Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Genocide and Nuclear War
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:21This is I Love You. Keep Going.
- 0:22It is February 29th, 2024 at 7:37 PM Pacific Standard Time.
- 0:31And I wanted to talk a little bit about the nature of
- 0:35suffering and and how suffering doesn't seem to lead to any kind
- 0:41of insight or any kind of what we might call enlightenment.
- 0:53And then what it is actually that we need to begin to see in
- 0:57order for those processes to happen.
- 1:02You look at the world, and the world is in terrible suffering
- 1:07all over the place in the in the Middle East and Gaza and Israel
- 1:12and the Ukraine in our own country.
- 1:21As we approach the election, I have almost a a a sort of
- 1:28anticipatory horror of what the possibilities are that are
- 1:32coming. And I find that most of the
- 1:40time, when I think about it and I think about my own ability to
- 1:44affect it, I feel rather hopeless about the whole thing.
- 1:51Hope, I know, is tricky. You don't want to hope too much
- 1:59and in some sense create a kind of Pollyanna ish positivity.
- 2:11On the other hand, each of us have the agents that we have in
- 2:15affecting these things. Mostly what we have is the
- 2:20capacity to talk about it in the social groups that we have, and
- 2:33it's very touchy these days to be able to talk about anything
- 2:39very polarized over the the course of the Gears of my life.
- 2:50I've watched this polarization happen, and I think that it it
- 2:57corresponds to the the gradual inequality that we've allowed to
- 3:03happen. When Iran fell just going all
- 3:17the way back to the 70s, there was this buzz about what it is
- 3:24that would have to happen in order for that process to
- 3:29unfold, the collapsing of these stable or what are viewed as
- 3:35stable societies. And the Rand Corporation came up
- 3:42with this metric of the relationship between the bottom
- 3:465th and the top fifth. And they said that when the
- 3:50wealth of the top 5th exceeded 40 times the wealth of the
- 3:55bottom 5th that the the the societies would become unstable
- 3:59and that the governments were likely to collapse.
- 4:04And that was at a time in this country where we weren't quite
- 4:07there yet. We were in the 30s of
- 4:10inequality. But we've now passed that up
- 4:13quite a bit. And then the rise of populists
- 4:25in the government. How does one confront that and
- 4:37then attend to the suffering experience that arises from that
- 4:45In Buddhist thought? Of course we're looking at the
- 4:48nature of the human conditioning as one of suffering, but it
- 4:52isn't so much the experience of what's happening, but the the
- 4:58willingness to cling to the particular outcome that you
- 5:01want. So when something happens that
- 5:05you enjoy as it begins to pass, as all things are impermanent,
- 5:09we cling to it, wanting it to last longer.
- 5:11And as things arise that are unpleasant, we resist their
- 5:15arising. And that action of either
- 5:21resisting or clinging is the thing that causes a suffering.
- 5:28I often talk about equanimity as this very lively, fully engaged
- 5:32activity where you keep your balance, and the near enemy of
- 5:37that is detachment, where you don't actually feel anything or
- 5:40invest much in whatever is happening.
- 5:45Christian. George, when when you're saying
- 5:50suffering, are you using a very narrow kind of definition?
- 5:54Are you talking about kind of the second arrow in in Buddhist
- 5:58terms, or are you talking about something more sort of the the
- 6:05way that everyone uses the term suffering?
- 6:08Well, I think I in this particular context in the
- 6:15describing the mechanism that we we talked about quite a bit that
- 6:22is the second era. We live in you know this country
- 6:26which is actually quite a privileged place to live the US
- 6:30Anyway, If you're in the US then you have a certain level of
- 6:35security. Not everybody of course in our
- 6:39society has that level of security.
- 6:48I noticed in that I stopped reading the New York Times, for
- 6:52instance, and the Los Angeles Times and also the Washington
- 6:55Post because the the the bias of the coverage was was became
- 7:02eventually unbearable. And I read the The Guardian.
- 7:09That's the only one I can do too.
- 7:12And and still I find the the coverage of the things that
- 7:16happened in the world to be very despairing.
- 7:26And at the same time when when I'm just working individually
- 7:29with people in the Metagroup community, the the different
- 7:34points of view that people hold. And in really trying to be
- 7:40caring and open to that whole mix that we have, it's very
- 7:45difficult to take a hard position on one thing or another
- 7:50without risking some front to some members of the group.
