Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP232: The Hadley Family Murders
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Welcome back everyone to another episode of Crimes
- 0:38and Consequences. I am Tanya and this is my lovely co host, Talia,
- 0:44and we are a couple of friends who also happen to be lawyers who
- 0:48enjoy coworkers, co workers, law partners. We enjoy talking about true crime
- 0:54and that's how this podcast started. So before I get into the episode today,
- 1:00I would just like to remind everyone to hit the subscribe like fallow button,
- 1:03whatever, but you have whatever, And I would like to think True
- 1:08Crime Daily for hosting us. Yes, so today is really a terrible story,
- 1:12just like all of our other episodes. But first, have you ever
- 1:17been to Port Saint Port Saint Lucy, Florida? Maybe maybe? Well,
- 1:23it's not really a town that was initially geared towards like young people are teenagers,
- 1:30Florida. It's like between well I believe it's on the Gulf Coast and
- 1:36it's between Orlando and Miami, which I know is a long stretch, but
- 1:40it's along that side, so the easter place for yeah, I don't know.
- 1:45So it was mostly, you know, geared toward retirees. You know,
- 1:51a lot of people in Michigan were from Michigan. A lot of people
- 1:53in Michigan go to Florida to spend the winters, to call them snowbirds.
- 1:57But it is the biggest city between Orlando and Miami, so you know,
- 2:04there's there's not a whole lot to do though. It's kind of like just
- 2:07it's not on the water. No, I don't believe it's on the water.
- 2:10Yeah, so there's not a whole lot to do. I mean,
- 2:14it's not geared toward like tourists and things like that. The New York Mets
- 2:19hold their spring training camps there, okay, and they are also known for
- 2:25growing marijuana. Oh okay. So over the years, pot dealers from Miami
- 2:30would buy vacant houses in Port Saint Luci and use them as grow facilities.
- 2:38Due to this, more than a third of the population is younger than twenty
- 2:42four years old. I thought it was a older part. Yeah, that's
- 2:45what it was meant to be. You know, so teenagers are literally literally
- 2:52just running around and in twenty eleven, I'm going to tell you a story
- 2:55about the Hadley family and Tyler Hadley. Tyler had Hadley was seventeen years old
- 3:00in twenty eleven. His parents were Blake and Mary Joe Hadley, and he
- 3:06was the younger of two boys. Mary Joe was an elementary school teacher at
- 3:10the local school, where she'd been teaching for about twenty years. His father,
- 3:15Blake, worked in a plant as an operator for Florida Power and Light.
- 3:23And the Hadleys were very family oriented and they actually originated originally were from
- 3:29Pennsylvania, and they moved to Florida to be closer to Blake's parents as they
- 3:34got older, and his parents lived in Fort Lauderdale. Tyler was described by
- 3:38family members as loving, but he was a bit withdrawn. He kept to
- 3:43himself, he was depressed, He suffered from anxiety, He had low self
- 3:50esteem, and he did struggle with an eating disorder blimia. Oh that's strange.
- 3:54Yeah, it's unusual for a boy. Right. As a younger boy,
- 3:59he was quick to quit sports and projects and hobbies because he just felt
- 4:03like he wasn't good enough. At them, so he would just give up
- 4:08instead of trying to really work at it and get better. By the time
- 4:12he was ten, he was being treated by doctors for a slew of things,
- 4:17including acne and depression. At ten a ten, as he's moving into
- 4:24his teen years, Tyler was going down the path of just being a troublemaker.
- 4:30He was doing stuff like vandalizing public bathrooms, painting cars something he's by
- 4:36painting cars in. Yeah, he would steal yard decorations, he set small
- 4:43fires, he would break windows. So a lot of vandalizing going on.
- 4:49Despite the medications that he was prescribed by doctors, and I'm not sure exactly
- 4:55what he was taking, but by the age of twelve, Tyler was self
- 4:59medicating at twelve. At twelve, he started drinking and getting drunk. Yeah,
- 5:04he started smoking weed by the time he was fifteen and taking pills and
- 5:11other who's hallucinogenics to dedicate himself. By the time he was sixteen, he
- 5:15was moving into a little bit of the harder things. Oh wow. To
- 5:17kids that he went to high school with, Tyler was known as like a
- 5:21druggy pillhead who had a history of mental illness and violence. Over the years.
- 5:28So you can imagine his parents. He's quite a handful for them.
- 5:32Yea. Over the years, I know you thought your kids were bad,
- 5:38Tyler's relationship with his parents was deteriorating. Oh yeah. As a child,
- 5:43he was a respectful and happy kid. And to neighbors, friends, and
- 5:48other family members, they all seemed close, like a close knit family.
