Latest / Newcomer Pod / Techstars CEO Maëlle Gavet Talks Pre-Seed Deals, YC, SoftBank & `Zombie Mode' Funds
Transcript
- 0:01Hey, it's Eric Newcomer. This week I'm talking to Myel
- 0:05Gave the CEO of tech stars of former ecommerce entrepreneur
- 0:10and the former chief operating officer of SoftBank back real
- 0:14estate company Compass. Myel has a great vantage point
- 0:17into early stage startups across the world.
- 0:22So we had a great conversation. I think I'll really enjoy it.
- 0:24Here's the episode. Thank you so much for coming on
- 0:27the show. I really appreciate it.
- 0:29My pleasure. Very excited to be here.
- 0:31I feel like you really get to see the full startup universe.
- 0:35Tech Stars covers so many startups.
- 0:38Can you just give me a sense like just so people really get
- 0:42this expanse of startups you see, like how many portfolio
- 0:46companies you have now or how do you think about sort of the
- 0:49reach of Tech Stars? Yes, absolutely.
- 0:51So Textures has been in business for 16 years now and we have
- 0:563600. Portfolio companies, so
- 1:00companies we invested in at some point or another during this 16
- 1:04years and. 1006. 103,600 and counting.
- 1:08We have a couple of investment in the making as we're speaking.
- 1:11So if you ask me again tomorrow, there will be a few more in our
- 1:14portfolio and we do that all around the world.
- 1:18So we have invested in companies from 60 different countries, 60
- 1:23and so we invest precede, we invest exclusively really early
- 1:27stage. And you have to have some
- 1:31relationship to tech because of the scale that it gives you.
- 1:34But other than that, like we're really invested across the board
- 1:37from fin tech to health tech to prop tech to like you name it,
- 1:42we usually have it. You've been at Tech Stars like 2
- 1:461/2 years now. I mean, we met like, I think on
- 1:49the conference circuit. You love to talk about what the
- 1:52Aspen Airport. You flagged me down, I think
- 1:54after like brainstorm. I think at the time I was at.
- 1:57Ozone and But you and I, we had already talked before, right?
- 2:00Right, right. And so I was in the.
- 2:02Information, Yeah. And then I came to your office
- 2:06when you were at Compass. So anyway, we've seen each other
- 2:08around the world for a long time now.
- 2:11And you sort of like went to tech stars during the pandemic,
- 2:14right? I mean, it was about the same
- 2:16time I think I quit Bloomberg to start the newsletter.
- 2:19So I mean a big job change in the pandemic and tech stars, I
- 2:22think for like. The incubator accelerator world,
- 2:26you know, the pandemic was like a real sort of like how do we
- 2:29react moment. What was the main thing you
- 2:31wanted to change? I mean it was sort of the reach
- 2:34or sort of the type of entrepreneur you attracted or
- 2:37like coming in like what was sort of your top priority?
- 2:42I wanted Textures to become the best and largest precede
- 2:46investor in the world. I thought that there was a lot
- 2:49of, again, really good building blocks.
- 2:52The fundamentals were there and it was also an opportunity to
- 2:57scale it, further streamline it, strengthen it, provide more
- 3:01value to entrepreneurs, help them get better terms, better
- 3:07exit, better valuation. And that's a look.
- 3:10That's a long process. The VC industry works in very,
- 3:13very long cycle. It's not like you arrive and
- 3:16then three months later things change, but that was the idea of
- 3:20taking this. Great company to like a whole
- 3:24different level where I mean to start, when I would talk about
- 3:28tech stars, people would actually know who we are and
- 3:32what we do. And I remember announcing that I
- 3:34was joining tech stars to my network and a few people
- 3:39including venture capitalist from Silicon Valley, we will
- 3:42remain unnamed saying why are you joining a nonprofit?
- 3:46And my answer was this is not a nonprofit, this is an investment
- 3:50business and a pretty good one at that is just they never
- 3:54really position themselves as an investment business.
- 3:57And so part of the work was to change internally and externally
- 4:02the image of textures to say we are a very large precede
- 4:07investors and by the way as per crunch base we a few months ago
- 4:11we officially became the largest precede investor in the world,
- 4:15so. Who did you pass?
- 4:20Is that 500 Global A? Lot of friendly people.
- 4:22A lot of friendly people. Just to sort of like quick
- 4:25facts, like what is the best return so far for like tech
- 4:28stars? We have some really cool company
- 4:31that I like very much. So companies like and I don't
- 4:35know how many of them you know, but like.
- 4:37Company like Chain Analysis. They've met the OK, so they met
- 4:41headlines not long ago because they provide blockchain data and
- 4:44analysis to governments, banks, and businesses around the globe.
- 4:48And when things like FTX happen. And it's only the most famous.
- 4:53But there's been multiple situations where figuring out
- 4:58what is happening in the blockchain crypto world has been
- 5:02pretty critical for a lot of institution.
- 5:05Chin Analysis is usually the company they call.
- 5:07That's a super high markup. What?
- 5:098 billion something? Yeah.
- 5:11The company, I think the last valuation was 7.3, but they had
- 5:14a peak above that. So that's one of them, one that
- 5:17I like very much. It's called Remitly.
- 5:20There are mobile payment service that enable users to make person
- 5:24to person international money transfer.
- 5:26So that's the tagline. What they do is that they allow
- 5:29to a large extent, immigrants from all around the world to
- 5:32send money in a safe and cheap way to their families and to the
- 5:37people who need it. And so that's a $6 billion
- 5:41company. They went through IPO in 2021.
- 5:46Yeah, because that was the year I joined.
- 5:48So 2021. And I think there this is a
- 5:51company with a mission which I think is is amazing.
- 5:54Can I have a third one that exactly?
- 5:56Yeah, people. I love specific companies.
- 5:58So the one that I find fascinating and again we're
- 6:01talking about billion dollar plus company, we can also talk
- 6:04about smaller company because with 3600 companies in our
- 6:07portfolio we got a bunch. But the one that I like a lot
- 6:11among our billion dollar plus company is a company called Zip
- 6:14Line. Oh yeah, of course.
- 6:16And most people, when they know about zip line, they mostly
- 6:20think you know about about either, if they know what.
- 6:24Drones in Africa? Right, exactly.
- 6:26Drones in Africa. And what they do is that they
- 6:29design and they manufacturers these drones and then they
- 6:32operate them to deliver vital medical products.
