Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Wake Up Call (7.29.24): Bitcoin Diligence for Pension Funds
Transcript
- 0:00Thank you for joining us today. We're excited to bring you a
- 0:02brand new show from the On Ramp Media umbrella.
- 0:05Wake Up Call is a weekly show that will be streamed live on
- 0:08LinkedIn every Monday morning. To catch the premiere of each
- 0:11episode, follow On Ramps LinkedIn page and add Wake Up
- 0:14Call events to your calendar. After the live premiere on
- 0:17LinkedIn, we will distribute each episode across On Ramp
- 0:20Media's podcast channels and YouTube page.
- 0:23Wake Up Call aims to educate financial professionals on the
- 0:26merits of the Bitcoin investment thesis, how this asset
- 0:29represents both a threat to legacy financial service
- 0:31businesses and an opportunity to differentiate oneselves and
- 0:35retain and attract new clients. Hosted by Mark Connors on Ramps,
- 0:39Head of Global Macro Strategy and Rich Kerr on Ramps,
- 0:42President of Managed Wealth, this show seeks to provide
- 0:45financial professionals the wake up call they need, prompt them
- 0:48to have an open mind with respect to Bitcoin, rethink
- 0:51their prior assumptions, become more educated on the topic, and
- 0:54learn from others who are already farther down this path.
- 0:57Mark and Rich bring a combined 60 plus years of experience
- 1:00across traditional markets and financial services and will
- 1:03share their unique perspectives and how their peers and
- 1:05colleagues can approach the realm of Bitcoin.
- 1:08Wake Up Call will feature guests from various backgrounds and
- 1:10industries will also share their own journeys to Bitcoin and how
- 1:14others can get up to speed. Now time for the show.
- 1:18Well, good morning everybody and welcome to the wake up call.
- 1:22I'm your host, Rich Kerr, who's the President of On Ramp Managed
- 1:26Wealth and joined today with my Co host Mark Connor.
- 1:30So Mark, good morning to you. I know that you just got back
- 1:34from Nashville. I'd love it if you could share
- 1:38some thoughts or impressions. Thanks, Rich.
- 1:41Yes. So this is our second, my second
- 1:44Bitcoin conference. And for those not familiar, it's
- 1:47by the majority of our of our audience in the advisor world.
- 1:52There's an annual conference has been for years in Miami mostly
- 1:57the last several years. And in Nashville from Thursday
- 2:01to Saturday, you had about 25,000 attendees.
- 2:06The difference about this year, Rich was that you had more
- 2:09institutional people. You know, some people lament the
- 2:12fact that BlackRock was there. You know, Fidelity's always
- 2:15been, you know, a kindred spirit with the Bitcoin ethos.
- 2:20But what what we There were three takeaways to cut to the
- 2:23chase on 25,000 people descending on on the country
- 2:28music capital of the world. One was it's first time you've
- 2:31seen a Republican or Democratic National candidate attend.
- 2:37Last year you had RFK Junior, this year you had RFK, this year
- 2:41you had Donald Trump attend. So that's got all the headlines.
- 2:44I think what was a little bit behind the headlines and not
- 2:48spoken about is that as opposed to Bitcoin Conference 2022,
- 2:54which was a bull market, you had people in like rolling swimming
- 2:59pools on the back of trucks. It was kind of like a almost a
- 3:02bacchanalia. This was relatively subdued
- 3:05still. And some people said, hey, this
- 3:06isn't we're in a bull market. Why isn't it frothy?
- 3:09And the answer is because it's not.
- 3:11We have not hit bull market phase yet.
- 3:13So even though you had Trump come and say we're going to
- 3:19first day in office, I'm firing Gary Gensler, I'm going to take
- 3:23our 200,000 Bitcoin that's in the DOJ, put it in a strategic
- 3:28reserve and other pro Bitcoin and crypto comments as he made,
- 3:33he kind of conflated it too. Shows you that he's on board,
- 3:36but not as alert as other politicians like Lummus.
- 3:40So that's the main thing, a lot of people, but you had people at
- 3:45the legislative Representative Lummus, who said that she's
- 3:51going to create a legislation that would make Bitcoin a, a
- 3:56strategic reserve, which is huge.
- 3:58Maybe why we're flirting with 70,000 today and yet we're still
- 4:02not in the bull market. That's a major take away.
- 4:06That's outstanding. Hey, Glenn, I'm, I'm curious and
- 4:10I'll introduce our guest, Glenn Cameron real quickly to you all.
- 4:14Glenn is joining us from the UK. So he is, he's in a completely
- 4:21different time zone. But Glenn joins us.
- 4:24He is in senior investment consultant with Cartwright and
- 4:29Cartwright is a prestigious pension management, pension
- 4:33administration, investment consultancy, actuarial services
- 4:37company that has been in existence since 1986, I believe,
- 4:42out in the UK, serving pensions and all sorts of different
- 4:46schemas. And so we're delighted to have
- 4:49Glenn here today. But Glenn, before we start
- 4:51diving into maybe your expertise and, and, and a little bit about
- 4:56the journey that you and your firm kind of went through and
- 5:00Bitcoin, any impressions that you had?
- 5:03Did you get a chance to watch any of the live show over in
- 5:07Nashville and and and how was that?
- 5:10Received. Yeah.
- 5:13Well, thanks both for having me. Mark Rich, it's a pleasure to be
- 5:18with you. I did watch some of it.
- 5:24I didn't watch all of it. Some kind of evaluating things
- 5:31on a subset of probably what was on offer.
- 5:34I did listen to President Trump's address.
- 5:40I did listen to Cynthia Lamas's address outside of those two.
- 5:46I listened to one that Dylan Leclair was the moderator for.
