Latest / Crypto Coin Show / Everyone is Underexposed to ETH, Ishan Bhadaini of SCRIB3 | Blockchain Interviews
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashton Addison from the Crypto Coin Show and today i'm Blockchain Interviews with e
- 0:04Sean by Donnie CEO of Scribe. Eesean, Welcome to the show and thanks
- 0:08for taking the time. Yeah, thanks for having me, Ashton, very
- 0:11welcome. Excited to dive into all the exciting news in the crypto markets today
- 0:16and what's happened this year. I feel like this is the kickoff of a
- 0:20huge year for blockchain adoption and crypto and I know you're deep in the weeds
- 0:26in it and you have some knowledge to share. I would love to start
- 0:29our conversation off by first of all, just hearing a little bit more about
- 0:32your background in blockchain and inscribe and everything else that you have been working on.
- 0:38Yeah, yeah, we'd love to. So, you know, I
- 0:41started off, you know previously, I was in private equity. I had
- 0:43my ownpe fund. My brother and I used to run. Caught the DeFi
- 0:46bug in twenty nineteen, had some friends show me the early blue chip stuff,
- 0:50you know, maker of a len compound, et cetera. And you
- 0:54know it was just very intuitive for me. You know, I just picked
- 0:58up DeFi before I even understood the back end infra of you know, ethereum
- 1:00and you know, smart contract platforms and things like that, and so I
- 1:04just got incredibly interested. Started to do you know, my you know,
- 1:07thousand hours of research. You know, how does this stuff work? You
- 1:10know, you know how how do these platforms? You know, like,
- 1:12how can you have this kind of decentralized trust? Why are so many people
- 1:15putting billions and billions of dollars up on these platforms? And then you know,
- 1:19started to do all the digging in research, went through DeFi Summer ended
- 1:23up doing pretty well for myself and DeFi Summer, like most people who were
- 1:26in that time did, it was a little hard not to. And then
- 1:30you know kind of built that conviction that this was, you know, in
- 1:34my opinion still is, you know, kind of the future finance where this
- 1:36will be kind of the back end infrastructure for all financial activity in the future.
- 1:40And you know, started to realize that, you know, hey,
- 1:42if this is a you know, this is just the perfect culmination of things
- 1:46I was always interested in, right, whether it was like philosophy, economics,
- 1:49finance, you know, governance, you know, et cetera. I
- 1:53think like politics is actually like a very underrated piece of you know some of
- 1:56the things that I think we're also front running the history of politics some respects,
- 2:00and so, you know, started to build that conviction. I realized
- 2:04that if you wanted to, there's potential an opportunity to build kind of a
- 2:07career in the space. And so started contributing around ecosystems a lot, worked
- 2:10at another kind of agency in the space, and then you know, started
- 2:14contributing a lot of different defive platforms. You know, contributed, spent a
- 2:16little bit of time at you know, redacted redacted Cartel, spent a lot
- 2:20of time in gains network and like the perpdex space, and then you know,
- 2:24just kind of made this realization that there was a massive white space and
- 2:29a just a supplied demand gap of people that really understood the core use cases
- 2:32of the technology and like the really like the underpinnings of how this stuff works,
- 2:37how it ticks, what the value prop is, and you know,
- 2:40how to kind of take some of this stuff to market, right, how
- 2:43to you know eloquently talk about the value prop of this technology. And so
- 2:50that was a little bit of the thesis around starting scribe. So you know,
- 2:52the thesis was really there's white space here to work on and build the
- 2:55most technical like the more technical crypt native, go to more mar stuff in
- 3:00the space. You know, no one is really doing it at a super
- 3:01high level constantly. Product should come up to us as we're working on gains
- 3:06Network and other projects that's like, hey, you guys are doing really well
- 3:07here, like can you guys help us out, and then just realize that
- 3:10there was just the kind of opportunity there to grow. Wow, it's incredible
- 3:15and amazing timing on joining in right at the beginning of DeFi, which is
- 3:20the start I believe as well of revolutionizing the entire financial sector, the trillions
- 3:25of dollars to get in you know, almost on day one and be so
- 3:30passionate that you just like doing it. You know. It's just like,
- 3:34as you said, it sort of touches on revolutionizing and all of these different
- 3:38industries. It's not just one thing, it changes everything, which it's just
- 3:42so cool and you know, all of that knowledge leading up to it's sort
- 3:46of like an entrepreneur's journey. People are coming to hey, we need help,
- 3:49and you're like, hey, I should start describe to solve this exact
- 3:53problem that I keep seeing in the market. Yeah, yeah, definitely.
