Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / The Burrito Method: Christ Isn't Curing My Cat
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking, feels so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. It has already
- 0:57been a day, just one of those days where the morning set the tone
- 1:03for everything else. And I have come to the conclusion that anybody who either
- 1:10is the parent of a child or has an animal in their house as a
- 1:14member of their family a pet, knows what it's like to have one of
- 1:19those days. A day when you wake up and you notice or smell something
- 1:26horrible, and then you spend who knows how long attending to the stinky end,
- 1:34the wrong end of your family member. You got to get out the
- 1:41paper towel and the spray bottle or the handy wipes or whatever. I'm trying
- 1:46not to give you too much detail. I don't want to put you off.
- 1:49I want to attract listeners, not repel them. But I know you
- 1:53know what I'm talking about. We got Cat about twelve years ago. His
- 2:00name is Cat. We spell it with a K. He's very Persian and
- 2:06he has become a lot more needy and lovey in the last year. I
- 2:13have no idea what that's about. Used to be, he would be in
- 2:15your zip code. If he was feeling hugely generous, he would lean up
- 2:20against you just a bit, you know, the generosity of the king to
- 2:24allow the jester in his court, in his throne room kind of thing.
- 2:29But he wasn't a lap cat, and I've always had a lapcat, so
- 2:31it was weird, like why are you so stand offish? Until about a
- 2:36year ago, and all of a sudden, he would start to just jump
- 2:40up onto my chest. Anytime I lay down on the couch or sat back
- 2:45in the bed or whatever, he would just jump up and he would flatten
- 2:46out where it was warm, and he would per per like nobody's business,
- 2:53and it was kind of zen. It was really relaxing. We would just
- 2:54hang out there and I'm like, oh, he's a lovey kiddy now right,
- 3:00And I appreciate that. And I'm so thankful that he was not lying
- 3:05on my chest last night, because when I woke up and he was sitting
- 3:12on the other side of the bed, he had left a very stinky residue.
- 3:17He is obviously not feeling well. I have a veterinary appointment scheduled for
- 3:23later. I don't know if he got into some bad food or it's a
- 3:30bug or something, but I'm really struggling here. But there is some nasty,
- 3:38nasty. It's nasty, and he is a Persian, so he's got
- 3:40this long fur. Sometimes we take him in to get it shaped back a
- 3:45little bit because it mats up. He's hard to brush. He panics and
- 3:47freaks out. So you know, he has this long, long fur and
- 3:52it catches all of the nasty stuff that's coming out of it. And there
- 3:55it is on the sheets and the bed. This is how he started my
- 3:59day. Blah and the smell, oh my god, cats like a big
- 4:10fuzzy septic tank. Natalie's out of town. She had to rush off to
- 4:18Denver for a business thing. She's gone till tomorrow. So now I'm stuck
- 4:25with this nasty cat, and I'm supposed to get it clean by myself.
- 4:32Someone on the internet told me of the burrito method. I had not heard
- 4:38of this, but the burrito The burrito method is where you take your cat
- 4:44and you roll him in a towel like a burrito so that his claws are
- 4:50concealed and you are not going to you know, bleed to death. Which
- 4:57is a problem because the last time this happened, I got scratched up pretty
- 5:00good. You know, I looked like I was I've been muled by a
- 5:04wild beast. And so I am alone this morning, seven o'clock. Grab
- 5:09a towel, grab the cat. I burrito the animal, and then I
- 5:15spend I don't know how long wrestling him into the sink because I try to
- 5:18spray him down. The cat's making that sound. Ah, he just feels
- 5:24like he's dying. It's just horrible. The dogs are freaking out because it's
- 5:28traumatizing. This isn't how they wanted to start their day either. And then
- 5:32I'm going around the house. I'm just cleaning. I'm cleaning all morning.
- 5:38There's a spot, there's a spot there, it's a spot, there's No,
- 5:41there's no glamour in being the parent of a child or the owner of
- 5:46a pet, because at some point we have all been there. It's not
- 5:53cuteness and purring and cuddles and fuzz and walks and yips and barks and happiness
- 6:00and joy joy. It is. I am trying not to end up in
- 6:05the urgent care while my burritoed cat sounds like he is being stretched on the
- 6:13rack during the inquisition. Anyway, we're gonna go to the vet. I
- 6:18told Natalie on the phone. I said, if they're gonna give him an
- 6:23injection, I don't even want to be in the zip code. I'm just
- 6:26gonna get in my car. Look, I'm gonna run down to a drive
- 6:29through. You know what I'm saying. You have fun with that. That's
- 6:32what they pay you for. If there's a needle and my cat involved,
- 6:38I am out. I don't even want to be around for that, because,
- 6:42oh my god, he's gonna flip. He's gonna be so mad.
- 6:47Speaking of drive throughs, and that's an unintended segue, but it's perfect because
- 6:55I wanted to tell you this story. I was thinking about it. I
- 6:58was telling naw To about it. On the phone this morning because it was
- 7:01kind of amazing. It happened last night, and it's something I wanted to
- 7:06share. I don't know, maybe it will inspice. Since I've taken you
- 7:10down that other road with nasty cat ass in it, I wanted to turn
- 7:15things around, maybe give you a smile and a little bit of encouragement,
- 7:20because I had a moment last night. Okay, it was at a drive
- 7:25through. Of all places, there's a little Chinese restaurant pretty close to where
- 7:30we live. It's been around forever. You've seen them, those little like
- 7:33egg Roll Garden or China Express type places, the little boxy restaurant with a
- 7:39drive through, and the menu has everything lettered so in case you can't pronounce
- 7:45some of the dishes, you just go, well, give me an A
- 7:46one and an R three and a D seven, and everybody knows what you
- 7:53want. And you cruise through the drive through and they give you everything in
- 7:56styrofoam containers, and then you drive home to eat it. They may have
- 8:00a little dining room, this one does. I'm telling you, for twenty
- 8:03years, I've been going to this place, and for twenty years, the
- 8:07same woman has been running the drive through. Obviously she's the owner. I'm
- 8:16guessing maybe she and her husband, who's the chef or the cook in the
- 8:20back. But twenty years ago, when I would go through that spot,
- 8:24the same woman in her fifties at the time, because she's got to be
- 8:28in her mid seventies now still there. So I pull around to the window
- 8:33and she takes my card and she's waiting on the food to be done.
