Latest / Old School, New School, Next School with Dom Giordano / Post-Election School Choice, Jared Polis and The Great Gatsby | Episode 75
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to Old School, New School, Next School with Dom Giordano, a podcast devoted to shedding
- 0:10light on issues pertaining to making America smart again. These include, among many topics,
- 0:17school choice and parental rights. This podcast is dedicated to reversing the deeply disturbing
- 0:24trend known as the dumbing down of America. Now, here's your host, educator, and noted
- 0:30talk media commentator, Dom Giordano. Hey, everyone, Dom Giordano with you post-election.
- 0:38Welcome in to Old School, New School, Next School. And with the big election, the tsunami for Democrats
- 0:45coming into office, it's a good time to see, does that swerve into what we do here, our mission,
- 0:53which is to stop American kids from getting dumber by the day? And the vehicles to do that are school
- 0:59choice for parents and kids, as you know, and also just anything we can to enable parental rights
- 1:08and to coach parents up to better educate their kids at home. All right, so with all that being said,
- 1:14what's my verdict on this election? And my verdict is America got dumber in the last couple of days.
- 1:21I say that not just because of the ideology part of this, but the idiocracy being ruled by idiocy
- 1:32continues. By that, I mean many of the people elected, some of them are Democrat Socialist Party
- 1:38on the Democrat side, but it's an extreme number of Democrats like where I am in Pennsylvania.
- 1:45They are anti-school choice. And deep down, many of them enunciate the idea we ought to rely on experts
- 1:54rather than the parents to be making a lot of educational decisions. In fact, it's not too long
- 2:01ago that Glenn Youngkin, who I think will run for national office, remember him? He's a big school
- 2:06choice guy, and he's the president of a group around that, former governor of Virginia. How did he win?
- 2:13What is it that turned? Because Virginia was tending to go blue, to go Democrat way. Well,
- 2:19Terry McAuliffe was a governor running for another term, and he got into it around parental rights,
- 2:27about things being talked in schools, and he went down the road of saying, hey, we ought to rely on
- 2:34the education experts, not the parents. Well, Youngkin used that very effectively, made the point that the
- 2:41parents are the kids' first and best teacher and always will be, no matter what, no matter how skilled,
- 2:47not taking anything away from teachers or anything else, they are the ones that ultimately will have
- 2:52the best interest of the child at heart. Even parents are only so-so. That's true, is it not?
- 2:58Does everybody not agree with that? So in this election, like where I am in Pennsylvania,
- 3:05Governor Josh Shapiro still has not signed off on school choice, the big, beautiful bill,
- 3:09that money coming in January, just right around the corner. Why? Well, he's a creature of the
- 3:15teachers' unions. The teachers' unions are some of his biggest benefactors. When he runs for president,
- 3:21which he will do, they will be extremely in his corner, as they will be Governor Pritzker
- 3:28in Illinois, another guy who I believe is a creature of the worst teachers' union in America.
- 3:34You can take your pick, but the Chicago teachers, to me, are the most thuggish and the worst in the
- 3:40country. And the Chicago schools illustrate that. So what did we lose in this? Well, what we lose is
- 3:47when you have more people in there that are creatures of the teachers' unions, one way or
- 3:54the other. They're not going to be for school choice. And in many instances, they're not going
- 4:00to be for school reform. Now, let's go back to what we've talked about in the one year of doing
- 4:07this podcast. And you might be a new listener. We're getting a lot more of them on YouTube and
- 4:12alike. Thank you for that. Spread the word. Well, one of the credos we use is the Mississippi miracle.
- 4:19The Mississippi miracle means that students in Mississippi, which were usually among the worst,
- 4:27if not the worst, they were ranked number 49 in all kinds of things that comes to education,
- 4:32are now among the best in the country. In fact, minority students at the fourth grade level do
- 4:39much better in Mississippi than California, where California outspends them by three or four times
- 4:44the amount of money spent on education. So what are the core things of the Mississippi miracle?
- 4:51It's bipartisan. Both parties buy into it. The teachers' unions are limited in this and what they're
- 4:57going to do to block it. If a child is still having trouble reading by the end of third grade,
- 5:03which is critical, they don't pass. They have to repeat. They coach up kids and they use the science
- 5:10of reading. We've talked about this, but think essentially phonics. What's so hard? In other
- 5:17words, post this election, we know what to do. I'll say that again. We know what to do to educate
- 5:27kids. So why don't we do it? Well, one of the biggest roadblocks are the teachers' unions. They don't want to do
- 5:34these things in various ways, shapes, or forms. They don't want to give up that power. They don't agree with
- 5:40phonics. They don't agree with the Mississippi miracle. They keep on trying to tell us it's fraudulent.