- 6:36And it's a $3 billion company. They did a successful
- 6:40fundraising in April of this year.
- 6:43And again, what they're doing really makes a lot of sense for
- 6:48the world and at the risk of using a Silicon Valley sentence,
- 6:52like to make the world a better place.
- 6:54But the reason why it matters so much is because I deeply believe
- 6:58and and so is my team, that big money comes from solving big
- 7:02problems and big problems usually are found.
- 7:07In things that make the world a better place.
- 7:09Not always, but it does help. So that's my $3 billion plus
- 7:15favorite company, but we got a quite a few others so I could
- 7:18keep going. Then are there standard terms
- 7:22for tech stars? Like if I'm an entrepreneur,
- 7:24like, yeah, what should I expect from you all in terms of money
- 7:28and ownership? Yeah, no, absolutely.
- 7:30So we have standard terms in their public.
- 7:32So it's $20,000 + 100,000 dollar convertible notes.
- 7:37And depending on the conversion of the notes, we end up on
- 7:41average with about 8% of the capital in the company.
- 7:45And basically what we provide to founders is the capital
- 7:49obviously, but there is what we call the textures formula.
- 7:52So it's the 120 K that I've just mentioned.
- 7:56It's the program themselves. Our actuator programs are very
- 8:00intense. It's small class, very small
- 8:02class. It's 10 to 15 companies.
- 8:05It's very hands on. You have the texters team this
- 8:09or Texters employee dedicated to that particular program.
- 8:14These tend to be people who are former entrepreneurs themselves
- 8:18and during this program it's like.
- 8:21Six days a week, it's very intense.
- 8:23I mean cannot have a second job or do a bunch of other stuff on
- 8:26the side. Like it's full time and it's
- 8:28it's not rare for an entrepreneur at the end of the
- 8:31program to be like, hey, I'd love to take a holiday.
- 8:33It's like that you called, you need to go and phone raise now.
- 8:36So there's the program itself, then there's all the services
- 8:39afterwards, because once you graduate from the program, we
- 8:43have a series of services from helping you to fundraise to
- 8:47connecting you with more mentors, more alumni.
- 8:50We have a. Large group of corporate
- 8:52partners, companies like Audi or ABN, Amro or JP Morgan or Ecolab
- 9:00and eBay. We've just announced A
- 9:01partnership with eBay. And so connecting them with this
- 9:04corporate partner does matter. And then last but not least, as
- 9:08I say, we have a huge network And so even after you graduate
- 9:11from the program, you can always leverage that network, which is
- 9:15truly global because we've been running.
- 9:18Tax rate of programs all around the world and we invested in 60
- 9:21plus countries. Like recently I was talking to a
- 9:24portfolio company of ours who is trying to figure out how to
- 9:28enter Japan. And guess what, we have a really
- 9:32good relationship with the Ministry of Economy in Japan and
- 9:35we have run multiple programs in Japan and we have a pretty
- 9:38robust mentor bench in Japan. And so it was literally a phone
- 9:43call. It's like yeah, sure, no
- 9:44problem. Let me connect you to X and we
- 9:47can do that in. A lot of countries around the
- 9:50world. So you you have this, you know,
- 9:52global View preseed companies. Yeah, I'm just curious given
- 9:56that to get your sense of the market right now because I feel
- 10:00like, you know, I've said this so many times, but it keeps
- 10:03being true, like AI feels so hot and then there's a downturn and
- 10:08a lot of other places, but there is still been this sort of hot
- 10:13seed environment because the late stage investors want to
- 10:15invest in something. And then the last point I would
- 10:18observe is just that, you know, the public, you know the big
- 10:22tech stocks have been back up. So I don't know how do you make
- 10:25what is your read on the funding environment right now?
- 10:28Because I imagine when you invest in a precede company, you
- 10:31want to make sure that there's some path to them fundraising,
- 10:35you know, a Series A down the road or how do you think about
- 10:38the environment? So complex question was a lot of
- 10:41different elements of answers. So let's start with the VC
- 10:45environment. So the VC there is a
- 10:47consolidation ongoing, it's not visible yet and in my view the
- 10:51worst is to come. Because.
- 10:54In terms of like VC firm shutting down?
- 10:55Use. Yes.
- 10:56Yeah, exactly. Emerging GP not being able to
- 11:00raise their next fund. And in the venture world, they
- 11:02don't shut down. It's like in the operating
- 11:05company world where a company goes like goes bankrupt and like
- 11:08literally fire people close the door and then that's it.
- 11:11In VC world, it's more like they move into zombie mode.
- 11:15Right. We're still managing our last
- 11:17phone, but we're not raising anymore.
- 11:20Makes it so hard for a reporter to call the end because it's
- 11:23like, well, OK, maybe they let it slip one year.
- 11:25Does that mean they're never raising again, or does that mean
- 11:28they're gonna try again next year?
- 11:29Exactly. It's a very slow, slow death.
- 11:32So this is definitely happening and then you combine that to the
- 11:36fact that a lot of venture firm have not yet taken the full
- 11:42write down. On their valuation, which by the
- 11:46way creates an even bigger, it compounds the problem because a
- 11:50lot of institutional Lps have public and private portfolio and
- 11:54the public portfolios have obviously the public market have
- 11:57obviously taken the right down, I mean valuation have.
- 12:00You dramatic. What I've always heard is you
- 12:02want to be in the red when everyone else is.
- 12:04Everybody else is falling. You want to mark it down of
- 12:07like, OK, it was a brutal period.
- 12:09But if you drag it out and you are in denial and you say, oh
- 12:12man, these companies are still good and then you have to mark
- 12:15them down, yes. Yeah, Then you look bad when
- 12:18everybody else is at least starting to rebound.
- 12:20And that's nobody. No Lps like that.
- 12:22But they're not. I don't think they're in denial.
- 12:25I think the VCs are basically for a lot of them, fundraising
- 12:28because you also have to remember we came from a period
- 12:31where it was not abnormal for a venture firm to raise every two
- 12:36years, sometime every year and so.
- 12:39A lot of the firms are now out in the market fund raising and
- 12:43if you take a significant write down then suddenly your
- 12:46performance on paper doesn't look great and so it creates a
- 12:49problem for you. So it's not like they're in
- 12:51denial, I just think that they're trying you're.
- 12:53Like it's worse. They know and they.
