Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 105
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder, true crime cases five four, three, two, one one
- 0:21one one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure
- 0:30you are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, So let's
- 0:34get started. The Letters of Circleville a harrowing mystery. Imagine walking out to
- 0:46your mailbox and before opening it and seeing what's inside, figuring that the worst
- 0:51thing you might find is a bill. That wasn't the case for the people
- 0:55of Circleville, Ohio. Starting in nineteen seventy six, letters were sent to
- 1:00residence which contained very personal details about the receiver's private lives, including their sex
- 1:07life. Though the letters were postmarked in Columbus, Ohio, the detail and
- 1:12accuracy led police to believe the person writing them to be a resident of the
- 1:18town itself. The end result was a series of events that would change a
- 1:23number of families and the town forever. Everything began with Mary Jellespie. At
- 1:30the time, she was working as a bus driver and was married to her
- 1:33husband Ron. The first letters that she had received leveled accusations that missus Jellespie
- 1:40was engaging in an affair with the local school superintendent, a man named Gordon
- 1:46Massey. In the letters. She was told that the letter writer was watching
- 1:49both their house and children. It also demanded that she ceased the affair.
- 1:56Mary wasn't the only one in the house to get a letter from this unknown
- 1:59person. Ron himself, her husband, eventually received his own. In one,
- 2:06he told him that his wife was in danger if she didn't stop seeing
- 2:09Massy. In a later letter, Ron was told that he would be killed
- 2:15if he didn't tell the school board about what his wife had been up to.
- 2:19Two weeks after the demand to inform the board hadn't been met, another
- 2:23letter arrived, claiming that if Mary didn't tell the truth about this affair alleged
- 2:29affair, the writer would blast it on posters, signs, and billboards until
- 2:34she finally did. At the time, Ron and Mary had kept the existence
- 2:38of the letters a closely guarded secret. Eventually, though, they reached out
- 2:43to Ron's sister and her husband, Karen and Paul fresh Hour, in hopes
- 2:47of finding some help. In addition to the four of them, a fifth
- 2:52person was told of the letters, Paul's sister, but beyond that, no
- 2:57one other than the person writing the letters knew they'd been sent. Since the
- 3:01first letter arrived, Mary had harbored a suspicion about who was writing them.
- 3:07She believed a man named David Longberry, a fellow driver, was responsible.
- 3:12The reason she believed he was the one writing the terrible letters was that at
- 3:15one point David had approached her romantically and had been rejected. She told of
- 3:22her suspicions to the others, and Paul offered to write Longberry, stating simply
- 3:27that he knew David was responsible for the letters and to stop. At first,
- 3:31it appeared her suspicions were correct because the letters didn't arrive in their mailbox
- 3:38for a few weeks. Then, on August nineteenth, nineteen seventy seven,
- 3:43the telephone rang in the Gillespie house. After Ron spoke on the phone,
- 3:46he became noticeably angry. He went to get his gun and told his children
- 3:53he planned to go talk to the person who was responsible for the letters.
- 3:57A matter of hours later, Billspie was dead. He crashed his truck into
- 4:02a tree after firing a gun. Officially, the cause of death was a
- 4:08result of a dui accident. Since his blood alcohol content at the time of
- 4:13the crash was zero point one six, this explanation didn't sit well with its
- 4:17friends and family. They claimed that Ron rarely, if ever, drank,
- 4:21and they had not seen him do so all that day. After his death,
- 4:26the circle of people receiving letters widened to include more residents of Circleville.
- 4:31The letters claimed that the sheriff had participated in a cover up related to the
- 4:36accident. Sheriff Radcliffe came out later and said he initially thought that foul play
- 4:43was involved, but the other individual, a possible suspect, had passed a
- 4:47polygraph test and the matter was settled as a simple dui crash. In addition
- 4:54to Ron's death, it came out that Mary had been engaging in an extramarital
- 4:59affair with Massey, but she claimed it had begun after the letters started showing
- 5:03up. February in nineteen eighty three brought another incident involving Mary Gillespie. Someone
- 5:11had started to hang several signs around Circleville, most of them specifically along the
- 5:16route in which she drove her buss. Most of these accused Gordon Massey of
- 5:21raping the twelve year old daughter of the Gillespies. At one point, Mary
- 5:27had had enough and stopped her buss to tear down one particular sign it nearly
- 5:31cost the woman her life. A gun had been rigged to shoot whoever tried
- 5:35to remove the sign. When the serial number was checked on the gun,
- 5:41it led police to Paul Freshaur, the now former husband of Ron's sister Karen.
- 5:47When police questioned him, he claimed that the gun had been stolen,
- 5:50though he never reported the theft to the police. They even requested a handwriting
- 5:57sample in which he was asked to copy the words from one of the letters.
- 6:00It is more common for someone to be as to write random words in
- 6:04their own handwriting. In the end, he was arrested for attempted murder.
- 6:10He would eventually be convicted of the crime, based mainly on the testimony of
- 6:14a handwriting expert who stated that she believed Paul to be the author of the
- 6:18letters. Even though he was behind bars for attempting to kill Mary, the
- 6:24letters continued to show up even during times when Paul had no access to male
- 6:30privileges. Some were even sent to Paul himself that sounded as if someone was
- 6:35claiming to have set him up. The prosecutor in his case even received one
- 6:40that accused the lawyer of killing a pregnant woman despite claiming innocence the entire time
- 6:46he was locked up. Paul fresh Hour was released on parole in May nineteen
- 6:50ninety four after he served ten years in prison. The story even made it
- 6:56to the small screen after the show Unsolved Mysteries did an episode about the letters.
- 7:01This prompted producers to get a letter of their own, warning them to
- 7:05stay away from Circleville. What may be the strangest part of this whole thing
- 7:12is how much the letter writer seemed to know about people's private lives. The
- 7:16dead pregnant woman who the writer claimed to have been killed by the prosecuting attorney
- 7:20was engaging in an affair with the attorney, and the baby she was carrying
- 7:26at the time of her death was his. In another prediction, the doctor
- 7:30who had done Ron's autopsy after his death was called a pedophile by the writer.
- 7:35In nineteen ninety three, thirteen different charges were filed against him for crimes
- 7:42against children. To this day, there's never been anyone claiming full responsibility for
- 7:46the letters. Even up to the day he died in twenty twelve, Paul
- 7:53Freshauer professed his innocence. So if it wasn't him, then who was the
- 7:59one to turn this town upside down. Some people point their fingers and marry
- 8:05herself. They ask, what are the odds that she'd stop her bus at
- 8:09the exact sign that had a gun attached to it in the entire town,
- 8:13only to have the bullets miss her completely. As for the bus driver that
- 8:18had initially been pegged, David Longberry, Well, he raped an eleven year
- 8:24old girl in nineteen ninety nine before killing himself while avoiding capture. Other potential
- 8:31writers of the letters were Karen, who would have access to Paul's gun and
- 8:35could have set him up after a contentious divorce. Others still have considered Massy's
- 8:41own son as a possibility, since a few of the letters were signed with
- 8:45the letter W leading them to believe it could have been him. There is
- 8:50also a person known as El Comino Man. This individual was seen standing near
- 8:56the area where the sign was that hit the booby trap with the gun.
- 9:01Karen, at the time this all was going on, happened to be dating
- 9:03a man who drove just such a car. In the end, we may
- 9:09never know who was the one or one to write those letters that changed Circleville
- 9:13forever. After the episode of Unsolved Mysteries aired, the letters dried up,
- 9:18and the writer went into the pages of history, yet never forgotten.