Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / ‘Good’ Hopelessness and Spiritual Death
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, Paul Levine and welcome to another conversation about
- 0:06major Buddhist principles and what we add to the conversations
- 0:12about that with the added value. I think, is that we reflect more
- 0:17on the psychological aspects on? We often enough.
- 0:20We leave the spiritual or purely purely Buddhist realm to become
- 0:26more, pragmatic or more inquisitive even of What those
- 0:31fancy sounding concepts mean or can mean to us which leads us to
- 0:38today's topic which is hopelessness and hopelessness
- 0:43and death. Correct?
- 0:45And Pema, chodron gives it already very different spin for
- 0:50her. Hopelessness is a good thing
- 0:53just as a very quick introduction and its Peak View
- 0:57into what awaits us in our discussion.
- 1:00Today. So with that introduction,
- 1:02please. Go ahead.
- 1:04Alrighty, so this is a topic that I think I'm really excited
- 1:10to talk to you about because I had so many issues with this
- 1:16topic and I would love to sort of just go in depth with I'll
- 1:21just give a very brief introduction summary of what she
- 1:25says when you say is hopelessness and Duck and what
- 1:28she means by it. And then I have my big question
- 1:33which To meet. Like, I genuinely disagree with
- 1:36the topic, from the bottom of my heart.
- 1:38So passion passion, like it is like, I wish I could like yeah,
- 1:46it is, it it costs so much anxiety and issues when I tried
- 1:51thinking about it. So so going off topic but
- 1:56hopeless and done essentially what she's saying is give up,
- 2:00hope that insecurity and pain can be exterminated.
- 2:04Dated and relax with groundlessness of the situation.
- 2:08Then we can relax with where we are and who we are.
- 2:13And she also says Buddhism, aka the thermal concept around
- 2:17Buddhism is not the concept of oh, I leave it to Buddha my
- 2:23problems to Buddha, you know how Christianity.
- 2:26And any other God based religion.
- 2:29We are like, oh, I leave it up to God, but she said in Buddhism
- 2:34when He said, follow the Dharma. We're not saying Fall, leave it
- 2:38up to Buddha, but it is, we need to appreciate impermanence and
- 2:43change. We need, we it is Dharma
- 2:48according to Buddhism as the total appreciation of
- 2:51impermanence and hope. And she also obviously says
- 2:57suffering is part of life, which I all.
- 3:00I don't agree with that tenant tenets of Buddhism.
- 3:05And and she's and to me, my question today is primarily, you
- 3:12know, when they announced hope that we could be better like the
- 3:18entire if I renounce hope that I could be better.
- 3:22What's what's the point of it all to me?
- 3:26That's my question for the day for you today, as a Buddhist
- 3:29yourself. What do you think about that?
- 3:32Yes. First of all, I don't know if
- 3:33I'm a good artist, but For some people.
- 3:36I Am. So You Think You Are Well, for
- 3:41me, it's a big source of inspiration.
- 3:44But I'm, I'm, I'm very on edge with a lot of traditional
- 3:51interpretations of Buddhism. And even in the kind of
- 3:53professional Buddhist Forum where I engage in discussions
- 3:57with I by no means represent the mainstream and overly Critical
- 4:02with with many aspects of how things I interpreted so that
- 4:05just on the side. So yes premature twins.
- 4:09Conceptualization is At hopelessness is necessary for us
- 4:13in order to arrive into the present, take responsibility for
- 4:18our life. Because if we have hope that
- 4:21something will improve in the future, then we already give
- 4:27away our power. Then we already stopped being
- 4:32responsible for ourselves, and we somehow hope that some other
- 4:36entity and she brings in other deities.
- 4:39For example, the day We'll take care of it.
- 4:41Right? Like you said.
- 4:42Yeah. Yeah, I think the main mistake
- 4:48that she does here is that she implies?
- 4:53I think she means something very specific but then uses a term
- 4:57that is so common, which is Hope or hopelessness.
- 5:00And that for me is am is mistaken writing when I take a
- 5:06word like that. Hope and hopelessness so much
- 5:08out of context as it's you. We used, I think one has to
- 5:12prepare the ground more than what she does.
- 5:16Because if not, then it's exactly what you experienced.
- 5:20I run to the danger of misinterpreting and
- 5:23misunderstanding of what she, what she's aiming at.
- 5:27So, do you? So you as a Buddhist, as a
- 5:30practicing Buddhist agree that we need to give up, hope that
- 5:36it's insecurity and pain can be exterminated.
- 5:40That we give up a very specific. Hope, not.
- 5:43All hope. This is where the mistake is for
- 5:45me. There are many kinds of Hope.
- 5:49Okay, so we can go into that. And then I'm going to just ask
- 5:52you, I am highlighting that because I think I have questions
- 5:57around that and then also relax with groundlessness of
- 6:01situation. We need to be okay with
- 6:03impermanence. Do you agree with that as a
- 6:06statement? Let's come to that a little bit
- 6:08later. So I'll go first.
- 6:10Adding commenting on the Hope thing.
- 6:12Yeah, sometimes I work with clients and they have a
- 6:17principle of hope that I think fits here.
- 6:20They think the, the job that I have right now sucks, and I'm
- 6:25applying for another one and I hope that the other one will be
- 6:27better. Yeah, this relationship sucks.
- 6:30I plan to end it but I think the next one will be better.
- 6:34I have it in my guts somehow and then you know, my kind of more
- 6:39complex. This question is, what are you
- 6:41sure, that you're not contributing anything to as it
- 6:43is now, I mean if you don't I mean sometimes it is like that,
- 6:47right? Sometimes we just have horrible
- 6:50work environments and everyone suffers from that.
- 6:52So, yes, the the derived hope that the next Position will be
- 6:57better is founded grounded, legitimate somehow, but if you
- 7:02are, if even if I pick up certain habits in this bad work
- 7:09environment, Runs, right. I become very passive.
- 7:12I became become some all anxious to make suggestions to make
- 7:17mistakes and so on. So, even if I have kind of, if I
- 7:21picked up these habits and transfer them to a new job.