- 5:53And you had the CEO of of similar scientific, you had I
- 6:05think the CFO of MicroStrategy and I think the CFO of
- 6:10Metaplanet on a platform that we're talking about Bitcoin on
- 6:14the balance sheet. And that's when I really
- 6:18recommend people go and watch because I think as well as the
- 6:23kind of nation state side of things, I think that that's
- 6:26going to be the next area that's really starting to kick off.
- 6:31And I think a lot of the thing, the details they described about
- 6:39what was going on in the boardroom to get them to the
- 6:42point where they're willing to put Bitcoin on the balance
- 6:44sheet, the way they're thinking about it strategically, yeah,
- 6:51there was a lot of useful information people may not be
- 6:56aware of. But I definitely think the
- 7:00corporate space, corporate adoption of Bitcoin is going to
- 7:05be a big area going forward. Yeah, I, I agree with you,
- 7:11Glenn. And in fact, you know, you kind
- 7:14of tease one of our future guests who will be joining us
- 7:17and there's a gentleman named Joe Iani who leads a firm called
- 7:21Acropolis. And you know, their their
- 7:24specialty in particular is around helping small businesses
- 7:29or corporations incorporate Bitcoin onto their balance sheet
- 7:34and designing strategies in order to do that effectively.
- 7:37And you know, to me, I, I see that as well as, you know, one
- 7:43of the patterns developing with, you know, industry or, or
- 7:49institutions that are ultimately moving towards Bitcoin.
- 7:53And each of them have to approach it in the right way.
- 7:56And there's always a first mover and then a second mover and then
- 7:59things start to unfold. And we're starting to see that
- 8:02right now with, you know, Sailor being a first mover in many
- 8:08respects and in a profound way and, and continuing to be.
- 8:12And then there's other companies that have just that you had just
- 8:15mentioned that kind of followed suit.
- 8:17And so it's really energizing to watch how these firms are coming
- 8:22forward executing their strategies.
- 8:25But I would agree with you, very, very good content there
- 8:28and worthwhile for everybody to go back and find that and take a
- 8:31look. And we'll and we'll make a
- 8:33commitment to to ensuring that we'll we'll have a dialogue
- 8:37around what does that look like and, and what, what role do
- 8:42investment professionals, you know, play in serving those
- 8:46markets and helping facilitate that to small businesses and
- 8:49corporations on the balance sheet.
- 8:51So thank you, Glenn, appreciate it.
- 8:54Well, and Speaking of what you know, maybe we, we talked about
- 8:57a different subset of institutions that seem to really
- 9:02be moving and and that's in your wheelhouse area.
- 9:05Glen pensions have, you know, certainly in the United States
- 9:10have caught a lot of attention when SWIB, you know, made a
- 9:16commitment or an allocation to towards Bitcoin and that's a
- 9:20well run large pension plan in the United States.
- 9:24But you're over there in the UK and you're an investment
- 9:28consultant to a number of, you know, pension plans yourself.
- 9:32And, and you guys seem to be equally at the forefront on this
- 9:37space. And, and there's a lot of work
- 9:39to be the first mover, so to speak, like Cartwright has been.
- 9:45And SO1I applaud you and for the courage that I think that that
- 9:51takes but two for for the detailed work that you've made
- 9:55in order to design a way to enter into this space when
- 10:00others have not been able to do that and so.
- 10:03Maybe I kick it to. You to kind of talk a little bit
- 10:05about your journey in leading pension plans forward with
- 10:11Bitcoin allocations and what were the key things that you
- 10:14needed to kind of discover as you went through this process of
- 10:19designing your thesis investment policies and ways to enter into
- 10:25the digital asset space? I'd love to hear your thoughts.
- 10:28Yeah. So I mean, so in the role I had
- 10:33prior to this, I gained a lot of experience in the space.
- 10:37And when I got off at this shop, it was on the basis that I would
- 10:41kind of lead this area for Cartwright.
- 10:47I mean, so I don't think, well, at least in our client basin,
- 10:55they're going to be, you know, needles in a haystack to find.
- 11:00I don't think there are pension schemes in the UK that are kind
- 11:04of demanding an allocation Bitcoin.
- 11:06That's not, you know, where we're at, right?
- 11:11It's essentially us driving conversation.
- 11:15So where approaching pension schemes and telling them that,
- 11:20you know, we think a Bitcoin allocation could be right for
- 11:24them, right. And the certain criteria that
- 11:31we're using to identify those pension schemes, probably the
- 11:38most important one is their investment horizon.
- 11:41So we deal mainly with the fine benefit pension schemes and the
- 11:47very large majority of them, more than 95% of them are aiming
- 11:52to get to a point where they're well enough funded so that they
- 11:56can offload themselves to an insurance company, right?
- 12:02And the company and the scheme itself can offload all the
- 12:06investment risk and not an insurance companies problem,
- 12:11right. So if a pension scheme if if it
- 12:17looks like you know, based on our expectations, market
- 12:21expectations and things like that, that the pension scheme
- 12:24can get there in the year or eighteen months, then
- 12:28immediately backgrounds off the table, right.
- 12:31So we kind of made a decision that it would need to be at
- 12:36least a full cycle. So four years, right, would be
- 12:40need to be the investment horizon before we would approach
- 12:43a pension scheme and suggest that situation.
- 12:49The other thing is the pension schemes are supported by
- 12:52sponsoring companies. So according to the regulations
- 12:57that they're not well enough funded, the company has to reach
- 13:01into its bank account and make regular contributions to pension
- 13:05scheme to get it back on track, right.
- 13:09But you don't want to be in a situation where you put so much
- 13:11pressure on the company that they end up falling over because
- 13:17they're the support for the pension scheme.
- 13:19So there's a balance to be struck there, right?
- 13:22So we don't want to be approaching company, I mean
- 13:27pension schemes where the companies are strapped and that,
- 13:31you know, if they make investments that don't pay off,
- 13:35it's going to be too burdensome. So we want pension schemes with
- 13:40what we call strong covenants, which is the the covenant or the
- 13:45promise between the pension scheme and the company or from
- 13:49the company to the pension scheme is strong, right.
