Latest / The Momentum Experiment / This truth was hard to admit (why I was sabotaging my business growth)
Transcript
- 0:00As soon as I put it in writing, I couldn't unsee what I had
- 0:04just admitted. I hit reply having confessed the real
- 0:08reason I was sabotaging my own progress with a key
- 0:12area of my business, my email list. Now today
- 0:15I'm sharing what I admitted, how it changed my perspective, and also what
- 0:19I am doing about it right now. And I'll give an update on how
- 0:23everything's going. Now, if you're new here, welcome. I'm Kat, and on this
- 0:27podcast, I'm sharing behind the scenes as I try real-time
- 0:30experiments to help me follow through on what matters and find
- 0:33momentum as a speaker and writer.
- 0:37So this email that I mentioned at the start of the episode, it was
- 0:41last April and my friend Chanel Basilio, she writes
- 0:45a newsletter called Growth in Reverse. It's where she reverse
- 0:48engineers how successful entrepreneurs grow their newsletters.
- 0:52And if you are someone who creates content on the internet as part of your
- 0:56business strategy, you know how critical it is to have a
- 1:00direct line of communication when at any moment
- 1:04platforms like YouTube, Meta, LinkedIn, they can suspend
- 1:07your account even if you did absolutely nothing wrong. You can just
- 1:11wake up and poof, it's gone. But more than that, when you
- 1:15get the right match of people who are joining your newsletter, who
- 1:19could also benefit from what you offer, that's a key part
- 1:23of how you run a business and earn an income. So
- 1:26even though I know deep down I would actually
- 1:30do this kind of work for free, if I won the lottery, I'd still be
- 1:34helping people in some way, but I have to earn a living
- 1:37because I didn't win the lottery. So back to
- 1:41this email. Now Chanel was starting a 30-day email
- 1:45series with real examples of tactics. And
- 1:49strategies for growth. And I had signed up because
- 1:53I knew that I needed to work on this.
- 1:57And I was, oh, okay. Hold on. I
- 2:01got a little bit lost here. Um, I signed up
- 2:05for this because I knew that this is something I needed to work on.
- 2:09And this was, this series was all on real tactics and strategies
- 2:13for growth. I knew that I had been ignoring this for a
- 2:17while. Now in the email
- 2:20confirmation, she asked everyone to reply with their
- 2:24biggest challenge right now when it comes to newsletter growth.
- 2:29And so this is my actual reply, by the
- 2:32way. So I said, your question about
- 2:36the biggest challenge has me thinking of a core issue I have.
- 2:40and have had for a long time. I don't
- 2:44advertise or actively grow my newsletter because I'm not
- 2:47proud of it... yet. I am
- 2:51100% self-sabotaging my growth because I
- 2:55don't want people to find out I'm a disappointment.
- 2:58So that's a fun admission to make. Melting face emoji.
- 3:04Okay, let me repeat. The core fear?
- 3:08I don't want people to find out I'm a disappointment.
- 3:13Even if a little part of that belief is
- 3:16true, then it actually makes perfect sense why
- 3:20I'm not actively promoting my newsletter. So
- 3:24instead, I just played it safe and I stuck with the
- 3:28lovely humans who had already joined my list within the past 6
- 3:31years. since starting it, which brings me to now,
- 3:36because one week after sharing my public tracker
- 3:39for my goal to reach a million people through speaking and writing,
- 3:43being confronted with the fact my email list has been a
- 3:46similar size for about 4 years, 4 years,
- 3:51that was a big deal. It was kind of a tough pill to swallow. Now,
- 3:56to be fair, when I shifted the focus of my business from more
- 4:00virtual presenting content to talking about momentum and follow-through, I
- 4:04did experience a drop-off. I invited people to, you know, you are
- 4:07welcome to exit, no hard feelings, and I meant it. And so there
- 4:11were people who dropped off. They didn't want to stick around, and that's okay. So,
- 4:15and there have been new subscribers since then. So there has been a change
- 4:18in the numbers, but overall it stayed about the same. Also,
- 4:22if you are one of the new subscribers who joined in the past sort of
- 4:25year and a half, hi, I'm really glad that you're here right now.