- 5:53But Tyler would often wait up for his dad to return home from the night
- 5:57shift that he worked at the plant, and they would play basketball in the
- 6:00driveway until midnight sometimes, and this is when he was younger. In their
- 6:05backyard they had Lee's had a pool. So during the summer and warmer,
- 6:11I mean it's warm in Florida, so I imagine they're using this pool all
- 6:14the time. They were always back there spending time, you know, all
- 6:18day long in the summer. That's what I'd be doing. Hell yeah,
- 6:21that's what i'd be doing too. If I had the wind, I'd be
- 6:26in the blind shut if I was in Florida. And I know you were
- 6:30like like a vampire. Well that's because sunheard. It's because Michigan sucks,
- 6:38and I don't have a pool. Michigan doesn't suck. I actually love Michigan.
- 6:42But I love Michigan, but it's hot outside in the summer, and
- 6:45I don't like to sweat. If I had a pool, i'd be in
- 6:46it. Okay, okay, just trust me, trust me. When Tyler
- 6:51reached high school, things took a dramatic turn, and the family soared to
- 6:56be more attacked, detached. So, you know, he's getting into drinking
- 7:00more and doing drugs, and he's probably you know, he's doing all this
- 7:05vandalizing so's plus he's a teen. Yeah, and that's normal to detach,
- 7:12right. Tyler appeared to be troubled, and he seemed to be somebody who
- 7:16just acted out for attention. Maybe not only did he do these things like
- 7:23this acting out, but he was really disrespectful to adults and other people in
- 7:28general. And one day Tyler and a few other boys dragged a love seat
- 7:33out into the woods. Okay, I don't know whose love seat this was,
- 7:38but they took it out there, they set it on fire. Yeah,
- 7:40they pretty all over it and lit it on fire boys team boys.
- 7:46Yeah, but the couch wasn't the only thing that burned. It caused a
- 7:50forest fire. Oh shit. Yeah. At the River Park Wildlife Reserve,
- 7:57so the police recalled. That's no good, No be pissed if I was
- 8:01his parents, I know, right, But the boys got off with just
- 8:03a warning of that one. So I'm surprised because something the forest on fire
- 8:09is pretty but they were mean too. They were just burning a couch in
- 8:13the forest. That's true, that's true, yeah, yes, but I
- 8:20guess reckless, reckless. Not soon after that, Tyler got into a fight
- 8:24at a friend's house and he was arrested for aggravated battery. Oh, it
- 8:30was pretty serious. That's a big that's a real fight. And he spent
- 8:33a week in jail, and I don't know if he was probably in the
- 8:35juvenile home, right, that's serious. Yeah, And he ended up not
- 8:41like a punch, that's no. This is a full out brawl probably,
- 8:46and he's probably beating the ship out of some sead right. He ended up
- 8:50on house arrest for a couple of weeks after that, Tyler told a friend
- 8:54over Facebook messenger that he knew his mom was disappointed in him and that really
- 9:00bothered him, but it didn't stop his aggressive behavior behavior. I know you're
- 9:07disappointing, right. In June of twenty eleven, Tyler came home from a
- 9:13party and he was wasted. So his mom had him admitted to a mental
- 9:20health clinic called New Horizons. Really shit, Yeah, he was wasted.
- 9:26Mary Joe, his mom had suffered from depression her entire life, and she
- 9:30was really scared that Tyler was going through the same thing. You know,
- 9:33he's obviously going through something and she, you know, beyond her ability to
- 9:39help him, so she wanted to get him some serious help. Mary Joe
- 9:45told friends and the doctors at the clinic that she was afraid that Tyler would
- 9:52hurt himself, but she was also afraid that he might hurt someone else,
- 9:56and since he was under the age of eighteen, she was able to admit
- 10:01yeah, without his consent, and at the at New Horizons, he did
- 10:07receive mandatory therapy. But this wasn't the first time that Tyler had received mental
- 10:13health mental health help. He had previously gone to therapy for his eating disorder
- 10:20and his poor self esteem. And he also one thing that was kind of
- 10:28odd was when he was younger, he took that human growth hormone HGHGH and
- 10:37I think he was prescribed as a way to boost his confidence, and I
- 10:41don't know how that helps confidence. I don't know, but his parents allowed
- 10:48him to take it. That's strange. So it's obvious here Tyler is fighting
- 10:54demons in his own mind, and as a result, he's sort of an
- 10:58outcast. School he was there's always a group of outcasts that go, oh
- 11:03yeah, he did, and he was hanging with the wrong kids. He
- 11:07was getting pulled deeper and deeper into the drug scene and drinking even at the
- 11:15young age of fifteen. Mary Joe was a devout Catholic who served as elector
- 11:20at the Saint Lucie Catholic Church. So Tyler and heard they didn't really see
- 11:26eye to eye on their way to live, because, I mean, you
- 11:31know, he's he's all shades of messed up. Tyler often felt that his
- 11:35parents put a lot of pressure on him to be something that he wasn't.