- 8:37I ordered a combo sweet and sour chicken and chow maine with fried rice,
- 8:43thirteen bucks or whatever. And I was watching her through the window, and
- 8:52I noticed that she wasn't mad, she wasn't happy, she was kind of
- 9:01vacant. I got the impression all of a sudden that she has been doing
- 9:09what she does for so long that I'll bet she doesn't even feel it anymore.
- 9:18Hello, Can I take your order? A three R one D seven
- 9:22Thank you, pularun thirteen dollars eighty cents. Thank you, have a good
- 9:28day. Over and over and over and over. She looked world weary,
- 9:33she looked worn down. Who knows, maybe she and her husband put every
- 9:39penny they had into this humble little restaurant. It's all they have it's all
- 9:43they do. It seems like they're always there. She's always there, and
- 9:48I was watching her, and I thought, I don't see any joy on
- 9:52this woman. I see duty, I see work ethic. I see bills
- 10:00to pay. I see there may not be anybody else to do it,
- 10:03or I can't afford to pay anybody else to do it. I just see
- 10:09a routine and so on a whim. And this sounds noble when I say
- 10:15it out loud, but it really wasn't. It was just an idea.
- 10:16I reached down and grab my wallet, and I happen to have a twenty
- 10:20dollar bill, which is weird because usually I don't even have cash anymore.
- 10:24It's all plastic debit cards and such. But there it was a twenty dollar
- 10:26bill. So I pulled it out, and I was waiting. She's inside
- 10:30the glass and she's waiting for the order to be done, and then she
- 10:33puts it in the plastic bag and she ties it up, and she opens
- 10:37the window gives it to me, thank you, have a good day.
- 10:41Barely looking at me. She is giving her five hundred thousandth order through that
- 10:46piece of glass, probably aching to go home and rest her feet and so
- 10:54I took the food and I looked at her and I said, you are
- 10:58always worse king and she paused. She was startled, really like I was
- 11:07talking to her. I wasn't looking at the order taker. I was talking
- 11:11to her the person, and she was stunned. She didn't say anything.
- 11:16I said, you are always here all the time. Yeah, yes,
- 11:22I'm here. I'm here very often. I'm very here all the time,
- 11:26you know. And I said, do you ever get a day off?
- 11:31Well? No, yeah, sometimes, you know, the English is kind
- 11:35of broken a little bit, but she's communicating, yeah, you know,
- 11:39sometimes I get a night off, day off, you know, occasionally.
- 11:45But you could tell that she was a workaholic, probably by necessity. And
- 11:50so I reached over and I grabbed my twenty and I handed it to her
- 11:56through the window, and she took it before she really what was going on,
- 12:01Like she knew I was giving her something, but she just like,
- 12:03what is this? And then she realized a twenty dollar bill. This is
- 12:07more than the order. She's like no, no, no, no,
- 12:11no no no no no too much, too much? No, I said,
- 12:13no, I want you to take that. I won't take it.
- 12:16I won't take it too much money, too much money. Thank you.
- 12:18Though no no, no, I won't take it. I insist you take
- 12:22it. And then I said this over and over because I didn't think she
- 12:26could argue with this. I said, it makes me happy. It makes
- 12:31me happy. It makes me happy, It makes me happy. And I'm
- 12:33smiling at her. She was sitting there with the open drive through window,
- 12:41holding a twenty dollar bill she doesn't know what to do with. And this
- 12:46woman broke out into the biggest smile you have ever seen. She was no
- 12:54longer punching the clock. She was no longer just an order taker at that
- 12:58moment. And somebody saw her and she just exploded in a smile. You
- 13:05should have seen her. She lit up like a freaking Christmas tree. It
- 13:11was like she came to life, like the dead had arisen, you know.
- 13:16And so I started to drive off because I was afraid she was going
- 13:20to like throw the twenty back in my open window, but I waved up.
- 13:26Makes me happy, thank you, makes me happy to have a good
- 13:28day, have a good day. So I'm cruising off and she's smiling,
- 13:31thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, and I am
- 13:35I must have been ten twelve fifteen feet from the window. My car window
- 13:39is still down. I can see her. She sticks her whole torso out
- 13:43the drive through window and goes, thank you for the tip. And I
- 13:50stuck my head out the window and looked back and I said, you're welcome.
- 13:56And I drove off and I was just grinning all way home. I
- 14:00told Natalie about it, and she thought it was charming as well. And
- 14:05I know it sounds like a lifetime movie. But you've heard me on this
- 14:11show talk about fighting despair, trying to seek out and find the good,
- 14:18to reignite the good in my own life because life's short. I need good.
- 14:24I need good, and I've become desperate to see us try to engage
- 14:28other people without so many disqualifiers. That woman, I don't even know her
- 14:35name. I don't know if she goes to church. Is she religious?
- 14:39Maybe what kind of religion? I have no idea. I doubt it's Baptist.
- 14:46Yeah, maybe she and her husband practice a kind of Eastern religion or
- 14:50a Buddhist faith. Who knows, but it didn't matter in the moment.
- 14:56What are your interests, Where do you live, what kind of what home
- 15:00do you have? What is your background? All of those things might be
- 15:03relevant in some context, but at that second in time, it was just
- 15:07about two human beings grinning at each other like idiots. It was about a
- 15:15small kindness which wasn't small at all. There are no little things right.
- 15:22Every day presents that kind of opportunity. Somebody's walking into a building, They're
- 15:28fifteen feet away. For some reason, we open the door and then we
- 15:33just wait for them. We hold it. It's not like they can't open
- 15:37the door for themselves, but this is our way of saying, hey,
- 15:41come on, I got your door for you, no problem. You're walking
- 15:46somewhere and you see two or three people who are attempting to take a selfie,
- 15:52but they're struggling because somebody's arm isn't long enough and they can't get all
- 15:56three faces on screen. So what do you do? You walk up and
- 16:00you go, hey, you guys want your picture? I got that.
- 16:03Hey, stand over here because the light's better. Oh you look great?
- 16:07Okay. Do you want it vertical or do you want it horizontal? Okay?
- 16:11Wonderful? All right here we go. Everybody three to one snap.
