Latest / Signal & Noise: Bringing Clarity to Media, Data, Tech and AI / Publisher Monetization Woes: Is the News Media in Jeopardy? with Jessica Hogue
Transcript
- 0:14Welcome to Signaling Noise. Today's guest is Jessica Hogue,
- 0:19the chief data officer of consumer media at Hearst,
- 0:23someone that I, as well as Rio know really well.
- 0:26She is one of the where are you now Nielsen execs that I worked
- 0:31with for quite a while when I was part of Nielsen.
- 0:34This episode's called publisher monetization woes.
- 0:37Is the news media in jeopardy? And for, for those that don't
- 0:41know Jessica, she's a terrific woman.
- 0:44She LED a bunch of really high profile product leadership and
- 0:48digital roles at Nielsen, as I mentioned for about 12 years.
- 0:51I joined through an acquisition from Exlate and worked with her
- 0:54a lot when we launched the Nielsen Marketing Cloud for a
- 0:57few years. And then she moved on to
- 0:58Innovid, helped take Innovid Public.
- 1:01She was there for a little bit over 4 years and now she is the
- 1:05Chief Data Officer of Consumer Media at Hearst.
- 1:09And she serves a really important role of, of combining
- 1:13and enriching and normalizing all of their consumer audience
- 1:18data across all of their properties within Hearst.
- 1:20And she plays a really good, and I saw this at Nielsen
- 1:23translation layer between the traditional world of media, the
- 1:28linear world of media, which she certainly did with the
- 1:30television ecosystem and the digital, largely digital media
- 1:34world. So we're thrilled to have her.
- 1:36She follows a long list of of really great guests that that
- 1:40Rio and I have had, including Stephanie Laser, Ben Wilde, Dr.
- 1:44Augustine Fu, Shiv Gupta, Mark Zagorski, Lou Pascalis, and
- 1:49we've got a whole bunch more coming up, Adam Greco.
- 1:51But I think you're really going to enjoy this episode in Rio.
- 1:54I was thrilled with the interview and I know you've got
- 1:56some feelings about that as well.
- 1:57It just goes great. I mean, she's so smart.
- 1:59She's been in industry, Brett, as you mentioned forever.
- 2:02You've seen a lot of the big changes.
- 2:04She's kind of been right there, some of the coolest, most
- 2:06innovative companies. She's just a really smart
- 2:08person. It kind of, I love what she's
- 2:10doing at Hearst and you'll hear it in the episode, how they're
- 2:12really trying to prepare for a totally different future.
- 2:16And they really want to be at the vanguard of this as the
- 2:18industry. And a big part of that's gonna
- 2:20be, I mean, she's chief data officer, right, preparing that
- 2:23data foundation, getting the audience data like from all
- 2:27these different places. And it's a big sprawling
- 2:28business that spans everything from traditional television,
- 2:31linear television to digital to magazines.
- 2:34So it's, it's cool hearing like what their vision is, what she's
- 2:37working on. And hers did pretty well last
- 2:39year. I mean, this year we'll see.
- 2:40It's, you know, it's been a tough environment for news
- 2:42publishers the last 20 years. And we talked about that a
- 2:44little bit. But, you know, last year they
- 2:45had really good performance by looking at here, they had record
- 2:48profits. And so it's it's a good success.
- 2:50Story. A couple other news items that
- 2:53probably worth mentioning as we as we kick this off, not not
- 2:56directly related, but definitely within kind of the world of
- 2:59advertising and AD tech. We had some recent Google News
- 3:02is interesting that keeps changing by the day.
- 3:04Right There was finally the remedies by from the from
- 3:07judgement about what to do following the antitrust trial
- 3:09when it was decided they were a monopoly.
- 3:11I I I tweeted that I thought this was a big nothing.
- 3:13Burger it'd be. Really.
- 3:13Yeah. The Google search specifically,
- 3:16not their sell side. Yeah, Yeah, that's coming,
- 3:19right. But they get to keep Chrome.
- 3:21They don't have to spin it off, right?
- 3:23They get to keep like, you know, nothing in the business is
- 3:25really impacted in the big way. Their stock bumped almost 7% as
- 3:29a result of that, I think. They, they, the Department of
- 3:31Justice sort of gave some recommendations, right?
- 3:33But but nothing that seems entirely enforceable and I'm not
- 3:37sure. It's going to change share
- 3:38search data and that's going to take years, right?
- 3:41Yeah. You know, take years.
- 3:43So not, you know, I think Google ends up looking pretty good up
- 3:46to this. But that said, Brett, you know,
- 3:47there's still the ad tech part. You know, that's I, I think they
- 3:50probably end up spinning that off.
- 3:51I mean, but I think it'd be better for them anyway.
- 3:54It's only it's, I think it's only contributing a few billion
- 3:56dollars to their. Bottom line.
- 3:57So like who? Really.
- 3:58Cares if you're Google, right? You focus in the future, which
- 4:00is definitely going to be AI search.
- 4:04I think this decision is it kind of like Harkins back to like
- 4:07remember the Microsoft decision? The DOJ sued them for being a
- 4:10monopoly. Yeah.
- 4:12Like and then didn't do anything, didn't really didn't
- 4:14sort of let them operate as as the same business really.
- 4:17Forced them to unbundle their browser from the hardware,
- 4:20right? Like so when you.
- 4:22But but it was a like. Few years later, Chrome's a
- 4:26bigger browser than Edge, right? Or whatever they Internet
- 4:28Explorer. So like, it was kind of a
- 4:30nothing burger back then. I mean, it seemed like it was
- 4:32going to be meaningful, but ended up like it was too little
- 4:34too late. I almost think this is the same
- 4:36thing, right? AI search is really changing it.
- 4:39That's where Google needs to compete.
- 4:40They were a monopoly in existing search and, and, and as well as,
- 4:44you know, with their ad tech, you know, owning both buy and
- 4:46sell. But it's almost like that's the,
- 4:48I'm going to say that's totally the past, but it's almost seems
- 4:51like that's less important moving forward than it has been
- 4:53so. I don't know but and.
- 4:56In this case, started in 2020 and yeah, it started in 2020 and
- 5:00that was, it's a very different world in 2025 than it was in
- 5:032020. Totally so.
- 5:05It's interesting how how slowly these justice motions move and
- 5:09by the time they. Not the speed of tech.
- 5:11Yeah, not the speed of tech, yeah.
- 5:13Yeah. And then you know, but at the
- 5:15same time Google like I think the EU did find them this
- 5:17morning. It was announced several billion
- 5:19dollars. I mean for Google it's peanuts,
- 5:20right? I mean, so like it looks like
- 5:22they're going to end up exiting this probably OK, the
- 5:25traditional business, maybe they get forced to sell off the the
- 5:27ad tech side of it, which would probably be a good thing.
- 5:29But but I think that that was the big news of this last couple
- 5:32weeks, probably worth calling out.
- 5:34But will this impact, you know, news publishers, you know, you
- 5:38know, I think the ad tech decision probably will have a
- 5:40bigger impact on them moving forward.
- 5:42But but you know, everything's, you know, I think AI is the big
- 5:46story here, not necessarily the Google decision.
- 5:48Yeah, they're saying let let market forces win.
- 5:51And AI is one of those market forces that's changed the entire
- 5:55landscape since 2020 of how AI of how search is being monetized
- 6:00and utilized by publishers and and other vendors as.
- 6:04Deferral. Traffic changes and as Google
- 6:07zero kind of that that day approaches.
- 6:09So I think that's the bigger story and that's certainly the
- 6:11bigger impact on publisher. So with that, why don't we jump
- 6:13into the episode? It's going to be a fun one.
- 6:15Now I agree with you, Bret. It kind of continues this.
- 6:16We talked to stuff laser about publisher tech and this re
- 6:19platforming. We have a loop of Scalis where
- 6:21we talk about the future of news, and here you get Jessica
- 6:24Hoag who's right in the front lines.
- 6:25Like add a big traditional publisher that's transitioning
- 6:29into a digital first publisher. So enjoy it everyone.
- 6:33It's a good one. Hey, Jessica, welcome to Signal
- 6:37and Noise. I'm glad to have you on the on
- 6:38the podcast. Yeah, it's so fun to be here.
- 6:40Thank you. And you and I go back quite a
- 6:42few years. We're both sort of part of what
- 6:44I like to call the Nielsen Mafia.
- 6:46And I'm in a, I'm in a company now with about 10 or 15 Nielsen
- 6:50people. So it, it, it holds well.
- 6:53And you and Rio worked together when Rio was Salaam Consulting,
- 6:57doing some work for Hearst. And, you know, I figured I'd
- 6:59love, I'd love to hear a little bit about, or I think our
- 7:02audience would love to hear a little bit about your background
- 7:04and kind of what brought you to your current role as chief data
- 7:07officer. Oh, yeah.
- 7:08At Hearst. Yeah, it's, you know, I get
- 7:10asked this question a fair amount because, you know, I
- 7:13think people are always interested in everyone else's
- 7:16career journey and it speaks a little to what we're trying to
- 7:19do at Hearst too. So I, it's fun to kind of go
- 7:22back and sort of look at how did I get here actually.
- 7:25So as you pointed out, a lot of my roots are really in analytics
- 7:29and measurement from more than a decade at Nielsen.
- 7:33I actually landed there in O6O7 when the company had made an
- 7:39acquisition in a small social listening startup.
- 7:41And so I do kind of, you know, there is a bit of a through line
- 7:45in my own journey, which is, you know, I like the build phase.
- 7:49I like the kind of startup like, you know, market fit finding
- 7:54era, if you will, but as. Painful as it can be sometimes.
- 7:58Yeah. You know, it's, it's change,
- 7:59it's it's high intensity, it's all good.
- 8:02But but yeah, so you know, Nielsen, I spent, you know, in a
- 8:06variety of different roles and in different, you know, sort of
- 8:10parts of that business at the time.
