Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Share Buybacks to Signal Confidence
Transcript
- Lucas: So last week, Shopify announced a $1.5 billion share buyback program. That's about 12 percent of its current market cap, and it came right after the stock had dropped 15 percent from its 2026 high. It's a textbook example of what I want to talk about today — how post ipo companies use buybacks to send a signal, not just to manage their balance sheet. Luna: And Shopify isn't alone. We've seen a wave of buyback announcements from companies that went public in the last few years. Airbnb, ZoomInfo, even some of the SPAC survivors. What's the signal they're trying to send? Lucas: The primary signal is undervaluation. Management is saying, 'Our stock is cheap, and we're putting our money where our mouth is.' But there's a second, subtler signal: stability. For a company that's only been public for three or four years, a buyback program signals that the board is confident in the long-term cash flow generation. It's a maturity marker. Luna: Right. Because if you're a newly public company and you're not generating enough free cash flow, you can't really do a buyback without borrowing, and that sends a different signal entirely. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where the nuance comes in. Look at Palantir — ticker symbol P-L-T-R. They've been public since late 2020, but they've never announced a buyback. Their free cash flow turned positive last year, but they're still reinvesting heavily. So the absence of a buyback isn't necessarily a negative signal. It could mean they see higher-return opportunities internally. Luna: But investors often interpret it as a negative. There's this expectation that once you're cash-flow positive, you should start returning capital. Especially if the stock is down. Lucas: And that's the tension. Because the stock is down for Palantir — it's off about 4 percent over the past five days, and it's been volatile all year. But management has said they prefer to use cash for acquisitions and R&D. Compare that to Airbnb, which announced a $2 billion buyback in February and then expanded it in May. Their stock is up modestly over the same period. Luna: So the market does seem to reward buybacks, at least in the short term. But is that always rational? I mean, a buyback can be a signal of confidence, but it can also be a way to juice earnings per share when revenue growth is slowing. Lucas: That's the dark side of buybacks. By reducing the share count, earnings per share goes up mechanically, even if net income is flat. And that can trigger executive compensation targets that are tied to EPS. So there's a potential agency problem. But for most post ipo tech companies, the primary motivation is counteracting dilution from employee stock-based compensation. Luna: Let's talk about that. Shopify's stock-based compensation was about $600 million last year. Their buyback is $1.5 billion. So it more than covers dilution, even if they don't execute the whole program. Lucas: Right. And that's a common pattern. Many post ipo companies issue a lot of equity to employees. If they don't buy back shares, the total share count grows, and each existing shareholder owns a smaller piece of the pie. So buybacks are partly a tool to keep the share count stable. It's a form of capital allocation that's specific to the post ipo phase. Luna: But there's also a timing element. Companies can announce a buyback and then not execute it for months. Or they can execute it aggressively when the stock is low. How do investors tell the difference? Lucas: You have to watch the actual execution. In the U.S., companies report buyback activity quarterly in their 10-Q or 10-K. You can see how many shares they repurchased and at what average price. Some companies are very transparent about their buyback strategy. Others are vague. For example, Alphabet — which went public way back in 2004 — discloses its buyback activity in detail. But a newer company like Coinbase, which went public in 2021, hasn't done any buybacks at all. Luna: And Coinbase's stock is down significantly from its direct listing price. So investors might be asking, why not buy back shares at these levels? But Coinbase has said they want to keep a large cash buffer for regulatory risks and market volatility. Lucas: That's a valid reason. And it ties back to what we were saying about maturity. A younger company with an uncertain regulatory environment might prioritize cash over buybacks. But there's another factor: leverage. If a company does a buyback with debt, they increase financial risk. For a post ipo company that's still finding its footing, that can be dangerous. Luna: So the signal isn't just 'we're doing a buyback.' It's 'we're doing a buyback with cash flow, not debt, and we're executing it consistently.' Lucas: Exactly. And that's where the market gets it right sometimes. Companies that announce a buyback but then don't execute — or execute at high prices — actually destroy value. There's research showing that the average company announces a buyback when the stock is relatively high, but the smart ones buy when the stock is low. post ipo companies have a unique opportunity: they often have a volatile stock price right after listing, so if they have the discipline to buy during dips, they can create huge long-term value. Luna: Which is exactly what NVIDIA has done. They've been public since 1999, but in the last few years they've been very active with buybacks, especially after any significant pullback. Their stock has obviously done incredibly well. Lucas: NVIDIA is a great example. But for a true post ipo case, look at Zoom Video Communications. They went public in 2019, and within two years they had a $1 billion buyback program. They executed it aggressively during the 2022 selloff. Their stock has since recovered, and the buyback was a net positive for shareholders. Luna: So what should a listener who's an investor in a post ipo company look for? If their portfolio company announces a buyback, how do they evaluate whether it's a good signal or not? Lucas: First, look at the size relative to market cap. Anything above 5 percent is meaningful. Second, look at the funding source — cash flow or debt. Third, look at the track record of execution. If the company has announced buybacks in the past but never completed them, that's a red flag. And fourth, look at insider selling. If insiders are selling while the company is buying back, that's a disconnect. You want alignment. Luna: And one more thing: the purpose. Is the buyback specifically to offset dilution? Or is it a broader return of capital program? The former is more common for post ipo companies, and it's usually a positive sign because it means management is shareholder-conscious. Lucas: Right. And that's actually a good segue. If you're finding these conversations useful for evaluating your own investments or for understanding what the companies you're building or running should be thinking about, it's worth mentioning that this show is supported entirely by listeners like you. There are no ads, no sponsors. The only reason we can keep doing deep dives like this is because some of you choose to contribute at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's completely optional, but it helps us stay independent. Luna: Yeah, and we really appreciate those who do. It lets us pick the topics we think matter most, without anyone pulling the strings. So if you've gotten value out of episodes like this one, consider throwing a few dollars our way. Lucas: Thanks for that. Now, back to buybacks. One more angle I want to hit: the impact on stock liquidity. When a company buys back a large number of shares, it reduces the float. That can actually make the stock more volatile, not less, because there are fewer shares available to trade. Luna: That's a counterintuitive point. Most people assume buybacks stabilize the stock, but if you think about it, a smaller float means each trade has a bigger impact on price. Lucas: Exactly. So for a post ipo company, there's a trade-off. A buyback signals confidence and offsets dilution, but it can also amplify price swings. That's why some companies use accelerated share repurchase programs, or ASRs, where they buy a large block from an investment bank in one go. That way, the market impact is concentrated and then done. Luna: And ASRs are more common among larger post ipo companies. I remember Shopify did an ASR in 2023 for about $500 million. It was a one-time purchase that removed a lot of shares from the market quickly. Lucas: Right. So the method matters too. Open market repurchases are more flexible but can take months. ASRs are faster but less flexible. The choice says something about management's conviction. If they're willing to do an ASR, they're really signaling that they think the stock is undervalued right now. Luna: So what's the bottom line for a post ipo company considering a buyback? What's the one piece of advice you'd give? Lucas: I'd say: be disciplined. Don't announce a buyback just because the stock is down and you feel pressure from investors. Only do it if you genuinely believe the stock is undervalued and you have the cash flow to support it. And then execute consistently. A well-timed, well-executed buyback program can create enormous value. But a poorly timed one can destroy it just as fast. Luna: And for investors, the lesson is to look beyond the headline. The announcement is just the beginning. Watch the execution, watch the funding, and watch for alignment with insider behavior. Lucas: Exactly. And on that note, I think we've covered the key angles. Next time, we might look at how post ipo companies handle dividend initiations — a different form of returning capital, but with its own set of signals. Luna: That sounds like a great follow-up. For now, thanks for listening, and we'll catch you on the next episode.