Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 87: What the New Wave cinema movement can tell us about contemporary France with Laure Astourian
Transcript
- 0:08You listening to the New Paris. I'm your host Lindsay term U du.
- 0:13Okay, here's some real talk. I know little to nothing about
- 0:16French Cinema, but I do know that when the actors aren't
- 0:19plugged, edmundo died in September.
- 0:22It came as a massive loss to a lot of French people as it
- 0:25happens. Talking about bederman do online
- 0:28and what little I knew about him.
- 0:30Connected me to someone, who knows quite a lot about French
- 0:33Cinema and that's when I thought, maybe it's time to
- 0:36finally do an episode on film, but not just any discussion.
- 0:40I've brought on law as story and an assistant professor of French
- 0:43at Bentley University, a specialist in French Cinema, and
- 0:46occasional translator and a current Fulbright research
- 0:49scholar in Paris. Her research looks at the role
- 0:52of Imperial ethnography in shaping 1960s French Cinema will
- 0:56be talking about that her connection to France and how the
- 0:59new of movement contributes to a modern understanding of French
- 1:02society. So with that, let's go to the
- 1:06movies. Love.
- 1:10Welcome to the show. Hi Lindsay.
- 1:12Thank you for having me 22 to preface a little bit.
- 1:16You and I were going to speak about French Cinema.
- 1:20I know that his were you know, field of study and research and
- 1:24also we had been talking online about Jean-Paul Belmondo whose
- 1:30recent death in early September highlighted.
- 1:34Just how much of a sort of Epic figure.
- 1:38He was. Friday, I think I don't, I
- 1:40certainly didn't realize he was so beloved.
- 1:43But, you know, you and I shared some messages and it's a good
- 1:48and that got us talking about your background, but for
- 1:52listeners to know law and I met up ahead of this, to actually
- 1:56discuss this, this chat. I mean, to discuss sort of how,
- 2:00how we would talk about French Cinema.
- 2:02And it turns out we have a lot of other things to talk about
- 2:06one of which being your very A particular connection to France.
- 2:10So maybe let's start there and then we'll get into your work.
- 2:13But you are half French but it's not quite as black and white.
- 2:20Is that a writer? So can you talk a little bit
- 2:23about what your connection is to France?
- 2:26Yes, so I was born and raised in California, but my dad is
- 2:32French. I'm a French citizen through my
- 2:34dad, but he's actually Armenian of origin ethnically.
- 2:39And my mother is Armenian from Lebanon.
- 2:44So, both of my parents actually speak French, but we spoke
- 2:49Armenian at home yet. It was important.
- 2:54I think to my father that I remain connected with French
- 2:59culture that I learned the language and so he made sure
- 3:06that that happened. And and does that mean.
- 3:09Then I mean, you know, that you spent, I don't know, a big chunk
- 3:14of each year coming back to France or what was the sort of
- 3:18split in time like when you were growing up, so I did spend a few
- 3:25Summers or a chunk of a few summers in nice where my
- 3:29grandmother lived. But actually what happened is
- 3:34that my dad was a grad student when I was a child.
- 3:38And thanks to the French government, which he was able to
- 3:41put me in a bilingual, French school.
- 3:43So, I spent most of my Elementary School in a French
- 3:47school. And that's how I learned French.
- 3:49So in Californians in California, yeah, okay, and you
- 3:55would come back over though to see family and not that often,
- 4:00not that often. Okay.
- 4:01So because obviously your name sounds.
- 4:05Yeah, obviously very good. It is.
- 4:08And that's, that was sort of my first indicator that, you know,
- 4:11your background is going to lead to all sorts of conversations,
- 4:15but then also means that you have a different upbringing.
- 4:21For example, then I must have in the u.s.
- 4:24Given that both, my parents were born in the US, you know, and so
- 4:29kind of curious how that family structure shaped your, I guess,
- 4:37your impressions and Opinions of both cultures because
- 4:40effectively you were part of, I mean, I've yes, Armenian culture
- 4:44as well, but but the two big countries of your I guess if
- 4:49your immediate family France and the u.s.
- 4:52So what, you know, how did you find that?
- 4:56Insider-outsider kind of mmm, experience?
- 5:01I think I was always a little bit confused to be honest
- 5:05because went, but it made me very Attentive I think and they
- 5:10do think that's part of why I ended up doing what I do, which
- 5:14is, you know, analyzing images and and text and so on.
- 5:19But yeah, it was confusing. I do think it's a vicious as the
- 5:24French say like in retrospect. It's a it's a wonderful thing to
- 5:28have access to different cultures, you know.
