Latest / No Way Out / The Fractals of Finance: Richard Brennan on Complex Adaptive Markets and the Real OODA Loop
Transcript
- 0:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so right before you joined us, Moose and I were talking about some books in the past and uh things that uh we've read uh in markets and things like that.
- 0:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Not all those books are true, just like leadership books.
- 0:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, people talk about great leadership examples, and look what I did, and you need to do this too.
- 0:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think Wall Street has the same failure mode, is they they look at these great traders and try to copy the 50-day moving averages, the 200-day moving averages, and they don't start with first principles.
- 0:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I kind of want to ask you to start off with is just just how did you get involved in looking at complex adapter systems applied to markets?
- 0:52Richard Brennan: Well, it really started from my educational background.
- 0:55Richard Brennan: So when I came out of school, I went into university and did geology.
- 1:00Richard Brennan: So I completed the course as a geologist, and then I I particularly specialized in soft rock sedimentology, which is more about oil and gas exploration.
- 1:09Richard Brennan: And at the time in Australia, this was during the minerals boom, and there wasn't uh many sort of job occupations going for oil and hydrocarbons.
- 1:17Richard Brennan: So I decided to do business as as a lead up to to extend my my knowledge into the business framework.
- 1:24Richard Brennan: So my passion has always been sort of science running parallel with business.
- 1:29Richard Brennan: And when I started my process, I I adopted the models that uh economics was saying was appropriate to adopt.
- 1:36Richard Brennan: I adopted uh value investment tech um techniques, the assumption that the system that we trade and invest in is analogous to the downstream of the firms, the economies, and all of these things.
- 1:48Richard Brennan: And I adopted uh what I what I refer to as a predictive model.
- 1:52Richard Brennan: And that's where I suffered a lot of grief in that it wasn't a sustainable solution for me.
- 1:58Richard Brennan: Um, you know, I had my wins, but then I had my inevitable significant setbacks.
- 2:03Richard Brennan: And um I was looking for something that geometrically built my wealth.
- 2:08Richard Brennan: Um, and um that led me ultimately after many, many failures of my predictive model, as I refer to it in in my head, adopting the economics path.
- 2:18Richard Brennan: It forced me to use my science background to challenge some of those assumptions and change my model.
- 2:23Richard Brennan: It was there that um I started looking at, well, look at the performance track record of investment managers over the course of time and let's start standing on the shoulders of those giants.
- 2:32Richard Brennan: Let's don't, I know you talked about listening to Wall Street gurus and things like that, is not necessarily the path, but what I wanted to see was what is a sustainable track record in investing?
- 2:42Richard Brennan: And when I looked at the performance track record of this particular class of investing called trend following, I found that it was a it was a wide success story.
- 2:52Richard Brennan: It wasn't just held by a few individuals like the Warren Buffett's or the Sorrisses or people like that.
- 2:58Richard Brennan: It was held by a very large class of participants in relative terms that had a very long track record of sustainability.
- 3:05Richard Brennan: And that's where I thought, right, well, looking at the success stories, the tr the validated track record, as opposed to the tips, the hot tips, all of these things that that you receive in predictive world, I started looking at their process and seeing what their process did.
- 3:21Richard Brennan: And that's where I used my science to start interrogating that process.
- 3:25Richard Brennan: What is it that makes this process work?
- 3:28Richard Brennan: And this is where my knowledge of complex adaptive systems and fractal geometry and these aspects sort of all merged into this assessment of what they were doing and recognizing that they were doing something that was effectively aligning, aligning with the market.
- 3:46Richard Brennan: And what I mean there is that in this world of finance, if you adopt the world of the predictive function in there, you're always assuming what the market's going to do down the track, and you might be applying value investment, all of these different strategies.
- 4:02Richard Brennan: But I was looking at a particular strategy that would avoid the predictive functions, because the predictive function is where you're meeting uncertainty, and your models have got to be right to avoid collapse or avoid ruin.
- 4:14Richard Brennan: And fortunately, in this particular system I was looking at, which is the investment world and the commodity space, the future space, the liquid investment space, there is a benchmark, a guide we can use that allows us to align with it, and that's called price.
- 4:31Richard Brennan: And price is the collective experience of all the players in that market.
- 4:37Richard Brennan: So if you could imagine the market is comprised of an ecosystem of lots of different types of agents.
- 4:44Richard Brennan: They all have their own vantage or their model of the world, and that most of them are applying a predictive response to that.
- 4:50Richard Brennan: What is the world going to do next?
- 4:52Richard Brennan: What is the world going to do next?
- 4:53Richard Brennan: And of course, if that predictive function fails, if there's a significant error there, risk of ruin, goodbye, out of the system you go, you you either dissolve back into the system or you're excluded from the system.
- 5:05Richard Brennan: No more chance to participate in what I call a reflexive system.
- 5:08Richard Brennan: So there is a benchmark.
- 5:11Richard Brennan: This is unlike what you'd find in your military circles.
- 5:15Richard Brennan: You don't have this benchmark.
- 5:17Richard Brennan: You've got a world of different variables to consider the topography, the terrain, the logistics, what the enemy is doing, all of these things.
- 5:26Richard Brennan: There's no guiding benchmark, but in my particular world of complex adaptive systems and in my market framework, there is a benchmark that reflects a consensus opinion of every participant, every vantage that consolidates into this thing called price.
- 5:44Richard Brennan: So to avoid the predictive function, all I've got to do is align with price.
- 5:51Richard Brennan: Align with price.
- 5:53Richard Brennan: So in your world of odor, where you observe, you orient, and then the rest falls out.
- 6:00Richard Brennan: I'm I'm thinking that the most important things is the observation and the orientation.
- 6:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's going to be the orientation.
- 6:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's the world model.
- 6:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's 100%, right?
- 6:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Exactly.
- 6:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's not so I see it.
- 6:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, so there is a predictive aspect to it, and then there's also the part where we have to engage with the environment.
- 6:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's where most people miss on that.
- 6:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to just uh pause here for a second, and you brought up a few things.
- 6:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Jerry Parker is the one that introduced us.
- 6:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So huge thanks to him uh for bringing us together.
- 6:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And of course, he uh wrote the forward to your book, The Fractals of Finance.
- 6:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The way I came across this book was from Keith McCullough from Hedgeye.
- 6:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh he was touting this book for a while over the last month, and uh Moose and I just spent some time with Keith and we asked him this question, or I asked him this question, and I don't know they the people that are listening to this podcast that may be affiliated with Hedgeye may want to put some earmuffs on because I'm going to share something that Keith may or may not want me to share.
- 6:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and this has to do with complex adapted systems.
- 6:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So here I'm standing with Keith and I asked him, Hey Keith, I got a serious question for you.
- 6:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You speak about complex adaptive systems all the time, and yet you still have analysts.
- 7:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, you can't break a complex adapted system into its constituent parts.
- 7:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: By definition, it's you it can't be done.
- 7:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's no neat reason to do that.
- 7:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So why is it um you still have analysts?
- 7:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, I won't tell you why uh what he told me, but I will tell you that uh it's probably not needed.
- 7:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the old model of breaking things down and getting the valuation of the company and all that, I believe it's still necessary because that's what makes a market.
- 7:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's what you said, is these agents are creating these predictions and these models and are following them, and it's creating this thing called price.
- 7:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's resonating, it's vibrating, and we get this thing called price.
- 7:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, I'm ready to go to the next level with you.
- 7:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do we figure out when the timing?
- 7:43Richard Brennan: Okay, yeah.
- 7:44Richard Brennan: So fortunately in our world of price, where we've got this benchmark of collective opinion, there is no when.
- 7:51Richard Brennan: So we just align with structure.
- 7:53Richard Brennan: We align with price.
- 7:55Richard Brennan: So if you could imagine we are like a shadow following, we we're a close shadow to price, always lagging it, but always trying to reduce the the error between our path and price's path.
- 8:10Richard Brennan: So this is where I view this as a non-predictive function.
- 8:15Richard Brennan: It's alignment function that avoids the need for prediction.
- 8:19Richard Brennan: So let's say that I didn't have trend following as my guide.
- 8:23Richard Brennan: Let's say that I adopted a predictive function in the market.
- 8:27Richard Brennan: I would be swimming in uncertainty there because there are so many variables that affect your predictive posture.
- 8:35Richard Brennan: What your mental model will not necessarily align with the greatest greater structure, because the greater structure is the composite of all of these different vantages that these agents all have.
- 8:48Richard Brennan: That is what the collective market does.
- 8:50Richard Brennan: It creates a collective structure, a bound constraining structure that's dynamic.
- 8:56Richard Brennan: And there's this reflexivity in this structure.
- 8:59Richard Brennan: I impress a force into the market when I do a trade.
- 9:02Richard Brennan: So when I enter a trade, I'm impressing a directional force into that trade.
- 9:07Richard Brennan: If I'm going long, I'm impressing a small directional force long in that market.
- 9:12Richard Brennan: Other agents with their models, their predictive models or their trend following models or whatever, they're all directing a small impetus on price.
- 9:21Richard Brennan: Now, how this all collates together is the consensus price opinion, where price currently sits, and it's a structure that I follow.
- 9:31Richard Brennan: So that's why when I say I'm a trend follower, I'm meaning it literally, um, I am following the trend in price.
- 9:38Richard Brennan: I'm not participating in it at all times.
- 9:41Richard Brennan: I'm only participating in it when things get material, because my belief is in these complex adaptive systems with the research I've done, is that change is never a continual, graded, gradual process.
- 9:55Richard Brennan: It comes in fits and starts.
- 9:57Richard Brennan: Changes of these complex adaptive systems, they reach thresholds where there is a phase transition in the collective structure of what these markets are.
- 10:08Richard Brennan: So there are periods of of apparent stability where you get very minimal volatility.
- 10:15Richard Brennan: And what that does to the market participants who are engaging in that market, because it's this reflexive system, is that we start getting a concentration in strategies into that particular calm environment.
- 10:26Richard Brennan: And that concentration of strategies is usually enhanced by leverage because people say, well, to get the necessary return I need in this calm environment, I've got to leverage myself up.
- 10:38Richard Brennan: Now, what that is progressively doing to the entire system during this period of calm is the risk is building.
- 10:45Richard Brennan: It's making the system more sensitive, much more sensitive than it was previously when we had a lot of divergent different opinions.
- 10:54Richard Brennan: Because when you've got divergent different opinions, you've got a much more stable structure.
- 10:59Richard Brennan: But when you start narrowing that into a calm environment, you start getting consensus of opinion.
- 11:05Richard Brennan: People doing the same thing.
- 11:06Richard Brennan: We get this loss of diversity in the market and we get this concentration, which makes a market incredibly sensitive, sensitive to change.
- 11:15Richard Brennan: And what happens is in these calm environments, when you get a small deviation from this calm environment, you get a major nonlinear amplification because it is the explosion of this risk that's been compressed into this calm model that's now exploding out, and you get a massive move or an exponential nonlinear move, and a new environment is created.
- 11:40Richard Brennan: It's not a gradual change, it's an explosion, if you like, a phase transition into a new structure.
- 11:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let me ask you this path dependency is a is a you know that the complex adaptive system, and and you're saying that the market is a complex adaptive system, it's a market.
- 11:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It could be a living system, it could be a reflection of our global consciousness.
- 11:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But there's some there's a couple of things, uh, characteristics of a complex adaptive system, and one is path dependency, it has a history.
- 12:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, how does that history f uh fit into this conversation about future price or current price?
- 12:11Richard Brennan: So, what what the history is, if if you imagine my journey as a trader, my journey as a trader commenced when I was born, effectively.
- 12:19Richard Brennan: In fact, it goes well back, goes well back.
- 12:22Richard Brennan: It goes back to the time, you know, Carl Sagan talks about we are stardust.
- 12:27Richard Brennan: So the composition of my body has been constrained by carbon, silicon, these elements.
- 12:34Richard Brennan: It's a constraining function.
- 12:36Richard Brennan: As I've evolved, as I've moved across time, the complex adaptive system is continually constraining me.
- 12:44Richard Brennan: Because it's not just one constant at the complex adaptive system, it's a nested hierarchy of systems within each other.
- 12:52Richard Brennan: Each one is constraining what the possible states are of the agent themselves.
