Latest / new renaissance capital / The Fight Against Chat Control in the EU w/ Lyudmyla Kozlovska
Transcript
- 0:00For many people it seems so far away.
- 0:02They say, no, it's never touched me.
- 0:04Unfortunately, it's not the case.
- 0:06You will never understand why your company is destroyed,
- 0:09why something happened around you and you never understand.
- 0:12It looks very weird how it could even happen.
- 0:15But because your data is stolen, it gives full roadmap
- 0:18how you can be attacked, how people who are important for you are affected.
- 0:24So please care about your data and let's fix protection
- 0:28of both Americans and Europeans as soon as possible. We can do it.
- 0:37What is going on, everybody? Frank here, joined today by an extremely special guest,
- 0:43Ludmila Kozlowska, president of the Open Dialogue Foundation. She advocates ferociously for the
- 0:49right of everyday people to use all sorts of freedom tech, from things like Bitcoin to open
- 0:54source AI and private chat communications, all of which we'll touch on today in this conversation.
- 1:01I've known Ludmila for a few years now. I think she was one of the first guests I ever had on.
- 1:05We've gotten to know each other. I remain in complete awe of the amount of work she gets done.
- 1:11Her voice, though it's become more pronounced than we've seen, we saw her at the center of a lot of
- 1:17what was happening around chat control about a month ago. And we're going to start with that here,
- 1:21about what was happening with kind of regulation
- 1:23that was kind of sneaked through the European Parliament,
- 1:26a vote that happened right before summer vacation happened.
- 1:29We'll talk about that today.
- 1:31But Ludmila, it's a pleasure to have you back here.
- 1:34Like I said, I admire what you do.
- 1:35I appreciate what you do.
- 1:36And I hopefully want to kind of let people listening today
- 1:40know just how much you do
- 1:41and maybe ways that they could support what you're doing as well.
- 1:44So please, if you don't mind, introduce yourself a bit.
- 1:46Thank you.
- 1:47Thank you, Frank, for all of these warm words.
- 1:49And I want to first of all address to our viewers that everything what I'm going to say, it depends and actually affects all of us.
- 1:59You, me, your friends, your family members.
- 2:02So it's really important to be active in defense of your privacy online.
- 2:05And I'm saying it as a human defender, as a victim of transnational repression, which means that different kind of legal instruments, financial tools, your travel data, communication data, everything can be weaponized.
- 2:17When I say it, it means that I lived it and I was able to overcome.
- 2:21And my purpose as a human defender who is running Open Dialogue Foundation for already 17 years
- 2:26and defending a number of political prisoners, hundreds of political prisoners in many countries,
- 2:34but also people who are politically prosecuted abroad, transnationally, this is what we call it.
- 2:40I'm saying it's that it's really important to pay attention to what's happening in different parliaments right now.
- 2:46We're capable right now, we have all tools to overcome a different kind of transnational repression.
- 2:52We're capable to make these changes, but only if we really pay attention and we just don't think that,
- 2:58oh, somebody is going to fix it for me.
- 3:00No, we have to participate jointly on it, and then we're going to fix it.
- 3:04Just like somebody hundreds of years ago fought for freedom of speech,
- 3:09and we can still enjoy it, but we can lose it.
- 3:13The same, we have to defend our rights online quite soon.
- 3:18Access to internet can be just through digital ID.
- 3:21It's not something science fiction.
- 3:23It's actually reality.
- 3:25It's already happening in many countries.
- 3:28And we are a small minority in this world where still we can enjoy our rights.
- 3:33And so this podcast, what I'm really grateful for your friends that you give me floor,
- 3:37I really want to gather people who understand this value.
- 3:41I don't want you just to listen.
- 3:42I want you to participate in this process.
- 3:44Maybe it sounds too ambitious, but it's your rights.
- 3:47If you don't fight for them, you're going to lose them.
- 3:50I appreciate all that.
- 3:51And I think it's really important.
- 3:53And yeah, it's something to keep in mind.
- 3:54When you hear someone like Ludmila talk, you kind of think like, oh, well, she's working
- 3:57on it.
- 3:58So everything needs to be fine.
- 3:59But Ludmila can't do this work alone.
- 4:00She needs your support on whatever levels you might be able to give it.
- 4:03So please, as you're listening, maybe pay particular attention to anything that she says that resonates
- 4:08with you.
- 4:08and if that's a place in which you can support in whatever capacity you're able to support,
- 4:13please consider doing so because I think what's happening right now is, so let's dive in. Let's
- 4:18start with chat control. So about a month ago, and I wanted to do this conversation earlier,
- 4:22but Ludmila worked so hard while this chat control fight was going on that she was actually
- 4:26sick for a while afterwards. So we had to give her some time to recuperate, but I'm grateful that
- 4:30she's better and that she has the time to speak about this today. But let's start with the high
- 4:35overview so last month chat control was adopted by the european parliament let's start with this
- 4:40so this is chat control 1.0 if i'm not mistaken can you explain to us what this is and what happened
- 4:45within the european parliament so it's basically something what used to be already
- 4:52applied to european union when um all social media like messenger or for example messenger in
- 5:01Meta or Facebook, Instagram, social media like X or any others.
- 5:08They basically were checking all our messages if we have any kind of child material there And they were proactively reporting it to special services law enforcement
- 5:21And this generated enormous amount of false positives and, of course,
- 5:26different kind of enormous amount of files which law enforcement is not even able to process.
- 5:33And that's why law enforcement was not happy with this kind of proposal.
- 5:39And cybersecurity experts, which I will just remind, over 800 of most known cybersecurity experts
- 5:46signed different kind of letters to warn that child control one or child control two,
- 5:54not effective at all.
- 5:55It's actually beneficial to one specific lobbyist company,
- 5:59which produce the specific software and nobody else is going to benefit from it.
- 6:05So this chat control one, which is not affecting your signal or your WhatsApp,
- 6:10but it's affecting all direct messages between social media networks.
- 6:16And of course, it's also affecting your emails and everything what you store on cloud
- 6:21with Google, for example.
- 6:25So from this perspective, it's very important to know about it, first of all.
- 6:31And then I have to say that I'm not happy about it because I know how much false positives and how much access to this data can be weaponized by authoritarian regimes or malicious actors.