- 3:58I think the point about there's there's a piece of the space for everybody,
- 4:00right, whatever your passion is, whether it's it's gaming, it's you know,
- 4:03crypto, it's it's economics, it's finance, it's uh, you know,
- 4:09governance and politics, it's a coordination, you know, like there's a
- 4:13piece of the space for everybody. And I think that's incredibly powerful, which
- 4:15is a big piece of the thesis. Right. It's like if if you
- 4:18can touch so many different areas and revolution has so many different sectors of you
- 4:21know, of people's lives, it's kind of hard to not be incredibly bullish.
- 4:28And I think one thing is that I've seen is like you know,
- 4:30you know, you can have like still traditional business models in this space.
- 4:33There's a lot of opportunities. You know, podcasting is a traditional web to
- 4:36business model, Right, that doesn't mean it's not available to be used.
- 4:39Like, you know, I think a lot of people just kind of sometimes
- 4:41over index on the need to do these like you know, new types of
- 4:46business models where you have you know, feeme mechanisms on these like immutable smart
- 4:49contract platforms and uh, and you know, I think there's still a massive
- 4:54opportunity and need for traditional style businesses, right, like agencies and you know,
- 4:59like podcasting media, and as you see, some of the most successful
- 5:02private businesses in the space still are look very much like traditional businesses, and
- 5:09so I think more people should lean into that. You know, accounting models,
- 5:13law firms. You know, there's plenty of need to just take a
- 5:15lot of these traditional models that don't necessarily you know, you don't need a
- 5:18Dow to do an agency, you don't need a Dow to do a law
- 5:21firm or something like that. I mean, those concepts are cool, and
- 5:25I think there's things to be explored there, but I don't think that's the
- 5:27first place people need to think. There's still a ton of opportunity to build
- 5:30traditional businesses, and that was something you know, I've always been passionate about
- 5:32building businesses my whole life. You know, my family comes from a retail
- 5:35entrepreneurial background. So it's like I've just been doing business for a long time,
- 5:40saw the opportunity. There's still plenty more opportunity out there, and so
- 5:44I think there's just an area that people under it and dig some a little
- 5:46bit. No, I think that's a great point, is Sean most of
- 5:51the biggest businesses in blockchain, they're not completely on the blockchain. If you're
- 5:56a new company and you're looking at ways to implement blockchain to innovate in the
- 6:00company, you can just do something small to start, you know, and
- 6:04the traditional business is still the core of the business. Financing coinbase. They're
- 6:09not, you know, a full dex on the blockchain with smart contracts or
- 6:13traditional business supporting people to get into web three and even gaming the games themselves,
- 6:18the ones that are built completely on the blockchain. I don't think we're
- 6:21ready for that yet. Maybe in the future, but just the tokenization of
- 6:26the assets and finding other ways to bring value with blockchain in traditional gaming,
- 6:30I think is the stepping stone we need right now to provide a lot more
- 6:34value. Same with agencies, law firms, accounting. As you mentioned,
- 6:39I would love to hear a little bit more about yourself in Scribe and what
- 6:44you and your team have built Inscribe. What are exactly are the main offerings
- 6:47that you guys are giving and providing value for in the blockchain space right now?
- 6:53Yeah? So yeah, we started Describe with kind of three people completely
- 6:57Bootschut the company, and we started in November of twenty need to which is,
- 7:00you know, as many note, probably one of the not so great
- 7:03times to kind of invest in starting a business. And yeah, we you
- 7:08know, we we spent twenty twenty three kind of scaling up. We started
- 7:11with three people. Now we're a team of about getting close to sixty full
- 7:13time heads, and you know, we think it's just a testament to product
- 7:16market fit. You know, when we have these conversations with teams about their
- 7:20kind of go to market needs, they really resonate with the fact that we're
- 7:23incredibly native. Uh, you know, we really understand the space. You
- 7:27know, you don't have to explain to us the core competences of your business.
- 7:29We understand the landscape, who your competitors are, and you know all
- 7:32that all kind of what we think about is table stakes and then we can
- 7:36get into the more nuanced conversations about you know, what is the actual go
- 7:40to market strategy. How are we thinking about you know, token launches,
- 7:43and how are we thinking about kind of continuing to build a business over the
- 7:46next you know, one, three five years. And so you know there's
- 7:48six areas of the business that we focus on. Uh, you know,
- 7:51we do content for projects, right everything from technical documentation to your you know,
- 7:56blog post, educational content, product updates, things like that. We
- 8:00run social at scale. You know, we think that that's the top distribution
- 8:03mechanism in the space. Right, How do people learn about projects through social?
