Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Spotify at $583: Great Business, But Priced for Perfection?
Transcript
- 0:00Spotify just reported generating nearly 5 1/2 billion U.S.
- 0:04dollars in a single quarter, which is honestly kind of
- 0:07insane. It's massive.
- 0:08Right. But here is the thing.
- 0:10Some of the smartest, most rigorous value investors on the
- 0:14planet are completely divided right now on whether this stock
- 0:17is a brilliant buy or like a ticking time bomb.
- 0:20Yeah, there is a huge split in the consensus right now.
- 0:23Because the market reaction has pushed the share price to around
- 0:26$583, and we really have to figure out if that number is
- 0:30built on solid fundamentals or if it's just, you know, priced
- 0:33for absolute sunny day perfection.
- 0:36So welcome to today's deep dive. Glad to be.
- 0:39Here our mission today for you listening is to take this
- 0:42freshly released October 22, 2026 Q 3 earnings report for
- 0:46Spotify technology ticker symbol SPOT and basically put it
- 0:50through a ruthless Buffett style value investing ringer.
- 0:54And to do that properly, you really need to rely on objective
- 0:57frameworks, not just, you know, market sentiment or hype.
- 1:00Exactly. So we're going to break down
- 1:02their financial plumbing by channeling the kind of
- 1:04analytical rigor you find in the Deep Values iOS app, which.
- 1:07Is such a great tool. It really is.
- 1:09It's fantastic for calculating that Buffett style intrinsic
- 1:12value for literally any stock. Yeah.
- 1:15And we will also be contextualizing these numbers
- 1:17against the broader market using the Buffett Indicator app on iOS
- 1:21and the Bubble Watch app for Android users.
- 1:24Right, because you need to know if the whole market is
- 1:25overpriced before you look at just one stock.
- 1:27Totally. And for those of you looking to
- 1:29automate this kind of heavy lifting on a daily basis, we are
- 1:32leaning heavily today on the research from Deep Value
- 1:35Intelligence, which is our multi agent AI analyst.
- 1:38It's a game changer honestly. It really is.
- 1:40If you are serious about understanding where the market
- 1:42is actually heading, checking out those tools and subscribing
- 1:45to the Deep Values podcast on Apple and Spotify are honestly
- 1:49the best moves you can make to build up your daily investing
- 1:51insights. Because look, without a rigid
- 1:53framework, looking at a stock trading at $583 is just noise.
- 1:58Yeah, we have to start by looking at the scoreboard.
- 2:01The Q32026 snapshot reveals a company that is fundamentally
- 2:06different from the one that existed even like 3 years ago.
- 2:10OK, let's unpack this because the scale of their operation
- 2:13right now is almost hard to comprehend.
- 2:15Spotify just hit 788 million monthly active users globally.
- 2:19Which is almost a tenth of the planet.
- 2:21Right. And out of that massive user
- 2:23base, 306 millionaire premium subscribers.
- 2:26And those premium numbers actually beat management's own
- 2:29internal guidance. Yeah, they did.
- 2:31They generated €4.969 billion in total revenue, which yielded a
- 2:37record 33% gross margin, and their operating income hit €672
- 2:43million. See, the focus for a really long
- 2:46time was purely on user acquisition.
- 2:49Like the prevailing narrative used to be that Spotify was just
- 2:52this low margin funnel. Just trying to capture as many
- 2:55ears as possible. Exactly, regardless of the cost,
- 2:57Yeah. But what's fascinating here is
- 2:59that the real story hidden in this Q3 report is operating
- 3:03leverage. OK, meaning what exactly I.
- 3:06Mean the business is finally scaling its profitability faster
- 3:09than its costs are growing. Got it.
- 3:12And my understanding of how they achieved that massive shift in
- 3:15operating leverage basically comes down to them abandoning a
- 3:18really flawed strategy. Oh, absolutely.
- 3:20Like a few years ago, Spotify was spending hundreds of
- 3:23millions of dollars acquiring exclusive podcasts.
