Latest / The Big Nerd Gaming Podcast / The Epic Return of the Big Nerd Gaming Podcast
Transcript
- Westen: What is up everyone and welcome back to the big nerd gaming podcast revamped rebooted Remastered better than ever. It's here Thank God. I know everyone was really sad that was gone but man Thank God we're back. So Long story short, it was too much for me. It was too much to do all my things and also do this podcast thought about it more. And when I think about all the podcasts I like in general, like I have a lot of like individual journalists, like political guys that I like, but when they do their solo pods and they interview people, like I like it, but I've always been a guy that just likes a crew, you know? I want a crew. I want to put a crew together and you know, just the chemistry and it's just a better podcast experience. So the Big Nerd Gaming podcast is back. but instead of just me interviewing different people, we have a set crew now. And when I was thinking about who my set crew could be, I thought about the boys that I play rematch with and how half the time when we're playing rematch feels like a podcast anyway. Why don't we just do a podcast? mean, we're all white guys with mics, it makes sense. So let me introduce you. to the new members of the Big Nerd Gaming podcast here to fight off the tyranny of pixelbite.com. We will not be taking over. First off, I'm fighting them off from acquiring you guys. Now you're in their sights for sure. ⁓ first off, we got David who gets special thanks because all the fancy graphics you're seeing are all him. David: ⁓ don't... You don't want to see my replies to Anders. I was jumping ship. Andrew: hahahahah ⁓ David: You Westen: He's handling a lot of the production stuff, which was definitely the hardest thing for me. How's it going, David? David: going good. I mean, it's just been a long week, but ready to talk some games, play some games. Westen: What, I mean, just brief, you I don't wanna hear too much about you, but maybe just a little bit. Like, it's gonna be a little bit about you. Enough said. All right. Moving on. David: Yeah. What? No, that was... I'm trying to... I almost can't have card. Um, I don't know. Andrew: You Westen: I didn't expect to talk about myself on this podcast. David: I did... Let's go ahead and this out. We're just gonna edit this out. Westen: You Andrew: is just this humble. David: I'm just drawing a blank. I just was... No, no, no, no, no, no. I'm 100 % I needed this. Andrew: You got him, stopped him! Westen: Leave it all in. Leave it all in. At the job interview, when David goes to interview for new jobs, he's tell me about yourself. And he's just first question he blakes. It's over. Andrew: Leave it all. We gotta have it. David: ⁓ man, I just... Andrew: He wasn't expecting it. Westen: I didn't expect this! David: Let me have David. I'm on Blue Sky at D Sunday. ⁓ Play games, love sports from the DC area. ⁓ All DC teams. DC teams. ⁓ Yeah, sports, games. I don't know, nothing. ⁓ yeah, huge. Andrew: You want me to introduce myself? A man who needs no introduction. Westen: What sports seems ⁓ unfortunate? Okay. Well, congrats on the lottery, ⁓ the draft lottery. wasn't as cool as getting Kade, but yeah. So anyway, all right, that's David. David's a very smart guy. As I said, you can see all the production stuff he's doing. He went against me in ⁓ game awards predictions. He was the only one crazy enough to also predict game awards at the very start of the year. So we will continue that throughout the year. ⁓ David: Curse team. We're learning. We're learning. It's not perfect. Westen: And yeah, he's a good guy overall, even though he does like blueprints. All right, moving on. We got Andrew, aka Man Child Media Review, which makes it sound like he has a website, but he's been very lazy about that. How's it going, man? Andrew: Dude, it's good, no complaints. I'm loving it. I'm excited to be back for the show. I've been watching it the entire time. So I'm excited to actually be on it, despite the lack of website. You kind of stole part of my intro there. Westen: Yeah, maybe. ⁓ Andrew, arguably the biggest fan of big nerd gaming. Arguably. Andrew: Number one, number one, David cannot have it. I don't know, all the work he's put in to getting you back up and running with the show here. Westen: Yeah, yeah, he might be. I think he passed you. David: I mean, I'm not the biggest fan, I'm the biggest hater. Number one hater. Number one troll. Andrew: The biggest hater, there we go, okay. What better crew then? Westen: Yeah, it's and that's and that's what I like about this dynamic is, you know, even though we are all white guys with mics, we do actually disagree occasionally. ⁓ Sometimes vehemently, sometimes about blueprints, sometimes about Kingdom Hearts. So yeah, I'm sure I'm sure that'll pop up on occasion. ⁓ So I'm also changing the general structure of the show. It's not going to be there will still be ranks, but they will be kind of an end piece of the show. So we're going to talk news kind of. Andrew: Kingdom Hearts, Westen: ⁓ I don't care that much about most gaming news. I think it's mostly awful. Like I just, I just went to Kinda Funny Games Daily, which is, I like Kinda Funny. It's actually one of my favorite podcast networks. But they do a daily podcast. They talk about news. The last like five headlines are about Soros sales, about GTA 6 pre-order leaks, about Kingdom Hearts 4 being teased potentially, which I mean, I'm sure that got Andrew a little. you know, chub, but other than ⁓ that, yeah. Nintendo's raises switch to price. Star Fox costs how much? I think there's another GTA price discourse. Like, I only want to talk about the news if there's something interesting to talk about. I don't want to chase every stupid headline. So ⁓ we will talk about news when it's significant and when I feel like there's discussion value, but overall probably won't be tons of news talk on the show. So we'll able to be talking about what we're playing, which might. Andrew: Love to hear it, but not horribly exciting news. Westen: Intersect with kind of the gaming discourse, which will definitely happen on this episode as we'll be talking about a very special very woke game ⁓ and And then we'll do some ranks at the end, so it's gonna be good. So let's get to it. So Like I said, no news. really care about this week. So we're gonna talk about games and there's one game We have all played this week and that is mixtape. Is it a game though? ⁓ We'll talk about the discourse lightly. mean, the most of the discourse is brain dead and not worth discussing. I do think there's like a dynamic playing off it that we will get into, but just general thoughts on the game. ⁓ Andrew, you teased your thoughts on blues, just beautiful work, ⁓ inadvertently hyping the podcast. So yes. Give me your thoughts on Mixtape. Andrew: The Veg Post King. David: Yeah. Andrew: I do not like it's MIM. I thought it was super weak. I have no interest in like you're saying, like all the discourse around it's woke or like it's, it got a weird like slam from the anti-woke people about like it being woke. And it's like, I don't see any of that having done the four hours. It's like a bunch of people saying that it's it's gay or it's LGBTQ. And it's like, there's actually none of that present at all. like, it's just, I feel like if people see that art style and they immediately go after it. and assume something out of an indie studio. ⁓ And I have no interest in that part of the discourse. But as a game, I did not like it. I thought it was super weak. I thought it would have been better as a feature film, as like an animated film. ⁓ I just thought like everything about it would have been better if all of the mini games had been removed. Like they all worked. They're all good stuff. Like, ⁓ like going and TPing, you know, a teacher's house or... skateboarding around with your friends or breaking into like abandoned places or construction sites with your friends. That's all really good stuff. But I felt like all of it was good because my adolescence was good. And it brought me back to moments in my adolescence that I really enjoyed and appreciated and thought were amazing. But then when the gameplay of it is you strafe back and forth with left and right on the analog stick and you click one button to throw a paper towel, there's just not a lot there. And that's fine, like I don't mind a visual novel sort of game. I just played And Roger a couple of weeks ago and that's an hour long and it had a huge impact. I cried, I thought it was amazing. Like thought the little mini game elements were really solid and it got its point across and its story across much better than this. So I just thought that like everything that this did other than presentation, I thought was kind of weak. Westen: We'll definitely get into the whether it would have been better as a movie thing. That was what I wanted to discuss because the bad discussion has been, it a game? And that's stupid, right? Obviously it's stupid. ⁓ Just cause it has no true fail states, whatever. obviously I want to avoid spoilers, but I feel like we'll be able to touch on them a little bit. I feel like most people that have been interested in this game have probably played and beat it. Like that's one thing. Andrew: Yeah, of course it is. David: Yeah. Westen: with movies versus games, like I'll see on movie discourse, people will just be spoiling stuff. But if people are really into movies, I guess they just kind of assume within like a month you've seen the frigging movie, because it's two to three hours. So mixtape, four hours. I think anyone that's interested has been like, okay, I'll play the game. David, did you have any additional thoughts ⁓ your experience? Did you like it more than Andrew? David: I did at the same time. think expectations going in because of all the reviews and you know, lofty, just kind of lofty expectations. I left kind of disappointed. I think I fall like at a seven out of 10, of for different reasons. I think like there are moments that are like pretty high in there. I think there's a lot of low, low moments where I'm just like, this is boring. Like what? You know, the characters themselves, I see some people say they're like unlikable or unrelatable. I think there's one of the