- 16:15Let me take another one, three to one snap. Okay, check them,
- 16:19make sure that I got what you want. You happy, and everybody
- 16:22smiles. Thank you, thank you, thank you. That is not a
- 16:26small thing. You have no idea who those people are, but you did
- 16:30something amazing for them, and you help them preserve a second in time and
- 16:36make it forever. Somebody's got car trouble, you pull over and say,
- 16:42can I give you a hand? I'm lousy at this because I know nothing
- 16:47about cars. And you got to be careful because people have to be concerned,
- 16:52legitimately concerned about who is coming to quote unquote help them. But you
- 16:57get it right. Usually almost always it's someone genuinely trying to assist, and
- 17:04that's a beautiful thing. We've got a neighbor across the street. She is
- 17:11of the Jewish faith. She's also one of the best people we know and
- 17:15a wonderful woman. She's got a garden in her backyard. She loves gardening,
- 17:22and at random she just shows up at the door with stuff. Hey,
- 17:26I've got extra basil in the back. I know you guys like that.
- 17:30The tomato crop came in really well, here's a bunch of tomatoes.
- 17:33I put them in a sack for you. Just take them. Enjoy.
- 17:37We're always checking on each other when we travel? Can you get the box
- 17:41off my porch? Would you check my mail? Somebody needs to get into
- 17:45the backyard. Can you let him in? Can you do that? Hey?
- 17:48While I'm gone, If you see a big moving truck back up,
- 17:52would you call me right? Well, that's a small thing. That's not
- 17:56a small thing. It's just people looking out for each other. And who
- 17:59gives a shit? Where they go to church? You take hot chocolate?
- 18:03How to the mailman on a chilly December day? What do you do on
- 18:08a rainy day? You see somebody who doesn't have an umbrella, and you
- 18:12do. It's obvious they're desperately trying not to get too wet. You run
- 18:18over, stick the umbrella up, or you give it to them, and
- 18:22then you take the hit and you walk in the door soaking wet. Why
- 18:27not? What's that cost you? You're stuck in traffic, checking your watch,
- 18:34stressed out because you're probably going to be late to wherever you were supposed
- 18:40to be ten minutes ago. And you see somebody else who is stuck in
- 18:45traffic checking their watch, maybe running late to wherever they need to be,
- 18:49And what do you do? The light turns green? Everybody else goes there's
- 18:53a space in front of you, and you stay stopped and wave go ahead,
- 18:59hop in there. I'll make a spot for you. Go ahead,
- 19:03get where you gotta go. We don't do that for the assholes that drive
- 19:08up on the shoulder and then purposefully try to wage in front of us.
- 19:12We have to teach those people a lesson. They get no quarter. But
- 19:17everybody else, we're all in the same boat. We're driving the same road.
- 19:22Here's a space. Take it. Have a good day. You buy
- 19:26some Starbucks on your way into the office, and you remember that your coworker
- 19:32loves a machiato. So what do you do. You buy a machiato and
- 19:37you show up and put it in front of him and say, hey,
- 19:38I got this for you. Have a good one. I had a coworker
- 19:45once and he had a note on his desk and it said, make someone
- 19:49feel important today. I know it sounds sacherin, but make someone feel important
- 19:57today. At least make them feel seen and noticed today. I don't know.
- 20:03I has almost nothing to do with anything else that's going on, But
- 20:08how can I not tell you that story about the woman in the drive through
- 20:11who may still today be thinking about that guy, total stranger who saw her
- 20:18for just a few seconds. Maybe it's the breath of oxygen she needed that'll
- 20:23carry her on for another another few weeks. I mean, I don't know.
- 20:27Maybe that's a rather noble accounting. Maybe I'm giving myself too much credit.
- 20:33But go out and make somebody feel important today, make him feel seen
- 20:38today. Okay, wash an angry cat's ass today. Actually that's not a
- 20:45small thing. That would be a that's a herculean effort and quite dangerous.
- 20:52Maybe that's a bad example. I don't know. Let me take a short
- 20:56break and we'll come back and see what you want to talk about in just
- 21:02a second. Oh my goodness, my speaking roster and the tour schedule has
- 21:15gotten busy. Kansas City on April the seventh, Sunday morning, Kansas City,
- 21:19I hope you can join us. Coming up also Los Angeles, Little
- 21:25Rock, Arkansas, Denver, Colorado, Saint Louis, Missouri, Dallas,
- 21:30Houston, Sarnia, Ontario, Toronto, Lexington, Bentonville. And I think
- 21:37there may be another city or two that's being added. It's all a blur.
- 21:41I have to go to my own website to remember where I'm going and
- 21:45you can too, Seth Andrews dot com slash events. I would love to
- 21:52see you at one of these speaking events that I'm doing all around the country
- 21:56and north of our border. Seven one nine, Matt, thanks for calling.
- 22:04What's on your mind? Well, I have a conundrum that I've been
- 22:07thinking about and applied your advice. I'm join the army next month, I
- 22:11should vow, and I'm debating what to do on Sundays. One day I'll
- 22:17have off of basic training. You know, I have a you'll be clean,
- 22:19you clean the barracks. I hear understand only that day, but you
- 22:22can go to service. You can go to service and get a break time
- 22:26basically from cleaning. I'm just wondering if it's worth having time off of cleaning
- 22:30or should I not worry about it and stake more srure to my principles.
- 22:34Could it be the first time of me going to church in over a decade.
- 22:37Let's make sure I'm understanding. They will give you time off if you
- 22:41go to religious service to go and sit, But if you opt out of
- 22:48church, then you're doing what you're cleaning toilets. Well, you have to
- 22:52clean the barracks. You know he cleans clean and all that. Certainly everyone
- 22:56has to do anyway, but just people who have a service to go to
- 22:59they can. They have a list of options from I understand. I think
- 23:03it don't mind you go and even just sleep in the back a little bit,
- 23:06as long as you're you know, quiet and whatnot. I just don't
- 23:08know if I want to break a principle by going to church. I can't
- 23:12tell you whether or not to go. I'm not convinced it's a betrayal of
- 23:17your conviction, unless your conviction is to never step in the building. If
- 23:22you want to use them, fine, I'll go in there. I'll sit
- 23:26in the back, I'll sit on my phone, I'll take a nap,
- 23:29I'll do whatever. I think you have every right to do that if you
- 23:33decide you want to. It doesn't mean that you are endorsing the religion.