- 12:58Richard Brennan: So if you can imagine over the course of time, the path I've taken, whether I've survived or not, the fact that I'm here now is a survival legacy.
- 13:08Richard Brennan: It's it's what I call the survivorship.
- 13:11Richard Brennan: I am here now talking to you, Moose and Ponch.
- 13:14Richard Brennan: I'm here talking because I am still active in the system.
- 13:18Richard Brennan: I'm still participating in the system.
- 13:20Richard Brennan: My pattern, or which is a consequence of these constraints that apply over the course of time, which lock in the particular trajectories or constraints within which I can operate.
- 13:33Richard Brennan: So if you could imagine, imagine the universe that is what I call pluripotent.
- 13:38Richard Brennan: As you start constraining system development, you start finding that the trajectory gets more bound.
- 13:47Richard Brennan: Everything gets more bound as you progress.
- 13:50Richard Brennan: And as the system develops, more and more complex adaptive systems all interacting with themselves, they create this constrained bound space.
- 13:58Richard Brennan: Now, this therefore means that I must stay within those bounds to survive within the system.
- 14:04Richard Brennan: This is part dependency.
- 14:06Richard Brennan: If I stray outside that bound, I either dissolve back into the system or I am excluded from the system.
- 14:12Richard Brennan: I am no longer participating.
- 14:14Richard Brennan: Okay.
- 14:15Richard Brennan: Viewing things from what I call an inside out perspective, because there is no vantage as an agent in this system I exist in outside that I can passively look in.
- 14:26Richard Brennan: I am participating in this system.
- 14:29Richard Brennan: And this is this reflexive participation.
- 14:31Richard Brennan: What my model is, what I think my model is, is constrained by my path.
- 14:37Richard Brennan: It's limited by my education, my culture, my background, who I've read.
- 14:42Richard Brennan: All of these things has constrained my mental model to be reflective of this path.
- 14:48Richard Brennan: And I'm continually mapping this mental model against what I have no access to, which is other participants' vantages.
- 14:57Richard Brennan: They've they're all unique.
- 14:58Richard Brennan: They've all got their paths.
- 15:00Richard Brennan: I don't share their paths, but I might correlate with their paths.
- 15:04Richard Brennan: Yes.
- 15:05Richard Brennan: Now that I've talked to you and Moose, we correlate.
- 15:08Richard Brennan: I'm now sharing ideas with you, you're sharing ideas with me.
- 15:12Richard Brennan: Together, we're both growing intellectually from the sharing of ideas.
- 15:17Richard Brennan: I'm correlating with you.
- 15:19Richard Brennan: But before I ever met you and Moose, um, we we were separate correlated paths or separate paths that are now correlating together.
- 15:28Richard Brennan: So I'm seeing this interaction occurring, this process interaction occurring.
- 15:33Richard Brennan: And I believe a process is the best way to define what we're talking about here.
- 15:38Richard Brennan: Because if I talk in terms of things, if I talk in terms of things, and when we draw down into things, we ultimately find at the lowest fundamental level they're processes.
- 15:48Richard Brennan: There are no things.
- 15:50Richard Brennan: Things is a what I call an explicit form that comes from a local sort of realization of what the map sort of is against the territory.
- 16:01Richard Brennan: It creates structure, it's a this relationship.
- 16:04Richard Brennan: So I just see processes, patterns, if you like.
- 16:07Richard Brennan: To sustain my pattern, I've got to survive.
- 16:10Richard Brennan: To sustain my pattern, I must cohere with every other vantage that surrounds me because they're all constraining me, they're all limiting me.
- 16:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what you described, you actually described orientation.
- 16:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, and and that it's you know, the experiences, the culture, the genetics.
- 16:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you brought up Carl Sagan, you brought out the path dependency.
- 16:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so all these things constrain us.
- 16:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's you you're calling it a reflexive market.
- 16:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's what we're projecting onto it comes back to us.
- 16:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So as above.
- 16:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Soros was wrought.
- 16:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 16:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 16:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, actually, Soros' first, I think, article he wrote was about consciousness, if I remember correctly.
- 16:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I there's a history with Soros and Mandelbrot and things like that.
- 16:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've got to look back in the in the past to really look at.
- 16:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we I think we talked about that on other episodes.
- 16:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, so now we have this orientation that is connected to the market.
- 16:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you're saying that all these participants, even those that aren't participating by buying and selling, but just observing the market, are influencing the market itself, right?
- 17:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The observer is still part of the system.
- 17:05Richard Brennan: You've got to be careful because uh I have a slight pushback there.
- 17:08Richard Brennan: Okay.
- 17:09Richard Brennan: I think an agent must be participating in that system.
- 17:12Richard Brennan: So when I boil down to bottom level, we've got lots of different systems.
- 17:18Richard Brennan: So this is where I view the environment of a firm and the environment of the economy and an environment as of a city, and the environment of the brain, and an environment of the body, as these separate nested systems.
- 17:34Richard Brennan: Now, within these separate nested systems, when you drill down into the process that defines that system, you find that there is a reflexivity going on between the agents in it and the system.
- 17:47Richard Brennan: So lots of us define systems in various ways.
- 17:50Richard Brennan: We've got simple systems, uh complicated systems, complex adaptive systems, chaotic systems.
- 17:58Richard Brennan: We've got these lots of different types of systems, but what I'm saying is that at ground zero, these are just definitions we have described to classify things.
- 18:08Richard Brennan: I'm saying at ground level, ultimately, it's all complex adaptive systems.
- 18:13Richard Brennan: But what we might be classing as a system like a jet engine, which is a a construction of parts, there is no reflexivity going on with a jet engine.
- 18:23Richard Brennan: There's just a componentry going together to create flight, or whatever.
- 18:28Richard Brennan: What I'm saying is if you we say, well, that is a form of collection of different components, that's not the underlying reflexivity.
- 18:36Richard Brennan: Go back further.
- 18:37Richard Brennan: What is?
- 18:38Richard Brennan: What is the complex adaptive system that's driving that?
- 18:42Richard Brennan: And ultimately, it comes down to the human context.
- 18:45Richard Brennan: Who's creating it?
- 18:47Richard Brennan: Who's doing it?
- 18:48Richard Brennan: This defines the vantage that I say, well, that actually is the broader complex adaptive system, the reflexivity in that system.
- 18:56Richard Brennan: And where we might be making our mistake is assuming that all systems are alike.
- 19:00Richard Brennan: They're not.
- 19:01Richard Brennan: Um, there are different classes of system or what we term systems.
- 19:04Richard Brennan: So that that's where I'm I'm seeing this.
- 19:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 19:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I was the way I was thinking about it is if if I'm not a participant in the market, meaning I'm not buying and selling any equity or anything or commodity, but I am shopping at Dollar General, that is a nested system.
- 19:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That Dollar General being correlated nested system.
- 19:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Agreed.
- 19:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Agreed.
- 19:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 19:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But the close the proximal the closer I am in proximity to the system I'm interacting with, the more influence.
- 19:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 19:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Help me out there.
- 19:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's the interactions that matter.
- 19:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 19:31Richard Brennan: Yeah.
- 19:31Richard Brennan: So, you know, uh- You might have heard of Steve Wolfram and the Wolfram project, which looks at cellular automata.
- 19:37Richard Brennan: So what it's doing is it's saying, right, let's see if we can create something that resembles this universe by creating these cells that have rules applied to them, and the rules create iterations.
- 19:52Richard Brennan: So each iteration creates a new layer of nodes or relationships.
- 19:58Richard Brennan: Now, as you progress the iteration, you start seeing what is called systems coming together, or what appears to be almost autonomous systems that are operating almost independently with other systems.
- 20:12Richard Brennan: They are still connected to those systems, they're still correlated to those systems, but they've got a degree of autonomy.
- 20:19Richard Brennan: Now, I'm viewing this world of nested systems in a very similar way, not exactly the Wolfram Way, but in a similar way to say, right, from this thing we call the universe, how do we get these systems?
- 20:32Richard Brennan: How do we get these agents?
- 20:34Richard Brennan: And this is where I I won't go into it in detail because that this really goes off the track, but it comes back to what I'm calling relations.
- 20:43Richard Brennan: So this is the difference between what I call a reductionist philosophy versus what I call a holistic philosophy.
- 20:49Richard Brennan: So if you can imagine as me being an agent in this system, I have this vantage, it's incomplete, it's partial all the time, it needs to be continually updated.
- 21:00Richard Brennan: Now, if I maintain my vantage, there's a risk there if I maintain that my vantage that um I'm going to get risk of ruin here, I'm going to be deleted from the system.
- 21:10Richard Brennan: I've got to adapt to that system.
- 21:11Richard Brennan: And this is where living systems come in, because living systems is the only system that allows this adaptive process to occur.
- 21:20Richard Brennan: It's where the agent has the ability to adapt their model.
- 21:30Richard Brennan: In other words, to alter their model to the terrain.
- 21:34Richard Brennan: The map being their frame, what they've experienced, their collective cultural history, their environment, all of this.
- 21:42Richard Brennan: This creates the map, or it creates what I call a zone of permissibility about which the agent can do things.
- 21:49Richard Brennan: It's their controlling hemisphere or their controlling Hubble volume, if you know what I mean.
- 21:55Richard Brennan: So it's saying there is a market out there, I don't have access to all of the knowledge of this market to make these perfect predictions.
- 22:04Richard Brennan: I've only got a partial model.
- 22:07Richard Brennan: So what I've got to do is I've if my model is incorrect, if there's an error in my model, I must extinguish that model and create a new model.
- 22:18Richard Brennan: So this is where.
- 22:20Richard Brennan: I believe that in adaptation, adaptation is a process of reconfiguring your map to the terrain.
- 22:28Richard Brennan: It's this error correction that's continually occurring.
- 22:31Richard Brennan: The smaller you can keep that, the smaller you can keep that, the greater chance of surviving.
- 22:37Richard Brennan: And in my trend following world, where I'm following this thing called price, I am minimizing that error function because fortunately I've got this guide rail called the collective opinion of everyone, every vantage.
- 22:50Richard Brennan: This collective opinion is the price.
- 22:53Richard Brennan: And unfortunately, in our world we evolved in, the world, the natural environment, the environment you guys deal with in your warfare, all of these, these don't have this guide rail.
- 23:06Richard Brennan: This guide rail is is unique to the markets.
- 23:10Richard Brennan: And this is where I thought, right, recognizing that it is inherent that we are predictive engines, that's what we do.
- 23:17Richard Brennan: We predict, as and this is where I totally agree with you.
- 23:20Richard Brennan: I've read your stuff, it's fantastic.
- 23:22Richard Brennan: It's this predictive modeling, you know?
- 23:24Richard Brennan: Cool.
- 23:24Richard Brennan: Yeah.
- 23:25Richard Brennan: Yeah, go, go, Ponch.
- 23:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so I uh this is fascinating.
- 23:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If I'm hearing you correctly, war or warfare is more complex than the market because the market provides us a price.
- 23:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It gives us something that we can look at.
- 23:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 23:37Richard Brennan: Okay only to those that adopt that price punch, because most people predict in that environment.
- 23:42Richard Brennan: Most traders, investors, they predict.
- 23:45Richard Brennan: They're using their function that evolved in the natural environment.
- 23:49Richard Brennan: And the markets they didn't evolve in.
- 23:52Richard Brennan: This is a different complex adaptive system.
- 23:55Richard Brennan: This is one where we've got intelligent agents.
- 24:55Richard Brennan: Everyone is intelligent.
- 24:57Richard Brennan: Everyone's got their own view, but they're using their predictive function.
- 25:01Richard Brennan: And this is where the problems arise in the market.
- 25:05Richard Brennan: Everyone thinks, well, why don't I survive in this market?
- 25:08Richard Brennan: And the reason is because the errors get too large to survive this negative SKU events.
- 25:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 25:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you're also describing, and I know you put this in, I can't remember which book, it's either in Complex Adaptive Markets or Um Fractals of Finance, but you you referenced Carl Friston, the free energy principle.
- 25:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what you just described there as we're trying to minimize that error, that gap between now we now this connects to consciousness and other things that we can potentially go into about markets.
- 25:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we've talked to folks uh a few weeks ago about this.
