Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 258:1-259:1
Transcript
- 0:01Okay, that's mine. Up, rage known for starting
- 0:04rational had today. Just a couple quick little
- 0:07things from where we left off. We're going to come two more
- 0:13examples at the end. Just a couple quick things here.
- 0:17One is how to manabu mix at. Can one do had Semana if it's
- 0:21only partially covered and the heating source is hot from
- 0:24below. So then according to pretty much
- 0:28all just about all Ashkenazi, postgame atamanov emits, at is
- 0:32no problem, you can wrap things up before shop is on Shabbos.
- 0:36If it's just partially, cut wrapped up, according to the
- 0:40show, honora and Because Anish, that's one of the mix at is uh,
- 0:44sir if it's mostly Pebble if there's a solid source of heat
- 0:48coming from below, then it is even how much fun of ameica is
- 0:51called a Samana. So there's a question of that
- 0:56only applies by coals or also our metal heating elements and
- 1:02it might have been might only apply by Cole's.
- 1:05If it's also you have the coals your column around the pot a
- 1:10little bit. But in general, the general
- 1:15approach by most ashkenazim is its 100% motor and by stardom, a
- 1:20lot of them want to say it should be uh sir according to
- 1:22the Shell scenarios, but the minute by many stardom is also
- 1:25to be makeup. Okay?
- 1:32So, an obvious question. Very common question is, can you
- 1:36put up pots are Shabbos and cover them up with a with a
- 1:41towel are Shabbos? You put up food on your hot
- 1:44plate or a black and you want to cover it up with a towel.
- 1:47So the general Min, ugh is most people allow it.
- 1:51However, some say it's only allowed, perhaps, some many say
- 1:56it's only allowed and this is both for stardom an Ashkenazi
- 1:59Jew. It's if there's air space on the
- 2:02Side of the pockets. You drape over a towel over all
- 2:06of your pots and on the side you don't tightly in close it and
- 2:11push it all the way around or wrap it around and therefore
- 2:14since there's air space all around, they say it's not Derek
- 2:17Hudson, honor, that's not the normal way that people did at
- 2:20Amana. It was either a towel wrapped
- 2:22around it or it's tightly packed sand sand or Golem and they
- 2:28would tightly packed it all the way around.
- 2:30That's called Derek Hudson. So the general Minnick is to be
- 2:34make on their Shabbos, just it's important to leave over some
- 2:37airspace some say, it's even okay, if there's not airspace
- 2:41and they say, it's only a problem, it was only a problem
- 2:43with Cole's. But nowadays, we don't really
- 2:48warm up our Our pots with cools, it's not it's it's not a same
- 2:53thing because metal you can't pack it around, you can't
- 2:56doesn't move, okay? Let me just there's no such
- 3:10thing as principal. There's no hot Semana with food
- 3:13inside food. Everyone says, if you're going
- 3:15to immerse, if you're going to immerse meat, you're going to
- 3:21immerse a piece of. What's the cake inside Talent?
- 3:28Cassadaga. The kiska Okay, so you have
- 3:36sausages, whatever you want to immerse inside an egg, anything
- 3:39you want to immerse inside a children Potter food, generally,
- 3:44all the postgame say it's not a problem.
- 3:48Now, what if you wrap it up. So then if you wrap it up, most
- 3:52postgame also say, it's for sure, not a problem because
- 3:56that's, that's how you cook that that's not called Derek, that's
- 3:59Mana, nobody would ever call that Derek at semana.
- 4:02That's the normal way of cooking.
- 4:03It's all in one part. It's about tilted, apart our
- 4:06tomatoes and you take a pot and you wrap it around.
- 4:09There is such an opinion that says one should pop holes in the
- 4:12rapping. I don't think there's a need for
- 4:14it. I don't know if it accomplishes
- 4:15anything because if you say it's wrapped, it's still wrapped.
- 4:17The whole doesn't take away being around.
- 4:20But anyway, some do say it's good to pop a hole in there and
- 4:23they're wrapping. Let's see.
- 4:27Okay, so let's let's read inside now ratio known and we'll get to
- 4:32have some few important examples, raishin uncut.
- 4:35Now it's this is an interesting halacha.
- 4:38You have to reorient yourself a little bit because this halacha
- 4:42believe it or not and Compasses quite a bit.