three characters for everybody. You know, it's whether it's, I think for me, probably more Cassandra, oddly enough, just kind of like the goody two shoes, ⁓ overbearing parents kind vibe. But I think the main character for me is just kind of unlikable. I don't, kind of a snob in terms of music and all these different things. And it's kind of... I just wanted more in terms of like, I liked some of the mini games were good. Some just felt like a lot of filler. You know, it's just some of the moments just didn't add up for me. Westen: definitely want to get into the characters more too. ⁓ games, I will say. So my review, I think by the time this podcast is out, my review will be up. And I say that this is the warrior, warrior where rock opera that life is strange fans have been waiting for. ⁓ But it's like, it's fucking warrior where like kind of like just a lot of random ass mini games. I mean, not quite the same, but you know what I mean? Like, ⁓ I thought that the mini games where it was basically felt like you were playing a music video were kind of cool. Like when the song hits and it's like, you know, like early in the skateboarding one, like the song has like a point where they clap and then all of sudden everyone claps during that. Like that shit's cool in my opinion. Like the kind of hi-fi rush vibes were like, I wish that they were all kind of like that. Like there's one where you're like sweeping like leaves or something and it's like, ⁓ okay. David: Yeah, it just... Andrew: Yeah, like what just what are we do- what are we doing here? Or like even like some of them play with like, okay, a character being kind of dragged through an area kind of like you were saying, like I enjoyed the the kind of music video like ones, but like the ones where you're just like a character's flying through the air and just like colliding with environment, like with objects and like they're scattering and it's like, okay, I've seen that effect before, like what is this- what does this add to anything that like, ⁓ the items move when you fly through them. Westen: There's the. Yeah, they needed to lean harder into it. felt like every mini game, I would like it for a second and then I'd be, like I wish they were warrior-ware length. I felt like a lot of them went on maybe just a minute, minute and a half too long. It never offended, like I guess I'm higher in the game than you. I gave it a 7.5. To me, the strength of the game is just, A, just the general direction. I was just constantly amazed by just how much they were going for it and I respected that. Andrew: Yes. Westen: Like even when I didn't like something, they just moved on. Like, you know, within four minutes you're doing something else and it's just constant. Like there's just constantly stuff going on. There's some writing that I really like. Occasionally I didn't like it. Like there are scenes where they're sitting around talking about high school and I felt like they're talking about high school the way that my buddies in our mid thirties would talk about high school. And I'm like, no, you don't know enough yet. to talk about this experience in like this like introspective way. Like you don't have enough life experience to know enough to talk about it this way. Nobody I knew at 18 was talking about life in the way you are talking about it right now. This feels like 40 year olds or late 30 year olds writing 18 year olds in the way that they feel. So that was the one thing, but there was some clever stuff. There was some moments that surprised me and made me laugh. I mean, that's the thing. It just constantly surprised me. You just don't know what's gonna come next. It just pates so well and I do, you and it's a game built around the soundtrack and it has a clever concept to integrate that soundtrack and the soundtrack's good. Like it's not, and that's probably my other thing, it's not as good as I hoped. As a white guy who likes alt rock, indie rock, I listened to 89X in Detroit my whole friggin' All the music's like from at least 10 years before. Andrew: Yeah. Westen: Like, you know, I'm looking, I'm like smashing pumpkins. I'm like waiting for fucking 1979 to come on. It does not come on. Hate to say it. I think it's loud or something is the song. It's a good song, but love. Yeah. It's a fine song, but it's not like the one I won't even that. That's the funniest thing about the discourse. ⁓ this is a licensed soundtrack. Where's all this money coming from? Have you seen the songs like they're not that crazy? David: love. It's love or something, I think. Andrew: Yeah It's like I only know like four of the songs exactly. It's like I didn't recognize any of this. David: It's all... There's like one song that I would, yeah. But I mean there's some good songs, like I don't like this type of music and I didn't leave thinking like, ⁓ what am I listening to? Westen: Yeah. ⁓ yeah, there are. Andrew: ⁓ yeah! Westen: But there are some big moments. does hit on some of the coming of age stuff, some of the letting go stuff. ⁓ I do think that's occasionally hurt by, like David said, the characters. Like Stacey is a bit snobby, but she's like confident enough at times where I didn't hate her or anything. But like her justification for not being able to go on this road trip was kind of weak. It's not explained as well as it could have been. They do like a light explanation, but it's not that great. ⁓ It's just like, I think David kind of said, it's just, I just felt like there's a lot of highs and lows. The lows rarely bothered me tons because you just move on so quick. ⁓ Like there's a party scene and you do the whole thing like through a video camera. And it was kind of cool at first, but once again, it just goes on a little too long. And that's just, ⁓ there's a scene where, David: He Westen: you're in cars and you can make like the fireworks explode and it works with the music. It's kind of cool. But then I think I think they do it twice and it's just a little too long each and that's just it just holds it back. I was into it the whole time. Like I started it. I had no desire to play anything else even. I know it's only four hours, but it's me we're talking about here. Like I became up and I wanted to see it through the end. ⁓ I like some of the writing. I think there's funny moments. I think there are some fun mini games like said the skateboarding, the clapping, there's a couple other crazy ones. But man, it is, you know, maybe it's just the expectations. I think it seemed like a game that was like literally right up my alley. And it was disappointing in that regard too. I liked it though. Like it was, was a fine experience. But yeah, I mean, obviously when you see 10, 10 out of 10, think. For a second it was at like 94 on OpenCritic, which is insane. It's down to like 87 now, but even then, not quite where you'd want it. But I'm in that seven to 7.5 range. Once I write my review, I'll probably decide for sure. I feel like I'm gonna shit on it more than I'm positive. So even though I did, I did enjoy it. There's just a lot to shit on, but like it is a well-paced experience. has, I liked their last game. ⁓ David: You're more positive on here. Westen: The Artful Escape. it's Beethoven dinosaur. Like it's just fascinating to see how much they've evolved in terms of like their general cinematic direction and just how bold they are. Like Artful Escape had some like crazy moments, but it felt very like classic, like within this genre. And this game just goes for it all the time. And I did respect that. And that kept me somewhat engaged, but yeah, a little disappointing. ⁓ Andrew David talked about the characters. ⁓ Stacey. Andrew: It's funny, I feel like I actually, so much of what you guys said, like I'm almost the opposite on. Where like, the score, like I'm with you guys on what's wrong with it, but like that makes me go like, ⁓ it's a six. Like it just didn't, like it doesn't execute well enough that it justifies being a game to me, which again, I know we'll get to, but like to me that as a result, then it's like, okay, then the experience is subpar and not violently subpar. I'm not gonna hate on this game for years. I think it might. end up in down the line, years down the line on the list that we're going to talk about at the end of the episode. But like, I don't hate the game. I don't like have any ill will toward the game. It just wasn't, it was subpar. I thought the characters actually, I thought was interesting. I got about halfway through and I started being like, ⁓ these kids are kind of insufferable. And that's when it clicked for me that I liked them because I was like, I actually felt like, these are other than what you're saying about like kind of the introspective retrospective look that they have on high school already. so young, like I actually thought that they were written really well as kids, because I was like, ⁓ like she's, yeah, the main character, Stacey, she's kind of snobby. And it's like, yeah, but like a lot of kids, like, because they don't have a fully established identity yet, they latch onto certain things. And so that's their obsession. That's the thing they know everything about. And they kind of become insufferable about it. And I thought that that was actually really fitting. They kind of all fell into a certain bubble or a certain group where that worked. I thought the writing was terrible though, when it came to the major kind of parents letting go of their kids kind of aspect with the cop. thought that like that whole plot, like the main plot kind of of the game was like that was where the writing was at its absolute lowest to me was like all the stuff where they're hanging out and they're kind of philosophizing like, yeah, some of it's a little too retrospective, a little too introspective, a little too thoughtful. Westen: Yeah. Andrew: But I also think that like, ⁓ like young kids, especially these kids who are like potheads, you're just getting high eating Cheetos hanging out. And it's like, maybe you are kind of doing these nonsense like, ⁓ maybe life is this bro. Like, I think that works. I think that's fine. But I think every time an adult kind of bisected with the story, it was like, it so cringe. David: Ha! Westen: Andrew's like, these kids were kind of insufferable, but you know what? I was