- 25:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That, hey, like I said, we've had Jerry Parker on here, we've had some other folks on.
- 25:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we've actually had uh Patrick Scotanis on here.
- 25:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think I mentioned that to you in the past.
- 25:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You did, you did.
- 25:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then we also have had uh Mooseviat on the show.
- 25:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I've got a couple other names.
- 25:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You had Mike Malise and I with Jerry.
- 25:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's right.
- 25:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's right.
- 25:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's right.
- 25:52Mark McGrath: Mike.
- 25:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 25:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and then one uh Larry Pisavano, so so a guy that uses fractals quite a bit.
- 25:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this might be a little woo-ish for people, but let's just get back to the first principles and the problem that's you're trying to solve here.
- 26:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And let's go back if we can.
- 26:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's wrong with the current dominant approaches in the market?
- 26:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What because that uh we haven't really defined the problem we're trying to solve with this.
- 26:12Richard Brennan: Okay, so this is if you can imagine I had my science strand going with my world and economics in business, etc.
- 26:19Richard Brennan: I saw this disconnect.
- 26:20Richard Brennan: This disconnect was telling me for some reason the economic model wasn't reflective of the science I was reading at the time.
- 26:26Richard Brennan: I was I was being sort of engaged by books like uh particularly the writers like David Baum, Albert Einstein, all of these.
- 26:34Richard Brennan: So all of these, the way the science was progressing, I believe there was this disconnect between the way economics was progressing.
- 26:41Richard Brennan: And I think the problem lies in the the traditional orthodoxy that the markets themselves are equilibrium-based systems.
- 26:49Richard Brennan: This is where it's totally, I believe, totally wrong.
- 26:52Richard Brennan: Because in an equilibrium-based system, which is a closed system that ultimately reaches an equilibrium point, there um it's not the market that is representative of the market we exist in.
- 27:04Richard Brennan: The market we exist in is what I call on the borders of chaos, and there's a particular reason for that.
- 27:10Richard Brennan: It's an open system.
- 27:11Richard Brennan: So agents, new agents come into the system.
- 27:14Richard Brennan: Central banks throw money into the si it's an open system.
- 27:18Richard Brennan: It's connected to firms, it's connected to economies, it's correlated to them, but don't have the same impression that the market is the same as the economy, because this is where we get this disconnect occurring with the rise of passive investment.
- 27:33Richard Brennan: These trends that keep on going, which totally disconnect from any notion of what the fundamental value is, because the assumption in in predictive world, where we assume that the markets are downstream of the economy, is that they must one must be sort of downstream of the other.
- 27:50Richard Brennan: If the economy is doing something, the markets ultimately must reflect that same thing.
- 27:56Richard Brennan: I don't think that's the case.
- 27:57Richard Brennan: They correlate, but I don't think that's the same case because what's driving the market is the reflexive nature of the participants in it and the structure of the market.
- 28:08Richard Brennan: It's this relational network of dynamism.
- 28:12Richard Brennan: It doesn't necessarily connect to the fundamentals.
- 28:15Richard Brennan: And we can see that because there's a lot of speculators in the market.
- 28:19Richard Brennan: They're not using fundamentals to invest in the market.
- 28:22Richard Brennan: Uh, we get uh random people that make random decisions in the market as far as having no connection, no correlation with the underlying market.
- 28:32Richard Brennan: They all impact the market.
- 28:34Richard Brennan: They all impact the market, but they're not necessarily reflexive in the economy they're representing.
- 28:39Richard Brennan: So I think the mistake is to assume that there is this direct correlated 100% correlated relationship between firms, economies, etc.
- 28:47Richard Brennan: They're all separate systems, and you've got to drill down into those systems to see where the reflexivity occurs, what's driving that reflexivity.
- 28:56Richard Brennan: Is it emotion?
- 28:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it emotion in the market that drives quite a bit?
- 29:01Richard Brennan: Emotion is a is a large factor.
- 29:03Richard Brennan: So if if you could imagine the symptoms of pain in the market terms, symptoms of pain is regret, it's not being on the big outlier, it's the I have a I have a predictive opinion that I am standing with.
- 29:18Richard Brennan: I'm prepared to ride that predictive opinion when the market is telling me something else.
- 29:23Richard Brennan: I'm prepared to average down into that opinion.
- 29:25Richard Brennan: And what that is doing is it's pushing you towards risk of ruin, it's pushing you towards exclusion from that system.
- 29:32Richard Brennan: I've I've done a recent series on my website which talks about the geometry of wealth.
- 29:37Richard Brennan: Now, bottom line for me as a trend follower, I'm in this for the game of geometric wealth.
- 29:43Richard Brennan: Now, what I'm saying is that the geometry of wealth is different to selecting the best assets.
- 29:50Richard Brennan: It's different to all of these things that require the predictive function to work.
- 29:54Richard Brennan: What the geometry of wealth is about is it's aligning the architecture with the system that it's embedded in.
- 30:01Richard Brennan: In other words, minimizing loss.
- 30:03Richard Brennan: So what that does is we all know uh the asymmetry that occurs in the geometric wealth path, because the wealth path is a multiplicative function.
- 30:13Richard Brennan: It's a Bayesian function.
- 30:15Richard Brennan: It's not, they're not independent arithmetic summations.
- 30:20Richard Brennan: This it's not a linear relationship.
- 30:22Richard Brennan: This is a Bayesian world we live in, where the controls, the controlling environment that surrounds the system is continually conditioning prize, conditioning prize, conditioning prize.
- 30:36Richard Brennan: And it's forcing us down a funnel of constraint.
- 30:38Richard Brennan: We can act within that constraint, but the system around us, the environment around us, is continually constraining us.
- 30:45Richard Brennan: We are but starlings in a flock of starlings that need to keep with the system.
- 30:51Richard Brennan: And we do that by applying local rules because we have no vantage to see the entire flock.
- 30:57Richard Brennan: We are doing what what do I need to do?
- 30:59Richard Brennan: I need to stay close to my neighbor.
- 31:00Richard Brennan: I need to have the similar speed as my neighbor, and I've got to avoid collision.
- 31:05Richard Brennan: Those are local rules, those heuristic local rules allow me to stay with the flock.
- 31:11Richard Brennan: I don't need this complete vantage, even though it'd be great, because then I could if if if I knew what the total constraint space out there would be, I'd have a very good chance of identifying what the next iteration of that constraint space is going to be.
- 31:25Richard Brennan: But I don't have that access.
- 31:27Richard Brennan: So I'm forced to use my local rules.
- 31:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You got me thinking about Starlings and then um breaking break breaking it down into it, you know, if you were to go in and break down how that works and look at the analyze each little bird, you're not going to figure it out.
- 31:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can't figure out that you can't and that's that's what we're saying about the market is you're wasting your time.
- 31:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I believe you're wasting your time, and I I'm preface this and make sure that's being generous, punch.
- 31:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You are wasting your time.
- 31:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'd I'd be a bit firmer there.
- 31:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, well, there's a lot of people that that are dependent on analysts breaking down the market.
- 31:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 31:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's okay.
- 31:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and actually the feedback I got from Keith on this was people need that.
- 31:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They want that.
- 31:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what they're attached to.
- 32:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'll give it to them.
- 32:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Again, you're most for the folks that work around Keith.
- 32:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He may not want you to know that, but I'm sharing that here with you now.
- 32:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I agree.
- 32:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: A complex adaptive system, you're wasting your time trying to break it down.
- 32:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, again, it could give you some comfort.
- 32:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It could help people out and go, This is what I need to hear in order to make this move and things like that.
- 32:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's a lot of fantastic connections here.
- 32:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose, I want to bring you in here, brother.
- 32:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Tell me what you're hearing based on your background in economics, Mises, everything that you got.
- 32:25Mark McGrath: Well, I mean, another classic case of having somebody describe orientation in Oodaloop sketch without having to know it or see it.
- 32:34Mark McGrath: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 32:35Mark McGrath: Yeah, a lot of parallels to the Austrian School of Economics, specifically around price as an ecosystem and you know, a living a living network thriving and living on on uh on price signals.
- 32:46Mark McGrath: Very resonant.
- 32:47Mark McGrath: Have you have you ever looked at things like Mises and Hayek?
- 32:50Mark McGrath: I mean, you're you're most I have.
- 32:53Richard Brennan: What excites me about this whole process is we are converging on ideas together, probably from different perspectives coming together.
- 33:01Richard Brennan: So that gives me a lot of confidence that there is a truth here.
- 33:05Richard Brennan: There is a truth here.
- 33:06Richard Brennan: But it's not just me, the writers that I've read, all of these things.
- 33:10Richard Brennan: There is this convergence going on.
- 33:12Richard Brennan: It's changing the paradigm, it's changing the way we see the world.
- 33:16Richard Brennan: You know, it's this continual sort of uh yeah, it's exciting having these dialogues because what I like about dialogue as opposed to diatribe is that uh it's the sharing of ideas.
- 33:27Richard Brennan: So I'm spinning off you, you're spinning off me, and I think this is a way forward, you know?
- 33:32Richard Brennan: Different vantages, if you like, different models and coming to a conclusion about how they all merge together.
- 33:39Mark McGrath: Yeah, it's also a lot of Marshall McLuhan, too, because I think of you know, the medium is the message, the market is an environment, and the environment has a direct effect on all the actors within it.
- 33:50Mark McGrath: And then as the as the technology continues to change and everything, you know, all that has a direct effect on on people that are acting.
- 33:58Mark McGrath: Yes.
- 33:58Mark McGrath: You know, it's all it's it's all still acting humans.
- 34:01Richard Brennan: Yeah.
- 34:02Richard Brennan: Yeah.
- 34:03Richard Brennan: Yeah.
- 34:03Richard Brennan: We we are actors giving our best guess, doing our best performance in a in a very uncertain world.
- 34:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm saying it's a simulation.
- 34:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if that's the case, then the market can be discovered and we can figure things out.
- 34:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And actually I want to push you on that.
- 34:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So fractals, the first book I had from you is again, it's uh the fractals of finance.
- 34:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's pretty solid.
- 34:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You get into uh fat tails, and most people look at Gaussian distributions, and that goes again, it's you know, flipping a coin and over and over, that gives you a Gaussian distribution.
- 34:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, but it's the interactions, it's the um the connections between things that matter.
- 34:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that gets you into a Pareto problem, into a fat tail zipla, a power law uh situation.
- 34:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And when we talk about risk management, we're not talking about Gaussian distribution type things.
- 34:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're talking about fat tails, and that's you know, Nassim Taleb talks about that quite a bit.
- 34:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But but most people don't know that that you can pay attention to those things in the fat tail through human sensors.
- 34:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Humans understand can sense things as long as they're allowed to stay connected to the world.
- 34:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and that's where your best bet is to pay attention to what people are sensing and not necessarily what your algos are telling you.
- 35:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, I'll flip that around.
- 35:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The way I understand trading uh now is one of the best things to do is follow a process, try to get your emotion out of it, and try to improve that process, that good process over and over.
- 35:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any thoughts on that?
- 35:13Richard Brennan: Yeah, so this is why I follow price, and this is why I'm calling it a non-predictive function.
- 35:17Richard Brennan: I've recognized the weakness in me, and this is the weakness of my career up until trend following, was adopting the predictive process.
- 35:25Richard Brennan: It meant that um, you know, depending on how, you know, the priors of that prediction, how strong that prediction was, would lead me into the most awful situations, things that um, you know, effectively totally crippled my wealth.
- 35:38Richard Brennan: So it was trying to find some heuristic, trying to find some shortcut to extract my predictive brain, which was always wanting to tell me otherwise, to a process that allowed this geometrical wealth compounding, this sustainable future, basically.
- 35:56Richard Brennan: And this is where I cottoned on to follow price.
- 35:59Richard Brennan: This is where we are so fortunate in this world of trading and investment to have this thing called price.
- 36:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So do you have a heuristic for this?
- 36:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm I'm curious.
- 36:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, no, me let me sure the so you already brought up the heuristic for birds.
- 36:17Richard Brennan: If if you can imagine your Oda principle, so what my my heuristic would be um first observe.
- 36:23Richard Brennan: So observe where uh my position is in relation to price.
- 36:27Richard Brennan: The next is orient.