- 7:25It will not be a good job, right?
- 7:28So I have to do more than just hope that the next thing will be
- 7:32better as than it is. Now I moved to Australia here
- 7:37was completely unhappy. I'm sure and it will be better.
- 7:40Better in Australia, and then my question is like well, how how
- 7:44do you justify your hope? It's not based on anything.
- 7:47This is really just like praying or something.
- 7:51So this is a kind of hope that I think is dysfunctional and
- 7:54stands in my way rather than asking myself.
- 7:56What do I contribute to that? Or what would be a mistake in
- 8:00the next environment? The next place that I live the
- 8:02next job. The next relationship that I
- 8:04have to be careful about because I might have under the current
- 8:08bad circumstances. Might have picked up habits that
- 8:11will be detrimental to the well-being in the next
- 8:15situation. So that's interesting because I
- 8:20I went Journey say like that, right?
- 8:22Like this expecting that the next job or moving from u.s.
- 8:26To Poland in terms of I gave which actually was really good
- 8:31because I met you, but but how do you if you don't try another
- 8:38job or if you Don't even like you.
- 8:41I have to have hope because if I don't try How will I know?
- 8:44Then? I'm just saying.
- 8:46Oh, I'm going to stay stuck in this situation.
- 8:49Right? Like, how do you know?
- 8:51What's the right balance? I don't think it's a balance
- 8:55thing. I mean, if someone isn't sure to
- 8:56drop situation, by all means, change the job.
- 9:00And now, there's another job and it's still not.
- 9:04Exactly. But, you know, don't think that
- 9:07just switching will fix everything.
- 9:10This is not usually how things work.
- 9:14Okay, if I spend enough time in a bad environment, there will be
- 9:19a residue in my mind. Somehow.
- 9:20I will have picked up bad habits because I wasn't encouraged.
- 9:25I wasn't a huge word. I wasn't acknowledged for what I
- 9:30did. This is that does not that
- 9:35leaves marks, you know, this hurt the king in all that,
- 9:39right? This will not just disappear.
- 9:42Because I adjusted to that somehow, I learned some
- 9:44strategies to duck down or to be super safe or to work too much
- 9:50or whatever strategies are employed.
- 9:52I did that during the time in order to survive in this
- 9:55environment. Now, what I did, this
- 9:58compensation is so to speak, the gravity that will will keep me
- 10:06on the planet in the next job as well.
- 10:09My mind will have the tendency to repeat the same.
- 10:11Same thing even though intellectually kind of
- 10:14unprepared for the next good thing.
- 10:17Right? There would be a tendency there.
- 10:20I'll sneak peek of of my own patterns that I had picked up as
- 10:26a previous job to, okay? Like, to learned helplessness,
- 10:29right? It's a comment.
- 10:30If, you know, if I was beaten as a kid by my parents, then I will
- 10:36not just forget about it when I'm 18 and move out and go to
- 10:39university. Of course, it will leave a
- 10:41damage in my mind. Right?
- 10:43I mean that's the whole thing with with issues that people
- 10:46work on is residues from the paths of bad.
- 10:49Isis. So in a miniature version on,
- 10:52it's not that dramatic. But to move to a new place, a
- 10:55new country, a new work, new relationship.
- 10:59I just, I'm not saying that it's necessarily has to be the case,
- 11:02but it wouldn't surprise me. If I, in order to make the best
- 11:07out of the next situation I needed to work on eradicating
- 11:12the past effects. Over compensations that I have
- 11:16to learn. So on, that does not just
- 11:19disappear. Usually.
- 11:23Yeah, I see what you're saying and correct me.
- 11:27If I'm incorrect. I'm trying to think of this as
- 11:29one of my one of my friends colleagues.
- 11:33Who who's on her? I think fixed marriage.
- 11:36I think we've mentioned that. I've mentioned that in the past.
- 11:39She keeps like like she's held her job longer than she's held
- 11:43her husband. Yes, and he's going on her
- 11:47number five and she keeps changing thinking, this might be
- 11:51the one. So, How would she approached
- 11:54the? How should she thought of pink
- 11:56about? Those are approach it?
- 11:58Yes. So here we have a very clear
- 12:01case when there is a pattern. There's an established pattern.
- 12:06So I changed three three jobs and I ended up being bullied in
- 12:12each one of them. Right, maybe in the first one.
- 12:15It was, It was kind of clear because the boss was a bully.
- 12:18But in the second and then the third one, I was more and more
- 12:23baffled because nobody else seems to have been bullied.
- 12:29That was me somehow, or the thing with always picking the
- 12:32wrong Partners, right? That's, that's something that we
- 12:34know from ourselves, May hopefully not.
- 12:37But there are people around us who kind of seemed to get along
- 12:42with the wrong people all the time.
- 12:44And then when I smell a pattern after a semester, wait a minute,
- 12:48there's there is something that I contribute to that, it becomes
- 12:53less, and less probable with each case.
- 12:55It becomes less and less probable.
- 12:57That it again was a One's a dense that I was picked, right?
- 13:02So then you know, to with a twinkle of the eye, then the
- 13:08universe is telling me something.
- 13:10Yeah. Yeah, and then I realize that I
- 13:13am, I am the like, I'm the common factor in whether it's,
- 13:19you know, in those relationships are exactly, yeah.
- 13:23So then what you want to just hope that the next one would be,
- 13:28it gets more. And more foolish.
- 13:29Look at my six times to say. No.
- 13:31The next one will be better than I'm really.
- 13:33No, it will not. You are doing something.
- 13:37Okay. So what am I going to do?
- 13:43They, of course, it's a complex psychological thing.
- 13:47It's, of course about change. But, let me pick up a formula
- 13:54that actually penetrate alone uses.
- 13:57And this virtue, same chapter, the metaphor of letting
- 14:01something died within me. So that's vague.
- 14:07It's I see the hope that the next marriage or the next job is
- 14:14going to somehow miraculously solve all my problems that
- 14:20particular home should definitely yes.
