Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / BBA Audits: What Tax Attorneys Need to Know with Robert Horwitz & Jennifer Black
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome to BBA audits what tax attorneys need
- 0:10to know. I'm Philipp Berendt, chair of the Beverly
- 0:12Hills Biossociation's tax law section. The tax
- 0:16section is sponsored by Hochmann, Salk, and Torcha
- 0:18Perez. The Hochmann, Salk, and Torcha Perez law
- 0:23firm advantage is experience and eye for innovation
- 0:26and a genuine dedication to clients, their families,
- 0:29and their business. In addition to their national
- 0:33practice in civil tax and criminal tax controversies
- 0:35and related litigation in federal and state courts,
- 0:42we also advise doing audits. And I'm delighted
- 0:45to introduce today's speaker, Jennifer Black
- 0:48and Robert Horowitz. Jennifer Black is Managing
- 0:52Director in Seidfried Kuperman's National Tax
- 0:55Office and has over two decades of combined legal
- 0:59and accounting experience. She has extensive
- 1:02experience dealing with complex tax issues, including
- 1:06partnerships, audit procedures under the Tax
- 1:09Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982,
- 1:13better known as TEFWA, and the bipartisan Budget
- 1:17Act of 2015, known as BVA. The interaction between
- 1:21TEFWA and collection due process procedures and
- 1:25disclosure issues involving section 6103. the
- 1:29Privacy Act and the Freedom of Information Act.
- 1:32Prior to Seidman -Kupperman, Jenny was Senior
- 1:35Counsel for the IRS Office of Chief Counsel in
- 1:39the Procedure and Administration Division. She
- 1:41served as a primary resource for both BBA and
- 1:44TEFA matters and was essential in implementing
- 1:47the BBA regime, including developing policies,
- 1:52interpreting statures of authoring regulations,
- 1:57reviewing and creating new forms, and assisting
- 1:59in developing internal procedures to perform
- 2:03examination under the BBA. Robert Horvitz as
- 2:07attorney, principal at Hoffmanshock and Toscher
- 2:09Press, has over 35 years of experience as a tax
- 2:13attorney, specializing in the representation
- 2:15of clients at civil and criminal tax matters,
- 2:18including civil audits and appeals, tax collection
- 2:21matters, criminal investigation, administrative
- 2:23hearings, and in civil and criminal trials and
- 2:27appeals in federal and state courts. He has served
- 2:30as a member of the Executive Committee of the
- 2:33Tax Section of the State Bar of California and
- 2:35was Chair of the Tax Section for 2015 to 2016.
- 2:41He was previously Chair of the Tax Procedure
- 2:43and Litigation Committee of the State Bar Taxation
- 2:48Section. And now let's get started and turn it
- 2:52over to you. Thank you, Philip. Next slide. If
- 3:08you could advance to slide five, that's where
- 3:11the actual presentation starts. There we go.
- 3:13That's just all of us. There you go. OK. Well,
- 3:17first, we're going to deal with what the BBA,
- 3:20which is the Balance Budget Act of 2015 applies
- 3:29to. And basically, it's called the Centralized
- 3:32Partnership Audit Regime, is the formal name,
- 3:36and it applies to all partnerships for tax years
- 3:39that begin on or after January 1, 2018. For tax
- 3:44years ending after the BBA was enacted and prior
- 3:50to January 1, 2018, a partnership could elect
- 3:55to be audited under the BBA rules and BBA applies
- 4:00unless a partnership elects out of the BBA. You
- 4:04can elect out of the BBA only if there are no
- 4:08more than 100 partners for the taxable year and
- 4:12all the partners have to be either individuals,
- 4:15C corporations, S corporations, foreign entities
- 4:20that would be C corporations if they were domestic
- 4:23and estates of deceased partners. So you can't
- 4:26have a partnership, a disregarded entity like
- 4:29a single member LLC, a trust or an estate that
- 4:34is a partner. Now then the number of partners
- 4:38are based on the number of K1s issued by the
- 4:43partnership and if one of the members is a S
- 4:47corporation then you include the number of K1s
- 4:52issued by the S corporation to its partners.
- 4:55So if there's 91 partners and an S corporation
- 4:59has 10 shareholders to whom it issues K1s, then
- 5:03it's going to be 101 partners. So you have to
- 5:07take that into consideration. Under the regulations,
- 5:11if in a state of the deceased partner issues
- 5:14K1s to several beneficiaries, it's not going
- 5:19to be treated as increasing the number of K -1s.
- 5:24So an estate that has five beneficiaries who
- 5:27get K -1s, if the estate is a partner, it's only
- 5:31going to be treated as one partner. Now the election
- 5:36out has to be made on a timely file tax return.
- 5:41And the election is made. There's a Q &A questions
- 5:45on the return. Question 33 on the current 1065
- 5:50asks if the partnership is electing out of BBA,
- 5:56and if there is an election out, the partnership
- 5:59would check the box yes, and would complete a
- 6:03schedule B2 election out, which would require
- 6:06it to include the names and TINs of all the partners,
- 6:11including the indirect partners who hold an interest
- 6:18through a S corporation. Next slide, please.
- 6:29Now then, the audit of the BBA occurs at the
- 6:33partnership level and all of the adjustments
- 6:36are required to be determined at the partnership
- 6:39level. The adjustments are to what are called
- 6:43partnership related items, and we'll be dealing
- 6:45with that on the next slide. They also apply
- 6:51to any penalty addition attacks or additional
- 6:54amount, which are basically the section, the
- 6:57chapter 63 A and B penalties, which would relate
- 7:01to any adjustment. And they also apply to any
- 7:05legal or factual determination underlying an
- 7:08adjustment. An example would be whether, what
- 7:11period of limitations applies to making the adjustment.
- 7:15If there's a determination there was a 25 % understatement
- 7:20of tax or there was fraud, that would be a legal
- 7:24or factual determination that would be determined
- 7:27at the partnership level. Okay, now then it only
- 7:31applies to income taxes. It doesn't apply to
- 7:35self -employment taxes. It doesn't apply to state
- 7:39and gift taxes. It doesn't apply to net investment
- 7:45income taxes, foreign withholding taxes, employment
- 7:49taxes, or excise taxes. And the IRS can make
- 7:57adjustments to partnership related items outside
- 8:00of BBA solely for purposes of these taxes. Next
- 8:04slide. Just want to note something real quick
- 8:07as we're going on to the next slide. The penalties
- 8:09that can be determined under BBA are only those
- 8:12penalties that are on an adjustment to a partnership
- 8:14-related item. That means that any of your filing
- 8:17penalties, like if you fail to file the partnership
- 8:20return timely, and any kind of filing penalty
- 8:23like that is not going to be subject to BBA.
- 8:28Now we're going to get into partnership -related
- 8:31items, and partnership -related items are defined
- 8:34at section 6241. 2B, and which is part of the
- 8:45definition of adjustments, and it's detailed
- 8:49in Reg 301 .6241 -6, and a partnership adjustment
- 8:55is— —Dash one. 6241 -1, A6. —Oh, okay. Dash one,
- 9:02A6. —Yeah, 6241 -1 is all the definitions and
- 9:05the regs. Dash six is the coordination procedures.
- 9:09Okay, so it's basically it's any item with or
- 9:14amount with respect to the partnership that is
- 9:16relevant to determining the tax liability of
- 9:20any person under chapter one and any partners
- 9:23distributive share and even though any person
- 9:27could mean anyone whether a partner or not the
- 9:30examples in the regulations show that basically
- 9:35it has to be a direct or indirect partner whose
- 9:38tax liability is affected. If it's someone who
- 9:41is not a partner or indirect partner, such as
- 9:45a vendor or a employee or a party that purchased
- 9:53an asset from the partnership who is not related
- 9:56to the partnership, then that person's liability
- 10:01would not be affected by the BBA procedures.
