Latest / Falcon Forward / How Private Equity Is Reshaping Commercial Insurance Brokers
Transcript
- Peter Brecht: All right, welcome to Falcon Forward. my name is Peter Brecht. I'm here with Mike Tangy. Mike, how is your Thursday morning going? Mike Tanghe: Thursday is great. having a good week and just having a good day. Thank you for asking. And yours? Peter Brecht: Yeah, yeah, awesome. it's going okay. we're still up in Lake Tahoe. we saw a brown berry yesterday. The kids were very excited and over the moon about that and just keeping things Mike Tanghe: that's cool. Peter Brecht: going. So they're out. I don't know what they're doing today, actually. I have no idea. they just know that dad's at home are here doing things and they're out doing other fun things. So it's good. Yeah. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, excellent. Excellent. Peter Brecht: great. Well, today's topic. So this is one that when we were talking about it in the pre-show, the pre-game here, we I was I was just kind of caught off guard by by in terms of how timely it was. And so there's there's a lot of conversation right now in kind of the private equity space and raising capital and all these different macro factors going on. And so wanted to kind of translate that into insurance terms and you know here you are with with that very concept. And so very excited to kind of jump into it today. So I'm gonna turn it over to you. My voice is kind of gone so I'm gonna let you do most of the talking on this episode. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, no problem. All right. Well, thanks, Peter. So what we wanted to address today is our industry has seen just massive entry from the private equity players over the past call it fifteen or so years. and in the past insurance was this, you know, industry that the private equity it really adorned. You know, they wanted to go after more manufacturing type. and insurance is just kind of one of those things, and maybe it's just that generally people either didn't understand it well or didn't didn't like it on it. But whatever reason the private equity people ignored insurance for a long time. A couple things had happened that made them take look at it is one was with in two thousand eight, the Great Recession, that impacted a lot of industries, commercial real estate, I mean housing, just It was very, very bad for a lot of industries that had done very, very good for a long period of time and that had a bunch of money dumped into them in the private equity side. how did insurance come through that? Pretty good. and so people started to take notice of that and see, wow, like insurance brokers in in actually did pretty well. people kept renewing their policies. Yeah, maybe exposures were down, but generally strong retention, predictable revenue, that came out pretty good. And you had something like COVID, that again impacted a lot of industries, restaurant, entertainment, airlines. I mean, you just go through a lot of these things were you know absolutely crushed because their business stopped. How did insurance do through COVID? again, in the I don't want to make light that these were terrible events for a lot of different people, but if you want to just specifically look how did insurance fare with the Great Recession with COVID, came out even better out of COVID as technology acceler accelerated a lot of change. and customers kept having to buy insurance and people kept renewing their policies. That predictable revenue stream kept coming. and then again, I would say COVID, and that'd be another podcast to do, it'd be interesting topic, is how did COVID accelerate the adoption of technology and insurance? I think you know, maybe by 10 years or so, things that would we would have been doing as far as Zoom meetings, as far as the use of of more distributed models, meaning that you don't necessarily have to have people in a central office paying expensive rent and commuting and all those types of things. that again, COVID was a massive technology accelerator for the insurance industry. so you have all those things happen and then you see that as banks get try get more and more creative about where they can deploy money, these private equity folks said, wow, we could actually buy agencies. We could lever them up, which is the private equity model, meaning borrow, have the company borrow on that. And then guess what? We have this predictable revenue stream, we have predictable cash flows, and we can service that debt. And if we do this and buy enough of these kind of inefficient smaller groups, bundle them up, you know, every three to five years, we can sell that and and and do pretty well. That's what people have done for the you know, maybe the last 15, call it even almost 20 years in our industry. What's also happened during that time, and this is where I think maybe the private equity people missed out without their understanding of industry, is we have been in a hard market for 16 years or maybe you know 14, 15 years called. what does a hard market mean? It means that insurance companies generally get to set rates, it's less buyer friendly, and so people seeing, you know, 10, 12, 20 percent renewal increases became the norm. for stuff. and in certain industries that was