- 8:13The one sort of consistent theme I was always working on is
- 8:15triangulating data sets right into different analytics or
- 8:18measurement products. And that occurred to me much
- 8:21later in the process of that's what I always kind of tried to
- 8:25get back to. And then from from Nielsen, I
- 8:28went to Innovid, which was just a phenomenal place to land in
- 8:32the sort of rise of CTVI mean by the time I got to innovate, it
- 8:35was already, you know, a very vibrant, but still young
- 8:39company, not a startup per SE, but still ascending in a lot of
- 8:43ways. And you took it in.
- 8:45Public or you were there when they went?
- 8:47Public, I was, yeah. So, so that kind of happened.
- 8:50It was, it was really, I mean, it's both a business case.
- 8:53It's thrilling. You know, it's incredible to
- 8:56work with founders and see that kind of trajectory.
- 9:00And that was a long time. That was a long time coming,
- 9:02right? They'd been around for quite a
- 9:03while, well over a decade I believe, before they.
- 9:06Were around 11 years old if I remember correctly around that
- 9:09time, so yeah. So I joined to help build a
- 9:14measurement in analytics framework and portfolio on top
- 9:18of the the core technology, which is the ad serving business
- 9:21at the time. And so that was also, you know,
- 9:23I was a general manager. I got to build that from the
- 9:26start. And you know, it started with,
- 9:29you know, Tal Telosin, which I'm sure a lot of folks in your
- 9:33audience and community will be familiar with, who had so many
- 9:36brilliant ideas about where the company could go.
- 9:38And so that was a really fun journey.
- 9:42You know, we built that out. We scaled that with the
- 9:44acquisition of TV Squared. And then yeah, you know, the
- 9:46company went public and continues to to really thrive in
- 9:50the measurement category as now a, you know, provider of outcome
- 9:55and reach and frequency metrics, which is really quite remarkable
- 9:59to see just knowing how how tough that was from the jump.
- 10:03And you ran, you ran point on the TV Squared acquisition and
- 10:07the kind of product management of that.
- 10:09Well, that was yeah, that I wouldn't say that I rank point.
- 10:14Yeah, that was very much a sort of community activity that I, I,
- 10:18you know, I like to think that I contributed a lot to, you know,
- 10:21what the company could become and why we had a right to sort
- 10:24of bring measurement and analytics to the marketplace,
- 10:27just especially, you know, from my various tours knowing how
- 10:31complicated it was. But I had a pretty strong point
- 10:33of view at the time that, you know, the the buy side, which in
- 10:37of it is really, you know, ad tech facing the buy side was,
- 10:40you know, at the time had a right to play in this sort of
- 10:44top down set of metrics. You know, we were delivering CTV
- 10:48at massive scale every day. And you know what, everybody
- 10:50needed reach in frequency metrics with like demographics
- 10:54and then to be able to know, you know, did the creative work, did
- 10:57it produce an outcome? And so I was really passionate
- 11:00about that and the TV Squared acquisition brought so much to
- 11:04that sort of funnel play, if you will.
- 11:06And then of course the diversification into to working
- 11:09with publishers on sort of more of a sell side offering as well.
- 11:12So it was great. Joe is phenomenal.
- 11:15It was really fun to to get to work with.
- 11:17She is. Hilarious too, I had her.
- 11:19On You haven't had her on yet. I had, I had her on a panel at
- 11:22one of our Brave New Worlds events, which I think it was the
- 11:24same event that you spoke at. And I mean, she just had me
- 11:26laughing on on the panel the entire time she.
- 11:30Was not been a guest in this podcast yet Jessica, but
- 11:32hopefully in the quite a. Personality.
- 11:33Quite. A.
- 11:34Personality. Yeah, she is.
- 11:37So let's see. So how did I get to Hearst?
- 11:39You know, I think somewhat similarly to to what even what
- 11:42we've been talking about already, Hearst didn't have a
- 11:45chief data officer in consumer media.
- 11:48And so it's been, you know, really quite a joy and a
- 11:51privilege to be able to to be the first in sort of design, you
- 11:55know, what does this role do and what's our reason for being?
- 11:57And and so part of, you know, that still has a little bit of
- 12:01a, you know, an entrepreneurial sense to it.
- 12:03Yeah, I was thinking. That it does it, you're kind of
- 12:05defining your role in a sense of defining, defining the function,
- 12:09right. Yeah, exactly.
- 12:10Intrapreneur isn't that, that isn't that.
- 12:12But that's that's described right?
- 12:13Yeah. You're exactly right, Rio.
- 12:15Yeah, it's definitely, you know, inside of this incredible, you
- 12:19know, storied institution. And so, you know, really our
- 12:24role here is, is to sort of develop and inform and execute
- 12:29on data strategies. That's kind of the, you know,
- 12:31job number one. Sometimes that takes, you know,
- 12:34really different forms. Sometimes it's, you know,
- 12:37partnering and thinking out loud with folks that are data leaders
- 12:40in their respective organizations.
- 12:43But what my team has really grown into a function to support
- 12:47a couple of areas, you know, largely I would sort of situated
- 12:51as building infrastructure around users and user data.
- 12:55And then increasingly we're moving on sort of the content
- 12:58side. And part of our opportunity is
- 13:02to do those things at scale so that we get the sort of, you
- 13:06know, scale across the the full footprint of Hearst Media
- 13:10properties and divisions. But also it kind of comes back
- 13:14to a very sort of core functional thing, which is, you
- 13:16know, we know on the other side of all of these various
- 13:19transformations that media companies and publishers, we, we
- 13:23want to have the best possible relationships with our actual
- 13:26readers and visitors and audience.
- 13:28And so, you know, for me in many ways, you know, most my day job
- 13:32is day-to-day to data, but it's kind of still its audience at
- 13:35the end of the day. And we, we saw a big opportunity
- 13:37to be able to infuse a lot of infrastructure and data and
- 13:41investment behind building out those kind of micro services, if
- 13:45you will and partnering really closely with the, the various
- 13:48folks in our, in our three divisions.
- 13:51Well, Jessica, we are thrilled to have you on here today.
- 13:53I mean, this is a really important topic and you know,
- 13:55we've come at it from different angles over previous episodes.
- 13:58Stephanie as a result, she talked about really the tech and
- 14:00the the re platforming. You know, we had Doctor Fool and
- 14:04he talked about some of the some things publishers experiencing
- 14:07for everything from ad fraud to referral revenue dipping.
- 14:13And last week we talked a little bit about, you know, some of the
- 14:15stuff going with AI. So we're thrilled to have you
- 14:17here. And I used to the background
- 14:19here for those or a little newer to this is the whole business
- 14:22model really that has bankrolled and funded and supported, let's
- 14:26say not only newsrooms, but investigative journalism as well
- 14:30as you know, all types of traditional media magazines.
- 14:32It's really been buckling under these converging forces.
- 14:35Everything from programmatic tech taxes that have siphoned
- 14:38away a ton of revenue from publishers to mounting signal
- 14:41loss as cookies have kind of gone away kind of not.
- 14:45I mean, for, I guess for the most part they have and you
- 14:48know, now AI, right? It's the latest thing.
- 14:50I mean, we're going to talk about that a lot as it, you
- 14:52know, referral traffic dips and that's definitely impacting
- 14:56revenue from display, right? It's going to affect publishers.
- 14:59So it's the bigger question is what is this doing to the
- 15:02quality journalism and by extension, the concept of really
- 15:06a vibrant Free Press, because it really does depend on publishers
- 15:08having healthy businesses and being able to replace the
- 15:11dollars they're losing with new revenue streams, whether it does
- 15:15smarter data strategies, you know, richer first party
- 15:18identity, a lot of the stuff you're working on, Jessica,
- 15:20we're really excited to hear about and just finding ways to
- 15:23bring into revenue streams. We're going to be talking about
- 15:24that. And I really think that fewer
- 15:26people are sit closer to this inflection point than you do as
- 15:30your world Chief Diet officer at Hearst, overseeing data
- 15:32development for an amazing like 137 year old media institution,
- 15:37I think we can call it that, that has properties across
- 15:39magazines, newspapers, streaming and commerce.
- 15:42And what's a big job to figure out how to turn this audience
- 15:45insight into sustainable value, not only for the readers that
- 15:48you mentioned, but for your advertisers.
- 15:50So I think it's it's a cool vantage point you have mixing
- 15:54this legacy print background with the really the stewardship
- 15:57of the metrics, everything from digital subscriptions to private
- 16:01marketplace yields, your clean room partnerships, what we do
- 16:04with AI in short, really navigating the crossroads right
- 16:07of I think where the industry is.
- 16:08Yeah. So I mean Hearst, I mean
- 16:10established in what, 1887? And.
- 16:13William Randolph Hearst was 23 and I think the first time I
- 16:16heard about it was yellow journalism.
- 16:19You know, when you're in like high school or middle school,
- 16:22you know, so note knowing that this year you're coming from
- 16:24sort of a legacy or you're in a legacy media or traditionally a
- 16:27legacy media organization that's been around for a long time.
- 16:30You know, Rio just laid out the thesis.
- 16:31I meant publisher monetization's challenged.
- 16:34It's in a challenged state, right?
- 16:35The news media's, we've known it.
- 16:37You've, you probably have read the articles from Lou Pascalis
- 16:40or heard him talking about defending the open web and the,
- 16:44in the, in how critical it is to our own democracy.
- 16:47Just at a very high level. When you think about digital
- 16:50transformation, because it's a driver of, of 75 to 80% of, of
- 16:55publisher, digital publisher revenue right now.
- 16:59How are you thinking about that journey at Hearst and how are
- 17:02you? How is your team sort of helping
- 17:03to transform, to adapt to some of these challenges?