insufferable as a kid, so I relate. But yeah, so there's two major conflicts in the game and they're big conflicts. like, especially if you're 18 years old, these are big, big conflicts and they are resolved so quickly and so cleanly, like just like it's done. I'm like, what? That's it? Like it's solved? Jesus. Andrew: Actually though, yeah, I mean I still am, but like, yes. David: haha Yeah, that's exactly like the conflicts you wanted so much more. They felt like they were building up to something, which I thought was kind of decently done, but then it just resolved way too quickly. There could have been so much more emotion behind it all, like between the conflicts between the friend group and then the parents. It just kind of was a letdown. Westen: And the performances are fine, but yeah, I don't think they're a standout. Like I'm not ranking anyone overly high in my rankings for performances this year. do you think that this would be a better movie than a game? David: No, I think it was just poorly executed. think, think, I think, I think mixtape in a. Yeah, I think mixtape in a vacuum. I'm not saying like the game doesn't need to be life of strange, have a bunch of choices and like branching paths and stuff. Like it's fine if it's a linear, you know, there's like discussion around like, oh, this needs like fail states or like, you know, things that go wrong and like failure. I'm like, Hey, why not? Every game needs Andrew: man. That's why though. That's why it needs to be a movie. It's like if it had been executed well... David: I just think if it was, ⁓ there's more interactivity ⁓ like build emotion, like that's ⁓ these games do well and why they're better off as games and not movies is that interactivity between whether it's the things you do, the things you read, the characters you interact with that you are choosing to do ⁓ that emotion. But I don't think Mixtape really capitalized on any of Andrew: I agree. think my argument would almost be that like at the level that they're achieving right now, it should have been an animated film because the kind of the lackluster story, the lackluster gameplay, like more energy goes into one thing. And so it improves, right? But if they were achieving at the level that they could have been, I think it actually does really work. Like you're saying it almost like to me, I almost thought of it later on as this kind of interactive time capsule. is like what they were going for and had they achieved on that, you're right, it is better as a game. But because they don't, I just can't feel like it should be a game. It is a game, it is. The argument of like, it's not a game, that's not true. But I don't know that it should be right now. Westen: The one thing I think you will agree with, Andrew, because you're a sucker for this stuff, the ending, 100%, is very much improved by being a game. Andrew: Oh, uh, it was, it's in my notes as like a paragraph. I wish I could talk about it. It's the most, I'm so glad you brought it up because I almost forgot. It is the, the last five minutes is the best part of the game. It's brilliance. It's, that is actually sheer brilliance. It actually probably is what stopped me from being like, this game sucks. Westen: not anything complicated, but ⁓ is a level of agency that just, it makes the whole experience feel 10 times more real, I guess, than it would as a movie. ⁓ I think ⁓ I had more rhythm, I would have enjoyed playing the game more too. Like ⁓ I've talked about the music, like when you're in the fucking car ⁓ everybody's like, know, and it's like, but. Andrew: Brilliant, headbanging. Westen: Mine was kind of terrible because I'm just not, I couldn't get the rhythm down. Like, like if I could get the rhythm down, it would have been friggin sweet, but I couldn't. So I can't really hold that against the game. I think that is one example of where it would have been a little better, where I think being a game makes it better. I think someone pointed out too, I haven't seen the movie because I don't really watch movies, but apparently, you know, this is inspired by Ferris Bueller or whatever. And I guess there's a similar scene where these like run through a bunch of stuff. David: haha Westen: because it's a game, it's a lot more elaborate, ⁓ like the whole chase scene than it would have been otherwise. So it's things like that too. ⁓ But yeah, mean, sadly, I mean, we disagree at some points, but we are all kind of roughly in the same zone, which is disappointing. David: Mm-hmm. I guess I have a question though. Those moments where you're, you know, you're exploding the fireworks or, know, you're doing these things, you're like, you know, they're banging on the car, head banging. Like, do you think it would be better if they gamified that more? Like whether it was like you had to be to the beat or you got like score points? Like, do you think it being freestyle, like whatever you want to do is... Andrew: Yes. Westen: I think Freestyle's better. I don't know how they, I mean, I guess they could have turned this into a quasi rhythm game too. ⁓ That would have been, I guess if they really did a good job, maybe. But it's crazy, because the Artful Escape had these moments where you could just like kind of riff on your guitar randomly. those just worked way better. That just worked better as like a free form thing, because I mean, that is guitar. Andrew: Mm-hmm. David: Yeah, no, don't think so. Westen: solo stuff is you're just kind of riffing. So just, that freedom worked. And then the stuff they wanted you to do here felt like ideally, so Andrew might be right in that way. it, the way it wants you to play, it only really makes sense if you're doing it in rhythm. So yeah, it actually might, know, the more I think about it, if they had it like guided to get you to like a, cause also you don't know what's coming in the song. I mean, that's part of why, why it's hard. ⁓ So like if I replayed it right after, I might've done better, but. The Artful Escape, the riff moments make more sense because you're literally riffing on a guitar and in this one you're trying to do stuff to the beat you don't necessarily know it's coming so ⁓ yeah it might have actually been better if they gave a fight or more. Andrew, right? Once in a while, I guess. Andrew: blind squirrels and whatnot. Westen: So I have a game, so we're each going to talk about a game this week besides mixtape. ⁓ Who wants to start? ⁓ Andrew, do you want to talk about mouse? ⁓ Andrew: Sure, let's do it. Yeah, I finished MousPi for hire a couple weeks ago. There's another one that got some, I think, incredibly foolish discourse, primarily just because of that like absolute wiener review from IGN. But like, I won't get too deep into it. Like, what I think is funny about the... Westen: Check bignergaming.com, I got my thoughts there. So that's all that needs to be said. Andrew: Yeah. Like, it's fun. that game, I think is really, that's like a solid, like right down Main Street 7.5. Like, I think the presentation there is incredible. It's another one that might actually end up a couple years down the line looking back on the list of games that don't age horribly well. Where like, it's really fun. ⁓ It's a good, like kind of boomer shooter, doom shooter ⁓ sort of game. Like the gunplay works. ⁓ All the different guns are cool looking. The animations are incredible. Like the style is brilliant. The rubber hose, like 30s cartoon look is just absolutely nailed. ⁓ The jazz soundtrack is awesome. All the kind of allusions to ⁓ noir films and that genre I think were fun and really cool. despite the complaints about it being all kind of cartoony cheese references and goofiness, I thought it was actually kind of interesting that down the stretch in the game, they actually kind of addressed some interesting stuff like the destruction of Black Wall Street. It's not like they're, I'm not sitting here saying that it's some deeply serious game, but they actually did a little bit more than I would have expected with kind of referencing real world things and then kind of doing a bit of social commentary with it. Nothing insane, but it's not like I'm looking to be hit over the head either. So it did a little bit more in that line than I actually would have thought of. And I definitely see the criticisms. Like I rolled my by the end at the, all the cheese references. Like it definitely got a little much even for the people saying like, yeah, it's about cartoon mice. Like, yeah, okay. But you could have maybe dialed it back like one or two points. ⁓ And then I think my big complaints would be that like the guns are all set dressing. It doesn't function like Doom in the way that like one gun is really gonna work on this type of enemy and then this gun is gonna be for this. It doesn't work that way at all to the point where by probably halfway through the game because I love like mob shooters and like and mob movies. I was just using the Tommy gun like dude like I'm just gonna rip with the Tommy gun. You almost never run out of ammo. Every time that I did you switch to the pistol and you switch right back as soon as you get ammo like the guns just It was fun to see the animations, I upgraded some of them just to kind of see what they do. But beyond that, actually mechanically it didn't really do too much. And then even the boss battles, it takes until probably midway through the game for those to get to a point where they're particularly doing anything interesting. The final boss I thought was really solid and really kind of that brought some crazy stuff to the table. And there were a couple in the midpoint where they did some interesting things. I don't know if we want to... talk spoilers on it, but yeah, I think it's a good game. It's right down Main Street, it's a solid game. I'd suggest it to people who like shooters, and if you like that old cartoon style, you're gonna love that game, 100%. It's a fun time, it's not as magnificent as maybe I would've liked, but it's really good. Westen: Yeah, I'm about halfway through. I'm probably in that 7.5 to 8 range as well, I'm not sure. I just fought probably one of the bosses you're talking about and I was like, ⁓ this is the first good boss in the game. Like it actually makes you use the flashlight, which is kind of nice, just interesting. But