- 6:44And victims as of now, even members of the parliament confirmed by themselves, there is no remedies how to protect ourselves.
- 6:52And this is the reason why so many members of the parliament were on our side.
- 6:56And unfortunately, the president of the European Parliament played a very negative role in re-establishing this chat control one.
- 7:06Because I remember, I reminded in March this year,
- 7:10the European Parliament, with absolute majority, refused this very useless,
- 7:16and in fact, benefiting to one lobbyist company proposal.
- 7:23Proposal, right.
- 7:24Yeah, exactly.
- 7:26So where are we right now?
- 7:28We right now are in a situation where EPP, the European biggest party,
- 7:35which actually controls both European Commission, but also other bodies,
- 7:41and it has majority in European Parliament.
- 7:42they used urgent procedure which allowed them, in fact, when we had majority of present members
- 7:50in the parliament who voted against chat control, they were not enough to be a constituency majority
- 7:58to refuse completely this proposal. And this is how with this absurd, with this emergency procedure,
- 8:05this chat control one was adopted. Still we now as a human rights group but also with many other
- 8:12experts trying to understand how we can establish accountability for this obvious abuse of power
- 8:20from the side of EPP and from other side accumulate as much as possible forces for September
- 8:29when the main fight for privacy and access to internet and in general defense of your digital privacy will begin.
- 8:40Why? Because we have simultaneously multiple processes in European Union, but not only in European Union,
- 8:47because the same law right now replicated with the protection against age verification and so on in US.
- 8:54It's not just what's affecting Europe. It's spreading quite fast in UK. I don't speak about even Australia.
- 9:02But it's also reaching US. And it's so important to see this negative impact it can bring to our societies.
- 9:10And it's so important to be vocal now.
- 9:13So if you are in US, you still can explain who are these lobbyists and why it's beneficial to them specifically.
- 9:20You can encourage your friends in Europe or in different countries, France, Germany, Spain, wherever, to be active to defend your rights.
- 9:31So be very careful and also see who from your constituency, what kind of congresspeople promote the same kind of drafts because it's very dangerous.
- 9:42It seems like it might never be there, but better to make sure it's never there and it's not spreading to the U.S.
- 9:48so what we have in september we're gonna have discussion about chat control 2 chat control 2
- 9:54it's even more dangerous because it's affecting every single photo on your mobile phone it's
- 10:00affecting every single uh chat within your signal uh i messages uh whatsapp also i think whatsapp
- 10:09anyway it's control yeah even before there's a back door there's people you're still using it i
- 10:15I mean, I'm also using, but I understand that it's like,
- 10:18you almost write in publicly Right But still you don want to be forcing this kind of privacy messenger like Signal or others to be forced to send and to monitor your messengers private messengers
- 10:34So this is the last step, and I think it will be very beneficial for China, for Russia, for Iran, for anybody who wants to undermine any kind of democratic standards or competitiveness, any kind of progress of Western civilization.
- 10:50this chat control tool will be just a gift for them
- 10:53because in fact you have capacity to control minds
- 10:57and get information from at least 480 million of people
- 11:02living in the European Union
- 11:04and then through this
- 11:05anybody who is communicating with the US
- 11:08anybody who is communicating with any other country
- 11:10they are also going to be affected
- 11:11because it works both sides, right?
- 11:14It never stops just one side
- 11:16so it's very dangerous
- 11:18and this is something which we really have to accumulate and we have to bring
- 11:22youth so if you're a young person you use your messenger you have to be on our
- 11:27side you have to be vocal and you have to say your position do you agree that
- 11:31it's effective at all to defend your rights as a young person with this kind
- 11:36of legislation if your parent do you want as a parent to be so much with the
- 11:43care of the state to lead you what your child has to do or you actually capable
- 11:50to be parent and decide what your child is gonna have or not because you buying
- 11:55at the end of the day phone giving access paying everything child cannot do
- 12:00it so I think this child protection it's just absolutely protects the same like
- 12:06in many other cases and this is something that has to be articulated by
- 12:11parents agree quite quite vocally could i i want to touch on that point there just real quick because
- 12:17what comes to mind is i think of my sisters and their children and i'm looking at maybe my 12 year
- 12:22old niece using something and my sister says oh no no don't worry like i have i've put certain
- 12:26controls on it exactly the reason i say that is because parents can opt to put whatever controls
- 12:31that they want it is already in place it's already in place i just want to clarify that for people who
- 12:35maybe don't have children or don't understand this it's not as if children can just be given in
- 12:40unbridled access to the internet, parents can make decisions on what sorts of filters to put on these
- 12:44devices for their children. So please, please continue. I just wanted to make sure people
- 12:48understood. And of course, we have to give more real tools for police. It's not the mean
- 12:53to have access for civilians for all citizens just because, right? It's actually for them to be able
- 12:59to process specific criminal cases and to put these criminals, pedophiles in prison and keep
- 13:06them there effectively because if they don't have this capacity and pedophile is not ending up
- 13:12isolated, his or she depends who's this criminal, they come back on the streets and they come back
- 13:20online, they come back everywhere, right? So effective tools for law enforcement and for
- 13:26judicial system to be able to process it, not to generate false positives for them,
- 13:32not to generate for them enormous amount of work which makes no sense and they not have time for real criminals.
- 13:38This is something what I think our society also has to articulate clearly to legislators.
- 13:44Legislators who say in the final words in whom we have still the biggest power.
- 13:50Because again, in European Parliament we had majority. It's unfortunate, very unfortunate moment.
- 13:56I mean, it was deliberately done that they knew that members of the parliament will be not present there.
- 14:02But our role is to, in September, to knock the door on of every single legislator and ask him,
- 14:09OK, what are we going to do now? How are we going to stop this chat control one?
- 14:12And how are we going to stop this chat control two? Because you were not present.
- 14:16We really have to make this point quite clear.
- 14:19So position of constituency is sound in this very, very problematic privacy situation and attack on our privacy rights.
- 14:30And then remember that we have at the same time, starting from September to December,
- 14:37every member of the European Union government, they have to produce or agree for so-called digital wallet,
- 14:45which will have your digital ID.
- 14:48And we know now that these digital wallets with age verification were hacked so many times.
- 14:53It shows so much vulnerability.
- 14:55It is so dangerous to keep concentrated data of everything,
- 15:01of single European resident or citizen or entity in one place.