- 7:57How does one balance that, trying to really accommodate
- 8:06everybody's point of view and at the same time taking some kind
- 8:10of position in relationship to the perception of what's
- 8:14happening? I don't, for instance, know
- 8:17what's happening. I know my experience with media,
- 8:22the reporting of it. It's so interesting to me that
- 8:33the that we have such a capacity for cruelty in our human
- 8:39experience that there there seems to be no limit to the
- 8:42amount of cruelty and that the experiencing of cruelty doesn't
- 8:48seem to provide any insight that would lead you to be less cruel
- 8:52to other people. And often in fact it it creates
- 8:55the opposite effect the the extremes of response.
- 9:02There seems to be a a collapse of mentalizing as we would talk
- 9:17about it, a sense of the non mentalizing mode of psychic
- 9:22equivalence where you understand what you think is happening and
- 9:26you think that your point of view on that is accurate enough
- 9:30that it it is the experience that everybody is happening.
- 9:35It it it is the experience that is happening for everyone.
- 9:38So that you can take these positions and yet really what
- 9:45we're all doing is responding to the stimuli that we select.
- 9:51I talked about this quite a bit, but we don't take a survey of
- 9:55what's happening. We take a survey of things that
- 9:58are our preference. And then from those moments,
- 10:01that gathering of what our preference is from what's
- 10:04available in in our sensing fields, we form a reality of
- 10:15this. I was talking to one of my
- 10:17students who is a neuroscience and this big idea that there is
- 10:27both what's happening and what we make out of what's happening
- 10:32as this new concept in neuroscience because they're
- 10:34being able to read the the brain as it functions in that way.
- 10:39And then you reflect on the the Buddhist philosophy of this.
- 10:42And 2600 years ago we they were talking about the experience of
- 10:48sensing and then assigning meaning to it.
- 10:52Essentially the same thing, Christian.
- 11:00George, not to like, fetishize suffering, but don't you think
- 11:04that, like the cruelties that are done to us, like in a sense
- 11:08they can maybe kind of turn us away from seeing those same
- 11:11kinds of things, but like in a traumatic way where we kind of
- 11:15disavow them or dissociate? But like when processed or when
- 11:20they're not overwhelming, don't you think they they can actually
- 11:24sensitize us to seeing those same kinds of cruelties in the
- 11:27world? And that gives an opportunity
- 11:30for compassion that maybe someone that hadn't been
- 11:33through, that wouldn't have that same level of kind of that that
- 11:38visceral sense of what's going on.
- 11:40I do think that if you can integrate the experience, but
- 11:50then the question of course is how does the world get to be the
- 11:53way that it is now if everybody were able to do that.
- 11:58And so maybe the conclusion is that they're not able to do
- 12:01that. I I what I think I found this
- 12:11week as things got so difficult in so many areas of the world is
- 12:16the the level of heartbreak that I'm experiencing is, is reaching
- 12:22the limit of what I can manage. And then I'm at that that point
- 12:27of in some ways losing the sense of agency that I I normally feel
- 12:37and then just being overwhelmed by the sadness of of everything
- 12:46and how does one. I'm thankful that I haven't
- 12:53responded with a normal conditioned response of
- 12:58converting that overwhelming sadness into anger which was the
- 13:02habit of the family that I grew up in.
- 13:07And it hasn't. That anger of blame and
- 13:11assigning responsibility hasn't also arisen and to as you say,
- 13:18which I quite like, opening that capacity for compassion to hold
- 13:24the experience of the suffering world and to in some way a
- 13:29process that and then the the that threshold where you're
- 13:37overwhelmed by the suffering experience and begin to lose
- 13:41your equanimity and then need to pull into a more sympathetic
- 13:47stance and and bring yourself back into balance.
- 13:58Putin said in the paper today, or at least it was reported in
- 14:02the paper today, that that if Europe engages on the side of
- 14:08Ukraine with troops that we are at the threshold of nuclear war.
- 14:14I found to be quite a staggering thing to to read in the paper.
- 14:23The UN on Monday said that the situation in Gaza was genocide
- 14:29now, whereas before it said that it was inciting genocide, and
- 14:34before that they had said that it was ethnic cleansing because
- 14:38of the mass starvation that's happening there, which were,
- 14:44they said was the result of the Israeli military preventing
- 14:49humanitarian aid from entering Rafah.
- 15:04And these I have the overwhelming experience of just
- 15:12heartbreak, experiencing that we I grew up in a country of that
- 15:24have succeeded in genocide. That's one of the things about
- 15:29being from the United States is that our history of slavery and
- 15:37our history of the genocide of the indigenous population
- 15:43produced this vastly powerful country.