- 17:09Yeah. You know, I have so much to say
- 17:12and on this one and there's a lot to unpack here there of
- 17:16course. So, so first of all, in the
- 17:18thesis, you know, no question things are, you know, the the
- 17:21models that got us here. If we talk about sort of high
- 17:25margin underwritten by ad sales, lots of consumer data by the
- 17:29way, you know, there, there is no sort of one way out of this
- 17:34situation anymore. And I think, you know, that's
- 17:37not unique to us and anyone in this sort of industry right now.
- 17:41Everyone. Yeah, yeah.
- 17:43And you know, I think you called it out.
- 17:45I mean, there are certainly, you know, shifts in big platform
- 17:48dynamics, there's regulatory dynamics, obviously generative
- 17:54AI. So those are all, you know, in
- 17:56my mind somewhat, you know, existential right in nature and,
- 18:00and really big, long and sort of enduring trends.
- 18:04And then there's just the kind of work a day stuff that we've
- 18:07all been grinding it out on. I mean, you, you hit the nail on
- 18:09the head. It's, you know, cookie
- 18:10deprecation that, you know, frankly, I was still at Nielsen
- 18:13when we were talking, talking about the cookie pop.
- 18:15And I'm like. Conversations going.
- 18:17On, you know, it's like the year of mobile that was a decade.
- 18:19So Yep, that that's still, but it is, you know, the, the
- 18:22practicality of having these really sort of opaque
- 18:24environments is still something to navigate on a day-to-day
- 18:27basis. Brand safety and the sort of
- 18:30impact to, to journalism is still something we're very much
- 18:34sort of working the problem on. And, you know, just the, the
- 18:37supply chain sort of at large, you know, interestingly, the
- 18:40supply chain we often talk about in, in AD tech, but I see just
- 18:43as many shifts in martech and we're sort of, you know, both.
- 18:47So all of those things for sure, for sure.
- 18:50I think that and this is really, you know, what compelled me to
- 18:53come here at this time is it's a big inflection point.
- 18:57So you know, you can kind of look at it as OK, like is just a
- 19:01lot of stuff to do. And that's true.
- 19:04I think we have the opportunity and this is kind of the the what
- 19:06inspires our vision to re architect a lot of the
- 19:09foundations. And so, you know, from our role
- 19:11just as the the data piece, you know, data is sort of
- 19:15fundamental and core, but it does kind of require us in this
- 19:18moment to really rethink, you know, how did we build the sort
- 19:22of foundational components of tech and data and, you know,
- 19:25user experience, How do we do that going forward?
- 19:30Certainly diversifying revenue, which I think we'll get into as
- 19:33well. And, you know, I don't sit in
- 19:35the the revenue lane necessarily, but a lot of what
- 19:38my team does is sort of create capabilities to, you know, to
- 19:42monetize our user experiences in a variety of different ways.
- 19:45And there's lots of different things happening on that front.
- 19:47So, yeah, I mean, I think it is, is very much a moment of a lot
- 19:52of change. I think I sort of choose to
- 19:56those things invigorate me. I mean, you know, I've, I've
- 19:58always kind of been in roles at some amount of change.
- 20:02And this is probably true of everybody's career, right.
- 20:04But even at Nielsen, you know, we were going through the the
- 20:07changes in streaming and television consumption for a
- 20:11long time. So I, I happen to, you know,
- 20:13find those things sort of those environments kind of
- 20:15interesting. And you can do a lot if you have
- 20:18the stamina, I think, to work through them.
- 20:21Yeah. It is the advertising industry
- 20:23and you made some, some really good points.
- 20:24We talked about this with Stephanie Laser about re
- 20:26architecting, re platforming, which is not something that's
- 20:29unique to Hearst. It's, it's common across all
- 20:33whether they're digital or legacy linear publishers.
- 20:36It's pretty common from a data strategy in in martech
- 20:39perspective, so. I think having audiences, having
- 20:42the measurement in place, you know, it's, it's, it's not easy,
- 20:46right? And I think those a lot of time
- 20:47that requires investments. So yeah.
- 20:49Yeah. But you kind of alluded to it
- 20:52earlier too. I mean, the, I think that
- 20:56transformation sort of inside of a company and if we describe
- 21:00that as intrapreneurship or what have you, I'm really inspired by
- 21:06the trajectory of Hearst in a lot of ways.
- 21:09And I maybe maybe the company is less well known for this on the
- 21:13media side. But, you know, obviously Hearst
- 21:16has been around for more than a century, approaching 140 years,
- 21:20which is really quite staggering when you think about it.
- 21:24And I remember really first learning about William Randolph
- 21:27Hearst when I was in J school. And it was, you know, the, the
- 21:30battle between Hearst and Pulitzer.
- 21:33And, you know, it was so fascinating to read about.
- 21:35But you know, if they think about where the company started
- 21:38from as a paper business, you know, in the 1920s and 30s, I'm
- 21:43probably going to get some of my chronology a little off here,
- 21:46you know, diversified into magazines, which was a very
- 21:49different product at that time. And with Cosmo and Good
- 21:54Housekeeping, these are brands that are still with us today.
- 21:57If you look at what the new editor in chief is doing with
- 21:59the brand Cosmo, it's like it's reinventing and sort of
- 22:04reconnecting to a lot of the values of that brand too.
- 22:06So and then you. Have a little show and tell
- 22:08right around the Cosmopolitan magazine.
- 22:10I think you might be able. To thank you for teeing this so
- 22:13for your for your studio audience, if you can see I've
- 22:16got this gorgeous piece of this is I could see.
- 22:19It and that was a little blurry, yeah.
- 22:20What a great brand font. Cosmopolitan.
- 22:23Had I just. Yeah, it's so I, we have a small
- 22:27place in the Adirondacks, and I was in this, you know, small
- 22:30sort of, you know, antique shop. And I was walking up the stairs
- 22:33looking for I don't know what. And on the side of this wall
- 22:36were a number of different framed covers of old magazines.
- 22:40And I immediately locked in and I saw Hearst International's
- 22:43Cosmopolitan. And I was like, I will, I must
- 22:45have that. And so it's it's, yeah, it's
- 22:47sitting here in my office as kind of a reminder of the
- 22:50history of the company. But yeah, I mean, this company
- 22:54has been doing transformation and diversification, and I think
- 22:58it's very much in the DNA of the company.
- 23:01And that's really inspiring. So it's like, OK, let's go do
- 23:04that again. What does it look like on the
- 23:06other side? There's a lot of unknowns I
- 23:08would say, but but yeah, the the, so the.
- 23:11Organizational change is a little easier because it's part
- 23:14of the sort of core, core competency of the organization
- 23:17because it's been doing this for so long and essentially.
- 23:19I don't know that change is ever easy, but I, I guess I would say
- 23:23that there are plenty of hallmarks and, and really great
- 23:30outcomes. And, and also our leadership is,
- 23:33you know, you know, often is the the case from leadership of go
- 23:36faster. And so I think all of those
- 23:38things kind of produce the right conditions to get through it.
- 23:43But yeah, I don't want to pretend that it's.
- 23:45Well, but oftentimes that's the hardest piece.
- 23:47If you don't have people aligned around change or accustomed to
- 23:50change, whether it's historically or otherwise, it
- 23:53becomes harder to implement because people get in the way,
- 23:56right? How many times have we heard
- 23:57that in our career, you know? Right, right, people.
- 24:00People are the bottleneck. That's typically the case.
- 24:02Yeah, yeah. But it, you know, kind of to
- 24:04bring it back to to what we're doing on the data side.
- 24:07So, you know, because of all of those things, it was sort of,
- 24:10you know, as you said, lots of companies are kind of looking at
- 24:13their architecture and and platforms and sort of taking
- 24:16this as an opportunity to take stock and retool for what the
- 24:19future is like. And we get a lot of support for
- 24:21that and a lot of, you know, really cool collaboration with
- 24:25different folks in our divisions to sort of see where we fit and
- 24:29we can help them go faster. And that's kind of like for for
- 24:33us, that's that's the spot we want to be in.
- 24:36Just turning back to monetization, obviously a really
- 24:38important topic and you're looking at publishing industry
- 24:41in general. I mean many people don't know
- 24:42this has been I think between 2002 and 2020, there was a 50%
- 24:48decline in revenue overall for the industry, which is really
- 24:51pretty catastrophic, right? So knowing that monetization is
- 24:53going to be really important, I know it's a big focus of what
- 24:56Hearst is you in general in your role, a big part of that.
- 24:59I mean, I guess one criticism of let's say digital has been a
- 25:03good portion of programmatic ad spend does not reach publishers,
- 25:06right? It's safe enough by
- 25:08intermediaries, by ad tech companies, by DSPS, by SSPS, by
- 25:12brand safety, ad verification, you know, the list goes really
- 25:14on and on. I think for some, for some
- 25:16deals, publishers are keeping well under 50%, right?
- 25:21And tech tax, right? And there's been great studies
- 25:24like last year, Brett, we talked about with Steph Laser, right,
- 25:26that like average CPMS for some open exchange are under a
- 25:30dollar, right? So like pubs are just not
- 25:33getting what's the expression was like digital pennies for
- 25:36traditional dollars, right? I mean, it's just.
- 25:38Yeah, it's been tough. So like knowing that how is
- 25:42first repositioning is inventory mix, private marketplaces,
- 25:45programmatic guarantee direct sold deals like what are you
- 25:48doing to capture more of the ad dollars I'll be.
- 25:50Curious to hear. It's a, it's a really great
- 25:52question. I would say that there are some
- 25:54things that sort of are consistent across the the three
- 25:57business units and then some things that maybe they're kind
- 26:00of pursuing uniquely to how they expose themselves to the
- 26:03markets. But but by and large, yeah, I
- 26:05mean there's a huge priority around direct sold private
- 26:08marketplace, programmatic guaranteed, You know, those are
- 26:10all environments where, you know, the objective is to do a
- 26:13few things right, to sort of get closer to the end customer sort
- 26:17of, you know, writ large. But those are places that we can
- 26:21make the environments data rich, fully controlled, brand safe,
- 26:25which obviously you know we are really motivated to sort of be
- 26:30out in front around. And so I would say those are all
- 26:33sort of across all three of our business units.