yeah, 100%. So, hey, I just wanted to say I did up the difficulty to hard because I literally was never dying. And I was like, all right. And actually I think hard is not a bad balance. David: Hmm. Westen: And that, and exactly what you're talking about as part of it, why? Cause my biggest issue with the game is there's just too many guns that are mediocre and just don't work as well as you'd hope. And the one that does is the Tommy gun. So if you're on normal, it's so hard to not just rip with that. Cause it's, cause you have so few, I'm over halfway through the game. There's still like, I think four guns ish that I have to unlock, but there's almost nothing that's good long range besides that gun. Andrew: Yep, just rip it. Westen: But then it also is pretty good short range. Like it's so high functioning and every other gun has this like massive weaknesses. Like the little pistol is just weak as hell. Kind of has bad sound design. ⁓ The shotgun is once again weak sound design, but also, I don't know, I have moments where I'm like moving quick and I shoot someone and it just like doesn't seem to affect them. ⁓ I think the art style too enhances the game. but it kind of hurts the game in terms of the animations because as good as the animations are, they are not really dynamic to what you're doing. Like obviously if you shoot someone in the leg in Doom, like they're gonna react to the leg, like all that's gonna happen is you're gonna see a little hit point on their leg with this game. I mean, that's kind of common if it's not like a full blown 3D thing, but, and they do have like different animations if you shoot someone's head off, like the head will explode or whatever, or like the poison gun makes them evaporate, same with. David: Hmm. Westen: burning them to death with the burning shotgun. So I mean, there is stuff there, but the shooting gets a little repetitive and there's just too many guns that I don't like. ⁓ But I also upped the game to hard so that I had to use more guns, because I also didn't like just being stuck on one gun. So, but yeah, the art style is incredible. It is still like a fun shooter. It is fun. Jesus, Andrew. ⁓ Leave it in, leave it in. ⁓ Andrew: Yikes. Big mouse drop. David: The producer in me is going crazy. Andrew: Continue. Yikes. It was a successful mute when I went to take a sip. Westen: Can't take this guy anywhere can't take this guy anywhere, but Andrew: and it wasn't. Westen: But yeah, it does just enough well and it's just unique enough. I do wish the environments they had done something different with the environments, because as awesome as the character models and the guns look, like the black and white plain environments, I don't know, maybe a pop of color actually would have done it better. And I think I saw like a mod or something where the environments have a little color to them. I think that would have done... Yeah, the blood mods maybe, but... But yeah, it's solid. David: It's all like a blood mod too. Yeah, I don't know. Andrew: say anything about any of that. Spoilers. Westen: It's a solid first person shooter. It has the Doom stuff going for with the unique thing. It does. I've kind of fallen off the plot a little bit, but early on it was dragging me in because I was like, whoa, this is way darker than I expected. There's a card game that's very simple, a little overly simple, and there's some flaws with it. Like you can't pick your deck. So like if I acquire new cards that are less than ideal, then I'm just stuck with this crappy card and it might get drawn like it's stupid. Andrew: So you actually can, but it's not until you've unlocked like 80 % of the cards. And so by that point, it's like, you've already won like 25 games. It's like, it's completely worthless. Westen: That's outrageous. That's outrageous. That's so stupid. But it's a baseball game and it is like conceptually lot of fun and I've had fun with it. over time it has worn out its welcome. like getting 10 fun card games out of a first person shooter is kind of cool. Like good for them. But yeah, solid 7.58 for me. We'll see how it ends. Maybe those last bosses will get me or maybe I'll just get more and more tired of the Andrew: It's neat. Westen: lack of enjoying all the guns. So I feel like I'll end up at 7.5 where you are. Too much agreement. Don't like it. ⁓ Where's the discourse? This is supposed to be edgy. This is supposed to be unlike anything else. right. David, let's talk about blueprints instead of vampire. Okay. Vampire Andrew: No discourse. David: Need more hot takes. Westen: crawlers for David. That was your selection this week. You beat it. You beat it. Okay. David: Yeah, I wrapped it up about a week ago. Yes, I actually 100 % the game. mean, there's, I think there's, I think there's like 162 just like bronze trophies. ⁓ But you get a trophy for literally every single thing you do. Like, Westen: Ha ha ha! Yeah, I have like, I think 72 and I've really only put like five or six hours in. So yeah. David: Yeah, so look you're at a hundred percent the game, but ⁓ Westen: So that's not looking good. David: I think it does a good job of, you know, if you enjoyed Vampire Survivors, it's basically that, in deck builder form. I think it does a good job hoarding that formula of, you know, getting upgrades, combining things, killing lots of mobs, know, seeing numbers on the screen, know, dopamine, you know, dopamine, dopamine everywhere. mean, you have like ultra kills and all these different things, but it just feels formulaic. It just, once you hit a certain point, everything just kind of feels the same. Like the characters don't, cause like it just, it becomes too easy to go, like become super powerful. ⁓ Like go infinite, there's this whole combo you know, that encourages you to cast cards, like an order, like one, two, three. just becomes too easy to increase your combos. I mean, think I died once. like actually died like in like 20 hours. It took me 20 hours to apply it in the game. And I just want more choice, more difficulty, more friction. It just felt like I was just going through the motions, unlocking stuff. Meta progression is really strong in that game. Like it's kind of slow early, but then you unlock a bunch of things like more rerolls, ⁓ more health. health regen, like all these different things that just make your life easier, which is good, but then the difficulty doesn't really match that. I found myself like late game, like the levels become longer, like take like an hour. Yeah, they become longer and slower and like eat like the, like the non-boss areas, like the mobs, they just take a while. And I found myself like, I don't think this is a healthy mindset with these games. It's like where, Westen: Jesus, really? David: You want to avoid the enemies because it's just taking too long. Like it's like this balance of like, I too, like, am I strong enough to beat the boss? Like, I don't feel like fighting these dudes. And it's like, that's not, I think like, you know, games like Slay the Spire do that well, where they put you on a path and like, you always feel like you need to get stronger versus like blow through the, you know, just the levels, which, so I think I fall like at eight out of 10. I actually do enjoy it. It's addicting. I mean, like Vampire Survivors, I think. I don't know if I should expect more from the game because it executes what it wants to do well, but I think other deck builders fit what I want more. Just more strategy, more friction, more difficulty. Westen: It's exactly that. It somehow perfectly captures the Empire survivors in a deck builder, which makes no sense. But that's also why the game doesn't really work to me, because that doesn't make sense. deck builders are not about like simple mindless gameplay. yeah, like I'm early on and I get the same stuff. Like there is the dopamine hits over and over. That's great. ⁓ The meta progression is great. You always feel like you're accomplishing something, but David: You Westen: I got really early in and I'm already, cause I mean, when you level up too, it's like, you don't really get stronger. You just get another card. Unless I missed something, didn't explain it, but. David: Do you not really know you get another card that allows you to like enable combos and upgrades and stuff Westen: Yeah, I mean... But sometimes it's a bad thing to get another card and you can't pass on them. So it's like, I don't know. ⁓ David: Well, eventually. The meta progression is really strong in this game. The same with the Vampire Survivors. You could not beat the game without it. Which is kind of like, it's not like a Slay the Spire or a Hades where your skill, with skill you can do, you can beat the game on your own. You have to have the meta progression. Which I've never been too much of a fan of in Roguelikes. Westen: So you eventually unlock that. No, no. But you can discard cards though, eventually. David: Well, you can choose to skip upgrades like you could in Vampire Survivors. You can skip, you can banish. Westen: Why, this is the two straight card games we've talked about where a basic feature is not available at the start. You have to unlock it like halfway in the game. What is going on? ⁓ Yeah. Andrew: you David: Well yeah, this is why these games for me where the meta progression is super heavy, it feels like I'm not playing the full game until like a third of the way in. Westen: Early on, was like kind of out on it, because I was, A, I was trying to beat every enemy, which already in the early levels is making each one take too long. And like they show you the combo thing early on, but you don't realize that it's like what the whole game is built around. So I was just kind of playing cards ⁓ and I didn't fully understand how it worked. So I wasn't even doing it right. But I was still winning. And then I hit the point where I was like, ⁓ I get the combo system and I'm using it. like, ⁓ this is like a cool thing. Like you got to. you know, try and get a nice balance of values. Like there's some strategy here, it's just enough. But then after another few hours with that, I'm like, okay, ⁓ I'm hoping for more. ⁓ And yeah, like for me, when I play, my strategy is like looking at the map and trying to figure out, because obviously you have to fight a lot of enemies just to get through