- 11:37I mean, I'm thinking that they were just normal parents. I just want
- 11:41you to fly what is it, fly straight or whatever it is, And
- 11:45I have no idea what you're but just go to school, do your homework,
- 11:48and take drugs. I mean, I doubt that. Who knows what
- 11:52my kids would say about me. I doubt it was any kind of unrealistic
- 11:56pressure. But then again, I wasn't there. I don't know, but
- 12:00Tyler felt that anything he would do was wrong in their eyes, and he
- 12:05would talk a suicide often to his friends and family, and it seemed that
- 12:09close family and friends kind of lost Tyler to his demons for a while.
- 12:16But once in a while he would show like his true caring self, you
- 12:20know, it would come through. But it was getting less and less common.
- 12:26Tyler's really struggling, and his mom's trying to get him this professional help,
- 12:33but they were also punishing him. You know, he was doing things
- 12:37that were wrong, and he was serving punishment at home. After a drunk
- 12:41driving incident, Mary Joe took away Tyler's phone and his car. He often
- 12:46got his phone taken away, but worse punishment for yes, for a teenager,
- 12:52but it didn't mean even though he didn't have his phone, that didn't
- 12:54mean that he wasn't still communicating with friends on Facebook and sneaking out of his
- 12:58house. On July sixteenth, twenty eleven, everything changed for this family.
- 13:05That morning, Tyler had made a plan seventeen year old Tyler. He wanted
- 13:09to throw a house party with Tyler kind of being an outcast and with all
- 13:16the trouble he'd been getting into recently, there was no way that his parents
- 13:18were going to allow him to a party, well now to the know.
- 13:22About one fifteen that afternoon, Tyler made a post on Facebook saying that he
- 13:28was going to be having a party at his crib quote unquote at eight pm,
- 13:33and then that that maybe what's that mean? No? Maybe maybe Some
- 13:41of Tyler's childhood friends knew that he had been getting into a lot of trouble
- 13:46with his parents, so they were skeptical when Tyler posted this on Facebook.
- 13:50I got to have a party, dude, right with the parents. And
- 13:54one of them even said, like in the Facebook post, said something like
- 13:58you know, they didn't say how, like how are you gonna have this
- 14:03party? Because you're being punished all the time. But Tyler's response to whatever
- 14:07was posted was I'm working on it. That doesn't sound no. By eight
- 14:13fifteen, this party was on and Tyler posted again on Facebook, this time
- 14:20saying to hit him up and to come. Multiple friends would message Tyler just
- 14:26in shock because they were worried, like what if your parents come home?
- 14:31Because he's like saying, you know, my parents aren't home, and he's
- 14:33like don't worry. They're not going to come home. It's all good.
- 14:37So by eleven thirty that night, on July sixteenth, they were over sixty
- 14:43teenagers wow at the Hadley house, and most of them didn't even know Tyler
- 14:48personally. Like, kids just started showing up. I mean, you hear
- 14:52the party, let's go. The party was starting to just get out of
- 14:56control too, bye. There's a lot of people, you see, is
- 15:01a lot sixty people. Kids were going through cabinets looking for food, and
- 15:05they were forming groups on the front lawn, smoking, throwing cans into the
- 15:11street, and it was just chaos. And at this point Tyler was getting
- 15:16worried about the noise level because he didn't want the neighbors to call the police
- 15:20and have the police showed up. So he asked all the partygoers to just
- 15:24stay inside. And he's like, I don't care if you smoke inside the
- 15:28house. You know, it's cool. But the house became trashed. Bottles
- 15:33were shattered on the floor, drinks were spilled, cigarettes were put out just
- 15:39on all surfaces. Kids were playing beer pong on the kitchen table. They're
- 15:45making out on the family couch. They were using the family's computer which was
- 15:50near the dining table, to blast music throughout the house. I mean they
- 15:54were smoking weed like it was just like can you imagine like an invented those
- 15:58parts? That show was just teenagers having a crazy party. Throughout the evening,
- 16:06various kids would ask Tyler, you know, where are your parents?
- 16:10And his answers were always different. Tyler told some of them that his parents
- 16:15were in Orlando. He told some of them they were in Georgia. He
- 16:19told a few of them that his parents didn't even live there anymore, and
- 16:22that the house was his what. Yeah. As the night progressed, Tyler
- 16:29just appeared more and more removed and just seemed strange. Although the most Tyler
- 16:36was always that way, so you know, like, Okay, he's not
- 16:40acting any differently. Around twelve thirty am, the party was running out of
- 16:45beer and I don't know who brought the beer. Tyler can't borrow it.