- 26:35Those are all priorities. Some of our businesses are a
- 26:38little bit more exposed, I would say to open auction inventory
- 26:41than others and those things have sort of been in motion for
- 26:45a while. Interestingly, you know, we've
- 26:47kind of put a little bit of a toe dip in the water around, you
- 26:50know, APMP that sort of goes across broader, you know, sort
- 26:53of footprint of our inventory. And understand, you know, from
- 26:57the from the buy side. What's interesting there, right?
- 26:59Because I think in a lot of ways, you know, we can talk
- 27:03about the sort of importance of data, first party data.
- 27:07You know, like we've been here, we've plenty of people have
- 27:10first party data. I don't think having first party
- 27:11data you, you have to sort of explain the texture and the
- 27:15quality and the value and then make it real, which often means
- 27:18sort of showing it in a really transparent way.
- 27:21And so those are all sort of, yeah, I would say underneath the
- 27:24surface sort of priorities of of how we're executing is to, you
- 27:28know, have a, you know, new and differentiated ways to also sort
- 27:33of make the quality of our inventory desirable such that,
- 27:37you know, we're kind of shifting into those in other sort of
- 27:40environment. You know, I have to have give
- 27:41major credit to the programmatic teams that actually run these
- 27:45functions in the divisions which we get to partner with and see.
- 27:48But I think the other thing to their credit is developed, you
- 27:52know, developing really strategic relationships in the
- 27:55market with the sort of buy side and the buying sort of
- 27:59platforms. And it's kind of interesting if
- 28:01you think about it, because you know, when I started,
- 28:03programmatic was all about get rid of the people, get rid of
- 28:06the relationship, like automating the machine.
- 28:08Automate everything. Yeah, yeah.
- 28:10And so you know, what we're doing to sort of reposition that
- 28:13interest, that inventory mix also comes back to having
- 28:17strategic relationships and partnerships which are people
- 28:20LED, you know, even though the the machines are sort of doing
- 28:23the the execution piece and I think that's important.
- 28:26Are you making changes to how, let's say the ad sellers work
- 28:28with like the digital and programmatic team in terms of
- 28:31creating offerings, bundling, bundling different types of
- 28:34services? Is there anything that you're
- 28:35doing there that you can call out?
- 28:36I mean, I would say yes, in terms of bundling, I mean some
- 28:39of the types of things that have been important is to to really
- 28:43sort of focus on the quality of the inventory and be a little
- 28:47bit more forward in the go to market of making that known.
- 28:50And so, you know, that's, that's everything from sustainability,
- 28:54it can be attention metrics that can be brand safety and
- 28:56suitability. I do sort of feel that, you
- 29:00know, even just the, the programmatic sort of priority
- 29:03and, and how those teams sort of work with centers of excellence,
- 29:06various holding companies, you know, that's all part of it.
- 29:08So there's a lot of energy behind it.
- 29:11There's no one sort of package that I would pick out
- 29:14necessarily, but part of that is, is here's why, right.
- 29:17You know, our our brands span a national footprint.
- 29:21If you look at the the lifestyle magazine brands and then in our
- 29:25news businesses, these are hyper local brands at the end of the
- 29:29day, immediate properties. And so I think one of the ways
- 29:32that we're sort of kind of wrestling through how we get
- 29:35more sort of exposure and how we package things is, is exploring
- 29:40where we can't have really sort of an authoritative, A
- 29:43differentiated inventory mix because we are hyperlocal.
- 29:47And you know, increasingly that's very attractive for
- 29:50performance advertisers that are, you know, looking to drive
- 29:52outcomes, looking to have sort of precision in a certain
- 29:55market. So those are all kind of
- 29:56features, I would say that that go into where we're finding
- 30:00resonance in the market. And it it sounds like when
- 30:03you're talking about inventory, are we talking about the
- 30:05audience targets as well as contextual sort of news content
- 30:10related inventory, which seems to be the big differentiator
- 30:12right for especially at the local level?
- 30:15Yeah, Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I, I think that there's
- 30:17a lot of different, you know, my, my sort of watchword on this
- 30:22front is having optionality, right?
- 30:23Because you, there are so many different requirements of what
- 30:27advertisers or what the buy side needs and wants given, you know,
- 30:31the, the vertical that they're in or the sort of objectives of
- 30:33any given campaign. And so, you know, there's
- 30:37certainly been a massive focus on 1st party data and actually
- 30:41we have quite a substantial footprint of first party data, I
- 30:44would say stronger than a lot of web publishers too.
- 30:47So that continues to be sort of a a priority in a defining
- 30:51characteristic. We're working with ecosystem
- 30:54IDs. But yes, I mean, contextual has
- 30:56been really important and our magazine division has an
- 31:00incredible product called Aura out, which is leveraging
- 31:04contextual signal AI. It's got sort of predictive
- 31:07elements too. And so those fit for certain use
- 31:11cases, we, we look at it as a portfolio, you know, what are
- 31:15the, what are the set of, you know, tools, KPIs, ways to sort
- 31:19of remix the audience and what layers we need to apply on to
- 31:23that to make it just which. Is kind of a did enrichment
- 31:26play, right? Sure.
- 31:28Yeah, absolutely. It's, it's, it's giving more
- 31:30sort of three dimensionality to to the actual audience data.
- 31:34Right, like, like, like as like, like this whole signal loss as
- 31:38you know, Google's teasing it out for years.
- 31:40I think. I know you want to get into that
- 31:41a little bit here. Like the hypothesis was just to
- 31:43really favor publishers with rich first party data signals,
- 31:46right, to provide deterministic signals, as well as I think for
- 31:49news publishers and the magazine publishers, right, who have this
- 31:53like great contextual data to like having those have a
- 31:56contextual signals plus deterministic first party data
- 31:58is really when people talk about premium inventory, I think
- 32:02you've got it in spades, right? Yeah, Yeah, I think so.
- 32:05And and I think there's there's also plenty to do.
- 32:08I mean, I really think we're just kind of scratching the
- 32:11surface of what we can surface around hyper local audiences and
- 32:16intent. And you know, this kind of dips
- 32:18into not just, you know, how programmatic and how do you sort
- 32:22of solve for the open auction sort of transformation, but it
- 32:26really does speak to, you know, what buyers want in terms of
- 32:29outcomes. And where I really see this
- 32:31going is, you know, if you can sort of triangulate around
- 32:34really high quality first party data, behavioral and contextual
- 32:38signals. And oh, by the way, we know a
- 32:40lot of how consumers behave in certain markets because we have
- 32:43such density in places like San Francisco, the state of Texas,
- 32:48you know, the parts of New England.
- 32:50You know, where you see this going is new ways of
- 32:52understanding, not just intent, right, but what what sort of
- 32:57where consumers might be headed next.
- 32:59And I think there's probably a lot we can do on particularly
- 33:04our news businesses because they're such a part of consumers
- 33:08day-to-day lives and increasingly provide more
- 33:11utility from the content experience.
- 33:14All that lends itself to just new ways that we can surface and
- 33:18present those those experiences to the to the advertising
- 33:22community of places that they want to be.
- 33:25It all ties back to relevance, right?
- 33:27And you've got to combine all of these things in order to make
- 33:30the advertising relevant to a consumer experience within any
- 33:33of your properties. Yeah, right.
- 33:35Yeah. And, you know, that means
- 33:36continuing to sort of do more, you know, get smarter about how
- 33:42to put the pieces of together. I mean, you know, I don't think
- 33:45it's sufficient just to say, yes, we have contextual do you,
- 33:47you know, you want to, you know, that these things have been sort
- 33:51of around for a while. So we're constantly looking for,
- 33:54OK, what's next And you know, where is the market headed?
- 33:56You know, I don't know if you've done a, a pod yet on the
- 33:59outcomes era, but that's a big, you know, we, we hear a lot
- 34:02about the, you know, really wanting to sort of push the
- 34:05boundaries of outcomes and that that means a whole new set of
- 34:09kind of tools. Yeah, it was Shiv Gupta.
- 34:11It was Shiv Gupta. We talked about that, right.
- 34:13And what does that mean? And does that mean a, you know,
- 34:16a double down on direct response advertising?
- 34:18Does it mean, you know, does it mean moving away from sort of
- 34:21brand awareness, Halo effect, brand, brand building,
- 34:24advertising like? Brett, that was my initial like
- 34:27when I first heard the whole outcomes here, I was like, oh,
- 34:29is that what that mean? Everything's going to be go back
- 34:31to the go back direct response to CPA.
- 34:33Right now get. A free super share on me.
- 34:36I don't think it, I don't think it necessarily should be that,
- 34:38but. Yeah, I don't think it's that.
- 34:40Yeah, I mean. Outcomes, I think just you're
- 34:43hinting at outcomes can be defined in a lot of different
- 34:45ways in a brand awareness Halo effect outcome that let's say
- 34:49it's a financial services organization.
- 34:50It's an outcome that has some level of influence on a consumer
- 34:54journey where they they, they get exposed to things deeper
- 34:58down funnel as they, as they start to show more intent, so.
- 35:01That's right. Yeah.
- 35:01Yeah, yeah, I agree with that. AIA little bit earlier, like
- 35:07referral traffic, I mean, you know, with with AI summaries, I
- 35:10mean I've seen different studies everywhere anywhere from 25 to
- 35:1296% of traffic dropping off right for publishers.
- 35:15Obviously this will impact yield of monetization right from from
- 35:18display love to know like what what is first doing in this
- 35:21area? Some we're calling it Google
- 35:23zero, like the Google 0 moment right knowing that you know at
- 35:26some point it could go to there. We've seen some interesting
- 35:28things like an industry we talked about Cloudflare a little
- 35:31bit their announcement kind of being the gatekeeper or wanting
- 35:34to collect tolls on behalf of publishers.