- 3:26They were just throwing money at content.
- 3:28Right, paying massive upfront fixed costs just to build this
- 3:31walled garden and keep certain shows off of rival platforms.
- 3:35It was incredibly capital intensive and honestly super
- 3:38risky. Yeah, they essentially realized
- 3:39that acting like a traditional Hollywood studio, you know,
- 3:42fronting massive budgets for exclusive content was just
- 3:45destroying their margins. Yeah, so they restarted.
- 3:49They abandoned the heavy fixed cost exclusive contracts and
- 3:52entirely shifted their focus toward scaling high margin
- 3:56marketplace software. We are talking about tools like
- 4:00their discovery mode, right? And that two sided promotional
- 4:03marketplace they built? Exactly.
- 4:05Instead of Spotify paying out of pocket to market music, they
- 4:09built software where record labels and artists can actually
- 4:12accept a slightly lower royalty rate in exchange for a boost in
- 4:16the recommendation algorithm. Wow, so it costs Spotify
- 4:20virtually nothing to just flip a switch in their algorithm?
- 4:23Literally nothing but the margin pick up on that lowered royalty
- 4:27rate drops straight to their bottom line.
- 4:29Right. That structural pivot is the
- 4:31actual mechanical reason they finally hit that 33% gross
- 4:35margin. That is wild.
- 4:36It fundamentally changes their entire relationship with the
- 4:39music industry. They move from being just a
- 4:41distributor that, you know, pays a toll to a promotional platform
- 4:45that the industry actually pays to access.
- 4:47Right. But that brings up a pretty
- 4:49massive point of friction though, and I kind of want to
- 4:51push back on the idea that they have fully escaped the music
- 4:55industry's structural problems. OK, let's hear it.
- 4:58Because the music business is notoriously terrible for
- 5:00margins. You have the big three labels,
- 5:02Universal, Sony and Warner, and they essentially operate as an
- 5:06oligopoly holding the master rights to like all the world's
- 5:09most popular music. Yeah, that's true.
- 5:12I've always viewed Spotify's business model kind of like
- 5:15running a restaurant where the grocery store takes 70% of your
- 5:18revenue right off the top. That's a great analogy, right?
- 5:21Before you even pay your waiters or turn on the lights, 70% is
- 5:25just gone. So no matter how good your
- 5:27software is, if your supplier has that much pricing power,
- 5:30your upside just feels completely capped.
- 5:33And that restaurant analogy perfectly highlights the core
- 5:35vulnerability of any streaming service.
- 5:38The cost of revenue is indeed massive.
- 5:41Yeah, if you look at the Q3 filings, the cost of revenue
- 5:44eats up almost 67 percent, 66.9% to be exact, of their net
- 5:49revenue. And that is predominantly
- 5:51royalty payouts to those exact labels you just mentioned.
- 5:54So the grocery store is still taking a huge.
- 5:57Cut they are. However the mechanism of those
- 6:00payouts is what actually saves Spotify.
- 6:03It is a pro rata variable royalty framework rather than a
- 6:07heavy fixed cost burden. OK, wait, meaning what?
- 6:10Meaning they don't pay a flat rate of, say, half a cent every
- 6:13single time a song is played. Correct.
- 6:16It doesn't matter how much money the platform is making in a
- 6:18vacuum. The payouts are determined by
- 6:21pooling the total revenue Spotify generates in a given
- 6:24month. OK.
- 6:25They take out their contractual cut first, of course, and then
- 6:28they distribute the rest to the labels based on their market
- 6:31share of total streams. Oh, I see.
- 6:34This mechanism aggressively protects Spotify's downside.
- 6:37Think about it. If a global economic contraction
- 6:40hits right, advertising budgets dry up in subscription growth
- 6:43stalls. Right, their total revenue pool
- 6:45would shrink. Exactly.
- 6:47But because the royalty payout is a percentage of that
- 6:50shrinking pool, their biggest expense automatically falls at
- 6:54the exact same time. Oh wow, so they are completely
- 6:58insulated from the kind of fixed cost death spirals that bankrupt
- 7:02traditional media companies during recessions.