- 8:07Right? And even more specifically, it's through Twitter for the most part.
- 8:09And I think now you're starting to see the growth of some of these
- 8:11decentralized platforms like Lens, Farcaster, Blue Sky, things like that. Like,
- 8:16it's definitely something that's important to keep an eye on. But that's where
- 8:20your top funnel distribution happens, right, That's how people learn about projects.
- 8:24And then we also do public relations. You know, we feel incredibly confident
- 8:28we have the most native public relations team in the space, you know,
- 8:31where you can you know, use public relations as a mechanism to build narrative,
- 8:33right, you know, help talk about the nuance of the project and
- 8:37you know why it's better than you know, competitors in the space and things
- 8:41like that. We also do design, community development, and business development.
- 8:46Community and business development, so six areas we focus on. There's a lot
- 8:50of other areas we're looking to grow into. And yeah, we just think
- 8:54that you know, again, teams really resonate with the crypto nativity of it.
- 8:56You know, we really get it, we understand it. We're thought
- 8:58partners. We're not just teams that come in and you you know, complete
- 9:01tasks. You know, we think of ourselves when we work with projects is
- 9:05you know, work core contributors to the team. We want to be treated
- 9:07as such. We want to have that type of impact, and so we
- 9:09don't want to be treated as this agency that's outside looking in with the hand
- 9:13away. We want to be integrated, just like you would bring on a
- 9:16new member of the team, a new group of people, a new cohort.
- 9:18We have those same expectations about how we work with teams, and that's
- 9:22what helps us work with you know, some of the coolest, most interesting
- 9:26teams in the space. We work with everyone from you know, we do
- 9:28every stage of the life cycle. We work with everyone from pre seat projects.
- 9:31We work in some of the largest teams in the space, like a
- 9:33UNISWAP Foundation, Wormhole, you know, axelar on and on. So we
- 9:39probably work with just a dozen projects in the top two hundred of market cap
- 9:41thirty teams at any given time, and it's just it's fun to be able
- 9:46to get into the day to day, the nitty gritty understand how these teams
- 9:50are thinking about things where they see the space. I think there's a ton
- 9:52of it's just really cool to be able to pick people's brains and see how
- 9:56these teams are building where they see the future. We work across you know,
- 10:00we work in the Salon ecosystem, we work a ton in the EVM
- 10:03ecosystem, we work in the cross chain you know, Messaging Cosmos ecosystem,
- 10:07and the IBC as well, And so you start to see the different theologies
- 10:13or the different you know, the different theses these teams have about where the
- 10:18space is going, whether it's modular, monolithic, or you know, how
- 10:22all of these different ecosystems are going to kind of work together or interact with
- 10:26each other as the space continues to develop. I think we're just we're still
- 10:31so nascent, right. This entire industry is, you know, ten,
- 10:33twelve, thirteen years old as a whole fourteen years old, and if you're
- 10:37really stretching it, there's there's just so much more to develop. I think
- 10:41anyone that thinks that has incredible conviction that tells you one hundred percent that this
- 10:46is where the world is going is frankly just it is frankly wrong. Like,
- 10:50I don't think anyone, you know, the smart you know, we
- 10:52chat with some of the smartest minds in the space, and even these guys
- 10:54who are building these innovative applications l ones L two's, you know, some
- 10:58of the largest applications, Even these guys don't know. They're just like,
- 11:01yeah, we're going to build for where we think it's going, but we're
- 11:03going to be nimble enough and you know, have enough grace to understand that
- 11:09we're not always going to be right, and you know, we're gonna have
- 11:11to be nimble enough to pivot as things change. Yeah, No, that's
- 11:13great advice, is Sean about Crypto moves so fast too, And you just
- 11:20never know when one upgrade of a protocol or one part of the blockchain that
- 11:24gets better changes everything, you know, whether it's new programming languages coming in
- 11:28and getting involved, which I've seen in the in the recent videos that we've
- 11:33done just more innovations in the space. Being able to pivot your startup is
- 11:37of utmost importance. And you know, there's no shame in uh being not
- 11:43one hundred percent right on the narrative when you first start the company, because