- 4:47It takes our understanding of mixed income of a shell, a bit
- 4:52differently. Not really, but a pot on top of
- 4:55a pot, so you'll see when we explained it and normally we say
- 4:59until now that, all right, a person can take up take a pot
- 5:04and put it on top of another pot and it's not a problem to cook
- 5:08as on a problem to warm it up. If it's fully cooked even on
- 5:10Shabbos morning, We also said there's no hard to Munna.
- 5:15If you have something that's mostly something that's mostly
- 5:21of Havel and item at the most suitable we said it's a problem
- 5:24of a tamannaah even erev Shabbos.
- 5:26And if will we said, if you have something that's what's it
- 5:30called it's not most you travel. If it's mostly favorable you
- 5:34can't even do it on Shabbos even if it's a cold item but we
- 5:38learned, if you have a cold item, you are allowed to do her
- 5:41to mana on a cold item on Shabbos.
- 5:43If it's not mostly Pebble, you have something hot.
- 5:47You want to just keep it hot on the counter.
- 5:49You're allowed to wrap a towel around it, if it's if it's not
- 5:55hot if it's hot so then there's the helices of tamannaah but if
- 5:59it's cold everyone says you can take a towel around the cold
- 6:03cold piece of chicken or a cold pot and wrap it around a Tamara
- 6:07on Shabbos is only if it's something that's hot to begin
- 6:10with, that's if it's not mostly about, that's if it's not mostly
- 6:13fat. Well, if it's a mostly Pebble,
- 6:15you have heating elements, you have Kohl's.
- 6:18So then it's a problem, even if it's cold.
- 6:21So, now, when you read, raishin and cut it puts a little twist,
- 6:24Olive, muhtar lenio need the audio notice, the words me, the
- 6:29audio, Miss is only erev Shabbos that were saying it's much
- 6:31better on Shabbos. It's not okay.
- 6:34That's that's clear from Gomorrah and Chavez to the
- 6:37rambam, the shulchan aruch. It's pretty clear that clichy a
- 6:41schwa d'Ivoire car Agave coderre Hannah, if you want to take a
- 6:47something called a cold item, a cold pot.
- 6:50And you want to put it on top of a coderre that's hot because
- 6:54there's a discussion. Are we talking about a coderre?
- 6:56That's on the fire, not on the fire.
- 6:58It's maybe we'll push that aside.
- 7:02Okay, could be, it's only if it's off the fire.
- 7:06Alright, so now you take it on are Shabbos and you want to put
- 7:09it on a, on a pot. So listen Shane's.
- 7:13The kotomi with the varro most you Pebbles.
- 7:15So he says you're allowed to do this Arab Shabbos.
- 7:19So the question is, it called, Mostly of Heaven Or Not.
- 7:21Most you have though, this blur is the definition a little bit.
- 7:25And so he says basically it goes like this.
- 7:28If it's erev Shabbos, that you're allowed to you, lot of
- 7:31put a pot on top of a pot. If it's cold on top of another
- 7:34and you're allowed to wrap it up even because that's if it's a
- 7:39pot on top of a pot because nobody it's not called Derek
- 7:44tamannaah. With most of you have felt if
- 7:46you're balancing one pot, on top of another pot.
- 7:51We're talking about if it's wrapped up because if it's not
- 7:55wrapped up, no, it's important to clarify, we're talking about
- 7:57wrapping up, as if it's not wrapped up, you're allowed to do
- 8:00it. Even on shalvis in the morning,
- 8:02visit pot on top of a pot relations Cuts talking about
- 8:05clearly only if you're wrapping it up and then it's only mutter
- 8:09on, erev Shabbos, if it would be on a the black, maybe directly
- 8:13it would be on angoulême directly.
- 8:16It would be, uh, say if it's completely wrapped all the way
- 8:19around, but He but here we say it's allowed to, but it's on a
- 8:22coderre, it's on top of a pot. So it depends how you want,
- 8:28understand it. But I think I'll leave that for
- 8:31this year, but it's two ways to read it.
- 8:35And it's so that's a question mark, many say that even if it's
- 8:40not on a heating up, even if it's off the heating element.