- 35:37You know, I think Google was telling publishers, if you block
- 35:40our LLM scraped from scraping you, we're not going to scrape
- 35:46you for search, right? You know, I mean, I think
- 35:48there's a lot of things that are in flux here, but we know that
- 35:51this is a trend and it's going to continue.
- 35:53And I do understand the traffic is already down, right?
- 35:55So wondering like, like what what are you doing in this area?
- 35:58Overhurst? Love to hear about your
- 36:00thoughts. Yeah, yeah.
- 36:02Well, definitely. You know, all of those shifts, I
- 36:05mean it, it does sort of, it does sort of remind me of, of
- 36:10social and sort of the, you know, understanding UGC as a
- 36:14behavior for the first time and, and how to sort of get good at
- 36:17that, you know, I, I think. It's a whole that's a whole
- 36:20other topic we could. I know.
- 36:22But yeah, yeah, Next up. I think, you know, we're all
- 36:25kind of going back to school and we're freshmen again, right?
- 36:27Like we don't, we don't know. So we've got to go and study and
- 36:30see how, you know, what, what behavior is like and how do
- 36:34consumers engage with the quote UN quote answer engines.
- 36:39You know, I think answer is sort of implies a lot of finality and
- 36:42actually what they're getting you to do that ask the next best
- 36:45question. But but yeah, I would say, you
- 36:48know, there's a lot of energy here around just studying what
- 36:52is happening and not missing that moment to sort of get to
- 36:56solutioning too quickly because it's such a seismic change.
- 37:00I'm actually really excited. We just kicked off some research
- 37:03that we're doing with a partner for one of our lifestyle brands
- 37:07to understand this very thing, right?
- 37:08You know, how does the the media brand show up both as a as is
- 37:14part of an answer, not the source, but as part of the
- 37:17answer? And what are all the subtleties
- 37:19that we can learn about the sort of brand ethos around it?
- 37:22Where does it naturally occur? And so that's what I mean by
- 37:25we've got to go and study and really learn how these things
- 37:28kind of work in the wild. So that's part of what we're
- 37:31doing. You know, certainly Hearst has
- 37:35licensing models with open AI with Rufus.
- 37:38So there's an element of that too, of, you know, we've got to
- 37:41participate to. Doing that.
- 37:44Yeah, exactly. There's a lot of to just, I
- 37:47would say, you know, different experiments around where we can
- 37:50leverage AI and create our own user experience.
- 37:53So if the if you know, part of what will transform overtime
- 37:57here is these new kind of surface areas where consumers
- 38:00are going deeper and deeper and deeper into getting more
- 38:03information, you know, whether it's an answer or they're
- 38:06searching more. You know, we're also
- 38:08experimenting to figure out, you know, where do we sort of
- 38:11provide utility and types of information to support that.
- 38:16And so if you think about all of the types of content that
- 38:20probably never makes it into an article, you know, there is an
- 38:23element of sort of re scaffolding of the the content
- 38:26that the sort of the CMS, if you will, of what are new ways that
- 38:30we might sort of leverage some of that information.
- 38:32That is part of the the sort of operation of just producing
- 38:36what, you know, what was an article or what was a stream
- 38:38historically into new types of formats.
- 38:41And so there's a lot of innovation happening on that
- 38:43front. And I'll kind of bring it back
- 38:44to to something that you're doing also in our team is, is
- 38:47really understanding ending this sort of semantic relationship of
- 38:51content. And, you know, we've really sort
- 38:54of impressed by how far AI has come in helping us sort of
- 39:00innovate in that area. And so we see that as sort of an
- 39:03input to if if part of an objective is to have more kind
- 39:07of DTC consumer engagement, keep them in our environments longer,
- 39:12keep sort of serving up new ways for them to consume content or
- 39:16information from us. You know, that's there are
- 39:19there's an element of personalization there
- 39:21potentially. And so we're doing, you know,
- 39:24some innovation now to see how we can plume all of the data
- 39:27that we sit on and, and sort of, you know, make it fit for
- 39:30purpose to to feed some of those user experiences.
- 39:33So you know, there's no one thing that.
- 39:36Yeah, it sounds like the end goal of that thought, that
- 39:38thought bubble is to drive more direct traffic, right, To Hearst
- 39:43properties, right? If your user experience is good,
- 39:45you know, you're not forcing someone because right now
- 39:47there's all this sort of hand waving in the industry, right?
- 39:50I mean, Jason Kent of DCN Digital content next, I think
- 39:53you guys remember it's a trade association dedicated to the
- 39:56digital content companies. Those on the the podcast that
- 39:59don't know it just put out a a study basically suggesting that
- 40:04you know zero click search, which is largely driven by
- 40:08Google. Is like a dead end in, in, in
- 40:12all of the data leading up until I think June of this year based
- 40:16on their interviews with like 20 different members.
- 40:18I don't know if Hearst was part of that and he just, you know
- 40:22it. All dead end as in like people
- 40:23are just not going to go from the search summaries to Europe.
- 40:25They've seen a. Precipitous and continuous
- 40:27decline every month, month over month through June 2025 of of
- 40:32referral traffic and and there's a big call out from from Jason
- 40:36as well as Lupus scales. He did something on Substack on
- 40:39the top about like the the threat to the open web, right,
- 40:43the threat to the foundations of of the open web and so.
- 40:47Just I'm assuming you consider hers to be part of the open web.
- 40:50Yeah. Oh yeah, absolutely.
- 40:53Some of your sites probably have like authentication or logins,
- 40:56but like most of them are. Just, I mean, that's why I was
- 40:58sort of, I mean, yes. And there's absolutely a sort of
- 41:02registered user base. There's a subscriber user base.
- 41:06It sort of depends on the brand. And, you know, across however
- 41:09many hundreds of domains, it's a, it's a little bit variable.
- 41:11But yeah, I mean, you know, Lou certainly talked about this, you
- 41:15know, one of my takeaways from his sub stack about, you know,
- 41:20sort of what's at risk here. You know, it was interesting
- 41:23because he was really making the point as well that context
- 41:26matters. Yep.
- 41:27And you know it. I'm glad, I'm glad you lead into
- 41:31that. Like, yeah, yeah.
- 41:33And how LLMS are kind of giving you kind of a black and white
- 41:37read of the world, which takes out the context, which, right,
- 41:41sort of denigrates the quality of content and has kind of
- 41:45harmful effects. It's kind of the right.
- 41:47Yeah, I mean, that's exactly right.
- 41:49Well, you know, this is I always sort of Telegraph to other
- 41:53things when I see patterns. And immediately when I read
- 41:56that, you know what it reminded me of of like sort of the
- 41:59beginning of digital advertising where we went for because
- 42:02digital, by the way, pre programmatic was all about
- 42:06selling contextual sold audience based on who came to the site.
- 42:10And then we sort of disaggregated the audience from
- 42:12the content. But, you know, linear television
- 42:16historically was all about you sold the audience audience, and
- 42:19then you had a pod. And so when I was reading that,
- 42:23I sort of felt like, OK, we're getting yet another sort of
- 42:26disaggregation moment. But you know, really what what
- 42:30sort of got me thinking about his, you know, the role of
- 42:33context and the importance there is at some level, this does come
- 42:37back to editorial. And I think only a company that
- 42:40is committed to sort of high quality information,
- 42:44journalistic principles can can offer that benefit of editorial
- 42:49and curation. And and there's a value there.
- 42:52But you know, do you think at. Times it's an undervalued value.
- 42:55Yeah, I mean, when I've trained consumers at times to sort of,
- 42:59you know, think that we can get these things for free.
- 43:02And yeah, yeah, I, I maybe mentioned it early on, but, you
- 43:06know, before I got into media, I went to J school here in New
- 43:09York when I was like relatively new out of college.
- 43:12And I feel like what I took away from that experience is it's
- 43:15reporting is really hard. It is hard work.
- 43:19And so, you know, I look at these things, it's like personal
- 43:22for me. I, I have such a sort of
- 43:23profound respect for how hard that is.
- 43:25And anyway, so it is important. I do think I was an aspiring
- 43:29journalist at 1.2. I totally, totally get it.
- 43:31Not there. Are a lot of people in AD tech
- 43:33and media? All three of us, right Crazy.
- 43:36And then I thought that I had the bad idea of like, maybe I'll
- 43:38write a novel. And I was like, well, that
- 43:40wasn't a good idea. See, I'm still working on my
- 43:41Great American novel, bro. We can we can all reconvene in
- 43:4520 years and see if we've done. It but, but, but I think it is
- 43:48interesting though, like this what we're talking about now,
- 43:50right? Because and I think publishers
- 43:51like generally don't understand that they have some leverage,
- 43:54right? Because these LLMS, they need
- 43:57accurate, vetted, fact checked content.
- 44:00And publishers have that. They have loads of that.
- 44:03You have it in spades, right? So it's OK.
- 44:05Like they need it, but but they're going to get it from
- 44:08somewhere. I think they'd yeah, you'd
- 44:10rather they get it from you, right?
- 44:12So the new models can be trained on your data and you know,
- 44:14whether even if they're not sending, whether they're sending
- 44:16referral traffic back to you or not, I think you're contributing
- 44:19to those models and you should be compensated something for it.
- 44:21I believe so. I think striking deals and I
- 44:23think publishers that don't strike deals are going to find
- 44:24they're going to get scraped anyway somehow.
- 44:26That's my, that's my belief. And and is legalese, is sort of
- 44:29legal enforcement really going to work?
- 44:31It doesn't work to date or, or Or are we better off with
- 44:34solutions like Cloudflare, right or and we've even gotten into
- 44:37some of the topics about pay-per-view, pay per article
- 44:41read right, Monetize. Not on a subscription basis, but
- 44:46on just an individual content read perspective.