- 11:46if you stick to that, it will die. You know, you need
- 11:48to pivot to survive. And I like what you said about the positioning of
- 11:54Scribe in actually being inside of the you know, inside of the team and
- 11:58not just somebody that's helping on the side. When I was running a startup
- 12:03personally, I realized the utmost importance that's needed for you know, the developers
- 12:09to be in house or the CTO to be a co founder, to have
- 12:13that technical expertise inside of the company, because once you try to hire externally
- 12:18and you have them at arms reach and something goes wrong or you need to
- 12:22pivot, it is just a hassle. You know. It's it's good to
- 12:26be in the team. So I'm glad to hear that you and your team
- 12:28are working so closely with these companies. Yeah, I think I can give
- 12:33you a really good example. You know. One of the things that I
- 12:35think is really cool about you know, the position that I get to that
- 12:41I get the opportunity to do, which is, you know, I get
- 12:43to meet with teams that are building at the forefront of this every single day,
- 12:48and it you know, one of the cool things is we're just a
- 12:50little more upstream than a traditional venture capital firm, where you know, typically
- 12:54we're working with teams that have already raised capital, right that I've already have
- 12:58a little bit of the co sign from some of the venture capital firms and
- 13:01minds in the space, and so whereas vcs are still trying to kind of
- 13:05uh separate the noise from the signal, we get a pretty good idea of
- 13:09the signal because these guys already have that co sign and so we start to
- 13:11get a little bit of, you know, not this long term vision like
- 13:15venture capital firms do have, like what is you know, what are these
- 13:16things are going to look like in five or ten years, But it's a
- 13:18little on a shorter timeline where it's like, hey, these teams have raised
- 13:22they've built product, and they're ready to go to market and they need that
- 13:26support. And so we get a little bit of a shorter view into what
- 13:28do things look like in the next one to two years and not necessarily what
- 13:31do things have to theorize about what things could possibly be over a five or
- 13:35ten year horizon. So, like I think a really great example is,
- 13:39like you know, we're seeing a ton of Bitcoin layer twos right now,
- 13:43and the growth of bitcoin defive. Now. I think traditionally you would think
- 13:46that you know, like the Bitcoin layer twos are like stacks, and you
- 13:52know, these things are incredibly slow moving technologies. These are not incredibly efficient.
- 13:56But I think you know, with as technology grows, you know,
- 13:58you're starting to see the realistic use of zeroledge proofs and you know, the
- 14:03ability to create succinct proofs in order to scale a Bitcoin layer two that could
- 14:07actually create real application layer. So people are now building you know, layer
- 14:11twos that are perfectly built for a ton of defile applications, gaming applications,
- 14:15other things like that. And so I think traditionally, you know, if
- 14:18you told people this six months or eight months ago, they'd be like,
- 14:20oh, Bitcoin l twos are never going to take off, it's never going
- 14:22to be fast enough. But now, you know, being able to build
- 14:24really succinct proofs, and you know, you know, even the advent of
- 14:28things like you know, fahval homomorphic, you know, encryption like this is
- 14:31going to create new scaling opportunities. And so you just have to be nimble
- 14:35enough to understand that, hey, you don't know where these things are going
- 14:37to go. You don't know what massive innovations can can be created in order
- 14:41to unlock new opportunities. And I definitely think that there's there's definitely going to
- 14:46be a market of people who really think that, you know, if I
- 14:50can have the true security of the most centralized physical infrastructure network, which is
- 14:54bitcoin, and just have these you know, worldwide access to nose to secure
- 14:58my network, that is potentially safer for things like large scale defile lending operations.
- 15:05Right if you want to build a money market, you know, I
- 15:07mean I'm in an you know, I wouldn't say EVM, Maxie, but
- 15:09you know, I'm incredibly bullshal the AVM. But it's a real narrative and
- 15:13it's a real, really interesting space. So like, you know, you
- 15:16just have to be nimble enough to understand that new things can come up every
- 15:22day, and you know the speed at which this industry changes. It's just
- 15:26you know, it's a it's a it's a it's a feature another bug.
