Latest / In My Kitchen with Paula / Beyond the Plate: Communicating Across Cultures
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Paula Mohamed, and welcome to In My Kitchen with Paula.
- 0:04This podcast is a gathering place for culinary adventures who love to travel.
- 0:09Every week, we'll come together with chefs, cookbook authors, talented home cooks, and everyone in between to talk about their story and their unique dish.
- 0:18Using food as the vehicle, we'll take a ride into the ins and outs of their culture and country.
- 0:23Come on, let's get this party started.
- 0:27Hey everybody, I have some food for thought to share with you today.
- 0:31Uh, this past week I have had my head in Portugal as I curate two upcoming episodes, one specifically around the Alentejo region with a really interesting guest, Alfredo, from Freijo do Maio.
- 0:44Alfredo and I have been speaking on the phone and it's got me thinking more and more about communicating with people from other countries.
- 0:52So, And how important it is that we recognize that we all have different communication styles.
- 0:57And as someone who loves to travel and explore culture through food and other vehicles, I see it almost like a dance where I'm the one that waits, watches, and listens to recognize the style of the person that I'm interacting with, and then I take their lead.
- 1:14Have you ever been traveling in another country where you've asked a question and you're sure they're saying yes to your request or question, but in actual fact, you realize later it is a no, or they say they understand what you said, but they definitely didn't.
- 1:30Um, these are experiences that I have done.
- 1:32definitely had, and I hope in this short episode, I can bring some awareness around the idea that you can have stronger connections to the people you meet in your travels by understanding the communication style of the country that you are going to.
- 1:48It can affect your experience from asking for directions, to having conversations with people you meet, to shopping at the local markets, or asking for clarity on a specific topic.
- 2:00Through my practical experience with In My Kitchen, from starting the business and then evolving it through the pandemic, I had the opportunity to communicate with people from a variety of cultural backgrounds, uh, from doing business together, recipe developing, going through a vetting process together, providing feedback.
- 2:21Receiving feedback.
- 2:23I learned quickly how to navigate the different communication styles, and I feel so lucky to have had these experiences, and I recognize the unique position it puts me in, and I want to share what I have learned with you.
- 2:36It was all of these interactions, like interacting for different purposes, uh, communicating with, people from different countries, facilitating actually over about a hundred different online cultural culinary experiences during the pandemic where, you know, the silver lining was of that time.
- 2:55I actually really gained an awareness of how to be mindful in how we communicate with people from different countries than our own.
- 3:04So just to give some background on the early days of In My Kitchen, because I'm not sure how many of you, experienced In My Kitchen in the beginning or are aware of how we started.
- 3:13I was recruiting the best home cooks from diverse cultures to provide In My Kitchen culinary experiences in their homes.
- 3:22And what looked like, what this looked like is, I would find them or they would find me and there would be a an email exchange, and then a phone call, and then we would meet.
- 3:32I had a very specific vetting process, and it was done strategically to be step by step.
- 3:39And I did that so the potential host could have an opportunity to slowly savor what was happening.
- 3:50ruminate on it, think about if this was a good fit for them and move on to the next step before they had to really commit into the tryout that is much more involved.
- 4:01And it also gave me a chance to really determine if this was going to be a good fit for In My Kitchen.
- 4:08So we had the email exchange, coffee, a phone call before that, then a coffee.
- 4:13Then I would actually go to their home to see if the space was suitable to host six people for a culinary event.
- 4:20And then they would be invited to do an In My Kitchen tryout where myself and three to four In My Kitchen selection committee members, aka good friends and family, would go to their home and we would have a two hour culinary experience cooking together and eating together.
- 4:37How great is that, eh?
- 4:38I mean, that's a whole other story about how wonderful that was.
- 4:42Um, but I would actually curate a menu in advance with the potential host.
- 4:47In My Kitchen would pay for the ingredients.
- 4:48It had to fit into our standard budget price points.
- 4:52And we were basically vetting the host at this point and a potential menu that we would use.
- 4:58And then after all of that, there would be the moment of, yes, you're in, or sorry, it is not a good fit.
- 5:05And just to give you an example, when we were at our peak, uh, just before the pandemic, we had hosts from countries, let me think now, we had Spain, Japan, Qatar, Taiwan, Mexico, Trinidad, Finland, Raymond, of course, from Vietnam.