to beyond that. So it's like, my goal is just to skip as many fights as possible and I'm still winning. And it's like, sometimes I have terrible luck. with the cards, like I'm not building combos. I'm still winning, it'll take forever. ⁓ So yeah, and you saying that the levels go on longer later, that just, that killed my boner for this game. David: Yeah, I mean the difficulty does go up. Yeah, the difficulty does go up and you have like more ways to manipulate the RNG, but your choices don't like... Sure, there's like, okay, I this in my deck and I know this combos with this like an evolution because you can make just like a vampire survivors. You can make like if you combine like the whip with the heart, you can you get like a stronger whip, you know, and it becomes one card. ⁓ And then there's like... a whole gem like socket system where you put tie upgrades to cards and like there's choices there but overall I don't feel like there's ever a wrong choice it just feels like a different choice and I want there to be wrong choices I want to learn throughout my progression you know because otherwise it just game is too easy I mean it's very accessible it's not like I'm gonna say it's too accessible but it just I want some more growth Westen: Yeah. Do you think this would be a good entry point for people into this genre or is it just too not or do you think it's not representative enough of what this genre is about? David: 100%. I think it's a representative enough. think there's enough elements there of like, you're crafting your deck, you you're learning, like it's not always right to take an upgrade or like certain things and like the overall deck building strategy of like, it's not always the quality of the card, it's what fits your deck. And I think that's like a common thing, like Slay the Spire. Like it's not always taking the best card. Sometimes it's taking the card that fits your deck and what you want to do. And I think it does a good job of that. It's approachable. It is on the easier side. ⁓ Yeah, I think it would actually be a perfect start for that. think much like Vampire Survivors, kind of that whole bullet heaven they call it, Westen: Yeah, it's just, yeah, I it. I had it at a seven. I feel like I might try it one more time and then I'll probably immediately flame out because I'm just out of the mode with it. I just, and the more I think it's one of those games where like in the moment I was like, okay, it's a seven. Like there's a lot I don't like, but like you said, the meta progression strong. There's just good vibes, like the way it captures everything, constant level ups. And then. You get out of the game for a weeks and you start thinking about it you're like, God, wait, I don't think I ever want to play that game again. And it just gets worse in my mind the more I think about it. And this discussion has not helped whatsoever. So I'm downgrading it to a. David: Oops. Yeah. Andrew: it makes you feel any better, I'm taking notes, because I've never played any of these deck builder games, so maybe it'll be my jumping on point. Westen: I think Bellatro, especially for a ⁓ gambling fiend such as yourself, I think Bellatro, yeah. Yeah, Bellatro is the king for that to me. ⁓ I could see it. I could see it being an okay entry level. But that's what I like about Bellatro. has the pick up and play, but it still has enough depth. And that's why I think that will be the ideal one. Andrew: ⁓ I guess, yeah. I played Bellatro, I never mind that. I guess that counts. David: Yeah. Andrew: Yeah, that game's bull- David: Yeah, it's just not as punishing like Slay the Spire. I mean, there's people that don't beat the first, like their first runs for like, you know, 25 hours plus. I mean, it just, it's, it's, it's punishing, you know, it teaches it really ⁓ punishes you for like making wrong car choices, going the wrong direction, you know, choosing upgrades when you shouldn't like it's punishing and vampire survivors or crawlers is the opposite of that. Westen: Yeah. Yeah, slay the- Sleigh of the Spire was my onboarding to the genre and I... David: Yeah, well know you don't play early access games so I've been I have been playing a lot of Slay This Fire too which at some point I'm sure we'll talk about. Westen: Yes, ⁓ I have real good discipline with that, because there is like a lot of early access games that are like, I'd love to start fields of mystery out right now. I'm not doing it. I refuse. All right. So we are mostly shitting on games today, which is fine. Sometimes that happens. Gaming world needed more of this, you know. ⁓ Andrew: Yes, negativity, we love it. This is why Pixelbyte is coming after you, by the way. Westen: They're they don't like my takes. I Andres legitimately doesn't like my takes to be fair. so I am going to I thought about talking about sorrows, which would be a pretty good one, but I'm reaching the end. So maybe on the next pod, I've been playing a lot of David: Ha! Westen: ⁓ I think I'm about halfway through We'll see how it ends. ⁓ I've heard that last hours are getting better, but. I'm pretty into it. Like I'm at like an eight out of 10 right now. And I kind of feel like this is like a mildly under looked gem this year. Like the vibes are incredible. This is some of the best pixel art ever with this art style. Like the lighting effects in particular are unbelievable. It's so good. I said the music, just all the cyberpunk stuff. If you like that genre, you're going to be into it. But the real highlight for the game for me is actually the combat. ⁓ It is basically 2d Batman or or spider-man whatever whatever you prefer and early on I'm like, okay, this might be a little too simple, but they keep adding mechanics you keep getting new mechanics and They keep adding more and more enemies on the screen and it's actually it's pretty good like when you Like just like Batman, you know or spider-man when you're really in a flow state, you're hitting you're dodging you're countering at the right point and then you also get a gun that charges and can take someone out. I just unlocked an overdrive which gives me unlimited ammo so I can really just shoot everybody. It's kind of like a super or whatever. It's actually pretty good. ⁓ I think the difficulty balancing was good. I just had a boss fight that I thought was pretty well made. It's every time. ⁓ If anything, I think my issue with the game is there's not enough combat. ⁓ There's a lot of platforming and the platforming in the game kind of annoying. ⁓ There is a... slight delay to the jump, which is constantly mildly awkward to me. And the pixel art, as beautiful as it is, does not offer a lot of detail, just kind of hard to do. And they're not like, there's like mild yellow paint kind of, but there's a lot of points where I'm like, just really searching around the environment, figuring out where the hell I'm supposed to go and dying, because I thought I could jump here and I couldn't. And that stuff's kind of annoying, but think it's pretty good. ⁓ if it keeps ramping up ⁓ we're like, the story's fine. And I, I feel like it's going to get to a point where it could be a lot better. I be into it. I don't know. ⁓ I'm, ⁓ feel ⁓ I think game's at a 7.7 on open critic. I'm just kind of surprised that it you know, kind of just quickly forgotten and overlooked after. such a long buildup, so I know neither of you guys have played it yet, I think, did you guys like Planet of Lana? Did ever play that one? David: Yeah. No, I know. I actually watched the front play the first one. So yes, I guess. Westen: I didn't like that. Yeah. Andrew: Those are both on the backlog. I've never tried them. David: Yeah, I mean, how does it replace? Because it reminds me of the Drifter from last year, kind of. It gives a similar vibe. I know it's a different gameplay style, like once more point and click adventure. Westen: Yeah, I arts. Yeah, definitely. I mean, obviously very different. mean, again, graphics are different. I mean, it's not the same type of setting, but and Drifter is more just you're just constantly going like you just it's blowing your mind plot wise. Replace isn't doing that, you know, but the Drifter is a point and click game. the the pace, the Drifter has like some pretty exciting moments despite being a point and click adventure, which is weird for that genre. But yeah, mean, every time a combat encounter is about to start, like I get excited, like I'm ready to go. So ⁓ I don't like Planet of Lana all that much, by the way, but that just has puzzle solving. And this game has a little bit of that, like sort of 2D, like environmental puzzle solving. It's also kind of mediocre. But for me, like just the combat, the visuals, the vibes are all enough to carry this to be a pretty strong game. And hopefully the story lands strong too at the end. ⁓ If it's been on your radar, I think it's worth a shot Andrew: funny, I'm glad to hear you say that, because it actually was one that, because of strictly the aura and the vibe and the look of it, I was like, this could be something that I'm into. And then I heard enough people say, it's mid, it's mid, it's mid. And I was kinda like, okay, it just kinda slid back down the backlog. It got the question mark in my notes, and I was about to take it off. And then you mentioned you might talk about it tonight, and I was like, we'll wait, we'll wait, we'll see. Now I'm kinda like, is it back, are we back? Am I gonna play it? Westen: Are we back? you into Batman combat? Like do you like it in those games or Spider-Man? David: Yeah. Andrew: I don't know, maybe. I love all those like the Arkham games, all the Spider-Man games. Yeah, dude. I'm in for all. Westen: Dude, yeah, dude, you'll like it. I think you'll like it, because it lands that combat in a 2D setting. like, there's a point a few hours in where I'm like, dude, I'm dodging way too much. Like there's way too much and I'm just constantly dodging. But they eventually give you enough counters and specials where I feel like I've reached a really nice flow with the combat. But I liked it for a moment one. Just, I felt like I saw the weaknesses coming and then they keep adding new elements that have push those aside so I'm happy with it. well hopefully that gets you guys to play it. I have one other game I played I today and I've