- 15:30Yeah, No, it's amazing and great insights there into bitcoin. I feel
- 15:33like bitcoin is some maxis that just see bitcoin as the store of value or
- 15:41the digital gold may not like it but there is more utility coming into bitcoin
- 15:45because of these other innovations, as you say, you know, whether ZK
- 15:48or layer twos that popped up, and hey, this can work with bitcoin
- 15:52as well. Bitcoin is the strongest blockchain network, It has the most value
- 15:56locked in, it is the hardest blockchain of them all. And adding that
- 16:03value into onto the Bitcoin network, I think is going to open up a
- 16:07lot of opportunities for decentralized finance. As you said, if you need to
- 16:11move trillions of dollars from the stock market, might as well do it on
- 16:15the hardest, most secure blockchain that there is. Yeah. I couldn't agree
- 16:19more. And you also mentioned at the beginning about when you started scribe it
- 16:26was sort of in the depths of the bear market November twenty two, and
- 16:30that was the same month that all hell broke loose on FTX. I actually
- 16:33saw you in across socials and in the news beforehand. You know, it
- 16:38looked like you were one of the first people waving the red flag on FTX,
- 16:45and you know, having that you had the winning lottery numbers there to
- 16:48guess that there was something wrong. Can you talk about what you saw exactly?
- 16:55What was the story leading up to the FTX crash and sort of how
- 16:57it all played out in your eyes. Yeah, yeah, I would love
- 17:00to. Yeah, yeah, definitely a little bit of a winning lottery ticket
- 17:03for myself. I think it definitely changed the trajectory of subscribed you know,
- 17:07my my personal career, and and you know a lot of other factors.
- 17:10So definitely a fun story to to talk about. I think, you know,
- 17:14I've obviously been you know, contributing around and working really closely in defive
- 17:17for quite a long time, and there was a few factors that started to
- 17:22pique my interest as to you know, there's probably something not super great going
- 17:26on here, I think, and a lot of it are not like this
- 17:29incredibly complex, you know. I think with c FI institutions it's, uh,
- 17:33it's it's you're not able to do a lot of the traditional just like
- 17:36on chain analytic analytical aspect of it, and so it's it's hard to really
- 17:41know the solvency of a project when a lot of the funds are like in
- 17:44bank accounts and in traditional you know, financial rails. But I think there
- 17:48was a couple of factors that I saw that really raised my eyebrow and made
- 17:52me think that something is not right there. I think one of the first
- 17:56things I saw was just the departure of top executives. I think you saw,
- 18:03Man, it's been so long night and it's like even hard to remember
- 18:04it's Sam Trabuco there. It is. So you saw Sam Trabuco leave in
- 18:07like I want to say, like may or June of twenty twenty two,
- 18:12you saw him leave. And you know, I think there's a fair argument
- 18:15to be made that maybe he just became post economic, right, And I
- 18:18think, honestly, like you talk about top signals, there is no better
- 18:22top signal than Chances Tubruco because now he just gets off scott free for you
- 18:25know, what is likely to be involved in some capacity to some of the
- 18:27things that happened at FTX. But he got it at the right time.
- 18:32And but you know, being the CIO of and you know, I guess
- 18:34co CEO at the time of Alameda, him leaving at what thought to be
- 18:40the best business in the world at the time, and you know, the
- 18:41fastest growing startup in probably history, red flag, right, you know,
- 18:45you're just making money hand over fist. You know, people would always talk
- 18:48about how how the scale of the trades that these guys were making, and
- 18:53you know the arms they were making, and how they were just killing people
- 18:56in DeFi which they were, right, there's on chain and proof that they
- 18:59were killing people. And so if they're making so much money hand over his
- 19:03why is this ky leaping? Yeah? I think this is a fair point.
- 19:04Maybe he's post economic, goes to buy about somewhere living on an island,
- 19:07sure, right, But I think what really doubled that down was you
- 19:11had ftx US CEO Brett Harrison, who actually just raised money for architect.
- 19:15He left in September. And this was supposed to be the adult in the
- 19:18room, right, He was supposed to be this like you know, tradified
- 19:22titan who comes in is going to fix all the kids and rally up the
- 19:25troops and build this really strong you know, you know, infrastructure to be
- 19:30able to scale up t to do a one hundred million dollar company. And
- 19:32he left, you know maybe even it was definitely under a year because he
- 19:37hadn't even hit his best period, right, And so it's like if you're
- 19:40going to leave a company before you're vesting where it's like you know, traditional
- 19:42startups, you have a one year cliff and then you start to vest over
- 19:45you know, maybe like the linear quarterly linear vesting period, massive red flag.