- 5:45Former Secretary of Education under President Biden, right before the election, went off on that.
- 5:52That this stuff is kind of made up. How do we know what they're doing in Mississippi really is a miracle?
- 5:56You see what's happening here. We actually know. It's not like we're walking around looking for a
- 6:02plutonium. We know what to do. Just take it and do it in your own state, in your own way. Each state
- 6:09could be a little bit different. Call it different things. Call it the Pennsylvania miracle. Call it
- 6:14whatever you want. Do it. So each time we have an election where more people are not on board with
- 6:21that, I say we get less free, parental rights, and we get dumber. And America can ill afford to get
- 6:30dumb. I have a whole array of things this week. We have a person who was a big education advocate,
- 6:37New York Post. For 13 years, Adriana Aviles, a fierce education advocate in former New York City
- 6:44schools, powerful teacher on the citywide council on high school, best in the city. She knew the
- 6:50principals and the teachers and trusted that her child getting good grades, especially in math,
- 6:56through his K to eight years. The son, they helped him review for the second math exam at the end of
- 7:02that time. What happened next devastated and prompted her to publicly confront the school chancellor about
- 7:09her parents' experience. In other words, she's saying she was lied to in the New York City public
- 7:15schools. Where did we hear that before? Remember Nikole Hannah-Jones, the famous person in the 1619
- 7:20project. That's where we heard it before. This woman is less ideological and is saying they conned her.
- 7:28They not only gave the grades, but they gave the lip service to this, and they were able to convince
- 7:33her which parent wouldn't be tremendously pleased that their student was a straight-A math student.
- 7:40Not the case, not nearly the case. How many of these things have to go on before there's a revolt
- 7:48of parents? And that revolt is happening across the country. Now, one of the things that is a remedy to
- 7:56it is school choice. We're just a couple months away from January where the school choice money will
- 8:02start to flow across the country. And here is Jared Polis, who's a Democrat, some would say a
- 8:08progressive. I think he's going to run for president. He's a smart guy. He is the governor still of Colorado.
- 8:16Here's what he said recently in a nutshell about accepting that school choice money. Now,
- 8:23I'm saying this because we still have about 19 states, many of them headed by Democrats,
- 8:29who have refused to accept or refuse to answer yet whether they'll take the money,
- 8:36you know, where you get a $1,700 tax break, couples $3,400 through the big, beautiful bill,
- 8:42and then this money goes to nonprofits in the state of your choice. And then they can free up parents to
- 8:49make a school choice. This is not taking money away from the public schools. In fact, the public schools
- 8:55will get more. Who could be against it? Well, any number of these governors are against it. As I said,
- 9:03this is a smart guy. I would say Colorado is a deep purple state, maybe even a blue state,
- 9:10pretty much reliably. He's been elected twice, I believe. Here's what Governor Jared Polis said
- 9:17about accepting that money. Well, from the state's perspective, it's free money. Now,
- 9:22obviously, it costs the federal government money. It contributes to our deficit. I'm also
- 9:26a bit of a fiscal hawk and concerned about that. In fact, if everybody takes advantage of it,
- 9:30it could cost the federal government $200 billion. Now, that's not likely. It's more likely to be
- 9:35probably in the $40 to $50 billion range. Nevertheless, it obviously is deficit spending
- 9:40that, you know, worsens our fiscal situation. But from the state perspective, it's free money
- 9:45for kids. You know, it encourages charitable contributions. Colorado actually has two
- 9:50laws in the books in our state law that provide tax credits for charitable donations. One is for
- 9:55early childhood donations. That started before I was governor. I signed a bill to continue that.
- 10:01Our second, which we started in my time, is donations and homelessness. Now, those are 50%
- 10:05tax credits, not 100% tax credits like this one. The federal one is far more generous. But it'll
- 10:10encourage a lot of charitable giving. So kids have more opportunities. And I appreciate that it goes
- 10:16all the way up to, you know, income levels of, you know, $200,000, depending on where you are.
- 10:21Because, you know, families think, oh, you know, somebody might be making a combined family income
- 10:25$140,000. They might seem rich. I know a lot of families making that much. They can't afford,
- 10:29you know, the summer enrichment or the tutors that their kid needs or the afterschool activities,
- 10:33because their mortgage and their car payments and everything else is taking up most of the money.
- 10:37So this will help people of low, middle, upper middle income levels, help kids achieve,
- 10:42give them the same kind of opportunities that people who have a lot of money have for their kids.