- 12:56Yes. And the Lp's know that, the
- 12:58institutional LP know that. So there's like the double
- 13:01effect. The first one is most
- 13:03institutional Lp's are overexposed to VC because the VC
- 13:07haven't taken the right down that the public market have.
- 13:10So there's like a denominator effect.
- 13:12And then the second reason is the Lp's know when they look at
- 13:16the their, the GP they invested in that some of them have not
- 13:20taken the full right down and they're like okay.
- 13:22Maybe we're going to wait to see where all of that.
- 13:25Lands. And so this environment very
- 13:29tricky at the moment and I think what we're observing is a
- 13:32complete change of the guard, a complete reorganization of the
- 13:36venture space. And it's not over, my guess,
- 13:39it's probably another couple of years, who knows.
- 13:41I don't have a great crystal ball on these things, but there
- 13:44is something happening and at the outcome of that change,
- 13:48we're most likely going to see very different players really
- 13:52influencing the markets. OK.
- 13:54So that's the VC piece of it and that means, you know, I would
- 13:58extrapolate over time less, less money available, right?
- 14:02Less easy money available. So the way we talk to our
- 14:06portfolio companies because we have you know a little over
- 14:1115,000 investors who have made an investment in the Textures
- 14:14portfolio companies we've been connected with.
- 14:17So we we talk to a lot of these people like we we are deal flow
- 14:20to the VC industry, we're not really VC ourselves.
- 14:23And what we tell our portfolio companies is it's not that there
- 14:27is no money, there absolutely is some money.
- 14:30It's just it's harder to get because the VC are going back to
- 14:34some fundamentals like you should probably do due diligence
- 14:37before you give a check of a few $1,000,000 to a company, you
- 14:41know wild stock. You are going to have to show a
- 14:45clear pass to profitability. Doesn't mean that you have to be
- 14:48profitable, but it has to be. Clear and credible.
- 14:52Not like, you know, the hockey stick that makes you profitable
- 14:54in year 10 if like all the planets align and you have no
- 14:58competition. And so that by definition makes
- 15:01it a lot harder to create compelling cases.
- 15:05And then in a lot of cases the VC will now ask, even at an
- 15:09early stage, to see some tractions.
- 15:11But if you combine that like we have companies that have raised
- 15:15recently very good round at seed and Series A level, but they had
- 15:20again like they had like a good track record, a clear pass to
- 15:23profitability, a great product market fit.
- 15:26I think if I had to summarize, gone are the times where you
- 15:29could go and raise five, ten, $15 million based on the napkin
- 15:33and a barely put together MVP. That's not happening anymore
- 15:37unless you're in AI. And that's a different that's a
- 15:40different thing, right? There's a certain strain of
- 15:43founder, you know, the not let's, I mean everybody's
- 15:46becoming the AI founder now. But you know some of the
- 15:48founders think, oh, the gloom and doom has been oversold.
- 15:52You know, VCs wanna get better terms.
- 15:55So it's like in VCs interest to emphasize like how bad things
- 15:59are. I don't know what do you say to
- 16:01that? I said that the valuation that
- 16:05we saw in 2021-2022 didn't make a lot of sense and I think we're
- 16:11seeing a recalibration of the market.
- 16:14We also say that to our portfolio companies, if you are
- 16:17being offered a down round, you probably should accept it
- 16:22because most likely and obviously it's always on the
- 16:24case by case basis, but most likely your last valuation was
- 16:29probably a little inflated. And the new valuation that
- 16:33you're getting is probably closer to reality.
- 16:37And so yes, it looks like a down round, but maybe the way you
- 16:41should look at it as your previous round was it out of the
- 16:44ordinary round and this is the normal round.
- 16:46So it's not a down round technically, it's just a normal
- 16:49round. How do you think about like
- 16:52going after spaces like I mean to some degree.
- 16:56I mean, I think you were just saying before we started
- 16:58recording that you know, you're in the business of like
- 17:00searching for Black Swan events. Does that mean like you're going
- 17:05deep in AI now or it's like, oh man, the foundation models have
- 17:08already been funded? Or how do you think about with
- 17:12so many portfolio companies targeting sectors?
- 17:15The way we think about it is by practices.
- 17:18So we have 15 practices. So again, like space and
- 17:21defense, we're one of the most active and now, if not the most
- 17:25active. Investor in the world in space
- 17:27and defense, health tech, we've invested in house tech really
- 17:30early on and we have a really strong practice there.
- 17:33And we have partner like United Healthcare in that program.
- 17:37And so again, 15 practices, some of them are industry related
- 17:41like the two I've just mentioned.
- 17:43Some of them are horizontal practices.
- 17:45So things like AI or things like blockchain would be in what we
- 17:50call horizontal practices, meaning there's not an AI
- 17:53industry. There is an AI capabilities that
- 17:56is now being implemented across industries and AI is nothing
- 18:02new. I think what has changed is or
- 18:04thanks to ChatGPT and the fact that it was so easy to
- 18:07understand, now my mother understand what AI means and so
- 18:11do VCs. It's as a result of that there
- 18:14is suddenly like the next full move of like oh, AI is the next
- 18:18thing that is going to change everything.
- 18:20And by the way I do agree that AI is actually.
- 18:22A once in a lifetime evolution from a tech perspective.
- 18:25So it's not to diminish the impact of AI, but like AI
- 18:29powered business, I've been in business for a really long time
- 18:34and we've invested in AI powered business for, I don't know,
- 18:3910-15 years. Like it's nothing completely
- 18:42brand new. So the people who are.
- 18:44Discovering AI right now, I don't know.
- 18:47From a VC perspective, it's like, yeah, there's a lot of
- 18:50things happening, but there were a lot of things happening two
- 18:52years ago as well. I mean you just announced this
- 18:55eBay partnership and you obviously have sort of a
- 18:59background in e-commerce. I'm curious sort of what the
- 19:04plan is there and you know, are you bullish on e-commerce today,
- 19:08some of the the Warby Parker type investments, I feel like
- 19:11some investors. I've sort of fallen out on
- 19:14direct to consumer sort of thinking that it's harder to
- 19:17build like a venture scale business.
- 19:20So what opportunity do you see in e-commerce right now for
- 19:23startups? So obviously I can't speak for
- 19:26eBay. They will have to have their own
- 19:28view and their own opinion. I'm just gonna talk about it
- 19:31from texture's point of view and from my point of view, because
- 19:33as you mentioned, I come from e-commerce and I spend quite a
- 19:36lot of time in that industry. I think people confuse often
- 19:40ecommerce with direct to consumer.