- 19:49Right, you have a thirty billion dollar business that you're potentially in vesting
- 19:52into. Why are you leaving right before your best period hits? So then
- 19:56that was like the like something fishy here, right, And you know,
- 20:00I was contributing really heavily to Gains Network at the time, which was,
- 20:02you know, a top two perpetual futures decks right after GMx. You know,
- 20:07Gains was by far and away number two volume behind those two, and
- 20:11so you know, it started to realize that, you know, one,
- 20:15this was like post Luna, right, so volume across the board is going
- 20:18down pretty significantly, right. And also another thing kind of even going before,
- 20:22is that I just had incredible conviction that there was going to be a
- 20:25massive domino to fall post Luna. Right. You can't. You can't burn
- 20:29sixty billion in market cap in like a week's time period and not have you
- 20:33know, like three ac Sure, like pretty big, but you know we're
- 20:37not talking about ten billion dollars or twenty billion dollars in assets going poof,
- 20:41right, You're talking about like, yeah, Celsius, like decent sized business,
- 20:45but like the actual value of that business was not that massive, maybe
- 20:48a billion, maybe two billion, Right, there was a couple small dominoes,
- 20:52but I felt in I have an incredible conviction that there was a big,
- 20:56big domino that was going to fall, right, you like, you
- 20:57know, sixty billion dollars is Leman's right, and so you're compared it to
- 21:02like the you know, two thousand and financial crisis, A ton of massive
- 21:04businesses you're talking about AIG and some of the largest businesses in the world started
- 21:08to go under. So I was I was definitely looking at what was like
- 21:12who was you know, who is going to be the most at risk?
- 21:18Right, who is really involved in that ecosystem? Who's playing around in Luna
- 21:21a ton and so so one of those players that wasn't just a regular sized
- 21:26hedge fund like a three AC someone is going to go down. So my
- 21:29like, you know, my senses, my spidy senses, word eatingly and
- 21:33and so then like you know, Brett Harrison Leaves, I, I,
- 21:37you know, working at GAINS, I saw that you know, the entire
- 21:40derivative space like c FI ANDTFI were going down, but actually the on chain
- 21:45derivative market share was increasing, and then and then you start to look at
- 21:48FTX volumes around that tem they're actually decreasing, but you still see these incredible
- 21:52spend levels, right. You see the money that they're spending, the people
- 21:56that they're bringing on. You start to hear some of these stories about you
- 21:59know, this big Bahama's mansion. And then that's when I started to do
- 22:03kind of the really deep due diligence of like, hey, what's really going
- 22:04on here? How are these numbers adding up? Like something just wasn't adding
- 22:07up. Yeah, they raised a decent amount of money, but like at
- 22:10a thirty billion dollar valuation, they raised like a billion, you know,
- 22:14a few billion. They weren't raising ten billion at a thirty billion dollar valuation.
- 22:17So they didn't have this like ungodly war chest. They had a war
- 22:21chest, but spending twenty million dollars a year on Miami Heat, naming rights
- 22:25for the FTX arena, you know, like you know, Sam's talking about
- 22:30investing in Twitter and helping Elon by Twitter, talking about the political contributions he's
- 22:37making, you know, taking the eye off the ball. They just ended
- 22:40up missing on a lot of product launches, right. They tried to do
- 22:41FTX stocks, which was just like, if you know, it was totally
- 22:45against everything they were talking about. Like the rhetoric was always we're going to
- 22:48be incredibly native, we're gonna be crypto, like we're gonna, you know,
- 22:52be this intersection of crypto and trad fi. And like, you know,
- 22:56what they were saying and the actions they were taking didn't match, and
- 22:59it started to seem like, right, FTX NFT dumped a bunch of money
- 23:02into that absolutely like totals zero, absolutely just terrible produm and so you started
- 23:08to put together it's like, hey, they're the're dumping a bunch of money
- 23:10in a product launches. These aren't working. They're dumping a bunch of money
- 23:12into marketing. It's not really working too well. And then their overall core
- 23:17business, the volume is going down, and then you have like this,
- 23:19you know what percentage of the volume that they're actually doing is Alameda versus everybody
- 23:23else, and you know the issues there, but it's like, ah,
- 23:26you know, maybe Alametera really is just killing everybody in this business is making
- 23:30a hundred million dollars a year, even Alameda is making one hundred million dollars
- 23:33a year, you're talking about, you know, a multi billion dollar company
- 23:36that's you know, spending hundreds of millions of dollars a year in you know,
- 23:40you know, they had a massively bloated payroll all of that, and
- 23:41so you start to put all of these pieces together, and I just got
- 23:45this incredible conviction that like this was this was the big domino that was going
- 23:48to drop post Luna. And then I put out this relatively long thread on
- 23:53Twitter around October and just laid it out of like, hey, this is
- 23:57why I'm pretty bearish on everything these guys happening, and you know, something
- 24:02isn't right here, something doesn't make sense. And then at the time,
- 24:06you know, I kind of got killed for it. Right, people are
- 24:07like, hey, these guys are destroying everybody on chain. Look at the
- 24:11on chain metrics, like you know, the kimchi trade and some of these
- 24:14other ar opportunities they're getting. But it's like, hey, you're we're talking
- 24:17about like, you know, peanuts versus like you know, like this massive,
- 24:21massive, thirty billion dollar business like the you know, you're talking about
- 24:23like picking up pennies in front of a steamroller. Right, They're like,
- 24:26yeah, they're doing a couple of arts here there, but these numbers just
- 24:29aren't adding up. And you know, I have like I have, I
- 24:32have texts from people that are like, hey, like sending you screenshots and
- 24:34people being like, this guy's crazy, this guy doesn't know what he's talking
- 24:37about. Uh. And then a month later I felt pretty vindicated. Yeah,
- 24:41amazing story. And that's I think that's exactly how it goes when you're
- 24:45a contrarian like that, but you have a hunch, and there's bound to
- 24:49be people that you know, they have a vested interest in it working.