- 23:37I think it just means you know how to work the system. But if
- 23:41it's a matter of conviction, that's certainly an internal conversation that only you can
- 23:45have with yourself. I mean, if it was a choice between hanging back
- 23:49relaxing, I can tune out a preacher with the best of them. I
- 23:52think most of us have probably developed that skill, and it was either that
- 23:57or going out and you know, scratching floors and washing walls and cleaning toilets.
- 24:03And I felt like maybe the people who got the church option were being
- 24:07shown favoritism. I might work that system. I might sneak in the back
- 24:11and say, fine, I'll hang out and do my thing, but I
- 24:15would never consider it an endorsement of the religion. And then I think,
- 24:19in my off hours, I would probably file some kind of complaints that religious
- 24:26services were being given preferential treatment. Why do we not have a secular option
- 24:33available to the non religious? I would certainly make that protest. Only you
- 24:37can decide if you want to stir the waters, you know, politically,
- 24:41if it's worth it to you. But that's my two cents. Well,
- 24:44I appreciate it, Seth, Thank you very much, thanks for calling.
- 24:47Catch you later, yeap. What would you do? Would you go?
- 24:49Would you sit in the back. You don't have to say the prayer,
- 24:53don't have to close your eyes, don't have to even listen to what's being
- 24:56said. You might even make it a forensic experiment listening to all the crap
- 25:00that's being told or taught or not being told or taught, and you're like,
- 25:03hmm, that's interesting. So that's what they're doing. But there's no
- 25:07doubt in my mind I would be saying, hey, wait a minute,
- 25:11is there a humanist gathering? Is there a secular assembly, a place for
- 25:17people who were not religious to go and hang out and maybe learn science and
- 25:22just do people stuff. Because this is a double standard if you aren't going
- 25:27to do something for all of us, only for the religious, likely for
- 25:33Christians. Two five three, Dan, are you with me? Yes,
- 25:40as youre am. Thanks for calling, Dan. What do you want to
- 25:41talk about? Well, there was a passage in the Bible. Well,
- 25:45now, I'm an atheist, and the only reason I like to look these
- 25:48things up is so I have ammunition against my sister who belongs to one of
- 25:52those megachurches, and I know things that she doesn't and it really makes her
- 25:56mad. But there's a passage where God is admonished by the other gods for
- 26:03punishing the Jews too bad at one time, or punishing somebody too hard.
- 26:10I don't know that verse. Where is it. I think it was.
- 26:14I think it's Ezekiel nineteen or seventeen, something like that. But I can
- 26:18never discipline myself hard enough to actually keep reading the Bible to find it.
- 26:23The equivalent of Zeus and Krishna and the flying spaghetti monster calling yahweh out for
- 26:30being a jerk to his own chosen people exactly. But I can't find anymore.
- 26:37Well, let's see what our people come up with. Put it in
- 26:38the comments section. I'd like to go back. Could I tell you something
- 26:42else I like to do. Yeah, whenever Mormons come to the door,
- 26:47I like to invite him in, because actually Mormons are nice people. And
- 26:52I bring out my Book of Mormon, and I show them where the first
- 26:55day where the Angel came to Joseph Smith was September twenty first, and I
- 27:00tell them how when Earth went in fire wrote that song September. They put
- 27:06September twenty first as the date. I say that was because it came out
- 27:10shortly after black people were allowed to be priests. The Mormons let them be
- 27:15priests, and that was celebration of that. And these Mormon boys, they're
- 27:18just well what and they just can't believe it. I would hate to do
- 27:22what they do. They have this expectation that they have to do their mission
- 27:26banging on doors intruding into people's homes. Who knows how much shit they get.
- 27:30But at the same time they have to deal with us. We know
- 27:33often much more about their religion than they do. But it's nice that you're
- 27:38kind to them, Like you don't beat them over the head of the baseball
- 27:41bat, right You're you're a human being to them. No, And even
- 27:45when I tell them that, I tell them, you know, it's just
- 27:48my opinion, and I do treat them good. I actually haven't signed my
- 27:51Book of Mormon and do and I got about fifteen or eighteen names in there
- 27:59something like that. But they're actually good kids, you know. And it's
- 28:03like I heard one of the people say on I think it was one of
- 28:06your shows, how when you're a baby and your parents raise you, you
- 28:10believe everything they say. And then when they in doctrine you into religion,
- 28:15of course you believe that because they've been protecting you your whole life. They
- 28:18would never lie to you. And that's how it all happens, you know,
- 28:22from the bottom up. Mostly I appreciate your kindness. Not everybody has
- 28:26the bandwidth to be able to open their door and have a conversation, but
- 28:30the fact that you didn't say fuck you, get off my porch, which
- 28:33is tempting given that our homes are our castles in private spaces. The fact
- 28:38that you didn't do that may have given them the impression that, hey,
- 28:42here's a non believer who's actually kind and good and gracious and human. I
- 28:47admire that and respect it. Thanks for sharing it, brother, and have
- 28:49a good week. Okay, really good to talk to you all right,
- 28:52hang in there, We'll see you later. Two eight one. I've got
- 28:57John. Thanks for calling? What John? Hi, Seth. It's good
- 29:02to talk to you again. How long has it been, Oh, just
- 29:06a few weeks. I called for the first time a few weeks ago just
- 29:08to thank you for everything that you do. But this time I really want
- 29:12to talk about how it really grinds my gears and makes me really angry whenever
- 29:18theists think that just because I don't believe in God, they think that I
- 29:21have no morals, that I have nothing to base my morals off of,
- 29:25and it just really pisses me off sometimes. How do you respond that my
- 29:30morality comes from empathy and from common sense, which basically means that which I
- 29:33wouldn't want done to me, I would not do to others. Like the
- 29:38other day, I was talking to somebody who was a Christian and he told
- 29:41me, well, since you're an atheist, you must be okay with people
- 29:44trafficking children. I'm just like, no, I wouldn't want others to do
- 29:48to me what I wouldn't do to others. I wouldn't want my own children
- 29:51to be trafficked, so I wouldn't want my I wouldn't traffic anybody else's.