- 15:07It's just dream of Iran, North Korea, Russia, China to hack it.
- 15:13You don't need to collect it anymore.
- 15:15you just go to one place you hack it and that's it it's so dangerous it's so so dangerous and this
- 15:22is something what we have to be vocal uh for some kind of extent in uk people will vocal about it and
- 15:30they kind of i don believe that they block it for for a long time they will have to repeat it multiple times but at least least this show that it possible And we have to do it also in the EU We have to be quite woke on this
- 15:44Appreciate that. There's just one thing, if we could rewind for just a quick moment.
- 15:48Could you just describe for people that maybe weren't as familiar with what happened with
- 15:52Chat Control 1, how it got pushed through Parliament again the day before most of the
- 15:56members of the European Parliament went on vacation? Could you just give us a quick timeline
- 16:00of how everything played out, because it seemed based on who you were retweeting and what you
- 16:04were sharing on Twitter and through social media that you were right at the epicenter of all this.
- 16:09So can you tell us a little bit about how this all happened and what it was like to be in the
- 16:12middle of it? It was honestly shocking for me, because for me, still European Parliament is a
- 16:19place where you defend human rights, where you actually can abolish bad laws and so on.
- 16:25and unfortunately I have to say that right now we see trends where even European Parliament became
- 16:33a place with a lot of so-called emergency procedures mainly initiated by the biggest
- 16:40party EPP and this is exactly what happened with chat control when EPP leadership brought
- 16:47back chat control one from death where in March European Parliament basically said
- 16:54no, we don't want it and we reflect the desire of EU citizens.
- 16:59And they used quite a rare, urgent procedure.
- 17:04And it was just very procedural.
- 17:06So you don't have ability to change much.
- 17:09You just need to reject or you have to agree with what council
- 17:12another body of European power, basically governments, propose.
- 17:18and we had 314 members who were voted to reject Kansel's position, right?
- 17:30And majority, so majority members said no, but it was not enough, as I said already,
- 17:39it's not enough amount of members of the parliament to be absolute majority to reject it.
- 17:47So, in fact, everybody present, we can say, voted no.
- 17:52Result was adopted just because not enough members were there.
- 17:56And that's why I'm saying that if you want to make this change,
- 18:00you have to contact as a constituency to your member of the parliament.
- 18:04You have to check vote lists or even not checking.
- 18:07You just ask what you have done to defend my right for privacy.
- 18:11I'm against chat control one.
- 18:12I don't want even to have chat control two.
- 18:14tell me what you as a member of the parliament have done for this and then you will know if this
- 18:20person actually was in the room or not i advise everybody who is watching this uh really really
- 18:27motivate people to ask this question to members of the parliament so they really understand that
- 18:31constituency care about privacy yeah it's really really important and then of course uh hold
- 18:36accountable president of european parliament because it's unacceptable that she as a leader
- 18:43of this body which said clearly no she used this procedure to please cancel so it's basically a play
- 18:51of one political group it's it's extremely embarrassing it's embarrassing for uh this
- 18:57procedure because it means if there is another power it's going to abuse the same uh way parliament
- 19:03parliament is losing its representation to constituency it means that it loses the trust
- 19:08of very people who elected them.
- 19:13This is the main institution we at least somehow trust.
- 19:18Because whenever there's a crazy proposal coming from the European Commission or the
- 19:22Council, this is the only place where you can block it.
- 19:25And when somebody just using political connections to undermine the entire process, it undermines
- 19:32democracy, the very basis how a society operates and trusts to each other, right?
- 19:39So it's a very dangerous thing.
- 19:41And a member of the European Parliament who was a negotiator on this file, Marketa Grigorova
- 19:48from Czech Republic, she called it unprecedented.
- 19:52And she specifically accused EPP in abusing its position as the largest political group
- 19:58to bring back proposal that parliament has already rejected so this is where we are and this is very
- 20:06dangerous gap and this is what we have to discuss and demand uh as accountability step appreciate
- 20:12that so the other thing that i wanted to note is that this isn't really from what i've read this is
- 20:17not really like a right or a left issue it wasn't like the left trying to get something across
- 20:21because there was a lot of opposition across the aisle from what i read so from the political right
- 20:25to the political left from cyber security experts to human rights defenders or advocates like
- 20:30yourself there were a lot of people pushing back so as as things gear up for september does is the
- 20:38europe is the european parliament aware of sort of the fight the the the the kind of wall of voices
- 20:44that it's going to be up against once it tries to implement chat control too um and do you think
- 20:50do you think that's a good thing?
- 20:51I mean, obviously it's good in a democracy
- 20:53that representatives are speaking up
- 20:55and represent the will of the people.
- 20:57But on a certain level,
- 20:58do you think they're also preparing
- 20:59to sort of make their arguments
- 21:01for why this thing has to be rammed
- 21:03through one way or another?
- 21:05Of course they're preparing.
- 21:06Of course, because if you look into
- 21:07what's happening on X
- 21:09and any kind of other social media,
- 21:11they everyday post in the same messages
- 21:13that they protect in children.
- 21:15They bring the same voices of Andrew Wohl
- 21:17who is justifying this policy.
- 21:21But for some reason,
- 21:23they escape any dialogue
- 21:25and any bringing independent voices
- 21:27who oppose it.
- 21:28And this is, for me, a red flag.
- 21:31And this is what means that
- 21:33voices of all of these experts,
- 21:36800 cybersecurity experts
- 21:37and researchers who signed
- 21:39two open letters
- 21:40warning how this technology
- 21:41actually produced
- 21:43unacceptable high amount of errors.