- 5:34Yeah, it was confusing because at home we spoke Armenian and my
- 5:37parents insisted on that. And I think that was a good
- 5:40decision. And I honestly, I commend them
- 5:43for being wise enough not to fall into the Trap of saying,
- 5:46well, if we speak our language, that our child is going to have
- 5:50difficulty learning other languages, which is right, which
- 5:52is a myth, its path. It actually facilitates language
- 5:57learning, but you know, I my father was connected to France.
- 6:05So like it at home we would listen to Jesus.
- 6:08And Bob, aha, we would watch French films, and my mother
- 6:12actually among other languages was a French teacher.
- 6:16So I and they actually met in Paris and in college, so there
- 6:22were all these connections. I think, I never quite felt
- 6:24American. I mean, I think that's true.
- 6:27But when I mean, let's not fast forward too much, but when I
- 6:31came to France for study abroad to Paris in college, I can't say
- 6:36that I felt French either. But now, you know, later on, I
- 6:42actually feel like, you know, connected to all of these
- 6:47cultures, you know, I and I think it's just that there's
- 6:50more depth and Nuance than we initially see when we're child,
- 6:55you know, we can't really make sense of it all but the reality
- 6:58is that American culture is incredibly diverse and the image
- 7:04that it has around the world is, you know, can be very reductive.
- 7:08Civ for lack of a better word word, I mean culture.
- 7:12And, you know, even in California, the state of
- 7:14California, the culture in, you know, the East Bay versus the
- 7:19culture and different parts of Allah is different.
- 7:21Let alone, you know, I don't know New York versus Montana or
- 7:24Florida or Shores. Michigan, you know, to give some
- 7:27examples and similarly. I think I was always wary like
- 7:32when Americans would, you know, make jokes about France or the
- 7:35French. I, you know, I didn't really
- 7:37enjoy that. Um, because well, you know, at
- 7:42one level it's ignorant and it's also just not true.
- 7:49Well, yeah, and it's this whole stereotyping that, you know,
- 7:52seems to be just an easier way of trying to categorize people
- 7:57but it does everybody to service and you know, exactly whittles
- 8:01down people's Humanity. So I really understand and also
- 8:04your point even though it's so obvious when you think think
- 8:08about just how vast America is but it's almost it almost Bears
- 8:13reminding when you're in Christ station with, I mean enough to
- 8:17speak for for all foreigners, but certainly with other French
- 8:20people when they're definitely just how incomparable most of
- 8:25the country really is it have difficult.
- 8:29It is to try to paint, you know, an American from one spot with a
- 8:34similar brush as from another so there's it's dangerous
- 8:37territory. Certainly to do that.
- 8:40And I'm wondering, how does your how has your background then and
- 8:43you're, you know, kind of unique perspective on France.
- 8:48How does that differ from that of?
- 8:50I don't know, a typical American who looks to France perhaps with
- 8:55not as much Nuance or with, you know, rose-colored glasses.
- 9:01What do you if you had to sort of sum up a clear difference
- 9:06between those perspectives? What?
- 9:08You know, what comes to mind? Great question.
- 9:15I think since I have both this feeling of being inside and
- 9:22getting certain things, especially since I started, you
- 9:25know, engaging with French culture, as a child.
- 9:27So there's some things that are just not shocking to me.
- 9:30And that shocked me in American culture, when I went back to
- 9:34American school, like one just like the the focus on.
- 9:38Lightness, and decorum, you know, in the classroom.
- 9:41Like, I remember very well, we would stand up when the
- 9:43principal walked in and more uniform.
- 9:46Yeah. It was very, I mean, the school
- 9:50I went to was also very, I mean, this is something to discuss the
- 9:54French education system. I mean, when I was on that
- 9:56campus, it was like being in France, huh?
- 10:00That was that was quite interesting, but it was it was
- 10:03also a bit strict. Which yeah, I think.
- 10:08I think is not ideal in some ways.
- 10:12But to answer your question. I think my perspective actually,
- 10:20you know, makes me very aware of the fact that both American and
- 10:24French culture include all of these other cultures, you know
- 10:29that. But when you speak about an
- 10:32American, like many Americans, you know, either their parents,
- 10:35or their grandparents or their great-grandparent is from
- 10:37somewhere somewhere. All sir, maybe they know a bit
- 10:40of some language or or their parents are, you know, speak
- 10:43another language and similarly, with France.
- 10:45I mean, there's this book, I was thinking about it's called the
- 10:48French Melting Pot by a historian called real.
