Latest / Bloomberg Law / Officials Blocking Citizens on Social Media, Legal Hot Tubs
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law.
- 0:03Speaker 2: What does a prosecutor have to prove in order to
- 0:06Speaker 2: get a Rico conviction? Tell us why the Solicitor General
- 0:10Speaker 2: is sometimes referred to as the tenth Justice.
- 0:12Speaker 1: Interviews with prominent attorneys in Bloomberg Legal Experts.
- 0:15Speaker 2: That's Jennifer k for Bloomberg Law. Joining me is former
- 0:18Speaker 2: federal prosecutor Robert miss.
- 0:20Speaker 1: And analysis of important legal issues, cases and headlines.
- 0:23Speaker 2: It's the toughest hurdle for prosecutors proving Trump's intent. Alito
- 0:27Speaker 2: took on Congress, saying Congress has no power to regulate
- 0:30Speaker 2: the Supreme Court.
- 0:31Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:37Speaker 2: Welcome to a special best of edition of the Bloomberg
- 0:40Speaker 2: Law Show. Ahead in this hour, the Supreme Court grapples
- 0:44Speaker 2: with whether public officials can block citizens on social media?
- 0:48Speaker 2: What exactly is a legal hot tub? And Instagram promoters
- 0:53Speaker 2: test the limits of a ninety year old securities law.
- 0:58Speaker 3: That's what makes these cases hard is that there are
- 1:01Speaker 3: First Amendment interests all over the place.
- 1:03Speaker 2: And not only are their First Amendment interests all over
- 1:06Speaker 2: the place, as Justice Elena Kagan put it, but the
- 1:10Speaker 2: justices questions seemed to be all over the place as
- 1:13Speaker 2: well as they considered whether public officials can block citizens
- 1:17Speaker 2: on social media. The two cases involved school board members
- 1:22Speaker 2: in San Diego and a city manager in Michigan who
- 1:25Speaker 2: blocked followers on social media, of course, evoking discussion of
- 1:29Speaker 2: former President Donald Trump's efforts to block people from his
- 1:33Speaker 2: Twitter account.
- 1:34Speaker 3: I mean, I don't think a citizen would be able
- 1:36Speaker 3: to really understand the Trump presidency, if you will, without
- 1:41Speaker 3: any access to all the things that the president said
- 1:45Speaker 3: on that account. It was an important part of how
- 1:48Speaker 3: he wielded his authority. And to cut a citizen off
- 1:52Speaker 3: from that is to cut a citizen off from part
- 1:55Speaker 3: of the way that government works.
- 1:57Speaker 2: The central question is whether the so social media activity
- 2:01Speaker 2: constitute state action, making it subject to the First Amendment,
- 2:06Speaker 2: and the federal appellate courts in the cases came to
- 2:09Speaker 2: opposite conclusions. The Justice has presented a host of social
- 2:13Speaker 2: media scenarios to the lawyers. Here are Justices Sonya Sotomayor
- 2:18Speaker 2: and Brett Kavanaugh.
- 2:19Speaker 4: So let's assume a mayor says, I'm setting up a
- 2:23Speaker 4: hotline for emergencies on my Facebook or Twitter, and if
- 2:29Speaker 4: you have an emergency, call that hotline and I will
- 2:34Speaker 4: use the power of my office to set in motion
- 2:38Speaker 4: government response for your emergency. Seems to me that that's
- 2:43Speaker 4: government faction, isn't it.
- 2:46Speaker 5: But suppose the city manager on the personal site says,
- 2:50Speaker 5: we have new recycling rules. You have to use a
- 2:53Speaker 5: blue bin, has to be at the curb, will be
- 2:55Speaker 5: picked up on Wednesdays. If you have any questions, contact me.
- 3:00Speaker 5: It's only on the personal site, not on the official site.
- 3:03Speaker 5: Such a state action.
- 3:05Speaker 2: Joining me is Professor Eric Golman, co director of the
- 3:08Speaker 2: High Tech Law Institute at Santa Clara University Law School.
- 3:12Speaker 2: Eric explained the main issue in these cases.
- 3:16Speaker 6: The core issue is what should happen when government officials
- 3:20Speaker 6: maintain social media accounts. Can they treat it as if
- 3:24Speaker 6: they're ordinary citizens or are they governed by the rules
- 3:28Speaker 6: that apply to government generally?
- 3:30Speaker 2: And are the issues in the two cases before the
- 3:33Speaker 2: court basically the same?
- 3:35Speaker 6: They're basically the same. There are little details about exactly
- 3:39Speaker 6: how the particular government officials were using their social medi
- 3:43Speaker 6: accounts that might matter to the final conclusion, but the
- 3:46Speaker 6: core questions the court's asking and the legal test it's
- 3:50Speaker 6: likely to adopt are probably going to be the same.
- 3:52Speaker 2: So let's talk about the concerns of some of the justices,
- 3:56Speaker 2: and Justice Elena Kagan said there are First Amendment interests
- 3:59Speaker 2: on all over the place.
- 4:01Speaker 6: I thought that was a really great line, honestly, just
- 4:03Speaker 6: as Kaigan has just such a great way of turning phrases,
- 4:07Speaker 6: and she's absolutely right their First Amendment considerations on all sides.
