Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #231 - Eric Wickham / Liz McDowell / J.J. McCullough
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Moameir and this is Van Color,
- 0:19British Columbia's bona fide culture and politics TV talk show. Tonight, we're
- 0:23focusing on some hot button consumer issues. JJ McCollough will be here to defend
- 0:29consumerism. We're also going to talk about greenwashing and what that has to do
- 0:33with Canada's Competition Bureau launching an inquiry into the Vancouver based athletic apparel retailer Lulu
- 0:40Lemon. But first, while stretchy likerapants are optional, groceries are not.
- 0:46And this month there has been a campaign to boycott one big Canadian grocer,
- 0:51in particular Loblaw Companies Limited, whose chains include the Real Canadian superstore, Shoppers,
- 0:57drug Mart, No Frails, Extra Foods, Tea and two supermarket Osaka
- 1:00Supermarket and more. To explain the Lablaws boycott and whether or not it's being
- 1:06effective, is a Toronto based journalist who has been working on a year long
- 1:10investigation on the price of groceries for The Hoser, which is an independent digital
- 1:15media outlet based in the Greater Toronto area. He is Eric Wickham. Eric,
- 1:22thank you so much for beaming in tonight. Oh mo, thanks for
- 1:25having me. This is a thrill. Now, there have been many analyzes
- 1:29about why grocery prices in Canada are so high. Some folks are blaming the
- 1:34federal government, others blame outside market influences. What is the case against big
- 1:40grocery chains like law blaws for being the reason why grocery prices are just so
- 1:45high these days? Well, I mean there's a lot of blame to go
- 1:48around with grocery prices, right. A lot of people like to blame inflation.
- 1:52A lot of people like to blame the government's inaction for regulating the grocers.
- 1:56But I do think that a lot of responsibility late like lives with grocers
- 2:00as well. We can see, you know, in twenty twenty two,
- 2:05the price of food was rising twice the rate of inflation at one point.
- 2:09And when a grocery store is continuously reporting record profits after this is happening,
- 2:20it is it's really easy to see why people would be upset with specific companies
- 2:25totally. Now I can understand consumers looking at Canada's oligopoly of grocers. You
- 2:31know, we have a lack of competition here where five big companies Loblaws Metro,
- 2:37Sobees, Walmart, and Costco make up about seventy five percent of total
- 2:43market share in terms of grocery stores. But why is Loblaw in particular the
- 2:47target of a boycott this month? Well, it's it's an interesting thing because
- 2:53I've seen some people throw out the fact that, you know, like,
- 2:55hey, Metro should feel very lucky, like Eric Laflesh should feel very grateful
- 3:00that Galen Weson's getting so much flak. But I will say, in Metro's
- 3:04defense, although their prices are also high, they were not the culprit in
- 3:09a bread price fixing scandal. They're not the ones that announced a partnership with
- 3:15Manual Life that would mean that two hundred and sixty different prescriptions would only be
- 3:20able to be fulfilled at their proprietary pharmacies, Right. I think putting Galen
- 3:27Weston as a very public face of your company and then having all these scandals
- 3:32happen over and over again is probably why La Blahs has a big target on
- 3:38their back. In you know this instance, you're forgetting the hero pay scandal
- 3:45where they rolled back hero Pay and then we realized that they actually told their
- 3:49competitors that they were going to do that, so you know, signaling to
- 3:51them that they should do that as well. You know, there's so many
- 3:54scandals. It's hard to keep track of them all, isn't it. No,
- 3:58Absolutely now law Lost stock has actually been hitting all time highs loab Blaw
- 4:02executive chairman and controlling shareholder Galen Weston, who you just alluded to, has
- 4:08apparently increased his wealth by hundreds of millions of dollars this month alone. So
- 4:14you know, is this boycott actually working? Are people stopping their shopping at
- 4:18at Loblaws? I mean it's a hard thing to keep track of. I
- 4:24mean I saw people throwing up the stock price as a reason why the boycott
- 4:29was failing within like a day of the boycott. Even launching boycotts take a
- 4:33long time. I think, you know, when something is only thirty days,
- 4:39we can't expect it to bring a company to its knees, so to
- 4:42speak. Blahbless is a massive company. I don't know if their stock price
- 4:47is going to be like incredibly impacted by this boycott. But I think the
- 4:53boycott does something more important than you know, crushing a company. I think
- 4:58it it opens up the common conversation for Canadians to talk about affordability in a
- 5:02larger way that gets away from you know, apples are too expensive. It's
- 5:06a conversation about I can't afford to pay for rents and my groceries and all
- 5:15the other increasing costs in my life. And I think that is something that
- 5:19as someone who has been investigating food for the past year, I haven't seen
- 5:24anything of the sort like I have since this boycott was announced. Is the
- 5:30larger structural problem the oligopoly itself. Like I'm thinking of a lot of communities
- 5:35where La Blaw might be your only choice in town, or certainly the only
- 5:40you know, economic choice in town, or maybe there's some higher end grossers
- 5:44that are available as well, And so I just feel like, not only
- 5:46for the consumer, but in terms of the suppliers, la Blaw exercises a
- 5:50lot of power. So even going beyond just one brand or one company,
- 5:56is the is the freedom of choice and competitiveness that the key issue here?