- 19:43It's like oh how can we create the next whatever Amazon or the
- 19:47next Warby Parker. I mean Amazon is not exactly
- 19:50direct to consumer, but you know what I mean?
- 19:51Like the basically people are associating ecommerce exactly
- 19:56like with a brand that creates a product and that then goes and
- 20:00sell it to the consumer whether they are the one producing that
- 20:03brand or whether like Amazon, they aggregate other people
- 20:07brands and then sell it. And it's not to say that there's
- 20:10no innovation there. Maybe there are some brand and
- 20:12some product that they're not properly sold to consumer.
- 20:15There's also, we have to remember we have a very US
- 20:18centric view of the world. There's a lot of other countries
- 20:21around the world who may not have the ecommerce landscape
- 20:25that we have in the US or we have in Europe.
- 20:27But to me that is like a tiny little piece of ecommerce.
- 20:31There is everything related to digital marketing, especially
- 20:35with AI now and all the content noise that is about to come our
- 20:39way thanks to that or because of that and the fact that Facebook
- 20:43is not the marketing platform that it used to be.
- 20:46Like digital marketing in itself, there's a whole world in
- 20:48there that needs to be reinvented.
- 20:50Payments, we talked about blockchain.
- 20:53There is like a whole universe of how do you do payment for
- 20:56e-commerce in a better way. Especially outside of the United
- 21:00States, especially in countries where the banking system is not
- 21:04as robust, though actually not that I'm saying it out loud, the
- 21:07banking system robust in the US there's a problem, but I you
- 21:10know what I mean. So payment, there's a ton of
- 21:12things to do. Infrastructure, the e-commerce
- 21:17require is a very CapEx intensive business, warehouses,
- 21:21distribution system, supply chain, so everything related to
- 21:25supply chain and we felt it. During COVID, where all the
- 21:29supply chains got disrupted and not just between China and the
- 21:33West, but like globally supply chain got disrupted, created a
- 21:37ton of questions around like how do we create a new supply chain
- 21:41more robust, more resilient, cheaper, faster.
- 21:44That's e-commerce. And then I'll give you one last
- 21:48one which is big. Is everything related to the
- 21:51environmental impact e-commerce? Is not necessarily the most
- 21:56friendly way of selling things to people.
- 21:59Think about the amount of cardboard that we are using
- 22:04thanks to Amazon. Think about all the goods that
- 22:07are being shipped from one side of the planet to another side of
- 22:10the planet, and then between warehouses and so there's a
- 22:13whole world. Around how do you do supply
- 22:16chain And again like these are four topics, but I can keep
- 22:19going. There's so many things that can
- 22:21be improving e-commerce. What can you say about the eBay
- 22:24partnership? That we're very excited.
- 22:27You just said there's something, but you haven't really said like
- 22:29what. I assume they'll work with some
- 22:32of your companies. Or yes, yes.
- 22:34The idea is that we run that program for three months
- 22:38together. There's gonna be.
- 22:40EBay executive coming into the program and you know, sharing
- 22:44their knowledge, sharing their problem, sharing feedback on the
- 22:48company's ideas that we selected.
- 22:51And to me that's the power of the partnership we have with so
- 22:55many of these corporate or government partner.
- 22:58Like if you're a space startup like we partner with NASA, like
- 23:03you probably should come and talk to us if you're in the food
- 23:06tech or agrotech business. We have a partnership with
- 23:10Ecolab, which is, if you may feel like that's a big deal,
- 23:13like if you are interested in the future of mobility, we have
- 23:17a partnership with Audi, autonomous car and all of that.
- 23:20Like you probably should also talk to us if you are interested
- 23:24in alternative energy. We have a big investment hub in
- 23:28Oslo with a company called Ecuador.
- 23:31And so that's everything related to alternative energies and I
- 23:35can keep going, I'm going to stop here, but it's just like.
- 23:38This partner bring an incredible amount of knowledge, including
- 23:43what are the things that are not working and that they would love
- 23:46for a startup to solve. And then they open their door to
- 23:50their labs, to their sales team to like It's just it takes to
- 23:54start up to a whole different level.
- 23:57And for the corporate partner or the government agency, it's just
- 24:00it's an opportunity to get plugged right into innovation.
- 24:04And see what's coming that could potentially help your business,
- 24:07but that could also disrupt your business.
- 24:10I want to take stock of like the do you do you call yourselves an
- 24:15accelerator incubator? First of all, I feel like people
- 24:18never know what to say. So we call ourself A precede
- 24:22investor, but joke apart, we call ourself A precede investor
- 24:28and the X rater. So the term that we use is X
- 24:30rater. Is really a mean to an end.
- 24:33It's just it's under the premise or the idea or the conviction
- 24:37actually based on the data that if you at the precede level, if
- 24:41you just give money to startups, you may as well go to the casino
- 24:49and play roulette. That is about the same chance of
- 24:53winning. And the reason is that at the
- 24:56precede level, most companies that you are going to be
- 25:00investing in, and there are exceptions, but most companies
- 25:03that you are going to be investing in, they're going to
- 25:05pivot. They're going to change what
- 25:07they want to work on. They're going to realize that
- 25:09what they were working on is not exactly that.
- 25:11A lot of them are first time founders.
- 25:14They're going to change their team because they started with
- 25:16one team and they're going to finish with another one.
- 25:18There's so many things that can change that.
- 25:22You basically, at the precede level, if you really want to
- 25:25increase your chances of getting somewhere with the company, you
- 25:31have to support them. You have to be with them in the
- 25:34trenches and go through the ups and downs of what it is to be an
- 25:39entrepreneur. Because it's so hard to be an
- 25:42entrepreneur. It's always been hard, but like
- 25:44right now it's particularly hard.
- 25:45And so it's really about this idea that just giving money is
- 25:49not enough. You need to provide support, You
- 25:52need to provide guidance, you need to provide mentorship, you
- 25:54need to provide connection, you need to provide all of that.
- 25:57And that's the reason why the X Rater program plus all the
- 26:00services after the program come into play.
- 26:03So how do you think of tech stars relative to Y Combinator?
- 26:07I mean, obviously, you know, they're the juggernaut in the
- 26:10room. Like are you trying to sell to
- 26:13the same founder? How much do you see them as sort
- 26:16of a direct competitor? How do you think about YC?