- 10:05Now then how do you go about determining if something
- 10:08is a partnership related item? It has to be an
- 10:12item or amount with respect to the partnership
- 10:14and that means that it's got to be shown or required
- 10:18to be shown or reported on the partnerships form
- 10:211065 or it's required to be maintained in the
- 10:25partnerships book or records. And just want to
- 10:35clarify one thing that you said. when you're
- 10:38determining whether or not something has an impact
- 10:42on Chapter 1 liability, you don't look at anybody
- 10:45specifically. So it's not a matter of whose liability
- 10:49is impacted, the statute and the regulations
- 10:51provided it. As long as it affects, it can affect
- 10:55Chapter 1 liability under the code, then that's
- 10:57what meets that requirement. So it's not a matter
- 11:00of like for Partnership 1, if the adjustment
- 11:03to liabilities would impact the liability. liability
- 11:07of one of its partners that it's a PRI, and at
- 11:09partnership two, that same adjustment wouldn't
- 11:12impact the liability of a particular partner,
- 11:15it's still a PRI. It's not dependent, because
- 11:18otherwise that would be completely unmanageable.
- 11:20So it's just whether or not that item can theoretically
- 11:23impact chapter one liability under the code.
- 11:27Okay, and basically an item is... or amount required
- 11:33to be shown on a return of a person other than
- 11:37the partnership that results after application
- 11:40of the code to a PRI. Based on the facts or circumstances
- 11:44of that person is not going to be a partnership
- 11:48item. And again, the regulations give an example
- 11:52of a partnership adjustment where the partnership
- 11:56has purchased $100 of widgets from individual
- 12:03A and the IRS does a VBA audit, makes an adjustment
- 12:10to the widget amounts and the how the widgets
- 12:15are treated. That will affect the partnership,
- 12:19and it will be an adjustment of a partnership
- 12:22-related item, but it will not affect the tax
- 12:25liability of the vendor who sold the widget to
- 12:29the IRS, assuming he is not a direct or indirect
- 12:33partner. And then Jenny has already gone over
- 12:40that. It's basically theoretical. If it can have
- 12:45an effect on Chapter 1 tax, then it's relevant.
- 12:49Next slide, please. And these are examples of
- 12:57what our partnership -related items. character,
- 13:00timing, and source of the partnerships. Income,
- 13:03gain, loss, deductions, and credits character
- 13:07would be something as to whether something is
- 13:09ordinary income or capital gain or whether it
- 13:15is an asset that can be depreciated or can be
- 13:21expensed. Timing would be the taxable year in
- 13:24which something should be included as income
- 13:28or deducted or claimed as a loss source would
- 13:32be is it is the item of income such such a thing
- 13:37as is it business income of the partnership is
- 13:40it interest income is it gained from the sale
- 13:45of an asset then there are Other examples of
- 13:49PRIs are contributions to and distributions from
- 13:53the partnership, including the value amount and
- 13:56character of the item contributed to or distributed
- 14:00by the partnership, the amount and character
- 14:03of liabilities. This would be whether or not
- 14:07the amount of the liability, but whether it's
- 14:11recourse, non -recourse. qualified non -recourse
- 14:14liability, the partnership's basis in its assets,
- 14:20capital accounts of the partners, elections made
- 14:23by the partnership, and whether or not a person
- 14:27is a partner in the partnership. And one of the
- 14:31main elections that often comes up in partnership
- 14:35audits is the 754 election which would allow
- 14:40a partnership to adjust the basis in its assets
- 14:43if there is a transfer by sale exchange or a
- 14:48death of a partner of a partnership interest
- 14:51or if there is a distribution of an asset to
- 14:55a partner. Next slide. So now I'm going to talk
- 15:01a little bit about inconsistent treatment. For
- 15:04those of you familiar with Tefra, you know that
- 15:07the partner has to file consistently with the
- 15:10partnership. I gave this talk one time and somebody
- 15:12raised their hand and they go, do you mean I've
- 15:14been not required to report consistently with
- 15:16my non -Tefra partnership for the last 10 years?
- 15:19I'm like... Yes, technically. So what it means
- 15:22to report consistently with the partnership is
- 15:24that you have to treat the partnership -related
- 15:26items in the same way that the partnership did.
- 15:29So generally, those items on your K1, so if they
- 15:32report to you that there's $100 of ordinary income,
- 15:35you have to report $100 of ordinary income. If
- 15:38you disagree with the treatment at the partnership,
- 15:40you can file inconsistently with the partnership,
- 15:43but you have to file it as inconsistent treatment.
- 15:45Otherwise, the IRS can just turn around and math
- 15:48error assess you. For example, my $100 example,
- 15:51you say, oh, no, no, no, I really was only allocated
- 15:54$80. I should not be allocated $100. You report
- 15:58$80 on your return instead of the $100. Now,
- 16:01if you don't file a notice of inconsistent treatment,
- 16:03the IRS can automatically adjust your return
- 16:05from $80 to $100. assess you the tax on that
- 16:09$20 without issuing a stat notice. If you file
- 16:12a notice of inconsistent treatment saying, hey,
- 16:14you know, they reported me $100. I think it should
- 16:16only be $80. At that point, the IRS, if they
- 16:20disagree with you, would have to open a partner
- 16:23level audit. Now, there are also all penalties
- 16:26for failing to file consistently with the partnership.
- 16:31If the partnership has a non -filer, like they
- 16:33hasn't filed a return yet, Anything that you
- 16:36report with respect to that partnership is per
- 16:38se inconsistent. So that means if you are, you
- 16:42know, weighting your K1 from the partnership
- 16:44and you need to go ahead and file with an estimate,
- 16:47you should file a notice of inconsistent treatment
- 16:49if that K1 would be coming from a BBA partnership
- 16:52because otherwise it's per se inconsistent. If
- 16:58the partnership goes through an audit and there
- 17:00are adjustments, you can't file inconsistently
- 17:03from those audit adjustments because the partner
- 17:05is bound to those adjustments. Now, I do know
- 17:10there's a lot of misconceptions about inconsistent
- 17:13treatment. So outside of BBA and previously Tefra,
- 17:18there is no requirement for a partner to file
- 17:20consistently with a partnership. Now there is
- 17:23a requirement for S -corp shareholders to file
- 17:25consistently. That's section 6037. So when you
- 17:29file inconsistently from a BBA partnership and
- 17:31you file your notice of inconsistent treatment,
- 17:33all it does is basically puts you in the same
- 17:35rules that would exist if BBA didn't exist, but
- 17:38it doesn't mean that it allows the partner to
- 17:41take actions that it could not normally do. So
- 17:44for example, if you had a non -BBA partnership
- 17:46and it did not make a 754 election, The partner
- 17:53can't turn around and make that 754 election
- 17:56on their return and be like, oh, the partnership
- 17:57should have made that. I'm going to make it for
- 18:00them. Similarly, for BBA, if you file inconsistently
- 18:05from the partnership, it doesn't give you the
- 18:06ability to make to do things that the partner
- 18:09would not normally be able to do. So more or
- 18:12less that the partner could do it outside of
- 18:14BBA. then they can generally do it in this situation
- 18:18as well. But inconsistent treatment is basically
- 18:21the character, the timing, and the amount of
- 18:23the item. But again, if you file inconsistently,
- 18:26please file a notice of inconsistent treatment.