- 14:23And more than that. This is something that payment
- 14:26doesn't get into so much I think, but I would add that from
- 14:30a psychological perspective and don't just let the Hope died.
- 14:35I also let the part of me died that has that hope. what I mean
- 14:41with that is I'm not tired to point that out.
- 14:45In contrast to normal psychology.
- 14:47We are fundamentally fragmented beings.
- 14:50We are not just a solid block of meanness or ins.
- 14:56That would, you know, move homogeneous lie in One
- 14:59Direction, smoothly know there are dozens of parts and us, that
- 15:05pull us in different directions and want different things.
- 15:07And many of those are incompatible and they leave the
- 15:11me. That is the Part of me that has
- 15:14to decide after all, were to go, literally where to move.
- 15:18If to stay in the job of to leave.
- 15:20If to, If this relationship is unsatisfactory enough to leave
- 15:25or to stay and to give it another try, all those decision
- 15:29makings right there are many parts and me that are pulling me
- 15:33in different directions. And sometimes it's really
- 15:36complicated to figure that out. There are many, many minimis in
- 15:41that sense Within Me. And, you know, it from corporate
- 15:45culture. It's by now.
- 15:46It's quite normal that when a big company opens a new project.
- 15:51They actually open a new account for that, right?
- 15:54Yeah. That's that's a very common
- 15:56thing. And I suggest to take this image
- 15:58and just say, that psychologically, something very
- 16:01similar happens. So I think about moving
- 16:04apartments, right? At that moment.
- 16:07I create a mini me that is, you know, it's kind of focused on
- 16:10that task and it It's kind of a life and that sense that it has
- 16:17its own kind of features. It's focused on a very specific
- 16:21task. And if I now let's say I pick
- 16:25the apartment and then I move actually, I have to let this
- 16:30thing die. It's time.
- 16:32It sold. What, what?
- 16:33Day this mini, this task of moving if I don't and I continue
- 16:39to carry that within me, right? I Will so that me was
- 16:45responsible for deciding, which apartment is good or not, right
- 16:49for the money location. And yeah, for the value, you
- 16:52know, you know the phenomenon I can move.
- 16:55I made my decision, I moved and then I get into fault-finding
- 16:58mode. Oh, this window, I should have
- 17:02added as shit. That's so much worse than what I
- 17:04thought and the neighbors are loud and so on.
- 17:07So I didn't let this kind of choosing I the mini me die.
- 17:13Keep it on it. Fulfilled of /, its purpose.
- 17:17And I have a right and then I'm still that still is still in the
- 17:23mode off. Is that the right apartment?
- 17:25I'm there. It's done.
- 17:27I can open a new account for moving again.
- 17:30But to just keep this thing on and to wonder if that was the
- 17:33right move and still expensive bad location and so on, that is
- 17:37the foolishness thing. And that is funny cuz you
- 17:40actually mentioned that comment because we are we are me and my
- 17:43partner and the process of moving to a new apartment.
- 17:47Dress and know that and yeah, and it's funny because like, you
- 17:51know, I went into this whole, you know, how nobody I am but I
- 17:57looked for different apartments. I couldn't find like absolute
- 18:01ten out of ten. Perfect, but I found two one
- 18:04that was like 9 out of 10, right?
- 18:09And the or eight out of ten really?
- 18:11But like the minute I chose it but me and my partner had
- 18:15immediate regrets. And we're like, What if we have
- 18:19to move again in 18 months because it doesn't have a
- 18:23balcony and it doesn't have floor-to-ceiling Windows because
- 18:27we really wanted that. And so what do you mean by like
- 18:34letting that project died or like letting that identity of
- 18:40you know, the person who's like hoping that the nuts apartment
- 18:44would be better because that that is kind of Necessary and I
- 18:48yes, I will try and and I do immediately get into
- 18:52fault-finding mode so I can make my.
- 18:54And the reason I do that in all honesty, in my head is I want
- 18:58the next thing, then my next apartment in 18 months, to be
- 19:02even better than the apartment of like, renting.
- 19:05Like that. I'll start to rent income.
- 19:07Yes. Yes.
- 19:09Okay. Now I think it's a good example.
- 19:11We're not too far off the topic on the book here.
- 19:15So you keep it there, right? Just for the sake of making sure
- 19:20that the next time things are, okay.
- 19:23Okay, but you do that, this is what you described now, big
- 19:28pictures. So it's kind of an open account,
- 19:32right? There's still information flow,
- 19:34big pictures. You have hundreds of these in
- 19:36your mind. This is not the only thing that
- 19:42you have open just to make sure that next time, it's like, you
- 19:47know, the rummage plays, the, the storage room where it's,
- 19:50like, who knows if I use this machine, maybe why to throw it
- 19:53away? I might need it. so we have
- 19:58those things in our mind and from the Starting point where I
- 20:06am already fragmented. Mhm.
- 20:10I proliferated that fragmentation.
- 20:12And there is a kind of accumulate more and more minimis
- 20:16with their own mini accounts and everything becomes heavier.
- 20:20My life has become, you know, it's there's so many
- 20:23associations that are going on. One thing happens five or ten of
- 20:28the open accounts kind of Pop up and have their say, and pull me
- 20:33again in different directions and it just becomes very
- 20:36confusing, an exhausting. Yes.
- 20:39It does. Absolutely because I'm like, oh,
- 20:42I should have known not to do this.
- 20:44Like, for example, I did this process of moving apartment
- 20:49about two years ago. And at that time, I had a
- 20:51full-on less needs to be Southeast face things.
- 20:54I can have sunlight needs to be in Hoboken, New Jersey, which is
- 20:58a, you know, very nice neighborhood and all of that.
- 21:03And the minute I moved him like shoot.
- 21:05I didn't consider that. I also wanted a balcony.
- 21:08Oh, I didn't consider that. I also wanted a bigger square
- 21:11footage or a coat closet because I forgot that and and I was
- 21:16miserable the past money here around the apartment.