even or certain lines of business that would even a lot worse. So here you have private equity being like, wow, we're buying these companies. if they just renew all their customers, they're growing 20%. If they can actually add new customers to that, now we're growing 20, 30, 40%. We're able to borrow money very cheaply with the cost of what interest rates were, especially coming out of COVID, when effectively you had three years of almost free money. and so that's a pretty good recipe of borrow money very cheap, use that money to buy a business that's growing at 20 to 30 percent, get all these things together in you know as a a model where private equity companies made a lot of money. and that's why we saw all the consolidation in our industry. Later I'll get into why this isn't necessarily a good thing for the customer or for the insurance brokers, but that was what the industry was. And so what do we have now? Markets have softened. We've ended our hard market. And again, insurance terms, that just means that insurance companies are having to lower their prices to retain their existing business. And insurance companies are looking to grow more business. And the way they do so is cut rates and they've made money. And so they're they're you know underwriting the management allows them to do so. And so you know if you look at how pricing goes, up, up, up for 14 years, which is an exceptionally long hard market, now things are going coming back the other way. On that. And so you could renew all your business, all your accounts if you're an insurance agency, and your revenue may be down five percent year over year. So now you're having to and the big brokers are now re reporting their quarterly earnings or most recent quarterly earnings, and it's showing that it's showing flat revenue growth, or you know, you know, going into the low single digits when it had been in the mid-mid teens. And what else happens with private equity companies? They have very short time frames. You know, typically three to five, maybe seven years is a typical private equity investment. And during that time, again, we can talk all about private equity, how that works. They're charging their investors for managing that money, but they have to return that money at some point. And that's the expectation of their investors, is that this money is going to get returned to them within that time period. You also have now these loans when they lever up these businesses and put a lot of debt on them. these loans are also three to five year time period. So something that was taken out when interest rates were very, very low. if you're trying to refinance that debt, you're gonna be looking and it's the same thing that happens like if you're have a mortgage on your home, and you you know took it out a five year term in two thousand twenty, you know, that's gonna be at two and a half percent. You know, good luck trying to get two and a half percent if you're trying to refinance a home now, you're gonna be paying six and a half percent. so same thing holds true for these private equity folks that are trying to refinance that debt. So again, you know, these are bad things happening at the same time as an investment. the insurance industry, in my opinion, still is very great. We'll get into why this a little bit later. But if you're looking at this purely of hey, this is an investment I had that was making me a bunch of money, now all of a sudden I either gotta refinance my debt and my business prospects don't look as good, you we're gonna see. you know, a a very big impact in the industry for those companies that are highly levered, that were built on a model of we need to consult or keep acquiring to grow. and now, you know, kind of the Warren Buffett quote of you know, who's swimming naked when the tide goes back out? Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: and and that will show. so what does that mean for us? What does that mean for if you're an insurance producer? or if you're an account manager on it. So if you're working at one of these companies, it means that work isn't going to be as fun as it once was. meaning that these management and you're gonna have management that may have you know grown up in the industry and you know built their business on relationships, but they sold to someone else and they got a lot of money on that and now these other people with the money these are their new owners they're in charge. And so when there's mandates of hey, we gotta cut hiring or hey, we gotta, we can't, you know, six months, we're not hiring anyone. Six months, no raises, six months, and and those are the mandates that come out with these private equity companies because Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: they're purely looking at this as a balance sheet. they're not looking at it as hey, where do we invest? How do we help out our people? so if you're an account manager, you're gonna be asked to do a lot more. If that person next to you leaves and goes somewhere else, they're probably that position's not gonna get filled. if you're a producer, And again, you're renewing accounts at a twenty percent renewal clip, you know, everyone's happy when things are are making money, but they're gonna look at it and be like, wow, like