- 21:46they have to be vocal again
- 21:49and if you know this kind of experts
- 21:51please say them that their voice was
- 21:53important but it has to be repeated even
- 21:55more vocal right now so any
- 21:57kind of events happening in Europe
- 21:59outside of Europe any kind
- 22:01of meeting happening any kind of publication
- 22:03in social media
- 22:04this is all instruments we can use
- 22:07to bring our voices again to be heard
- 22:09and remember to tag
- 22:11to mention to invite
- 22:13to meet with members of the
- 22:15parliament and saying i'm your constituency i want you to fix it because the parliament may know
- 22:22but everybody expects that with a summer vacation everybody will forget about the issue
- 22:27and this is why it was done just before vacation season right always all the sneaky laws proposals
- 22:34done during vacation period or just before vacation because the two months of european
- 22:40vacations it's a brilliant time when you forget about something right and then in september you're
- 22:45so busy children to school you happen work and everything you just have no time right everybody
- 22:50is so busy so this is a moment when your rights are the most vulnerable and this is a moment where
- 22:57you have just secure fraction of your time to make this effort send email but not just chat gbt email
- 23:05right you just make it a little bit human and and say i'm this and this i want you to fix this
- 23:10i wanted to fix uh my privacy and and uh vote against chat control i want you to investigate
- 23:17what happened actually before vacation season so these kind of small steps it's important if you're
- 23:25ready to invest your time more we need to do actually surveys we need to find survey companies
- 23:31who will help us to do independent survey and show
- 23:35how actually young people and parents are satisfied with existing tools
- 23:41and what they think about chat control.
- 23:44Do they actually support it at all?
- 23:46I'm pretty sure that majority of people have no clue,
- 23:48but if they understand how it's going to damage their cyber security,
- 23:53security, human rights, they will think twice.
- 23:56And they will say what they think about it,
- 23:58but just majority have no clue about it.
- 24:00So we need to go out of this bubble.
- 24:01We need to speak with universities.
- 24:03We need to speak with schools even.
- 24:06And we need to speak with parents of these children.
- 24:09It means like huge category of people.
- 24:11And we can only do if people who care about privacy go out of their bubble and speak up about it.
- 24:17Encourage people to be more sensitive for this issue.
- 24:22Yeah, 100%.
- 24:23One thing I really want to do, because it's one thing to give a call to action.
- 24:27but as a former teacher i know that oftentimes people need very specific instructions so
- 24:32is there any websites or very specific things that people can do i know you mentioned have
- 24:37conversations or post on social media send a letter but is there a way to check out is there
- 24:42a place where you can go and see a form letter like what an example of this sort of letter should
- 24:45look like um any other places you should direct people to go to right now if they're looking to
- 24:50take action or educate themselves about what they can do?
- 24:53So there are two options.
- 24:55If you're kind of lazy enough, but you still want to do something.
- 25:00Okay, we're busy now, right?
- 25:02You just go, there is an amazing chat control EU website,
- 25:07which gather all lists of members apart from all countries
- 25:10and gives you exactly draft you need to address.
- 25:13And there is the latest updates.
- 25:15So this website is, I think, in this specific issue,
- 25:19is a bright example of what we have, like accumulation of knowledge and instructions,
- 25:24what has to be done.
- 25:27But if you want to do a little bit more sophisticated, reach out to me on any kind of social media,
- 25:34Noster, Instagram, Facebook, whatever, and I will get you to our group where we have
- 25:41volunteers and where we do more sophisticated things.
- 25:44if you have ability to speak personally with members of the parliament, which is more effective.
- 25:49We need faces of defenders of privacy.
- 25:53Because members of the parliament are human and they want to feel that the work they doing is actually useful Because imagine what stress they have They going be re and and what uh epp party will say oh you defending pedophiles and he was a no i defending
- 26:10constituency right for privacy and i have this and this and this person from my village from my city
- 26:17from my small i don't know town whatever who said me who met with me and so he said his story why
- 26:24it's for him important so be this person this is very specific and i'm happy to prepare you i will
- 26:30happy to uh you know give arguments but we need this kind of people especially young people
- 26:36parents like it's pretty much everybody who just want to contribute uh time and to live in free
- 26:43society yeah 100 um i will leave in the show notes a link to uh to both i'll leave links to
- 26:51Ludmila's social media, but also to that
- 26:53chat control EU website.
- 26:54And if you're totally busy and you don't want to do
- 26:57not the first, not the second, just support us financially,
- 26:59you know, you also need
- 27:01this.
- 27:03This is also an important contribution.
- 27:05Yeah, the Open Dialogue
- 27:07Foundation, which Ludmila
- 27:09is the president of. There will be a link to that
- 27:11in the show notes as well. Very, very important
- 27:13to support.
- 27:15I believe you could do so via BTC
- 27:17Pay Server as well as traditional financial
- 27:19methods as well. Hopefully it was again repaired.
- 27:21I think it's working.
- 27:22Yeah, it's working.
- 27:23Yeah, that's a whole different story, which we're going to get into in just a moment.
- 27:28I appreciate that.
- 27:29Thank you for the heads up on all of that.
- 27:31To other people, you know, it was funny.
- 27:33What made me initially want to reach out to you, there was a post from Alex Gladstein saying like, this is why we Noster.
- 27:38And it was about, you know, like internet restrictions and this and that.
- 27:41And your response was like, my friend, like there's no, like the Noster, the Noster thing.
- 27:47If you have the ID just to get into your phone or whatever.
- 27:50Exactly.
- 27:50Nostar doesn't matter.
- 27:51There's no privacy there.
- 27:53And I'm not saying that Alex is a friend.
- 27:55I'm not saying it.
- 27:56It's like I think I knew what he was getting at.
- 27:58But the point here, if you're not catching on to everything that Ludmilla is saying,
- 28:01your signal, your Nostar, all these other freedom tech tools.
- 28:05Everything is going to be too digital.
- 28:06It's all under surveillance.
- 28:09So if that means something to you, please act.
- 28:11I have a feeling it does if you're listening to this podcast.
- 28:13So please act one of those three or four options that Ludmilla just mentioned.
- 28:17There's two other things that I wanted to touch on while we have you here, Ludmilla.
- 28:20First, I want to touch on a little bit of this paper that you just published on transnational financial repression.
- 28:27I think you co-authored it with Jorge Gerasati.
- 28:30This was for the Hoover Institute, if I'm not mistaken.
- 28:33And I want to just dive into that a little bit because I think that it's related to chat control in a way.
- 28:39So it's a financial issue, but a lot of this is all really about where your information goes and then who it is shared with.
- 28:46So can you share with people what transnational financial repression is, how you experienced it?
- 28:52That's initially what got you involved in doing this work that you do as a human rights defender, as an activist.
- 28:57And then maybe just a little bit of what you touch on in the paper.
- 29:00Sure. Transnational financial repression, long definition, but in fact, it means when dictators capable to cut you off from financial services,
- 29:10get your travel data, weaponize your communication data, everything around your digital data.