- 4:11Speaker 6: It's not like there's an easy path forward that balances
- 4:15Speaker 6: all the respective interests. On the one hand, people who
- 4:18Speaker 6: work for the government should be free to engage their
- 4:21Speaker 6: communities and express themselves publicly as private citizens. That's the
- 4:25Speaker 6: constitutionally protected right. They don't give up that right by
- 4:28Speaker 6: going to work for the government. On the other hand,
- 4:31Speaker 6: when the government controls online discourse spaces where people are
- 4:37Speaker 6: talking to each other, there's a really real and significant
- 4:41Speaker 6: risk of censorship. And so the concern is that if
- 4:45Speaker 6: the government officials can act like private individuals, they can
- 4:49Speaker 6: functionally censor conversations. Now, if they're acting as a private individual,
- 4:53Speaker 6: they're allowed to do that, but as the actings the government,
- 4:56Speaker 6: they're not. And so either we're going to circumscribe the
- 5:00Speaker 6: free speech rights of government employees, or we're going to
- 5:03Speaker 6: allow government employees to circumferent the free speech rights of
- 5:07Speaker 6: the people who want to engage with them. Somebody is
- 5:09Speaker 6: going to lose something here.
- 5:11Speaker 2: And in these local cases, it's just as important for
- 5:15Speaker 2: constituents to hear what their school board members are saying,
- 5:19Speaker 2: or their town managers and the like.
- 5:23Speaker 6: It's not just to be able to hear what the
- 5:25Speaker 6: government officials are saying, but also to be able to
- 5:27Speaker 6: talk back to them, and even more importantly, in certain circumstances,
- 5:31Speaker 6: be able to talk to each other as constituents or
- 5:34Speaker 6: as citizens that are responding to the posting of a
- 5:39Speaker 6: government official. And so when a government official exercises some
- 5:43Speaker 6: of the tools that provide them via social media to
- 5:46Speaker 6: control conversations, what they're really doing is distorting the conversation
- 5:50Speaker 6: that citizens might want to have with each other.
- 5:52Speaker 2: So I don't know why. To me, it seems like,
- 5:55Speaker 2: you know, if you're posting public information on a web side,
- 6:00Speaker 2: on a Facebook page, that that should be open to
- 6:04Speaker 2: the public and the public able to comment, and if
- 6:07Speaker 2: you want not to do that, then have a private
- 6:09Speaker 2: page as well.
- 6:11Speaker 6: So certainly those ideas came out. In fact, there are
- 6:13Speaker 6: three different categories of pages that a government official might have.
- 6:18Speaker 6: They may have an official government page, they may have
- 6:22Speaker 6: a campaign page which is not part of their official
- 6:24Speaker 6: government duties but still is an important place for them
- 6:27Speaker 6: to evangelize the work they're doing, and they may have
- 6:31Speaker 6: a personal page that has nothing to do with their
- 6:34Speaker 6: role in government. And figuring out which account is in
- 6:37Speaker 6: which category is something that is baffling to us as
- 6:41Speaker 6: citizens when we see our government officials online. And it's
- 6:44Speaker 6: also vexxing to the government officials because so often they
- 6:48Speaker 6: want to take their victory labs, they want to evangelize
- 6:51Speaker 6: their work, to tout their successes, and we aren't sure
- 6:54Speaker 6: are they telling them as official government policy, as a
- 6:57Speaker 6: campaign promise, or just because they're counting their own work
- 7:01Speaker 6: as a private individual. And the court didn't know how
- 7:04Speaker 6: to approach that issue. They understood the trade offs, but
- 7:07Speaker 6: there was no clear way to move forward that was
- 7:10Speaker 6: going to satisfy everybody.
- 7:11Speaker 2: So I want to get your reaction to what, just
- 7:14Speaker 2: as Amy Cony Barrett said.
- 7:16Speaker 7: I think it's very difficult when you have an official
- 7:20Speaker 7: who can in some sense define his own authority. So
- 7:22Speaker 7: I think for a governor or you know, President Trump,
- 7:25Speaker 7: it's a harder call than someone like a police officer
- 7:28Speaker 7: who's a subordinator. I could you know, my lucker could
- 7:31Speaker 7: just start posting things and say this is the official
- 7:34Speaker 7: business of the Barrett Chambers, right, and that wouldn't be okay.
- 7:38Speaker 7: But if you know that wouldn't be okay.
- 7:44Speaker 2: That come and got a laugh, of course, But what
- 7:47Speaker 2: do you think about the content of what she's saying.
- 7:51Speaker 6: I mean, the the ample she gave was kind of
- 7:54Speaker 6: weird because clerk wouldn't be likely to be able to
- 7:57Speaker 6: set up and speak on behalf of their judge that
- 8:00Speaker 6: employs them. So that was a weird example. But the
- 8:03Speaker 6: broader principle is one hundred percent correct that the Court
- 8:07Speaker 6: is trying to figure out how do they simultaneously govern
- 8:10Speaker 6: the top of the political hierarchy, like a president or
- 8:15Speaker 6: a governor or even a mayor, someone who's at the
- 8:18Speaker 6: top of the organizational Peermid and all the people who
- 8:21Speaker 6: are rank and fly, all government employees, some of who
- 8:24Speaker 6: might also be able to speak on behalf of the government,
- 8:26Speaker 6: others of whom have no real legitimacy to do so.
- 8:29Speaker 6: And the Supreme Court is struggling figure out, how can
- 8:31Speaker 6: we come up with one rule that covers all of
- 8:34Speaker 6: those different types of job, responsibilities, and status in the hierarchy,
- 8:39Speaker 6: and it's possible that they cannot come up with a
- 8:41Speaker 6: single rule that will cover it. They may need multiple
- 8:43Speaker 6: rules that will have to be iterated over time.