- 8:43So you're allowed to do it on Shabbos, erev Shabbos, but you
- 8:46can't be doing this on Shabbos. You take something cold because
- 8:50there's something called, I mean, I don't know if it has a
- 8:52technical term, anot moly to bulk home is if you can't, but
- 8:56one of the roles of had Savannah as you can't to, this is an
- 8:59interesting, not everyone, so aware you can't take something
- 9:02on Shabbos, that's cold. And then use had tamannaah to
- 9:07heat it up, such as it be a problem, it's a nest, it's
- 9:13definitely necessary, O'Bannon to take a pot, or a piece of
- 9:16schnitzel, or a hollow and red and put it on top of your
- 9:21children, pot shop this morning. It's cool right?
- 9:24Take it on top of a on top of a chilling powder on top of your
- 9:27pot and then completely wrap it up even though it's on top of a
- 9:32coderre. So normally we said coderre
- 9:34talk. go because there is not a not a problem of Mexico of a
- 9:37show and it's not a problem of it's not a problem on erev
- 9:43Shabbos but it is a problem on Chavez because Is it in their
- 9:49abundant not heat up your food from being cold, to being hot if
- 9:53it's through had to Munna. All right, now the mission of
- 9:57the right here says that it's, if you're heating it up, even
- 10:03below, you had selected bow. It's a problem.
- 10:06However, sorry on is if you look in the mirror lock-up later and
- 10:11shit in your hat and you look at the official kinara, it says oh
- 10:14and if you look at the tour, they all say it has to be yards
- 10:18to let Both, if it's not yet to let it boil, then it's not a
- 10:21problem. In other words, if you put your
- 10:23collar, you can wrap it up with a hundred towels on top of your
- 10:27children pot, if the caller will not reach out to let it blow,
- 10:31but if it reaches out to let us bow, so that's when you can't
- 10:34wrap it up. That's right.
- 10:39So one solution is not to keep it relevant, yet.
- 10:43Have no choice if it's going to be if your call is going to
- 10:46reach out. So let it bow on top of your toe
- 10:48and pot, you can't wrap it up. Just make sure it's not
- 10:51completely wrapped and that pretty much.
- 10:53Yeah. So just leave over 10% exposed
- 10:57to the air and you avoided the problem.
- 11:00What about are going to save it for later?
- 11:02Can you do this with foil wrapping?
- 11:05You can you rap, can you rap? Your haleh take it out of
- 11:09plastic bags. Now, wrap it up and to put it on
- 11:12top. So, there are 22 million
- 11:14opinions on this one. Everyone says, if you're going
- 11:16to take that, thought that Halo and wrap it up, completely, and
- 11:19then wrap it and wrap it, and wrap it with the foil.
- 11:21So, it's like, you know, wrapped around a couple times, everyone
- 11:25says, that's a problem. All right?
- 11:27What if you only wrap it around it once?
- 11:29So then the are two common opinions out there and I mean,
- 11:34how them halacha. So one opinion says, It's a stir
- 11:38because you're wrapping it if it's completely wrapped.
- 11:43But that's only, if your intention is to wrap it for the
- 11:47own sole purpose of keeping it hot warm in it and keeping it
- 11:51hot. If there's even a ten percent.
- 11:55Let's say that's side. Reason of wrapping it.
- 11:58Like, you don't want dust, you don't want something to Splash
- 12:01on it, you don't want it to become worried about mice, we
- 12:05learned yesterday, you don't want You know, kids are throwing
- 12:08balls or whatever spitballs you want to protect it from the top,
- 12:12you've got commenting as you want to keep it from, maybe
- 12:17being Flay, shake or touching something.
- 12:19The food is that helps. So then for also any reason that
- 12:23you have for having a wrapped on all sides with one layer for
- 12:26sure. Not a problem because now some
- 12:29say, even if, that's not your intention.
- 12:32Now, many say, that is a problem.
- 12:35It was Moshe is one of them that if that's your All intention.
- 12:38Then that's that is a problem. If it's wrapped on all sides,
- 12:41even one layer, some, right? That the minimum effort from the
- 12:46former bunion in Israel, and in America, that it's not about
- 12:50that. It's the minute is not to follow
- 12:53this extreme that one rapping is okay.
- 12:56Well, let's Aquila either because their assumption is.
- 13:01Everybody wants it to be wrapped on all sides.