- 36:28Richard Brennan: Now, in orient, I'm not predicting here, I'm simply orientating with price.
- 36:35Richard Brennan: So what that means is that um I'm also then doing an assessment of where my position relates to that benchmark.
- 36:45Richard Brennan: Is it is the error minimal?
- 36:47Richard Brennan: I'm always trying to minimize the error.
- 36:49Richard Brennan: So what I'm doing is then saying, right, well, according to my current orientation in price, if my error function is growing, I eliminate.
- 37:00Richard Brennan: I exit.
- 37:01Richard Brennan: And then what I do is I adapt my model.
- 37:06Richard Brennan: So once I've eliminated and adapt the model, I adapt my model back to aligning with the benchmark.
- 37:14Richard Brennan: So it's this continual trailing like a shadow.
- 37:18Richard Brennan: It's a bit like, you know, when you guys go on a forced route march at nighttime.
- 37:22Richard Brennan: The best way to do that is have the leader, someone holding his backpack, bum pack, have someone holding his bum pack, someone holding his bum pack, someone holding his bum pack.
- 37:30Richard Brennan: They're all following the leader.
- 37:32Richard Brennan: They're minimizing error when they're under uncertainty in the night, when they can't see where they're going.
- 37:38Richard Brennan: The leader is the one sort of orientating, and everyone else is following like a shadow, holding onto the bum pack, the forced route march at night time in the middle of, you know, a moonless night where it's totally dark, you can't see where you're going.
- 37:51Richard Brennan: I spent a bit of time in the reserves here in in Australia, and some of these things hold as dear memories, you know, and uh why why this process was thought of, you know, it was very clever.
- 38:02Richard Brennan: But anyway, so I don't want to get off too far off track.
- 38:05Richard Brennan: So I'm trying to minimize this, orientating with this benchmark.
- 38:09Richard Brennan: I am then, if I if the error is too large, I am adapting by exiting that position.
- 38:15Richard Brennan: What that is, is it's saying that is no longer, I'm no longer participating in that system because my error being minimal means that it doesn't ever get to the fat left tail of the distribution.
- 38:28Richard Brennan: So I'm not going into exponential world where I can never recover.
- 38:31Richard Brennan: Unfortunately, it's it's not a very fair world, this market.
- 38:35Richard Brennan: You find that a 50% loss means that you've got to recover 100% to get back to where you were.
- 38:41Richard Brennan: It's a very asymmetric sort of relationship in this system.
- 38:45Richard Brennan: And losses count.
- 38:47Richard Brennan: They really count to your geometric wealth.
- 38:50Richard Brennan: Because it's a multiplicative process, if you are compounding off $50,000, it's a lot less than compounding off $100,000.
- 38:57Richard Brennan: So the way that the geometry of wealth goes is it says, right, if you can minimize the loss function, you're halfway there.
- 39:06Richard Brennan: Because what that's doing is it's protecting the compounding function.
- 39:09Richard Brennan: And if you protect the compounding function, you're protecting the geometry of wealth.
- 39:14Richard Brennan: You're not getting these crippling events that significantly reduce your ability to generate wealth.
- 39:22Richard Brennan: But then on top of that, this is where the outliers come in.
- 39:25Richard Brennan: There is a beneficial geometry in markets, and this is where I talk about living systems exploiting their environment, not just passively sitting within it.
- 39:33Richard Brennan: Agents actively exploiting it.
- 39:36Richard Brennan: They are minimizing loss, but they are exploiting opportunity.
- 39:40Richard Brennan: This is where measures such as the Sharp ratio fail to observe this fact.
- 39:45Richard Brennan: But there is exploitation.
- 39:47Richard Brennan: For instance, if I say, what is the best geometric shape to grow compounding?
- 39:53Richard Brennan: And people say, Well, it's a straight line, they say.
- 39:56Richard Brennan: They say, if I have a non-compounded geometry that's a straight line, if I then compound that geometry, I get this nice exponential growth.
- 40:05Richard Brennan: What they're forgetting is that actually it's not the straight line.
- 40:08Richard Brennan: There is a better geometry than that.
- 40:10Richard Brennan: There is a geometry where you minimize loss, but then you get a massive step up, minimize loss, massive step up, minimize loss, massive step up.
- 40:21Richard Brennan: That, when compounded, produces a far higher compounded geometry than the straight line.
- 40:27Richard Brennan: So the sharp world, the world of normal distributions, the world lacking fat tau distributions, which we know is a misnomer because every single liquid market I've examined over sufficient data history displays these fat tau properties.
- 40:43Richard Brennan: It's telling us that the major causal reasons for change are not in the in the bulk of the curve.
- 40:51Richard Brennan: It resides in the towers of the curve.
- 40:53Richard Brennan: So your success as an investor over many cycles is dominated by a handful of events that occur in those tails.
- 41:02Richard Brennan: They are the most monumental changing environments you'll ever get.
- 41:08Richard Brennan: They can either destroy you, they'll destroy you if you hold in the opposite position to those tail responses, that will cripple you.
- 41:17Richard Brennan: Ruin.
- 41:18Richard Brennan: Goodbye.
- 41:18Richard Brennan: Or it could be the thing that explodes you into future opportunity if you're on the right side of them.
- 41:25Richard Brennan: When I look at the history of events over the course of time, and I look at, you know, successful investors, you know, I look at Warren Buffett and I say, well, you know, if Warren Buffett had to come to a conclusion, what was the reasons for your success, he would look over the course of his history and he'd say, I could probably list it on ten fingers, Coca-Cola or Amitar, occasional events, occasional things, the Pareto distribution.
- 41:48Richard Brennan: These are the things that drive his wealth.
- 41:51Richard Brennan: Also, Warren Buffett is successful because he's never been he's never compromised his geometry.
- 41:58Richard Brennan: He has he's allowed significant drawdowns to occur, but drawdowns are the price of participating in this particular market.
- 42:08Richard Brennan: It's the it's the price of admission into the market.
- 42:13Richard Brennan: I I view volatility as not being risk.
- 42:16Richard Brennan: Risk is permanent loss to your capital.
- 42:18Richard Brennan: That's that's what risk is.
- 42:20Richard Brennan: Volatility is that that's the shape of the markets.
- 42:23Richard Brennan: That's the shape of these fractal markets.
- 42:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I I I appreciate the uh the the the heuristics there.
- 42:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think we can refine these.
- 42:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm we're not going to do it today, but I think that I mean, this is what Moose and I've been talking about for a while.
- 42:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do want to challenge you on something, or or not challenge you, but I want to see if we can expand some thoughts here.
- 42:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So geometry, you know, when we talk about geometry of the markets, let's go to physics first.
- 42:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So um we you know, we've had Adrian Bijan on the show a couple times.
- 42:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We spent some time with him down at Duke.
- 42:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, we follow his books, and and you get into his books, he starts talking about the time and beauty, beauty being the you know, Febonacci sequence, the geometry that's harmonics in the universe that tell us that's attractive, that's ugly.
- 43:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, you look at Moose's face right now, he's got no, I'm messing with you, Moose.
- 43:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But the whole point is um the the universe, you know, going back to the orientation, we are predisposed to see things in certain ways in the universe, right?
- 43:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Music sounds good to us because music sounds good to us.
- 43:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's harmonic innate in us already, right?
- 43:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So why wouldn't that be true in the way we see things in the market?
- 43:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it possible that these and I had we've asked Carl First on this uh on the show actually, is it possible that these harmonics, this geometry exists that creates some type of attractor state that tells us that this is going to go there and then bounce off or it's gonna go higher and things like that.
- 43:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when you talk about geometry, that's the type of geometry we're we're questioning is does that exist in the markets?
- 43:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I believe it does.
- 43:43Richard Brennan: And so this is how I connect the dots here.
- 43:45Richard Brennan: So I view the world we inhabit as being finite but unbounded.
- 43:51Richard Brennan: And what I want to say there is that to produce what I view things as there's two ways to look at this world.
- 43:57Richard Brennan: One is what I call the the a generative frame, which is the frame adopted by people that uh adopt the reductionist argument.
- 44:06Richard Brennan: They look at, well, here is uh an organism.
- 44:09Richard Brennan: Let's drill down into the organism to see the organs, then the cells, then what constitutes the cells, the atoms, the this is what I'm I'm regarding as the this is the view we get from inside out the system.
- 44:24Richard Brennan: It is what I'm calling the explicate view.
- 44:27Richard Brennan: I'm going back to David Bomb here.
- 44:29Richard Brennan: It is the the structure we see as agents embedded in a system.
- 44:35Richard Brennan: Now that is half the view, because I believe that the reductionary argument doesn't include some of the most important things we see with complex adaptive systems, and that is the relationships between things.
- 44:49Richard Brennan: When you adopt the reductionary argument, you're looking at um the fundamental componentry, going down, going down, going down.
- 44:56Richard Brennan: You're missing the relationships, you're missing the correlations, you're missing the structure, the relational situation, you're missing the system, the whole.
- 45:05Richard Brennan: Because in a process driven system, process is what counts, and process creates residue, process creates outcomes.
- 45:14Richard Brennan: Outcomes are what we are seeing from this inside out perspective.
- 45:18Richard Brennan: We're seeing the outcomes, we're not aware of the greater process.
- 45:23Richard Brennan: So in David Baum's viewpoint, this is there is this implicate order, this order that is not accessible to those that are embedded in that system, but it is forming the constraints, it's forming the processes that can occur to create the structural residue that we see as the explicate form of that system.
- 45:45Richard Brennan: So the reason I'm going there is that I'm looking at things from a subtractive frame.
- 45:51Richard Brennan: I'm not looking at things from a generative frame because the way I view this universe is I don't believe that any uh when we're looking at the whole, the universe, we don't actually create anything genuinely new in that universe.
- 46:04Richard Brennan: To do so would mean we would need something being input into that universe.
- 46:09Richard Brennan: And we are already defining that universe as the whole.
- 46:12Richard Brennan: There is nothing outside it.
- 46:14Richard Brennan: There is absentia.
- 46:16Richard Brennan: It's not like uh some physicists who say, well, our universe arose from a quantum vacuum uh fluctuation, because I'm saying, well, that's a thing, that's a thing that exists to create that universe.
- 46:28Richard Brennan: Go back to board principles.
- 46:29Richard Brennan: What are we dealing with?
- 46:30Richard Brennan: We are dealing with what I call a pluripotent field, effectively, of that allows anything that's permissible within that context.
- 46:40Richard Brennan: So what I'm saying is it's deterministic.
- 46:43Richard Brennan: I'm saying it's finite, but the differentiation that unfolds in that universe from creating symmetry breaking.
- 46:53Richard Brennan: So symmetry breaking is a process where new systems are nested within new systems, within new systems.
- 46:59Richard Brennan: So we are seeing agents, the relationship between agents, creating this relational structure, which therefore deterministically decides how that system unfolds.
- 47:10Richard Brennan: That determinism is shaped by what I call an attractor.
- 47:13Richard Brennan: It's a bound state space constrained, but it evolves dynamically.
- 47:19Richard Brennan: And it comprises all of our vantages, which are personal vantages, are local attractors.
- 47:27Richard Brennan: We are constrained within our local vantage.
- 47:30Richard Brennan: The only way to change our vantage is to update our model.
- 47:34Richard Brennan: Create a new model, which creates a new attractor.
- 47:37Richard Brennan: When you bring all of these together, you get a massive state space, but it is constrained state space.
- 47:44Richard Brennan: Now, so what mathematics allows that situation to occur?
- 47:49Richard Brennan: Finite but unbounded.
- 47:51Richard Brennan: What is a mathematics?
- 47:52Richard Brennan: It's not like our traditional thoughts in physics where you know Einstein looked at the particular possible shapes or geometries of a universe that was infinite or finite or whatever.
- 48:03Richard Brennan: In this structure, an unbounded structure, the universe is still unfolding.
- 48:07Richard Brennan: So something allows infinite, infinite within a finite structure.
- 48:13Richard Brennan: That is a canter set.
- 48:14Richard Brennan: So in mathematics, that is a canter set.
- 48:19Richard Brennan: And a canter set is where we've got a finite interval, let's say between zero and one.
- 48:24Richard Brennan: And what you do is you reduce a you you subtract a segment from that canter set to create two segments.