- 13:53Those are kind of the two main criteria.
- 13:56But once we get to that point, then it's reaching out to them
- 14:00and you know, doing it in a way that's easy for them to say yes.
- 14:06All right, so say, you know, obviously bitcoins been in the
- 14:10headlines a lot. Admittedly the coverage is both
- 14:13positive and negative, but when something's in the headlines as
- 14:18much as Bitcoin is, could be important, right?
- 14:21And we certainly think it is important.
- 14:24And what we'd like is just the opportunity free of charge for
- 14:29us to come in and do some education, right.
- 14:34And then we've got kind of like an hour, hour and a half with
- 14:37questions where we kind of take them through the Bitcoin thesis
- 14:42and make them understand exactly what Bitcoin is and how it fits
- 14:48into a portfolio. You know, what it does for a
- 14:52portfolio and what makes it unique.
- 14:58And you know, then we have much more in depth training if they
- 15:04wish. So if questions come up like how
- 15:07do I know they'll only ever be 21 million Bitcoin as a maximum
- 15:11supply? And, you know, the sort of
- 15:14nutshell answer is not going to cut it.
- 15:17Then we've got an entire presentation explaining the
- 15:21entire protocol in kind of a plain English way.
- 15:25If their objections are on on environmental grounds, right?
- 15:30We take them through, you know, essentially we just give them
- 15:35the facts and let them draw their own conclusions.
- 15:38But ultimately by doing that, they can see that, you know, the
- 15:41headlines aren't necessarily refracting reality, right?
- 15:45And that Bitcoin can actually play a positive role, you know,
- 15:50if you are a big proponent of the energy transition and you
- 15:56know, climate change and all that kind of thing.
- 16:00Well, even on those grounds, Bitcoin has a pivotal role to
- 16:03pay in that space. You know, prime example would
- 16:07obviously be the ERCOT grid in Texas with demand response and
- 16:12things like that. So we kind of explain all of
- 16:14those things to them and lay out dispel some of the myths around
- 16:18that area. And then we also take them
- 16:23through the kind of social and societal implications of of
- 16:30Bitcoin not only in developed markets or even they so in
- 16:36developed markets, but in developing markets, right.
- 16:40And what it's doing to fight against authoritarianism and,
- 16:48you know, preserve human rights and things like that around the
- 16:52world. And we show them various things.
- 16:54We mentioned CBDC's and the implications of those.
- 17:01So, Lynn, can I ask a question? Yeah, of course you can.
- 17:05When you're in there and could you piqued our interest or not
- 17:10just a memory of the of what a panel we had at the at the
- 17:14conference with Alex Gladstein of the Human Rights Foundation
- 17:18and about the impact of how he sees Bitcoin helping other
- 17:21countries. I know advisors may like that,
- 17:24but isn't the focus really on or pension funds on their on
- 17:31satisfying their investment policy?
- 17:33Are they, how much are they worried about the investment
- 17:36policy, which is a long dated liability and you know, serving
- 17:39those long dated liabilities versus also the risk to their
- 17:43career? Meaning like on that duality of
- 17:47serving even are they willing to do you see them sort of gulping
- 17:53saying it may help, but boy, I don't know if I want to, you
- 17:57know, die on this hill or present this thing and and what
- 18:01hurdle do you get? What has helped you get them
- 18:05over that? Is it the economic benefit or is
- 18:08it reducing their concerns about what you just said about it's
- 18:13not an energy issue, it's an energy benefit, It's not a
- 18:16criminal haven. It is actually transparent.
- 18:19You know that those two different vectors?
- 18:23So I'm going to even summarize and paraphrase the regulations,
- 18:32but essentially the latest regulations here in the UK are
- 18:36that trustees have to consider environmental, social and
- 18:41governance factors when they're making any investment, right?
- 18:45So unless you can clear the bar with that stuff, you ain't going
- 18:51anywhere, no matter what they think of the investment thesis,
- 18:54right? So if they've got objections on
- 18:58those grounds, you do need to deal with them, but that's not
- 19:00enough to get them to invest because like you say,
- 19:05particularly with so you have two different types of trustees.
- 19:09We're actually through, OK. So you have employer nominated
- 19:13trustees which are appointed by the company itself.
- 19:17You have member nominated trustees which are nominated and
- 19:22appointed by the membership of the pension scheme to represent
- 19:26them. And the third type of trustee
- 19:29you have is professional trust, OK, which is a subset of the
- 19:35employer nominates the trustees, but these are firms of trustees
- 19:41that's basically will set on 15 or 20 pension scheme trustee
- 19:48boards. And they do this as a
- 19:51professional. And with those professional
- 19:56trustees, there is a natural conflict here because they have
- 20:03a career as a professional trustee, right?
- 20:06And so not everything they do may be based purely on
- 20:14investment or governance grounds or anything like that.
- 20:17It may also be based on how it's going to be appeared to others,
- 20:22right. And so that's definitely a
- 20:26challenge, right, Is, you know, like I'm not a member of this
- 20:32pension scheme. I just and professional trustee
- 20:36on its trustee board. You're promising me all the
- 20:39subside, but I'm thinking about my own career and I'm not going
- 20:43to get any of that upside. If this thing goes really well,
- 20:47I'm not going to get any credit for it.
- 20:49But if it goes really badly, so there's no upside and there's a
- 20:53lot of downside here for me personally, right in, in, in the
- 20:57professional thing. But I think so the way that I
- 21:02deal with that is I talk to them about, OK, so you're looking at
- 21:06the risk as one way, right? But the risk actually exists two
- 21:10ways, right? Because we're at a point in
- 21:16history where equities are about or trading at a valuation on a
- 21:26Cape ratio basis, which is about double its hundred year average,
- 21:31right? It's only been more richly
- 21:34valued once, which was in the.com bubble at least.