- 6:00Maybe like it is it is one of those things where I mean, we
- 6:03all have to eat. So I mean, if your only option is lab
- 6:08Blaws or another large company like, please continue to do so, right,
- 6:15I think it's a it's a very Canadian issue to only have a handful of
- 6:18companies in a specific industry. This is not limited to grocery stores. I
- 6:23mean you can see it in telecom, you can see that mining, you
- 6:26can see that in energy. There is a specific lack of competition, I
- 6:31think. But beyond that, I think that there is a lot of flame
- 6:38to be going and going around for the government, right, Like, I
- 6:40think that there needs to be specific regulations to keep prices from getting out of
- 6:46hand, right, I think that we also need to be talking about affordability
- 6:50more right. I don't know what it's like in BC, but in Ontario.
- 6:56Yeah, well it's I keep thinking about the lines between Vancouver and Toronto.
- 7:00It's one. It's I mean heartbreak around playoff time, although you guys
- 7:04are looking good against the oilers, and it's housing and affordability, right,
- 7:11Like. The one status all thrown around is that in twenty twenty two,
- 7:16sixteen percent of households in Ontario faced food and security. And to me,
- 7:20that is the real issue that we should be trying to address. Right,
- 7:26sixteen percent of households, which meant nearly one in five kids in the country.
- 7:30We're facing food in security, which is terrifying. And I mean,
- 7:34as much as I'd like to talk about competition and supply chains and which companies
- 7:41are getting away with, what I think that we should be really focusing on
- 7:44how we can get more food to Canadians. Absolutely, Eric, I appreciate
- 7:48your time tonight and I have to be honest, it warms my heart to
- 7:53see you breaking the monopoly of voices that are explaining grocery prices to Canadians.
- 7:57So thank you so much. Well, thanks again, Mo, This is
- 8:01great. Thank you folks. That was Eric Wickham. Find his work on
- 8:05the price of groceries at Thehoser dot Ca. Now after some business, what
- 8:09is greenwashing? And is my beloved Vancouver yoga clothing brand Lululemon guilty of it?
- 8:16Let's talk about it up next. Welcome back to This is Van Color.
- 8:28Earlier this month, Canada's Competition Bureau launched an inquiry into Vancouver based athletic
- 8:33apparel juggernaut lulu Lemon, following allegations from an environmental group stand Earth, that
- 8:41Lululemon was misleading its customers with greenwashing marketing. What is that? Well,
- 8:46The senior campaigns director for stand Earth, Liz McDowell, is here to explain
- 8:50it to us. And this conversation is brought to you by Pacific Sands Beach
- 8:56Resort in Tafino, laid back Luxury as beachfront as it gets. So,
- 9:01Liz, what is greenwashing and why is it harmful to consumers? Well,
- 9:07it's actually pretty simple, and so greenwashing is the practice of a corporation misrepresenting
- 9:13the environmental harms of its products, and so it's harmful to consumers because it's
- 9:18deceptive to them. It makes it really hard for consumers to choose brands that
- 9:22align with their values. And what we're really seeing is like, especially as
- 9:28consumers actually care more and more and are demanding more and sustainability from the products
- 9:31and services that they purchase, we are seeing greenwashing become rife and in vacued
- 9:37systemic. And so whether it's something like a retail giant like Lululemon that is
- 9:43raking in billions in profits through slogans like b planet while doubling its climate pollution
- 9:52right over the same time. And we'll get into Lululemon in a second.
