Latest / Making It in The Toy Industry / #313: Why Manufacturing in China Is Harder Than You Think (7 Challenges and How To Avoid Them)
Transcript
- 0:00If you think manufacturing your toy in China is as easy as finding a factory online sending over your idea and just waiting for samples to show up at your door I am about to burst your bubble my future toy person hey there toy people Azhelle Wade here and welcome back to another episode of making it in the Toy Industry this is a weekly podcast brought to you by the Toy Coach dot com today we are talking about manufacturing your toy in China and why it's not as easy as it looks online I get so many messages from people who found a factory sent over their idea and then just everything stalled and I want you to know exactly what you're walking into before you send that first email to a factory by the end of this episode you are gonna learn the seven things that make working with a factory in China so hard who you're really talking to why a factory will always say yes and how to protect your idea the language barrier color challenges distance your credibility so much more for every one of these challenges I'm gonna tell you how I get around it after working in the toy industry for over 16 years I've developed over 500 toys and games with dozens of factories across the globe today I have students in Toy Creators Academy and I work one on one with clients in my accelerator and studio programs I help them manage their factory relationships and product development process any one of these seven things can bring your toy development process to a screeching halt and when I get to number four I'm gonna share an embarrassing time in my young toy career one of these things happened to me it's very embarrassing challenge number one you never quite know who you're talking to when you reach out to a random factory you found online there is just no way to know if you're actually talking to someone at that factory you could be talking to a designer art toy factory in Shenzhen or a wooden toy factory in Ningbo or you might be talking to a sourcing agent in Hong Kong or you might be talking to a trading company in Guangzhou you might be thinking what's the difference well both a sourcing agent and a trading company are middlemen to your toy idea a sourcing agent is an individual consultant kind of like a freelance product manager that will introduce you to various factories coordinate development and charge a flat rate for that work and a surcharge on your production run or both now a trading company on the other hand is a group or a company that might look like a factory but they actually don't manufacture any product on the premises instead they buy and sell goods from multiple factories and resell it to their clients trading companies usually operate by adding a surcharge to your products per unit price and a large trading company may have several sourcing agents working for it now if you work with a sourcing agent or a trading company the biggest risk is that their fee may make the cost of your product unprofitable labor costs in China have been rising for years and that coupled with ever changing tariff rates means there's just less room in our margins for extra unnecessary expenses you simply may not be able to afford the two to four dollars per unit surcharge that working with a middleman might cost you not only that you also lose control you don't have direct contact with your factory so changes might take longer agreements may be muddy or confusing and if that agent decides it's time for a career change in the middle of developing your product you could be starting over from scratch or get passed on to a factory that barely speaks any English ask me how I know and if you're thinking oh Azhelle I vetted a factory online I saw their website there were photos of their factory floor they sent me images of products they make oh I'm so good Azhelle well to that I say bring a magnifying glass up to those photos AI has become a massive tool for less than impressive factories in China to build out impressive digital identities prior to the AI boom most factories didn't have websites at all and the few that did exist were super simple and dated and look like they were out of the 90s but today AI makes it so easy for any factory to put up a great looking website with photo realistic images of factory floors copy that speaks to you and even sample shots if it wasn't for my experience traveling to China and seeing factories in person I might not have been able to spot which of these factory site photos I saw were real and which were fake a beautiful website doesn't tell you anything anymore you really have to know who you're actually dealing with and the right questions to ask first things first if I am confident that a factory is sending me AI renderings of products or factory floor images I'm gonna just ask them to send me non AI rendered images and if they don't comply I ask for a video call and if they reject that then I reject them and I move on to another factory because that tells me they have something to hide second have a quality assurance agency research the company records in China's business registry and do a full vetting of the factory conditions in person I will link to my favorite agency in the description third you wanna look up their export records and you wanna see if they actually ship out toys and games and how much of their shipments are toys and games you can use a tool like Import Yeti to do that research and I cannot underestimate the importance of that research I once looked into a supplier that told one of my clients they made wooden toys and their export records showed that they were mostly shipping electronics orange flag they could ship both but mostly wooden toys and then one time I found out that 97% of the exports of a factory I was researching were of a competitor product which indicated to me that they were probably owned or partly owned by that brand that's why they primarily ship their product and do you want to produce your product in a factory owned by your competitor probably not because when your competitor goes to walk the factory floor to look at their production line what are they gonna see your