- 4:29Today though, I'm not actually talking about the number I'm talking
- 4:33about what the number represents,
- 4:37because when I see it, to me it represents
- 4:41years of holding myself back. I mean
- 4:45actual years. There is no way
- 4:49to know for sure, but I am confident
- 4:53that the cost of my inaction has been a
- 4:57meaningful amount. And this, like
- 5:00what I am describing right now is what happens when
- 5:04your dreaded identity is stronger than your desired
- 5:08identity. To put it another way, it's what happens when
- 5:12your why not is stronger than your why.
- 5:16And it's one of the reasons that I talk about what I talk about,
- 5:20because there are some just genuine things that can hold us back from
- 5:24following through on things that matter, even if we have a strong
- 5:27desire. To get on the other side, this can
- 5:31happen to us. And I share this today
- 5:35because I, one, I'm trying to be very public with what
- 5:38I'm doing. And when I showed those numbers, I felt
- 5:42like I needed to confront it. But I also wanted to share a little bit
- 5:46about that because for me, I'm not actually embarrassed by the number. If I
- 5:50picture a room of over 3,000 people, That's
- 5:54a pretty big room of people to be talking to. So
- 5:58it's not the number, it's the fact that that number has just kind of stayed
- 6:01in a certain area for a while. And I just wanna touch on this
- 6:05idea of dreaded identity. So when I say dreaded identity,
- 6:09I am actually talking about this version of ourselves that
- 6:13we don't want others to see or think of us, or even for ourselves, we
- 6:16don't want to see ourselves that way. Yeah. And
- 6:20it's not that I don't want to disappoint people, it's that I don't wanna be
- 6:24a disappointment. Like, I don't wanna be the reason that
- 6:27somebody says, oh, that was a waste of my time, or why did I even
- 6:31bother? This person is not worth it. That is this
- 6:35dreaded identity. And imagining that that might happen is something
- 6:38that holds me back from putting myself out there. Now, I
- 6:42have actually been doing some active work, so I wanted to share So
- 6:46what that means now. So over the past couple of months, I have been
- 6:50taking advantage of coworking sessions. So I'm in Chanel's community
- 6:54and every Monday there is a coworking call. Um, if you know me at all,
- 6:58you know, I love a coworking call and I have that time dedicated
- 7:02on my calendar for at least 1 hour a week I will spend
- 7:06on my newsletter. Now it's not to date, it hasn't been a
- 7:09ton of like growth stuff and trying to get in front of more people, but
- 7:12I have been making changes so I can feel more confident in
- 7:16what I'm sending out. And some of those changes have been to the structure
- 7:20and deciding to have it formatted a little bit more like an intro, an
- 7:24article, maybe my, my podcast or what I'm reading, et cetera. So
- 7:28I, I've switched up the actual format. So that's new. I've
- 7:32also switched up the look of it a little bit. Nothing crazy. Just
- 7:36added some dividers and some color and some headings. And, and actually I
- 7:40like it. And so it makes me happier, but it just, I think it has
- 7:43a nice polish to it. But more than that, one of the other things I
- 7:47did recently is as I was working on
- 7:51my newsletter on those Mondays, I recognized the importance of
- 7:55social proof. And I'm, I am going to talk about social proof and testimonials
- 7:59because that is an area that I am also experimenting with. But
- 8:03I decided that I wanted to ask people
- 8:07that I could trust if they would be willing to share testimonials with me.
