Latest / Views and News with Clarence Ford / When workplace toxicity becomes a dismissible offence
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Exactly.
- 0:00Speaker 2: In a short while, we'll talk to Bradley Workman Davies.
- 0:04Speaker 2: He's a direct Atments attorneys, and he's recently highlighted a
- 0:08Speaker 2: very significant evolving shifting South African labor jurisprudence regarding workplace
- 0:14Speaker 2: toxicity and bullying. I think from our vantage point, it's
- 0:17Speaker 2: not necessarily things that you hear on air, but such
- 0:22Speaker 2: accounts we get anonymously. It appears on our what's app line,
- 0:29Speaker 2: and it maybe points to more toxic work spaces that
- 0:32Speaker 2: are existing at this moment in time. And they said
- 0:33Speaker 2: it would come. They said it would come, and we
- 0:37Speaker 2: are going to explore when workplace toxicity essentially becomes a
- 0:40Speaker 2: dismissible offense. We're going to have that conversation with Bradley
- 0:43Speaker 2: in a short while. Before we get there, you've been
- 0:45Speaker 2: active on the WhatsApp line, so let's just reflect your
- 0:48Speaker 2: mind in respect and in response to questions that we've
- 0:51Speaker 2: discussed a little earlier, there's one in from Obama. Let's
- 0:55Speaker 2: take a listen.
- 0:55Speaker 1: Joe.
- 0:56Speaker 3: I think it's so funny how they have this big
- 1:00Speaker 3: vote and they were all going on about it.
- 1:02Speaker 1: I remember because I took part in it. You know,
- 1:04Speaker 1: this is it. This is the final thing, and the.
- 1:06Speaker 4: EU you never even be allowed back in if you leave,
- 1:09Speaker 4: and all these strets and everything, and you know what
- 1:12Speaker 4: democratic country and the people voted and the answer was clear,
- 1:16Speaker 4: and then look what happens.
- 1:17Speaker 3: See this is the problem with like I hate you said,
- 1:21Speaker 3: but almost democratically, the labor side, the heavy democrats, the
- 1:28Speaker 3: work kind of people. They only accept majority rules and
- 1:32Speaker 3: democracy if it's the answer they want.
- 1:36Speaker 1: You know, now everyone's found it.
- 1:37Speaker 3: And all this going on about the extra migration, they're
- 1:41Speaker 3: not from the EU.
- 1:42Speaker 1: It has worked.
- 1:44Speaker 3: The other migrants are people coming for asylum and other
- 1:48Speaker 3: types of things.
- 1:49Speaker 1: We all know it's not from the EU.
- 1:51Speaker 3: So yeah, I don't understand why they're changing a process
- 1:56Speaker 3: or go voted. And it's almost like saying us saying in.
- 1:59Speaker 1: NIGHTE for all.
- 2:00Speaker 3: Well, I mean, Nason Mandela did get voted in by
- 2:03Speaker 3: the majority, but you know it's not really what the
- 2:07Speaker 3: other forty of us wanted, so we're not going to
- 2:10Speaker 3: honor it. It doesn't make sense. Why do you bother voting?
- 2:14Speaker 2: They only accept democracy when it is when I get
- 2:19Speaker 2: from it what they want. That's very interesting. There's so
- 2:21Speaker 2: much that you said in that in that one minute,
- 2:24Speaker 2: A little club Obama, thank you very much for it.
- 2:26Speaker 2: There's another one in from Florists Joe.
- 2:29Speaker 5: Clarence, who are morem and Floris is of Augusta. This
- 2:33Speaker 5: one Lucy Gigabe, this fothy guy who think that he's
- 2:38Speaker 5: the main Let me tell you he's calling for why
- 2:44Speaker 5: a march on March's not marching against white foreigners. Let
- 2:49Speaker 5: me tell you he himself is a beneficiary of illegal foreigners.
- 2:54Speaker 5: I work for foreigners, but they are a legal standing
- 2:58Speaker 5: in South Africa. They play Texas. Let me tell you.
- 3:01Speaker 5: I'm with them for eighteen years. They are taking much
- 3:05Speaker 5: better care than our own South Africans.
- 3:09Speaker 1: Let me tell you that.