- 16:48I don't know how much his dad had in the house. But Tyler asked
- 16:52a twenty where there will somebody probably will. She brought a few, trust
- 16:56me. So they're running out, and Tyler asks a twenty one year old
- 17:02partygoer named Mark Andrews and his girlfriend Ashley if they would run up to the
- 17:07local gas station and get four more cases of bush light. Yeah, it's
- 17:11garbage. I don't like beer anyway. When I was seventeen, I drink
- 17:15anything. Yeah, you probably had like PAP's Blue Ribbon and mad Wild Turkey
- 17:23or whatever, I know yet anything. While they were exchanging the money and
- 17:27making the plan for them to go up to the gas station, Tyler told
- 17:32Ashley, who didn't know him very well, that his dad was dead,
- 17:37and she thought he meant that he had passed away a long time ago.
- 17:41So the night continues into chaos. More and where people were coming to the
- 17:45house. This house is being trashed. More and more. Kids were selling
- 17:51weed and pills to each other. Others had vandalized some neighbor's property, like
- 17:56the neighboring properties, and by one fifty teen, Tyler had just lost all
- 18:02control of this party. I'm surprised the police weren't called earlier. I know
- 18:06they do, they get called, but by I mean, let me just
- 18:08tell you. Pictures were knocked off the wall, furniture was overturned, the
- 18:14house had just some kind of stench to it. It's probably beer, spilled
- 18:18beer, Yeah, puke, there's probably all kinds of stuff going on,
- 18:22and Tyler, who probably now is on the verge of like just completely having
- 18:26a meltdown because he's lost control of this party. He asked his childhood best
- 18:30friend named Michael to step outside and get some air with him, Like,
- 18:34can you can you come with me on a walk? I need some fresh
- 18:37air. So Michael stimulated, oh, yeah, for sure. Michael would
- 18:42recall that for most of the parties, Tyler sat alone and was just staring
- 18:47out into space. So they go outside and on their walk, Tyler tells
- 18:52Michael that he had killed his parents earlier that day. Michael's like, hmm,
- 18:59come on now, you know he doesn't believe it. But then his
- 19:02parents aren't at the house, so Michael quickly shuts it down and they just
- 19:07continue walking, and Tyler said, no, really, I did take a
- 19:11look their car. Their cars are still in the driveway, and if they're
- 19:18not home, then why are their cars gone? Damn. So Michael still
- 19:22didn't believe him, and so Tyler took Michael back to the house and into
- 19:26the garage. Michael immediately saw a bloody shoeprint and he was He backed out
- 19:33of the garage and he shut the door back into the garage and he shut
- 19:37the door. Tyler then took Michael to the master bedroom. Oh no,
- 19:42right away, Michael noticed traces of blood on the door handle and the doorframe.
- 19:48And once Tyler unlocked and opened the door because apparently the door was locked,
- 19:52both boys entered the room. The master bedroom was in complete disarray.
- 20:00There was a huge pile of random items piled high on the bed, things
- 20:04like dining room chairs and blood soaked towels, dining room chairs. There's dining
- 20:11room chairs. There was other furniture. There was like a mop that was
- 20:17used to clean up like used liesole wipes, like just filled with blood.
- 20:22Like it's all thrown into this room. Yeah, all the cleaning stuff and
- 20:29so underneath underneath everything if as the bed, like on the floor, I
- 20:36mean there's like on the bed is just furniture and stuff. And so Michael
- 20:41looks on the floor and he's looking and he sees Tyler's dad's leg, Blake's
- 20:47leg. For some reason, though, Michael didn't leave the party, like
- 20:52he's like, oh shit, and they leave the bedroom. And Michael didn't
- 20:56leave the party right away. He stayed another forty five and it's drinking and
- 21:00smoking and even taking selfies with Tyler, and he said, you know,
- 21:04I took self He said, I took the selfies because I knew I was
- 21:07never going to see my friend again after this. So afterward, when Michael
- 21:15goes home, he does make a call to crime stoppers to report what happened,
- 21:18but it's like an hour later they all shades of fuck, oh my
- 21:22gosh, seriously, so you're probably wondering what happened exactly. I would like
- 21:27to know, Okay, So around a nine point forty that day, the
- 21:33day before he killed his parents, Tyler got a Facebook message from a friend
- 21:40saying, hey, did you do it yet? Tyler had been threatening,
- 21:45saying like I'm going to kill my parents, although nobody really believed him,
- 21:48but he gets this message, did you do it yet? Tyler writes back
- 21:52that he didn't do it yet. He called his mom you know some names,
- 21:57saying that she deserved to die. He did, Tyler did. And
- 22:03Tyler told that friend that after he was going to kill his parents, he
- 22:07planned to throw a huge party, like this is his plan. So just
- 22:11before five pm, Tyler took his parents' phones and he hid them. Then
- 22:18this is the day of the murder. Yeah, this is the day of
- 22:21the murder. Then he took three hits of ecstasy. Oh shit, he
- 22:26felt shit. Yeah, he felt like I wouldn't be able to go through
- 22:29with it if I wasn't high. He listened to a song by a Little
- 22:33Boosy called Feel Lucky to hype himself up before he went into the garage to
- 22:40look for a weapon. Tyler found a clawhammer. No no, and then
- 22:48he went back into the house a clawhammer, a clawhammer. Upon returning inside,
- 22:55his mom is in one of the bedrooms. She's sitting at a computer.
