Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA’s Stablecoin Proposal: What Credit Unions Need to Know Now
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Okay everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Kel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Today I'm gonna be chatting about NCAA's stable coin proposal and what credit
- 0:08unions need to know in that regard.
- 0:11Now the NCUA has issued a proposed rule to implement the Genius Act, which was
- 0:16signed into law on July 18th, 2025.
- 0:20That act requires that NCUA and other regulators establish a
- 0:25licensing framework for credit union subsidiaries that want to issue payment.
- 0:30Stable coins.
- 0:31Here's one of the big takeaways.
- 0:33Credit unions cannot issue stable coins directly.
- 0:36They must do so through a licensed subsidiary.
- 0:40And when you hear subsidiary, what do you think of?
- 0:43Of course, credit union service organizations or QSOs.
- 0:47So that's likely where this will land.
- 0:50If it makes sense for you and your credit unions your credit
- 0:54union members and the industry.
- 0:57So this proposal sets the groundwork for how that would work, and it raises
- 1:02some important strategic and regulatory questions that I'm gonna break down here.
- 1:06As a refresher, what is the Genius Act?
- 1:09The Genius Act?
- 1:10Creates a federal regulatory structure for payment.
- 1:13Stable coins under the act only permitted payment, stablecoin, issuers, or pps.
- 1:20I, we'll see if that acronym takes off.
- 1:22Can issue payment Stable coins in the United States.
- 1:26Insured depository institutions, including credit unions,
- 1:29cannot issue these directly.
- 1:32They must operate through subsidiaries.
- 1:34Those subsidiaries are supervised by their primary federal regulator, and of
- 1:39course that would be NCUA in federally insured credit unions instances.
- 1:43The act also requires one-to-one reserve backing using US currency
- 1:48or other approved liquid assets, public redemption policies.
- 1:54Monthly reserve disclosures, A ML and BSA and sanctions compliance.
- 1:59IT and risk management standards and critically stable coins
- 2:04are not federally insured.
- 2:06They are not backed by the full faith and credit of the United States,
- 2:11and they cannot be marketed as such.
- 2:14Now, NCA must also implement.
- 2:17Issue implementing regulations by July 18th, 2026.
- 2:22It'll be interesting to see when that comes out.
- 2:25It'll be interesting to see if when that comes out, Kyle Halman still
- 2:28on the board or we have a new board chair or who knows, Halman and Osco
- 2:32win, win or lose their lawsuit.
- 2:34There could be different board members proposing that required rule so to speak.
- 2:40Now, this proposal is only phase one licensing and investment structure.
- 2:44A sub sec, a second proposal will cover operational standards.
- 2:49So we've got this proposal, we have another proposal, which
- 2:51will be operational standards.
- 2:53And then they would have the implementing regulations that will follow.
- 2:56So the office of General counsel which has lost a big chunk of their
- 3:00staff because of the reorganization, is gonna be quite busy on.
- 3:04Proposing these regulations, which may or may not have any bandwidth in the
- 3:09credit union industry, time will tell.
- 3:11So how is this similar to the banking regulators?
- 3:15Is in, is the NCOA proposal materially different from the
- 3:18banking regulators are doing?
- 3:20The short answer is no, not really.
- 3:22Structurally, they're almost identical, and that's because they're
- 3:25all implementing the same law.
- 3:27The Genius Act, the statute directs the NCOA, the FDIC, the OCC, and
- 3:32the Federal Reserve to build a licensing framework for PP sis.
- 3:38Now across regulators, you see the same architecture.
- 3:41Stable coins must be issued through a subsidiary, A licensed
- 3:44subsidiary applications are reviewed under the same statutory factors.
- 3:49Regulators have 120 days to act once an application is substantially complete.
- 3:54Now that's interesting in that it puts the onus on the
- 3:57regulators that if you're late.
- 3:59You're going to get, you're gonna get approved.
- 4:01So if they missed 120 K, 120 day, but what that also means is substantially complete.
- 4:06You'll, what you'll see in field membership cases historically
- 4:10or other actions is they'll say, your application is incomplete.
- 4:13You need to address A, B, C.
- 4:15And that restarts the clock.
- 4:16So watch for that 1, 2, 3 years down the road.
- 4:20Once this thing is actually up and running, issuers must
- 4:23maintain one-to-one reserves.
- 4:25There are strict governance capital liquidity al a ML,
- 4:29and technology expectations.
- 4:31And as I said previously, stable coins cannot be marketed as federally insured.
- 4:36Where they differ is not in substance, but in institutional structure,
- 4:40banking regulators generally assume a single parent bank model.
- 4:43An N two A proposal anticipates widely held joint owned cooperative
- 4:47subsidiaries, IE QSOs, that reflects the credit union model, so sub substantively
- 4:54similar, structurally tailored.
- 4:57A quick note on the Clarity Act and the rewards versus interest question.
- 5:02There's another bill floating around the Proposed Clarity Act,
- 5:05and some have asked whether that changes the stable coin landscape.
- 5:10So here's my take.