only put an hour in but I just have to talk about it because it's so weird. ⁓ David: the eighth game he's juggling. The eighth game he's gonna be juggling. Andrew: He never stops. Dude, I get stressed out. I've got like three in rotation right now and I'm like, this is too much. We're getting a little too much. Westen: Let me sell you on this game. It is $6. $6. It is currently sitting at an overwhelmingly positive on Steam with over 2,000 reviews. It is called Andrew: He knows I love a deal. Westen: Librarian, Tidy Up the Arcane Library. It is a game, you're just in a little library, there are over 3,000 books on the ground and just all over the place. because a fairy messed it up. Your job is to get all the books and put them back where they belong on the shelves. Andrew: like Dewey Decimal System level. Westen: Like, so you pick up a book, right? And it might say like intro to transfiguration. This is an arcane library. So then you look at the map, like the library map, and you figure out what section that book belongs in, and you put it there. Now each book has multiple volumes, so there's no like, this is standalone book, it's like volume three. So you also have to like, so the shelves, a lot of them have 10 spots, but then some have like four. So you have to figure out like, Once you get enough books, you can be like, ⁓ this is one with 10 volumes. ⁓ this one four. And you put them in order, like in the correct shelf spot. Eventually you unlock spells that make it go faster, but like the library is a mess, right? So you just pick up books, you put them back and slowly you will see the library get organized and you will see all the clutter disappear. But there's like a mild, ⁓ and I think that alone would not be quite enough for me, but there's also just a very mild, very mild. puzzle solving element of figuring out what category each thing goes into, because it's not always like super obvious. Like there's several books I've like, I'm just putting this back on the ground for now until I do more and maybe I can figure out with process elimination. ⁓ And so eventually you unlock spells. So if you want to make it quicker, I think those spells will help. ⁓ I'm trying to just do it raw, just no spells, just put them all back. See, I'll see if I run out of patience. I feel like that might happen, but. I've played an hour and man this seems like a really fun like 20 minutes on my Steam deck game. Like for just when I don't have much time. And it's six bucks. It's six bucks. So. David: Mm. Andrew: It sounds so satisfying, but at the same time, for like the first, the lead up to you explaining it, I thought we were doing like a game segment where you were like, where you were gonna give me essentially one of these like, ⁓ here's an indie game and I'm gonna describe it to you. Is it a real indie game or not? Because there are always some like weird out there concept and I always make fun of like for anyone who is not privy, I regularly make fun of indies for being like, this one's about a giraffe who's going through, you know, David: Yeah. Westen: Hahahaha Andrew: the loss of their sibling and they're doing it by organizing their room. Here's a three hour, you know, comic book adventure about a giraffe. Westen: concept seems intriguing though. ⁓ But ⁓ I mean, the only story element ⁓ I've seen so far is there's a note left for you and some fairy messed up the library and this person's like, yeah, you gotta, they like locked you in the library until you do it ⁓ a magic spell, of course. And ⁓ they do promise you pizza though, if you get it done. So, ⁓ but yeah, ⁓ mean, if you look at one picture, Andrew: Of course. Westen: Like there are just books everywhere. So yeah, I mean the satisfaction, like I've only organized like think 150 books after like an hour. I have not used any spells. don't think I've unlocked even the ability to get spells yet, but the spells when I'm looking at them, they would make things go a fair bit quicker. There's like a cool down, but they can do things like you grab a book from the series and it highlights all the other books on the ground that go in the series or you pick up a book, it'll immediately highlight the bookshelf. Like right now I'm picking up books. and then I'm just looking at the map, figuring out where to go. I'm hoping I pick up multiple books that kind of seem similar so I can just do multiple at once. yeah, it's wildly satisfying and I'm not even that far in so I only imagine it'll get more so as I go. But for six bucks, I think it's worth considering. David: Would you say it's more like a puzzle? I found this piece, I can't use it yet. Or is it more a finding seek? Like, ⁓ I'm looking for book and I just look for it. Or it's like more you just A plus B, you have to find things and put them together. You might not be able to solve it now, but you can solve it later. ⁓ Westen: You can always solve it. ⁓ I'm sure if you, you know, there's just some that just feels just vague enough. there's like little color indicators when you put books back. So ⁓ that kind of tell you if you're doing it wrong, although they're a little vague, they're a little tough to parse sometimes. ⁓ But yeah, I mean, it's just pure cozy, I'd say, but there is just just enough puzzle where I feel like that's why I like the game. Like just that element. Activates me just enough where I'm like, okay, this is not just purely mindless. So First like I said for six bucks. I just wanted to throw it out there because it's really weird I haven't heard anyone talk about it yet. It came out in late April Yeah All right So that's what we got for this week. That was good discussion. I thought and it only get better But look the people are here for one thing these sickos. They're here for the ranks. All right And it's time to rank stuff. So David: Never heard of it. Westen: Here's the way I think the ranks, there will be weeks where we have different things, right? But I, on bignergaming.com, I'm obviously always ranking stuff. So, that was actually one of the problems with the old ⁓ for me is like, I'm trying to think of stuff to rank ⁓ month. And I'm like, I'm already ranking a bunch of stuff. Like there's just only so much stuff I can rank. ⁓ So what I'm probably gonna do is mostly have you guys rank off a list I did. But then every other episode, I believe we're gonna mostly be just like, ranking the games we played within a given month. So good structure there. So ⁓ one of the most viewed lists I've ever made, I think it is the most viewed via Blue Sky at least. ⁓ I've had some good Google search traffic ones, but like just through social media, I posted the top 10 games of the 2020s that will age the worst. People love that shit. They love it. So I'm having you guys rank it now. my top five, just to throw it out there, look at bignerdgaming.com if you want justification. My number five was Ghost of Tsushima. Open world, very old school structure. I know it has a decent story, but I don't think it's good enough. Four, Horizon Forbidden West. Middle point of a story, like ends on a cliffhanger once again. Old school, open world design. Number three, Psychonauts 2. Felt like it was made in 2007 and thus. has quickly been forgotten, even though, you know, I mean, it was fine, it got nominated, but never seen it discussed since. Number two, Hogwarts Legacy. Cool game in some ways, but a lot of open world slop. ⁓ And number one, Stray, just, I mean, as soon as the game awards ended, everybody forgot about that stupid ass game. ⁓ David: You Westen: Who wants to go first? Yeah, if it was a- David: I just think if it wasn't a cat, mean, there's other games that do the same thing better or the same that didn't get the same shine. Andrew: Yeah, you're right. Westen: Yeah, I mean, it had its moments. I mean, I'd say it's mildly better than Little Kitty Big City, but that's about it. ⁓ Andrew: BOOM Westen: which I gave a seven to, it was a fine game. ⁓ Who wants to go first? David, let's go David. Let's give me you take top five games that will age the worst from the 2020s. We're doing this for the 2020s, because obviously if you're picking 2010s, like some of those games have already aged bad. Yeah, so. David: Sure. Yeah, it's, I think this whole thing is pretty interesting because if when you, when I think of games that don't gauge well, often you think of games that like, they had bad controls because they're like, you know, for the 2000s, like that 3d controls. think now like games are for the most part, technically sound, I mean outside of like bugs, you know, so it's interesting thinking of Westen: Yeah. And side note, that's exactly my point. Like people were like, no way on a lot of the games. I'm like, dude, that's the thing. Almost none of these games are gonna age that bad, honestly. Like none of these games are gonna age like some of the old N64 platformers or the PS1 action games. Like those games are just kind of tough to play now sometimes. It's not gonna be like that. Sorry, go ahead. David: Yeah. Yeah, no, no, no. And you had like some sequels or like prequels like Hades. Like Hades obviously is an amazing game, but like does Hades 2 do everything better? It kind of took a different route or tried to be more hot takes. I think my list might be better. actually, it's definitely better. am I talking about? So I'm going to preface this. I have not played all these games. So I'm going to talk shit about games I haven't played. I'm not going to say which. Westen: Okay, okay, okay. Andrew: Damn, go hard. ⁓ shit, this man is going nuts. People are gonna love this. People are gonna love that. Westen: This man, this man, this man belongs on this man belongs on twitter.com for sure. Does this talk about games he has played? David: You Well, because all the games I play are perfect. And age just wonderfully. Yeah. ⁓ Andrew: ⁓ yes, of course. Westen: Sorry, x.com, x.com. Andrew: The everything app? Westen: You David: on the list, number five, it's gonna be Mario Kart World, which I actually love this game. And I think the gameplay itself is fine, but I think the overall, I think it's too tied to the open world system. Because essentially you have this giant free roam map and open world and all the tracks chained together. And when you do like racing online with friends and stuff, there's