- 7:04Precisely, to use your analogy, the grocery store automatically
- 7:08lowers the price of the ingredients if the restaurant
- 7:11has a slow night. That is incredible downside
- 7:13protection. But I know the real magic of
- 7:16their financial plumbing is something called negative
- 7:18working capital, right? Yes, that is the hidden engine
- 7:21of their cash flow generation. Because when you or I sign up
- 7:25for Spotify Premium, they charge a credit card on day one of the
- 7:28billing cycle. Like, they collect that
- 7:30subscription fee immediately. Right.
- 7:32But under their contracts, they do not pay those variable
- 7:35royalties out to the music labels for, what, 60 to 90 days
- 7:38usually. Yeah.
- 7:39So for two to three months, Spotify is just sitting on
- 7:42billions of dollars of other people's money.
- 7:44Yep. They hold that cash and they
- 7:47create what's called an operational float, and as the
- 7:50revenue base compounds globally, this pool of delayed cash just
- 7:54grows right alongside it. That's amazing.
- 7:56They take that float, they park it in short term investments,
- 7:59government paper, bank deposits, and they just earn finance
- 8:02income off it. Their entire business model is
- 8:05structurally designed to force cash into their bank accounts
- 8:08long before they ever have to settle their liabilities.
- 8:11See, here's where it gets really interesting for anyone trying to
- 8:13actually value this business. We've established that the
- 8:16underlying plumbing is practically churning out cash,
- 8:18yes. But when we look at the stock
- 8:20trading around $583 and we apply the strictest Benjamin Graham
- 8:26style deep value parameters to it, oh, it fails.
- 8:28It completely fails the task. Spectacularly, Graham's
- 8:31framework requires a wide margin of safety on current earnings
- 8:34and assets, right? With a price to earnings ratio
- 8:37hovering near 30X right now, it sits far outside his ideal
- 8:40threshold of 15X. Yeah.
- 8:42Double the threshold. And Graham's preferred price to
- 8:45book ratio is under 1.5 X. Spotify is currently trading at
- 8:49a price to book of 10 point 3X. Insane.
- 8:52So by those traditional metrics, a deep value purist wouldn't
- 8:55even touch the stock with a 10 foot pole.
- 8:57But you know, those traditional metrics start to crack a bit
- 9:00when you apply them to a modern software business, which is why
- 9:04it actually passes Peter Lynch's framework exactly.
- 9:07Because Lynch looks for growth at a reasonable price, focusing
- 9:10on the PEG ratio. And with Spotify's PEG ratio
- 9:13currently sitting at 0.81 X, the speed at which their earnings
- 9:17are growing actually justifies that higher PE multiple, right?
- 9:21And if we connect this to the bigger picture, we really have
- 9:25to recognize why a price to book ratio of 10.3 X is fundamentally
- 9:29misleading for a company like Spotify.
- 9:31How so? Well, traditional book value was
- 9:34designed for the industrial age. It measures tangible assets, you
- 9:37know, like factories, inventory, real estate.
- 9:40Stuff you can touch. Exactly.
- 9:42But Spotify's most valuable economic assets are their
- 9:44recommendation algorithms, their global user data infrastructure,
- 9:48and their direct customer relationships, right?
- 9:51Under gap accounting rules, all of those digital assets are
- 9:54expensed as research and development.
- 9:56They do not get capitalized on the balance sheet.
- 9:58Oh wow. So the accounting rules
- 10:00essentially forced them to look asset poor on paper, yes, when
- 10:04in reality they possess this digital infrastructure that
- 10:07reaches 788 million people. I mean, they don't need to build
- 10:10a new factory to add their next 10 million users.
- 10:13Exactly which makes their true economic earning power vastly
- 10:16understated by traditional book value.
- 10:18And you know, on top of that, their balance sheet is
- 10:20remarkably de risked right now. They are now entirely free of
- 10:24funded corporate debt. Completely free.