we're paying our producers the same for renewal business. well that guess what? That's already our on the books, that's already our business. Let's Peter Brecht: Mm. Mike Tanghe: redo contracts and let's lower what we're gonna pay producers on renewal business so we can incentivize them to try and go out and hunt new business. They're gonna say, hey, you're a highly paid producer on something. We don't want you servicing these accounts. we want you going out finding new business. So they're gonna change their account management model of how do we work with, you know, in as a producer, yes, making money is great. but you know, why do why is a good producer, a g in my opinion, a good producer? It's because they know that client inside and out and they enjoy knowing that client inside and out. And When the client, you know, so and what does all that mean? And why do I think this is one of the greatest jobs in the world is you get very entwined with your clients. And again, I've had clients now that I've worked with for 25 years, and I've seen good, I've seen bad. but my point is it's I work with them. Like we're on a you know, we're talking on a regular basis. extremely gratifying to have that level of relationship, and I think very rare in most industries that I see that you can have that level of relationship where you're truly an advisor to your client. And in these models where it's like, you know, that is a lot of my time spent on those relationships. And why do I do it? One, because I enjoy it, one, because it's the right thing to do for the client. but the third is that I want to make sure that account renews with us on it. And if you switch that model and say, hey Mike, go out and find new business instead of working on retaining your old, who gets hurt in that? It's the customer, because they're gonna be dealing with multiple people, they're gonna get frustrated because it's something that they don't necessarily understand insurance. And before when they had, you know, their their person that they could call that understood exactly what to do. Now this customer is trying to have to explain things or they're sending things out and it's not right and keeps coming back to them and they don't know. So it's just it's setting themselves up for and again, my opinion, very short sighted. Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: but if you're, you know, a private equity company and you gotta make this, you know, refinance this loan and make things look pretty on a balance sheet, those are things that they do. And we see that happen all the time, with our clients. So Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: so for a producer, not as fun. Potentially job compensation cuts. and then again that that pressure of, you know, and with our we don't pressure our producers to go out and produce business. We want them to, for sure, and we'll give them the tools and the support to go out and do so, but we're not gonna have, you know, Monday morning meetings where we say, you know, what are you closing this week? And and I've worked at organizations that have done that and to me that's not fun. That's not what I want to do. So again, I would say it would take the fun out of the job if you're in that type of environment. I'll go into a little bit of what it means for account managers, but I realize I've been talking nonstop and I could probably insert a period now and take a breath. So Peter Brecht: No, it's it's good. yeah, I d I I've it's never being fun pawned off, you know, feeling pawned off to somebody else, right? So if you've if you are Going out as a broker and and that's how we win business, like you said, is through the relationship side, right? So we want to build a relationship with somebody. and that's really kind of what we stand on more than anything else. And I think any broker, you know, maybe they can stand on the brand name that they work for, if you're working at one of the the bigger shops. But but ultimately it's it's you know, the broker wants to sell themselves too, right? And if you take that component away and it's like, hey, great, now I'm gonna have you work with my account manager, we want that to be more of a like That's fine. They don't have a problem with that. But they also want to know that you're still in control of everything. And if something goes sideways or they just wanna talk through something, that you're gonna be able to do that. I think that's critical. the other part that's interesting. that that I was kind of thinking about and and you might get to this a little bit later, but with all the PE stuff too, like I'm looking at all these insure techs that are kind of coming on the scene, right? And they're kind of I think following a lot of the same patterns as the PEs are because there's a ton of them that kind of came online in COVID and it kind of peaked. And now you're kind of seeing it taper off a little bit and maybe overheat in a sense. and so it's it's and everything's kind of coming back to reality. I've talked to a couple other brokerages and you know friends that work there and they're like, yeah, we just we we don't use a lot of AI tech Now we just kind of use Gemini or whatever our chat tool is and it's working fine. Like we're getting the same amount