- 44:50Right. Yeah.
- 44:51Is that something you'll get? I mean, that's an interesting
- 44:53topic, I think. I think, I think Brian O'kelly
- 44:56was talking about it a few months ago.
- 44:57I, I had a bunch of things I posted on it about, you know,
- 45:00are micro payments a viable solution for publishers, right?
- 45:03And you know, micro payments to those who don't know what they
- 45:05are, they're very small payments, right?
- 45:07Because they're so small. I mean, they're sometimes we
- 45:09could be talking pennies. You probably can't use credit
- 45:12cards for them and credit card processors for payments you
- 45:15probably need like maybe. And people are throwing thrown
- 45:18out stable coins which are pegged to the dollar, right.
- 45:20So people throwing this out is, is that a viable thing where
- 45:23people have, you know, have a wallet, they click it, they OK,
- 45:26they pay. It's like, you know, you you buy
- 45:29gas and then you just expend it as you go visit sites.
- 45:32I mean, that's one solution. And I'm also a believer to Brett
- 45:34that, you know, I don't think one thing is going to save
- 45:36publishing. I think it's going to need to be
- 45:38a bunch of different things deployed at once.
- 45:40Yeah. And and kind of see what sticks.
- 45:42And maybe out of 10 things, two or three do right or 4 do, and I
- 45:46don't know. But is that something that
- 45:48Hearst is like experimenting at all?
- 45:49Or I would, I mean if, but I'd love to hear your personal views
- 45:52on, if nothing else, just go bad.
- 45:53Yeah. Well, personally I haven't, I
- 45:55haven't seen many of those experiences sort of in my own
- 45:58kind of traversing of my media diet.
- 46:01But I think it's the right idea in so far.
- 46:03And, and to be honest, I'm not sure if we have personally, you
- 46:07know, in any of our brands experimented at all with the
- 46:10micro payments. There are some of the things we
- 46:12have done which I'll get into. But generally speaking, I think
- 46:16that I'm, I'm very sort of into the idea of experimenting with
- 46:22willingness to pay and the value exchange and in whatever format
- 46:26that comes because. And you know, sometimes for us,
- 46:30that's as simple as are you willing to give us some personal
- 46:32information in exchange to read this article, which, you know,
- 46:36depending on where that consumer sits in, in sort of how they
- 46:39value their own privacy or pennies on the dollar, they're
- 46:42all just, they're a value exchange.
- 46:44And I do think as sort of purveyors of content and
- 46:48experiences, we can get really good at modernizing the look and
- 46:52feel of how we present those offers.
- 46:55But for me, it's a even more fundamental of how can we
- 46:58reestablish this willingness to pay for content which I find,
- 47:03you know, totally the right idea.
- 47:05You mentioned training people. We train them to expect free
- 47:08content that'll be subsidized by display, but yeah.
- 47:10No. And well and we've also trained,
- 47:12you know, in streaming by introducing sort of like the,
- 47:15you know, freemium sort of ad supported, you know, all the way
- 47:18to subscription. I think it's all right.
- 47:20I mean, I think, you know, every time you look at studies, you do
- 47:23start to see there are different cohorts for that have different
- 47:27needs and wants and those different sort of ways of
- 47:29getting to the content do have their own fit.
- 47:32So, yeah, the, the things that we have that I've seen a lot in
- 47:37our businesses is all around the sort of optimizing the
- 47:41subscription or the paywall and having those be very dynamic,
- 47:45which is, you know, a little different than the premise of
- 47:48micro payments. But it's not that sort of far
- 47:50afield, right? It, it's sort of, you know, we,
- 47:52we had, and, and this has been a lot of innovation in our
- 47:55newspaper business, but you know, the, the paywall and The
- 47:57Reg walls can be very sort of, you know, rigid instruments, if
- 48:02you will. And, you know, what's been
- 48:04interesting to sort of study is that you've got a lot of people
- 48:06who may not be in ADMA where that paper is published every
- 48:09day. But like I'm from Lai, you know,
- 48:12I read about California, even though I haven't lived there in,
- 48:15you know, 25 years at this point.
- 48:16And so I might have very different sort of behaviors of,
- 48:22you know, being in a behind a pay wall or accepting that.
- 48:26And so one of the things that that there's been a lot of work
- 48:29to do is to get really good at those meters and leverage a lot
- 48:32of AI and a lot of signals. So that, you know, we're doing
- 48:36our very best job of anticipating what the, you know,
- 48:39the the user on the other side, giving them sort of an option
- 48:43that we think is going to be most sort of relevant for them.
- 48:46But yeah, the micro payments will be interesting to see how
- 48:49it go, how it goes. Yeah.
- 48:52I find, I find a consumer experience perspective that the
- 48:54actual pay walls to be frustrating.
- 48:57I wonder if micro payments would be, if there would be any less
- 49:00friction in that type of process because it's because then you're
- 49:03going to increase sort of the, the, the frequency of asking for
- 49:07payment, right? There's got to be like, I think
- 49:10of the Economist. I love the Economist, but I
- 49:12don't have time to get through that magazine every week, right.
- 49:15So I paid for it for years, but as my life got busier, I just
- 49:18eventually was like I they piled up.
- 49:19I can't like so I so I cancelled, but I would pay for
- 49:23it. But every once in a while I'll
- 49:24see like on X or on LinkedIn someone shares an.
- 49:27It's always paywall but I would pay.
- 49:29I'd pay per article a small amount.
- 49:31It's an easy way to do it. The other thing that's I mean,
- 49:34this is on a different end of the spectrum, but I really love
- 49:36the ability to gift an article. I think it's sort of so
- 49:39wonderful and it comes with that very cute little icon too
- 49:42usually. So I think there's a lot there,
- 49:45but again, I think it's fundamental for the, you know,
- 49:50to re establish that value exchange.
- 49:52And this is so true because of, you know, at the end of the day,
- 49:55what we're doing is we're re establishing direct
- 49:58relationships with users, not through all sorts of
- 50:01intermediaries. And that's going to take.
- 50:03A lot of that's a critical point, yeah.
- 50:05Because a lot of news, I'd like to see that.
- 50:07I don't know if you know the numbers for this, but a lot of
- 50:09news is consumed through aggregators, whether it's Google
- 50:12News or Apple News. Yeah, right.
- 50:13And, and often times my local news just in New Jersey is, is
- 50:18blocked by paywalls. And so which is incredibly
- 50:20frustrating from a consumer experience perspective because
- 50:22I'm like, I just want to read about, you know, XYZ that
- 50:25happened in the town over and it's blocked by a paywall, you
- 50:29know, And so I often go direct to to publishers, but but you
- 50:33know, do you know what the stats are in terms of people using
- 50:35aggregators to consume news versus going direct?
- 50:38I don't. I've I've heard it's 10 billion
- 50:40at least a year. That's not going to publishers
- 50:43that's being safe and off by different.
- 50:45I think that's just Google and Meta, right?
- 50:47I was the one yeah. I mean, I don't know how I know
- 50:49that's one study, but you know, it's but it's a lot.
- 50:51Yeah, yeah, Apple news is certainly big.
- 50:54I mean, you know, X, you know, was a lot of places where people
- 50:58would just get headlines, threads, blue sky.
- 51:00I mean, so all of these things are sort of also generational a
- 51:04little too. You know, we we sort of grew up
- 51:06in the Facebook feed and, and X headline.
- 51:10So yeah, it's it's interesting. But yeah, I think doubling down
- 51:14on at the end of the day are people, do they value the
- 51:17content enough? And the the best thing for
- 51:21Hearst is that we've invest so much in great content and
- 51:25quality that we have high confidence that that consumers
- 51:29are going to want to meet us there.
- 51:30We haven't even scratched the service in all the the sort of
- 51:32data journalism. Now there's also different ways
- 51:35of sort of presenting that I think will appeal to different
- 51:38kind of cohorts of users over time too.
- 51:40So direct, direct relationships with consumers is is a number
- 51:44one priority it sounds. Absolutely, Yeah.
- 51:46Absolutely, yeah. Well, looking at looking at
- 51:48content, I mean, I think we, we, we'd be remiss if we didn't talk
- 51:50about, you know, keyword blocking and brand safety and
- 51:57just I think, I think your favorite topic, one of your top
- 52:00five. Right.
- 52:01Yeah. Yeah, yeah, we're gonna have a
- 52:02Zagorski on in a few weeks, by the way, so.
- 52:05Also a friend and a former Nielsen colleague.
- 52:07Yeah, he's. Part of the Nielsen Mafia,
- 52:09right? Yeah.
- 52:11Yeah. Is there any interesting news
- 52:13there? I know that's been kind of a
- 52:15problem for publishers as a source of, you know, some I
- 52:19think valid complaints right, about overzealous keyword
- 52:21blocking. And you know, there's some, I
- 52:23think we quoted Bret like a couple episodes ago, some some
- 52:25of the numbers about what percent of content was
- 52:29completely has been completely blocked, some of it for, you
- 52:32know, let's say not the best reasons.
- 52:34You know, I was, I was pretty surprised by this when I got
- 52:36here. Maybe it's just it was a little
- 52:40ignorance on my part, but I sort of thought like I thought we had
- 52:43solved brand safety. I mean we were at Nielsen at the
- 52:45time where Nielsen was also sort of innovating in this space.
- 52:51At some level there is a change management aspect of this, the
- 52:55fact that keyword lists don't have like perishable dates and
- 52:58they just sort of sit there and sort of.
- 53:00Accumulate dynamic, are they? I mean, it's, it's, it's sort
- 53:04of, I was so struck by, OK, that's actually how this works.
- 53:07And you know, we can sort of pick on, you know, methodologies
- 53:11of how we do brand safety and suitability.
