Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️100 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 22nd Sep Water Day 1 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments, and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. Today marks the beginning of a vast and important new topic: water. But before we reached any of that evidence, the early morning was taken up with conflicts of interest, late disclosure, and questions about who would or would not be permitted to speak. And those exchanges left their
- 1:14own mark on the day. There was something else in the room today that's a bit harder to describe. At the start, the atmosphere felt tense and unnecessarily confrontational. The commission seemed to move between two very different positions. When deciding who could speak, it exercised clear authority. But
- 1:34when concerns were raised about conflicts of interest, date disclosures, or timetabling issues, the responses seemed to be that there was little the commission could do. It felt like a difficult seesaw between having considerable power over proceedings, and at other moments appearing powerless to
- 1:52address the concerns being raised. I cannot know what anyone else in the room was thinking, and I do not want to overstate it, but from where we were sitting, there was a sense of frustration, perhaps even unease, directed towards those who continue to scrutinise this proposal and ask difficult
- 2:11questions. Whatever the reason, it was dispiriting and energy sapping. People have given years of their lives to this process. They have attended in good faith, worked their way through 1000s of pages of technical evidence, and tried to represent the communities that will live with the consequences of
- 2:28whatever is decided. They should not be made to feel like they are the problem simply because they continue to ask difficult questions. Scrutiny is, after all, part of a public inquiry, and those providing it should be treated accordingly, listened to with respect, not treated as an inconvenience. We are not
- 2:51disrupting the process; we are taking part in it. And that was the atmosphere in which we began what was already going to be an exhausting day. First, listening to the LOX agency' excellent response to the applicant's transboundary material, and then hearing NIEA's response on many of the same issues. And one
- 3:12final point before we begin: those of us representing the communities most directly affected by this proposal are routinely described as third parties, a remarkably diminishing term for people who will be left living with the consequences long after the inquiry has ended, and everyone
- 3:30else has gone home. So today, as I've already said, is all about water, water quality and discharge parameters, surface water, ground water, private water supplies, public water supplies, protected water courses, Atlantic salmon, fresh water pearl mussels and newts, cumulative impacts, mitigation,
- 3:54etc. So, quite a wee small topic, and this was just the first of our eight days on the subject, the morning began with introductions, and there were plenty of them. The already in alone listed experts covering surface water, groundwater processing, geochemistry, ponds, ecology, fish, freshwater pearl
- 4:19mussels, peat, construction, mine waste, and radon. It's a useful reminder, if we needed one, that water runs through almost every part of this development proposal. But before we got anywhere near the water evidence, two potential conflicts of interest were raised. Fermanagoma District
- 4:40Council explained that its ecologist, Dr. Peter Walker, works for RSK, where Steve Coates, one of Dalradian's witnesses, is also now employed. mr. Coates had previously worked on the Corrinalt project. The council said that ethical walls and restrictions on sharing information. Had been put in
- 5:01place, Doctor Walker confirmed that he had not discussed the case with mr. Coates and had not shared any information with him. Dalradian gave similar assurances. Then came a separate disclosure involving Dalradian's psychology witness, Tim Goodwin. mr. Goodwin had previously provided advice on one of the
- 5:24community groups opposing the mine.
- 5:26Dalradian said that involvement had been limited, that he had not produced a report, had not been paid, and had not received information after 2019. Several community members were deeply unhappy that this was only being disclosed now. They asked for time to consider what it might mean, particularly when Dallein
- 5:49itself had previously made quite a point of questioning their experts about their earlier, much less involvement in the project. And then Gerard Moyne attempted to speak on behalf of communities in Donegal. The commission ruled that because his name was not on the relevant statement of case list, he did
- 6:10not have speaking rights. That prompted objection from community members. They argued that this, after all, is a public inquiry. That water is probably the most important transboundary issue in the entire application, and that someone who had travelled from the republic should at least be
- 6:31given the courtesy and opportunity to be heard. The DFI department's response was that the Our House Convention does not automatically give somebody a right to speak at an inquiry, and that written participation can be good enough. It also pointed out that the LOX agency is a cross-border body, and can
- 6:52address the potential effects of development on both sides of the border. And with all of that dealt with, or at least parked for another day, we finally reached the water evidence. Richard Honey, representing the Locks Agency, began with a position that could have hardly been clearer. The agency is
- 7:13advising that planning permission should be refused. Its position is that the development cannot lawfully be approved because of its potential effect on Atlantic salmon and on the integrity of the Uncleoo and River Foyle special areas of conservation. Now Dalriadon accepts that the
- 7:34pollen row burns and the unnamed watercourses are used by Atlantic salmon. It also accepts that these headwaters are functionally linked to the protected river system, and it accepts that salmon are sensitive to changes in water chemistry and flow. But the disagreement is over what all of
- 7:54that actually means. Dalradian would argue that these burns are of limited importance, and that its proposals will protect the aquatic environment. The Locks Agency surprisingly says almost exactly the opposite. It says all three burns-the pollen row, the unnamed burn, and the Curranalt burn-are natural
- 8:15headwaters that contribute to the wider salmon population. It says the pollen row provides spawning and juvenile habitat. It says the unnamed burn contains good quality salmon habitat. It says the EDNA evidence indicates the presence of Atlantic salmon in the Coronalt burn. The agency's
- 8:42argument is that the habitat does not suddenly become unimportant because it happens to fall outside the line somebody is drawn around a special area of conservation. If salmon belonging to that protected population use the habitat, then it is functionally linked to the protected
- 9:01population, mr. Honey also accused the Shadow Habitats Regulation Assessment of what he called salami slicing. To explain, a Shadow Habitats Regulation Assessment, or Shadow HRA, is the applicant's own assessment of how the proposed development could affect internationally protected
- 9:23habitats and species. It's called shadow because it is not the final legal assessment that must be carried out by the relevant public authority, but it is intended to provide the evidence on which that decision can be based. And to come back to salami slicing, this means looking at the individual
- 9:43effects separately, rather than considering how changes to flows, water chemistry, sediment, and habitat would all be experienced together through construction, operation, and eventually closure. Dr. Sarah McLean, the LOPS agency director of. Science then spent several hours taking us through the
- 10:03scientific basis for the agency's position, and her central message was actually remarkably straightforward. The question is whether Atlantic salmon use these burns. The Lox agency's answer to that is unequivocally yes. It has electrofishing results, eDNA evidence, habitat surveys, and
- 10:26records of salmon nests, or also known as reds, gathered over several years. Dr. McLean explained that electrofishing only gives you a snapshot in time. Very young salmon can be tiny; they can be hidden down amongst the gravel and very easily missed during a survey carried out in June. By
- 10:48September, those same fish are bigger, heavier, and much easier to detect. So, a survey that finds no salmon does not prove that salmon are absent, but a survey that finds salmon does prove that they are present.