product you can learn a lot from public import records the fourth thing to do is have your lawyer do a background check when prepping your NNN agreement the lawyer I use in China utilizes the business license of a factory to do company research and draft the NNN and his reports usually reveal underlying company structures like how I mentioned the factory might have a sourcing agent or a trading company but doing research like that is expensive especially when you have to check several factories and you don't even know where to start so my clients and creators inside of Toy Creators Academy do not start from scratch when they're looking for factories I am sending them list of factories that I'm either actively using right now or that other clients of mine have used or that I've used in the past so that we already have an idea of which factories are best for which products and how they work plus my factory list is sorted by category Chef's kiss okay let's say you do all of your homework or you work with me and you finally find a real factory and they make exactly the kind of toy that you're making you're thinking oh I'm good I'm in the clear not so fast that is where we get to challenge number two the factory is always gonna say yes now just because a factory makes plush doesn't mean they're good for every kind of plush if you're making like a higher end plush and you're talking to a factory that's set up for a low cost cheaper plush product then they are still not a good match for you even though it says that they do plush on their website it's the same thing if you're like making an adult collectible doll and you're talking to a factory who primarily does action figures I mean yeah those are similar products and they likely do have the tools you need but will they know the details of eye types and hair types to create exactly the product that you want you really need to know what they're good at making because if you can avoid it you don't want to be their test dummy for a new product type the hard part is even a great factory wants your business and because they want your business they are going to say 100% yes even if they're only feeling like 80% confident and that might mean that sometimes they're outsourcing some of your project so you have to be aware that a factory has specialties and that if your product combines multiple materials or products from multiple specialties like wood parts digital components and books one factory likely won't produce all of that at the highest quality but if they still think they can produce your core product they're gonna say yes so you have to ask the right questions for example instead of sending a rendering of your toy idea and your Bill of materials to your factory saying hey can you make this you do need to specifically ask can you produce all of these pieces in your factory and then list every piece in plain text if they can produce it they're usually gonna get like really specific about their machinery or they're gonna say yes or they're gonna ask for some details they will need to execute that but otherwise they will tell you we're gonna do this in house but these three things we're gonna have to outsource that's it that's just the answer you you just wanna know so you can gauge your expectations as far as different levels of and you wanna know who's actually handling your product alright next you might be wondering how do you vet a factory's capabilities before you have them sign an NNN which is a sort of an NDA in China well you wanna be careful with the kind of details that you share in the factory vetting process you should share the general product components or a competitor product when you're doing your initial vetting to find out if a factory can just manufacture something close to what you need you can do that prior to sending any confidential information that way there's a clear understanding of what your needs are without unnecessarily sending your super detailed spec to every single factory that you possibly could find when in the end out of the 10 you're only gonna work with one and this is where challenge number three comes in the third challenge is protecting your idea before you send it how do you protect your idea when you literally have to share all of its intimate details to get it manufactured there are a few key ways to protect your intellectual property when you're sharing it with a factory for development No. 1 trademark the name in the US and in China No. 2 patent your invention if it's patentable and No. 3 have the factory sign an NDA I know I've said NNN like four or five times so far in this video and I haven't yet explained what it is but we're gonna get to that now an NDN agreement drafted by a lawyer in China is gonna be written in Chinese and English I've seen many creators use standard NDAs with factories in China but what's this what's specific about an NNN is that it's designed to ban a factory from sharing your idea making it themselves or going around you to your customers to resell products they've made for you and so the acronym NDN stands for non disclosure non use non circumvention but since there's a high price tag on getting a lawyer in China to draft an NDN you don't want to do that for every factory you chat with only the one or two max that you intend to move forward with so one method to test the factory's capabilities and get initial costing is to explain your product without giving away any of the intellectual property so let's say you have a building set like a Lego and you explain the parts but you remove or hide maybe the patented connectors which might be the core intellectual property or let's say that you have some technology built into like a squishy toy but you only disclose the squishy separate from the technology inside it and you don't explain to the factory how they combine and how they work basically you have the factory quote all of your components kind of separately and almost underdeveloped parts before you reveal the secret sauce now this of course means that the quote won't be as accurate at all but it will give you the rough information or the last bit of information you may need before you choose which factory to move forward with also in sharing these parts