- 5:23Italy, um, oh, Iran, Leila from Iran.
- 5:27And I know there were at least two more that I can't think of at the moment, but I'm sure you can see that through this process there was a minefield of sensitive interactions.
- 5:38How do you tell someone their home is not suitable?
- 5:41Right?
- 5:41I mean, that could be very awkward.
- 5:43And it wasn't that we were looking for anything grandiose or big, fancy, quite the opposite.
- 5:50It just needed to be configured in a way that would be conducive to having six people there for hands on cooking experience and a sit down, let's eat together type experience.
- 6:03How does someone go through this process only to have the selection committee determine It is not the right fit.
- 6:10And how do you curate menus with someone where your goal is to create a menu that is balancing an interactive hands on experience with dishes that also tell the stories of the host and explore the culture, where oftentimes the host is thinking more about their favorite recipes and their favorite dishes that they want to share, and it could be a, uh, a beautiful stew, but it takes 24 hours.
- 6:38Cooking on a very low heat.
- 6:40Right?
- 6:40So there is these mind fields, if you will, that I was navigating.
- 6:47I quickly recognized that my favored way of communicating, which fit beautifully during my event production career, being direct and concise, wasn't going to work in all of these situations.
- 7:00Looking back, if I had not recognized that right away, that I needed to adjust my communication style.
- 7:05I probably, I know I would have offended some people inadvertently and that would just, that would, oh, that would just make me feel awful.
- 7:12I, I, I would not want that to happen.
- 7:17As you know, if you've been listening to our podcasts and participated in In My Kitchen events, I am passionate about connecting across cultures.
- 7:25It helps us to understand each other and our world.
- 7:29And it's why I started In My Kitchen.
- 7:31And when we're eating together and cooking together, I think it takes the pressure off our, of what our differences are in how we communicate.
- 7:39It bridges those gaps beautifully.
- 7:42And that is why I love using food as a vehicle to create connection.
- 7:47But we can't be cooking and eating together all the time.
- 7:51And when I started this podcast show and interviewing people from diverse cultural backgrounds, other countries, I knew being curious would not be enough.
- 8:02I feel I have a responsibility to be an excellent cultural communicator or communicating across cultures and make my guests feel comfortable and trust me as that is going to make a better experience for everyone, including you, my listeners.
- 8:18So this has led me to pair my practical experience and my own research, so to speak, from In My Kitchen with evidence based studies of well being, creating connections and intercultural communication.
- 8:33And this learning is still continuing and probably will never stop.
- 8:37Uh, actually currently I'm reading the book Culture Map by Erin Meyer, focused more on doing business across cultures, but you can, you know, what I'm talking about now and what she talks about in her book, they can cross.
- 8:51how you use them from business to travel to teaching crosses many platforms.
- 8:58Anyway, this book was recommended to me by one of our next podcast guests, Lara Victoria, and I'm only halfway through the book and so far I would definitely recommend this to anyone that wants to learn more about how people think, lead, and get things done across cultures.
- 9:15This book, uh, takes what I knew intuitively when I started in my kitchen and has literally mapped out the communication styles of countries on a low context to high context communication index.
- 9:29It's really interesting.
- 9:30So I knew through my, when I was started in my kitchen that I would be conversing with people.
- 9:36from different cultures, obviously different countries and needed to be sensitive to what I said and what I heard and be mindful of how we communicated and converse.
- 9:47Uh, so basically what Myers has done is these countries sit on an index or a scale where some are low context communicators and some are high context communicators.
- 9:57So low context would be like Canada, the US, Australia, we're, we're very direct, very concise.
- 10:04We follow up meetings with email summaries and high context is, as you can probably guess, is like China, uh, Japan, Spain.
- 10:15Portugal, where there's a lot more being communicated, not just in the words, but also in the what's not being said, and in the spaces in between the sentences, and the physical gestures and facial tones as well.
- 10:30It's, it's so much more complex.
- 10:32So after my experience with In My Kitchen and what I've been learning more recently in the fields of positive psychology and intercultural communication, I can confidently say, just as a caveat to everything, that no matter what, And like in all communication, kindness and respect will always prevail.