- 3:11Speaker 5: So my Lucy Gagarbe can take his whatever and yeah
- 3:17Speaker 5: it may not implementent myself.
- 3:20Speaker 2: Take care whatever and whatever.
- 3:22Speaker 1: Lucy.
- 3:23Speaker 2: There you go from Flores out in Wooster. It is
- 3:27Speaker 2: ten thirty nine. Now we're going to chat to Bradley
- 3:29Speaker 2: work when Davis's director at Velopments. It's good to have
- 3:32Speaker 2: you with us, Bradley. Thank you for joining us.
- 3:35Speaker 6: Hi, good morning plans are you Bradley?
- 3:37Speaker 2: I suggested from my vantage point, maybe we are experiencing
- 3:43Speaker 2: more workplace toxicity at this time from your vantage point
- 3:49Speaker 2: in the legal business, Are you seeing that playthrough in
- 3:52Speaker 2: your offices as well, and I'm talking about clients now.
- 3:55Speaker 6: Yes, absolutely so we are definitely getting more requests from
- 4:00Speaker 6: clients and potential clients on how to deal with bullying,
- 4:03Speaker 6: workplace toxicity, harassment within the workplace. I don't think that
- 4:07Speaker 6: that's as a result of that conduct being more prevalent
- 4:10Speaker 6: in workplaces. I think it's simply as a result of
- 4:13Speaker 6: employees and people generally becoming more aware of their rights
- 4:16Speaker 6: to deal with that within the workplace, and in particular
- 4:20Speaker 6: an awareness of the protections that they've now got against
- 4:23Speaker 6: that kind of conduct in the workplace. I think primarily
- 4:26Speaker 6: because there was a recent promulgation of a Code of
- 4:30Speaker 6: a Good Practice in terms of Employment Equity Act. It
- 4:32Speaker 6: came out in about twenty twenty two, and that's the
- 4:35Speaker 6: Code of Good Practice on the prevention and elimination of
- 4:38Speaker 6: harassment in the workplaces, and that's for the first time
- 4:41Speaker 6: tried to define and delineate what kind of conduct would
- 4:45Speaker 6: contemplate or would constitute harassment. It's a very broad scope,
- 4:49Speaker 6: you know, physical harassment all the way up into unfortunately,
- 4:53Speaker 6: sexual harassment. Psychological harassment, mobbing, victimization, toxicity, bullying withholding of benefits,
- 5:00Speaker 6: if you're in sort of the vertical position of authority
- 5:04Speaker 6: you employee on employee harassment and so for the first time,
- 5:07Speaker 6: that code gives a very good framework for understanding what
- 5:11Speaker 6: is harassment and the broad scope of harassment, what constitutes
- 5:14Speaker 6: a workplace for example, and what sort of recourse you
- 5:18Speaker 6: as an employee have if you are the victim or
- 5:21Speaker 6: if you see that kind of conduct happening in the workplace.
- 5:24Speaker 6: So again, I think since the propagation of that code,
- 5:27Speaker 6: people have become more aware and I realized that there's
- 5:29Speaker 6: a framework within which that conduct should be dealt with.
- 5:33Speaker 6: And for that reason, you're starting to then see a
- 5:34Speaker 6: lot more queries. You're starting to see employers taking action
- 5:38Speaker 6: against that kind of conduct in the workplace, and then
- 5:40Speaker 6: of course you're starting to see those cases coming out
- 5:42Speaker 6: in the city man the labor courts.
- 5:44Speaker 2: I was in management and fast moving consumer goods, and
- 5:49Speaker 2: I think employers in the past maybe relied on it's
- 5:53Speaker 2: called a progressive discipline. I know that I did a
- 5:56Speaker 2: course in interactive management or was around counseling. It was,
- 5:59Speaker 2: but verbal warnings was written warnings for what we considered
- 6:04Speaker 2: inter what personal friction. But the Commission for Code, Conciliation, Mediation, arbitration,
- 6:12Speaker 2: and the labor courts are backing summary dismissal for toxic behavior.
- 6:17Speaker 2: Does this mean the intensity of such toxicity is increasing?