- 10:46Some of your Democratic colleagues have indicated that they might be interested in this,
- 10:51particularly in New York. Governor Hochul has said she will sign on to the tax credit,
- 10:54but we don't have a timeline. In Pennsylvania, Governor Shapiro says that he is thinking about
- 11:00signing on to this. But many of your Democratic colleagues have kept their head down on this
- 11:05issue. So what is your message to the Democratic governors who are hesitant to sign on to this?
- 11:10Well, it's really, well, first of all, I have one message is an American, one is a Coloradan.
- 11:14As a Coloradan, we actually don't want them to sign on. Because if, for instance, California didn't sign
- 11:18on, I can go after all those California residents and say, you can get the $1,700 back, give to Colorado
- 11:24kids, even though they'd rather give to California kids. But as an American, of course, we care about
- 11:28all kids. And of course, those resources can be helpful in any state. I want to make sure people
- 11:34understand whether whatever governor opts in to receive the charitable contributions in their state
- 11:38or not, taxpayers in their state can still get this tax credit. They just will have to donate to help
- 11:42kids in other states. And that's what I kind of the point that if there are states that don't opt in,
- 11:48absolutely, we'll be talking to residents of those states to try to get those donations to Colorado
- 11:53charities. We'd love to have them. We welcome that. And I think, you know, if a governor is really
- 11:58looking out for how can we produce more resources? Look, I mean, it's a big, it's a lot of money.
- 12:03You know, if it comes in at $50 billion, you know, Colorado is about 2%. That could be about a
- 12:08billion dollar influx in Colorado for scholarships and for summer programs and for after school
- 12:14activities and enrichment and for tutoring. I mean, that level of resources is a real game changer.
- 12:20And if other states opt out, you know, Colorado kids will get even more.
- 12:23Why do you think your party has been so resistant to school choice movements in recent years? And do
- 12:29you think that tide might turn? First of all, I think some of the resistance on this one is just sort
- 12:33of what it's caught up in. Obviously, if I had been in Congress, I would have voted against H.R. 1.
- 12:38It slashed health care spending. You know, it was a it was a terrible bill. We're dealing with this
- 12:43at the state level now, made it harder to qualify for many of our social safety net programs, added a
- 12:48lot of administrative overhead and bureaucracy to these processes. So there's a natural reaction
- 12:53against that. It doesn't mean that there weren't good things in it. Certainly some of the pro-growth
- 12:57tax cuts and certainly encouraging charitable contributions to help kids was a plus. You know, Democrats were really at the table in creating
- 13:08the charter school movement. It was created under in Colorado under my predecessor, Governor Roy Romer.
- 13:13Obviously, Bill Clinton, Barack Obama, huge supporters of public charter schools.
- 13:18And, you know, again, part of what Colorado offers and it's not just charter schools, it's district schools.
- 13:22It's we have something where we have kind of an innovation school where they get additional freedom beyond kind of normal district schools, but it's still under the district.
- 13:32It's just about choices for parents and, you know, looking at, you know, being able to choose a dual language school where your kid learns Mandarin in English.
- 13:41We have a, you know, a public one in Denver. We have French in English, German in English, Russian in English, and of course, many Spanish ones where kids are fully fluent in Spanish by sixth grade.
- 13:50We have expeditionary learning schools. We have STEM focused schools. You know, as a father of two kids, I know how different kids are, can be.
- 13:56And it's really incredible to get that buy-in from parents and kids into the education they're getting.
- 14:02And I think we do well on that counting in the state of Colorado.
- 14:07All right. That's Governor Jared Polis. That's not some right wing ideologue.
- 14:12That's somebody that gets it, that this is what has to be done. It will be revolutionary across America.
- 14:21So, again, in this election, there were a lot of issues, you know, the war with Iran, affordability, all those things.
- 14:28Let's talk about affordability. Think about how many parents cannot afford, maybe they're relatively close, but they just can't do it, the ability to go to the school of their choice.
- 14:42It could be a private school. It could be moderate private school costs. It could be a religious school, Catholic school. It could be a charter school.
- 14:51They are just blocked from it.
- 14:53When we talk about the affordability crisis, that was the issue in this election.
- 14:56How about affordability to put your kid, when all is said and done, in the best choice for that child based upon all the information and knowledge of your students?
- 15:09So that's why I said before the election, never vote for anyone who is not in favor of school choice.
- 15:15It's a tell. It tells you that you probably don't want to vote for them for other reasons.
- 15:22In other words, this is a layup. What's the fear?
- 15:26Well, the fear is the teachers unions, the public schools, even if they're not functioning, there seems to be something that goes off in the minds of people to say, you got to be with this.