- 13:06Not only for the If the main purpose is to keep it warm but
- 13:10the only but it's not the only purpose.
- 13:12It's also to protect it or keshava says that he writes like
- 13:17it's mutter because this is everyone's reason.
- 13:20But if you know yourself that's not the reasoning.
- 13:23So it's perhaps a question, but there's often an ulterior
- 13:27motive. Even, it's not the main reason,
- 13:29there's always for many of us. There's a small even a small
- 13:33reason we don't want it to be. What's it called?
- 13:37Or to prevent it from drying out from the air, that's another
- 13:40reason. Now another reason why some
- 13:44people say look at scale, it's okay.
- 13:46Quoted by the their emotion, others is that if it's Ackley,
- 13:50if you call one wrapping of the aluminum Ackley again, it
- 13:54doesn't mean it's a cliff or all Holocaust of tumor and Tara.
- 13:58But it means for the helical Chavez that we look at it,
- 14:01conceptually for the assert, their abundance of her
- 14:03tamannaah. We look at it as a cleat.
- 14:06And with one clearly never say that.
- 14:08The clay itself is a Samana, everyone's a lot of put food
- 14:12inside a dish and no one calls that tomorrow night with its own
- 14:16pot. So if you consider this tin foil
- 14:20wrapping as a cleat for this, hello, but the Mana and for
- 14:23sure, it wouldn't be a problem. I was going to save it for
- 14:25later, but here pouring water inside a thermos and one for
- 14:30water inside a thermos. So one can and many reasons
- 14:34given one is because That's clear itself.
- 14:38The thermos itself is one clear. You can never call its own.
- 14:41Clearly had some uh no because anisha's famous for saying that
- 14:46another reason is when you close it there's some air space on top
- 14:49might be a reason. You also you're doing it to
- 14:52prevent it. You don't want it to spill.
- 14:54You don't want things to fall inside.
- 14:57So that's another reason why people close it.
- 14:59So, that's another reason why it should be.
- 15:01Okay. Also, we don't say this is a
- 15:02good principle in general. We don't say, hats mana on.
- 15:06Chavez by cliche knee. There's never an Asura.
- 15:09That's if it's not most you fellow, if it's not most
- 15:12suitable then like with the towel we never say there's have
- 15:16fun with it. You're always allowed to do it
- 15:18tomorrow with a cliche knee. It's only by a Cleary.
- 15:21Sean. Is there a nest of their London?
- 15:23I've had some money that takes that one another on a little bit
- 15:28of roll over here without learning inside.
- 15:34The challah itself. It's nothing.
- 15:38It's a it wasn't even hot the foil so it's like, it's okay
- 15:42nothing. So, it wouldn't be a problem of
- 15:45doing hot Semana with the work. It can't be a problem with doing
- 15:49that tomorrow with Carla from. If it would be no increase the
- 15:54heat, but since you're putting it on a healing heating element
- 15:56and you're making something cold to hot and it doesn't matter if
- 16:00it's a clearly reveal whatever. You want to if there is such a
- 16:03thing, then it's not when we were violent, even 100 exactly
- 16:15the healing of making it hard and it could get Yachts to let
- 16:18it go. I live.
- 16:19It soak in and our mission world but could we it has to be upset.
- 16:24Can you put ice in the cooler for sure.
- 16:27You can. First of all it's cold.
- 16:30Plus all the reasons why the Thermos.
- 16:32So you can even wrap up 100 times around.
- 16:37Yeah, you can even wrap a towel around a thermos and a cooler.
- 16:44Correct, there's definitely not unless it's mostly of Havel and
- 16:47it'll make it hot if it's keeps it could and it reaches out to
- 16:50letter, but that's obviously not the case of a high schooler.
- 16:54Okay, let's read a little bit more inside and then we have a
- 16:56couple more things here. Wait, did we finish this?
- 17:01Fine. So we pretty much finished had
- 17:03Semana the I'll do a couple examples ratio and Ted has a
- 17:08little bit of a tamannaah. It's actually a hidden.
- 17:11It's it's, it's called Genie HUD, Simona a tilt too long.
- 17:15So really, it's a halacha of tilt, oh, really, this is a
- 17:18seaman of Musa, which I'd rather save for later, but it's here
- 17:22now. Okay, let's see.