- 8:45Speaker 2: So you think that there's no clear legal test that
- 8:47Speaker 2: they could come out with.
- 8:49Speaker 6: Honestly, no, there is no clear legal test. And I
- 8:52Speaker 6: think we can be a little bit more emphatic that
- 8:55Speaker 6: the different considerations include things like what's the employee's job
- 9:00Speaker 6: and what tools are available in social media to be
- 9:03Speaker 6: able to co control conversations and which of those tools
- 9:06Speaker 6: was wielded, and how did the person describe or characterize
- 9:10Speaker 6: their account, and how much of the account was used
- 9:13Speaker 6: with official related postings versus personal postings, like we need
- 9:18Speaker 6: a multi dimensional matrix to try to figure out where
- 9:21Speaker 6: to place all the different nodes in those questions. And
- 9:25Speaker 6: that's why, even with two cases in front of the
- 9:27Speaker 6: Supreme Court that they can use to compare and contrast,
- 9:29Speaker 6: they still don't have enough cases to cover the full
- 9:32Speaker 6: range of facts that are going to be implicated by
- 9:34Speaker 6: their ruling.
- 9:35Speaker 2: How about the idea that was floated by Justice Katanji Brown,
- 9:39Speaker 2: Jackson of a clear disclaimer indicating that government officials were
- 9:44Speaker 2: posting on social media in their personal capacity.
- 9:47Speaker 6: Certainly no doubt that legends would help at least us
- 9:51Speaker 6: as constituents know what to expect. But the disclaimers could
- 9:55Speaker 6: just be another form of a manipulation by the government official.
- 9:59Speaker 6: They could say I'm not speaking officially, but then speak
- 10:02Speaker 6: in ways that actually are fully official, or vice versa.
- 10:05Speaker 6: They can say, this official government account, but let me
- 10:07Speaker 6: highlight some of my personal attributes and treat them as
- 10:10Speaker 6: if they're a part of the government responsibility. And so
- 10:14Speaker 6: the disclaimer doesn't really solve the problems that I think
- 10:18Speaker 6: we have. But no doubt that if somebody portrays their
- 10:24Speaker 6: account as an official government account without trying to walk
- 10:28Speaker 6: it back or qualify that, I think the rules should
- 10:32Speaker 6: be that we should hold them to that approach. But
- 10:34Speaker 6: if they don't officially represent as part of their government account,
- 10:38Speaker 6: it still might be part of their government function, and
- 10:40Speaker 6: so the disclaimer is not going to be complete.
- 10:43Speaker 2: Coming up, we'll discuss whether there was any consensus on
- 10:46Speaker 2: the court. I'm Jim Grosso. When you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 10:58Speaker 1: Is Bloomberg with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 11:04Speaker 2: You're listening to a special best of edition of the
- 11:07Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Show. Joining me is Professor Eric Goldman of
- 11:11Speaker 2: Santa Clara University Law School about Supreme Court oral arguments
- 11:15Speaker 2: over whether public officials can be sued for restricting access
- 11:19Speaker 2: to their social media feeds. It's the first of several
- 11:23Speaker 2: social media classes this term. The first case involves two
- 11:27Speaker 2: San Diego Area school board members who set up Facebook
- 11:31Speaker 2: and Twitter pages during their twenty fourteen campaigns, then continued
- 11:36Speaker 2: using the sites to talk about school issues after winning
- 11:39Speaker 2: election and taking their seats. They set up their pages
- 11:42Speaker 2: so that their posts were open to comment by members
- 11:45Speaker 2: of the public. Two of their constituents left frequent comments
- 11:49Speaker 2: criticizing the board, and the school board members eventually blocked them.
- 11:54Speaker 2: The second case involves a city manager in Michigan who
- 11:58Speaker 2: used his Facebook page to post both family and professional information.
- 12:02Speaker 2: His post in twenty twenty about the COVID nineteen pandemic
- 12:06Speaker 2: drew a series of critical comments from a follower, who
- 12:10Speaker 2: he then blocked. Federal appeals courts reached opposite decisions in
- 12:14Speaker 2: the cases, and now it's up to the Supreme Court.
- 12:18Speaker 2: The Biden administration was backing the government officials' positions. They
- 12:23Speaker 2: characterized the Facebook and Twitter feeds as private property. That
- 12:27Speaker 2: seemed to me to be a not a great concept here.
- 12:31Speaker 6: It's a really awkward conversation because we know that the
- 12:36Speaker 6: social media services have their own rules, they have their
- 12:40Speaker 6: own technological options that differ amongst themselves, and they have
- 12:46Speaker 6: the ability to intervene with respective part guaris and content
- 12:50Speaker 6: irrespective of whether or not the Constitution would permit the
- 12:54Speaker 6: government official take that action. So they're like the elephant
- 12:57Speaker 6: in the room. Everyone knows that the social media services
- 13:00Speaker 6: are an integal player in this conversation, but they're not
- 13:03Speaker 6: the plaintiff or the defendant, and as a result, they're
- 13:07Speaker 6: not actually represented in this litigation, and as a result,
- 13:11Speaker 6: the Supreme Court is likely to treat them as this
- 13:13Speaker 6: opaque third party player who is immaterial or inconsequential to
- 13:18Speaker 6: the rules. That's actually a good outcome. I really don't
- 13:21Speaker 6: want the Supreme Court talking about social media as a
- 13:25Speaker 6: private entity or not. I don't want them making hard
- 13:28Speaker 6: lines when that's not the question the government has to answer.