of work done. We're just not maybe spending as much on the tech. So I don't know, just one little side note there, but give you a chance to catch breath. Mike Tanghe: Ha ha no, and it it's absolutely right of there's always people and I l know you do this as well, but I I listen to a lot of podcasts, on it and it's just it's something I enjoy when I'm exercising or or whatever or folding laundry. and it always just kind of amazes me when they're talking about, you know, how can we and a lot of it isn't like how can we use tech to help. on our existing, it's how can we use how can we disrupt and how can we replace and how can we and at the end of the day, like people don't understand insurance generally, they don't like insurance generally. They know they need to have it and they want to find someone that they can understand and they trust and they know that will just make this insurance thing easier for them. So they don't, you know, get these repeated requests for things they don't understand or they don't find themselves in an uncovered claim scenario. so it's it's like that's fundamentally what our business is is how do we make things easier for our clients on it. And you know, and tech is great for that. You know, we s again I mentioned being a podcast that COVID accelerated tech adoption in our industry. But that was for ways that enabled us to communicate more with our client. Like Zoom, for example. Zoom wasn't that it was, you know, It's got cool filters and Mike looks better on a camera than he does when he's sitting across a conference table with him. No, it's Zoom was something that allowed me to not have to jump on an airplane, spend all day and then sit across from a client on stuff on it, where I could still have and again, I don't discount that when we still will have those meetings with clients and we'll still do that in person, but it's much more deliberate when we do that. And We can have a lot of interim meetings over Zoom or Teams or whatever your your your mode is. and it allows us just, hey, I get to see this person, I get to communicate with them, and then you know, 30 minutes later I'm having a call with someone, you know, in a different country or different state or different so something like that. So tech in that didn't replace Mike Tangy and you know our client wasn't, you know, now just going to Zoom and and going and buying insurance. It just it was an enabler of the us to more freely communicate with our clients and have that direct connection with them. So like those to me are the things that, yes, that will help our job. And you know, we're we're doing quite a bit with AI, but it's not as a replacement or it's not something we're gonna hand off to our clients and say, learn this new tech. But it's instead what things are we doing right now and if we do like for policy review or proposal creations or stuff like that. Instead of the manual repetitive time consuming process, can we utilize tech to generate that faster? Because then guess what? Now I have instead of spending two hours on something, I spent took me 15 minutes and it looks better than it took me than when I spent two hours Peter Brecht: Right. Mike Tanghe: on it. And now I can have eight conversations with different clients rather than just one during that that two hour period. So that Peter Brecht: Totally. Mike Tanghe: to me is how tech will work in in in insurance. And again, like these things of we're gonna repl you know use And and again, there's certain policies that don't need to be purchased by by through a broker, the commodities, and tech's great for that. Now, do I think it's wise to, you know, raise five hundred million dollars to sell renters policies that are you know hundred dollar kind of loss leader type policies? No, I wish, you know, frankly, that every client would buy their renters' policies via a tech thing. problem is is we still see clients who buy a a policy from one of those online folks. And It's not done correctly, doesn't have the right limits. So so it's still something that we need to correct. but again, I look at this business that you you know, raise five hundred million dollars, you lose twenty million dollars a year, selling hundred dollar policies to me just doesn't seem like a great business model, no matter how cool the website is or or so far. So anyways, I'm going off a little tangent on that side. Peter Brecht: Yeah, yeah, yeah. No. Yeah, A AI is I kind of look at it like the Iron Man suit, right? It's it kinda enhances your abilities, but it doesn't replace the person inside. So it's it's good stuff. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. All right. Yeah, well Mike Tanghe: Great great example. I like that. It's what we should call our AI tool, iron iron person. Peter Brecht: what did he yeah, there you go. Some we gotta come up with something for it, but yeah, all right. I love it. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Excellent. I want to add one piece too, because I talked quite a bit about like what it means for producers, but if you're an account manager listening to this, whether it's a someone who's working at our company, or someone who's thinking about joining our company, you know, this w these things, like you need to be aware of it, right? You need to be aware is you know, what is the financial basis for our company? and you know, do we have a lot of debt? do we have a lot of debt that's coming due? Were we overpaying on things? Because In those situations, again, you need to look at you don't want to be the last person, you know, well, the music's still playing on the Titanic and things have gotten miserable because you're your folks are are are are leaving. So, you know, this confluence of of events is gonna mean you know more work for people, so not replacing people when when other people leave, less support on you. So so again, that investment in hey, if we want to grow our you know. We spend a lot of time as an agency looking at what are our growth plans, what do we need to support our team, and then investing on the front end. So, you know, we're excited to have a new account manager join us in two weeks on the personal lines, High Network Personalized side. And the reason we did that is because we have a new producer starting on that. And we know that in the beginning that that you know things aren't gonna be as busy for our will be effectively a little understaffed if you look at it purely on a financial standpoint on it. But we know that this producer is gonna do great things and bring in more business. So, you know, if you're working in a place that's strapped on the PE model, you know, they're not gonna hire that person. They're gonna go tell the producer to produce, they're gonna pile more work on the account managers, and it's only when two of them leave that they'll you know bring on one replacement type thing. So again, if you're an account manager, just be aware of, you know, how is your company being run? and you know, does that match up with what you value? you know, and if you're someone who values taking care of the customer, always looking out for the customer, always doing right by the customer, then that could be, you know, you could have those values effectively being squashed by management decisions. So you'll likely see more like utilisations of VAs, you know, where can they cut costs? So it's one of the things that had been popular is the use of of virtual assistants in other countries. What we're gonna likely see though are those VA type positions being pushed to be completely AI. and if you've someone who've played around with like AI is great, but it also does some funky things. and if you're a client, you don't care how great it was for the nine client interactions that happened before, if you're getting a funky reaction or a hallucinated response, you're Peter Brecht: Okay. Mike Tanghe: not gonna k again care how great it was for everyone else or how much time it saved or blah blah blah. You're just gonna be like, Well what would this why is this thing telling me the wrong thing? Or worse, I act on what it did. and I've heard stories of people, you know, prospects of ours that we're working with that are trying to get like claims resolved that are in it's like talking to, you know, just this black hole of repeating yourself and just it just it doesn't get resolved. And we see that with some mortgage companies and stuff like that, that it's just it's painful and it's annoying and Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: it's a time waster. so again, you know, look at how is your firm utilizing AI. Hopefully it's used to enhance the service that you're providing and free up time so you can have those conversations with clients. and it's not as a means to, hey, let's replace our people and do this 'cause it's works pretty good most of the time. Peter Brecht: Yep. Totally. Makes makes sense. I mean we have we have we have clients that are very specific on which account managers they like to work with, right? And it's like if if Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: so and so, you know, it's it and it just imagine if they got pawned off on AI. Can't imagine the the amount I I don't know. We just we're a little different. Mike Tanghe: Yep. And on one hand, I highly encourage all this stuff that's going on because it just it creates opportunity for our agency. I love the consolidation, Peter Brecht: Right. Mike Tanghe: I love the MA. not because that's something that we're looking to do, you know, actually the opposite of that, but it just creates opportunities for us to bring on new clients that want to work with a broker that looks like how their broker used to before they sold. And then the same thing is we want those account managers and producers who want to work for a firm that was how things used to be on it. And again, I'm not talking about, hey, you're gonna go back in time and you know, it's it's we're doing things in my opinion the right way we'll continue to do so and welcome anyone's feedback or commentary on on this topic. Peter Brecht: Yeah. Awesome. Well, Mike, thank you for thanks for your time today. Is there anything else you wanted to go over before we close out today's episode? Mike Tanghe: that's good for me. Thanks, Peter. Peter Brecht: All right. well thank you guys for listening to Falcon Forward. we'll be here again next week. And in the meantime, if have any questions or comments, yeah, leave in the the comment section. All right, thanks guys. Mike Tanghe: Thanks, Peter.