- 29:15when you have no clue about it.
- 29:18So nobody asks you.
- 29:20Nobody protects you, right?
- 29:21Because it's emergency tools and states assume that they can trust to each other
- 29:26and share this data emergency.
- 29:28Because they assume that you might be criminal.
- 29:31So all of these assumptions and these emergency tools
- 29:34make Western citizens and entities extremely vulnerable
- 29:38against weaponization of malicious actors
- 29:40who want to destroy you just because you're competitors
- 29:43or for some other reason, so you're a brilliant scientist.
- 29:47You're not just a humanity defender.
- 29:48What I'm trying to say, the transnational financial repression,
- 29:50it's not only about activists anymore.
- 29:53It's unfortunately touched every single person.
- 29:56And this is what we specifically brought to Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe,
- 30:03where US, Europe, Canada, UK and many other countries are part of it.
- 30:08So it's 57 member states, part of this organization.
- 30:11and usually they decide how financial, cybersecurity, national security laws
- 30:17has to be spread in these countries.
- 30:18This time we're brought to them saying,
- 30:20guys, the law you proposed actually heavily weaponized
- 30:24by some actually members of even your organization.
- 30:27And there is no remedies how to protect Western citizens and entities.
- 30:31And I was a victim of this kind of weaponization.
- 30:33What does it mean?
- 30:34My bank account was terminated.
- 30:36This is the reason why I used Bitcoin, to overcome it.
- 30:38But in this development, what we see right now, even using your Bitcoin or any kind of privacy tool can be compromised if the very access to Internet, this is precisely what you mentioned, going to be through digital ID.
- 30:53If I would have no access to my Internet connection privately, it means that every single move is going to be recorded.
- 31:04And not only recorded, at some point I can be just refused to enter Internet.
- 31:08And this is something what we see right now for example in Central Asian countries And Kazakhstan is a part of these conventions And first this country was abusing my rights in Belgium
- 31:23and tried to get all my financial communication and travel data
- 31:27from all member states of European Union,
- 31:30but also from US, where I'm active and where my family members live in organization operates.
- 31:35And luckily, because my case is so known in Belgium,
- 31:38this time Belgian courts and even prosecutor and police they refused to comply with this
- 31:44criminal complaint which they fabricated against me and my organization so just as a background
- 31:50they were using exactly to the point of our discussion chat control accusation against me
- 31:57that i harassed children online how it was happened harassment i was recording testimonies
- 32:03of victims of torching mass shooting in Kazakhstan back in January 2022
- 32:08and earlier before, where there was also political killing.
- 32:13So these victims testified with names of perpetrators.
- 32:18And these perpetrators, they said that they are fathers of minor children.
- 32:22And their children are crying watching these interviews.
- 32:25Of course, the children are not only not able to watch anything,
- 32:28some of them are less than one year old,
- 32:30they are not even able to understand the language we are talking to.
- 32:33But procedure works in a way that no matter how absurd the accusation is there, normally all my travel communication financial data, both from all member states of the EU and US, has to be given to them.
- 32:48And now imagine, it's affecting, for example, someone who is less known than me, who has no protection in Belgium or any kind of European or US jurisdiction.
- 33:02this data is going to be shared immediately.
- 33:05So it's very dangerous, and it's affecting not only activists,
- 33:08it can affect anybody who can be targeted,
- 33:11who is potential interest in these authoritarian states.
- 33:16Pretty big category if we understand that any kind of AI expert,
- 33:21anybody who is involved in semiconductors,
- 33:23or any kind of new technology, military technology, biological technology,
- 33:28like almost every single aspect of our life right now,
- 33:32can be treated as a weapon, right? And it means that we have to understand this issue as
- 33:39national security. And this is what precisely was mentioned in the resolution of
- 33:44Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe. And this is now created as a roadmap to make this law binding
- 33:51and protecting our rights. We have to work on national levels.
- 33:55It means that we need to have partners and coalition of legislators
- 33:58understanding this issue in US.
- 34:00We need to have the same legislators
- 34:02understanding this issue in Europe.
- 34:04In Europe, we already work in European Parliament.
- 34:07We have a majority here who understand this issue
- 34:09and we're going to develop even more deep
- 34:13this work in the coming months.
- 34:16But not in US yet.
- 34:18So if you're in US and you want to support our work
- 34:20on this regard and you want to protect Americans' data,
- 34:24both entities and individuals,
- 34:26please reach out.
- 34:27I'm happy to coordinate how we can make this happen.
- 34:31And with this paper, why we also published in Hoover,
- 34:35because this is a perfect institution who understands all political aspects.
- 34:40They understand the need to defend your freedom.
- 34:43It's never given.
- 34:44It's only when you fight for it, you actually can keep your freedom.
- 34:48It's constant investment.
- 34:49Investment and once more, investment and defense.
- 34:52Second, they understand this financial security
- 34:56National security, cyber security issues
- 34:59They bring in knowledge from every single angle
- 35:01This is why I love Hoover
- 35:03It's like brilliant people with brilliant souls
- 35:06They are very kind in any kind of
- 35:09Just amazing community
- 35:13Who allows you to grow, to build coalitions
- 35:17So it's really important
- 35:19And then, of course, third input, that they have access both for students and they have access for journalists and have access for broad audience, even politicians who can read our messages.
- 35:35So from these three perspectives, it was very strategic for us and we are very grateful for Hoover that they hosted this article and we are capable to bring it to attentions of so broad a category of people.
- 35:48And of course, Stanford itself, it's a paradise for experts on encryption, quantum computer and everything, right?
- 35:57So they also need to understand that they are the risk.
- 36:01For many people, it seems so far away.
- 36:04They say, no, it's never touched me.
- 36:06Unfortunately, it's not the case.
- 36:07You will never understand why your company is destroyed, why something happened around you.
- 36:12And you never understand.
- 36:14It looks very weird how it could even happen.
- 36:16But because your data is stolen it gives full roadmap how you can be attacked how people who are important for you are affected So please care about your data and let fix protection of both Americans and Europeans as soon as possible
- 36:33We can do it.
- 36:34Appreciate that.
- 36:35One of the things that was important, and I want to bring it up just in case maybe some of this, what you're hearing today is new.