- 13:31Speaker 6: But it's impossible to ignore the shadow of the cast
- 13:34Speaker 6: over everything that takes place on their services.
- 13:37Speaker 2: The federal appeals courts reached opposite conclusions in the lower
- 13:42Speaker 2: court cases.
- 13:43Speaker 6: That's correct. The Ninth Circuit held that the government officials
- 13:46Speaker 6: in that case school board members were acting in their
- 13:50Speaker 6: function as government officials when they blocked some constituents from
- 13:54Speaker 6: access in social mediaccount. In the sixth Circuit it was
- 13:58Speaker 6: a government employee who had also blocked individuals. The court
- 14:03Speaker 6: had held in that case that he was acting as
- 14:05Speaker 6: a private individual. That was his private account.
- 14:08Speaker 2: So there were three hours, i believe, of oral arguments.
- 14:12Speaker 2: Did you see some justices, some blocks of justices sort
- 14:16Speaker 2: of coming to some conclusions or did you see any patterns?
- 14:23Speaker 6: The short answer is no, Really, the oral arguments were
- 14:26Speaker 6: quite opaque about where the judges are likely to end up,
- 14:29Speaker 6: which is unusual. But one would have hoped that we
- 14:31Speaker 6: would have been able to get a clearer line from
- 14:33Speaker 6: the oral arguments. Having said that, there are two things
- 14:36Speaker 6: that stood out to me. First is that some justices
- 14:39Speaker 6: seem to be gravittaining around the test that was advocated
- 14:42Speaker 6: by the Department of Justice and was endorsed by the
- 14:46Speaker 6: lawyers for the government employees about looking at the duties
- 14:50Speaker 6: of the government official and their authority to speak on
- 14:53Speaker 6: behalf of the government. And so Justice Gore such, for example,
- 14:56Speaker 6: at one point, said it sounds like we got consensus
- 14:58Speaker 6: that's the right test. I don't know if there was consensus,
- 15:02Speaker 6: but it wouldn't surprise me if the test looked something
- 15:04Speaker 6: like that. At the end of the oral arguments, Justice
- 15:07Speaker 6: Kagan once again had a really powerful turn of the phrase.
- 15:11Speaker 6: She came and basically blasted the government lawyers, saying that
- 15:14Speaker 6: the government lawyers proposed test was really out of sync
- 15:19Speaker 6: with the importance of social media to the government function
- 15:23Speaker 6: and would limit the ability of us as constituents or
- 15:27Speaker 6: to be able to defend our own interests when the
- 15:29Speaker 6: government keeps embracing social media. So I saw kind of
- 15:32Speaker 6: two opposite approaches there, Justice Gore such saying, you know,
- 15:36Speaker 6: sounds good to me, let's go with the test that
- 15:38Speaker 6: you proposed, and Jessic Kagan saying that test is actually
- 15:40Speaker 6: really harmful to the future.
- 15:43Speaker 2: Was there a split on ideological lines or did this
- 15:45Speaker 2: cross ideological lines?
- 15:47Speaker 6: I couldn't put together a pattern that represented any kind
- 15:51Speaker 6: of ideological partisan fit. But having said that, I would
- 15:55Speaker 6: say that it seemed like some of the quote more
- 15:57Speaker 6: conservative justices were more inclined to support the government employees
- 16:02Speaker 6: freedom to do what they want, whereas some of the
- 16:04Speaker 6: quote more liberal justices were more skeptical about how that
- 16:07Speaker 6: could lead to censorship.
- 16:09Speaker 2: So at times when we've had these oral arguments at
- 16:12Speaker 2: the Supreme Court involving, you know, the Internet, texting, social media,
- 16:18Speaker 2: the justices have seemed to be a step behind, maybe
- 16:21Speaker 2: more than one step. Did it seem like they fully
- 16:25Speaker 2: grasped what was going on in these cases?
- 16:28Speaker 6: They really didn't. This was yet another example of how
- 16:31Speaker 6: the Internet baffles Supreme Court justices. And just to be clear,
- 16:35Speaker 6: we don't know how many Supreme Court justices spend time
- 16:38Speaker 6: on social media, but it's not like they do it publicly.
- 16:41Speaker 6: So they're just not familiar with social media at the
- 16:45Speaker 6: same degree that most of us, as everyday users are,
- 16:48Speaker 6: So it's not surprising that it's a little bit baffling
- 16:51Speaker 6: to them if they're not immersed in that as part
- 16:53Speaker 6: of their daily functions. There was a really awkward line
- 16:56Speaker 6: that came from Chief Justice Roberts where he talked about
- 16:59Speaker 6: social media, described it as the gathering of protons, and
- 17:03Speaker 6: it was such a reductionist approach that social media is
- 17:07Speaker 6: just about the movement of electronic pulses on the Internet.
- 17:10Speaker 6: That's all it is. And it's kind of like saying
- 17:12Speaker 6: that Supreme Court opinions are just inc on a piece
- 17:15Speaker 6: of paper. It's a reductionist conclusion that isn't inherently wrong,
- 17:20Speaker 6: but it completely misunderstands the scope and the stakes at
- 17:24Speaker 6: issue in this case.
- 17:26Speaker 2: And this is the first of several social media clashes
- 17:30Speaker 2: that coming up this term involving the First Amendment and
- 17:33Speaker 2: how it applies to social media companies.