- 26:19I think YC is an amazing business.
- 26:21I've always recognized that they've done a lot of really
- 26:24interesting stuff and starting with they've built an incredible
- 26:27brand. Like the simple fact that even
- 26:30though Textures and YC started X Rater program at the same time,
- 26:35the fact that the world associate the world X Rater with
- 26:38YC tells you a lot about what they've been able to do.
- 26:42And look, I'm a very competitive person, but at the same time I
- 26:45want to give credit where credit is due.
- 26:47I think they've done a pretty, pretty fantastic job.
- 26:50They've also done a pretty fantastic job in in building
- 26:53relationship with Silicon Valley.
- 26:55We operate in 16 countries, so we invest in 60 plus countries,
- 27:00but we have physical offices in 1616 and until very recently we
- 27:06were not in Silicon Valley, which is problematic.
- 27:10I think YC has done a very strong job at that.
- 27:13Yeah, there was a second where? I mean it's almost to your
- 27:15advantage that they're very focused on their presence in
- 27:18Mountain View in California, like for a second they were
- 27:21during the pandemic sort of flirting with going all remote,
- 27:25which would have brought more of a direct competition or?
- 27:29The way I think about it is we've done an analysis when I
- 27:33join because we're business. So I was like, OK, can we talk
- 27:36about our target addressable market and apply to us the same
- 27:40thing that we're applying to our portfolio companies when we
- 27:42select them and when we help them grow?
- 27:45And so I was like okay, what's the target addressable market?
- 27:47Like how many founders do we think could be backed every year
- 27:52by a precede investor. And we've done a ton of analysis
- 27:56and I give you the bottom line the IT was like this probably
- 28:01every year depending on how you look at it, between 70,000 and
- 28:05100,000 entrepreneurs who would be worse looking at and
- 28:11potentially back at the precede level.
- 28:14And a lot of them are not VC backable right now, which is by
- 28:18the way why we don't consider ourself a VC.
- 28:21We're really considering ourself as the deal flow to the venture
- 28:24world. And a lot of this entrepreneur
- 28:26that I've just put in that target addressable market,
- 28:29actually they don't even know that the VC world exists.
- 28:32They don't even know how to access it.
- 28:34When they know it exists, they don't know how to access it and
- 28:36so. We look at that target
- 28:37addressable market and we're like OK again 70 to 100,000
- 28:42entrepreneurs every year that could potentially benefit from
- 28:46an actuator program and from precede investment.
- 28:50And so if you look at that the fact that there is a few well
- 28:55known big actuators out there that make a few 100 investment a
- 28:59year like we're not even scratching the surface.
- 29:01That's an interesting way to like look at it, but the counter
- 29:03to that is. I mean, I'm gonna make them
- 29:05number up whereas you've done an analysis.
- 29:07But like in a vintage year like they're probably like what that
- 29:1150 or like some that have like some huge exit that justifies
- 29:17the investment or like how many companies do you think there are
- 29:19a year that like end up producing this sort of exit that
- 29:24would justify the model rather? Than so I think the premise of
- 29:29your question is flowed if you asking me how many.
- 29:33Are making an exit right now. Yeah, you're probably right.
- 29:35I mean, I think the number is a little higher, but not by much.
- 29:38My question back at you is how many should have like why is it
- 29:43that until not that long ago, most of the high valuation?
- 29:48I mean actually. So I don't know why I'm saying
- 29:50not that long ago until today, Why is there a premium in
- 29:53companies that are in Silicon Valley?
- 29:56Why like objectively why? Because it's not like the
- 30:00company that is being created in New York.
- 30:03Or Boston or Atlanta have less of an addressable market like.
- 30:08So they have lower exit, lower valuation based on the fact that
- 30:16they're not based in Silicon Valley and I'm just only talking
- 30:19about the US now. Let's talk about the rest of the
- 30:22world, let's talk about Europe where valuation are way behind
- 30:26where they are in the US Let's talk about Latam and Africa that
- 30:29the venture world is just discovering.
- 30:32It's to me what your question points out is the fundamental
- 30:38problem in the system that we created a system where there's
- 30:42only a few companies that are going to have a shot at being
- 30:48given the money, the contact, the support, the valuation.
- 30:51And by the way, because that universe is so tiny, then you
- 30:54see crazy valuation that are not justified by any multiple.
- 30:58And so again, my question back at you is.
- 31:01What if the valuation on this very tiny pool was going down a
- 31:07little bit and the money was flowing more freely across more
- 31:11companies? Because the world would benefit
- 31:14from having a hell of a lot more companies being supported,
- 31:18rewarded and invested by venture capital.
- 31:23Right. I mean what I'm hearing, I think
- 31:24the limit of my question is it's sort of.
- 31:26Reflects like a 0 sum world where nothing has been done to
- 31:29create new companies where it's like ideally you're like
- 31:32expanding that number by, you know, giving them sort of more
- 31:36access. But I mean I do think there is
- 31:38sometimes this dueling world where they're like there's this
- 31:41elite cadre of founders who like many of them have started
- 31:44company before. And like I mean a lot of the top
- 31:47forget like accelerators, but a lot of the top seed funds sort
- 31:50of can think that way where it's like you got to see them all,
- 31:53you got to you know, you pick among them but like the list is.
- 31:56Not so, so long and then that's how you win.
- 32:00And then I think there's this sort of the opposite view which
- 32:03you're saying, which is you can sort of create winners.
- 32:05If anything, Silicon Valley's over invested in itself.
- 32:08Like there are people from all over the world that could create
- 32:12great companies. Yeah, I mean those are sort of
- 32:15we see both investing methods. I mean in terms of, yeah, I
- 32:20don't know expanding outside of Silicon Valley.
- 32:23I mean, Europe, like I wrote a lot about and there was a lot of
- 32:26excitement. I think in this sort of even in
- 32:28the elitist worlds of venture capital where it's like, oh,
- 32:31Hoppin and UI Path, you know, we're both so high flying that
- 32:35everyone was like, oh, we need to do the Silicon Valley
- 32:37playbook over there and then those companies have come back
- 32:39to earth. I'm curious like, yeah, I mean I
- 32:43don't know how do you take stock on sort of the European tech
- 32:47market there and the appetite? Yeah.
- 32:50So it's related to a bigger macroeconomic question, which is
- 32:55valuation to a large extent are supported by the VC environment.
- 33:01So it's a bit of a chicken and egg situation.