- 5:11It does not replace the Genius Act.
- 5:14The Genius Act governs how stable coins are issued, and
- 5:17supervised clarity is broader.
- 5:20It addresses how digital assets are classified and whether they
- 5:23fall under the SEC or S or the cf.
- 5:27TC jurisdiction.
- 5:29Now here's the subtle issue.
- 5:30Genius is designed to keep payment stable coins from looking like interest
- 5:35bearing deposits or securities.
- 5:37If an issuer pays something that walks and talks like yield, even
- 5:40if it's labeled rewards, regulators will look carefully at whether it's
- 5:44economically the same as paying interest.
- 5:47That becomes a safety and soundness issue under genius and
- 5:50potentially a classification issue.
- 5:52Under clarity, if the product starts to resemble an investment contract for
- 5:57credit unions, especially this matters, stable coins are not insured shares.
- 6:01They cannot blur that line.
- 6:04So while clarity affects the broader digital asset market structure,
- 6:07the interest versus reward debate will likely play out inside the
- 6:11genius supervisory framework.
- 6:13And as an aside, there's a lot of.
- 6:15Podcast, the FinTech Takes podcast, talks a lot about this rewards versus
- 6:20interest and, in the FinTech takes discussions, it seems pretty clear that
- 6:25this was a loophole, that the people got into the law, that were supportive
- 6:29of crypto, that were supportive of stablecoin, and that quite frankly,
- 6:34I think the banks and credit union lobbyists missed because there is a
- 6:37workaround that allows it to be rewards.
- 6:39It just can't come directly from the stable coin.
- 6:42And I think the Clarity Act has come along saying, oops, we should have done better.
- 6:49On this, and it's creating as structured, potentially more competition for
- 6:56banks than banks thought it would.
- 6:58When they saw that originally they were not allowed to pay
- 7:01interest, but this reward loophole.
- 7:04Seems to be potentially problematic in that regard, so it'll be interesting
- 7:09to see where that plays out.
- 7:11If credit unions want to participate in issuing stable coins, it must, as
- 7:16I said, must do through a subsidiary.
- 7:18So that would be a qso and that subsidiary must obtain an nnc A-P-P-S-I license.
- 7:24So here's the nuance.
- 7:25Instead of requiring every investing credit union to apply individually, the
- 7:29subsidiary applies jointly with only what the roll calls parent companies
- 7:34who qualifies as a parent company, any credit union that owns 10% or more on
- 7:39voting securities or has the ability to direct management or policies.
- 7:44If no credit union owned tens percent, the largest SH shareholder becomes the
- 7:48parent company NCOA selected the 10%.
- 7:52Because it's a common material control threshold in banking laws.
- 7:57This avoids forcing dozens of investing credit unions to file
- 8:00duplicate duplicative applications, especially giving the 120
- 8:05day statutory decision clock.
- 8:08The framework clearly anticipates, pooled cooperative models like QSOs.
- 8:14Now, then there's the investment limitation in QSO implications.
- 8:17As a reminder for federal credit unions, the constraint is the 1% cap.
- 8:22Federal credit unions may invest up to 1% of total paid in unimpaired
- 8:26capital and surplus into organizations such as QSOs, PPSI investments
- 8:32aggregate into the same 1% bucket.
- 8:35So if your institution is already near its Q cell limits partition.
- 8:38Participations may be a bit constrained.
- 8:41The NCA is also proposing that psis formed by federal credit unions operate
- 8:46through of course, the part 7 1 2 QSO framework that raises legitimate
- 8:52question, should p psis be treated differently from traditional QSOs?
- 8:56Should certain part 7 1 2 requirements be streamlined or made tougher?
- 9:03Should PP sis be required to register in the queue?
- 9:06So registry.
- 9:08The board, the NSU Board of one is openly requesting comments on these issues.
- 9:13Now in regards to licensing, re requirements and evaluation factors,
- 9:17applications is proposed, will be evaluated under statutory factors
- 9:21including financial condition and re reserve sufficiency,
- 9:25absence of disqualifying felony convictions, competence, experience,
- 9:30and integrity of management, adequacy of redemption policies.
- 9:34Overall safe, safety and soundness as proposed applicants must
- 9:38submit detailed business plans, pro forma financial statements.
- 9:43Capital and liquidity plans, technology and risk management documentation,
- 9:48biographical and financial reports.
- 9:50Fingerprints for certain officers and directors.
- 9:53Once an application is deemed substantially complete, and
- 9:56Sue has 120 days to decide.
- 9:58As I mentioned before, if the agency fails to act within that timeframe,
- 10:02the application is deemed approved.
- 10:04That's not a situation any regional director ever wants to find
- 10:07themself in where they approve something by not responding.
- 10:11So this statutory clock is important and it does matter.
- 10:16So the cost question and Sue is also including, considering how to fund these
- 10:20expanded, this expanded supervisory role.
- 10:23Options include licensing fees, examination fees, or spreading
- 10:27the cost across all credit unions through the general budget.
- 10:31My guess is a lot of credit unions won't like that last option unless of
- 10:35course they wanna be in stable coins.