- 10:52It's about, you know, the different waves of immigration
- 10:55to France and there have been many.
- 10:59And I think, you know, broadly speaking.
- 11:04I'm very aware of that and in fact, that shaped When I was
- 11:09working on my dissertation at first, what the theme that
- 11:12interested me, was the role of the foreign in the new wave of
- 11:16the French New Wave, the the late 1950s and 60s film
- 11:20movement, huh? Because I was thinking, well,
- 11:22this I like, and yes valda has Greek Origins there shall as
- 11:26level who's Armenian? What else is only good?
- 11:31That was half, Swiss. You know, Jean seberg was
- 11:34American, you know, thinking about, you know, the new wave.
- 11:37If the Of French product. And then meanwhile, there were
- 11:40all these co-productions. So, you know, you know, what is
- 11:43a French film. Exactly.
- 11:45And the same goes today, you know, usually films and TV
- 11:48series or co-productions between, you know, at least two,
- 11:50if not a few more countries, so I was always kind of sensitive
- 11:56to that. And but, you know, the Rose
- 12:01Colored Glasses. It's interesting because I, you
- 12:06know, I love all the things that people love about France and
- 12:09Paris. I really do love France and
- 12:12French culture. There's a lot that I that I
- 12:15really appreciate but I think I think I have a I think I'm
- 12:20interested in digging deeper. I guess.
- 12:23That's right Rob. That's your, that's your
- 12:25research. Yeah, what do you call it?
- 12:29Like your inkling and your eagerness to research and to you
- 12:33know, it's sort of like the journalist thing.
- 12:35You always want to go deeper. You want to understand more.
- 12:39Well, so this is very interesting in, you're bringing
- 12:40into the conversation what I wanted us to discuss also, which
- 12:44is, you know, how you then got. Into this role of, I mean, as
- 12:51you said, you did a dissertation, so you have your
- 12:52PhD in in this particular in front in French Cinema, or
- 12:58French. Well, it's funny because I was
- 13:00actually in a literature Department called French and
- 13:02romance philology. And therefore there was actually
- 13:05quite a bit of literature and philology, but my dissertation
- 13:10is on Cinema. And I was always, I mean, I
- 13:13didn't quite know what I was doing at first, but ultimately,
- 13:18I wrote about Cinema. So.
- 13:19Okay. So for you it's sort of made
- 13:23sense regardless of your background as a French citizen
- 13:28to study in Paris. Yes.
- 13:30Did you you knew you were going to eventually, you know, get
- 13:33yourself over here to do research and to study for
- 13:36different lengths of time or different at different points of
- 13:39your education. Yeah.
- 13:41So I remember very well in, in high school.
- 13:46I had a Very nice teacher. Her name is Marion kleeger.
- 13:50Who was my French teacher. Actually, there's a funny story.
- 13:53So I actually, after going to that French school.
- 13:56I think until fourth grade. I had to switch schools and I
- 14:03didn't study French at all for several years.
- 14:06And in high school. I finally had the chance and I
- 14:08was, you know, really I was probably losing my skills and
- 14:13in, in high school. I really wanted to learn
- 14:16Spanish. And, by the way, I Will do, but
- 14:19the last was so, I mean, I hope this puts person surely isn't
- 14:23listening, but it was so bad that I was like, I can't do
- 14:26this. I mean, I think I'm gonna have
- 14:28to take French. So, it's really thanks to that
- 14:32Spanish teacher went over his head that I ended up back on the
- 14:37French path model. Hey, you know what you want to
- 14:45do with your life. It's also about What you don't
- 14:48want to do? So at least in that, one of your
- 14:51Spanish was not in the cards. No, I mean, I would really love
- 14:54to get back into it. But that's how I ended up in
- 14:56this French class. And this teacher was a very
- 14:58encouraging Teacher who has, who was into the Arts and she also
- 15:02taught a course called Art and society.
- 15:04And you know, we read rilke and she was just very passionate
- 15:07about Paris. I remember the first time she
- 15:09drew the at home, these small, you know, the snail-shaped
- 15:12chalkboard. And I was like, ooh, because my,
- 15:15you know, even though my parents Met in Paris.
- 15:18And I think that was a motivator for me.
- 15:20It was a motivating factor. I was, you know, curious about
- 15:23that. I had, you know, not really
- 15:26spent time in Paris. And so relatedly.
- 15:30The other thing is in this class, we watch this film by
- 15:33simply collect fish called Chicago chefs on Shah.
- 15:36I don't know if you're familiar with all know but it's a it sure
- 15:39is a tongue twister. Totally.