- 9:54So I just want to keep it straight. Yeah, it's when a company
- 9:56says, hey, this product is one hundred percent recycled, but then you
- 10:00learned out, you learn that it's not recycled. Yeah, exactly, and
- 10:03so like or for example, we also recently launched a greenwashing legal challenge against
- 10:09fodist b C and for to SBC. You know, we claim is misrepresenting
- 10:13gas as a climate friendly source of home heating. Right, And so that's
- 10:16another example. Okay, not so much now, So let's go back to
- 10:20lu Lemon. What are they telling consumers and then what's the reality? Yeah,
- 10:24so, as I mentioned, so lul Lemon has a big B planet
- 10:28marketing campaign and in fact even claims that some of its clothes are restorative to
- 10:31the earth. Okay, what istative for the earth? Great question, couldn't
- 10:35tell you. And you know, we're arguing that the company is actually significantly
- 10:41exaggerating and misrepresenting the impact of its sustainability initiatives because you look at it's like
- 10:46flagship yoga pants. They're all made with polyester. Polyester is made from oil,
- 10:52right, and they're manufactured in factories that are predominantly run on polluting coal.
- 10:58Methane gas have a huge climate impact. And so as I mentioned this
- 11:03company, so it it raked in almost ten billion dollars in profits last year.
- 11:07It could certainly afford to be genuinely investing in powering its factor with renewable
- 11:11energy or using you know, less harmful products to make its close. Instead,
- 11:16what it's doing is you know, telling a big sustainability story while literally
- 11:22doubling its climate footprint. It's green, has gas emissions in the same time
- 11:26period. Where do we draw the line? Because I can certainly see companies
- 11:28saying, hey, we care about the environment, which is a very broad
- 11:33statement, but not actually having its production or manufacture or sales that actually reflect
- 11:39that. So where do we draw the line of deception? That's a great
- 11:43question. And I think, you know, in some cases, like in
- 11:45the Lululemon case, I think it's very clear that this is greenwash. Other
- 11:48times it's more nuanced. And so you know, what we look for is
- 11:50like, are they actually making an effort? Are they making investments? Where
- 11:54are they putting their profits? Are they so, for example, some not
- 11:58not a ton, but clothing brands are actually investing in renewable energy to power
- 12:03their factories, Okay, are actually investing and making clothes from less harmful fabrics.
- 12:09And so if we see that, then we're like, Okay, I
- 12:11you know, you can market that initiative, but you know when you say
- 12:15something really broad like b planet, and you can't actually back up like what
- 12:18that means, right, that feels like you're trying to trade off people wanting
- 12:24to feel good about their purchases and wanting to feel like they're contributing to sustainability
- 12:28and not to environmental harms while you are, you know, actually having a
- 12:33really bad climate impact. So it'd be like a junk food company saying our
- 12:39food is healthy, which again is a broad term a lot of things yet
- 12:41but to most people who would know, they would say that this is clearly
- 12:46not healthy. Yeah, completely. And I think that's a really good parallel
- 12:48because we have actually, you know, products have been pulled for making claims
- 12:52of being anti aging or anti you know, antioxidants, right, superfoods,
- 12:56cancer fighting, all of that, when they're not. So this is actually
- 13:00really similar. And so in fact, what we're seeing sometimes is companies like
- 13:03not only are they exaggerating the benefits of products, but they are actively behind
- 13:07the seeds lobbying against climate policy. Oh interesting, and so that is you
- 13:13know, very much green wise. Now when it comes to clothing, particularly
- 13:16is the big issue fast fashion because I feel like fast fashion itself, this
- 13:20idea of producing a ton of clothing that doesn't really last very long, I
- 13:24feel like just that concept can never be environmentally friendly, right, yeah,
- 13:30I mean I think so. I think there's a short answer, analog answer
- 13:33to what you're asking. And the short okay, okay, So short answer
- 13:37is like, yes, absolutely, fast fashion is a problem. And the
- 13:41media answer is it's not the only problem. So for sure, the fashion
- 13:45industry writ large, multi trillion dollar industry, in fact, responsible for up
- 13:48to eight percent of all greenhouse gas emissions worldwide. Massive and growing, like
- 13:54expected to keep growing, growing, growing, okay, and so you know,
- 13:56and it's not just fast fashion, like most luxury brands, most athletic
- 14:01brands are not doing nearly enough to transition their supply chains to for example,
- 14:05be powered on renewable energy to use you know, use less energy in their
- 14:09production and so like, is fast fashion a problem, yes, And as
- 14:13long as they're producing more and more and more and more, is that a
- 14:16problem. Yes, And there is not a clothing not a clothing brand.