- 6:24Speaker 6: No, not necessarily. So this concept that you've mentioned of
- 6:27Speaker 6: progressive discipline is still going to have to apply because
- 6:30Speaker 6: if you have a look at an instance of conduct
- 6:32Speaker 6: which constitutes harassment in the workplace, and I think that's
- 6:35Speaker 6: the broader category within which you should look at it,
- 6:37Speaker 6: because that's what it's called in terms of this code again,
- 6:40Speaker 6: Code of Good Practice on the Prevention and Elimination of
- 6:42Speaker 6: Harassment in the Workplace, which then breaks down into those
- 6:45Speaker 6: various kinds of examples of where that can be evidenced.
- 6:48Speaker 6: But that still then should be dealt with by an
- 6:50Speaker 6: employer in terms of its disciplinary code or a general
- 6:54Speaker 6: disciplinary procedure that you would expect to see for a
- 6:56Speaker 6: fair process in terms of the lab Relations Act. So
- 7:00Speaker 6: as always with that overarching structure of is the imposition
- 7:03Speaker 6: of the discipline e sanption fair, you have to have
- 7:06Speaker 6: a look at, for example, is it a single isolated
- 7:08Speaker 6: incident of for example, in this case which came out now,
- 7:11Speaker 6: which is dealt with in the CTMA, it was the opposite.
- 7:14Speaker 6: It was a number of instances of harassment in respect
- 7:17Speaker 6: of a number of different colleagues and employees across an
- 7:21Speaker 6: extended period of time that were fairly significant, and then,
- 7:24Speaker 6: for example, taking into account their employees' lack of remorse
- 7:27Speaker 6: and lack of appreciation of why their conduct was problematic,
- 7:30Speaker 6: that would then obviously show you that it's a fairly extreme,
- 7:34Speaker 6: severe type of misconduct which could then be dealt with.
- 7:37Speaker 6: To say, the first instance where we become aware of
- 7:40Speaker 6: all of these issues and we go to a discipliney
- 7:42Speaker 6: process for the first time, well that should justify some redismissal.
- 7:46Speaker 6: But let's say there's a lesser incident of harassment which
- 7:50Speaker 6: can be dealt with more informally, where, for example, the
- 7:53Speaker 6: employee shows an appreciation of why their conduct inappropriate, shows remorse,
- 7:58Speaker 6: and undertakes not to conduct themselves in that manner as well,
- 8:00Speaker 6: you would expect that the discipline process might result in
- 8:04Speaker 6: a lesser sanction, some kind of a warning, some kind
- 8:06Speaker 6: of a portion, and then allowing the employees to continue
- 8:08Speaker 6: to be employed and show some kind of an improvement
- 8:11Speaker 6: as well, So it all depends on a case by
- 8:13Speaker 6: case basis. But having said that, Clarence, because under the
- 8:17Speaker 6: Employment Equity Act, an employer is actually vicariously liable for
- 8:22Speaker 6: the conduct of its employees who are potentially arrassing other employees,
- 8:26Speaker 6: even third parties, and if it fails to take the
- 8:28Speaker 6: appropriate steps, there's vicious liability on the part of the employer.
- 8:32Speaker 6: I think employers are generally treating it quite seriously and
- 8:35Speaker 6: potentially imposing quite severe discipline action in respect for these
- 8:39Speaker 6: instances when it becomes aware of them.
- 8:41Speaker 2: And I think some trends have been flagged on this
- 8:43Speaker 2: particular show trends to the effect that seventy percent of
- 8:47Speaker 2: the workspace will be populated by millennials by twenty thirty,
- 8:53Speaker 2: and a psychologist also estimating that that, yeah, we're going
- 8:59Speaker 2: to see more all kind of toxicity in the workspace
- 9:03Speaker 2: coming with that generational kind of assumption of economic action.
- 9:12Speaker 2: But specifically, you have noted that workplace bullying used an
- 9:16Speaker 2: occupied and uncomfortable I think you've called it an ambiguous
- 9:21Speaker 2: space in labor law. And I think the question that
- 9:23Speaker 2: I want to understand is what shifted to make the
- 9:25Speaker 2: CCMA and the labor courts that it takes such a hard,
- 9:29Speaker 2: maybe an uncompromising line as well on workplace toxicity.
