they were they were unbothered by competition, and effectively they became more bothered by competition when other products or other viable products started to sub to take root, including things like zero and and so on and so forth.
- 37:51Richard Sergeant: But that was really replicating to a certain extent stuff that was already there, it was just the way it was delivered, just kind of changed.
- 37:59Richard Sergeant: And we had a strong period where just giving enhancements to and finding things which replicated were all were already in place was very much the thing.
- 38:11Richard Sergeant: So here's an alternative to what we've already got, and then kind of ideas kind of started to kind of go starting to splinter.
- 38:20Richard Sergeant: Now we have the bit there are gaps from which we can fill.
- 38:23Richard Sergeant: So we've so a vendor kind of goes, okay, there's a gap between doing your books and getting the data in.
- 38:29Richard Sergeant: So you have the likes of a seat bank evolving over time, saying, How can we make that process of getting data in easier?
- 38:37Richard Sergeant: So then we have this kind of like spotting gaps and funneling things through, which were augmented augmentations to process, but that kind of then just kind of seems to have proliferated to the point now where vendors are generating ideas and trying to convince people that this is something that they should do.
- 38:55Richard Sergeant: And I find that quite challenging to deal with because it's about trying to say we are a solution for as many people as possible, therefore, we need to try and you know find those people and convince them to come with us.
- 39:09Richard Sergeant: And I think that's where a lot of sales tension has come up and a lot of acquisition of of technology is kind of come from.
- 39:19Richard Sergeant: What I think is starting to evolve now is a much that marketplace is much more mature from the buyer side.
- 39:27Richard Sergeant: So accountants are up to the rivals in tech.
- 39:29Richard Sergeant: They spend a lot of money on tech.
- 39:32Richard Sergeant: You know, I did some research with accounting web accounting web intelligence stuff.
- 39:36Richard Sergeant: It was in 2004, 5.
- 39:38Richard Sergeant: I think it's still highly you know relevant now, the numbers.
- 39:41Richard Sergeant: So just to kind of what that said is that um back in 2010 I did a lot of work with brokers, people buying and selling practices, and I saw lots of anonymised PLs.
- 39:51Richard Sergeant: And what I was looking for, why I'm a figure of interest to it, was the technology costline, and that as a percentage of revenue kind of gave me this figure of how much it costs to service clients for tech.
- 40:03Richard Sergeant: I mean, roughly, and it was always always 4% pool.
- 40:07Richard Sergeant: I mean it's metronomically 4%.
- 40:09Richard Sergeant: When we re-ran that service back in, I've re-run that those data and tried to get it five, six hundred firms came back, and the average is seven point six, which is nearly doubled, right?
- 40:22Richard Sergeant: And the larger the firm, the more likely they are to be around that seven, eight percent mark.
- 40:28Richard Sergeant: The smaller the firm, the much more likely it was going to be 10% or more.
- 40:34Paul Shrimpling: As
- 40:34Richard Sergeant: much as 14-15%.
- 40:36Richard Sergeant: You know, what that says to me is a couple of things.
- 40:39Richard Sergeant: The first thing is that larger firms are able to kind of get better discounts and but also get better marginal gains out of introducing things, and the second thing is that generally we are accumulating costs and not converting that into revenue, and don't worry and worry about the profit part, it's just the revenue side where you're not actually seeing that kind of one boost, the juice kind of coming through, and that kind of concerns me a little bit, and and that's goes to that first thing about how do you get value out of these relationships from the accountant's perspective, and then that yeah,
- 41:12Paul Shrimpling: so
- 41:12Richard Sergeant: now we're in a point where we are saturated with technology, it's an expense that we can quantify within the business quite well and its impact.
- 41:23Richard Sergeant: It doesn't look amazing, and at the same time, you know, we're being told we need more or different stuff that we're doing, and I think what's happening is slowly and surely is that people are starting to go, okay, let's start with what it is that I need, and being much more conscious in and what I'm advocating for a lot more these days is start with your business case and don't worry about what the solution is.
- 41:49Richard Sergeant: You know, your solutions will come to you once you kind of understand that you've kind of got a problem, and if you as a firm can define what that problem is, and there's some very simple ways of doing that, I think.