- 15:41I'm like, huh, but but that takes place I think Near bestie.
- 15:48So in the old GM and I remember seeing that and that film
- 15:51actually, I have not seen it since then by the way, so
- 15:54hopefully I won't hate it if I see it now, but I remember
- 15:57seeing the rooftops of Paris, you know, of the old cm in in
- 16:03that film and I was like, huh? I want to live there.
- 16:07I want to go to Paris. So I really remember that that
- 16:10that's the Paris. I want to live in, you know, not
- 16:12the poster Paris, you know, Lucia and wild or whatever, you
- 16:15know, those cliche posters. We see like This like kind of
- 16:18real life. Interesting neighborhood with
- 16:20real people cast of characters. That's where I want to live.
- 16:23And I think that's what actually really, you know, planted the
- 16:28seed in my head and so in college, yeah, I really wanted
- 16:32to spend a year in Paris and that's what I did.
- 16:35And and if you're in Paris right now, which you are and that's
- 16:40also what sort of connected us. It's because you're back doing
- 16:44research again, but also are you In the 11th.
- 16:48Again, I sure am and I'm very happy to be here.
- 16:51Yeah, I finally. Well, actually, I've lived in
- 16:53the, I've spent time in the 11th, you know, in the past.
- 16:56But this particular neighborhood actually does remind me very
- 17:00much of the vibe of that phone. So you so you've come for a full
- 17:04circle. Essentially.
- 17:07My adolescent, dreams have been, it's been fulfilled.
- 17:11What's up, so then, you know, let's get to the sort of the
- 17:16thing that Connected us which was you know, this very amusing
- 17:21almost Johnny. Hallyday level memorial for been
- 17:27Mondo when he died and so I'm curious.
- 17:31You know, what is, what is the way?
- 17:33What is the lens that you you give to French Cinema in your
- 17:38work? And and what is What should we
- 17:42know? What should?
- 17:43What should listeners know, especially particularly those
- 17:45who are interested in French Cinema, or at least seen a lot
- 17:48of these old films. What do you hope that they can
- 17:53think about the next time they're watching these films.
- 17:57Well, one thing I try to do in my work but in an organic way,
- 18:02meaning, I'm not, you know, imposing it but really searching
- 18:05for the connections is to situate late 1950s and early
- 18:101960s. French Cinema, so some of the
- 18:13works of the French new wave and then also Cinema verite which
- 18:16was a documentary tradition that actually, you know, Blended
- 18:20documentary with fiction in the broader context of the end of
- 18:24the French Empire, the dissolution of the French
- 18:27Colonial Empire, which was of course, a long process, but with
- 18:32the decolonization the formal, or official becomes ation of
- 18:38most of France's sub-Saharan African colonies, In 1960.
- 18:42And then in 1962, the end of the long, Algerian War.
- 18:46This was really, you know, the moment when there was quite an
- 18:51awareness of what was happening. It was a turning point, at
- 18:55least, you know, it was a turning point in many ways,
- 18:58including in people's minds yet, these films a lot of these
- 19:01famous films including breathless a Buddhist oof
- 19:05storing Jean-Paul, Belmondo, which was made in 1960, which
- 19:08was released in 1960. They're not really Considered in
- 19:12relation to that broader context.
- 19:15Now, of course, that wasn't the only thing going on.
- 19:18This was a period of really rapid modernization.
- 19:21American films were huge influence and so on.
- 19:26But I really, I want to say that I wanted to find a way to make
- 19:30this connection, but really, it wasn't like that.
- 19:32It's really by doing research that I ended up becoming
- 19:36interested in the status of ethnography or anthropology.
- 19:42In these films because I saw that there was a connection
- 19:45through a specific person and his films and that person is
- 19:49Jean hoosh who was an interesting figure an
- 19:54ethnographer. So an anthropologist and you
- 19:58know, an experimental filmmaker of sorts who was really admired
- 20:03by these French directors, including Goodell has, he was
- 20:08really admired for the film's, he was making In in, for
- 20:14example, Ivory Coast or just outside of Ivory Coast.
- 20:18And one of those films was called mwah mwah from around
- 20:241958. And without getting into, too
- 20:28many details that film really inspired go down when he was
- 20:31making breathless. So I was thinking and and you
- 20:33know, I'm not the first to notice.
- 20:34There's a I should make that clear.