- 17:36Speaker 6: So just to be clear, there's going to be a
- 17:38Speaker 6: steady stream of Internet law cases going to the Supreme
- 17:41Speaker 6: Court and likely to be decided by the Supreme Court
- 17:45Speaker 6: over the next few years. We've had just this upswell
- 17:48Speaker 6: of legislation trying to regulate the Internet, and many of
- 17:52Speaker 6: those laws are going to end up before the Supreme Court.
- 17:55Speaker 6: So we're just kind of at the beginning of this
- 17:58Speaker 6: multi year cycle where the Supreme Court is going to
- 18:00Speaker 6: be regularly deciding the future of the Internet. One of
- 18:03Speaker 6: the other cases they've set it, or there's two companion
- 18:06Speaker 6: cases involved the Texas and Florida's social media censorship laws.
- 18:10Speaker 6: These are laws that were enacted to basically take government
- 18:14Speaker 6: control over the functional operations of social media. Sounds like
- 18:18Speaker 6: the kind of thing that we would think would be
- 18:20Speaker 6: clearly censorship, and yet the Florida Court said that some
- 18:24Speaker 6: of it was struck down, some of it was okay.
- 18:27Speaker 6: The Texas pele Court said it all sounds good to me.
- 18:30Speaker 6: And so the future of the Internet is very much
- 18:32Speaker 6: mistake in that set of cases as well, because if
- 18:35Speaker 6: the Supreme Court says that the government can dictate how
- 18:38Speaker 6: social media runs its operations, they are going to be
- 18:41Speaker 6: dictating what editorial decisions those services can make.
- 18:45Speaker 2: A lot more oral arguments on social media to come.
- 18:49Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Eric. That's Eric Goldman, a professor at
- 18:52Speaker 2: Santa Clara University School of Law and co director of
- 18:56Speaker 2: the High Tech Law Institute. Coming up next, what exactly
- 19:01Speaker 2: is a legal hot tub? Remember you can always get
- 19:04Speaker 2: the latest legal news by listening to our Bloomberg Law
- 19:06Speaker 2: podcasts and attorneys looking for legal research. Whether you're an
- 19:11Speaker 2: in house counsel or in private practice, Bloomberg Law gives
- 19:14Speaker 2: you the edge with the latest in AI powered legal analytics,
- 19:18Speaker 2: business insights, and workflow tools. With guidance from our experts,
- 19:23Speaker 2: you'll grasp the latest trends in the legal industry, helping
- 19:26Speaker 2: you achieve better results for the practice of law, the
- 19:29Speaker 2: business of law, the future of law. Visit Bloomberg Law
- 19:33Speaker 2: dot com. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 19:45Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 19:50Speaker 2: You're listening to a special best of edition of the
- 19:53Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Show. What exactly is a legal hot tub.
- 19:59Speaker 2: It's not diverting or exciting as it may sound, and
- 20:02Speaker 2: it really has nothing to do with hot tubs. It's
- 20:05Speaker 2: formally called concurrent expert testimony or a concurrent expert evidence proceeding,
- 20:11Speaker 2: and it's more like a discussion among experts. If you
- 20:14Speaker 2: haven't heard about it, it's because it's a novelty in
- 20:17Speaker 2: US courts. Here to tell us all about it and
- 20:20Speaker 2: how it got. That name is Dan paskin Bloomberg Law Reporter.
- 20:25Speaker 2: So tell us exactly what this legal hot tub is, Dan.
- 20:30Speaker 8: Yes, So you can kind of think of it as
- 20:32Speaker 8: a debate between experts, often economic experts, but not necessarily
- 20:37Speaker 8: where instead of one sitting on the stand in a
- 20:40Speaker 8: trial or in the pre trial hearing and getting examined
- 20:44Speaker 8: and then cross examined by one size attorneys and then
- 20:46Speaker 8: the other. Both or all of the witnesses sit together
- 20:50Speaker 8: before the judge and are basically prompted to debate each
- 20:53Speaker 8: other on a series of predetermined topics or questions.
- 20:56Speaker 2: So, tell us about this hot tub. It doesn't sound
- 21:00Speaker 2: very legal to say, even legalta. Tell us what federal
- 21:04Speaker 2: Judge James Donado used it for in San Francisco this summer.
- 21:08Speaker 8: So Donado held the second hot sub he's held in
- 21:12Speaker 8: this case. This is a lawsuit alleging Google basically has
- 21:16Speaker 8: anti competitive control over the payment systems in its playstore,
- 21:21Speaker 8: which is like if you have an Android, Sponi's where
- 21:23Speaker 8: you get your apps. And so the second hotu was
- 21:27Speaker 8: to basically determine whether the plaintiffs experts have reached kind
- 21:31Speaker 8: of valid models for figuring out how much consumers were
- 21:36Speaker 8: harmed by these playstore policies and what the impact was
- 21:40Speaker 8: on the market. Pretty central evidence for a trial to
- 21:45Speaker 8: figure out whether Google, in fact, you know, overcharged customers
- 21:49Speaker 8: and buy how much if it did.
- 21:51Speaker 2: Is the judge the only one asking questions? Or are
- 21:54Speaker 2: the lawyers asking questions? Is their cross talk between the experts.
- 21:58Speaker 8: There's a lot of cross time. It's almost exclusively Tonauto
- 22:01Speaker 8: asking the question. He allows the attorneys a couple attorneys
- 22:05Speaker 8: to sit with the experts in the hot sub, but
- 22:08Speaker 8: they're really only allowed to ask questions right at the
- 22:10Speaker 8: end if they have kind of clarifying questions for either expert.