- 48:32Richard Brennan: Keep on doing that, and you get infinite variation.
- 48:37Richard Brennan: There is it's a bit like uh you might have heard the Xeno's paradox argument.
- 48:42Richard Brennan: You will get infinite forms of differentiation potential existing in that canter set.
- 48:48Richard Brennan: That canter set sets up everything to be fractal in nature from the lowest level to the highest level.
- 48:55Richard Brennan: So fractals is the way the universe is telling us, well, this is how I've built this universe in fractal form because I don't have rulers, I don't have a timepiece, I'm not manufacturing this, I'm allowing this system to evolve, like from a seed to where it is now through iteration, model updates, iteration, model updates, iteration, model updates at all scales.
- 49:26Richard Brennan: This process we're talking about at the agent level, the reflexive nature between the system it's contained with, or or the vantage it's contained with, you will find there's a symmetry between the boundary of the vantage and what it contains.
- 49:43Richard Brennan: So this is a this starts coming to the world of John Wheeler, who is a very famous physicist who was very heavily involved in general relativity, and then also got very heavily involved in quantum mechanics.
- 49:57Richard Brennan: And he he drew this famous image of um an I.
- 50:02Richard Brennan: So there was a U representative of the universe.
- 50:05Richard Brennan: He drew a U being the universe, and there was this I on one of the legs of the U looking at the universe, and he says this is the participatory universe.
- 50:16Richard Brennan: And what I believe he was getting to is this relational arrangement that exists between agent and system.
- 50:23Richard Brennan: This reflective arrang and so that's fascinated me.
- 50:28Richard Brennan: And then he came up with an amazing um a couple of amazing things that are right in my territory.
- 50:33Richard Brennan: One is he said, the boundary of a boundary is zero.
- 50:37Richard Brennan: Now, to anyone listening to that, they think it's gobbledygook.
- 50:41Richard Brennan: But what he is expressing is the symmetry that exists between what what the container holds and the stuff that's within it.
- 50:49Richard Brennan: They are they are isomorphic representations, the same thing, one represented in structure, one represented in content or stuff.
- 50:59Richard Brennan: Now, when you start collecting these all together, you get this participatory universe.
- 51:04Richard Brennan: And uh you get what Wheeler Wheeler um uh anticipated at the beginning of this was a pluripotent condition called the Wheeler-de-Witt equation.
- 51:12Richard Brennan: It's starting to get into heavy physics here, but the Wheeler-de-Witt equation is uh an equation that represents the quantum mechanical state of the entire universe.
- 51:21Richard Brennan: And uh it's a state recognized by physicists as being logical, but it is a static state, a state that can't dynamically evolve.
- 51:30Richard Brennan: And I don't know how to get the dynamism, to get things rolling from this pluripotent state.
- 51:35Richard Brennan: But I'm I'm sorry, I'm I'm sort of I am digressing a lot in this and uh No, this is fine.
- 51:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh there's a you describe the Oodaloop perfectly.
- 51:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the Oodaloop is a nested thing, right?
- 51:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Agents interact with each.
- 51:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 51:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So everything you're you're bringing up in here is is uh resonates with us.
- 51:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't disagree with that, whatever, uh whatsoever.
- 51:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's it is nested, right?
- 51:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 51:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the the agent interacts with its environment, we get that.
- 51:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Most people don't understand that about the oodaloop.
- 51:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's a reason one of the things we have with the show is trying to course correct that.
- 52:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But one of the you know, one of the questions that we're gonna get asked, and why should a fund manager give a crap about this conversation on fractals and complex adaptive systems?
- 52:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What you know if they're if they're already making you know twenty, thirty million dollars a year and they're managing, you know, $1.4 billion, whatever it may be, right?
- 52:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why do they care why should they care about this?
- 52:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or should they?
- 52:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes, they should.
- 52:27Richard Brennan: Okay, if it if you hold evolution dear to your heart, which I do, Darwin's theory of evolution, magnificent.
- 52:34Richard Brennan: This is a this is a territory that just explains so much to me.
- 52:38Richard Brennan: And and the way I explain this universe is is like upscaling Darwin's theory of evolution to a fitness landscape, what survives, what dies.
- 52:46Richard Brennan: It's a test.
- 52:47Richard Brennan: The test that always occurs between the agent and the system they're embedded in.
- 52:51Richard Brennan: So why it matters is people have got to realize that they have evolved in this system, which is a complex adaptive system.
- 52:59Richard Brennan: And what it has done is it created certain certain features that people with using their brains can't escape from.
- 53:07Richard Brennan: They will always predict.
- 53:10Richard Brennan: And prediction was very effective in the natural environment because what it allowed it to do was to minimize that prediction error.
- 53:19Richard Brennan: Because if you waited for the event to occur, it's too late.
- 53:23Richard Brennan: The predator has already eaten you, the lion's already got you, the cheaters already jumped on you.
- 53:28Richard Brennan: So you've got to predict, you've got to be in advance of that, but your prediction has only got to allow for a small error.
- 53:36Richard Brennan: You can't afford that error to get large, but the benefit of prediction is it gives you uh an advantage.
- 53:42Richard Brennan: So what do you predict?
- 53:43Richard Brennan: You predict what your model is saying against what your senses are detecting from your observation.
- 53:51Richard Brennan: So we are magnificent measuring objects.
- 53:54Richard Brennan: That that's how we've evolved.
- 53:55Richard Brennan: You'll notice that the way we've evolved is all of our receptors are orientated outwards, our skin.
- 54:03Richard Brennan: You'll notice when you put a scalpel into your brain, there is no feeling in the brain.
- 54:07Richard Brennan: You don't feel your brain Hmm.
- 54:09Richard Brennan: I haven't heard that lately, so don't do that.
- 54:12Richard Brennan: Don't do that.
- 54:13Richard Brennan: But if you can imagine everything's outward, it's expressing the position of the agent within the environment.
- 54:20Richard Brennan: It's measuring, it's feedback.
- 54:22Richard Brennan: The feedback is saying, what is the error?
- 54:25Richard Brennan: What is the error?
- 54:26Richard Brennan: What is the minimize, minimize, minimize, minimize, and it's therefore if if it's wrong, it's got to do something with its model.
- 54:33Richard Brennan: It's got to update its model, it's got to clear it away, neuroplasticity, get the re neurons rewiring a different way.
- 54:42Richard Brennan: It's saying the measurement it's doing, and this is where we get to your controlled hallucination, it's creating a controlled hallucination of what it thinks is out there because it doesn't have full access to it.
- 54:57Richard Brennan: Everyone's doing it.
- 54:58Richard Brennan: Now, for the fund manager, every investor that is adopting a predictive function is doing that.
- 55:06Richard Brennan: Now the problem with the markets is that it isn't an environment we've evolved in.
- 55:13Richard Brennan: It is a manufactured environment comprising agents ourselves, who are very intelligent.
- 55:19Richard Brennan: So if you are adopting the predictive function, it's a bit like your warfare.
- 55:24Richard Brennan: You've got to outthink, outclass, outbeat the strategies that your enemy are doing.
- 55:30Richard Brennan: That's how the predictive function works.
- 55:33Richard Brennan: But is there a heuristic you can use to resolve that, to reduce the predictive error of dealing with uncertainty?
- 55:40Richard Brennan: I'm saying yes, there is in trend following world, we just follow the price.
- 55:44Richard Brennan: Um, because that that price is a recognition of all of the different vantages, their views, their collective opinion.
- 55:51Richard Brennan: Um, you can't go wrong.
- 55:54Richard Brennan: It's saying, if I follow this benchmark, you know, what other system do you know where you're given a guiding benchmark like that?
- 56:02Richard Brennan: I don't know any.
- 56:03Richard Brennan: I don't know any.
- 56:04Richard Brennan: So I'm thinking you all s well, yeah, take the back.
- 56:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All systems try to do that, but that generally anytime you put a measure out there, you measure the wrong thing and you fail anyway, right?
- 56:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 56:12Richard Brennan: There are so many variables to deal with using our prediction engines, which we've got to do.
- 56:17Richard Brennan: We've got to do.
- 56:18Richard Brennan: And you know, a good example is and our prediction engines are a result of our causal path.
- 56:24Richard Brennan: Everything we've learned along the way, everything that's biased us, that really defines our mental model.
- 56:30Richard Brennan: Read a lot of um Lisa Feldman Barrett, if you you might have um read about her, like Anil Seth, the brain is a prediction engine.
- 56:37Richard Brennan: Uh, she puts a very good point here.
- 56:39Richard Brennan: The point here is that a person, a man who developed, evolved, born into conflict, always conflict.
- 56:48Richard Brennan: That influenced the way he saw the world.
- 56:51Richard Brennan: And after that period he was in a in a jungle, and he noticed that um there was a person ahead of him who was holding a stick.
- 56:59Richard Brennan: Now, he didn't see it as a stick.
- 57:01Richard Brennan: His prize was so fixated on that conflict situation he interpreted that as a gun.
- 57:07Richard Brennan: So he killed that person, but that person was holding a stick.
- 57:11Richard Brennan: It shows how powerful the brain is in creating this controlled hallucination that is different to what the actual situation was.
- 57:23Richard Brennan: And and something I want to get away from, and this is this is always interesting to me, is I want to get away from the notion that there is a separate fundamental reality because I believe the complex adaptive system, the way the agents interact with their neighbors, the network of relations, that is a reality.
- 57:42Richard Brennan: There is no separate fundamental stuff.
- 57:45Richard Brennan: Right, right.
- 57:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's this is important.
- 57:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um when we bring up a boundary, and uh, we know that in free energy principle and active inference, they put a boundary, it's a statistical boundary, it's just so we can define what's on the inside and what's on the outside.
- 57:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There are no boundaries.
- 57:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And people find this hard to believe.
- 57:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's no boundary between all of us right now, right?
- 58:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're all one, if you want to call it that.
- 58:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 58:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Some people get go, that's a little too woo-ish for me.
- 58:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, well then how does Wi-Fi work?
- 58:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, you know, I'll throw that out there.
- 58:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But it is entirely possible that all of us are communicating with each other and we don't know it, and we're projecting price of the market out there, and we're reacting to that.
- 58:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And this is what we talked to Jerry Parker about this briefly too.
- 58:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, the trend falling to me is is is a subset of of something bigger that needs to be discovered.
- 58:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know what it is yet.
- 58:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have ideas.
- 58:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Same thing that I think uh uh Keith McCool is doing at Hedgehog.
- 58:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He found a subset of something bigger and it's still working, right?
- 58:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not saying it doesn't work, I'm just saying I think there's more.
- 58:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know if it's a lot of things.
- 58:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I view it as life punch.
- 58:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 58:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's it's an we're we're evolving towards something.
- 58:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh as well, I'll just call it as traders now, that there's something more out there.
- 58:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The moment we say this works best right now, it works, it's a good practice at the moment until we find something better.
- 58:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what I think we're having a conversation about is what what more can we do based off all these first principles that we've been thrown around, that we're trying to understand that a that a you know, five girls playing basketball is no different than 15 members or or three teams working together on a product, it's no different than the market, right?
- 59:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a it's a fractal, it's a complex adaptive system.
- 59:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It is.
- 59:12Richard Brennan: So if we take these don't think all we can do is observe and orient.
- 59:19Richard Brennan: Um so imagine this.
- 59:21Richard Brennan: So if, for instance, the system was resolvable, in other words, if for instance, I was in a position where I knew what everybody else was doing, let's say I'm this mythical figure, this omnipotent figure that um could observe everybody's actions.
- 59:38Richard Brennan: I could resolve what happens next, but that is physically impossible because I'm bound in that system.
- 59:44Richard Brennan: I'm a participant in that system, my vantage is limited.
- 59:47Richard Brennan: I don't have it's a bit like I am not sitting in a laboratory with a laboratory coat looking at a glass box, and inside there is a system operating.
- 59:57Richard Brennan: That is a passive observation from outside the system.
- 1:00:00Richard Brennan: Um, in that, the physics often does problems like that, but it forgets a point that in the reality that we exist in, we are embedded in that system.
- 1:00:10Richard Brennan: There is a reflexive component of it.