- 10:27Completely earlier in 2026, they fully retired over €1.4 billion
- 10:32in senior notes. So right now they are sitting on
- 10:36$10.74 billion in cash and short term investments.
- 10:39That is a mountain of cash. It is they have officially
- 10:42finalized their transformation from this cash burning startup
- 10:45into a capital light compounding machine and they are operating
- 10:49with a 17% free cash flow margin.
- 10:52That 17% free cash flow margin is really the ultimate truth
- 10:55teller here. So let's take that cash
- 10:58generation and try to figure out what the actual intrinsic value
- 11:01per share is today. OK, let's do the math.
- 11:04Because the models anchor on Spotify's trailing free cash
- 11:07flow, which currently sits at a massive $3.46 billion over the
- 11:12last 12 months. And the discounted cash flow or
- 11:15DCF analysis is where we strip away all the market sentiment
- 11:19and just look purely at the math of future cash generation.
- 11:22Right, So what do the projections look like?
- 11:25The models project 2 main scenarios.
- 11:28The first is what we call a nominal growth model.
- 11:31This basically assumes they can continue compounding their cash
- 11:34flow at about 12% a year for the next 5 years, OK.
- 11:37And then after that, the model assumes their growth steps down
- 11:40as they fully saturate the global market, eventually
- 11:43settling at a 3% perpetual terminal growth rate, which you
- 11:47know, roughly mirrors long term global inflation.
- 11:50Now hitting 12% annual growth for the next 5 years is pretty
- 11:54aggressive considering their current scale.
- 11:56But you know, given their success with that high margin
- 11:58marketplace software we talked about, it's mathematically
- 12:02feasible. Yeah, it's not out of the realm
- 12:04of possibility. So under that nominal growth
- 12:07assumption, what is the intrinsic value per share?
- 12:10It calculates out to $600.75. OK, 600 bucks.
- 12:14What's the other scenario? The alternative is the
- 12:17conservative model. This projection deliberately
- 12:20strips away the assumption of high double digit growth.
- 12:23It assumes a much more muted 5% growth rate for the next 5
- 12:26years, dropping to a 2.5% terminal rate.
- 12:30Much safer assumptions. Exactly.
- 12:33And in this pessimistic scenario, the intrinsic value
- 12:36drops significantly down to $345.33 per share.
- 12:41OK, So what does this all mean for you?
- 12:44Listening right now, with the stock currently trading around
- 12:47$583, it is hovering dangerously close to that aggressive $600.00
- 12:53nominal value. Very close.
- 12:55And value investing fundamentally requires a margin
- 12:59of safety. Like the general rule of thumb
- 13:01is to look for a 30% discount to the conservative intrinsic value
- 13:05right? Just in case your growth
- 13:07assumptions fail to materialize. Right.
- 13:10And applying a 30% discount to that conservative $345 target
- 13:14would require an entry price of around $241.00 a share.
- 13:19So at $583, the market is offering absolutely 0 margin of
- 13:24safety. None 0.
- 13:27The market has just fully digested the transformation from
- 13:29a low margin music distributor to a high margin software
- 13:32business and they have priced it accordingly.
- 13:35And this specific valuation tension is causing a massive
- 13:38divergent among institutional investors right now.
- 13:41Oh really? Who's doing what?
- 13:43Well, according to the recent filings, strict deep value funds
- 13:46like Fundsmith have completely liquidated their positions in
- 13:50Spotify. They just sold everything.
- 13:52Sold it all. They bought in years ago when
- 13:54the market misunderstood the operating leverage.
- 13:56The thesis played out exactly as planned and they just took their
- 14:00profits off the table. I mean they probably ran the
- 14:02exact same DCF models, looked at the $583 price tag and determine
- 14:06the risk to reward ratio is no longer in their.
- 14:08Favor exactly, but on the flip side of that exact same trade,
- 14:12growth oriented quality funds like Lone Pine Capital are
- 14:15actively acquiring shares at these all time highs.