- 24:52And there still are, you know, many accounts that they hopefully the recovery
- 24:57happens eventually. But yeah, that's calling it calling the bottom, and that
- 25:02really was the bottom. We've turned around so much since then. Throughout twenty
- 25:07twenty three, in the latter half, you know, Bitcoin just was on
- 25:10fire, and moving into twenty twenty four, it seems like, you know,
- 25:14there was a small dip buying after the Bitcoin ETF launched, but the
- 25:18amount of volume that's happened with tradfi coming in to bitcoin, you know,
- 25:23buying billions and billions they need it for the back in the ETF, it's
- 25:26seen a one to eighty degree turn. And usually that's what happens in these
- 25:30cycles, is it gets to the depths of the bear and then I feel
- 25:33like this one and actually we're still pretty early on in what's coming up in
- 25:37the next cycle for bitcoin and for crypto altogether, because I don't know if
- 25:44it's proper to say this time feels different because there's bigger companies. I'm sure
- 25:48they'll be bound to be funny business as well, but when when the biggest
- 25:53financial companies in the world are getting involved, I feel like it's a little
- 25:56bit different. Do you have timism on moving forward post Bitcoin ETF, potentially
- 26:03ethereum, other coin ETF, and just the crypto market in general moving forward
- 26:08twenty twenty four to twenty five. I think everybody's underweight ether right now.
- 26:14I think it's going to be so obvious in hindsight. I think you're starting
- 26:17to see the movement for it. I think you have a lot of eth
- 26:19being sucked up in the market. You have, you know, like I'm
- 26:22one of the biggest igon layer bulls you will ever meet. I think like
- 26:26just the concept of being able to export to centralized trust is a massive,
- 26:30massive, primitive that we're still not evil. I think even the Eigen Layer
- 26:34team that hasn't even been able to wrap their heads around all of the different
- 26:37opportunities. I think there's going to be consumer opportunities. I think it's going
- 26:41to be like it's going to be a real zero to one innovation, just
- 26:45full stop, like just real actual innovation, like and un mass scale.
- 26:49But I think you have, like you have four eight for forecoming proto dank
- 26:53charting that's going to be pretty massive. That's going to make gas fees a
- 26:56lot cheaper. It's going to really open the door for you know, uh,
- 27:02for more retail to find it realistic to use a lot of these layer
- 27:06to networks. And I think you're starting to see a lot more exchanges and
- 27:08on rampings going directly to L two's. I think it's gonna hit a point
- 27:11where, you know, if you if you interacted with eight layer one,
- 27:14it's going to be kind of like a oh shit, you used to used
- 27:15to trade on ethel one. While it's like a that's that's impressive where you
- 27:18were early. I think you have four eight four four, you have Iigen
- 27:22Layer and just all of the l rts and Iigen layers just eating so much
- 27:26etherium off of the market. I think you have blast and other kind of
- 27:30things like this that are just eating market share, and then you have this
- 27:33like giant behemoth elephant in the room, which is the ethereum metf. I
- 27:37think one of the things that people in the market is probably not pricing improperly
- 27:41is that you can't stop in ETF anymore. There is no ability. I
- 27:45think once you start to get to like Solana and like down the rabbit hole
- 27:48like that, I think there's arguments to be made about centralization. But I
- 27:51think the bitcoin, like the the verdicts that have happened on the bitcoin ETF
- 27:55are going to be so easily played out in court for an ethereum etf that
- 27:59it's essentially a done deal. Net Like, there is nothing that is going
- 28:02to stop anybody from launching ethereum metf. I think may might be a little
- 28:07bit exciting, like it might be a little bit optimistic, but I think,
- 28:11like you know, Q three, it'd be hard to see we don't
- 28:12get an ethereal metf before Q three Q four, And once that happens,
- 28:18the inflows you're going to see are just gonna be in cripple, so you
- 28:21have you know, four eight four four Denkune, You're gonna have a massive
- 28:23like it's just gonna be easier and cheaper and cleaner to use the Ethereum network.