- 42:00Richard Sergeant: If you follow a process to establish a business case and do the hard yards internally to understand what that is, your solution path becomes a lot lot quicker and a lot easier, and the the power rests a little bit more with you rather than with the vendor trying to convince you that you need to change lots and things differently.
- 42:24Richard Sergeant: And I think that's what we're starting to see.
- 42:27Richard Sergeant: And I like I said, I'm I'm I'm advocating for more and more these days is how do we create the signals to vendors has been on you look like you fit, we're gonna talk to you.
- 42:40Richard Sergeant: Now I think what the singles signals need to be is here is what our problem and what our challenge is, this is what we're trying to do and trying to get out of the problem.
- 42:48Richard Sergeant: How do you fit into that picture?
- 42:50Richard Sergeant: How do you fit into that chip?
- 42:53Richard Sergeant: So I think the signals often change.
- 42:56Paul Shrimpling: So it says, is the shift the fact that the the buyers, the accountants in this case are getting um more aware of the costs, savvier around the tech anyway, and therefore being more choosy, but haven't necessarily jumped into the space you're advocating there, which is work out what the business case is, what the problem it is that you're trying to fix before you get anywhere near a conversation with any tech provider.
- 43:19Paul Shrimpling: Um so we're on that journey into that um um have it fit.
- 43:24Paul Shrimpling: Are we are we also therefore heading into a place where we're we're uh we're in the need for bespoke pieces from firm to firm?
- 43:32Paul Shrimpling: Is is does that is that the natural follow-on to it?
- 43:35Paul Shrimpling: I
- 43:36Richard Sergeant: don't think so.
- 43:36Richard Sergeant: I don't and I don't think but I I think the choices are out there now are starting to reveal themselves.
- 43:43Richard Sergeant: So there are ways in which you that if you can map out an end-to-end process, there are parts of those that can be very few vendors kind of occupy the whole of a process.
- 43:56Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, of course.
- 43:57Richard Sergeant: So in which case, which bit are you struggling with?
- 44:00Richard Sergeant: And the answer at the moment from vendors is well, we'll do that bit for you, and they create these connections between things, and
- 44:08Paul Shrimpling: you
- 44:09Richard Sergeant: know that's kind of how we'll work it.
- 44:10Richard Sergeant: So you end up bolting up, bolting together all these different bits of kit and kind of hoping it all kind of works together.
- 44:17Richard Sergeant: I think that's evolving and changing now because we've got other tools which are emerging that mean that you can still keep those vendors in place to do the core bits that we're super confident that they can deliver on, but maybe there are different ways in which we can handle some of the other bits.
- 44:35Richard Sergeant: So defining what your process is and then identifying where the blocks are and where the challenges are, I think helps to redefine this idea of what we're looking from from vendors.
- 44:47Richard Sergeant: And there are tools increasingly out there, and they're not all there yet, but increasingly out there that counts and Will be able to utilize either by themselves or with internal teams or with external consultants that can help create those pathways to ease things forward.
- 45:04Richard Sergeant: I think that's where it's going at the moment.
- 45:07Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, brilliant.
- 45:08Paul Shrimpling: Um there's I don't know before just because we're in the middle of recording this, I don't know where the podcast that I recorded last week with Ryan Tierney is in the mix.
- 45:18Paul Shrimpling: So it's either just before this one or just after this one, Richard.
- 45:21Paul Shrimpling: Um, but it's imminent if it's not already uh in the uh in the library when you listen to this.
- 45:25Paul Shrimpling: So Ryan uh runs a manufactur two manufacturing businesses, one's in the metal racking space and then and the other one's in the um uh uh uh chairs for people with significant disabilities.
- 45:38Paul Shrimpling: They call it the they make life-changing chairs for people who really need support and help.
- 45:43Paul Shrimpling: Um and he's applied uh the Toyota production system, simplified it profoundly, and has created this culture of improvement, and it's a real deep cultural improvement.
- 46:01Paul Shrimpling: So there's half the team are making an improvement on their work position every week.