- 14:24Some are doing well, but most are failing, like the vast majority are
- 14:26not doing what's needed, so actually, like it's a sector wide problem.
- 14:28So really, what I'm hearing is you're not letting rich people off the hook
- 14:33if they're buying luxury brands, correct, right, because their luxury brands still
- 14:35may be harmful to the environment. Yeah, and in fact probably still are
- 14:39quite harmful to the environment. Yeah. So I guess I also want to
- 14:43say though, because I think so often this gets framed as like an issue
- 14:46for consumers to deal with, and I don't think that at all, because
- 14:50I don't think, like what can we do. All we can do is
- 14:52look at what a company says and if it claims to be sustainable, like
- 14:56we are doing our best, and so actually it's incumbent on companies to be
- 15:00doing better making the investments and telling the truth so that we can make more
- 15:03informed choices, because right now we just can't. You preempted me because that
- 15:05was literally going to be my question of like what are we supposed to do?
- 15:09So, Liz, I appreciate your time tonight. Thanks so much for
- 15:13putting a lens on this and explaining it to me in a way that makes
- 15:16sense. Yeah, so happy to be here, folks. That was the
- 15:18senior campaigns director of stand Earth Liz McDowell. Check out their website at stand
- 15:24dot earth to learn more about them, and thank you so much to Pacific
- 15:28Sands Beach Resort and to FINO for supporting local conversations. Now stick around because
- 15:33in a whole show about consumer issues, JJ McCullough will be here to tell
- 15:37us why consumerism is actually a good thing. That's up next. Welcome back
- 15:50to this as Van color. We've been talking about consumer issues tonight, but
- 15:54let's zoom out to a broader question. Is there anything good about consumerism the
- 16:00aspiration of acquiring the things beyond the purpose of survival. Here to discuss is
- 16:04a political commentator and YouTuber based right here in Vancouver. He is JJ McCullough.
- 16:11And this is the crunch. So, Jj, you're just fishing for
- 16:18clicks at this point. I saw your last video and you're now saying that
- 16:22consumerism is a good thing. Well, I certainly said that consumerism isn't evil,
- 16:26which I feel like is often the kind of like dominant disposition in the
- 16:30culture these days. You know, we live in a consumerist society. We
- 16:33live in a capitalist sort of economy, right. We live at the culmination
- 16:37of a very long history of perfecting so many creature comforts in our lives,
- 16:42you know, whether that's food, fashion, you know, toys, games,
- 16:47you know, all sorts of objects that we just have that are the
- 16:49culmination, like I said, of a great sort of inheritance. And yet
- 16:52I feel like the dominant sort of theme and sort of like the broad culture,
- 16:56especially in sort of like intellectual culture, is that you're supposed to hate
- 16:59consumerism. Also feel guilty and ashamed for living in this marvelous society that has
- 17:03given us so many wonderful things, and so weirdly enough, it feels like
- 17:06a radical statement to just say, like this is good. I'm happy that
- 17:10we live in a thriving consumer of society. Wow. I just feel like
- 17:12there are so many downsides to consumerism. Now, I don't think it's like
- 17:17the evil of the world that perhaps some people may say it is. But
- 17:19I think when it comes to things like hoarding or wasteful spending beyond your means,
- 17:25or a certain type of snobbery. You know, consumerism does take us
- 17:27away from the things that matter, doesn't it. Well, I mean,
- 17:30consumerism can also be a source of bringing us closer to other people. Give
- 17:34you an example, Well, for example, Like, you know, you
- 17:37have a collection, right, you consume a whole bunch of things, whether
- 17:40that's you know, sports jerseys, Funko pops, you know, rare spoons,
- 17:44whatever it is. People have all sorts of collections. Yeah, and
- 17:45that gives you an ind to sort of speak with other people. Right,
- 17:49I was wearing my cool and the RUDEOU shirt. Yes, I spoke with
- 17:52your producer. We had an instant rapport because of my consumer decision. Right.
- 17:56There's lots of just ways in which sort of our small consumer choices allow
- 18:00us to connect with each other. And I think that's a that's a good
- 18:02thing, right, It's you're right, though, I mean obviously there's downsides
- 18:04to consumerism as well. Another thing that I would sort of say is,
- 18:07like, you know, the environmental impact of some of the things that we
- 18:11buy, in the way that things are being made, it is excess.