- 1:00:11Richard Brennan: Now, as soon as you introduce reflexivity into anything, prediction goes out the back door because you need to know what every other participant, their vantages, and what their behaviors are going to be.
- 1:00:24Richard Brennan: And what I say is the future is unknowable.
- 1:00:28Richard Brennan: Because what I'm saying is the future is constructed each iteration.
- 1:00:32Richard Brennan: It's not like if I had better data, if I had better technology, if I could examine this system more closely, I could get better at what I could do.
- 1:00:42Richard Brennan: And I think that's what most industry looks at.
- 1:00:44Richard Brennan: They employ quant divisions, research teams, analysts, as you call it, to try and assess a fictitious future that doesn't exist.
- 1:00:53Richard Brennan: So what I'm saying is that it's not like the future is hidden in fog.
- 1:00:59Richard Brennan: It's there, but if I remove the fog with better models, better data, I will see things clearer, I'll be able to predict further.
- 1:01:07Richard Brennan: That's not how this system works.
- 1:01:09Richard Brennan: This system is iterating and unfolding with everybody's vantages, the reflexive nature of the system, stepping forward, stepping forward.
- 1:01:17Richard Brennan: The future is unwritten.
- 1:01:19Richard Brennan: It's it's continually being written as we're unfolding in it continually.
- 1:01:24Richard Brennan: To appreciate that, you realize prediction is only a very short-term measure.
- 1:01:31Richard Brennan: It's a bit like uh predicting the weather, in that you might have a very narrow window, assuming nothing goes wrong, assuming the system's stable configuration plays out in a short window, you've only got a very short window.
- 1:01:46Richard Brennan: If you try and go further than that, the path, you know, um this is where, you know, people like uh, you know, with a butterfly effect, small changes, small impacts can create nonlinear massive changes.
- 1:02:00Richard Brennan: It can totally change your path in the attractor.
- 1:02:03Richard Brennan: So getting back to it, I've got this view of this deterministic system, which have these paths that are being cut.
- 1:02:10Richard Brennan: Now, these paths are never replicating themselves.
- 1:02:14Richard Brennan: They follow the attractor, but it's a bit like you know how we talk about the three-body problem?
- 1:02:19Richard Brennan: You know how we say, well, physics is very easy to understand when we've got a two-body problem, but add a third body in there, it becomes a lot harder.
- 1:02:27Richard Brennan: Now, complicate that by putting millions and millions of agents there, all with advantage.
- 1:02:34Richard Brennan: It's impossible to decipher.
- 1:02:37Richard Brennan: You know, three-body problem was something that took so long to resolve, how to how to work that out.
- 1:02:42Richard Brennan: Three bodies.
- 1:02:44Richard Brennan: Millions of agents, my goodness me, impossible.
- 1:02:48Richard Brennan: But we do know certain things.
- 1:02:50Richard Brennan: We know we know how the system expresses itself through certain cues, certain things we can observe with our models.
- 1:02:59Richard Brennan: What is the volatility?
- 1:03:01Richard Brennan: What is the sensitivity of that market?
- 1:03:03Richard Brennan: What was it you know, the research I've done um with my data is that I've observed, as Mandelbrot did, that all of the markets have fat tails.
- 1:03:14Richard Brennan: They all have this Parito principle in effect.
- 1:03:17Richard Brennan: What this is showing is that change is not gradual.
- 1:03:20Richard Brennan: It's punctuated, a bit like uh evolutionary history under under Steve um not not um not Dorked, but um punctuated equilibrium.
- 1:03:28Richard Brennan: That's the thing.
- 1:03:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I was gonna say that and punctu so punctuated the way I the way I learned punctuated equilibrium is a scroll flying, you know, like a scroll jumping out of a tree and flying.
- 1:03:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's punctuated equilibrium.
- 1:03:39Richard Brennan: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:03:40Richard Brennan: So, you know, we get volatility clusters.
- 1:03:43Richard Brennan: What we know is that high volatility begets high volatility.
- 1:03:47Richard Brennan: There is memory in the market.
- 1:03:49Richard Brennan: The memory, it outlasts.
- 1:03:51Richard Brennan: It lasts for periods of time.
- 1:03:53Richard Brennan: Quiet begets quiet.
- 1:03:55Richard Brennan: High volatility begets high volatility.
- 1:03:58Richard Brennan: It's fractal.
- 1:03:59Richard Brennan: There's memory.
- 1:04:00Richard Brennan: So when I say memory, I'm not talking about it's got a brain.
- 1:04:03Richard Brennan: I'm talking about the same memory that exists when you look at a river system.
- 1:04:07Richard Brennan: So if you look at a river system, you see the sedimentary layers of the banks, you see that there were periods of flood, there are periods of quiet, there is memory in the market.
- 1:04:18Richard Brennan: And what that memory does is it shapes what can happen next.
- 1:04:22Richard Brennan: It constrains what can happen next.
- 1:04:24Richard Brennan: And I see this in the market.
- 1:04:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And to me, that would be the attractor landscape, the affordances in the environment that allows us to take action.
- 1:04:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Exactly.
- 1:04:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And whoever who I think those people that can find those attractors in the market, and that's where I'm saying I think the next level of this all goes, is is we get an advantage.
- 1:04:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And right now This is this observation punch.
- 1:04:45Richard Brennan: So if you I spent some time with the indigenous Aborigines of Australia, it was a wonderful time.
- 1:04:51Richard Brennan: I followed one of the elders as we walked through the landscape, and he he pointed to this particular wattle, which is a tree in Australia.
- 1:04:58Richard Brennan: We have a particular wattle tree, and he said, I said, the trout will be swimming in the river over here in this particular section.
- 1:05:04Richard Brennan: And I thought, what is this?
- 1:05:06Richard Brennan: This is observation.
- 1:05:07Richard Brennan: This is looking at relationships.
- 1:05:09Richard Brennan: This is his knowledge that the blossom would attract a particular type of insect that would then collect in this particular area of the stream that would then attract the trout.
- 1:05:19Richard Brennan: It was his observation of the his situational assessment that allowed him to orient with it.
- 1:05:26Richard Brennan: Um that's what this is, I think we're talking about here, Ponch.
- 1:05:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I think so.
- 1:05:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: To me, that would be the harmonics within the ecology that allows that to happen is if you pay attention to those things, and I think it's actually a lower energy approach as opposed to what's happening now, where we take all these folks and try to figure things out, break it down.
- 1:05:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's another way.
- 1:05:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you sit back and just look at how ecology, you know, the environment works, it goes, okay, how does this all flow together?
- 1:05:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Those folks that see that in the market are going to be at it have an advantage.
- 1:05:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I what I understand, what I understand right now is very few people do uh the work, you know, follow the work that uh uh Jerry does and follows the work that Keith does.
- 1:06:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we talked to Keith, he's like, hey, we're we're way ahead of everybody at the moment.
- 1:06:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh he's like, there's most people in the market can't put their heads around this.
- 1:06:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm sure those that are listening to this, they go, you guys are out of your mind.
- 1:06:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, everybody knows there's a way to do this, and that's the way we're gonna do it.
- 1:06:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I hear the same thing in basketball.
- 1:06:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, there's a dominant approach, everybody follows the same thing.
- 1:06:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, there's actually a better way to coach, there's a better way to do things.
- 1:06:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's all we're asking is if you challenge the assumptions and go, okay, what is what do the first principles say?
- 1:06:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And how do we build up on those?
- 1:06:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what we're asking, and that's why we're having this conversation.
- 1:06:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose, uh, thoughts from you?
- 1:06:33Mark McGrath: Yeah, I mean, my mind's going in a million directions because it resonates with so much of what we talk about across uh, you know, Boyd, McLoon, Austrian economics, complex adaptive systems.
- 1:06:45Mark McGrath: And I agree with you.
- 1:06:46Mark McGrath: And uh, Richard, I'm glad you affirmed this is that you know, managers, even if they're doing well, traders, even if they're doing well, if they become more aware of these things and learn them deeper, that they can only be even more successful than they already are.
- 1:07:02Richard Brennan: I think so, Moose.
- 1:07:03Richard Brennan: Yeah.
- 1:07:03Richard Brennan: It's been a humbling exercise.
- 1:07:05Richard Brennan: I entered this game with a predictive mindset because I I thought I was right.
- 1:07:09Richard Brennan: I thought I knew everything.
- 1:07:10Richard Brennan: I thought I knew which way the market would go.
- 1:07:12Richard Brennan: But I think Jerry, Jerry, I'm glad you mentioned it.
- 1:07:16Richard Brennan: He's been my mentor.
- 1:07:17Richard Brennan: So we have done.
- 1:07:18Richard Brennan: Dialogues like you guys have dialogues, and I'll listen to Jerry, I'll then revise my opinion, I'll say something, he'll do the same.
- 1:07:26Richard Brennan: We we feed off each other.
- 1:07:28Richard Brennan: Um I think that I was very attracted to Jerry's process.
- 1:07:31Richard Brennan: When you first listen to Jerry, um, a lot of people when they first listen to Jerry think it can't be that simple.
- 1:07:37Richard Brennan: It really can't be that simple, is it?
- 1:07:39Richard Brennan: But when you look at the track record, when you look at the track record of trend followers in general, you realize that it is simple, but where the difficulty arises is preventing your mind from hacking the process.
- 1:07:52Richard Brennan: Because my mind, the hardest thing to do, as simple as the rules are, is to stick with the process.
- 1:07:58Richard Brennan: The mind always wants to override it.
- 1:08:01Richard Brennan: You've got it's it's a very ugly strategy for to resolve the mind.
- 1:08:07Richard Brennan: Things don't occur all the time.
- 1:08:09Richard Brennan: You can't get immediate cash flow at every particular point in the time, even though fund managers will say you can.
- 1:08:15Richard Brennan: Their success or failure is is dictated by their performance return over a year or whatever.
- 1:08:21Richard Brennan: If they don't achieve the necessary performance, they're out.
- 1:08:23Richard Brennan: That's not how the markets work.
- 1:08:25Richard Brennan: The markets might have been quiet for their particular strategy for a year.
- 1:08:28Richard Brennan: Their fault, they were doing the right process, but they've got the incentives in the industry is totally wrong.
- 1:08:35Richard Brennan: The economics of the industry, equilibrium-based systems, Gaussian distributions, that's a world that doesn't exist.
- 1:08:43Richard Brennan: It's a world that when you examine the markets, it's a wiggly world, as Alan Watts would say.
- 1:08:47Richard Brennan: You know, it's not this smooth world, it's a punctuated world inherently nonlinear, but it is deterministic.
- 1:08:57Richard Brennan: And I just want to go back to Pont.
- 1:08:58Richard Brennan: Why do these patterns, mathematical patterns, appear called fractals?
- 1:09:03Richard Brennan: Well, in a deterministic structure with an infinite bound, those patterns are continually being repeated by the systems that are basically bound by the constraints of that finite attractor.
- 1:09:17Richard Brennan: If you can imagine I started with a canter set, I would expect all of the structural configurations of the systems that are defined by that canter set will be fractal in structure.
- 1:09:28Richard Brennan: Why is the golden ratio so prominent?
- 1:09:31Richard Brennan: Well, it's part of that fractal structure.
- 1:09:33Richard Brennan: It's not like why do these mathematical patterns appear so frequently in all of the different systems I observe?
- 1:09:40Richard Brennan: That's telling you something about the commonality between the evolution of that system and its rules-based iterative process.
- 1:09:49Richard Brennan: The commonality of it is because it doesn't use rulers, it doesn't use timepieces, it uses fractals.
- 1:09:57Richard Brennan: The Mandelbrot set.
- 1:09:58Richard Brennan: The Mandelbrot set to me is a set of survival.
- 1:10:03Richard Brennan: In other words, when you look at the coastlines of Britain, when you look at the coastlines of Australia, fractal in nature, what does that mean?
- 1:10:10Richard Brennan: It means that this iteration at all scales has been carving a geometry of success elimination, success elimination, this continual process that these agents are doing, this geometry is being carved and it's growing.
- 1:10:25Richard Brennan: So each is creating a solid foundation for the next step.
- 1:10:29Richard Brennan: And in this system, we don't get anything new coming in, but we do get emergent structure coming out.
- 1:10:37Richard Brennan: And this emergent structure is built on foundations, how the agents all interact, creating emergent structure.