these intermissions, which is you going like Mario Stadium. to another track. And it's just this long, like highway-esque thing until you do like one lap on a track. And like sometimes you'll get these times where you do like the old school, like three laps on a track and play, but I just think Mario Kart World comparison to like Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is never gonna meet that level of content for people. I think it's gonna be restricted by this open world. I think it's just not gonna. be on the same level or even like Mario Kart Wii, going back to just, think people prefer the just simple Grand Prix, you know, drop in, do three lap structure. Westen: I think that's a good take, because I really feel like Mario Kart World, I've never seen anyone talk about it. I I saw Mario Kart 8, I saw people getting hyped for all the DLC packs for years. Like, I really have not seen much discussion. David: Yeah. Well, to be fair, Mario Kart 8, it took a while to get those DLC packs. ⁓ It was, I mean, of course it was a portable Wii U game, But once they did, they just kept coming. And ⁓ also, I mean, the gameplay in that game is And like Mario Kart World, don't, I think they could easily, ⁓ like if they don't have to tie it to open world, I think my take will age horribly. But I, because I think they can just do the three lap tracks if they really want it to, but I don't know if that's their vision. So. Westen: I like the take. I like the start. Strong start. David: Yeah. I'm going to go for number four, a game I haven't played. is Pokemon CA. I think it just from what I've seen and what I've talked with friends, I don't know if it does that much better besides the battle system than Arceus. I think Arceus's world, I have played Arceus. I'm not completely talking out my ass. the world is more intriguing. Just the overall, like, you know, open world. Andrew: So good. David: crafting just everything the world for zia just is bland to me on paper and I Just and also just the overall course. I mean, there's the z to a like, you know, that's your Which from my understanding you don't actually you played it Western, right? You don't go z to a completely It's not like 26 the 26 letters, right? Westen: Yes. No, so I haven't played it and I explicitly didn't play it because yeah, you've switched from like V to F and I gave that the dumbest design decision of 2025 on the nerdy's and some people were like, well, no, it would have been too much. I'm like, you advertise the game Z to A. That's what it's about. David: Yeah. Yeah. Andrew: Yeah, you can't, like, that's the name. You can't do that. I didn't know that they did that and I'm now retroactively pissed off. I haven't even played it, but that pisses me off. David: Yeah, yeah, that's... Westen: And the worst part is, the worst part, I think, I don't know 100 % know, but I think the way that it ranks is like where basically you go up eight fucking ranks, like the amount of standard gym leaders in a Pokemon game, like fuck you Nintendo. Yeah, dude, get the fuck out, man. So no, I won't be playing that game. ⁓ my only dispute with that one is I feel like, I feel like it, ⁓ you know. Andrew: ⁓ get out of here, yep, that's ass. That's dirty and I don't like it. David: Yeah. I bet you wrote about it. Westen: it wasn't that acclaimed, you know? Like my games were all like rated 84 or higher. was only 80, everything was 84 or higher, was that it? David: It's a Pokemon game. It was, like, hey, I fulfilled the criteria of, whatever 10 % on OpenCritic. Westen: Okay, okay, maybe it was that high. I don't remember what it got scores, so. Okay, well, all right, all right. David: I think it's like an 80 or 79 or maybe I'm wrong. number three, ⁓ Doom the Dark Ages. I just don't think slow paced gameplay is people like as much from Doom. ⁓ I mean, Doom 1, super fast paced. ⁓ know, with Eternal And it just feels like talk more fondly about Doom 1 and 2 of the modern Dooms. Dark Ages is kind of, mean, it came out a year ago now. And it's kind of just came and went. mean, I it on Game Pass and didn't really get nominated for, think it was a couple Game of Year awards. something like that. So. Westen: Yeah, think best action was in there too. David: you know, and I'm trying to, was trying to avoid, cause I like Hogwarts or Deathloop. mean, Deathloop was on your list. I think, I mean, you talk about, I think one of the most forgettable ⁓ award nominees, I ⁓ the ending for that game, just the overall latter half just didn't do much for me. know they went back and fixed some stuff, but Number one for me, I think, is Unique, because it's actually a fabulous game. I have played it. It's the only thing I've ever done on VR, is Half-Life Alex. I think that game will age poorly for the simple fact that VR, I just don't think is long for this world. I think it is on its last legs. ⁓ yeah. Westen: Fufufufu You're definitely not going to pixel by now. You're not going to pixel by now. Andre's will not allow it. Andrew: Get it, get it, get it, get it, get it. Get it, get it, get it, get it. I'm with you dude, 100%. After trying it a couple times, I get that the technology may improve, but I don't know man, I just think it's shit every time. David: Audrey says I already knew he was gonna be so It's just, there's too much of a barrier to entry and that game is locked behind it. I've seen, I've tried, because after playing it, playing it with friends for like a half hour, I tried downloading, there's there's mods where it's like, ⁓ it becomes playable, you know, just like on Steam without VR. It's just not even close to the same thing. I just don't like, people will look fondly back like, ⁓ man, this game was so good of what VR is capable of, but. no one's gonna be able to play it. So it's just, think we talk about games that locked on like the DS store and that close and like, emulation saves some of these games. I think that game, it's not gonna be easy to emulate. It's it's kind of gonna be the one of a kind and I think it's gonna eventually kind of be lost behind. Westen: There's a clever way to go about that one. There's a clever way to cop out and not shit on anyone. Doom the Dark Ages, mild. I actually think Doom the Dark Ages could go the other way. A couple years ago, people were like, oh, that was a bold direction. I had a few issues with it, but it's my, I like it more than the journal, for sure. Yeah. David: Yeah. What the sort of cop out? Yeah, I think it's a bold direction, but it's just not. I think people just prefer racing around the room, stomping on heads, versus the slow pace, sword and shield type. Westen: Sure. All right, Andrew, let's see what you got. Andrew: Alright, so first of all, I didn't do the Metacritic review scores. I think they all should fall north of it, but I just I didn't do that. I was not going to do it in order, but it actually... Westen: Andrew not doing his homework. Shocker from a guy who relates to the mixtape characters. Wow. David: To be fair, you gave us our homework last minute. Yeah, see, that's our excuse. Andrew: That's true, that's true! Get him, get him, get him, get him! Take the attention off me and get him! I did adopt David's rule of not taking yours, so Deathloop was on mine as well. Actually, I played it way after it came out, but for me it was the fact that like... Westen: True, Yeah, fair, fair. Sometimes professors, that's how real life works, okay? David: Yeah. Westen: Everybody hates Doodle. Andrew: And I know people complain about this all the time. It just, wasn't open-ended enough. And like, I'm not saying that it, like, I get that it can, like, it can be just one way. Like you have to take them out in this order. That's fine. But the fact that it's like, you have to pick up these three notes in order to be able to get this person or like to make it like work properly and to unlock certain routes. I thought that was kind like, just, you depleted the concept and like you didn't fulfill it properly. So that would have been there. And then I think. As I mentioned earlier, think despite loving M.O.S.P.I., that's an honorable mention. Mixtape might end up on this list in a couple of years. And Bonanza is on Weston's list, I haven't finished it yet. But I'm starting to see why it's just not enough game kind hold ⁓ There's not enough with the concepts, ⁓ despite me really enjoying it. But my actual list. ⁓ Some of these are for the... ⁓ the simple fact that, so I didn't love, and we debated this already and it kind of got mentioned, like, sequels did it better, so the previous game is aging poorly, and I agree with you guys that like, if games are like technically sound, like it's hard to say they aged poorly anyway, but like yeah, like I'm loving Hades 1, I don't know that I'd actually wanna play a double the length Hades, so Hades 2 might actually suffer for me versus Hades 1 is still worth going back to, I don't know, we'll see, The direction I went is either it will age poorly because it will age poorly or ⁓ it just may not hold up to its place in the discussion or its place in like kind of where gamers have it now, then. Like it just in like its cultural relevance, its ⁓ of like impact on ⁓ gaming sphere and on gamers I think will deplete as time goes on. And so number five is Animal Crossing New Horizons. I think it's the weakest. Westen: I considered that one actually for mine. Andrew: I think it's one of the weakest like Animal Crossing games. ⁓ think that though after games like Stardew Valley, you're going to have a hard time doing these kind of very simple like farm sims and like town sims. You need more content at this point. It's been done a million times. It's the reason that despite me liking it, a lot of people bashed the Hobbiton one that came out a couple of years ago, Tales of the Shire. It's just... if you're doing the same thing over and over again and there's four items in it, it's just like, it's not going to do anymore. And then also I think it got overrated because it was everyone's COVID comfort game. And that's great. I'm glad we all had that experience, but it's, I think it got a lot of love because of what it did for us and the time that it came out and not because it was the best possible game. David: Do you think people will be blinded by kind of nostalgia for