- 29:56And even then I even tell people, well, you really we should read
- 30:00your Bible, and I say read and not reread, because I can tell
- 30:03you that you haven't read it. Because in passages like Numbers twenty five,
- 30:07God told the Israelites to kill many men, well all of them, and
- 30:11actually all of the non virgin women, boys and infant boys, and to
- 30:15only spare virgin girls. And the entire Book of Joshua, there is so
- 30:22much genocide, and God is even okay with slavery if you look at Leviticus
- 30:26twenty five and Exodus twenty one, like this is disgusting, and supposedly from
- 30:32Christians, this is divine morality, and I just don't understand how they can
- 30:36defend things like this. I think the reasons may be as diverse as the
- 30:40people themselves. I think some simply have been brainwashed to think no one can
- 30:45be moral without God. I think other people want to shoot the messenger when
- 30:48we come and criticize their religion. So hey, why not say we would
- 30:53support Hitler, you know, or we would go out and rape and kill
- 30:59if it wasn't for their God. I think a lot of people use it
- 31:03to stop conversation. I mean, it's an accusation really when you hear it
- 31:07in that way, well, how do you know rape and murder are wrong?
- 31:11Is really an accusation that an atheist doesn't know rape and murder are wrong,
- 31:17which is an offensive thing to say in that way. I understand your
- 31:19frustration. Oh yeah, it's very frustrating. I agree. And all the
- 31:25time a lot of theists will tell me, well, you know Hitler was
- 31:27an atheist. No, he wasn't. He was a Christian. He was
- 31:30a Catholic, and in fact he hated the Jews for religious reasons. He
- 31:36also referenced the Christian God in mind comp and had God with us on the
- 31:40belt buckles of SS officers. There have been a lot, and there's been
- 31:45books. There's a lot of ink been spilled on Hitler, and then we
- 31:48find them saying, well, Hitler was smart enough to have weaponized the religion.
- 31:52He's an atheist, but he knew politically aligning with the Catholic Church and
- 31:57invoking the Christian God would buy him political and even popular capital. So he
- 32:04didn't really mean it when it's a total skate and it's frustrating to hear.
- 32:08But I think many people share your frustration. I celebrate you as a moral
- 32:14creature, and your evolved morality is helping to make a difference in this world.
- 32:20You are one of the good ones, or at least that's my hope.
- 32:22Brother, So thanks for calling the show. Thanks for taking my call.
- 32:24See you later. He said something that I wanted to come back to,
- 32:30and he used the word common sense. I used to think, oh,
- 32:36good, common sense, and then we would always say, well,
- 32:37common sense isn't common at all. But I used to use the words to
- 32:42the phrase common sense, as we all need this. But psychologists have addressed
- 32:50the idea of common sense and how it may not necessarily be a good thing.
- 32:55So I took the liberty of pulling up an article from Psychology Today called
- 33:00the problem with common sense, And I'm scrolling down to a paragraph and it
- 33:06says common sense is common because many people are perceived to believe it. The
- 33:13problem is that doesn't make it true. Looks like a duck walks like a
- 33:17duck is common sense? But consider looks like a gator walks like a gator?
- 33:23Will lots of people confuse alligators and crocodiles. Why do so many people
- 33:30misspell, lose and loose? Why do so many people say literally when they
- 33:36mean figuratively? Common isn't a good enough criterion to make something true? And
- 33:42so again I don't think we want to be pedantic here. I understand the
- 33:45larger point, right, engage brain, use your rationality, vet your sources,
- 33:52find out what is true. But common sense. I had to evolve
- 33:55my own thinking on this, and I still sort of navigate that when I
- 34:00talk about common sense and the calliquial sense. I think people understand what I
- 34:04mean, But common sense, you know, there's more to it from a
- 34:09psychology standpoint, and so we might guard our language whenever we use that in
- 34:15conversation. I've got two one eight, Hi, what's your name? Nat?
- 34:20Like the bug only minus the g Thanks for calling that what's on your
- 34:23mind? Well, I was just calling to talk about the whole thing about
- 34:29Next Benedict, that poor trans kid that died recently after getting jumped in the
- 34:36bathroom. I am kind of like a gentle giant, and I've been picked
- 34:42on a lot and dealt with a lot of crap. And the people who
- 34:45treated me decent looked a lot more like Next Benedict, and the people who
- 34:52treated me like crap. If you will allow me quickly, there are some
- 34:55people who are listening to you and me and they hear Next Benedict, and
- 34:59they don't know what we're talking about. So can I frame it quickly before
- 35:04we go any further? Would that be going? Yeah, okay, go
- 35:07ahead. Next ben Atitt was a student actually in my relative zip code in
- 35:12the suburb of Tulsa, a non binary student at o Wasso High School.
- 35:17And there was a confrontation, bullied bullying. Next was bullied by some people
- 35:23who assaulted and beat Next in a bathroom. That assault resulted in cuts and
- 35:30bruises and ended up in the hospital. I mean, this was just hate
- 35:34and bigotry and smallness, and it's one of those things where we've got people
- 35:38like our Superintendent of Public Instruction, even our governor, and they're going off
- 35:43on the woke and the woke ism, and so people like Next have been
- 35:46vilified in that way. So Next goes to the hospital with these injuries and
- 35:52dies the next day, and everybody said, oh, you know was beaten
- 36:00to death, which was I think a reasonable assumption given what had happened the
- 36:05assault itself. There was just an autopsy report released. The manner of death
- 36:10ruled as suicide, the probable cause of death being diaphenhydramine and fluexitine combining toxicity,
- 36:20according to the Oklahoma Medical Examiner's Office. So the thinking is is that,
- 36:27yeah, there were physical injuries, but the chemicals in the body actually
- 36:31explain the death more than the cuts and bruises. Now this is a challenge,
- 36:36right because this is a hot button issue. You and I are pissed
- 36:39off about the hate, about the assault, about the lack of safety,
- 36:43the danger to trans people, non binary people. It's our fellow human beings.