- 18:28That is form 8082. Next slide, please. Jennifer,
- 18:32Jenny, if a partnership is elected out of BBA,
- 18:36do the rules of consistent treatment apply? No,
- 18:40only to BBA and TEPRA partnerships. So outside
- 18:43of BBA, those rules don't apply. Next slide,
- 18:48please. Partnership representative or PR. So
- 18:53the PR is the, I like to describe the PR as the
- 18:57all -powerful Oz. The partnership selects this
- 19:01person. And this person has the sole authority
- 19:04to act on behalf of the partnership under BBA.
- 19:08The person has no power outside of BBA, but they
- 19:10have absolute authority inside of BBA. There's
- 19:14no requirement that it be a partner like it was
- 19:16for TMP under TEFRA. It can be any person, some
- 19:20random person off the street, your choice, so
- 19:22long as that person has a substantial presence
- 19:24in the United States. don't choose one and you
- 19:29refuse to choose one, the IRS can select a PR
- 19:32for you. If the IRS determines you don't have
- 19:35a PR in effect, they give you 30 days to pick
- 19:38your person. But if you think you're going to
- 19:40be cute and just not name somebody and think
- 19:43it's going to stymie the IRS, no, they'll just
- 19:45pick somebody. So the partners and the partnership
- 19:49are bound by the actions taken by the PR, which
- 19:51is why I say he is the all -powerful Oz. You
- 19:55designate the PR on the partnership return. It's
- 19:58a year -by -year designation, so just because
- 20:01you named me on your 2018 return doesn't make
- 20:05me the PR for 2019. You have to actually put
- 20:07me on the 2019 return as well. Similarly, if
- 20:11your partnership agreement says that John Doe
- 20:14is supposed to be the PR, but you put Jane Smith
- 20:17on that 1065, Jane Smith is your PR. You can
- 20:21change the PR and then you do that using the
- 20:23form 8979. Now you just can't change the PR.
- 20:27whenever you want. Pretty much it has to be in
- 20:30a circumstance where the PR will be taking a
- 20:33certain action like filing an AAR, filing a Form
- 20:388985 if you're under audit. But basically if
- 20:42the PR is not doing anything then there's no
- 20:45ability to just change the PR because otherwise
- 20:47you'd be sending in all these forms repeatedly
- 20:50and the IRS would be processing them in situations
- 20:52where it doesn't doesn't have any impact, which
- 20:56obviously, especially with the resource issues
- 20:58of the IRS right now, they're not going to be
- 21:02processing in these forms. But if the PR needs
- 21:05to do something, at that point, you can always
- 21:07change the PR. Next slide, please. So who can
- 21:13be PR as I kind of said it can be anybody off
- 21:15the street so long as they have substantial presence
- 21:17in the United States That is really a kind of
- 21:20a low bar They have to make themselves available
- 21:23to meet in person with the IRS in the US at a
- 21:26reasonable time and place They have to have a
- 21:28street address in the US a US telephone number
- 21:31and a US 10 I'll be honest, as long as the person
- 21:37works, is working with the IRS and not having
- 21:40any problems, it probably doesn't necessarily
- 21:42matter if they're in Hong Kong. If they're willing
- 21:44to meet with the IRS in the U .S. and has a U
- 21:49.S. 10 and a U .S. phone number, if it's not
- 21:53broke, don't fix it basically. The PR that you've
- 21:59selected is good and less than until the IRS
- 22:03says otherwise. The PR can be an entity. If you
- 22:08designate an entity as your PR, you must also
- 22:11appoint a designated individual or DI who will
- 22:14have sole authority to act on behalf of the entity
- 22:18PR. The designated individual must also have
- 22:21substantial presence in the United States. Now,
- 22:23I just want to make something clear. When I said
- 22:25you can pick anybody up, I do mean that. The
- 22:29PR, the DI, doesn't have to have any relationship
- 22:32at all to the partnership. They don't have to
- 22:34have state law authority to bind the partnership.
- 22:37The DI doesn't have to have any relationship
- 22:39with the partnership. Only requirement to be
- 22:42the PR is substantial presence in the United
- 22:44States. Now personally, I don't see, a lot of
- 22:48people like to name entity PRs and name that
- 22:51DI. personally on team individual PR, I don't
- 22:57see a real benefit to naming a entity PR because
- 23:01you're going to have to name a DI anyways and
- 23:04that DI is going to be the one taking all the
- 23:06actions. So why not just pick the DI? The person
- 23:09you were going to pick as DI as the PR, but there
- 23:11are a lot of people that feel very strongly that
- 23:14they should have entity PR. I just think it adds
- 23:16a layer of complication that is as unneeded because
- 23:20you know, if you name an entity PR and you name,
- 23:25you know, John Doe is your DI, but Jane Smith
- 23:29is the managing member of the Entity PR, and
- 23:32Jane Smith signs on behalf of that Entity PR,
- 23:35it's not good. So if your push -out election
- 23:37is signed by the wrong person, it's not good.
- 23:39So that's why I like Entity PRs. I mean, individual
- 23:42PRs over Entity PRs is because it's like you've
- 23:44got the person's name and that's the person signing,
- 23:46you don't have to deal with anything else. But
- 23:49you are free to choose an Entity if you want,
- 23:52so long as you name a DI. Next slide, please.
- 23:59This is a overall timeline of a BBA audit. It's
- 24:02just oversimplified, as simplified, as easy as
- 24:05I can make it. You know, it starts with a NAP,
- 24:08then there's audit, and you can go to appeals
- 24:10on the merits of the adjustments. After that,
- 24:13if you do or do not go, NOPA with two P's. is
- 24:17issued, which gives you the right to request
- 24:19modification of the imputed underpayment. If
- 24:22any modifications are denied, then you can go
- 24:24to appeals solely on the denied modifications.
- 24:27You can't revisit the adjustments. If everything
- 24:30is not all agreed, the IRS issues an FPAL with
- 24:321A. You can make a push out election. You can
- 24:35kind of see, you know, you can either petition
- 24:37or not. And then it goes on to, you know, assessment
- 24:40and collection. There's a more complex version
- 24:45of this called the IRS Roadmap that LB and I
- 24:48put out a couple years ago. You can probably
- 24:49Google it or find it on the IRS website. It's
- 24:53got more detail than this and it has all the
- 24:57form numbers and letter numbers on it. So if
- 25:00you want to see all that together, I recommend
- 25:03going to that. I'm also going to do a general
- 25:05plug for the IRS's BBA website. It is very well
- 25:09done. It has a lot of information. It's updated
- 25:14routinely. There's actually a newsletter you
- 25:17can sign up for that will email you when a change
- 25:20is made to the website and what the change was.
- 25:23So I highly recommend. It's a very well -done
- 25:26website. I'm signed up for the newsletter, so
- 25:31I recommend it. Robert, what kind of notices
- 25:36do people get under BBA? Okay. Next slide. Well,
- 25:40There are three statutory notices, but prior
- 25:44to the statutory notices, when the IRS first
- 25:48selects a partnership for audit under the BBA
- 25:51regime, it will send a letter 2205D, which is
- 25:56a notice of selection for audit. And if it's
- 25:58going to audit several years, it will send one
- 26:02letter for each year that is going to be audited.
- 26:05And the letter is normally sent to the partnership.
- 26:09Then there are three statutorily required notices.
- 26:13The notice of administrative proceeding, which
- 26:16starts the audit process. Then after the audit
- 26:21process is generally completed and the IRS has
- 26:25computed a proposed imputed underpayment, it
- 26:29will issue a notice of proposed partnership adjustment.