that time? because they'll be looking back like, oh it was so much fun, this was my escape then. That was kind of why I almost, left it off the list. So I was like, oh it might actually age well because people will look back as like that was my escape. Because I don't think the game itself, yeah because I don't think the game itself is best Animal Crossing game. I don't even know if it's, maybe it's top three, but because there's like, I have fond memories of like Andrew: Yes, 100%. Yes. But so that's, I would just discredit that. Maybe. David: Wild World and the Gamecube. Those just had so much more character with the characters too. Andrew: Yeah, same. I agree. Number four, I have Astro Bot, which was my game of the year, the year that it came out. And I think it's technically sound. think the sound is awesome. I think it's a ton of fun. I liked Astro's Playroom. I like this. ⁓ I love this game. Like this was one of my favorite, it's still one of my favorite games, but at the end of the day, think it's gonna, over the years, it's gonna fade into the, any other three. And maybe it's cause I'm not a huge 3D platformer. Westen: Ooooo Andrew: guy myself, I think it's just going to fade into the noise with all the other, like a lot of other 3D platformers. I don't know that it will stand the test of time as like the 3D platformer. And part of that is I think because it relies so much on like all the Sony IP, which I like those levels. I love the Uncharted level because Uncharted is my favorite game series. But like, I think that it kind of because of that shtick and because of the fact that it's not doing anything particularly phenomenal. think there's just for years, there haven't been as many great 3D platformers. it kind of hit for people because like, ⁓ we haven't had a great one in a while and this is a great 3D platformer, but will it stand the test of time like the way that it was game of the year? I don't Westen: That was on my age the best list, by the way. It's bold, it's bold. I like that. I like that it's bold. Andrew: I think it's an amazing game. David: Yeah, I mean, for me, think it's, yeah, yeah, I think it's hard for it to, I mean, obviously, it's technically sound and shouldn't age poorly in that way. But I do think maybe 20 years from now, what if we never get an AVE Escape game? Like, you know, like all these games, like, what if they just are still dormant? you people look back, like, ⁓ this game series is 40 years old. You know, it's a relic. Andrew: Yes. Yes. Yeah, it's impact, I think will decrease. At number three, God of War Ragnarok. think that it's a good game. I think the story is worse than the first one. I think it suffers from the, we're gonna go bigger and it's gonna be more. ⁓ I know it's not technically an open world, but it's just like, it's more worlds, it's more exploration, it's bigger, bigger, bigger. think it was right at the height, it was being built at the height of the like, go bigger, go bigger, go bigger. with games and I think it suffers for that. And so I think when people look back on the new God of War series, they're gonna say play the first one. ⁓ I don't know, I think this one is, it suffers from being bigger. Westen: I hate the take. I really like Ragnarok, but yeah, haven't like felt a lot of like I replayed the original God of War. It is an all-timer for me, or the 2018 one. And I really loved Ragnarok after I played it, but I have not had the same desire to go back and play it. Andrew: ⁓ it's a great game. Yes. to go back, exactly. David: ⁓ I still, it's on the list of 25 for this year that I will get to. Westen: Now you won't. Andrew: Great game. It's so much fun. But yeah. David: Well, see, the issue is now. It's now I'm playing all this new stuff for the podcast. It's like now I have an excuse. Westen: Yeah, see, exactly, exactly. I sabotaged you. Andrew: There you go. Number two. ⁓ This might considered a cop-out. Oblivion Remaster. ⁓ Like, I get it's a remaster, but like, dude, it's the laziest remaster ever and I think it's beloved because it was a shadow drop, which ⁓ I fell it too. I was like, ⁓ my goodness! ⁓ I've never Oblivion! I get to play Oblivion now! I loved Skyrim! I was a Skyrim kid! Now I get to play Oblivion! Westen: A little bit. Andrew: And like, the fact that they didn't do any, like they did almost nothing to it, like there's still game-breaking bugs in it that they never fixed. It looks better, it looks nice, I'm not saying it doesn't look nice, but it doesn't look that much better, and I think this is a game that like, really would have been, I guess that's wrong. It does look that much better, but it still doesn't look good, like that good. And I think also that like, it would have benefited from a full rebuild. Which I guess on Bethesda's engine still wouldn't be that much, and wouldn't mean that much, but like, David: It's a Bethesda game. Andrew: The repetitive dungeons, the repetitive oblivion gates, it's just not gonna... ⁓ still don't think it's enough to save the game on its own. The writing's better, ⁓ quests are better than Skyrim, but it just still won't hold up. Westen: Yeah, that's, yes, that's the one strength of the game. it's tough, like Starfield, you for all people complain about, I have my own issues with it, but the combat is solid enough in that game. And that is a first for Bethesda. And now we're going back, you're just totally rehashing that same combat engine from two games ago. It is tough. The combat's tough for me. And yeah. Andrew: Yes. Yes. And then they're gonna do the same thing with Fallout 3 and everyone's gonna go, oh my goodness, Fallout 3! And it's just gonna be the same conversation. Westen: I think because of VATS, New Vegas would be crazy. VATS I think will allow Fallout's combat to age a little better because it's like a system literally designed because their combat's terrible. know, or in part because of that. So, all right, number one. David: You think they do 3 or New Vegas? Andrew: I hope you're Vegas. But I think three. That's true. And then at number one, my raging hate boner is Dragon's Dogma 2. Fuck that piece of shit game. That game got so much love, and I fell for it initially. I was like, the emergent gameplay, all the interactions, this is so fun, it doesn't hold your hand, the quest design is so cool. I was in love with it for 30 hours, and from that point on, it was a slog to get through to the end. I fucking hated the final boss. Westen: Yes. Yes. Yes. Andrew: I- the- I- when I saw that there was a real ending that you could get by doing the bullshit, like figure out all this bullshit in the world, and everything's now- like the sky is red and it makes the world insufferable to play through, fuck you! Fuck that game! It was so repetitive, the same ten monsters by the end of it, I hated every second of it by the end. I- I- ⁓ GOD, FUCK THAT GAME! Westen: But Andrew, if you don't experience the true ending, can't comment on this. I think ⁓ my only problem with that number one is that I feel like it already happened in real time over the course of like two months. Cause like that game was like, game of the year contender and that no one, almost nobody was calling for it to be game of the year. Even, yeah, no, it qualifies. It does qualify. Yeah. Andrew: Yeah, fuck that. I'm not doing it. David: You didn't beat the game then! Andrew: Yeah, that's fair. But it's still like an 88 on Metacritic. So it qualifies, but fuck that game, dude. David: There was a lot of hype going into that. Westen: There is too much about that game where, I mean, I tried like the demo after two hours of Mickey, I'm good, but just everything I'd heard or hear about like, oh, some people are oh, it's so cool if you don't, this guy can like totally destroy your everything if he has red eyes or whatever the hell it was. And I was like, wait, that sounds awful. and, and, and, so I just had to be stressed about that the whole time, like that my whole rug could get totally ruined by this one thing. I don't know. Yeah. And like I did not. David: ⁓ yes. Literally just like ruins your playthrough and it's like... Andrew: Yeah, I don't want that actually. Westen: The combat I felt like was good in a, you can dick around kind of way. Like you can do stupid, kind of like Crimson Desert where it's like, ⁓ you can do stupid shit. That's kind of funny. But then after a while, it's just like, actually I need the basics of this game to be better. And I mean, you can't lock on like just a lot of the basic stuff is not that good. It's just, you can do funny stuff with like climbing and grabbing and throwing and such, Andrew: Yes. Yeah. Because even the moves, like there's a huge move set for each class, but then you're just doing the same animation over and over. And I guess that's kind of a problem with action games a lot of the time, but I just felt like you'd have, there's 15 moves for a class, but two of them are good. So you do the same two moves over. Westen: You guys had strong lists. I'm proud of you guys. You're budding list makers over here. All right, well that was it for the return of the Bignor Gaming podcast. I'm expecting, we went a little over where I wanted, but that's okay in terms of time. We're close, we'll get close to it's on me for adding Librarian, tidy up the arcane library to the mix, so I take full blame. So we will have a bi-weekly rotation going forward. I Monday release, as long as David's up to that. So yeah, it's gonna be great. David: We'll get there. If there's any comments, there's things that need to be improved, let me know. I'm new to this. It may seem like I know what I'm doing, but I have no clue. I know. Westen: He kind of does. yeah, yeah, comment, like, subscribe, you know, yeah, I'm supposed to say that stuff. Comment, like, subscribe. ⁓ We'll put links to our social media accounts on there. And obviously, I'll post it on bignerdgaming.com and have some reference links and stuff. So yeah, follow these guys if you're not on various social media. think mostly Blue Sky, but Andrew's on Twitter as well. And yeah, appreciate you guys listening. Appreciate you, David and Andrew, for coming on. David: You Westen: It was a lot of fun. I think it'll get more fun as time goes on. So I ⁓ appreciate it and we will see you in a few weeks. David: Thanks for having us.