- 14:18Wait, really? Buying at the top?
- 14:20Yeah, they are looking at that 70% cash flow margin, the
- 14:24massive $10 billion cash pile, the complete lack of debt and
- 14:28they are basically betting that the compounding engine still has
- 14:31a long runway. That institutional divide brings
- 14:34up a really crucial component of this analysis, which is
- 14:37governance and capital allocation.
- 14:40Always comes back to management. Because when a stock is priced
- 14:43for perfection, the individuals steering the ship and deciding
- 14:46how to deploy that $10.74 billion cash pile become the
- 14:50ultimate deciders of future shareholder value.
- 14:52Absolutely. And this brings us to a
- 14:54structural red flag for many traditional investors, which is
- 14:57the voting rights. Ah yes, Spotify utilizes a dual
- 15:02tier voting system. The founders, Daniel Eck and
- 15:04Martin Lorenzen own less than 25% of the actual ordinary
- 15:09economic shares OK. However, through a specialized
- 15:12class of shares called Beneficiary certificates, they
- 15:15hold nearly 70% of the company's total voting power.
- 15:19Wow. So that dual tier structure
- 15:21completely insulates management from any outside.
- 15:23Pressure completely. Activist investors cannot build
- 15:26a position, swoop in and force a sale, or, you know, initiate A
- 15:30dividend or restructure the board.
- 15:33Eck and Lorenz and have total, unchallengeable control to
- 15:36manage the company's capital allocation exactly how they see
- 15:40fit. OK, well, let me push back on
- 15:41their capital allocation strategy right now then, because
- 15:44the math seems somewhat contradictory.
- 15:46How so? We just established that the
- 15:48stock is trading around $583. It is trading massively above
- 15:53its conservative intrinsic value and bumping right up against its
- 15:56most optimistic nominal value right yet.
- 15:59Just this past August, so August 2026, the board expanded their
- 16:02share buyback authorization by another $1.5 billion.
- 16:06They did. If the stock is offering zero
- 16:08margin of safety, isn't deploying billions of dollars to
- 16:12buy back shares at all time highs an objectively terrible
- 16:15use of capital? I mean, traditional financial
- 16:17theory dictates you only buy back stock when you believe it
- 16:20is severely undervalued. It's a great point, and it
- 16:23really raises an important question about information
- 16:26asymmetry. Right.
- 16:27What do they know that we don't? Exactly why would a management
- 16:30team with complete voting control and access to literally
- 16:33every piece of internal data authorize a massive buyback at
- 16:37peak valuations? The answer lies in their long
- 16:39term internal forecasting. If you look back at their 2022
- 16:43Investor Day, management set a very public target to achieve
- 16:4630% plus gross margins by the year 2030.
- 16:50And as we covered in the Q32026 numbers, they just hit 33% gross
- 16:56margins, right? They achieved their 2030
- 16:58profitability targets 4 entire years ahead of schedule.
- 17:02Exactly. So the buybacks at 583 dollars
- 17:05are a massive signaling mechanism.
- 17:08The founders are essentially communicating to the market that
- 17:10their structural efficiencies, you know the strict headcount
- 17:13discipline, dropping those expensive exclusive contracts
- 17:17and specifically the scaling of their automated promotional
- 17:19software, all of that is going to drive future cash flow
- 17:23significantly higher than the $3.46 billion trailing figure we
- 17:28are currently anchoring our models on.
- 17:30Wow, so they are betting billions of dollars that even
- 17:33the most optimistic market estimates are currently too low.
- 17:36That's exactly what they're saying.
- 17:37They're looking at the $600.00 nominal DCF target and saying
- 17:41your assumptions are outdated based on what we have coming
- 17:44down the pipeline. It is a massive, confident bet
- 17:47on their own operational leverage just continuing to
- 17:50expand into uncharted territory. It really forces investors to
- 17:53decide if they trust management's internal visibility
- 17:57more than they trust, you know, conservative historical
- 17:59modeling. Well, Spotify is an incredible
- 18:02case study in modern market dynamics.