- 33:03In other words, if, and I know that not everybody is going to
- 33:07agree with me, but that's fine, they can ping me on social media
- 33:10and continue that conversation. I think if the VC environment,
- 33:14if the funding environment in Europe was significantly more
- 33:17robust than it is. We would be seeing there a
- 33:19different valuation, but it's not.
- 33:22I think the US has created and again, we're not going to go
- 33:25down history lane, but like there is a whole history of
- 33:30creating the venture capital world the way we know it in the
- 33:34US, which is significantly better than other solutions that
- 33:39have been pursued in Europe, let alone in the rest of the world
- 33:43and so in general. They're in Europe significantly
- 33:48less VCs with significantly smaller fund.
- 33:52Europe doesn't have pension fund or very few pension fund at the
- 33:56way it exists in the US Pension fund have to a large extent
- 33:59contributed to the allocation of large chunk of money to VC.
- 34:04And so you combine all of that with the fact that the European
- 34:08market is still very fragmented both in terms of legislation,
- 34:12banking system and language. And it makes the market more
- 34:16difficult for a company to scale in.
- 34:18And so like you have the perfect combination that makes valuation
- 34:22lower, objectively lower than in the US.
- 34:26Changing gear slightly, but I think touching on some of the
- 34:28same themes like, I mean you wrote Trampled by Unicorn, Big
- 34:32Tech's Empathy problem and how to fix it several years ago now,
- 34:37right? Can you give us sort of first
- 34:40like what you know, a quick snapshot of what your core
- 34:43argument? Was there.
- 34:44And then I'd like to just like take stock on if you've seen
- 34:47anything change. Yeah, so my core argument there
- 34:52was 2 arguments. The first one was I think tech
- 34:56companies have forgotten empathy as a key peeler.
- 35:02And empathy is really understanding the impact the
- 35:05corporate empathy, not individual empathy.
- 35:07Corporate empathy is really about understanding the impact
- 35:10of your decision. On the stakeholders around you,
- 35:13not just your employees and your users, but just in general like
- 35:18the world around you. And that's a shortcoming that is
- 35:22going to keep creating problems over and over again.
- 35:26So that was the first thesis and I was talking about why is that
- 35:31and how do we fix that internally?
- 35:32Like how do we create more corporate empathy, Again, not in
- 35:36a nonprofit like. Kumbaya around the campfire way,
- 35:42but more in terms of like, hey, empathy is a way to think about
- 35:45the impact that you're going to have and how you keep your
- 35:47business from making mistakes that are going to alienate a
- 35:50certain number of stakeholders. So that was thesis #1, Thesis
- 35:54#2, slightly more unpopular, but I'm going to blame it on my
- 35:59European roots. It was around the idea that the
- 36:02reason why Western societies have, in my opinion, thrived
- 36:07over the centuries. Is because we found with
- 36:11different ways of doing it, different models across the
- 36:14Atlantic. But we have found a pretty good
- 36:17balance between entrepreneurial innovation and democratically
- 36:24elected regulators. And it's not perfect.
- 36:28Like there's back and forth and the pendulum sometimes swing a
- 36:31little too far one way and then it swings a little too far the
- 36:34other way. And again, the US has created an
- 36:36environment which is. Objectively different from
- 36:39Europe. But if you take a step back, in
- 36:41both cases, what you're really seeing is a decently good
- 36:46balance between the two, where there's enough innovation to
- 36:49drive things forward. But there's also government that
- 36:52have been democratically elected for a certain vision of society,
- 36:55for a certain set of rules, values, whatever you want to
- 36:59call it, and that are counterbalancing like the
- 37:03unbridled innovation. Right.
- 37:05So I started with that and what I talked about in the book is
- 37:08how tech liminaries and big tech companies in particular push the
- 37:13pendulum way too far in terms of we don't want any regulation.
- 37:17We should be able to do whatever we want.
- 37:19And that's because we're making the world a better place and my
- 37:22whole. A few chapters in the book were
- 37:25about that. We're about the fact that the
- 37:27pendulum went way too far. And I am not.
- 37:30I'm certainly not advocating for like top down regulation on
- 37:34everything, but the idea that the industry would self regulate
- 37:38is not at all justified by 20 centuries of history.
- 37:43Like there's not a single industry that's self regulated.
- 37:47Why on earth do we think that the tech industry is going to
- 37:50regulate itself? So that was the thesis.
- 37:52It's interesting. I mean, I guess to help bring it
- 37:55to the current moment for you, in some ways I feel like there
- 37:58has been this recognition in Congress that they were too slow
- 38:03on social media and that with AI they need to sort of move much
- 38:07quicker. I mean, it's yours for the
- 38:10listener. You're sort of scrunching your
- 38:12face on that one. I mean, yeah, I'm curious apply
- 38:15what you wrote to what you think is happening in AI and like,
- 38:18what? You would like to see or what
- 38:20you see happening. So let me start with the
- 38:24positive. I think the positive is that
- 38:27there has been a recognition that's a true recognition like
- 38:32it's now really big on the agenda that tech innovation and
- 38:36tech disruption is here to stay. When well used, it is a
- 38:41formidable driver of progress and improvement of standards of
- 38:45living. And so all of that is really
- 38:48great when not. Run that well, we have some
- 38:51problems and we probably should be looking at it.
- 38:54And and that to me is a huge difference than what it was even
- 38:585 let's say seven years ago. I remember being at a dinner
- 39:02table in Silicon Valley and talking about the fact that I
- 39:07found this idea of self regulation problematic to say
- 39:11the least. And the people around the table
- 39:13looking at me like I was a communist.
- 39:15Yeah, nobody in Silicon Valley wants to hear that.
- 39:18So I think the positive is that I think the challenge that I
- 39:22have is the current conversation on AI is one.
- 39:27I am not sure that every political person involved in
- 39:33this conversation is really up to speed on the technical
- 39:37aspects of AI, even at a pretty basic level.
- 39:42And that terrifies me because there is something even worse
- 39:46than no legislation. It's legislation based on
- 39:50something that doesn't exist or that is completely the opposite
- 39:54of what you think it is, because then that creates additional
- 39:58negative effects. So I'm quite concerned based on
- 40:03what I heard so far about the ability of our politicians again
- 40:09across the Atlantic. I mean, Italy like ban ChatGPT,
- 40:13right? Like, yeah, there's been some,
- 40:15that's what. I'm talking about.