- 8:11So I used Kit, uh, so Kit is my email service
- 8:15provider and they have an MCP so that I could
- 8:19say, basically say, can you tag everyone who opens almost
- 8:23all of my emails? If somebody is opening almost every single one of my emails,
- 8:27tag them with the highest engaged subscriber. And I
- 8:31sent an email to those highest engaged subscribers and just said,
- 8:35hey, I don't love asking for help, but I, uh, would you please send me
- 8:38a testimonial for this newsletter? This is what it looks like and
- 8:42showed a couple of screenshots of what it looks like. I didn't send this to
- 8:45everyone on my list because one of the things you want to do when you're
- 8:48trying to push back against a belief. So if I'm trying to challenge this belief
- 8:51that my newsletter is a big old disappointment and I'm a disappointment,
- 8:55well, then I don't want to just ask everybody for feedback. I just
- 8:59want the people who regularly open all my emails and just say to them,
- 9:04I feel uncomfortable asking, but could you just ask me? Because that's just the honest
- 9:07truth. I don't love asking for help. I'm working on it though.
- 9:11And when I started to get the replies, when I started to have people actually
- 9:15give testimonials about the newsletter and what it means to
- 9:19them, that started to shift for me. I started to really
- 9:22change my belief about what I am sending and the
- 9:26value of my email. And so taking that risk and
- 9:30asking people that I felt confident weren't gonna be mean to me
- 9:34was a really, really helpful change and exercise
- 9:38and experiment for me. And I have noticed a shift and I
- 9:42do feel better about my content. And I've even had a close friend of mine
- 9:45who's on my email list say, I can, I sense the shift just
- 9:49even in your writing and how you show up in my inbox. Now, of course,
- 9:52she's a close friend, so she can also see that in other ways, but
- 9:56just getting that feedback has really, really been meaningful to me. And
- 10:00it's starting to challenge this fear that I've had that's been looming over me.
- 10:04So that's been a really, really important thing for me. The other thing
- 10:08is that I have started to look towards the other direction, which is,
- 10:12okay, now that I'm feeling a little more confident, a little bit more proud of
- 10:15what I am putting out there, then I, now how do I
- 10:19actually get in front of people who could benefit from the work I
- 10:22do and what I share? And so doing that, I am looking at, or I
- 10:26have started actually developing a quiz, and the quiz is
- 10:30to help people to figure out Okay, why am I stuck? So I talk a
- 10:33lot about identifying which, what's the real reason? Is it logical,
- 10:37biological, or psychological? And I want a quiz
- 10:41so that I can help people figure out which one. So I've started to craft
- 10:44it. As I started to test my initial quiz, it's 15 questions.
- 10:48I realized got a couple of things that are snagging and need to be
- 10:51edited a little bit. However, the way that I
- 10:55have shifted this is, uh, or not the way that I've shifted it, but
- 10:59Now I know it's on the way and it is something I'm working on. And
- 11:02by telling you and sharing on the podcast that I'm working on a quiz,
- 11:06then it's something I'm more likely to follow through on and make sure it happens.
- 11:10I don't want to rush it because I want it to be good, but I
- 11:12also want to have a version 1 that is out this month. So this is,
- 11:16as I record this, this is August 2026. And so to have
- 11:20at least a version 1 that is out this month, and
- 11:24maybe I'll even ask for some testers, maybe a small group of people who are
- 11:28willing to test the V1, maybe the alpha,
- 11:31and then I can put this out a little bit more widely. Because if I
- 11:35can have a good tool like that, when I do talk about the different ways
- 11:38we get stuck, and if someone's just not quite clear or they want some more
- 11:42insight, then I can direct them towards the quiz. And then they're also
- 11:46likely a person who could benefit from, okay, well, now what? And
- 11:49that's what I talk about in my newsletter. So
- 11:53that's what I wanted to share today is really this, this newsletter
- 11:58I'd say issue of mine, not newsletter issue, like the one
- 12:01that's coming out, but the issue I have had with really, really holding
- 12:05myself back. And for a moment I thought maybe I'll actually
- 12:09try to calculate the cost of my inaction, but
- 12:12it's really hard because I cannot A/B test that. I can't say
- 12:16here's what it would be one way and here's what it would be the other.