- 22:13Speaker 8: Otherwise Tonao prompts one side or the other. We'll say like, yeah,
- 22:18Speaker 8: I read your report, I had this question about this,
- 22:21Speaker 8: you know, one part of the model, and then we'll
- 22:24Speaker 8: prompt the other expert to be like, do you disagree
- 22:26Speaker 8: with that? So why it got pretty heated. Several times
- 22:30Speaker 8: there was I don't know if you would call it yelling,
- 22:32Speaker 8: but definitely raised voices. The court reporter had to interrupt
- 22:36Speaker 8: I think three separate times because two experts and the
- 22:40Speaker 8: judge were talking over each other and she couldn't transcribe
- 22:43Speaker 8: that in real time. So it definitely is a little
- 22:46Speaker 8: more chaotic than your average court oral testimony.
- 22:49Speaker 2: Is this because the expert testimony is so complex for
- 22:53Speaker 2: the judge to understand? Or is it because this is quicker?
- 22:58Speaker 2: I mean, what's the real reason behind this?
- 23:01Speaker 8: The reason do not ouheld the hantu was to answer
- 23:05Speaker 8: this Google motion over whether the experts should be allowed
- 23:08Speaker 8: to test or not, and Donato told me in an
- 23:11Speaker 8: interview afterwards that it's very useful for him understanding their
- 23:16Speaker 8: testimony and their models. It is really complicated, and that's
- 23:18Speaker 8: a big reason why judges are deploying hot tubs. They
- 23:22Speaker 8: haven't deployed too many of them. But it's not just
- 23:25Speaker 8: about the complexity. It's also faster, Tonatoa said, it's a
- 23:28Speaker 8: lot cleaner compared like normal expert testimony, non hot tub
- 23:33Speaker 8: testimony to a game of telephone. Right, you've got the
- 23:36Speaker 8: expert on the stand, you've got their attorney questioning them,
- 23:39Speaker 8: and then you've got the judge hearing their answers. So
- 23:41Speaker 8: it's kind of filtered through what questions the attorney wants
- 23:44Speaker 8: to ask and then how the economist in this case
- 23:48Speaker 8: answers those questions. The judge might not necessarily be getting
- 23:51Speaker 8: the exact answers they're looking for and instead getting, you know,
- 23:55Speaker 8: the versions that the economist wants to give, the response
- 23:58Speaker 8: to the questions the attorney wants to ask. And so
- 24:01Speaker 8: by having this hot tub, it's a lot more direct
- 24:03Speaker 8: and clear. The judge can ask really complex questions and
- 24:07Speaker 8: get you know, exactly what they want out of them
- 24:10Speaker 8: and kind of follow up if you have dodges the
- 24:12Speaker 8: question and doesn't answers have factorily and they're kind of
- 24:15Speaker 8: us to typically get hired for these cases. One who's
- 24:20Speaker 8: done several of these told me that it's pretty hard
- 24:23Speaker 8: for an attorney to cross examine them, to kind of
- 24:25Speaker 8: catch them in errors or obfuscations, because the stuff is
- 24:29Speaker 8: so complex and because it involves, you know, so many
- 24:31Speaker 8: years of study. Really the only person in the courtroom
- 24:34Speaker 8: can really call them on their mistakes or on lack
- 24:38Speaker 8: of clarity is the other economists. So it also means
- 24:40Speaker 8: that you have the only other person able to make
- 24:43Speaker 8: these calls in the room with them and able to
- 24:47Speaker 8: disagree in real time.
- 24:48Speaker 2: Do attorneys object to this because it's taking them out
- 24:52Speaker 2: of the equation with a very important witness or witnesses?
- 24:57Speaker 8: Yeah, So, I mean like these are arguable some of
- 25:00Speaker 8: the most important players in a trial, especially in anti
- 25:04Speaker 8: trust but also in I imagine you know, patent cases
- 25:07Speaker 8: and elsewhere, and what they come up with can really
- 25:10Speaker 8: determine not just whether a company or an individual is
- 25:14Speaker 8: liable or not, but also you know, monetarily how much
- 25:17Speaker 8: they have to pay the attorneys aren't the biggest fans
- 25:21Speaker 8: of having to step back and basically watch this thing happen.
- 25:24Speaker 8: But once I spoke to you, also appreciated how useful
- 25:28Speaker 8: it was for the judge and again how clean the
- 25:31Speaker 8: whole thing was. But yeah, you're right, they they definitely
- 25:34Speaker 8: lose quite a bit of control. They're they're relegated to
- 25:37Speaker 8: preparing for the hot dub and then you know, trying
- 25:40Speaker 8: to pick up pieces afterwards. Probably the most helpless they
- 25:44Speaker 8: are throughout the proceedings.
- 25:46Speaker 2: So where does that term hot tub come from Australia?
- 25:49Speaker 8: Which kind of when you when you learn that makes
- 25:52Speaker 8: quite of the descent, I feel like you can you
- 25:54Speaker 8: can definitely imagine for one of what's an Australian accents,
- 25:57Speaker 8: saying hot at least makes sense to me.
- 25:59Speaker 6: Right.
- 26:00Speaker 8: These originated pretty much right around the beginning of the decade,
- 26:04Speaker 8: and it was deployed originally by the Australian Competition Tribunal.
- 26:09Speaker 8: And there are kind of antitrust dedicated court system basically
- 26:12Speaker 8: for this reason to get a clearer understanding of what
- 26:15Speaker 8: experts we're talking about and make them really drill down
- 26:18Speaker 8: on their agreements and their disagreements. It was pretty successful there.