- 53:13But I think we would be remiss if we didn't acknowledge that
- 53:17part of this is just the, the sort of behavior of, you know,
- 53:21things are very dynamic and content is very dynamic.
- 53:23And having these sort of persistent things that
- 53:26accumulate time just probably doesn't meet the, the sort of
- 53:29dynamic nature of content. But for us, I mean, we, you
- 53:33know, we just sort of decided that we could kind of help
- 53:36ourselves a little bit more. And so we have been working with
- 53:40some partners to help us understand newer methodologies
- 53:44that are a little bit more semantic in nature that can get
- 53:47us a sort of corpus of data that says, you know, this may be
- 53:50breaking news, but it's also safe or suitable or lower medium
- 53:55risk for these set of reasons. And we just felt we needed to
- 53:58bring our own data sets to the equation as opposed to just
- 54:01saying, hey, you know, you shouldn't block news.
- 54:04There's a lot of good stuff here.
- 54:05And so we're working through that right now.
- 54:09I do think, you know, what's what's probably going to be
- 54:13surprising for advertisers is just how much sort of missed
- 54:16opportunity and efficiency can be had because these are high
- 54:20quality audiences, they're highly engaged.
- 54:22And so we're looking forward to sort of being able to expose
- 54:25more where we have not just brand safe, but highly sort of
- 54:28relevant environments for brands to be in.
- 54:30But you know, at some level this this comes down to sort of the
- 54:33mechanics of, you know, how do we use ML, How do we use AI?
- 54:37How can we make these things more dynamic?
- 54:40And so it's been fun to sort of see where the just like the
- 54:43methodologies have evolved and. It's gone from like the
- 54:46sledgehammer sort of approach with keyword block lists to you
- 54:50need more of a chisel approach, right?
- 54:52That's specific to, you know, it's much more dynamic, much
- 54:55more adaptable. That's more like a shotgun
- 54:57approach. Everything the blast was immense
- 54:59blast radius, right like. These huge portions of your
- 55:02inventory get blocked for for potentially reasons that don't
- 55:06that aren't really valid. Right, right, right.
- 55:09Yeah. I mean, my, you know, there was
- 55:10this really sort of charming story that we discovered that
- 55:14when we were doing our own analysis, which was a an article
- 55:18that was published from, I believe it was our West Coast
- 55:22station in Monterey. So it was from our our
- 55:25television stations digital property.
- 55:27And they were reporting on. And, you know, I don't, I think
- 55:31it was maybe labeled as an accident, but it was, you know,
- 55:33a woman who had delivered a baby on the side of a road.
- 55:36And so that certainly created an but the whole story was this
- 55:39very heartwarming story about an EMT who had been trained just
- 55:43the weekend before who was able to, you know, manage the
- 55:47situation, deliver the baby. And it was like such a feel good
- 55:50story, but, you know, blocked because, you know, you had
- 55:53emergency and, you know, all sorts of words that probably
- 55:56would have connoted something else.
- 55:57And so, you know, everyone's got these kind of anecdotes, of
- 56:00course. But then let's have those kind
- 56:02of conversations with our advertisers to make sure that,
- 56:05you know, we can bring forward environments that are brand
- 56:07safe, that are brand suitable and highlight for them places
- 56:11where, you know, maybe they hadn't considered but that they
- 56:13would agree or you know, the right places for their brands to
- 56:15be. Another topic we want to touch
- 56:17in a little bit was let's say supply path optimization or
- 56:21compression. And for those who aren't super
- 56:25big I tech nerds, you know, there's just been this belief
- 56:29that like maybe publishers shouldn't be working with as
- 56:32many dozens of SSPS. It makes it very difficult to
- 56:35understand the whole supply supply path, right?
- 56:39And the whole supply chain for media, it adds, it adds
- 56:41additional fees. And you know, I guess there's a
- 56:44question about, you know, by looking at the supply path by
- 56:47potentially if maybe going direct to DSP for publishers,
- 56:50right? I mean, I think with, you know,
- 56:52with with trade desk doing some interesting, right, the open
- 56:56path, right. Love to know your opinion like
- 56:58anything is going on Hearst in terms of SSPS, exchanges,
- 57:01resellers like compressing that supply path, reducing hops and
- 57:05anything to help really improve your monetization and yield.
- 57:09Yeah. So I sort of phoned a friend
- 57:12because I knew we were probably going to talk about this and you
- 57:15know, because listen, I mean things change so quickly.
- 57:17You kind of always want to stay close to to where the business
- 57:19is headed. I think it's generally true that
- 57:22we're trying to get sort of closer to the advertiser and
- 57:26make the the supply path as sort of short and clean as possible.
- 57:30So those, I think I mentioned it before, but those values kind of
- 57:33persist here too. You know, we, we have direct
- 57:37integrations, we have strategic partnerships with the, the big
- 57:40DSPS and they're kind of parent companies.
- 57:43I don't think we use resellers. That's not sort of really part
- 57:46of the strategy. But you know, some of our
- 57:48divisions are also integrated with Open Path.
- 57:50So again, you know, here we're kind of, you know, trying to
- 57:53sort of lean in and stay close, try a few strategies, if you
- 57:58will. Ultimately, it's, it's still we
- 58:02want to participate and be sort of closer to the advertiser with
- 58:06as much sort of transparency as we can about the quality of the
- 58:09inventory. And you can see that kind of in
- 58:12our SSP strategy and the SPO strategy as well.
- 58:15Has there been an active effort to reduce number of SSPS or
- 58:18clean out the supply path at? All, you know, I don't know, I
- 58:21know that I could really sort of speak to a specific number or
- 58:24target. I think it's about having the
- 58:27right partners. You know, there's definitely,
- 58:30you know, the s s PS I've been trying to to sort of understand
- 58:33and stay close to this concept of containerization as well,
- 58:36which is was a new word that I, you know, just started hearing a
- 58:39lot about certainly in the last, you know, several weeks.
- 58:43And so, you know, I think we have to sort of stay close and
- 58:45understand what's our opportunity is these sort of
- 58:48dynamics are shifting. That is so fascinating to me
- 58:51because it's sort of this, the way I think about it, it's like
- 58:54an unbundling of that stack, right?
- 58:57You're sort of unbundling the data, the custom algorithms.
- 59:01And so those types of things are also the.
- 59:04DSP, the roles of DSP and SSP kind of get are maybe up in the
- 59:07air, right? What does this mediation or
- 59:09decisioning layer sit if you take it kind of out of I side,
- 59:13right and maybe it kind of becomes an AI thing?
- 59:15Does it become a sell side thing, a supply thing?
- 59:18I mean, I think that's really interesting.
- 59:19And then the approach for containerization on on sell
- 59:22side. For that's a.
- 59:23Programmatic 3.0, right? I mean, Scott Messer talks about
- 59:25this all the time, right? So.
- 59:27And then you've got the, the sort of ad serving layer in
- 59:29between. I mean, I remember, you know,
- 59:31one of my last roles at Nielsen is I, I ran all the digital
- 59:35revenue, which included all of the platforms and the big walled
- 59:38gardens and the publishers, their digital businesses.
- 59:41And I remember inheriting that business.
- 59:42I'm like, there are hundreds of DSPS and SSP, hundreds and
- 59:47hundreds. And of course that sort of went
- 59:49through a massive pruning and then the sort of DSP
- 59:52functionality has sort of grown and grown overtime.
- 59:54And we saw that certainly with streaming.
- 59:56So, yeah, I mean, I think these things kind of always have a
- 59:59natural gyration to them. But you know, some of those
- 1:00:03dynamics are interesting to me because you've also got this ad
- 1:00:05serving layer, you know that happened.
- 1:00:07The SSP becomes a mini AD server, right in this scenario,
- 1:00:10right. If you're taking mediational
- 1:00:11layer moving closer to supply and DSPS, I mean, I mean, then
- 1:00:14you're probably going to see a million DSPS again because it's
- 1:00:17if, if they're not doing the decisioning, they'd be
- 1:00:19definitely less robust in our functionality.
- 1:00:21It's probably easier to create one, right?
- 1:00:23You know, I, I know I've kind of said it a few times here, but
- 1:00:25partnerships in the space really do matter.
- 1:00:27And having good partnerships and, and sort of staying close
- 1:00:31to the partners that we work with on their kind of own sort
- 1:00:33of road map and innovation is I think, you know, really
- 1:00:37impressive about how Hearst works with different partners
- 1:00:40too, to sort of try to stay in front of certain areas.
- 1:00:43And so it's fun, you know, we're kind of we get to participate
- 1:00:46sometimes we're not always leading all those conversations.
- 1:00:49But for me, it'll be interesting to really see how the the next
- 1:00:53sort of round of data, you know, what are we really talking
- 1:00:56about? What can we do that's
- 1:00:57differentiated in that regardless of how this sort of
- 1:01:00pipes start to shake out? And are you, are you internally
- 1:01:03tracking sort of the percentage of sales that are going through
- 1:01:07private marketplace going through direct with, with KPI's
- 1:01:10that are sort of driven to increase that share of your
- 1:01:13total? Like you, you, you've, there's
- 1:01:16been a lot of emphasis on the importance of, of content on, on
- 1:01:21the willingness to pay and the, and the valuation of that
- 1:01:24content, which is your core competency.
- 1:01:27And then and then that leans itself towards more direct
- 1:01:29sales, right, you know, in more direct relationships with
- 1:01:33consumers on the other side of the the fence.
- 1:01:36That's right. That's right.