- 20:36There's a lot of great scholarship on this entire
- 20:41period. And and angers hush, but I was
- 20:43really kind of thinking, they're, you know, more more can
- 20:48be done with this. This is pretty significant that
- 20:50this, you know, quintessential, French film is inspired by an
- 20:54ethnography, made in Ivory Coast, just before
- 20:57decolonization. And so that's kind of what got
- 21:01me on my journey, but you know, broadly speaking in a way my
- 21:06work on 1960s French Cinema, tries to connect it or make it
- 21:11more. Are relevant to today, you know,
- 21:16because I think I feel that sometimes those films are seen
- 21:19as, you know, kind of relics of the past Sean.
- 21:22They're actually quite relevant. They really foreshadow a lot of
- 21:26what we see today in French society and the world.
- 21:29But would you argue that the sort of the, the, the
- 21:33foreshadowing was unintentional? I mean, was there, was there a
- 21:39deliberate? I'm great with a deliberate
- 21:42choice to, I guess if, you know, set these stories in these
- 21:47locations in these among these among these populations, these
- 21:51Colonial populations as in a, as a, as a way of bringing
- 21:58commentary to, you know, what France was involved with or is
- 22:03it simply? Well, it's normal.
- 22:05This is an extension of France. And therefore this is where
- 22:08we're going to tell these stories.
- 22:10And this is where we can set. Them.
- 22:12I'm just sort of wondering how, how deliberate or intentional it
- 22:16was as a criticism or, is that really something we're just
- 22:19seeing now. Well, that's a really important
- 22:22question because I think, first of all, who's when he was making
- 22:24those films, it was absolutely deliberate because he was an
- 22:27ethnographer and that's what an ethnographer would do a French
- 22:30ethnographer and I should add that the French tradition of
- 22:34ethnography or really ethnology is what it's called.
- 22:36Anthropology is a very unique and Rich one.
- 22:41So Israel, whose crucially with really embedded in that
- 22:45tradition, he was part of that tradition.
- 22:47He worked with maths algol. He screamed his films at the
- 22:51musée de l'homme. You know, the which now, you
- 22:55know, the musée de l'homme collections are associated with
- 22:58Kim horny, but at the time that was really the anthropology the
- 23:04site of anthropology. So what's really interesting to
- 23:08me is that Hoosh in the 60s. And this is a big part of my
- 23:13project actually made several films in Paris simultaneously.
- 23:18He continued to make films in the former colonies, but the
- 23:25fact that he made these films in Paris, including a really
- 23:28important and really interesting one called Clinique Donita
- 23:32Chronicle of a summer in 1961. That was released his, you know,
- 23:37that isn't really Questioned that much.
- 23:40And to me, we'll really my argument on some level is that
- 23:45there's a sort of Auto ethnographic gaze emerging in
- 23:48French Cinema, in the 1960s. So that their awareness or
- 23:53sensitivity to this idea of ethnography of anthropology,
- 23:57whatever it was that they actually start saying, huh?
- 24:02We, I guess we could study ourselves to, I guess we're not,
- 24:05you know, the center of the universe, right?
- 24:08I guess, you know, parisians. Kind of like a tribe of sorts
- 24:11to, with their own codes, their own rituals and so on.
- 24:14So, even when this was facetious, even when it was just
- 24:18kind of in passing, I'm not saying that these people were
- 24:22trying to make ethnographies necessarily.
- 24:25But there's really a strain in the films of that period.
- 24:28Where you, you, if you look at it, through the lens of Earth,
- 24:31through this broader context of ethnographic film making you
- 24:34sort of see that that there's a growing self-awareness.
- 24:39And I find that really interesting because that's not
- 24:42how those films are typically seen.
- 24:45So when you're saying self-awareness, however, you're
- 24:47not necessarily saying that at the time these ethnographers or
- 24:52or the filmmakers, you know, those those who I guess wouldn't
- 24:56necessarily be considered actual ethnographers.
- 25:00They're not exactly saying or they're not suggesting that
- 25:06Frances imperialism. The bad thing, there's not
- 25:10necessarily the level of critique, right?
- 25:13This is, they're not activists. This isn't necessarily militant
- 25:18filmmaking. And in fact, that's what I find.
- 25:19Interesting. So, some of these filmmakers and
- 25:22again, it's actually not the same across the board, but some
- 25:26of the filmmakers whose works. I, I analyze our cleats mouska
- 25:31and Anthony who made a very important film called list that
- 25:36you may also see statues. Also, So die, which which, which
- 25:41is about imperialism, and it's a very it's an, it's an important
- 25:44anti anti-imperial film and it was censored for a very, very
- 25:48long time. Actually, but it's not in the
- 25:52project. It's not that film.