- 9:34Speaker 6: So I think it does come about as a result
- 9:36Speaker 6: of this Code of Good Practice which was promulgated in
- 9:38Speaker 6: twenty twenty two and again just to pull back a level.
- 9:42Speaker 6: That's in terms of the Employment Equity Act, which has
- 9:44Speaker 6: got sections in sections five and six which talk about
- 9:47Speaker 6: the fact that in employerments obviously take action to prevent
- 9:50Speaker 6: unfair discrimination in the workplace, and that of course is
- 9:53Speaker 6: in terms of hiring policies, internal policies in relating to
- 9:56Speaker 6: constitutionally protected grant like gender, race, political belief systems, et cetera,
- 10:01Speaker 6: et cetera, So that protection has always been there. And
- 10:04Speaker 6: then the new amendance to the Employment Equity Act said
- 10:07Speaker 6: that harassment is actually a form of unfair discrimination. So
- 10:10Speaker 6: that started to create an additional level of protection and
- 10:14Speaker 6: created an obligation on employers to make sure that you
- 10:16Speaker 6: weren't exposing your employees to harassment as a form of
- 10:19Speaker 6: unfair discrimination within the workplace. And then, as I say,
- 10:22Speaker 6: in twenty twenty two, this Code Good Practice came out
- 10:25Speaker 6: which set out quite extensively what are all of the
- 10:29Speaker 6: types of conduct without it being a closed list which
- 10:32Speaker 6: could constitute harassment within the workplace. What is a workplace
- 10:35Speaker 6: for example, which is again a very broad category. It's
- 10:38Speaker 6: obviously the workplace as we would understand it officers, premises,
- 10:41Speaker 6: but even for example social events which are organized by
- 10:44Speaker 6: the employer, a transport provided by the employer, offsite, remote
- 10:49Speaker 6: working venues, et cetera, et cetera. So this code really
- 10:53Speaker 6: does create a very precise framework for determining what's problematic,
- 10:58Speaker 6: where can it be problematic, and maps out formal as
- 11:01Speaker 6: well as informal procedures which employees can use to bring
- 11:04Speaker 6: these types of misconduct to the attention of the employer.
- 11:07Speaker 6: And then creates a very strong obligation on the employer
- 11:09Speaker 6: to take appropriate action. As I said, if the employer
- 11:12Speaker 6: doesn't take action, there's potential by careous liability. So I
- 11:15Speaker 6: think it's this framework which creates the legal obligation to
- 11:19Speaker 6: deal with harassment. And again then because employees become aware
- 11:23Speaker 6: that this framework exists, they realized that there's recourse, there's
- 11:26Speaker 6: mechanisms that we can now use with in the workplace.
- 11:28Speaker 6: So the kind of reporting of these instances has become
- 11:32Speaker 6: more prevalent in the workplace and therefore disputes about the
- 11:35Speaker 6: imposition of things like dismissal. But again, you're absolutely right.
- 11:38Speaker 6: When you then get to the stage of the CCMA,
- 11:41Speaker 6: which was in this particular case, and the employee complained
- 11:44Speaker 6: about the fact that they had been dismissed for having
- 11:46Speaker 6: been found guilty on a discipline basis of having committed
- 11:49Speaker 6: this very serious harassment, bullying toxicity in the workplace, the
- 11:53Speaker 6: CCMA said, no, the employee was absolutely right. They found
- 11:56Speaker 6: you correctly guilty of harassment and you should have been dismissed.
- 11:59Speaker 2: Wow, our guest, Bradley workman Davies, you may want to
- 12:03Speaker 2: join in on the conversation. You can do that via
- 12:04Speaker 2: what'sapp and seven two five six seven one five six
- 12:07Speaker 2: seven and you can call any time and two one
- 12:09Speaker 2: four four six o five six seven engage Bradley directly.
- 12:14Speaker 2: We're going to test that that legal threshold for dismissal
- 12:17Speaker 2: when we come back, Davies, our guest direct at Varkment's attorneys.
- 12:21Speaker 2: We're talking very important matter when workplaceity toxicity becomes a
- 12:25Speaker 2: dismissible offense, and we're trying to establish that that line
- 12:29Speaker 2: in the sand that legal threshold for dismissal. Bradley clarify
- 12:34Speaker 2: that for us.