- 26:33The NOPA, which then triggers a right for the
- 26:39taxpayer to seek for the partnership to invoke
- 26:43the modification procedures and seek to have
- 26:47the imputed underpayment modified. And then notice
- 26:53a final partnership adjustment, the FPA, which
- 26:56basically is the ticket for the partnership to
- 27:00either do a pushout election and also if it wants
- 27:06to, to dispute the proposed adjustments in either
- 27:12tax court, district court, or the federal court
- 27:15of claims. All of the three statutory notices
- 27:19have to be mailed to both the partnership and
- 27:22the partnership representative at their last
- 27:25known addresses. And the partners are not entitled
- 27:30to notice from the IRS, unlike TEFRA, where partners
- 27:34were entitled to notice and partners could participate
- 27:39in the audit process. So basically, as Jenny
- 27:45noted, the PR is the all -powerful odds. The
- 27:51partners have no say in what goes on in the proceedings.
- 27:56The IRS does not have to consider anything the
- 27:59partners say or do during the proceedings. Partners
- 28:04cannot initiate a judicial proceeding. Remember,
- 28:09in TEFRA, if the partnership did not file a timely
- 28:13petition in tax court, a partner could institute
- 28:18a judicial proceeding to challenge the adjustments
- 28:22in the notice of partnership administrative adjustment.
- 28:29Now then there's a question about whether a partner
- 28:32can intervene in a partnership proceeding under
- 28:36BBA. If you look at tax court rule 64B, there
- 28:41is permissive intervention, which is basically
- 28:45if an individual has a stake in the outcome of
- 28:49the proceedings and that no party adequately
- 28:54protects, tax court can allow that person to
- 28:59intervene in the proceeding. So that would basically
- 29:03be a fact and circumstance test. This is somewhat
- 29:07different than the federal rule as a civil procedure,
- 29:11rule 24, which basically allows permissive intervention
- 29:16only if there is a statutory right to conditionally
- 29:21intervene or if there's a claim or defense that
- 29:25shares issues of factor law with the issues raised
- 29:31in the main action. So someone may not, an individual
- 29:36partner may not be able to intervene in a partnership
- 29:41proceeding if it was instituted in district court
- 29:44or federal court of claims and potentially could
- 29:47intervene if it was instituted in the tax court.
- 29:52Next slide. I just want to note that under TEFRA,
- 29:55because all the partners were parties to the
- 29:57proceeding and the partnership is not a partner
- 29:58to the proceeding, all partners had the right
- 30:01to participate in the proceeding. I can tell
- 30:03you in the 12 years I did TEFRA, I think I saw
- 30:06somebody participate one time. So they never
- 30:11did it under TEFRA. I'll be curious to see if
- 30:13people want to intervene under TEFRA, I mean
- 30:16at BBA. But I guess nobody ever did it under
- 30:18TEFRA and they had an absolute right to do so.
- 30:20So it'll be curious. is any problem with people
- 30:23intervening so long as they meet the test, but
- 30:25it's also going to be hard to figure out who
- 30:27has an interest. You know, if it's that they
- 30:30didn't elect to push out, you don't know who
- 30:32the partner is going to be. Okay, now this basically
- 30:38details the various notices. The first is the
- 30:42notice of selection for exam, and this is basically
- 30:46the extreme right -hand column. discusses some
- 30:50of the things to be done if a partnership gets
- 30:53a letter 2205D. It should engage counsel or someone
- 31:01to represent it. It could be an accountant. It
- 31:04could be an attorney, someone who has expertise
- 31:07in dealing with the IRS and dealing with BBA
- 31:10audits. The partnership should consider whether
- 31:14it wants to change the partnership representative
- 31:17or the designated individual of the partnership
- 31:21representative because there's only a very limited
- 31:24window of opportunity to make that adjustment.
- 31:28And then this also kicks off the time to file
- 31:33an administrative adjustment request, because
- 31:36once the notice of administrative proceeding
- 31:39is issued, you cannot make an administrative
- 31:42adjustment request. And there's usually 30 days.
- 31:46between the issuance of the letter 2205D and
- 31:51the issuance of the Notice of Administrative
- 31:54Proceedings. Once the Notice of Administrative
- 31:57Proceeding is issued, the partnership can no
- 32:00longer file an administrative adjustment request,
- 32:04and there's going to be an opening conference,
- 32:06like in any audit, an opening conference with
- 32:10the examining agent, and IDRs are going to be
- 32:13issued. And if... The addition of time is needed.
- 32:20The IRS will request the partnership representative
- 32:25to execute a statute extension to extend the
- 32:30statute limitations. Then after the IRS examining
- 32:34agent has completed the audit, a summary report
- 32:38will be issued. And this includes the preliminary
- 32:42audit results and the proposed imputed underpayment.
- 32:51It includes a letter which has instructions for
- 32:56requesting a conference with the examining agent
- 33:00and the form 886A, the explanation of items which
- 33:06will have a explanation of the reasons for any
- 33:13adjustments being proposed in the summary report.
- 33:18Next slide. Then, shortly after the summary report
- 33:27is issued, the IRS is going to issue a 30 -day
- 33:31letter to the Partnership for Representatives,
- 33:35which includes instructions on how to file a
- 33:40protest with IRS appeals if the partnership disagrees
- 33:45with the proposed adjustments and they also include
- 33:50a the same form that is was with the summary
- 33:55report for preliminary IU calculation and another
- 34:00form 886 a and then If you're going to file a
- 34:05notice on a protest, this is the time to do so.
- 34:09You have 30 days to do it. If you fail to file
- 34:12a protest within the 30 -day period, the IRS
- 34:17can basically send the case to the technical
- 34:25services unit to issue the NOPA. If you do file
- 34:30a protest, first the IRS is going to require
- 34:33you to grant an extension of time if there are
- 34:37not at least 18 months remaining on the statute
- 34:40of limitations for assessment. And then once
- 34:44the protest is filed, the examining agent can
- 34:48prepare and submit to appeals a rebuttal to the
- 34:53protest. explaining why the agent thinks that
- 34:56the protest is incorrect. And then it appeals,
- 35:02you will, if there is appeals and the parties
- 35:08can reach an agreement as to what the adjustments
- 35:12are, then they could sign an agreement as to
- 35:19the adjustments. Now then once appeals is done,
- 35:22The NOPA will be issued by appeals and it's issued
- 35:27to both the partnership and the partnership representative.
- 35:31And it will include instructions for the modification
- 35:35requests, the final imputed underpayment amount,
- 35:39and any revisions to the form 886A. And what
- 35:44you have to do then is if there is going to be
- 35:48a modification request. It has to be submitted
- 35:51within 270 days of the NOPA being issued, and
- 35:56you can request an extension. It's unlike the
- 36:00extensions for the statute of limitations on
- 36:03assessment, which the IRS usually initiates.
- 36:07The partnership has to be the party requesting
- 36:09the extension, and the extension has to be requested
- 36:13in sufficient time so that the IRS can sign approve
- 36:20the extension before the 270 day period expires.
- 36:25Because if the IRS doesn't sign the extension
- 36:29before the expiration, then it can't be extended.
- 36:35A partnership can consider waiving the modification
- 36:38period, in which case the FPAL would be issued.
- 36:44We have a question in the chat asking waving
- 36:47the 270 day period. It's extremely difficult
- 36:49Can you comment on how to make that waiver? It's
- 36:52there's a specific form for it. I don't know
- 36:54why it would be difficult the IRS usually will
- 36:57give you the Form I believe with the NOPA often
- 37:01you know or at least Mention it in the NOPA.
- 37:04I haven't pulled the letter for the NOPA in a
- 37:06while, but I'm I find out your question. I'm
- 37:09trying to I Think it's form 89 81 So you could
- 37:15fill out the Form 89 -81 and have your PR sign
- 37:18it and that's how you would do the waiver of
- 37:21the modification, remainder of the modification
- 37:23period. And you can also do that after you submit
- 37:25your modification request. So if you submit your
- 37:27modification request on day 100 and you're like,
- 37:29I'm done, I don't wanna sit around and wait anymore,
- 37:31you can wait the remainder of it. Yeah. It's
- 37:35similar though to a regular IRS audit when the
- 37:38IRS... issues to notice the deficiency of the
- 37:41taxpayer can waive his right to go to tax court
- 37:44and the deficiency can be assessed. So similarly,
- 37:49you can waive the modification period. And then
- 37:54if modification is requested, the IRS will determine
- 38:01whether or not to allow the modifications, and
- 38:05they'll issue a modification determination package.