- 10:50If you show you are trying to understand and are not projecting your way as the right way all the time, I can promise you, you'll have a positive connection.
- 10:59The key though, is you may not get all the information you need and you may not obtain the outcomes you were hoping for.
- 11:07I am sure none of us want to end up inadvertently offending someone, right?
- 11:12So, uh, here's an example of something that Myers shares in her book, Culture Map, that shows how we can offend somebody.
- 11:24There is a meeting and people are in attendance from a variety of countries.
- 11:28After the meeting, an email is sent out recapping who is responsible for what action items.
- 11:34For those of us listening from Canada or the US, this sounds pretty standard and expected, right?
- 11:40However, from some countries who have a rich oral tradition and written word is less necessary, this email can actually be taken as an insult as they are thinking, according to Myers, Don't you think I know this?
- 11:53Don't you trust that I'm going to get this done?
- 11:56Why are you micromanaging me?
- 11:58Countries that have this style of communication are an example of high context communication countries like China, Japan, Korea, Africa, Okay, so what do we do?
- 12:12So in this specific situation, it can be as simple as the person who's sending the email out recognizing that it's a group of people from different countries with different communication styles and saying something like, Hey, everyone, a lot of information was given out today.
- 12:33I'm not always able to pick it all up at once, hoping you can just review what I've written below.
- 12:39Let me know if I've missed anything.
- 12:40Really appreciate it.
- 12:41Thanks.
- 12:43And what that does, just a slight little deprecating, self deprecating comment, it takes the possible negativity that you could project out onto somebody else, onto yourself and alleviates any kind of misunderstandings and helps people understand the why behind what you're doing.
- 13:03When traveling or doing business or anything that requires communicating with people from other countries, what I have learned is it really helps the relationship or connecting with someone if you have some understanding of where that country sits on the culture map.
- 13:20High context and low context terminology comes from Myers, but you don't need to read the book necessarily to start gaining an awareness of this.
- 13:28Just listening to this episode is going to automatically make you more aware and mindful.
- 13:34It doesn't take much to uncover a country's communication style.
- 13:38Watch, listen, and ask.
- 13:41Like I said in the beginning, it's like dancing with somebody, but not taking the lead.
- 13:47For example, are they using lots of hand gestures?
- 13:49That is a good sign.
- 13:50They're probably a higher index communicator.
- 13:53Listen to how things are said and what is exactly said, or more importantly, what is not said.
- 13:58And then reframe your questions, requests, etc.
- 14:02accordingly.
- 14:03Here's an example, a personal example of what I mean.
- 14:06On a recent trip to Japan, I was visiting a little island called Ikuchijima.
- 14:12and stayed in this fabulous, place.
- 14:15And the manager was this lovely woman who was so gracious and I really felt I connected with her and I really enjoyed meeting her.
- 14:23When we were leaving, I stopped and spoke with her and I asked her if she'd be interested to be a podcast guest.
- 14:29I'd like to have her as a podcast guest on my, In My Kitchen with Paula show.
- 14:35She said she was honored that I asked and gave me her card.
- 14:38She was very appreciative and again, very gracious.
- 14:42And I assumed from the positivity and the tone of this exchange that she wanted to be on my show.
- 14:49Uh, when I got back to Vancouver, I emailed her and I did get a response.
- 14:53and it was lovely and positive.
- 14:56I don't know if you have experienced this, but, You can tell if somebody is a high index or low index communicator often in how they construct emails.
- 15:05So high index communicators, there will be some pleasantries and sincere interest in how you're doing and then get into the, the challenge.
- 15:14the business of things.
- 15:15More low index communicators, direct communicators.
- 15:20It's, uh, like no pleasantries and this can just dive right into the business.
- 15:26And it's not lost on me that we can take this conversation into different directions and, you know, is this something that men do more versus women?
- 15:36I don't know.
- 15:37People who are in business versus people who, maybe are in.
- 15:42The arts are different industries.
- 15:44I don't know.
- 15:45But for this purpose, I'm looking at this through the lens of communicating with countries that we're traveling to.
- 15:52Okay, so let's go back to my example.
- 15:54So she had very lovely pleasantries in the beginning.