- 12:36Speaker 6: Yeah. So this code again, which is where you must
- 12:38Speaker 6: also always go back to, creates a very broad initial
- 12:42Speaker 6: category of what constitutes harassment. So it actually says it's
- 12:45Speaker 6: any unwanted conduct in the workplace which creates a hostile
- 12:48Speaker 6: work environment. I mean charent you can immediately feed it's
- 12:51Speaker 6: there's a lot of circumstances where you, as an employeemight
- 12:55Speaker 6: turn around and say, yes, it's unwanted conduct. I'm being
- 12:57Speaker 6: subjected to some kind of conduct by a cal leager, manager, supervisor.
- 13:02Speaker 6: Interesting enough, it also extends to people that you might
- 13:04Speaker 6: interact with in the course and spoke of your employment.
- 13:06Speaker 6: So those third parties, customers, clients, et cetera, et cetera,
- 13:10Speaker 6: and you equally have an obligation to ensure that you're
- 13:12Speaker 6: not harassing those third party non employees as well. But
- 13:16Speaker 6: any unwanted conduct that creates a hostile working environment. So
- 13:19Speaker 6: you could subjectively turn around and say I feel like
- 13:22Speaker 6: I am subjected to some kind of a hostile working
- 13:24Speaker 6: environment by, for example, my manager pressurizing me to deliver
- 13:28Speaker 6: to a deadline, et cetera, et cetera. And there may
- 13:31Speaker 6: well be instances where that is harassment within the workplace.
- 13:34Speaker 6: But there's a very nice mechanism in terms of the
- 13:37Speaker 6: code as well, which creates almost a bit of a
- 13:40Speaker 6: reality check to an employee's subjective perceptions of harassment. It
- 13:44Speaker 6: says that, luck not every single instance of a subjective
- 13:48Speaker 6: perception of harassment would constitute harassment for the purposes for
- 13:52Speaker 6: the code. It's got to be subject to a reasonable test.
- 13:54Speaker 6: Would a reasonable person in your circumstances take offense or
- 13:58Speaker 6: consider this is unwanted conduct as well. So again it's
- 14:01Speaker 6: it's a very broad category, as I said, unwanted conduct
- 14:04Speaker 6: which creates a hostile work environment. There are then some
- 14:07Speaker 6: very specific category that talks about for example, actual physical harassment,
- 14:11Speaker 6: physical assault, psychological harassment, psychological pressure on employees. But again
- 14:19Speaker 6: it's got to pass the test of what it's subjectively
- 14:23Speaker 6: but reasonably constitute harassment in the hands of a reasonable person.
- 14:27Speaker 2: Yeah, and ultimately this is the test at tension, the
- 14:30Speaker 2: push and pull between protecting a business's productivity, I guess,
- 14:33Speaker 2: and the employee's constitutional right to dignity. Let's go there.
- 14:37Speaker 2: So if an employer fails to act against that workplace bully,
- 14:44Speaker 2: they risk constructive dismissal claim maybe.
- 14:48Speaker 6: Yeah, they could. So the constructive dismissial obviously presupposes that
- 14:51Speaker 6: the employee in that particular situation has resigned, and then
- 14:55Speaker 6: would seek to hold the employee responsible for that resignation.
- 14:58Speaker 6: They would essentially say, I have brought these instances of
- 15:02Speaker 6: workplace harassment to your attention, I've asked you for assistance,
- 15:05Speaker 6: You've failed to help me. And again, that's a very
- 15:08Speaker 6: positive duty on an employer in terms of the code.
- 15:11Speaker 6: You must conduct an investigation, you must allow the employe
- 15:14Speaker 6: an opportunity to propose a resolution to the situation. You
- 15:18Speaker 6: must take action and not allow the harassment to continue.