- 36:49And so my first inclination is to say, well, that's a bunch
- 36:52of bullshit. Oklahoma's covering its tracks. We know Next was beaten to death,
- 36:57but I don't believe that is actually true, and I've had to will
- 37:01myself past this sort of you know, knee jerk into screw this state because
- 37:07Ryan Walters makes me crazy and understand that chemically, it looks like the substances
- 37:15in Nexx's blood were responsible for the death itself. But that then becomes a
- 37:22separate issue because we're still talking about the assault in the bathroom at a high
- 37:25school where Necks was supposed to be safe, and the lack of outrage by
- 37:30an entire culture of Oklahomans and Americans means that it might be less safe for
- 37:37the next person who goes in there. It's just so madening. So anyway,
- 37:40that's the context, and you are understandably outraged. Yeah, I have
- 37:46quite a few friends in the trans community, in the GLBT community. They
- 37:52have treated me with nothing but respect and kindness. And the people that I
- 37:59hear having the most problems with the trans community and all that tend to be
- 38:06the ones that have really, in my experience, have been the real douche
- 38:12nozzles, the ones that have treated me like shit, like I was something
- 38:15foul they stepped in. And the whole idea of everything that people are saying
- 38:23about the trans community is utter horseshit. Take the whole bathroom saying how they
- 38:30were worried about dudes pretending to be trans just so they can get into a
- 38:36woman's restroom and do that shit. They're worried about trans people doing stuff to
- 38:42kids. If we want to see grooming, I've seen two headlines just in
- 38:46the month of March about pastors convicted youth pastors are regular pastors who were grooming
- 38:53kids sexually assaulting the kids. So our outrage is under standable. And mostly
- 39:01you and I are confronted by small people who wants everybody else to look like
- 39:07them and sound like them, and vote like them, and worship like them.
- 39:09And I think they're tremendously insecure. I think the secure person looks around
- 39:15and says, Wow, what a wide, wild spectrum of humanity, and
- 39:20we all get a chance to share the world together. I mean, that's
- 39:22a much more beautiful place to be. And I think, you know,
- 39:24the ugly heart just doesn't get there, doesn't want to get there, And
- 39:29so your outrage is understandable. And the best we can do, I think,
- 39:32is to advocate for the next benedicts that are still with us. And
- 39:37I appreciate your call very much. You hang in there. Okay, well
- 39:40see bye bye, one more short break. I'll be right back and we'll
- 39:47go to the phones again next. Thank you so much for listening and thanks
- 39:59for your support. You want the broadcast totally commercial free, and you want
- 40:02to get it a couple of days early. Become a patron Patreon dot com
- 40:08slash seth Andrews really matters makes a difference. Thank you for your support.
- 40:15Is it Jose at nine to five one? Thanks for calling? What do
- 40:20you want to talk about? So? I'm a lot like you, Like
- 40:22I grew up very Catholic, you know, Monday Bible Study, Tuesday youth
- 40:28group, Wednesday choir practice. Then the weekend was all church, going to
- 40:32Mass and all that kind of jazz. So eventually I'm forty one years old
- 40:37now. But when I turned thirty five, I really the bug hit me
- 40:42to start, you know, really questioning what I believe in and why I
- 40:44believe in and all that kind of stuff. And I came to the conclusion
- 40:49that I'm an atheist because I found that I have no real good reason to
- 40:52believe any of it. However, I've always struggled with my family because my
- 40:59dad's a deacon in the Catholic Church. So how do I deal with that
- 41:04kind of clash of lifestyles where I pretty much live a completely secular lifestyle,
- 41:10whereas you know, I don't deal with any religion stuff. But every time
- 41:14I go visit family, I'm sort of bombarded with, oh, well,
- 41:19when are we gonna go to church? When are you gonna have a little
- 41:22boy? You know, when now you're gonna go get them baptized. I
- 41:23hate living like that. I've never come out to them and told them like,
- 41:28look, I'm not I'm an atheist. I don't believe because I feel
- 41:30like it's gonna crush them to their core. You know what I'm saying.
- 41:35I know exactly what you're saying. So they're not onto you, or maybe
- 41:39they suspect we've had talks. I'm sure they suspect. My dad has always
- 41:45you know, anytime that we have those kind of conversations, he's always just
- 41:49like, well, you know, look for Jesus and look in the Bible,
- 41:52go study, go seek them out, and then you'll give your answers.
- 41:55But I've never found a good answer for anything. I am always grieved
- 42:01when I see people who. They're not living a fully authentic life around everybody
- 42:07because of that kind of blowback, which is not your fault. It's your
- 42:13father's fault, even if he means it from the most sincere of ways.
- 42:17The fact that you are worried about whether or not he's going to melt down
- 42:22and cry and shout and be disappointed, and it's going to just ruin your
- 42:25relationship. That problem is a dad problem. It is not a jose problem.
- 42:32Your dad would never abide somebody telling him that he could not live authentically.
- 42:38He's like, I'm going to live my faith. I'm going to be
- 42:40my this is who I am. Who's going to tell me I can't be
- 42:44me? Then his son is over here literally wringing his hands, going,
- 42:50God, if I say something to Dad, the shit's going to hit the
- 42:53fan. How much of this grief do I need? Is that what I'm
- 42:57hearing from you? Yeah, well, my dad, I'm sure my dad
- 43:01could deal with it a little bit better. My mom, I feel like
- 43:05she's going to be the one that really I feel like her world will collapse
- 43:09if she hears me say those words. Only you can decide if coming out
- 43:15to them is the right move. For you. My one thing that I
- 43:20would say, and it cost me. My mother and I do not speak.
- 43:23She is blocked on my phone. We don't converse, we don't interact.
- 43:29There was a boundary violation of several that have caused it cost us the
- 43:32relationship, and it's her fault. But not everybody is prepared to do that.
- 43:38The cost benefit for everybody, it may not be worth it. If
- 43:43you want to be a little more, I don't know. I hate the
- 43:47word silent. But if you want to play chestnut checkers, if you want
- 43:51to just not rock the boat because the relationship with them and the lack of
- 43:55conflict is worth it to you, I would not you for not wearing it
- 44:02on your sleeve. But I am struck by the double standard. You are
- 44:07the one having to do all the bending man, You're the one having to
- 44:09say, ah, my god. I don't want to be too open about
- 44:14who I am, what I think, what my values are, because it'll
- 44:16make other people uncomfortable. That's rough, and I'm convinced that it's healthy,
- 44:22even if it freaks them out, even if they lose their minds. I
- 44:25think it's healthy for it religious people to know that we are here we are
- 44:30all around them. There are more of us than they may think, and
- 44:34we are good, moral, equal human beings. And that's my desire for
- 44:39you. But I can't tell you whether it's worth it at this measure.