- 28:27I think you have this entire supply section where like, you know,
- 28:30I don't think igen layer like full on Maintenet and witdrawals are going to happen
- 28:33for probably a quarter or two, right, so all of that Ether is
- 28:37just getting sucked up, sucked up, sucked up last other platforms like that,
- 28:41and then you know you have an ETF do comes and the excitement around
- 28:45the ETF. So there's just gonna be a massive underweight supply of ethereum on
- 28:49the market and everyone's gonna want it. Everyone's gonna look for it. It's
- 28:53the easiest, you know, it's one of the easiest absts to buy.
- 28:56You know, you can buy it on a paypale like anywhere you can buy
- 28:59bit when you can buy a three nowadays, and so it's very retail friendly.
- 29:03There's real use cases. So I think it appeals to a broader audience
- 29:06that are outside of like this, you know, like, hey, I
- 29:08like bitcoin, Like personally, I don't really have any bitcoin in my portfolio,
- 29:11to be totally frank, It's like, I think I'm starting to get
- 29:15more excited, but if I'm gonna invest in the ecosystem, I'm probably gonna
- 29:17invest in, like, you know, some of these layer twos, ordinals,
- 29:19like some of these more high beta things. I think you're finally starting
- 29:22to get bitcoin beta, which is going to pull away from some of the
- 29:25potential of bitcoin growth. Is like when you have that beta, and I
- 29:29think there's a ton of ethere in beta too, I don't know how well
- 29:30it's going to perform because a lot of the beta doesn't necessarily, you know,
- 29:36get that same exposure as like the actual vanilla ether. And so you
- 29:41have staking, liquid steaking, you have restaking, you have like blasts and
- 29:45other l twos like that, and then you have four eight four four and
- 29:48then just the eigen layered narrative as a whole. I think it's something that
- 29:49traditional financial infrastructure is going to like once, once it clicks for them,
- 29:53because I think it's pretty intuitive that you can export the trust of potentially eight
- 29:57hundred thousand validators, how many of those are actual like individual Soulo validators are
- 30:03interesting, but like hey, I'm telling everyone right now, like I think
- 30:04buying adapt note and running a node and like, you know, I'm not
- 30:08you know, like I'm not a dev by trade, but I run adapt
- 30:11note at home. I think it's incredibly importantybody should un adapt noted at home.
- 30:15And I think once you get resticking, it's going to be a lot
- 30:17more realistic. It's going to be a lot more it's going to be easier,
- 30:19and it's going to be a lot more financially beneficial to be running a
- 30:22note at home. The ability to export eight hundred thousand nodes of trust or
- 30:26you know whatever fraction of people that are actually going to restake is a like
- 30:32real zero to one innovation that I don't think the world's ready for. So
- 30:34that that was just my I guess my ethereum you know bow case. That's
- 30:38amazing. Yeah, I'm incredibly bullish as well. And I do also think
- 30:42theorem is going to outperform Bitcoin in near term leading up to the theorem ETF.
- 30:48If not in May, then yeah, Q three, Q four,
- 30:52it's it's it's got to be a done deal. So it's very exciting.
- 30:53Thank you for that sort of alpha on you know, some of the beta
- 30:57areas and Egan Layer. I think a lot of people need to still look
- 31:02into that and realize that the value potential there. You know, we've covered
- 31:06the past, the present, the future, all great insights, so much
- 31:11to digest. It's all the time that we have for this episode, Eeshan,
- 31:14but I would love to have you back on the show and in your
- 31:15future and wishing you all the best for Scribe and all the innovations that you're
- 31:21working on and you're dealing with in crypto. So thank you so much.
- 31:25Yeah, yeah, of course, thank you for the time Ashton. It
- 31:26was fun. It's just nice to get out there and you know, put
- 31:30on my bull hat a little bit. But yeah, I appreciate the time.