- 36:41I want to just talk quickly about the role that the institution called the Financial Action Task Force or the FATF plays in all of this.
- 36:49because a lot of the work that you do is around engaging with representatives in civil society on a European Union level or on a state and federal level within the U.S.
- 37:00You've done a lot of engaging with policymakers and politicians.
- 37:04The FATF is a little bit of a different force here, and they're kind of the force behind a lot of AML, CFT, so anti-money laundering, anti-terrorist financing regulation.
- 37:15So they're not the ones, they're not implementing it technically because they are not a government in and of themselves, but they are this sort of international organization that has a lot of influence over what happens within governments, especially.
- 37:29They're not even international organizations.
- 37:31They're actually a combination of government who are gathering from time to time for informal gathering.
- 37:35This is like the most interesting thing that if you try to hold accountable them as an organization, you cannot because it doesn't exist as a body.
- 37:47So this is a huge problem because we want to put effort and they deliberately as a body or website, in fact, or gathering saying that they don't care about human rights.
- 38:00It's not their actually even mandate to do so.
- 38:04But with long-term campaign we are doing, and we're exposing specific cases, for example, we brought a case of Barlek Mende-Gaziv, Mayankens and others' cases, showing how American data can be weaponized by authoritarian regimes.
- 38:21It's not just some third country affected with financial repression, where Financial Action Task Force rules use as a repression tool, as an invisible prison, as actually digital prison.
- 38:34It's happening on Western territories.
- 38:36And these rules were created to protect Western civilization, first of all, in place and then spread it as a standard for global security.
- 38:46We show that this trust-based approach is actually so much broken.
- 38:50It has to be reviewed.
- 38:51It has to be re-evaluated. We have to have specific numbers, how many actually damages
- 38:57it's produced for businesses, for competitiveness, for people's lives. Because a lot of people
- 39:02are financially excluded, their businesses destroyed, knowledge stolen. It's a national
- 39:08security thing. So we see police, the biggest police organization, Interpol, is also heavily
- 39:13abused based on these rules. Why? Because you cannot initiate red notice of Interpol, any kind
- 39:19of an autism interval if you don't have enough legal emergency tool ground to enforce this police
- 39:27cooperation. And more and more we see that authoritarian regimes started to use financial
- 39:34action task force rules and Interpol rules and many other national security tools and corporations
- 39:40as a best tool which gives them free access to data and enormous amount of power to destroy any
- 39:49single person they want to destroy in Western countries, even politicians. In
- 39:54resolution of Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, Parliament
- 39:58Assembly, they mentioned members of the Prime Ministers of Western countries who
- 40:02were wanted by Russia. And Russia is capable to put, for example, diffusion
- 40:07notice of INSEPAL in the way that if it's wanted person from Estonia, Estonian
- 40:14government will never see this request so when official from Estonia will travel to third country
- 40:20i don't know let's say to Qatar or to any other country to Africa to Latin America they can be
- 40:28potentially arrested and you as a state actually excluded from this so the tools which were created
- 40:37to have more flexibility to catch criminals doesn't work.
- 40:43And you need to say about it.
- 40:45You need to actually react and review these laws.
- 40:48Because we live in the world where a majority of the states are authoritarian
- 40:51and they are a majority in this police organization.
- 40:53And they perfectly know how they can weaponize it.
- 40:56So we as Western citizens should not pay our taxes.
- 41:01It's something funded by us is going to be weaponized against us.
- 41:05and we should hold accountable
- 41:07also financial action task force
- 41:09no matter how they
- 41:10right now try to escape it
- 41:12we need to ask our politicians
- 41:14okay what you have done
- 41:17how much money spent there
- 41:18actually and why my
- 41:21tax money is going there right
- 41:22so I want to have real
- 41:25protection not something what sounds
- 41:26like protection on the paper but undermines
- 41:29my rights and more
- 41:31victims speak up
- 41:33more evidences we have but
- 41:34as a human organization, we have a huge dilemma that before we have
- 41:39any in place remedies victims afraid to speak up it's just few victims who really able to do so
- 41:48like myself because i know how to actually move around right but majority of people
- 41:53they're really not ready they already so much broken their family members are so much against
- 42:01of it um and i understand it because i also lived quite hard with with my family with everybody
- 42:08around this experience.
- 42:10So it's really important to make one step ahead
- 42:14and to prevent it.
- 42:15And that's why it's so important for everybody
- 42:17who listens to this podcast,
- 42:19ask your politician what they have done
- 42:22to protect your right, financial right,
- 42:25travel data, communication data.
- 42:27These are basics.
- 42:28And your access to internet,
- 42:29it has to be free, not free for payment,
- 42:34but free access as a protection of your privacy.
- 42:38and basically private access to internet.
- 42:43Yep. Yeah, 100% appreciate all that.
- 42:45Thank you, Ludmilla.
- 42:46One thing that I wasn't planning to get into,
- 42:48but we were talking a little bit about it off camera,
- 42:51but we're on camera, but before we started recording,
- 42:53was what's currently happening with AI.
- 42:56You commented on what Claude just announced,
- 42:59which is that there's going to be a Claude watermark
- 43:00on whatever you put out.
- 43:02And then we're also seeing the fact that certain models,
- 43:06the frontier models from the United States.
- 43:08We're seeing the Bitcoin red team,
- 43:10which is Rob Hamilton and Kale
- 43:13trying to do the best they can to audit
- 43:15tons of open source code right now,
- 43:17not being able to rely on the American frontier models
- 43:20to do this.
- 43:21Instead, having to rely on models like Kimi K3,
- 43:25which are Chinese open source, open weight models.
- 43:28We're at a new frontier with these,
- 43:32for lack of a better term,
- 43:33we're on a new frontier,
- 43:34or in a new place with these frontier models
- 43:36and what's happening.
- 43:38Curious to get your thoughts on it.
- 43:40We could start with the Claude watermarking,
- 43:42everything that you write.
- 43:43You were saying kind of how kind of taken back
- 43:46you were at this,
- 43:47because this is obviously going to have
- 43:49a tremendous effect on intellectual property
- 43:51and the way that we put information out there
- 43:53and how credible that information will be.
- 43:55So I just want to get your thoughts on this,
- 43:56if you don't mind.