- 44:45I don't know how bad it's going to get. I don't know what it's
- 44:47going to cost you personally. That's a very intimate personal decision that only you
- 44:52can make. I just want to be able to live in harmony because I
- 44:55love my parents deeply. They're great people like us. I couldn't think of
- 45:00a more respectable person than my father, because I know him personally. I
- 45:04know that kind of person. He is my mother as well. But you
- 45:07know, my mom's a little bit more old school, a little bit more
- 45:08judgmental. She's the kind of the pearl clutcher anytime she sees like a gay
- 45:15couple and shit like that. The thing about it is that, you know,
- 45:17they're such great, respectable people. I want them in my life because
- 45:22they are great people, not just because they're my parents, but they're great
- 45:25people as a whole. So I don't want to break that relationship down if
- 45:30I just have to live my life or the rest of their lives in this
- 45:34fashion, then so be it kind of pains me, yes, Jose.
- 45:39If you tell them you are not a Christian or a Catholic, or you
- 45:44don't believe in God and the relationship breaks down, you didn't break it.
- 45:50Okay, That's all I'm trying to say. If they lose their mind,
- 45:54if they start to put up walls, if your mom starts to clutch those
- 45:59pearls when it comes to you, she starts to treat you like the other
- 46:01people she's discriminating against. She may be good in all these other areas,
- 46:06but we have to face the fact that she's being bigoted against human beings,
- 46:10a marginalized group of good people who deserve better. If your relationship breaks down,
- 46:16you didn't break it. Your mother and potentially your father broke it because
- 46:22they cannot or will not exist in a circumstance of equality respect even respectful disagreement.
- 46:29There will be shouts and tears and emotional blackmail and consequences and conflict,
- 46:35and all of that shit's going to be their fault. And so go at
- 46:38your own speed. But it's my hope for you, brother, that at
- 46:42some point you give yourself the same latitude that they give themselves every single day
- 46:49personally, though, I'm encouraged by you to bust out of the Catholic faith,
- 46:53to make that journey right, to check things out, to kick the
- 46:59tires, to to do what you have done and honestly and get where you
- 47:02are is huge. I am just tremendously inspired by you, and I want
- 47:08you to know that, Jose, I appreciate that. Brother. Just one
- 47:13last thing. When I was a kid, I went to a Catholic retreat
- 47:16with my dad and we had this experience of a perceived demonic possession. And
- 47:21I say perceived because I couldn't tell you exactly what happened, but I saw
- 47:24what happened, you know what I'm saying. So now my dad has this
- 47:29guilt trip on me where anytime we have these conversations and I told them pretty
- 47:32much that I'm deviating from religion almost completely. He takes it as this demon
- 47:39that attacked him twenty years ago is coming back being manifested through me to get
- 47:45back at him. You know what I'm saying, You're carrying a demon.
- 47:50Oh wait, wait, wait wait, hang on, hang on, Yeah,
- 47:52there's a revenge demon backpacking on you to get back at your dad.
- 47:57Yes, yes, that's what trip that he's been throwing at me, and
- 48:01he's been telling my wife is I've been away from home. I'm right now.
- 48:05I'm actually on my drive back from Chicago to California on my way home,
- 48:09and my wife spoke with my dad just yesterday or the day before,
- 48:15and she was telling me how he brought this up to my wife. I'm
- 48:20sitting on the edge of my chair and my hands are vibrating right now because
- 48:25I mean, I could tell you the entire story if you have the time,
- 48:29but I'm sure you've got other people that you want to speak to.
- 48:31I'm just saying, your dad is giving him permission then to talk to your
- 48:37wife about how you're possessed with a damon or you have the devil whispering in
- 48:42your ear, and that's why you're such a screw up. I mean,
- 48:45that's his reasoning for the conversations that we've had where I've pretty much presented to
- 48:51him that I am no longer following religion period. I didn't say I was
- 48:54an atheist like you said, I am not following religion. I got you.
- 49:00Here's the last thing I will leave you with. Your journey is about
- 49:04you and The mistake we often make is we try to convince other people if
- 49:08only I explain what's been going on in my life a certain way, if
- 49:13there's a certain series of words, if I string them together in this way,
- 49:15or if I just show them this, they'll get it and they'll understand,
- 49:21and they'll sort of be inside my skull and know even if they disagree,
- 49:24at least they'll feel it. And that's a mistake because that makes at
- 49:31some point you are then making your journey about other people. So your journey
- 49:37the steps you take, the words you say, your values, or how
- 49:42you act out your values. You are waiting for a pingback from a third
- 49:46party, your mother, your father, religious friends, the church itself,
- 49:50etc. I think your journey is about you. In my life, I
- 49:55have come to the point where anybody around me can come up with any shit
- 49:59story they want. Oh, Seth's got demons. I've heard that one Seth's
- 50:02going through midlife. I've heard that one Seth just wants attention. I've heard
- 50:07that one Seth has cashed in and somehow he's becoming a squillionaire as an atheist.
- 50:13I haven't seen that one, and I give that as much power as
- 50:15it deserves none, because my journey's about me. I don't let it derail
- 50:21me. I live my life on my terms, and I will engage.
- 50:24When they step over the boundary of my life and start to inject that stuff,
- 50:30then it's on. But until then, people are going to say what
- 50:32they're going to say, including your dad. If he wants to hold the
- 50:35demons, it's a defense mechanism. It's a whole lot easier for him to
- 50:38use that cookie cutter than to say, maybe the whole of the faith that
- 50:43I have been practicing and preaching on the order of decades is total crap.
- 50:49I understand how demons would be a much more attractive option for him. So,
- 50:52but your journeys about you, Hoseiah, it's a total cop out.
- 50:58It's proof that religion have evolved so many mechanisms to defend against skeptics, critics,
- 51:06people with doubts. You know, if you want a great proof of
- 51:10evolution, just look at Christianity, Catholicism, Islam, etc. They have
- 51:15all of these evolved defense mechanisms in place, and you can see them.
- 51:19Do that. Know what it is, but don't let it interrupt your day.
- 51:22Man, Your journey is about you okay, Jose, thank you.
- 51:25Drive safe out there. Okay, We'll see you. I will. You
- 51:31know, it's always flattering and humbling when somebody calls and they say, Seth,
- 51:36I'm going through something. What do you think? What should I do?
- 51:42And I feel this tremendous responsibility, like why are you asking me?