- 1:01:37So Speaking of data and analytics, you did a ton of work
- 1:01:40on the measurement side, reach and reach and frequency
- 1:01:44measurement advanced analytics. I've been heavily involved in
- 1:01:48that from the Nielsen marketing Cloud days with with multi touch
- 1:01:52attribution kind of commercializing that, which was
- 1:01:56kind of a Matt Krepsick baby and he's he's my new CEO right with
- 1:02:00the Visual IQ acquisition. And then I went to new star
- 1:02:03where that was all our MMMMTA algorithmic logic to
- 1:02:07understanding consumer propensity and outcomes,
- 1:02:09etcetera, etcetera. How are you thinking because you
- 1:02:12do come from, you know sort of that that core cloth, that
- 1:02:16Nielsen cloth, how are you thinking about in implementing
- 1:02:20advanced analytics and attribution to prove outcomes to
- 1:02:23to clients? You know, there's so much kind
- 1:02:25of at play of, you know, what does, what does the end market
- 1:02:28really need from us? So that's a, that's an early,
- 1:02:32you know, stage journey for us, but it's been fun.
- 1:02:35You know, I've been involved in, in different initiatives across
- 1:02:38our division and get to bring in vendors that I know from my
- 1:02:41prior life too. And so right now more than more
- 1:02:44than anything, my activity is to sort of try to act as glue, stay
- 1:02:48connected, bring in and and sort of recommend partners that maybe
- 1:02:52are used for a specific business unit for a specific reason and
- 1:02:56try to sort of help informally. I would say, kind of establish
- 1:03:00that framework and portfolio. I'll add though, interestingly
- 1:03:04enough, Hurst as a brand, we brought on and retained an
- 1:03:10agency of record last year. We're working with our partner
- 1:03:14PMG so that we could market some of our media brands.
- 1:03:17And I've been heavily involved in not the campaigns, those are
- 1:03:21sort of led by our our CM OS and our communications teams.
- 1:03:24But on how do we as now a brand put ourselves in the shoes of
- 1:03:28understanding how do we build reach and frequency across media
- 1:03:31channels today? How do we measure it?
- 1:03:34And so ironically, I'm working with the, you know, companies
- 1:03:36I've worked at before and companies I've partnered before
- 1:03:39and getting to see that sort of maturation of these capabilities
- 1:03:43as a brand, which is enormously informative to sort of where we
- 1:03:48think we want to go in building out our own capabilities, so.
- 1:03:51You bring it up, I think that's like figuring out like what's
- 1:03:54going to be attractive and palatable to CMO is right.
- 1:03:56And I think that's like it's overlooked a lot.
- 1:03:58And I think the whole act like, I mean, I love the fact there's
- 1:04:01been a lot of discussion the last six months about, OK, a lot
- 1:04:04of the attribution stats aren't. I mean, the technologies have
- 1:04:07not been. It's been as more art than
- 1:04:08science like a lot of times. I mean food we talked about this
- 1:04:11Brett, remember that, that a lot of the ACT about the
- 1:04:14attributions gained, right. And you know, I think digital
- 1:04:18has been safe feeding off a lot of taking credit for a lot of
- 1:04:21attribution. I think the platforms have been
- 1:04:24certainly accused of taking credit for a lot of attribution
- 1:04:26that they probably didn't do much to earn, right.
- 1:04:29And I think traditional channels have been punished for that.
- 1:04:31So and maybe maybe shifting more towards marketing mix modeling,
- 1:04:36you know, like again, another thing, we're going back, right?
- 1:04:39Yeah. You know, maybe like that we
- 1:04:41should be taking an approach that, you know, we want to be
- 1:04:43looking at the full consumer journey, maybe hitting these
- 1:04:45channels and maybe we can't cleanly attribute everything,
- 1:04:49but we know people are there, so we should be in front of them.
- 1:04:52Well, in the the challenge with MTA and MMA that's not sort of
- 1:04:56automated, especially as we practice it at at new start was
- 1:04:59just the length of time it took. Not only did you need the data
- 1:05:02sort of governance and housekeeping like like GM is a
- 1:05:07perfect example of a client of ours.
- 1:05:08They had they had 60 different data warehouses across their
- 1:05:13brand 60 And so half of our job was literally unifying kind of
- 1:05:18what you 2. Just.
- 1:05:19Cleansing. Engineering it's not dating
- 1:05:23because. You're not going to be able to
- 1:05:24do any of the the advanced analytics and attribution unless
- 1:05:28you've got so so that that within the 66.
- 1:05:30Months to a year they they, they probably bought or licensing the
- 1:05:33same data at least three or four times paying for right, I mean
- 1:05:36yeah, you find these big companies like they'll do that
- 1:05:38like like like we licensed the same poke data 3 or 4 times and
- 1:05:42paid for it right and poked it, you know never said anything I
- 1:05:44that would not surprise me these big works like it's it's.
- 1:05:47Yeah, it's interesting too, because I mean, when, when I was
- 1:05:50working with people like Krepsick, like back in the day,
- 1:05:52market mix modeling was not about outcome.
- 1:05:55It was about channel allocation. Yeah, it was like it's.
- 1:05:58Strategic It's a strategic planning plan.
- 1:06:00Yeah, so it's been so fascinating to see how, you
- 1:06:04know, we sort of all got sort of persuaded that we could be
- 1:06:08precisely deterministic everywhere.
- 1:06:10Yeah. And you know, anyway, so now
- 1:06:13we're sort of back to probabilistic ish.
- 1:06:15But the, the sort of unification of MTA and MMM is also just
- 1:06:20methodologically really fascinating as kind of
- 1:06:23practitioners. But I do believe, you know, I,
- 1:06:26I, I, I'm trying to remember there's a, there's a, an
- 1:06:31industry group, gosh, I'm forgetting the name now, which
- 1:06:34has for years been very consistent talking about, you
- 1:06:38know, despite sort of any of the perceived or real challenges
- 1:06:42with MTA that we can't only do like we still have to build
- 1:06:46brands, we still have to build funnels.
- 1:06:49And you can't only sort of be optimizing to the the conversion
- 1:06:54because otherwise you have under weighted the opportunity to sort
- 1:06:58of identify people. And you know, there was a
- 1:07:00period, period of time too, where we called those
- 1:07:01impressions waste because they weren't in the target that was
- 1:07:04going to drive a conversion, the underweighting.
- 1:07:06Pieces, that's the challenge, right, because you end up it's
- 1:07:09it really is driven by algorithmic logic because
- 1:07:11there's so many different influencing factors that drive
- 1:07:14like consumer propensity. I'm going to buy a snow shovel
- 1:07:17if I don't have a snow shovel in advance of a snowstorm, right?
- 1:07:20Don't give credit to the last click, or to the last
- 1:07:23impression, or the view through impression or yeah.
- 1:07:26All that. Sort of stuff, right and so
- 1:07:28media oftentimes gets overcredited.
- 1:07:30That was sort of Doctor Foos argument, right?
- 1:07:33Radically overcredited just in defense of a vendor, right?
- 1:07:37Or an agency in the dollars they're spending so.
- 1:07:39Yeah. I mean, not think it's so
- 1:07:41academic, but there was a time at Nielsen when we had different
- 1:07:46tools in our portfolio. We had MTA and MMM and brand
- 1:07:49lift and brand awareness. And I distinctly remember a few
- 1:07:52meetings with an advertiser where we had instrumented
- 1:07:55everything and then everything was in conflict.
- 1:07:57And it was sort of like, what are we?
- 1:07:59How can we have? Brand wiggle your way out of
- 1:08:02that. How can we have conversion and
- 1:08:03no brand awareness? But I, you know, yeah.
- 1:08:07Anyway, this is sort of, you know, part of why sort of
- 1:08:11stepping back and not launching waiting so quickly into what can
- 1:08:15we do at her 1st as a, as a sort of media partner is, is in part
- 1:08:19because I think we've got to know where we have real strength
- 1:08:22in, in that media equation. Like what's the job to be done?
- 1:08:25Because we can drive awareness, we can drive reach.
- 1:08:28But you know, I come from a sort of a mindset of we should know
- 1:08:32exactly what job we're hired to do.
- 1:08:33And if it's to drive conversions, then you might be
- 1:08:36getting a created dynamically rotated creative in market.
- 1:08:40But and it's just that. But so I'm, I'm kind of, you
- 1:08:42know, yeah, caught up in this notion of like, if we're gonna,
- 1:08:45if we're gonna do full funnel measurement, like let's be clear
- 1:08:47on what, what's the media job to be done?
- 1:08:51And then let's measure it accordingly.
- 1:08:52Well, if it's an outcome and the outcome is broader then right,
- 1:08:54it's not gonna be outcomes, not necessarily be conversion or
- 1:08:56sale. It might be you're generating
- 1:08:57awareness like some of these products, like you know, Brett,
- 1:09:00you mentioned financial services like might have a multi year
- 1:09:03sales cycle or buying a cars once every seven years.
- 1:09:06So you know, unless you're gonna hit the person like the month
- 1:09:08before they go to buy, right. I mean, it's like, and by then
- 1:09:10they might have already decided what they want from previous
- 1:09:13advertisements. So I think thinking a broader
- 1:09:15view, if we are in the age of outcomes, I mean you know like
- 1:09:17the outcome, it should span the full customer experience right
- 1:09:22from, you know, where does through to consideration through
- 1:09:25to everything. Although I'm, I think the EG
- 1:09:27outcomes, I'm gonna finish with this, but I think the age of
- 1:09:28outcomes is suggesting that, well, we can't do that.
- 1:09:31We can't do full funnel measurement.
- 1:09:33So we're just gonna name any outcome that you're gonna
- 1:09:36measure. We can measure that discreetly.
- 1:09:37But I think when you expect the. Last click right the last click.
- 1:09:41Well, this has been great. We covered all the topics and
- 1:09:43thank you just for for being such a good sport and thank you
- 1:09:47for the show and tell. I mean that I think that made
- 1:09:49the episode. Right.
- 1:09:49I hope it's not totally cringe of like, Oh my God, here she
- 1:09:52goes with her screamed visual aid.
- 1:09:55But Oh well, I am who I am, yeah.
- 1:09:58Yeah. Well, thanks again.
- 1:09:59This is great.