- 40:16Right. I know like that.
- 40:18I don't know. I definitely.
- 40:21I used to be more like pro tech regulation more like oh, excited
- 40:26about Elizabeth Warren. And I mean I'm first of all I
- 40:29find like Marc Andreessen's recent argument that the people,
- 40:33the companies that are going to benefit most from AI regulation
- 40:35are the incumbent big players who can do all sort of the.
- 40:40Whatever verification protocols. And then some ways, it's just a
- 40:44barrier to startups and it creates a sort of protectionism.
- 40:48I'm very sympathetic to that argument that like any
- 40:51regulation on AI, is gonna end up being pretty hostile to
- 40:56startups, and startups are the very companies that society
- 41:00should be cheering for. But it doesn't necessarily have
- 41:03to be. I think to me, the false choice
- 41:07that is being put in front of us is like.
- 41:10Regulation or no, regular, like all in regulation, like let's
- 41:14create a super agency and let's audit every single algorithm.
- 41:18I'd be curious to understand how the hell they're planning to do
- 41:20that. But okay, like let's do either
- 41:22that or let's do nothing. And I'm like, what about trying
- 41:27a few things? And it's one of the things that
- 41:29was very fascinating to me talking to my tech friends over
- 41:34the years is it is totally acceptable in the tech world.
- 41:39To make mistakes like this is literally called A/B testing.
- 41:42Like we test one thing, it works great, it doesn't work, That's
- 41:45fine, We'll try the next thing. But somehow my tech friends were
- 41:49expecting the government to get it right from the get go.
- 41:51Like like the when GDPR came in. And I know it's a very
- 41:55controversial topic in the US, but when GDPR came out, like, I
- 41:59can't remember how many conversation I had with people
- 42:01were like, and this is not perfect and this is not perfect
- 42:04and this is not perfect. I'm like, OK, yeah, it's not
- 42:07perfect. But the idea that we want to
- 42:09figure out how companies are using data and make sure that
- 42:13there is a modicum of privacy, and again I'm overly simplifying
- 42:16it, that doesn't seem completely crazy to me.
- 42:19And so back to your question, I am certainly not advocating all
- 42:24hands on deck, top down legislation and as I've just
- 42:28said, like the idea of having some kind of super agency that
- 42:31would audit every single algorithm like I'm not.
- 42:35First of all, I don't see how it's working practically.
- 42:38And then I'm not sure that we have now enough knowledge to
- 42:43regulate a I in that way. But I don't buy either the idea
- 42:49that you shouldn't do anything but you should just let
- 42:52companies do whatever they want. Because we have multiple
- 42:56examples of companies, tech and non tech, which when left
- 43:01completely alone with our regulation didn't necessarily
- 43:05drive humanity to the best output possible.
- 43:08Yeah. And certainly, I mean, I think,
- 43:09you know, the beauty of democracy is that regular people
- 43:12should get to set sort of the rules that they want to live by.
- 43:16And it's not just sort of these oligarchic type companies.
- 43:20So sympathetic on some level, but then and there you can sort
- 43:23of make like a capitalist style argument which I think you're
- 43:26getting at, which is there are a lot of countries they can
- 43:28compete with different types of regulation and sort of see which
- 43:32ones work and create better societies.
- 43:33And then other countries can sort of learn from what works
- 43:37and what doesn't. We've talked about the
- 43:38regulation piece, these sort of, I don't know, voluntary empathy
- 43:42piece. I mean, anecdotally it feels
- 43:44like in some ways there's almost been like a turn against or like
- 43:48you sort of see, you know, with like the all ends of the world.
- 43:51Sort of a bristling at the idea, you know, almost like a
- 43:54rebellion from being told to, I don't know, be nicer, I don't
- 43:59know. I'm curious what your view of
- 44:00this, you know, Elana and Mark Zuckerberg are.
- 44:03Want to fight with each other. I know empathy is a broad
- 44:06concept, so me, but I don't know.
- 44:07I just sort of a tonal thing in the air.
- 44:10Yes. So I think it's because there is
- 44:12a confusion on the definition of empathy.
- 44:14Yeah, empathy is not sympathy and it's not PD and it's not a
- 44:21weakness. It keeps saying to people.
- 44:23And especially when the book came out, it's like you can fire
- 44:26people with empathy. Like you can fire a lot of
- 44:29people with empathy. What it means is just that.
- 44:33You are going to be thinking, really thinking about the impact
- 44:37that it has and you're going to try to mitigate it as much as
- 44:40possible. It doesn't change the fact that
- 44:42you are still going to make that decision and implement it,
- 44:45because you should still fight for the interest of the
- 44:48business. Look, I don't know Elon Musk.
- 44:50I have never met him. So obviously the image that I
- 44:53have of him comes from his regular tweeting and all the
- 44:57articles that I could read. So I'm going to caveat that by
- 45:00saying maybe he's a lovely man. I have no idea.
- 45:03I think my argument about empathy is could he have done
- 45:07everything that he's done with just a little more thinking
- 45:13about how to reduce the impact on people's life that is letting
- 45:18go on making the communication a little more human, on making
- 45:23people feel more valuable. I think most people understand
- 45:27that tough business decision have to be made.
- 45:30I think it then just become. A lot of question about how are
- 45:34they being communicated, how are they being treated, what is
- 45:37being said to them. And so again, I don't know him.
- 45:41As I say, he's maybe a lovely man in private.
- 45:46It's just I think too many people confuse and so mean with
- 45:50sympathy. Yeah, it's just so mean.
- 45:53It's like, why anyway? I don't know.
- 45:55Yeah. It's why would you choose?
- 45:57I mean, you know. Again, I called comment on him
- 46:00specifically. I don't know, but I think the
- 46:02conversation I've had over the years was don't confuse empathy
- 46:07with sympathy and with weakness. I actually believe that an
- 46:12empathetic person is a stronger person because they can
- 46:17understand better how people around them are going to react
- 46:21to what they're doing, what they're saying, the decision
- 46:24they're making. And as a result of that, they
- 46:26see around the corner. A way to describe empathy, again
- 46:30from a corporate perspective, in a more basic term, is empathy
- 46:35allows you to see around the corner of what's coming.
- 46:38Who wouldn't want that? And then, yeah, you can go to
- 46:40war. You can fire people, you can
- 46:42restructure your entire company, you can cut it into pieces like
- 46:46it's not. I think there's a confusion on.