- 46:07Paul Shrimpling: So half of them do it this week, half of them do it next week.
- 46:10Paul Shrimpling: It doesn't quite work that cleanly,
- 46:12Richard Sergeant: and
- 46:12Paul Shrimpling: basically everyone's doing two improvements a month every month across 60 odd people in CT Matters, which is the name of the business, the uh chair making business.
- 46:22Paul Shrimpling: Sparrow Metals is just instigating that.
- 46:25Paul Shrimpling: That's been running for and building over eight years.
- 46:27Paul Shrimpling: In Sparrow Metals, it's he's only in there for what 12, 12, 15 months now.
- 46:32Paul Shrimpling: Um, but they have very much have defined the process from the start to finish and worked out where's the where's the key improvement that we need to make in terms of investing time, effort, and energy.
- 46:45Paul Shrimpling: And as they make make remove all the big lumpy problems, then we're looking fine-tuning the next layer, and then because they're really clear on your recommendation there around define the process around payroll, define the process around bookkeeping, define the process around and that and what they are really good at, and what Ryan's really good at and his team are really good at is from the client's perspective, the moments that the client experiences is that's where the value is.
- 47:15Paul Shrimpling: If we're divide designing a process that suits you,
- 47:18Richard Sergeant: yeah,
- 47:19Paul Shrimpling: but isn't connected to the client, you won't build value into your process, and you'll probably buy technology that is going to undermine the profitability of your business rather than contribute to it because it's not connected to the client value.
- 47:31Paul Shrimpling: Yes.
- 47:32Richard Sergeant: Well, I think that's super important, actually, Paul.
- 47:34Richard Sergeant: I would advocate, and when I again when I do consultancy work with the vendors that I work with, some of the things are about that kind of customer experience part, I would I would kind of say, but the important thing is like this is how it works for you internally, and let's be really super clear about how that works end-to-end, and then you've got to flip the whole thing on its head and say, This is what your customer experience is.
- 47:59Richard Sergeant: So, what is the very next thing that they do?
- 48:02Richard Sergeant: Not skip it, not say, and then they onboard and then they do this and that.
- 48:06Richard Sergeant: It's like, well, what is that onboarding process?
- 48:08Richard Sergeant: What are you what are you doing?
- 48:09Richard Sergeant: What are all those infinitely small steps?
- 48:13Richard Sergeant: And it's a real pain in the ass to do, but you can map out this is what we think is going on to this is the reality of what our current kind experience is.
- 48:21Richard Sergeant: And you look at the two, it's enormously powerful, enormously powerful.
- 48:26Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, huge, huge, and it's that you know, that's real leadership and management work to improve the processes rather than be running around like a scattered cat with the next job, which was the point you were making earlier.
- 48:37Paul Shrimpling: How do we how do we actually reduce the noise and the overload of work and tone that down?
- 48:48Paul Shrimpling: Well, actually, improve the processes, free up time, use the technology well, free up time, and instead of throwing more of the same work into the pot, start to have deeper, more meaningful conversations with your clients,
- 49:01Richard Sergeant: yeah, which
- 49:02Paul Shrimpling: will build a value equation potentially.
- 49:04Richard Sergeant: Yeah, yeah.
- 49:05Richard Sergeant: I'm always interested in that, and I love your your perspective on this, is that is the um who within the business is able to ask the questions.
- 49:14Richard Sergeant: So, you know, I my my my accountant, if we will, I deal with a a partner, it's very nice.
- 49:23Richard Sergeant: I've been passed from partner to partner.
- 49:25Richard Sergeant: I'm a training client, I accept that, you know.
- 49:27Richard Sergeant: But the people I deal with on a day-to-day basis, all the people that my you know my my uh my person deals with kind of are are not the partners.
- 49:39Richard Sergeant: So the day-to-day stuff is very, very functional, and then um and they're quite genius, some of them aren't even qualified yet.
- 49:47Paul Shrimpling: Yes.
- 49:47Richard Sergeant: Who's able to ask the questions to open up those conversations?
- 49:51Paul Shrimpling: Yeah.
- 49:52Paul Shrimpling: What's behind you asking, posing that question, Richard?