- 43:58So first of all, I see the huge repetition
- 44:02of what we just discussed with financial law,
- 44:05cybersecurity law,
- 44:06and what's affected with our travel data,
- 44:09communication data.
- 44:10It's the same now with AI.
- 44:12And what is AI?
- 44:13We come to the point when a lot of huge massive
- 44:17of our information, personal information,
- 44:20our professional experience,
- 44:22our intelligence we build in AI,
- 44:24which we share with a company,
- 44:27service provider is about to decide what is actually yours and what is not yours.
- 44:36And in fact, in case of Claude, it just was said, everything is mine. No matter
- 44:41what you put inside, it's just mine. And my point was to show how for human
- 44:48defenders it's gonna work and how actually it's gonna affect our rights.
- 44:52First, you cannot expect from AI that AI will produce something really useful for human rights defenders.
- 45:01We educate models. We ask models all the time, keep our style of writing,
- 45:06argumentation, because it's natural. Nobody trains in AI with human rights.
- 45:11So what we do, what we already contribute for everybody, right, and when we as an activist are using it,
- 45:18we educate every single model and we do it for purpose, Grok, every single, to give this knowledge of human rights values.
- 45:27Which is explicitly lack of it, right?
- 45:30Otherwise, we would not have all this discussion that AI has to be with different kind of limitations and so on.
- 45:36And now all of this knowledge, what we give, which we cannot for obvious reasons take from AI, is marked as not our knowledge.
- 45:44It just in this case of with Claude it just Claude 1 We discuss and we use Claude of course or any other models and unfortunately EU regulation demands this Waterman But in the case of Claude I think
- 46:00this is the most strict at the moment, how they use it. They, in fact, use it as opportunity to
- 46:10steal all our intelligence every every single user so not just watermark how it was asked by
- 46:16EU legislation but they did it just like everything is ours just by default but if you are producing
- 46:24some fault information it's yours so it's kind of everything what you produce is ours but if you run
- 46:30and you use it somewhere it's yours you know so it's very it's nice deal not very comfortable
- 46:35So, and I see in this, besides this intellectual property thing and educating model, another
- 46:43thing that it allows for service providers, in this case AI cloud, which already, unfortunately,
- 46:52doing proactive sharing information if any kind of request from the government is coming.
- 46:58So whatever you use, it can be proactively shared with authoritarian regimes.
- 47:05it's extremely sad and i raise this issue with claude i'm waiting for their response what they're
- 47:10going to say about it they can give you a model which actually
- 47:19all the time decreasing capacity of your answer what does it mean if you pay for high subscription
- 47:25they will always give you less qualified answers and and less advanced model by default because
- 47:34you for example discuss reform of interpol which is i do for example i work on sensitive issues
- 47:41with victims of torture and mass shooting right if i use their testimonies and i work on them on
- 47:45translation i have to do like triple check of any kind of translation of course i'm doing because i
- 47:51don't have enough resources right and still it's better than nothing but then again this product
- 47:58is gonna be marked that it's a cloth, it's not my translation check, right?
- 48:06And formatting and everything. So it's a huge problem of property rights at this moment.
- 48:15It's a huge problem of security because this watermark, if they are not used yet as a civilian
- 48:21tool, it's an infrastructure for any kind of regime to know every single person who might
- 48:26interview and how this document travel around right to whom it was sent and when it was sent
- 48:31so this metadata deep deeply built in these tokens by Claude it's very very sensitive and
- 48:39very dangerous thing this is what i also addressed with them in what kind of measures they have for
- 48:44such client like like myself and i hope they will respond so to back to the point it's extremely
- 48:52dangerous and we see this when bad actors will want to weaponize Claude against us, we have almost
- 48:59no tools. While we want to be legitimate users and again laws created for good purposes were used in
- 49:09fact to limit our rights and capacity. And this is example where both Senate but also European
- 49:17Parliament and many national parliaments has to address. In order for them to address it properly,
- 49:21not like European Parliament did it right now together with Commission right
- 49:25they need to have voices of constituents users so again and again
- 49:31whenever you want to protect yourself from chat control protect your future
- 49:36with your access to intelligence and protect your rights to be actually
- 49:40owner of your intelligence and intelligence and this is something again
- 49:45this is more sophisticated it's not yet created any website for this so I would
- 49:49advise people to contact me so we can actually
- 49:51build an expert coalition
- 49:53and work on it. It's something
- 49:55I believe pretty urgent because this technology develops very fast and it part of our life society and we going to live in this world of AI It better to set it correctly from the day one than wait until it too late
- 50:11Is there, so oftentimes I think about Bitcoin when it comes to having conversations with people,
- 50:17oftentimes we think there's some sort of malicious intent, but there's just a lack of education,
- 50:21a lack of sort of understanding about the benefits of this technology. Is it a similar thing with AI
- 50:26where some of this stuff is happening and it's happening, it's so new.
- 50:30Oftentimes you're interfacing with people, politicians,
- 50:33policymakers who are a little bit older.
- 50:34Do they not even necessarily understand the issues
- 50:37that this is potentially causing right now?
- 50:39I'm just kind of thinking about it.
- 50:40I mean, the majority of them are even not allowed now to use,
- 50:43for example, American AI.
- 50:45Yeah, that's right. That's right. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 50:47Do you think that that inevitably changes?
- 50:49So we've seen, as I mentioned earlier, the Bitcoin Red team,
- 50:53the people who have been auditing the open source code
- 50:55of many different Bitcoin projects
- 50:57since the cold card hack
- 50:59or firmware vulnerability.
- 51:01A lot of them have,
- 51:02like Rob Hamilton of Anchor Watch,
- 51:05he's run up against this thing
- 51:07of the American model saying,
- 51:08no, no, no, we can't have you go do that.
- 51:10Yes.
- 51:10This is a classical example.
- 51:12This is a classical example
- 51:13when law is applied against
- 51:15actually social need,
- 51:18you know, because what he does,
- 51:20he's protecting social needs,
- 51:22social interest, national interest,
- 51:24because this is American and many other citizens of Western countries
- 51:27or just users of American technology.
- 51:30Yeah, let's say because Bitcoin was said
- 51:33that it's national technology of US, right?
- 51:36So there is no tool switch nowadays from US AI
- 51:42you can use to defend it.