- 51:45I guess I've got some equity. I do a lot of this. I've
- 51:50been through it. I've been on the front lines of activism for fifteen years
- 51:53in that since. Maybe I'm not a total imposter, but I'm not a
- 51:58professional and I don't have the answer that everybody wants. Hell, I want
- 52:02it. Hey, how can I get someone too? And that's usually the
- 52:08first sign that we're about to get into trouble. How do I get this
- 52:13person to understand, to act, to not act, to react, to
- 52:21be How do I get them? That's a problem because we have now taken
- 52:28the responsibility for the life, the attitudes, the opinions and decisions of somebody
- 52:34outside of us, and whenever they do something that is stupid or gross,
- 52:42or bigoted or deluded or just factually wrong, we can't convince them otherwise we
- 52:50failed. I failed. I am not succeeding. I have not had success,
- 52:54and in my own life, I have had to will myself into a
- 52:58better definition of what a successful life looks like because I spent years and years
- 53:04and years stacking the deck against me, guaranteeing failure because my expectations were so
- 53:12unrealistic. I was so naive. How can I get my religious mother and
- 53:16father to see why I'm an atheist? And so I would engage, and
- 53:22I would open the Bible, often a Bible that I knew better than most
- 53:27of the people in my family, including those who were teaching Sunday school,
- 53:32and I would say, this is a problem, and that doesn't work,
- 53:35and this is untrue, and this is contradictory, and this is just outright
- 53:37offensive. And so I've got legitimate reasons for walking away, and you need
- 53:42to understand that. And I would recommend that you consider doing the same.
- 53:45There is a better way. And in my naive mind, I somehow hope
- 53:52that they would either agree with me and say, wow, thanks for bringing
- 53:57this to our attention, and they would join me in this exit from mythology
- 54:02and dogmatism, or at the very least they would have a three dimensional understanding
- 54:08for their apostate child that did not happen, and I felt like I failed.
- 54:17I am not successful in this way. Well, I was never going
- 54:22to be successful, not like that. How can I make them? Is
- 54:29no longer part of my equation for success. Am I being true to me
- 54:35despite the consequences? Yes, in that way I'm a success. Have I
- 54:40found a life that is more fulfilling and wonderful for me? Yes? Have
- 54:46I discovered something that's a better fit for me? Yes? Have I learned
- 54:52more about the world even later in life, late to the party, but
- 54:58still there and and soaking up as much science and information. Have I been
- 55:04honest with myself even when it hurts? Yes, that I set my jaw
- 55:12and pushed through the fears of burning in hell forever to find out if a
- 55:16hell even made sense? Yes, despite the consequences or potential consequences. Did
- 55:24I give myself permission to examine religious dogmatism, the Bible, the history of
- 55:30the Bible, the sourcing or lack of sourcing of the Bible, the contradictory
- 55:36and offensive scriptures, the debunked mythologies of the Bible. That I continue to
- 55:40push through and make that journey even when everybody else around me told me not
- 55:46to. Yes, have I come to an understanding of the tremendous importance of
- 55:52self care and self respect? How do we live our lives without self respect?
- 55:59Why do we continue to throw ourselves under the steamroller of other people and
- 56:02then let them blame us when we get hurt? Why do we tell that
- 56:07person over there, you can't tell me what to do, but change the
- 56:13rules for somebody who might be a sibling? My brother said, my sister
- 56:19said, my daughter, my son, my mother, my father, my
- 56:22uncle. Oh well, it's different with them their family. Why is it
- 56:25different? Reframing that understanding that the rules of self care and the boundaries of
- 56:31self respect apply even to those on our family tree. Understanding that was I
- 56:38successful? I think so. I think that is a victory. I don't
- 56:45think success always has to feel good. Success won't always include everyone. Success
- 56:53sometimes includes conflict or refusing to engage in conflict. So often is not this
- 57:01Hollywood ending that everybody dreams about? And I understand why we want to all
- 57:07be on the same team, pursuing the same thing for the right reason,
- 57:12and at the end, everybody's a winner, everybody gets a trophy. But
- 57:16if we put that expectation in place, we are destined to be disappointed,
- 57:22even devastated, and then often we blame ourselves because I failed. But if
- 57:29you make your journey more about being true to yourself, that's the starting point,
- 57:34and you say I am being a success in that, and then we
- 57:38live our lives loud and proud if we can in front of all of these
- 57:43other people, hoping that if someone else is on a similar journey, or
- 57:47maybe there's enough of a crack to let in the light, maybe they'd be
- 57:52open to conversation. Our example, our authenticity, our life might impact their
- 58:00reception, but the change still happens internally in their minds. We provide the
- 58:06opportunity. They must take responsibility. Why, because their journey belongs to them,
- 58:15not a life without challenge, disagreement, or even conflict, but self
- 58:21care, self respect, and authenticity. And even when the shit hits the
- 58:25fan, if you've gotten at least close to that point, I think you
- 58:30may have a successful life even when everybody else around you seems to be spinning
- 58:36into oblivion. Realizing that that's their problem, and you can decide how much
- 58:40of their problem you let into your home. That's success, not a utopian
- 58:46Hollywood success, but a real world, sometimes messy, but still valid success.
- 58:53So embrace that, give yourself the credit you deserve. Okay, And
- 59:02with that, I am off to care for a sick kitty. To medicate
- 59:09a sick cat, which means more of the burrito method. I think we
- 59:15take the towel. We're going to wrap him up, and it's for your
- 59:16own good and good for kitty because he could have been born into a home
- 59:22when we said, well, you know what, we don't want any of
- 59:24those medicines. The Lord is the best medicine. Dear Jesus, we asked
- 59:30that you help cat not to have diarrhea. Today, we ask that you
- 59:37perform a divine miracle on his little feline exit hole. He closed the back
- 59:44door to all of this sickness and disease. Lord, may Christ cure his
- 59:50keeyster. May the Savior sooth his sphincter and bring him back to proper intestinal
- 59:57health. Where two or more are gathered in Jesus's name praying over this cats
- 1:00:04poor poophole, their request shall be done. We ask this in Jesus name.
- 1:00:10We could be doing that, but no, we are a science based
- 1:00:15household and so Kat, prepare yourself. It's time to take your meds,
- 1:00:21and I'm off to do that very thing. Love you much, be safe
- 1:00:25and well. See you next week. Follow the Thinking Atheist on Facebook and
- 1:00:30Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t
- 1:00:35shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and
- 1:00:39details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The
- 1:00:45Thinkingatheist dot com.