- 15:58And again, my, you know, assumption was that she was interested in being on the podcast show.
- 16:04There was a sentence after the, pleasantries that said she was worried her English was not good enough.
- 16:11And I sort of glossed over that, carried on and, uh, But I couldn't get her to schedule a date or fill out the podcast guest form.
- 16:21Eventually I just let some time go by and I reached out again and then I never heard back from her.
- 16:26And I was so disappointed because I really enjoyed meeting her and I couldn't figure out where our conversation went wrong.
- 16:32At first I thought perhaps she has a lot of humility and is very, being very humble and I should have reached out more and more and really, explained to her how much I wanted her to be on the show.
- 16:45And then I recalled a conversation, actually podcast episodes that I had with Naomi.
- 16:50So Naomi was one of our original In My Kitchen hosts, and she's from Kobe, Japan.
- 16:56And, uh, Naomi in our podcast interview talked a lot about how the Japanese are raised to think about the group, not in the individual.
- 17:06So putting the group first and the needs and wants of the community or the group versus your own.
- 17:12And it's actually frowned upon to put yourself out there and to be individual.
- 17:17So I wondered if this played into what happened with my podcast request.
- 17:23Also, now when I look back on the conversation, When I asked her in person, as I was leaving the hotel, or it wasn't really a hotel, but where we were staying, she never actually, not once, did she actually say, yes, I'd like to stay here.
- 17:39to be on your podcast show.
- 17:40If you recall in the first exchange, she said she was honored to be asked and gave me her card.
- 17:47And then over email, she was telling me she was worried her English was not good enough.
- 17:53And that's very typical of, non direct communication is, or high index communicators, is adding in some sort of self deprecating comments, which could be, you know, is what she said was kind of a very polite way of saying no, which Naomi has also told me is very typical in Japanese culture to avoid saying no.
- 18:12And silence can actually speak volumes here.
- 18:15Anyway, as I said, we could analyze the scenario in many different ways, but looking at it through the lens of connecting through our travels with the people in the countries that we visit.
- 18:26I think it's important if you're interested to take some time to get to know the communication style of the country that you're going to.
- 18:34Another sort of aha moment for me I've had around this is thinking about my dad when he was alive and his business dealings.
- 18:42So my father was from Pakistan and his business was with the Japanese.
- 18:48Pakistan and Japan, both being Asian countries, have similarities in their communication styles.
- 18:54They both have indirect communication styles, according to Myers, meaning that there is a lot said that is not spoken.
- 19:01There is a high regard for elders, and I know this from my experience with my father and our relatives, and what my father taught me about his experience with the Japanese.
- 19:13Both India and Japan make an effort to save face.
- 19:17The following is a quote from the book by Brown and Levenson, Politeness, Some Universals in Language Usage, in both Japan and India.
- 19:27People tend to avoid public embarrassment and preserve the face of others, particularly those of higher status, through indirect language and nonverbal cues.
- 19:40So, I now realize that this is comparing Japan to India versus Pakistan, but I think the similarities cross the borders here.
- 19:48My point here is I often say jokingly, my father was more Japanese than he was Pakistani.
- 19:54And in actual fact, I wasn't that far off.
- 19:57In terms of communication, they are very similar.
- 20:01I realize now that my dad's success in building such strong and lifelong relationships with his Japanese customers is most likely due in large part to the comfort level in how they negotiated and negotiated.
- 20:14Communicated together a natural understanding of each other and an ease that built trust and respect quickly.
- 20:23Well, I hope this has given you some food for thought, and I'd love to know what your thoughts are around this episode.
- 20:30Feel free to carry on the conversation with me.
- 20:32I would love to chat to you.
- 20:33You can email me at paula@inmykitchen.ca or find me on Instagram at In My Kitchen, Paula.
- 20:42And if you enjoyed this episode, please provide a positive review on Apple Podcasts.
- 20:47You just go to the show, not the episode.
- 20:49You go to the show and click the three dots on the right.
- 20:52And it really helps me to get our podcast show out there to other culinary adventures like yourself.
- 20:59Have a look at the show notes.
- 21:00I'll put in the books that I referenced in there and, um, catch you on the next episode of In My Kitchen with Paula.
- 21:09Thanks for listening.