- 51:45But what we see and what we hear from security experts,
- 51:49cybersecurity experts, that actually the newest models
- 51:52they used against actually to hack
- 51:55the legitimate users of Bitcoin and their wallets.
- 52:00And this is something what has to be prevented.
- 52:03It's exactly the thing we have to address.
- 52:07Yeah.
- 52:07Yeah, we don't want the bad guys having access to attack with it
- 52:10without the good guys having the access to protect with it.
- 52:13I'm not trying to create just such a binary.
- 52:15We just want everyday people to have the same power
- 52:17that the most, I don't know, powerful or like the bad actors.
- 52:21I would here even go one step ahead and say, if we see that such people like Rob, who is, he has all possible verification and everything, right?
- 52:31And then he was degraded with his right and access.
- 52:34That's right.
- 52:34It's mean that people who...
- 52:36Let me explain that a little bit.
- 52:37So what Rob did is he did the whole KYC process for the frontier models.
- 52:41I think it was, I think he was using OpenAI and he went through everything.
- 52:46And then he said, like, this is what I'm doing with it.
- 52:48I'm doing these security audits.
- 52:49and OpenAI said, OK, well, we can't give you our top models.
- 52:52We'll just let you use these models.
- 52:54That's what Mila was referring to there.
- 52:55Exactly. Thank you, Fran.
- 52:57So and then we see that cybersecurity experts say specifically
- 53:01that models of OpenAI or Claude and other American, basically, AI companies
- 53:09were used to hack these legitimate users of Bitcoin and wallets.
- 53:14It means that they should know how to evade these security flagships.
- 53:20Who can do it if normal cybersecurity experts from the US are not allowed to use it?
- 53:26It means that the states.
- 53:27Yep.
- 53:28Which states right now have access to the cybersecurity cooperation, proactive sharing
- 53:35of information?
- 53:36This is precisely an example.
- 53:37How many Bitcoin users lost?
- 53:40Over 5,000 of people, right?
- 53:43At least wallet?
- 53:44users yeah yeah two thousand bitcoin maybe five thousand people yeah yes so it's example how these
- 53:51specific laws which i was saying transnational repression can be targeted simple people this is
- 53:56example because they use the i normal person have obstruction you cannot you're going to be
- 54:01degraded immediately in your rights you will not have this uh supermodal but states can do it
- 54:07And the worst part that OpenAI CLOTE or any kind of these providers they have to comply with international law they have to it means that they have to give this higher access to model to state requests
- 54:22which kind of state's request afterwards was abused you don't know and that's why it has to
- 54:28be stopped and this is example when i say it's not only problem of activists it's not only a
- 54:33It's a problem of me. It's a problem of every single person.
- 54:36Yeah. If information can travel into the wrong hands,
- 54:40we all have the potential to become a victim of that information traveling.
- 54:43And it's not only already information, it's AI models.
- 54:47It's not only about travel communication.
- 54:50Actually, this is what's happened with cold card,
- 54:52what happened with BTC servers and everything.
- 54:54It's use case of national security transfer of AI higher model to probably states.
- 55:00And we need to ask for investigation of this case.
- 55:02who got access to these models
- 55:04because hacker groups nowadays
- 55:06doesn't exist separately from the states.
- 55:09Russia supports these hackers.
- 55:11Otherwise, it would be easy to identify them.
- 55:14North Korea is the same.
- 55:15It's state and state and once again state.
- 55:17So it was an attack for mainly Americans
- 55:20because cold card was probably,
- 55:22I would say,
- 55:23mostly famous and spread in the US still
- 55:27around Americans.
- 55:29and it has to be investigated.
- 55:33Yeah, 100%.
- 55:35Ludmila, I don't want to take up too much more of your time,
- 55:37but I just wanted to open the floor.
- 55:38If there's anything we didn't touch on or any final thoughts,
- 55:41anything else that's on your mind right now that you wanted to share, please.
- 55:45I think we discussed everything.
- 55:46What I would say that care about your privacy.
- 55:50You might do all right in your protocol,
- 55:53but you have no idea how your rights can be weaponized
- 55:56if those authoritarian regimes can get access for your data.
- 56:00And what's happened with ColdCard, what's happened with me,
- 56:02what's happened with many donors of U.S.
- 56:04who were donating for good causes and were prosecuted
- 56:08just because of weaponization, these laws,
- 56:11it's all united in one thing.
- 56:12We have jointly defend our privacy online
- 56:16and in general our privacy.
- 56:19So fight for it.
- 56:20Be active as much as possible.
- 56:23Join us and support us.
- 56:24I'm going to highlight that and just double click on it just to say, you know, again, you're probably going to close this podcast and go walk away and do whatever.
- 56:32My suggestion is go into the show notes now.
- 56:35Click on at least one of the links that I've shared that enables you to do something.
- 56:39Start there and then maybe go down the rabbit hole a bit.
- 56:42It's not a matter of everybody doing everything, but it is a matter of everybody doing a little something, especially to support the sort of lead that people like Ludmilla have taken.
- 56:51um you know listening to a lot of these podcasts i think oftentimes there's that psychological
- 56:56phenomenon where because there's a lot of people looking on nobody does anything but we have to
- 57:02realize that we all have to do something here because we we're going we're going to be responsible
- 57:07for defending our own rights but the bigger thing too is that we have to shift the overton window
- 57:11we have to talk about privacy not as something taboo but as something that's a normal part of
- 57:16the human experience and without everyday people speaking up. Access to WhatsApp. Privacy. It's
- 57:21access to it. It's your real access to your life. That's right. It's just simple as it is. And what's
- 57:27happened with cold card again, with abuse of AI, it's probably what states behind these hackers.
- 57:32Otherwise, you had not access to these systems. Yeah. So we want to stop this. The only way to
- 57:38do it is to speak up and to work together. We're a fairly small group of people listening to podcasts
- 57:42like this so it's it's even more important that we speak up and and i think educate the quote
- 57:47unquote normies in our life about why this is important because it will it will impact them
- 57:51eventually as well so ludmila thank you for doing the work that you do thank you for educating people
- 57:54thank you for sharing these resources again they will all be in the show notes and i appreciate all
- 57:59you're doing i hope to see you in person soon and that's that thank you so much thank you thank you
- 58:03frank and thank you everybody who was with us that's it hope to see you soon thank you everybody
- 58:08We'll talk soon. Bye-bye.