- 21:21So I see what you're saying is like if you just if for the next
- 21:25move, I just say, you know what, this is what it is in 18 months,
- 21:29I live. Ali.
- 21:30Wait, what? I'm going to what I need in my
- 21:33next apartment. Yeah, I should just do it at
- 21:36that time rather than the minute I moved there because they'll
- 21:39just is that what you think? This is what I'm saying?
- 21:42And of course there's a cost to that if I keep it open the
- 21:46account and invest cognitive energy into it.
- 21:49So I would just everything that is great or not.
- 21:53Great with the apartment. Of course, there's some benefits
- 21:56of that righteous, the conscious deliberation that we select like
- 22:00Again, in the big picture, probably I did not do that and
- 22:07of consciously on a purpose to leave it open but out of habit.
- 22:11So it's just one more thing next to the other, you know, the
- 22:15older we get and we don't get into the habit of closing these
- 22:19accounts. They stay open and the older, we
- 22:21get, it gets more and more exhausting because I'm carrying
- 22:25a cognitive apparatus apparatus around, that becomes more and
- 22:29more. Heavy and more, and more kind,
- 22:31of fragmented or more. And more things are calling for
- 22:35attention or registering things food, and life, and
- 22:40communication, and intimacy, everything becomes problematic.
- 22:44Because I don't want to forget the mistakes that I've ever
- 22:47done. Which again, is something that I
- 22:52do want to do. I do not want to make my whole,
- 22:56I do not want to make the same set of mistakes over and over.
- 23:00Over again, which is why I need to have hope that things will be
- 23:04better like in my mind. That is the whole reason why you
- 23:08keep these things open because it is imperative in life that we
- 23:13don't make the same freaking mistakes over and over again.
- 23:17I don't make the same mistake of like by getting into another
- 23:22wrong apartment. Yeah, in 18 months.
- 23:25So there is a benefit to it too. Right right.
- 23:28There is the benefit. Now, let's look The alternative.
- 23:31Now it's let's say we have not discussed how but I let it die.
- 23:36Actually. I close the account and this
- 23:38mini me is dead and gone. That does not mean that it's out
- 23:44of the system. What it means is that I trust my
- 23:48unconscious to provide me with enough information.
- 23:51It will not have the same level of details as when I do it.
- 23:54Consciously those deliberations, right, but I kind of, I trust
- 23:59that my unconscious will Give me the basic gist of what I don't
- 24:03want to forget. I delegated, right?
- 24:07So they let it die means. I trust that my unconscious will
- 24:11give me enough information. Next time when I move without me
- 24:17continuing the list, the conscious list all the time.
- 24:21So on Whose shoulders should it be this?
- 24:24Wait, I think the unconscious is the place where it belongs.
- 24:28Basic trust that I will. Number two, main things or, you
- 24:33know, write it on paper or in an Excel sheet and then forgot
- 24:37about that you can put it in the cloud and then you have access
- 24:40to that. But when I can do, I can leave
- 24:43it in the Excel rather than what is fun.
- 24:46Because in the brain, it gets heavy and tiresome.
- 24:50Exactly. Okay, because Consciousness is
- 24:53not made for this. Consciousness is best when it
- 24:57can dedicate a lot of cognitive energy to very Eschews.
- 25:01And then to use all this differentiated intelligence that
- 25:04the unconscious doesn't have to do my nude calculations.
- 25:08This is what Consciousness is. And but you overburden it with a
- 25:12hundred open accounts, and a hundred minimis with all their
- 25:15own agendas and all their own targets and goals.
- 25:19Then we must use the system for something that it's not made
- 25:23for. Okay.
- 25:26Okay. So now that makes sense, but I'm
- 25:31going to come back to the question of this person who is
- 25:34switching jobs as switching marriages now for them to say
- 25:39okay, you know what there is a problem within me and I need to
- 25:44fix that rather than trying to change my marriage and my
- 25:49apartment changed my job. Now.
- 25:53Let me figure out what Do I need to do from there?
- 25:58But to do that, you do need to then observe this current
- 26:02situation and say, okay. These are the things that need
- 26:05to change. In the next relationship and
- 26:11all. So what do we do?
- 26:12We go from there them. Well, it has to start with some
- 26:15sort of look from the outside, right?
- 26:21It can ask a coach. I can ask my sometimes and
- 26:26bigger companies that are person people that we can talk to some
- 26:30tutors mentors. Someone who's not directly my
- 26:34boss, right? Yeah, and then We'll ask that
- 26:38question. So how do you deal with that?
- 26:40How to do that and so on? Because I need to come to think
- 26:43of things that I have not thought about before.
- 26:45That's the challenge here, right?
- 26:48I can do it with some deliberation of with Ruth
- 26:51determination of. Okay.
- 26:52Let me not with relationships. For example, let me not go into
- 26:56a relationship for the next two months.
- 26:59I need to figure out what I've done in the past.
- 27:02So even if I do it alone, right? I can write down, things.
- 27:06I need to be. Curious.
- 27:08Because again, the challenges to see something that I have not
- 27:11seen before I can with curiosity, look at my self my
- 27:16own life and think about the relationships that I had.
- 27:21And with curiosity to look at other peoples relationship.
- 27:23Like how would they doing that? And then compare it to is that
- 27:27what I would do? So someone says honey, can you
- 27:31pass me the sugar? And how would I react in that
- 27:35situation? And how did that person react?
- 27:38Why didn't I have interactions like these?
- 27:41So I use if I do it alone. It's challenging.
- 27:46But well, it's something that we do but I should use many many
- 27:51tricks kind of to externalise my my point of view so that I can
- 27:56look at myself, my life, my past.
- 27:58It's from a different perspective.
- 28:01In order to increase the chances that I will see something that I
- 28:05couldn't see before make sense like sounds.
- 28:09So that is what you mean that like in that moment.
- 28:12I start to observe myself and I stopped to see my own patterns
- 28:18and behaviors and I renounce the hope that things could be
- 28:24better. That is what you meant fire,
- 28:26renunciation of Hope and The hopelessness and because and I
- 28:32correct in that sense. Yes.