- 46:50The equal. I covered Uber so closely.
- 46:52And you know Travis Kalanick like.
- 46:54Just could not seem to really understand what he was doing
- 46:58that upset people so much it was terrible and apologizing and you
- 47:01know just those things. I mean ultimately got pushed out
- 47:04because of at some point misunderstanding sort of your
- 47:08customers when the public mood is just.
- 47:11That's exactly what I'm talking about.
- 47:13I think this is a perfect example.
- 47:15This is not questioning whether or not you were strategy was
- 47:19good or bad. I think it's about questioning
- 47:21whether. More empathy in understanding
- 47:23the impact of some decisions on the drivers, on local
- 47:28communities, on employees. Understanding that impact better
- 47:32in advance would have helped Uber be even more successful
- 47:37than they are today. You were what, the Chief
- 47:41Operating Officer at Compass, right?
- 47:43Yeah. I mean, a company that raised a
- 47:45ton of money from SoftBank, you probably know the number like.
- 47:49Now that you're an investor, you know spend so much time on the
- 47:52operator side like I don't know what do you, how do you make
- 47:55sense of like the SoftBank strategy?
- 47:58Are you still close to that world or I'm curious like having
- 48:03seen sort of the massive amounts of money if you think that era
- 48:07is ever going to come back or how you would take stock of it?
- 48:11I mean, history always comes back.
- 48:14I know also literally comes back.
- 48:16I mean, he was in the.com. He maybe he'll get to do it
- 48:18again, you know? Yeah.
- 48:20I'm old enough to remember the time where everything was about
- 48:24gross that we went through the phase where I'm talking about
- 48:27industry wide, not just specifically so big like
- 48:30industry wide. Then it was all about
- 48:32profitability, then forget about profitability, let's go back to
- 48:35top line. So it's cycle.
- 48:37I wish I could tell you that's it.
- 48:38That's the moment in history where we're finally.
- 48:40Going now, we're all responsible, interest rates
- 48:42responsible. Exactly.
- 48:44Like valuations are now normal. Like people are going to do
- 48:47proper due diligence, like the whole thing.
- 48:50I maybe I'm cynical, but I just think that like, no, like, I
- 48:54don't know how long it's going to take, but at some point
- 48:56someone, whether it's South Bank or someone else, is going to
- 48:59figure out the next thing. That will allow them to convince
- 49:03LP that they can deploy a lot of money.
- 49:06I mean we talked about South Bank, it's the same thing with
- 49:08Tiger like they frankly 1824 months ago they turned the VC
- 49:13industry upside down by increasing valuation and
- 49:16changing due diligence timing. And so it's a cycle, it's going
- 49:20to come, it's a kind of. You talk to Lps like why?
- 49:23Why Do you have a sense of like why do they let them do these?
- 49:28I mean some of it I guess is sovereign wealth where it's like
- 49:30a very. Some of it is.
- 49:34So again, I can't comment specifically on South Bank and
- 49:37Tiger because I was not in the room when these conversations
- 49:40were happening. I think the again, I'm going to
- 49:43take the positive hat and then I'll put a slightly less
- 49:45positive hat on it. The positive view on that is the
- 49:49world woke up pension funds, sovereign funds, family offices,
- 49:54woke up to the fact that there was this unbelievable source of
- 49:58innovation. That was working on some of the
- 50:01biggest problem in the world or sometimes not really
- 50:05transforming problem. It's still solving day-to-day
- 50:07challenges for a large chunk of the population and that there
- 50:11was an opportunity to surf that wave, support this innovation
- 50:16and make it bigger or faster. And so for me, on the positive
- 50:19front, there's been an awakening.
- 50:22To venture capital and to the fact that there was this massive
- 50:26flow of innovation coming and the opportunity to support them.
- 50:30I think like everything else, the human race tends to be a
- 50:36race made of excess. Like we're very excessive
- 50:40species in every way, by the way, like good and bad.
- 50:45And so I think like, you know, we.
- 50:47Like they woke up to ventures. Suddenly it was like, Oh my God,
- 50:50look at all these billion dollar companies, like I should be on
- 50:53it. There's a little bit of FOMO.
- 50:55And then there's the little bit of like, we as again as this PC,
- 50:58we like to dream. We like to think about how we
- 51:00going to make the world so much better and so different.
- 51:03Like we write science fiction books to help us think about how
- 51:06the world could be different. And so I think that happened.
- 51:10And then it become almost like a self fulfilling prophecy because
- 51:13as long as the money kept flowing, you could see this
- 51:16valuation go up and up and up and up and the only thing that
- 51:19would stop you was like like if you didn't have any more money
- 51:24or if you believed that we were about to reach the peak.
- 51:27But every time someone say, oh we're about to reach the peak,
- 51:30there was another something happening, another company going
- 51:33public at a crazy valuation. And so suddenly you would have
- 51:38LP be like. God damn it, Maybe I missed
- 51:40that. Like, what do I do to not miss
- 51:42the next one? And so I think it's just that
- 51:46dynamic that led us to very. Recitable, enthusiastic species.
- 51:51Yeah. There was a time where it felt
- 51:54like nothing could go wrong, that valuation in VC would keep
- 51:58going up and up and why. And I, some of the conversation
- 52:04we had with institutional Lps over the last 12 months was
- 52:07almost like them. Realizing that venture is a
- 52:11highly volatile investment asset class and one that is certainly
- 52:17not providing any guarantee in terms of return.
- 52:20And it was like almost like this ah moment around like oh wait,
- 52:25actually, yeah, venture can be really volatile.
- 52:28Like yeah, it can. Risk capital, Well, this was so
- 52:34great. Thank you so much for coming on
- 52:35the show. It was a blessed.
- 52:37My pleasure always. Great.
- 52:39All right. Thank you.
- 52:40Thanks, Eric. Thanks so much.
- 52:42I'm Eric Newcomer. That was my conversation with
- 52:44Mayel Gavi, CEO of Tech Stars. Shout out to Tommy Herron, our
- 52:49audio editor, Riley Kinsella, my chief of Staff, Young Chomsky.
- 52:52For the theme music. You can follow us on YouTube.
- 52:55We appreciate your reviews on Apple podcast.
- 52:58And of course, most important, subscribe, Become a pain
- 53:01subscriber to the substack at newcomer.co.
- 53:05Thanks so much. Goodbye.
- 53:06Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 53:07Goodbye.