- 10:37They'd rather have it spread out if you in it.
- 10:39If you're not in it, you probably wanna have the individuals.
- 10:43That are in it to pay for it.
- 10:45Because Stablecoin participation is optional and likely limiting to limited
- 10:49to a minority of institutions, the board is obviously seeking whether costs should
- 10:54be born only by those participants.
- 10:57That discussion could become a significant part of the debate.
- 11:01In closing on this topic, what does this mean?
- 11:03First, this rule does not push credit unions into stable coins.
- 11:07It creates a potential pathway.
- 11:09Second, the framework is cooperatively friendly.
- 11:12Third, capital constraints and structure.
- 11:14Structural limits matter.
- 11:16Fourth, operational standards are still coming, so stay tuned for that.
- 11:21I guess it would be pretty soon.
- 11:23This is one of the most significant expansions of NNC a's supervisory
- 11:27authority In recent memory.
- 11:28Some would pose, it places the agency firmly into digital asset regulation
- 11:34but in a cautious safety focused way.
- 11:37Comments are due 60 days after federal registered publication.
- 11:41So roughly in 60 days from now, if your credit union is even considering
- 11:46this space, now is the time to engage.
- 11:48If the proposal makes sense, NSU A does listen to comments, so I
- 11:52encourage you to take a look at that.
- 11:55Now, pivoting away from that proposal NCUA also recently announced.
- 12:01Stage five of their round of deregulation proposals.
- 12:04The short version on this is that this is mostly changes from
- 12:08happy to glad or glad to happy.
- 12:10What does that mean?
- 12:11It means these are mundane tweaks to regulations and the items that we're in.
- 12:19Version five of this is relates to three proposals conversion of insured
- 12:24credit unions to mutual savings banks.
- 12:26The board proposes to reduce regulatory burden and increase flexibility by
- 12:31eliminating some procedural disclosure and communication requirements
- 12:35for converting insured credit unions to mutual savings banks.
- 12:39That happens very rarely.
- 12:40I can't remember the last time that happened.
- 12:43It was big about 15 years ago.
- 12:45But they're making it less onerous.
- 12:47Should a credit union wanna take this direction, impact on credit unions?
- 12:51Among other things, the proposed changes would simplify regulatory
- 12:54compliance for conversion disclosures and allow credit unions the flexibility
- 12:59to design disclosures that are effective and clear for their members.
- 13:03The next proposal that ha has a tweak to it.
- 13:08Is the mergers of insured credit unions into other credit
- 13:10unions, voluntary termination or conversion of insured status.
- 13:15The board proposes to retain the core disclosure.
- 13:18And notification requirements, whether credit union's members vote on a decision
- 13:22to merge or terminate federal insurance coverage and convert to private insurance,
- 13:27but eliminate prescriptive requirements associated with those disclosures.
- 13:32What's the impact on credit unions?
- 13:33This proposed change would relax.
- 13:35Dictate to provide modest merger related cost savings
- 13:39and reduce unnecessary burden.
- 13:41It would provide credit unions with greater flexibility in designing
- 13:45effective communications while still ensuring that members receive clear
- 13:49and prominent notice of a proposed termination of federal insurance.
- 13:52Why any credit union would wanna go to private insurance.
- 13:55I have no idea.
- 13:56And so it's rare this is even.
- 13:59Even rare than the Mutual Savings Bank one discussed earlier.
- 14:03So again, this is this is a deregulatory change that really impacts virtually
- 14:09nobody, or as Van Morrison once said, what's the sound of one hand clapping?
- 14:14Lastly, the organization and operation of Federal Credit Unions.
- 14:19The board proposes to rescind herbs oh six dash one because the current
- 14:22field of membership, FOM requirements are in the chartering manual.
- 14:26So what's the impact?
- 14:27This change would eliminate a redundant standard currently
- 14:30listed in more than one area.
- 14:33This would ease.
- 14:34The compliance burden on federal credit unions by limiting the number of sources
- 14:37they must check to ensure compliance with applicable community chartering
- 14:41and field membership requirements.
- 14:43So again, not much there.
- 14:45The big takeaway is what we talked about for most of this podcast,
- 14:48which is the stable coin proposal, which was required to be put out.
- 14:52NCA is going in the direction that they're required by the
- 14:55law, by the Trump administration.
- 14:57And it will be interesting to see.
- 14:59Where this where this heads, it'll be more interesting to see if stable
- 15:02coins actually do ever take off and do impact banks and credit unions.
- 15:06A lot of noise around this, a lot of theories around it.
- 15:10And you gotta play to win sometimes.
- 15:12I'm not sure if this is something that will ultimately be important
- 15:15for credit unions or not.
- 15:17What's your take on it?
- 15:18Send me a note.
- 15:19If you believe stable coins are the future or are not the future.
- 15:23All right.
- 15:23This is mark Rele.
- 15:24We've got some more exciting episodes coming up.
- 15:26I wanna thank you for listening.
- 15:28Thank you for watching.
- 15:29As always, mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.