- 23:00She's not in the master bedroom. She's at a computer. He goes
- 23:03inside the house. He's got the hammer in his hand. I'm not sure
- 23:07where his dad was at the time, but he stares at his mom for
- 23:10like five minutes, just staring at her, and he's deciding what to do
- 23:15next. He is so then he goes up behind her. He raises the
- 23:19claw hammer above his head and he hits his mom in the back of the
- 23:23head. Mary Joe screamed out, and she said. She turns around,
- 23:30She's like why why, and she's screaming, still live and she's still alive.
- 23:33And Blake, Tyler's dad. He hears Mary Joe screaming and he comes
- 23:41running into the room. He blacks eyes with Tyler, who's because Mary Joe's
- 23:47now on the floor and he's hitting her. He's still hitting He's still hitting
- 23:49her, and he's like, why why are you doing this? You know
- 23:53what's going on? And Tyler responded, quote, why the fuck not?
- 23:59And then he attacks his dad with the hammer. I'm surprised his dad couldn't
- 24:03take him down, you know, I'm surprised too. He must have really
- 24:07caught him. But he was on three hit day. Yeah, he's got
- 24:11some super human strength. I mean he was. He was. He was
- 24:15maybe like six foot and one hundred and sixty pounds like Tyler was, So
- 24:18he was thin. And his dad wasn't like a thin guy. He's not
- 24:22like a huge guy. But I mean, I would think, but I
- 24:26don't know. I wasn't there. So all, when all was said and
- 24:30done, Mary Joe suffered thirty six blows thirty six blows mostly to her head
- 24:40and six blows six yeah, I know. And Blake suffered at least thirty
- 24:48nine blows. That's rage coming out, oh yeah, And it was estimated
- 24:53that Tyler they were mutilating. Oh yeah, because he only hit them like
- 24:57in they're up body like had had in probably their upper back. It was
- 25:04estimated that Tyler spent a full minute beating each of his parents. And a
- 25:11minute might not sound like a lot, but when you're hitting someone, I
- 25:15mean, I have a claw hammer. If you think about it, I
- 25:18mean, that's a long time. Yeah, it's a lot of effort.
- 25:22That's overkill. Yeah, that's way beyond what it's necessary to get the deed.
- 25:27Yeah. Right. And the most disturbing fact though, is that Mary,
- 25:32Joe and Blake were still alive. What and they were still conscious during
- 25:37this attack. None of the hits they suffered killed them immediately, but they
- 25:42would die shortly thereafter due to their injuries. Wow, probably to blunt due
- 25:47to blunt force trauma, bleeding. Yeah, they were conscious enough, I
- 25:51mean to know that their son was murdering them. After they were done dead,
- 25:57I know, and Tyler was done, he quickly covered their heads with
- 26:02towels as he just couldn't stand to look at that. He dragged his parents'
- 26:07bodies into the master bedroom and he laid them side by side, face down.
- 26:12Tyler put the claw hammer between his parents' bodies. And at this point,
- 26:18now the living room, which is where Mary Joe was initially where he
- 26:23the where the attack started. The living room was just a bloody mess.
- 26:27Tyler himself was covered head to toe and blood splatter. So he's like,
- 26:33if I'm going to have this party, because he still got his mind on
- 26:36the party, he was going to have to get cleaning. It took him
- 26:38over three hours to clean up this gory mass, which was longer than he
- 26:44had anticipated. He took every single piece of potentially incriminating evidence and piled it
- 26:51onto the bed and on his parents' bodies. So, like I told you,
- 26:55this included the coffee table, dining chairs, there were pillows probably from
- 27:00the sofa, broken dishes, shattered glasses, a sponge mop, used chlorox
- 27:04wipes, and bloody towels. Essentially, everything he used to clean was thrown
- 27:10into the pile, and anything that had evidence on it meaning blood splatter that
- 27:17could be moved ended up in their bedroom. And I have a picture of
- 27:22it. I mean, their bedroom is trashed. There's also another photo that
- 27:27will show during the video, and it's pretty graphics, so it's not of
- 27:32Blake. And Mary Joe. But it's graphics, so I just want to
- 27:33warn everyone. So now it's time. Okay, cleans up. Now it's
- 27:38time. He needs to get clean. So he takes a shower. He
- 27:42looks himself in the mirror and he said like he couldn't help but laugh at
- 27:47his reflection. What I don't know what he happened in the shower, and
- 27:51then he's just lost it. Yea, three hits, three hits. Yeah,
- 27:56and that's when he saw the shower. He posts on Facebook and says,
- 27:59oh the part. So that's now, you know, kids start to
- 28:04show up, and the evening goes into case. I have no idea.