- 21:40You say equities race of the world is pretty cheap, but when
- 21:44you consider that's more than 60% of equity markets of the US,
- 21:50it's highly relevant. You know, I think if you look at
- 21:58government balance sheets, it's pretty clear that financial
- 22:02repression is going to be the name of the game.
- 22:06So there's a lot of risk in equities, there's a lot of risk
- 22:09in fixed income markets. And you know, that's the where
- 22:17most of the money lies in capital markets and what you're
- 22:19invested in. And if your peers start to
- 22:24realize something before you do, which is kind of an escape valve
- 22:29from this whole system. And money, as it has been for
- 22:34the last 15 years, starts flowing into this sort of pure
- 22:39monetary asset, right? This hard money, the sound
- 22:43money, right? And you don't have exposure to
- 22:47that asset in your portfolio, right?
- 22:50So what's happening is money's been taken out of the asset
- 22:54classes that are in your portfolio and being put into an
- 22:58asset class that isn't in your portfolio, right?
- 23:02And say that too loud out too, too often out loud.
- 23:06That's that. That's a scary right.
- 23:09I mean that if you had that visual.
- 23:12Yeah. That might be quite the turning
- 23:15point. Because the The thing is, why
- 23:17are equities overvalued? Well, it's because every month
- 23:23that happens in my case, right, is a certain amount of money pre
- 23:28tax gets taken off my salary and put into a pension scheme,
- 23:32right? It's an automatic buy, right?
- 23:34It doesn't matter whether the equities are overvalued,
- 23:37undervalued or anything. You multiply that by hundreds of
- 23:40millions of people, right? It's just a place to park money
- 23:44because everybody knows, right? Sam, my boss always likes to say
- 23:49there's only three things you can do with money.
- 23:51You can save money, you can spend money or you can invest
- 23:55money, right? But the problem is with the way
- 23:59the monetary system works today, you can't save money, right?
- 24:03You cannot take your money and put it under your mattress,
- 24:07right? If you do that, it's not going
- 24:09to be worth very much by the time you want to spend it in 20
- 24:12years, right? So you first, you, you're forced
- 24:15to either spend it or invest it, right.
- 24:18But the, so that is what people are doing.
- 24:21They're spending and automatically investing their
- 24:24money. But the equity premium to its
- 24:28long term historic valuation is that it's not trading a double
- 24:32that valuation, right. And what's that's reflecting is
- 24:36that equities contain a monetary premium.
- 24:39So we're not just big buying equities anymore for the
- 24:43investment return, like the actual income yield or the free
- 24:47cash flow yield from those assets.
- 24:49We're using them as a form of money, right?
- 24:53And so they contain this massive monetary premium, which is half
- 24:56of their value, right? And when you've got an asset
- 25:01which is a pure monetary asset, right, which is where a monetary
- 25:06premium belongs. And more and more people every
- 25:10day are realizing that, right, it makes sense for them to take
- 25:15money from a place where they aren't getting a proper yield
- 25:18income yield, right, and put it into a pure monetary asset,
- 25:23right? And so you can be first to
- 25:27realize it or you can be lost to realize it, right?
- 25:30But the value is going to be sucked out of where it doesn't
- 25:34belong and put into somewhere where it does belong.
- 25:37And you know what, Bitcoins like less than half a percent of a
- 25:43global portfolio in terms of all the assets in the world, right?
- 25:47So you don't need a lot of explosion, right?
- 25:50You just need some exposure so that as people realize this, you
- 25:56ride that way to the top. But if you wait until, if you're
- 26:00the last person that's realized that, right, you're going to end
- 26:03up having to take 20 or 30% of your assets and put it into this
- 26:06thing. And you're not going to have had
- 26:08the benefit of, you know, being ahead of the curve, realizing
- 26:14things before, you know, before, before it's essentially all
- 26:19priced in. That is the opportunity.
- 26:22That is the alpha, but not easy to explain to people, that's for
- 26:28sure. Especially the media doesn't
- 26:30help. I'll tell you what that that's a
- 26:34great conversation and I think we can continue to just pull and
- 26:38pull on that thread. Thank you for those
- 26:41observations. I, I wonder if we can flip gears
- 26:46a little bit. You, you know, you at
- 26:50Cartwright, you guys have, have you, you've done your work and,
- 26:55and, and a tremendous amount of it and, and everybody has to
- 26:59start somewhere, right? And, and just like Cartwright
- 27:02did. And so maybe share a little bit
- 27:04you, you once told Mark and IA story about going to the
- 27:08Bloomberg and kind of starting the journey, right, of how do we
- 27:13access this? You had an opinion, you had a
- 27:16thesis that you wanted to pull forward, but now you got to go
- 27:19into motion. You got to, you got to start
- 27:21stepping through a process and, and it's usually a very defined
- 27:25one as an investment consultant would put things through rigor.
- 27:29So maybe, you know, walk us through what that looks like or
- 27:33our audience. Yeah, sure.
- 27:36So, yeah. So when I joined Cartwright 2
- 27:401/2 years ago, the idea was what I've already said is educate our
- 27:48client base, but in parallel, find a way to operationalize
- 27:53this. So if one of these clients turns
- 27:56around, goes, Glenn, you've convinced me we need an
- 28:02allocation to be going in our portfolio, what am I going to
- 28:05do? Is it going to be on a traisal
- 28:09held by the Chairman of trustees?
- 28:12Where are we going to put this thing right?