- 18:12But at the same time, what I would also add is that we've made
- 18:15a lot of progress as far as these kinds of things go. Like we
- 18:18have a reality show all about the shame of hoarding, for instance, Right,
- 18:22we're much more aware that this is a problem than we used to.
- 18:25And as I say in the video, Like, a lot of ways that
- 18:27our products are being made are much more environmentally conscious than they've ever been in
- 18:32the past. You know, it's easy to be cynical about this. All
- 18:33the corporations are just greenwashing and that kind of thing, but it is objectively
- 18:37true, for instance, that we're like using less plastic, that we have
- 18:40more robust recycling programs than ever before, that people are more conscious about things
- 18:45like the importance of reusing and reselling. So like, there's a lot about
- 18:48our consumer culture that I think is perfectly fine to be happy and thankful and
- 18:52pleased with. Do you think on a personal level we should set up guidelines
- 18:56in terms of how we look at consumerism. I like the fact that you
- 18:59brought up this idea of connecting with other people, but I feel like if
- 19:03consumerism is driving you into isolation, that's probably a bad thing. Or again,
- 19:07when it comes to excess or waste, Like, do you think consumers
- 19:10should think about it differently as opposed to just throwing out the baby with the
- 19:12bathwall. Yeah, exactly, And I think that you hit exactly on it.
- 19:15We shouldn't throw it out the baby with the bathwater, even though I
- 19:17feel like you know, when I imagine myself being in university or even in
- 19:21high school, I feel like you were often taught to just be shamed and
- 19:23embarrassed and disgusted that we live in this vulgar consumerist society, this vulgar capitalist
- 19:30economy and that kind of thing. And then but that's that sort of message,
- 19:33like what do you do with that? It's like, we're not going
- 19:36to overthrow the system, nor should we want to. So I think that
- 19:38a much more reasonable solution is to sort of say, like, yes,
- 19:41there's good things about consumerism, there's bad things about consumerism. Let's try to
- 19:45embrace a healthy consumerism that teaches us how to be responsible consumers totally not but
- 19:49not like just consumers that are racked with guilt and shame. Like we're engaging
- 19:53in this kind of like you know, religious sin that we have to sort
- 19:56of atone for. Right, That's just not I don't that that's a healthy
- 20:00attitude. It's hard to live in a society in which you have this dominant
- 20:03economic model that everybody participates in, right, But then everybody is sort of
- 20:07told by our intellectual betters that you're also supposed to feel ashamed to be participates.
- 20:11One thing I like is that I know, growing up, if I
- 20:14really wanted a certain toy or whatever, I would have to do chores,
- 20:17save up my money, and then when I actually got it, it did
- 20:21feel very rewarding. And I think there is something where you're tying consumerism into
- 20:25you know, a certain work ethic or just the idea of you have to
- 20:27work for something. I do think that there are some good aspects of it
- 20:30too. I've never been one of the evil guys. Well, and what
- 20:33you're saying is important as well, Like gratitude is important totally. That was
- 20:37the other thing that I was taught when I was a kid too, like
- 20:40take care of your toys, don't throw your clothes on the floor, you
- 20:42know, like just treat your objects with a certain degree of reverence, because
- 20:45you know, if you haven't worked hard for them, somebody has. Somebody
- 20:48had to acquire the money to purchase it, and you know, somebody made
- 20:52this in a factory somewhere. Like you'd be aware of these sort of like
- 20:55larger sort of social factors that go into creating the things that we have.
- 21:00But then once you have them, you know, appreciate them, don't take
- 21:02it for granted a great message. JJ. Always fun chatting with you.
- 21:04Thanks so much for your time tonight. Thanks for having me folks, Thank
- 21:07you so much for watching. And thank you to the Hosers, Eric Wickham
- 21:11stand Ertz, Liz McDowell and JJ McCullough for their time tonight. Now,
- 21:15if you have any thoughts about tonight's show, shoot me an email mo at.
- 21:21This isvancolor dot com. Are you boycotting any stores this month? Do
- 21:23you love consumerism? Let me know. Also find me on x or on
- 21:29TikTok at van Color. We will be back next week, but for now,
- 21:33this is Van Color and I'm moamir telling you that in a province where
- 21:37you can be anything, be colorful. Peace