- 15:37You can't be for school choice. It's just a bunch of radicals that are saying that.
- 15:41Really? How about Governor Jared Polis, who's a progressive, but a smart guy and the governor of a state that gets it.
- 15:49And it's well underway in Colorado. Now, to illustrate how desperate this crisis is, I look each week here on Old School, New School, Next School.
- 15:58I look toward taking a look through Twitter and other places, other social media, to see if teachers are speaking out and blowing the whistle on what it's like to teach in America's public schools or private schools.
- 16:16This is a teacher with junior and seniors, I believe, and they are reading The Great Gatsby.
- 16:25Not my favorite book when I taught, but OK, The Great Gatsby.
- 16:30I'm going to play for you the teacher talking about the commentary students had on this.
- 16:36This is not made up. This is an actual teacher saying, what the heck am I going to do here?
- 16:40Now, one of the problems is fewer and fewer public schools, but schools in general, are not requiring that students read a full book.
- 16:50Maybe through the whole four years of high school, they don't read a full book.
- 16:54The Great Gatsby necessarily wouldn't be my choice. I'm not going to get into all that.
- 16:59But listen to this teacher explain the rationale, the thinking of these students.
- 17:05This is not made up. And you tell me if we don't have a dumbness problem, if we don't have a dumbing down.
- 17:12And what's the next effect? Well, you know, America is still going forward.
- 17:16Is it? People talk all the time about how are elections in Alaska, for example, in this election cycle, we had two people put on the ballot named Dan Sullivan.
- 17:27One was the sitting senator. The other was somebody put up by a political party to try to siphon votes off.
- 17:34But in some of the polling places, they put incumbent, meaning Dan Sullivan was the incumbent, the sitting senator.
- 17:43And there was a great debate about whether people in Alaska would be able to know the word incumbent.
- 17:53And I got to tell you, jury's out with me because he got the person who was a phony, fraudulent Dan Sullivan, made up, just put on there to try to siphon all votes.
- 18:02He got at least 3,500 votes and still counting. And that race is neck and neck.
- 18:08The leader, the Democrat who is leading Peltola, has about a 600 vote lead.
- 18:13But Decoy Dan, the other person put on the ballot to siphon all votes, has about a 3,500 votes for him.
- 18:23See what I'm getting at here. Now, some people have come out of polling places and when told about this, they went, wow, wait a minute, which Dan Sullivan did I vote for?
- 18:32Well, didn't you see incumbent? And they go, yeah, but I was kind of fuzzy on that, et cetera.
- 18:37So I think this is a great example. You ask yourself and you can let me know, you can always email me, domshow at AOL.com.
- 18:46You think most people around you, wherever you are in America, around the world, but they know the word incumbent.
- 18:51If you said, hey, he's the incumbent, I don't know. I think in America, I would take the bet if we had Kalshi or whatever, I would take the bet that I said the over and under, maybe about 40%.
- 19:05No, I don't know if I'd go 50% that could give you an adequate definition of incumbent.
- 19:10So without further ado, here's this teacher trying to stay in the profession, trying to deal with these responses to the Great Gatsby.
- 19:20Here's what she said.
- 19:22I teach high school English and we just got done reading the Great Gatsby in class.
- 19:27And these are some of the things my students said while we read it.
- 19:32Why did the dude write like this?
- 19:36Bro is doing too much.
- 19:38It's like old English or something.
- 19:44Tom's tough, but Gatsby's tougher.
- 19:52Daisy is a bop low key.
- 19:55Like, am I wrong?
- 19:57Exactly.
- 19:58No, I'm not.
- 20:02There's no way people used to talk like this.
- 20:08The writing is performative AF.
- 20:11And I said, yes, they did because it's modern English, not old English.
- 20:16And they said, so what?
- 20:19Did we all just get dumber or something?
- 20:24There was a line where Nick is describing how hot the day is and how they're all sweating and really uncomfortable.
- 20:31And he says that his underwear is snaking up his leg.
- 20:35And a student said, yo, miss, why is he telling us about his snake?
- 20:42When we watched the movie, I asked them, were the characters what you thought they would be like?
- 20:52And a reply was, I mean, not really.
- 20:57Like, bruh, I thought Daisy'd be like hot.
- 21:03And finally, I asked them, can anyone remind us what big event happened in Chapter 8?
- 21:10And someone replied, yeah, that dude came over and Gatsby got slimed out.
- 21:17Thank you.
- 21:18All right.
- 21:18That should be pretty stunning stuff up and down.