- 28:07There's two dead bodies up stairs. Now, so let's go back a little
- 28:11bit to Tyler's confession to his friend Michael. So, as I told you,
- 28:15Michael stayed at the party for forty five minutes after Tyler had just proved
- 28:18to him that he had murdered his parents. Between Tyler's confession to Michael and
- 28:25Michael leaving the party, other party goers heard that there was another party at
- 28:30a different house, so everyone quickly started to clear out, causing commotion in
- 28:34the front yard. Over fourteen cars peeled off loudly from the Hadley residence.
- 28:41A neighbor to the Hadley residence named ray Anne Wallace just had enough of the
- 28:47noise in the bauchery and she finally called nine on once when the kids started
- 28:51drifting into her yard during their departure. Within two minutes of Rayan's called,
- 28:56police arrived at the Hadley residence and due to the fact that most of the
- 29:02kids now had gone had left and gone to the other party, there's only
- 29:06about twenty people left, and so the police go to Tyler, you know,
- 29:11and he promises the police, yes, we'll keep it down for the
- 29:15rest of the night. So police let him off without a warning and they
- 29:19head back to their cruiser and they left. By two thirty am. All
- 29:26of the kids now have learned that the other party that was supposed to be
- 29:29happening was just a rumor, so they all headed back to the Hadley residence
- 29:34and party was back on despite the police having just left. At this point,
- 29:41it's clear that something it was really wrong with Tyler, and other conversations
- 29:45with Michael and other partygoers at the time, Tyler mentioned suicide multiple times and
- 29:51even told Michael how he was going to do it. Michael left the party
- 29:55about three am, so maybe he stayed. I don't know. Due to
- 29:57this, I don't know. I'm trying to give Michael the benefit of the
- 30:00doubt. But he left about just before three am. And when he left,
- 30:04he found some percocet pills that Tyler planned to use to kill himself and
- 30:08he hid them in a hall closet to prevent that. At four forty six
- 30:15am, police were again dispatched. The party's still going on. The party
- 30:19is still going on. Hell, And so they go back to the Hadley
- 30:23home. But now this is due to the call that Michael made OH crime
- 30:30stoppers. He informed them of what Michael, excuse me, what Tyler had
- 30:37done, and he told them everything. So when police arrived, they could
- 30:41see the shadow of someone pacing back and forth in the front living room.
- 30:48One of the officers his name was Officer Green. He peered through the window
- 30:51and he saw Tyler pacing across the living room talking to himself. Then he
- 30:56started. Tyler started grabbing books, like stacks of books from a book shelf
- 31:00by the front door and taking them back into the master bedroom. Why,
- 31:03I don't know. After the third trip, I'm thinking maybe there was some
- 31:07blood splatter on them. After Tyler's third trip, Officer Green finally knocked on
- 31:11the front door, but Tyler didn't answer it right away. Instead, he
- 31:15went and turned all the lights off in the house before he answered the door.
- 31:21Tyler looked very disturbed to Officer Green. His eyes were wide, he
- 31:26wasn't blinking when he answered. He left his left hand behind his back,
- 31:30which caused the other officer that was with Officer Green, his name was Officer
- 31:37Zamowski to draw his gun. After being ordered to get on the ground,
- 31:41Officer searched Tyler his person to ensure that he didn't have any weapons on him
- 31:47before they handcuffed him, Seemingly frantic and incoherent. When police asked if any
- 31:52adults were home, Tyler responded no, before saying to Officer Green that he
- 31:57knew he was going to Rock Road, which is where the county jail was.
- 32:02Upon entering the house, the police were met with just disorder and it
- 32:08was just disgusting. There were empty beer bottles, cans everywhere. Yeah,
- 32:15pots and pans were all over the counter, said those parties. Yeah.