- 38:09And if the taxpayer disagrees with the modification
- 38:15determination, if the IRS does not allow the
- 38:19modifications or only allows them in part, the
- 38:24PR can file a protest and go to appeals, challenging
- 38:30the IRS's modification determination. And then
- 38:36once, and at the end of that, the partnership
- 38:41representative can agree to modifications, can
- 38:46waive the notice, the right to receive a FPA
- 38:50notice. in which case that would end the case
- 38:54and then the IRS would basically either assess
- 38:59the partnership or if the partnership has elected
- 39:02a push -out election do the push -out election?
- 39:05No. No. You have to have an FPAW to make a push
- 39:09-out election. Okay. So if you sign the NOPA
- 39:13agreeing to the adjustments, if you read what
- 39:16you actually sign, it'll say, I'm consenting
- 39:18to the assessment and collection of the imputed
- 39:20underpayment determined in the NOPA. You have
- 39:22to have an FPAW to push out. So if you want to
- 39:24push out, don't sign that. So you can get an
- 39:30FPAW so that you can make a push -out election.
- 39:34Just go ahead, read it before you sign it, but
- 39:37you have to have an FPAH in order to make the
- 39:39push -out election. I thought in the IRM there
- 39:44was provision that you can sign the FPAH, the
- 39:4715027, the modification document. With the FPAH,
- 39:53that comes with the FPAH. Okay. So the FPAH is
- 39:57letter... I think 5933, it's form 15027 and the
- 40:05886A. So if you receive the FPA, you can make
- 40:09the election within the 45 days and you can sign
- 40:11the 15027. But you have to make that, or you
- 40:16could just default. I think the. Let me look
- 40:20at the back end of the 15027, but you get the
- 40:2415027 at two different points in the audit. You
- 40:27get it if you've requested modification of the
- 40:29imputed underpayment. You'll get it when the
- 40:31IRS makes the termination as to the modifications
- 40:37that you requested, and it's part of the FPAL.
- 40:40So it's gonna show you the adjustments that are
- 40:43being made, as well as the... I have the 15027
- 40:47here, as well as the modifications that have
- 40:51been approved. And so the last page. Okay, yeah,
- 41:08it doesn't say anything. So if you signed the
- 41:0915027, you're not waiving your right to request.
- 41:15make a push -out election, but you have to have
- 41:17an FPAW to make a push -out election. So if you
- 41:19don't get an FPAW, no push -out election. And
- 41:23you get 45 days after the FPAW is issued to make
- 41:26the push -out election, and then you have 90
- 41:29days after the FPAW is issued to file a petition
- 41:34with either the tax court the district court
- 41:37or the federal court court of federal claims
- 41:39and if you go to the district court of the court
- 41:41of federal claims you're required to make a deposit
- 41:44next slide okay a partnership is any adjustment
- 41:51to a partnership related item and basically it's
- 41:57a adjustment that is to a monetary money number,
- 42:03which can be - That's my term. Yeah, I know.
- 42:08It's official. It's basically any, if it's a
- 42:13- It's got a dollar sign in front of it. Yeah,
- 42:18if it's got a dollar sign, it's a money adjustment.
- 42:22So if you go to the schedule K or K1 and there
- 42:28is an adjustment, to a liability, even though
- 42:32that is not something normally considered in
- 42:35determining the income deductions credits on
- 42:40the partnership. It will be an adjustment that
- 42:45can go into computation of the IU. A change to
- 42:51an asset can go into the computation of an IU,
- 42:55such as recharacterizing a changing what determining
- 43:01whether or not an asset is depreciable. If the
- 43:05partnership has purchased a piece of property
- 43:09with a building on it and allocated 90 percent
- 43:13of the purchase price to the building, the IRS
- 43:15goes in and says only 50 percent. of the purchase
- 43:19price is to the building, that's going to be
- 43:22a change that is going to be computed as part
- 43:27of the IU. So basically money numbers, things
- 43:31such as an adjustment as to the number of hours
- 43:35for the energy credit, that's not a money number.
- 43:39Whether an election was made was proper isn't
- 43:43a money number, but there are adjustments. However,
- 43:47the determination that an election was not valid
- 43:51can affect the money numbers on the returns.
- 43:55And similarly, a change as to the number of kilowatt
- 43:59hours for the energy credit could affect money
- 44:03numbers. Next slide. Oh, and back, can we go
- 44:09back to the bottom? of the prior slide. It doesn't
- 44:15matter whether or not a partner would have paid
- 44:17tax on the adjustment had it appeared on the
- 44:21return. If it's an adjustment to a money number,
- 44:24it is going to be taken into account in computing
- 44:29the IU. And so if you have normally, you wouldn't
- 44:36consider the how liabilities are characterized
- 44:44on the Schedule K -1 as being a number, money
- 44:48number, but if there is a relocation of a liability
- 44:53from recourse to non -recourse, that is going,
- 44:57could change the tax liability of one or more
- 45:01of the partners because the partners may no longer,
- 45:05may have not be at risk. So then there are positive
- 45:11and negative adjustments which go into the imputed
- 45:15underpayments. And under the regulations, under
- 45:19the BBA, the negative adjustments are any item
- 45:25that will decrease an item of income or increase
- 45:30a credit. And so an increase in an expense is
- 45:34a negative adjustment. A decrease in capital
- 45:37gains is a negative adjustment. A decrease in
- 45:40ordinary income is a negative adjustment. An
- 45:44increase in a capital loss is a negative adjustment.
- 45:50An increase in a credit is a negative adjustment.
- 45:54And you could have a offsetting Negative adjustment.
- 45:59Any other adjustment is going to be a positive
- 46:02adjustment. So if you increase a capital gain
- 46:09and reduce ordinary income, you're going to have
- 46:12a negative adjustment to ordinary income, but
- 46:16a positive adjustment to an increase in capital
- 46:19gains. Now then, below are the examples of some
- 46:26of the positive adjustments. As we mentioned,
- 46:30an increase in ordinary income, decreasing expenses,
- 46:34decreasing capital losses, increasing capital
- 46:39gains, decreasing credit credits, adjustments
- 46:42to non -income items. Those are not negative
- 46:46adjustments. Next slide, please. And I'm going
- 46:49to hand it off to Jenny. I just want to make
- 46:52I know a lot of people like to think of the adjustments
- 46:55as taxpayer favorable and taxpayer unfavorable.
- 47:00I highly recommend you don't do that. Use the
- 47:04definitions of positive and negative adjustments
- 47:06because not thinking of things as taxpayer favorable
- 47:10tech is unfavorable will not get you to the right
- 47:12answer in all cases. In addition some some adjustments
- 47:16can be favorable for one partner but unfavorable
- 47:19for another so I I know people do it. I hear
- 47:22it a lot. I always say think of them, use the
- 47:25definitions of positive and negative adjustments
- 47:27because otherwise you may end up in a situation
- 47:30where you've gotten it wrong because of using
- 47:33the term taxpayer favorable and unfavorable.