- 15:21Speaker 6: And if in those circumstances, the employee has done all
- 15:24Speaker 6: that they can to bring it to your attention and you,
- 15:27Speaker 6: as the employer, are simply not taking the relevant steps
- 15:30Speaker 6: to protect them to deal with that harassment within the workplace,
- 15:34Speaker 6: then of course the employee can resign, and I think
- 15:36Speaker 6: that that would be a good basis upon which the
- 15:37Speaker 6: employee could then claim that constructive dismissal, again holding the
- 15:41Speaker 6: employer responsible for forcing the employee to resign. In the
- 15:44Speaker 6: circumstances what you can sometimes also find in the circumstances
- 15:49Speaker 6: is that the employee would then simply continue to be employed,
- 15:53Speaker 6: which I suppose strategically is better as well, because then
- 15:55Speaker 6: you continue to be employed, continue to receive your salary.
- 15:59Speaker 6: I suppose it down side of course, clients, though, is
- 16:01Speaker 6: that you're then in the workplace and potentially still subject
- 16:03Speaker 6: to that harassment on an ongoing basis. But you could
- 16:06Speaker 6: then launch an unfair discrimination claim in terms of Employment
- 16:08Speaker 6: Equity Act and seek protection from the labor courts while
- 16:12Speaker 6: you remain employed within the workplace. But yes, to answer
- 16:15Speaker 6: your question, resignation is possible and then holding the employer
- 16:18Speaker 6: responsible for putting you into that position where you had
- 16:21Speaker 6: no option other than to resign. Absolutely.
- 16:23Speaker 2: Bradley Workman Davis is a director at Developments. Let's get
- 16:27Speaker 2: some free advice, maybe a top piece of advice for
- 16:30Speaker 2: South African business owners. Are we talking about anti bullying policies?
- 16:34Speaker 2: They clearly must be sused. Yeah, how do you know
- 16:38Speaker 2: your policies are legally robust enough to stand up at
- 16:41Speaker 2: the CCMA when dealing with that toxic HYE performer.
- 16:47Speaker 6: So I think it's an intersection of both an actual
- 16:50Speaker 6: policy in respect of harassment within the workplace, and a
- 16:53Speaker 6: very good place to start is, of course, this code
- 16:55Speaker 6: which came out in twenty twenty two. Again it's the
- 16:57Speaker 6: Code of Good Practice on the Prevention and Elimination of
- 17:00Speaker 6: Harassment in the Workplace, and it very extensively sets out
- 17:03Speaker 6: again what's the workplace, What constitutes harassment, vertical harassment, horizontal
- 17:08Speaker 6: harassment between different levels of employees, what happens in relation
- 17:11Speaker 6: to employees on employee harassment, employees being harassed by third parties,
- 17:16Speaker 6: employees harassing third parties, formal and informal mechanisms for dealing
- 17:21Speaker 6: with that. What sort of assistance do you as an
- 17:23Speaker 6: employer have to give, for example, even do you have
- 17:26Speaker 6: to provide their employee with additional thick leave when they're
- 17:29Speaker 6: dealing with the mental or physical consequences of being the
- 17:31Speaker 6: victim of abuse. It's all there in the code. So
- 17:34Speaker 6: the code is a very good place to start. And
- 17:36Speaker 6: what we very often find is that employers, especially bigger employers,
- 17:40Speaker 6: with established HR departments, policies and procedure handbooks as well,
- 17:44Speaker 6: they will adopt a code which is very similar to
- 17:46Speaker 6: and derives itself from the content of that code. I
- 17:49Speaker 6: think if you are a smaller employer, you could probably
- 17:53Speaker 6: adopt that code or just follow the processes which you
- 17:56Speaker 6: see in that code when you're dealing with workplace harassments.
- 18:00Speaker 6: The additional important thing, of course, is as I mentioned earlier,
- 18:03Speaker 6: is that if you do identify harassment within the workplace
- 18:06Speaker 6: and you're then dealing with it, you should of course
- 18:08Speaker 6: then do that fairly in terms of a disciplinary code.
- 18:10Speaker 6: So you also have to have a good disciplinary code
- 18:13Speaker 6: which gives effect to the rights of an employee not
- 18:15Speaker 6: to be unfairly dismissed.
- 18:17Speaker 2: We're gonna wrap it there, but I think some really
- 18:20Speaker 2: great insights and they are appreciated. Bradley Workman Davies talking
- 18:24Speaker 2: to us about workplace toxicity and when it becomes a
- 18:29Speaker 2: dismissible offense. I would suggest