- 25:54I'm studying. I'm actually studying the film's
- 25:55they made in Metropolitan France.
- 25:58And so those two directors do have they were more.
- 26:02They were among the more politically active.
- 26:06Let's say, but this wasn't Early, this kind of Auto
- 26:11ethnographic Trend or awareness. In my view wasn't necessarily
- 26:15and didn't have to be a political act.
- 26:19It's almost in. It can be inadvertent.
- 26:21In fact, yeah, so then how do how do you understand these this
- 26:28wave? Or this this style of
- 26:30filmmaking? How do you see it as a
- 26:33contributor to, I guess some of the conversations were having
- 26:38today. Or perhaps the films that are
- 26:41being produced about contemporary French society.
- 26:43Today. I know that's not your focus.
- 26:45But just if even as a on a macro level, you know, how do you see
- 26:51that as an influence? So, great question.
- 26:56So I think one of the important contributions of these films, is
- 27:01there kind of more authentic and they're known for this
- 27:04authentic, portrayal of Paris. Let's say film.
- 27:09In the streets with natural light and so on.
- 27:13And in fact that film I mentioned Clinic donnetta, it's
- 27:15really like one of the first examples of reality TV in a way.
- 27:20I mean, I watched that film. It's like yeah, they're like in
- 27:22people's faces asking them if they're happy and people are
- 27:26really giving them like honest opinions, you know, really
- 27:29unfiltered. It's very touching.
- 27:32Actually. I really like that film but and
- 27:36it and it's a it's a film that actually does deal with.
- 27:39Some of these questions with the Algerian war on some level.
- 27:44IT addresses that albeit in a circuitous way or actually
- 27:48truncated. In fact, like the footage was
- 27:51removed. But yeah, but I suppose and
- 27:55there's great scholarship on on Chronicle of a summer notably by
- 27:59The Scholar, Sam diorio, but but how How does it affect today and
- 28:07these conversations? Well, it makes them directly
- 28:09relevant. You know, it gives us a way to
- 28:11look at look at these films and say, well, actually, that was a
- 28:15turning point and these films reflect that because I think,
- 28:18when we talk about issues plaguing France and not only
- 28:22France today, you know, these issues are not a historical.
- 28:27They have a history and so it's important to to to know that
- 28:32history or to want to know that history and and that history
- 28:36exists, you know, not only in the books, not only through
- 28:38monuments, not only through declarations or or paintings, or
- 28:43whatever. It's also in the cinema.
- 28:46And, and, and I suppose that what I find interesting is that,
- 28:51you know, when people think of some of these films, it's like
- 28:53so French, right? They think.
- 28:55Oh, this is so French. That's the past.
- 28:57It's, it's gone things are really different.
- 28:59Now when actually these films are very much tied to and
- 29:05Actually quite engaged with the moment in which their emerging
- 29:10and that includes the process of decolonization and and
- 29:15everything that comes with that that obviously has not been
- 29:20fully dealt with well now. And, and me about as being, you
- 29:24know, the issues plaguing society today, right?
- 29:27For specific issues around identity that I feel like I
- 29:30constantly talk about on this show that, you know, it's just
- 29:34the ongoing, Debate and certainly as you know, we're in
- 29:40an election year and these are the this will forever.
- 29:44I don't see a time or I can't at least you know believe we will
- 29:48live a time where identity in French identity which has been
- 29:52so some so very much at the heart of you know over the
- 29:58course of generations of what has been a difficult theme for
- 30:02the French to to navigate. I See it never not having this
- 30:07place in in this course, but certainly, you know, I think
- 30:11it's very interesting to consider at least in people's
- 30:14minds that some of these films and surely literature at the
- 30:17time as well. Could have, you know, could
- 30:22continue to teach us something about what we're going through
- 30:24today. Absolutely.
- 30:26Yeah. Yeah, that's the idea.
- 30:29I'm just, I'm just, you know, I'm thinking back to what you
- 30:31said about filming in the streets and the and the idea
- 30:35that it was actually Actually, perhaps more authentic.
- 30:36And the word authentic is so complicated.
- 30:38So fraudulently, and, and it's a word we're using yet again now,
- 30:44to talk about you, no more modern depictions of Paris,
- 30:49whether that's in loop on or people saw or the god-awful
- 30:52Emily in Paris, but there's a reason, there's a reason this is
- 30:56this is a theme that keeps coming up and I wonder and
- 30:59again, would publicly inauthentic Emily in Paris from
- 31:01what I understand. Yeah.
- 31:03I know. What's that?