- 26:21Speaker 8: They've modified it quite a bit. I don't think it's
- 26:23Speaker 8: technically called the hot ted there anymore, but it's effectively
- 26:25Speaker 8: the way we still run the way. That's Nato Rana
- 26:28Speaker 8: in his courtroom, and it's taken off in a bunch
- 26:30Speaker 8: of other countries in Europe, in South Africa, Canada has
- 26:34Speaker 8: used it. It's mostly been unpopular. In the US. We've
- 26:37Speaker 8: only found a little less than two dozen instances of
- 26:41Speaker 8: federal judges using on although also it's been to ployed
- 26:45Speaker 8: in arbitration a little bit, but it hasn't it hasn't
- 26:47Speaker 8: taken off.
- 26:48Speaker 2: Yeah, and I'm wondering have there been any appeals based
- 26:52Speaker 2: on the fact that this was used So.
- 26:55Speaker 8: Denata's case, he in the Google play is used a
- 27:00Speaker 8: hot tub for class certification about a year ago. It
- 27:03Speaker 8: was last June, and Google appealed to the ruling, which
- 27:08Speaker 8: he found in favor of the class and certified a
- 27:11Speaker 8: cost of consumers are pretty large cost of consumers that
- 27:14Speaker 8: would have put Google on the hook for quite a
- 27:16Speaker 8: bit of money and hypothetical damages. Google appealed that to
- 27:19Speaker 8: the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in California, but before
- 27:22Speaker 8: they could actually rule and it was kind of unclear
- 27:25Speaker 8: exactly how much the hot tub aspect of it would
- 27:28Speaker 8: affect the ruling. I'm not sure that would have changed anything.
- 27:32Speaker 8: Donato actually changed his mind in part because of evidence
- 27:35Speaker 8: that came up at the hot tub that I attended
- 27:39Speaker 8: and decertified the class, kind of rendering the Ninth Circuit
- 27:42Speaker 8: librations mood.
- 27:44Speaker 2: There's no appeal from his reversal, but in the end
- 27:46Speaker 2: he decertified the class.
- 27:49Speaker 8: Yeah, and it looks like they probably won't. But no,
- 27:51Speaker 8: there hasn't been any other appeals. The Ninth Circuit basically
- 27:55Speaker 8: handed the ruling back to Donado when he changed his
- 27:59Speaker 8: mind at the end of August.
- 28:01Speaker 2: So this was pretty consequential then to make him change
- 28:05Speaker 2: his mind.
- 28:06Speaker 6: Yeah.
- 28:07Speaker 8: So if you read his ruling on the classification, he
- 28:10Speaker 8: quotes from the hot tub that I attended at the
- 28:12Speaker 8: beginning of August and basically says it helped him get
- 28:15Speaker 8: a better understanding of the issues. Basically, what happened was
- 28:19Speaker 8: part of the model that one of the experts used
- 28:23Speaker 8: in certifying the class was also relevant for determining damages
- 28:27Speaker 8: to that class, and the defendants expert tried to poke
- 28:31Speaker 8: some holes in it. At the hot tub that I attended,
- 28:34Speaker 8: and Donato found this to be kind of a valid attack,
- 28:37Speaker 8: and so he didn't just throw out the testimony of
- 28:41Speaker 8: that plaintiffs expert for the merits of the harms, but
- 28:45Speaker 8: also for the classes off.
- 28:47Speaker 2: I think they have to come up with a new
- 28:48Speaker 2: name for this, don't you. The judge held a hot
- 28:50Speaker 2: tub just doesn't sound right.
- 28:53Speaker 8: Oh yeah, I mean my pitching the story was quite
- 28:55Speaker 8: the experience. I got a lot of raised arostrum editors,
- 28:58Speaker 8: although I have the receiver of a variety of memes
- 29:02Speaker 8: created from it, which was pretty nice. But now attorneys
- 29:04Speaker 8: don't love it. I talked to an economist she said
- 29:08Speaker 8: strongly believes we need to find another term for it.
- 29:11Speaker 8: If she mentioned that it's kind of weird when you're
- 29:13Speaker 8: at a conference and someone walks up to you and
- 29:15Speaker 8: it's like, I recognize you from the hot sub I
- 29:17Speaker 8: think people are trying to find another term. But concurrent
- 29:20Speaker 8: expert evidence, that concurrent expert witness proceeding is not very catchy,
- 29:24Speaker 8: not very.
- 29:25Speaker 2: Catchy at all. Thanks so much, Dan. That's Dan paskin,
- 29:28Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Reporter, Coming up next on The Bloomberg Law Show.
- 29:32Speaker 2: Instagram promoters test the limits of a ninety year old
- 29:36Speaker 2: securities law. This is Bloomberg.
- 29:47Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 29:52Speaker 2: You're listening to a special best of edition of the
- 29:55Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Show.
- 29:57Speaker 9: Real Estate Investing Made Simple. Grant Cardon here in the
- 30:00Speaker 9: on every Monday, I said, Steve, would I pay you
- 30:02Speaker 9: last month? Steve was paid thirty one and twenty dollars
- 30:07Speaker 9: last month because he invested at Cardoncapital dot Com.
- 30:12Speaker 2: In October, the Supreme Court declined to hear a case
- 30:15Speaker 2: involving a lawsuit against real estate management company Cardone Capital
- 30:20Speaker 2: and its CEO, Grant Cardone, for misleading statements in YouTube
- 30:24Speaker 2: and Instagram videos. The lawsuit was dismissed on other grounds
- 30:29Speaker 2: days after the Justices refused the case, But the core
- 30:32Speaker 2: issue remains, what does it mean to sell securities in
- 30:36Speaker 2: the age of YouTube and Instagram? As venture capital firms
- 30:40Speaker 2: and others hyping investment projects online are facing lawsuits from
- 30:45Speaker 2: disgruntled buyers. Joining me is Anne Lipton, a business law
- 30:49Speaker 2: professor at Tulane University. Tell us about the provision in
- 30:54Speaker 2: the thirty three Securities.