- 47:37Now moving on to choices. So BBA is really a
- 47:41regime of partnership choices. There are three
- 47:44major choices that the partnership can make in
- 47:47BBA audits. They can be, for the most part, mixed
- 47:50and matched up. For example, you can pay an imputed
- 47:55underpayment with respect to some adjustments
- 47:57and push out with respect to others if you do
- 47:59multiple imputed underpayments, which you can
- 48:01do. This is a thing I've been talking about a
- 48:06lot lately because I don't think that people
- 48:08really... go through the analysis of what these
- 48:12particular options are for their clients. And
- 48:14they all, I'm always going to push out. And I
- 48:17go, well, what do you mean you're always going
- 48:18to push out? So if the impeded underpayment's
- 48:21100 ,000 and your partners would have paid $80
- 48:25,000 in tax on the adjustments if you push out,
- 48:29and it costs you $30 ,000 to issue those statements,
- 48:33then you could still. free country, you're welcome
- 48:36to push out, but you've just made a poor economic
- 48:38decision where there's more cash going out of
- 48:40pocket than it would have been if you'd paid
- 48:42the imputed underpayment. Personally, I think
- 48:46understanding the choices under BBA and then
- 48:49the and what each one of them do and what you
- 48:53can do with each one of them is probably the
- 48:55most important thing in BBA. These all come up
- 48:58during exam, except for pushout, which is right
- 49:00at the end once the FPOS is issued. Because you
- 49:02need to be able to advise your client on what
- 49:05the best option is for your client for that particular
- 49:08circumstance. And there's not one right answer.
- 49:12It's always going to depend. And it can depend
- 49:16on the audit. what may be the right answer for
- 49:19the client in audit of 2020 may not be the right
- 49:23option for the client and an audit of 2022. So
- 49:26I think this is probably the most important thing
- 49:29that you need to understand for BBA is that there
- 49:31are multiple choices within BBA. They do not
- 49:35have the same end result. So it's not like you
- 49:38can pick one, whichever one you pick, you end
- 49:40up in the same place. No, they all have different
- 49:43end results. So, and that's... That's intentional
- 49:46and BBA. And so, you know, that's why it's so
- 49:50important for you to understand what the choices
- 49:52are. So the three major choices. You can pay
- 49:55the imputed underpayment, calculate on the adjustments.
- 49:59is a partnership level tax. It is not a partner
- 50:02tax. It is not calculated by any shape or form
- 50:05relative to partner tax. It has its own separate
- 50:07calculation, which we'll get into when we move
- 50:10to the next slide. You can request to modify
- 50:12the imputed underpayment as Robert kind of went
- 50:14into. At that point, you can take into account
- 50:17the partner's facts and circumstances. it must
- 50:21be requested by the partnership. And there's
- 50:25specific types of modifications that can be requested.
- 50:28Again, I kind of mentioned, and then you can
- 50:30like to push out adjustments. So those are the
- 50:32three major choices that you have. The IRS can't
- 50:35take away any of these choices. These are always
- 50:37gonna be your choices unless you wave the FPAW
- 50:40and then you don't get it and then you can't
- 50:41push out, but that's a choice that you've made.
- 50:44So it's important to... realize that it's not
- 50:47always one right answer, and you really need
- 50:49to look at the facts and circumstances of a particular
- 50:51situation. Next slide, please. So here is a very
- 50:58basic, you know, unputed underpayment calculation.
- 51:02It can get complicated, but for the most part,
- 51:06this is really it. It's lawyer math. So first,
- 51:11you appropriately net the adjustments. Then you
- 51:14multiply them by the highest rate under Section
- 51:161 or 11, right now that's Section 1, 37%, plus
- 51:20or minus adjustments to credits equals imputed
- 51:22underpayment. Basic math. So what does it mean
- 51:25to appropriately net the adjustments? Well, for
- 51:28the most part, if they will net on the Schedule
- 51:31K, then they will net in the calculation of the
- 51:34imputed underpayment. So Robert gave an example
- 51:36earlier where if you had an increase to ordinary
- 51:40income and a decrease to capital gain, those
- 51:44two things aren't going to offset each other.
- 51:50because they are separately stated items. Otherwise,
- 51:53you could report everything as an ordinary loss
- 51:55and even though it should be capital and like
- 51:57there would be no consequence because the two
- 52:00adjustments would offset. So they can only be
- 52:03netted if they would net on the partnership return.
- 52:05That's the general. I would go by that. Usually
- 52:08the IRS, when you look at the forms that the
- 52:11IRS gives you, like the 14791, 14792, 15027,
- 52:17they will group adjustments by the line item
- 52:20on the schedule K, or the schedule L, or I'm
- 52:24assuming the K2. I don't pretend to know much
- 52:27about the K2. what you should look at as well.
- 52:31So like if you increased ordinary supplies and
- 52:36professional fees, those all net into schedule
- 52:39K line one. So those two things would net in
- 52:42your calculation of the imputed underpayment.
- 52:44But if it won't net on the partnership return,
- 52:47if it's required to be separately stated for
- 52:49any reason, then it's not gonna net. And so the
- 52:55adjustments to credits, If you have an increase
- 53:00in credits, which would be a negative adjustment,
- 53:06then basically if you have an increase in credits,
- 53:10I mean decrease in credits, sorry, I hate credits
- 53:12because it's the opposite. If you decrease credits,
- 53:17That's a positive adjustment and that will add
- 53:19to the impeded underpayment. But if it goes the
- 53:21other way, if you have a reduction in credits,
- 53:24it will not necessarily reduce the impeded underpayment.
- 53:27The IRS would need to determine that it should
- 53:30reduce the impeded underpayment. It's going to
- 53:32depend on kind of what the credit is. Just be
- 53:37aware of that. So if you're doing an impeded
- 53:40underpayment calculation as part of a AAR, you
- 53:44won't be able to, if you have an increase in
- 53:47credits, you won't be able to offset the IU because
- 53:49an IRS has to determine otherwise. And so now
- 53:53you kind of heard, we're talking about how like
- 53:57all adjustments to partnership related items,
- 53:59if they're money, go into the calculation, the
- 54:02impeded underpayment, which is not. at all, normally
- 54:05how income taxes work. There are certain types
- 54:07of things that are taxed, certain types of things
- 54:09that aren't taxed. Well, that's not true. BBA
- 54:11treats all adjustments the same. It doesn't matter
- 54:14what they are. They're all taxed exactly the
- 54:16same. You just add them all up, multiply by the
- 54:19highest rate. It doesn't matter what the underlying
- 54:22item is. It pretty much loses its character,
- 54:24kind of, except for the netting issues when you're
- 54:27calculating the impeded underpayment. Next slide,
- 54:30please. So that's why this rule exists. I call
- 54:35this a subsume rule. That's not anywhere in the
- 54:38regulations. It's in the original preamble to
- 54:41the regulations. But the IRS has the ability
- 54:45to treat some adjustments as zero solely for
- 54:48purposes of calculating the IU, if the effect
- 54:51of the adjustment is reflected in another adjustment.
- 54:54Now, there's really two parts to this rule under
- 54:56the regulation. There's what I refer to as the
- 54:59IRS rule, and then there's the general rule.
- 55:02For this particular one, where the effect of
- 55:06an adjustment is reflected in another adjustment,
- 55:08the IRS has discretion to do that. They still
- 55:12make the adjustment, but it's just treated as
- 55:14zero as part of the IU calculation. It doesn't
- 55:18become an adjustment that does not result in
- 55:21an imputed underpayment. It's very broad authority,
- 55:24discretionary on part of the IRS. In the IRM,
- 55:28you'll see some examples of situations where
- 55:30it directs agents to use this rule. Oftentimes,
- 55:35if they increase ordinary income by $100, which
- 55:38also results in an increase in net earnings and
- 55:41self -employment and an increase in QBI, they'll
- 55:44treat the net earnings and self -employment and
- 55:46the QBI adjustments as zero because they only
- 55:49occurred because of that adjustment to the net
- 55:51ordinary income. Now, like all the cases that
- 55:55they're in court right now, if you didn't put
- 55:57your net earnings and self -employment at zero
- 55:59there, if they just adjust net earnings and self
- 56:03-employment, they're not gonna treat it as zero.