- 32:20Tyler's bedroom floor was covered in unrolled cigars. Oh, I don't know it's
- 32:28yeah. I think it was tobacco. The furniture was overturned in Tyler's brother's
- 32:31bedroom. I'm not sure where the brother was. I'm thinking he's college aged,
- 32:36so he might have been somewhere else. They found the family dog locked
- 32:40in closet. But this wasn't the worst. The police finally reached the master
- 32:46bedroom and they immediately noticed the dried blood on the door frame, and because
- 32:52the door was locked, they had to force it open and they just entered
- 32:55this room of horrors. Right. Nearly two thousand people attended Mary, Joe
- 33:02and Blake's funeral. Michael became the state's star witness for the trial, and
- 33:10in twenty fourteen, Tyler entered a plea of no contest to two counts a
- 33:16first degree murder with a weapon. He was convicted on those two counts a
- 33:22first degree murder, and sentenced to two consecutive life terms, so they weren't
- 33:27concurrent. They were to be served one after the other, and he didn't
- 33:30get death. Yeah, Florida, it's Florida. Because he was a minor
- 33:35at the time of the crime. The state did eventually have to reverse his
- 33:38sentence on new sentencing qualms. That can't sentence them to life life, right,
- 33:47right, they have to have a chance for parole. Mm hmm.
- 33:51So seven years after the murder of his parents in twenty eighteen, the now
- 33:55twenty five year old Tyler, he had a resentencing trial. Tyler was chained
- 34:00at the ankles and wrists, and he showed no emotion as the judge read
- 34:06his new sentence, and Tyler was again sentenced to life in prison. However,
- 34:12they were to be served at the same time, and by law,
- 34:15he'd be automatically allowed like his case would be automatically reviewed for parole after twenty
- 34:20five years. Yep. Lord has gone back and forth with that law.
- 34:24Yeah, in Alabama too, because we have the cases on that, Yeah,
- 34:30we have, and that federal Cruel and Unusual punishment federal law. Oh
- 34:37yeah, the cruel and unusual punishment. Yet because they're minors, to this
- 34:40day, friends and family really struggle to understand the motivation behind Tyler's actions,
- 34:49you know what for a party like what? Yeah, Like they just don't
- 34:52they don't understand. And yvery upsetting. Although he said some kind of messed
- 34:55up things, I mean, he said he said he was going to kill
- 34:58his parents. People never really he thought he was capable of doing it,
- 35:00obviously. I mean I would never think that about any of my friends.
- 35:05Yeah, but I would also never say that. Yeah, that's true.
- 35:08That's true. Yeah, it's not the most common theory though, revolves around
- 35:14two things, Tyler's drug and alcohol abuse and his mental health issues. Although
- 35:19I was I thought he was getting treated for his mental health issues, doesn't
- 35:22mean he was getting treated properly. That's true. It was widely known by
- 35:27a circle of friends that that Tyler held some resentment against his parents still all
- 35:31teenagers, I know, for you know, punishing him and forcing him to
- 35:37go to the drug abuse program that you know, I help him, trying
- 35:42to help him. Yeah, even when he did receive the mental health though,
- 35:45he'd often lie and manipulate the doctors. So, like you said,
- 35:47he might not even have been getting like proper treatment. He was prescribed antidepression
- 35:53medication. He would mix that with various other pills, you know, to
- 35:58get messed up. And when the police originally searched the house, they didn't
- 36:02find any pills other than two prescriptions for Tyler. So yeah, so I'm
- 36:09not sure he could have been buying them though, right, he could have
- 36:14been buying anything. In a letter from jail, Tyler wrote to his grandparents,
- 36:20and he told them that he wished his doctors never put him on that
- 36:24one pill, he said, but he never specified what that one pill was.
- 36:29Antidepressant. Sorry. During his first trial in twenty fourteen, Kathleen Hyde,
- 36:36who was the mental health specialist who Tyler's team called to the defense as
- 36:40a defense witness. She stated that when he killed his parents, Tyler was
- 36:45in a major depressive episode. She said that this episode fueled intrusive thoughts about
- 36:52suicide and killing his parents. She told the court that there were various reasons
- 36:58leading to Tyler's homicide thoughts, including obsessive thoughts, severe depression, and the
- 37:05inability to care for others. None of this, yeah, and this was
- 37:10premanitating, Yeah, right exactly. Wasn't spontaneous, you know? None of
- 37:15this, though, I think, is able to justify what he did.
- 37:19But during his resentencing, Tyler's team pushed hard that Tyler was capable of rehabilitation.
- 37:27Even family members testified that Tyler understood his actions and should stay in prison.
- 37:34Despite listening to various testimonies, the judge ruled that whether or not Tyler
- 37:38was capable of rehabilitation, was anyone's best guess, and he upheld, like
- 37:44I told you, those life sentences. The judge noticed, or the judge
- 37:47noted that Tyler had casually spoken about killing his parents for weeks leading up to
- 37:52that and the party. Yeah, and there a party, right, I
- 37:58mean, and he even told people that he was waiting for his brother to
- 38:02move out before he did. So, yeah, you're right. The brother
- 38:07was Yeah, so he wasn't there, even though he still hit a bedroom
- 38:09there. He maintained that the crime the judge maintained that the crime was premeditated,
- 38:15like you said, and the fact that these were his parents and he
- 38:20killed them so personally, like you said, it was a race. He
- 38:22was just in a race, and it was just overkill. Yeah, overkill.