- 15:51When Trump was in office, the UN said that the camps that he set
- 15:58up and the taking of children and selling them through the
- 16:03private adoption agencies that took the children was a
- 16:07genocide. But it it it's in this country,
- 16:12there's so much that's not really responded to that that
- 16:24caused this outcry. But they didn't close the camps
- 16:34until he was out of office. Egypt is setting up refugee
- 16:47camps, but they're behind a wall, and camps in Syria are
- 16:52behind a wall. So there's no capacity for the
- 16:56Palestinian people to immigrate out of the situation that
- 17:00they're in. So they're not really being
- 17:02helped by either side. So as a as a as a person, a
- 17:17single person without much in the way of power particularly to
- 17:24do anything about this, the the balance is how to to continue to
- 17:29operate in the world and to advocate and to express my
- 17:33experience of these things and not completely lose equanimity
- 17:41and not have to disappear into some kind of idealizing state.
- 17:49And I imagine that if this isn't the experience that I'm having,
- 17:53everybody else is in the same boat.
- 17:55Because it is the human experience of this kind of in
- 18:03some sense, it's as a taxpayer the the money of that we pay is
- 18:09then making these kinds of things in this country anyway
- 18:13possible. And so we are all in, in a way,
- 18:18complicit. How do you find equanimity with
- 18:27this? Well, Buddhist teaching, of
- 18:37course, would be to turn into it and to allow the sense of this,
- 18:42or at least as I experience the heartbreak, this, the sadness,
- 18:47to fully manifest and attempt to hold it in balance.
- 18:55We each have our own conditioning, of course, and so
- 18:57we assign meaning to this. And the the powerlessness of my
- 19:01own childhood exacerbates the experience of the powerlessness
- 19:06that I feel. In response to this, I'm talking
- 19:12about myself because I don't want to assign blame or
- 19:21intention to other people, but it's find overwhelmingly
- 19:41sad. So then when we talk about
- 19:48meditation strategies that then we can apply to this, the
- 19:54equanimity practices are really focusing on intensity.
- 20:00My favorite equanimity technique is the increasing, decreasing,
- 20:04same gone technique where you note the experience of the
- 20:08sensation as it is is increasing, decreasing.
- 20:12It's staying the same or it vanishes as old things are
- 20:16impermanent. Another one is low, medium,
- 20:23high. Or when you're working with
- 20:26emotions, simply doing the noting feeling, states
- 20:28technique. Or you're noting moment by
- 20:31moment the experience of emotions that are happening.
- 20:38We talk about four kinds of emotions to pay attention to the
- 20:44present moment experience, the self generated emotion, the
- 20:48somatic sized emotion and the empathetic emotional experience
- 20:51of other people and how that cascading of emotional reaction
- 21:00can get so intense. You have the present moment
- 21:04experience and if it exceeds the window of tolerance then you
- 21:07have an emotional event that needs to be regulated which we
- 21:10regulate through thinking mostly.
- 21:13The thinking process pulls us out of the experience of the
- 21:16moment into the thought process and generates in that that
- 21:22thought process and emotion that can mask or displays the
- 21:26experience of the present moment.
- 21:28And we use the strategies that we learn in our family system.
- 21:34So if you have beneficial strategies we have, we tend to
- 21:38be more resilient. And if we use afflictive
- 21:40strategies, we tend to to continue to overwhelm ourselves.
- 21:44If you use a lot of afflictive strategies, you probably have
- 21:47semanticized emotional centers that then become reactive.
- 21:51And all of them conflate. When you don't have good clarity
- 21:56and create these intense emotional experiences and
- 22:05holding them each in spaciousness and separate so
- 22:09that you can have each of the three aspects of these
- 22:15experiences that make up emotional content and balance
- 22:21them. And so then the experience of
- 22:33powerlessness arises. And I find that one to be
- 22:39particularly hard to to be with that, that desire of wishing to
- 22:52be able to affect some kind of change that would resolve the
- 22:59experience that people are having such hardship and horror
- 23:07but having no real method to do much about it, that sense
- 23:13difficulty without having to retreat from it.
- 23:19I think that that probably is the way that I have in the past,
- 23:23simply withdrawn from it, not following what's happening, not
- 23:31voicing a response to it. It simply feels impossible to
- 23:38make any kind of impression. How then do you stay in the
- 23:46present moment when that's the experience
- 24:01in the way that I grew up? One of the things that that
- 24:04plagued me was panic attacks and not really recognizing when
- 24:09everything sort of clumped together, that my mind was
- 24:13accelerating and fearfulness by catastrophizing and then
- 24:16generating these very intense experiences of The thing about
- 24:21the emotional regulation system is that it's pretty automatic
- 24:26Once you're trained, it just doesn't.