- 49:57Richard Sergeant: I think it's a couple of things.
- 49:58Richard Sergeant: The first is that it's a practical problem.
- 50:01Richard Sergeant: You know, if we if we heap even more responsibility on a few people, is that the right thing to do?
- 50:06Richard Sergeant: I don't know.
- 50:06Richard Sergeant: But the second thing is around how do we bring people into the practice?
- 50:10Richard Sergeant: What are we asking them to do, what we're training them to do, where do they learn, whose knees are they sitting at to get this kind of information?
- 50:19Richard Sergeant: And some of my concerns around the ambiguous noise of you know gazing into the future around a world of technology that could do everything for you, you know, why do we need all these people to do low menial kind of jobs?
- 50:39Richard Sergeant: I think is utterly demeaning to the profession to a certain extent.
- 50:43Paul Shrimpling: Yeah.
- 50:43Richard Sergeant: But at the same time, I can see what you're talking about.
- 50:46Richard Sergeant: You know, we wouldn't advocate people to do low-value jobs if they can be automated.
- 50:51Richard Sergeant: We think that was probably a good thing.
- 50:53Richard Sergeant: But what are we taking away from the experience of being in that job and learning about that job?
- 50:59Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I know.
- 50:59Paul Shrimpling: I think that's powerful.
- 51:00Paul Shrimpling: And I think that's why I think um when I was running my manufacturing business with my father, we we went round Toyota Bernaston to get a real sense as to what a process managed business really looks like at scale and applied it to our manufacturing business in our way, you know, unique to us, but taking those benefits.
- 51:21Paul Shrimpling: I think I'm circling back to the process improvement at the and I'm uh what I've written down as you were talking there, uh Richard, is there's there's different layers of conversation taking place between accountant and customer client.
- 51:36Paul Shrimpling: There's the partner level business leader conversation, business leader to partner conversation.
- 51:40Paul Shrimpling: There's the financial controller to whoever the equivalent is in the accountancy firm level, and then there's the bookkeeper to bookkeeper level type conversation.
- 51:51Paul Shrimpling: No, okay, that's me oversimplifying it, but ultimately those three, and you want if you want, yeah, if you want to have another layer, then great.
- 51:58Paul Shrimpling: Um I'm just it's that who in the business can ask questions.
- 52:03Paul Shrimpling: Well, the bookkeeper level people should be having a conversation where there's greater curiosity about what's going on, but have a sense as to what their internal customer is.
- 52:13Paul Shrimpling: Because you know, not everyone's dealing directly and influencing the end client, the end customer, they've got an internal customer who then does that.
- 52:22Paul Shrimpling: Um, and it's and that's straight out of the Toyota production system is how do we improve the processes between our internal person talking to our client's bookkeeper?
- 52:32Paul Shrimpling: Well, using your words from this discussion, how do you collaborate better to smooth it so it's better for the client so that you do less work?
- 52:41Paul Shrimpling: Is not where we've been as a profession because we chart have been charging by the hour, as opposed to let's improve the processes for the client and increase the value to the client.
- 52:50Richard Sergeant: Yes.
- 52:51Richard Sergeant: But and as customers, and I am a customer of accountant, I don't care how the work's done.
- 52:56Paul Shrimpling: No,
- 52:57Richard Sergeant: you don't really don't care.
- 52:58Richard Sergeant: As long as it's quick and easy and it's timely.
- 53:01Richard Sergeant: And it's a standard, that's that's what I'm after.
- 53:07Richard Sergeant: It's what else am I expecting?
- 53:11Richard Sergeant: I I have I'm actually fairly kind of relaxed about my expectations, if that makes sense.
- 53:16Richard Sergeant: What I expect from them is to be my insurance policy.
- 53:19Richard Sergeant: So if I have a question or something I don't understand, they're gonna give me an answer or an insight which is based around me and my business, not a generic answer I could get from ChatGPT that you know would give me lots of information, but probably not the right because it doesn't have contacts.
- 53:38Richard Sergeant: And so what I'm expecting, I'm expecting to be there for me.