- 30:56Speaker 10: Act okay so Section twelve is from the nineteen thirty
- 30:59Speaker 10: three Ccurities Act, and it basically has two separate provisions.
- 31:03Speaker 10: The first is that a purchaser of a security that
- 31:06Speaker 10: was sold unregistered when it should have been registered has
- 31:10Speaker 10: a right to sue the seller. And then secondly, they
- 31:14Speaker 10: can sue anyone who sold it to them or who
- 31:17Speaker 10: solicited the purchase if the prospectus or sales documents contained
- 31:24Speaker 10: false statements. Now, sometimes there's a bit of a debate
- 31:27Speaker 10: about what counts as a prospectus, but what it comes
- 31:29Speaker 10: down to is that this is sometimes a more attractive
- 31:32Speaker 10: option than say, more traditional ways of suing for false statements,
- 31:36Speaker 10: like Section ten B, which is the anti fraud statute,
- 31:39Speaker 10: because if you sue for false statements in connection with
- 31:43Speaker 10: essentially these unregistered security sales under section twelve, you don't
- 31:47Speaker 10: have to show that you relied on the false statement,
- 31:50Speaker 10: and you don't have to show that there was any
- 31:51Speaker 10: intent to make a false statement.
- 31:53Speaker 2: The Supreme Court decided not to take a case involving
- 31:56Speaker 2: cardone Capital. Tell us a little about the issue.
- 32:00Speaker 10: Who's there, Well, that was the case that was Actually
- 32:02Speaker 10: it wasn't a registered offering. I believe it was under
- 32:04Speaker 10: regulation A so Regulation A is an exemption from full
- 32:09Speaker 10: on registered offerings, but it does require some degree of
- 32:13Speaker 10: filing and disclosure with the SEC. So it wasn't an
- 32:16Speaker 10: unregistered offering. But because it's not registered offerings, the standard
- 32:21Speaker 10: protections available in registered offerings are not available to purchasers. Instead,
- 32:26Speaker 10: the only liability available would be, you know, just straight
- 32:28Speaker 10: up fraud, which is again very hard to prove, or
- 32:31Speaker 10: Section twelve liability. That's what's available. And so this real
- 32:34Speaker 10: estate company, they used social media to advertise the offering
- 32:39Speaker 10: that was filed with the SEC. They had documents with
- 32:42Speaker 10: the SEC and so forth, and shareholders claimed that these
- 32:45Speaker 10: advertisements were solicitations. In the Ninth Circuit agreed and repudiated.
- 32:50Speaker 10: I mean, you know, some of the case law that
- 32:51Speaker 10: had held there must be direct contact hadn't come out
- 32:54Speaker 10: of the Ninth Circuit, so at very least it was
- 32:55Speaker 10: disagreeing with you know, the other courts that had imposed
- 32:59Speaker 10: something like direct contact requirement. But the Supreme Court denies sort,
- 33:04Speaker 10: you know, I mean, there are any number of reasons
- 33:06Speaker 10: why they could have denied SIRT, but one possibility is
- 33:08Speaker 10: that the social media cases are new. They're you know,
- 33:12Speaker 10: looking to this old precedent that was generated under IPO situations,
- 33:16Speaker 10: and you know, it may take some time to work
- 33:18Speaker 10: through the court.
- 33:19Speaker 2: You know, if you ask an average person, it doesn't
- 33:21Speaker 2: seem like the difficult question. They're online, they're soliciting. Yeah,
- 33:26Speaker 2: they're selling.
- 33:27Speaker 10: What makes so difficult, Well, because the interesting thing is
- 33:31Speaker 10: that the word solicit it doesn't actually appear in the statute.
- 33:35Speaker 10: What the statute says is imposing liability for selling. The
- 33:38Speaker 10: Supreme Court's interpretation of selling in Printer versus Doll, this
- 33:42Speaker 10: case from nineteen eighty eight is the one that imposed
- 33:45Speaker 10: this concept of solicitation with this very specific kind of definition.
- 33:49Speaker 10: And to be honest, Printer doesn't seem to really understand
- 33:52Speaker 10: how security sales works. There are parts of it that
- 33:56Speaker 10: display a kind of lack of understanding. This concept of
- 33:59Speaker 10: solicit Exactly how we're defining it is not in the statute.
- 34:03Speaker 10: It comes from the Supreme Court case Lawn. So now
- 34:05Speaker 10: we're all trying to figure out what the Supreme Court
- 34:06Speaker 10: man and how you translate a case in nineteen eighty
- 34:09Speaker 10: eight it's today.
- 34:10Speaker 2: That's Anne Lipton, a business law professor at Tulane University,
- 34:14Speaker 2: and that's it for this edition. Of the Bloomberg Law Show.
- 34:17Speaker 2: Remember you can always get the latest legal news by
- 34:19Speaker 2: listening to our Bloomberg Law podcasts. You can find them
- 34:22Speaker 2: on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot bloomberg dot
- 34:27Speaker 2: com slash podcast Slash Law. Stay with us today's top
- 34:32Speaker 2: stories and global business headlines are coming up right now.