- 28:16And so that story that I was telling you about Bloomberg was
- 28:21going into Bloomberg and going into, you know, the fun research
- 28:27kind of section of Bloomberg there and typing in the word
- 28:31Bitcoin and looking at what are the options around the world,
- 28:35right? And at the time that I did that,
- 28:39which was probably 18 months ago, there were more than
- 28:44seventy options, 70, right? So it's like, OK, how do I
- 28:50decide which of those seventy options is the way that I'm
- 28:54going to recommend to our clients that they should be
- 28:57accessing this asset, right? But from all perspectives, right
- 29:02from security to fees, you know in terms of in kind subscription
- 29:15and redemptions, bankruptcy or counterparty risks, control of
- 29:23the asset, a whole bunch of criteria.
- 29:27We came up I think with I think it was 12 criteria and we
- 29:34basically got those seventy options and then as new ones
- 29:39came to market, we added them to the long list and we evaluated
- 29:43in across 12 criteria. Nice.
- 29:46And what I kind of found out was that's pretty hard to get our
- 29:54deal right. Did that the the there's a green
- 29:59techniques to every single one of our 12 criteria, right.
- 30:03I had plenty that I had seven or eight.
- 30:06I had maybe one that had 11 out of 12, but I didn't have one
- 30:12that was 12 out of 12, right? And so that mean I needed to
- 30:19keep looking, right? Because until we've made
- 30:22absolutely sure that we can't get things ideal, I didn't want
- 30:25to give up and compromise, right?
- 30:28Because if I've taken a board of trustees and on a journey to
- 30:37understand Bitcoin and they have gotten them over the line to
- 30:41say, OK, we're interested in making an allocation.
- 30:45I need to make damn sure that the way that I show them to
- 30:51access the asset is the optimal way in all you know across a
- 30:58range of different criteria. At On Ramp, we believe that
- 31:03Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 31:07The hard part is securing it right.
- 31:10There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 31:12exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 31:15arrangement. On Ramp solves for these
- 31:17concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 31:20solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 31:24ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 31:26possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 31:30your family is protected as well.
- 31:33On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 31:35whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 31:38to your existing self custody setup.
- 31:41For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 31:45Glenn, when you say that, as you can tell, I'm like choking on my
- 31:49own words. Access to the asset just for
- 31:53everyone here. I grew up in the world where the
- 31:56favorite 3 letters for anybody involved in markets was DTC in
- 32:01the US because then, you know, there was safekeeping, it was
- 32:05liquid. It was if, if your certificate
- 32:07got lost, just print another one.
- 32:09All good. So why is what you just said?
- 32:13I mean, I know why, but can you kind of go into how this is a
- 32:17bearer asset and this is critical that part?
- 32:21And I guess the last question is, is that lost or appreciated
- 32:26by the folks you're talking to, not just by Bitcoin, but you
- 32:30need to do it the right way? Yeah.
- 32:33So, OK, So what is a bearer asset?
- 32:37So a bearer assets is something that if you hold it, it belongs
- 32:43to you. So a bar of gold or a gold coin
- 32:46would be a good example, right? If it's in my possession, it
- 32:49means it belongs to me. But if I leave that gold coin
- 32:54lying around and Richard picks it up and takes it home within,
- 32:58it's no longer mine, right? There's no register anywhere
- 33:02that's saying, you know, this gold coin belongs to Glenn.
- 33:06So if Richard's got to give it back to Glenn, right?
- 33:10And it also means that if I give that gold coin to somebody,
- 33:16right? That's all that's required to
- 33:18transfer the asset, right? I just physically hand it to
- 33:22someone, right? And that's very different from
- 33:28an equity, a bond, because they're all held by custodians.
- 33:33It's in fact very difficult to actually get the physical share
- 33:38certificate for an equity ownership.
- 33:41You have to get kind of special permission.
- 33:44It's a whole kind of process to be able to actually custody your
- 33:50own shares, right? Normally when you access them,
- 33:54there's a custodian holding. And you mentioned the DTCC and
- 33:59it's a common myth that oh, you know, if the DTCC has got it,
- 34:04it's fine. But if you actually look at the
- 34:07notional exposure of the assets that the DTCC is custody versus
- 34:17the actual collateral backing it, right, and you take into
- 34:21account the collateral buffers that the DTTC, the DTCC has,
- 34:27right? The notional exposure is in the
- 34:30multiple trillions, right? The collateral backing it is
- 34:361/10 of that right And the capital buffers that the DTCC
- 34:44has in case you know, major counterparties default is
- 34:48nowhere near enough to cover all of that.
- 34:53And the, if you actually delve down into the nitty gritty of
- 35:01the legislation and the contracts and all of that kind
- 35:04of thing, what you realize is that in a systemic event where
- 35:10you know, like a GFC type of event, if you know like a
- 35:18clearing house went down because a major counterparty defaulted
- 35:23or something like that, you would end up as an unsecured
- 35:26creditor even as a major equity fund manager or whatever, right?
- 35:30So how? Many people understand that that
- 35:32you're talking to you think because obviously.
- 35:37Yeah, you got to, you got to, you really got to go down the
- 35:40rabbit hole and the stuff and you got to read a lot.
- 35:43And there are people who've kind of laid it out neatly.
- 35:49But yeah, people just do all of these, set up all these, you
- 35:55know, they'll invest enough equity, fine.
- 35:58They don't even know who the custodian is most of the time,
- 36:00right? But they certainly not the
- 36:05difference between a bearer asset and a non bearer asset is
- 36:11the with a bearer asset, if it's in your physical position,
- 36:14there's no counterparty risk because somebody else isn't
- 36:17holding it on my behalf. So, but with all of these assets
- 36:27in the traditional finance system, there's counterparty
- 36:30risk everywhere because somebody's holding the assets on
- 36:33behalf of the, you know, the beneficial owner of the assets,
- 36:38right? But with Bitcoin, like so in my
- 36:42personal capacity, I own Bitcoin, right?
- 36:45I can, I can buy Bitcoin and I can custody it myself, right?