- 1:10:44Richard Brennan: So then when I look at technologies like stealth technologies, all of the technologies that humans believe are innovative, I say, Well, it's actually not innovative.
- 1:10:54Richard Brennan: You're using what the octopus used for its camouflage.
- 1:10:56Richard Brennan: It's been discovered.
- 1:10:58Richard Brennan: Yeah.
- 1:10:58Richard Brennan: It's already there.
- 1:11:00Richard Brennan: Nature is deploying it.
- 1:11:01Richard Brennan: It's a reuse, it's emergence.
- 1:11:05Richard Brennan: There is no new generation.
- 1:11:06Richard Brennan: So when we look at things from a reductionary perspective, we're always looking for the cause.
- 1:11:11Richard Brennan: What caused that?
- 1:11:12Richard Brennan: What caused that?
- 1:11:13Richard Brennan: What caused that?
- 1:11:14Richard Brennan: That's this reductionist view we have as agents with a limit advantage.
- 1:11:18Richard Brennan: What caused this structure?
- 1:11:19Richard Brennan: It must be a new structure, etc.
- 1:11:21Richard Brennan: But it's not.
- 1:11:22Richard Brennan: It's a subtractive frame.
- 1:11:24Richard Brennan: What's carving the structure, the residue, what's carved, the process is carving all the time.
- 1:11:30Richard Brennan: And the process creates part dependence.
- 1:11:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's a there's another aspect in here, and I learned this through uh Alan Green, who's been on the show, talking about constants.
- 1:11:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you know, the constants are are found throughout the universe, not because we came up with a map, but just because they're constants, right?
- 1:11:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're out there.
- 1:11:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So yeah, Fibonacci is one, and you get into Euler number, you get into others, and you get into harmonics too.
- 1:11:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's why we were saying this is these are things that are naturally occurring within the pyramids or naturally occurring within the platonic solids, they're naturally occurring everywhere, right?
- 1:11:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if these things are happening, they're happening for a reason.
- 1:11:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And again, I don't think we have to understand why.
- 1:12:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh hopefully I'm following you on that.
- 1:12:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But if we understand what, what's going on, then we can apply that to just about anything we do.
- 1:12:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I uh you know, we you and I had a brief conversation about uh the platonic space, things that are defined in biology, which again connects to everything we talked about.
- 1:12:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's not to say that we, you know, that theory is it's not 100% yet, but they're they're looking at, hey, there's other things out there that we need to consider as to why our cells divide and what those cells end up doing in the in the first place.
- 1:12:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I don't think anything you're saying is um out of the ordinary.
- 1:12:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'd I'd I'd say that most people won't have a damn clue what the hell we're talking about, man.
- 1:12:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh no, I probably for us.
- 1:12:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:12:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But but that's okay for us because okay, now now let's flip the script.
- 1:12:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you know, Moose sent me a note earlier, he's like, why do we do anything but we should just be trading all the time?
- 1:12:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, I I kind of agree, but we that's not the world I came from in the internet.
- 1:12:48Richard Brennan: Yeah, we should be philosopher's punch.
- 1:12:49Richard Brennan: We should be uh well we should be sitting here having these conversations.
- 1:12:53Richard Brennan: That's what keeps me going.
- 1:12:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm sure people are going, why are you why aren't you guys billionaires?
- 1:12:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the answer is really simple, because I'm doing other things.
- 1:12:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I told Keith this and others this I'm like, I don't trade.
- 1:13:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't sit around and trade.
- 1:13:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I when I have time, I do, and I make money following a process.
- 1:13:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the moment I put my emotion into it, I screw things up.
- 1:13:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So um follow the process, and there's other things you can do.
- 1:13:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose and I had a conversation last week last week with somebody we met uh up in Connecticut, and he asked me, you know, how do I trade off of um a uh a process that Keith does?
- 1:13:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I said, Well, it's easy, you know, low end of the range, if I'm close to it, I buy.
- 1:13:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: High end of the range, I sell.
- 1:13:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, that's it.
- 1:13:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It doesn't get any easier for that, easier than that for me.
- 1:13:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, but it's hard to do, right?
- 1:13:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because it's because your emotions get in the way.
- 1:13:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Man, that bright.
- 1:13:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There are days you don't need to trade, right?
- 1:13:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You just go, uh you gotta walk away and there's nothing I need to do today.
- 1:13:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna go do something else.
- 1:13:41Richard Brennan: Yeah.
- 1:13:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But yeah.
- 1:13:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:13:43Richard Brennan: So some some people think that we're always in the market.
- 1:13:46Richard Brennan: Trend follower isn't always in the market.
- 1:13:48Richard Brennan: So if you imagine we've got a very diversified system, what we're doing there is we're scouting for opportunities because we know in this fat-tailed world that every single market displays these properties, but we know that we can't predict in advance, but we know that they exist.
- 1:14:02Richard Brennan: We just don't know when.
- 1:14:04Richard Brennan: So our diversified model spreads this massive net.
- 1:14:07Richard Brennan: And people say you're diversified because you're trying to reduce your risk, the volatility of the profile.
- 1:14:12Richard Brennan: No, I'm trying to spread opportunity.
- 1:14:14Richard Brennan: So I'm spreading opportunity across the fractal structure.
- 1:14:18Richard Brennan: So if you can imagine, I'll give you an Emmy.
- 1:14:20Richard Brennan: If we accept that the markets have a fractal structure, imagine something that does have a fractal structure, like a tree, and we've got a very large trunk and then branches that come out that then go to twigs, that then go to leaves.
- 1:14:36Richard Brennan: So that is a fractal structure.
- 1:14:38Richard Brennan: So if we only have a very small sample over that tree, the chances are we're gonna get not the dominant trunk, we're gonna get the leaves, a small section, things that don't offer much opportunity for us.
- 1:14:54Richard Brennan: But if we spread our diversification net across the entire market, which is what we're trying to do with our trend following models, we get access to more of the structure, the the the trunks, the things that really move the needle.
- 1:15:10Richard Brennan: So when we look at fractal structures, we realize something very important.
- 1:15:14Richard Brennan: The assumption under Gaussian geometry and under the bell curve is that as we increase our diversification, we dilute our edge.
- 1:15:23Richard Brennan: That that's the assumption under diversification.
- 1:15:26Richard Brennan: It's because they say if you spread your net too widely, you uh slowly start um diluting the edge associated with the trend following.
- 1:15:37Richard Brennan: We say no, that's not the case.
- 1:15:38Richard Brennan: But when we expand our net, we're actually getting greater access to the fractal structure.
- 1:15:44Richard Brennan: So because it's a non-linear landscape, we don't know what's going to be the next big move.
- 1:15:51Richard Brennan: And just to put this into context, you know that we were writing the co a lot of trend followers are writing the cocoa trade uh a year and a half ago, two years ago.
- 1:16:00Richard Brennan: That was a move I think that went from 2,000 US dollars per ton up to 12,000 US dollars per ton or even further, and then came back.
- 1:16:10Richard Brennan: So in relation to the rest of the portfolio, that was such a monumental lifting exercise.
- 1:16:17Richard Brennan: If you were on the right side of it, that lifted your portfolio up, all concentrated on one event.
- 1:16:23Richard Brennan: It's a bit like when I say to Warren Buffett, he said, That's my Coca-Cola amateil of my diversification.
- 1:16:31Richard Brennan: That did all of the heavy lifting to pay for so many of the small losses I was prepared to tolerate across the rest of my portfolio.
- 1:16:41Richard Brennan: That was the thing that drove my geometric wealth path up.
- 1:16:45Richard Brennan: Now, if I had reduced my diversification, because people were telling me, oh, as you increase diversification, you're you dilute your returns.
- 1:16:53Richard Brennan: If I'd done that, I wouldn't have been in COCO, I'd have been in the commons.
- 1:16:57Richard Brennan: That's right.
- 1:16:58Richard Brennan: The currencies, SP, whatever.
- 1:17:00Richard Brennan: Expanded my net over all of these.
- 1:17:02Richard Brennan: I had access to that opportunity.
- 1:17:04Richard Brennan: That is the pareto effect of this distribution.
- 1:17:08Richard Brennan: So the diversification is one part.
- 1:17:11Richard Brennan: The second part is minimization of error, cutting losses short.
- 1:17:15Richard Brennan: That's what cutting losses short means.
- 1:17:17Richard Brennan: Minimization of error between the model and and and the system by following the benchmark.
- 1:17:23Richard Brennan: Letting profits run is saying, I don't know what is gonna how long these things are gonna last for.
- 1:17:30Richard Brennan: I might be I might be at the intersection where the trunk of the tree is fattest.
- 1:17:35Richard Brennan: This might be a doozy.
- 1:17:36Richard Brennan: This might be something I could never anticipate, never predict.
- 1:17:40Richard Brennan: So I'm not going to let my brain hack me.
- 1:17:43Richard Brennan: That brain is always trying to hack me.
- 1:17:44Richard Brennan: Every time I cut losses short, it's hacking me, saying, you loser, you loser, you loser, you loser.
- 1:17:50Richard Brennan: But what I'm saying is, hey, it's process man, it's process man, it's process man.
- 1:17:55Richard Brennan: I'm not losing.
- 1:17:56Richard Brennan: I win geometrically because I know, looking at the data, I know that they have fat tail properties.
- 1:18:02Richard Brennan: I don't know when.
- 1:18:03Richard Brennan: So I've got a process that is overriding this stupid predictive mind that's getting me into so much trouble.
- 1:18:10Richard Brennan: Most investors and traders out there who have this stupid predictive mind, they get themselves in trouble.
- 1:18:16Richard Brennan: And when you look at the track record of successful investors and why you see this massive amount, 30, 50 plus funds that have outperformed Buffett.
- 1:18:26Richard Brennan: I'll repeat that.
- 1:18:28Richard Brennan: 30 to 50 funds, trend following funds that have outperformed Buffett in terms of their their Ma ratio, their risk adjusted return, their geometric profile.
- 1:18:39Richard Brennan: They've outperformed them.
- 1:18:40Richard Brennan: Not much is sung about these people.
- 1:18:42Richard Brennan: Not many people know about it.
- 1:18:44Richard Brennan: A few people know about the Turtle Trader Experiment, a few people know about Jerry, few people know about Ed Sakota, a few people know about some of the names you might hear in industry.
- 1:18:54Richard Brennan: But most of the industry refuses to accept that we exist.
- 1:18:59Richard Brennan: And the reason is because they're built on this premise of this economic orthodoxy of equilibrium-based systems, Gaussian distributions, analysis, data analysis, Black Shoals model.
- 1:19:11Richard Brennan: These are all based on this fundamental present premise of a Gaussian distribution, which is fundamentally flawed.
- 1:19:18Richard Brennan: But the industry has progressed it.
- 1:19:20Richard Brennan: Why have they progressed it?
- 1:19:21Richard Brennan: It's because it gives them a degree of confidence because they can calculate it.
- 1:19:25Richard Brennan: It's simplistic to calculate.
- 1:19:27Richard Brennan: It's not like nonlinear equations.
- 1:19:28Richard Brennan: This is simplistic to calculate, but it gives them confidence that they've got something they can track, they can monitor, they can put into a spreadsheet, they can convince investors, but this isn't the way the market works.
- 1:19:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We call them merchants of certainty, right?
- 1:19:43Mark McGrath: That's a great decay and the merchants of certainty.
- 1:19:46Mark McGrath: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 1:19:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But that's that's normal.
- 1:19:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So they're taking an ordered system approach, which is comfortable.
- 1:19:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We all like it, and we're applying it to an unordered system.
- 1:19:53Richard Brennan: Investors understand it.
- 1:19:53Richard Brennan: They go, oh yeah, that must be off.
- 1:19:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:19:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I I think, again, I think we're getting lucky.
- 1:19:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Not hate say lucky.
- 1:19:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we're connecting to folks that understand this, and we're all trying to learn from each other.
- 1:20:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Like, okay, what do you see and how are we doing?
- 1:20:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because we're not taking any way anything away from each other by going, hey man, I don't I don't necessarily agree with that 100%, but I think we can do more.
- 1:20:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know?
- 1:20:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna I'm gonna borrow that and take this and see what I get out of it and look for a higher probability of a kill, just like we'd use with an aim seven sparrow or uh, you know, an aim 54 missile coming off a jet.