- 11:03She also rejected the idea that spawning habitat is somehow more important than nursery habitat or refuge habitat. Atlantic salmon need different types of habitat at different stages of their lives. The loss of any one of those habitats can reduce the number of fish that survive and eventually return to spawn. The
- 11:26pollen row is particularly important because Dalreadian proposed to divert and culvert approximately one kilometre of it. The LAX agency says that would turn a naturally variable headwater into a managed and much more uniform channel, and that natural variation matters. High flows move sediment and
- 11:49help to clean the spawning gravel. Lower flows provide other habitat conditions. If you alter that natural pattern, fine sediment can settle between the stones. The riverbed can become compacted, and less oxygen may reach the salmon eggs buried in the gravel. Dalradin has argued that stabilising the flow could
- 12:11actually be beneficial. The Locks Agency's response was memorable. There is no artificial version of a natural river that is somehow better than the natural river itself. Dr. McLean also addressed comparison Dalradin had drawn with the A Five Road project and with recreational angling. She
- 12:34explained that the A Five affects water courses further down the catchment. It has been assessed over many years and does not create the same long-term operational risk as a gold mine located in the headwaters, and comparing carefully regulated recreational angling with the loss or
- 12:54degradation of the habitat of an entire salmon population, she said was simply not valid. After lunch, it was NIEA's turn to give its updated position, and NIEA strongly endorsed much of what we had already heard from the locks agency. It said the issues is not the sheer number of appendices and documents the
- 13:19applicant has produced; the issue is whether the evidence actually meets the legal test, and its specialists remain unable to rule out adverse effects on the integrity of the protected sites. NIEA also explained the very close connection between Atlantic salmon and freshwater pearl
- 13:41mussels, during part of their life cycle, the young mussels attach themselves to the gills of salmon. So, if you damage the salmon population, you may also damage the freshwater pearl mussel population. The two simply cannot be assessed as though they have nothing to do with each other. On nitrates,
- 14:04NIEA accepts the principle of Dalradian's proposed Betterment Plan. Under that plan, reductions in agricultural nitrate would be used to offset nitrate coming from the development. But NIEA said the applicant had not yet demonstrated that the plan would actually result in betterment in
- 14:26the relevant stretch of the river. It has not shown how often contingency discharges might be used, what would happen after the mine closes, or what the long-term future would be for the farms being removed from agricultural production, NIEA also identified discrepancies between its own biological
- 14:47monitoring results and dalradiance. At all six locations sampled by NIEA in the spring of 2026, NIEA recorded a higher water quality. Status than the status reported in the applicant's results, and that matters because Dalreadian has relied on its monitoring results to support its description of
- 15:11some of these water courses as being of low ecological value. On flows, NIEA said that Atta and Glenelly burns could meet the relevant conservation targets, but the Kurnault burn, the Pauln Roe burn, and the unnamed water courses would not, and because of that, NIEA remains unable to rule out
- 15:36likely significant effects on the special areas of conservation, Groundwater and private water supplies received a much shorter airing. 61 private water supplies have been identified on or around the site. Only three of these are registered with the Drinking Water Inspectorate, and
- 15:56important information, including the use and depth of some of the supplies, is still missing. The inspector believes those issues can be dealt with through conditions ensuring that households retain their private supply or are provided with another wholesome source of drinking water. Any issue
- 16:15concerning the public water supply is to be discussed between the applicant and Northern Ireland water, and that brought the first day of water evidence to an end. It was a very different day for those of us sitting in the room. There was very little or no opportunity for third parties to
- 16:35speak. For most of the day, we simply sat, listened, and recorded, while two statutory bodies spent more than three hours explaining their concerns.
- 16:46In the end, there was one fairly simple question: Can these natural headwaters be altered, diverted, and managed for decades without damaging the Atlantic salmon, the freshwater pearl mussels, and the protected river system downstream. Today, both the LOX agency and NIEA said that Dalrading has not
- 17:11demonstrated that they can. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Front Line. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the
- 17:31conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities, and don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these
- 17:49voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them?