- 53:41Richard Sergeant: I think if they asked me to pay for more stuff and formalise that relationship, I'd be happy to do that, but not right now.
- 53:58Paul Shrimpling: Just in case they're listening.
- 54:01Richard Sergeant: That's right, because I don't I don't I've kind of gone through a period, I've kind of gone through a period of working together to kind of to put certain things in place.
- 54:11Richard Sergeant: So actually the ongoing check-ins from it don't make sense for what I need them to do.
- 54:17Richard Sergeant: But what I'm trying to say is that I don't expect them to give me everything for the price that I'm paying.
- 54:22Richard Sergeant: And I do expect to pay for the stuff that
- 54:26Paul Shrimpling: I
- 54:27Richard Sergeant: do expect them to pay pay for stuff, and if I'm gonna have a service that requires them to more deeply engage with me in my business, then I would be happy to pay for it, providing that I thought it was appropriate, proportionate, and gonna deliver value.
- 54:41Richard Sergeant: I don't want to have a quarterly meeting with somebody just for the sake of it, if that makes sense.
- 54:46Paul Shrimpling: No, indeed.
- 54:47Paul Shrimpling: Indeed.
- 54:48Paul Shrimpling: Um we when we talk and and train managers and leadership teams in and around this space, Rich, we talk about um uh the three uh three value elements.
- 55:00Paul Shrimpling: Uh now I talk about effing value, just because I like to, you know, just what E double F I N G.
- 55:06Paul Shrimpling: So E double F, there's um uh an emotional payoff, there's a functional payoff, and there's a financial payoff.
- 55:13Richard Sergeant: Okay.
- 55:14Paul Shrimpling: And are we doing a di is your accountant asking you questions that enable them to help you improve functionally what's going on in your business?
- 55:22Paul Shrimpling: So instead of you doing the payroll, someone else is doing the payroll in the firm, in the accounting firm, that's a functional payoff because it saves you time.
- 55:29Paul Shrimpling: Um, financial payoff, back to let's get back to compliance.
- 55:33Paul Shrimpling: Make sure you're paying only the amount of tax that you really need to pay, and let's ensure that you've got the um financial results of your business in a timely way so you can make better financial decisions.
- 55:43Paul Shrimpling: So we're in sort of financial and functional payoff a little bit there, but then there's what you talked about repeatedly, and this is the insurance, the protection, the reassurance.
- 55:52Paul Shrimpling: That's all an emotional payoff,
- 55:55Richard Sergeant: which
- 55:55Paul Shrimpling: is really hard to put a numbered value to, but is probably of more value than the functional and the financial at times, at some times, not all time, because this you know, clients' experience, their life, their business is fluctuating.
- 56:10Paul Shrimpling: So it's about timing and relevance is the best sales and marketing uh reference points of all time.
- 56:14Paul Shrimpling: If the timing's right and it's relevant, we're quids in.
- 56:17Paul Shrimpling: If the timing's wrong and it's relevant, we're quids out, you know.
- 56:19Richard Sergeant: Yeah, I know I like that.
- 56:20Richard Sergeant: I like that a lot.
- 56:22Richard Sergeant: I do want to say hello to my accountant though, because if they ever do watch this, I want to know they do appreciate them.
- 56:26Richard Sergeant: So I'm with TC Group and helping for years when there were terrorists in the books.
- 56:32Richard Sergeant: So yeah, hello, and thank you, Mark.
- 56:34Richard Sergeant: Thank you, uh the team there that look after me.
- 56:37Richard Sergeant: It's well I said the the the emotional payoff for me is has been there in terms of taking a w actually there was a crossover between the emotional and the functional, and to use your term, taking away stuff from me actually allowed me to do other stuff, and that was you know,
- 56:57Paul Shrimpling: yeah.
- 56:58Richard Sergeant: I don't even want to make my stun, you know, I don't even want to understand the fact that I can be given to somebody else is utterly reassuring, and I like that very much.
- 57:06Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, brilliant.
- 57:07Paul Shrimpling: Uh and it I I think it helps when it comes to what questions do you ask clients in that emotional space, the functional space, and the financial space, and all of a sudden both parties start to appreciate the value payoff just because there's been a curious conversation, a collaborative around a particular issue in the business or whatever.