- 28:36Okay, so it did not mean that you know, I stopped hoping that
- 28:42things are going to get better because that's how I interpreted
- 28:46it. And I was like, well, then
- 28:47what's the point of self-development?
- 28:49And then write the point of trying to change things and all
- 28:52of them? And by the way, this is also
- 28:55very misleading as a representation of Buddhism.
- 28:58I mean the whole point of the Buddha historically.
- 29:04Was, you know, kind of the good message of there is Liberation.
- 29:08There is a state of mind that is completely free from the normal
- 29:14problems that we have. I mean, again, this is most
- 29:17relevant for monastics, not for normal people, but the whole
- 29:20idea of Nirvana of samadhi. Moksha, Liberation is that.
- 29:26Of course I go. I start this path with the hope
- 29:29that I will approach that. Why else would I do that?
- 29:33Yeah, exactly, like, even in meditation and all the whole,
- 29:37the reason why I do that is the hope that I will, you know, how
- 29:42get better. Okay, that makes sense.
- 29:45Now, coming back to that agree, an example of observing yourself
- 29:49and all of that, right? So generally, what happens is, I
- 29:53observe myself and I say, okay, you know, what, in my, these are
- 29:57the four things. I keep repeating my behaviors
- 30:01and patterns that I keep. Be doing for them, in my job and
- 30:06my relationship in my apartment sort whatever.
- 30:09We're going to drop the apartment search.
- 30:11As an example. I think we would like, in my
- 30:13relationship, my job. And I go to my next job with
- 30:20that kind of understanding, and yet.
- 30:25And, and something like this happen to me, right?
- 30:28I observed in my job, particularly.
- 30:33I had a problem speaking out when something was bothering me
- 30:38to my manager and I let it go, let it go, let it go and then I
- 30:42would get irritated and then say it and it would obviously come
- 30:45out all wrong. I observe myself before I took
- 30:50that next role and yet in that next world, I still saw myself
- 30:55doing that same mistake. Yes, and then I was, and then
- 31:02that want me, even More sadder in my next job or my next
- 31:05relationship with my manager because I kept saying something
- 31:09myself making that same mistake again and again and to me that
- 31:18was like, very, very sad, right? Because that is definitely a
- 31:23consequence of starting to observe yourself as you don't
- 31:26like yourself and you don't like those patterns and you're unable
- 31:30to change those patterns, but they're very Deeply ingrained in
- 31:33yourself. Yes.
- 31:36So what do you think about that or is that a separate topic?
- 31:41Or we can, you know, push it to the side to none of this?
- 31:44I think it definitely belongs here.
- 31:48First of all, it's unnecessary but important to remember to
- 31:53change oneself is very, very difficult.
- 31:56There is no way around. It doesn't matter.
- 31:58If you're a Buddhist, if you read books, all of that, it's
- 32:03there's obviously there are many parts and us that are stubborn
- 32:07difficult to change and are not good for us. and, Let's not kind
- 32:15of Hope again, that this will dramatically be improved in the
- 32:22next year of our Ally of the next five years of our life.
- 32:25Wait a minute before your listeners.
- 32:27Cannot see that. But but you want to interject
- 32:30here. If the Mind wasn't so freaking
- 32:34difficult, Humanity would have long figured it out.
- 32:39It's not just that we haven't the 10,000 years.
- 32:44Okay, is it founded or unfounded and fondant and partly partly,
- 32:50right? So the mind is a mess.
- 32:52That's what I'm saying. It's it's a it's not something
- 32:56that has been designed by one intelligence.
- 33:00You know it one piece. Like a good engineering engineer
- 33:05would do or good program. Would you it relies on
- 33:08evolutionary development and all those different kind of sub
- 33:13programs and and survival mechanisms and all that with
- 33:18we're good back, then, you know, we were visits.
- 33:22And you would have been great if we had, tossed them out when we
- 33:25moved on to be mammals and so on.
- 33:27But we didn't and parts of the, this is that And that causes a
- 33:33lot of issues because it was programmed for a different
- 33:35purpose for a different life circumstances.
- 33:38And so on. It's not that the mind is
- 33:40something nice and easy and pliant and malleable.
- 33:45And so on, it's a mess. It's like a house where, you
- 33:49know, 50,000 people have lived in and everyone left their crap
- 33:52there. Yeah, you know, they moved out
- 33:57and took all the stuff with them.
- 33:58No, still there. So that is just, you know, one
- 34:02description of why it's so difficult for us to have, you
- 34:07know, a good life. We could be satisfied because we
- 34:09have to deal with many different structural issues of the Mind in
- 34:15different ways. Okay, so that just as a short
- 34:21preamble to, what do I do? When I see a pattern that I
- 34:25don't like and I want to change it.
- 34:27Okay. Here would distinguish unable to
- 34:29change it. It's like unable to change it
- 34:32because my mind is like tougher to change like you already
- 34:36mentioned. Yes.
- 34:38So I would distinguish wood in between two cases.
- 34:41One is, it's not firmly kind of stuck.
- 34:48I mind, but it can, it can just change, we change relatively
- 34:53simply. So, in that case, I set up a
- 34:57strong determination. This is what is necessary.
- 35:01And then I tell myself. Okay.
- 35:02It's the next job. The next position.
- 35:04I have to be careful not to start.
- 35:07As I ended the last one with my boss.
- 35:09For example, before a conversation with my boss,
- 35:14breathe a couple of times. I remind myself all I want to
- 35:17how I want to To contribute to this conversation and with kind
- 35:21of reminding myself and observing myself.
- 35:25I go into this conversation afterwards.
- 35:26I will review how I did and I just kind of my plans.
- 35:30So this would be the simple case.
- 35:32And the more complex case the things that I'm doing wrong with
- 35:37my boss represent. They have a history, a long
- 35:41history. It's not just the one thing,
- 35:45it's not just this job. It's not just the boss.