- 36:50I can do that on a collaborative basis or I can do it on an
- 36:53individual basis. But I can't go and buy shares in
- 36:57NVIDIA and have them in my personal custody, right?
- 37:04With gold, I suppose I can buy gold coins and stuff like that.
- 37:07But then the problem is that, you know, the transaction costs,
- 37:12they are really high. Like if I buy a gold coin and
- 37:14then I immediately turn around and sell it, it's going to cost
- 37:17me 5 to 10% of the value of what I've invested to do the round
- 37:24trip. With Bitcoin, I can buy it,
- 37:27casting myself and sell it. And you know, the transaction
- 37:31costs are going to be negligible, almost 0.
- 37:36So in my opinion, it's the only asset that you can actually hold
- 37:40with 0 counterparty risk, right? Like in a meaningful way.
- 37:45Like if you want to hold a billion dollars worth of
- 37:47Bitcoin, right? Unless you know, unless you're
- 37:52going to actually dig your own fault in your ground and hire
- 37:55security guards and stuff like that, you're going to hold it
- 37:58through some sort of fun vehicle, right?
- 38:01And, you know, being somebody else is holding it for you.
- 38:06Do they have the the goal that they're holding for you?
- 38:09Are they lending it out? You know, they're all these
- 38:11types of kinds of things that you need to take into account.
- 38:17And so that's one of the huge benefits of Bitcoin.
- 38:22But if you then are lazy, right? And you just go, oh, I'll just
- 38:28invest in Bitcoin in the way the 1st way that I come across,
- 38:32right? You essentially get rid of that
- 38:37attribute plus a whole lot of other attributes that are really
- 38:40valuable about Bitcoin because of the way you've decided to
- 38:44access the assets. Yeah.
- 38:48So kind of. Going back to the ways to
- 38:53access, right. And, and I think I, I've been on
- 38:59the record multiple times, like I'm, I'm glad the ETFs are here
- 39:04because it raises the, the consciousness in the, in the
- 39:07public and, and it creates access points.
- 39:10And, and secondarily, the one thing that I also know it in my
- 39:15heart hearts around Bitcoin is once people understand the
- 39:19unique nature of it. And, and, and, and that might be
- 39:25that they are, are resonating on the price go up, number of go up
- 39:30type of, you know, dynamic. It's fine if that's what they
- 39:34want, you know, they triggers them to say, Oh gosh, I need to
- 39:37go down the, the rabbit hole just a little bit more.
- 39:39What is this? Why is it so outperforming in My
- 39:42Portfolio? And, and I think end clients
- 39:47will ultimately start, you know, raising the bar towards
- 39:51education, meaning they're going to go back to their advisor and
- 39:55say, what is this? Wow, why, why, why do we have it
- 39:59in our portfolio? You know, how does it operate?
- 40:03You know, how did you come to this conclusion?
- 40:05Or conversely, why don't we have it in the portfolio?
- 40:10How are we missing out on this? And so I think that there's a
- 40:14dynamic there that will lead. End clients to actually do their
- 40:19own research and and become even more educated around Bitcoin as
- 40:23it you know, regardless of the way that they arrive to it.
- 40:27And so my, my hope is that once that happens, right, people
- 40:34start looking at the ETF structure a little bit
- 40:37differently and saying, OK, well, is this the right way for
- 40:40me to own Bitcoin? Because, or maybe the better
- 40:43question is, do I really own Bitcoin or do I simply have a
- 40:47proxy? And that might lead to another
- 40:51interesting conversation along the way.
- 40:54And then ultimately capital gains implications.
- 40:58You know, I own the ETF now I need to get out of it in order
- 41:02to go over to Bitcoin itself and and have ownership of it.
- 41:07But why did you at Cartwright not go down maybe that easy
- 41:12button path with ETFs? What, what, why did you, why did
- 41:18you go down a different path with ownership assurances and
- 41:21things on that nature for clients?
- 41:22I guess maybe it's my question. Yeah.
- 41:25So, yeah, it's a good question because oh, BlackRock have got
- 41:31an ETF, you know. Well, it's BlackRock.
- 41:34It surely must be, you know, yeah, the base play, base way to
- 41:40invest in Bitcoin. Surely, You know, if you can
- 41:43invest in Bitcoin through BlackRock, isn't it the base way
- 41:47to do it? Or Fidelity or Franklin
- 41:49Templeton or Invesco, right. But so I was working back in
- 41:592008, right? And I know that if I had had a
- 42:05crystal ball and could see what was coming, I didn't see what
- 42:08was coming. But the things that happened on
- 42:13certain days there with, you know, major global banks down
- 42:216070% in a single day, right? Just absolutely.
- 42:27I mean, it was just carnage, right?
- 42:30And institutions the size of Lehman's AIG, you know, here in
- 42:40the UK, Northern Trust, right? Governments having having to
- 42:45print billions and billions, hundreds of billions of dollars
- 42:50to try and keep the system afloat, right?
- 42:53So what is going to be happening if that ever happens again?
- 42:59What does the world look like, right?
- 43:00And in that world, it's all about counterparty risk, who
- 43:04owes me what, right? And can they pay, right?
- 43:08So the first thing I want to know is if the people holding
- 43:13the Bitcoin go bankrupt, what happens to my Bitcoin, right?
- 43:20And so that's what I immediately do when I look at, when I looked
- 43:24at all 78 of the funds we ultimately looked at including
- 43:29the ETFs. The first thing I do is I go to
- 43:32the risk disclosures in the filings, right?
- 43:36And I look at bankruptcy, what happens, right?
- 43:40And it's very interesting when you do it, right, because all of
- 43:44it a sudden you realize that for example, in the case of the
- 43:49iShares Bitcoin Trust, right, that actually what you're
- 43:56exposed to is the custodian, not BlackRock, right?
- 44:00So who's the custodian? Coinbase.
- 44:04OK, So what is Coinbase's credit rating?