- 57:27Paul Shrimpling: Um, very that's interesting
- 57:28Richard Sergeant: actually.
- 57:28Richard Sergeant: So just go back to that, your F model, F model.
- 57:31Richard Sergeant: I I
- 57:38Paul Shrimpling: yeah
- 57:38Richard Sergeant: I think the the development of that is it doesn't have to be based on inconvenience and pain, it can be based on opportunity as well.
- 57:46Richard Sergeant: So actually it's just as mapping out a process to find where the opportunities lie.
- 57:51Richard Sergeant: I think it's just as
- 57:52Paul Shrimpling: 100%.
- 57:53Richard Sergeant: Yeah,
- 57:53Paul Shrimpling: yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 57:54Paul Shrimpling: But I think just to turn that into a practical conversation, just because I'm coming off the back of my year-end com year-end meeting with my accountant last week, no, this week on Tuesday.
- 58:04Paul Shrimpling: Yeah.
- 58:04Paul Shrimpling: So uh this is uh my year ends uh 30th of June.
- 58:08Paul Shrimpling: Uh, we're now at on the 24th of July.
- 58:11Paul Shrimpling: I had my year-end meeting on Tuesday.
- 58:13Paul Shrimpling: Um, we do that every year because timing really matters to me.
- 58:17Paul Shrimpling: Not all clients are that pedantic about the timing, but that's that's a part of the value equation.
- 58:21Paul Shrimpling: And you know, you said you wanted it quick and easy.
- 58:24Paul Shrimpling: You know, the speed, the timeliness is part of the uh value equation as well.
- 58:28Paul Shrimpling: Um, where am I going with this?
- 58:30Paul Shrimpling: Um, you talked about yes, not just about pain, it's also about opportunity.
- 58:34Paul Shrimpling: Well, we had a conversation about the accounts over the last 12 months and what the grass looked like compared with previous financial years, and we also looked at the forecast and compared the forecast this year, going forwards compared with where we were with the forecast 12 months ago and how we performed against forecast.
- 58:50Paul Shrimpling: And so, and then we're looking at the opportunity within the forecast to grow the business, not just about the difficulties we've had over the last 12 months.
- 58:57Paul Shrimpling: And it's just there's a practical service level discussion, management accounts, annual accounts versus forecast is just a practical service, and I agree 100%.
- 59:07Paul Shrimpling: Let's have both conversations
- 59:09Richard Sergeant: because
- 59:09Paul Shrimpling: the value lies in the pain resolution and the helping the client um achieve or make better decisions, have the management information to make the most of the opportunities they face.
- 59:23Paul Shrimpling: But if you don't know what they are, you can't help them.
- 59:25Paul Shrimpling: So now we're being curious about the future of the can I ask permission and just talk about the future plans that you've got for the business.
- 59:31Richard Sergeant: Yeah.
- 59:31Paul Shrimpling: So for me, Richard, the standout, and I'm gonna ask you the question here, but the standout for me is the simple skill of asking permission to dive into a space that you might be slightly uncomfortable, they might be slightly uncomfortable.
- 59:42Paul Shrimpling: If they say yes, you've got let's just have a collaborative chat.
- 59:45Paul Shrimpling: I think just so powerful, simple, valuable, amazing.
- 59:52Paul Shrimpling: What in our conversation today, Richard, what's what stood out for you that's made you think in a deeper way that you think is relevant to maybe the vendors or relevant to the profession?
- 1:00:01Richard Sergeant: I think that there's two actually.
- 1:00:02Richard Sergeant: Um one is um the the uh I think the uh there's something we've said out loud which I kind of understand, but I think I understand it a little bit better now, which is this idea of what change is coming in terms of uh accountants understanding more about where what they need from their vendor relationships, and and and and not so much from the vendor relationship, but what are they looking for functionally?
- 1:00:33Richard Sergeant: So rather than being trying to take on board everything that's coming their way, which is difficult and challenging, is kind of saying, well, actually, we can we start from a position of ourselves and then we go and see if it fits our jigsaw puzzle.