- 35:48My what my mind is doing. It puts me back to the time when
- 35:51I was a little girl and I was talking to my dad or my primary
- 35:56school teacher, right? And I wanted to prove a point or
- 36:01they wanted to to do something that was against my will or they
- 36:07want to impose on me an image of what I should do or who I should
- 36:11be and I didn't like that. And I'm still stuck in that same
- 36:14program. I couldn't let that go back
- 36:17then. And now I'm triggered each time,
- 36:20you know, a boss tells me something in a certain way.
- 36:23It gives off a false alarm. Also, I'm kicks me back in time
- 36:29and suddenly. I'm the little girl again the
- 36:31tries to prove itself to her dad or the primary school teacher.
- 36:35So when an issue has such a history, it cannot be just
- 36:42kicked out of the system, probably because it has set up
- 36:47routes for such a long time and it helped to Define who I am and
- 36:54so many ways. Right.
- 36:58So then the task is more important, then it might be
- 37:03necessary and I'm simplifying. It's not in all cases, but it
- 37:05might be necessary that the issue with my boss now and that
- 37:09I have a pattern with bosses, for example, tells me that it's
- 37:13necessary to face this old shit. That I didn't get over with
- 37:20decades ago, and that that might be necessary in order to be free
- 37:26to see the situations. Now as they are and not to be
- 37:29triggered back and to regress into childhood thinking and that
- 37:34these programs are automatically reactivated.
- 37:39I have a feeling that I think you're like, sort of I'm
- 37:44surprised I'm saying that, but like you I think you're still
- 37:47simplifying it a little bit because let's take my example.
- 37:51Right? We we have had this issue two
- 37:55years ago. I came to you and told you about
- 37:57my manager who I had a tough time speaking up to even though
- 38:02I totally disagree with what he was talking and my gut instinct
- 38:07was a hundred percent, right? I had data-driven did that.
- 38:11I had data-driven thought process and thinking too.
- 38:17To speak up about this particular, which direction the
- 38:19company needed to go at cycle. Same thing happened last year,
- 38:25or six months ago, and we had this conversation where you
- 38:29were, like, okay, Bobby, you already know you've done this in
- 38:31the past. Why do this is how you should
- 38:34speak up? This is how you should do it and
- 38:36I still wasn't able to speak up to him.
- 38:39And we have already walked through, you know, my previous
- 38:44psyche. But patriarchal issue.
- 38:46It's from India where and all of that and I was still not able
- 38:51despite knowing and understanding that this is
- 38:54coming from my previous top office about you know,
- 38:58patriarchy my own father issues, ETC.
- 39:01I still even the second time or the third time around, this
- 39:04happened in the past two years. I was still not able to do that.
- 39:10Which is why I my question was like, you know, and when this
- 39:15third time The second time this happened.
- 39:18I got extremely sad and upset about the fact that I could not
- 39:22change and I was unable to change.
- 39:25And in that moment you start to give up hope and that's what I
- 39:31thought. She meant by being hopeless,
- 39:33that things will ever change that made you sad, right?
- 39:38If I give up, I give up that. I will change.
- 39:43Yes. Yeah.
- 39:45Yeah, that's also then Yeah, exactly.
- 39:48So then what do you like? Which is why I had so many
- 39:50issues with this particular chapter and this whole concept.
- 39:55So what what does somebody like, you know, someone tries to
- 39:58change? They go into a marriage from the
- 40:01second marriage, breaks apart, they step back.
- 40:03And they say, okay, you know what, these are my issues and
- 40:06they go into the third marriage, and they still see themselves,
- 40:10making those same mistakes. So, at that time, they know it's
- 40:13their own issues. Number one.
- 40:15They already know they. I've tried to change and they
- 40:17still failed and they're working on fixing themselves.
- 40:21But you know, it's they are where they are.
- 40:25So what what does, what does a person do in that scenario?
- 40:29Yeah, there is there is not the one thing that you can do.
- 40:33Then there is nothing like the okay and worst case you do that.
- 40:39You know, there is a you know, rule of thumb is Don't repeat
- 40:45what you already know doesn't work.
- 40:48Thank you, that you can. Yeah, rule out right.
- 40:52And then, you know, it's kind of unsatisfying as it is.
- 40:56I have to come up with something else.
- 40:59It doesn't have to be more complex or more rooted in the
- 41:02past or more fancy. It can be, for example, to
- 41:08increase my kind of, my memory function to write things down on
- 41:12paper. For example, it could I'm just
- 41:14making up a simple example. The next time I go to the boss.
- 41:18I have this paper in front of me and it looks stupid that I
- 41:21talked with that, but I read out the lines that I wrote down
- 41:25there basically, because it might be that I'm Kind of my
- 41:29memory function is just abandoning me when I come into a
- 41:32stressful environment. And then I forget what I wanted
- 41:36to say. Another possibility, again.
- 41:38Nothing fancy is at a time when I don't have issues behind bars.
- 41:43I go into their office. And, and I give the speech,
- 41:47like, look, I have this issue and I have had it in the past.
- 41:50I want to become free of it. I don't know what to do.
- 41:53Occasionally. I've had it with you, and I
- 41:56wanted to talk to you about how we can maybe Circumvent it in
- 42:00the future. Maybe we can agree on some
- 42:01signals. Some signs may be, is that okay
- 42:05for you? If you ask me, if I'm fine, or
- 42:07if I want to add something. So to maybe, establish some
- 42:12other ground rules, which is again, more pragmatic than
- 42:15psychological or there are so many ways.
- 42:18I can go into kind of observing myself or do therapy, or do
- 42:21coaching, which would be more psychological things, or again,
- 42:26something that borders on the spiritual approach.
- 42:28Let me reduce. My overall tension and life, let
- 42:31me reduce my overall self-criticism and life kind of
- 42:37coupled with self honesty that I develop.
- 42:40Let me be more kind to myself not as an immediate remedy to
- 42:45that issue, but maybe my overall levels are too high got it.
- 42:51So not renounce. Hope still right?
- 42:53So I would not that you can improve.
- 42:56Okay, so that was interesting because in the book she died.