- 31:05I'm just sort of wondering whether that was an issue and
- 31:07maybe maybe you can answer this. But just you know, whether this
- 31:11idea of authenticity and representation even of a place,
- 31:14you know, so Paris at that time whether that was important to
- 31:17people. Hmm, or maybe they just didn't
- 31:20have enough of a you know, it didn't travel as much.
- 31:23They didn't necessarily see, you know different depictions, or
- 31:28maybe there wasn't the idea to mask it.
- 31:30I mean, I obviously you said they'd come out, they truncated
- 31:32bits of hmm, and that will be a rogerian Warfare.
- 31:35Answers, they preemptively got they knew that they would have
- 31:39problems and so they didn't include those parts.
- 31:42Yeah, but I guess I'm just wonder how much you know, the
- 31:46the faithfulness to a place and and sort of trying to do it.
- 31:52Justice was as important then and that's that's maybe just a
- 31:55matter of opinion as well. You know, like what you think
- 31:57having, you know, spent so much time watching all these new wave
- 32:01films. How true to the era?
- 32:04Do you think it was? With respect to Paris.
- 32:09Great question. I do think that faithfulness to
- 32:12a place and the deep understanding of the place or at
- 32:15least trying to have a deep understanding of a place or even
- 32:18a thing before depicting. It is really important at the
- 32:22same time, you know, in these films the, the Paris we see is
- 32:26the world of the filmmakers, right?
- 32:28And they're actors. So we're not, you know, these
- 32:31aren't like social documentary is trying to show us, you know,
- 32:34the sea. Seedy underbelly of this or that
- 32:37neighborhood or which exists, you know, there are many many
- 32:41films on, you know, neighborhoods and, you know,
- 32:46struggling families and so on. So she'll that wasn't
- 32:48necessarily the goal. So, you know, it's funny because
- 32:51these films could be called self-centered, but actually, I
- 32:57think that's what's interesting about them.
- 33:00If we look at it from this different angle.
- 33:02Because actually, when you say this faithfulness to place, that
- 33:05was actually One of the big ideas that Jean who's that
- 33:08ethnographer, who inspired inspired some of the new wave
- 33:12and 1960s filmmakers. He actually wrote an article
- 33:17about how depiction of foreign places or non-french places
- 33:22should be authentic. Like We should strive for that.
- 33:26And it's also kind of against, you know, filming in a studio or
- 33:31really presenting a stereotype, a stereotypical, you know.
- 33:35Isn't ation of others. So, so I mean II, don't think I
- 33:39have a ready-made answer for you, but I think it's okay
- 33:41interesting because that is actually key.
- 33:44This idea of trying to seize a reality instead of providing a
- 33:49kind of folkloric example, you know, whether absolutely a
- 33:53distant land or of Paris, and I think you do that.
- 33:56Also, in your work, it's part of what's, you know, motivating you
- 34:00in a way. Yeah.
- 34:01No, I turned on facing real. I certainly try to and You know,
- 34:06I'm sure I could keep pushing myself to do even better.
- 34:09But it's just, you know, it's a sticking point for me.
- 34:12It's a, it's a point of frustration and know I think
- 34:16while I could never imagine myself in any sort of long
- 34:21Academic Program, like a PhD to do research on it, one theme
- 34:26like this. I do think there are parallels,
- 34:29in sort of the way. We become very attached to a
- 34:33certain Mission. Certain.
- 34:35Subject and trying to pursue that any way we can.
- 34:39So, I guess you and I are more similar than we made me not
- 34:44being an academic and me the other day.
- 34:48But, you know, these are still important contributions to to
- 34:52the broader world of scholarship.
- 34:55And so I guess to leave people with something.
- 34:59That's, you know, you've mentioned a whole host of films
- 35:02that I will put in the show notes.
- 35:03So people can, you know, go through, And say, okay, I'm
- 35:06going to watch this. I've seen this want to see this
- 35:08again. What, what else could they read
- 35:11or potentially? What other films that you
- 35:12haven't mentioned are worth picking up and exploring to
- 35:17further their understanding of this sort of this viewpoint on
- 35:23New Wave. Great questions.
- 35:26So I would add. So I think, I already mentioned
- 35:28breathless a Buddhist oof. Connect Anita, Chronicle of a
- 35:32summer list that you may also see which I think.
- 35:35On YouTube, by the way, I would add, there are two films.
- 35:42I actually really liked and would like to write about.
- 35:45But haven't at length yet. There is a film by ousmane,
- 35:49sembène called black, girl, it's Lanois, who do ellipses.