- 24:28So you'd find yourself caught up in these thought patterns that
- 24:31carry you into these extreme fearful states.
- 24:34And when I was, I don't know, 20 years ago or so, working with
- 24:40Shinzen, he said. Just see if you can stay with
- 24:44the panic attack all the way through it and just note the
- 24:48intensity of it as increasing, decreasing, staying the same.
- 24:51And I noticed that when I finally was able to do that, all
- 24:55the way up into that state, I was laying on my bed and noting
- 25:02the intensity of it. And and I really felt that my
- 25:05whole body was flapping up and down on the bed from the
- 25:09physical sensations of the energy moving through the body.
- 25:13And I would open my eyes and I was just completely still.
- 25:16And then I would close my eyes and get caught up on these waves
- 25:20of emotional energy and holding. That whole experience in
- 25:25equanimity completely resolved that process for me, and I
- 25:29haven't really had anything like it since.
- 25:42So that experience of powerlessness and that
- 25:45experience of heartbreak. And then there's the piece about
- 25:54what's coming. You look at that, those
- 25:58situations, you look at the coming election.
- 26:02I don't. I find the motivations of the
- 26:17hard right to be impenetrable to my way of thinking about the
- 26:22world. I can't make sense of it, but
- 26:28it's frightening to me that that that makes sense to so many
- 26:37people. And then when I think about the
- 26:49points of view that I hold and the the people that I know, I
- 26:53don't find those points of view particularly frightening.
- 26:55But I hear the the hard right being equally frightened or at
- 27:01least expressing the same kind of fearfulness about it.
- 27:05That also is hard for me to make sense.
- 27:07So that that an openness to the different points of view that
- 27:17people have seems easier than a hard rejection of them, as it
- 27:29appears to me. So I think that these are the
- 27:39reason I'm I'm talking about this is because these are the
- 27:43the edges of practice, at least as I experience it.
- 27:49I can go into a state and hold a very sacred view of everything
- 27:54and and not be so bothered by all of this.
- 27:57But coming into the ordinary sense of reality, it's very hard
- 28:01to be in those experiences as they arise.
- 28:11So in terms of today's practice, why don't we do some
- 28:14concentration practice to settle and then go into just that
- 28:23equanimity practice of noting intensity.
- 28:28It's a so it doesn't matter what the activations are we're we're
- 28:32just really focusing on intensity.
- 28:34Is the experience of the present moment the same as it was
- 28:37before? Are you noticing increasing
- 28:39intensity or decreasing intensity as the that particular
- 28:44pattern of sensory activations ended and then coming into
- 28:49another one. It's a it's a kind of I'm
- 29:00listening to myself talk and listening to the the quality of
- 29:04feeling and it seems quite distressed.
- 29:09So I'm one who apologize for it not being lighter, but the world
- 29:19seems hard this week to me. So go ahead and settle into your
- 29:25meditation postures. All right, Let go of the
- 29:34meditation comments or questions about the meditation.
- 29:49So we have a level one meditation and attachment level
- 29:57one in April. In May, we're going to do a 15
- 30:03day residential retreat in Poland at the Sacred Mirror
- 30:09Center outside of Ansk. We have a few spaces left for
- 30:15that for take a look at that on the website.
- 30:18Then we're going to do a four day commuter retreat in Utrecht
- 30:22at the end of May into the beginning of June.
- 30:28We're going to do a meditation and addiction level 2 for the
- 30:32first time as a virtual experience.
- 30:36So that's a 12 week program that meets three times a week for an
- 30:40hour, so Monday, Wednesday and Friday for an hour.
- 30:44Going through that the four modules of the meditation and
- 30:50and addiction program, I think we're gonna do a couple of level
- 30:55one meditation and addictions coming up to that.
- 30:59That should be in July. We'll begin a couple of level 2
- 31:04meditation and attachments in July and August and September.
- 31:10So we have a pretty full calendar coming up.
- 31:12Take a look at that. Most of it's up on the website.
- 31:16Ioffer this teaching freely and I am very appreciative of your
- 31:21practice. We do have a donation a link on
- 31:29the website if your resource and can make a donation that's
- 31:32appreciated. It helps support me and also the
- 31:34work that Medigroup is doing. Good to see you.
- 31:37We will see you soon.