- 21:23I'll tell you this, that that teacher at the high school level, probably next week, I'll just give you a little thumbnail on this.
- 21:33It's come out now, big study, that the SATs, you know, the test to get into college, and most of us knew our SAT score at some point.
- 21:41I remember mine, very good in English, not so, well, decent in math.
- 21:46I, you know, got over the line, are much easier than even when people took it 10 or 15 years ago, let alone 25 years ago.
- 21:56I'll give you details on that next week.
- 21:58It's all part of a fraudulent syndrome.
- 22:01You know, the syndrome we saw, shrinkflation during the crisis around affordability and all, where they put fewer potato chips in a bag and still charge the same price.
- 22:11And they try to make the bag funny so you can't see how many chips are in there, that kind of thing.
- 22:16Put one or two fewer chips in there.
- 22:19Yeah.
- 22:20That type of stuff.
- 22:21Well, this is the fraud that's going on.
- 22:24So we make everything easier.
- 22:26We continue to dumb it down.
- 22:28It's not getting easier as much as it's getting dumber.
- 22:31People know less and less.
- 22:33Well, because less and less is required.
- 22:36That's what the bottom line is.
- 22:38So am I astonished that people don't know the word incumbent?
- 22:41It made national news for days because it was a real life.
- 22:44No, I'm not astonished by that.
- 22:47I think anywhere that you go, you're going to see a great number of people.
- 22:50Try it out yourself and let me know.
- 22:52Incumbent.
- 22:53You got three seconds here.
- 22:55All right.
- 22:56So we'll get into that next week.
- 22:58But the bottom line on this election cycle, what happened here is I believe America got
- 23:05dumber.
- 23:06And the remedy with Dr.
- 23:08Dom here is I know what to do.
- 23:10Let's do what they're doing in Mississippi.
- 23:13Now, while all that's going on in your state and that's going to take a lot of fights, Mississippi
- 23:20got it through.
- 23:22Sometime we're going to have to go back and see.
- 23:24I'm not exactly sure.
- 23:26They were so desperate, tired of being 50 and everything, the national joke that they
- 23:31actually did it.
- 23:33But until we do that, we need parental choice.
- 23:36In other words, until we do as a mechanized program across the country, state by state,
- 23:41the Mississippi miracle, we know what to do.
- 23:44You got to fend for your own kid.
- 23:45And the only way to do that is through school choice, is through educating yourself as a
- 23:53parent to what actually is going on in the school you are until you get school choice,
- 23:58like this woman in New York.
- 23:59And then the tips that I'll give you each week over the years that help a parent to both assess
- 24:06and then remedy what may be happening with their child.
- 24:10That's our mission here.
- 24:13It's pretty post-election to say, harsh to say, but America did get dumber.
- 24:19And now we're going to have to fight more battles on this.
- 24:21But the revolution is coming.
- 24:24In January, you're going to hear a lot, and we will be on top of this big time,
- 24:28about the money that's going to be out there for school choice.
- 24:32Think of Governor Polis in Colorado.
- 24:35And think, it's not made up of that teacher this week with the Great Gatsby.
- 24:39Can you dismiss it and say, well, when I was in school, we might have said something that dumb.
- 24:43Really?
- 24:44I think it gets dumber every day.
- 24:46And these are apparently kids that are college track,
- 24:49not necessarily kids that are just in some holding pattern here.
- 24:53All right, send me an email.
- 24:55Whatever you're seeing out there, particularly if you differ, let me know.
- 24:59We'll use them here on the podcast each week.
- 25:03It goes to domshow at AOL.com.
- 25:06America did get a bit dumber, in my estimation, in this election cycle,
- 25:12because the people elected are not about education reform.
- 25:15But guess what?
- 25:17Freedom is on the horizon.
- 25:19We're about two months out, give or take, to where this all starts to churn.
- 25:26And what's going to be happening, and Governor Polis just said it,
- 25:29when the state next door is open for school choice, and your state is not,
- 25:36the money's going to flow there, and people are going to go nuts.
- 25:39And we're talking hundreds of millions of dollars, if not a billion dollars or more.
- 25:43Even Governor Hochul, in a relatively tough race in New York,
- 25:48signed off on school choice.
- 25:50Signed off on the big, beautiful bill.
- 25:52Enjoy.
- 25:54Let people know about this.
- 25:55We're thrilled that you're with us.
- 25:57Dom Giordano on Old School, New School, Next School.
- 26:01Old School, New School, Next School with Dom Giordano
- 26:04is a presentation of Giordano Productions, LLC.
- 26:08Copyright 2026.
- 26:10All rights reserved.