- 56:06But then the second part of the rule, second
- 56:08sentence in the rule, the general rule as I call
- 56:11it, it really says generally in the regulation.
- 56:14It says if you have a positive adjustment that
- 56:17is related to or results from another positive
- 56:20adjustment, one of those positive adjustments
- 56:22will generally be treated as zero unless the
- 56:25IRS determines otherwise. So you can kind of
- 56:27see related to or results from is narrower than
- 56:30reflected in. Really, I think honestly that that
- 56:33first part of the rule, the IRS has discretion
- 56:35to treat any adjustment it wants to as zero,
- 56:37as long as it determines it makes sense to do
- 56:39so, because reflected in is very subjective.
- 56:42But related to and result from is a little bit
- 56:44more objective. It's kind of a but for causation
- 56:46test. And so you have to have two positive adjustments
- 56:50for this to work. Whereas in the first part of
- 56:52the rule with the IRS discretion, there's no
- 56:54requirement that there be positive adjustments.
- 56:56You can treat negative adjustments as zero. In
- 56:59fact, there's actually an example in the IRM
- 57:01of where that would happen. I don't remember
- 57:04what it is off the top of my head. If you'd asked
- 57:08me yesterday, I probably would remember, but
- 57:09now I don't. The second part of the rule, this
- 57:14general rule, if you have two positive adjustments,
- 57:17which are related to a result from one another,
- 57:19treating one as zero, partnerships can utilize
- 57:21this rule themselves. If they're doing an AR
- 57:25and they want to pay the impediment or payment,
- 57:27they're calculating, they can use this part of
- 57:28the rule when they calculate that. And you can
- 57:31treat more than one adjustment as zero. In my
- 57:34example I just gave a minute ago where you increase
- 57:36ordinary income and it... or ordinary income
- 57:41increase also results in an increase in net earnings
- 57:43of self -employment and an increase in QBI. In
- 57:46the example here I have in the slide, they're
- 57:48different amounts just to demonstrate that they
- 57:49don't have to be the same number. It doesn't
- 57:51have to be $100 across the board. It can be 100
- 57:54for ordinary income and 50 to QBI, 75 to net
- 57:57earnings of self -employment. It doesn't matter.
- 57:58They don't have to be the same amount. But they
- 58:01are all related to results from each other. So
- 58:03in this particular example, you would treat the
- 58:05QBI and the net earnings of self -employment
- 58:07as zero, because they relate to a result from
- 58:10the adjustment to the ordinary income. Now, you're
- 58:14like, oh, well, unless the IRS determined otherwise,
- 58:16they're always going to determine otherwise,
- 58:18right? I would say no. You know, it's a kind
- 58:23of general rule. General rules generally apply.
- 58:27And so, in my view, it needs to be a reason why
- 58:30it shouldn't be treated as zero. And situations
- 58:33I can think of where that might apply is if people
- 58:36are using it abusively. Like say, for example,
- 58:39you have two adjustments that relate to each
- 58:41other. One is $5 and one's a million dollars
- 58:44and you treat the million dollar adjustment as
- 58:45zero and the $5 adjustment as the subject to
- 58:50the IU. I could see the IRS determining otherwise
- 58:53in that case and I think it would be relatively
- 58:54justified. So if you're using it abusively, the
- 58:57IRS may determine otherwise, but it's not, I
- 59:00would never expect it to be a situation where
- 59:02it's like, I don't like you, therefore I'm gonna
- 59:04determine otherwise. Next slide, please. Adjustments
- 59:11that do not result in an impeded underpayment,
- 59:13ATD and R is how I like to write it because I
- 59:15got super lazy typing out adjustments that do
- 59:17not result in an IU. So after you've netted all
- 59:21your appropriately, netted all your adjustments,
- 59:24and we didn't go into groupings and subgroupings
- 59:27on this. That's way too deep for this presentation.
- 59:31Then if you end up with... Negative adjustments
- 59:35that can't net with anything else, those become
- 59:39adjustments that do not result in an IU and they
- 59:41have a specific treatment under BBA and it depends
- 59:44on which choice you've, which one of your choices
- 59:47you've picked. If you're paying the imputed underpayment,
- 59:49the partnership will take that adjustment into
- 59:53account on its adjustment year return. So in
- 59:55the example of you increase ordinary income and
- 59:58you decrease capital gain, debt reduction and
- 1:00:03capital gain is an adjustment that does not result
- 1:00:06and it will show up on the adjustment year return.
- 1:00:08They'll reduce their income or their capital
- 1:00:10gain on the adjustment year return and pay the
- 1:00:12imputed underpayment on the ordinary income.
- 1:00:15If there's a modification where partners are
- 1:00:16taking into account adjustments like amended
- 1:00:18return modification, the partners also take into
- 1:00:21account their allocable share of any adjustments
- 1:00:23that do not result to deny you. If you push out
- 1:00:26the The all adjustments go with it. So the adjustments
- 1:00:29that do not result and go get pushed out as well.
- 1:00:32And if you're doing an AR, if you have adjustments
- 1:00:34that do not result, they must be pushed out to
- 1:00:36the reviewed your partners. There's no choices.
- 1:00:38I think we're running low on time here. I'm going
- 1:00:42to turn it back over to Roberts to try to get
- 1:00:46the modification relatively quickly. OK, thank
- 1:00:51you, Jenny. Modification, basically the partnership.
- 1:00:54may request modification of the imputed underpayment,
- 1:00:59and it would have to submit Form 8940 through
- 1:01:03the IRS Electronic Porto. And this has to be
- 1:01:06done within 270 days after the NOPA is issued.
- 1:01:10But you can submit a Form 8984, the partnership,
- 1:01:15to request an extension. And it should be done
- 1:01:18in sufficient time so the IRS, if it approves
- 1:01:21the extension, can sign it. before the expiration
- 1:01:25of the 207 -day period. Now, normally, if there
- 1:01:30is a modification request, the normal procedure
- 1:01:33is that the partners for whom modification is
- 1:01:37sought, and it would be individual partners for
- 1:01:40whom you'd seek a modification, the partners
- 1:01:42would file an amended return for the reviewed
- 1:01:46year, taking into account all of the adjustments,
- 1:01:50regardless of whether they are included in the
- 1:01:53imputed underpayment. And they would then have
- 1:01:56to pay any tax, penalties, and interest if the
- 1:02:04modification results in additional tax. at the
- 1:02:09time when the modification is requested. Also,
- 1:02:15if there are changes to tax attributes, they
- 1:02:19would have to file amended returns for years
- 1:02:23affected by the changes. So if there is a reduction
- 1:02:27in a net operating loss due to the modification,
- 1:02:31then... there would have to be amended returns
- 1:02:35filed, and if necessary, additional tax paid
- 1:02:39for the years affected by the reduction of the
- 1:02:44net operating loss. Now then, the IRS, if it
- 1:02:48denies modifications, you can go to appeals.
- 1:02:53Now then, normally, the statute does not give
- 1:02:59anyone the power to force someone to make a modification.
