Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Have FTC Warnings Caused Enough Change?, AI Bot Bait and Switch, Live From DC
Transcript
- 0:01Good morning, everybody. It is Tuesday, June 16th. Uh, Kyle's holding down home base. I'm here live in Washington, DC, at the CBT News Fair Pricing and Compliance Summit.
- 0:10Today, we're gonna talk about more FTC warnings and an AI bot that may have given the wrong price for a used car to a customer that a dealership had on there. That's always yikes. [laughs] Yikes. Oh.
- 0:24Dude, it's a beautiful day in Washington, DC, right now. And if you can see behind me, you can probably see a little crack through the door- Just a room full of people.
- 0:31Room, room full of packed people It is a room full of people. And, and let me tell you, the, the crowd here is amazing. Like, a lot of dealers, a lot of high-level, um, you know, legal and state association folks.
- 0:41Really impressed with the crowd, uh, that, that, uh, for, uh, CBT, Jim Fitzpatrick, and Bridget were able to assemble here. Um, so we're gonna be talking about, throughout the day, what's happening here.
- 0:51Um, but first we gotta talk about some news, and, uh, we gotta talk about some things that are going on, but it all does come together very cohesively.
- 0:58Uh, want to definitely thank our friends at Wide Whale for sponsoring today's show. The FTC did send a warning to 97 auto dealers in March. You'd think the reviews would be a disaster, right? But not really.
- 1:09Their average rating was 4.34 stars. This is almost in line with the rest of the market.
- 1:14But when Wide Whale looked beyond the stars and into the review content, complaints about pricing, financing, advertising, and bait-and-switch tactics showed up nearly twice as often in those reviews.
- 1:25So that's the difference between measuring ratings and using reviews to understand your business.
- 1:29On June 18th, just two days away, Wide Whale is walking through the data and going to show dealers what their reviews might be saying that their dashboards aren't. You should be a part of that, um, webinar.
- 1:40You can register at widewhale.com/ftc. That's gonna be a good one. This is the week of the FTC. You guys are there right now. There's gonna be conversation.
- 1:49I can't wait to hear from you what the conversation on ground is tomorrow.
- 1:54Uh, and, and pay attention to the socials today, as I'm, I'm guessing you guys are gonna be dropping some stuff because I th- I think this is the first time anybody's- I hope so. Have-...
- 2:03had, like, a really resolved in-person conversation about it. Uh-oh. You hear me, Kyle? We lost, we, we lost P- Oh, there he comes. Oh. He's coming back. We'll see. He's back. We're back. We're back, folks. You hear me?
- 2:18[laughs] Yeah. We're, we're, we're- Oh, man. It's such-... in tech troubles today. I lost tech earlier. You're losing tech. It'll be fine. I don't know why- We'll get together on it...
- 2:25expensive hotels can't seem to get Wi-Fi right. What even is that? I just don't even understand it. It can't be that hard. I don't know.
- 2:31We wanna also thank our friends at Force Marketing for sponsoring our con- uh, coverage of today's event. So we're gonna be coming to you throughout the day. Thanks to our friends at Force Marketing.
- 2:40So stay tuned to our LinkedIn channel, our Instagram channel. There's gonna be a lot of more interviews and content, uh, coming out. Let's talk about some news, huh? Let's do it. You reading, I reading?
- 2:50I'll read it, I'll read it. [laughs] Even as the FTC is turning up the heat on deceptive vehicle pricing, new data suggests hidden charges may remain common across both new and used vehicle sales.
- 3:00Copilot, uh, found 59% of 500 assisted used car purchases included discretionary fees not reflected in the advertised online price.
- 3:10Uh, CarEdge found meaningful differences between advertised prices and actual quotes at nearly 40% of dealers, with CEO Zach Shefska, good friend of the podcast, saying there is still an endemic price misinformation on the internet.
- 3:24In April, Lindsay Automotive Group agreed to a settlement already with the FTC that could cost up to $75 million in consumer restitution, plus a $3.1 million penalty tied to deceptive pricing and unwanted add-ons.
- 3:37Goodness. Dealers who advertise all-in pricing say they're competing against stores showing lower teaser prices and revealing fees later in the buying process. Here's the, here's the one.
- 3:47Uh, FTC Consumer Protection Bureau Director Christopher M- Mofarrej says that the agency has been encouraged by dealer responses so far, but s- added, "That said, you've always got your bad apples out there."
- 4:01Okay, so pr- Don't be a bad apple... don't be a bad apple. So many people you mentioned are actually here right now. Yeah. Um, Zach Shefska is here. Uh, Christopher Mofarrej is also going to be here.