- 38:27It wasn't done on impulse, and it was just done through hatred that
- 38:30was brewing against the two people that tried to help him the most. Since
- 38:37being in prison, Tyler has completed his ged and he scored a twenty one
- 38:40hundred on the SAT. Oh he's smart. Yeah. Most of his days
- 38:45reading books like Harry Potter and anything by James Patterson. I do like James
- 38:51Patterson. Yeah, his books are really good. Tyler started meetings meeting with
- 38:55a priest named Father Michael, who had encouraged Tyler to confess his sins to
- 39:00God and repent to be able to be forgiven. In letters to his grandparent
- 39:05parents, Tyler was torn up with guilt. He said he was depressed,
- 39:08angry, confused, and delusional like when at the time of the crimes.
- 39:15And he told him that he was planning to be ordained when he's released from
- 39:20prison one day. I think that's gonna happen. That's going to happen either.
- 39:24As for Michael, his friend that called crime Steppers, he said that
- 39:30Tyler murdering his parents was the worst thing that he ever happened to him.
- 39:35Oh yeah, I bet. I mean he was. He was really traumatized.
- 39:38I mean yeah, you know, Plus he was like the star witness,
- 39:42so he's like yeah, so he just you know, he relives it.
- 39:47He says this caused him problems socially. He couldn't go to school without
- 39:53people coming to him and asking him about it. You know, they all
- 39:59wanted like the gory details from him. So Ryan Hatley, who was Tyler's
- 40:07other brother, I even really talked about him. He was the older brother
- 40:09that had moved out. He wrote a book about life after his parents were
- 40:15murdered. He dove deep into the grief and how he survived. Ryan struggled
- 40:21to forgive his brother. That be hard, yeah, and he's struggled to
- 40:24maintain a relationship with him. And he has no family like his I mean,
- 40:29he just has his brother and his parents are gone, right, Like
- 40:31it's it's got to be hard. Since Tyler's resentencing in twenty fourteen, or
- 40:37since his sentencing in twenty fourteen and his resentencing in twenty eighteen, Ryan occasionally
- 40:43visits Tyler in prison. He's learned to live with the idea that two things
- 40:47can be true at the same time, that he can be angry at his
- 40:52brother for what he did while still loving my you know, and caring about
- 40:55him. So I'm sure it's a real struggle. Like you said, I
- 40:59it's a it's going to be some resentment. But yeah, you learn to
- 41:04forgive, right, like I guess you have to. He's your brother.
- 41:07I don't know that the only family, like you said of you, yea
- 41:12to live with that hate and anger doesn't do any any good for me.
- 41:16That's yeah, you have a point there, right, He's because he's got
- 41:20to move on with his life, you know. And yeah, so that
- 41:23is the really sad story about that is very sad the Hadley family. So
- 41:30that makes me very very just happened for nothing. I hate these crimes that
- 41:36are just like seemed to be for no reason. Not that anybody should be
- 41:39murdered for a reason, and I just want to clarify that, but senseless,
- 41:44like just like, yeah, Hitler, Hitler. Maybe yeah, you're
- 41:47right, but you know, some of these I'm just like, why,
- 41:52Like, was throwing the party that important apparently to seven times seventeen? Yeah,
- 42:00so well, thank you Tuleia wow for listening. Very depressing. Yeah,
- 42:05thank you everyone for listening to today's episode or watching. Don't forget to
- 42:10hit the like, subscribe follow button if you would like to hear more episodes.
- 42:15We do offer a Patreon yep It's patreon dot com slash t nt Crimes
- 42:22where we release one extra episode that's not to the public. It's only to
- 42:27our subscribers, one a week, and we have to do shout outs to
- 42:31them. Yeah, we will have to do them soon, but we do
- 42:35them one week and we also release the weekly episode like this one to our
- 42:39subscribers. They get it early and it is ad free. You can go
- 42:44to our website Crimes and Consequences dot com. There's information about that. We
- 42:49also have merch like the lovely shirt that Talia is wearing inside Dead Inside got
- 42:53a little skeleton on it for lawyers too, so that's yeah. Yeah,
- 43:00it does help to be dead inside when you're an attorney. I mean it's
- 43:02the only way sometimes to get the job done, sadly, and I think
- 43:08that's everything. Oh, you can also subscribe to those extra episodes on Apple
- 43:12Podcasts on the app, it's the same episodes that are on the patreum.
- 43:15I think that's everything. So until our next episode, don't kill each other. Bye.