- 17:25We spoke about this one. Just a little tidbit high
- 17:30tomorrow. Only applies by Why food is
- 17:33never a problem to wrap up a cleat?
- 17:36You want to warm up, people have plate, warmers.
- 17:39You want to warm up your plates. No problem whatsoever.
- 17:48Yes, that's coming right up here.
- 17:50Here we are. Thank you now.
- 17:53Can you heat up a baby bottle? Has milk.
- 18:00Let's assume. So it's also depends if the
- 18:03liquid was cooked or not cooked before.
- 18:05But let's assume we're talking about wrong milk.
- 18:08That was wasn't cooked yet and you want to heat it up, but you
- 18:12want to warm it up by putting it inside inside water?
- 18:16Hot water. To put it.
- 18:24So there you're there, you're putting the food would be taking
- 18:28the milk without the bottle, inside hot water, that's can't
- 18:33do that. It's going to mix in and it
- 18:35won't work. So that would be okay.
- 18:37Obviously to pour milk inside water, as long as you're not
- 18:41going to be cooking, it is no problem, then the issues of had
- 18:44tamannaah the issue of what someone is now you're wrapping
- 18:47up a bottle, you have a clean with milk and now you're
- 18:51wrapping it up with water if it's cold but to make it hot,
- 19:03once you want to make something a hot then you could have that's
- 19:06money, right. So, if you have the bottle half
- 19:25in half out and it's not completely immersed in water for
- 19:29sure, not a problem. Assuming it won't reach.
- 19:32You had selected vo. Perhaps, even if it reaches you
- 19:34had selectable, now, we said about the cliche knee see that's
- 19:40it's so you're not going to have at some If you wrap your case,
- 19:47you put boiling hot water in a in a kid is in a washing cup.
- 19:50So if you wrap up that washing cup with the towel, you won't
- 19:53have its money issues because it's a cliche knee.
- 19:56But the but since you want to take something cold and heat it
- 20:00up, then you could, if you fully immerse, the baby bottle inside
- 20:05water. So some say, that's a problem.
- 20:08Some say, it's not a problem, just leave it as a my hook it.
- 20:12But if it's not Lately. Immersed, for sure.
- 20:15It's no problem. But if you it's okay, yeah.
- 20:21For sure. Not a problem, the sure it's not
- 20:23a problem. The yeah, you look at the clean
- 20:29some say it's okay if it's even if it's fully immersed and one
- 20:36of the one of the reasons they let they say it's okay is
- 20:39because the water itself is going to be it's going to
- 20:42constantly get cooler and cooler over time.
- 20:45And since since the water itself is getting cooler and cooler
- 20:50over time, that's called it's not called the most beautiful
- 20:54and it wouldn't be it wouldn't be an issue if you're making the
- 20:58water. Also depends.
- 20:59If, if the milk could reach out to let it boil which practically
- 21:05/ I believe that's impossible. Any case that we're talking
- 21:08about when a person heats up their baby bottle.
- 21:10It will never turn into Yachts. Let about as far as I know but I
- 21:13guess it depends how deep and Whatever it depends on the
- 21:16situation. So, in general, there's there's,
- 21:25there's a Tarzana mission of Bureau, who's against it.
- 21:28So, it's a Muckle kids, if you're a lot, it completely
- 21:31immerse it or not. Okay, this one.
- 21:39This will be mentioned, we did all this.
- 21:42Okay, we're good. I am not going to go into too
- 21:45much detail about a crock pot that has.
- 21:48That's that probably takes a while to go over just to avoid
- 21:51the issues of hsieh. Yeah, whatever.
- 21:56I think we'll skip the crock pots for this type of share of
- 21:59its total. Take already a few minutes.
- 22:01You have to deal with shi'a Hazara, hats mana and all that
- 22:04kind of stuff. It's so, it was good.
- 22:06Let's let's cover a little bit of ground for these.
- 22:09Over racing on Ted. Comedy need one of you to a
- 22:13olive so Mohan right. Those are like pieces of cotton
- 22:19little pieces of cotton. All right.
- 22:22Should tell no one but him Derek Nick.
- 22:24Right now, we're talking about if it's.
- 22:26So, we're talking about cases where it's moxa.