- 4:10So, uh, we'll maybe, uh, ask them a few more questions about this. You know, I was sitting having breakfast with Don Hall, Chair
- 4:17of the VADA, and he said, "You know, in this room right now," and a lot of people that pay attention to the content in our ecosystem and some others, um, it's... He said, "It's like the choir," right?
- 4:26"We are the people who believe this." Mm. He's like, "The question is, can the choir sing loud enough that everybody can hear what's going to happen?"
- 4:33Um, 'cause he's concerned that if we don't get our, our ducks in order, that the manufacturers are gonna step in- Mm-hmm... and st- use it as a lane to start selling direct- Mm...
- 4:40which that is the first time I've ever heard that. Absolutely. Yeah, well, because, I mean, if you think about it as an OEM, you've got some of the largest public risk, uh, on your brand right now in, in- Mm-hmm...
- 4:50uh, like in the public eye, right? So many people are talking about the FTC, what it's doing in the marketplace. The conversation has not just stayed inside of retail auto.
- 4:59Consumers are starting to understand this, especially with, uh, places like CarEdge starting to present this as, as a warning to, to, uh, consumers. You've got more and more of that in the public eye.
- 5:11And, and the OEM can't stand, can't res- uh, can't, like, stand up under the pressure of the public eye looking at their dealers going, "What are you doing?"
- 5:20So you're either gonna see a lot of dealership shutdowns, a lot of hefty fines, or the OEM's gonna figure out how to make it right. So yeah, the, the choir better sing louder.
- 5:29And I would say if you're, if you're even on the edge of, like, "Ah, maybe I'll just, like, see how everybody else does it for a little while," quit. Mm. Get over yourself. I don't know. [laughs] There you go.
- 5:42Kyle, there's your, there's your pull quote from today. Get over yourself. Yeah. Speaking of... No, I can't say speaking of getting over yourself. But let's just go right into the second story- [laughs]...
- 5:49'cause we're running pretty tight today, but, um- Let's do it...
- 5:52you know, go ahead and let you read it A Canadian BMW owner thought he'd successfully negotiated the sale of his vehicle back to the dealership, only to discover the AI bot he'd been chatting with quoted him 7,000 more than the store was willing to pay.
- 6:02Toronto BMW customer Zach Giacomelli received a trade-in offer of $27,000, 160, uh, $27,162 from, quote, "Quin," even scheduling an appointment to finalize the deal.
- 6:17Uh, BMW Toronto initially lowered the offer by roughly $7,000. But after media inquiries, agreed to honor the chatbot's original price.
- 6:25[laughs] Uh, management said the inflated offer stemmed from a miscommunication by a human employee that caused the bot to interpret Giacomelli's loan balance as the vehicle's purchase price. So data- Ooh...
- 6:35structured data, data structured data. Uh, S- Scott Shadbolt, pre-owned sales direct- manager at BMW Toronto said, "It's a bit of a new territory for us.
- 6:45We're trying to figure out the best way for a good AI customer experience." I mean, if, if you ever played Monopoly, you know you get that card that says, "Bank makes error in your favor," right? Mm.
- 6:55That's what this customer found like- f- found out like. But this is, again, one of those conversations. You have AI bots trying to be efficient and doing business.
- 7:03I don't know, like, do you think that if a human, like a BDC was answering this call, if they would've made the same mistake? Oh, I've seen it happen plenty of times. Yeah. Yeah.
- 7:12So this is not an AI- There's transposition... it's not really an AI story. But it's- This is a really- It's a presentation of data issue, right? Mm-hmm. Very, very clearly this is your pre- loan value.
- 7:22This is what the vehicle's value is. Like, it's, it's presentation of data. And no matter whether that's going to a human or a bot, it's just gotta be clear. Yes, without a doubt.
- 7:31And, you know, I, I know that a lot of the conversations going on around the legalities of advertising marketing, I've already heard social media come up. I've heard AI come up.
- 7:39I don't know where that's- how that's gonna unpack today. But, you know, this is just a continuation of the conversation.
- 7:45If the data isn't sound to begin with, everything else built on top of it is kinda going to be a mess. Um, you know, we'll ask some specific questions while we're out here today with some of the folks.
- 7:55I think right, right up next is a dealer panel. It's gonna include Kevin Frye, um, and, uh, Brian Benstock. So certainly, uh, gonna have a few opinions. You know, you get two dealers together, you have three opinions.
- 8:06Oh, those two- But we always say- Those two can have a couple opinions, I'll tell you about that. [laughs] So we're gonna, we're gonna jump in there. Might as well cue the outro music. We have a lot of content to get to.
- 8:13You're gonna be holding down the fort while we're gone. Listen, whatever you're doing today, like Kyle said, do it the right way. Like, what, what did you say? You said a thing. I said- What's your pull quote?
- 8:22Well, stop being dumb. [laughs] Stop being dumb. [laughs] What a pull quote. [upbeat music]