- 44:07Is it an invest? Do they have an investment grade
- 44:11credit rating? No.
- 44:13Would I invest in the Coinbase bonds?
- 44:17No. So am I just kidding myself that
- 44:24I've got my Bitcoin allocation through BlackRock?
- 44:29But that's not what's going to count in that world if it ever
- 44:33happens again, where everything's going through the
- 44:37floor and everybody owes each other money and there's not
- 44:42enough to go around and it's like a game of musical chairs
- 44:45and who's going to end up with, you know, And what's important
- 44:51to realize about these filings, I'll show you on the screen now,
- 44:56is that they don't put stuff in there that they don't need to
- 45:00put in there. They are kind of covering their
- 45:04backsides because they know the risks.
- 45:07They're legal and compliance. People have told them what the
- 45:11risks are. And they've said you have to
- 45:12have this immediate filing, right?
- 45:16So I'll show you if I share my screen here, right?
- 45:22Let me just OK, so let's do this.
- 45:33Is it working? OK, let's see.
- 45:39All righty. So this is the I shares, but
- 45:45coin trust filing the security Exchange Commission.
- 45:50So what I'll do is I'll just search for the word bankruptcy,
- 45:57the first couple of references and I'll blow this up when we
- 46:01get to the relevant part. But these first references are
- 46:04just FTX and various crypto scams blowing up.
- 46:11But if you kind of keep going through it, you eventually get
- 46:16to the part that really kind of counts.
- 46:24Let's have a look. I think it was one up.
- 46:30OK, so let's blow this up and look.
- 46:35So I think this is interesting for people to actually see in
- 46:38black and white. OK, so let's read here.
- 46:47Moreover, in the event of an insolvency or bankruptcy of the
- 46:51prime Boca or the Bitcoin custodian, so in this case,
- 46:55that's Coinbase. In the future, given that the
- 46:59contractual protections and legal rights of customers with
- 47:03respect to digital assets, in other words Bitcoin held on
- 47:07their behalf by third parties, counterparty risk are relatively
- 47:12untested in a bankruptcy of an entity such as the Bitcoin
- 47:17custodian or prime broker in the virtual currency, there's a risk
- 47:22the customer's assets, including the trust's assets.
- 47:25So this is the I shares Bitcoin trust may be considered the
- 47:30property of the bankruptcy estate of the prime broker or
- 47:34the Bitcoin custodian. And customers, including the
- 47:39trust may be at risk of being treated as general unsecured
- 47:45creditors of such entities and subject to the risk of total
- 47:49loss. OK, so the language couldn't be
- 47:59that much clearer, right? So what if there's a way of
- 48:04holding Bitcoin where you get rid of that risk?
- 48:07Because what I say will be worse, way worse for hard,
- 48:12right, for professional trustees, for anybody who
- 48:16decides to invest in Bitcoin. It's not what everybody's afraid
- 48:20about. What everybody's delusional, but
- 48:23afraid about is that they're going to invest in this thing
- 48:27and it's going to become apparent that it's all in the
- 48:30illusion and Bitcoin's going to go to zero, OK?
- 48:34That's what people are afraid about.
- 48:35But what they should really be a bit afraid about is you invest
- 48:39in this thing and we're right, and it goes up 20X50X, right?
- 48:47And it's now, you know, worth a hell of a lot.
- 48:54And Coinbase goes bankrupt and your Bitcoin ends up in the
- 49:00bankruptcy estate and you're an unsecured creditor.
- 49:05All the secured creditors just get paid out and there's nothing
- 49:08left, right? That's a way worse outcome, and
- 49:13one that's preventable. If you know how to hold the
- 49:16Bitcoin property such that it doesn't matter who goes
- 49:20bankrupt, you ain't losing your Bitcoin.
- 49:23Glenn, your point about it doesn't matter if you know who
- 49:27goes bankrupt, you're not getting your your Bitcoin in
- 49:30that in that event back to when you said Lehman's and and at
- 49:34that time in O eight, you know, Rich you you were there Schwab
- 49:37watching it happen. You guys, as in, you know, a non
- 49:42levered entity were and for other reasons due to, you know,
- 49:47your diligence as as a firm weren't impacted like the other
- 49:52firms, but the Fed decided Bear Stearns for saving Lehman were
- 49:56not. More recently, the the Swiss
- 49:58government said we're going to let Chris Swiss go and we're
- 50:03going to save certain parts of the capital structure.
- 50:06They decided which investor bases.
- 50:09So to your point about the DTCC, you know, being levered,
- 50:13everyone's like, come on, is it really going to happen?
- 50:16And the point is DTCC doesn't have to necessarily go under.
- 50:20There could be an event where all of a sudden an entity funded
- 50:24by the government, just like it was in March of 23, decides who
- 50:29and how assets are allocated. And the main fallout is more
- 50:34money printing, which means whatever you have as a as an
- 50:39investment will lose buying power.
- 50:42You know, we just crossed 35 trillion in debt this morning
- 50:46right before the call started. We're growing debt at 10% a year
- 50:51or more. Is your portfolio growing 10% a
- 50:55year? So those are the the dynamics.
- 50:58I think sometimes people push back.
- 51:01It's like you guys are all doom and gloomers like, no, we're the
- 51:06Fed is not going to let things default.
- 51:08They're simply going to print more money and decide which
- 51:12assets or liabilities they save, which they let go.
- 51:15And it's going to be Bob's your uncle.
- 51:18That's for the UK crowd. They're there, Glenn, for you.
- 51:21And I know, I know it's not home based for you.
- 51:25So I'm going to be a little careful.
- 51:26I know being, being over there in Scotland.
- 51:28And, and so it, it will be just a stealthy decline.
- 51:33So that's more like you're talking about the right way to
- 51:36buy it, which is why you're here.