- 35:56And I believe that's from 1966 or around.
- 35:59Then, that is an excellent film for understanding, how even
- 36:05after Derp formal, the formal end of the Empire.
- 36:08It really wasn't over and you know, the same hierarchies and
- 36:12issues lingered. So that's just, you know, in
- 36:15with in that decade, you know, we're not even talking about the
- 36:18present. So there's that film and then
- 36:23what else I really like? And write about a lesser known
- 36:29film called passive. Oopah Paris seen by and it's an
- 36:33Omnibus film. And And I think the English
- 36:36translation is obviously not a literal one.
- 36:38It's 6 in Paris and it includes see that.
- 36:42Yeah, it's shorts by go, da whole Mashable and whoosh.
- 36:50And then I also think another interesting film which in my
- 36:56opinion does not fall. So I should I really quickly, I
- 37:00should mention that. What I'm what I'm talking about
- 37:02and ethnography. I'm referring to Imperial
- 37:04ethnography. There was actually such a thing
- 37:06as domestic ethnography but fight, not another film.
- 37:11Of course. I haven't seen it.
- 37:13Sorry so much info. Is that Cleo from five to seven
- 37:17Cleo the Sakai set by nes valda, which is a fantastic film.
- 37:22Well, and I'm always happy to put forward the work of any has
- 37:24valda. Who is just incredible or was
- 37:28incredible? I should say, so that's great.
- 37:31This is this is so fascinating and it gives me a whole new
- 37:34reason to To re-watch a bunch of old films.
- 37:37Interestingly, when I was in college and, you know, studying
- 37:40French literature. And and I mean, sort of culture.
- 37:45In general, we didn't watch any of these films.
- 37:47I watched Men on these tools. Oh, yeah.
- 37:50I watched that movie, all these people and I watched something
- 37:55that was more contemporary at the time.
- 37:56Called Les enfants du Chic about Jesus.
- 37:59And and Alfred M. You say and it was.
- 38:00Okay. I haven't felt when she became
- 38:03sort of one of my. I mean, I'm I love That film
- 38:05still, even though it is, you know, I don't even think it was
- 38:08well received in France, but to my, you know, I think I watch it
- 38:13still as a college student enamored with the idea of
- 38:19Storytelling and that, you know, that particular depiction of a,
- 38:24of a time and to, to literary figures who are known to have
- 38:27been so enamored with each other.
- 38:28But again, my references are so very different from all the
- 38:33films you've talked about today. So it gives me.
- 38:35Lots to think about and to go watch and I hope everyone who's
- 38:39listening. We'll go do the same law.
- 38:42Can you just to close? Can you just tell us, you know,
- 38:46what, what your research your your dissertation is going to be
- 38:51called and where people might be able to read your even scholarly
- 38:56work. Oh, thanks, so the title of so,
- 39:00I'm working on a book. It's currently under review and
- 39:04the process is Of a long one, but hopefully in a couple of
- 39:07years, it'll be out there in the world hopefully, but so I don't
- 39:15know what the exact title will be.
- 39:16But part of the title will definitely include something
- 39:18like ethnography and national identity in 1960s, French
- 39:23Cinema. Other than that, I'm working on
- 39:27a piece right now, I, which will hopefully be published soon.
- 39:33I can't yet tell you where but If you look me up in a week, you
- 39:37might see it that's on contemporary French Cinema.
- 39:41And on a film that actually has a really deep and strong sense
- 39:45of place. It's called sea level tone, but
- 39:48should the wind drop and it's by a friend, charming and director,
- 39:51and it's really brilliant. So yeah, that that is a, that is
- 39:56a 2020 film. There's no certainly, that
- 39:59should be accessible to people online, I believe, but I guess
- 40:04everyone will just have to Google your name and find your
- 40:06work but law, it's been so fascinating to talk to you.
- 40:11Thank you. And let's have you back on.
- 40:13Perhaps to talk about I'd love a very specific contemporary film
- 40:17that. I'll you know, why not.
- 40:19I'll give you the homework to watch and then comment.
- 40:22Absolutely. Thank you, Lindsay.
- 40:24This is really fun. That's the show for today.
- 40:29As always. Thank you for listening
- 40:31subscribing and sharing with Friends.
- 40:33You can find all previous episodes of The New Parish
- 40:35podcast, wherever you stream your podcasts and on world radio
- 40:39Paris. If you're enjoying these
- 40:40conversations, please consider picking up a copy of the New
- 40:43Paris book or my recent release removed by museun from your
- 40:47local book sellers. Until next time again put