- 42:59Did say suffering is part of life and we don't have to feel.
- 43:03It's happening because we personally made the wrong move
- 43:06as what she is. I've literally went this out
- 43:09verbatim. So so then coming to the top
- 43:14against like. So then she said suffering, as
- 43:17part of life, or when Buddhism generally, you know, you always
- 43:20have Buddha say all suffering is part of life.
- 43:24Is that like do you agree with that?
- 43:27And And do you need to really just accept?
- 43:33Like yeah, what do you think about that?
- 43:37Yeah, that for me is too philosophical.
- 43:39I know many teachers kind of argue like that.
- 43:42I don't know. What's the point.
- 43:45The world didn't need the Buddha to to know that there is
- 43:48suffering in life. As long as there have been
- 43:51humans. They have been also dying.
- 43:54I guess that's a fact and the pain from from These has just
- 44:00imagine how people live 50 years ago, when Dental Care was not
- 44:03there, you know, famous example of Louis.
- 44:06XIV the French King. Yeah.
- 44:08Yeah. Terrible teeth.
- 44:10He was hard-working, you know, you never see that in movies,
- 44:13but it's a fact that he had rotten teeth.
- 44:16He was thinking out of the mouth pain, all the time.
- 44:20He had constipation and he would have to defecate in public which
- 44:23is another funny story about blue the for tonight, but we
- 44:26won't go there. So didn't he?
- 44:29I know that he was suffering because he didn't read Buddhist
- 44:31texts is not. I guess he was quite aware that
- 44:34he was suffering. So we don't need spirituality to
- 44:37tell us that life can be hard and that when we get older, you
- 44:41know, the limbs and the muscles and those are three roses and
- 44:46all these illnesses come that is a fact.
- 44:49It's kind of Superfluous like y to make that the center.
- 44:54Unless I mean something very specific unless I mean that
- 45:00there are there is a type of issues.
- 45:03There is a type of suffering that is avoidable.
- 45:08Death is not Frailty of the body's not disease, is not well,
- 45:14so, basically, the physical is not even though we live in a
- 45:19time when we hack the body and we exercise and can take
- 45:21supplements and so on. So yes, of course, there's
- 45:24Improvement there, but eventually we have to suffer
- 45:27some physiological suffering. What about the mind though?
- 45:32Right? And this is much more with the
- 45:37kind of the philosophy of Buddhism goes into.
- 45:40So here, the messages, where the Buddha says there is a specific
- 45:44kind of suffering that is mind made, and this is what you can
- 45:48get, rid of. And by the way, many people who
- 45:52casually or more seriously have meditated or have found another
- 45:58formula for their life, to be closer to the family, or to get
- 46:05rid of the family, or the contact, with the family,
- 46:07because so disturbing. How many many people have found
- 46:10ways that substantially help them with kind of the mental
- 46:16Joy, their ability to to enjoy life for themselves, right?
- 46:21Yeah. This is much more aware of those
- 46:24kinds of messages are located. Those Buddhist, philosophy
- 46:28messages. It's just very specific.
- 46:31Right? So it goes into the code of the
- 46:34mind. If a few were all these Buddhist
- 46:37techniques are supposed to get us.
- 46:40Very, very deep into the fabric of what the mind is made of, and
- 46:46to kind of change micro problems micro issues that always grow
- 46:53and grow, and grow and turn out into the life issues that we
- 46:56have like attachment for example, like the end of Bility
- 46:59to let go or to let those mini me projects die.
- 47:03Yeah, these are not kind of the lowest level of the issue.
- 47:07They are based on more fundamental principles of the
- 47:10Mind where the chat attaches two small things where it creates
- 47:15micro Minis and even smaller kind of fragments that already
- 47:20displayed this same attachment to other stuff in the mind,
- 47:25right? And then they grow, and then
- 47:27they become a parent. Daily life and real life,
- 47:31relationships objects, and so on.
- 47:34So the Buddhist practice is targeting kind of those micro
- 47:39elements and to discuss make them dysfunction on that level.
- 47:44Interesting. Okay.
- 47:46Okay, that makes sense. Or little bit of a dummy plans.
- 47:52I went through everything, but I may have more questions around
- 47:56there. But I think I finally understood
- 48:01what hopelessness what she means by.
- 48:04Primo, means I hopelessness and what does like hopelessness in
- 48:09terms of there will be dark. I will get sick at some point or
- 48:13another. Oh, my you'll get sick and I
- 48:19need to be okay with that now, actually, I kind of have the
- 48:23third question around that is is even if I recall and remember
- 48:29that even like coming to the physical aspect of off this
- 48:33question that the physical impermanence and physical, I
- 48:37need to be hopeless that I will die.
- 48:38Right? I cannot have hope that I will
- 48:40never ever. Even though I still have hope
- 48:44that a vampire will come bite. Me and Twilight kind Arrow, you
- 48:48know left. However, so far doesn't seem
- 48:51likely. So, what I need to be okay with
- 48:53that, how do you how do you have the feet?
- 48:59How do you become, okay, with the fear of death is sort of
- 49:06like the question that I have around this physical
- 49:08hopelessness and to give you an example.
- 49:14I my mother is, as you know, but there's a catch.
- 49:19Cancer survivor. She's around 70 years old and
- 49:24write this year with covid happening.
- 49:26And she being in India. I have this extreme fear that I
- 49:31wouldn't get to meet her or see her before she dies.
- 49:34Yes, how do you have? And I have an immense fear that
- 49:42she will die. And how do you become okay, with
- 49:47that kind of that physical fear that, you know, I will die or
- 49:52she will some people obviously have it for themselves or that
- 49:55she will die. Realistically speaking.
- 49:58I think we that is something that will just be there.
- 50:02So that there is an aspect of that that we will not be okay
- 50:05with there is something utterly unacceptable about people that
- 50:10we love that. We are attached to dying
- 50:12ourselves dying. Unless we go again, into
- 50:16spiritual Heights, that are kind of not necessary to go into,
- 50:21because that's the article to become enlightened and not to
- 50:23worry about these things. Yeah, so we're probably not
- 50:26enlightened beings and will not be enlightened.