- 1:20:20Richard Brennan: It's your world just amazes me.
- 1:20:23Richard Brennan: Uh and and I'm gonna be doing a lot more listening to it.
- 1:20:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's it's very interesting.
- 1:20:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We appreciate it.
- 1:20:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I definitely want to have more conversations with you, and I don't want to I don't want to leave at the moment.
- 1:20:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do want to kind of wrap some things up because we've been going for about 90 minutes, uh, and I'll turn it over to Moose here in a second.
- 1:20:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So big picture.
- 1:20:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Grateful for Keith uh McCullough for uh talking about books.
- 1:20:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you're not familiar with his work, I'm talking to our audience out there.
- 1:20:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:20:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Please check out his work, what he does with this in markets.
- 1:20:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not saying he's right all the time.
- 1:20:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I we you know, I I I love challenging him on stuff.
- 1:20:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I hey man, look at this.
- 1:20:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do do me a favor, look at this.
- 1:20:53Richard Brennan: By the way, Punch, I loved your your video uh of your recent Hedgeye Live.
- 1:20:58Richard Brennan: That was fantastic.
- 1:20:59Richard Brennan: Just wanted to say that.
- 1:21:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I talked about attractors in there and fractals.
- 1:21:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah, I was listening.
- 1:21:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I was ticking the boxes as you're going through.
- 1:21:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Some psychedelics and and some trauma.
- 1:21:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's basically an orientation on the Oodle loop, but just to go through it, but we never brought up the Oodle loop.
- 1:21:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so these are the folks that are impressive to me, are the ones that are looking at complex adaptive systems and asking, hey man, are we doing this right in in our environment?
- 1:21:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you know, is our context really an ordered system?
- 1:21:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'd say, no, it's not.
- 1:21:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Teams are not ordered systems, they're complex adaptive systems, and that's why we take the lessons from complex adaptive systems and apply them to teams.
- 1:21:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you can do that, if you can learn ecological dynamics, if you can learn things like the constraints-led approach and apply it to coaching, you're going to dominate.
- 1:21:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And by the way, you're going to find something better if you go down that path too, right?
- 1:21:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what I think you know, having Jerry Parker on here, you know, on the conversation, and even Larry Pescevento looking at how he does work with uh fractal geometry uh in the market, it's pretty pretty spectacular.
- 1:21:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But most people push back on that because it's not mainstream.
- 1:21:56Richard Brennan: Yeah, well, that's one of you.
- 1:21:57Richard Brennan: They think it's woo, and the only reason they think it's woo is they're so disconnected with the process.
- 1:22:01Richard Brennan: If they understood the process what we're talking about, they'd see as there's a logical foundation, you know.
- 1:22:08Richard Brennan: This geometry we're talking about is a consequence of being a deterministic system that has a state space that's confined.
- 1:22:15Richard Brennan: Therefore, you will get repeating mathematics under that arrangement.
- 1:22:18Richard Brennan: It's natural to expect that.
- 1:22:20Richard Brennan: So interesting.
- 1:22:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So hey, I talked to Dan the other day.
- 1:22:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I understand uh you might be going to uh join Keith on TV.
- 1:22:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that sound right?
- 1:22:26Richard Brennan: I hope so.
- 1:22:27Richard Brennan: So yeah, yeah, Dan Dan sent me an email and I'm looking forward to that one.
- 1:22:31Richard Brennan: So uh I hope uh Keith is uh gentle on me.
- 1:22:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, no, he's he's he's fun to hang out with.
- 1:22:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh let me let me do this.
- 1:22:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna turn it over to Moose to kind of have us have him wrap this up and take us out, Moose, and and take us where you want to go, Moose.
- 1:22:43Mark McGrath: Well, I mean, I think it it's been said it can't be said enough that you have to look at these things and talk about these things, and these are the things that people should be dialoguing on, and lest the uh the the things that are in the mainstream that are designed to poison your your brain and your and your intellect and and and create dissonance between how you operate in capital markets and and how you interact with reality.
- 1:23:06Mark McGrath: And I think that when people, as I was saying earlier, and we say this all the time, the the better that you understand what we teach, the more effective that you can become.
- 1:23:18Mark McGrath: And that's how you get the geometric results.
- 1:23:20Mark McGrath: And even if you're getting the the results now and you still don't know these things, digging into them is only going to get you better results.
- 1:23:29Richard Brennan: Exactly.
- 1:23:30Richard Brennan: You talked about harmonics before.
- 1:23:32Richard Brennan: The reason why harmonics is so attractive to us is because it's a sign of coherence.
- 1:23:38Mark McGrath: It's all around us, whether we like it or not.
- 1:23:40Richard Brennan: You know, I hear a tune that's harmonic to me.
- 1:23:43Richard Brennan: It might be different to how a Japanese person will interpret their music.
- 1:23:47Richard Brennan: I might just see, you know, see it a bit different.
- 1:23:50Richard Brennan: But to me, it's something that's very coherent to my worldview.
- 1:23:53Richard Brennan: That's why it's attractive to me.
- 1:23:55Richard Brennan: That's why um people talk about beautiful symmetry, um, the perfect symmetry.
- 1:24:00Richard Brennan: This harmonics, based on the fact that we are causally nested in a system and we are part of that system, and the harmonics brings up memories of the past.
- 1:24:11Richard Brennan: I'll listen to beautiful music and it'll bring me back to my childhood.
- 1:24:14Richard Brennan: It'll bring me back to these this is all this coherent causal train of connections, and the harmonics is because it is is coherent with the frequency of which my ter my map has been created inside this vast terrain.
- 1:24:30Richard Brennan: That's how I'm saying it.
- 1:24:32Mark McGrath: Could not have said it better myself.
- 1:24:34Mark McGrath: It's all around us.
- 1:24:35Mark McGrath: As we say this all the time, it's all around us, and you're subject to these things whether you care or not.
- 1:24:40Mark McGrath: But the when you take the interest to learn it deeper, you only you only become better at what it is that you do, regardless of what you do, but especially in capital markets, because you know, there's very few places other than war fighting where the state of flux is as is as palpable as it is in markets.
- 1:24:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I admire guys.
- 1:24:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Difficult.
- 1:25:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Those are past.
- 1:25:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So where can our uh listeners find your work?
- 1:25:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh what's what do you have out there?
- 1:25:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh by the way, I I accidentally found your second book.
- 1:25:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I didn't know you had a second book yet.
- 1:25:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Gotcha.
- 1:25:09Richard Brennan: Okay, so yeah, I've I've got that second book.
- 1:25:11Richard Brennan: Uh so Fractals of Finance was well, actually, my first book was uh a co-written piece with Adam Havrelev, who um I I work uh for East Coast Capital Management, which is a fund manager in in Sydney.
- 1:25:23Richard Brennan: I'm their what they call a strategy ambassador.
- 1:25:25Richard Brennan: So I co-wrote a book with Adam called Um it was under the Aussie Turtles brand.
- 1:25:30Richard Brennan: That's a project I'm I collaborate with Adam on, called The Aussie Turtles Trend Following Guide.
- 1:25:37Richard Brennan: That also has a foreword from Jerry, but that's about the process of trend following.
- 1:25:41Richard Brennan: Then the fractals of finance was something I wrote to start my foray because it is continuing.
- 1:25:47Richard Brennan: I've got some more books planned.
- 1:25:48Richard Brennan: Fractals of Finance started looking at the fractal structure, Benoit Mandelbrot, starting to introduce readers to my mindset.
- 1:25:57Richard Brennan: Because as you you guys know, um when people listen to us, they think we're coming from herbly-gurbly land out there, they they can't get the connection.
- 1:26:05Richard Brennan: If you follow the path of thinking, you slowly cohere.
- 1:26:09Richard Brennan: So The Fractals is the first book, Complex Adaptive Markets is the second book.
- 1:26:13Richard Brennan: That's giving a structure underneath the fractal position.
- 1:26:16Richard Brennan: Um, it talks about um a lot of what we've talked about here.
- 1:26:19Richard Brennan: It's called Carved by Impossibility.
- 1:26:21Richard Brennan: Carved by and possibility is starting to look at things.
- 1:26:23Richard Brennan: I've talked to you about what I call the generative frame and the subtractive frame.
- 1:26:27Richard Brennan: Carved by impossibility looks at um the subtractive frame.
- 1:26:31Richard Brennan: It's trying to interpret from David Bomb's perspective the overriding system, the constraints that create part dependence, um, and what we observe as as agents within that system.
- 1:26:43Richard Brennan: And then the later book will be the determined universe.
- 1:26:48Richard Brennan: And this is because fundamentally at the moment, my viewpoint is sitting on a view of what we call superdeterminism, but I don't I don't necessarily think we should all get into that.
- 1:26:59Richard Brennan: But it's basically saying it it's coherence all the way down, it's causality all the way down, nested systems.
- 1:27:06Richard Brennan: There is no randomness.
- 1:27:07Richard Brennan: Randomness is a term that doesn't exist in my universe.
- 1:27:11Richard Brennan: If there was randomness, we'd get what we call a halting problem with iterative functions, and if we get a halting problem, we get a cessation.
- 1:27:19Richard Brennan: End of that system.
- 1:27:20Richard Brennan: To actually be here now, sitting in this position here, there has been no randomness in our causative past.
- 1:27:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 1:27:29Richard Brennan: Also, it it sits firmly with my view of what I call a covariant universe.
- 1:27:34Richard Brennan: Why, for instance, I can sit on this planet Earth and do physical experiments and expect the fact that if I go to Andromeda Galaxy, sit on one of those planets, perform those same experiments, why are those experiments going to do the same thing or express the same thing?
- 1:27:51Richard Brennan: Why are the laws, why are the things we have in this universe all so consistent to create a covariant universe?
- 1:27:58Richard Brennan: This is something that Einstein basically promoted Einstein's thoughts away from this static universe, Newton's universe.
- 1:28:05Richard Brennan: Um, that deter that the that was more like a mechanistic universe, very much like where economics up until about the 90s and 90s, before complex adaptive systems were accepted, that's where economics sort of is more Newton's universe.
- 1:28:18Richard Brennan: Einstein brought the picture of the dynamic relationships between the container and the content, space-time and the stuff, the dynamical relationship there.
- 1:28:27Richard Brennan: This is where reflexivity started coming into the argument.
- 1:28:30Richard Brennan: And then as you drill down into the quantum mechanics argument, you see that the questions are still, you know, out there.
- 1:28:36Richard Brennan: What is the wave function?
- 1:28:38Richard Brennan: Is it uh limit of our knowledge or is it an ontological object?
- 1:28:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I always tell Moose that uh economics, what it did for me, it gave me the ability to read energy maneuverability charts that were designed for an ordered system.
- 1:28:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um it's that's the best thing economics has ever done for me, man.
- 1:28:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But hey, Richard, uh appreciate your uh your time today.
- 1:28:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It is uh it's a big time difference between where we are on the East Coast and in the U.S.
- 1:29:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: and where you are somewhere in Australia.
- 1:29:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But thanks so much for being with us.
- 1:29:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're in Brisbane, right?
- 1:29:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm Brisbane.
- 1:29:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's right.
- 1:29:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, Brisbane.
- 1:29:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep.
- 1:29:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 1:29:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well again, thank you so much.
- 1:29:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're gonna keep you on here for a moment.
- 1:29:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh this has been a fascinating conversation.
- 1:29:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're gonna have more with you soon because I think.
- 1:29:18Richard Brennan: Conch, I I love chatting about this sort of stuff.
- 1:29:20Richard Brennan: So m more the more the merrier.
- 1:29:22Richard Brennan: And listen, something I did forget to say, you can catch me on atstradingsolutions.com.
- 1:29:26Richard Brennan: That that's my website.
- 1:29:28Richard Brennan: It's called the Traders Outpost.
- 1:29:29Richard Brennan: Um, this is where I do a lot of this writing.
- 1:29:32Richard Brennan: So if people want to follow my train of thought, get on there.
- 1:29:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, thanks again.
- 1:29:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks for uh being here on No Way Up and uh we'll uh keep you on for a few moments.
- 1:29:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks.
- 1:29:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thank you.