of your idea a factory that really understands the material will ask for more specifics so if you're doing this with like three to five factories you'll see the way that they respond will tell you who is more informed in that method of production then once you know which one to two factories can actually deliver what you need that's when you invest in that N&N you get it signed you send over all of your factory specs for more accurate quoting now factory communication is time consuming work it's very detailed work and that's why it's a core task that I handle for all of my accelerator and studio clients one wrong email can turn a factory off of your project completely and having someone experienced on your team that's me can get you faster responses and get you taken much more seriously if you want to work with me one on one you are welcome to book a discovery call I will drop the link in the description so you've got a real factory it's the right factory their quotes are decent your idea is protected now you actually have to share your idea and start getting this product developed enter challenge No. 4 challenge No. 4 is the language barrier obvious one I know the language barrier is probably the most obvious challenge on this list assuming you speak English and that your factory is speaking Mandarin it's gonna be hard to communicate what you want and even harder to communicate why you want it that way and this barrier starts even before you talk about your toy because remember that business license I think I mentioned earlier in challenge one that thing is coming to you in full Chinese so you are gonna need to translate it just to understand that basic piece of information at all but the biggest place where the language barrier is gonna come into play is communicating your product idea and that is why it is so imperative that you share a detailed spec sheet or specification packet and a Bom so that your factory can understand what your product is and how it should work now once you get your first sample you are likely to have a ton of revisions and you will be tempted to write up one nice organized long email explaining all of your revisions one by one and i'mma tell you do not do that do not do it I Learned this lesson the hard way over 10 years ago when I was first starting out I was working on this friendship bracelet maker for a company called horizon I had all these revisions and I wrote the factory this super long email I thought I was being the most organized little worker bee I was so proud of myself I explain every single change I wanted in these numbered paragraphs that were just diatribes just I paragraph on top of paragraph I really thought it was a great detailed response I was very proud of it and a day later the factory responded but barely I think it was'cause at the time Google Translate wasn't really huge and they just were not going to read and translate all of that and they didn't I had to redo all of my work I Learned to keep my communication really simple and I Learned the correct way to Mark up sample photographs for a factory to understand what we needed the wrong way is to write a sonnet long email like I did back in what 2,012 the right way is to take photos of your product sample from every angle ruler in the shot and Mark up your requested changes photo by photo number them I like to put mine on a white box with red text I put arrows pointing to every detail area every change request then in your email to the factory list those same changes again reference the same numbers keep it super short and concise it's just like a reference email and don't use like vague words to make changes like make this bigger you wanna be like make this 2 cm taller from this point alright I want you to tell me in the comments if you've ever sent a factory a sonnet long email like I did just say guilty if that was you and then vow to never do it again alright there's also one thing that gets lost in translation more than words do and that is color baby so challenge number five is color when you are working with a factory you have to choose Pantone colors for everything you possibly can so the factory has something to exactly match colors to and I know what you're thinking I already picked my colors on my computer can I just send them the file no like maybe but no the color on your screen the color on their screen and then the color that's gonna print is they're all gonna be totally different and it's even worse if they're not printing it but they're supposed to reference it to paint something now there's a difference when a factory is actually printing Pantone spot colors which is very expensive versus using Pantone colors as a guide to match paint to there's also different types of like Pantone books and and there have been a lot of updates over the years so that is gonna have to get its own video but you can buy Pantone books and I will tell you it is worth it to buy a Pantone book you can get them used you don't have to buy them new they are that very expensive hundreds and thousands of dollars but you also can borrow them from your local library usually you can't take them out but you could use them there now if you're printing something like a package it's important that your artwork includes like a CMYK color guide that the factory can use to make sure that their printer is accurately printing the colors that you want also bonus tip never approve production off of a screen always get a print or get a sample even if it means you have to wait an extra two weeks to launch let's say you've got your right factory your ideas protected you know how to talk to them your colors are locked now you just have to reach them and they are on the other side of the world working opposite hours to you and oh they're also behind a digital firewall enter challenge number six the distance so China still has internet file firewalls that block apps that you probably use every day like zoom and Skype isn't even a thing anymore so the tools that have worked for me are Microsoft Teams but you're gonna have to pay for it WeChat and then 10 Cent Meeting which is my brand new go to video app now WhatsApp is still restricted but I find a lot of my counterparts are able to use a VPN