- 50:28So, we will suffer from that the aspect where we, if we want to,
- 50:34we can work on. Is to take a stand of a radical
- 50:40responsibility, right? So let's say I'm afraid that my
- 50:46mother passes away of the disease.
- 50:50What that would mean would be? Okay.
- 50:52So let me do the things with her so that I don't regret it
- 50:56afterwards that I didn't do it. So if I'm afraid of that and
- 51:00it's Justified, it's not just a really neurotic kind of concern,
- 51:03but she is actually sick. And there is a danger that
- 51:07cancer comes back or whatever it is.
- 51:09Let me face that. And let me take responsibility
- 51:12for my actions and that sense. If I accept that, there isn't a
- 51:18real threat, not just the Article or principle.
- 51:21But there is someone in a risk group, right?
- 51:24We're covid. She's older.
- 51:27Yeah, exactly. So, if I, if I see the truth of
- 51:30that, what would I look like to do with her?
- 51:34Not in order to avoid pain, or dying or something?
- 51:38But what should I talk more on the internet with her Zoom, or
- 51:43with arms at Meriter? Should I go there and spend more
- 51:47time with her? Should I from the distance?
- 51:50Do something for her. Should I organize a nurse that
- 51:53would take care of her? What is it that I want to do?
- 51:56So, to take responsibility for the fact of me, knowing that
- 52:01there is a good chance that things got worse.
- 52:05Okay. And even after I do all of that,
- 52:10which is starting to talk more with her starting to record icon
- 52:15travel or, you know, I'm starting to talk to her more and
- 52:20doing more zoom face time with her.
- 52:24I am doing more for her from a distance, whatever.
- 52:29I can things that I know will bring her Joy or at least feel
- 52:34make her feel loved. How do I personally or how do
- 52:39you personally prepare for for the duck?
- 52:42Which is inevitable and like because I know when that death
- 52:52happens it's sort of like will devastate me.
- 52:56Well, it's not Partners death. Whether yeah, health condition,
- 52:59or if it's my or if it's my mother, how do you ensure that
- 53:05you are? You know, you don't like just
- 53:10fall apart. Yes, like a, she says, in the
- 53:13book When Things Fall Apart, well, to make it very short
- 53:16because we have to wrap it up, slowly me.
- 53:19Maybe we'll come back to the topic but to make it very short.
- 53:21I think if I did that what you already said, I I made her feel
- 53:25loved and so on. This is already one of the best
- 53:28things that practically I can do because the effect of that is I
- 53:33will have less or no regret afterwards.
- 53:38Which is one issue that many people have this when we kind
- 53:41of, when we when we sum up the different issues that we have
- 53:48when people pass away. The guilt is one of them, right?
- 53:52So at least a reduced debt. Yep, now additionally, if I
- 53:56wanted to more, if it's really important for me.
- 53:59I can do kind of certain meditations.
- 54:04I can talk to people. I can volunteer in a hospice.
- 54:11Then I can really if it's really something that I'm afraid.
- 54:14I'm not equipped to deal with as a general issue.
- 54:18I can confront myself more and make myself more acquainted with
- 54:22the phenomenon phenomenon of death.
- 54:25Which our Western culture so good to make a taboo, right?
- 54:30And in other cultures present, so it's not such a shock so I
- 54:36can do that to familiarize myself with the feeling.
- 54:39I can. I can do those kind of
- 54:43psychological spiritual Mini-Me deaths and to see the pain of
- 54:48letting go of something that was important to me, a part of an
- 54:50identity. So I can do all these things.
- 54:53But again, not to neglect, the Practical stuff I can volunteer
- 54:55in a hospice. I can use to see people how they
- 54:59get more frail and eventually die from the disease.
- 55:03So that when it happens to someone who is very, very close
- 55:07to me, at least, it's not the first time that I experienced
- 55:11that. I'm not just the second time
- 55:12that I experienced that. And that I went through it a
- 55:15couple of times with people that I cared more in a more abstract
- 55:20sense, you know, because it was the nice lady, the nice old, and
- 55:24And in a hospice or Hospital. Is that so far?
- 55:28Okay, with this topic and it's very fruitful.
- 55:31I think it's important to come back to it at some point.
- 55:34But today it's enough. Yeah.
- 55:37Yeah, no. Does this was absolutely great.
- 55:39We talked about how to think about Hope and hopelessness.
- 55:45So have be hopeless or be realistic in that this body will
- 55:52fail. This body will die.
- 55:54I will get sick but be In that mental hope that I can improve.
- 56:02It may take me longer because my brain is so fragmented and or
- 56:08It's Your Love past history. The way I think of it as like,
- 56:11you know, I've done a situation 10x finds the first time I
- 56:16expect to change, or I try to change it.
- 56:19It may not succeed. It may not even succeed in the
- 56:22first four dimes. Yeah, but eventually, it may
- 56:25find my heart. Into fixing it or smart that
- 56:30money into fixing it. As you know, the startup linger
- 56:34phase and and we need to in that situation.
- 56:39We sort of like, you know, remain relaxed.
- 56:42And one suspect, let those fragments of my brain sort of or
- 56:48identity died identity. That always wants to live in
- 56:52this perfect home. When I start to die, when I
- 56:55loved that particular. The dye is, is when I'm to come
- 57:01relax with their I am or who I am.
- 57:04At least for the short term. Yes, more relaxed.
- 57:07Yes. I open up soil.
- 57:09A lot of capabilities to either chill.
- 57:12If I want or to focus on the things that are left that I want
- 57:15to work on it to achieve. Yeah, and yeah.
- 57:20And only then will apparently I will at least be a little bit
- 57:25better. So So this was really helpful,
- 57:30and this is great. This is definitely stuff that I
- 57:35may come back to you, especially around the Death part the last
- 57:38part, but I think I finally understood the hopelessness
- 57:43part. So that was great.
- 57:46Thank you. Thank you Polly.