- 12:20But based on people that are in my
- 12:24you know, in my circles, in my networks, and, and who, who do similar
- 12:27work, or even if it's a different topic, I know that I could run a
- 12:30similar business. I know I've been leaving a lot on the
- 12:34table, and it's something that is worth overcoming
- 12:38and worth addressing. And I would just say for you, if you're listening to this
- 12:42and there is something in your life where you feel like there is a real
- 12:44cost to your inaction, it is worth doing the exercise of
- 12:48asking, what are you afraid of if you do follow through? Are there any
- 12:52worries that come up for you? And for me, it was this idea of picturing
- 12:56a person subscribing, opening the email or
- 12:59emails, and just feeling like, nah, this is not worth my time.
- 13:03This is not valuable. And here's the thing that could still happen
- 13:08because not everyone is going to be a fit. And I know
- 13:11that. And I think really what I had
- 13:15to work on is being proud of my own work and
- 13:19feeling good about it, having clarity of what I'm actually saying. Mm-hmm.
- 13:23And that way I can separate the fact that someone might be
- 13:26disappointed, but it doesn't necessarily mean I'm a disappointment.
- 13:30And the way I work on that is through my confidence and how I see
- 13:33my writing and what I'm actually putting into it and working
- 13:37at getting a little bit better every single week. And those are some of the
- 13:40ways that I am doing this. And, uh, I'll check back in and I'll
- 13:44report back on the, how the quiz is building
- 13:47up. And then I guess also, what am I doing to get out in front
- 13:50of other people? Because That's another really big part of this. I know
- 13:54this sounds like Business 101. Anyone who's starting
- 13:58a business that has an online component where you are trying to get in
- 14:02front of new audiences knows the importance of an email list.
- 14:06And, but I also have a suspicion that I'm not alone with other people
- 14:09who are playing it small and holding themselves back when it comes to actually
- 14:14growing the list and getting in front of more people. And that's been my experience.
- 14:17Now. I wanna do a little tracker update. I
- 14:21don't actually have it in front of me at the moment, but I did. I,
- 14:25I know it because it's only been a few days. It is currently August
- 14:295th as of me recording this. And when it
- 14:32comes to posts, it's, uh, it's only been one.
- 14:36I've only posted one in the first 5 days of this month and my target
- 14:39is 20. So I have 19 more to go.
- 14:43And the exercise of just actually entering the
- 14:46tracker and saying one. Yeah. was enough to make me say, okay, you gotta,
- 14:50this, you have to start to deliver. So I need to pick up the
- 14:54pace on that. However, appearances, I was also able
- 14:58to add a 1 because yesterday a podcast that I was a
- 15:02guest on with Jay Clouse is the Creator Science Podcast that just
- 15:05was released this week. And I already have some
- 15:09DMs from people who listened to that episode. And so I was able to
- 15:13check off that I have 1 appearance there, uh, which is just
- 15:17really exciting. And then for the newsletter, I actually. Have to, I'm going to
- 15:21report on that next week because I realized as I was prepping for this,
- 15:25that when I created the tracker and I put in the number for
- 15:29till the end of July, it actually wasn't the end of the month yet. So
- 15:31I need to update what the true number was towards the end of July,
- 15:35and then I can update it week to week and it will be accurate of
- 15:38how many new people have joined since then. And that's
- 15:42also something that's directly related to today. So I think.
- 15:46I, this is my hypothesis that if I'm reporting each week, it's
- 15:50going to help light a fire to make sure that I stay on top of
- 15:53that. Those are my, those are my experiments. Those are
- 15:57my updates. And I'm excited to keep on
- 16:01show, just sharing the real numbers and talking about this in public because woo,
- 16:05it definitely, yeah,
- 16:09it's, it's something I'm feeling it, but. Hopefully some
- 16:12of this has landed with you, and maybe if there's anything that you've pulled today
- 16:16from the conversation, you can use it to help find you or find
- 16:20your follow-through and your momentum with something that matters.