- 1:03:05And with respect to modifications, where there
- 1:03:08is a reallocation of an item between two partners,
- 1:03:13such as they reallocate income from partner A
- 1:03:17to partner B, partner B whose income is reduced
- 1:03:22cannot file a modify. a modification unless partner
- 1:03:27A who got the additional income also files a
- 1:03:31modification. And then the modification request
- 1:03:35is made by the partnership and signed by the
- 1:03:38partnership rep. Next page. Yeah, we're going
- 1:03:41to have to decide how far we're going to go over
- 1:03:43because we have 34 slides in this deck and we're
- 1:03:46on slide 23. Yeah My recommendation is that we
- 1:03:51get through If we get through this modification
- 1:03:54slide real quick, I'll hit push out really briefly
- 1:03:57and And we can wrap up from that Okay. Well then
- 1:04:02the regulations list the types of modification
- 1:04:07that can be requested. There's a rate modification,
- 1:04:11such as C corporations are taxed at a lower rate
- 1:04:15than individuals. So if a partner is a C corporation,
- 1:04:19it can do a modification request, and it would
- 1:04:22pay lower tax than would be paid if the partner
- 1:04:29should pay the tax. Capital gains and qualified
- 1:04:32dividend adjustments. that are allocable to individuals
- 1:04:37and S corporations, they're going to be taxed
- 1:04:40at a lower rate than the ordinary income rate
- 1:04:42for individuals. Then if there is a tax exempt
- 1:04:46partner, you can seek a modification for the
- 1:04:49tax exempt partner. And to the extent that there
- 1:04:54is You know the tax exempt income will not be
- 1:05:00include will be excluded from calculation of
- 1:05:03the IU But if there's unrelated business taxable
- 1:05:07income of the tax exempt entity that will not
- 1:05:10that will still go into the calculation of the
- 1:05:13IU amended return Puin modification. This is
- 1:05:18where the partners file amended returns and take
- 1:05:21into account their share of adjustments number
- 1:05:24and composition or as Jenny says slice and dice
- 1:05:27and basically the example given in the regulation
- 1:05:32is a partnership with only two partners, both
- 1:05:37publicly traded C corporations where there are
- 1:05:40two rental properties that on the return are
- 1:05:43treated as separate activities. There is a positive
- 1:05:48adjustment increasing income to one and a negative
- 1:05:52adjustment increasing the loss to the other rental
- 1:05:56property. And if the partnership can substantiate
- 1:06:02the information that these are publicly traded
- 1:06:06partnerships and these should be treated as the
- 1:06:10same activity. They can net the increased loss
- 1:06:15of one property against the increased gain in
- 1:06:18the other. Then there are specified passive activity
- 1:06:21losses and those relate to publicly traded partnerships.
- 1:06:27There are modifications for regulated investment
- 1:06:37companies, RICs, and real estate investment trusts,
- 1:06:42and that is a partnership may request a modification
- 1:06:46based on deficiency dividends distributives under
- 1:06:51IRC section 860A by 860F by a relevant partner
- 1:06:57that is a RIC or an REIT. There are treaty benefits
- 1:07:01and that is if a partner is a foreign individual
- 1:07:05and under a treaty income tax treaty between
- 1:07:09the IRS and that individual's company the income
- 1:07:16would be taxed at either a lower rate or would
- 1:07:21be exempt from tax, then that can be taken into
- 1:07:25account in a modification. Similarly, if there
- 1:07:29is a closing agreement between either the partnership
- 1:07:32or a partner, which treats a partnership related
- 1:07:38item and the amount paid. of any additional taxes
- 1:07:43paid. You can request a modification based on
- 1:07:46the closing agreement. And then a partnership
- 1:07:49can request a modification based on any other
- 1:07:53reason. And then the modifications have to be
- 1:07:58approved by the IRS. And the partnership has
- 1:08:04to provide All of the required information to
- 1:08:08substantiate that the modification is appropriate
- 1:08:12and the partners and they have to include a declaration
- 1:08:16from the partners who filed amended returns that
- 1:08:20they have filed the returns and paid the tax
- 1:08:25both for the reviewed year and any affected year.
- 1:08:29And if the partnership is using the alternate
- 1:08:32method, they have to get a statement. that the
- 1:08:39relevant partners have agreed to take into account
- 1:08:43adjustments to any tax attributes. And that is
- 1:08:48it for modification types. All right, let's go
- 1:08:52ahead. Which real quick over to 2026 as a visual
- 1:08:56while I cover pushout super quick and then we'll
- 1:08:58have to just call it there. So as I kind of mentioned
- 1:09:02before, you have to have an FPAH in order to
- 1:09:03make a pushout election. You do that on form
- 1:09:0689 -88. You have to be electronically submitted
- 1:09:08to the portal. That happens during the exam.
- 1:09:12The PR has to sign the pushout election. Once
- 1:09:14the adjustments become finally determined, i
- 1:09:17.e. that either was a final court decision or
- 1:09:19the FPAL defaults, the partnership has 60 days
- 1:09:22to issue the push -out statements to its partners.
- 1:09:24That's Form 8986, and there's a transmittal that
- 1:09:27goes along with it, Form 8985. Once the partners
- 1:09:31receive those push -out statements, there's one
- 1:09:34of two options that happens. If the partner is
- 1:09:37a tax -paying entity, like a C -corp or an individual,
- 1:09:40partners will calculate what their change in
- 1:09:43tax for the year under audit would have been
- 1:09:45if they had properly reported those items to
- 1:09:48begin with. And that increase or decrease in
- 1:09:50tax is an increase or decrease in their current
- 1:09:53year tax. I'm just gonna say current year. It's
- 1:09:56the year in which the statements are furnished.
- 1:09:58But more than likely, it's gonna be on your next
- 1:10:00filed return. And if it's a pass -through partner
- 1:10:04such as another partnership, that pass -through
- 1:10:06partner must issue its own statements to its
- 1:10:08partners. And if it does not do that timely,
- 1:10:12then it has to pay an imputed underpayment calculated
- 1:10:15on those adjustments. Now, the problem with tiers
- 1:10:17is that every single tier has the same due date.
- 1:10:20All tiers must either push out or pay by the
- 1:10:23extended due date of the audited partnership's
- 1:10:26adjustment year return. So if the court decision
- 1:10:28became final today, 2025 is the adjustment year,
- 1:10:32so that means all pass -through partners all
- 1:10:35the way up the chain have until September 15,
- 1:10:382026, regardless of whether or not the audited
- 1:10:41partnership has to file or files and extension
- 1:10:44has until that date. So if you are a pass -through
- 1:10:46partner and you receive one of these statements,
- 1:10:49be kind to those above you and get that done
- 1:10:51as soon as possible because if you leave that
- 1:10:53person... four tiers up, holding the bag at the
- 1:10:55last because they get their statement like the
- 1:10:58day before the end of the due date and they have
- 1:11:00to pay the IE, they're not going to be happy
- 1:11:02with you. So be kind, don't procrastinate. So
- 1:11:08if you go to the rest of the slides, you'll see
- 1:11:10we have a slide that goes through some of the
- 1:11:13costs and benefits of each particular choice.
- 1:11:16I kind of said earlier that I think that knowing
- 1:11:18these choices is probably the most important
- 1:11:20thing that you can get out of BBA. It goes into
- 1:11:24a few other things, but we are already 10 minutes
- 1:11:27over. For me, it's 440 in the afternoon. I know
- 1:11:32for you guys it's a lot earlier, but I'm on the
- 1:11:35East Coast. I think we're going to call it there.
- 1:11:38If there's any questions, you can feel free to
- 1:11:41reach out to one of us. Our contact information
- 1:11:44is on the first couple of slides. I hope you
- 1:11:49enjoyed the presentation and to VBA. All right.
- 1:11:55This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 1:11:57both for taking the time out of your day to share
- 1:12:00with our members. And thank you so much to our
- 1:12:02audience. Have a good afternoon, everybody. Thank
- 1:12:05you. You may be eligible for CLE credit in your
- 1:12:08state. Visit bhba .org slash podcasts for more
- 1:12:12information.