- 1:00:45Richard Sergeant: So actually saying that aloud is quite was quite useful for me.
- 1:00:48Richard Sergeant: And the second thing is that you give me something to effing think about a little bit more.
- 1:00:52Richard Sergeant: I like that, and I can understand that it I can relate to it quite a lot, and I can see how how broadly powerful that will be.
- 1:01:03Richard Sergeant: And I'm gonna chew that one over a little bit more, I think.
- 1:01:07Paul Shrimpling: Brilliant, brilliant.
- 1:01:08Paul Shrimpling: Well, we uh I'd love to know what once you've chewed it over where it uh where it takes you.
- 1:01:13Paul Shrimpling: Um and and it's uh I think you know we started out very much on this conversation in that human space um and the curiosity piece.
- 1:01:23Paul Shrimpling: It's not just about the business, it's about the individual, and then we expanded that out into well, talk about the customers, talk about the suppliers, talk about the team.
- 1:01:31Paul Shrimpling: And so there's you know, you're building a deeper appreciation.
- 1:01:36Paul Shrimpling: You'll never have the understanding levels that the business owner has, but you've got an appreciation, and the trust equation between you and your client will be elevated, it's different and elevated.
- 1:01:46Paul Shrimpling: I love that a lot.
- 1:01:47Paul Shrimpling: Um, and then I think you know, your insight around the um the money spent on technology from 4% to 7.6%.
- 1:01:55Paul Shrimpling: But if you're a smaller business, it's like to be double that at 14-15%, and therefore it means you're not getting the ROI out of that because we've not process mapped our what we do, and then we elevated that into, but that process map has also got to deliver value for the client, which then signposts what technology you need to do what you need to do in order to um have a better accounting firm.
- 1:02:17Paul Shrimpling: So love the fact that we've been in both the human and the numbers space.
- 1:02:20Paul Shrimpling: Um, and um I I consider you as one of the gentlemen in the profession, Richard.
- 1:02:25Paul Shrimpling: So I'm really pleased that you were able to say yes to uh joining us on this podcast.
- 1:02:28Paul Shrimpling: Can't thank you enough.
- 1:02:31Richard Sergeant: Well, thanks for having me.
- 1:02:32Richard Sergeant: It's great.
- 1:02:34Richard Sergeant: Um, thank you for having me on.
- 1:02:37Paul Shrimpling: Well, that's very kind, that's very kind.
- 1:02:38Paul Shrimpling: I look forward to crossing swords with you again soon, Richard.
- 1:02:41Paul Shrimpling: In the discussion with Richard, we unpacked the value equation in overview, what we call the effing value, EFF, emotional, functional, and financial payoff.
- 1:03:05Paul Shrimpling: If you believe you and your firm can benefit from building the knowledge, the skill, the habits, and the processes to support delivering greater effing value to your clients, you'd want to consider, I think, looking at the Accountants Growth Academy.
- 1:03:23Paul Shrimpling: Check out the link to the Growth Academy in the show notes and you can find out more.
- 1:03:27Paul Shrimpling: You'll find more valuable discussions with the leaders of ambitious accounting firms at humanize the numbers.online.
- 1:03:35Paul Shrimpling: You can also sign up to be notified each time a new podcast is made available.
- 1:03:40Paul Shrimpling: You're about to hear a short excerpt from a podcast discussion with Martin Bissett, the famous Martin Bissett.
- 1:03:51Paul Shrimpling: If you like what you hear and you want to get to the full podcast, go to humanize the numbers.online or go to your favorite podcast platform.
- 1:04:00Martin Bissett: And over and over again, and I would say right up to the modern day, that is still the very last question to be uh considered by your run-of-the-mill accounting practice.
- 1:04:11Martin Bissett: We worry about what the depth of reports say, we worry about what the partner's gonna say, whether we're PE backed to worry about what the shareholders are gonna say and the KPIs that we've got to reach, and so on and so on and so on.
- 1:04:22Martin Bissett: But very rarely in practice over the years did I ever find anyone in leadership ever say, Yeah, but what's in the best interest of the client?