- 22:31These items were not satisfied to be used and they had no
- 22:35purpose. So then should someone behind
- 22:37their microprocessor little tan if it just by chance that got
- 22:41covered up with these? Items.
- 22:42They're still considered a moxa and and you can't move these
- 22:46items directly. So why do you do if it's not
- 22:49completely immersed and you can reach the handle?
- 22:52That's, it's almost completely immersed, but not 100%.
- 22:56So then what do you do? You just elements are ikey
- 22:59silly. They had no float.
- 23:00So you just lift up the cover or you reach in, you got to know
- 23:05putting your finger a little bit Without trying to move them at
- 23:08all and, and that's okay. They'll be calaca yard.
- 23:12You just sneak your hand in through them.
- 23:14If you need to, and you lift up the cover and you let all of
- 23:17them fall out. And since the cover itself is
- 23:20not moxa, it's we're caught what now, we're talking about two
- 23:24books, a total minutes Todd, I don't want to get into a whole
- 23:27thing over here, but it looks up, but it's important to know.
- 23:30I decided I have to make sure we had some board were all on the
- 23:32same page is a major difference when it comes to moxf, it's
- 23:35Toto, kill, AA, car yard and tilt.
- 23:37Minutes are throughout our means you're handling it and not
- 23:42normal fashion. You're not using your hand.
- 23:44The way you normally use your hand, using your elbow, your
- 23:47backhand your foot. When it's, when a hand is
- 23:49normally used for using, maybe your left hand, versus your
- 23:52right hand, you're using your backwards hands using two hands
- 23:57at the same time, when it's always done with one hand, these
- 24:00are all examples of que la Caridad, the way you're using
- 24:02your hand is very abnormal. Okay, minutes odd.
- 24:07Means you're holding your using your hands, the way you always
- 24:09use your hand, but your it's in directly or indirectly moving
- 24:15it. So here, you're moving, you're
- 24:16holding the key. So I normally with your hand and
- 24:19you're not really touching the, the milking directly.
- 24:24You're not moving them directly in a normal fashion, and that's
- 24:27called me nuts at, okay? Okay.
- 24:30Gunshot make certain regulations a total elements Ledo Wright
- 24:33mean, it's not. Okay, the even you had on the
- 24:36costume of Charlie Chaplin, but if you set them aside, these are
- 24:39what you use, it could even be for this one Shabbos.
- 24:41But you set them aside for this job is for every Shabbos.
- 24:44Knees. Smoking, you're using like
- 24:47rocks, normally, rocks are moxa some rocks, but if you're using
- 24:51them as door posts or door thing to hold, open a door.
- 24:54So that you picked one and that's what you use every week
- 24:57are all week. So, that's no longer moxa about
- 25:00am. Come on, Big Easy, summer feel
- 25:02like than the class, mucho, tell 21.
- 25:04But if you use them with summer, then Cara world, even if you
- 25:09didn't, you're out to move them. The honeymoon least, um, gives
- 25:12him Shane on doing with her. This is because normally we
- 25:16assume that they're not moxa, unless we assume that they are
- 25:19looks alike as for business, you're selling them, okay?
- 25:23Alvaro? Even to know, That would tell us
- 25:24where it's reformulate, but if you put them aside because
- 25:28normally these these will items you, they were used that you
- 25:31have them to use them when you need them.
- 25:33But if you set them aside specifically to sell them as for
- 25:36business. So then that's it.
- 25:38One of the categories and look so intolerant of amla, equally
- 25:40menarche slavin over. Okay.
- 25:43Same thing behind all the Martian hotel Key selected, are
- 25:45you just pick up the top of the lid?
- 25:47She a starts clearly as we explained the lid itself,
- 25:50physically. So you're a lot of hold that
- 25:52normally valve will be shamalia like And even though they're on
- 25:54top of it and they follow who cares the loan, I said buses Lon
- 25:59the even though ones on top ones on bottom it doesn't matter.
- 26:02It doesn't turn it into a besi. Sabes East is when they're
- 26:05serving the your cotton balls are serving.
- 26:12What's who's serving who the cotton balls are tough out there
- 26:14serving the cleat. So you don't call it a buses.
- 26:17It's only a bus when the bus is serving and whole supporting,
- 26:22what's more important? Okay.
- 26:26Should we stop? Maybe?
- 26:27We'll stop. All right.