and use WhatsApp just fine now we also have to recognize there is a time zone difference when your revisions really need a conversation I highly recommend a video call but a factory is gonna Wanna meet with you early in their morning which if you're in the US and on the eastern side that's gonna mean 7 or 8 or nine PM now when I worked full time in the toy industry I often did my factory calls at 8 or nine PM which means that factory workers are sometimes taking those calls from home before they head into the office cause it's that early for them now if you're in the UK this is gonna flip a little bit their early morning is the middle of your night so you might meet in your morning which is the end of their work day and if you're in Australia ugh you're lucky my my lucky Australian clients Sydney is only two or three hours ahead of China so you can actually meet during normal working hours how nice and then there are the holidays so I really highly recommend you put a Chinese holiday calendar on your own calendar right now because there are a lot of smaller holidays that you won't see coming and they will shut down your production process because they shut down the factory so to make it easy I actually built a free calendar with the Chinese holidays for 2026 and 2027 you can add it to your Google Calendar I will put the link to that in the description as well now when a factory shuts down it's not just that they're like off for those days nobody's working on projects for those days so a backlog of work is building up and then it's gonna take time for everyone to get back into the factory set up the machines and ramp up production all over again so you have to count all of that in your timeline alright if you're thinking this is a lot I don't wanna do this you are right it's a lot but you can do this but there is one more challenge that without overcoming this last challenge none of the other challenges matter and that is challenge number seven your credibility when you reach out to a factory for the first time they don't know who you are and if you don't approach them the right way they are not gonna think you are a serious business worth doing business with factories invest a lot of their time and their money and their team effort in the early stages of a relationship with you cause that is the sample stage and they are not doing that out of the goodness of their heart they're doing it so you will place a production order so if you come off as a small unimportant fish in a big pond they are not gonna prioritize responding to you or they may not work with you at all because they're not gonna believe that you're ever gonna place an order so even when I reach out to a factory contact for my clients in accelerator or in the studio I choose to reintroduce myself along with my credibility as you know it's ever growing and I wanna remind them because people at factories change roles and I'm reminding them of who I am and the last time we worked together just to make sure that they take this inquiry seriously and if you don't have a history like that and if you don't have a consultant bringing you in under high regard you are at a little bit of a disadvantage now most of the time a factory isn't charging you really appropriately for the amount of development time they're putting into your first sample so if you are developing a sample with no intention of making production or you and you disappear after the sample is created that is not gonna look good and likely that factory is not gonna want to work with you again and this is actually why we have conversations with every person who comes into the accelerator before they join it's because our factory contacts are really cherished they are protected so some of these people I've been working with since 2,016 I cannot risk anyone misusing those factories or abusing the dedication and the hard work that they put into developing a sample so yes you can absolutely do this on your own the right way one step at a time and if you have the tenacity to not give up you will get there or you can definitely come in with someone who's already has the relationships and jump the line that could be me helping you but either way I am so confident that you can do this so here's what we Learned today you never quite know who you're talking to especially now that AI can make any factory look good online so you've got to ask for real photos or have a video call or have a QA team check on them and look into their import export records the factory will always say yes so ask if they can make all of your product pieces protect your idea by having factories quote the parts without the secret sauce before you sign that NNN then we talked about keeping your communications simple and marking up your sample photos using Pantones to nail in on specific colors that you want how to plan around the firewall and the time zones and China holidays plus we talked about the importance of credibility here is your action item for the week I want you to put all of the China holidays on your calendar I'm gonna put the link in the show notes you can grab that it's just gonna make it so much easier for you to plan out your production schedule if you know when the factories will be taken off I know it's a lot to think about that is why I love working with clients who are launching their toy ideas if you want my eyes on your toy or game as you develop it you should also check out Toy Creators Academy it's a group coaching program where you learn how to do all of this and you can get me reviewing your work along the way or you might wanna work with me one on one in the accelerator so I can manage these conversations for you or you might wanna join the studio where my team just does all the heavy lifting for you and you just get to check in like the toy CEO that you are now before I can welcome you into any of those we do need to have a discovery call so the link to that is in the description and I look forward to meeting with you as always thank you so much for spending this time with me today I know your time is valuable and that there are a ton of podcasts out there so it truly means the world to me that you tune into this one until next week I'll see you later Toy Creator