- 51:38And you know, we're rich and I are just sort of, I'm not going
- 51:42to speak for you Rich, but I, I saw the problem in Tratfi and
- 51:46I'll, I don't want to end it, but I want to reiterate the
- 51:49reason why Bitcoin is getting the attention of treasurer's
- 51:53like you mentioned, who are now putting on balance sheet.
- 51:58I don't put any credence in politicians, but investors and
- 52:01asset managers know to save the house.
- 52:04They got to have some so. Yeah, yeah.
- 52:08And I definitely think that the people who've got Bitcoin at
- 52:15some point in the future are going to be glad to have it.
- 52:20That actually kind of is linked to another point, which is if
- 52:27you invest in those ETFs, it's dollars in, dollars out.
- 52:32You ain't getting any Bitcoin out of those things, right?
- 52:36And it's kind of a nonsensical way to invest in Bitcoin in my
- 52:41mind, because you're investing in an ETF structure.
- 52:47And so I always go to the limit, to the extreme with things.
- 52:52What would happen to Bitcoin if 100% of people access the
- 52:56Bitcoin through the ETF? Would Bitcoin have any chance of
- 53:00becoming what it promises to be? No, of course not.
- 53:06So why invest in a way that's kind of against the investment
- 53:11thesis of Bitcoin, right? You want to be able to actually
- 53:14use the asset operationally like a corporate treasurer would,
- 53:19like a big charity that's trying to get money into an
- 53:24authoritarian regime or a place where there's been a natural
- 53:27disaster. They need to get money to, you
- 53:31know, where it needs to be quickly.
- 53:32But the traditional financial system won't let them send money
- 53:36into that country or whatever. But now you've got an ETF,
- 53:40right? You can't see units of an ETF
- 53:43into an authoritarian country, right.
- 53:47And it's. Yeah, I mean, I'm.
- 53:53I'm not saying that it's not a good thing that the ETFs exist
- 53:57and you know, and whatever, but ultimately, when you're dealing
- 54:01with pension schemes and stuff like that, you're not looking
- 54:03for, OK, you want everything to be the Rolls Royce version of
- 54:08how to do it right. And for me, the ETF's don't cut
- 54:12it right for a whole bunch of reasons.
- 54:17Yeah, we haven't got into yet, but there are others.
- 54:22Well, I'll tell you for, for our audiences, stick, stick around
- 54:27with us for a little bit longer than what we might normally go.
- 54:32What Glenn is, is, has been talking about.
- 54:35It's just fascinating. I think we could sit here for
- 54:37another hour, two hours and just, you know, talk to you
- 54:40about your due diligence and your perspectives around risk.
- 54:46What really is the risk? And, and, and I think you're
- 54:48hitting on, you know, a number of things that hopefully will,
- 54:53you know, allow our, our audience to think a little bit
- 54:56differently and go down that that path a little bit further.
- 55:02But we have been working on at on ramp, a case study that kind
- 55:07of helps, you know, showcase, you know, a way that that
- 55:12Cartwright might have gone through a process and some of
- 55:16them evaluation criteria and why most importantly, I think it's
- 55:19the why it's important element. You know, when you're defining
- 55:25all of the criteria that that makes it a decision to actually
- 55:32make an investment on behalf of whomever your clients are, You
- 55:35want to make certain that you understand why it's really
- 55:39important. And I think Cartwright, I want
- 55:42to applaud your firm. I think that they've done a
- 55:43fantastic job of, of creating these definitions and, and, and,
- 55:50and sussing them out to say, okay, what is the right way?
- 55:54What is the best way to minimize single party failure or
- 55:57counterparty risks? And you know what, what, in the
- 56:01event of worst case outcome, right?
- 56:03I mean, you're, what you're trying to do is build a
- 56:05bulletproof institutional grade solution from end to end, right,
- 56:10That allows your, your clients to to benefit from Bitcoin, not
- 56:16just as as a price proxy, but for the future potential of its
- 56:20application and, and ownership of the fundamental asset.
- 56:24And so kudos to you on the on the custodial journey,
- 56:29everything that you've done. This white paper is going to be,
- 56:35I believe, Mark, correct me if I'm wrong, released later this
- 56:39week by On Ramp, and it will detail the full due diligence
- 56:44process that Cartwright has gone through.
- 56:47It's a way for you to think about how it fits into your
- 56:51firm. And, you know, maybe you come up
- 56:53with different, you know, criteria and we'd always be
- 56:56interested in hearing, you know, what those criteria were.
- 57:00But that being said, we encourage you to go ahead and
- 57:03sign up this week, if you can for our weekly On Ramp research
- 57:09and insights newsletter. And if you do go into the on
- 57:14rampbitcoin.com and sign up for that newsletter, we will make
- 57:19sure that you are the 1st to get this paper.
- 57:23And so we encourage you to do that.
- 57:25But in the meantime, I just want to say, Glenn, thank you for
- 57:31coming on and sharing a little bit of your insights.
- 57:35You know, it's clear to me and I and I, I, I, I, I bet Mark too,
- 57:40that you are a deeply researched individual in the space and, and
- 57:45have done your homework. So we appreciate you helping
- 57:49point out ways that others might be able to follow.
- 57:53Mark any any closing thoughts? Nope, echo what you say Rich
- 57:58Glenn, you and Cartwright have done the work.
- 58:01We it's demonstrated in what you've shared and that we will
- 58:05re share out in that let docs and if people hit us up on the
- 58:10website, it's there. Don't listen to us do the work
- 58:14and then just be curious because things are changing a bit here.
- 58:19Thanks a lot guys. Thank you.
- 58:21Thanks. Thanks.
- 58:24Bye bye. Thanks for listening to this
- 58:27week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 58:29valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 58:31rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 58:34All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 58:36notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 58:39reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 58:41entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 58:44investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 58:47your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 58:50Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 58:54one of our private client advisors.