- 18:04And when you zoom out and look at the whole trajectory, this
- 18:07company has officially graduated.
- 18:09They really have. They successfully transition
- 18:11from a cash burning, low margin platform desperately trying to
- 18:15acquire users at any cost into a highly profitable, debt free
- 18:18quality compounder. But the ultimate catch is that
- 18:21at almost $600 a share, the secret is entirely out.
- 18:25Yeah, the market is incredibly efficient at pricing in obvious
- 18:29quality. Which means if you are a
- 18:31conservative value investor demanding a margin of safety,
- 18:34you are likely going to be sitting on the sidelines waiting
- 18:36for a cyclical pullback or, you know, an earnings miss or maybe
- 18:40a broader macroeconomic correction to offer a better
- 18:43entry point. It is the textbook definition of
- 18:46a wonderful business trading at a premium price.
- 18:48Exactly in evaluating these exact scenarios, deciding
- 18:52whether a stock is a genuine long term bargain or a market
- 18:55bubble fully priced for perfection is exactly what the
- 18:58tools we've referenced are built for.
- 19:01They make the math easy. They do.
- 19:03So if you want to run these discounted cash flow models
- 19:05yourself and test your own growth assumptions on other
- 19:08companies in your portfolio, definitely check out the Deep
- 19:11Values iOS app, the Buffett Indicator for iOS, and Bubble
- 19:15Watch on Android. All highly recommended.
- 19:18And we have provided all the links so you can access Deep
- 19:21Value Intelligence, our multi agent AI analyst.
- 19:24And be sure to subscribe to the Deep Values podcast on Spotify
- 19:27and Apple for daily investing insights that really go beyond
- 19:30the headlines. As always, remember that this
- 19:33deep dive is strictly for educational purposes, right?
- 19:36We provide the blueprints, but you must do your own thorough
- 19:39due diligence before putting your hard earned money to work.
- 19:42Exactly. The models are only as good as
- 19:44the assumptions you put into them.
- 19:46But before we wrap up, I want to leave you with one final thread
- 19:49to pull on something buried in the Q3 operating expenses that
- 19:53could honestly completely upend everything.
- 19:56We just. Discussed.
- 19:56Oh, this is the really interesting part.
- 19:58Yeah, the filings highlighted significant ongoing investments
- 20:02related specifically to quote LLM inference DJ voice synthesis
- 20:06and compute infrastructure. Now we all know about their AI
- 20:09DJ, but if Spotify continues to aggressively integrate
- 20:12artificial intelligence into the very fabric of how audio is
- 20:16generated. How programmatic ad bidding is
- 20:18executed and how content is personalized at scale?
- 20:22Could it eventually shed its identity as a music streaming
- 20:24company entirely? It's a huge question.
- 20:28Treating Spotify purely as a distributor of human created
- 20:31music might be a fundamentally backward looking thesis at this
- 20:34point, right? Because if five years from now,
- 20:37the market begins to view Spotify as an AI infrastructure
- 20:40company that simply utilizes audio as its primary output, how
- 20:44might that fundamentally break and rewrite every single
- 20:47valuation model we just built? It changes everything because
- 20:50suddenly you aren't valuing a restaurant where the grocery
- 20:54store takes 70% of the revenue, you are valuing the underlying
- 20:57digital grid itself. If they can synthesize content,
- 21:00their variable royalty costs could just plummet even further.
- 21:04And the margin profile of an AI tech layer commands an entirely
- 21:08different multiple than a media platform.
- 21:09Exactly. It completely shifts the
- 21:11paradigm from valuing a mature media distributor to valuing a
- 21:15foundational high margin technology layer.
- 21:19So the next time you look at Spotify's valuation, ask
- 21:22yourself, are you paying premium prices for a finished music
- 21:26streaming platform, or are you buying into an AI infrastructure
- 21:29network that hasn't even finished laying its foundation?
- 21:32Something to think about.